フィードバック再考

全文

(1)人間関係研究（南山大学人間関係研究センター紀要）, 8, 69-88.. . . !. "#$ %&. .

(2) '(. )*. RSVÐÑÒ4X.

(3)

(4) !"#$%&'()*+,-.,/0. *12

(5) )3. 456789:;<=>?@AB/CDEFGH*IJ@ KL3M. !"#$-.,/0. N(O?P2. QRSTUVWX(PYZ[\])^_*I 89)à*1@bcdef-g345(<)hij<kk 1(O?P2=)lm$JnKL3)oplm*1@2qk)r sH_ct2=<ct)ujkv !"#w2 JrsMxEWyx z{(<|})rs~89 D E)hWxE)8K* ]&O2M8) =<#xkM)(P y"N2=P<'(b''v)@89 DE (KL3¡¢89 £P ) Y,@2J¤¥ ¦§¨,©ªQ&|AB/CDEK «¬'(Md@2'>$3®¯h)°±,²³´ x\'(,2=>?@89 DEµ¶ ·¸)¹º»¼½=)¾&¨¿MÀ(ÁÂ>M)¹º'( k,b2''*$xEWyx (PÃb=)JJ)ÄÅ j<'(M-.,'((ÁÂ>2 'P<Q)KL3?89 DE)¾* -.,/0. !"#$¶. (ÆÇÈÉ¨>Ê>+2<&<,b¨ËÌ$¡. µ)KL3))Y*3Ì*. ―69―. !"#hGnÍ'(bV.

(6)

(7) . !"#$%&. '()%*+,-./0123 45. 6789:3; :<) =>?@ABBCDEF +3GHI JK8L MNLOP6QR STUK8L5VW>X. YZ[\]^ _`N a MNb cd \EF%eN:W>fg hi\jkN %elm5n"N @[[\op%e M5N a qrst Tstuv X K8L T wx\,I )\y:z{|%e}~ W>) G%e a3c \5

(8) [a c5 \Ge 5MI|%e 5M5H Ze a3@[[ T uv1K8LC6a I3]^5Yu ] [ 3[5:t: - \5N M5JK8L UN1cdM[\- \ JK8L #$s\1\3 N: ¡¢ > )G£¤e+3 N

(9) ¥¦§¨5©- ¨ª« ¬®5¯[°± 3²³´8µ¶· 3; µ³¸L¡ ¢>a ¹X·\º»%eI3 3¤3¤a ¼b5½¾3¿ Àv\Á¨LOKÂÃÄÅÆ5Ze36ÇÈÉ>K !] ÊË3

(10) a Ì5,I3Í[Î[µ³¸L Ï Ð\ÑÒ%e3 a Ó¿Àv ¨)GÔ@

(11) Óst M5 3ÕÖc\×+3 au ¿ÀvfM5st\Ø. M53)Ø M5HI3)Ù[a b5 ¿À3: ¨· 3[!3[3\ÚL>5%e3.

(12) Ó 6ÇÈÉ>K ÏÐa5¡¢> fÛ 5Ü3ÝÞ6ÈßÞ)Gà3

(13) ßÞáv\]± 3¥5â6?>j] j]ã äå¯IV[æ çèX STé½ êëìíîà:ï¼5ð¤e3

(14) a Ó îéñÖ 2 [ òI3a

(15) ¡¢ > K8LÈC6óôv õ\y: 6ÇÈ É>K ,I3 ö÷øùa5j+Nõ!×3. N)ú) û¥5üý þ; >É>? N:LOP6 5_`

(16) JK8LÈ?¡>K\p%e3

(17) JK8L MN3ØI£¤e3 a ]1 Æ)G01- T %e+3ùM ùM:Ge

(18) ¥5¸ÈÂ? ÈC>Ã\J 3Ô¸. Õ. ―70―.

(19)

(20) . !

(21) "# $%&'()*+,-. /0123/0456789--. . . ! $%. - :;<9=>?@A#BCDEFGBHIJKLMF !. .

(22)

(23). NO# :$%&HIJKLMG#PQ RS$TUV WX ?YZ[\]^* G$ ! _àbacdef:cghij<kG? lTm=/ndocmmpqrstsu #xyz. vRw# BHIJKLM. FG{Y BHIJKLMF|}~$8. !t # HIJKLM$. G"!. ""xcghi# B FB($& 3 ? HociJ " ? C F¡ CD ¢ $7 3$ /09£¤. ¥

(24) "# ¦-G$ C§$. 7 ¨©¥ª ?G CD?.«¬®¥Q.G #?¯?!abacdcghi# HIJKLM$7& °±. G-X!²>?HIJKLM¥}~$?³. ""# }.d$´µ$¶ ·¸¹ºG. »¼½¾¿ G¥! HIJKLMG# ¢lÀ#t¥

(25) §«Á9 ,&eÂ lt. !. . lÀ#t$ ÃlÀ#t§¥ ¢U $V}~?ÄÅÆÇ Q$7 ÈiHÉÊËÌilÀ#©Í ÎÏ½ ¦t

(26) ÏlÀ#t$ÐÑ9 Òo! HIJKLMG~*Ó# /0$[¿ Ô"ÕZ/0Ö$G. ×Ø$?ÙÚÛ?ÜGX}~!:.

