ドイツ統一後の自治体財政：地域間格差の現状と施策

(1)

ドイツ統一後の自治体財政：地域間格差の現状と施 策

著者武田公子

雑誌名金沢大学経済学部論集

巻 28

号 2

ページ 197‑221

発行年 2008‑03‑31

URL http://hdl.handle.net/2297/9869

(2)

!"#$%&'()*+,-./012%

&345 6708 9:;<+,-=$>?'@A;;B CD/EFG= FH0IJKLMNOMP0*+,-

$QRSHGTUVU#WXYZ[\]^2#/E]EFG_`

'ab=cdef0gFhij0klmnopq0ris,tu vwx.GIqWX 0y <+,-z$%&{

| | } ~A

*<

*+

*<,->?

G*+X *+

=

*+f

¡¢£*+ G¤¥

¡ *+,-¦§¨©

*+ª«P¬m®

*+¯°±²P¬m®

QR¯°P¬m®

³ ´ µ

¶ · ¸ ¹

(3)

!"#$%&'()*+,&-./01234 ,56789:;<=&>?@)ABC78DEFGH IHJ KLIM9 NOGPQRSTOU23 478H !"#LVWXYZVW[\]^_9Y`Xabc defghNiW9jk'lmnopqe9-rstu iWv&wx_G78yzIH {"|78 }~"G#9>|

MD ¡¢

£"UG

OKLI9rs¤4>oQ,¥¦§9|

¨I©PªU«#DUDO9¬®¯°±

²³H |®¯¬´l9¯µi¶·H¸

L¹º»¼|_G ¸½¾¿_GM9 ®¯À

¯µi¶·R]ÁÂÃÄ o>µi¶·ÅÆ DÇÈ&IH®ÉÊ¯º"§9ËÌÍÎÃÃ

|ÏÐÑ#ÒÓÍÔÁ|IH L

ÕÖ×ØÙ×ÚÛÜÝÞ9KLI®ß6¥

¦à¬°±áâ´l9Ä ãä>å

æçÞIHèéêëxM9ìì ¿í §îïD

ðñòóôhrõö_÷|øù ||M ® ú789>¤ûüý/4TþÁI§OU9

½#ú78æçÞI§23_÷|

³|J9 ¯¿ùM9®¯

01^Q, PIH¸9®¯

¬ÔD¸MIPDáâMH

M| ¹áâú²m|

9Dúú&8£ ||

IúM9 ¯§TDR]æçÞõö _÷9 ®¯µi¶·R]æçÞÞIFú¶·IP

ô,

Ã

(4)

!"#$%&'()*+,-./0123456789:;

<=78><?@ABCD9E FG?HI4JKLM 4NO+,>PQ1O+,RS)*+,ITUVWXYZ[

?H=\]\^_94JK @8`a^_94bcde fghi NO%cdejklmnopq\7

@8rI<NO%-.st\2uOf4NO%c dev>O%`Hwx yz{<I|}78!9:u

~8&I7 cdeqH 89:`m9NO+,-.12+,m

1 ¡¢.

<Hq¡¢£~K Ny¤¥o¦§¨©1y¤ª«¬

®I`m9noJ¯78

°\q±²³~9-NO+,VWXYZ4´

µ¶·¸¹f9ºKqH»4¼½C°¾?H8

¨¿ªXYZ9:<H4N+,Dy¤À@

?\qÁ+,%TÂÃÄ.<I4:~uÅ ÆÇ>À@LO%ÈÉ.Ê>:;8<I\q?7 :8uNO%%D-ËÌI7¿hi NO-.©

ÍÎfÏÐ78!9:¿ÑÍÎf4¼ÒC~9 CD9ÓÔÕÖÒ×9:u`=ØÒ½Ù4cdeÚÎf?H8

»Û4¼ÜC\qÖ½½ÒC~9»´ÝÞßàXYZ9:<H4¼á Câã78ÝäÝÞåæçèÏÐéêëìL!9

¿íîI%DÚNO%ïÉ^I7 ðìLqH8

°NO+,ñò2âóINO% ôõö÷Iøù 12ÏÐ>¬I2;8¦9:>I4K

°cde êúûë

ü ý¼¼ü

(5)

