カナダ少年法制におけるダイヴァージョンと修復的司法

全文

(1)人間関係研究（南山大学人間関係研究センター紀要）, 3, 148-169.. .

(2) . . !. ". ÙÚÛÛÜÝÛÞ. .

(3) . .

(4) . . . !"#"$%!& '() *+,-. ./01 234 /562,7/89:;2< =>?,@A')BCD,EFGHI (JK LM)N=2+&OPI Q7EF

(5)

(6) RKS

(7) ,TUV2<W

(8) WX ` . YZ[\] '(I 7^ _)'*"W+&/ab 89:;cdI W. @M& e7N=2fghiI 2,7^. j+,kl7mnopqrstab89:;uv,wx,yQz7 ^ *{( W/|}BCD~. W 2,7^. . Qb:; IN,7 . !& * 2N +,h . !& {7^ * . ~. Wmnopqrsty/+,e /. @¡D,7¢ab89:;£I {uv 2Wv!& ¤BCD¥ ,¦§¨©ªt«cd7 {¬ ®!&W¯°,!@¡D±² ( {³BCuv3´µ #u ¶·@¡D3¸¹ºv& {`¯°D,7»¯° ¼½¾¿°À½Á')UÂcÃv& {ÄÅCÁ') ¯°ÆÇ,ÈÉÊËÃv& {ÌÍ,7ÎÏÐÑ ')@¡D,BChÏÒÓBChÔÕ ÒÓ7Ö×. ―148―.

(9) ( {ßàáÂz,âãä ¯°D~. WÌÍåæ,ç. kèéê ( {ëì,7íab89:;£ I îï,ËNðYñ,òËÃj( {ó3ôõ.ö÷ø ú . !& D,ËNðYñ,òËÃj( {+&ù&!& * Lû!& mnopqrst/JKXYZ[ Pü6 Wj+&ý)LM(I 2,7/7 þ jXYZ[AM1¯°D~. WÌÍBCD,,. àáÂzâãI W(º70Sþ)X YZ[II 2,7^ _({7 * #. ,´,®/ª,KXYZ[Y qÌÍ, UÂc:Ò

(10) mU å,öV:Ò"7j( ëì, u6I '()W,/ L,

(11) mNë ¤¯ . °D¾°Dâ«¨[¥,Qzg7^)W_M& * L ,

(12) m N ë / | W I @N. =, 9!v!& uva . . /a:; . ,,0h& . WÂ,2^)W*y7D,8?@A, =ëþ '(I N89:;6:;Õ '(I ,u7Q b,I W{ *{( W / `ë6,NBCD !! ` `ë6,N89 "# . . ! "7y & *NBCDN89 / 456)u)W@Njab:;LI :Ò ,mnopqrst ,¹ºv& {)W . ,7^ *.

(13) mNë mnopqrst,

(14) < Á 5± W(º7~. Wmnopqrst,. ' NI h,_HI { W* y/¤¥(v& ¤c¥ /¤¥ Wj. . ¤¥ /¤a¥I{uv+&ù&,SM' )W v& {^j01 26 W/)*{& /,-.34756 W. +,. nqr%D') uv7^ * ` T¤NëìnªY,N ¥Û a G

(15) 89:;`. ―149―.

(16)

(17) . !" #$. %&'() *+ ,-./0,12, 3456)78*9 :;<=>?@A(#

(18) &BCDE338FG H .

(19) . . ! " #$$%& '( )%IJKA(#

(20) L8MNOPQRSTU

(21) STU&VWXY&Z[\]^J_à&b\UJ 7 c=de"fNghOijWklNOiNUL8

(22) +mn o4 p6E33E8HqrIJKE3338stJuvwL8 $ ) E8 x`)HE6yz{|&}~&uvw&L 8MNOPA(#

(23) Z&UJ *. +

(24) . ,( . -. ./(/+ + . . . 01 + . 2 . 1 3 4 + 04 . " #$%5& ) 0 3 4 + 6 2 + 7 , 8' '( 99%: ;#< . . 1 . = 7 > ? 1. @( A ? =1 @ ? . 2BC . > ? ? + . D E 2F/