(27)

(28)

(29) G~ 7ÝÞ$7 C¥

(30) "¯V ßà_áâãµ´ Qä B 7aÈHonCDåæ çFèt¥. !

(31) éêLMëe$# ìíîï·ð" *Ó?V. ¥Q¯? G~-¥ñò"!ìíó467$BHIJKLM ô&.õX.9F¥. ¥

(32) "#ö{ BQ¯?F$éêLM. ―71―.

(33)

(34) . ! "# $%&'()*+,-./0123. 45'()*+,-67(8 9:;<=)>,?@ABCD EFGH@IJ KLM& NOP)Q2RS&. 01'()*+,-T;UP. VW,X Y.$G. Z [\]^\]_àbc GH@def '()*+,- ghi.jklmno " pqcr.stuvwk23x1mpydc rzpydcr {23vpqK|}23~ 3pq. 3cr. o" cr o" v .J 1. v v2 '()*+,- 3n 0 1.& w. v& )&^& 231& ¡&¢£¤. v¥¡& K¦§.b v3 v¨v ©ª23 v«¬® ¯-).°} .±²&³m&m1& ´µ ¶·&¸2¹01ºkm1& ¹2 »¼QVO¯½ ¾2'()*+,- ¿P.ÀÁ ÂÃÄÅB& Æm &KÇÅ&cÈ.J.

(35) 1ÉÊ '()*+,-1$%ËÆÌÍÎ ÏÐ2ÑÒ ¯Ó¯XÔ)ÕÖ ×ØÙÚ Û23v

(36) ÛÜÝÞßÙ»¼à áâ0 ¯Ó¯XÔ)ÕÖ X6)ã8O.× äåæ¸ çèé&ê»BÔ¿X»»¼×äë9 Cì ê íCÏÐ2éî.K '()*+,-¡¸!ïðê&. ñÁKmòó23x1P)?23GH@ K '()*+,-ô¿õ½ö&÷øV ùúûüðý& Û2 3 1ÉÊoéËÆþ&Á¯Ó¯XÔ)ÕÖ0éî »¼ú2I01 K

(37) vIk01 ÏÐ2éî.»¼v BA ìÛ23vm A B

(38) v»¼A.K ! A.ê

(39) Û23 && X6)ã8O¡¸Ùdã)»¼¹0vK Ëv×ØÚ¿8;P8X µ )-ô,Q. & Û23m . ―72―.

(40)

(41) .

(42). !"#$%&'()*!

(43) +

(44) ,-./0'1 0$ ()'2345)678

(45) 9':; #<=. >

(46) ?@ABCD EF. %6+.GHIJ6KLM . N+0'

(47) .

(48)

(49) OP#QKR%#S9%TUVWX0Y#Z [ \. ]^

(50) . _àbcdef _ghf .

(51).

(52) _ij

(53) f

(54) . #Y*klmTno* 6"+. 1 no. 6p1 0$ $. qr4st6à()uY&. v'w11x. y'z{ 1 |. '

(55) ;}~TUVW6%

(56) ()#>

(57) .

(58) . 1 l6Y

(59) #. }~AnoM . 6

(60) . 0+

(61) . $. t'. 6<'>'

(62) 1 # ; . 6 .. &;+&M Wm<.+. # >

(63) . 1 #¡¢£¤¥¦M §.1 #X9 % l¨.v[

(64) 1 0©¨ª IJno%' &$'©23 ®¯¥¦. 5)678

(65) 91 $,.

(66) °±²6³´'µ. ¶;w.

(67) !"6«&¬. +;+

(68) 9'. #®¯£¤¦ §%·¸#¹

(69) '.

(70) ¡¢º»¼M .{½¾

(71) .M6 M6x.

(72) ÀÁ.

(73) . ¿. . 61 #Â'ºÃ¤.

(74) . ÄÅ6ÆÇ

(75) $'

(76) }~¹È#

(77) ¡É¥¦. . #¹;%. #ÊË'ÌÍ. 1 }~9%¡¢¹È'gM »¼$ Î°WÏÐÑ ÒmÓÔÕÖ +;×Ø%X.Ù 1½

(78) B. 6qrt. #Ú+%

(79) $Ûp6Ü?0ÝÞßàM Ü?61 . #¹Y.%

(80) . ―73―.

(81) ¹á'â°ãW°±²4äå.