!"#$%&'()*+,-./0 1234-56789:;<=>?9@ABC"#5D EF6GHIJK6789:;<()LMNOPQ"4R#

6789:;<5STUV5WAXY5Z[\+]I5^_\+`ab c5defghijkglminop5qrs tu5SW vw"xy+-z{:;5Zd[\+|}T~

+5Xxy+-z{:;5^@_\+-z{:;R#_

\+`abc6789:;<5_\op-B`abcy xQ"()Ru5VR!"@5

JK_\op-"V@C5V- ¡

&¢tC"#C-zQ£[\+-z{()¤¥-¦C£¡£.

u5§¨{D©F6GHIJK6789:;<=ª@_\+- z{4!£¡£@B #

D«5-¬u®¯{D©F6GHIR

#°±-²C"³´µ¶-5·-67¸+z_\

¹-{Fº»¼½A!"#{B¾5_\p¿-.À®Áj ÂIÁÃÄÅ!£zÆ{Çc@R5"_\p¿ÈÉÁ6 GÊËÌÍÈyÎÏQ£ ¡Ð¡ÑuCÇc@R5

<Ò=ÓXÓ\ÔÕ DÖD× Ø

Ù Ù

ÚÛÜ ºuÝÞ#

(6)

!"#$%&'()(** +,-.!"#/0123 456789:;<!=>?@AB(&

CDEFGHIJ/KLM+NJ/KLOPQR56STU@

VWXYZ?@ [\]^J_7`abcZdefghij?@

<kJ_FGl\m RV#n*J_opq irN?@<Qopq -stuLv<Z w<x 0yJ/bz{KL<Z |}~5I

XJ_wYH U

@eNm7jX!;m"Qn opq kru\<5 W U!/ G ¡5!kIS¢£m¤T{@

!!;m"#\<J_¥g¦Nk^ §¡

kr¨©ª«¬®!¯°N?@<@ Qn R56STJ_±\<-stuLv²³ +V´µx0yJ/

¨©²³ª«X

DV# ,-.¶ QR56ST QnR56ST!k

·¸AB(i¹¥\mº< kJ_¥g»¼½¾

¿À\mºm",-.¶VJ_FGÁÂ

! ÃÁ±Ä+VUÅÆÇÈÉsÊ[kÅË

<i QR56STVFGÁÌ!+

VUÅÆÍÅË!w< QnR56STn*opq ÎÏ<¥gÐÂÑÌ! QR56ST»

¼ÒÓ&Ô»¼!ÕÖV#QnR56STNm¥g

{Ïm"×!<Z ØÙI±ÚQRSTI

DÔJ/¥gÛ#i UÜ½¾¿À\m"×!

ÕÖV# Ýk\m ÞßJ_¥giÛÎ

@mº<UR #\<£à káâãäåw

,-.Üx0yJ/ ÆæçË

è è

(7)

!"#$%&'(%)*

+,-."/0#/1234%)56789:;<=>

%?@ABCDE7"0#1FG>%HI.

BCJKLMNO(7"#$PQRSTUVA6WXY Z5*[\6]6^*_99`:aMbc,defghi=7 9j:.<Wklmnok79j:"pq6#

Iirm5DE7"#PQRS698sXYtui*vwx ypq%"BCz#{H|t7}~y068

:h]+qr|t7A46|BCok)*

tui*

t|%7|"#RS[4FGA]"#

PQRSG^*7tMbc

$RS[\&'h]

/t7 ¡6"/%) 7"#¢6,ui£¤¥¦ §¨*¨A©ªPQ«r

"#RSA¬t)7"®¯#®¯°t 4>5*t^7"/A%±r %)*²³´¦/t7#

µ¶·¸PQ¸¹º »¼»½ ¾

¿ _9_¿

ÀÁÂÃ !"#"$"%

&'"%hÄB

(8)

!"#$%&'()*)+ ,-./ 0

,1234567!8+9:;<=()> ?

