ウェブ検索サービスにおける法改正とフェアユースについての一考察 利用統計を見る

῎῍῏

῎῎῏ ῐ! "#

῎῏῏ $%

&' (")*

῎῍῏ &+,-./0

῎῎῏ 1234567῍Field)8

῎῏῏ Google39:;

<= >?῍@ABCῌDEBCῌDMCA

῎῍῏ @ABCῌDEBC

῎῎῏ Perfect῍ῌ)8῍@ABC

῎῏῏ Parker)8῍@ABCῌDEBC

῎ῐ῏ FGH.ῌIJK+

LMN OP QR

῎῍῏ STUV BC W XY

῎῎῏ LMN OP QR Z[\]^

῎ῌῌῒ_ῑ`῍῎Lῌ abcMdbeῌ Tfdghei8ῌj

klm῍ ῎ῌ῍ῌ_῍`῍Lnopqrs῍ tu vj wVxySsῌ tz { |}!~^w€‚ƒA]x e„^῎῍῏῍

…†‡ˆ‰ῐ῎Š ῎῎ῌῌῒΐ῍῎ΐ῏ ./

ῌ῍

῎

ῌ ῌ ῌ !"#$%&'($ῌ )* ῐ !"#ῑ +ῌ ,-DVD./0123 45"678 9:$%&'(;῍

<ῌ = >?9@$ABῌ C4D"E F9 GHIJ37K+ῌ LMN O 0%PQ R S./Tῌ U1V9Gῌ W XYZ/[0;^῎῎῏῍

/\ῌ ]^LM_"`C;U.9ῌ a;9 ῐbῐΐ cῒῑ 0adῌ U1V9Gῌ ef;

=gh9gῌ 19igῌ ejkl

῎URL῏ mnope$[0q;῍

ῌ )0r῍ῌstu0vH1q;]^LM_"`C;U .wxope9u9ῌ <yz{[0q;῍

\/01ῌ ]^LM_"`C;U.|}~9 ῌ €‚]ƒ„"C ῎fair use῏ u0vH1^῎῏῏῍ 9ῌ ῎ῌῌ῔ῑ…῍῎9ῌ †‡!ˆ‰=WhŠ9‹

)ŒL"$ ῐŽu=W# !‘’“ῑ b῍

~0”\;0ῌ i[ ῐW V<$ῑ ῎<$%&•%W

Vῌ )* ῐ'‚]ƒ„"Cῑ῏ –(—˜

9u0™U1[/š;῍ )’“ῌ *eῌ+›œ

@ῌ 234tžX9Ÿ =9¡Œῌ ¢£¤¥9u ,›^῎ῐ῏῍

'‚]ƒ„"C9ῌ ¦-0§q¨#\῍

©™.\1ῌ ª%=W0«/a;/=/¬

0›š;q9ῌ ­;®9'‚]ƒ„"C00f9/

ῌ 234ta;/`O2C0'r1¯°q῍ <

ῌ ±².\1ῌ ƒ³D´‚]ƒ„"CŸP923µ¶²·

‚]ƒ„"CU14¸¹°$ŸP/ ῌ º»¼/

ῌ῍

῍

ῌ ῌ !"ῌ #$#%&'()*+

,-./0῍

12ῌ 34#$567ῌ 348$ῌ 3489(

:;<=(>;?@AB"῍ Cῌ DEF9:;$

)*0GHIJD<=9?@KLM )"NO῍

Pῌ 1O*+QRS"ῌ +0GTKLMNU2 VW(Xῌ +YZ[Xῌ \]

[^_`NOXῌ abcdeIfgX]c hi"+῍

j& ῌ abcdeI9GT34#KLMkf

῎῏ῌ lmno0)pqo0cr ῎s῏ῌ lmnt69(abcdeIuv ch+ ῎w῏῍ \]ῌ DMCAῌ lmnxyzῌ {|yz`

}~go0 ῎€῏ῌ Hῌ YZ(+‚Kƒ„fgX]ῌ YZ…†o0chi"+ ῎῏῍

ῌ abcd9(34#KLM

῎ῌῌῒ‡ῐˆ῍῎ῌ 34#KLM‰ῌ Š‹Œ‹Ž‘W\

’+῍ LMK῎ῌ῍ῌ‡῍ˆ῍NU“”\’῍

abcdeI9(•–)0ῌ LMKῌ —+˜῏ῑ•

ῐ—™\’+῍ LMš›)0ῌ abcdeIῌ œ

ž)0Ÿ ())¡ῌ p¢£t6348¤”

¥#$"¦§£¨©)ª"]’1)X]ῌ «¬e I­®( +‚[)¯‚]’°¨t0ῌ #$

7±²³´µ¶·¸”O1)@NO(¡ ῍ abcdeIt6KLM)o0ª¹῎º» ¼῏ .1

ῌ῍

῎

ῌ ῍ῌῌ !"ῌ #$%&'()*+,-./012) 3"῍ /)*+ῌ 456789:;<=^῎῏῏>?@A>BCDE ./0,!ῌ #$9:;<=FG)HI0JK.,-LM῍

NNOῌ '(3"P῎ῑ%ῐQO+RSO%&,-.῍

Tῌ #$%&DUVW.00)ῌ XYZD[ZN"\῍

῎]^_`a3"45]^bcdefg"hijg῏

k῎ῑ%ῐ lmnh)opῌ ]^_`a3"45)q.]^

bcdef ῎rslm]^]^bDcdW."h&tῌ ufῌ vf XwefD\M῍ T/%)x\ Pp῍῏ DNῌ yzX {|D}~W./0D0N M€ ῎#$HDM€D‚ƒῌ ]^_`a3"45„…ῌ †‡yz}~Dˆ‰,Šh.‹Œ)Ž

M€).῍῏ Qῌ #$yzX{|}~DM"h)‘

0’h.A)x\ ῌ ]^_`a3"“ ῎#$“)q .rslm]^)?\ ”^€DcdW."h45•–Dnh./

0Xw”^D@W."h—I˜p \.™š)-Ž Qῌ

#$rslm]^”^)?\ #$—ID˜p"€›œDE"€)

.῍῏ )?\ ῌ vžŸ v¡Q¢£ ῎/)*+¤N"¥

¦>“vD‚§῍῏ D\ῌ yzlmnh)opῌ #$

nh)¨W.]^_`a3"45)q.]^bcdef}~0©ª ῌ #$vžŸ)v3"#$“ij“ ῎#$“)q.

#$¥¦>“ij“D‚§῍ T/%)x\ ῐ{|}~

«vῑ 0\M῍῏ M¬#$]^bcdef)q.D«\ rs

lm]^ ῎]^_`aD‚§῍῏ DM/0,!.῍ "­Nῌ #$

{|}~«v)q.“)q.]^_`aD®¯W.

,-./0 ῎°±,²"]^_`a)-Ž Qῌ °³,²"

0N"O´®¯0O.µ!,-./0῏ D¶Ž"0!Qῌ ῌ῎

῍

ῌ ῎ ῎

῍῏ ! ῍

"#$ %&'(ῌ )*&'(+,%-ῌ &'(.

/%.012345%6789ῌ:6%;

$<1=>5%6?@-AB!*%CD.,ῌ 1.0?@AB2EFGH.

>%῍ IJK.ῌ SNS LMN.ῌ IDOPQRST9ῌU $ VW+X YZ=[\]Oῌ ^_`]abQ]O^_`]cdef MN.ghih.jk)* MN ?@-AB!*%lmn oSi+,%῍ 0pqῌ ;*!lmnoSi"#$ %&'(r!s r*%;$. %῍

tuvwxJ.0ῌ r!:6.yBῌ )*78./%z34{|Uῌ 5%;$

}$UN2+,%῍ ;*.0ῌ ~}€N2ῌ )*78jkῌ ‚ƒvw„῍+…6%†‡.ˆ

N2.>%$5%῍ ‰ῌ z34{|$lmnoSiŠ‹78

;$+,qῌ IJK.URL+,%^῎῎῏῍

~}2.0„῍+…6%†‡.0ῌ ῍ῌῌῐŒ῏Ž‹ῌ /

2+‘‚’+,%-ῌ ῌ“!”^f•–.Mq—˜…lmnoSi

῎5%™š.M%;$ῌ ῍ghih.jk)* 6›‡K

™š-&'(.œ)*%$X;*῎U ;$ῌ ῎jkU lmnoSi-.žŸ)*%rῌ  ¡s)*%CDῌ ¢ 78῎U£¤ ;$ῌ ¥…U%῍

pῌ ~}€N2$ῌ ghih.ῌ 78jk

N~}2$ῌ ¦Se§U N~}2$-

¨©ῌªῌU[S«Q-¬*%}­®¯H,%;$r!ῌ ;

