第4章 情報通信の規制改革 : 相互接続規制と「ネ ット中立性」規制
著者 滝川 敏明
雑誌名 日米構造問題協議の影響の再検討?
ページ 179‑201
発行年 2015‑11‑25
その他のタイトル Telecom Regulatory Reform: Interconnection and Net neutrality
URL http://hdl.handle.net/10112/11403
Wtr).+*.+ftfr*fr lifrn#Al ffis2fr
2015+ l l E
lE+flE,fEOffiff|]BTH
-tEE&ffiflfttlL t;i.v f trnE] flfitJ
i€/il ftEE
+44 E#&Eoflfilet$-ffiEE*iflfirJl tnv f 'Fntt] fi.fit1
ffi 4 H {EffiE{EO*flffiU&S -ffiEi,F.ffiflfr\L t?. v hHnftl HfttJ
i€,[ ffi EE
EA
t. ll Uirl:
2 . ei,iEGit:r-iri6tE Efififlft1I,)&€
3. 1>9-iyl.o*#flfit_ t,i y I,+iEl flt )oElF
4. tr-f U
1. lJ De)l:
lff,frlf*wit vf :Lv--) = r)) bbv't! tflfiJetsl ,rftEElt:*iEt
\frfr,Lls.cav,za. : /)i#ifitt. E*: L 0)ttffifr1trd*#+*(E I i
^ l*. .
,s+E a e t,) r: I b **ffiffi Cr-flfi\ L }t+li 6 i L n' bft * .> t: " I E *lAE ) tr* @,h t + Y b : L tt:,L'*. t tE*) or* 6 t wv'<, E*fr ftt] I r, {, ff +i*
t: t 4frfi\ofintiHatl:ttJ?frc $ l: b-f " t 0) Hqfra+a o*l: L f ! bbtl
<rta ( . *wo>4ffit:-cv,<IEF<* 6. 44frnjxElfr++ofrflr*W(Jg70 +ft) -cA rr . iEE {'ffi # A fl fil L < 3 /: *Efitl#tB6 t W rL L. #.+ t'&rtt 7, L Jtr:. +*Bffi+i*(El,^ l-i*)r:J t)HfilL/i. :d)#x. fi4itErr{47
Ll:f:tl<t <, iEf,i*f +i- Y^fit*.d)I ),s-'>a Trre.iEl:EELt.
t\frfltfllt E)t a **r: $ v. < lr. ffi & r E*n'i* t a*nr H fi i: i*f <' 3 &
\'" #Efit*,o) I ).s-:/3 TrimtiL, iHl#+rl#rrET-t6. flfiI&B€lr$
-E*tflilt ao(,xT r, o)#v.r3 2'1;3 l] *rPfllt:]fr t) tr* *Lfft,Tb9 , . 0).F.t' b { iqf-*fl #n#,t t> tL z.
(179)
E*fl#'l t ffi&f nij. A*nriH H# t#ryf 6 o-c lt A r,'r' U off el: if L
<d, ?al:y)l.#+itrrfilri: iL<r,,6 LL\i OrrEI€: LlrA" ffi+t*l:. t A
ffi fiiJ rr, A*rrdr i.&.fiJn' bl+ t tt b 6 #,fi! t it A v,. q* i:4 D tffi +firl FE A
1:hRattt#o&rt.n, b+l&flfrrir-{ b ontffi+i*alygt? b 6" iiYH#f|]#a#,{*
L-), h*#Haqrt*t€@t b(:d)/:b I ) .s*
"/
3 > tt1rrbbv\) :
L ritr+i*r: I6flfilatt)fr.rbb. Lr'{. gE+i*r: J 6lEtrillt;tr#* tffiffi
t 4 a <, f,t+i*fl lT&H ilffi ftExtDG* L fi.af 6' I irre u'"
. a-62.#,itfr.ff b t:-tL- ft,&&E x#tril€x0)frflr*wnrEri L, gt+i*t:
r b *lhfllt!, : * *e b tu\ 3 f:. : 4)+rl r : : tr * ("lR z tuT ! t: a fii@)t t @, Rt&ETb.>l:tt, U.,{?,aql * irF.*t !t.>a\''4 " E,E*t:,','(rtEl]i:&
if L /:' ) 0r r. 4ffi "c tr€fi i$trE*a fr16\&+,r:. \,' <&Ef i a. Efi,i6trE
*.tt, 1 > t - i.t | Itl?a)nrl*€ff.J {: a, r 3 /j o "e. t,fEffi iEtrE*l L ry
Ji : L rrj, E r? L l... i*#,6tr8*-e tr, tE6E rEEfi.fiii#tBqrr#ffi L r ij
r) . E tr A* {: J 6 lfrt& + offi+'rl il t fi.fi11 L < v' 6. . 0) /: b #.+ t*ffil6 o) 1?
