「証券化不動産の鑑定評価における評価バイアス」

全文

(1)

(2) .

(3) !"#$%&'&()*+,-(./0$ 12(3456$%781 9:,- ;<=2> ?(@AB CD9$EF!GHIJKLM(N O&P:2 ,-QRSKLTUEFV,-WXY!Z$% 78<1 9:,- [\]^_!àb c5d BefRSKLTUEFV,-(NOg02 hi j<J-REIT 9 $klmnopq!rstuv!`#s%w xy(z {|},- ./(~56$122#s% uv9)6s 78<RSKLTUEFV,9$JKLM!c5$s 2& mn 0$opqpM !0$%. 2010 2 P >¡¢£S¤ MJU09058¥ ¦§¥ ¨©.

(4) ª 1 « ¬ ................................................................................................................................... 1. ª 1 ® 78 ¯)................................................................................................................ 1. ª 2 ® °`±pK ........................................................................................................ 3 ª 3 ® 78 [².................................................................................................................... 5. ª 2 « ³ ´µ ............................................................................................ 6. ª 1 ® ³ ¶......................................................................................... 6. ª 2 ® ·² 14 ¸¹ .............................................................................................................. 8. ª 3 ® ·² 19 ¸¹ ............................................................................................................ 10 ª 4 ® ·² 21 ¸¹ ............................................................................................................ 11. ª 3 « J-REIT opq!rsRSKLTUEFV º ................................................... 12 ª 1 ® ,- »¼2º0$hi....................................................................................... 12. ª 2 ® tuv ..................................................................................................................... 13. ª 1 ½ opq ..................................................................................................................... 13 ª 2 ½ ¾o¿ ..................................................................................................................... 15. ª 3 ½ Àxy.................................................................................................................. 16. ª 3 ® ÁÂ ............................................................................................................................. 17. ª 4 « ÃÄC ..................................................................................................................... 18 ª 5 « x ................................................................................................................................. 19 Å^ÆÇ...................................................................................................................................... 20. Å^ÈÉ.................................................................................................................................. 20. i.

(5) 7«<78 ¶Ê]ËÌ$%PÍª®<78 ¯)!~0$% ÎªÏ®<°` ÐÑ!ÒOH$Ó,-2H @AB(IÔÕ0EF]Ö!`:%×ØªÙ®<78 [ ²!~0%.

(6) {| Ú ÛÜ]Ýu !Þßàá0$12(âã256$%w sÚäå æY')ç ©gw èréêÛ&*+ë~(ìíîH)61) mZ $ïð ñ?9$òÐÑ!`:12(ìíîH)6$2)% w&w6) ë~Û0$óAô(õä56$129#{| Ú(ß)öMR!÷ø&ù`ú !`:12 <$ûü(:122 $%16) 12{|ýÐþ!`!m0$2:

(7) !²5$<2$% &'&()1 9:&ë~56$ Z$(ÄP6 s|w6)( . {| Úú

(8) #&P:122$%w& w 9:,-{|H$ò ² g{| Ú Å! $2$12(56$%1 9:,-(NO$12<.

(9) w = (6&P:ô(^)6$%16 {| ÎÃ ²!0$2$<Z:% Ps(z ó (J-REIT) . èr !2#ç©(. èréê "B2mn!`:|#2èréê "B2 $< %&'( ,-(NO&P:122$%w s? Þô("ä56 (¹)0$129#%&'(mn *+(,-56$% &'&() JKLM(./0$12()6 $%(z<³ ¸¹9# ÛÜ ] w .æô/01ô õä(`6$2;34<Z$%Psý569$` 7u(`6sg3)z89Ò:9$dBÛ0$ ºÑ t;f Ã<=`6s%&'&()@=2&@AB0 >r ?"B9#ò(@CÃAB56$,-QCjRSKLTUEFV,2DEW(/0$,-2&3456$% 1).

(10) !" # $ 5, 6, 25 %&'

(11) () *# $ 24 %& '+,-. 2) /01234/05 678/19 $ 11 %$ 2 :34$ 201 %$ 2 : 3) ;<=>?@ABCDEFGHAIJKLMNOPQRS;<=>?@ABCDEFGH /050TUVRS W7

(12) XYZ[\]^_àb&c`defghi jk2008 l 6 m 17 n. 1.

(13) @AB(IEF!ÔÕ0F32&G dB ;')@A B HIJK!L²&>6$dB!M0$12gdBÛ& NOÈ!P&12PsQF2RF(C&smnòf STÃ !?P0$12f(ÄP6$23456$ (Crosby, Hughes and. Murdoch (2004), Crosby, Lizieri and McAllister (2009)f)%w U@AB 56$. (V9#=IJKLM(=s)56$ô(3456$ (Wolverton and Gallimore (1999), Gallimore and Wolverton (2000))% w&RSKLTUEFV,-(NO$12 »¼2&>W ÏY(^ )6$%PÍªäX0$Y ZdBef Q. [ ò2I \]W(NOg0>$s@AB HImnIJ K!L²0$12 "^$dB!@AB(M0$12<Z$%ÎªÏ _à&[email protected]$?9=w >r!?"0$@AB e:( à|2#&P:12b&?(@AB HImnIJ K L²!`:2:= <Z$% 11<@AB(cI!HI0$9:|2&{| d e,f$ghiq¿/jKT!kl&cò<Z#s2&= m !`:20$|g%m©') mèréêQ@ABW " B %&!`°0$|(56$4)%16) |Ë 9:no !ÒOI JKLM(=s)56&P:12(^)6$% 1 9:,-Cp7<J-REIT 9$klmopq u v!ÒOCj ÙY!1)'&s% ª mq!"r&sdB $<mI(./0 $']1)'&s% ªÏs ò]w 5!1)'0$22=w6) dB ab2f 9:mZ$'!1)'0$12<Z$%=&°ËÌs9: no!ÒORSKLTUEFV,-(NO$ <Z6tdB ab(c5 efàáVu&>Psk+ @ABÛ0$à& @.(c>$s xy2&JKLM>$12(56$% ªÙ%m©mn |s 9:dB$< ò(./0$' ]1)'&s%=&Ë 9:,- [\(%m©mn | ./0$ <Z6t}*&ab c5dBefJKLM(>$ 12(56$% 16) ,- [\!Z)s1)'0$12vØ . Zw!x0$Zs#2$<Z:%78< ´µ!Ö0$22=tuv xy9)6s ,- [\ ]^_!`Ã!`:12!yÃ20$%. 4). o

(14) pqrst+uvwxy7cz{e|}

(15) ~~ cv

(16) ~+-+.. 2.

(17)

(18) 78< ÛÜ mq@AB(IEF !ÔÕ0,-XY!r$%&'&() Ó,-!mz#s °`<@AB9$EF(IÛ&{|EF!ÔÕ012!~&s = w6ef >./&%Psw uvFç=*+2#$% 0$°`]w uvFçu}uH!`:2 >W ÙÒuH$12(<$% PÍª?!ÛÜ2&sLT~pUÐÑ9$<Z$%1 u} 0$2&Smolen and Hambleton (1997), Wolverton and Gallimore (1999),. Gallimore and Wolverton (2000), Crosby, Hughes and Murdoch (2004), Amidu, Aluko and Hansz. (2008) (Z$%16) 0Ì"ä5H$]. ,-!mz#s= <Z$% ÎªÏtÃFç!r$129@AB(IÛ&{| EF!ÔÕ012 ô] <Z$%1 u}0$2& Worzala and Kinnard (1998), Hansz (2004) (Z$%16) 0Ì" ä5H$] ,-!mz#s= <Z$% w&ªÙpTM! 0$12!yÃ2&sÎ ] <Z$%1 u}0$2&McAllister et al. (2003), Crosby, Lizieri and McAllister (2009) (Z$%. Ps16) °`])6sxyu}uH!`:2> W ÙÒuH$12(<$% PÍª?(@AB CD9$EFÉ!GHI ¸´! `#s2 xyZ$w ô!~0$xy()6s= <Z$%1 9:u }0$2&Smolen and Hambleton (1997), McAllister et al. (2003), Hansz (2004), Crosby, Lizieri and McAllister (2009) (ÄP6$%. ÎªÏ?({|I ¸´!`:'f:'<> ?(@AB (V/`É9#ß) . Û0$p()6w xy2. &I (=s)56&P:ô!34&s= <Z$%1 9:u }0$2&Wolverton and Gallimore (1999), Gallimore and Wolverton (2000), Amidu, Aluko and Hansz (2008) (ÄP6$%. w&ªÙ@AB CDg`É (?9$IE F!2:= <Z$%1 u}0$2&Crosby, Hughes and Murdoch (2004), Worzala and Kinnard (1998) (ÄP6$%. 16) °`0$¶Cj 2<Z$% Smolen and Hambleton (1997) <@AB(IÔÕ0EF]. z ? 292 ©!ÛÜ2&sLT~pUÐÑ!ÒOW 9:xy!$% ªXB 78.8%ßgU ?(@AB')I!¸´0$9:. V!'H)6$2s%ªÏXB 79.8%n 2 $@AB')}É. Z$w6C VQI!¸´5$VW!'H)6$2s%ªÙ. 3.