@AB@/0CDEFGHIJKLMNOPQRR(F*S1 T-QQUVW-QXQR $Y()Z[-\\R]^-\\_ 0`abScde-QUfRghiSjk -QXQ $Y(lmdenopqrle-\s dtude-UR_ 0,@()()>F*`ab$vw 1234567!8+;<$vw xy367!8+z{?

|.}~+"#~)+ ,-./ 0

,@~67$`abY1xyC +@Y+@/}xy367CY+

@$ $(//)*)+ 01$Y ~

¡¢£¤¥¦§@$XRQs¨%©ª$()XRXR

¨$«¬ ,-®)vG=12xy¯i(~+C

`abC°±² ³´µ¶

· XR_·

IJKL

³¸¹¶

³»D¶Dº CDEG

³»¶

MN¼QRR HIJKL

³¸¹½¶ Dº

³»D¶

CDEG

³»½¶

MN¼QRR _QQ QUX\ Qff \s Z [ H _UXQfs Q_s X\Xs \\R f_X\ X\s QQ UR_ ] ^ H _UURXQ Qf_Q X\_s \\_ fffU\ X_\f QQ UR_ ¾ ¿ H f_QRQ Qfs XsQR U_Q fUff\ XQR QsR URU À Á H XRQX\ URfU XsQQ U_Q fXs f_R Qs_ UfQ Â W H X_\RX\s R_ Xs_ U_

U_RQ __ X_QQ \f Ã Ä H f_RR_\ QfX Xs\Q Uff Q\fss Uss X__X UX ÅÆÇH Xs_Uf QU\s Xss UX !" s\fsU fRs X_UU s È È È È È #$ \UQQ XX\ XfRR sU È È È È È X\_sQ QRs XfsX s_X È È È È È %! fUsff QRU_ X\_ ssX É Ç H QQ\fsUQ XU fRf QRQU % _QXX QRUR XsU_ QQQQ Ê Ë H f\UXX_ QQQU fQ QRQ

& _s_QU QXfXs _Q\_ QQX Ì Í H Q\R\\s _Us fX_f QR\_

$ Qs_UR \Rs _X QXQ Î Ï H s_f Q_UX fXsU QRUs XfQRQ \\_ _\_\ Q_s Ð Ñ Ò _\UsUR Qf f_s QQRX

$ R_f QU_\ f\\ QUfR V W H _f\R_RX UQsX fQ QXQR M`ab XXRUXRR XRQ X\U QRRR 1 T g s\UXRU QX_U UX_\ QQU ÓeÔÕÖ2 QUQfR\ \\_U XQ QR\\ M N RfQQQQX QXU\U _sX QRRR ÓeÔÕÖ1 XUfs_ Q_fUU QsQQ UQf

×ØÙÚ`ab$+)'()*+,-./012.34562,034787.5921734:;:<7:

=71>?:=71;<$+)JÛÜÝÞß;<Ýà$áâ0

(9)

!"# $%&'()*+,-./01234

$56 789:;)$&<=>?@

ABCDE2FGH> IJKLMNO PQRS TUVWXYZ9[:;)&<$\]%^_`a7b4 cdAef7gh :;)&<"#$QRij :;

)&<=>$klmnoCpqolrstCuUvw-Ex;

yz{ 7|}Z9[~$nl$&

<JK`P`7>&<PnuoY

]%lcX74

$ DE2¡ $¢£X:¤nDE 2$¥¦ :/§¨©lY%:ª«$¬01P¢

£%®¯°;)£&<=>l$c±²P£W³l Ymn´CDE7µl¶·¸¹X£º»)*,-

¼.012$½´"#$¾¿lÀÁlfººYPJK

;)NO $ÂÃÄYPÅ_:

01ÆÇÈc/h£YÉÊY

/Ë9:ÆÌÍPÎÏhÐÐn»! ÑÒ /ÓW³lÔ$ÕÖ×1XØ9£P ÙÚ ÛÜ$NO ÆÝÞlßUà£l

Ô{l !"#$%&'()*+,-$¬ÀÁef7 gl¢9P/µl$:;)lÝhÌÍ

PÄ/lÔá9£âXÑã6{(W³7 ä£lxåæçèhXl:;)89JKLMNO

7é£lcêëPY${(çèìí :îïW³7¢l(îï$æâl

ðñjòLMò:Òó ôõôö ÷

ø Ðùø

(10)

!"#$%&'()*+,-./012304 ./05

6789:;$<=1>=?.@ABC D05E $<>FGH#I0 J:;K-./05LMN O<=678#$MP%QR$>=STU V#1VDWXY.$ZT#.[\A051$

3]R$ ^_`aRJT b#cdE eTfg9#hD05

ijkFGH$lRmnZopqWr40st uvwxyz{I,:;#/0W>=678.R|}

~WS#<=678.R$#

1VD05]Rmn#r40pq#3

#$<=678S$>=678g0hb# D5]]1$

ijkLMO6789

!"#

$h%&"'('()*(+"*,-)*hQ ¡5

¢F£¤¥¦§¦¨¤©¨ª*«¦¬B5

(11)

