• 検索結果がありません。

Investigationofinhibitoryeffectsof semiconductortoothbrushonbiofilm formation

N/A
N/A
Protected

Academic year: 2022

シェア "Investigationofinhibitoryeffectsof semiconductortoothbrushonbiofilm formation"

Copied!
17
0
0

読み込み中.... (全文を見る)

全文

(1)

I nvest i gat i onofi nhi bi t or yef f ect sof

semi conduct ort oot hbr ushonbi of i l m f or mat i on

Depar t men tofBehavi or alPedi at r i cDen t i s t r y

Ok ayamaUni ver si t yGr aduat eSchoolofMedi ci ne.Dent i s t r yand Phar maceu t i cal Sci ences

Kazi Ani surRahman

December1 2,201 2

(2)

1.Introduction

Streptococcusmutansisimplicatedasapnmarycausativeagentofdental cariesinhumans1‑2)IOneofitsimportantvirulencepropertiesistheabilityto form biofilms,termed dentalplaque,on tooth surfaces,after which accumulationofacidsindentalplaqueleadstolocalizeddecalcificationofthe enamelsurface.Therefore,removalofcanogenicdentalplaquefrom tooth surfacesisconsideredtobeafundamentaltechniqueforpreventionofdental Ca「leS.

Semi‑conductorpowdershavebeenshowntohaveabactericidaleffectfor photocatalyzed disinfectionofwater,while photosensitive titanium dioxide (TiO2)suspended inwaterwasdemonstrated to reduce the time oflight exposure requlred to induce disinfection 3) Furthermore,TiO2 has a bactericidaleffectonseveralspeciesofmicroorganisms,suchasEscherichI'a coII・ 4)and Streptococcus sobrI・nusAHT5) ltwas also reported thatSI sobrinusceHsweredamagedduetoslgnificantdisruptionofceHmembranes andce"wallsafterphotocatalyticactionfor60‑120min6)

A newlyintroducedtoothbrushwithTiO2embeddedjnasemiconductorin thebodyofthebrush,namedthe(Soladeyl2),wasrepo什edtohavebetter plaql」e 「emOVlng POtentialwhen compared to conventionaltoothbrushes, Suggestingthatthephotocatalyticpropertiesofthesemiconductormayhave bactericidalactivitiesandreducedentalplaqueontoothsurfaces7).However, themechanism causlngthereducedplaqueremainstobeelucidated.The (Soladey‑3)containsasemiconductorwithaTiO2rodandsolarpanel,as TiO2WaSreportedtobemoresensitiveunderUVlightinwater8).lnthisstudy, wefoundreducedbiofHm formationbyS.mutansfoIIowlnguseOfSoladey13,

(3)

anewlyintroducedtoothbrushthatcontainsasemiconductoralongwitha TiO2rodandsolarpanel・lnaddition,wevisuallyobservedthemorphologyof thesuげaceofhydroxyapatite(HA)pelletsa冊erbrushingwiththeSoladey‑3 andconsideredthepossl‑blemechanismsrelatedtoitse斤ects.

2.Materialsandmethods

2・1,HApelletsandtoothbrushes

HA pellets (10xlOx2 mm,APP‑100,PENTAX,Tokyo,Japan)were employedinthisstudy.Forthetoothbrushes,weusedaSoladey‑3toothbrush (ShikenLtd.C0.,Osaka,Japan)ContainingaTiO2rodembeddedintheneck and a sola「panelonthe topofthe hand一e ofthe body,and a regular toothbrushwithastainlesssteelrodintheneckasaplacebo.

2.2.Bacteriaandculturemedia

S.mutansMT8148R,whichisresistanttostreptomycln,wasusedinthis study.BacteriaweregrowninToddHewitt(TH)Broth(BectonDickinsonCo., Maryland,USA)includingstreptomycin(500トtg/ml)overnightat370Cpriorto theexpe「imentalprocedure.

2.3.Sa/ivasample

Unstimulated whole saliva was collected from a healthy subjectinto a beakerplacedoniceandclarifiedbycentrifugationfor30minat12,000g, afte「whichthesupematantwascollectedandkeptaト200Cuntiluse.