(19) I!¸´0$9:'H$@AB2&×= '#s ¢pT&îH ý5QMortgage bankW<Z$2 xy!$%. Wolverton and Gallimore (1999), Gallimore and Wolverton (2000) <@AB (V. (client feedback) (? . ÔÕ0EF]Ö (perceptual theory). z/z ?!ÛÜ2&sLT~pUÐÑ xy!uv&$% }ÐÑ<5 s @A!GHs(Zsw {| 5I!¹r 0$0$2O$%w 9:e@AB') f 9:(V!0$'2 e )6sopq¡uv. Fç!Nr&$% <@AB ,56$(V9#?2&. . Q {| ÀW p()6?(ß) . !ò ¹. r !`:B (price validator) 2&p&&P:12 ô!~&$%w& w xy2&?9${|ò ÀQIW (=s)56 $ô!34&$% Amidu, Aluko and Hansz (2008) < Wolverton and Gallimore (1999), Gallimore and. Wolverton (2000) 9$LT~pUÐÑ wç¢K£¤öL ?. 88 ©!ÛÜ2&}* ÐÑ!t;&$%w xy2&33% B(ß). . !ò ¹r !`:B (price validator) 2&p&$12(1)'2. #$% Crosby, Hughes and Murdoch (2004) <z ¥`9¦?Û&LT~pU ÐÑ!`@AB(IEF!ÔÕ0F3 : ×== @AB 9$? M<Z$12!34&$%Ps?ú LT~pUÐÑ!ÒO I §¨34=@AB')NO'H(Z$12(1)'2 #s(w69#Iú EF2 x()6$% Worzala and Kinnard (1998) @AB(IÔÕ0EF]z. 927 © ? ! Û Ü 2 & s L T ~ p U Ð Ñ ! Ò O ` t (behavioral. experimental) Fç!Nr&s= <Z$%}<(1)éê @ABÛ0$ à&@.(2)l56sI´f© 5(I ¸ Xª$. EF]«¬Ãº!`#s(s Ï] Í6=IEF! 2 xy!$% Hansz (2004) <@AB2éê $ m2Héê2& à. @.(IÔÕ0EF]tÃFç!rsuv!`#$% }<Z$dr®Û0$5!yÃ2&s! 23 © ?@A&. ¯)!°TU¢p¿/£¿p¡ 11 ©2UöpU±TU/£¿p¡ 12 ©ST²¤³ uH!`#s<UöpU±TU/£¿p¡Û&w Ø éê2& à !STÃ~0$!~&$5)%w xy2&UöpU±TU/£¿p. ¡°TU¢p¿/£¿p¡´Ì«¬ÃXCcI!"&s12') 5). x.e{

(20) { x x 6 rst

(21) ¡¢ 7 l£ ¤epqRS¥ ¦ 30§40%cë©+

(22) ¡¢ 12 ªm£x«¥¦ ¬v pq rs

(23) 3 ªmx®¯rs-7&. 4.

(24) @AB2éê $ m(I{|EF!ÔÕ0ô!~&$% Ps}t<UöpU±TU/£¿p¡Û&h µ¶ÃKT·T¸¹º! )6s»H<Ztñ µ¶ÃKT·T¸¹º!sH<sUöpU ±TU/£¿p¡ I(nc56$ô=34&$%} I(@AB9#{|EF!GH$12 ô!~&s Z ¼2]<Z$% McAllister et al. (2003) <zH$pTM! 0$3½<. Z$ Investment Property Databank Monthly Index !uv0$12¾z ¿T ÀÁp£hp9¦?!ÛÜ2&sLT~pUÐÑ!`:129@AB( ?Û&dCÃ'H!`:12(~56$%PsÎI=2 ¨56s IPD Monthly Index ?2@AB m9#=EF!GH$ 2 x()6$%. Crosby, Lizieri and McAllister (2009) <zH$¿TÀ Â}l w6Ã6 ÎI ÀÄ]uv!`@AB(I ¨" Û&ÔÕ0EFV º!`#$%}<Å$Â} ¿TÀèrB( I ¨"Û&<!`:KT·T¸¹º!w6Ã6#$s¿T À Â}l< sÎI ÀÄ«¬ÃXC(NO$12!á¬op q!rstuv9~&$%2HzÆdrò jÇ (ÈP#s 2007 ØÉÊp¡T/ËTÀÌQù` Íýú Îý(ßÏ` $Â} óW ¿TÀ äX I(U Â} ¿T À w62´Ì«¬ÃXC>jÇ&sY(ÐÐ56$%} I(@AB9#{|EF!GH$12 ô!~&s Z ¼ 2]<Z$%. 78ª« ¬!ÄÑÒ«')[²56$% ªÏ«<(zH$0$Ó9¦ ´µ] Ö!`:% ªÙ«<J-REIT 9$klmnopq!rstuv!`:129 @AB(IÔÕ0EF]1)'0$% ªÓ«<ÔÕ ÐÑg´µ Öw&klmnopq!r sYuv9#)6s Zw]Ã !`:% ªÒ«x<Z$%78<)6sxy]ÁÃP2!`:%. 5.

(25)

(26) 7«<0$ ´µ2&³ ¸¹µ Ö]Ö!`:%ª®<}³ ¶!Ö&ªÏ«')ªÓ«<n. ¸¹Y]×ØÖ!`:%. . !. ³2!`:ñ «Ã³<Z. 0$çÙ 1964 56s= <Z$%³ ·² 14 Ñ. ¸¹(`6w Ø·² 19 ·² 21 . ¸¹(`6. Í/Ú#$%Í` ³ÁÑÛ«2ÜÑÙ«9[²5 6$% Á< ò] ¶Ýgw òEF!ÔÕ0]© Þ>ËÌ)6$22=w ò !`:ñß256$FàÉ]× Ø)6$%Ü< òPsáÈ !`:ñâr0Ì Fç! Â}ã2~&$%. Cj<Í` ³!¶æ0$% Áª«< 0$7Ã^_2&2w ò 0$¶Ý9¦w !`:12 Cì(ËÌ)6$%!8®2w. äå2& ò2(1) =s)0r(2) 'ÛÃHZô (3)Û0$Xæ2#sÙ] 9#NÍ$ µ¶!çè I9#é&s= 2&$%w&Ít mnòÉ klÃ( ÄP6$s N¹ò!À0$12(? <Z$12 !~&$%Ps?9$ êéÃêëÃCì5g ?2& ìí(ËÌ)6$% ÁªÏ«< ÂlÔ¦}Ì2&®í/8® Âlg }Ì ]ËÌ)6$%11< Âl!w r2&îu56$ u}2& }Ì!w X Ã%rÔ¦ï%m !*VOîu56$ u}2&$% ÁªÙ«< ò! ²0$2&ðÃ®íkl Ã]ËÌ$%PÍðÃ2&ß=ÃêéÃµ¶ Ã`Ã(#2&~56$%Ps®í2&®®íñ ®®íò®®í] w6Ã6 !#2&~56$%w&kl Ã2&8®0$klÃóå0$klÃóå9¦w ô ®0$klÃ] #(~56$% ÁªÓ«< ò0$Óõö2& òEF!$ Ó '÷Lr9¦w ² no]ËÌ)6$%11<æ2Pø. õög×Xùr õö!O2&s11 Óõö(~56$% ÁªÒ«< 7Ã½2&ÛÜ õòqY õ. 6.