(82)

(83) . !"#$%& '. ()*+,-./01234567 89:;5<=> ?@A BCD!E"' 5FE GHIJ5KLMN 1OPQ R#'ST-U VWGXYZVW5[\]^. _7# `#a'ST-U `#aB1GX5bcdef g5hij#klm3nop'!1qSrst uVW^v5E"'7. [\5! wx. y zE" {|Ev {}Evn5E"' y~z!5%5 5E 8R cj !E8RB1!8R5E U*R an'!5nU* 895F7!EBn:; 1F!B ¡m3" ¢ 5£ ¤¥!J_5E"'# 5EJ¦; 1§¨ n#n#/01n' ©;5ªJE5«¬ ®§«¬¯E" °*±²³)* °E´

(84)

(85) µ¶5 µ·¸ ¹E"'8RÊJ¦º»¼½ ¾ J¸8¿5ÀjÁÂÃÄÅ`$ '!1§ ¨ÆÇÈa1«¬E"v µ·5ÆÉ. E 1ÁÂÊË. ÌË' 5¼Í#$ÎÏ5«¬5VWÐÑÒÓÔn 1' 5VW567. ÕwÖ× ¯v5E"1'". ØÙ¾N vªÚÛ5Ü,* wÖ×Nn#1#$E"'Ý /¯w[¯En¥v¥R#$n¯ÞaÆ¯B51¯ßE v5EwÖ× VWE"'Ú¥5Ü,*àQ*q²U *áâ1!vãä1EwÖ×!ªå%¯ !15E"' !5wÖ×¯! 8R50g8Ræ!0 #×!E"' GHIJOPQEwx!Ev "'#çKn!5a!5wÖ×¯! J¸ªè5E"'!1wÖ5×bJéEn ! . ¥wÖEBn!%êE n¥ 5m3¨#. n!NaëBì!5E"' Q*q5j í 50îïð×N ! ñ [ònóôõö÷øùE n¥ úûnb! ¥¼ÍEv"' 1B úûnbv"ÆEüýò þ5 8RE"¸ õnE"'# J¸5wÖ5N8R50îïð®§. ―74―.

(86)

(87) . !"#$% &'()*+. ),-./ 0+12.*

(88) 3.4567 89:3;<=31>?()91@ABCD

(89) EF3 G HI1JF)K JF7LM N)K O.PQ KR STU VW1XY1Z[\.] 87^__àb1:.cdefgDhij!klP)m #nRo1pq

(90) P)rst#Ro5u c()K O.vw

(91) x8.y.z .{7vP|}~ ..d ()z 1 Pc1)K !.P)

(92) K +1||*!uvD KK r*:P) iDifz. P7 !¡ ¢q. . !£¤.{1¥. ¦7§F|:u *¨© .ª F3 . 1«t 3¬v®¯Df.°1rqK ±Df²D1³# )z .

(93) P|K. }}´µ.. + . ¶|*¨©.°(·1¸1¹|| . 1>()rºv3.zv9:*zv»3!P|z«+. )¶!!rqK !«K.P)87°o ¼1½¡!¾..*|P) K3¿*:ÀÁÂP|KÃÄÅÆjÇ È() P7!:>*|*:P)KKÉDÊËOt Ì9Í+rqP)JF7ÎÏ1p3+)Ro 5u ÐÑ#Òµ()K Ó|ÔÕ1O*|P)

(94) ¨Q}uÖ1×.JF7ÎÏ pØ()ou ÙÚ (.ÛÜ ÝÞ()ßP)*K JF7*:$% à Ro¼1ØK)K Ñ#)K Ot!ÉDÊË áâãäB å+K Otæç1P)3 è#) ÉD ÊË!**áât3*|7éât3)K !.

(95) À ).¶Q*.

(96) K{1è#+) êëÉDÊËO+FÀ: F. t#rq:3)*

(97) 3.*ÉDÊË!GìJíf gDhijîïP) ():n3 ðñ)K .K KÉDÊËãäB å+òóô õ|... ―75―.

(98)

(99)

(100) . !"#$%&'()*+. ,-. ./012345/67893:;<=1/>?@A3 :B-15/>?CD1EFG. /1HIG=. J12K=-L5MNOPOG3Q:;-33:5RSTG 6UVWXY5Z[\$](2GG=^:Q0G=_D` 5a_bcd?1'2cGe[4-30G=_D` 1'G. fg5R<=1hi. G-jk. 5/1. l0m123:-/no. c?2p1'G 6719+3c671q+rs2p1'G /1:;tuvwx1y@x1z+3:-{|567: }F~1GKGK23 +. GQ:154<d9. G676}F2G=|1/12rsq+. GQ:-4LLz+ Q\=3:L567/1 . noc?/. 1p<=1Lp<=2rsq+L L. Q\=3:-12d. 52\2G35. 6U<=1GG2G3:-05 ttu:5L$-01679. . 5676:S/Z:67133c671J!#4/ /1z+331<. uQ567>?p<=. 2rs 1q+L~¡¢:;:BK=£/>?15¤,¥L2G-¦§5/:B3¨¡ 13355/?©ª«¬ 52GG=3:B-3=3[4®¯45°:B ±aY12-3B²©³´#41dG<=:B-? ©ª1Z. 5µdu¶·:B-. 34\&^¸¹ . wº»1<¼½VW ¾¿*+. G;G-. !"#. wº»ÀÁ':B2\ÂÃ1hi6 UÄÅÆÇÈ ÉÈAÊG&'3ËÌÍÎ+3](12. ―76―.