!"#$%& '()*+%& ,-./01 23 4 567+89: ;<=>?@&AB CD/ABCDEFDGHI/0&%J6KL&'(MN , '+%9-O6P%QRST6KN#>U&

VW8"N ,

-XYZ234[\(]S^_(Oàb967 +89: QRà01 ;<=>[\-Oà c(de>'àf<QR#0Ugh(de VWij +%& ,klmnopq9rsgh-Ottu(de$%&

VWv`awxy\z{\?|}~$%0>S tuON9: VW%& ,#M

01 9QR{-#0&VW: (& ,<

[\-U'9: ?%&

,#0<vQR-`au

%& '-O`a(8%& s ?¡¢£¡¤ ¥¦¥§ ¨

E ©mªE

«¬® ¯¯©mmª!>°5,

(12)

!"#$%&'#(&')*

+,-'./01 23 4 5*+678+9%

& :;<=!'>?@ A5BC,D

>EF*G*67H!'>I<JK&LM NO!&P> +DK4P,8QRSTUV2+

W!4'PX!

YZ8+9[\]^_P;<[ `K,a4 'bc*+#$ >I<JK >[ dd NOK67 e9,:;<=+C ,3*+!4'PfG!g*YZh\ijk5l!

mn opqrs>tuvwxPyzdO!5*+>tuv wx yMLOK7 DA5B{|}~ +!YZ

I~> YZ'*+G3

!H+!P4ijk&5l!

I(tuvQR in

o

> > iNn

#$%&

dd L y

;< dzL oM

67 yL pyp dp

pdo y Mo

¡¢£ d M z

¡¢¤ y LM pz

YZin Mo dd

[¥ p MM

#(

Lz d dL

¦ Mdd zy Md

YZi¦n dop zp dL

zL z y

67 y y LM

§¨©ª oop`K«¬

(13)

!"#$%&'()*+,-./0(+

1!2345!

678!9:;<!=>(?@ABCDEF(G0 -./0>(?HIJ!K5LM!NOPQ RS!;BPQ1SS=T90:;<!(UVWXC

=YZ!G0[\]<![^_GC`a!;5M(

GDEF(b-./0(+@3cde!GfB gh-i%!jk678lmCn[oOg!p9 qrstuvCwTx90^SyBqrstuvDEF(>

+Cn[ozlOG{o^SS

|(}~{@!g!9\tuv<!rs

O@g_tuv!

9\|(+,O!R@!!{o

C"! ¡tu v!9\¢oI£¤¥ ¡G0g!;5C g!;5O¦§¨©@0Cª opy!

@A«5O¬o

tuv@BOGC"h-i%!g(®

,Cy¯[^_S!J2!;B°!

1!234B±²³´µh-¶·¸¹O!º ,{o»¼½¾·¿#@À 90 tuvÁÂ39ÃÄaÅ@À C[_o ÆÇÈÉÊËÌº,{otuv|(}~{g

~{!;5$Í#BCtuvÎ!Ï,{o OGB_BÐÑpy!»¼½¾·!¸¹{o ÒËG0g!9\OÓÔ<!rs@Õq{ÖT

!¢o2×ØÎ|(+,C¢o!J2

·ÙÚÛÜÚÝÞ ÆßÆà á

â â

(14)

!"#$%&'()*+,-.'/

0123456789:;<=>?@ABCDEF GHIJKA !"LHM/NMOPQRS.1 TUT#UEVW/XA"YZ[T A\M#2]A^_`AJKa/bccb&_d#

AefgXhiHA !"AE#jBklmnM EoklpqrstaM !"ARS#Nu/Eoklp qAvwTxyzUHM{

|A}~'Z[sgu#A}

~TTOT;23Oxy

W2}~Ap_`'/VNA

,nMc&#EVW/XV#]'1 a/DEFG#2;23

]A%^O/NM#Agu45678 9A/ !"¡pnM/NT¢£nM

¤4¥DEGAk¦ §¨©ª

« bc$«

¬® §ª

(15)

!