(25) E . 0. ? . +> 2. " #$%)& )) G. . . 7 = . , 8 3 4 + ' ( )#% < CH * + 3 4 + . . F/ I 4 D. ' ? . . . 2 . 1 /. + . ? D ? " #$%9& JK 0 3 4 + 0 2 + E7 '( J#% <6 ? 1. + L( > ? 1. 3 4 3 4 + . . F / D ? / + 7 " #$%M& J% 0 D 7? 1+ E7'( K$ <6 . + : D ? + : =. . += 6 ? N4. 13 4 . ? O P Q R S TS S U O! ! VW X Y ZP U S [ U \ U Q! \ ] U U U ] ^[U ! ! " #$$K& ' '( #9J: )( "&A(#

(26) )+ H4E6E3338 E?" ¡W¢£A(tT¤yz{

(27) [¥¢£ A(tT|&b&¦_§+¨©Uª«)E76E 3338p ¬e"L8&A(#tT+?®]¯°±²@¨©&yzU³& A(DE33E8EH7 ´ µ&¶·¸"L8 ¹&º»EW¼½½@ª« L8 DQR¾¿À[¥@L8¨©{ D

(28) ¾¿À|+ÁÂ , E4Ã6E33E8)qrFG * 4+ 4 ,4? /( / 02'. 3 4 ? +>+ 4 . 1 _O TO ] TS S U O! ZO P Q Y Q ! . -7 , ? 1 . /+ `( D . L(3 ` 7 ` + + " #$$#& ' ( #)%ª«L8 &U\ #ÄÅZÆÇJÈ ÉÊËkÌÍÎÏZ #ÄÅÐÑ¶L8¨©{ &

(29) ¾¿À U&ÒÓvÔÆmJUÕÖ. ―150―.

(30)

(31) . L8XA(#

(32) U&"yz{W×z{%Ø+&Ù^ )3. Ú) H 8Z)78&µU\ÛUJÜÝyz{W ×z{%ØÞßàáZ&\ZâãäZß[¥&Ïåvæçèé\ ZÚ#ZL8ÈÉÊËkÌÍ³JvÆÇJI ZÛêëÎ¥[\Zâ)38n[¥)38n[ìíîïð ñògóðjfOiîMôWõöÍ÷øðùÍúfùð;ûÏY )). JÛUüýJ^þê&ÈÉÊËkÌÍàª« )E. L8XæZhífÍ&Õ&\Û ). UJ[t Z [¥

(33) Ý & U\&ÈÉÊËkÌÍª«L8 &¹[¥ \ ÆU«ýJ&\Z[UJ ³³ª«L8 ÈÉÊËkÌÍÄÅv Z[Û\Zâ³&ÆÇUIZZ [ÛvÛª«L8 &U\&ÈÉÊËkÌÍQR¾¿ ÀàZ&«U ÆUÆÇJÒ Ó&&\Û³Jª«L8 &[¥& ÈÉÊËkÌÍUü &ÈÉÊËkÌÍ& µUv\_ . &ÈÉÊËkÌÍUSU

(34) v# )H. «&vÕÖJª«L8 "JL8+ L8|& CJZL8 CZ[ÛvÛÈÉÊËkÌÍU vZJL8ÑµUIÛ Æ &ÈÉÊËkÌÍµUv\_Û&\³Ju vw& W EH´ &\ÛUüÑIµ&&ÈÉÊËkÌÍ&è

(35) I8. E W ? 4. §W{|& )7. . + UÛ&&\X{&ÎÏ\Zâ ³&L8&YëqZ[ÛÝ JL8JL8)E)8st vL8& ë¹ µUIÛ) /uvwL8 Ù) ÈÉÊËkÌÍ&v[JµUZÛ µJXü &ÈÉÊËkÌÍ &ë ë) µUIÛ Æ#µUv\ ÛöíËMÌÍWù i ËI

(36) W U þL8&Òv&æÒvZÞßrU. ―151―.