(27) 9¦9#l$òPsáÈ Â} õ]ËÌ)6$%Û Ü õ2 ÛÜ2$8®PsóåÉ!åÃõ0$12g w úXï9¦úXïC ï%!õ0$12<Z$256$%16 ÛÜ!1õU 2îl& 0$12<Z$%òqY õ2 ò ÷ ³û!õ0$12<Z$%9#l$òPsáÈ. Â} õ2 òPsáÈ Â}!@AyÃVOõ0$12<Z $% ò Â}2&¹)òüò ò ýò Ó] Â }(þ)6$%áÈ Â}2&¹)áÈ2üáÈ ÏÂ}(þ)6 $% ò Â} : ¹)ò2{|ô!X0$]Ít. êéµ¶ j<ÖÃ2^)6$!s0{|< ²56$<Z:{| !é~0$N¹ò256$%üò2{|ô!X0$] 2m0$U 2 Ps . !m0$ñ u. É¹. )ò2} {|¶Ý j ²56$<Z:{|2\]0$129 {|('ÛÃü56$|H$m. u r{|>{|!N¹é. ~0$ò256$% ò2{|ô!X0$]çÉ9$ êéÃ!»¼20$yÃ j<¹)ò 2$Ó!s5| H$ µ¶!N¹é~0$ò256$% ýò2Æ É. ðÃ{|ô!X&]w %rÍeÉ! 2&s µ¶ !N¹é~0$ò256$% áÈ Â} : ¹)áÈ2¹)ò2} {|¶Ý j sá

(28) É ²0$<Z:µ¶!é~0$N¹áÈ!:%üáÈ 2üò2} {|¶Ý j sá

(29) É ²0$< Z:µ¶!N¹é~0$áÈ!:% Áª«<®íuv9¦kluv2& ®í9¦kl (w6Ã6 %r !2ò ²ÔÕ0EF] uv]w Cì 2Nrwç(ËÌ)6$% Áª«< w2& òPsáÈ!l$. Fç]ËÌ)6$% ò!l$ Fç2&õç mn´çà&ç ÙÂ}l56~56$%áÈ!l$. Fç2& aáÈ |¨çá´çà&uvç(~56 ÎáÈ |Iuç%çMSKÀçá´ç(~56 $% ò!l$Fç : õç2òqYH$ÛÜ Ð þõ!l1 Ðþõ]õ¹!`#ÛÜ ò!l$ Fç256$%mn´ç2. mn!àá&NO M! `16)m$mnòVO¹9¦qY¹É!`:12<ÛÜ. §¨ò!l$Fç256$%à&ç2ÛÜ(^N "0<Z :2,-56$à& Í/ Á!l$129ÛÜ §¨ò!l $Fç256$%. 7.

(30) Áª«< Fà2&!`:s Fà]ËÌ) 6$%11<sªÏ«')ª«P<ËÌ)6s]tñ èrw ç]~56$% ÁªÛ«<K2&w L²3. gs!0$ß Z$½. ]ËÌ)6$% Üª«9¦ªÏ«< òZ$áÈ !`:ñw 6Ã6 Â}ã2VOâr0Ì Fç(~56$% ÜªÙ«< ÛÜ ò0$2&w ÛÜ2$ "#g? ìíklÃ ÐÑà&ç9$<r$¨FçÉ] ~56$%. " # $%& ³·² 14 Ñ. ¸¹(`6s%1 »¼2&$^ . <êër® m!yÃ2&s8® (w #. <Z#s12. Û&rq ô<>w à&ô!%&sFç ßô(c P#ss<Z$256$%2H <!8®/óå! T G2&&w (^s#N "0<Z:à&!'îH 2& ù`(`6$sw 9: à&ô!%&s. «Ã³(ß256s% 16)ÛV0$s·² 14 ¸¹(1) sò¶Ý 1õ (2)à &ç9$Fç T(ÃÖ(3)ÛÜ 0${| ÞíÃu v %(4)§¨òPs§¨áÈ Ð] ^w(5)µ¶Ã/çÃ/åÖ Ãå)ÑQo*poö£¤TMW +t(,-P6$122#s% Cj<16) ¸¹Y]×ØÖ!`:% (1) sò¶Ý 1õ. ·² 14 ¸¹C ³<ò¶Ý2&¹)òüò. ò ÙÂ}(~56s%}¸¹1 ¹)ò ì!1õ 0$ 22= ò ì9¦ ýò ¶Ý õ(`6s% ¹)ò]¸¹ <ÖÃ{|< ²56$<Z:{|!é~ 0$N¹ò2ì56$»H<Z#s(¸¹Ø<{|ô!X0$] Ít êéµ¶ j<ÖÃ2^)6$!s0{|< ²56$<Z :{|!é~0$N¹ò2 ì 1õ (`6s%Ps1 9: 2&(i){|Å¾B(ßÏC.{|Å¾&Å/"(ßÏ<Z$1 2(ii){|Å¾B(56sQ0R1 É!An&s0$9: l mn !<12(iii)ÛÜ('r ,${|êë56$122 (1s56$122#s%1 9:¹)ò!l$12 (1õ 56 s129#?(¸¹C 2´Ì9{|D# {| !À0$12 . (~56$122#s%. ò]¸¹ (i)ðÃmn ÛÜ2)Ps(ii). 8.

(31) @AyÃ9¦9ðÃ{|ô!^20$12(Nr< µ¶ !N¹é~0$ò2ì56s%w¸¹Ø<1 ò!{|ô !X0$]çÉ9$êéÃ!»¼20$yÃ j<¹) ò 2$Ó!s5|H$ µ¶!N¹é~0$ ò2ì&s<{|ô!X& |H$< ýò 2&Æ É ðÃ{|!X&]w %rÍe! 2&s µ¶!N¹é~0$ò2 l (`6s% Ps¸¹Ø ò!l$12("^$| 2&(i) 3 0$çÙPsóÔ¦ç©0$çÙ>yÃ j<Ú ~0s 4¨!é0ò!l$|(ii)5Nç>yÃ j <6,Q7! 2&sò!l$|(iii)éêfNçPs5Nç> yÃ j<d Î! 2&sò!l$|(1s56s% (2) à&ç9$Fç T(ÃÖ. ·² 14 ¸¹C ³<à&ç9$ Fç2&. {|7()6$(rqðÃr)6s DCF ç (Discounted Cash Flow Analysis) )6'#s%w s·² 14 ¸¹<1 DCF ç!. Äsà&ç9$Fç T(ÃÖ(`6$22={|ç H$%2DCF çH$. n8 ^w(1õ)6$122#s%. ¸¹Ø ³<à&ç2&{|ç9¦ DCF ç ÏÒ. Fç()6$%1 à&ç2ÛÜ(^N "0<Z:2,56$à& Í/ Á!l$12<Z{|ç<,$ à&! %9#0$129W 9:¨ à&ò!l $% P=. a R. s»&P l$ à&òa ,$ à&R %!w6Ã6 Z)0% wDCF ç<Î0$G ,$ùN0$à&9¦9:ò!w ùN ,$VO. nw6Ã6!¬0$2:W 9:¨. à&ò!l$% n. P= ∑. ak. k =1 (1 + r ). k. +. PR. (1 + r ). n. ,. s»& PR =. a n +1 Rt. 11<P l$ à&òak ;, à&PR 9:òn äX,$ Z$uv,$r . n8Rt ×<%!w6Ã6é0%. w&tí 3 0$çÙPsóÔ¦ ç©0$çÙ>yÃ j<Ú~0s 4¨!é0 ò!l$É1 DCF ç Nr(ß=<Z$2)6s%. 9.

