• 検索結果がありません。

国際銀行業史の研究をめぐって

N/A
N/A
Protected

Academic year: 2021

シェア "国際銀行業史の研究をめぐって"

Copied!
17
0
0

読み込み中.... (全文を見る)

全文

(1)

著者 居城 弘

雑誌名 静岡大学経済研究

12

3

ページ 89‑104

発行年 2008‑01‑31

出版者 静岡大学人文学部

URL http://doi.org/10.14945/00005841

(2)

0123

4 56789a0bc

d ef56782

567899 !"#$f78aef78%&'(

) 56*+,-./a56789

0123

455660778989:566;<=>?5@45ABBCDE3"FGH IJKLMNOF#P374589:56IQR0ST3UVWXMLF>BKL>?

5@45YZ=>[9Y\3"F756%&]^N_[9`gA5 hijNkl3 him2>noK7klhicpqrs8tsuv3wx=>WyBzAM75645a{

|hia}WAU~FV?0€37+‚ƒ„F8…5†‡aˆ‰ŠKL>

7856†‡‹<8=>Œa3O>?

78956IQRR0ŽFŒaK0OF?‘’I“”K07•–789

—˜K56™9aŽš›8œ7klhia†‡3‹P+‚ž98†Ÿ7 ¡¢—3W }=>9A£~F_?+‚†¤F9aœKL>?~_7¥¦§¨©ª«¬­ƒ®

æO+‚¯3'=>°±²75³†‡A´µ9:9Šaœ3"F£~F_?

œcœ¶·¸¹º»IO¼[J½¾Ÿ¿À74556IOÁÂQR3‹P789:9 A7ÃÄÅÆ7893#7569aœ7Çp30789kl<Caœ8X

>#P3OM7ŒŒ378956IQRA¹È6=>Œa3O>?™ÉÊ*A5ËjN QR=>Œa3OÌ7+‚Ê*8+‚†‡56IOÍÎAMB_p=?ŒK0ÏO>

lÐIÁÂK0OV7ÑO>5@*+JÒÓÔ7 ¡Si856ՃÖ3×™É +‚ÓÔØJ3BÙÚOÛÜÝN>Œa3#75 45a0ÑO>Ê*ÞßYZ=>

àáâãäåç

è é ê

ëìíîïðñòóôõö÷ø

üý

(3)

ŒaaO>?56I™ÉÊ*aaB37+‚Ê*56IOQR07+‚†Ÿ8ž97þ¡7 ÿffO+‚†¤F9012I3¼1Ç37+‚ƒ„¢“458{|+‚A6_O 78KQR=>Œa3O>œ7l5 ¡†‡3#>+‚†‡·¡9aAbc6=>?783 a0Œ#PO90569aœ‡dep>Œa3O>A7Œ9Þßfaœ

05 9aÙÚOSEaœ7ÑO>*+ÒÓÔbcp¼1>+‚ÓÔ ¡ -bcIOBa=>ŒaAÇ#P?œ_A~_ ¡-2_2Ç~

~O'A7Ç>ŒaaO_?Œ ¡-3NNOF7807569 cpOVÇ>KL>?

4ý{ !¿À7569"gI3£#78A~$%&-K7'FK¥¦§¨©º5 87()*+8,¹3"FBŸÇ>ŒaaO_A7Œ#POÚ0ª545 5663a-eKOV77889:566*156*+,-./3aBÚX2 ÙÚO.»B'BKL_?ŒPœ_780756788kl787L>F0/@«78 a0Ì>KL>A756789"gI9:4YA5 784Ycp1Ÿ3ŸÇ>3 2_340#POBKL_c?Çp375678945879 !3'F7Œ~KÞ4Z567œN8_F?~_Œ3W}œfkl 783'œ739FŸÇ:;œ_ef5kl78Ÿ<=87e f78>i3#>%&'(3'F†M±²>??(356789A{|I3zA M@3_Œa0756*+,-./3a#PO.»AF_aN>ŒaAKÚ

>c3'FBœ8_F?¹C07567893'F¶D6œFúûEcpF$'' GHE67I8_BKL>?9:J§¦KL¦,MN0(7O73X_>PQ 47ff7*+½RS¿À7TUOQR@3>?aV3V<545ZWXYZÔ[

ZW\8aœ7569:†‡0]I3BI3BÙÚOÖ!^²7{|45_a 0`ghiÇ3>BaOF>A7ŒPœ_jk3l>_23B77889:566

?‘ÙÚOPmMAj_’7567893nEL7Œ~Kúû3#o pc3O_Œa87GHE67œ_F?pqr

st4udvvwDx,¹9:Fyz{Ùy3"F7|}~€‚¬ÙFƒ„…†‡ˆWa=

>‰9:ù©Š‹Œ5678a))ŽAgÇ_A7ŒKŠ0*N.¦‘¦w

’Ç_?¹C0“,”• !–¦-37ÇF•1—V3Oc_•E8D˜N Ú_GHO™œ756789ùúû3'FGHE67œ_BKL>?“

,07º3šn7ٛœf56783W=>7 `¸s3BaVžŸO ¡A 8X_?dvvwDx¢,¹9:Fyz{Ùyúû ¡£¤¥¦‡

ýv

(4)

à©çª«¬­®æ0¯°

45J§¦KL¦,MN<Q079:a78J§¦KL,MN±²=>?þŠ0 ST3UVÛܳšœ´F''J§¦K‹6FP<Q;œFV?¸¹º»lÐ IÁÙa{|hiC—Z074ý{(µ¿ÀTU3<Qœ7šn7J§¦KL¦, MNaFN><˜Aj_?f5V¶Ša=>·96¸0|¹5·96[9º»¼a

¸³œ7½57ª5'l45Wy8¾¿Y\BÖ6œFÚ7FXÀ>·95Á¾¿Y\

A7š3o¾OÂ6N''L_?