glllFEfrA iL<','6.
t/jL*EI . EU . E+rr"'f tL{, ffi.+t*o)I,4ktE|].r.il./:Hfrrjat#t
I990+'ft t: 4ffi L /: . L rt' L ffi48* b E 0) r* 6 L a Rrr tl, i&,f= E* a) fl fil#
B6lt*E#1fl(Jj r,, fr,frIf,+h t: f,l li t:*tr 3 ttB t,turrv'. €fi,rE{et:ttErr)
*e L H D ( . H XTASfilEtAff b 9, ik+ htfrjlL av,frllErra 6 0 : otd)
**flfi\tffi.+itflfitjl:+mf!t:E 3 &i 6 : t lt'c 3 ,r v' } /rra 3 fi.( 3 /:.
Li'LrrTrt b, 1> l-i't It+t t t A ffi#fttrt*jfu (Information Technology: I T)rr. ERfrE&*aE*M,bffJ+*f*tffiL< 3(v'6. +ffi
r rr, #i#iEEEX a &., ffig< b 7a )kE rofi ftlj&+ a&e+ L. + iL t o) H#.
,' r, E +?) lH#iE{a flqfr) ow* ffi. t +ftat 6. * f , ffi 2 ffi ? ]laflfr tr o)*ffi, Hfi{l:rv'<fftEf L,kt.ffi3hfr'ctt4 ,, -.?-., I t:E€a5g*OU,L L<t,i.
r) if/ ftlx tErroixEtr*-xE. Eu. E4olL*r'ffi1 tEx EHl5o'lr.l0#l*.
;{ r I E66^+i*+6ffrrti Wfr#* f;4ei0(2013+). 143-54E.
080)
#48 lH#,&Eonfil&4-iEE*ffiflfirlL li-v l4nEl fl6tl v l. +r:.t41 flfirit&Eif 6"
2 . €ft iEtr r:$ tt btqEwffiflfrla*+
rEft iiE{BflfilJ0,)+,t, t ilifit-f b o tttBtrEIffi oEffi t:-rr,'< d)fllill.c b b. tE
E{:ffH-15 E]ffirt, i v l, -
' tvfiLL<*Et)t ts- L t tl *tt! j&Faall
t:liitav,. a 0)l:btr4,hft*.nrtEli v I. , -, tgi€'f b. L ii&tl blL
t r' L lE*ria t a ft <!'t. : itrriEft,1EtrE*t t H r&r4&l ** L't b R.
fi<*>b" Ln'L, 6EI#i v l-,7-r0)fr6A+.nr l+EEB.ffi) -l-r3:Lt
fi.fi1i&E6r{*#'fi l} rt{J, +EE*ffi L /: EIffi i.,+- ?' v I n -, t L <#6ti 6.
4,a'c r*. 6RiEtrE*t:E*a i'v I n - 2 E*rrjt-t < * 6 L'f 4 Hfr nr r-
ffi,Lre.>Tvr7a.