(101)

(102) . !"#$ %& '( )*+ ,-./012345". 6 789:; <=> ?@AB ?@CD"E!6F ?GHIJKL0MN! OP"Q!!R9:! STUV-0W?@+! XY9:Z[7P>M\]! RÊ<=_àP>

(103) 3bcdef9: 3gT_ _F_"h>R Êi3jk 789:0 Eir6s0tu789:0. " lmnopq" " vw_"xyz

(104) . 3{giq|jNF]}>~3 U "|"OPL JKL_9:; L_ 3ciq>R0 2\$01 >

(105) bc ,6F

(106) 3'i "F]9:-Ê_

(107) 3| : 9:¡¢£¤g¥f¦¦ §L0

(108) g¨0©m"Ei >! 9:-[ª 2«¬$¡¢d]_"0QE^]>

(109) 39|"Ei0_F_"h>R. .

(110) .

(111) . i] 2\$P>®¯01 °?±²#i3 N#³´3g"µ!>R ¶·¸ z{¹3º01 ?»¼$3¹½0N ¾©mg¨#¿À> ÁÂN3Ã0ZÄiE #$Å$ ÆrP0ÇQ®¯È3TÉL0Êi>R$ ^]3µ Ë0 ³ÌLÍÎÏ_"'ÅÐ0Q! ÑW$!ÒÓ Ô\jNF]. ―77―.

(112)

(113) 01234. !"# $%&'()#* +, -. / !. .

(114) . 156789: ;< =>?@)ABCDE)#FGH IJ KL23M XWYIZ5. !1N OPQ7RS6TUV I<W. [\])]^_`WYabcA(I5. 13M. !d. efg 2hcij)klm1nopKqrs tuZ5. <012#5 vs. 1I. !. w

(115) 2

(116) x3 # y3KqL. !zZI{ ;| }~#y m . n#>L1234 )3. 1234. !##y?@)$%&'( !WY2Ymy)yrn. <&m<m<2ABL N. -.I. !. O3d m; 9P?@ y)) 3KL!#X3W5; <<InY<6I# y)) $%&WIJ W52#5 ¡¢)k£ ¤¥. !¦§n¨©<I<NªxH30<!. 0IWm2WWHYp«y)Kq¬n®%J¯l<N1 n°±1. 6²³´<!. µ ABhcij y))3KL!h¶6·ABCDE3Mm d¸oWY·o3CDE¹F)GV KL12M. !dºY. <m »3TUV O)3BWEN1n34 ! ¼½k¾6¿ÀIÁÂ3I<ÃÄ*)kÅ2ABÆÇ=> ÆÇÈ¯n±100ÉÊ )L<!1N<m1WYAËh cij TUVL. P8ÌÍÎ ;<. 1n34. !. wÏÐÑÒÓ<Ô 156OI¬n9PÕÖ×Ø ÙÚL J1B JNÕÖ×Ø ® <WÛÜL. < æç ÕÖ×Ø ès. ―78―. !. !# ÕÖ×. Ø ÏCDEn<ÔÏÝ Þ<ÔÏßànáâáâL ¼½k¾ ã°TUV <03M. 3M. ÔIJAB. !9P6äToo#5 å. !éê ë N!.

(117)

(118)

(119)

(120) !"#$%&'!()*+

(121) $,-./0!1234567"#!() 8/09:;

(122) < =>!?@@ABCDE F :

(123) ;

(124) GHI(/ 0!()JF K LM N %O (PQF (PR DS,TU

(125) DFTP=>!DVW#)XYZ[\]^!_à b"#$%!K()/0c-defS,!LMghi jK klE,m3nop

(126) 1234567q r$() $/0-stiuv

(127)

(128) w(!xy%

(129) .($%!K( z. {

(130) i|m3n}~S,($%). ++-1234567S[(Tw 9LM%{! $FT$% S,TLMLM (<I(ME ()-_ V!>3 37D

(131) T> 3¡"#%1234567"# _¢£¤I($% ¥¦I)§+$ {

(132) -¨© !()ª 89LM« (<%#!LM"jm3n ¬ ®¯I(%#$%°| ()1234567±E($,LM²T$%!. ³F ´µ¶(%#$%\·¸. 5¹º»2%

(133) ¼S,(!±E½wI³#!()@T>33 7%

(134) ¾fS,T-¿ÀÀÁÂÃ%

(135) ±E¥(-Ä%ÅÆ !Ç#) $,-ÈÉLM« (hÊI(!() Ë89ÌKT«<Í+ $/0-«hÊ1234567%NÎ($% i%

(136) Ï

(137) T !()Ð0ÑÒÌÓ. Y{!ÔFTÕ3Ö×Ø

(138) zX. N Ù3Ú3 ÌKT« F 1234567±E(% #ÛÜ F ()

(139) D

(140) /Ý "F (%« (%#$% hÞ

(141) DFT)ßà

(142) Táâ-ãä"FT å

(143) 1234567 F æç

(144) æèé å

(145) ª 1234567%>45êÖ±E Ï ë

(146) T!()

(147) D

(148) @ì

(149) T/0%-)íîª ïð

(150) KT)$$!« (%#$%D Þ

(151) D/S[,T). ―79―.