2.4.Biofilm formationassay

HApeHetsweredividedinto3groups,theneitherbrushedwiththeSoladey13 toothbrushastheexperimental(EX group)o「the placebotoothbrush(PL group),whilethethirdgroupwasnotbrushedandusedasacontrol・Brushing wasdoneinajarcontainingdistilledwaterandunderaHghtsource(40W, 750LUX)bythesameindividuals,whomaintainedthesamelevelofconstant

(4)

forceandusedatechniquesimilartonormaltoothbrushing.Toestimate biofilm formation,HApelletswithorwithoutbrushingwereexposedtohuman salivafor2hoursat37oC.ThreepeHetseachfrom theEXgroup,PLgroup, and controlgroups were placed into 6‑we" culture plates (CELLSTAR, Greinerbiol0ne,Frickenhausen.Germany)with5mlofTH brothcontaining lx106colony‑formingunits(CFU)/mlofS.mutansineachweH.Thepellets were then incubated at370C on a shakerat60 rpm underanaerobic conditions(80% N2,10% H2,10% CO2).FoHowing incubation,thepe‖ets wererinsed3timeswithphosphatebu斤eredsaline(PBS)toremoveJoosely boundcells.Next,theywereplacedintofreshPBS(5ml),chiHedonice,and theattachedbacteriawereremovedbyultrasonicvibrationfor1min.P巨s containlngbacteriawereseriallydilutedwithnormalsalinetoprepare102‑,

104‑,and106‑folddilutionsample・Next,100LLloforlglnalandeachofthe d仙tedsampleswereplatedonMitis‑Saliva「山S(MS)a9ar(Becton,Dickinson) for48hoursat370C underananaerobiccondition,FinaHy,thenumbersof bacterialcolonieswerecountedandtheresultsweresubjectedtostatistical analysIS.

2.5.X‑rayphotoelectronspectroscopy(XPS)

ThechemicalcompositionsoftheHA pelletswithandwithoutbrushingwas analyzed using anXPS device (AXISINOVA,Shimadzu Co.,Ltd.Kyoto, Japan)equippedwithanAIKα photonwith1486・6eVofenergy・Allbinding ener9‑eSWerereferredtoastheCIspeakofthealiphaticsurfacecarbonat 276‑288eV,andthehigh‑resolutionXPSspectraoftheCa2p(338‑356 eV),P2p(125137eV),andO ls(525‑537eV)photoelect「onpeakswere analyzed.

(5)

2・6・MorphologicalanalysisofHApellets

PelletsintheEXandPLgroupswerebrushed10,20,30,40,or50times, thenexposedtohumansalivafor2hoursat37oC,fotfowedbylnCubationin dist川edwaterfor24 hoursat37oC,Toevaluatethe recoverytimeofthe perimeterand area ofthe HA crystals,pellets brushed 50 times were incubatedindistilledwaterfor12.24,48,72,96,or120hoursat37oC.To reducetechnicalerror,aHbrushingprocedureswereperformed3timesbythe same individuals.To evaluate the HA pelletsurfacesafterbrushing and bacteria一adherence,they were obseⅣed uslng a scann∫ng e一ectron microscope (SEM;HitachiS‑4800,Tokyo,Japan)atlow (x800)and high (xlOO.000) magnifications.Measurements ofthe length ofthe crystal perimeterandsurfaceareaweredoneatx100,000magni¶CationuslngZeiss LSM Image Browserso斤ware,version 3・1・0199 (www・zeiss・de)I Data obtainedwerethensubjectedtostatisticalanaJysIS.

2.7.Statisticalanalysis

StatisticalanaJysJSWasPerformeduslngaOne‑WayANOVAtest,alongwith Fisher's protected leastsignificantdifference (PLSD)posthoc testand Student'st‑tes

t

.A p‑vaLue <0・05 was considered to be slgnifican

t

・All calculationswereperformedusingSPSS1610so冊ware(SPSS,lnc・,Chicago, IL).

3.Results

lnthe biofilm formationassay,the proportion ofS・mutansorganismsin biofitmsformedinculturesofpelletswithoutsucroseandbrushedwiththe Soladey13(EX group)wassignificantly reduced after6 (p=0・006)and 12

(6)

(p=01004),(Fig.1A).ln the EX group,a few S.mutans colonies were observed,while biofHmsformed with the peHetsfrom the controland PL groupsconsistedofthickerandmoreuniform layersascomparedtotheEX group・When1% sucrosewasadded,thequantityofbiofilm intheEXgroup was21fold lessascomparedtothecontro一groupa什er12 hours.The cell countofS.mutansintheEXgroupdecreased(p=0.004)a什er24hoursand wassignificantlysmallerthanthatobservedincontrolgroup(Fig.1B).lnthe controlgroup,the biofilm wasdense and coveredthe HA peHetsurfaces.