(37)

(38) . !"#$%&'()*+),- .(/#$. 0123456789:;<=>?'@),-" AB8C$D 0( E56FGH7A I:; A B8B$0( EJK567LM NO E;FG78 P:QRST; EUV<WX> ?YZ[\]("^(_+-àbcdefHg h),( "(V<WX>?YZHijklHm+n 7AI;. o(p". qrstuvw^x_yz@{mM|+V<WX>?YZ }~ _("@ 6 yz7;Hm"_+-q rstuvm *_yz("!)_m. 7#$<Z ¡¢M£¤¥|¦ +§yz¨w_m©(mª«"m+;+§ yz¬ |O®O¯°_±²v³6´µ¶·¸¹º @_» ¦_¼½56¾@¿ÀHm_!+ 7AÁ;. !"),-+§ Â|#$0DÃÄvwV<WX>?YZÅ Æ Ç07¥. ;stuÈÉ%&567ÂÊ. ;À». ©§ËÄÃ+),-ABI9$Ì§"+Â|ÅÆÍÎ ÏÐÑÒÓÔ V<WX>?YZMÕÖ_0®5@×m+¦ «) Ø7#$ÙÚLM #$<Z ¥ ÛÜÝ;Þ7ßàáâ; jãä0åæ 7Aê;. çèH+éÓ|m-ABÁ9$Â|#$0DÍÎÏÐÑ ÒÓÔ "ëº_. 7A B ;. ¢âìÌ)íîïðñéÓ|m-. Ì+ ABÁ9 $0åDÏÐÑòóÒÓÔ ôf#$V<WX>?Y ZõöH ÷øÑùúûü7ý4¢yþm+Ç0 û #$ÙÚ¦du>;. [. 7 #$OÅ !

(39) ¢øÑ ! y. '![ý4yzÏ; yUV<WX>?YZ 7+#$y(U yd 7 . .

(40) ; ; ì E

(41) E 7 O E :Ø O E >YZ øÑ øÑ+¨ ì; FGl ¶H 78P;. m+ #$Ç0vwV<WX>?YZFG70 ü; ( u)ÄÃN,+ABIP$!"ABÁP$!w Â |#$070;±²º),7;m!vm # $V<WX>?YZ56()ëºH,+-+« . ―152―.

(42) aZ A BIB $0@{mUV<WX> 78A;. ?YZ56H #$ÙÚ0)FG_%&. . )»Hm+- ÷ý4!"ÙÚLMÒÓw +yþ(>YZa>UÈ V<WX> ?YZ(_Lm >YZa>(Í4V <WX>?YZéÓH Í4ÜÝ:ØH >YZ a>( Û#$*ïðñd7Ú øÑd_;ÈH+¦«) . !". %&(l+),- ABêP$Z>WX>e) Â|#$CP (. !"%&§"+m-. Z àZ>e`Zavm@ Í4(LØ

(43) H+¦«) #$Û*ïðñÉ¡7;d V<WX>?YZ>>(Èm¦ Ç0 788;. FG(1î"m+-Ì+ Z ) ?YZ>Ñ( ÌÌ_V<WX>?YZ¾mHùúûüH ABÁP$ Z>7uZ; d7 >; ó d7ZdZ; >7V >; 78;. (Mm+(nom-L0(H ë º±²7;(m¦V0N¬£ V<WX>?YZ56m¦)@p"+),7A P ;U 7Á;

(44) ABÁC $Ze >)Ì+-© .

(45) ABÁ9$!"M¦_+m7A A ; ! "# " $ % % $ &' % ( ) *+, -./ / 0 ,10 23 4 5 4 6 3 0, 14 70*+, -./ / 0 ,10 6 , 8 , 1 ! " 9 . # #.

