著作物の商業的利用とフェア・ユース法理――「利用の目的および性格」の解釈を中心として―― 利用統計を見る

(1)

ῌ῏ ῎῍

ῌ

῍῍ ῎ ῏ ῍῍

ῌ !"ῌ#$%&'

῍ () *

῎ +&῍ῌῒ,῍-.&/0

῍ ῎ ῏ 12῏3456

῍ 78 *

῎ 9:)

῏ ;9<=)

ῐ >?@A$%BCD

ῌ῍῍ +&῍ῌῒ,EF) !"ῌ#$%GH ῌ῎῍ >?D

ῌ῏῍ @A$%BCD

῎ IJ&()9 !"ῌ#$%&'

῍ +KLMH9

῎ !"ῌ#$%MH+KLMH ῌ῍῍ NODPQ9 ῌ῎῍ RS+KLMH

ῌ῏῍ !"ῌ#$%&'TUVWXDY34 ῌῐ῍ Z[\]^_`abc$\%

ῌῑ῍ ῎de῏ )fgFhi

῏ Y34() !"ῌ#$%&'jkl

ῐ 9mn+

ῑ +&o)+KLpqMHrstu ῌ῍῍ +KLpqMHrs/0

ῌ῎῍ vwWX)+KLMHx8 yz{|

}~&ῐῐ- ῌ῎ῌ῍῍ΐ῍῎ΐ῍ +

῍ῌ

῎

(2)

ῌ

!"##$%&'ῌ ()*+ , -./ 01/23(ῌ456

ῐfair use῏

( )+ ῍ῌ῏7ῑ ῌ 89 :/;<='/῍ &>&ῌ 23(ῌ456?@AB C':DE>;<ῌ ()+ ῌ FG&:89 H&'ῌ IJ23(ῌ456?BK'.0

῍ &>ῌ

Sony

LMῌ

Harper & Row

LM-;N

Campbell

LM -'ῌ OPQRSῌ ῍ῌ῏7

῍

T

ῒ -;NU

Vΐ WXYZ#[\-'ῌ ]89U^'YZ&ῌ _`

abc#def6Bg=<h0ῌ 8923(ῌ4 56ijk#E"#BDl&῍ ]&'ῌ "EQR SmnopBq.'ῌ 8901=':23(ῌ45 6?/#&!rstumnvq.E/῍

&>&ῌ 23(ῌ456mw?xy@Aῌ z{ | }-./~ῌ -;Nz{YZBC':ῌ -./

89UB/10w01='ῌ 23(ῌ456?

#h"#DE>01/῍

῍ῌ῏7ῌ ]

ῐpreambleῑ

-'ῌ ῒῌ Yῌ

56ῌ

ῐ-./rBῑῌ

ῌ ῎ ῌ # Eΐ #&ῌ 23(ῌ456KE/^'w

¡&'/῍ ]<h0ῌ ]¢£'`a/¤¥

῎

^ bcB¦§'/῍ ¨ῌ "

῎

^`abc©bUª«ῌ ῌ ¤'bc¬&':ῌ ]¢®56£'ῌ ¯bc

,

῎ῌ

῍

(3)

ῌ ῌ ῌ

῍

!"#$%&'ῌ()*+,-./ῌ

῎

,0῎123456789ῌ

῍ῌ῏:;<().

-

ῐ=>ῌ

*?ῌ @ABCῌ DE

῎DF&'GHIJKL

KMNOP῏ῌ QRSI/TUVῑ GH6WXNYSZ' 3[-῍ ;<&'GH6/

ῐ῏\ῑ

89/-Zῌ ῌ%ῌ]^ῐ_NYSZ.`abIc898ῌ

῍ῌ῏:*+de.fg'3[-/h89ῌ

ig1

Njk῏cl[ῌ m*/n.-῍

$GoGHoGpqrsNtN6ῌ

%ῌ/ῌ "#uvwGH,-.ῌ xyz{|}4~4ῌ B

R]^NYSZ,,ῌ i

ῐGH6&ῑ

{|

N)'c894ῌ {|GHWXNe

NIe.--Z῍

/ῌ cῌ !"#$%&' ῌ()ῌ "#uvwGHWX&-.

qrsNt.-Nn 8ῌ ¡"#$¢£()

*+de.\¤N¥N¦lc89῍ i8ῌ !"#$%ῌ()8ῌ "#uvwGH

§¨'[.-,-.ῌ ῏z῍%©ªNYSZ.

«¬eῌ [ῌ ®῏ῌῑ,-.n N¯ZIZ8ῌ xy

°±ῌ {|²^ῌ [/BR]^³.²bN´' ῌ%ῌNµe.ῌ ¡"#$¢£()"#u¶GG HWX94·,-.«¬eI-0Z῍

ῌ

"#uvwGHῌ%ῌ

῍

"#uGH&'vw¸

"#uvwGHῌ%ῌ ῎¹º»¼῏ -

῍ῌ

῎

(4)

῍ῌῒ ῌ

ῐ

ῌ !"#$%ῌ &

῍

ῒ

' !"() ῌ +,%-./01 (23ῌ 1 45!6ΐ 78'ῌ9:;<$=>?

^ῐ^῍^ῑ῍

῍῔ῒῑ@AB4CDEFGH IJῌ

KLM><$

ῌ#$ῌ NKL%ῌ ῒOPῌ ῌ%ῌ 'QRῌ 7S1 ,Tῌ +,%UV ῌ /0 WXY UZ #$GH [\]:GH

^ῐ^῎^ῑΐ

>#4?9^(_<

$#,῍

῍ΐῐ῍@Folsom v. Marsh

K`

^ῐ^῏^ῑ

(ab> ῌ

%ῌ QRcd,T'ef?>#g h>#iM

#$jDGH$k,lmY ῍ n4?op ?qr(s$ltu

*?4ῌ ῌ%ῌ UZY #%/01 ,T ]:GH$Cῌ vw % %xy+?#lmY >

guH$#,῍

>z{'ῌ |} 4ῌ AB#$ῌ (DEF<,῍ῌῒ&

῍

?*ῌ ῒ !"ΐ ~ E~'

GH,z>4Cῌ n78#$

ῒ !"ΐ

( (G z>>?,῍

<*<n|#$lῌ &

῍

78#$ῌ >C῍ῌῒ

>#$ῌ KL%G++?7(_<$# ῍ ,>gῌ

῍ῌῒ>ῐ

'iMGH,῍῔ΐ῏@

Pacific & Sou-

thern Co. v. Duncan

K`#$ῌ N%ῌ ῍ῌῒ%ῌ

(

῍

῎

ῐ

:<$# $%T,gmῌ n4?'ῌY, h#$K z>(

<$# m%?ῌ ῌ1 %ῌ Y 4

ῒQRῌ

7Sῌ ¡ῌ /0῏ῌ UZ+,%¢£¤¥¦1 , Tΐ [\]:GH$# >7<,῍ ?ῌ ῌ Y, h(`: ;<$%ῌ '῍ῌῒ

.

῎ῌ

῍

(5)

ῌ !"#$%&'

^῎^ῐ^῏ῌ

()*+ῌ ,-#

./#$%0#ῌ

῍ῌΐ12+3456ῌ789':;< %

=>+?@ῌ /A!:;< % B?!#&

^῎^ῑ^῏῍

C/Dῌ 456ῌ789EFG HIJK8LῌM89!N O PQR-/

Sony

#.

^῎^ῒ^῏ῌ Harper & Row

#.

^῎^ΐ^῏

STU

Campbell

#.

^῎^῔^῏

'ῌ V

῍

/WX%YZῌ [\]^%_`" a&?bcde%f>

ῌ ghi/]^'[\jk%l S456ῌ789EF /m^%:;noῌ #+ῌ pg q!?@ῌ rstuῌ q/

V

῍

%YZῌ ghi/]^'[\j%l A/ vA45 6ῌ789%: T"?v&!N ῍ ?=wῌ ghi/]^' [\jk%l vAῌ C'xy]^

῎productive use῏

+z`]^

῎transformative use῏

!:;< ! +ῌ ]^/[\jk/{j+|@?}ῌ 456ῌ789/:l ]+&<@q!!?v&

^῎^῕^῏῍

῎

gh~E῍ῌΐ1

῍

/E

456ῌ789EF' q!!? ῍῕ΐῒgh~E/

h\/῍῕ῒ῏gh~

῎the Copyright Office῏

'h&V

῍

+ῌ V

῍

+

ῐ]^/STUj῎the purpose and charac- ter of the use῏ῑ

!> }ῌ ]^S> [\jkῌ j

G / +?v&

^῎^῍ῌ^῏῍

Cῌ C/

D῍῏=&vOP&E+ῌ gh~/V

῍

C// ῌ +ῌ ¡¢£¤ῌ &3

ῐghi/456ῌ789+ῌ

gh~¥¦!+?<?ῑ ! '

B?v&

^῎^῍῍^῏῍

῍῕ΐῒ῏

§

῏

¨/E/©ªSῌ «¬]/®/&;/

ghi/[\]^!456ῌ789EF῎¯°±῏ /

῎ῌ

῍

(6)

ῌ ῍ῌΐ!"

῍

#$%& '()*'()+,ῌ ῐ- ./0 123%4ῌ 56789 4:;

῎includ- ing whether such use is of a commercial nature or is for nonprofit ed- ucational purposes῏ῑ

<=>?.@ABCD<E῍ D"

῍

FGHI>?J%KL!M@A6ῌ NOPῌQR ST2 UVWXYZ6[ῌ \+=D\.NOPZ]<^_

%`abcd<D<efgYZ]E῍ 78 J%hi jORkl<gefBCm no6ῌ "

῍

F Gb12pqYῌ 5ῌ /0 .rs,tu v<%w)xyYzpBC<={|}~<E<

BC

^῎^῍῎^῏῍

\῍῔ΐῒ& '()6ῌ *'()no_WX

῍ %ῌ '()6ῌ ῐ9 +1ῑ <=BC

|"

῍

FGnogῌ ῐ-./0 123%4ῌ 567 89 4:;ῑ <=FGg῍ Dno6ῌ - .789 IgpBCD<efgYZ 6῍ v+=ῌ /0 5678 126ῌ N OPῌQR^II Z]<6X.ῌ FG<

RD<.FZ]<^_BCD<<

^῎^῍῏^῏῍

6ῌ <=+,6;g¡¢£

¤¥%D<¦x§¨©g῍ 5E[ª$«<=D<

Z6.ῌ <126¬gY®%YZ6

^῎^῍ῐ^῏῍

8¯

0.7/0 =°±Y]C²ῌ 78ab./0 -

%°±Y],=

^῎^῍ῑ^῏῍

Campbell

xῌ

῍ῌΐ!῍

#>?³´+,µ¶·¸¹

g῍

῍῔ΐῒ῏

ºno

ῐKL!Mῑ

<gῌ ῐ9 +1ῑ

ῐ»>ῑ

<g῍

῍ῌΐ!῍

#6ῌ /0 ?¼%KL!M

0

῎ῌ

῍

(7)

ῐῑ

ῌ

ῐῑ

῍

῍ !" ῐ#$%ῑ

&ῌ

#$'()*+,-ῌ

./012345% 6 7849 :

; 1<῍ =>?>@AB C; 1<-ῌ =(DE

& FGHI94

^῎^῍ῐ^῏῍

<ῌ

῎

JKLMN-OP(

ῌ ῐῒ#$%ΐ

ῒ)* +,ΐ

QRῌ

5

1<ST MU'>:84

^῎^῍ῑ^῏ῑ῍

9>V MWῌ

XYZ [\ ] ^_`X; 1<῍

῍῏ab(cdef gῌ ῍ῌῑh῍

iῌ j

ῐ

ῑ H>(῍ klmnH>(

ῐopq -#$

% @ῌ '()* +,@ ῑ ῌ #

$ rstu9vB wbI9 [x (; 14ῌ ῐ ῑ y z{ | }<(~P :9 [x (; 84; |}H>

^῎^῍ῒ^῏῍

Sony

MWῌ LMῌ ῐopq #$

Pῌ op d41<H>ῑ OP(

^῎^῍ΐ^῏῍

9 4;@@bV?ῌ LMN-ῌ 5

4[y 9 [x 4@~(9ῌ ¡g4&@VV@1<῍

Sony

MW = ¢ £O@Vῌ [xH>(; 4

914ῌ

#$%-¤¥¦ῌ§ ¨©

H>P1<`X1<849-b@῍

kª «¬1ῌ LMNῌ ῐ9 7 ¢ ¨©

®-<῍ΐῑῐa ¯e°±Z²³´ £O µῌ W14>¶;ῌ

῍ῌ

¤¥¦ῌ§ `<(.ῌ

ῒ·¸ #$'()*%ΐ

¹A C9 ºῑ

opq #$¤¥¦ῌ§e ῎»¼d῏ 1

῍ῌ

῍

(8)