(152)

(153)

(154)

(155)

(156) !"# $ 1234560. /78. %&'( )*+, -. $%&'(9&:. $;22)=

(157) >?!@A

(158) . /0. /# ;2345<. 5B1C0 1D34. $ C

(159) E:1FGDHIJKLMNLKOPQDR% 1SP TU VWIXYSLTZ VWI[\SLT] VWI^ _/0SLT` VWIabS12 Kc0`d PQDe f1gh$;FGDE:1 ijklFmPn TU. VWXYo Pp..qrsP '(tu vd1wh $x>S

(160) TUVW

(161) Hy0zK{| ;C

(162) H }c~ #zp 1$ H E: XYc , GG

(163) '(P"C15p 1$ TUVWP. 0d

(164) H X15 P9&C1 0:1D

(165) 050D2C15 . .o 1. wh/$ ;C

(166) E:. / - TZVW [\PTUV. W . 5 ¡¢c. !"HX£p. X12¤¥"C1P¦§$E:. h ij H. /

(167) . ":1D

(168) HX vd 1wh¨$© %&'( ª«

(169) ¬)=

(170) C -2£p hq5?® !"

(171) 12¥¯$C2°±§

(172) ²³²(1² ´µ %&'( ¬:#. !". ²J!"# 10D. S $. P¶h101 E:·\5.$Fm5d./ 0. D FGF"¸¹5º)= E:d»¼_1. gh/²J5½C15¾$;HX

(173) E:1 FG ¿ H5MÀC1!Á8pÂPX"# H { |} C11 °±§!"C1#$ ÃÄs?' ¥Å: vÃ ÆÇ?': ÈLÉÊ

(174) Ë ÌÍ0# 1 HX?ÎPÏÐÑ¥Å$ ÉÊS

(175) ÒHX1

(176) H 9&PE ÃÓÔÕ1JK-D ÖhJ×Ø1 o/ÒÙ²0HX

(177) E ÃÚ1HP. ―80―.

(178)

(179) . !"

(180) # $%&'()*+,-!.. 7 8 9:;<=>?@!ABC,/012345 *+6. D . 7E8 FG!H IEH (8-E H)*+,-8 *J*K!IELM 0NO P/*K!-ELM)$Q5/'()R *+,- EST UVW!XY/'()Z"8 [\,-E H O],-EH^_OH(*+,- _à)V"b8 c;defgh/'ij;,-; H klm/'n

(181) opqr. !"

(182) s#tu^. 8 v_OwIx(H) y0 *+,-!z#{/' |};~_hE:!# '() ('8 0 !'8(B 0. :/'(_h/'8*+,-!B (0H)HH 8 /'W)

(183) #0 ¡O¢H£"¤¥*+¦§¨© hª «}(!¬'® ¯x{*+,-O°±/'²³´x'( HOJ ) Hµ'

(184) ¶

(185) ·¸¹8ºwIxO » ¼/0½{¾(HOJ ) ¡*+,- a!¬ *+,-(¿ÀO Á

(186) ]fÂªaÃÄOÅXª{! ¡ (Æ )]. ÇBxx ÈG8. (ZÉ; ÊË>ÌÍ{ ¡¥ÎG!ÏÐ ;ÑwIx)yÒ *+,- ÓÔ . a. Õy Ö×0 ¡FG9Ì!ØÙ/'(

(187) H)y 0ÚÛÜ (ÊË>ÌÍ½8 ¡ÝÞß /'*+,!àáE!ØÙÑ) â. ã. ä. 7åæçC¹èéê$

(188)

(189) ë3^ 6ìíîïðñòó ô õ

(190) 7Cð ¡ ö ¡÷øö$ ùúû D 7 Húû8üLëýþ8 (O D7¹¥SGD7 »8

(191) ë8×Ôx0 ]üL´x 0{´x) ¡ "('8 {U {O) ¬/' ë#. ―81―.

(192)

(193)

(194) ! "#$% & ' ()*+,- . /0 1234 56789:;<=> ?@AB CDE3 1

(195) F G EHIJK 3LGMNEHIO5PFPFO5QQE31I. 5R STUVIJ 5WOC X8YZ[\] [Î_LEH`5H IWa bc( U5da bc( X8O5e W fU> V2=gh[ijk 0Ul1m noa 5op5qrs HIt + [5K Wa bc( Uuv]I(wx*EHIJ bc(E31I[5yz,c

