• 検索結果がありません。

Vol.64 , No.3(2016)190堀田 和義「ジャイナ教在家信者はいかなる条件のもとでsallekhanaが認められるのか?」

N/A
N/A
Protected

Academic year: 2021

シェア "Vol.64 , No.3(2016)190堀田 和義「ジャイナ教在家信者はいかなる条件のもとでsallekhanaが認められるのか?」"

Copied!
6
0
0

読み込み中.... (全文を見る)

全文

(1)

Journal

ofIndian

and BuddhistStudiesVol.64,No.3,March 2016

(77)

Under

Which

Conditions

Is

sallekhana

Permitted

forJain

Laity?

HOTTA

Kazuyoshi

Introduction

In

Jainism,

the

practice

of

fasting

unto

death

is

known

as sallekhandi.

Since

early

times,

such

fasting

has

been

practiced

not only

by

mendicants

but

also

by

laypersons.

5ince

sallekhandi, which

is

a

kind

of voluntary

death,

was criticized as constituting suicide,i)

sorne

Jain

monks

have

emphasized

that

sallekhana and suicide

differ

in

various

points.

This

paper

fbcuses

on

the

conditions under which sallekhana

is

permissible

forJain

laity

through

an examination of

5'ravakaca-ra

texts

concerning

the

code

fbr

laypersons.

2)

First,

Iwill survey the various word

forms

ofsallekhana

in

the

texts

belonging

to

this

genre.

Second,

I

will

determine

the

place

that

sallekhandi

holds

in

the code

for

laypersons.

FinallM

I

will examine

the

conditions under which the

practice

of sallekhana

is

permitted.

1.

Word-Forms

ofsallekhana-The

word sallekhana-3)

is

derived

from

root sami/likh.

It

is

considered

to

be

way of

death

for

the wise

(paptditamara4a).`}

The

term

is

interpreted

as rneaning "to

scrape ofl7'

(lekhana)

"properly"

(sam)

the outer

body

and

inner

passions.S}

In

Digambara

Sanskrit

texts,the word-form sallekhana'

is

most

prevalent,

6)

but

additionally sallekha, ')

sallekhana,B) sulekhana-,9) and sallesarpaiO> can also

be

found.

on the other

hand,

gvetambara

Sanskrit

texts

mostly use

the

fbrm

samlekhana'.ii)

Digambara

Prakrit

texts

also use saUehana,i2) saliihana,i3) and sallekhana,i`) while

Svetambara

Prakrit

texts

use sarplehana-.iS)

Such

differences

in

the

preverb

fbrms

have

been

pointed

out as a characteristic of the IUttvarthasatra,i6)

but

can also

be

applied toother

texts.

(2)

1119-(78)

Under Which ConditionsIssallekhandPermitted

fbrJain

Laity?

(HoTTA)

2.

The

Place

of sallekhana"-

in

the

Codes

for

Laypersons

Mest S'ravaka-caratexts

discuss

twelve vratas consisting of

five

aptuvratas, three

gu"avratas,

and

fbur

s'iksa-vratas.

The

contents of

the

five

a"uvratas are common

to

atl

texts,

while

the

contents of

the

gu"avratas

and s'iksavratas vary.

Some

texts count

sallekhana as one ofthe s'iksdivratas.i')

Other

texts

discuss

sallekhana- even though they

do

not count

it

as one of

the

s'iksavratas,iS)

In

particular

the

Dharrnaratnakara

(DhR),

Dharmasarngrahas'ra-vaka-ca-ra

(gr(M)),

and

Sagaradharmamrta

(SDhA)

each

dedicate

one

chapter

to

a

discussion

ofsallekhana,and the Navapadaprakaru4avrtti

(NPPV)

describes

it

in

detail

by

referring tothe story ofa role model. From the above, although

the

practice

of sallekhana

does

not constitute an obligation

for

laypersons,

it

can

be

said

that

it

is

recommended

to

enthusiastic

practitioners,

3.

Under

Which

Conditions

Is

sallekhand

Permitted?

Jainism

has

made the

fo11owing

three

counterarguments against the criticism that

sallekhana

is

equivalent

to

suicide,

i.e.,

(a)

the

conditions under which the

practice

of sallekhana

is

permitted,

(b)

the

difference

of

the

state of mind

possessed

by

a

practitioner

engaging

in

sallekhana and a

person

killing

a

living

being,

and

(c)

the

five

types

of

transgression

of

the

rules

pertaining

to

sallekhana. As space

is

limited,

the

discussien

below

is

limited

to

(a)

in

this

paper.

i")

The

Umdsvamis'ra-vaka-cara

(gr(U))

and

Sra'vakacarasaroddhara

(Sr(PN))

list

the

foIlowing

six conditions,

i.e.