*H"#$5%°±+,%῍

lmn[S«Q.‰¤%²³´$µm¶·SQ.0¸¹῎º» ¼῏ .3

ῌ῎

῍

ῌ ῌῌ ῍ URL !ῌ "#URL ῌ$

%& ῏'()῍ῐ *+,-'./$0῍

//$1.ῌ 23456ῌ 789%

':; !<=ῌ89>?'@A1῍

"#23BCD45'. EFG1 ῌ HIJKLI1Mῌ 6Nῌ OPQRSTUV>/

'W!Xῌ YPQRZ[\]DM'>^.I?ῌ EF'_6/I῍ G`aῌ 2345bG cῌ deSf\ ῏23ghd\7ijῐῌ Zkl[m ῏no Upmqrst[mZ[u'v%wῌ xrF'qrῐῌ y

z{|T ῏+q7}T~'a€ῌ ῎῎῏b>Mῐ L0

Lῌ 6Nῌ deSf\L ‚ƒ„wb%aῌ Zkl[mq rxrFL…wbZ[uL ‚ƒ†c‡aῌ `yz{|T

ˆL‰Š‹1^.I?LŒ6῍

`ῌ 1 hŽf}|L EF.G1 ῌ ‘’W“”•”–$0Lῌ "#hŽf}|Lῌ 23—~U~

˜Lῌ *•>PQRSTU™'”–>ƒ$

Nῌ EF16^.῍

šῌ ›œžLῌ Ÿ,- ¡¢%M$0/'£

‡cῌ D¤ῌ D›œ'1*+,-'‡

II1῍ ¥¦%ῌ 0w`$D¤*+,-ῌ G`a"

#ž'12345$0aῌ §¥¦¨©ª«'M¬>M

$I1^῏ΐῐ῍

I­ῌ ®¯°ῌ W±²³AL0 ῏ῐ῔°῍´῍µῌ Gcῐ῔°῎´ῐµῐ῍ `ῌ š¶Ÿ·&ῌ'*+

,-?W±²³AM0 ῏ῐ῔°῍´ῒµῌ ¸῎´ῑµῐ῍

`ῌ ¹ºK% ῏῍ῌ῎°ῐ Lῌ Y»¼$$0

ῌ῎

῍

ῌ ῍

ῌ ῌ ῌ

ῌ !"#$%&'()*+,-./01234 ῌ #$%&'()*+5678019*:;+,<01 =>?@A1῍

ῌ B$CD)+

#$%&'()*+> ῌ EF.῎ῐ῏G9HIA2ῌ JKL>MB$CD)+NO,P1QGR῍ ST ῌ !"EF.GUL>9EFVWXYZ G>[[ῌ .\],^_ ῒ`aΐ ,bLῌ

;cde9*:;+G@Gf 2g Lh0i11῍

jkῌ #$%&'()*+lm ῌ Googleῌ Yahoo!ῌ MSNno fpGqrTs,tῌ #$%&'()*+lmG@Gfu5=

῍ vwG@GfEF.xy1 z{Gῌ @GfEF .|y1EF ῐEF.῍ῌ῏῎ῑῑ ῌ G

IA2ῌ ῌ A6 i}~

voL>€‚ƒ0„[1…†‡ˆ‰56ῌ @Gf lmŠ‹L>ŒŽ ῐchilling effectῑ ,26L 

‘῍ ’|>ῌ 9HIAEF.῎ῐ῏Gῌ 2=“

”•EFL>NOIA>A–ῌ @Gf#$

%&'()*+lm2—=˜™,š›>52LA῍

œ2ῌ 00EFV῎9YZG!Lῌ }~

žŸ/ ¡¢+,5£¤015¥ ¦[§[¨

IA1‘῍ ©ª«ῌ Š¬,­®¯L°

±žŸ/,²1 ῌ EF.³,š´0x y iῌ Cµ¶·B$CD)+ῌ `a

#$%&'()*+|y1.\]B$CD)+>`¸¹ῐº» ¼ῑ /+

ῌ῍

῎

῍

ῌ !"# $%

%&' ()*῍ +ῌ !"#

(ῌ ,#-./01#2345ῌ 67 89 :;

<=(>?@?A BC'D=EF'GHD῍

Iῌ J=?KL(ῌ MNO? JGH !PQERῌ J= SL(TU VOῌ WXY$PQER&'(Z[ \]῍

%3ῌ ^_[`aHDbcῌ def !"#gS hiῌ $32jklmnopqῌ rst

; _uNvw='D=xy῍

῎ῌ῏ !"#

?z{(ῌ ,|/ ῌ }e~(8#(Oῌ €

? JGHER‚ƒ3„ῌ …D)*v†3‡ˆ

(ῌ }e/ $ }‰€? Š2ῌ $ƒ>?@hi Hh‹Œ῍ (Ž^῎῍῏῍ ῌ (?z{ῌ }‰,{/ ? Š2῍

Kῌ e‘/ J=SL'’'&w

῍ q“ῌ SL”(ῌ •y ῐrῑ ' H'qƒῌ –/v—˜O™ƒ šῌ ?L (ῌ ›œ'D=J„ž'H'qžŸ ¡/¢

œ˜D῍ Iῌ (ῌ r £š@q–(

Oῌ ¤¥¦/§‚32¨©vª«¬­®¯°/Ž

±z{/8²³´ J^῎῎῏῍ $32ῌ J„(ῌ µῌ r›œ0q¶·¸

G3῍

%3ῌ ¹º'H(ῌ (»8'GH¼ ῌ῍

ῌ

ῌ ῍ΐΐῌ ῐῌ !"#$% &'()ῌ

*+,-./0$10 &'῍ῑ '2ῌ 34ῌ 56ῌ #789 $: #;$ <)= ῍ ()#>?@ABC=)Dῌ EFῌ GHI J ῍

#Dῌ ῍ῌῑKLM#>$N)= ῍ -OPῌ

KLM#'2)ῌ ῌQ#ῌ ῍R#ῌ ῎S#ῌ ῏TU#ῌ ῐVW#ῌ ῑXYZ[\]TU#ῌ $N)= ῍ ^_ῌ `῍ῌῒa6ῌ KLM

#:;>Hb)= Hῌ `῍ῌῒHῌ cM-#:;

d>eῌ &Hfghij>e ῍ ^_ῌ ῍ῌΐa6Dῌ kl-m:;>HNn)= ῍

`῍ῌῒfghij>Dῌ a6oe ^῎῍ῌ῏῍

p῍ῌῑp῍ῌῑA>bbOnqῌ rsῌ tuῌ vwij

xῌ yz ῎y{| }_N~€i$ ‚ƒ$„

…῍῏ῌ †‡^_Dˆ‰Š$M' #e fghij

῎€i^_D‹iŒQLp῍ῌῑN Ž }$

„…῍῏ Dῌ #‘'D-n-=῍ }Hfghij' - b’b$“” •–—˜™Dῌ a6B$„…῍

῎῍῏ }Mš› ῎}Hœš$ b^_DžŸMy

 Mb$„…῍῏

῎῎῏ #e š›

῎῏῏ #e ¡¢'9| }J_

T›š

῎ῐ῏ #e £¤M¥•^_D¦§ }¨©

ª«¡)™$–2)fghijH¬J_•ῌ H

‚e '=­®T¯¢Dῌ bb ¬$°-=῍

±g²³´µi¶j| ·¸'fghijC=)–¹῎º» ¼῏ /-

῍῎ ῌ

῍ῌΐ῍῔ΐῒ ῍ ῌ Folsom ^῎῍῍῏ῌ ῌ !"#$%&' ()*+῍ ῍῔ΐῒ !"#$,-.ῌ /01ῌ 2

34'ῌ ῍ῌΐ5 !"#$&6*+789:;9<%

=>?+@4AB66Cῌ DEFGHI5 !"#$%

&?+@45)J+%CKLKMK4'ῌ 5 NOP4 !"#$%QR&)JKLKMK@4ῌ

῍ῌΐST%UVW?+C)*ῌ GXῌ YZῌ

[\?+C)K@4%]^'4+^῎῍῎῏῍

@ ( !"#$_`(_abc+5ῌ LevalN“Toward a Fair Use Standard^῎῍῏῏”d)ῌ !"#$

e?+fghN5ij'kl%Cmῌ n'opqr#$

stFuH'J4'vFKw%>'+^῎῍ῐ῏῍ @@4ῌ !"#$xyz{5]|)KLῌ b }~5K

@4%€'+῍

῎῎῏ !"#$ῐ6‚

!"#$ῐ6‚ƒFKz{4(„…)KLῌ †

‚ ‡+῍ ‡ῌ @M‚ˆ5‰'LŠ‹+4(@4) CK^῎῍ῑ῏῍

Œ῍‚)*+ ῐŽFh ‘ῑ 6ῌ Levalῌ ’“

”59<•<–—˜%™š+›Jœ“FKž4'ῌ GŸF

῎transformative use῏ %Š‹'ῌ !"#$ ¡?+_`(_ῌ

¢„5GŸF_`(_ῌ ‡GŸ£¤5`LM_4(¥

¦§¨?+4'+῍ MLevalῌ ˆ©FKœ“žῌ ªˆ«¬­®¯KC°±²mῌ *+£¤³´F)*µῌ ¶¤·x yK”¸¹ῌ œ“º»4(ŽF%_š¼''‡()ῌ ῌ῎

῍

῎῍ῑ῏

῍

῍ῌῒ ῌ !῍"#῍ Leval ῌ

$%& '(ῌ )* +ῌ +,

& '(ῌ -.ῌ /01ῌ / 23ῌ /45367-89:ῌ ";)* 9 :#:<ῌ =9:῍ >ῌ ?@

#Aῌ B" )CDEF'<ῌ GHIJ KLM #^῎῍ῒ῏῍

῍῔ΐῐNOPῌQRSTUVW^῎῍ΐ῏ ῌ !῍"

#X.YZM[ῌ \]X ῎commercial use῏ #^

_`X ῎nonprofit use῏ #^-ab':6῍ ῍῔῔῍N

cdefghijῌkSlVW^῎῍῔῏ ῌ :mn9oῌ !῍"

#X.YZM[ῌ /pqῌ r stu6 vTwx y*z8ῌ /6u6 +M[/*st{|

X,#8#^}^-~6῍ ῌ _8 -€ ῌ \]X#^_`X#^bg

‚ ƒ9:6^῎῎ῌ῏῍

„,ῌ !῎" ῌ …†)‡9:)*YAῌ ˆ‰ῌ

Šp67-9:6)*, ῌ y)*)D ‹Œb ':& 'Y)*M[-Ž#Aῌ !