( I ) ttritfio)rIc*tEillt
E RfitrE#-tt 2 )o jEEESEE {: J 4 ff Et E iL< r,'' 6. # r ffi E (riii) trrE
,fa (ffi6 L 1:/r-i) l-)at:ba@ffi<bb" *ZwEffifr)H. -Lifi/)Etffi aflJH L (*16 a n hffi4 0);8tr{i- uxErr$4fi(z? - t, -, t > d\6Et -
E^ L #?F/r L')'ebb" -Fffifr}4o)ft*ll, tirifi4r.,,;atrFlffia&.&t*.
tlttlltttt- €^ tief;( * rr v..
Lfr.o)@HfilBo) G* rrTifi't - EafiE1)ft*tfiJ*f bat#t, b B )n' c,, rEEffit:ffiA L t:i- v
^o)#I*t *]Ll^r 5 ef 6EF,rrH 5 fL'cv'6.
&w E o /,E* t ):ffi, L Tifi r: trlEf -r 3 L. -t a E H< e, a. fr E t&Jt#tt h t) t*
',,I#A r: ij', r < 6, +Effi 6A*ri g ?I/)Tiffi SF5 r ++ofi t) l&v, A Tift off +A*t:E&f're : &rrE=:iL< 3/:. :itlrtEftiEtro lEBft*#
(Separations Principle).1 66v,tt lt -1> "i 7i L) #<bb''.
2 ) Tim Wu The Mastet St itch: The Rise and Fall of Inforrnatiorl Embiles (Knopf, 2010), at 304.311.
(181)
It-a> .'>17a);hlii8+. L<tl:1:/9-it l0) t:i.v l- rFi.f*
(network neutrality).1 L L .(ffi E 6 il< v' b " 4 > I - i'v l. <'trlllt6 :] 7 i,l*7at) r-'., a >taa- Ii/r7 [:ElH++ArrrEA Lav,. :t61:.
iEtr+ t r-r < lEl + t:W. D W a : L & +E, L r',, 6 ( r ir r: r',, < &fit -e J[E! -l 6)"
XEI*+i*(E I. r7 l.if)oEet:Jiv'(6, 7t'-<tt*-J> . '>^7at A#t bil&t lffiTb.>t:" AT&T+Ui*(1982+)3)ll, tJFhffiEl L L<AT
& T ar<+E9/itt <- a < lEE6! r: {., trsJ L. *Bi6EA*,rEEE*1EE r: i€Hf
6 : L tH D /:. *EoiiIEffi fiJ {, E D (A D . 1996+Efi,iEEi*lr, ft4€;6
fi * t: t:tt bffi+ *{+nr#ts 5 il6 *'c, &fi f5-ifi a+lrrEEElEglrFS r:Efr i 6
- L ,a- i+ tr +. 1)
Ln'LnRoF- 1.7x l. El:#v.(4ErlFtffir*A#A *">avta. E la^
l.iir:pF6f. *EoEEEfiIr: ji)'< {, *-a>. ->
^7 ^#o)i.l+ttfi.D
L < 3 r',' 6 5)" +6ffi At: J t) A+rt#€'tfi +,lL'c e 6. A*0) E H t:ft rl
#ffiltf 6&eff b6 o t" ffi fi oa*ffiffi t EttrriE*rifi 6 b v, ttffi+wffi) i: r I tr' 6 a* r: rqfr|Ji trrf . iHH#fl# a ffi iE 6 ii 6. tEft i6E {: ii
". r lB E fi#i, b \,' tt* - a > . i
^, t^ (. i y I- F YErr l') t EttsrrG* {: -et: ts
fi{f60lliiEt}6^{*<b7,.
3 ) United States v. American Tel. and Tel. Co..552. F.Supp. l3l (DDC 1982).
4) 47 US.C. gS 27r-275 (2000). :/) l iErllH *,#tF C Cril999+t:Et*Lt-
Computer III Further Remand Order, 14 F C C Rcd (1999).