(32) Ps{|ç %2DCF ç. n8]W 9:^w(1. õ56s%% ^w2&{|ç à&ò9¦ DCF ç 9: ò ¨,$ à&')ÛÜ ò!{|l$ñùr56$ 8<Z^ à&EF!$ ´ 2 >:õtô!Ä?= 256s%. . n8 ^w2&DCF çZ$^qY à&!Í/qY. @0ñùr56$8<Z%ÄP6$´ 2 >:. õtô : à& Ò&^256sáÈg>r ´ m$= !A> = 256s%1 9:&BB2=õtô!Ä?<Z()w1 ÄP6$õtô C]1õ~56s% (3) ÛÜ 0${| ÞíÃuv % {|H$â(à&ô!%&smnú2´ 0$129# ò ²w 0${| ÞíÃD=Ð>EF!GH$122 w 9:{|uv aDîH(1õ 56s%1 {|uv®íuv9 ¦kluv0$STÃ 1õ 9¦w6) uvxy!Kú s!0$12()6s% (4) §¨òPs§¨áÈ Ð] ^w. ·² 14 ¸¹<§¨òPs§¨áÈ Ð Cì2&ÛÜ ò. ²!×=ÖÃ']tÃi10$sG Fç9l)6s§¨òP s§¨áÈ EF9¦Ü§¨òPs§¨áÈ(X0$iVm$÷ø!` H$×<÷ø<Z$I GB>Ld2&~&$%Ps 1 9:§¨òPs§¨áÈ Ðno!Ks!0$12( )6s% (5) µ¶Ã/çÃ/åÖÃå)ÑQo*poö£¤TMW +t 1H>8®/óå!T2&sG à&ôEF! $!9×ØIJ& !c$ßô K¾!GH·² 14 ¸ ¹< ñ`:å)ÑQo*poö£¤TMWóåm0$ ÐÑ½yg8L®; e0$ÐÑ½y!k¾0$22=UuM Ú9 $ÐÑ!âr0$12(,-P6s%w&1 å)Ñ ÐÑ "#9¦Ð Ñ1)'0$12(<½(Z$|H$ mz! K1s0$12()6s%. ³·² 14 Ñ. ¸¹ Ø·² 19 . ¸¹(`6s%. ·² 19 ¸¹<}³ÜªÙ«! & ÛÜ ò0$ 2&w Nr"#gËT£NLöT£/OPpU] âr7Ö¬Q 0$1õ Ps DCF ç Nrno 1õ gà&>r½y «É(,-P 6s%. 10.

(33) "#2& 3 0$çÙa0$ 3 R ¦óÔ¦ç©0$çÙa0$óm$mnR¦}ç a0$ç©(`:mnÉ ³!$22=w6) ÛÜ Zs#DCF ç!Nr0$12<à&ò!l$12( )6s% w&7Ö¬Q 1õ 2& @AyÃ õgËT£NL öT£/OPpUQóSå ÉÔ¦ûü0$p!X0$B(`#s ÛÜ e0$ÐÑKW õÛÜ T!Äst®ÐÑ " #0$õ(`6$122Psw6) !K(U5$12 (ìíîH)6$122#s%169# ]w. no .æô(ÐP#s2$<Z:% Ps·² 19 ¸¹C <?9# DCF çr$à&>r½y t)](./&s12!GH}¸¹<w6) à&>r½y «9¦½y. ì 1õ (`6s%1 ¸¹ »¼]z8Vxé8®ué . é<DCF ç ¨~56$à& !õ8Ã´&. 0 õÃ2&¨ÄP6$W56sX0 à& ²8g n8 !õ8Ã´0$2&$Ì2 x(56s6)%1 9:¸¹ 9#9$I .æô9¦01ô(9õä56$12 2#s2$<Z:%.

(34) ·² 21 ¸¹<@AB"°Ô¦%mÉ õ2&(i)@ABÔ¦ K(@ABC"56$|H$r"°(ii)?Ps dBm$%mÉ õ!`:12()6s% 1 ¸¹9#?PsdB(ÛÜ 0$%m Xªg@ABgK"°2 $ %m Xª!1)'& H6t)12()6$122#s%. 6). 4

(35)

(36)

(37) !"#

(38) $%&'()*+"#$,'-./01/%2"#

(39) 3 456 78 93:; Web <=>$?@A$BCDE?F'1 http://www.mlit.go.jp/singikai/kokudosin/fukan/fukan.html. 11.

(40)

(41) 7«<J-REIT 9$klmnopq!r@AB(I EF!ÔÕ0ô]º!`:%PÍª®<7« tuv!ÒOº 0$hi!1)'&s<1 9:I(@AB9#EF!GH$ 2 ,- »¼]^_!`:%ÎªÏ®<J-REIT 9$klmn opq!rstuv!`:%×ØªÙ®<7«<)6sxy]P2 !`:%. 78< H$RSKLTUEFV,-äy0$%2 HmqH$XY!rW 9:Ù] hi º! `:% ª himq!`#sdB$< ò Xª º<Z$% STÃ ôg@AB ô9$EF!mAs<mq !"r&sdB $<mIÅ(./0$']«¬Ãº! `:% ªÏ hidB ab(c5efJKLM(>$12 º <Z$%STÃs 9:dB$<ò(./&s|dB. ab2JKLM 5f 9:m(./0$']º0$%78. hi=&RSKLTUEFV,-(NO$ <Z6tdB ab(c5 efàáVu&>Psk+ @ABÛ0$à& @.(c>$s xy2&JKLM>$2:= <Z$%Cj<dB ab !ÑT Y$rdB9$. 2&uv!1. $%1 9:dB ab!~03½2&7^<Z6tíúú0$ ? © É 3½!r$Ì2^)6$%&'&()w6) opq!Z[Ã àá/0$12("^'#ss78<W\ 2&ÜdB ]¤L 9#dB ab!^Ö5uv!`#s%&s(#xy _à` 6$Ì<Z$% ªÙ hi%m©mn |s 9:JKLM(. /0$'] º<Z$%=&Ë 9:,- [\(%m©mn | ./0$ <Z6t}*&ab c5dBefJKLM( >$12(56$% RSKLTUEFV,-(NO$12 »¼2&>W ÏY(^)6$% PÍªäX0$Y ZdBef Q [ ò2 I \]W(NOg0>$s7)@AB HImnIJK!L 7). GGH6I'JKL3MNOP@3QRKL3S$TF?UV'GPWX Y$Z3Q[\3]^D6JKL3Q_\PQR`3MabHcde3HI' Ffghi/jkPlm?F'1mnd?3XY$%F?6opqr/s t4u`nv/Fw03[\n]^x/d?myfG/'1. 12.