(i)

a

great

famine,

(iD

a

fatal

disease,

(iii)

old age,

(iv)

in

case one

is

about

to

be

ki11ed

by

hostile

forces,

(v)

in

case the ascetic

practices

might

be

lost,

and

(vi)

in

case one

is

at

death's

doon

20)The

Praffnottarus'rctvakacara

(Sr(S))

lists

(1)

old age,

(2)

lack

ofphysical abilitM

(3)

a

fatal

disease,

(4)

an unavoidable calamity and

(s)

a

great

famine.2i)

Furtherrnore,

phrases

equivalent

to

(v)

and

(vi)

above are also added.22)

The

imrusarthanus'as-

ana

(PM)

also

lists

the

fo11owing

five

conditions,

i.e.,

(1)

a

fatal

disease,

(2)

an unavoidable calarnity

(3)

in

case one's selficontrol might

be

destroyed

by

ill-doers,

(4)

in

cases

in

which water or

fire

might cause one's

death,

and

(s)

in

case one

knows

one's end

through

inauspicious

signs. 23)

The

Dharmasaipgrahasi'avakctcara

(Sr(M))

lists

(1)

a

great

famine,

(2)

an unavoidable calamity; and

(3)

a

fatal

disease,24)

and also

(3)

Under Which ConditionsIssallekhanaPermitted

fbrJain

Laity?

(HoT'rA) (79)

Ratnakara4das'ra-vakacara

(RK)

and

the

Ratnakarapdas'ravakacaratika

(RKT)

list

(1)

an unavoidable calamity;

(2)

a

great

famine,

(3)

old age, and

(4)

a

fatal

disease

alongside a

phrase

that

is

equivalent

to

(v).

26)The

Dharmopades'aptyasavarsagravakdicara

(SR(B))

lists

the

same

fbur

conditions,

but

lacks

a

phrase

corresponding to

(v).

2')The

Ca-ritrasara

(cs)

lists

(1)

an unavoidable calamitM

(2)

a

great

farnine,

and

(3)

old age as well as a

phrase

equivalent to

(v).

The Ldtisarrihita

(LS)

lists

(1)

old age,

(z)

an unavoidable calamitM and

(3)

a

fatal

disease.

28)

Siddhasenagaptn

interprets

the

content ofUmasvati's commentary

on

the

Tattvarthastitra

as

the

tirne

when

dharma

and a-vafyaka are

damaged

based

on

the

fo11owing

three

defects

(dosa):2")

(1)

kala

(hard

times

or a

great

famine),

(2)

samhananadaurbalya

(weakening

of

the

body),30)

and

(3)

upasarga

(calamity

caused

by

a

god,

man, an animal or oneselO.

Jinabhadra

also

interprets

it

as

the

same

three

situations,

but

he

does

not rnention a

great

farnine.

Akalafika

and Vidyanandin mention

the

case

in

which

avatfyaka

is

destroyed

through

damage

tothe senses caused

by

(1)

old age and

(2)

disease,

while

the

ibgas'a-stra

(YS)

and Ybgas'a-stravrtti

(YSV)

list

cases

in

which

(1)

one cannot

practice

the

six

avaEfyakas

and

(2)

one

is

at

death's

door.

The

other

texts

only mention that

death

isnear

for

some reason. 3i)

From

the

above,

it

can

be

said that an unavoidable calamity, a

great

famine,

old age, and a

fatal

disease

are essential conditions, and

phrases

such as `'in case one

is

at

death's

door"

and "for

the

purpose

ofdharmd'

loosely

encompass these

four

conditions.

These

fbur

conditions are

decreased

in

number as needed and

in

the

last

case,

the

expression "in case one

is

at

death's

door"

incorporates

allofthem.

4.

Conclusion

The

fo11owing

stanza taken

from

the

ksastilakacampa

(YTC)

skillfu11y expresses the

background

in

which

these

conditions were established. "Ifthe

king

who

has

learned

a

military art

for

twelve

years

fe11

into

disorder

in

the

field,

what can

be

a military art

for

him?

The

past

conduct ofthe monk who

is

at

death's

door

is

the same."32) This stanza

implies

the

difference

between

sallekhandi and suicide.