5 ) i, t e', + ilt4ifl 8l t: tlXElEfl ry, I +F ?( F T C ) rrErt.fr F-l* t *aA L /:-
Federal Trade Commission (FTC) (2007), Broadband Connectivity Competition Policy:
FTC Staff Report 2N7. at 757 (liv l1-rG*Fioit#r.trlrmD, iHlAr*iIrHtl6
&f 36irv I j -, tt--L\LEEi6BAl:H, A*LE,) ) >7 > t- t7o-, , {lL 6) :EEff6oiLHl:.1,,<*t*W--P^ul Joskow "Vertical lntegration". The Antitrust
BuUetin, Vol.55, No.3 (2010), ar 563 69.
082)
t'4+ E#,68,7)flfiiJet+-+84*liflS! L ti v l4nftl flfitl
(2) *E!flirft*r+o lffiEl*t.l ilf,
eR)6Fa d) *E-tl|f,* t :- R*> .c < frE*r& e n ( L' 6 iE E fl fi I I r. +E E#ffi A tkfril.f bfl1i,)<t,A.
7 1996+rgfiiEEi*.a 1fr4##.J flfr)
XEtEft iEl=fl fiUo&+i*lr1ee6+rEfi,rEEi* (rilT t1996+i*l) 7' < b \,
iE+lriEtr*E * ( F c c ) rriEffi L r v' 6 " rtsAA*?) A T & T a rlsl (1984+) L t:'tA, l.: )vani*1l(Regional Bell Operating Compa.nies).l ,rtrH J e t: H4,
L /-. : o,.r,LE'a&*11rr1996+i*r)+.t: 6flfl*t*.< *> b
"
t, b 0) frffi.t: t b + tr -., r 7 I: ) rr E * 4h, 8 < er 4 L. 0) ",2.#t : *-J u, <, llt*.*
It 1996+i*ofi,firJfi|JE t ffi * L /:. fi.fi{4{& 0) A T & r rr*Eei l:iE rr il 6 L
/:€fi EtrE]ffi o i v l') - ) l:EW-l b i v l, - 2 t *tffi A*rrffiHt:ffi * i 6 : L ir#&fi r:rnl ffi'e b 0, **< { b /" L t, a."n#< b b. : o-e!. rJ
A)1#A#t:rti. 7" t, o t *&-l A "
Eft i6E ji. v I v - 2 ff E *.&,&('6 a < 6. i') l') -,'\o&**(7, +
^) t #fl4
^ft*t:E&i 6 : L A &ffi ,r^,LtE-66*?l t: i$fil iil lf, 4lA
lE6i v l. r-r0)-HErr.tu6. S-,i .v | 1- 2l7'C0)ffiT"1\.a/:i>l\il
i6. :,)#4ri. E l. 7
^ l. i*l: l6MC I S+++Ii{rr&A,:ELI:$a<&)
6. +!J;trt. Ytfr^ Lft*o)MC I l:?.v lr-r*#.tft.4&'f6:}tAT&
1996+&rrfi,EJ- 6#ffiHtB, E. l.'
^ F *0)M C r *rJ*84 t #ffi I,- [,
l?, L L $ o t:iqtt 6. /: t' L r9964i*lt, E l' 7 x l' Ite t #ffi 'f L L tfi.firl l:
ir I L'* r,f. r \.ft
^tr1flfr|t
6 L<\' b.-] * l], M c r 9ti{tabE l. 7
^ | t*o 4&fi h E lt t b frfr! ('z + -'" :/ * 2 *fiH) d, tf * A*rff &AEd
)1 t E t b. L * nffio u'**l+ L i 6. : iL r:tf L 1996+i*il. fr t*f&fi 0)
7 ) P.L. No. lM 104. 110 Stat.56 (1996).
8 ) MCI Communications Corp. v. American Tel. and Tel. Co.708 F 2d. l08l (?th Cir. 1983).
( 183 r
A.*r: r,r,b r,,f , -l-r< ,)iEEA* i :w#.t *#l! * a "
I996+i* lt#ffi t lfEE*ffi (interconnection) ] L {tEldll < r"' 6' & & Eia
*rti,8
^@)
b \, \ ttT&) A+r:#ffi A - fr ffi t.E &t 7, a<'li a (, -f -{<?)iB Eft*.ff< tL?*LFfiEt 7. )BF.tsffirt tBat:&ffit b(<*Ll: J 0.H,-d)Etii.