{|·iaœf5A·9ÃÉuC{|ª«3EeÁٜFV3L_7¾¿

†‡3‹P…58¾¿9:4Y6N>ŒaAm2p_Œa0opcKL>?aV3f53 aÄklŝhi7'~M))7)Æ+7 Ç8È.N)*+Ohia¾

¿†‡3"F7¾¿†‡…58¾¿9:ˆ‰=>1Ø4YA74ý{ !ÉvÊvD·¿

À7ËOCÇ_Œa0tÌ=ÍڌaKL_?ŒŒ3"F7¹59:4Ya0ΊƗ˜K7œcB«ÏI3f6œ7¾¿†‡…59:ˆ‰=>4YaœCÇ_B A567893ÐOpOF?pÑr

stdu|}~4ýýv‡4ÒK0756789g»aœ7‰L>5èӊa5†‡S

¢KL>Ð5èӊÒ45†‡7Ô0šÕ5èӊÒ45†‡9:8P78 9ŽaœF>?šn7ٛœ3Œ#PO567893×<œ_07ÖרLM7

šn0569aÙÚ93ÛE"F_•–78Ü¦ÝÞNßKN7à¦ßKN‡7

šÖ0FXÀ>f/@«78áÁa=>ÃÄÅÆkl5678KL>?(Š3'F 07kl8/@«a†‡3×<œ_78â㜉kl/@«78äåçèéêëìíëîìïåðåëéíð ñíëòŽ7L>F0‰kl78óôõ èçöèèôíëòèëŽa0Ì>ŒaAL>?Œ0÷øIzù3 SFpF>Sú‚KL>?|}€A7569:9'~Meèӊa45†‡8šÕ 5èӊÒ45†‡3#>9:8P7893'F7/@«78aFP0ãSF>

Œa3'FûGüœ"p>07FXÀ>/@«ƒ®4Yaœ9 ýa

=>78aFo¾3=ÍÚaþÿcpKLÎP?ff‰f5678aFP07f úKñçé0éö2èçöèíöôíëòö7L>F0ñçé0éö13åçèéêëíëîïåðåëéíðôíëòöaãÇ>78 4KL>?XA5K0f/@«78a5Ç>ŒaBËFA7Œp78'6«Ï30 758n`¹85³$,¹A9~>œ7%NaK/@«4£abcOWyAF _0ffd78eçèöéîèëïfñíëòö8KL>?/@«78aFP5ú00KL>Ł|

}~dvvD7w҇aÇ>?569:93XM79:cpJ§¦KL¦,MN

ƒN_A5678KL>aœ75678 !o¾3ÇF>?

Œ~Kkl/@«78OSúAzVSFpÚ__27'6aœF>BA ý4

(5)

zÇ~~33cÚF>Œa0_œcKL>?œcœ•Š K07/@

«780ã0cOMzVSFpF>?_aN̼€0%&-9:¸¹ú û KÄ/@«78ÅaFPSúSœF>?7P¼7ù O€úû3"FB7Ä/@«78Å jASFpF>Aj!KL>?¶D7

¹7KúûK0Ä56789"ë0èçëí0éåëíðñíëòéëêÅaFP jAzVSFp>#P3 OF>Œa#œ7ŒŒK0$~KúûùK¤FSú‚3'F¾%œ_P NK7569:9"gI38P78aFP÷øI&8cO !aœ7567897 'œ_F?56789È89 !7Çp30ÅÆ—˜B·aaB3ÙÚVÖ6

œÚF>?_aNÌ$,K0569:9"gI3£#78aaB3n(™978 A569:9Þß)£*£œF>Ak˜KL>cp7569:9(

+ùIQRB,ß3F7-gÇ>bAL>?

5678ŸV¶ÚF_0f5KL>A7Œ#PO4YÅÆŸB_pœ

_<=0bc.>¢AcMaœ7))7/ǝhi01aœ_ºkl7 8Ÿœ(!2O3V4Ï35Í>Œa3=>?

6789:;<

D7Ç%Nay=·7™y>[(7?@A2>ÌIcpŸÇ_?n(™–

a†‡Ba27%Nacp 5¼ƒBŸÁٜ_?“‘7€80¢—‡7°C9 3ÛE"FF_A(7l5 ¡9÷ÛhÙÇ3_?œcœwvD·(µcp0D$

‡°C9hÙÇ3_?

E7FGHIJK;<

4ü)dDŸ¹B0LN–%7(§NaN3ÖM‡%Na7ÇN))7 53ƒBO ÁٜFÚÙ783ZW=>?É4D3fP!ACÝÇ>?3#M€83778ÚD87  ¡Q9ž99A%2p_?0[R“9:0STÇ_?~_§NaN3"Fn(

789£#Œa0%2pOc_?ÉvD·307UV†‡9:ˆ‰œ_?Év7ÊvD·

¸9WSk˜07l5 ¡9 ýaœF_?œcœª5678Ò%&X6aaB 379ÞßÁœY³ÿZB8O_?Çp3j«9BÁٜ_AUV7¦[¦\

]^¸‡7ŒaA€8_`¼YS.=>ŒaaO_?0[R“9:3B¢C=O

½57°Cgg6±Ú²Œœ74üü)D30ƒ„FhT3:Fi~_?j6à kN‘‹78aœ4üü)D39lmœDnÇ_A7678Bo/ÁÙ¬==2_

_27pqÛm7–)NJrsÛÜBÛOM7ýdD3D$ƒ„hTOVÇ_?†

t•–:¸3#>`¿OuSvÝA0w°CÁٜ_Œa877xyz3#M4£{6 ýd

(6)

™UÇ3_?€80|¹}½Ÿi3~œF_ŒaBÇF>?

€7‚ƒIJ„K;<

ÉDLN–%KŸÇ>?Ãą†07LN–% ýK8X_?€80 ¡9a°C 93ÛE"FF_?ÉwD30fP!ACÝÇ7‡ÉüDܦ+N‘%‹78aœŸÇ

>Œa3O>?(7ƒBOB<879-ˆAÁٜF_?4üÊÊDà‰Š‹Na

Œ¦¦rsK07†‡™=_`3@0X_? ¡9A ýKL_A7(üvD·c p°Cœ°œ9Ah™œFVaFPŽBœ_?ýdD778aœ0'7ýD67 83\8=>?