(42) ²0$12 "^$dB!@AB(M0$12<Z$%ÎªÏ _à&[email protected]$?9=w >r!?"0$@AB e:(à |2#&P:12b&?(@AB HImnIJK. L²!`:2:= <Z$8)% <w 9:JKLM(=s)56$|2&f 9:~pM (56$<Z:'%9w |@AB ÖÃ`³9# i156$9)%2&Ã9$mnQmbc d WgQ0/ R1 É lmnPs%m©mnH$%&'(mn(^)6$% 11< 7eÃ!N¹ò2&s|@ABN¹ò9= còZ$ò<@A!"0129#N¹ò< @A!`:| 2´Ì±öfU/o±öfU(NO$122$%w&s Ù] l~p Mw6) ±öfU(o±öfU!$|N¹ò9=cw DZ$wDJKLM ''#s@A!`:12(56$% w 9:±öfU2&ç©')èréêú èr_Qé 1, é 2W g,-ghiq¿/jKTPs%m©mn |èréê " B %&f(^)6$%wo±öfU2&,-ghiq¿/¢M¾ gò jÇ>:Kq ýÐþV jf(^)6$% 1 9:wZ$jwJKLM ''#s@A(`6$~pM !P2s= (é 3 <Z$%78<2H (1-1), (1-2) ~pMäy&uv! 1$%0 òhijH$Ã9$mng%m©mn H$%&'(mnäy&wJKLM('H)6$~pM!&uv !1$%. 7<J-REIT klåopq!rs%uvZsW 9:opq pM![S&s% 7<r$opqÜ J-REIT ç©9#ë~56$mq ¡ OMööpMsXk"K9¦XK9klåO¿<àá5 6$= <Z$%uv<r$´ ì9¦¨wçW 2<Z$% jZsmò2&mò!áj<. $129#ls%. 10). ® ô2&×lmP< {no] p{;qP< o]11)9¦®í²r 8). G3,f/z{$|F?}$d?6~3nV' /xOOPfG6YiH6/F1mm/nI'@3 3stHIEZ3Pt^&'Gn}$d?YiHI'XY nV'WE'1 9) GGH6Yim?$%&' '¡x¢F Fx£¡F¤FdP¥m?F'1¦mZ3,f/XY$6£¡ §¢F§3o¨n©ªV' «$Z3,f/stn¬ªV'6/F1 10) 3®¯C°Pe$±QPs²m³´µ¶$T^·¸¹º=P-»D ¼'GH½¾3µ¶3/$I'¿PjV'e$³´µ¶m?Àm1. 13.

(43) p!óååô2&ÁájóSØ 12)!4r&s%w UÜ ç©²rp´ 9¦q$²rp´ !L²&s% klå %rîuW 9:ì&s%Ê¹Mr2 áÈÁ I13) : Ê¹M2&%r56$´( 50%C = 2&ì&s% ] áÈÁI : r2( 50%C ´!Y$= 2&s%. w UmqYH$K L²!"r&sdB !àá&Ü dB9#(`6s12!é0²rp´ !L²&s%5) m° !àá&m°(%m©<Z$| Xª]s dB ²rp´ !w6Ã6L²&Z$%0 s%m©mnH$dB²r p´ 2%m©mnH$dB²rp´ !L²&s14)%Ps¿TÀ q

(44) 62&ºöf£¿TÀ') m=%m©mn2&ÄP6 $s¿TÀ q²rp!L²&s% uvr$ÑT opq,$2001 ') 2008 = <Z$% C 9:[S56sopqpM')uvr$´ T!P2s= ( é 7 <Z$%Ps16) ´ «¬Yé 8 ~0% 16) opq]%m©mn Xªl<ç©ã2 m !á¬&s= (é 4 <Z$%1 9:& $2|q, tç©ef% m©') m´8(c12(õ<$%2005 ØÉCu|56s ç©] $2Uf¡öpUç©!A·vÃ 6. w8. o . m°(%m©<Z$12('$% Î}*&%m©mn Xªl<dBã2 !á¬& s= (é 5, 6 <Z$%11<Ê¹M2!uHw6Ã6á¬!`#$% 7<dB ab!~03½2&r$ÜdB ]¤LQÑT Y$ÜdB. Wäy0$2Ê¹M<û7ú(×=]¤. L(c>Q23.7%WÎxyÁúQ18.0%WQ16.4%W2# $%<(×=]¤L(c>Q22.7%WÎú Q15.6%WxyÁúQ10.1%W2#$%Ps;ab dB2& Ê¹M<®úQ9.0%W;zúQ7.6%W{|Áú Q6.4%W<;zúQ9.8%W{|ÁQ9.8%W2#sd B%m©') m0$. (c>#$12(õ. <$% 16) m ÀÄ!mq !`#sdBl9¦% 11). ÁÂÃÄm?6ÅÁÆ3B° ½Ç nÈÉV'Ê¸ËÌÃÍyH3³´µ¶ m?hÎm1 12) ÏÐÑÒ`6s²ÍÓÏÐÔÕÍm?hÀm1 Ö×ØÙ3Ú=Û$|F?6½! ÜÝm? 1/12 Ò3OPÞm1 13) ßàá6(1)ÇÍ$%&'ßâ3ãäåßà3á(2)æçèéêë ìpPíî$ßâV'GPlmXY$%&'ÂXßà3á3YhPïðV'1 14) ñòH°V F Pf GGH6o¨óôõstö÷=øÅùúö÷=¤3 ,f/ûüö÷=3ý¬H6/xÅùúö÷=þo¨óôõst¤%,é Åùúö÷=o¨óôõst¤3,f/Hùúö÷=`3ý¬Pd1. 14.

(45) m©mn Xªlé&s= (} 1, 2 <Z$%mq !`#sdBl. $22005 C <a 5 ê9$(`6s(e2~f<Z#s. Û&2005 Cu<w U éê9#(`6s( >K¾&$12(õ<$%Ps%m©mn Xªl16) m. ÀÄ! $2° s9:2005 Cu<%mB') m´8(c ç©( >|&ssÑT2&%m©') m´8( 2005 Cu<s) c>#$12(õ<$%. ®<~&sÙ] hi!º0$smò!ÛÜ2&Ê¹M/ ]w6Ã6Cj ¾o¿!À0$% ln Pit = α 0 + ∑α j ln X j + ∑ β k FDk + ∑ γ l LDl + ∑ δ mTDm + ∑ ϕ g NVDg + ∑ λh SVDh + ηID + µit j. Pit :. X j:. FD k :. LD l : TD m :. k. l. m. g. (i = 1,2, L , N ). ÜÝI¡s²Ç. ÏÐÑÒ`ßâqr½¿µ¶ÃÄ µ¶. (t = 1,2, L , T ) ( j = 1,2,3,4). (k = 1,2, L , K ). õö÷=`. (l = 1,2, L , L) (m = 1,2, L , M ). ö÷=` ö÷=`. NVD g : ùúö÷=`þo¨óôõst. ( g = 1,2, L , G ). SVD h : ùúö÷=ò¨óôõst. ID : µ it :. (3.1). h. (h = 1,2, L , H ). ¹º Þªö÷=` [\ü.

(46)

(47) . !"#$%&'(. )*+,!"- ./012#$/34(56-789 :;<=>?/34@ABC!"#$% F #DE F84(55/ GH!"-7BC!"-IJKL@/34( M +N!"- OP;QRSTU0VWXY;Z[KL45 A#$/34(56- \]

(48) ^ _à84 t #D&b64()c d6eZ[R% f 5, 6 gR 64\hiXAJ jcOPZQAkl845A. . OPZQAU0VWXYZ[Rm #$%&'( dJ +n!"-

(49) opq4.U0VWXY_ Cm #$/34(56- A<rJ

(50) :_à84 t #D&'(. L stuv.- 2001w2008 x/34; dv.y/z{|01}~. e~ ;)64c 3c. -sv.%c. S =/%J %&'5A/GJc(t- z{. 15.