That

is

to

say; sallekhana

is

a

religious

practice

in

which one

dies

with

dignity

for

the

teachings

ofJainism.

'Iexpress my sincere

gratitude

toDr,ShinFtijinaga

(National

InstituteofTechnology, Miyakonoj6

College)and Dr,Tomoyuki Uno

(Chikushi

Jogakuen

University)

fbr

providing

me with generous access tothetextsconsulted

fbr

this

paper.

(4)

-1121-(80)

Under Which ConditionsIssallekhana Permitted

forJain

Laity?

(HoT'TA)

Notes1)

Tukol lg76 argues

fbr

sallekhandi from the viewpoint ofajudge, Recently, the relation

between

sallekhana and suicide

have

become

a major

public

issue.

See

`lain

practjce

of Santharaallowed

by

Supreme Court," lndia 7bdcty:

http:11indiatodayLintoday.inlstoryLjain-practice-of-santhara-allowed-by-suprerrie-court!11462019.html

(the

last

browsed

date

October 28,2015), 2) As

fbr

a

previous

study on this

issue,

see Williams1963: 166-172;Sogani1967: 117-119; Bhargava 1968:

139-142. As

fbr

a study

based

on

gvetambara

canonical texts and

inscriptions,

see

Caillat

1977. 3) As totheother various names, see Settar1989:95-98. 4)

As

tothe

division

of

death

inJainacanonical texts,see Schubring 1935:

g16s,

5) T(P) g705.As to the examples of

sallekha inPalicanonical texts,see Kawasaki 2005. 6) KAT,CPT,CS,T(A), T(P),T(Bh), T(V),

T(g),DhR, PAA, PASU, RK,RKT,LS,

gr(A),

gr(AD),

Sr(U),

Sr(PN),

Sr(B),

Sr(M),

Sr(S),

SDhA, SRS,HP. Doha and

grDK

do

not use theword

derived

from

the root samt/7ikh-. 7) PP,RM, VC,

8) YTC. 9) BhDhU, 10)

Sr(G).TheetymologyofthiswQrdformisunknown.

11) T(U), T(S),T(H),NPPS4 PRE PRPX4YS,YSV,

SrDKY

SrPrV

12) CP, 13) KA,BhS(D).According to

thevariant ofKA, thereare

four

rnanuscripts which use salreha4a. 14)

gr(V).

Is) NPe

grPr.

16) SeeKanakura 1944:174. 17)

CP,

CPT,

Doha,PP,BhDhU, BhS(D),RM, VC,

Sr(G),

Sr(V),

18) KA, KAT, CS,T(A),T(U),T(P),T(Bh),T(V),T(g),T(S),T(H), DhR, PAA, PASU, PRP, PRPY YTC,YS,YSY RK,RKT,LS,

Sr(A),

Sr(AD),

gr(U),

Sr(PN),

Sr(B),

Sr(M),

Sr(S),

SrDK,

SrDKY

SrPr,

grPrM

SDhA, SRS, HP. As to sallekhana',

gr(PN)

states almost the same contents as

Sr(U).

The contents of

guravratas

and s'iksavratas of US and

gr`vS>

are not clear.

Sr(AD)

seems not toinclude sallekhana

in

s'iksa-vrtttas, 19) SDhA isa

kind

of anthology; so I

do

not

discuss

itinthis

paper.

20)

Sr(U)

450-451

(-

Sr(PN)

349-350). 21)

gr(S)

22.3-5. 22)

Sr(S)

22.11ab. 23) PAA 99-100. 24)

Sr(M)

7.21. 25)

gr(M)

7.9-10, 26)

RK

122.

KAT

quotes

thisstanza and

fo11ows

itsopinion.

Sr(G)

isalmost the same as RK. See

gr(G)

3.50.

27)

SR(B)

5.3. 28)

CS,

pp.

260-261;

LS233. 29) T(S)on T(U)7.17.T(S)

inserts

theword

"mararpam."

30)

As

to

the

word saTnhanana, see Kawasaki 2014:442. 31) YTC 891-895;

gr(A)

6.98;

SrPrV

on

SrPr

377, 380, 383; SRS 31.61;HP 58.160-161. Furthermore,we can categorize

KA,CP,BhDhU,BhS(D), and PASU intothis

group.

32) YTC 898.

Primary Literatureand Abbriviaritons

US UPdsakasaiTiskaraofPadmanandin inPaficavim.s'ati.Ed,A.N.Upadhye and H.L.Jain.JivarajaJaina

Grantham51a, no. Io.