(46) 9 : ; ! < ; . = > ? @@A

(47) B CD. :$ E

(48)

(49) ? 7A 8; AB 8 C $D0(O|Ì+ÜO| m¦O|7. . ;»ïÊ)LH+ ÙÚ#$O#$(øÑÜ_@Hp" _» Zdfjã_@_m+7A ;) " F G6 H 0 6 +, / + I4 7 05 H 0 ,6 J 05 4 6 3 0K L 4 0 I , 1M 4 M I3 4 + ,87 6 J 1 0 ,N2 O0 H 6 0 P+ /4 70Q6 4 0 4 0> ?@BA

(50)

(51) R% RS 7A C ;; T . *+,-./ / 0 ,10 Q P> ??RA

(52) UB 7A 9 ;(V ;

(53) WWR 7A I ;9 : # X

(54) "F". &D *+, -./ / 0 ,10 23 4 ( Y . $ Z. # [ . ?

(55) US. ―153―.

(56) .

(57)

(58) . !"# $%&'()*+,-./01. 23453-60789:;<=>?"8@A60BCD E'0( FGHI'0 JA38K*( LMCN,8 OP'(*0/$ Q*R(*0S T ! " # $ %# & '( )* # + , & $$+ # # & %( )- %+ . . + %/) %, 0 1 2 3 4 3 2 51 6 72 899:9 ;<= >? @A@ = 4 >9? @ B @A 1 @ 2 6 8BB2 @ @ 1 2 3 4 3 2 51 6 7

(59) C CD D UVWXY8K*(. Z[\F]^T_àbcdS eE+ %+ * # " 0& '# F &. + , + # & "G % " ! . H1 IJ ? 2 8A 3 2 6 @K2 @ =@ =L9K; M >? @A@ = N3 2 6 2 @ ? O ? 93 P 8BB2 @ @ J? > 93 A ? Q K L I2 3 9@ 2 @ >3 96 @ = 1 2 3 4 3 2 51 @ M6 @

(60) C D UV WXY8K*( Z[\F]^Tfg`cdS fg R! S ' &" $ &$$+ * * + & %& '! %! ! 42 ? 2 &" T+ %U V! "W&

(61) C fE! , &%! . ( &F %X ( )* # + , ' & "Y&)% UV " * &%*! %H1IZA A : ? M6 @

(62) C ! %! + ! %&, + ! .&" T -+ S

(63) D ff " . + %! %X. . ! " 1>? 9 %&# D 8h' B ij>kl mWXY n opqrsotu vw8xy-z{ |0B }~ 8 -z{|0B o ~ 8W-G60B a $qxWQu 8C*-G60B 8~-|( oE-60B *8z60 -¡8¢£|

(64) o|0B ¤ x¥¦§ ¨¢\©ª8-z{|0B «¬WQ+® ¯§-°7±$ ot8²60³J ¯§-´µ ¶B *±C $·pS f¸ + # * $! D # " # E! " U ! % G" ! F! $ # S! " # X. # " %! # + - E ! * )" *! % " -+ , *' & "Y&)% U [' ' % " *+ % [%# ! " + & + % H1@ =\ ] 1 @ 2 6 ;899:2 9 J ? > 6 @ 2 + # ^ 0 [_ + . . 0D `. $+ %U aF&$! *! % ! " " 0 . ! " T

(65)

(66) . . .

(67) . eT¹º»¼½E¾o'¿& À ÁÂÃÄÅ8¢Æ(s oÀ-ÇÈ ÉÀÊËÃÄÅ8¢Æ60ÀÌ( Í¢S¿& À @À ÎQ0Ï§\ÐÑ8z(_Òm ÓÔÕ-Ö× ØºÒm( q¿& *8Ù*( . ―154―.

(68) 8ÛQ*ÜÝ$ ÞE ßà-áEQ*BC$s0 ÓÀ8C âa ßà-á0BC$s0uãäåÒæçS B èw-éê( ºä ËQ8ë0ëìßà! . # " D % ! # + -$ ! * ) " * äÒ8Ù*( 9:;<=>?"íî8z60èwà ' $·0Sï' ÓÔÕ ØðÒm$·0q8ÛQ*Ü Ý8Ù/0LHñòÜ xó ÌÜu*±Hôõç8Cö÷60C f¹. $·pS . ºä8h' qø *8K*( ab8èw60HI-Nù 60ö8Üp( ÓÀ8Câ8ë0ëìßà-ú*0B $s0u'åÒ ï UVWHI( nëìßàû ü7 Àýþ ü w-./ij# í$·0 Bç } =

