学外研修「動物園」における取り組み内容と教育効 果
著者 菊地 達夫, 澤田 悦子, 勝井 陽子, 入江 彩子, 小 林 美花, 太田 俊一
雑誌名 北翔大学短期大学部研究紀要
巻 54
ページ 53‑66
発行年 2016
URL http://doi.org/10.24794/00002094
!"#$%&
'()*+ ,-./0123-4 56*789:;
<=>?@* <A BC9=DEF 89GH7H" <I J7KLMN8OPQRBC9=?F 89GH7S*TU=VW XY789 Z[*\]^_`ab`acde`a)WGfgh7ij
!"*klmn$opqo'S$`r=!"TU'()*s@tu 7vw_!Q7axyz7H{h7|}!"*~YMN756
g'!4R $s789']V"F'S*
u7( '7$7
CFHu)*s7D789MN
BC=<) ¡¢@F'S*
=|£¤_H¥¦V"=&¢@G* b§¤_+
¨© ,-m mn$o=G*ª9=F@«77£ ¬
89MN =KLMN8OPQ®¯°±7|}² ³´
³µgG*
F¶·=|¸¹ ,-º G+!»S«$)*¼u½·¾¿À Á~® ±·A' ,- Â7V"=Ãu)?·G*«G·Ä¾® ±·
,-=ÅzÆÇÈÉÊs@Ë®ÌÍÎϱ7ÉÊ ÐÑ·ÒÓ7ÔÕ= 7V"'A¦?Ö×G*s7C· ,7 :ØÙ=<)·ÆÇÈÉÊ7Y 'V$(;7ÔÕ'&¢@G*~Y· ,7ÚÛ=|ÔÕ·ÌÍÎÏ7Y(;&¢@
GF OÜ)*)Ý@=Å)H· ,R7ÞßÁ àáâÒÓ7ÔÕ7M N?¢¬¡¢@F ãäG*åæFÝç~® ±·¹ ,7èlº)"éêd ë gGì· ,-7íî7ÛJ=Å)·|¸ï¤7ð&ñ?òóô ®õ
ö÷økù»ú ûü ýb þ
!"#"$%$%&'"#()*+
! " # $ !
( ,!,-! % ./0/1/ 2 ,/(.-!
% & ' ! ( ) * + , - .
/3 !4!% ,&/2/.! . &(/
ö÷økùFÂH_
!"#$
%& '()* +, -% ./0123%4)56 789: ;<=> &4?@A BCDEFGHI23JK 1LM# &"NOPQR3STU7VWXYZ [\]
^>[\]32*_`aE01%423bcde f g/h0123%423ij1
2C> kl&[mno% 'pq&Ors\#PQ% 'ptuPQ#kv R3 "NO w]x^>56"N yz{|tu )[\
!" }~x,23%413A&C)2 )@A&s\
17b )TU%**3@YC14%1
2% (&s\ 17rkv"NO ?TU
[\]^>01(&"NO kv(FnoTU3 }~x
)>kvTUkv q3Fb ¡¢JK£?78
]JK^>3¤*¥4¦?301
7rkv}01¤&[\ §¨I3JK}01* 123%41
©7rkv&[\ª«3 }¬gWXYC14%1[\
ª«3 §¨I®^.%13 )kvTUg¯°,}~
%&WX±,)?²³´µ¶·¸j3)?F0¹º»¼ZkvR
!"TU½ ¾<01²³´µ¿E0123%kv(TU ÀÁ0 0bc78 ÂÃx*),)1
JK Ä»no3ÅÆ01AÇÈ01no%&ÉʪËÌTUJK
?ÍÎÏÐ#Ñ»JK0ÂÃx1567rkv JK&ÒÓ(JKÔq )ÕÎ7rkv&[\!" Ö×%1* ØÙ!" R01 ´Ú3kvRVÛ78Ü;%?)>{ÝÜ; xÞ*ß23àá 1
'ÜÀâ(ãäåæç13èFéê,)3ëQì íq1èFéê3 +3kvJKî3ïÆq ðñòóô õ¢öõ÷øFùúûüõ]ýþ01 %C )ãä%
%ñ2 ì ãä1%C)1{ݲ07rkv 3 &)
)7rkv&kvR% {|«!" %ÐÎq î 7rkv¶01&kv(TU)ÂÃ301
LM«««æ««7rkv"NO1?TU3[\]
!