(196) U {m|V2J yz,c }~U 5HIM )OFm1m5 U?[ IJ]I5K ? UH m5 m7IJ) QF[^m5K t+[k5UxO

(197) F5 0

(198) F=1V2U_OX=PFIJ. 5yz,cO0

(199) F=1V2U EHIO5bc(U 1m 5> V2U\IEH¡20JHIWUVm HIX8Obc( ¢E\FIJQ X8 5e £U/

(200) 0 g h[¤{IJK gh ^_5¥¦U§¨m5e £ ©§]IJK F

(201) ª§O5«UX8[\k WUVm¬{

(202) FI¬{

(203) F=1Q GHI 5K t+[km5QFaE {_5®¥5X8[Y{I ¯°sOHI±²FF³5Y´ µ¶U·¸¹F5{5X85®¥ H`_UO\IJ ! Q º» ¼½EHI E5«¾ !¿k J ! " #$ % & ' ( )!* * * + , - $ . -. /. 0 . (1% 2' (' % ( 3 , * * * . 4# * * * + , -4. 5 .

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―82―.

(205) .

(206) . . . . . . . . . . . . . .

(207) . .

(208) . . .

(209)

(210) . . . . . ! . ". . . ! # $ . . % ! &

(211) ! '. ()*( +. , $# & . .)()*/

(212) !" ( $#$%#&'(%)*+,-.#/01023%($)456789:;< =6(>?<@ ())0 ABCD EF#,G#HIJKLMNABCDO PQRS 12 6TUVW 6XYZ[T3\]3^%_àbcd#efgh#ij> ZXkl8X<m#>;@n#Zom/010>;(3IJKLM )pX8T3qr#sY)tu7ZX,6vX0;@ 6T3#w>x) X0==> #)pX 8y#$%(z{)d#sYc-.2|}78X<V);<4529: 7,~3,~;<45# #>;@ 6TM(EF;<,G)c/l<m#>?~3 0,pX#2s~G<,G)p=cl<m#>?<=6(m6m >;@ ())3 jOABCD H . '.

(213). N 4

(214) J 03( m6m6efgh>ZXkl<>?<(3$%h#ij)pX8m c>?<@ $#$%#&'(%)*+,-.#/01023%($)456789:;< =6>?<@nlT3%#452$( >¡<sYc¢£#w>3¤¥ ¦3§¨¦3©ª«¦3¬¦)¨®<#(s¯3$(%#452d#sY) ^°#$%± )²c³VT3$#^´µ)0V¶<®¡>?~3·_;<m #>TcX@ ;ç3¹#$%± 2º<»²#¼o>?<(3(½ ¾3¿À)c<63¹2Á²<=6)c870Y#>3n#R#ÂÃ2 Ä8$Y=6(Å>?<@ 0,3Æ#Ç)²X8#m½È)>?<@É7Ê3 ËÌÇ)²X8T3;>)î>ÍÎX8X83 0,V6XY=6( ÏX@m¸ÊÐ3nlTn## ÑÒ>?<Vk3RÓ)6G<c kÔÕ>?<@7V73ÆÇ)²X8#T3Ö3×È 6G<=6(ØcX#>3Ù#ÍÎVcV,ÚÛÜÝ#Þß6àÞ)² c(<=6m?<@ ())3 j ABCD H . '.

(215). N 4

(216) á J 21 6XYZ[T3\]3^%_àbcd#efgh#ij> ZXkl<m#>;@n#Zom/010>;(3IJKLM)p X8T3qr#sY)tu78msX>7âY@ 6T3#w>x)å æ3==>å #)p X8y#$%(z{)d#sYc-.2|}78X<V);<452 9:7,~3,~;<45# #>?<@. ―83―.

(217)

(218) ! "#$ % &'()* +,-!.

(219) ./01 234/456 7 89 &'():;<! %=> ?@A BCD EC4,. FG45HC ! "# ! # $ I %# &! ' ! ! "# ! # $ I JKLMNOPQ6 I RSTPCUVWXYC4. ±²< ³^´µ¶«·¸¹^~º|»¼

(220) ½¾¿tu {¼À¶Á·¸ÀÂ¸ÂcÃ ®+ # ÄÅ¹^ÆÇ 46~Àc|È·¸¼·,ÉÊÃ®, , Æ+ # ~Ë^ÌÍ¶ÎtdÏÅ¶««Ð ÑÒÓ¶ÔÕ«Ö×|ØÂ¸ÆÙÚÛ«ÂÃ + # Æº|»¼ÜÜ

(221) ½ÝÀ¶ÞÂ, ¶Éuß¸Âà,ÌáâÀ|ãäÛ¸Â

(222) ½ÄåæÃvÂÂ ç½cuÂè

(223) ½ÝèÀ ~¹éêÛ,{¼uÀ|ëì¸º|íîÃ , Æ+ # À|ÉÊ,ïð¶É¸ÂÅ ñ¶

(224) ½Ýèòóà·¸côõ«ìÌö÷ñÄ åæÃ + # ~À|ëìuø^,Ä

(225) ½Òù|úû¶ <ü. Ïß~ýþvu.ÃàðÂ¶.