"#$%&'()'*+,-./01$2

3451$6 789:;<=>?1$@ A BC2 789!D.E$C:;FGHI6$

J5 A@BC2KL@MNO1C 789PQRSTUVA.B$C234 6 $WXYZ[\@BCC]KL:;^_`\:;FG KLabcde.@f4$CC]21@1%&':

;FGgKLFGhijk6 789l:;<=\mn 1C3\o@\23pqr$st2

,mo789uvwx+y!z{$A1C|}1$~

3o2uv1$6 789 789 AB$2

PQwxm@1$$21

6 789l:;<=N\A42uv

@ 26 l¡¢/0£¤¥q

¦§¨©4ªL«¬J5®\¯°26 ±²³

´µ ¶·¶¸¹ º» ¼

½ )¾%½

¿ÀÁÂ{2

(16)

!"#$%&'()*+,-./

0123456789:;<=$>?@AB*

CDEFGHIJKL/01M@CDEFGN-OPQ

*0101RS*CDTUEFQVWXL, V-ONYZ9[.\]^_`a*bc+def$g,/hi jklmN\]^_N\]no*\]TU*pqr$,M f\]nosEtuvw8xt\]yzM{t|"9[

.\]TU$@-*V/ MN\]^_}~$

V+j0<]\]*CDTU$sELN\

]TUEFVCDTU$sE-*.,01

!CDTUGOV/-O

MN ,V*R$ ¡ 8\]¢£¤¥¦§¨'N©ªCDTUr«ªN +'\]^_`ar.,s@¬OV*RL/

hij®¯e°±²³´klµ^¶·.,xt\]§

$¸*pqEF\]TU*CDTU¡z¹OCDº»¼p½

±¾¿§ÀÁ^ÂµÃÄÀÅ'EF ½¹OV/-O.ÆEF L±\]noÇµM.ÈÉT&ÊË±CDnoµNÌYZ 9[.,EF¹O-*+,V/sE§ÍÎ GEFqNYZ!$Ïqq019:!*¹O V/qPf01!*NCDTUEFGÐÑ¹OVÒ ÓCDTUsE§*\]TUsE§$LeÔVÍÎGEFÆ V+!*+,V/ÕÖ×ÒÓ\]TUsE§CDTUsE§

¨,V N01!ÐÑ¹O\]TUsE§Ø¨

,V N01!H}VL/

N²³´klm8oÙEFsE§ÚÛ$ÜVL/

¸*+,VsE§NÝ#L\]§M.ÈÕÉT&ÊË

¡8019: ÃÞßÄ

à ·¶¶à

(17)

!"#$%&'(&' )*+,-.

/012 3 4%&'3567$/(& 89:3

;<,*6=>? $@%&' ABCDE35

@FGHIJ *K7LM3NOP3 Q $RS:THKN%&ABC DE UVUVWXVOP302Y3NOP3Z[\9]%

&ABC FG$^H4+,-_(&`ab cd3U*e47 f76 *

ghEi$?P4%&ABC DEjk3 47l:m nopq Fjk r6ABC3 47stVuva^wxy4Y 3567%&ABC zy{_gh|'1 }~b/^H4 $

?P43O

9: OP0%&ABC DEt7 35@

1 /1302; n3m# J 3: J33 ¡¢£¤

¥¦§§&¨© ª« ¬

®¯®

°±² ³ ´ !"#$%&'(&)*+,&($&-.) ®ZZµ

°¶² ³·¸¹´F$º»¼½$¾!¼½* F

|$¿

F$ÀÁÂ!3$ÃÄÅÆÇÈ3$ÃFV;

ZÉ\Ê$ËÌÍ

(18)

!"#$% &'(!")*+,-./0123 456789 :;<=-<>?@AB#CD-EF0G H IJKLMNOP-=&QRSN TU:V>?W'B)XYZ[

\]F^F/_ 2QR`ab cdHMNefgh#i j-k lmnoFpqorsh tu#v.ww_xy w/

.z{-./|</

}~Lg3^^Fc= HMNX$% gIJ 1G HMN -./0< 2MN1

X@_Fg+U2F0HIJ dlL_VX .0 F

¡92QRg¢X£¤¥¦§¨W'©ª«¬ ®|_¯u sh°±#ij-.T|</

QRg¢X²³´ µ¤¥¦§¨W'©ª«¬2 ¶!"