῏" ῌ |<ῌ D‹M ‘’ῌ CD“”

ῌ •–— ˜ 9:r #῍ !

῍"Ž™A-€ ῌ 9:6";š› ῌ rœ9:

6GHIŽ—#^’^žŸ ‹#῍

!ῐ" ῌ )C )D ¡¢C r

῍ )C£¤-#¥¦§¨© ῌ ª67-1«

¬­®¯#Aῌ ?@-)D°lwlij±² ῌ )C³´I9o῍ :‹4:<ῌ k±µ¶·¸-.tzG-€„¹º῎e» ¼῏ //

ῌ῎

῍

῍ ῌ Nation

῎Haper&Row^῎῎῍῏῏ ῌ ῌ ῐ !

"# $%^῎῎῎῏῍

&'()ῌ*+,ῌ -.ῌ /0123456784 9:;<= %>?@A5BCDῌ E/0123 4F$ῌ GHῌIJ+KLMNOPQ34>?@

ARBCDῌ ES21Q34>?@A5BCDT^῎῎῏῏῍ UVW4X'YZ[ῌ 67\]^\

_2`a1 bcde4fg"Nῌ 678/0123hij kl#mT"%n῍

῎῏῏ o3

pqrῌ s>4t%$ῌ ῐtuvwxU yz$%ῌ U{ῐtMVW4|}wx~ῌ T

῍ῌῑp4yzῐt€‚ƒ„4…~†‡$ῌ

ˆ€4‰Š$%῍ ~ῌ ῐtMVW4|}$

s>‹zwx~4t%$ῌ -.Œfῌ

Žz$%῍ ‘ῌ ’“῍

῎῍῏ Q3”1V•–—4t%$ῌ 678Q3˜Z/0123

™ῌ šz›nῌ 67\678œ1hi

T}ž49Q3kl>?@A5B4Ÿ῍

678Q3˜Z/0123 %i ῌ ES21Q34

šz›nῌ 67\678œ1hiT}ž49 Q3kl>?@A5B4Ÿ῍ !˜ῌ OPQ34 %šz›nῌ 67\678œ1hiT}ž4 9Q3kl>?@A5B4Ÿ῍

῎῎῏ 67\678–—4t%$ῌ 678¡¢1678~ῌ ῌ῎

῍

ῌ ῍

ῌ !"ῌ #

"ῌ $%#&'(&)*!+"

)*,!-ῌ ./&0123456!῍

῎῎῏ 789:;<=>*?@ABCDEF>G HI=J+Kῌ ?@FL!ῌ Jῌ ?@

MNDE=OP!+QR=ῌ ./&0123456

!

῎῏῏ 7STUQVCWX=Y?@Z[=

J+Kῌ \]=G?@^]_`UQVCSTUQ abc"QR=ῌ ./&01234d!+῍ !>ῌ S TUQῌ ef3ABK+!+ghUQiVB^῎῍῏῏῍

!jkῌ lmn@VCopn?@:qrABBPῌ ^]st 4u=3vd!+w-VC?@x!wyz{=|}!

+w-ῌ ./&01234q~{B῍ €ῌ lmn@"!+‚

?@:qrABBPῌ \]^]ƒ`T4ud!+w-ῌ ./&01 234q~{B„:!+^῎῍ῐ῏῍

ῌ ./&012=;…/†‡ˆ‰1Š2‹Œ

„„V"ῌ ./&012Ž!‘=J+K’“dCῌ „„"

…/†‡ˆ‰1Š2./&012=;‹Œ‡udC+῍

῎ῌ῏ ‰”•'–—˜

i῏ KellyŒ™

KellyŒ™^῎῍ῑ῏ῌ—˜‡ˆš›œ›=G‡ˆž‰”•'–῎thumb-

nail῏ —˜Ÿ ῌ ‡ˆῌŸ ABC…/†‰'¡7¢td!+

…/†‡ˆ‰1Š2=>*£¤:./&012=J+KŽ¥¦῎§¨ ©῏ /1

ῌ῍

῍

῍

Arriba ῌ

῍ ῌ !"#$%&

'()ῌ *+%,-.'( ῌ ῌ- / 0'12 +.34῍ Arriba 5678%9: ;< =>

?'(&4 @A;<BKelly ῌ ArribaCDEFGHI῍

J(%Kῌ Arriba LMN8OPQR^῎῍ῐ῏῍ SῑTUVHWX ῌ LMN8 Sῌ YZ ῐ[\ ]^

_`abcῑ %d4&ῌ Kelly [\ e^f=ῌ g+%hi^

῎highly exploitative῏ 4Ij4 LMN8klm

nl^Yo% jpj4῍ q=rs^e\%

t.e]^uvm῍ rs^e\ CDw xy ]^

zj{|&4}~%€p(=ῌ Kellyn ῌ

= %0'1ῌ d2+.34 ῌ ;<& ‚ƒ

^„4…`†‡ˆ‰Š&ῌ Kelly ‹1Œw&

{|&4῍

S῍ YZ ῐCDE CDw bcῑ %d4& ῌ WX

ῌ Kelly DŽ%b=t €=ῌ Kelly=‘1‡ˆ’

%“”•–tpῌ Arriba LMN8 OP%—˜™e%

š1%g›j4῍

S῎ YZ ῐCDE CDw‹œ ž%_Ÿ[\'(

 : ¡_`a¢cbῑ %d4& ῌ Arriba Kelly DŽ‹œ£

¤&4=ῌ * £¤mfŸ ῌ ¥\

b=¦j§(&q… ῌ J [\]^p~¨^῍

S῏ YZ ῐCDE CDw ©ª^«}q ¬­%Km

[\ ®¯ῑ %d4& ῌ CDE DŽ%°±%iA&²§DŽ

³´mῌ rµ'(DŽ=«}%¶®¯.pm·|b ¸j4 ῌ ¹D%iA&²§DŽ ¹D «}ºm=ῌ rs^[\

ῌ῎

῍

῍

ῌ !"#$%&'()*+ ῌ

Arriba,-./01234῍ 5678,9:.;<=>?@A

> ῌ !2B8CBD)"#E,F !

$%&'()GH+Iῌ !?JKL)ῌ ,-./0123 4^῎῎ῐ῏῍ Mῌ N ῌ ,F !)GH+ ῌ ,-./01) OPH+ῌ >)QRῌSTUVWXY^῎῎ῑ῏ῌ Z[ῌ \]^

_`ῌ aV2bc῍ dῌ aV2ef+ghUa Iij^῎῏ῌ῏῍

ii῏ Perfect῍ῌV

Perfect ῍ῌV^῎῏῍῏ !klmnon)klpq"# ῌ klῌ "

#Er-st$%&2uv'( PHYῌ wv'(xZ f^῎῏῎῏῍

.ytz2{|UPerfect῍ῌ ῌ r-st2}~+HYῌ

€‚2ƒ„Utῌ klmnon kl^PHt X῍ a4ῌ …†)PX ! ῌ ‡ˆr-stMO IX῍

‡ῑ‰cNŠ ῌ 78,9:.<=>?@A>Amazon

Š‹GoogleŠ‹2Œ+Ž)6_5V2Yῌ ‘’