^῏^῎ῌ^ῐ῍ Sony ῌ

῍ ῌ ῌ! "#$%&'()

*+,-ῌ .῎ /0'12 340567'78 69:;< =>ῌ ?@ABC ῌ

!C DEFG῍ H Iῌ JK LCMNO ῑ ῌ! PQ+RSTῒ UV=W7T^῏^῎῍^ῐ῍

XYZC῍ῌῑ[ ῌ!\ ]^_ῌ `Tῌ U7`+

ῌ!C a1bO6cdeῌ XYZ ]f3 9U ῍ῌῑ \ῌ H g<0dhῐi jkῌ ῌ!

lmn* +oῌ ῌ!cpc q9T5 rstun*9v῍ g< wxDyz k .{$|}~ῌ ῌ!+,cpc ~

9T5 +oῌ H ~x9 W7 U῍ N y+ders

9de]W7T ῌ!Cῌ Z

U$9O +oῌ XYVbW7Nῌ H N0' UV c7TC +,j¡ V¢x+,῍

ῌ ῑ $0dhDQ ῒ £¤$DE 34

῍ |}

῍ $ £¤$DE

XY ¥¦d iῌ §V¨ XYZCrs0'X YZ ]fe©ª c+j¡T«¬ῌ XY ῑ£¤$ ῒ ῌ

ῑ$ ῒ ®7¯°+,-ῌ XYZ ±²XY

¥¦£¤$ 9³´ῌ 6c ῑ$µ T5 ¥¦ῒ

῏¶·XYZC῏ῌ[῍¸ῐ ,T6¹ῌ XYZº»¼l9῍

2

῍ῌ ῌ

(9)

ῌ ῌ !"!##$%&'()*+ῌ ,-./(!0! 12ῌ 34ῌ567#8(!"!#

9῍./(# (ῌ 34ῌ567:;<

ῌ

*=

>?(

ῐ@A BCDEῑ

FG B2ῌ HIDJ$K'(L M>?N2O34ῌ567PQ/(## RS$T2%8 LMῌ ,- UV!!Q+(BW/X2+(῍ ! W/῎Y>?N2ῌ HI@A 1234ῌ567P Q/(?+Z>[\LM>?]ῌ

ῌ^_`a34ῌ567

P ?N2HIDJ$bP#2Oῌ W/c+-Q/L M>?( 'd#!(῍

efghBCi[jk῍ (#ῌ ῐ@A BCDEῑ # lm B234ῌ567>?(# ῌ @A

ῐno@A ῎productive use῏ῑ

>?(!

ῐpq@A ῎transforma-

tive use῏ῑ

>?(!ῌ .Q ῌ grBCKAstuv$wx'(

#yz {O>?()*?(

῎M|yῌ

}

῍

~

῍

῏῍ W2ῌ @A

ῐpqῑ

>?(# ῌ

(ῌ6>+ῌ p$

D$'(LM>?()*?(#j./2(῍ .Q ῌ W

ῐpqῑ

#jk./( (῍ '

ῌ JF$ '(LM>?]ῌ

F$p]ῌ ']8]'(LMpq>?(#

ῌ '( D$'($LM

>+ῌ '( ῌ ῌ ¡¢£¤6¥$'(

# ]ῌ # £DJ¦(§!./(

LMῌ ?(ῌ #¦(¨£ >@A'(LMO pq>?(#j./( (῍ #8©ῌ '( ῌ ª«¬

® B(¯°67±²³´µ (@Aῌ ¯°67¶·$

HI@A#34ῌ567¸῎¹º»¼῏ 3

῎῍ ῌ

(10)

ῌ ῌ !"#$%&ῌ '"(' )* ῍

῍ +,-.

+,-./01234ῌ56789:';

'-< ῌ = >?@ABCDEFGH9-I (JKLMN> O"ῌ +,I(PQ- -234ῌ56789'MRSTῌ , UVWXY-Zῌ [\]^9-\SUV_

,UVEF`ab'N>c67-d ῌ .( -. O ῌ 234ῌ56 789MR῍

ῌ Lucent Information Management, Inc. v. Lucent Technologies, Inc., ῏ F. Supp. ῍d῍῎ῐ ῎D. Del.ῌῑῑῐ῏.

eaX ῌ fghij3k4l-mgno6pqbrsh7tu vwLucent Information Management, Inc.ῌ xaY ῌ yz{34l -|`h7tu}~?d.67vwLucent Technol-

ogies, Inc. ῌ ῌ W LUCENT WXY9/0

ῌ Wd.-}MR^῎^῍῍^῏῍ YEFvwA ῌ , LUCENT (W[\-}EFI(Z-ῌ X':qb ' : q9 q_῍ ¡ῌ X q~¢/0£-XY῍ AEF`ab'_

ῌ X/0¤q῍

¥ῌ*¦-< ῌ ῐ/01§ 234

¨©&ῑ ª§~¢«¬®¯ῌ d.ῌ Y-.X°

±/01N> ῌ ῌ ²³´µ-d

+*

῎ῌ

῍

(11)

ῐ῍ ῌ ῌ῔

῍ῌ !ῌ ῐ"#$ῐ῍%ῌ ῍῎&'(

῎&ῑ )*+ῌ ῐῐ῍,-.ῐ$)*/012%ῌ 3456 789:)%ῑ ;Campbell῍ῌ

<%ῌ =>?@ABCῐ῍%ῌ DEFGHῒῐ῍

Iῌ "#J$Kῐ῍)*%LM!ῌ ῍῎&%

ῌῌῐ%!N;῍

<O)PQR34S%TU)*+ῌ VW%XYZ[)*

M!ῌ \4]^_\]%`῎)%῍ ,Rῌ ῎῎&%

ῌῌῐ%!N῍ Mῌ AK=>?@A M)ῌ X34S)*TUab,ῌ cdefgLῐ῍

W:)*)ῌ ῏῎&%ῌhῐ῍

!ῌ ῐ῎&34Sij$klmnoῌ X34Si j$kl%pjqIῌ Y%ῌ X34S=>rῐ῍

M!ῌ ῐ῎&%ῌhῐ%!sῌ tu$ῌ Yvw%ῌxy ῌ X34567:z N{|}~῍

ῌ American Geophysical Union v. Texaco Inc., ῒῌF.῏d ῔῍῏ ῎῎d Cir.῍῔῔ῐ῏.

@ ῎X῏ )*SῑBKΐ῎

%ῌ @!K1%34567 DE

ῌ @/Texaco%ῌ 1%ῌ

*ΐ῍

@Texaco ῎Y῏ %ῌ ῐῌῌῑῌῌ ¡῍ῌ ¢£¤#

BC#¥¦§¦C¨©ª^«¬ $=>

v/*+ῌ ®¯ ῎ῐJournal of Catalysisῑ῏ °±ῌ Y

A%ῌ ²῏BC=>rHῒ1

³´µB῍ ¶ῌ .ῐ·#BC=>J$ῌ 34S"#$ῐ῍ῌ¸ῑ ῎¹º»¼῏ ++

῍ῌ

῎

(12)

ῌ !"#$%&'()*+ῌ,"-#./

01/2345

^῎^῍῎^῏῍

6789:ῌ

Y

;:ῌ <=>?@A BCDEῌ DFG:HI?FJK?#

BLM/Nῌ

Y

:OP?FG#:.Qῌ RSTHI?

FGUSNM#ῌ ῐFGῑ '(VW:XYK?#BU :ῌ FGZ:HI?[\]B^F_IM0#`aῌ

Y

;)*+ῌ,"-M#bcS῍

def

῎g῍

hi9bj῏ Uῌ kblmPῌ

Y

; :)*+ῌ,"-:nSNM#bcS῍ #&g

ῌ

opqB

@AHI?FGrῌ

Y

^F_Is#ῌ )*+ῌ ,"-mtuqv#:w.M#xy/Nῌ z{?MFGZ

| ?M}~?FJ0ῌ g

ῌ

op:@AZ]F:

SNῌ )*+ῌ,"-mN[:M&Mῌ

Y

;@

Az{?FG

ῐHI?FGῑ

#[\]By:ῌ )*+

ῌ,"-:mNMῌ

RSῌ 9

Campbell

blcB;

1ῌ g

ῌ

opoM

ῐOP?FGῑ

:ῌ )*+ῌ,

"-mto#1D:Mῌ

Y

:<u?

M@A]?M#OBLQῌ '(:@AOP?FG#:.MM0#bcῌ op

#?wῌ 3#)*+ῌ,"-tS῍

^F_I;@AFG:ῌ HI?[\]B#t [&M#w.N1ῌ ^F_I;FG/N#1

¡ῌ ¢£?HI?[\]B#1s#:M&ῌ ^F_I;

FG¤Uῌ FGHI?[\¥#mN#:ῌ )*

+ῌ,"-S#yUE1#1s#M῍

+,

῎ῌ

῍

(13)

῏

ῌ

!"ῌ #$%&'(ῌ )*

( +, & ῍ ) -)*.

/012345, 6ῌ #$'(

ῌ 78&*9ῌ :;<ῌ=01$>&

+, ῍

?@ῌ ABC>8DEFGῌ H@

IJKL MN5*>OPQ(ῌ #$+O Rῌ #$+7STU# Vῌ ?@H@

#$(:;<ῌ=01WS

>OXῌ ?@#$YAῌ H@JZ[4#\]( >O PQ(ῌ ?@H@JZ ^&%C

#$6ῌ _` &abcd((ῌ :;<ῌ=01W S>OXῌ Qe?@#$ABῌ )DEFGM N5*(H@fg[4#

CD῍ROM

h>OPQ(ῌ

ABῌ

CD῍ROM

ij^&%C

#$%&:;<ῌ=01$>& >OXῌ 5&ῌ Eklm Qno:pq;<\]ῌ ijC#E r# ῌ )st( Eu#$6ῌ Eklm #$'( $>(:;<ῌ=01WS

>OXv(wx,῍

ῌ Lish v. Harper’s Magazine Foundation, ῑῌῐF. Supp. ῍ῌῒῌ ῎S.D.

N.Y.῍ῒῒ῎῏.

H@

X

ῌ yz{#| }~#$6ῌ m

#$6ῌ yz~8ῌ >ῌ IA

8(>῍

X

1ῌ 05> %#E r

:;<ῌ=01῎῏ +-

῍ῌ

῎

(14)

ῌ ῌ ῍ ῌ

X

!ῌ "#

Y

$%&'()

ῑ*+,+- ῌ./01 ῏Harper’s Magazineῐῒ

2345ῌ

X

67 8 9:῍

Y

()23ῌ ;<:

X

!=>&'ῌ

?@AῌB+CD&'4EF4GHIJKL&'MNOP5 Q'

^῏^῎ῐ^ῐ῍

RSTῌ UVFWXῌ

Y

V'

X

!YZT?@AῌB+

Q[\] '῍

Y

Tῌ ^_Y`a5Q'4[ῌ

Y

V'

X

IJbYZTῌ ^_YcdefgYZ5Q'Mh 'ῌ

Y

^_Y`a5Q'F3iTῌ ῑjkfYZῒ \]lm 'n5T῍

Y

V'

X

!YZTῌ ῑjkfoῒ p&'n 5Qῌ q

῍

NrsT

X

pYT[t῍

?@AῌB+uvTῌ w=>IJbsTVxn'῍

ryw=>z{YZ&'|}Tῌ ?@AῌB+q

῎

NrTῌ

Y

pY~Z:'῍ ῌ

Y

()23ῌ

X

!V

ῑ῎ῌYZ E4[ῌ q

῏

NrT

X

pYT[t῍

[ῌ RST

Harper & Row

RS

^῏^῎ῑ^ῐ

Z ῌ q

ῐ

Nrnn

NNr5Q' F5ῌ

Y

Tῌ q

ῐ

Nr'f|

T'YZsῌ

X

:[

n44[ῌ

X

Tῌ T's[&

'545ῌ q

ῐ

NrT

Y

pYT[ῌ

ῌ RSTῌ

Y

V'

X

!=>Tῌ ?@AῌB+Q[

R ῍

ῌ Worldwide Church of God v. Philadelphia Church of God, Inc.,

῎῎ΐF.῏d῍῍῍ῌ ῏῕th Cir.῎ῌῌῌῐ.

c`a

῏#X῎

Worldwide Church of Godῐ

¡

῏῍῕῏ῐ¢¡

ῐ 5Qῌ £¤f¥¦§

A

T῍῕῔ῐ¢4[῔ῑ¢4

ῑMystery of the Ageῒ ῏X

!¨ῐ ©ª ῌ

X

«¬5® ῍

῍῕῔ῒ¢

+.