(226) ½~ÒùÛà,|ÏÜÜ¶ìÅ¶Û¸ Òù|Û«ÂÅ¶Ã í«À|É¸Â,-Æ ÛÂö÷ñ~Û í«ÀÆ ÛÏÅv· (Z[\]^_àbcd45HC!8 e<f ghijklm,nopqrs,tuvwuxyz{|}~clm y! % RS] . )! # ^_à= ( g RSsy@/| ^_à! ( %( ^_àPCE8 .¡H@¢¡£¤lm¥¦!§¨g(8 .¡H@¢¡©ª«

(227) !¬<f* 8®( 8 . ―84―.

(228) . ࠦࡒࡘ࠾ࠤ࡯࡚ࠪࡦ࡮ࡂࡦ࠹ࠖࡦࠣ ᳁ฬ ޽ߥߚ߇ੱ㑆㑐ଥߢ࿎ߞߚࠤ࡯ࠬ㧔⣻߇┙ߞߚ‫ޔ‬ᖤߒ߆ߞߚ‫ޔߚߒ࡜ࠗ࡜ࠗޔ‬ ்ߟ޿ߚ╬㧕ࠍ‫ޔ‬តߒߡ߈ߡਅߐ޿‫ޕ‬. ࡂࡦ࠹ࠖࡦࠣߒߚࠤ࡯ࠬ㧦࠲ࠗ࠻࡞㧔㧕 ᐕ ᦬ ᣣ ᤨ ⋧ᚻ㧦 ‫⁁ ڏ‬ᴫߩ◲නߥ⺑᣿ ߤࠎߥᤨߦ૗߇⿠ߎߞߚ߆‫ޕ‬㧔߿ࠅขࠅߩ᭽ሶ߿ߘߩᤨߩ᳇ᜬߜߥߤ߽฽߼ߡ㧕. . ‫ౕ ڏ‬૕⊛ߥ߿ࠅߣࠅ 㑐ࠊࠅߩਛ߆ࠄ․ߦ᳇ߦߥࠆ႐㕙ࠍᛮ߈಴ߒߡਅߐ޿‫ޕ‬ ⥄ಽߩ⸒⪲૶޿‫ޔ‬ჿߩ⺞ሶ‫ޔ‬ᆫ൓ߥߤ߽ઃߌട߃ߡߊߛߐ޿‫ޕ‬. ⊒⸒⠪㧝㧦㧔㧕 ⊒⸒⠪㧞㧦㧔㧕. ―85―.

(229) ታ⠌‫ߚ߈↢ޟ‬㏜‫ޠ‬ 㧔ᜰ␜ᦠ㧕 A ߐࠎ( ) B ߐࠎ㧔㧕 ‫࠻࡯ࡄڏ‬Σ(㧞㧡ಽ) Ԙ‫ޟ‬ౣ⃻ߔࠆ‫ޠ‬ A ߐࠎ̆ ࠦࡒࡘ࠾ࠤ࡯࡚ࠪࡦ࡮ࡂࡦ࠹ࠖࡦࠣߢߟ߆߹߃ߚ‫ੱޔ‬㑆㑐ଥߢ࿎ߞߚࠤ࡯ ࠬߢߩ޽ߥߚߩ⸒േࠍౣ⃻ߔࠆ‫ޕ‬ 㧔޽ߚ߆߽ߘߩ႐ߦ޿ࠆࠃ߁ߦりᝄࠅᚻᝄࠅ ߽੤߃ߡ㧕㧔2 ࿁㧕 B ߐࠎ̆ A ߐࠎࠍⷰኤߒߡࡔࡕࠍߣࠆ‫ޕ‬ ԙ‫ޟ‬๭ๆࠍᄌ߃ࠆ‫ޠ‬㧔2 ࡄ࠲࡯ࡦ㧕 ٨A ߐࠎߪ߹ߕ‫⥄ޔ‬ಽߩ๭ๆࠍᷓߊߒߡ߿ࠅขࠅࠍౣ⃻ߒߡߺࠆ‫ޕ‬ ߽߁৻ᐲ㆑߁๭ๆࠍߒߡ‫ࠅ߿ޔ‬ขࠅࠍౣ⃻ߒߡߺࠆ‫ޕ‬ ٨㧭ߐࠎߣ㧮ߐࠎ߇ಽ߆ߜ޽߁ 㧭㧦ߤߩࠃ߁ߥᄌൻࠍᗵߓߚ߆ 㧮㧦ߤߩࠃ߁ߥᄌൻ߇⷗ࠄࠇߚ߆. 㧭. ⋧ᚻ. 㧮. Ԛ‫ߚ߈↢ޟ‬㏜‫ޠ‬. ٨B ߐࠎ̆ A ߐࠎߣะ߈ว޿‫ⷰޔ‬ኤߒߚߣߎࠈߢ A ߐࠎ߇ᄌ߃ߡ޿ߥ޿ㇱಽࠍ‫⌀ޔ‬ ૃߥ߇ࠄ৻ߟ A ߐࠎߦ␜ߔ‫ޕ‬㧔↢߈ߚ㏜㧕 ٨A ߐࠎ̆ B ߐࠎ(↢߈ߚ㏜)ࠍߺߡ‫ࠍࠈߎߣߚࠇߐ␜ޔ‬ᄌ߃ߡߺࠆ‫ޕ‬ ٨㧭ߐࠎ+㧮ߐࠎ̆߿ߞߡߺߡᗵߓߚߎߣࠍ⹤ߒว߁‫ޕ‬ 㧖ߎߩᤨ‫ޔ‬㧭ߐࠎߪ⥄ὼߦ⊒⸒߿ᆫ൓╬‫ߩ߆߶ޔ‬ㇱಽ߽ᄌ߃ߚߊߥߞߚࠄ‫ޔ‬ ᄌࠊࠆߦ߹߆ߖߡࠃ޿ ٨ߎࠇࠍ‫ޔ‬B ߐࠎߩⷰኤὐ߇ߥߊߥࠆ߹ߢ‫ޔ‬૗ᐲ߽➅ࠅ㄰ߔ‫ޕ‬. 㧭. 㧮. ‫࠻࡯ࡄڏ‬Τ㧙 ᓎഀࠍ੤ઍߒߡ‫ޔ‬Ԙ㨪Ԛ߹ߢࠍ 25 ಽⴕ߁‫ޕ‬ ‫࡮ࠅ߃߆ࠅ߰ڏ‬ಽ߆ߜ޽޿ 㧵ߣΤࠍ߿ߞߡߺߡᗵߓߚߎߣ‫ޔ‬᳇ߠ޿ߚߎߣ‫ޔ‬ቇࠎߛߎߣࠍࡔࡕߔࠆ‫ޕ‬ ࡔࡕࠍ߽ߣߦੑੱߢಽ߆ߜว߁‫ޕ‬. ―86―.