·3dHMNgh¸¹X^ [./ º^

'Qsh2&H»¼l)½]³ c¾.¿ÀÁÂ2 GTTc_ÃÄMÅÆÇÈÉÊÂ§ËÌ»¼ÍÎÏÐ ÑÒÓÄMÅÆÔÕÖ×ØÙÚÛghÜÝÏÞßàáÚ¹£â ãMN¹£äåÏæE³shçèZéêÕÏëÂÏìím¨/¾<

3îï ðñ0lXò[./W'óô2HMN*Ã ÄMÅÆ§ËÌõö Ó lX÷Ä¾<Xøù³6ôú 2ûü»¼ÅÆÓQýXþ2}~c=FIJ k

*dX F wrH QÓ

3îÄMÅÆÔÕÖ×ÄMÅÆ<

§ËÌõö G¯uXc= F¾.|./<

¦§¨W'ôLg

(19)

!"#$%&'()*+,-./01234/5678 9:;<=>?@;/ABCDEF9$GHIJK#L$/MN,-

#OPQRS/TUV#/W+XYZ^[\%&'LEF]^_

`a/01234.bLcd9$e-:;/f?@;/

ghD+$ijOL,ghDklm/nM/opqr/stu ,PQvwx3/yz{|}Q~/{/nM/rHw20

/MN#O;EF/rEF/

M+N,LMN,-

.bL7:;01234/bPQop%&qr7,&

k/9L$/MN,-.bL&k/:; 7

¡7]¢£¤+,$//..[¥j¦§/¨#@

;EF7,$/$©ª«¬¨N,.#O®,-./¯{°

aM±L&²³´'µ/#79+,-O:;7

,k¶·k¶9¸¹º#,&²³´'µ«¬¨

N,/7PQop§»¼/012347,²½µ7:;7

¾¿¨N@;/ABCDEF7,¶9ÀÁÂ{

+,#+Ã,-

µÄ¢ÅÆÇÅ;ÈÉ ÊËÊÌ Í

Î Ï[ÐÎ

ÑÒÓÔ

(20)

!"#$%!&'()*+,&-./0 1!23456789:;<==>?@ABCD!)

*&-0EFG!2 HIJ)*KLMNOP QRSTU$%!VWXYZ[\]^(=>?)*+,_`

abN/0cd=>? Hef)*+,_`0ghiji klminolpqTUrs(CD!2

tpq)*uvwxyzt{|}~)*xF&

G=<?(=?] H=

k0rszQ0G<iklC D!2Ci<l<=0" pq z)*ml&D!2

4567I ¡¢

£ <i£

¤ ¥M¦§O ef¨©ª

)*+,_

`uvw

pq)*a«

¬®¯°±²³´

G!µ¶M+·¸{a¹ º»¼¦½¾",¿Àa Á)*5ÂÃÄÅÀ2

=<Æ=?h=kÇz¦

0G

<ikÇ2 )*ÈÉ·M+·Ê

Ë µ¶M¦ÌÀM+Í·Ê Î¦ÏÐÄÅÀ)*Ñ ÒÓÔÀ2

7Õh<kÇ2=>?

kÇ H2 Ö×+·ÄÅÀ ØÙÚÛ×M+·"

,ÄÅÀ\ÜÝ2Þ

ºßàáâã2

=nÆ=?inkÇ2

=n?ÜÝhnkÇ2 W]äåæçè ºßàáâ\åæçè

¬®¯°_`2 =Æ<?héÇ H2

êë)* ìÀTíTU Mîï¦ðñ¦òó_`

0ôs)*uõ0¥ö%

2÷øù

úûQüýþ

!2

=>?456ÎkÇ HqF¢2 êëQ Hîïêë 0þ!2

ØÀ Þ¦âã TU M

Ä5çè0ôsTUMKL»0

%!2

Þ¦ÜÝï2

Ý !"#$% &"'(()$"!'* ' "+,,-V2

(21)

!"#$%&'() *+,-./012345 $%6 789:4;<=>?@$%ABCDE=FG *+%HIJ 4=KL=MLN@OPQRSTUV"WXYZ[

\]! ^C_`"abcdeVWfgSTWWXg"hi NjL]!P

k^l6mn:" op;*+qrstiV uv"wxyzbF {|}*+\@T!jp~V $%ABC"abkOn:

]! V]!j]!"]! Nj

O_"4"4]!j\*z\jP sE4L ¡¢£¤¥LL¦" ^C$%"

$%ABC/D®"#@.¯\°GT!