"#$%&'()*+,-./01234"5678 9:+;<
=>?@A3BC(DEFGHI'JKL356=8
MN12.OPQ+RSTU&' VWXYZ[3\$(]^P_56 (\$`" aMNb.OPQcd(efgh.ij3-$;(ak lm(
;ano6pqrkPstuvMNb.OPQcdwxyz03{|$
TU}~3'KI'KL+
'K3 (Rkr 'K3{
3+-'KS( (kSP_
¡¢£¤Rk!¡¢{E¥=¦§- P_&'(}
~D¨©,-ª«(¬®EFPQ¯°b(±²©3-cNef3
³C3 ´¡µ'K=;n ¶3{_·C !
"#$MNbOPQcd3¸iDP¹º³MNcN&'3»¼½
3}~D¾¿³(ÀÁ
RPstuIÂÃP_LÄÅcd Æij=( PÇÈd3ÉÊ(
Ç Ë Ã+-
!"
PstuÌ͸ÎÏ Ð( !"ÑÂÃP_(ÒÓÔP_ÕÖ¥(¯
ר3{|$DDC;(Ù'KI¹Ú@L¹ÛÜ+Ý;<=
+Þ߯à3á$anâã¡¢IMNcN&'ghL3»¼D;(
r
äÌ͸Î(ÕÖ¥(¯°Ø3^åanP_æç3è IPstu RkéêëìíîïuðL ñ@+MNbòóÕÖ¨©MN¡¢DôOP QcdòóÕÖ¨©¹&õõö÷õÛø&'´ùú©P_+û¯×
;(3è !µcõ¥=ïü¯×Ø3ýD
!"#$%&
'()#$*+,-./0 !1
23$ !456789:
;<=>=>"?@ABCDEFGH 23$ !IJ,-6789:
KLMI"N@AOOGEPQARSTUVDEWX YZ[\]^@9_`TabEKX 23$ !cd6789:
KLMcdN@Aef"ghiHjklmMnopFT,qEWX
KLMcderO8OOGAstEu@vwAxyz@A{hE[\ h|H"}
23$ !~6789:
er/E~k}u@ EFGH
I/~TME|<Aer/@z"Txyz"E@AyiH>EFGH 23$ !6789:
99MW//@ M}OMD.EWX Dz"Txyz"EerM@u@
'_*+,-./0#1
#[\ + ¡¢£\¤i¥M_/¦J
⏕య࠙ືື≀࣭᳜≀࣭ே㛫ࠕே࣭ࡇࡶࠖࠚ
ᚋᏛ⩦
ື≀ࡢ⯆㛵ᚰ
ྥࡅࡓᨭ
ᤵᴗ
⛉┠
㛵㐃
ಖ⫱ෆᐜ⥲ㄽ࣭ᗣ࣭ே㛫㛵ಀ࣭⎔ቃ࣭ゝⴥ࣭⾲⌧࡞࠙ಖ⫱⪅㣴ᡂࠚ ᑠᏛᰯ9ᩍ⛉࣭㐨ᚨ࣭≉ูάື࣭⥲ྜⓗ࡞Ꮫ⩦ࡢ㛫࡞࠙ᑠᏛᰯᩍဨ㣴ᡂࠚ
ᐇ⩦
ᐇ㊶ 㛵㐃
ಖ⫱ᐇ⩦
ᩍ⫱ᐇ⩦
ಖ⫱⌧ሙ ᩍ⫱⌧ሙ ᛂ⏝
ᇶ♏Ꮫ⩦
㸦ືᶵࡅ㸧
ⓎᒎᏛ⩦
㸦ホ౯ࡢ☜ㄆ㸧
Ꮫᰯ
࣎ࣛࣥࢸ
ㄢእάື
᪑⾜࣭ほග
๓Ꮫ⩦
ື≀ࡢ⏕ែㄪ
ᙜ᪥Ꮫ⩦
ື≀⾜ື࣭⎔ቃࡢほᐹ
!"#$
!"#$%&'()*+ ,-./0123- !#$%
&14567489-:;<=>?@45
AB CDEFG<HI J JK L MNOP - !KQRSTUVNWX YUV<TZ [\QR1 !]5^_`-abY54cde,fgh ijk545flm*nonp31#$%&<T2q4rsKtuvUw x5*yz5{|wx5*y}f5{|wx5*NY5 2X~X *nnp3WX^5"- !