Solapar:

Jaina

SarpskrtiSarpraksakaSahgha, 1962.KA

Dvadas'aJnupreksa

of

Karttikeya.Ed.A. N. upadhye,

Srimad

Rajacandra

Jaina

Sastramata.

Agas:

Srimad

Rajacandra

ASrama,

1960.KAT Dvdidas'a-nupreksctttka'of

gubhacandra.

SeeKA.CP Caritrupra-bh.rta

in

Astapa-hudaof Kundakunda. Ed,PannalalaSahityacirya.Sonagir: Bhiratavarsiya Anekanta VidvatParisad, 1989-199o,clrTCaritraprabh.rtatikaof

Srutasagara.

SeeCP.CS Caritrusdraof Camurpdaraya.

See

SASI.

T(A)

Iuttvdirthasatrawith commentary of Akalanka

(Rojava-rttika).

Ed.Mahendrakumira

Jaina.

sth ed.

Bharatiya

Jfianapitha

Mtirtidevi

Jaina

Granthamala, Samskrta

Grantha,

nos. 10,20.New Delhi:

(5)

UnderWhich ConditionsIssallekhanct Permitted

forJain

Laity?

<HoTTA)

(81)

Ed.

Mody

Keshavlal

Premchand,

Bibliotheca

Indica,

Calcutta:

Asiatic

Society

1903.

T(P)

7icittvarthasatra

with commentary of PbjyapAda

(Sarvarthasiddhi).

Ed. PhttlacandraSiddhantaSastri,

2nd ed. Bharatiya

Jfianapitha

MartideviJaina

Granthamala,

Samskrta

Grantha,

no. 13.

Vdrdnasi:

Bharatlya

Jfianapitha,

1971, T(Bh) TUttvarthasUtrawith commentary of Bhaskaranandin

(Tlattvarthav.rtti).

Ed.A,

S5ntiraja

S5stri.

Mysore: University of Mysore Oriental Library; 1944. T(V)

1lattvarthasatrawith commentry of Vidyanandin

(7tittvarthaglokavarttika).

Ed. Manoharalala

NyayaSastrin.SaraswatiOrientalResearch SanskritSeries,no. 16.Ahmedabad: SarasvatiPustaka

Bharpdara,1998. T(S) 1lattvarthastitruwith commentary of

Srutas5gara

(TUttvarthavrtti),

Ed. Mahendrakumara

Jaina.

2nd ed. Bharatiya

Jfianapitha

Mtirtidevl

Jaina

Granthamala, Samskrta

Grantha,

no. 4,New

Delhi:

Bharatiya

JfiAnapitha,

1999.T(S)fottvarthasiltrawith commentary of

Siddhasenagarpin,

Ed. HiralalRasikdasKapadia.

Sresthi

Devacandra Lalabhai

Jainapustakoddhara,

nos. 67,76.BombaM 1926. T(H) 1icittvarthastitrawith commentary ofHaribhadra and

Jinabhadra.

Editor unknown. Surat:

griratnapuriyagresthirsabhadevajIkeSarimalajijainaSvetarpbarasarpstha,

1936.Doha Savayadhammadoha. See

SASI.

DhR DharmaratndkaraofJayasena. Ed.A.N.Upadhye.

Jivaraja

Jaina

Granthamala, no. 24. SoLapar:

Jaina

SarpskrtiSamraksaka Sangha, 1974. NPP Navapadaprukararpaof Devagupta.Editorunknown. Bombay:

SrTJinagEsana

Aradhana

Trest,

vie sarpe

2045.NPPV Navapadaprakara4avrttiofYaSodeva,

See

NPP. PAA

Puruljarthanus'as-

ana ofGovinda. See

SAS3.

PASU Purusarthasidd}tyupdyaof Amptacandra,

Editor

unknown.

grimad

Rajacandra

Jaina

gastramala,

no. 7,AgEs:

SriparamaSrutaprabhavakamarpdala,

1977.PP Padmapurana ofRaviserpa.

Ed.

PannalalaJaina.BharatTyaJfianapithaMartideviJainaGranthamala,SamskrtaGrantha,no. 21.New

Delhi:Bharatiya

Jfianapitha,

2003. PRP PraE;amaratiprakararpaof Umasvati. Editor unknown.

gresrhidevacandralalabha-ijainapustakoddhara,

no. ss.Bombay:

Sresthidevacandralalabha'lj'aina-pustakeddharasarpstha,

1940,

PRPV

Pras'amaratiprakararpa

of Haribhadra, See PRP. BhDhU

Bhavyadharmopades'opdsaka-dlyayanaof

Jinadeva.