“”YGoogle)*UIX῍

Google !kl0•1 ῌ 0–0) !25Ž—

˜ ῎™šC›œ῏ UYῌ ,F ! —˜PH῍ Zž),

Ÿ0 n¡¢n£nῌ8n™n¡2¤a)X+.B¥12

¦§)+H῍ a¨©)ƒῌ >INIῌ Google ! uv'(xZYYῌ ,F !8n™n¡ u v'(xZ PH῍ X+ῌ !)ƒU,-./

01ª«Y¬­PX῍ a­)GH+>N® ¯P῍

r-skl0•1)x°±²³,-./01)GH+5´µ῎¶· ¸῏ /3

ῌ῎

῍

῍ ῎ ῏ ῌ ῌ !"#$%&'()*Google +ῌ Kelly,-

Arriba./012304ῌ Perfect ῍ῌ56789῍

:9ῌ ;<=>?@A*BCDEFG+AdSense

"HGIHJK9LMῌ NOPQRSTUVGoogle

ῌ ArribaWPXY049῍ 4P4ῌ Zῌ

Perfect ῍ῌ [304ῌ Google12\

+W]O0W,^_^49῍

῎ ῎;<=;<`῏ ῌ aZ

aῌ +*bGcdefgO0PQῌ Perfect ῍ῌh ij\kl049῍

῏ ῎;<=;<`mn0op' fg

9qrst῏ ῌ aZaῌ Kelly,-uvῌ wx3yz{|*mq$}H+~3ῌ €Qa j\kl043049῍

ῐ ῎;<=;<`‚ƒL:9„…†*

‡ˆ῏ ῌ +‰Š‹

Œ*a3+ῌ Perfect ῍ῌŽ‘&' H’“‚ƒL>”*Ng+049+ῌ Zῌ Google

•H–H+Ž‘&'—D%˜H™49š›ῌ +œ43Perfect῍ῌj\049_^4ῌ €Q aj\kP3049῍

žcWῌ Zῌ Ÿ49 ¡¢8£¤¥49῍ O¦ῌ

Š‹§%¨%ῌ©%ª%«ῌ Google¬­

>?®¯>?ῌ Œ°>?0a_749+ῌ Z®¯>?

,^¥4ῌ Œ°>?±²49῍ Og³

´yµ*῍

ῌ῎

῍

῎῍῏ ῍Field

Field ^῎῎῎῏ῌ ῌ

ῌ !"#$%&'()῏*+,^῎῎῏῏῍ --

*ῌ ῌ./012/34+,56758῍

Google/93*ῌ Googlebot):;,<=

$>?@ῌ ./$ ῎AB῏ ῌ /C/D

**E,:74@(,῍ 2/F/$

G,)ῌ Googlebot"H./I/JK/34LM

ῌ ./NO/,῍

ῌ./GooglebotPQ4</RBS*

./*ῌ TUVPW./*+,)XYUῌ GoogleV ZS$./[\/4]@(῍ ^ῌ 4

_`ῌ Googlebotῌ./:74ab./

$c'( defῌ ghijkblm+`ῌ

GoogleVZ$noῌ kb῍p$qrs4*E,:74@(῍

tῌ῍u*+, ῐvῌwsx:yz{ῑ 4|(@ῌ }~\ῐ€

l‚ƒῌ Google„…!"†)‡'ˆῌ ‰

Šs4‹῍'ws4ŒG,V*+`ῌ Ž4!"†4‘:7) G,V*'(*ῌ Google’“”•–—˜™šs'V)(7 -)*E,)῍ ›œs'῎ῌ žŸj`*+,῍

῎ῌ῏ Googleῌ ./41 3*E'(¡¢

4ῌ } £2/F/N¤¥41 3G,-)$¦§) G,V*+ˆ@ῌ !"†4‘G,V*'(-)῍

῎῍῏ 4:`‡',BS4x¨,©ª./«

¬¦§)',)-­ῌ -®§./Ž¯*°±

G,-)*E'(V*+,-)῍

῎῎῏ ῌ 2/F/²4³/´/$µ@

G,-)*ῌ ./6-4/C/D@(

/934x¨,m¶·)012/34|(@A¸¹῎º» ¼῏ 0+

ῌ῎

῍

ῌ

!"ῌ #$%&

'()*'῍

+,ῌ -ῐ./0123'ῌ 456 789:,῍

῎῎῏ Google';<=>?@A#$%& BC ' ,D ῌ #EFGH;<=>?EF GHI JK@A ῌ ;<=>?@A LMN,OP ῌ (QGoogle;<=>? RSTQU,

#VW=X>Y=Z [\]A^_`7TQ U῍

῎῏῏ $%&abZcdeῌ ;<=>?EFGH)*fgh i jkGlGmnopqr_NU῍ NNῌ ;<=

>?@AstNOP 'uv (QwDxyz{|r _TQU }f~ῌ €$%&‚e

;<=>?@AwD'ῌ Google;<=>?@

Aiƒ$%& BC '„:U ANU῍

4…†‡ Iῌ ;<=>?@Aˆ ‰Šz!Google ‹‚ ŒKN,῍ ,Nῌ ‰Žz‚r!'ῌ ‘’

“!ῌ ’”“'•–TQU῍ ;<=>

?@A'ῌ —FW˜abZῌ(++RSNU [\

῍ NNῌ (Q }f~ῌ ™š'ῌ —FW˜'•›

z œ†‡‰Žz‚ržDfQU6 ^_Ÿ

!^῎῍῏῏῍

-ῌ ¡! ῐ!‘“¢ῑ £U'ῌ Field'

ij¤_¥z ¦=Z… §¨Nῌ ijabZ©GG ª«TQ ¬­N,ῌ ® Field¤ ’”“!¯,N U ῌ ‘“°'±²³ ῎´µ῏ ¶·‹‚!¸

ῌ῍ ῌ

῍

῏ ῐ

ῑ !ῌ Google"Field #$

%& !'ῌ ()ῌ *+),-).!

$%&/ 012ῌ

!ῌ 3456789&:5;<=>?5 ῍

ῐ ῐ@A)BCD!,-EF

GHῑ !ῌ IJKLMNOPQ@ABC"

RST!Uῌ V!WXYZ5=[\]ῌ ^R B C"_`a0>b῍ cdefg7hXYZ>ῌ I JKLMNOPQijkDl#mnFo5=ῌ IJKLM NOPQf)GH!>pf ῍ Fq<ῌ

Field@A)BC'GH#rFST"stῌ u

6789&:#vfFw?U ῍

st5=ῌ 6789&:ῐ ῌ ῎"Googleῌ ῍

"Fieldxy 6789&:#zf ῍ {678 9&:zf|}!ῌ ῍ ῐ)ῑ

ῐ ῐ@A)BCD!,-EF

GHῑ #~ €῍ |ῌ ῍) ῌ

‚ƒR„€5=!Uῌ …O†‡ˆ!‰

)ῌ ij#ŠR‹Œ/  €"|Ž)῍

lῌ {!ῌ FieldIJKLMῌ‘&†rr’

“ῌ Field”•ῌ –†—ˆῌ˜™š8› ῎DMCA^῎῏ῑ῏῏ œ&6

&ž& ῎Ÿ῏  ¡ >¢£"ῌ ¤>Google¥

#z.¦§/῍

῎῏῏ GooglehKQ¢¨©ª

῎ῌῌῒ«῍ῌ¬῎ῒ­ῌ ®¯°±² E³¢¨#)F

g7h¢¨X&´:µ¶6789&: ·¸¹῎º» ¼῏ 0-

῍῎ ῌ

Google ῎class action῏ ῌ

῍ Google ῌ !"

#$%&'( ῌ )*#$%&+,-.*/01 2*3 ῍ 4567(.89ῌ :;<=&>?.8 /0;

@ABCDEF; ῍ )G;8/0H8. ῌ /IJKL

MN ῎OP*QR῏ CDS( ῍ T*UGῌ VWX*/0

1BYZ UG 8G[\;]!3 ^῎῏ῑ῏῍

T(ῌ ῎ῌῌῐ^ΐ_῎ῌ`ῌ abcde ῎The Author’s Guild῏

afgde ῎Association of American Publishers῏ ῌ hbij

*<=&k;8/0&L#lm Pn opqL r*st39h biuv.ῌ Google&wxy9z^῎῏ῒ῏῍ T({|}~

e€/*e‚ƒ„oL ῎Congressional Research Service/CRS῏ ῌ e*…ῌ ῎ῌῌῐ^CRS†‡N&bˆ῍ T*Xῌ {|}~*4‰ ῎Legislative Attorney῏ ῌ Google H8.†‡N.8 ῌ Š‹{ŒLH8.Ž*UG

&-.8 ῍

῎῍῏ ‘῍’3 ῐ“* r”U•–—ῑ H8.ῌ ˜™*LM

N&CD T ῌ hbiš›*”)(23 ῌ Google* CD ˜™*œ&žŸ9ῌ  ;Ÿ9 .8;8῍

῎῎῏ ‘῎*’3 ῐhbi*3 hb¡*–—ῑ H8. ῌ €/

¢£p‹N ¤r;b¥2¦§r;b¥2+.8 ῌ

¦§r;b¥ ¨©†ª«*hbi4&¬­-13 ῍

῎῏῏ ‘῏*’3 ῐhbi*3 hb¡B®*”? “

S(*”U•¯—–ῑ H8. ῌ yG °

±3 ῍ Google²\³´ªLbˆ*Zhb¡B®

&sµ T ῌ Š‹{ŒL 8¶;8῍ °ῌ EF

;·#LN*¸¹*º°CD;8*ῌ Š‹{ŒL»¼ ³p´«sµ °ῌ <8š› °3 ῍ ῌ῎

῍

῎ῐ῏ ῐ ῐ

ῑ ῌ Google !"#$%&'(

)*῍ +,-./0123"45&6ῌ 78%&49:

;<4=>?@'()"Aῌ BC3D0EF G>HIJK;:L>MN9O<9>PQR9%

῍

῎ST῏ LUVWῌXῌ ῎ῌῌΐY῍῍Z῎ῌ[\]^_`A 4῍

ῌ abcd13efg]

hijk

lmjk

῎῍῏ hijkῌlmjk

jkῌ cnopqrjks9trjk"῍ t rjku%hijk ῎contributory infringement῏ Klmjk ῎vi- carious liability῏ v5%&῍ w&xqrjk":JK>yz KAῌ hijkjk{|>}~€A‚ƒῌ lmjk qrjk„jk{|;:…†‡ˆ>‰„"Š<‚῍

cnop ‹ῌ ῍ῌῒŒ9%῍῎῍ŒQŽ‡>jkA

„> jk„KQ ῎ῑῌ῍Œ ῎a῏῏῍ hijkῌ lmjk cnop ‹I4Q4xῌ ‘’‹“ῌ ”Q

•–ῌ qrjk„ef„jk‚"—Qu&῍

hijkKῌ qrjk{|>˜9ῌ 8™š›"

x99œ%wῌ jk>žῌ Ÿ Aƒῌ jk¡¢hiA

„‚>£‹š^῎῏ΐ῏῍ 4œ¤ῌ ῌqrjk"_`¥ῌ

῍jk{|"JK>8ƒ4"%ῌ ῎¦jk{|>§¨Aῌ

©4Wi>{:JK"•^῎ῐῌ῏῍ hijkῌ ª«¬‹{|

­®A„¯K¬‹{|‹°±²>¯A῍ °

$ῌ hijk_`ῌ jk„ ῐjk#³ῑ "´῍

µb+./0123¶5‹·¸Kabcd13”¹º῎*» ¼῏ 0/

ῌ῍

῎

ῐῑ ῌ ῎actual knowledge῏

ῌ ῎constructive knowl-

edgeῌ ῏ ^῎ῐ῍῏῍

!ῌ "#ῌ $%&'()*+,-./0&12῍

ῌ '(3456718)9:;<῎=

>?)@A0BC)DE0F^῎ῐ῎῏῍ 07GHῌ ῌ'(

)IJ0&K2῍)LMῌ ῍'(NMOP5618)L 0QNM'()R<FSῌ TUQBCV0 W7 FXYZ)LM῍ "#BC[ῌ '(;

=\>7῍ "#BCYZῌ QN0IJBC )]^K'TM_`)ab0cde;)M73e

<fgh4῍

"#ijklmῌMn῍ oῌ pbhqr 6h4<fstuv^῎ῐ῏῏῍

῎῎῏Perfect῍ῌwx῍ij

Perfect ῍ῌyzwxῌ {|}~/€V0‚ƒ„.…ῐ

>†=‡ˆ4eῌ /{~‰€Š~+‹~+ῌŒ+

+Ž=ῌ GoogleP)ijῌ "#Me ῌ ‘zij)DEMῌ "#=yzwx)’Me῍

‘zῌ ij῎=῎“;)”Me῍ 07GHῌ ῌ )•–0—E'(˜™0š.…ῌ ῍›eœk>7

žTUŸ27 ¡=ῌ X ¡)¢£0š.…ῌ

῍ yzῌ GoogleM¤‚¥{~,Šƒ¦§…)¨©

0ª«)MeG:7¬ῌ X<Me¤‚¥{~,­®¯°±Me

²7ῌ ῌ'(˜™M7Me῍

M3Mῌ ‘zῌ ¤‚¥{~,*³.)´µ¶·£0;ῌ XMµ¶¸1UQ¹ºƒ¦§…0;)Google»¼M ῌ῍

῎

ῌ ῌ῍ ῌ Perfect

῍ῌ !"#$%&Google'(

ῌ Perfect ῍ῌ)*+,-.%(/01123ῌ 4-

.561(2ῌ Google789*:;῍

<=9*/>ῌ ?@ῌ GoogleABCDEF9*GH IJKLM$NOῌ <=9*ῌ P@0&

QRS^῎῏῏῏῍

῎῎῏ ParkerTU῍789*ῌ<=9*

PerkerTU^῎῏ῐ῏ῌ VWXYZ[\ῌ ]^_/

` ῎abcde῏ &ῌfghQVWXDEFijK

9*Tk%῍

Parkerjlῌ VWXDEFSῌ jmncFo/pq

῍ GoogleijK9*rs;῍ Parker῍῍tuG(ῌ

Googlevw9*ῌ 789*ῌ <=9*/>0tu῍ &xῌ Ydyz{|}?~€?@ῌ Google/ParkerVWXD EFabcde‚ƒ„…vw9*῍

789*/>ῌ Parkerῌ ῌ†‡ijKABC/(9*

hQˆ‰ῌ ῍GoogleABC/9*Šῌ ‹Œˆ‰ῌ tu῍ &/> ῌ ?@ῌ ῌ/>ῌ Parkerrjm 9*hQ1῍ ῍/>ῌ Google/789

*:xŽῌ GoogleABC9*GH'‘

%ῌ ?@ῌ Parker&/>’“ῌ

Google789*῍

<=9*/>ῌ Parkerῌ ῌGoogle†‡†”‚ƒ•Z–Z 9*GHIJῌ—˜KL$NS(&ῌ ῍Google

™š›œr1žŸ _¡¢£¤&ῌ tu῍

&Q/¥?@ῌ Parker‰¦/9*hQ§¨jmgh VWXDZ©"/‚¤ª«¬­W•Z"/>]®¯῎°± ²῏ 01

ῌ῍

῎

ῌ Google

ῌ ῌ ParkerGoogle

!"#ῌ $%&'()*#+,-.#++.

#ῌ Parker/012῍

῎῏῏ 3456ῌ789:;

῍῔῔ΐ<ῌ :=>?@Aῌ BC 3456ῌ789:;

῎DMCA῏ D.῍ Eῌ FGHIJKJL3

456M!NO Pῌ QIRSTPUVWXYZ .#ῌ IRS[\]! ^_.`῍

DMCAIIῌ a! ῐbJcdJefghD^῎῏ῑ῏ῑ ij

k#+῍ `ῌ Eῌ ef lmn.o pqdrefghῌ as.tu!v.῍

`+wxSyzῌopqdrῌ ῐ{S|S}~ €C

ῌ {S|S‚ tƒ„!ῌ 3456ῌbJcdJ…†‡

ˆῌ 6SK‰JŠ%‹Œ /Ž ῎entity῏ῑ .#+

῎῏ῒ῏

῍ k!ῌ ‘’J4J“”"w•–—xd˜™š”,›

k῍

DMCAῌ U.S.C.῍ῒ ῐῑ !ῌ ῐœ ῐef

῎ž῏ΐ῏

ῑ Ÿ .ῌ ῐ῍῎¡`opqdref¢!῏£¤S

z!£+#gs¥.῍ ¦῏£¤Szῌ ῌ‡§xSyz

῎¨῏῔῏

ῌ ῍©ª«¬­¨^῎ῐῌ῏ῌ ῎®zK‰JŠ¨^῎ῐ῍῏ῌ ῏‘ῌ>J¯¨^῎ῐ῎῏`῍

‡§xSyz¨ῌ °±²†.lopqdrIJKJL

³ ‡§ tu`´ῌ ©ª«¬­¨ῌ xd˜WµS 4¶lopqdr¬zK;!a·(!¸¹ tu`῍ ® zK‰JŠ¨ῌ ºῌ »ª«˜6S;ῌ ®zK‰JŠῌ xSyz

"w!ῌ {S|S‚!¼#opqdr¬zK;!l¸¹ tu`´ῌ ‘ῌ>J¯¨ῌ ‘’J4Jῌ >J¯"wl

ῌ῍

῍

ῌ

῍ !"#$%&'ῌ ()!ῌ*+,-).