't l'7 - ) tffrt\t z,') L\,) Hfr<bb" i t l, - 2 ttiH?-AI:Ett tubLn>|:ll, ?Z b titiEffit;rffiffi* h )r-'f b,L'qlt&)a" i't l'1 ^tLb-rfl)
*t'r* b L n>, lEEA*rt E e,4)i6,faEIffi t,fua*rr6f 6 E,fEEffi e iEEEffi
L(, ?ty | ,7 - , &&t lU<l ls IJ lllt ts r, tst" r "
i v | 1 -, t lhi.-t b H.:#.t ;Btr G*rr+*A L r \,' 6 t: 6 r'r'r? c, f , +E E*ffil: I D s-trt?, v l'1-, tY,,fr,f b. L. tthti'l.l- afllfl1rr1996+i*<"
*>2"" i t 1,7 - 2 tliffir+-t:t Aodg*.l-v,: L reot. &trfy'},r.t:lttr
\l+ii b b L o Hfi n'#Et b " fr r*Afih t E -f 6 t ;i. v l- v -, t fr A t b
G*l:tEE*#.1*# t-aRI z*tltrlJ, tr+rrll(itl:EE L tr\,. #t#.8
^ft*a it lr-?1t4,{f 56/:r). :r-+t-t&€-e3 tu,t,c>Tb6" WF.ft*
rr+EE#ffitrEffi Lffiil b. Lt: I \ , fr&nqetjbxffiSila: L rr< 3 6,)"
L r' L . 1e96+ i*r'flfrI b iEE&ffirE{**# lr. rF r#iEaffi G* i: FREt 6
#,fiI<" rt t <, f -r( o)EEA+ i: -F+ i: i&H 5 fL6 r0). eiE{=A* t: -ff t:tB
E&ffit *tr*ft i afl €lr. Xtr-cA#A+ t:{;ffi 6! t: -# 5 lL< I t: | = + > +
t'J7(common carrier).1 *#t:tE\-f 7r. :1+> +r')7*tr*L lt. t-U
^ ft& t * e> b t\ HAf ^r( l: -e* Brl + l+ < lY# t &.&t Z : L t tE' i6tr+
o^#4*# t :*#lt tl affifir{|c b 6. {Edfi!a*r:[Ettf r:, i^i(/)iEl=
1 frtro;i- t l,-2fii*ls:t4E#ffi*#t64lL-f 7an'
9 ) Howard A. Shelanski 'Adjusting Regulation to Competitio[ Toward A New Model for U.S Telecommunications Policy",24 Yale J. on Res.55,68 (2m7).
10) 47 U.SC. S 2sl (a) (l) (20m).
(184)
H4+ fi#iEEo)fi.filet+-+E{*liflfiiJ I t;i.v I.trnE.l fl81
tqE*tr?*'f ,:< ai&trG*r: (fi &ifrh a6 *t:/),t'b 6f \ *#tt rJ b.
l t:rr,'<l*, rEtrE1ffil:i,'li6 i ') l-, - rh*.t!4fuL't bE nr{ftt+.
e><v,b" €fi,EEt: lt,i- 7 l-1-rfrxlrtb6l:rD. Et#a*t:ir.) 1,7-,
#ffi.t*Efrfi,f *t/:##.ft*ltfrr*l:8^'e B a','L il.En: tu< 3 t"'.