(51) |01}~AJ 2003w2006 xv.J %&. c(,/ z{|. 01~ - =.4u;z /3D % ¡¢845A;/[L. cc £¤/-¥G¦A. J L(. §¨%f 10, 11 g8()c gJc F #§¨-f 9 AD/34( )*+,!"AJ 89 :;<=>?/34 ABC!"/ F #%EFJc§¨ 2003w2006 xs©%c89 op/_`ª« 1%34- 5¬/BC!";®R6c()c Km¯°%. ± dop/BC!";_`®R645AAL ²=U0%&. c(55Ae . c./ ²³´_`L2;µ¶845A;¡. ·R6c(. ¸+N!"AJ

(52) q4\m. d:Z[R_à84(55/- 2003w2006 x§¨ 84( )* ¹º»Y§¨84A ¼½¾p¿À

(53) ]2003w 2006 x/ÁZ:ÂÃÄÅ^%Æ«AJcop SAÇTÈOPÀQOP :;_`ÉY:AJ R6c(¯°AJ WÅÊËY]

(54) ^:; _`Ì;ÍWÎY:AL. c()c HÏU0ÐÑ¿ÒÈ. Óz{|¿ ÔÕ¾p:; 0.6w0.8 Ö×A[b ØK Ù£z{|ÐÑ ¿:A2AJ j Ú 0.4w0.6 Ö×AØª«L /Ú Æ«ÂÃÄÅA2; 0.3w0.7 Ö×AL. 4(dÛ QOP. 4(. M ÜÝ§¨84A ¹º»Y§¨STÞß/-L; Ù£z{| ÐÑ¿À

(55) ]2003w2006 xÁZ:ÂÃÄÅ^%Æ«AJ jcop. ,àÈQOP/:; 0.1w0.3 Ö×AJ _`R6c( 56e§¨D +N!"/34 OPAU0VWXYZ[Rm -,;345A 8LbáÈQOP/-ZOPAklJ Ø01âq%&. 45Aãäa;gåR64§ÄL. c(. Áæ+n!"AJ

(56) q4\m. d:Z[R_à84( )* ¹º»Y§¨84A

(57) §Ä<r ¼½¾p ¿À

(58) ]2003w2006 x/ÁZ:ÂÃÄÅ^%Æ«AJcop S AÇTÈOPÀQOP. :;_`ÉY:AJ R6c(. :Z[RAJ j4A ÈOP/- 0.2w0.4 Ö× QOP/- 0.5w0.7 Ö×A OPA012;Dçè/3. c(. M ÜÝ§¨84A Ù£z{|ÐÑ¿À

(59) ]2003w 2006 xÁZ:ÂÃÄÅ^%Æ«AJ jcop ÈOPÀQOP/-. 16.

(60) :;_`ÉY:AJ R6 dZ[R- 0.2w0.3 Ö×/3. c(. £é/- ËÉWXêëìíîï#$AJ J-REIT 4ðz{| u%cE$¥%ñò ónm!"m #$%& +,- z{|²=U0%&. c(. c./ ²³´_`L2. ;µ¶84m #$/34(+N- .4²³2; OPAT'L34m #$/34(+n-

(61) op 'L012AOP;T'L34m # $/34( ,ô¥§¨D ²=U0%& `L2;µ¶845A;èeAL. c./²³´_. c(dJ ²=U0%&. c. OP;ÈOPÀQOP/34op- ZOPopAklJ ,õ 8 LbáÉYõ²³;Z[KL45Ae ËÉWXêëìíîïµ¶;g åR64§ÄL. c()c

(62) opA

(63) op/ . d<òöõ/345A;èeAL. c(. L £¤/-OPAJ ¿÷84øùúû%üý845 A;/[L. cc 7stU0þ¯4\þ¯p@AJ . OP%R645AAJc(JJL;e LAJ jcop- 'J R6cOP]hiX^-{À6ù; ò4Ú/34c dm -z sa; 4A 4/3

(64) '(5m ./

(65) ãäL 2Ò äí2%g8 DLô Mu%üý845Aa;æïAJ gR6c(. 17.

(66) £é/- éq4,ô¥e²e6c§¨Æ[ $z{| U0×3Dm ADbqz{|øHa%D45A% . !`%"g84(. £¤/- #¶)/&b6 4. !L$ ¸N84. !. L$%ÏJ d6&6v'R64(ÅÊê(ÅÊêm ü%& '(+,- $z{|þ¯J. ); u*Y%+,J z{. |øGJ d'Lu*Y%-.845A/34(+N- z{|U 084DtLE/ú0!%&'5A/34( +,. !$%ÏAJ - 12z{|þ¯J. ); u. *Y%+,J z{|øGJ d'Lu*Y

(67) %-.845A/ 34(534AJ - OP;QRST äí5JK U0 62;òÒ8KL45A;7e64c/34(Jc; *Y%üýJ z{|ø

(68) %-.845A. 5'L u. ZOPAQOP. .¢_ 12;8QJ OPQRL462;8Q R645A;v'R64(56. U09:a;)D ;<4. ø$%Ï%e8=¨;v'R64( cÌJ

(69) ãäL >G84628Q=¨-?84A'´ La@;3415)(Jc;. 5'Lu*Y-89 % sAB8. 4a-LK 34,Z[R %CDLKüý86D5A;gåR64( +N. !$%ÏAJ - 'L u*Y%EFJc/ d. 6eu¥%ñò U049[GÀHv',IGù: m Æ«AL4 %üýJ z{|øGJ "J845A/3416)(5' LÆ«:%g85A. K ÀLo¥%&'5A;MNL. q4U0O×;õJ )cøHa;DKP¢R645A;v'R 64(,/ 5'L×L "J- z{|øLo¥äí%Ø45A LK "JR6cÆ«:;µ×% J)'5A;7e64(d'Lop. Quan and Quigley (1991), QRÀSª (2002) /úTR6 4'L Lo /U. V01Wü;&LKL4A' YXYZîï (smoothing problem) ;[5DÒ 8KL. J)'5A;7e64(. 'L. !%ñò z{|øHa%Ø45A- ;<4. ø$%Ï%e8=¨;v'R64(dJ d'L-g \< a;Ø)45A. $z{|LoReL4]^284ÚA7e64(. 15). GE6I'JKL3MNOP@3QRPpF?UV'$Z3Q[\6Q_ \PopQR`3MabHcde3HI'Ffghi/k P

(70) m?F'1mnd ?opqrQR`Pñ$]^xmXY$Q[\6!Dx/'nZ3 v6 V'Ffe3HI'1 16) G3,f/O6pPV'e3HId?6//F1IxyH/'O P°mH3}33 PV^WE'1. 18.

(71)

(72) £¤/-$z{|U0q4U0VWXYm ADbqU0 ;<;U0³_`8ëìJ J-REIT 12a4ðz{| u%cE$¥%ñò ËÉWXêëìíîïµ¶%èeJc()c d6 eîïEb847cÒ E$¥§¨%d) z{|øHa%Ø 45A%AJcKm. !`%"gJc(d6e. æ$. z{|LoReL4]^Ò

(73) Hefgh;i,R645Aãäa;gR 6c( ó/-. R6cïAJ ¸Nm ü%&'( +,- z{|OP%g8úû]¢_ Ò äí% g8úû^m D`jèeLkl%&'5Aï; R6 4 /34(£¤/- \m d'L %ABüý845A;/[L . cc J-REIT U0þ¯st4\p. . OP%Rm45AAJc(æ 5'L üý X?n 4!"#$%o45A;AL4/3

(74) '( +N- 5'LU0îï; z{|pMU0ù ò c opm îï/34(d'Lop qr%s. c ;tuLovb45. A/ T'Lëì%Úce8(æ DwK7c%&. K5A;AL. 4/3

(75) '( 56em - æïAJc(. xyzx £ÐÑ%o43cD ú{|}/34Sª~ ½Zà|- Z L4ú{%D)Jc()c ÐÑÃÍ3c . - . !ÐÑZZ9}|]z{|12îfI^ Õ !ÐÑZZ| . à| ¢£Z¤. !ÐÑZZ| È ¡ Ù£Z. !ÐÑZZ¥|%-ò K¦eú{%. cÌ[)Jc()c Q§¨©ª]Investment Property Databank ^- «¬Lu "J%cÌKAAÚ Kgå%cÌ[)Jc(wKycJ)8(. 19.