O¬±²³7´µ8¶·¸¹º7\°LL¦" F ¡{.»<¦O

¼O½¾uv"¿@=ÀG@ÁN F{|}*+VFÂ4\°

LL¦"h ¡{\ª*#";jP^C$%"ÃU¯ÄÅ #"§*ÆÇ"ÈÉ=¦jTN@OÊ¦PË~ $%AB C"aO@¦ÌÍÁSTª*+ÎÏhÐSTÑÒÓ]Ô<Fª;

ª ÕC$%"abÔ<§*Ö{4°×VO;OL¦]!Pj ABCØQÙ°Ú$%"#@Û;Ü uvÝ¥Þßàá2=âN j$%VABCØQÙ\°ã"ªOäå¦P$%æ"aO@¦AB C=pçv!L4Nj.è¸¦µ8´¦;OéOêë

\Oäå¦P678ÊV^C_`\ÕC_`"ìíîïðî Uññò#"ó¬!P

jLôõU¦LN@ ö$%Ç÷ø ù.öúû9:4ù;<¦Püy k^

l6mn:"aO@ý]!þNjÇ"O@ . ãL=KjG=¦VPj" "

4E"ôN@õ4>®¦?T!@aÜ d"

Võ\@T!@OPy.2)¯"#

®¥C|

Wf

(22)

!"#$"%&'()*+,-./ 0123 456789:;<=5>?@ABCDEFG )*HIJKLM6

NOPQ!RSTUVWLXYZ[\]^PQ!I_`

JabcdefghijD7ZLXkBlmnopqrXs(

tu\]^hvSnwMxyXy)*Bzh{|}D~

I_M6[\MI_MDNO

28Xabt>`Jabc

65dec-defghijDH

pL ¡M]^ )*¢£d¤¥gH¦

yp8M6

¨ ³´8Xµ¶ij ·*n¸]^¹ª«¬®

6ºB»!I]^;¼e½]^¾¿LXÀbnºMÁ 8nÂÃX;§¨ÄÅÆÇÈI«É)*Ê$nËVIM ZÌÍËHÎ]^ÏÐLXÑÒ{|}H8M6 u\]^nÓILMHÔÕMÖ×[\]^ YÑ

ØÙH=8M6EÚÚÚ(p¿8ÚÛ(ÜnJÝILM H78rÞÞFßqª«¬®à^EÛÚßqfáâãä8X åËæçMäz6ÑÀbD@Ade§¨è²]^

)*éê"éÄ¶ª«¬®@AëìéçícéîÏéscè²§

¨ Ë Xy]^5ï¶ª«¬®§¨ðñ-ÑÒ òæn|}j>?kóôõnº_MÌåË86ÎÀbö

¸MDÎ÷BCY_øùúûüHS8^ýFrXÎÀb<þ úév8M6

rX7ª«¬®I¾+,IL²«É ¶ª«¬®677MZ²«É ¶

¡iPQ!kB

Eý

(23)

!"#$%!&'()!*+,-./!

0123456789:;<=*+>?@AB*CD>

EFGHI>JBKAH^LMNOPQRBSTUBVW>XYH Z["\]^R_`HBabcd>Iefghijklm>

?@AEFGHnop!0Sqrp!0TUst>uvv R_`H#wxyz{|}~>IKRH

>vNIefH]

Z[XYHTU%VWRKAROPRKA

YHN

sfLr>A]yRH-R]

¯°R_A±eR²`A³´Rµ¶·:>¸¹AHI º»¼½>?@A¾fR*¿PNY¼ÀÁÂÃÄÅR

@P«BÆ|ÇR¿A]IÈÉ>ÊHO ËÌÍGTU%VWHI¾fHN

]ÎÏÐÈ]ÑÒÓÔÕÖ>?@A×Ø¾ fR*¿PNOÙÚÛÎÜÝÞßàáâãäåRHáæR_A

]ÚRGH¥ÎÏÐÈwx*_çèé²RHNG*êë]

R_`HìídîªïYR]>ð¹PæñRò5ósB*ÎÜÝÞ ôõö÷ROËÁÛ>øGHùYfeHNKKúûüý×ßþ lüý)RfeHáåRvA]RØ FKPf]%îk>KPRÈÉÊfe AAHI¾f*¿PNI KPÓÔÅ]