‘7’“‚J‚”;<

(D7•–±k7837Ù783ZW=>?§NaN™–7Ǘ¾¿™–7kW9ŠOA 93¥™œ_?%Na7à¦-ßÈ)7 53ƒBOA' ¡78ŸA˜™Ç_?

ÉdD3fP!š›A8X7¾¿™–J‹¦œC¸K…†3Z=>?€80DÚ8Pƒ

B 5‡aeDڃBŸ8_?9Þß0 ¡7Q97ž99KL_A7k63 0 ¡9 ýaœF_?üvD·¿À30žŸ :¸OB92°C9AXh=>Œa aO_?

¡7¢£¤¥;<

Ê)D9KL>A7Ðf5678aÑOM•–3¹BF_? 57,¹K¦=

>%&- ýa=>¾¿™–AŸ3¥™œ_?4üÊÊDrsKËOǗ ¡78A_`œ7

§_78B9¨©7hª#«OVÇ_A7€80?¬­ ¡9n®3 ÁÙ=>Œa3Zœ_?œcœ7“‘cp%&-7%Naa 5½æ ¡†‡-eKOV7 5 `«o†‡3B£9ÛE"Vo¯aF_Œa7‡7°C÷ÛA?‘cp Pc_ŒaAf°KL_?÷±0“‘cpdv²1³´œ2F_?œcœwvD·‘

307V9¼^¸µ¶7^43#>pq7†‡V_`O3#M4£·43@0X>?

Œ43–<¸6A8X7 ý9KL> ¡9ÁÙ7ƒBO6^7Z]†‡Va }¹6A0cp_?Çp3º¦¥¦BüvD‡7¥Nü47»N¼‹üýD‡O

¹7ºhi3ƒBœ9ÁÙ½>Oo/4£A<2p_?€80¸¹9 73¾¿"F_Œa87 ¡†‡ÀMÁFÂÃ6I8O7xyz8 ¡-¼' 3†MÅÄ-Žc7wvvD·¿À7‡°C9hÙ<27ývD·30ÅÆ%

ß0 )v²3ǜ_?«89:9м:¸7™–¼™Éÿ°C7ÝM¨œ§¦NÈɼ

°COo/6œ_?¬ÊË9AÛÞßYZœ7€80 ¡°CÊË9ÌÏ ÁٜF_?r

stu4ýwý‡7P¼4ýü)‡7Î ÏЁ4ýýv74ýýʇ7|}~dvv dvvw‡

ý

(7)

O¥¦?

¿±£ÑcpopcO#P37%Na7 57,¹OÇ))7ÇN))a†‡

ýa=>fkl78ºO907f5ap«Ïa¾¿3‹Pl5 ¡†‡a¾¿

9:KLM7‰Ç— ¡78Žaœ¾¹ÈBF_?ŒE0N7«Ïf783B Ò*œ_ÈKL_?_-œ7à¦-ßÈ)8+ÓÔO@–/@«f78-e07/

@« `j«78aL~MÖXpOF98F_aÇ>?œzùOƒBO0 M2pœ7/@«ƒ„…54YnÕPaaB37j«9÷ÛA ¡9#MÙÚ V7j«9Bb$œB™978qÖ3_BK0OV70[ÿ°C3Bo/I3 ccX_aFP?r

st)u|}~4ýý4 )҇7P¼4ýü)‡¥¦?

œcœ))«Ïf5678‰Ço ¡78IOȎ074üüvD·cpÖ6œ77š

3‡°CØj«9÷ÛhÙÇ37kl5¼[Ê*ÙÚ9:3UVWX>#

P3O_ŒaAÇF>?ŒÛEABaBÜKL_0•–±k78KL_

aÇ>?Œ#POkl789ÛEÖ607#PO343#¼1_c?~

_Œa3#56780#P3ÖXF_cAGHKL>A7E0

¿yÝÌKaML²>?

~_7ÞJaœf°aœ0793¥™œ_0¾¿™™=W}OÊ*`g™

–O™9¸¹A ýKL_EKL>?5 l¾¿9Š8™y¾¿†‡83‹P9 ÁÂAºOÌIKL_#P3ßX>?ef789i´#PO75 uC[

9O745|A~a~àc3hiÁÙm27kl78Ÿ3¥™=>aFPá¦- 07f78Ÿ30@pOFŒaASEKLM7f°KBL_?#œÎf5 uC [9a½$'ÚAÒcIKL_aFN>K0OF-ÎPc?

n(3¾¿WyÁÂ3#>…5a9:ˆ‰b079:878566;=A7 âH5_=_2307ËãOo‚—˜ALMP>KL>?

_aNÌ74‡kl78a‹‹-Wy—Z89ä3~M7d‡¹5783#>

klƒB£9åØ87‡j«78¼¸¹¥™7)‡Çp30ŒŒKGHa=>567 84YCØoÄAºO—˜KL>?ŒpÅÆ*1¾¿†‡3‹Pƒ„…57¾

¿9:9Aˆ‰Ç_?r

stÉuè¢a%é9:ùúû¤êŠ‹‰Šë dvv456IuS½xQRì¥¦?

ý)

(8)

~_fkl78Aklhi7aV3))7 Ç8È.N)*+5Oa¾¿†

‡…5ˆ‰=>ÌIK7f¹59:4Ycp1Ÿœ_ÅÆaœŸÇ_ŒaBÙÚOf

°KL_?BaBŒf°0f39FŸÇ_ef78i´3B“0~>Œa OKL>A‡Œ7íaœ0¿yEKÚ#P?