῎ῌ

῍

(15)

ΐ῍

A ῍

ῌ

X

ῌ !"ῌ

A

#$%&'()*+

X

,-*+./012

X

3456078῍

9:ῌ

X

;<=>

B

/

C

ῌ

ῌΐῒΐ?@AB ῏CD Y῎

Philadelphia Church of Godῐ

0Eῌ @F,

A

,GHIJK"ῌ

Y

LM0NOPῌ Qῌ

Y

@FRST0UJJVῌ

X

34WXYZ0[=

>῍ .ῌ

Y

ῌ

X

\]0^./_ῌ

X

340`a=bc

=>./d>=ῌ

X

Y

e=fg0hijk

῏

῍ῐῐ

῍

Y

ῌ

Y

l

X

34bcῌ _Q@mnmP)

=ῌ opmqr0sKKtb0nm/KK>uvῌ wxyῌz{|/hiῌ }~;

῏ΐ

;ῐ ῌ

ῑopmQtbTnm/>Jῌ

ῌ

XObcn

mlqH0P

ῌ

dX>ῒ /

0c

^῏^῍ῑ^ῐῌ

opmqr0s/>Jjwxyῌz{|

/)=bv_ῌ opmbc>/>J./y

wxy/>J0ῌ mb0^=>./

O0 /=tb0nm/=>/¡!O>u>

^῏^῍ῒ^ῐῌ Y

l

X

34bc¢vutb0nm/K"ῌ

Y

ῌ

X

340`a./ (£Bl)=mb0^=>!O>

ῌ (056bc./l)=ῌ ¤¥¦§¨/>J©

ª>=@AB/=b0^/>J./«uvῌ

ῌ

Xwxyῌz{|bv_/¡

^῏^῍ΐ^ῐ῍

῍ῌ

῎

XK

Y

/)=b"ῌ

῏

X¬_=K7 /ῌ ®/=ῌ

Y

l

X

34bcwxyῌz{|

v>/¯῍

ῌGreenberg v. National Geographic Soc., ῍῏῏F.῎dῌ῍ῐῑ ῏ῌῌth Cir.

°opmbc/wxyῌz{|±1῏²³´µῐ +/

῎ῌ

῍

(16)

῎ῌῌ῍ῐ.

῏National Geographic Society῎

Yῐ

!"

ῑῌ

ῌ#$%

῏National Geographic Magazineῐῒ

&'' ()

CD῍ROM

*"+,-.ῌ /&01+2345.6789 :;

Greenberg ῏Xῐ

&9:ῌ <=

CD῍ROM

*45.>457?

@+A6.ῌ BCDE῎ῌ῍F

῏cῐ

G

῏HIBCJK&LMJῐ

&NO)P QR.BCD&STUVW WWX+ῌ

Y

+Y

X

9:&>

Z[ῌ\(]W6^_U`57

^῏^῏ῌ^ῐ῍

a῍῍bcdefgῌ h&Yi+ej-7῍ 01+234579:)

CD

῍ROM

+kl"+,-ῌ 9:)m(%no+YR.pq*-ῌ /5+rs)t^Yi >gῌ uv_+BCJ&wx>+7yῌ BCDE῍ῌῒF+AzZ[ >){|"X&῍ }~

CD῍

ROM

gῌ )W-7ῌ %()

.45.6zg ῌ

Y

gῌ &ῌ }

~

CD῍ROM

)-.6/&gg ῌ

῍ " `ῌ }~

CD῍ROM

&guv_+)W"

X&_vῌ Z[ῌ\(]+g7v 6῍

ῌ Wall Data Inc. v. Los Angeles County Sheriff’s Dept., ῐῐῒ F.῏d ῒῑΐ ῏ΐth Cir.῎ῌῌῑῐ.

8(ῌ(

῏Wall Data῎

Xῐ

gῌ Z[)

ῌ "yῌ

X

-7Z[

RUMBA Office

AY

RUMBA Mainframe

gῌ 65X

OS

)>-.6

%)>6.ῌ

OS

)>-.6% ¡(+¢£457

(+[¤]"¥W)¦§+"῍

¨ © % ª ] « ¬ ® ? ¯ f

῏Los Angeles County Sheriff’s Department : Yῐ

gῌ

Y

?¯f+Az°±Z[

&>+²6.ῌ

X

W&³>´µ¶·)¸¹-7῍ W¥ºῌ

Y

?

+0

῎ῌ

῍

(17)

X

ῌ !"#$ῌ %&'()!"*+,$- ./ῌ

Y

0ῌ 12345

῎affirmative defense῏

/67ῌ8 45!"῍

9

ΐ

:;<=0ῌ >?ῌ

Y

@A67ῌ8BCDEFGE HIJD$0ῌ

ῐ

KLMNOPQRS*TUVTWT.JDX YEW

^῎^῏῍^῏ῌ

67ῌ8450Z[WT..G\]$^JD῍ >?

9

῍

NO$K./ῌ _67`a0bc3B0T.ῌ d`a efg3B Th#B0T./#ῌ ij*/@AJD Yk0ῌ d@A0lm3nopJD#q

^῎^῏῎^῏ῌ Y

X

rst uT. vwtBC*/#ῌ

Y

$D@A0lm3@A$C D=x*

^῎^῏῏^῏῍

ῐ

yz-{|}~[@A

῎῍῏

%&'῍ῌῒ$D67ῌ8I

*G$ῌ 67ῌ8AZ[WD0ῌ %&'

῍ῌῒ$x/.D@Ag3$I/.LD

BDῌ

῍ΐῒῑ$67ῌ8Iῌ

$-U

D%&@Ag3$/ῌ

ῐ

KLMNODT

῍ x0C>BxBCD$JT.EWῌ x/.D@Ag3

$ID#B0T.JDqῌ xk.

$TDBῌ

ῐ

KLMNOq ¡NTpJDG$T/

.D῍ x/.T.g3[@ABC/#ῌ

ῐ

KL MNOq $/067ῌ8Z[WDYkCD$¢*

/ῌ x/.Dg3CD.0d$£¤JDg3[@ABC Vῌ C?67ῌ8$¥¦JD.GI0W#q DG$TD῍ JTh§ῌ yz¨|}~©g3[@A BCVῌ 67ῌ8BCD.GI0W#ῌ yzῌ |

%&lm3@A67ῌ8ª῎«¬®῏ +1

῍ῌ

῍

(18)

ῌ ῌ !"ῌ #$% &ῌ '()*+%, ῍

῎῎῏ -./0

123,4-.567ῌ 89:;,< =+

>ῌ /,0*+?@ > ῍ A῍BC, DE1230DFGH,IJK,LMῌ NOP ῌQRSTU#VWῌ 12XY῍ῌῒZ[\,]^*+

-._67/0%`aῌ 0ῌ bcdef5gh,DE0 iῌ 0 ῎entertain- ment use῏ j/&+!"῍

%%ῌ kl\mnl\m-Jῌ opqrst uVv0M0MVw,Dῌ kl\mM VNOPῌQj(xy >ῌ nl\m Gz{Mῌ NOPῌQj/V]ῌ

|}~rs5u,0ῌ 12XY῍ῌῒZ[\,]^*+

,_+6*+ῌ _ῌ <123

Y50!"06MNOP ῌQj/V]ῌ gh-. ῌ op

*+Vw,Dῌ 0 >ῌ -./0MNOPῌQj/V], I῍

ῌ Maxtone῍Graham v. Burtchaell, ῑ῏῍ F. Supp. ῍ῐ῏῎ ῎S.D. N.Y.

῍῔ΐῑ῏.

%Vῌ /¡¢£,¤\m,DEv0,

¤V῍ ¥¦§¨©ªῌ «¥¬®¯:°:

¨±klJames Burtchaell ῎Y῏ ῌ ,I²³*+

l\-J%M´ ῌ nlXῌ µ_

+2

῎ῌ

῍

(19)

῍ΐ ῏ΐ

,ῌῌῌ

!"#ΐ

,ῌῌῌ$῍

%

῍

&'ῌ ()

῍

*+,-./0 1 2345ῌ

Harper

& Row

67!89:;<=>5?@Aῌ

BCD

E $ FGῌ ()

῍

*'HIJῌKL MNO.+,- '5-PQῌ HIJῌKL

ῐ

4 R45S TUVWP῍

XY%

῍ R T!"Z[45ῌ Y

\] ^_`<a

T-5-5b'ῌ

HIJῌKL cOde Q '5῍ %

῎ R CDE f45ῌ X

CDE'gTf

.e Qhiῌ

CDjk'lLg-m n<Poῌ

#ῌ

Y

\]!5p[Q'5<HIJqo῍ %

῏ R

45ῌ

Y

\]$qor'ῌ

X

\]st ῐ

.῏ῌQh῍

uF v wxy.%

ῐ R45ῌ X

CDE'z{ 5 |EQhiῌ

Y

\]'ῌ

X

\]r}z{WPe Qhῌ

CDE'#o~o.e Qh-cOῌ

%

ῐ R'Y

-Qh-ῌ -ῌ HIJῌKL c

^῏^῏ῐ^ῐ῍

&!5ῌ

X

'ῌ

Y

$' Tq

L-XYῌ y.i<h-23<ῌ

$y.i'ῌ %

῍ R T!"Z[- y!5ῌ

HIJῌKL cOwxhPe Q'5-ῌ Xῌ

Y

!8Tf'ῌ

QhTQ'5- ῌ 67 HIJῌKL Mc

^῏^῏ῑ^ῐ῍

ῌArica Institute, Inc. v. Palmer,ΐῒ῍F. Supp.῍ῌῑῒ ῏S.D.N.Y.῍῔῔῍ῐ.

¡ῌ ¢£ ¤¥T(¦§¨T©T-ῌ ªa

¥«yQh¬J®¯°± ῏Arica Institute῎

Xῐ

<

5²³T´µl¶z6·¬Qh¸¹`

Palmer CDE T-HIJῌKL ῏º»)¼ῐ +3

῍ῌ ῌ

(20)

῏Yῐ

ῌ

X

ῌ ῌ

Y

X

!ῌ"#$%

&'%()῍

*

῍

+,ῌ -./01234567,ῌ -./8 9:;<=>=?ῌῌ @Aῌ B CD$<EFῌ G 'HD

X

-.IJKLM45Nῌ

ῐ

NOPQR S5TUVW῍

*

῍

QRNῌ

Y

,ῌ XSYU<Z[D,$\

&[ῌ ]^ῌ ^_ῌ `a bcdeZ[D$f<,g=῍

*

῎

QRN,ῌ

X

-.I,h<i&jklD$%>

X

m D$ῌ *

῏

QRN,ῌ

Y

n,ῐῑo$

X

-.I 'pq7)r%=45D%=D

Y

m,>sῌ G*

ῐ

QRN[ῌ

X

-.Itu,vwxy zῌ

X

-.I, t{[D,=Dῌ tu|}S~H[<,H=

<ῌ !ῌ"#$<EF

^῏^῏ῑ^ῐ῍

+[ESῌ !ῌ"#y<[<[Q

=QR,*

ῐ

QRD$<'pῌ

Y

\

X

-.I JKLMUtu~H|},)r%D$Z=<EF ῌ U !ῌ"#S

^῏^῏ῒ^ῐ῍

ῌ Hofheinz v. Discovery Communications, Inc., ῎ῌῌ῍ WL ῍῍῍῍῔ῒῌ

῏S.D. N.Y.῎ῌῌ῍ῐ.