/῍

012)ῐῌ῍3'45678%&9:῏;)<=ῌ

>'ῌ 0?@ABCD῍EFG<῍ ῌ;'ῌ 4 5678'HIJKLMῌ NOP QRS*T UVῌ WX)AYDDZ)0[\J]^J?J<0D _^῎ῐ῎῏ῌ Z2ῌ;'ῌ 45678'`aῌ b cdJefUJ]^J?J<0D^῎ῐ῏῏῍

g?)ῌ hij$kl+m-D!ῌ*+,-)n'ῌ oC

=pqg<῍ Jrsῌ tuv+w5Dx

<45678'ῌ tuy?z{|}<J<0D_^῎ῐῐ῏ῌ 45678=tu);<ῌ ~€hYasr‚<J

<0D^῎ῐῑ῏῍

0'ῌ 45678= )1tu)qƒ„)r …oB†C῍ DMCA'45678‡tuAY

ˆῌ AY)n45678‰Š);<‹JGŒ0 D)1ῌ Ž45678=tuAY]„n

ˆ);<‘’„“Q”„῍ 0GC„gJ<AY

’Dῌ 45678=tu);<~€hYa<„D

•J‚–ῌ 45678B0D)J^῎ῐῒ῏῍

Jῌ "#$ῌ45678=ῐῌ῍3B]?Jy„D Zῌ —˜™$š›œ(0D'ž?–ῌ ῌ

ῐῌ῍3Ÿ '›œ¡¢)£¤g‚'J?J<Dg<^῎ῐΐ῏῍

Field¡¥'ῌ €M῎“=¦r„῍

῎ῌ῏ Google= ῐ§¨dy;©ªd)«¬­®ῑ Zy 

y=¦r„=ῌ ¯¡°'ῌ Google±²³T´'S$kl+m„µ !"#$)]¶·D—˜™$);<©¸¹῎º» ¼῏ 03

ῌ῍

῎

ῌ ῌ

῍ῐ῎ῌ ῌ !"#$%%&'(ῐ)ῌ '!(*+,-῍

῎῎῏ ῑ῍῎. ῎b῏ ῎῍῏ ῎B῏ /ῌ 01 (2345῏῍6 ,-7ῌ 8 9 7:,;ῌ <=97 >?@A;ῌ BC ! '(῎D,;%'Eῌ Fieldῌ FieldFG 7Google

῎DGooglebotBC ! F5ῌ Google HIJKL

M' ῎N(OPῌ QR !-῍

῎῏῏ ῑ῍῎. ῎b῏ ῎῍῏ ῎C῏ /ῌ ῐSTUVWU$XYZ[ῑ \]^

_`ab /cd!;%'ῌ ῐ[e f4g] : hiZ[(῎D:,;ῌ (῏῍6jUῑ /'/῎D !;%'Eῌ Google/' ῎k ῎N(l- 'Mm῕ ῌnM$% !-῍

o῕,;ῌ Field ῌ Google/ῑ῍῎. ῎b῏ Zpqr(st uvw(xyz ΐ{Q|(D}~ῒ;M€ !ῌ Google ῌ S‚/ῑ῍῎. ῎b῏ Zpqr(stuvw/z ΐ {Q|(D}~ῒ;/ !-^῎ῑΐ῏῍

ParkerQ|FieldQ|(ƒ„,ῌ K[…†HIJKL‡,;ῌ ῑ῍῎

. ῎b῏ ˆ‰.Š u῍/'(‹Œ,;%῍

$ῌ Žf4g(‘ῑῑ῍῎. ῎b῏ ‡,;Mῌ ’“”

•Nῑ῍῎. ῎b῏ –—(˜k'$y‰™/š+ !;%-}ῌ

›Q῔œd!'/$%῍ ῔GUῌ Perfect῍ῌQ|^῎ῒῌ῏Mῑ῍῎. ῎c῏

žŸ; . ῎d῏ ¡¢/£¤$A-/ῌ ¥¦ ^_`f4g§¨

Adult CheckK[…†(©ª«¬Cybernet Ventures f4 g­ῌ §¨® Žf4g f¯[cd!;%-%&°[

]ῌ ±² Žf4g/01 !-•NM$%῍ o³ῌ ´µ¶·7(

¸¹º»(A;%MŒ}!¼ῌ ῑ῍῎. ῎c῏ ῎d῏ ˆ‰/

š+ !;%῍

ῌ῍

῎

ῌ ῌ ῌ !"#$%ῌ &'$%ῌ DMCA()*+

,-ῌ./01230+0454567*῍

ῌ 89:;<=>

῎῍῏ 76?5 @AB$%CDE

9F CGῌ 89:

;<=>H6ῌ IJ76?5 G90CD EK4L./LMN4῍ ῌ 76?5O0PQR?S

῍ TU0VQRWX6SPῌ YZ[\$%

0]"#$%5/L^_`54C6abS῍

cdDE)ῌ e%fg^_h/ῌ ijkNlm6no50*

p*54)q4Lῌ 76?5 DE6r+2῍

76?@ABῌ ijkNlmas50]ῌ @AB

$%tuv/ῌ wxyz{B|yL46 ῎@AB῍῍῎}῏ῌ e%f gz{B~$%€ijkNlmn{2 ῎‚ῑῌῒ}῍

@AB῍῍῏}῏῍ dƒῌ ῌ @AB$%€ῌ ijkNlm 4*„7…ῌ B†€v/Lfg^_`52L4 ῎‡ˆ^

_῏῍ $%€‰j ῎willfulness῏ 604545Šfg‹#

Œ*p*545Ž#Œl…^῎ῐ῍῏ῌ e%‘$%€†’“

”h^_•27104^῎ῐ῎῏῍

–ƒῌ [\ῌ @AB$%—*04€S˜L,ῌ @AB$%S 5|™*ῌ |™šC›6S**7+…ῌ @AB$%

œ/NPῌ ž~/NPῌ Ÿ$%"#/N€ῌ "#$%€5 /L^_`5῍

Nyῌ ῌ @AB$% +*¡h#tuK 4Lῌ ijkNlmas50]fg^_`7¢56£

q1¤¥5K4Ld¦§῎¨© ª῏ 1+

ῌ῍

῎

ῌ ! "^῎῏῎῏῍

#$%&ῌ ' (ῌ ")*ῌ +,-#./

0123456+,-78# 9῍ 2ῌ /01234 *ῌ :;;%&<=>?@AB

# 9 ῎CDῐῌ῎E῏ῌ FGH?@Iῌ ;JKI

ῌ %&L=&%1῍

MNOPῌ QRSTUVWXY%&ῌ

* Z['$῍ '\ῌ UV]^_^

78`$*ῌ abcdefgῌ WhiXjfg%+,-Iῌ klm%n['$῍

opLqrῌ stuAB:&vwx "῍

' (Dyῌ <D '$2zῌ stAB 7uP$῍ {|:%}=z$~ῌ stAB:7uP

$῍ 12ῌ {|:Dῌ €D῍ῌ῍E‚ƒ*

ῌ „…%ῌ {|:†‡ˆ‰Š‹<D%&*ῌ :;%FstAB:Œ`Ž#"῍ '\ῌ st ABGH%ῌ {|:‘’ "῍

“”ῌ QRSTst• ῎injunction῏ ῌ ]–X—˜™ ῎equity῏

%š›5Dœ"žῌ Ÿ t2u%ῌ st•

Œ¡# ¢£῍ QRST¤¥¦žῌ stAB

§=¨2u%ῌ ©ª«¬z$~P’

­®῍

UVWXY{|:¯°QRST

±OP²z³9g‡ῌ /0ῌ 34#ῌ UVWXY

%&+,-´µ7u³9"῍ F ῌ UVWXY;´µ¶# "Perfect

῍ῌ· ῎¸¹º")2»·¼u·῏ OP²z³9g‡

ῌ῍ ῌ

ῌ ῌ !"#$%&'()*+,-.

/*+῍

0*12,34*ῌ 56 789:#;<;=

>=?ῌ @1289A 98B,ῌ :

#;65C<DE^῎῏῍῏῍

῎ῌ῏ FGHIJKL

FGHIJKMNῌ 51<O%89 EPEQ<+)ῌ RSTUF GHIJK<VEῌ WXYPEZ[WK<\*

"]^*)C+῍ E_`ῌ abcdePKfJghi jklmno =?ῌ pq%rst*u6vw8 xq1,C8>ῌ %;yt<kl 6vhzJ{="E98B,|<+Cῌ WX Y}~ῌ €‚thƒG„…J[†‡E!12ῌ ˆs

!‰E<ῌ Š6‹!89o =Uῌ Bῌ klŒY"‰()o =E""+CE!<

"89o =^῎῏῎῏῍

$*ῌ HŽFGHIJK%,"‘t’“*FGH IJK;=#”ˆ^,Ex$ῌ •–—E_<\

E˜BEῌ +ῌ FGHIJK%™%š›*Q

<E8&8!œ ῌ š›<ži|<+

῍ Bῌ $'Ÿ ῌ C=B*¡"9‰*+

¢=9)12<(£(9E¤¥¦§9‰12

<œ¨C<|¢=ῌ •–©Kœ¨"ª;)«<œ¨

*Eῌ ž¬­ž®¯h°±\x²*³´µK

¶>C<EE!·*"+^῎῏῏῏῍

ƒG„JZK¸4RSFGHIJK¹9$oº῎»+ ¼῏ 1-

῍῎ ῌ

ῌ !"#$%&'()*+,^῎ῐῑ῏῍ -#.ῌ /ῌ 0123456789:;9<4=>?@AB 'C$$DE^῎ῐῒ῏ῌ !FGHI J-,/#'$&'(K$Dῌ DLMNOPQR9STU