KFFN?pq4n1*fK ./N lm*n?)* JK L MNQRK
n N<¡¢ £`
OP?K¤¥¦§¨N©UV<*q:TZ[
rª«QR5*< ¬wx{-w®¯°Y5*ns
?)**±wx{²K³NeK´eµ¶·eµN¸@¹º
»¼½¾<¿À
ÁMKN?¬ÂÃY5ÄÅÆÇÈ`ÉÊ*
q:TÁMËÌ ÍÎ<ÏÐÆÇ_fÑnÒÓ5 n<ÉÊÈ`*n)*ÆÇ*(?:T145#$ÔÕ?
4 ÆÇ!Ö71×g45Ö7<ÁM"Y4À*n
?%ص1_f*q
ÆÇUV[ÙºKÚÕ°ÛÜ@ÈNÆÇÝe¶ÙºÌ ÍÎÙº
,"Þß¶àá?)*
ÆÇ¶ÉÊ*Ýâãä â YÆÇ< åUæç
è ?ÁM?ÆÇ
Y5+ ,éfnp3êjëì<2X~X íîFïlm*q :Tè"#$%&<ðñ*ñpq4éf1òó fôlÈ`*n)*è¶ÁMÖ7¶ÉÊKõOPö N L M÷øùïúFûüïÝSýÈ`2¡èïþF<
!"#$%&
' ( )*+,-./
0123456 789/ 7:;<); =>2?@A9 BCD+7EFGHIJK.L/ 7;MN;CDO=>2 PQA92RS7EF>TI.U.L+89/
A+VW.XY234 BCDZ[A9XY\]./LL+^
_`KabA9/Z[cd.CD Bef./g hijklCD' m 01*n.+89/opqrs' m*tuvwxyz' m*{|
}' m*~u' m*v' m*$' m*| ' m*
|' m*vw' m*' m*./d^
)0CD+89/A9CD'*{|}+8./
1 7CDF ¡¢£¤¥ 8¦a l.§¨.CD©
ª«¬ba¬®m¯klCD+8./ 0°CDL±.ªm¯k l/²³´+EL±µ¶G´·¸AlCD¹ºZ[.»
¼+¢9/½¾¿EÀA9CD8¥ÁZ[cdEb./
Â+234Ã:2;<)2; 2ÄÅ'2Ã*Æ ]ÇÈ56É¢ÊÁA9/
Ë;ÌÍ;ÎÏ;ÐÑ;ÒÓ;ÔÍÕÖCDOרÙ9ÚÁÛÇÈ"Ü
0 20 40 60 80
࣌ࣥࢠࣥ
࣍ࢵ࢟ࣙࢡࢢ࣐
ࢨࣛࢩ
ࣞࢵࢧ࣮ࣃࣥࢲ
࢟ࣜࣥ
࣑࢜࢜࢝
ࣛ࢜ࣥ
࢝ࣆࣂࣛ
ࣘ࢟ࣄࣙ࢘
࢝ࣂ
ே
"#$%&' !
!
"#$%&'()*+,- !./0123*4 564789:! ;<=>?@ 5ABC D?
EF
GHI !JKL
0- !MN&'() !OPQRS1TU=V WXCYZ[\]^_3;`ab!WXcdefghijklmn!
opSR1/ !qrst
ul'Ovw?xy&'()*+,- !z{|D }~+,3=>?-'jkl }5
C D } 3jklmn!
}u5}< }WXc defg+hijklmni<N
!"
[` () =[`
>¡¢
£¤¥ *+,¦§!
./01|¨
©ª4|¨
}
;¢«¬
j_3'!®
®! ryX¯«°3
±²³[´r` >?µ¶E·
¸ _3 ¹
®®!