TheseresultsindicatethatuseoftheSoJadey‑3toothbrushreducedbacterial colonizationunderthevarioustestconditions.

XPS high‑resolutionspectra forthe HA pelletswJLth orwithoutbrushing revealed a slgnificantchemjcalshin ofthe peak.ln comparisons among groups,the peak representing the binding energy ofCa 2P showed a significantincreaseof1.2eV intheEX groupascomparedtoPLgroup(Fig.

2A),SuggestingthatuseoftheSoladey‑3toothbrushproducedashin owards higherbindingenergy.lncontrast,theP2psurfaceconcentrationwas13110 eV inthisgroup,lowerthanthatinthePL(132.1eV)andcontrol(13117eV) groups.Thus,the binding energyforP 2pwasslgnificantly reduced a什er brushingwithSoladey‑3(1.1eV)(Figure2A).Interestingly,a什er120hoursof incubationbllowln9b「ushin9WiththeSoladey‑3,allofthepeaks「etumedto normallevels(Fig.2B).Thepeakrepresenting0IswasunchangedunderaH ofthetestedconditions(Fig.2A,B).

ThesurfacesofthepeHetsintheEX,PL andcontroJgroupswereobserved usln9 an SEM.Atleast10 areaswere selected foreach 9「OuP,andthe surfaceareaandperimeterlengthofthecrystalsweremeasured.lntheEX

(7)

group,themeanvaluesforthesurfaceareaandperimeterlengthoftheHA crystalsweredecreased,andthesizedecreasedwithincreaslngnumbersof brushing.Somegapswereobservedbetweenthecrystalswithadecreasein thecrystalsize(Fig13A).ThesizeofpeHetssubjectedto50tinleSbrushing wassignificantlysmaHerthanthatofthosesubjectedtofewerbrushings(Fig.

3B,C).TherewasalsoasignificantdifferenceinmeancrystalsizeintheEX groupascomparedtothePLandcontrolgroups(Fig.3B,C).Toevaluate recovery,pelletsslJbjectedto50timesbrushingwereselectedfrom theEX groupand incubatedfor12,24,48,72,96,or120 hours,afterwhichthe surfaceareaandperimeterlengthofthecrystalsweremeasured.Thecrystals wererestoredtotheoriginalsizeafter120hours(Fig.4).

4.Discussion

TiO2isthoughttoenhancesolardisinfectionbyformlngOHlg,10),aradical consideredtohaveverydamaglngeffectsoni「「adiatedbiologlCalsystemsat diffusioncontro"edrates11112),asweHasceHwaHsandmembranes14).Thus, whenaTiO2equlPPedtoothbrushisused,biofilmslikelybecomesdisrupted byhydroxylradicals.Furthermore,theeffectivenessofthesemiconductorin thetoothbrushisdependentontheconcentrationofTiO2andlightintensity31 10)Alnaddition,OH・generatedinwaterdunnglightexposurejnthepresence ofTiO2WasShown to be responsible forbacterialdisinfection 10) ln the presentstudy,WeusedatoothbrushequlPPedwithasolarpanelandTiO2 Semiconductor to enhance the production of free radicals to prevent adherenceofS,mutansorganismstoHA.

lnthepresentstudy,Calcium and/Orphosphoruswasdetectedjnthebinding

(8)

energyregl0nOfCa2pandP2pelectronsuslngXPSafter50timesbrushing with the Soladey‑3 toothbrush.Spontaneous re‑precIPitation has been reported to be dependent on environmental pH, temperature, ionic concentration,calcium/phosphorus(Ca/P)molarratio,andthepresenceof organicorinorganicelements14)IOrganicphosphatesandphosphonatesare weHknowntohavehighaffinitiesforadsorptiontoapatitesurfaces15116)・ln thehumanoralenvironment.S,mutansadhesionismodulatedbysalivary proteinadsorptionontotheenamelsurface17)AWe foundthatchangesin surfacecorTlPOSitionoftheHA peHetsoccurredasaresultofbrushingthe surfacesofthepe"ets.ThesesurfacechangesresultedintowerS,mutans aqinityascomparedtothenon‑brushedpellets.