(76) Amidu, A., Aluko, B, and Hansz, J. (2008) "Client feedback pressure and the role of real surveyors and valuers," Journal of Property Research, 25(2), p.p.89-106. Crosby, N., Hughes, C., and Murdoch, J. (2004) "Influences on secured lending property valuations in the UK," Working Papers in Real Estate & Planning, University of Reading. Crosby, N., Lizieri, C., and McAllister, P. (2009) "Means, Motive and Opportunity? Disentangling Client Influence on Performance Measurement Appraisals", Working Papers in Real Estate & Planning, University of Reading. Gallimore, P. and Wolverton, M.L. (2000) "The objective in valuation: a study of the influence of client feedback," Journal of Property Research, 17(1), p.p.47-58. Hansz, J.A. (2004) "The use of a pending mortgage reference point in valuation judgement," Journal of Property Investment and Finance, 22(3), p.p.259-268. McAllister, P. Baum, A., Crosby, N., Gallimore, P., and Gray, A. (2004) "Appraiser behaviour and appraisal smoothing: some qualitative and quantitative evidence," Journal of Property Research, 20(3), p.p.261-280. Quan, D., and Quigley, J. (1991) "Price formation and the appraisal function in real estate markets," Journal of Real Estate Finance and Economics, 4(2), p.p.127-146. Smolen, G.E., and Hambleton, D.C. (1997) "Is the real estate appraiser's role too much to expect?," The Appraisal Journal, 65(1), p.p.9-17. Wolverton, M.L., and Gallimore, P. (1999) "Client feedback and the role of the appraiser," Journal of Real Estate Research, 18(7), p.p.415-432. Worzala, E.M., Lenk, M.M., and Kinnard, W.N. (1998) "How client pressure affects the appraisal of residential property," The Appraisal Journal, 66(4), p.p.416-427. Sª~ (2010) 7z{|U0qr®$z{|U0ï@2|U0 + 21 ¯ °±.. !. QRS²ÀSª~ (2002) 7Ï0 qr®þ¯A0162@ QRS² (³) ´z{|Lo¥µ p.p.19-66.. ©¶·ñ¸7z{|U0Æ«]¹, 14 xºI^@ http://tochi.mlit.go.jp/w-new/h1407_f1.pdf ©¶·ñ¸7z{|U0Æ«]¹, 19 xºI^@ http://tochi.mlit.go.jp/kantei/additional1.pdf ©¶·ñ¸7z{|U0Æ«]¹, 21 xºI^@ http://tochi.mlit.go.jp/kantei/20090828kijun_zenbun.pdf ©¶»¼½¶Ï !¾½z{|U0à½¿ 12z{|U0Æ«ù#ÀQÁ}½ ¼þÂ. http://www.mlit.go.jp/singikai/kokudosin/fukan/fukan.html. 20.

(77)

(78) . . !"#. $%&'() *.

(79) .

(80) . $%&'()*+, -.*/01. -67*89':;< -67*89' =/9>?/+,-.* :;<=/ /01 BCDEFG&: $%8<' ;F89'<H01 !"5 ()* !"4.

(81) . . 23245.

(82)

(83)

(84)

(85) . 532@A. !" . #$%&'( )&*+$,%-./0$1%2. #3 IA 3%456 7. ; . #$%8'(9:$,%-./56 7. !"2. J8?K;LM J8?K;F9>?/+. ,-.*/01. #3#A5 )&*+$,<=>?-./ @. . !"". 01QR89' $%NO=P8 <HF=*S;/.*/F 9'<H +,-.*/. #35!5 ABCDE FG HI. J KL/MNOKL/PQN?R.ST U?./SVWXYPNZ[. !"I NTU9. NTU9F8/F9V =WX01. QY89'F:;< QY89'F: /F=*S;/.*/F+ ;</ ,-.*/01 Z[V'F9O=9 Z[V'F\ *;F89'<H01 !" * !"A. "

(86)

(87)

(88)

(89) \]^_àU% b H. "#4. )&$,%cd./e- -./F. 5"

(90) F

(91) \. I # )&$,%-./ . f. . #$%&'()&$,-./5. !"!. ]^LM J ]^LM _01 (H;()* . #3!#5 #$%8'( )&$,-./0$&'%23. f. %45. !I@. G`=<?F -67*a8/a9 9V* V=WX01. #3@5# 56 k . !I#. b/O;/cd b/O;/F9>?/+ 8/ ,-.*/01. #3525 . !I4. $%T-e* 7f(H?KT-e* f6' f6'01. !I2. ([*<H9L Z[;8/F9V M =WX01. !I". BiLM ([*<H ghf<HF 98/+,-.*/0 j T-e*; 1. !II KT?fk* l`'_01. !IA. Bi [-;<HK $%[-;<H ;F7/`X01 K; . &gIhij3&-0&Ihij3& !";. 9$U&$%lm$,+B./-5 P n ./

(92)

(93)

(94) \. op./ I,qrlms'$tU5n . "AA . #3##4 -./5. ]^_à . cd./%./5 ucd./- F

(95) <v?Mw5 cd./%$1lmqr cd./%Jkxy Iz6 n

(96) %{|n n

(97)

(98) @

(99) .

(100) \ }%+B%[~<xyIzk PN. #"2 %{| F

(101) \%{|P+B. #$%&'()&$,-./5n . 44 #$%8'( )&$,-./0$&'%23. @. %45n #$%&'()&$,-./5. !I mn8/. 01mn89' <H. "24 #$%8'( )&$,-./0$&'%23.

(102) ]^_`

(103) \ . %45. N[;oK/F !I! T-e*f6 ' -67*Ff* !A@ Z'T-e* ;. N[;oK/F8/F9 V=WX -67*Ff*Z'T -e*;F9>?/+, -.*/01. @ 9$,%./- -5 . "I -./5 s'$tU. @ ]^_` 7. !A4. p,eHK;L p,eHK;F8/F M +,-.*/01. IA -./ . ]^_` 7. !A5. 01-q=*/F -q=*/F8 r6st'F7/ / `X. 4"" ./e $,+Be5n. !"; ]^_`n 7. uvw4@@!x yz{|}~ . 21.

(104)

(105) . .

(106) .

(107) .

(108) . ! "#$%&. '()*"+,-& .+&*#/"01 23. 4

(109) . 6789:+ ;<). =>+?@A;B+ CD E23. 4 0/+ 1. F GHI=J-. KL@#)MA-N &M#$%&MOP9.+ &23. . RS@&. RS@&E23 . . . 5. .

(110)

(111)

(112) !" #$% & . '()*+,-.#$

(113) / + 23

(114) #$. 45-.6723

(115) 89:;<=23>.? B&

(116) !" & . 4Q455 @ A

(117) 5. TF! '(CD+-. B&. 23 B

(118) !EF" &0G9 !EF"H IJKLM23NOPQRS !EF"T.U. VWX>RMYZ [\239IJKLH !EF"VWE]YZ [\23^P;<\@ _. #/+-M8 UV"+,-&.+&MO 9:+P9.+&23. WW '()*+,-. &

(119) #$.

(120) #$. -XYMZ[ -XY#$%&OP ; 9.+&E23. 44\ #$% d

(121) && .bc#$% ef d

(122) #$% !" && .

(123) '(+-.`(+-VW.6723a(+ -VW.678 B

(124) & .bc &

(125) & .bc#$%. A);]M@&M \ A);] #/"0123 9<^+M_N 9<^+M_N)M#+ 4 )M#+M@ M@`&23 `&. W &%Z@&. T. 9<^+MI =J-. &%Z@&M#$%&O P9.+&23. 9<^+MI=J-M# /"0123 . 4gh.

(126) +i23=23>.jkl. mnT=(+-jkl 1&

(127) #$. 23

(128) . !" B oUM#$%.