Lfi,LWHb.*a i t l r - ) tl'fr4-Afr11tE L<r\re\'i#6t:lt. 4l.4
*tt ? 0) ft*D]*d) G*o ; i v I n -, t.*#-t b : L t: t 0 fr B8
^< z
4 "
i l,-,qt*tttr.E:d-bq*'ctt, i v |,-,*h*t'r4Zt:d>, $b*tt
IUA*ZtEE#ffi-f 6:al:J 0 iv l'1-2 AfrtLJ a t'fbt'z\" fi*fN
h t 6 I b G*rt.+A L & v.t#A r : rt. [tff+rriiBEA* r: +E E*ffi.* wfl-t 6 u'
*lt a v'.
tEE*ffi t&trrrifi fiIf 6 : l r: B :r x t t,l+ i . iEtra*rriEE##a+E*&
'f b 0) tt. ffi+48+a D xt frFhf 6 Ef ,ra v' ( |.' 6 i#a r: [F€ I ft /3 v r. fi iI-i v l, - ) a)t{Ellfr t ttRt b i'v ln-2 t Wffil za t:d> o)lltn*Ftt
5t:t3rr:x I.rrr.r.6. :0)t:bl:lBa##.tfri G*t ,);t ( tv'. #ffi t ffiE,#ffi. L L <liErtt( {, . ffi +i*o#41: I tt Effi jfifijnraf* I itra v'B 6 t :lEE&#.t Wfr ,rrAfil f 6 : L. n EI,4iY, [ *L b b I ] < rt a v'.
: c, l:1996+i*it, O tiEEeffil *#t:lt i<, @ I 7 > tt > F tv I 4gU
#.rt. L L " . 0) *# t!. iB,ftsffi ;E t &HEE* (t&&68. Etffi H[EE. #+*hffi frEtrE)t:ttifr-fa.L|:Jb&#.t lfifii69r:Er8Ea
" ' /t,b z;f 17 t .1 l:tj
b t : ft*'i h o a fr * fr'l,.\ t 4 h ).ffJ frqiu< *> a "
1996+i*ltzd)t, @tEE*ffiFl&t'=
^ |**a lflf-l#(wholesa]e rate) l
L -l-^r E : I t#.rt.LL. trt#+Hrt*M.a [:] x l. I lt tEHrHr]HHl r: J
6'3). tEEEffi flAofl frrl {1. *ffi #,fitl t: l* a ( #frfi t :,y'4 L. t b frfrr|< b b.
11) Shelanski, Adjusting Regulation. supra note 9, at 68.
12) Daniel F. Spulber and Christopher S. Yoo, 'Rethinking Broadband Internet Access", 22 Harv. J.L. & Tech. l.29 (20G).
(185)
*ffiE& A Eitrrrft D b t:ti < b ILt!, ft.i 6 tt /:A*ll' *ffi*h L L< Edt
<Hv'#l#tan*:&-16 : L r: ] t) , *H.ff1t:#ffifr6 e E U#iif,aigFt< 5 6.
. o*ffi t &.tl 6 t:r) r: rtfl fi!6tB6rr#ffi *,1fff r:, v. < rxff t&frld1 t *tfu L t tt
lLtttr btr\t\o
^ | at*.lfrHflf^t r,,r- Lrv,6. Lr'L, #H,
^, tr^ l-t:Ait','t
b, aF^a#tfra^ l. I I 6 r^ l.rY&< HE3iL, L/:/rz(#ffii+#ir{4(
-#E 3 tr 6. : o /: r)#ffi ffi H{EJ t:6 t\ (*ffi, t E t t 7, N a G* t - E tt)) t,h\' 6
*ffifl &#.fr| L t a . #+ * o#Bn, 6 ll. lt+-L + n69 rr * kflfr.,r t.f b.il't
zJtb 4
"
/: /i LttEE#ffil*t#r$i^r(olElEf*i:-et:i6}fl i tL aa t tt+.tr D ' l7>ts> i:r, I l tfilJ+++l *r#tt, ^{)rfE-#a+1(1996+i*d)HE*-ctt "locat
exchange carrier" ) {: JEt L (i6H 3 iL 6 "). : o,Hr. F |
= z | *0> *Eff
1996+i* t: E 4 : iL< v, 6. *H, 1996+ i* t: tt.': )v ai& *1t0) 1t tfr,ft* t1l 7
,.)r, F)v) f tfrifl#] aE.H.**tirr < < 6#+-t.6f1jrlt/rvrfii,t, l:/rlL tJ, F C C rr#.fir.' t#i 6 : L ir-e * b a offiEirb bts) ", I a v 1 E I b+t
ffi Eff nr*& L, iH H#rr#ffi L * jEE=E-E & iEfl i 6 J a t: t. < \,' b " 7, ) r
, r-" )v*ffiffrr ( < 6..,r€-;f,A+totlfrG*rr;E-il6+i- E1tffi+6!l:E'l*-c
3 6 tsft/rgj,& L ( \, A L z i- b n b. L r, L. F C C ljfr.frl0)#.Lw. zt \, !