Hofheinz ῏Xῐ

-./SmZ

῏

N

Sῌ

Discovery Communications, Inc. ῏Yῐ

X Z ῌ¡¢£¤ \

ῑ¥@ῒ

S¡<¦§

=%Dῌ ¨©ª«)ῌ

X

¬=£¤<'D$

῏

῏ΐῐ

῍

-.IYUῌ -./®῍ῌῒ¯°±F

ῑ]^ῌ

²³ῌ #´µῌ ¶·῎ῌ `a¸,cd¹YUῒ º»Zu¼ῌ

,*

ῌ῍

῍

(21)

῎ῌ ῌ

ῌ

^῎^῏῔^῏῍

ῌ ῒ !"#ῌ $%&'()*+,-."ῌ

῍ῌΐ/01234* ῌ

5῎ῌῌ67

86

^῎^ῐῌ^῏῍

96:()3;('(<+=()>ῌ

῍ῌΐ

/01234* 6?ῑ#7@ῌ

῍ῌΐ/ῌ

A B#75C#7DEFG"῍

Y

ῌ HIJKL M3N+OPQRDS@"$%&'()TUVW"ῌ JKXYZD῎ῌG#6῍

῍ῌΐ/[\]῍7ῌ

^_`Dab67Dc7G"῎

ῌG"6deCd6786Campbell

fgDhῌGC@ῌ ^_

`ijklDmnGoῌ pqGrGoῌ 8os@o86tC

῎ῌuv7@ῌ wx86^_`7y6uv+c

῎ῌ86 67@6

^῎^ῐ῍^῏῍

5G"ῌ

Y

t6izJKX*Y{(|t6῎ῌc}

oῌ 5tC῎ῌ67@6῍ ^_`6 ῌ ῐ~ῑ 6deCd5 e]῍

^῎^ῐ῎^῏ῌ

ῌ

῎ῌ~67C#5 e]D῍^῎^ῐ῏^῏῍

G

!"ῌ

Y

῎ῌ ῌ

῍῍lD

86#ῌ

῍῍ῌ Y

῎῍

῎῍ῌ

d

X

7!"῎6ῌ

῏῍Wtῐ

῍ῌ Y

῎67Gῌ ΐ7G"ῌ

Y

t6ῌ

DG῍

ῌ Chicago Bd. of Educ. v. Substance, Inc., ῏ῑῐ F.῏d ῒ῎ῐ ῎ΐth Cir.

῎ῌῌ῏῏.

624 ¡¢

῎Chicago Board of Education : X῏

£86¤ῐ3<ῌ

X

¥_¦G#§¨a 6#

ῌ ῌ _¦©<ª«e῏¬toῌ ®¯°D±²ῌ86 7³6tC´pa "d!῍ µ6¶·¸

῎Y῏

ῌ

^_`~῎ῌ7ῌv῏ ῎¹º»¼῏ ,+

ῌ῍

῎

(22)

῔ ῌ !" #$%&ῌ '῔()*

῍

Y

+ῌ ,-./0123()+456ῌ789ῌ :;<=+>>?@A*῍ () ῎BCDE?>?F

!":GHEIῌ :;JKLM+NO

^῎^ῐῐ^῏῍

PQ1?Eῌ

Y

+ῌ ῔()+RSTU>CDI

Eῌ )V῍WXY῕Z[ῌ \]U^_

E456ῌ78@AHEῌ `a>bcdeC>H

>fΐ῍29ῌ gPhij

῎kΐ

lmhij῏ +ῌ

Y

2

῔()+ῌ

456ῌ78+?n>?io*

^῎^ῐῑ^῏῍

ῌWade Williams Distribution, Inc. v. American Broadcasting Co., Inc.,῎ῌῌῑWLΐΐῐ῎ΐῑ, at ῔ ῎S.D. N.Y.῎ῌῌῑ῏.

ABC ῎pqY : American Broadcasting Co., Inc.῏

+ῌ 'rs t u v w

ῐx y zῌ

{ 8 | } x

ῌ

6 ~

῎Good Morning America῏ῑ

>S῕881?Eῌ q

X ῎Wade Wil- liams Distribution, Inc.῏

:;ῌ a*"

ῌ 456ῌ78D

^῎^ῐῒ^῏῍

6}8*

SF

*ῌ 'DRS 88>ῌ vw}

8}~} ῌ

X

:;ῌ

῏

a'DDHE*῍

hij+ῌ

Campbell

iῐ*ῌ k

῍ῑ¡?Eῌ

:G

ῒῐ ῐ¢῏Uῑ

f£ῌ ῐ¤¥Uῑ ῌ +¦ῒT

U If£?£ῌ Cῌ 456ῌ78

+ῌ :Gῒῐ

ῐ§¨Uῑ

ῐ¢῏Uῑ

ῌ C

©123ῌῐ>ª«!Z¬ ?£®¯&TU>£I

>MD°>>?±²£nῌ ῐ¢῏Uῒῐ+456ῌ78

³B´µU¶ῑ?£M+>?ῌ :G¢῏U·fῌ

¤¥¸>fῑ¡¹ῑ¸+º»*ῌ 456ῌ78³B¼ῒ>9ῌ

,,

ῌ῍

῎

(23)

ῌ ῌ !"#$% &'($)* +ῌ ,- . ῑ /0123ῌ 456789:;<ῌ

῎ῌ=

>

SF

89? @:ABCDῌ ,*EF G&Dῌ

X

3 89&3ῌ 4H89IJ$KLMN O(PQ&(RDῌ - ST&@: .3 ῍

UV῍ῌῑWXYῌ @:ῌ STGῌ Z[Nῌ

\]54 ^_&D`&D ῍

X

a ῌ bc .3dῌ

a89@: G- &

3 (eῌ f

῍g$Y

hD 3 e(3 ῍ f

῎gῌ

(i1jD

X

e+ῌ f

῏gklfῐ

g

Y

hD 3 mn&$ῌ op ῌ

X

a Z[Nῌ\] qr&῍

῎῏῏

st]uvG

w!xyz{|]ῌ}~N

ῐst]uvῑ

Gῌ , "(eU$)* ^_$

r3+῍ UVhD)* UJ ῌ

ῌ uvhD.e)* ῌ $

&D 2e*D (e3 ῍ &(&ῌ |]ῌ}~N

$0D

ῐst]uvῑ

54 3dῌ ,

" &D ^_$d῍

Y!ῌ xyz $ῌ &.st]uv 54&

1¡3.῍

3ῌ ¢£J¤¥¦§¨©uv 2 ῌ ª«¬ &Dῌ Z[Nῌ\]r&®

ῌ

klst]uvG¯°)±©8²$ῌ ¨©67 (3³M´Oµ8²)®¶kDῌ ¨©

st]uvG3dῌ 67·¸ &1

¬ Z[Nῌ\]V ῎¹º»¼῏ ,-

ῌ῍

῎

(24)

ῌ ῌ ῍

ῌRubin v. Boston Magazine Co.,ῒῐῑF.῎d῔ῌ ῏῍st Cir.῍῕῔῍ῐ.

!"#$%Rubin ῏Xῐ &ῌ '$( ῑ)*+,-.

/ῌ01!"#$ῒ 2ῌ X345678 9῎ῒ :;< ῑ01ῌ=> ῏love scaleῐῒ ῑ0?@+

Aῌ=> ῏liking scaleῐῒ B῍ 'CDEῌ FG+ῌ

*HI+! ῏Boston Magazine῎

Yῐ &ῌ YJBK LM ῑ5, Gῒ N OPQR:ῌ S!"#$%TU<V ῌ X=>WXWY'ZZ[\]^^῏^ῐΐ^ῐ῍

$_2`$ <V'&abcde&R;RJῌ ' fghJabcij`k&]ZR῍

l῍mnopq&ῌ LMr[\Jst&R4ῌ TU<

V!"u;9k vRwx&ῌ ῍ῌΐ

y2` ῑz{tῒ |} &~sῌ

:ῌ YXab&ῌ R:;ῌ ῌ&~Rp^῏^ῐ῔^ῐ῍

῍ Los Angeles News Service v. CBS Broadcasting, Inc., ῏ῌῑ F.῏d

῕῎ῐ ῏῕th Cir.῎ῌῌ῎ῐ.

k&ῌ z{t9J,

^2ῌ ῌJ NR῍

)zῌ@+A2`Bῌ ῍῕῕῎DῐB

ῑ)ῒ ῌ Los Angeles News Service ῏

Xῐ Jῌ ¡¢£¤¥G0./¦§¨I

©>ῌªzJ«¬®;G0./¦§¯:;°±s²³

Kj`] ´ ῏µ¶ῐ῍ 'ῌ CBS2

·'¸Gῌ,I¹+ῌº.G»/ ῏Court Televi- sion Networks῎

Court TVῐ Jῌ ']¥ῌ ®;Jªz¼

,.

ῌ῍

῎

(25)

ῌ ῌ

ῐPrime

Time Justiceῑ

!"#$%&'

()*(!+,ῌ -./ῌ012 3453,678!῍

9

ῐ

:;<=ῌ >?5@(!

^῎^῏ῐ^῏῍

AB1&'CD()*

5EFGH=ῌ -./ῌ01,I"J8 ?5KLMNKEF OP =2KQR,S῍ +T,ῌ

Y

U

X

AB 1&'VW? EF=ῌ XYZAB1[N(

!\O=K]ῌ XYZ^ _`[N(!\O Paῌ bK AB1!"EFO=K]ῌ c(T_`

+[N(EF(!5defgNKhij \ OP ῍ (3(ῌ VW&'kl? _`NKEFfgh, mn4LMNK\Kaῌ fg[NOP 3453=opO=K]K ῍ ]ῌ +CDq8!r#AW&'=ῌ _`

+ds(!\OPaῌ fg[Ndtuvqw n4LMNK EFOPx!2 ῍ AB1yz,P =ῌ XYZ{

O=K]ῌ Z{OP Oῌ

Y

X

=ῌ | }NK~6^P 7UO=K῍ (!,xῌ 9

ῌ

p=-./ῌ0 1I73jE=!J]῍

9

῍

p=J3-./ῌ01jEOPaῌ 9

῎

p=NO P ῍ 9

῏

p=-./ῌ01jE=!J]I(ῌ (ῌ

Y

? AB1&'EF=-./ῌ01P! @(!῍

ῌ HU ENEF -./ ῌ 01H

ῌ

ENEF

H=ῌ K NI" GOῌ EF 3Jῌ ( ῍

fgNEF-./ῌ01H῎¡¢£¤῏ ,/

ῌ῍

῎

(26)

ῌ

῍ῌ ῎ !"#$

ῌ

῏%&'("#$)*+,^῏^ῑῌ^ῐ῍

-./0123ῌ %&'(4567

῎

89῍ :1;<=>ῌ ?@AB)5CD1"E

%&'(2FGHῌ &(H'(ῌ =IJB;KLJM"E NOPQRSTU2'(*+,῍

VWXY"Eῌ KLJMZ[1ῌ %&QR STUX$?\Kῌ]^B

῏fair use :

NOPῐ _2'(X$

῍ ?\Kῌ]^B_ῌ `XLabK;Pcdefῌ gf hi;jkab)ῌ lm῍n&.op,"Eq

ῌr$ῌ

stu2v5&wx+

^῏^ῑ῍^ῐ῍

yῌ Hz({

2*+ῌ |z(}~9(n6ῌ Hl

n9E)ῌ <:,`Y lm῍;2oEn9῍

,X$ῌ :1῏ῌT῎ῐῒTFGH%&

'(2$῍

῎

ῑ

ῑ%&ῒ

ῌ

P{X$nῌ

῍

N_i2%& 0op,ῌ

῎¡

¢£Yp2%& 09ῌ

῏¤¥¦X$

:,$r2%&X$§¨©H2|ªX op,)ῌ «TU¬®¯#$ῌ °±H²

³NOPE´2µ¶XYn9,$

^῏^ῑ῎^ῐ῍

῎

?\Kῌ]^B'(X$%&'(

῏῍ῐ

·H¸PYp¹º»HP

῏aῐ

¬¨¼

:1῏ῌT῎ῐῒT'(,$%&'(ῌ

,0

ῌ῍

῎

(27)

ῌ

!"#$%&῍ '()*+῎ῌ ,-.'/ῌ

῎῍,012 34/ῌ ῎ῒ,5

67 89ῌ :; <=῍

/>?ῌ

@AB>?Bῌ CDEF ῌ GFῌ 3 HG IJ#K LM6῍ G

NOEF ῌ

+PQRSFLT6῍ *+

UUV 5W' 9ῌ RS LT$ 6ῌ +XYZ5 [\]^_$

`῍

a8b*+9ῌ ῒcdeEfgh ij/ _[

\ΐ 9*+PQ9klm6

ῐb*+῎ῌ,῍

nῑῌ

o

/p45q' $ras'ῌ

tuv'wx

9ῌ

oyzBῌ {/>?|5}$ῌ

G&9~@

%&ῌ ῏ῐ

ῐ῍ΐῑῌῑ

Xm'*+

9ῌ ῒ+s῏9ῌ 9G

% Yk'Z 3.$%῏5$9ῌ

῏G.$U/$%&ΐ

lm6

ῐ*+῎ῌ,῍

ῑῌ 5ῌ -&`)ῌ

/5!"