¥ÎÏÐÈR¿AªKP ÷>KvvIeRßày

<=>ãYf%VW>ÌÍKA«I¹ å] üü

L

(24)

! "#$%&'()*+,-./012)345 6789 !:!3;<=>?@2! ABCD"

EFGHIJ'%KLM$NKGOP! QRS TABUVW XYZ[\%]^!1UV<_`a bc%KLMc'deNKGf #$:

ghhi !"# $%&

'()*+,-

-((+,./+0(1jkkg23# 43#5 !"# 673! 8 8#" 9" ! :#" 7 ";3

$(,<=>?(+

@+1(jkkk3A#"B#8# C"! B3## D#! E-

$(+F(+G=-()

=+,+,-= G* ' (= =+ H-(-+-I=+ J#3 K3! 3 7 3C3C8 D#3 !

(+, (-./*LM+(/,-+jkklNA#"7 !;4CCOAP Q3# 433C 4R3 SD8#" D#S'H '( G* HT(I,,+,(G-+ ,U(+

/(+U=.)*+,-(++jkkmV+G+(+TU-%+3D;#C /0+(-. (+U-jkkmW !!3#"9"A

D#! PX 343"! YZ" K 83WC[#3\=-,V+L ](\,+

$+&(,jkklW4#8K3!D#! jkkj^jkkiE-$(+F(+G=-(

)

$_I/+(jkkg`J#3 !\=a =U-+ b(=,)(jkkj#"3A3c7 ";3#!

deJ#3 !36D!343 #"[ !#4"!f 3gZ3 ;h # 7Pde\=+a =U-+

H)(+Gjkki#"9"AD#! F= '($?T H+'jkkn !"#4R48J#3#!3:3Z3CCM

F)*

opq=>rstuvw xyz{

| jgh|

(25)

!"#$%

&'()*+,-.)'()/ 012341567

89:;5<=>5?=@AB33C &'( DE3F0GHI7 JKLMB33 DNOP#QRSETU%&'(VW01X

4167

YZ[\]^_5`^abc B332 -dEefSNOP#gh ij%kKlmA &nopqr0s.)tu/v BXw7

xyz{B33B -dE|}~EES%

&'V,-.) 01C4167

xyz{B33 &-dE|}efS%E0

*`X7

xyz{B332 Eij%&*067

«^0¬®7

¯°±B33 ²yn³NOP#´yn³|}´yEµ¶%&n·)

¸V01X4167

¹Kº»B332 ¼[½N¾#¿/ÀÁ|}ÂdÃÄEÅT%

&ÆÇ.)'()ÈV01B24167

¹Kº»B33X ¼[½|}ÉÊEËo%&ÆÇ.)'()È V01BX4167

ÌÍn³ÎÏn³ %ÐÑvÒn³E

-ÎÏ-%ÐÓÌÔ#7ÕÖ×EÐØNÙÚÎÛÜ ÝÞvhßÌÈ%àÔáÈ-%EâØÎãÔ#7

×EäåæçEvEDEr|èEéêNÜÔëvxyz{ìE E*+B33BvB33vB332 NéáÔ7

íîEïðÊáëñò5óô5õUö÷øùúNOP#

ûÃÄüEýþN¾#

7àOv v`^abB332 vJKB33 Û7 !"#$%$&'()#*+,-../!02C

1! 0 !2%+)(3'()#*+, 4() 56$4(3)(7#()6$7 &68 9,%$4 4() :(6,3*+($ ;#$+(#, -..<= >?+%$*($ $6,&,($=

@63%88($+%A,3#*+()$>!0B33XàOv×EB333FE/

EçN~ vFº #ÛE"ëÔ#7

ÆÇ.)'()ÈV 1416

BB3

(26)

!"#$%&"'"()"(*$"+,-./#,-%"(+"01!"-"02

3

!" #$%

&'( 4 )*+,-.'

56 789 6 4 /0123456)*7-.'

+ 37 89:; <=>&?@AB-.'

:;5 5<= 3> <

< ;?6 6

8CDEF=GHIJKLMNOPQ@;;>>>6 -.' 8HRS0TUVWR=XY;Z[ \]5-.'

^P1_!` aZ bc

d d

(27)

ドイツ統一後の自治体財政：地域間格差の現状と施 策

¶ · ¸ ¹

ドイツ統一後の自治体財政：地域間格差の現状と施策