/j*ffi L<v'av'.
, 7o- t./s7 lrt:fff 6 F c cffifilo)+HEr[
1996+Er.ettr a ilf . trffiL<','61:{,/.r.rrBf, FCClt. 7E- t',,{
13) 2m5+FCCfi.H|]"
14) 47 Us.C. S 251 (c) (3) (2000);47 U.S.C. $ 251 (c) (a) (2000)
l5) 47 U.S.c. S 251 (d) (2000) (lirlr-r4*t:*ffi5tav':Lr{' &#.t*r' bq
*AcDH*ffi) t frtr a a L l:rs b b t F C C ll6ra L t lillra c,,r',' l).
086)
+4+ lit#$,=o)flfilet+-+E4&#fl6l t t,i v l4nltl fl6tl
7l-.'(Hitji.v Fi6E:i'v l
' - , ) t:*,1L< tt1996+i*t: J 6 +EE*ffi.*r*(R
(f 7 > .)\> F )v+a*#) tiEEA*t:EIfl Lrru\fiitt2005+l:ft46 l- tot. U
ntHvt( * t (20ts42 E i.v l. +nftflfil?)ts.fi t'c-&ffi+tr).:0)1fr.
\ lo>#.L*. L Geetnatory forbearance).l t FC Crr*ffiLl:o)lt, -/E- I:)r , F"hr-ra-)\> r*Ltt*t t), I )4--> r 7t: j r,aitt:+#eiL<v'6r.
bTb6tl)" Ao- ts)t> r- . +t- E'^ tE&i5A*l:rr'<iHHA$E*.d)
iEfr&tEtl:A Lt','6'8'"
7 tt - l: / \ > i-'r: rt+EEEffi*i*ErEt H L a !,' L',' i F C C F,f,4t:ti L.
,&Eft.Xa+ n'b F..Xt * *EA-l- b $ o)fl\fr.ltl:. tr+nr#^3 ful: ir 0)o, fufi.
frBo*< r: Ji','(fi+t*t&X L L <filillE S fL<v ' za Lo>'4.frn, b<bA. Lb
L F C Cittt+fillFE;'!^l:rr,'(, .H,rrr#ff6!t:-t5, ffi+ffyl +: :) r t:fi,
)<L-)bb: L. t F.#L<v'a Ltr+Ji6D)" FC Ca):d)494tt, et+i*j&
IE t:$','r, ) 4-.2 a > ta&t 7" ilt*t * L<v.a.
( 3 ) E*o)Sfifi-* I Ill*#E*tt6t*l[l*ftrro*E
E +4)i&r=EE (ffi#'A)E t a7v- l:zt> I"#.fitlt -LEB,XE F C CflfrlL IL
*J-a : L r: J 0, #ffifrfloA*f^r3,Ht.E Ef : Lir"c5 6.
t6) flftilt*i6.Lr:"r DA*tff+a{EiE<46*er:ri. F c c ll1996+iioilB tE i6 ( "regulatory forbearance'): tir<3 Z (1996+i*401+). FCClt, 2005+7tr - t:
)\ > Y 7 ,-L 7 F zi
-Appropriate
Framework fo! Broadband Access to the lntemet over Wireline Facilities. Report and Order and Notice of Proposed Rulemaking 20 F.C.C.R.