4‡~$Œp«Ï3"F07â1j«K9:ÅÆDÇAœVî_!˜3LM7

Œp«Ïa*™¾¿ÁÙ_2307V<·95º¶BaK7klhi3"e>

*™±ïE3l5 ¡†‡"g78Ÿ=>Œa3#7¾¿†‡…58¾¿9:

ˆ‰8PŒaA01pKL_ŒaKL>?

d‡œcB7Œp«Ï2>9075 7893"e>-a0÷ø3OpOFŽ

7*ðÇ>5693ccX>-70>c3±>ÙÚO-3ÇpÇF _ŒaKL>?OcKBj«45=y0`g3#>+Nߦ-8*+0`7xyz ÛE3²=>‡AKL>?œ_Aklhia†‡3#¼1>cBœOF -A74£±µ¶8qµB_pœ_i´KB7ÛÜA5 78ÅÆ3ÛÜA³æŒa ñTòó=>bAL_?ŒA¹578ÅÆa0ÎÅÆ—˜K5678AŸÇ

_7íKL_?k67567894ôœ_Ç~~O4£·48µ¶07ËV5678 xŸ¾¿õc=BaOM7ö÷qµD¼7ƒBGH7Çp3078_[3:Fi~

>BBøOVOc_?k6756789+ùf°Ce>0~$BŒp78A à'ù3>NOc_Ë×ËãO-KL7_23OVÇ_OËV 4£_`84£{63#>>[7ƒ„FhT79GHkð0ú®3ûBOF!2K L_?567893“_07“‘cp7Œ#PO4YAbcI3à3>N OFËãO-3#P3'=>caFPâHccNF_KL>?r

stÊuºO-3'F7OcÄ$V7xyz7qa'3'F0¿yýþ¥

¦?ÿ‰%&-/@«78'7xyz¬Ž7‰7xyz’3"e>%&-/@

«784ýwvD·ffüvD·‘3ce ¡†‡o‚Ö6 ýaœŽ 0ٙ

F•†d)ì7"#$71±234ýwý‡74ýüɇ7|}~dvv‡44Ò¿À?

~_7klK789-ÙÚÇ3Wœ0žef78i´30(5=>#P37

¬­8 078OB927Ç~~OYIOƒ4ABa2p_A73_Fœf7 8i´307#POYIƒ4A0ÚMœ_Baœ08a2pOFŒaBf°KL _?ŒŒa0%&-¬IOf7Øíº»I-½&56ÊBaK0GHaÇ

Oc_aN>ÍÚOKLÎPc?œcœ7Œ½5aœ7ËOf5678A›Ÿ=

>!2Aj7ST3%´=><˜OcKwvvD·304£0738>78AD¼œ7 ýÉ

(9)

_23D9A2epOVO_ŒaO07f78N>63'o=ÍÚEK0OcÎP c?L>F0~_ª5678STa8ÞeA7‰fP!båfíðc1íç0èçŽ3#7£9ÌÏ8 9ÞߨAd6Ç>aFPŒaAL_cPc7Çp30‰´Öº»ŽARSÇ¿

À0PKL_cOBopc3=>bAL>#P3ßX>?per stwu|}~dvv‡üÒ?

àf窫¬­2

f5¿l¥¦§¨©º57aV3ÆÈN-8a%é7àÈNÔØ3"FB 4ý{(µ7

1Ø5678C=>ÚA¹~_?ŒPœ_Ú30f5i´aÒ*

AFF_Œa0FP~KBOF?*™ÁÙa3‹P¾¿9:8569:†‡

ˆ‰Am2p_aFP<=KL>?œcœ7efi´3073a~p$3(D3 -gÇ_71ØA5678Ÿ;œ_aœÛ,Ç>bAL>?

šn04ý{(µaV3wvD·¿À7*™GH2>¥¦§¨©·95Ò%&AX6œ7

*™AD=>#P3OF_Œa7aMXef53#>·913'œŒ _œ

#Pa=>¹857aV3a%é8ÆÈN-7àÈNÔO73#>·96ATU3<Qœ7

%&-3'(=>%&]—Z=>#P3O_ŒaKL>?¥¦§¨©(D53a 07*™GH'…3#>hiÁÙ0n!âHKL_?ºuC[93"F04ý{wv D·¿ÀÙ02’3L75 K† Wal5hiÁÙm2>ÚA¹~_?'

~Ma%é012a=>¥¦§¨©5K07uC[9 ýa=>'lÁÂ"

aœ7*™ÁÙ9:4W3#¹]3ƒ4=>ŒaA¹Vm2p_aFP<=KL>?

Œ_2f5¿l5#3#>5678Ÿ3"F075 uC[9$%a¹F½

$'ÚAÙÚOaO_aFPŒaAKÚ>?ŒE0f5678a'÷K0cOM o&aF#Ff°KL>?Çp30l5hiÁÙ0uChiaœ-eK0OV7uvq rs8t'¾ÿ_2hi¾ÿB/2ÙÚO(KL_?Œ#P37f5{|hiƒ

®3'(=>]aœ7'l<C3#>hiÁÙkj=>Œa07FXÌ[9|â.KL 7Œ_230[9|â]®²_œ§Æßaœ†MÅ~_KL>?_aNÌ a%éi´307È.N)*+5'6aœ7a%ÝÆKNJ‹¦œâ]½

†œ‰a%ékl78ŽŸœ_A7))hi3'F0‰a%é))78Ž

07=ÍöÙ78J‹¦œ¥™3#>ý)*M⸹IO$%3ƒNp_5*I˜™a

œ}eKL_?ÆÈN-3'F07©‡78Nß+¦‹,-N߇k l<C˜™A-J6œ7ÊvD·‘23ce))KklƒBAkj=>?ƒBR 407f5a*™›&3"F7/ÇKqs¾ÿa.Æ/012a=>·9ÃÉ0À