lt is wellknown that organic phosphoric compounds are exceHent antibacterialagents18)・Therefore.itispossib一ethatthepresenceofcertain amounts ofphosphor‑containJng components on the surface may induce antibacterialactivitythatinhibitsthegrowthofbacterialce"S.Also,changesin surfaceroughnessandsurfacemorphologyareimportantfactorsthatimpact bacterialbehavior19)・ThecrystalsizeofpeHetsbrushed50timeswiththe Soladey‑3inthepresenceoflightandwatermayhavebecomesIgnificantly decreasedduetoshrinkage.whichcreatedsomegapspacesbetweenthe crystals.BrushingwithSoladey‑3producesnegativeenergyelectronsthat changethesurfacemorphologyofHA,thusgapsthatform asaresultmaybe dueto a hydrophobicaction ofthe crystals.These findingssuggestthat brushing50timeswiththistoothbrushcanmodifythe HA surface,which mightbeanimportantfactorforpreventionofbacterialadhesion.

lnsummary,theSoladey‑3TiO2SemiconductortoothbrushequlPPedwitha

(9)

Solarpanel,hasantibacteriaIeffectsandcancontrolbacterialadhesionbetter thancommoncommerciallyavailabletoothbrushes.Ourfindingssuggestthat thissemiconductortoothbrushcouldbeusefulforcontroHngofdentalcaries.

Acknowledgmen

t :

WethankAssociateProfessorHiroshiKominamiofKinkiUniversity,Japan, forperformlngtheXPSanalysIS.

(10)

References:

1・HamadaS.andSladeHD.:Biology,immunoLogy,andcarl0genicityof Streptococcusmutans.M/'crlDb/'o/Rev.,44(2):331‑334,1980.

21LoescheWJ.:RoleofStreptococcusmutansinhumandentaldecay.

M/'crobio/Rev.,50(4):353‑380,1986.

3.MatsunagaT.,TomodaR.,NakajimaT.,Nakamura N.,KomineT.: ContinuousISterHizationsystemthatusesphotosemiconductorpowders.

App/Env/'rlDnMicrobio/,,54:133011333,1988.

4.MatsunagaT.:Sterilization with particulate photo semiconductor.J Ant/'bactAnWung/'cAgents.,13:2111220,1985.

5. MoriokaT.,SaitoT.,NaraY.andOnodaK.:Antibacterjalactionof powdered semiconductoron a serotype g Streptococcus mutans.

CariesRes.,22:230‑231,1988.

6.SaitoT.,lwaseT,Horie J.,MoriokaT.:Mode ofphotocatalytic bactericidalaction of powdered semiconductorTiO2 0n mutans streptococci.JPhotochem Photobio/B.,14:369‑379,1992.

7.HooverJN.,Singer DL Pahwa P.and Komlyama K.:Clinical evaluationofalightenergyconversiontoothbrush.JC//'nPen‑odonto/., 19:434‑436,1992.

8.OHisDF.:Contaminantdegradationinwater.EnvironSc/'Techno/.,19:

480‑484,1985,

9.lrelandJC.,KIostermannP.,RiceEW.andClarckRM.:lnactivationof Escherichia coliby titanium dioxide photocatalytic oxidation・App/

Env/IronM/'crob/'o/.,59:166811670,1993.

(11)

10・Bekbolet M.and Araz CV.:lnactivation of Escherich/'a col/'by photocatalyticoxidation.Chemosphere.,32:9591965,1996.

ll.MeckstrothWK.,DorfmanLM.,HeikkilaRE.:ReactivityofthehydroxyJ radicalwithamygdalininaqueoussolution.B/'ochem Pharmacol.,29:

3307‑3309,1980.

12.AIpenE.L:Radiat/IonBiophysics.SanDiego:AcademicPress.,38:32‑

168,1997

13.SaLih FM.:EnhancementofsoJarinactivationofEscherich/'a col/'by titanium dioxidephotocatalyticoxidation.JAppIM/'crob/'ol.,92:9201926, 2002.

14.LeGerosRZ.:Formationofcalcium phosphatesinvitro.ln:MyersHM (ed).Calcium phosphatesinoralbiologyand medicine.New York:

Karger,46167,1991.

15.Jung A.,Bisaz S.,BartholdiP.,and Flejsch H.: Influence of pyrophosphateontheexchangeofcalcium and phosphate ionson hydroxyapatite.Calc/'fT/'ssueRes.,13(1):27‑40,1973.