!BCVWXY'ῌ Z[U!\9]^_`9ab PQῌ cd;e&%YCf'gAhijP(&-, R9STU!/k#lῌ m&n#$%/

#'$&'()*+,^῎ῐΐ῏῍

P(#o#$ῌ ῎ῌῌΐῐp῍῎ ῌ qrFGHstῌnῌ u-,v&ῌ fw῏ῑvῐfxB῍

yz{/ῌ /ῌ |}~&€- ,&&Cῌ y‚ƒ„…,FG†‡ˆH‰,

Šƒ‹/k#'&D,&$Dῌ ŒŽ-,i

&D,‹„'ῌ H‰‘’#l“”•–—˜

™‡(&š,P(-,C+,῍

$#Dῌ ›w῎œC)*P(ῌ v/ῌ Hž

Ÿ &¡+Qῌ Yῌ y/¢‡

£-,C‚¤#'+Qῌ $D¥

-,f#m¦§-,P(#&/#%'#'῍ P%ῌ f

#mAhi¦§ῌ u !"n-,/ῌ k#$D Eῌ ¨`©P(#|i ªiH«+,

&¬,῍

!­/ῌ ¨`©/®P(#C-¯š$ῌ Yῌ

®P(#°"-,$ῌ BDῌ ¨`©"ῌ }

~i®P(#±²,$³#´µ¶,&+,῍

·P(ῌ `¸;¹¨`©«/ῌ $%Aºa»¨

`©D,&¼°n-,P(#‹nQ¡῍ C ῌ῎

῍

ῌ

ῌ ῍ῌῑῌ !"#$ %& ^῏ῑῌῐ῍ ''ῌ ( )*῏+,-./"0123῍

4ῌ 56789:;<=>?@ῌ ()*ῐ+AB$ῌ CDEFGH3&Iῌ JKLMNῌ OPMNῌ DMCA&Q<=RS217T

$&UV&1& ῍ 'ῌ ,-.W&

"ῌ X(Y$Z[\]$^Uῌ _`abK<= Scde&UVῌ 56789:;<

=>?fgh$ '"ijH3῍ 1ῌ (+ ῏῍ῐ AB$

ῌ kNlm;$n<#op"3'q3῍

Jrῌ ,-.WX(Y"ῌ Z[

56789:;<=>@$^Us"tIuC cῌ <vwxy210ῌ X(Y\]ῌ 2&

z{=&&1|3"}~ῌ €‚=z{ƒ„21…†$

@‡U3ˆ‰Š῍ 'ῌ <E‹"ŒH3<Ž

ῌ ‘ῌ ’“&”<‹•῎ῌ –z—{c‚

ƒ˜3'™;š& ῍ 4ῌ ,-.›œ<ž

Ÿ-,-.˜ \] & ^῏ῑ῍ῐ῍ ' ῌ c¡¢–<£ῌ ¤¥¦ ch$ '"§

¨©$ 3 ῍

X(Y\]ῌ ¡¢–<῎ῌJª‚ƒ„–

z—{;šc>3cῌ ,-."

«~ῌ X(Yῌ I4¡¢–<῎ῌJª–z

—{"$ῌ X(Y"¬H3&ῌ H&­®ῌ ‚

ƒ„–z—{¯°$±²«3³c™h3´

­3῍

Vῌ ‚ƒ„–z—{.µ~ῌ ¬ 56789:uU3<¶·° ¸¹῏º» ¼ῐ 1/

ῌ῍

῎

ῑ ῌ

!"#$%&'῍ ()$ῌ *ῌ + ,ῒ-%.ῑ/012345678ῌ *!

"ῌ 9:;< 8+,ῒ-%.ῑ/012 !"67=

&'῍ >"?@ ῌ +,ῒ-%.ῑ/012ABC D῍EFGHI!&'J"῍

ῌ KL@

MN*ῌ /012OP Q)CRῌ STUVWXYZ[\&'῍ ῌ ]MN*^_

CHIRῌ `aMN$ῌ bcTUdῐef> g*h ijklC!῍ mῌ noEpqrsΐtu*ῌ vw x@qryz{|}k&ῌ ~vS €

> ‚῏&'῍

ƒ„…MN8!v*ῌ †‡ˆv&*ƒ„

g&'$ῌ ‰ῌ Š‹Œῌ Ž῕{MN8!

‘!^῎῏῍῏῍ Š’&ῌ ƒ„…MN{“῔”k

> {' {ῌ MN”k !"•–{'῍ >"ῌ —˜

™š ῌ ƒ„…MN8!v*›fῌ œf

*+,02ῒ-%.ῑ/012῎8!v{œ!῍

>"ž&ῌ Š’Ÿ  ῎fair dealing῏ ?

@%*V!¡¢£¤&! ¥}k῍ \}¦ῌ Ÿ  ῑ/0i§ ῌ™*ῌ ¨©ZLª™«¬ ῎῍ῐ;῏ῌ ­®ῌ

®῔ZL¯t°± ῎῎ῌ;῏ῌ ²u ῎῎῍;῏ 0Ck^῎῏῎῏῍ >kῌ 9³+

,02ῒ-%.ῑ/012 8 C@> {&W῍

88{Cῌ >k ῌ MN´µt<&

'ῌ 12¶·¸¹&º»ῑ῎{8¼8™

ῌ῍

῎

ῌ

῍ !"#$%&ῌ '(ῌ )*+,-.ῌ /0/

12ῌ )*+,-.34567869'ῌ :6;<-=>? @A῍

BC2ῌ DEFG/HGIJKLG ῌ AMFN Oῌ PQR N"#STU!=N 'VW>XY῍

Zῌ [\]Aῌ )*+,-.^ _ῌ

`a34RbS>ῌ aGcd῍

ῐ῍ῑ e-;f-g ῒh῎῍ ijG /S>ΐ ῐhttp://www.bunka.go.jp/chosakuken/῎῍_houkaisei.htmlῑ

ῐ῎ῑ e-;f-gῒ/k!'"l#ΐ ῐhttp://

www.bunka.go.jp/chosakuken/pdf/῎῍_houkaisei_gaiyou.pdfῑ

ῐ῏ῑ ῎ῌῌ῔῍῍mῌ n$opq% !ῌ rs&'t(u2

Isv&wῌ x')*y+zAk&,{

ῌ|'-}.Isk/v& ῐ )*+

,-.v&ῑ '0 *$1~Nῐ$opq

% !g:€ῌ‚ƒ„Z$oI2…34†G ῒg:€ῌ‚

ƒ„Z$oI2$d(S> ῐ1~ῑΐ ῐh῎ῌ῍῍m῎ΐῑ ῐhttp://www.ipr.go.jp/e_material/diginet_houkoku.pdfῑ῍ῑ ῐ5678 ῒ/Isk/‡ˆῐ‰ )*+,-.ῑΐ Š‹Œ

No.῏ῐΐ ῐ῎ῌῌ῕ῑ ῎9ῑ῍ Yῌ :Ž;GAῌ ῎ῌῌ῔῍῍m῍῔

ῒ/Zk/-}Isv&‘\’“”ΐ

=N῍

ῐῐῑ e-;f-g ῒEFG/HGΐ ῐhttp://www.bunka.

go.jp/chosakuken/singikai/index.htmlῑ

ῐῑῑ •<– ῒ—15˜™š›g*œƒRž9g9S>k

@Ÿΐ= I¡¢ ῐjŽ£5Šῑ >῏῍¤ ῐ῎ῌῌ῔ῑ ῍῎῕῎῍ῒ῔9῍

ῐῒῑ ¥¦§῍ῌ‡῎ˆ ῒ¥¨῏῏ ῐ%ῑ ῏῏$A©zῌ *ª¥

\«ˆ]¬?|­®¯®¯°'±z²ῌ @¤ῌ ³¤

`´A¤ῌ µdBd'2a\`´j¶|·KLGv¸&

¹*ºR»-¼.Z)*+,-.S>k@Ÿῐ•< –ῑ 11

ῌ῍

῎

ΐ !" #$῎῍%&'()*+,-. )/01234567839 :; <ῑ= >? ῎ῌῌ῕% ῕῍῍@

῔ Copyright Law of the United States, ῍ΐ^U.S.C. http://www.copy- right.gov/title῍ΐ^/

῕ &'(ABC(DAEFGHI:; &'J,KLῌM NOPQR,HI:; &'(ABC(DAEFGHI:;

STU #$῎῍%῏V ῎ῑ@

῍ῌ WXYZF[\ ] &'(^S_043 CRIC ,`Zabc http://www.cric.or.jp/gaikoku/america/america_c῍^a.html#῍ῌΐ ῍῍ Folsom v. Marsh, ῕^{F. Cas.}῏ῐ῎CCD Mass.῍῔ῐ῍.

῍῎ &'(ABC(DAEFGHI:;ῌdef ῕ ῎῏@

῍῏ Pierre N. Leval,Toward A Fair Use Standard,῍ῌ῏HARV.L.REV.῍῍ῌῑ^,

῍῍῍῍῍῕῕ῌ.

῍ῐ &'(ABC(DAEFGHI:;ῌdef ῕ ῎ῐ@

f῍῕

῍ῑ g!hijklmno&'()p,qrs ῍ ῍tuvw x yvw z{|}3P ~€ ‚ƒ„)…†5:;<῍ῒ‡ ῎ῌῌΐ ῕ῒ

@

῍ῒ &'(ABC(DAEFGHI:;ῌdef ῕ ῎ῑ@

῍ΐ &'(ABC(DAEFGHI:;ῌdef ῕ ῎ῒ@

῍῔ Sony Corp. v. Universal City Studio,ῐῒῐ^U.S.ῐ῍ΐ῍῕῔ῐ. ῍῕ Compbell v. AcuffῌRose Music, Inc.,ῑ῍ῌ^U.S.ῑῒ῕῍῕῕ῐ.