1,t853. 14856 f 2 (2m5) ( Broadband Access Order-)-l: t\, l4<oas- l:tt>
17) Broadband Access Order. para47: D.F. Spulbe! and C.S. Yoo. Rethinking Broadband Intemet Access 22 Harv. l.L. & Tech. l. 25 (2m) (A*o!f*#rrfi+f 6fliiitt4fr 07i, )v,ltt< L l:b Ll:).
18) Broadband Access Order, para47.
19) Id. para"S0 (Aa-l*r\rY'1>9-i-t l'o*#l*. f ("fr( re64flil:lt)*t1ffi3- Ao<tltr < , f.R.L<,,,hfrryoESl t r, 7 F{: I rt +l|ffit-r ts 166).
( 187)
ffi#€lllEftiEEflfi!t:Jjv'(, F C C r$Etli/: []tr-l{:/ }...1 . tTIr- f*
)\, l:) ,)Etlt'ikll(!r&vro ae- l:)\>'r-6iIr-,|r7 [it E Dftfi,iEE' ffiek< b 4 L L <. E Di*eHtt;6H L (
"'6.,6/fl i*elt tEfi,iEtrs*i*
(ur liEGii*l)l a)'cbb"
EF,*Effil*.t frAi a +*Af -{( r:iiil=i*rl*ffin# tix L <"' 6 (iEtr
*32*\ " r o *#r*, *81996+i*o ttEE*ffi I *# 71' i$*A t:Hti c, tL t:*#<bb.Lt*i6'f6"
-t-r( o+F*A t iI * L t b *ft*# t : lE Z. 6 )1 4*# ( l t I fEtEEEft iE
E=ikffi ofrAb*)t:t!7 >.)\> li,l,t: l6*ffiEf;*#rri*3 tL<r,'6 (lEE
*33*) " I # I &rE'tEft,iE'f=#H t ## A Ent*. ff Effi FFI l: }s tt 6 Effi
'-l,kffi o)fi% t E i- b 2 t 7 t € I 6 i&B,iffi L fr.d> < v' a'?". *ffi fl+fi.fi{ li,
*EF c c o*A LFlffil) I RWtElt a
^ l- ) **'c b A "
-iE+*!FE r: t'if 6 J D 6
^L fi
ra #H#.ff *# t 6 )i 4*A t: pEf L < e*i olt, xEl1996+i*r:Jj rl6 [.r,LlEf;fi*il] l:rE'tttc,irl:*#u *iiI-t6. E
*rtt N T T ri^r,rE;6++it:tE gi b
" t:ti L, E 6d)iEGii*tt N T T L #E t f , A h 4** (t | ffi#ftefi"AE--nkffi of,i A G*) t : FRtf 6 ffi fitJ u u < v'
b. : tuttB+t*d) H&T],kfrltilt: t;tt bfrBifr)1F'l+t.f.1t)t 6.
L I' L I il%, t 7 ) #Aft?kffifr E ft* 0) &ft#,{. L I b ff # A 0) ** tt,
4&:tl kt: jjtl 6fr ,h*frh t:.tu'< aaKoffi+*.ia?hn' b B'2 t 7 *l6t1tE,
t I 4 " Z o) a i, fr &, t 7 lllt t: J \ fr BA&)J t *ft. L, * ),al frEt*tt E
ofr#'U(intZil.Lbu,o>$#\ 'Ct> 62) "
ffi+ * t: t b Hr*r-r h flft\ 0) *t *ai h d) + (. ryt I (*ffi t 6 tr ) ffi &fl firi r:,r
m) EniEE'!*,ri*. wfr59+r2q25A*F.H868(&fri&tr +&B+ 6 H%A*4t74?).
22) idE*rl, +,\1 )t(#fiffiEF) +*trr*e L(t+: l8tlEiiEBakfr)E tt'&.11,
,z r 7 ro% ) L ffJf',A ft b a \, 4-rE51i6E+*i*ffi afi flH'(, (Wfrffi+$| .',e + fr258 ) ettr(+&24+6 El9B)< http://www.soumu.gojp/main-content/000189798.pdf >" fiSl
(r88)