(69) - D±$ ëì ßà úBïÊ'0Bç ij#8K*( N,QÖ-./±$ c8K*(Kxó8@A60B ç @A8( -8

(70) ±$ 7 öÏWQ-P60Bæç ø

(71) 8K*( ³J-ü70Bç ø

(72) $ 45QB8K*(N, Q-%(*0Bõç ¤Q*B. ç èw'Sí ø

(73) z{ z-vü (*0ö Ùh8Ù/0Ë- 60ö8. ëìßà o Ö¨8E'¼Òç çSëìßà ú. -80C 'Qp HP3 8 p( ëìßà XY/$N,F'0ö 8 LHWQ* JAW8E'0sC '(* ºÒç çSB 7 ëìßàEËQ86*± ëìßàij#o otQ¿&('0ö a8

(74) ·ÝQ**±8Qp(* $·0S ëìßà ² À

(75) \XYQ8K*( À( ¿& À8 ÞE èwCà'M . Å$ . f. 3âQp*±/$ Q* 6(

(76) ûE8. xV8Ù/0UV8E'(*SBB8C9À8Ù/ 0 .

(77) , 3Ü×'(ÙÝ 8"!û$ À~-60B8CQp $·0S ºä 9:;<=>?"( ëìßà

(78) ¾- 8Üw|M8 *Q08Ù*(C

(79) ¾±0C ((*S

(80) 8. 8hp(

(81) ¾Üw'(*h±$·0Sâ $ F ëìßàú'(* F8Ü0 =\" lû û Å=û lû. ―155―.

(82)

(83)

(84) . !"#$%& '() *+, 45. ./01236 789:;% *<=>1?@ABCDEFG 4U. HIJKLMNOPQ>RNSRT6R@NVW XY01ZST23TZ6[\#SABN0]^]S 4`. _J01aPbc23NdeGfgeGhijk ldeGmnFodeGmpqfrqstdeGfuv wx6-1>y"z{|f}~ N?& < CDS @ EFmg ¡¢m £¤S¥Z@CD¦§ EF¨©ª«¬ N&®2789:ABS¯T2Z36°losNCDEF GH±²³2´?>1 4µ¶·(¸¹ º»¼#¶½ 2¾¿TMCDEFGHO\2deGf geGhiÀÁ23-RÂÃ6]deGf geGhiÄÅ#ÆHÇÈ#Sjk-R>&1ÉCDEFG HÊ789:NÄÅ#ÆHÁËÌ12Ì01Í233Î3 4Ï. ./NÐ3ÑÒÓT236 789:tÔGÕÖ×T2ÍØ&®ÙÚÛ2NlEFÜ Ý0Ã]ÞTßà#á¨âoEF¨â ãäsEF åæ Àç¨zèéê2ë\#ì¤íîïð2ë\ #geåæñò¨íîóCDDôõCD¨ö÷}~ø |ùúû¡¢éüýþüt&deG µ. íîÑ./01236-ZSÍØÚÛP #Z1É ( ¹ ZT2

(85) uv SGNÑ EF¨@1 23S3G>1-S6è789 :2 ( ¹ NÀçECDPtÔ· !"2EG t# SEF °

(86) EéSTC . Dt2%3>1T6 789:32N·(¸¹ f

(87) (CDÆH< v 5Ï¶ZS# CDEFGH±× ¹ f(£vZS f\ - 4. çÙRTZ6[\#NCDè ( ¹ £J

(88) |Ú&ï@132 . è 013H>1236 CDEFGH¥789:32N@03- . . T2 ( ¹ ÑM&¬R>N×J#. ―156―.