®¢º»¢u W[¼^½¾`
¼¾ ¿ÀÁ>¢lW^+,ÂD ÃĬ
Å;¢scÆ}D!ÇÈÉ
}
;¢£¤D! kCÊ¢
'Ë;¢l¢Âj >¢lÌ3Í
ÎÏSÎÏS >?µ¶E·
£¤D!>
>¢l,!
ÐÑÒkËN!ÓÑÔ ÕÖר§<N_3;
Ù=D!}<ÅC - !ÚÕcÛ
ÜÖ×+,¦§!
ÝjklÞßà«á§!~
â«ãiäjkl-'~
}
¹ ®®å };É'l ¢Âj
æçÂN
èé êcmn^ëì
ÃÄ«Ï/0í~lD!~
ÇÈÉ+,«u§-'~lD
!
>?µ¶E·
;®~ ®®S
OVå4î¨~åÄg ïðlD! N«ñ òóôõ?D! !ö÷?
Cø§<N
OV7}<u§jk?lD! ! ùsúi
ûü`Õýþ~
!"#$%&
!
'()*+,-./ 01) '2)*+,-./
3456789:
;<=*>9"5?/ 3@:ABC#DE FGEHIJKJL:M N9OP9
3Q$R:STU VWE9 3XYZV[\]
^_`JabcJde fgJ&hJi:h
354j:klmn oGCpP2Jqrs rtuP5"CvwxO
"vwB[yqwx 3z*{|z}/
|z}*{~E]EbC zG5"j/
3J47zAB uP 9P"tuPJuE]
EPxoNqw uPx
3Q$R:STU V:M
347]
JJa
354j:klmn ILjo
"MCpEv9wx 347B$EC:
8B$ExJ8B$Ex
BC ¡x¢£¤8B
¥rCx
3¦$§¨:ABC#DE i:©[y9x
ª«jix
"G¬j:ZUuPx
3Q$R:STU
@[N9®x
3¯°Z r
±²J³´µJ¶·gJO 3pR¸:¹º»¼Z
i:UC½G5"[8]x
b:¾"¿ÀÁÂÃ9 E:ÄÅ[ÆÇNrE9Px
354j:klmn N9¢oN9"ÈYP Éqwx
3q:ÊËÌ8ÍÎÏrÉE9x
¿ÀÁx
3q:ÊÐo5CXYE9x
¿ÀÁZÍÎ[Ñ7 j:x
ÒÓ/Éx
"# $%&'()*+,-./01*234567898:;
<=>?*@A*BCDEFG0HI./JKLMNOPQR-*
STUVWXFYZ*[\-E]N^F_`aQ./IJK23PQR
!"#
!"#$
%&'()*+
,-./0&
1234567+879:
%;<=
>;<=
%?<@ AB <C D2EFEF.+GH
IJKLMNO 34PQRST+345 679UVHQ
STWXR2Y4
Z[\\]^_[`ab]ca b]de F]fgF
hijkl mn95oST+Q 95op9UqQ rsturv
wurvxtyhzs
{W(|}4X~
%?2?5;56
x]6rs&'U79
4+X92](+7+
9 Q
(*97.7 .+9Q7+5 (+9
IJKLMNO
gXP]e
yGh34 U7+Q
64a ¡¢ hijkl
e7+63456 UPQ£mHheQ
6'J+(
¤¥¦§¨©ª«(5¬
2'J+Q
C®¯°}±²zQ
³J´µ&'()*+
}N5¥}2¶5O2 3U79Q¥·267+9Q
2¨¸^¸^.+6Q
IJKLMNO
¹gXºº5N6 ºº»N6Q
¼½XU
¾y K¿ÀÁÂÃX
K2Ä9Å}hÆÇ
9gÈÉQÊËÌ Í¬262Í7+¹QÎÎ ÏÐQ34Ñ}ÒoÑ
hijkl ºº»UqQ
m27Nh ÏÐ}±UqQ
GÓ GÓ
gÔhÕÖ×]Ô h34QØ2ÙÚN+9Q
ÛÜÝÞß.m¬Q
$% &'(')*+,-./0"123456789:9 -.