ýÊ

(10)

m2>ÆÈN-™·9$%KL_?p1r

stüuèé êdvv4‡1±234ýwý‡ýÊýw74vÉÒ?~_7ÆÈN-/@«DÚ78‰%

Na,Ó78Ž2>!2B¥¦?1±234ýüɇšnìšÕ9‰%Na,Ó 78Ž

œ_AefaV3a%é8ÆÈN-))hi'6a=>5678Ÿ307ª [9452JA¥™œ_-eKOV7¬­8 078ج­4W3#>Ç~~O !ƒ4 AÝNp73#‘256789CA153O_ŒaAtÌÇ#P?YIO

ƒ4AbKL_Œa3Wœ07Œ#PO7893a-ÙÚÇA#Ç

OeÌOpOF?V8=>kl784£+ùA/úF>#P3756789+ù 0-aÈ3+ùB3ÐOpOFKL7*ð5 789Aà=>Ç~

~O-0>c34N>BKL_Œa7-¼'0œÌœÌ•θ¹˜

9NP>5xjN>BKL_cpKL>?×j·3"FB7kl9PjK B-ÙÚOÞß93'F0¬­3#>6¬¸9^Ý87¾¿ÿ7½x7M30

¬­9:4WØ3#>Ç~~OYIƒ4A8XF>0Œ#PO<=3BaFF

>KL>?p8r

stýu93"e>%,)ݼaYIƒ43'F7f78i´k˜cp0o/IOc cXM0¾%ÇOF#PKL>?œcœ7ŒE3'F07‰9ŸfP!Ž:”

=>ŒaAbKLÎP?aMXefP!š›a%1ÙÚK7bpc$%8%&d 6=>#PO5_œ_aF_ŒaAL_cPcAGHaOÎP?

šÖ37ef5678Ÿ;œ_aœ¹dœOeÌOpOFŒa07¾¿…5 9:3cÄ=>;Nawx7cp<=2=ÚKL_?f5569:ÌÏ>j I«}07§NaN9:hiAäv=>×#9:I?¦@-3ƒNpF_Œa0ABa

ŒÎKL>?¾¿†‡3"e>‡duSA§NaN78™y3#vÝÇ>Œa²Ea

œ7{|¾¿†‡A7§NaNCf;Na¢—7Ca‡uSvÝ7Çp35;

NaQ9§P—Za7¡3#¾¿†‡…5a¾¿9:Aˆ‰Ç>?§NaN9:

hi0Çp3ª5¼D’¸9vÝ7Çp3¸¹hiKl5ÙÚD8*1_W’¸¹v Ý45BEV2_7%&-569:±>jI«}Y\KL>?

%&-¿l5#3"F7uCv¾¿3W=>†‡…5a9:A§NaN9:hia-

‘¦NJ¢—ˆ‰wx3#8X>aFP<˜07†‡ˆ‰¢Osƒ„%&

-569:±ÕFGKL_A‡aFP9:I-ßKLM7Çp3uCv†‡A;

ýw

(11)

NanK8X>Œa3#>7 ¡-AKÚ>?ŒPœ_ÖÛ07f5 [9a{|hiK%&K0$»N,%HÞ¨œ.Iœ_?

¾¿9:±§NaNwx×Jcp<=07œ_A%&-¿l5#3aÚX 2ÙÚOâHKL_?âH0ª53"FËãO—˜a“”4íœI8p>

KL>A7½KaŒÎžØ5uCv†‡A759:4Y3#ˆ‰Ç7Ø5*+

nK†‡aœ8FP>ŒaAÌÇ_aFPŒaKL>?pqLr

st4vu_aNÌa%é3Wœœ§M-a“”3'F07èš4vì‰a%é3"

e>56IuS½xŽ¥¦?~_7ÆÈN-©‡78))ƒBÙÚO 4Ía'07ÆÈN-))a¾¿9:A7§NaNˆ‰3wx3>NOc _j! Rœ7ÆÈN-$%3NkO9:4WŸ3#7 ¡7¢Os OPa§NaNwxcp<=Ì=ŒaKL_E3'F071±234ýwý‡4vÒ?

%&-¿l5#A))ØklhiKÓ¿WyÁÙ¹6Ç37œcBŒK

¾¿†‡…5a9:7;Nawxcp<=œQR=>_2307*™¾¿±ºhi3Ø 578ÅÆïEYQ=>ŒaA01pKL_?ef5678Ÿ307Œ#P3 {|hiK%& K7Ø5[99:I$F¾ÿ0c>aFPo¾OÌRAL_?

aV3ŒE0a%é8ÆÈN-7§,)8,¹5678CaœÇOe

ÌOpOF?œcœOAp7Ba#MâHA7Œ~Kkj15KL_c7;Na-

‘¦NJ>j3_Fœ7¾SÚx~KTt=>ŒaaO_c7œ;N aJ½ƒ®I«}_3Œ~Kl>BaO_c07~_Ε3'oÇ>bAL

>âHKL>?

àU窫¬­®VWXY®Z[\]^_`g¬­æ¬­hijk

4‡5678A5_œ_3'F079-JI !Þ4¢AcM3lxA8X

Ú_?Œ~Kúû*1756789 !3'F07-JI30•Î78KÈ N-,¦ß7¸[YZ8ÕFGmYZ÷ŽAopc3ÇF>?3#Ì5678 90l5 ¡9A ýKLM7¾¹aœF>Œa0o@KL>?kl78nl

ƒB9aœ07‰¥¦§¨©EeuC·9‡“37CÇ_uC ¡¢—Á†auv

·9ƒ„F_23SFp>ž9S78 ¡¢—À=ŽA ýKL>?|}4ýýv4d҇

ŒKj«*+d„FA¼1>A7uCvo÷8ƒ„’5$O_27‰kl78

¹Ba7ªƒBÒK¸9|pO\A¼1>ŽŒa7Œ#P3¹ƒBÒ8ƒBSTÒ

³1³Wy0D¸\(D=>A7ŒÚ0«ÏI3Y\IOBKL_M7qrs ýü

(12)

IOÚBœ7569:hi2>D¸\3ÛÜÝN_ŒaA¹dÇF>?56 78 `¸s8ªBtKÈN-,¦ß$S3#756788 ¸9rsk˜3l

>uÛOúûZ5A-ÇF>?pqqr

st44uÎ ÏЁ4ýý7|}~4ýýv74ýý‡?