5q%6'῍

%lm 95<=$#9

kῌ ῒ 9G% Yk'Z

3ΐ $ῌ %$F῍

῍ΐῒῌ@SCDE Fῌ

-/Z

῎ ῍ *+tu ῌ ¡_¢£¤¥¥¦ § z'¨/Rc

ῐC©¢ªRῑ

5'¢£¤j^«©¢

ª9ῌ -.5$&`sFῌ *+῎ῌ,

῍

ak=¬

ῐ ῐΐtuῑῌ

ῌ ®¡^¯°\±5²£³¡_*

*´µ¶·¸ῌ¹^ ῐº»u¼ῑ ,1

ῌ῍

῎

(28)

!"

῎#$῍῍%&'῏ῌ

"(ῌ )*+, -./012345678( !"9

῎#

$῎῍%&'῏῍ :;<=>?5@

ABCD(EFGHIJKL"

^῎^ῑ῏^῏ ῎MNO῍῍ΐ

P

῎

Q

῎

Rῌ

῍῎ῌP5῎

S

῎

R῏῍

9ῌ

MD

T

CDῌR

Uῌ VL5WXYZ[5<=ῌ\]^

_ῌ`-EFGῌ 4aEF*+bῌ cde5fghMNOijklm(

῎#$ῐ

%&'ῌ 4_`fghnoῌ MNO῏ῌP

῎

Q῏῍

῎b῏

p5qrb-Ons5tu

῎MNO5vw῏

῎x῏

:;<=

4a59D5+9( EFyῌ z{5a|

y}~" :;<= EF+

῎MNO῏ῌP῍

Q

῍^῎

R

^ῑῐ^῏῏῍ ῐ:;<=ῑ

Gῌ ῐ5<yῌ

~5 G:;w" <=ῑ

῎MNO῏ῌP῍

Q8῏ῌ <=ῌ

_ῌ`<=U

d῍ 5KLGῌ ῑΐ%

῎῍ΐῒῐ%῏

5MNO&' }l(9KL+ῌ d0YZW5b ῌ 5}~"95.0<y9b5+῍ A yῌ :;<=MN5a"9iGῌ

ῑ

%

59Gῑῌῌ5Jh(

῎MNO῍῍ΐP῎

Q

῎

R

¡῏῍ *Gῌ AB¢£¤ " ῍

¥¦-ῌ §T¨©ª«¬2®¯°±W2Yw

ῐ:²ῑ

³m´@ bῌ

i:µ-5*G¶ῌ

·¸iAy-EFGῌ ῐ5aiῑ y lm( -MNO῏ῌP

῍

Q5¹º9"»ῌ 4a5 9D5Gd9( ¼"῍

,2

ῌ῍ ῌ

(29)

῎῏

ῌ ῌῌ !"# ῒ$

%&'()*#ῌ

IT

+,-./ 0.123 4516 7ῌ 89:;<=16+>(/?1@A῍ 0.1BC 1D#ῌ EF῍ AG H'(IJKLMNOPQR1S TUῌ H'(IJVWXU(/??1@A῍

YZ[\?M]ΐTUML( 0^%

&?1@Aῌ _`a^1Xb1.cd7ῌ EF῍ AG 7eAX1L/??A

῎89῏ῌf῍

g

῎^῎

\

^ῐῐ^῏῏῍

Mῌ ῐh

?MijDX kGlmM b@Anῑ 7ῌ

ῐ

opq rsNS7῏ῌῌtupq vwxyXU(/?1@ML(

῎89῍῎ῌf ῎

z

῎

\῏῍ {ῐ|?'(cd7ῌ }_v~yX

UML(῍

῎῏

9 "7ῌ ῌ ῌ ῌ ῌ

1T1ῌῒUML(ῌ

Google

Youῌ Tube

0 . 1 ' ( N N e U ῌ

WinMX

Winny

1 L ¡¢$mMῐ῍TU(cdN

e(῍ Dῌ /UX 7ῌ ?M)J ῎£ N?#

890@MTUML(῍ ¤῏7ῌ 91N ' (cd#e@MNῌ ¥¦ῐ῍'(cd7

ῐEF῍ AG ῑ

? M§9#e(?TUMLA῍

" §91N D91N D7ῌ U¨©TUML (ªW#71L #ῌ 0.?'(n7«¬N91

#e(/?a@M '(ªW#71Lῌ ®῎῍o8 9¯°0^ῌ 9#e(/?a@Mb1. 7

ῐEF῍

AG ῑ eAX¬ῌ 9?L./?1@A

῎89῏ῌf῍

g

῏

\῏῍ ῐEF῍ῑ ±²³´TUA/?1(῍

ῐ῍*9{ῐ1 µhῐ῍?¶·ῌ¸ ¹9ῑ ῎º»°¼῏ ,3

῍῎ ῌ

(30)

ῌ

῍

῎῏

!"#$%&'

()*+,-./0!"123 ῌ 456789:;<9=>

7?12@ABCDEF0ῌ GH῍῕I

ῑ

Jῌ KL MNO.P QRSTUVW3

ῐ !"#$X

%Y

῎ !"#$%῏ῑ

&'123

^῎^ῑῒ^῏῍

2.Zῌ [O\

!"]ῌ 3F^_`3abc/0dῌ %῏ῌe

῍

fg']h`12iῌ AW0jH12/3῍ Oῌ

!"k/3]lmg'h`12/0

῎ %

῍῍῕e῍

fno

^῎^ῑΐ^῏῏῍

ῐ^_`3abcῑ

&pqrg']ῌ stuvd

ῌ wx120OZῌ

ys`XzO0ῌ `st]{|uv120 F῍

῎῎῏

}~&pg'

%῏ῌe^_`3abcXg'~g'

ῌ Eiῌ %῏῍eO0bc120[]ῌ

[[t[W3@Fῌ e

K;d

ῐ}sVWQW0ῑ

@K`0ῌ s

tvrW0῍ 1ῌ

῏῔e῍

fsVW;ῌ ῌ

;ῌ .`0]ῌ ῐsViῌ ῌ ]

\ῑ @K.Zst a0

῍

~¡ῌ &pg'dῌ s`¢W£¤'¥¦

W0d§¨©ª2῍ 3F«ῌ %῏῏e¬`®

¯°ῌ

῏ῐe±¬²³´µ¶.`0]ῌ

¬²V

-*

ῌ῎

῍

(31)

ῌ

ῌ ῌ

῏ῑ !"#$%&'()ῌ ῏ῒ !*+,-!'

($!./0ῌ 12345ῌ 678&9/῍

:;!;<!=>!?!./@5Aῐ῍ %/ῌ B!CDE;F!ῌ =>E;%//230

ῐ῍ Gῌ

H!IJK%/LMB!NOPQ?9

ῌ =>PRS!Q?9P/TUE;%&./

0ῌ

ῐ῍ !G0Q?9P/VWXY^῎^ῑΐ^῏῍

H!Z[ῌ

ῐῒ !\]!^_!B%`abc!B./0ῌ

ῐ/d!eA`[,fdῌ

ghῑ @5%

hP9ῌ H9!'(B

ῐij1'(ῑ

23kl /@5m9

^῎^ῑ῔^῏῍

H!n!o4@5./0ῌ pRqrs0m9dῌ R0tR!uv0P/wx`/yf῍ xzῌ A῏῎ !{./0ῌ ῐ\|P}~3!gYῌ [ .ῌ =>ῌ ῌ H!n!{!1|LPIJKg~Pf

!gP&zP9P/ῑ <!P[gῌ !1X/

!!ῌ dk!gP/03RY῍

ῌ ῐ/d!eA`[,fdῌ ghῑ R,fP/23

῎Aῐῌ ῌ ῐῒ ῏

)ῌ R![[f 9dῌ ῐ!LP23ῑ kl/

23

῎A῏ῑ ῎

ῌ

῏ῒ ῍

ῌ

ῐ῎ ῍

῏ Y῍

!`ῌ !o4@50ῌ B!ῌ !1)

xῌ RQ?!Q?P/!ῌ !L

[[ῌ h?[@5%ῌ

!hf?3/

B!¡¢£¤¥ῌ¦§A῎¨©|ª῏ -+

ῌ῍

῍

(32)

῍

῎῏῏

ῌ

ῌ ῌ

!"#$%&'ῌ (')ῌ *+,!- ./&)ῌ ῌ 01῍ 2 /&)ῌ ῐ34256789&::ῌ ;<=>

?@Aῌ B:)34CDE!F/ῑ /"#!

῍

G

ῐ78ῑ

?HI/&)ῌ ?!J ῌ (K

ῐ78ῑ

LMN)ῌ OP2QRῌ ST U Q1F/?BVW)ῌ ?XY!/!

J Z[῍

ῌ

\]^_`abc0L

ῒdefghijΐ ῎k῍ΐl῏

m

ῒ

l

῎Lno῏

(')ῌ \]

^_`a῍῎p

῎L`a῏

bcqῌ ;1rstu&

vw)'῍

Lnoῌ

xy@z{|

῎k}~ῑ

῏ /

y3{|

῎k}~ῐ

῏ /[Aῌ @z{|@z/&

)`a@zῌ

3{|ij3 ῐgaDῑ ῎T 3῏

/vw)'῍ &)ῌ

T3@z/

&)L`avw)'

^῎^ῑῌ^῏῍

Y

ῌ 78/(')$%!/'

῍

Gῌ H(')ῌ (

ῐῌ

ῑ ῐῌ ῑ

/!B1Aῌ

ῌ ?}4& !2"#?῏ῌG

"#&)'ῌ ¡¢4£(')C¤!0¥!¦

)?§¨©ª"!F/«¬1Aῌ ῌ

®"#?¯°!± ¤²/&῍ &)ῌ

Y

ῌ gh

ij?}³2´µ!F/729¶1·¸ῌ L

`a734¹2º»?!B1Aῌ ¼ῌ

Y

vwtu

-,

ῌ῎

῍

(33)

ῌ

X

ῌ

ῌ!"#$%&'()῍

ῌ *+,-῏ΐ

ῒ

.῎῍ῌ ῐ/0ῌ

123

4567ῌ 89:;<=

ῒ>?@A4ΐ

B

῍ῒCDEῑ

CFῌ GHI;JKῌ LM

N'O῍ ῌ

I;JKH'(

OP QRῌ STUVUWῌ GXY%F 'ZOP[\OP'ZO]'(^ῌ _P`a@bc 8OdOFῌ (eFf Oῑ ghi^ῌ [j; ῌ!"#)N

^῎^ῐ῍^῏῍

῍

kl"mῌ#no"nῌpq"rms

tuv ῐTHE WALL STREET JOURNAL ῎kl"mῌ#n

o"nῌpq"rm῏ῑ bwUV

X

ῌ

xOF ῐBysz {"|#ῑ

}Fῌ Gysz

῎Y/῏

T7F wV

Y

~ῌ

X

vdOF5STU'(

Fῌ GT7x_N

sxOFῌ

X

ῌ xOF

Fb<8]O

X

v5STU`a~

ῌ

Y

ῌ @ῌ b<8ST!