(89) S>16R@ÑÒR>789: á¨./01236N[\#;% *<=>123 -ÂáN¶J&Ú½Â áT6 . [\#;%ÂáçNCDEFGH H78 9:QRRÂ>@[\ <=>1 *

(90)

(91) 789:Ã 3MÂT 236@1N¬H &@[\#;% & * åæ

(92) 01R3H `5UDy SáÜÝ&T6· N×ÊàH P y"9:-ÙÎ3¶JN78 9: NS3iR>@\ <=>12301

(93)

(94)

(95)

(96) 5. 6@

(97)

(98) NÊ789:NÆ H¥#S( S #S(Î A O 3MR>>1 (

(99)

(100) >1S3NÊ& ! " # $ % #&'(! )"$ *# % % & + Î ¶ ¶ &2 CDt& ´?

(101)

(102) , . / 0 12,

(103) ( 3 3 3. $ 6 -1t2±N ¶NO NSÑA 2i01®Ù2789: N&á

(104)

(105) ,-. / 01 2,

(106) 4 5 6( 3 @:AB<=>1®Ù

(107)

(108) 78 . 918 :,

(109) 4 5 6( 3 6R @K¦?2&Þ

(110)

(111) ;< = 1 > 4 56( -áNH#?2Sùú &-ST2]T6

(112)

(113) NK Ï``D 2 EFEGtÔ&789:@1ZT2k T236Ï`` DyNCDEFGHÚ& ( ¹ 2789:O XY01è±H±. Âá01-ST6 789:%ùú3MN·@1y" * S >16-1NCDEF GZt² &R3ÆH±Â·N78 9:#%&Ñ

(114) ²³ B²Ù U. 3ÓT236-1t2·y" *N. ―157―.

(115)

(116)

(117) !""#$ %&'()*+, -./012345$ 6789#9:;<. =,9. #>?@:!. A 9B,. CDEF$GH# I9, JKLMNOPLQ# 9. RS KT$UV

(118) 9. WXHYZ$[\;. <]^ _`KTabcM$daeB,9. Cg h E. #"f

(119) ] !. ijklmn co pq012#

(120) Krs9,tueB ,v co2tw

(121) ] ! JB=I9, x yz{I9,|wc} "#~{n M $v9"# MI9,$M$n

(122) Cg E. v9"# $#,

(123) eB,9 !. #,. "@:$]^: "#n

(124) v9

(125) ]f:! j l$mn ~KI9,|w 2 ¡¢{ C E|wc} £

(126)

(127) ¤¥C. .

(128)

(129) C§E. E|w

(130) ¦^@: !£. 01os9, ¢{¨©C . . E#ªKwn$wW=B ¨©«¬C . E e?0. CE. #9:;<=B I9,A®{n. ¯°da ±²

(131) 9#³´B !µf ¶c M·@:¸ #9:RA.

(132) ] !. A "R. I9, 01z{¹2 º»¼½´9©¾¿ÀÁÂ ##CÃjklÄ jklE I9,JÅÆUÇ "#@,CijklÈE M¸@:#,9. !. ©¾¿Év,Ê "# U=ËeB9"# A.

(133) ] C ! ". # $ . % # & ' ( ) * +, .". # E! "BO, ij$ ÌI9,ÍÎÏ$SÐ

(134) v9ÑÒ ,9. R# ÓÔÕÖ×ØÙÚ

(135) v. 9,mn,9. ÛÜÝ9CLQEI. R vÞßÇ

(136) ]. #>?@:!. ÌS, ÍÎÏ àpÎáSÐ

(137) v ÏÎáä´å ?. Câã. EA®

(138) C /0 1 )23. 4. 3 E æJBâç "#

(139) v. C . 56 789 :;7 6 <( 1 2%$= ! ". # $ % # E!" R/èéêëìíîMïCpðñME¶òB. Aóôõ#9. :´®

(140) 9$ JR9ö÷øù#, úb¼½s® «¬Mn

(141) v9 û¡$^üýº¼#,$ eB þM$eB,9. CE.

(142) ] !% Ó. W ÔÕÖ×ØôÙÚJz{ u2$]^: / èéêëìíînJBU,s#9: 2?=B !ÌÓ. ―158―.