~_75678l5 ¡9aW}œ7uCvÉÿaœ_¾¿9:9A8X>Œ

a3O>?uCœ°œ9:87uvÉ0vA¾g=>~K9:9OAKL>?l5  ¡98¾¿9:9_2356780j«*+dÇj«Q998¹B¹5K;

NaÜ‹7ÆÈNO‡¸9dÇA8X>Œa3O>?

56789 ýI`Þ3'F0¿±#PKL>A7k630f56kl783

"FB7«Ï3a3È893cOMÙÚOoÑA@p_Ak˜KL_?pqÑr st4du«ÏIOÈ"#$9 !o3'F£B=a¿y#PKL>?f5a%N

a7 57,¹OÇ))7ÇN))a†‡9: ý9aœ_A‰Ço ¡ 78Ža0Ì_J‹¦œKLM7l5 ¡9A ýKL_?œcœ9 !0 4ý {üvD·¿À30Ö6œ7kl545ÙÚ `K9:3UVccX>j«9

÷ÛP2F_?

È.N)*+«Ïf78BŽš€ãKL_A7 ¡9÷ÛAPFŒa7j«

*+0`gÛÜ#M¹Vde_ŒaOf°AL_aFP?Œ3_Fœ+Ó Ô8à¦-ßÈ)f78i´307j«78aÙÚV0ÑO>ŒaOF98 _?zFƒBOwœj«45ƒ„…5,-./nx_?j«°C980 [ÿ°CÞß3Bo/I3†MÅÄ-aÇ>?

|}~4ýý4‡ ýÒ7P¼4ýü)74ýüü‡

d‡f78aef78%&a'(2

56789+ù3"e>V¶Š0f78KL_?f78A56789ÞßK

>}2_07¾¹I30f545IO%&]PÇ3#>56¾¿±>j3#>B KL_Œa0FP~KBOF?Çp3f78056…5±¾y*+KL>f;NadÇ 3"F…gI3Z$O«}3L_?56†‡3"F;Nan†‡´Az>IKLM7

¾¿†‡…5a9:A§NaNC¢—7Ca§NaN9:hiK‡3wx=>Y\3"

F7f78>}0opcKL_?ef780ŒPœ_f783#>56¾¿…5 9:>j3'œ75@45±$F:maFP@«cp7Œ3'(IOÌ IBaKŸÇ7QRœ_?'~M56789ÌÏK7f78aef78

ýý

(13)

%&'(WyA{Mz²p_KL_?Œ%&0#PO|\__cAGH aO>?

f78ZW±3'F0f55 78ÙÚV±M7~_f5¾¿ZW±

B±M7{|¾¿ZW±3Žš@´PBKL_ŒaAopc3ÇF>?ŒŒa0 f5678ZW056¾¿ZWa}dLX3_BKL756¾¿†‡ˆ‰*

1f78ZWAB_pÇ_Œa|~Ç3>?

f78z>I>}0ývD·‘2Z4aœ7š3(OVÇ>?FP~KBO VŒ0ef78ZW3#>BKL_?Œ#POef78ZW0#M¹I307 f5 ýa=>¾¿Y\cp7¾¿ËÕ6ÛEA<8œ_ŒaAqKL_?Œ-J I3 58%Na3֜8>a7¾¿ËÕ63#7_aNÌ 5i´30¾¿3 2>f5÷Û0Ùi3[yœ7cX¥¦§¨©Ù€8757,¹7§,)a†‡Ah

™œ_Œa7%Na3'F0'fuC÷±[y7a%é7,¹7)*+OuCS¢

VËÕ6A<8œ_?Œ#P3¾¿ËÕ6aàc¾¿hÙ07ŒÌÏ3"e>e f78<Ca9ÁÙ¾SKL7ŒŒaAf78,Æ)(B_p=Œ

a3O_?pqÍr

st4u|}~dvv4‡dvv)‡?

‡5678j«9¼ccXM<C3'F

7•E07f780 ¡9 ýaœ9QRœÚ_KL>A74ý{üvD·

¿À77š3FXÀ>j«9÷ÛP2>#P3O_343'FKL>?ŒK0ef 78<C3#7 ¡9ÌÏKBf78,Æ)8Åk%ßAtÇ7ÕFK B¹VÛÜde>#P3O_ŒaAtÌÇ>?½57ÕFEKB#MZ$Oj«

93o/6œF_K0OcÎPc?œcœj«9¼†MÅ83"F7))3"

e>ºf788Ò3cOMÜOSA@p_KL_?ܦ+N‘%‹78i´7

“‘7 ¡FA€8$F ýKL_A74ývvD·(µcp0°C7‡9O3#>$

‚ÕFAº`Þ2>#P3O_?Œ7íaœ07f"#$ef78a%&3 '(=>_2j«°C9o/I3ƒÌ=„]8_ŒaAÇF>?|}~ dvv) D7dÊÒ¿y‡ÝÞ¦‘¦a78i´7j«ƒB9 ý0 ¡†‡KL7 ¡9 abc3W}=>°C9aœ¾¿9:uCœ°œ9:7uv0m9:‡8_KLM7 _23bOj«¸9dÇ_23Q993†MÅÄ-KL_?~_ÙÚ93'F 7ÝÞ¦‘¦a7807l5 ¡†‡a¾¿9:A€83aº9KL>aœ7ÙÚ D89cp0…†"FF_aÇ>A7 5l³9¼WÝ2>•–±k78a

4vv

(14)

%& K7Œa0$¹V%‡=>#P3OM7 ¡9_23BÙÚD89a }AbaO_?œcœ7€8ÕF?ÛGm0 ¡FKLM7Œ3#M))

¾¿†‡_2 ¡9a¾¿9:3#7Œp5¾¿ZW3ˆÝœ_aÇ

F>?|}~ dvvÉ7dvvʇŒ3_Fœ•–±k78i´7Ðd8a0ÑOM7j

«45¼[Ê*ÙÚ3UVWXM7j«9o/I3QRœ_Œaf°aœ_?aV3

€80j«9:4WKL>ÈÉa½´¹6œ73BaF 5 `™É†‡4Y a¹F½$'Ú*17 5™–8l5aV3¥¦§¨©™=a†‡ÁٜF_?