See

SAS3.

BhS(D) Prak.rtabhjvasarpgraha of

Devasena. See

SAS3,

YTC YasiastilakacampUof Somadeva, Ed. KailaSacandra

Sastri.

Bharatiya

Jfianapltha

Martidevi

Jaina

Granthamala, Sarpsk;ta Grantha, no. 2s, Vararpasi:Bharatiya

" /

Jfianapitha,

1964.YS Ybgas'a-straofHemacandra. Ed.MuniJambavijaya. Murribar:Sri

Jaina

Sahitya

VikisaMarpdqla,1977.YSV Ybgas'a'stravrttiof Hemacandra, SeeYS. RK Ratnakarandas'ra-vaka'caraof

Samantabhadra.

Ed.

Jugalakigora

Mukhtara. MarpikacandraDigambaraJaina GranthamEla, no. 24,

Bombay: Marpikacandra Digambara

Jainagranthamala

Samiti, vie sarpe 1982. RKT

Ratnakarandas'ravakacaratika-of Prabhacandra. See RK. RM Ratnarndlaof

givakoti.

See

SAS3,

Ls

Latisamhita-of Rajamalla. Ed. DaravarilalaNyayatirtha. Marpikacandra Digambara

Jaina

Granthamala,no, 26.Bornbay:MarpikacandraDigarnbara

Jainagranthamala

5amiti,vie sarpe 1984.

VC Virira-n'gacaritaofJatasirphanandin. Ed.A.N.Upadhye. BharatavarsiyaAnekanta VidvatParisad,

no, 24.Varanasi:BharatavarsiyaAnekanta Vidvat Parisad,lgg6.

SASI

S'ravakacarusaipgraha,vol. 1.

Ed.Hiralala

Sastri.

Jivaraja

Jaina

Granthamala, Hindi Vibhaga, no. 27.Solfipar:

Jaina

Sarpskrti Sarpraksaka

Sangha,

lg76.

SASz

Sra'vakacarttsarpgraha,

vol. 2.Ed. Hiralaia

Sastri,

Jivaraja

Jaina

Granthamala,

Hindi

Vibhaga,

no. 28.

SolapUr:

Jaina

Sarpskrti

SarpraksakaSangha, lg76.

SAS3

S'ra-vakdica-rusarrigraha,vol. 3.Ed. Hiralila

Sistri.

Jivaraj"aJaina

Granthamala, HindiVibhaga,no. 2g,

SolapUr:

Jaina

SarpskrtJiSarpraksakaSangha, 2003.

Sr(A)

Amitagatis'ra-vaka-caraof Amitagati.See

(6)

(82)

under which ConditionsIssallekhana- Permitted

fbrJain

Laity?

(HorrA)

SASI.

Sr(AD)

Vratoclyotanas'ra'vaka-caraof Abhradeva. See

SAS3,

Sr(U)

Umasvamfs'ra-vakacaraof

Umasvamin.

See

SAS3.

Sr(G)

Gu"abhasa4aSravakacara of Gurpabhasarpa.See

SAS.

Sr(PN)

Sra-vaka-carasaroddhara

of Padmanandin. See

SAS3,

Sr(B)

Dharmopades'apty[isavarsctEfravakacaraof

Brahrnanernidatta.See

SAS2,

Sr(M)

Dharniasarrigrahas'ravaka-caraof Medhavin. See

gAS2.

Sr(V)

vasunandis'ravaka-caraof Vasunandin, Ed. Hirirala

Jaina.

Bharatiya

Jfianapitha

Martidevi

Jaina

Granthamala, Prakrta Grantha, no, 3. Vararpasi:Bharatiya

Jfianapitha,

1952.

Sr(VS)

Vratasaras'ra'vaka'cara,Author unknown.

See

SAS3.

Sr(S)

PraSnottams'ra-vakaca-raof Sakalakirti,See

SAS2,

SrDK

S'ra-ddhadinakrtyaof Devendra, Editorunknown. Bombay:

jinagasana

Aradhana

Trest,

vie sarTio 2045.

SrDKV

S'raddhadinakrtyavrttiof Devendra. See

SrDK.

grPr

SravakapTzv'n-apti

of

Umasvati.

Ed, Balacandra

Sastri.