(143) 9B /èéêëìíîO 2 3àp#J ^ #:

(144) ]^ /èéêëìíî

(145) ? ¶cR# CgE. ,eB,9 ! s x2#,#9:R= 01z{¹2 01º»Â9,9

(146) è×èîU Ç,99"##¹Â ò,9 R

(147)

(148) 9 CE. !. # Î$eB,9. ": ;<

(149) § 1

(150) )#, 2x. Kr#u2$,9. !h§1. æ

(151) ëìë×î#ë × s9,

(152) . "v. C E. è W# )v$=eB . C E. CE. ChE. -(F ëìë×î è u2#,K "# ! -./2)#I

(153) ]^ Krs9, Q £

(154) . ,9. $ J K §§ 13n01ÍÎ2. ®B=. !" 12 01z{. ¹2ij#mn,C jkllE ¿z{¹ O /èéêëìíî 2Ð? õ:

(155) ] #>,@9!£. !JB 2. CE. $ xJBA®.

(156) . FDF@,ÑeB. ~01. 2S ëC 1E /èéêëìí C§E. î#, #·£,9 012Ñ . ! Jæ. CE. s9, 2Ut. /èéêëìíîcM$daeB @:. $01ÍÎ2#¬v$B,9. !"@:.

(157) ] !. C E >

(158) . ? @ A . B . C DE6 9EF9 GC H9 9 E6 8C : IC 8C 6 7J K L HM N L E 6 : OEPPN 9 9 C C E8 OG76 Q C RS 6 C C 8N 8Q T UN L S J EL V6 C 78M C L EJ V9 N E8 UN L S V L L N E 8L + -@B /èéêëìíî "@:c #·£= CEx #9: 2ØXHÜ

(159) O

(160) O A#eB,9 ! CE$

(161) W @ . ,X L VD6 7 - -@B 2rö #OI9, @:? Ç,9 #eB ! #, y012Ø CW .

(162) ,E

(163) ] "# pðñp6

(164) q 01Ð? "# Ì¹#q¹ O, da "# Óº»c 0 "# 01 ¾¹ $üý ". ―159―.

(165)

(166)

(167) !"#$%&'()*"#$ +,-./01# 2345678

(168) 9:;<=>?@ <ABCD+#$ECDFGHIJKLM"#NO #MP QR"#$SCD TUVWXYZ[\01(]($ ^CD_`LaU[bcXde`f[g[h +#$iCD jk]lmnopqrsnopt

(169) (]($uvw`xyzw` {nxyzw|]jk}z]($%~dK"# +#$ 'q'(t

(170) (#$+, 3@8 . .

(171)

(172) . . . .

(173) . !. " # .

(174) . ". . $ % & '( ) &$ * ( + & , * & . /0'1 '* & ' * ( 2' )32. ( 2 '2 45 26) & . '7, 2) * ( 2'

(175). 8 9 . : . ;: < = 9 . . .

(176) > ?@@?A B 38C C # D

(177) !

(178). EF G2'HI4 4 & '7& 0+ *> JBA K = ;

(179) <. < L !. < BJK 38M . . .

(180) N NO N

(181) . 9

(182). @O B F P . . . . . . . Q Q . D

(183) " R

(184) .

(185) GI0. G2' HI4 4 & '7& S( 2 ( * ( 2' /5& & + * ( % & 2' 5 ( '+ ( ) & ' 75 + * ( + &

(186). 8 9 . T> JA NM . . . " ;. = R O :

(187) < ;. " ##

(188) 9O . ! . . UV L 9O M. #. D. " ;

(189) ?B KBO JK . T

(190). .

(191) ! W .

(192) G2' HI4 4 & '7& 0+ * ET " ##.

(193) 9.

(194). . > BA ? X !

(195) 9 R < < ; < . BB . : . ;. W D .

(196) Y" ; ,* * &Z& 2' & * 2G2* [3 ( .& /032' ( 7& * ( 2 '245 ( '+ ( ) & > A KO J@ 3 86Tn3 8 3 ?D8 @¡,]¢" . " . C F

(197)

(198) . . EF M

(199) . R L

(200)

(201) !

(202) > JA @L D.

(203) X !

(204) 9 < . KO J\. . . C.