16.Ba「telsT.andA「endsJ∴Adso「Ptionofapolyphosphonateonbovine enamelandhydroxyapatite.CariesRes.,13:218‑226,1979.

17.ShimotoyodomeA.,KobayashiH.,Tokimitsu I.,Hase T.,lnoueT., MatsukuboT,,TakaesuY.:Saliva‑promotedadhesionofStreptococcus mutansMT8148associateswithdentalplaqueandcariesexperience.

CariesRes.,41:2121218,2007.

18.SawaiJ.:QuantitativeevaluationofantibacterialactivitiesofmetaHic oxide powders (ZnO,MgO and CaO)by conductimetric assay・J MjcrobioIMethods"54(2):177‑182,2003.

(12)

19.ZhangW.,LuoY..WangH.,PuS.andChuPK.:BiocompatibiJityof silverandcopperplasmadopedpolyethylene.SurfCoatTech.,203:

25 5 0 ‑ 25 5 3, 20 0 9.

(13)

FigureLegend:

Figure1ViableceHcountsofS.mutansontheHA peHets,HA pelretswere treated50timeswithSoladey‑3(EXgroup)orcontroltoothbrush (controlgroup)andwereincubationwithS.mutansfor6,12or24 hours.Incubationwasperformedundertheconditionwith(B)or withoutsucrose(A).★P<0.05了★P<0.001.

Figure2XPSanalysISforbindingenergyontheSurfaceofHA treatedwith Soladey‑3 (experimentalgroup)ornormaltoothbrush (placebo group).HA peHetwithoutthebrushingtreatmentwasusedasa controL.(A)The peakpositionofCa,P and O inexperimental, placeboandcontrolgroupafter24hoursincubation.(B)After120 hoursincubation,thepeakpositionofCa,Pand0inexperimental, placeboandcont「olgroupwasalmostinsameposition.Asterisks indicate'P<0.05.

Figure3SEM imageof(A)physicalchangeofHAmolecularsize(B)surface a「eaofmoleculesand(C)pe「imete「ofmoleculesafterbrushing withsoladey13andplacebotoothbrush.Asterisksindicate'P<0.05,

★★P<0.001了 ★★P<0.0001

Figure4(A)lnHA peHetsexposedto50timesbrushingwiththeSoladey‑3, thecrystalsreturnedtonormalsizeafter120hoursofincubation (x100,000).Graphsdepictchangesinthe(B)surfaceareaand(C) perimete「ofHA moleculesafter12.24,48,72,96,and120hours ofincubation,as weHas comparisons with the controlgroupI Asterisksindicate'P<0.05,''P<0.001,'''P<0.0001.

(14)

MeannumberofS.mutans

AI

Vu th

outsucroseB.

W ith ]

%sucros

e

CFUJ

m f

■ ■ H

⊂)+ O)

8.E+05

4E+05

0

MeannumberofS.mutans o

「「

li;:

co

+ LL)

⊂)+ rO

Ji

+1

⊂)

⊂)

一⊃cubatio⊃ti∃e(hours)

■ Ex pe ri m en ta f (E X ) g r

oup

□ C

ontrolgroup 一⊃cubatio⊃ti∃e(hours)

■ Ex

perim

ent a I (E X )

groupControlgroup

¶igure.

(15)

IntellSity /礼ll

J

⊂⊃ トJ tJJ

.

fi u Oヽ

⊂⊃

⊂ ⊃⊂ ⊃

⊂ ⊃⊂ ⊃⊂ ⊃

⊂⊃

( = >⊂ ⊃

(=>

⊂ ⊃⊂ ⊃⊂ ⊃

(=>

( = >( = >

(=>

( = >( = >( = >

J l く つ

ロコ

E

= etと (JQr一 ■r 'JJ

:I て3(PtJ

りq

l.rー< O<\ tIし■Iリ ー^JJI. ̲

Q l uJ

o ' >

01 ⊂)

co t

lltenSity/a,ll.

ー ▲ ‑

ー▲ ‑

( = > ⊂

⊃ (=> ⊂⊃ (=> (=> (=> (=> (=> (=>

⊂ >

LJ UJ ,t

lt J IG

ー∞\ C l

( = >く

> (=> (=> (=> ⊂⊃ (=

>⊂ ⊃( = >( = >

( = >( =

> (=> (=> (=> (=> (=

>( = >( = >( = >

ll.

■ l

l l l l l

ll

、.I

Ezj

ト一 ーて3t「コJ

U J ト一

21 ⊂ )

ー■

Uq ト一

r l..