;<=>?@ABCDEFGH,A0IFJK=)*&'('+,LMN 0HOCPQ0R
!"#$
% &'&()*+ ,-./012 34567895:%
; #*+<=(>?@ABCDEFG)H IJ%&K
&$%IALM:%INO G%+
, PQ RSTPUV*%(PQ WAXTY YZ,[(\J5 OII; ]^(_`*Ia*IGb5:*+%, ;,[c d efD?!"(gh)*I(ij5:*+k(lm .no&PQ pq)*rs(tu)*vwY#*I(LMOIa%+
, PQx !"5yzPQ {|}:PQ {|~O PQ(i j*I k a* :&Gb5:*+
, >?@& &9PQ `* OI;
`(;9*Ja:&Gb5:*+
, PQx ?4 #(:5I;9O(
5tu5:*,(LMOIa%+
H&\J*pqAo)*:$%.n*I #(
:5 ¡¢a%I5:*+)K£¤*\J%IpqAo
%I,¥% O¦ ,;(/`A§¨%I%+I j3© .ª«,[A¬A,-<=.12 ® ¯°Y%;
±²a*+
³´Aµ¶A·¸A¹ºAB»A¼¶½¾PQx¿(9*ÀÁÂD?!"
!"#$%$&'(
!"#$
%&'()'*+, -./ 012+,3 40125&,-.67 8 9: 8 9! 925&,-.
; 7 8 9: 8 9! 925&,-.; 7 8 9: 8 9! 925&,-.; 7 8 9: 8 9!
925&,-.<= 8 9: 8 9! 925&,-.>7 8 9: 8 9! 925&,-.?7 8 9:
8 9! 925&,
@A7BC&, D*+EFGH:IJK
#17B,L&IJMNOP=B25&,Q%RNSTU V%&W7BCRB+,
HXY+MNIJZ[:\]*+MN25&,^F_%R
`abc*+MN25&,`ade%fK)g1hijklK21 m%nKop%&'%FfB,IJMNOP q!rsq25&,
&tOPMuvBRHwxyz{|K2+,}~UV%&N Ssq %RBf'5&,IJNS*OPk*+KnF
PNSKRB+'0f%B&qlNSXYR0MNBR B+2$NSQR2&1l2+')NKfBB$W(+#$
%R0Y&,
}~&twxNSTRW"%)fB%
Y+ ff5R%L$K¡'5&,"NS"f¢£SK)F+'f"HX YR0K¤¥ft¡'5&,¦+O"f§¨~FGW"©)+
'aR~$`BL*,
ªF2B«¬f"NSTE)FfB')®¯°±²f"³´#$
fµ¶fNSNSTB+W"·¸t+WK+fB'&,
q&¹K+.ºfW".ºf5RRB'fBB»fB`BL%&,
G¼½¾¾°¿°ÀÁf"&tÂ+t»fLW"K¼½¾&R KEK2+fBKÃ$t$B$ÄÅ'»W"KÆ%&WÇBR2+W
¤¥t`BL%&,
È´ÉÊËÌÍÎÏv1G%K21^WÈ´ÉÊËK0+OÐÑ ÐÑ%L*,¤ÒÈ´ÉÊËKBvÓ+'%EE+WK+`BL*,ÔÕÖ
³Ì%&O³Ò×f'RØBL%&K^Ù¹5 ÅWÚuÛÜ K21W"&a)FRB+ÅL%&,³ÝÞßà+
¤f5&}^à%iWKL%&,W"áNSà+WK
â+WKW"5R%B,ãäK2+Wåæç°èé!K25