3#€80(DKLMOApTUOZWkjœN_KL_?pq×r

st4)u‰4ýwý‡7|}~dvv4‡?•–±k78ZW153œ_0Œ#P 37j«9ÁÙ3L_A7™N¿yŠ‹3#BƒNpF_?'~M7€

80•–¹Baœ77nQ9ŒÕ3Z$KL_Œa77n°CUOkŽA15K L_Œa73#¹7™= ¡†‡Ø83‡Úˆ3>ŒaAKÚ_Œa7 5¬­¼°C8l³D8º<8aœ«}¾ÿœ_?l³D8cpDQ=>u v†‡8 ¡†‡AD89$Fa½$'FF_?|}~7dvvÊD ý҇

Œ#P37f56780l5 ¡9¾yaœ_A7Œ395gœF_XeK 0Oc_?BjÎÄl5 ¡93W}C;œ_¾¿9:90127j«*+dÇ b07Q99QRB_pœ7uCuv˜9¼°C7¢—‡O3~M7j«

¼[Ê*ÙÚ3<CŒœ_j«˜9¼°C9¼a<ÄKFVKLÎP?L>F0~_

j«˜9¸9¯31>#P3OÌ756780n“aj«45DQ3aÙ ÚOBaO>KLÎP?Œ#PO<˜cpopcaO>#P356780756¾¿ÁÙ

%NÆÈKL_aFP3a~pOFDœ_Œa3OÎP?

Çp307j«=y45Y\3UVWX>aaB37j«5¬­aW}AEc~M76¬

¸9¯‘’_2l³D8¹5O¸¹hia}œ8PÙڇdD89ˆ

‰3#M75678j«9accXM0I3U~>aaB375678)£786A

<#ŒaaO>?

5678j«9¼<C0#P3<Ä-KLÎPc?“‘0l5 ¡9 ý3 98FB7š3j«[9a†‡WyAÁÂU6=>á¦-BL_KLÎPœ7 l5 ¡ ý4£o¯“F_78BL_?

œcœŒPœ_Ú07ef78A#œÎ“‘cpo/I37j«545a†‡WyU 2>_237l5 ¡935g=>ŒaOV7Q9°CØÏ-9ÁÙ=>4£o¯

yK<Cœ_Œa7Çp30j«5¬­aWyU2>Œa3#5³D89‡d 4v4

(15)

ˆ‰œ_Œa7Œa3#ef784£9”Aœ<œ_ŒaA7f5678B7 o/IKLdI3KL7ef78a%&±cpB7j«9o/6=>#P34£

9 !ÖMÁÙlp_K0Oc_KLÎPc?ŒŒa07j«98j«5¬

­Y³D893UVWX_•–±k789”EPj3¾%=>ŒaAKÚ>?5 678.»a0Œ#P37¾¿ÌÏK¾¹IOBa"ÇN''7j«9 Aj«453³šœ_ÛÜ7Y³9O¸¹uC3_F=>o/IOB92N

>ÍÚK0OF-ÎPc?

à•窫–—˜™š›æª«¬­®

?(35678a56*+,-./;NaJ½W}3'FKL>?¾¹I307

;Na¾y*+aœ756¾¿?Ù`ÞA;NanK8X7ŒK‡duSAvÝÇ7

§NaN3C¢—A7CÇ>?¢—0§NaNK‡c7§NaNQ9—Zœ756 …5AŒ§NaNQ97¡Sœ3#8XFVaFPÅ83"F7f5678 0l5 ¡†‡ ý9aœ£Ä-?klj«ƒBK§NaNC;Na¢—Á†a§

NaNK†Ÿ7§NaNKuC¢—Á†aklj«ƒBK†Ÿ*17;Na …5,-./0lÐI3ÁٜF_?;Na§P—Za7;Na¸9vÝdÇAŒ

,-./ƒNF_?

f5678A756¾¿ÁÙa}d´X3 ¡†‡a…59*1;

Na…5,-./ÁÂ3ÙÚO5_œ_Œa0ûFOF?

œcœ7f5 ýa=>{|hiY\AÖ6œ7¹75·963#>%&]œ<3

#f5a*™Wy0žÂx™N>ŒaaO_?¹75*™$%cp7hiÁ Ùa56…53"e>f578a;Na¼wxcp<=2œ7ef78§Na NƒBA8X_?;Nan ¡†‡Ø59:4YBa3ŒÕ=>Œa7ŒK

‡duSvÝ=>ŒaA2Ç_?Çp3ef5678ŸaaB3756¾¿Ë Õ6ÛEyK7kl5a¹75Ò¾¿3W=> ¡†‡cOM`ތÕ=>#P3 OM73#f5678 ¡†‡,Æ)0(OVÇF_?-e K0OV7ef5678 KBa%é8ÆÈN-i´30klhia†‡3"F7Ü

‹¢—8ÆÈN¢—¶v̜_Ç~~OI8QR=>#P3O_ŒaAÇ

>?ef780¹5Ù788¸¹hia}œ7kl5l³D8ˆ‰œ7¸¹uC a¹5cpuCÁÙa½´¼E¹2F_?Œ#POÚ07;Na…5,-.