(129) '(CD+-.pq.r8(lÈ]. 4!4 CD+,i.6723aE]CD+,i.67 ef#$ &

(130) !Ls= &#$ 8 1 tD+,u

(131) CD+(vw'(CD+-. 1 FTF tD+,x

(132) CD+yvwtD+,u.`t 23 & D+,u.23<tatD+,u.8.z 1 {+.(vw'(CD+-. &

(133) #$ % &. 4 ! {+.yvw

(134) (v+-.`(+i.23|. 23 &

(135) . !" & . 23

(136) . !" . 8.} &

(137) #$%~ &. ! aM'"=. 5. ef_N) =>+. F efghij. KLbc-Md@d&M #$%&OP9.+&2 3 9<^+M_N)M@ &M#/"012 3 23kl(M# $%&MOP9.+&. 9<^+A?$8+& 9<^+MA? #$%&OP9.+&2 $8+& 3. TWWF. ef#d :;B+. TWW opG@&. TWW. efO ;<). (+-Dkl#$

(138) <HnP. 4 S= (+

(139) 4)*+,.'(.)*+,.45-. 4 >.\<t9)*+,5S:. 23#$. #$. 4FF 5-. &

(140) #$%. 23#$ . {+.(vw'(+- &

(141) S.bc &

(142) .bc TT &

(143) \Pbc {+.yvw

(144) '(+-`+(v.23|8 .}#o.. 23mnCD #d:;B+=> +OP9.+&. 5 F. 23

(145) . opG@&OP9.+& 23. TF '(+-#$ . 23#$

(146) !" & . ^;=J%?MO ;<)23. !! . qa)M"+,-&.+ TWT! qr)1@& &OP9.+&23 . k.6723.5- #$ ef#$

(147) !" . (CD+.pq

(148) 23.<t#$ 23#$

(149) !" & . 5!! {+.(vw'(+- &. TW!\. stCD 8 stCD E23 9:+;<) . !4! {+.yvw

(150) '(+-`+(v.23|8. ef#$. .} &. TW! u=>+. mvwxMyaA -M@#)NJ23 . !" & . {+.(vw

(151) '(CD+-.`+i.23|. W45 8.}#$. {+.yvwE]+-.#$. z{|W\\}~ . 22. 23#$.

(152) !"#$%

(153)

(154) !" #$%&$# ''''%&$# ( !". #$%& #$%& ()* ( !" #$%& #$%& (( !". #$%&$# ''''%&$# +,- +./01234526 #$%& #$%& +(708534526 #$%&$# ''''%&$# #9#:;<=>??@ABCDEFGHIJKLM %&9%&BCDEFGHIJKLM #9#:;<=>??@ABCDEFGHIJKLM. . & ' ()*+,-.)/0123/045 . .

(155) . $ / " / / / /! / // / / " " "! "$ " "/ "" " " ! $ / " !/ !" ! !!$ !$. n n . !! %&'()*+,-. ! 0(12+345 / " 67-8(),9 / / 6:;) " <=()>*+,. ! ?@A>B345 ! CD34509+ ! !! EF-,1>)A ! G.7+.H(. $ :%IJ& $ ! " <K?@+(. $ $ LMJ,9>:%I+ $ $ 2:1JN ! !$ OP(. / ! 6@+Q2.>:%IJ& " ! %&'>J?:%I+ " " RSI92+345 " $ %T-.>(. " $ 7UV%&' WX:%IJ& YZ09+ [=(. )A+>:%I+ / +\]6@J *J^ / .16(. / ! %&'>09+ / ! >7- / ! _àb / / $ %&'*2c:. / / ! )dIJT / / efY(. / gJ& / ! Ghi(. / CD345:%IJ& " !" / klmn09+oabpqrstuv Vwxyo09+>abpz{tx| }~tu k nn{3n }. 23. "# "/# # "# "# "# # "# "# /# /# # $# # "# !# $# $!# !# /# # # # # # !# # !# # !# # !# # !/# # #. " ! ! ! $ " $ ! $ $ ! / $$ ! "! ! $ ! " ! ! " ". # $# # $!# # # # # !# $$# $# # # # # /# # "# /# $# # # "# # # ""# # /# # "# # "# # /$# # "#. $$ $ $/ !$ $/ ! $! ! $ / $ $ $ / $$ $ / "! ! /! !! $ !/ !$ j/!.

(156) 6789*+,-.)/0123/:;<5=>?@ A #$%&'( *+,- ./ 01 %&'( 2+34%&'( 56789:;<= >?@9=A%&'( BCD@<EA89:;<= FGE>DA=E

(157)

(158) H9I

(159) <J

(160) ?KLM< NO@

(161) JPM<D

(162) KQ>R<S%&'( TU VW <X<D@YZ<KE@A%&'( [\]^_à%&'( EJD <D

(163) <J62bc de34%&'( fgh^_à%&'( ij APk

(164) lm>RJ . bnopGq bnopGst rstuvw uvw ! ) ) " ! ) " " . ! ) ) ) "" "" " " "" "" "" "" . " ) " " " " " " !). . ! ) " " "" "" " " " " ). " ! ) ) ).

(165) " !" "! ") ") ") " " " " ". B789*+,-.)/0123/:;<5=CDA . Y}~d Y}~d jz{ jz{. !"#$ %& '()$ *+$ ,-) & ./0

(166) 12345

(167) 67894:

(168) ;<=

(169) 41

(170) >6?34 & @A !BCDE FG504HIJ<KL4M N-OP @QRST$ UCVW"#$ H15 45

(171) 41XBYZ"#$ [\"#$ @Q]>28

(172) ;<K0^4_ 8>0<MI `XaJ<KL4M b8

(173) 8 % @QDE K4H8 cdH85IMH

(174) efg & i`Xjkl3Imnopqrstuvwxy iz{|jY}~jfjz{Sp . 24. & & % & && &%. % & & & & % & %. % % & % & % % . % & & & & % & h.

(175) % & && & & % & .

(176) . . .

(177) !"#$. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .

(178) !"#$. . . . . . . .

(179) !"#$ . . . . . E /:F7GH893 /:45IJ=KLMNOPL>?@ OQLCDA. 25.

(180) . . %&'() *+,./01234 56 ./0127834 56. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .

(181) . . . . . . . .

(182) . . . . . . E +,-./0123 /:45IJ=KLMNOPL>?@ OQLCDA. 26.

(183) RSTUVWX5$%. mn. 3o. . .

(184)

(185)

(186) . . . . . . #$%&'. . ()*+,-.. ()*+,/0-.. 1. !". 23456+,-. 23786 (9 6+,/0-.. 1. :;<=>?@AB. CD

(187) >?EFGHIJ

(188) D

(189) KLMNGH. JO

(190) C. PGQR@AB

(191) STU. C

(192) D

(193) TVWPGQRIJ

(194) D

(195) KLMNPGQR. JO

(196) C. 6X@AB

(197) SYU. C

(198) D

(199) YVW6XIJ

(200) D

(201) KLMN6X. JO

(202) C. Z@AB

(203) S1U. C

(204) D

(205) 1IJ

(206) D

(207) KLMN. JO

(208) C. [\]^@AB

(209) S_U àbcdeRf. abcdeR#ghiI C

(210) D

(211) _VW[\jkIJ

(212) D

(213) KLMN[\jk. JO

(214) C. [\]^@AB

(215) SlU `bcdeRf. bcdeR#ghiI C

(216) D

(217) lVW[\jkIJ

(218) D

(219) KLMN[\jk. JO

(220) C. YZ[\]^

(221) !"#! "#" # $!$"# %! &' $ !%" $ $ % $#! !# %# ()*+ $,# $, ",$ , $#,% %! &' , ,% #,# , % , %# -./0 #% %"! ! " #! %" %! &' % !# " $%" %#. 1234567 %% "! $ " $ %! &' $%! %"! $ %# " %# 8934567 # $" #" # %"!% %! &' "! $ ! #! % $ " $$ %# :;<=>?@<ABCDAEFDAGHIDJKLMNOPQR5STUVWVN . _` abc. !

(222) "#. . . . .

(223). . .

(224). $%

(225) &

(226)

(227) .

(228) .

(229) . ! " # $%

(230) &

(231)

(232)

(233) .

(234)

(235)

(236) .

(237)

(238)

(239) . .

(240) !"#$%&!'()*+,-./01234567892345678:5;<=>?@ABCD !"#E%&!'12345678()*+,-./5;<=>?@ABCD !"#F%&!'2345678()*+,-./5;<=>?@ABCD !G()"?GH)IJ'KLMHDBC NNNO!NNO!N!. <$PO!QPO!$RPSTUV?WXY CZ. 27.

(241) dIbc=>?@ A is

(242)