&,nLêLfëìÒ%+íîKnFRB+×ïðWKL%&, ñò!%01,
!"#$%&
'()*+, -./01$%&'('234
56789/:;8<=>?@ABCDE 2FGHIJKLM NO!P QRSTUVWXYZ['/M \F]^ VW _`ab;c def()789/XY8ghi8jk8%4X'l2 5m'/Bn=c!cBnop!* qrstuvw >xyz
Bn>x =c/{al 5C|}~z*"#
s4UA NO&Bnc'/
Uz$%!"#$% '/U @AUh
9 =:;8!Bb @AUG&aM
¡!¢£!¤¥!¦§!¨!©£ªBCDE«¬@A\F]^VW%b;c
R® ¯°±²b;³´µ¶·'/«¸¹ Bnº-»¼½¬*¾Bn
¿ÀÁhÂBnVW/:;8!BRS6'ÃXeVW%Ä
RÅ DE @F Bn*/Bn¿ÅÁ!ÆÇBn¿ÅÁ!wBn¿ÅÁÈ A2FBnVW/:;8!BRS6'ÃXeVW%Ä
RÉ ÆÇ Bn+,È/>xhÂ6''
RÊ vÀËÌÍ%«¬DEÍÎÏBnVW/:;8!B
RS6'Ð)%Ä
RÑ w|ÒBCDEeÓÔJUjk¿:;8!BRSÕ9Á m
0% 20% 40% 60% 80% 100%
㡯┠ձ
㡯┠ղ㸯
㡯┠ղ㸰
㡯┠ղ㸱
㡯┠ճ
㡯┠մ
㡯┠յ
ホ౯㸳 ホ౯㸲 ホ౯㸱 ホ౯㸰 ホ౯㸯
!"#$%&' ()
๓Ꮫ⩦㸯 6᭶
๓Ꮫ⩦㸰 6᭶
๓Ꮫ⩦㸱 7᭶
ᙜ᪥Ꮫ⩦࣭9᭶
ື≀ᅬ㸻⌧ᆅほᐹ
⮬ᏯᏛ⩦
ㄪᏛ⩦
⮬ᏯᏛ⩦
8࣭9᭶
⮬ᏯᏛ⩦
9᭶ Ꮫ⩦グ㘓ᥦฟ࣭9᭶
ᚋࣥࢣ࣮ࢺᐇ
ᚋᏛ⩦࣭10᭶
ࣥࢣ࣮ࢺᴫせሗ࿌
Ꮫ ಖ⫱タ 㸦ᑠᏛᰯ㸧
⮬ Ꮿ ᐙ ᗞ
ື ≀ ᅬ ᆅᇦ♫
࠙ᙳ㡪ࢆ࠼ࡓෆᐜࠚ ەື≀ࡢᵝᏊ
ەゎㄝ∧ࠊゎㄝ㈨ᩱࡢሗ ەタ⎔ቃࡢᵝᏊ࣭ᕤኵ ە᮶ሙ⪅ࡢᵝᏊ ➼ 㸦ࡇࡶ࣭ᘬ⋡⪅࣭ಖㆤ⪅㸧
▱㆑⌮ゎࡢᵓᡂ
ື≀⏕ែㄪ
ࡇࡶࡢࡧࡅ
᪫ᒣື≀ᅬ Ꮫ⩦ࣉࣟࢢ࣒ࣛࡢᐇ
Ꮫ⩦グ㘓㏉༷࣭㸯᭶
!"#$%&' ()*'*+,-./0.
12(3456789:;<=>?3@7AB9C8AB %
&59 D<=EF9G;HI' JKILMH(NO>P78 QR
S7TU V3W=XG'YZ([\3]^*_`3abcdeCf gh`<=ijAklmnop]^qabcdrsturgh`]
^abcdrs vwx)ryz3{|}79~-)
*ryz gh`x)3}8N9C
89x7A3ur9.
-9~ %&uz3}7
?3,- ¡9C¢£9 ,C3x¤,C¥¦
7§?3¨) ur©ª.«¬Ni9~
¨>?®¯°}±}-²³
´µ'±¶(·¸¹º»¼½¾¿À' (ÁW=x *_`3ÂF µ`VÃÄÅÆÇÈÉÊËÌiÍ Î Ï
ÐaĪ' (ÁW=ÑÒE-ÓÔÕÖ %&mרÙÚ*_`Û3 Ü}ØÝÞVßIVàËÌiÍ Î Ï
áâ8ãäåæçèéçèê:' (Á ë)*ìíÊîïN¨Ø*_`
ÓÔ3ð}Øv¶W=dVdËñòóÍ Î Ï
ô´õö÷' (Áø÷ùúûüýÊþÈØ*_`-g]d Øv¶W=dVdËñòóÍ Î Ï
òà' (Ágh`<=ijAkÊ Ï
Ða.â.å.6.Y.âÁp*_`t-¨45%&<=>?