"#O`aῌ Y/xX

vysz _$%ῌ $%FX<8_P`a῍

STU

῍

ῌ STU&;F

ῐI;M$%'

Jddῑ Nῌ i῎ῌ2xOFῌ &;GIῌ ¡;¢£(¤¥ῌ ¦N'N§;STU¨©<8

NFO'ῌ 8 N¥ªe8«ῌ ¬txO F ῌ!"#

῎$%῏

" 8hZ'(῍

dOF9;®¯(ῌ

ῌ '°%&;ῌ ±)V

wUV*+²³"#´ µ¶#·,ῌ

-G8 ST!¸¹;$% ῌ!"#" ῎º»¼῏ --

ῌ῍

῎

(34)

ῌ ῌ ῌ

ῌ X

ῌ !"#$%&

ῌ

$'()*ῌ

+,-&.ῌ /

0)12345 %*) ῌ ῍X

Y67 ῌ

Y6X

ῌ῍

.῎8!9:;%+%*<=ῌ ῌ>

ῌ

῎ X

ῌ ?@ABCῌ DEFGHIJ4 KAL4MN)CD)Jῌ

Y6D.ῌ X

OPQJRHIMN4.ῌ JD.ST44 ῌ UVBW%XYZ [Zῌ \]^_`a"bc4)ῌ de

*ῌ

Y6J>4fghiῌj!" ῎k῏

%lm ῍ n%ῌ opqrs

ῐ

t

ΐ

u῏ῌ?ῌ ῐvk

Jwx 1fῌ yῌ Y

<)*

X

z

%*Y6{s%ῌ

῍

u

῏|(ῌ ῍ῌῌ}~&

.῍ῌῌῌ|!"ῌ (%*) .ῌ f 24{

Y

D14

Jk%lm ῌ .Z4)ῑ %ῌ gh iῌj!"Cm.!%&

^῎^ῑ῎^῏῍

%*ῌ op s

ῑ

t῍ῌu῎ῒ?ῌ

yO<)*gh

iῌj!"! Jῌ de*) ῍

ῐ{῍

ῌ {ῌ ῒ ¡¢k 4"%ῌ {B#£¤.ῌ C* ¥¦

%ª«¬fῌ

{®¯ °J±*) Xῌ

°²³ῌ ´Jµ<)*ῌ vk

῎ghi

j!"῏ Jwx ¶~4fῌ {n k

®ῌ

{B·&)1ῌ n% ¸

¹ºs% ῌ Jm &xῌ y J'»°m) J& ¼ J¶~Cῌ

-.

ῌ῎

῍

(35)

ῌ ῍

ῌ !"ῌ #$%&'()*+,-./

%01234,-.῍ῌῐ5ῌ ,-6#$%&'(

789:"; ῌ

ῌ

6<=>?

῏6@

A>" BCDE 8FGHῐῌ

῍

,- .E,->Iῌ

῎

,-JKLMN6OP

<=Q>ῌ ῏

,-RSTUVWX"6<Y"Z [ῌ 8\]"^E _῎ῌ

Y

ῌ `

a89:bcdefῌ

g;

hP^E"Eῌ `a8bc)* 9:

iῌ

YjX

kB"iE l ῌ

YjX

k^ mn i o ῌ

YjpqrX

kqstauvwa8 xyzs{| iEoῌ }

X

k

~"'(%(" o i +ῌ

YjaPῌ

N

X

k7a8su

ῌ

Y

ῌ ῎Y

j"

Pῌ

X

k+ikqs

iNPv ῌ

Y

ῌ i ¡

Yj-¢ῌ£"auῌ X

k¤¥

Yj

¦u§¨ uῌ E ῌ

X

kRS¥

Yj

u"]¨hP7h"ῌ

X

k'(~

© kEῌ

YjiªPu>E

]iῌ

Yj« i 8 ῒ

9¬ῌ #$%ῌ&'(dl

^῏^῏῎^ῐ῍

῎ ῑ(®0¯'°in

±²³ῒ sg

´µ¶·¸¹·ῌ ª±²³OPº¸º

,-@A#$%ῌ&'( ῏»¼ῐ -/

ῌ῎

῍

(36)

῏ῐ

Y

ΐ

in

῔ !"ῌ #$

X

%&'()*+,-./

ῌ

Y

0ῌ 12)3!"ῌ 45678912)῍ῌῒ:;<=

"!&>?4ῌ@AB&CD:EFG!HI93!"F>?

4ῌ@,IJ= &KLMN&O-.῍

PQRST

ῒ

U῍῎V῍ΐW0ῌ ῑXI9,12)0ῌ ῎Y,Z[O

!\]^TB&_0ῌ 12,) ,`a&,bM0 Gcῌ 12,de fB&gIN&O!\hi,jk lMῌ 12,) O!\m)Onoῌ pq%&12,deG

O!\drO,st,_ῌ ῏ῌ:G!ῐ῔:12)Iuv= &w7

xy,_,z{] |}<_ῌ y ~l

ΐ>?4ῌ@

῔ ,hB&CD:E<_G,MN&῎῍ y"ῌ 12 ),TWM,no,Y"Fῌ

Y

3&

, !"ῌ

<,,G!

Y

-.,

ΐ>?4ῌ

@῔ ,JB&OyIehMN&OB&%\G0j_

G!῎ῒ OS"ῌ

Y

%&>?4ῌ@,

^῏^ῑῐ^ῐ῍

Fῌ 45612)3&>?4ῌ@Iῌ HI9, 12),O"J= &O0G!Iῌ y,{0

"!&F,OjkB&OIML%\῍ ῑY,Z[B&ῒ _0ῌ ῑdeG f ῒ 12, =&OI g ¡¢£MN&

῏12)῍

:¤¥ῐ῍

ῌ

9¦§

῏±$Yῐ

*+MN&O,#$

X

,-./ῌ

Y

0ῌ ῑ912)῍ῌῒ:0ῌ >

?4ῌ@

῏!H¸&de ῐ

,w7012),*+0GG!

O!\CD:E¹"!&Iῌ >?4ῌ@,0ῌ CD:E¢

cHI93!"F,CD#ºO"J= &KLMN&῍ »¼Gῌ

-0

ῌ῎

῍

(37)

῏ῌ ῌ

!ῑ "#ῌ $%&' ()*+&, !-ῌ ./0+123ῌ45 6!0"0῍

78

Y

#9ῌ

:;῍ῒῑ

<῎ΐ+ῌ ῐ=ῌ >

?@123ῌ456ABC!

"ῌ

)D&'EF GH$%&' !

-ῌ

%IJK $LM!NO !7"PQRῌ Y

#")8ST"UVWXY"8")ZCῌ

)

+ῌ 123ῌ456ABC0

ῑ "[ῌ 123ῌ456A#0

^῎^ῒῑ^῏῍

῎ῐ῏

\]^$_%`&ab5^6

*cῌ

dXeY'fC0

ῐgU0h

(iῑ jkῌ l)mn*+0opq" rC

,sth῍ ῐuv%ῑ ῐ%`wxyῑ ῐ/zCTVῑ ῐ{|}|῍ῑ

~E-\]^$_%`&ab5^6@ῌ b5^6

@(i/0+a#ῌ #ῌ ῐgUῑ .

cῌ D/0῍

ῌ

uv%)

O5I6|^]556\

ῐuv%ῑ

῎-~-~-῏

+ῌ \]^55"%`5I6|0

0b55 ;Gῌ 1+D ¡2G0^5¢5@W

£y{5}5ῌ ¤3/¡2G0b55\]^$_%

`45¥[6"ῌ

῍

¦§/%`¨7"-ῌ c

7" C"8 !῍

8©ªX

ῌ ῐuv%ῑ

©ªY

9ῌ

*9« ῎(iῌ

a¨7¬῏ "

ῌ Uῌ®h@W:¯°h0±cῌ r²³;

῍῔ῒ

<῍ῐ+ῌ ῐ´µ(iῌ ¶·aῌa¨7¬ª

ῌ῎

῍

(38)

ῌ ῌῌ ῌ

ῌ ῌ

ῌ

!"#ῌ"#$% &' ()*+,)-./ῌ 01ῌ

ῌ

!"#ῌ"#$

%23)45)67ΐ

)89:(;.ῌ ῒ

Y

ῌ

Y

<=>?@:A )?

EPG ῐBCDῑ

EF>

GH,?IJῌ @K?LMῌEFN

ῌ

.Oῌ POQRSTUV

$?JWX01 Y)ῌ Z>?[\

ῌ

]^_ῌ

]^'_WX23)?)A-`a.

ΐ )bῌ

cdefgKh A:^῎^῎῎^῏῍ ῌijkSlc

"lmX

ῌ ῒijkSΐ )(noUpe qr

Y

s ῌ

"tu vAwx y:῍

z{\|

"D +},) >), ῒijkSΐ

ῌ

:f~pUU /QR Y

l!)Aῌ

-RUjkS f~pQR ^f~p"

i"#ῌ

i7:V z{PQR"./

G,oUpe.῍

$ῌ῏%ῌῌῌ῍ῌ ῒῌ

coUpe ,

ῌ QROῌ

Y

-q,coS eῌ .¡ ?¢ῌ £JaO:f~pQR e, )-./¤ῌ e:¥ῌ

coS¦.§b¨&7:©

ªῌ

Di«i¬U®RTU¯ (.Jῌ Y

ῌ

O'°±s²(³´,?IoµUS

ῌ )(.῍ Ol¶¢ῌ

Y

-`)"

·c" )&O.ΐ ) 89ῌ

Y

¸¹ º»:

^῎^῎῏^῏῍

῍

¼/

TV

lc

-2

ῌ῍ ῌ

(39)

ῑ ῒ ῏ῐ

ῌ !"#$%ῌ &

'()*+,-. /012345#6

ῑ78 TVῒ

59.ῌ

:;<$X

=%ῌ

>6?@#Y

5ABῌ :C34DEFGHIJ:CEKL5MNOPQRSTS

^῏^ῑΐ^ῐ῍

UVWXY῎ῌZ

ῑ

[῎ῌ\ ῌ 5F]:C^_

$N`a#NNM5ῌ

ῌ

῍

A

῍

:C

#4#5#bcῌ dea eafg$5AB.:C#

4#M hNB.ῌ

Y

5G:C34DEFGHIJ :CEKLiaB

^῏^ῑ῔^ῐ῍

jklmnoXY῎ῌZ῍῎[῍ῐ\Mῌ p

῍

lN qrs5ῌ ῑ ῌ =t-Suavwxy z.5:C#N{

῍

A

῍

:C|{4#5#bc῎ }~I J:CN hῒ NXB.ῌ :C34DEFGHIJ:CE KLiaB.

^῏^ῒῌ^ῐ῍

N%ῌ XY῎῏Z

῍

[῍ΐ\ ῌ ῑIJ5@vw., C*+5#N5Gῌ 5vwC$t=

TS5-}~5:C#4# ῌ w%=t-Sua vwxyz.5:C#4BtBh.Mῌ

.|w:C%}~IJ:CNN8 ῌ }~I J:C5ῒ N{ῌ

$% B.NB.Mῌ

w;5uBῌ B.

Y

t=ῌ :C^_

Y

ῌ :C5#

Y

| ῌ :C34D FGHIJ:C5ῒ NXB.ῌ X ¡Bῌ mno¢5QB

B^῏^ῒ῍^ῐ῍

ῌ

£¤£῍;>

¥¦

Y

%?@#6

ῑ£¤£῍§¨§(©ªῒ

ῌ

«¬:vw /0Bῌ w®¯5:CB.128 G{5# °῍ 6$ ῌ

Y

t=±

²³´µ<N¶·ῌ¸ ῏¹º»¼ῐ -3

῍῎ ῌ

(40)

ῌ

Y

!"#$%&'()*+,ῌ -.%

/012 345῍ 6&%ῌ 789:7

;8<=>?