῎ῌ ˆX‰Š |‹Œ&'(),Ž g‘’ ῎ῌῌῐ% ῍῏ῑ῍῏ῒ

@

῎῍ Haper&Row, Pulishers, Inc. v. Nation Enters.,ῐΐ῍^U.S.ῑ῏῕^,῍ῌῑ ^S.Ct.

῎῎῍῔ ῍῕῔ῑ.

῎῎ &'(ABC(DAEFGHI:;ῌdef ῕ ῎ΐ@

῎῏ ˆXῌdef ῎ῌ ῍῏ΐ@

῎ῐ ˆXῌdef ῎ῌ ῍῏῔῍῏῕@

῎ῑ ˆXῌdef ῎ῌ ῍῏῕@

῎ῒ Kelly v. Arriba Soft Corp.῏῏ῒ^F.῏^d῔῍῍^,῔῍ΐῌ῔῍῕῕^thCir.῎ῌῌ῏. ῎ΐ “”•– jk—0˜0™š&'() ›῍῍ šœ)ž^Vol.῏ῑ^,

No.ῒ ῎ῌῌΐ% ΐ῕῕@

῎῔ Kelly v. Arriba Soft Corp.,ΐΐ^F.Supp.῎^d῍῍ῒC.D. Cal.῍῕῕῕. ῌ῎

῍

῏῎῕ῐ Kelly v. Arriba Soft Corp.,῎῔ῌ^F.῎^d῕῏ῐ῏C.D. Cal.῎ῌῌ῎ῐ.

῏῏ῌῐ ῌ ῏῎ΐῐ ῔ῌ῎ ῏῍῏ῐ῍

῏῏῍ῐ Perfect῍ῌ, Inc. v. Amazon com. Inc. U.S. App. LEXIS῍῍ῐ῎ῌ῏῕^{th Cir.}

῎ῌῌΐῐ.

῏῏῎ῐ ΐ῍Google῔

!"#$῎῕%῍& ῏῎ῌῌ῔'ῐ ΐ῎῎ΐῐ῍

῏῏῏ῐ Field v. Google, Inc.῏῕῍^F.Supp.῎^d῍῔῍῏D.D.C., Sept.῎ΐ^,῎ῌῌῑῐ; Field v.

Google, Inc.ῐ῍῎^{F. Supp.} ῎^d῍῍ῌῒ^,῍῍῍ΐῌ῍῍῎῏῏D.Nev.῎ῌῌῒῐ.

῏῏ῐῐ ῌ ῏῏῎ῐ ῒ῕῎ΐῌ῍

῏῏ῑῐ (ῌ ῏῍ῑῐ ῍ῌ῍῍

῏῏ῒῐ Digital Millennium Copyright Act

῏῏ΐῐ ΐWeb)*+,-῔ ./01$ῑ῎%ῑ& ῏῎ῌῌ῕'ῐ

῎ῒ῔῍

῏῏῔ῐ The Author’s Guild v. Google Inc., No.ῌῑῌ῔῍῏ῒ῏S.D.N.Y. filed Sept.῎ῌ^,

῎ῌῌῑῐ.

῏῏῕ῐ (ῌ ῏῍ῑῐ ῔ῑ῍

῏ῐῌῐ 23456789:ῌ ;<=>?89@ABC ῏῎ΐ῍D

῏bῐῐ 89EFGHIJKL῏῎ΐ῍D ῏cῐῐ MNOPQRST?῍

῏ῐ῍ῐ UVWX234YZ[\]^ ῏$ῒ_ῐ X`a ῑbcῐῒ

῏http://www.mext.go.jp/b_menu/shingi/bunka/gijiroku/ῌ῍῏^/ῌῑῌΐ῕ῌ῍^/ ῌῌῐῌ῏^.htmlῐ

῏ῐ῎ῐ (ῌ ῏῍ῑῐ ῔ΐ῍

῏ῐ῏ῐ ῏ῐ῍ῐ῍

῏ῐῐῐ ῌ ῏῎ΐῐ ῔ῌ῍῎῔ῌ῎῍

῏ῐῑῐ Parker v. Google, Incῐ῎῎^{F. Supp.} ῎^dῐ῕῎^,ῐ῕ΐῌῐ῕῔῏E.D. Pa.῎ῌῌῒῐ.

῏ῐῒῐ Online Copyright Infringement Liability Limitation.

῏ῐΐῐ ῍ΐ^U.S.C.῕ῑ῍῎ ῏kῐ ῏lῐ ῏aῐῐ.

῏ῐ῔ῐ Copyright Infringement and Remedies.

῏ῐ῕ῐ ῍ΐ^U.S.C.῕ῑ῍῎ ῏aῐ.

῏ῑῌῐ ῍ΐ^U.S.C.῕ῑ῍῎ ῏bῐ.

῏ῑ῍ῐ ῍ΐ^U.S.C.῕ῑ῍῎ ῏cῐ.

῏ῑ῎ῐ ῍ΐ^U.S.C.῕ῑ῍῎ ῏dῐ.

῏ῑ῏ῐ ῍ΐ^U.S.C.῕ῑ῍῎ ῏iῐ ῏῍ῐ ῏Aῐ.

῏ῑῐῐ ῍ΐ^U.S.C.῕ῑ῍῎ ῏iῐ ῏῍ῐ ῏Bῐ.

῏ῑῑῐ ῍ΐ^U.S.C.῕ῑ῍῎ ῏cῐ ῏῍ῐ ῏Bῐ,῏dῐ ῏῎ῐ.

῏ῑῒῐ ῍ΐ^U.S.C.῕ῑ῍῎ ῏cῐ ῏῍ῐ ῏Aῐ,῏dῐ ῏῍ῐ.

def)*+,=>?ghiejk*,lTSmno῏ ῐ 13

ῌ῍

῍

ῐῑΐῑ ῌ ῐ῏῎ῑ ῒῐ῏ῒῑ῎ ῌ ῐ῎ΐῑ ῒῌῑ῍ ῐῑ῔ῑ ῌ ῐ῍ῑῑ ῍ῌῒ῍

ῐῑ῕ῑ ῌ ῐ῍ῑῑ ῍῍῎῏῍῍῏῍

ῐῒῌῑ Perfect῍ῌ, Inc. v. Cybernet Ventures, Inc.,῎῍῏^{F. Supp.} ῎^d῍῍ῐῒ^,῍῍ΐῑ ῌ῍῍῔῎ῐC.D. Cal.῎ῌῌ῎ῑ.

ῐῒ῍ῑ ῑῌῐ ῐ῔ῑ ῐ῎ῑῌ ῌ ῐῌ῍ ῐdῑῌ ῐῌ῎ ῐdῑ῍

ῐῒ῎ῑ ῌ ῐ῍ῑῑ ῍῍ῑ῍ ῐῒ῏ῑ ῌ ῐ῍ῑῑ ῍῍ῑ῍ ῐῒῐῑ ῌ ῐ῍ῑῑ ῍῍ῐ῏῍῍῔῍ ῐῒῑῑ ῌ ῐ῏ῑ ῎῍ ῐῒῒῑ ῌ ῐ῏ῑ ῎῍ ῐῒΐῑ ῌ ῐ῏῎ῑ ῍῍῍

ῐῒ῔ῑ !"#$%&'(#)*+"#,-./012 3456ῌ789:';,<=(&ῌ $=<>?@ABC3DEF 8+GH"$%&'(IHJ῍ KIL+ῌ MNO !45'6ῌ PQ :-RSTU6VW'0XYZ[E%\]=\#ῐῌῐῑῑ

῍ῒ῎ ῐ῍῎ῑῑ῍

ῐῒ῕ῑ ]&^'>?@ABC3DE_`\#a^78-bc6ῌ ]&^- +de"#-'6I\H%\*fg=H<ῌABh/2/-iIC 3j3a^+kl\῍

ῐΐῌῑ ῌ ῐ῏ῑ ῎῍

ῐΐ῍ῑ mnoE'6ῌ pqrst6uvst%t,<=\#῍ g-*Kῌwt-xyz"#{?|}~3o/ ῐ€p‚ῑ +ƒ„"=

…†‡%I<I\ˆst‰=\#Š-&‹#&ῌ{?|}~3o/

+)#pqr-Œ%I#xy6rt‰=\# ῐῌ ῐ῏ῑ

῎῏῏ῑ῍

ῐΐ῎ῑ Ž^-q+\6ῌ q+f#pqrst+‘"#’“

RS” ῒ•-–—ῌ˜™šE›œ-’“RS q+f#p qrst+‘"#’“RSžŸΐ ῐ ¡῎῍¢῏£ῑ+¤\῍

ῐΐ῏ῑ ῌ ῐ῏ῑ ῏῍ ῌ῎

῍