しJ

ト■ G tT

r.1 lし■‑J.. ト一

IntellSity/a.u.

トJ UJ

. l ゝr J

1

ロ ヽ‑ 」

(=> く> (=>

⊂ ⊃( = >( = >( = >

⊂⊃ く> (=>

( = >( = >( = >( = >

く> く> ⊂>

⊂ >⊂ >く >⊂ >

く> (=> く>

( = >( = >( = >く >

tJI I

r

ノー ,JI ト■㌧」

D).i:

: o

L

E● ■ノー

C )

U l

U ⊂ J L ) L OL J U ( J⊂ U A J ) )

′ . ■ ■ 】 ■

、. し■

< し■'..し■1JlAヽ1JI

ト 一

lttenSjty/a.lT.

UJ UJ UJ UJ

U J U J t J J

IJ LJ UJ UJ

J ゝ J i 〔 J l

⊂⊃ (ノ1 ⊂⊃ Ul

( = > リ 1⊂ ⊃

(=>

( = >

く>

( = > ( = > ( = > く >

(=>

( = >

く>

( = > ( = > ( = >

(

= >

く つ

UJ UJ (「

.一ゝ .一ゝ

E●し 0 0 ヽ

e: a) 」 P

E='

U J J

Uq ̲

0 ヽ

■■■ 企

a tくし■リlノー: tJ3

lltenSity/a.ll,

ー▲

lJ

■ i

G

0 0 ⊂ ⊃

LJ J

ゝG

、J

(=>

( = >

(=>

( = >⊂ ⊃

(=>

( = >( = >

(=>

( = >

(=>

( = >く >

(=>

( = >⊂ ⊃

ll.

\】

E'

■■l ー「コ

̲1. UrUJ

■ ■ ■

( 伯

= u G tJ

ト■

<lし■.. ̲

ltteltSity/a.ll.

一. トJ UJ

. f iI J lq ヽ

‑I

⊂>

⊂ >

⊂⊃

⊂ >⊂ >⊂ >

⊂>

く>

⊂ >

く>

⊂ ⊃⊂ >⊂ >

⊂>

⊂⊃

⊂ ⊃

く>

⊂ ⊃( = >( = >

く>

⊂>

⊂ ⊃

く>

⊂ ⊃く >⊂ ⊃

⊂>

r^ J

l

'^

tj

E

g

Uq )l

C )

班撃≡ト U l ( ′ . ・ ) . ▲

o< :Iし■.し■tし■JIノーJ⊂)I

⊂ )o l U l U l

IExperimen

ta

l

g

roupP一acebogroupInotrgroup

Figure2

(16)

Figure3

MeanareaofHAcWstals

l

l

0(control))0EjX 0

Brushing

ti

m

es

(tim

e

)

Ex

pe

rimental(EX)group

pla

c

eb

o

(PL)group

MeanperimeterofHAcrystals

○(noコtrO

203040

50

Brushingtimes(time)

mXperi∃

e⊃ta

(mX)group

□ p 一

acebo(P)group

(17)

>

lncubationtimes(hours)

0

MeanperimeterofHAc「ystals

(0

′十

O

ト・ トJ

2448

L

D

O l

jZE

⊂)

5i] (

̲J

′▼

ll0

12

MeanareaofHAcrystals tZI

ul G Ej g ti

。 喜 呂 害 go 害 喜 og '=

244872

[ncubationtimes(hours)

参照

関連したドキュメント

ヨーロッパ近代法の幕開けは、1789年のフランス革命の勃発、その後のナポレオンによる継承と

による解析を行い,それぞれの予測法の有明粘土への 適用性 を吟味す る。 なお,既報 3) で,提案式が必ず しも,予測精度がよ くなかった原因が正規圧密地盤 と

すなわち環境行動 を心がける人は、 どちらともいえな い人 よりも WTP を低 く表明することがわかった。大 村湾 との関わ りは訪問経験がマイナスの係数を事実認

このように、家庭で使用す る分別容器 と収集 の方 法 には様 々な形 と組み合わせがあ り得 る。 これ らの 中か ら実際にどのよ うな方法が選択

[r]

[r]

各種 目と各評価 との相関係数 を見 ると ( 表 1 ), 守備 の評価 との相関が低 い ことが 目につ く,そ して,そ の中では,連続 シ ョー トキ ックのみが高い相関を示

[r]