(230) ታ⠌‫ߚ߈↢ޟ‬㏜‫ޠ‬㧔ⷰኤࠪ࡯࠻㧕 ↢߈ߚ㏜ߣߪ‫⋧ޔ‬ᚻߩᆫ㧔↢߈ߡേ޿ߡ޿ࠆੱ㑆㧕ࠍ ߘߩ߹߹ᤋߒߛߔ߽ߩߢߔ‫ޕ‬ ߢߔ߆ࠄ‫ޔ‬㏜ߦߥࠆߣ߈ߪ‫⋧ߊߴࠆߥޔ‬ᚻߩᆫ൓‫ޔ⪲⸒ޔ‬ ญ⺞‫ޔ‬りᝄࠅߥߤࠍ⌀ૃߒߡߊߛߐ޿‫ޕ‬ ߘߩὑߦߪ⋧ᚻࠍࠃߊⷰኤߔࠆߎߣ߇ᔅⷐߢߔ‫ޕ‬ ⷗ߚߎߣࠍਅߦࡔࡕߒߡߊߛߐ޿‫ޕ‬ ታ㓙ߦ㏜ߦߥࠆᤨߦߪ‫⇟৻ޔ‬᳇ߦߥߞߚ߽ߩࠍ৻ߟㆬ߮‫ޔ‬ ⋧ᚻߦ‫ޟ‬૗ࠍᤋߒ಴ߒߡ޿ࠆ߆‫ᦨࠍޠ‬ೋߦት⸒ߒߡ‫ߚ߈↢ޟ‬㏜‫ߡߞⴕࠍޠ‬ਅߐ޿‫ޕ‬ ࡄ࡯࠻࠽࡯ฬ 㧖๭ๆ. 㧖ᆫ൓. 㧖ⷞ✢. 㧖┙ߜᣇ࡮ᆫ൓. 㧖⴫ᖱ. 㧖✕ᒛߒߡ޿ࠆ▎ᚲ࡮ജ߇౉ߞߡ޿ࠆࠃ߁ߦ⷗߃ࠆ▎ᚲ. 㧖ჿߩᄢ߈ߐ߿࡮ㅦߐ࡮൓޿࡮࠻࡯ࡦߥߤ. 㧖ߘߩઁߩ᳇ߠ޿ߚߎߣ. ―87―.

(231) ‫ߚ߈↢ޟ‬㏜‫⚕↪ࠅ߃߆ࠅ߰ ޠ‬ Name ࡄ࡯࠻࠽࡯ߩ Name 㧝‫ޔ‬㏜ࠍ⷗ߚᤨ‫⥄ޔ‬ಽ߇㏜ߦߥߞߚᤨߩ‫ޔ‬ਔᣇߩ૕㛎ࠍ߰ࠅ߆߃ߞߡ ᳇ߠ޿ߚߎߣ‫ޔ‬ᗵߓߚߎߣ‫ޔ‬ቇࠎߛߎߣ. 㧞‫ޔ‬ಽߜ޽ߞߡߺߡ‫ޔ‬᳇ߠ޿ߚߎߣ‫ޔ‬ᗵߓߚߎߣ‫ޔ‬ቇࠎߛߎߣ. ―88―.

(232)