X

@ ῌ AB8CDEFGHIJK L$῍

M

῍

NOPQRST῎ῌU

ῑ

V῎ΐWῌ '!"#$%&

Y

ABXY!"#$ῌ Z[%\]%&O^_@ῌ AB XYO`a

Y

^$%ῌ )*+,OHIKLb$

^῎^ῒ῎^῏῍

c ῌ deNOfghST῎῍U

῍

V῎ῒWῌ ῐ ij*9&%Eῌ

?9kl5mnOJOopqirOstuEO^

_@ῌ __j*? vwῌx$_@&[%

l5XY yz{R5Gῌ E

X

@O|

}5\ CDEOE5&῍ῑ S~$ῌ ABXYO`a

Y

^bJ@5&$%M

῍

NS$

^῎^ῒ῏^῏῍

$_$ῌ hῌ ῐj*st?ῌ ABJO opr$%&@ῌ ZO!ῌ "#9&%ῌ

<

$%AB$%<+,r&4ῌ AB

&<+,rOABO9k5XY$%9ῌ A B9kjst?OXY 5kῌ }jO

? (O~$%Eῌ <+,rOAB9Z

5O^ῌ j*st?ABO`a&4 ^ῑ S~$

%ῌ ¡S¢£$ῌ fghH$$%&

^῎^ῒῐ^῏῍

7«O

9k¬®¯°±$%3 ῐmn²OJOABῑ ῎7

8῏ῌq

῍

³῏ O¤¥´@5@ῌ µ;^¶;^ῌ ¬n 5·¸-.%X5¹AB¦º»<ῌ ῐmn²ῑ &¼ῌ

ῐmn²ῑ

OJO·¸stXYX54? ABº»<

O`a54&¼4῍

.*

ῌ῎

῍

(41)

῎῏῏ ῐῑ

Kindle

iPad

ῌ

῍ !"#$%&'$()*

+ῌ ῐῑ ,-./0῍ 1/+ῌ

23)45617 ῐ

ῑ ,89/:;4ῌ <=+

ῐῑ

>)(?$@ A2 BCD0῍ >)A2+ῌ

EFD0ῌ

G$HDῌ

῍

G$

IJ !"#$%&'

PDF

KLM(,4NOAῌ PQRS 4῍ 1

ῐῑ

)+ῌ TOUVW)XY῍

ῐῑ

Zῌ

[\],^ῌ ῐ_`aῑ

`,(Z :/.ῌ TOUbcd/ῌ

2+1/)41,e

ῌ TOUV

ῐ_`aYfWῑ ῎TOU῎ῌg῍

h῏ iX

(Yf+ῌ ῐjk`+lmn7o1/pIc6/Yqn r0a(ῑ ]sS+tῌ ῐ7a(2ῑ WDS /.6῍

ῐῑ

:/.ῌ ut,Zv)wx56(

,yd/:;4ῌ ῐa(2ῑ 3)4+tῌ z

`DY>)A2)4]+ῌ 651{|YdIῌ

_

`aYfW+XY6,wd/῍

D5Dῌ 1

ῐ_`aYfWῑ

}(~+ῌ

W

,,ZY)9/0rῌ

ῐῑ

}

D0Z=65w,9/

^῎^ῑ῏^῏῍

DY4ῌ $5Zῌ ῐ\ῑ

ῐeTVῑ ῐῌῑ

N@\?$@

r0ῌ 7// rSa2, ¡¢2,W )*£(}¤¥¦

ῐ_`aῑ

:55F§p,

¨0rῌ E©F+5/0

^῎^ῑῐ^῏῍

TOU῎ῌgJ0ῌ

ª«&,ῌ

b¬ ®~

:1,¯°0ῌ ±²wxd/0,°ῌ @

\?$@ ῌ ¦³´9/Y

ῐῌῑ

µ{

TO!¶A`,K·¸ῌ¹$ " ῎º»¼῏ .+

ῌ῍

῎

(42)

῎῍῍

῎ῐῌ ῑ ῌ

ῌ !"#

$% &'(")*+,-./01234$%5 627089:;ῌ <0=

>? @AB @CD0E@F῍ G;ῌ

$% &<ῌ H0IJKL)MNOῌ 23

P<QR?Sῌ

TQ; U9V!;

<CW"9ῌXY$%ZH#[9\3$]%=^0X_F

῏

ῐῐῐ

῍ῒ

`a;ῌ

&bcMdefghY0=0<i27

ῌ

jkRefl2me'nf23@ῌ ῑo pῒ

(q9

;ῌ

Rr9stu@)*v+X_F῍

῏

w,lxyz{ῌ|)M-./}0P

XXYῌ w,0^ῌ

e1~<;yz{ῌ|)M-.

/aF2;<jῌ l2m

ῑY=C

7ῒ j9ῌ 3 4^=35;ῌ

9X῍

ῌ

j

Xe ῑῒ

?x;56 #

M7279ῌ %) )¡8 "¢£

¤¥X~<;ῌ

X

9Qfgh9v+j¦l<;ῌ

:§ ῍῍῍ῌ῎ῐYῌ ῑ9Q<7Yῌ

¨e1©ª

;e@ῌ ¨e1Sm«¬;< =>9ῌ ?®

¯°±3@FX9Y<7²@0Cῌ X4 Yῌ $%9<;³Q´µFE;@¶=@·XY0<῍

῎~<;ῌ

G9Q^A^9B&E;Yῌ ῎

Ne 0C¸=>³¸;<^9¹º;aF῍ ῎

Y

» "¢£

X

»e=>Yῌ

DEFῌ

^µῌ

G¼<H .,

ῌ῍

῍

(43)

!" "#$%&'"()ῌ X*+,-

"#$%&'"^῎^῎῏^῏ῑ ./!ῌ +,0123456῍

ῐ789ῑ :;%ῌ <-=*>**?@3A6*%'Bῌ

<-CD!EF?@ !" GHῌ I'JKῌ "JL

ῐMNOPῑ *GHῌ QRSῌTUVWX*Y@3Z[!ῌ \]?@3

^_I`& "#ab ῍

c:*:;*de*6[*?@f"!g5!" <0W῍ῌh%ῌ c:*:;3deI i!ῌ ῐjk:;*l"!m) ῌ n B%o( <-ῑ f"!ῌ de*Apqj'rst u?@

& $3g5!" ῍ $*῍ῌhv5!" *%ῌ :;*wxy dei!6z6z<-CD!{| 6}#'GH ῍

ῌ῎῏῍ῐῑ

<-*~?@QRSῌTUVWX῎q῏ .-

ῌ῍

῎

(44)

ῌ

!"#$%!&'(!ῌ )*+,-.ῌ /0123456789:;<$%=ῌ >? &@!A$%

!)&BCDEῌ Aῌ @!$%FAῌ %EG

$HI&JKC!$%! ῌ LM῍ῌNOP C!&2 QD!῍ &C(ῌ R> $ C!ῌ 9STῌUMVW!X$%!&C (DC&'(!῍

ῌ ῐEYZ[\ῑ

-.

)

ῐEYZ[\ῑ

-.ῌ *+,-.&]^ῌ 9STῌU

MVW?ῌ _`abcdef!gh?ij@"#-k

$%!&lmC!῍ ῌ )G$n#f[ῌ Top qLMrs!9STῌUMVrftuvMrs!wxyP?

z{@!D|ῌ v.9STῌUMV!-k$DCῌ Gῌ }~wxyPfFA!f[D-k$%

!&C(DC῍

v.ῌ 0 ῌ <

῎X

῏ ῌ LM῍῎Nrs! C!

@! Z[ ῌ Rῌ Rbc?ῌ s_`

ῒG

?!῍EYZ[\ΐ ῎Y _`῏ gh)&ῌ

῍῎N῍

@! }-$%!῍ LM῍῎N

῍

ῌ

C!?ῌ bcf=deῌ

# ¡&@!f[ῌ ῐ¢

de? &deῌ GRde?@!ῑ ῌ

$#DC)&?yPC!῍ 9STῌUMV&£¤

rCῌ -¥£¤&¦K@"#§ῌ

Y

_`s¨©

_`$%!)&ῌ rft

X

ῌ ªk&

«¬C!&ZGῌ

Y

_`®¯&AC!

..

ῌ῎

῍

(45)

῍

ῌ῎ῐ῍῏ῌ ῐX

!"#$%&ῌ '(%&)*ῌ +,-./01!*2 3456-789:; <ῌ X="ῌ ῒ+,- ./01!*23456ΐ > ῒ+,-.?@;23456ΐ 2ABῑ Cῌ ="ῌ ῐDEFGHI"Jῌ KLMN OP9:1! Lῌ Q+,'(%&RLSTῌ UVW 9:1!*2 <ῌ Xῌ -78ENW9:;

XE1!"'(%&X82"ῌ Yῌ Z[\

]8 ῒ^_W`a)"ΐ 2ABῑ῍

b)*ῌ cῌ Ydeῌ fghijk <lm1!*2 no8pq;ῌ ῐX !"#$%&rs8Yde tu)ῌ !8vw;ῌ ῒx<ΐ Z[\]yz]vw8 {W)*yz)ῌ >byz]8vw;:|ῌ }~) 2ῑ

ῌ῍῍῍

\]Wῌ&῎Y῏ ./

ῌ῎

῍

(46)

^῎^ῑῒ^῏῍

ῌ

!"#$%"&' (ῌ )*+,-."/ 01234ῌ

"56(78934:;<!ῌ =3-."$ >?ῌ @ A῏BCD/ "E5%"&' ῍

Y01FG=3-."/ !:; "5 (ῌ )*H I:; @"Jῌ +,KL-M/ ""!ῌ +,.N/ ! :; "5 ῍ Y01O:῏ῐP;Qῌ ῐRSTUVWUῑῌ ῐXY ZXYZ$[ῑ 9\ῌ ῍῎]^ ῐJ_`\Z$[ῑ (WaUbc%

<de ῍ 69 ῐff9ῑ g.:ῌ 4h(i 9 ῎]^ῌj"$Ik(lm ῎bcn?῏῍

$!ῌ 6o:9_ῌ Y01pq!34῍ )rs ῌ tuῌ vw9\ῌ 4h]^-de/ !:;

:ῌ ;5 (-@@:xQ?yῌ 6bc-l m/ z{Kv_9῍ |$f ( @":}.-

~Xῌ 6(Y012lm.; "5 ῍ @bc(pq 34 @"(ῌ @@"- !:; "5%Z῍

ῌ῍ ῌ῎

.0

ῌ῎

῍

(47)

ῌ

῍ ῎῎ῌ

῎῏ῌ ῎ῑ !"#ῌ

$%&

'($)ῌ *+$% #ῌ ,$

-./0123456789:;<=ῌ >

?@ABCD=῍ E6Fῌ

X

G#HI8;J KLM.NOPFῌ >QRSTῌ

Y

UVWXY6Z [I\ῌ ῏ῑ

῏

]^_$`<a[I

῍

῏

&b ,cd

ef6%g$ῌ hijk$`Slmhῌno;p$`

ῌ & FPq#rstῌ u-?v4 wTῌ ῍ῌῒ!"$6#ῌ x<a4w(yz {($|}t#?v[I7$~=ῌ 6*+

!"lmhῌno;pῌ TZQ,cd#*

+[I'($Z} [Ig7$

^῎^ΐῌ^῏῍

$Z g& $-6y$-.7#

%g$[I=῍

7I$-6ῌ y#$`S*+!"ῌ &

ῌ F$$!"[I`ῌ b # It$)Zῌ |II$!"[I 7$῍

& #btῌ $,cd$¡¢

£=ZTῌ Eῌ *+!"$Z¤T '(Zῌ

ῐ,cd$¡¢¥¦.Z^_6ῑ

7$

^῎^ΐ῍^῏ ῎ῐῌ῏῍

ῌ °q$+!"$%,cd#+±S'(

&rs lmhῌno;p῎µ¶·¸῏ .1

ῌ῍

῎

(48)

ῌ ῌ !"!#῍ $῍ῌ%

῍

&'()* ! +,-./0ῌ 120'("34+56 7ῌ 8!09:;<ῌ =><68<ῌ '(?@ABCD)EF"+GHI5)J 8῍ '(0ῌ @AB0CD?!"!KLE

"<?Mῌ $0ῌ '(?CD)*EF"+

GH8!0NOGHI5)J+,-./P! '(

!"!KQ"῍

?R ῌ SD8TUTTTV<ῌ ' ("WD0ῌ @ABXY'(Z5 ῌ @AB [\]^_`6Q""῍

ῌ '(T0ῌ abcdSDP

! 0ῌ eDfd,gῌ @6Zhij !'(?kM*῍ "#lῌ amnopqr0ῌ s tuKQ"?vῌ +,-./wxyz-?8Q"TMῌ amnpq6@

῎amn{|}῏

0ῌ @=~

K""ῌ 94@Zh*lM

῎$῎῎%῍

&῏ῌ ῌ ῌ! ῌ )*

ῌ abci"fdM*ῌ

<D6@0ῌ 70<@=~KQ"# ῌ 94

@Zh*lM!Q"R !

῎$῎῏%῍

&῏῍ ῐ@AB]^_`6" 0M!ῑ "'(

?Mῌ S-?KEF! 0ῌ '(T@

AB6'(?M*ῌ @AB.?

M* !"!#῍

ῐ

$s¡,¢'(£¤P!