2nd ed. Bharatiya

Jfianapitha

MUrtidevi

Jaina

Grantharnala,

PralcrtaGrantha, no. 8.New Delhi:Bharatiya

Jfianapitha,

1999.

SrPrV

S'raffvakapnv'nrvaptiv.rtti

of

Haribhadra.See

SrPr.

SDhA Sagdiradharmamrtaof

Agadhara.

Ed.Kailagacandra

SEstri.

Bharatiya

Jfianapitha

Manidevi

Jaina

Granthamala, Sarpskna Grantha, no. 47. Vararpasi:Bharatiya

Jfianapitha,

2000.

SRS

SubhaJs.

itaratnasarridoha

ofAmitagati. Ed.BalacandraSiddhantaSastrL

Jivaraja

Jaina

Granthamala,

Hindi

Vibh2ga, no. 31.Solapar:JainaSamslcrtiSamraksaka Sangha, 1977, HP

Harivarps'apuraoa of

Jinasena.

Ed. Pannalala

Jaina.

Bharatiya

Jfianapitha

Martidevi

Jaina

Grantharnala, Sarpsk;taGrantha,no, 27.Var5rpasT:

BharatiyaJfianapitha,

1962.

Secondary Literature

Bhargava, Dayanand. 1968.Jaina Ethics,Delhi:MotilalBanarsidass. Caillat,Colette.1977."Fasting

unto Death According to the

Jaina

Tradition."ActaOrientalia38:

66.Hotta

Kazuyoshi

te

MiUX.

2oos."Shi

ni

itaru

dary'iki:

Seinaru

girei

kajisatsu

ka?"

fiV:E6

uaft:

ee

7:it

6ueJkL7bli

e

ge7bts

?

Shiseigaku

kenkya

fl!k\blfi

1O:76-96.

Kanalcura Ensh6

SA

eq

fl,..

1944.Indoseishin

bunka

no

kenkya:

TbkuniJaina ochiishintoshite

EPNss

J""]jt{ica)ffza:rv:9'vl

}-E

pi]its2

L"(.Tokyo:Baiftikan.

KawasakiYutaka

ptose.

2oos.`'Pari

butten

ni arawareru sallekha t6no goni tsuite"7S' iJ

ll,M

O:N2'L6

sallekha

{Oge.

t:OV}(.Jainakyo-

kenkyii

t7kt

l

tXblee

11:21-51

.2014.

"Mahavira

no shintai toBudda no shintai" V A "7

i

'

l7

(D

fica;

t

tLL

ve

(D

fit6

.In

Okuda Sh6bsensei shoju

kinen

Indogaku

Bukkyjgaku

ronsha

aj

N

ee

re

ft

tstwfi

E'dft

-f >/

le7tAnj

\whfi,

438-445.Tokyo:K6sei

Shuppansha.

Schubring, walther. Ig3s. DieLehre

der

Jainas:

Nach

den

alten

Quellen

dangestellt.

Berlin:Walter

de

Gruyten

Setta4

S.

1989.InvitingDeath:lndianAttitudetowardsthe

Rittial

Death,

Leiden:E.

J.

Brill.

Sogani,Kamal Chand. 1g67.Ethical

Doctrines

inJainism.

Solapar:

Jaina

SarpskrtiSamraksaka Sangha. Tukol,T.K.1976.SallekhanatsNot Suicide.Ahmedabad: L.D.InstituteofIndology

Williams,R.1963.Jaina YbgurASurvcy

ofthe

Mediaeval

Sravakacarus.

London:OxfbrdUniversityPress.

Keywords s'ravakacdira,sallekhana,suicide

参照

関連したドキュメント

人は何者なので︑これをみ心にとめられるのですか︒

しかしながら,式 (8) の Courant 条件による時間増分

チツヂヅに共通する音声条件は,いずれも狭母音の前であることである。だからと

この映画は沼田家に家庭教師がやって来るところから始まり、その家庭教師が去って行くところで閉じる物語であるが、その立ち去り際がなかなか派手で刺激的である。なごやかな雰囲気で始まった茂之の合格パ

ƒ ƒ (2) (2) 内在的性質< 内在的性質< KCN KCN である>は、他の である>は、他の

停止等の対象となっているが、 「青」区分として、観光目的の新規入国が条件付きで認めら

わからない その他 がん検診を受けても見落としがあると思っているから がん検診そのものを知らないから

( 同様に、行為者には、一つの生命侵害の認識しか認められないため、一つの故意犯しか認められないことになると思われる。