/3'(IO7܋8ÆÈNO1؅5ŸYQ2=BK0L_A7«Ï IzAMB5gIKL7;Na56*+«}õc=#POBK0Ba#MOc_

4vd

(16)

eB756789ÞßKf78aef78%&07f78>jI«}õc

=Baœ<8œ_Œa0<kKL_?ef5678ù a-ˆAÁÂ=>aa B37;Na-‘¦NJ…5,-./ƒ®ÌÏ3'œTt¡SB_p=Œa3O _aNp>K0OF-ÎPc?

dvvwD44¢dÊ,‡

s¥ýþn£u

ͺ¤8ì ‰a%é))78DQa£9Ž¥Ù¢Õ™Fúû¤Év§d¨7dvvw ¢

ͺ Ä%&-/@«784D94üwvüvD·,¹ 5 ý3Ł4‡d‡ ÇÙ¢45F•†¤)ɧ47¨74ýwý

ͺ¦‚ ‰4ý{(µ 53"e>%&-¸¹Þ¦,%NÜM§N™y i´Ž¢=y45ùF¤š)ɧš)¨74ýwý

ͺ P¼ ‰%&-/@«78Ö¨Ùڎ٢45Fúû¤)§¨74ýü)

€ Ä/@«780[9:a6Y\Ö6Å©©™Ù¢™F”û¤ý§d¨74ýüü ͺè é ê ¢a%é9:ùúûa%éÁ9:,-./aÈ%[-KN¤êŠ‹‰Šë7

dvv4

ͺ ù ‰7xyz’3"e>/@«78Ž 0Ù¢™F•ª¤d)§¨ 4ýüd

€ Ä%&-/@«78'7xyz¬•–±k78«2èë¬èèðeåðéïf ýaœÅ7¢4£ùF¤šdʧš)¨

ͺ©­ ® ‰šn7ٛ¿œ§NaN78‡d)Mœ‘N-‡ŽæF Ù¢æ•†¤

4)¨74ý

ͺ € ‰šn7ٛ¿œ4üýÉ4ý4)‡Ç— ¡a/@«78A5_œ_Ž7¢5 645¤šdý¨74ýwü

ͺ1±2 3 ‰4ý{(µ3"e>©‡78klޱy7¢9:45¤474wʨ7 wý

€ ¢ÆÈN-¯5º»a))%Na,Ó78ùúû¤ÇÙC°y74ýüÉ ͺ±q ² ¢))Ò¾¿—ZaY\¤7ꊋ‰Šë74ýýÊD

ͺ³ ´ µ Ä,¹¯5º»ZŸ’7 53"e>ζÏ978Å7ÇÙ¢45Fúû¤dɨ7 4ýüd

€ ‰šn7ٛœ569¹}½y3"e>ζÏ978ٱ‡y‡7¢9:45¤

dvü7dvý¨4ýü)

4v

(17)

ͺ| } ~  ‰56789ù4üwv4ý4)D‡úû·¸Ž4‡d‡¢4£ÿ¤d¨7)¨7 4ýýv74ýý4

€ ĕ–±k788 ¸9rs74ý4DÅ ¢4£ÿ¤4¨74ýý

€ ‰±k3"e>fkl78 4üýv 4ý4DŽ¢4£ÿ¤)§)¨74ýýü

€ Än±kl578aj«78Èɇ74üýv4ý47ÝM¨œ§¦N*+¹/Å

¢4£ÿ¤É§¨74ýýü

€ ‰fkl789ùúû·¸Ž¢4£ÿ¤)¨7dvv4

€ ‰56¸¹\Zafkl7874üwv 4ý4Ž¢4£ÿ¤ü§)¨7dvvd

€ ‰f5678a))74üýv4ý4Dށ4‡d‡‡)‡É‡Ê‡¢4£ÿ¤

)d¨7)¨7)4§d¨7)¨7)d§)¨7)§d¨7dvv dvvÊ

€ ‰))3"e>f56784üýv4ý4DŽ¢Õ™Fúû¤)ý§Ê¨7dvvw ͺ¹º » ¼ ‰½1è¾çéèë0íðñíëòcåç¿åçí0éåë74üÉ4ü)D{|hi’3"e>)

) ¡auSށ±‡y‡7¢45•À¤4d4§)ɨ74dd§4d¨

ͺ¶yÁÿ ‰4ý{(µ7 53"e>l5789:hiƒ®+ùIf±k3"e

>9:rsaW}3"FŽ¢=y45ùF¤š)v§š¨74ýw)

ͺÎ Ï Ð ‰;NaJ½6ζÏ978§NaNƒBŽ7ȟ±ÄÅÆ9¢569:

¾yaAǤ=yl•=74ýüÊ

€ ‰Ü¦+N‘%‹7874üý 4ý4üDŽ 6ÈÙF¢™F•†¤dd¨74ýýv

€ Äfkl78§NaN9Å7ÉnÊ|}~97¢÷ø9:ùúûŒ

f71Ë*+9:Y\ 4üwv 4ý4)7ꊋ‰Šë74ýýd

€ ‰šn7ٛœ%NaaÇN))3"e>ܦ+N‘%‹784‡‚¬Ù¢4

£ÿ¤d§)¨74ýýÊ

€ Ěn7ٛœ3"e>Ǘ ¡78ÅÆI8Å1±zÙÌ9¢dv{

¸¹º»¼Z¤7ÇÍÙFC°y74ýýÊ

4v)

参照

関連したドキュメント

これを逃れ得る者は一人もいない。受容する以 外にないのだが,われわれは皆一様に葛藤と苦 闘を繰り返す。このことについては,キュプ

 私は、発掘・整理担当者として郷土遺跡と向き合っ てきたが、平成 12 ( 2000

名の下に、アプリオリとアポステリオリの対を分析性と綜合性の対に解消しようとする論理実証主義の  

 本研究所は、いくつかの出版活動を行っている。「Publications of RIMS」

[r]

世界規模でのがん研究支援を行っている。当会は UICC 国内委員会を通じて、その研究支

世界規模でのがん研究支援を行っている。当会は UICC 国内委員会を通じて、その研究支