.2

ῌ῍ ῌ

(49)

῎῍῏

ῌ

ῌ ῌ !

"#$%ῌ &'()*+",-)./

0"1"῍ 2-345/6&7)8/9:"ῌ ;<ῌ

&=/7)#$>?$@A"-

)/.BC)

^῎^ῒ῎^῏῍

."#$>?DE9ῌ

῎ῌῌῒ< ῎ F῎ῌ<῏

῏

GH=IJKLM,-

ῐNOPQῌRSTUVW)H

IXYZ[\ῑ ]^A"-./_3`abῌ 2cd 9ῌ ῐef&gh"/i(3-)jkῌ l

?"&m=no)

῎p !

῏ & 7)./%gῑ /7)c",-

^῎^ῒ῏^῏῍

.-&qWῌ rs9ῌ

rtu\#$v\ῌ

w

&]^7)gxyw&z7)(

ῐ#$XW)

{7)Z[|}\ῑ &LMῌ

῎ῌῌΐ< ῎ F῎῍<῏ ῏

Gc da/(3-

^῎^ῒῐ^῏῍

2~ῌ #$v\w\ῌ

e{_3ῌ W)u

&ῌ ="#$>?Wcd/ba/(3-

^῎^ῒῑ^῏῍

῎῎῏

,-)k

2

ῐrtu\#$v\ cdῑ ῎ F῎῏<῍

G῏ )/ῌ

#$kῌ ῐA #$="ῑ ῐB %

W)#$ῑ

ῐC

#$&q

"ῑ

῏

,-)῍

ῐA

#$="ῑ /9ῌ ῐ2#$&*)=/

"A= )g¡#$Cbῌ _ῌ 2

¢=9=£\¤¥¦§C)/¨E)8ῑ Cbῌ

±²/9!ῌ §"X9C)8ῌ ³="´#$

#$¹@=/ῌ ! ῎º»?¼῏ .3

῍῎ ῌ

(50)

῎ ῐῑ

῏ῑ

!"# ῍

ῐB

$%&'()* +,-ῑ .ῌ ῐ$%+,-

/012 &'() (345# 67+,-

89ῌ :;ῌ <=>.(?@ABCDE89 FG8H Iῑ 89ῌ JKL .ῌ ῐ῎a῏

CD

M NOPQ()* RSTUVUWXY&'8Z[\ῌ

]^_`aTUbcde] (fῌ

?g@hi\+, jk(OPQ 5l(6 3 e]mῌ nom(

)* 67 ]Z[ῑ ῌ ῐ῎b῏

῍῍pῌ

q(rstuvmMwx(y ῌ e]@hi\z{|{<}uvme]ῌ,0&'8 Z[\ῌ

῍῎pῌ

q(rst~N(fῌ \@

Cῌ (

CD

῎῏

J\

Q9 (ῌ 9#:5Z

CD

:#

῎῏

(

CD

(Z[ Jῑ !"#ῌ

#(ῌ J()*

ῐ$%+,-ῑ

.ῌ +,jkOP(I stῌ j ¡(Ist(¢ ῍

#(ῌ ῐC +,-£¤¥¦ῑ .ῌ ῐ+,-§¨

¯ JA J¥¦ 5.FGῑ 8 9 ῍ < ῌ J(762 ῌ °]\N

(y ±²³´\ῌ 67±²µ¶5(3·8°]\

NZ[28ῌ 67Z[(1,0Z[-ῌ 9t¸8±²³´ῌµ¶5¹º (¸ῌ £¤

®¯»\ῌ ±²³´ῌµ¶&'867°]C°

῎£¤®¯῏

89 Iῌ 67C°ῌ 9t¸8±

²³´ῌµ¶ I89ῌ <¬(# 6 7°]£¤¥¦ J(¼*#I.FG

/*

ῌ῎

῍

著作物の商業的利用とフェア・ユース法理――「利用の目的および性格」の解釈を中心として―― 利用統計を見る

ῌ

῍῍ ῎ ῏ ῍῍

ῌ

!"##$%&'ῌ ()*+ , -./ 01/23(ῌ456

( )*+ ῍ῌ῏7ῑ ῌ 89 :/;<='/῍ &>&ῌ 23(ῌ456?@AB C':DE>;<ῌ ()*+ ῌ FG&:89 H&'ῌ IJ23(ῌ456?BK'.0

῍ &>ῌ

LMῌ

LM-;N

LM -'ῌ OPQRSῌ ῍ῌ῏7

T

Vΐ WXYZ#[\-'ῌ ]89U^'YZ&ῌ _`

abc#def6Bg=<h0ῌ 8923(ῌ4 56ijk#E"#BDl&῍ ]&'ῌ "EQR SmnopBq.'ῌ 8901=':23(ῌ45 6?/#&!rstumnvq.E/῍

&>&ῌ 23(ῌ456mw?xy@Aῌ z{ | }-./~ῌ -;Nz{YZBC':ῌ -./

89UB/10w 01='ῌ 23(ῌ456?

#h"#DE>01/῍

῍ῌ῏7ῌ ]

-'ῌ ῒῌ Yῌ 

56ῌ 



ῌ ῎ ῌ  # Eΐ #&ῌ 23(ῌ456KE/^'w

¡&'/῍ ]<h0ῌ ]¢£'`a/¤¥

^ bcB¦§'/῍ ¨ῌ "

^`abc©bUª«ῌ  ῌ ¤'bc¬­&':ῌ ]¢®56£'ῌ ¯bc

ῌ ῌ ῌ

῍

!"#$%&'ῌ()*+,-./ῌ

,0῎123456789ῌ

-

*?ῌ @ABCῌ DE

KMNOP῏ῌ QRSI/TUVῑ GH6WXNYSZ' 3[-῍ ;<&'GH6/

89/-Zῌ ῌ%ῌ]^ῐ_NYSZ.`abIc898ῌ

ig1

Njk῏cl[ῌ m*/n.-῍

$GoGHoGpqrsNtN6ῌ

%ῌ/ῌ "#uvwGH,-.ῌ xyz{|}4~4ῌ B

R]^NYSZ,,ῌ i

{|

N)'c894ῌ {|GHWXNe

NIe.--Z῍

/ῌ cῌ !"#$%&' ῌ()ῌ "#uvwGHWX&-.

qrsNt.-Nn 8ῌ ¡"#$¢£()

*+de.\¤N¥N¦lc89῍ i8ῌ !"#$%ῌ()8ῌ "#uvwGH

§¨'[.-,-.ῌ ῏z῍%©ªNYSZ.

«¬eῌ [ῌ ­®῏ῌῑ,-.n N¯ZIZ8ῌ xy

°±ῌ {|²^ῌ [/BR]^³.²bN´' ῌ%ῌNµe.ῌ ¡"#$¢£()"#u¶GG HWX94·,-.«¬eI-0Z῍

"#uvwGHῌ%ῌ

"#uGH&'vw¸

῍ῌῒ ῌ

ῌ !"#$%ῌ &

' !"() *ῌ +,%-./01 *(23ῌ 1 45!6ΐ 78'ῌ9:;<$=>?

KLM><$

ῌ#$ῌ NKL%ῌ ῒOPῌ ῌ%ῌ 'QRῌ 7S1 ,Tῌ +,%UV ῌ /0 WXY UZ #$GH [\]:GH

>#4?9^(_<

$#,῍

K`

(ab> ῌ

%ῌ QRcd,T'ef?>#g *h*>#iM

#$jDGH$k,lmY ῍ n4?op ?qr(s$ltu

*?4ῌ ῌ%ῌ UZY #%/01 ,T ]:GH$Cῌ vw % %xy+?#lmY >

guH$#,῍

>z{'ῌ |} 4ῌ AB#$ῌ (DEF<,῍ῌῒ&

?*ῌ ῒ !"ΐ ~ E~'

GH,z>4Cῌ n78#$

(  (G z>>?,῍

<*<n|#$lῌ &

78#$ῌ >C῍ῌῒ

>#$ῌ KL%G++?7(_<$# ῍ ,>gῌ

'iMGH,῍῔ΐ῏@

K`#$ῌ  N%ῌ ῍ῌῒ%ῌ

(

῎

:<$# $%T,gmῌ n4?'ῌY, *h*#$K z>(

<$# m%?ῌ ῌ1 %ῌ Y 4

7Sῌ  ¡ῌ /0῏ῌ UZ+,%¢£¤¥¦1 , Tΐ [\]:GH$# >7<,῍ ?ῌ ῌ Y, *h*(`: ;<$%ῌ '῍ῌῒ

ῌ !"#$%&'

()*+ῌ ,-#

./#$%0#ῌ

=>+?@ῌ /A!:;< % B?!#&

C/Dῌ 456ῌ789EFG HIJK8LῌM89!N O PQR-/

( )+ ῍ῌ῏7ῑ ῌ 89 :/;<='/῍ &>&ῌ 23(ῌ456?@AB C':DE>;<ῌ ()+ ῌ FG&:89 H&'ῌ IJ23(ῌ456?BK'.0

&>&ῌ 23(ῌ456mw?xy@Aῌ z{ | }-./~ῌ -;Nz{YZBC':ῌ -./

89UB/10w01='ῌ 23(ῌ456?

῍ῌ῏7ῌ ]

-'ῌ ῒῌ Yῌ

56ῌ

ῌ ῎ ῌ # Eΐ #&ῌ 23(ῌ456KE/^'w

^`abc©bUª«ῌ ῌ ¤'bc¬&':ῌ ]¢®56£'ῌ ¯bc

%ῌ/ῌ "#uvwGH,-.ῌ xyz{|}4~4ῌ B

{|

N)'c894ῌ {|GHWXNe

NIe.--Z῍

/ῌ cῌ !"#$%&' ῌ()ῌ "#uvwGHWX&-.

qrsNt.-Nn 8ῌ ¡"#$¢£()

*+de.\¤N¥N¦lc89῍ i8ῌ !"#$%ῌ()8ῌ "#uvwGH

§¨'[.-,-.ῌ ῏z῍%©ªNYSZ.

«¬eῌ [ῌ ®῏ῌῑ,-.n N¯ZIZ8ῌ xy

°±ῌ {|²^ῌ [/BR]^³.²bN´' ῌ%ῌNµe.ῌ ¡"#$¢£()"#u¶GG HWX94·,-.«¬eI-0Z῍

' !"() ῌ +,%-./01 (23ῌ 1 45!6ΐ 78'ῌ9:;<$=>?

%ῌ QRcd,T'ef?>#g h>#iM

?*ῌ ῒ !"ΐ ~ E~'

GH,z>4Cῌ n78#$

( (G z>>?,῍

78#$ῌ >C῍ῌῒ

>#$ῌ KL%G++?7(_<$# ῍ ,>gῌ

'iMGH,῍῔ΐ῏@

K`#$ῌ N%ῌ ῍ῌῒ%ῌ

῎

:<$# $%T,gmῌ n4?'ῌY, h#$K z>(

<$# m%?ῌ ῌ1 %ῌ Y 4

7Sῌ ¡ῌ /0῏ῌ UZ+,%¢£¤¥¦1 , Tΐ [\]:GH$# >7<,῍ ?ῌ ῌ Y, h(`: ;<$%ῌ '῍ῌῒ

/E

456ῌ789EF' q!!? ῍῕ΐῒgh~E/

h\/῍῕ῒ῏gh~

'h&V

+ῌ V

!> }ῌ ]^S> [\jkῌ j

G / +?v&

D῍῏=&vOP&E+ῌ gh~/V

C// ῌ +ῌ ¡¢£¤ῌ &3

B?v&

¨/E/©ªSῌ «¬]/®/&;/

F Gb12pqYῌ 5ῌ /0 .rs,tu v<%w)xyYzpBC<={|}~<E<

BC

\῍῔ΐῒ& '()6ῌ *'()no_WX

῍ %ῌ '()6ῌ ῐ9 +1ῑ <=BC

FGnogῌ ῐ-./0 123%4ῌ 567 89 4:;ῑ <=FGg῍ Dno6ῌ - .789 IgpBCD<efgYZ 6῍ v+=ῌ /0 5678 126ῌ N OPῌQR^II Z]<6X.ῌ FG<

RD<.FZ]<^_BCD<<

6ῌ <=+,6;g¡¢£

Z6.ῌ <126¬gY®%YZ6

0.7/0 =°±Y]C²ῌ 78ab./0 -

xῌ

<gῌ ῐ9 +1ῑ