(205) . D

(206) . DR L

(207)

(208) !

(209) > JA @ L D.

(210) X !

(211) 9 < . J 3 8M . . . .

(212) N N?]¢W.

(213) 9 R

(214) T

(215)

(216) . 9 Q. 0) * & ' * ( % & ]& & 5 2H ./ 52) ( + - '7 5 2+ & 7 & ] ' ) > A 3?8 F G2' HI4 4 & '7& 0+ * /F D =

(217)

(218) . . $ % & '( ) & $ * ( + &( ' 3 ' 7 /0 ^[& 2 & * ( +. ) ' 7 0' ) * ( + )0 & .& '*

(219). 89 " L 9 #. L L ;. . . W . > ?A . ―160―.

(220) O . .

(221) 3 8

(222) . 9

(223) @JC . L . . C F \ .

(224) 9 =

(225). L

(226)

(227) G2' H I4 4 & '7& 0+ * . : . : . ;. < . .

(228) KO F ;M L

(229) .

(230) N O B 3 8M . . .

(231) N NB F ;M L

(232)

(233) N ? O B 3 ¤ 8M . . . .

(234) N NN9¥/¦§¨© ª n«¬]®¯]zw&°±²³´µCD¶·]¸ ¹º

(235) »¼½¾~d K01(¿À

(236) (#, 3 8C . C #F G2' HI4 4 & '7& 0+ * ET L

(237) " JO JN > J K A ? . R <. = 9 KO N@ . W . : . #

(238) F YR R.

(239) !. R !.

(240) . _ 8 ET

(241) Y` . #.

(242) . a # . #.

(243) . DM # ! . .

(244) W . " . . . . .

(245) B ?J . : . ". V G2 'H I4 4 & '7& 0+ * E= # a.

(246). .

(247) .

(248) ! R L R # > A BT

(249) . O ". . =

(250) . JBO 0ÁÂÃÄ3@ 8ÅÆ ÇÈÉÊ, 3 @ 8]¢C D

(251)

(252). G2'HI4 4 & '7& '7* [ &b c> A 3 8

(253) . " # . !.

(254) . " . R

(255)

(256) =

(257) . . D" ##

(258)

(259). .

(260) . D TR R "

(261) . D

(262) " # . . ! L !. < R

(263) G2 ' HI4 4 & ' 7& 0+ *> A . .

(264) B 3 8 . . .

(265) ?J BN 3 8 ! . 9 F F

(266) R R ! . £ "

(267) # R W . !. . #.

(268) . . Y R. L R # > KNA U D : < . K N "

(269)

(270). d

(271) . . . R R . 9=. D L . .

(272)

(273) . .

(274) . . G2' H5& 2' ( '32'4 ) ( + *c( * [* [ &b c 0+ *> KKA U D. : < . ?@ . . T .

(275) N J F #. QW " ##.

(276) 9.

(277) G2' H I4 4 & '7& 0+ *> JBA K . ! . D . ?K F P . . . . F _ 8 e

(278) .

(279).

(280) . T

(281) Ea.

(282)

(283)

(284) . f. ! . . 3 & ' *1 & ( '$ % & '( ) & $ * ( + &

(285). 8 9" L 9 #. L W . . . . F P . . > J B A O N UV . . .

(286) N ?JO ?B]¢ÂÃÄ3?8, 3¤ 8 .

(287) N? 3¤ ? 8 .

(288) ?@? 3¤ 8 C . . .

(289) B B R R.

(290). Q T . C . . C 9. C L D . . D Yg 8 # .

(291) ". . !.

(292) . ―161―.

(293) . .

(294) . . .

(295) ! " #$ % &' ( & )* + &,& + * )-& )$ ./ $$ "$ %&0")1 23 3 & )4& ./ $ 5.) 67 + " $ * " ) "38 & * ) 9)4* ) ' ( & )* + &' $ * / &* ) :* $ " * / +;& & / $ * ( &< =>? @A > B C C . D E E F GE HI E JKG E F L M B. B. N. C I O . PH E < =Q? Q RI E SE . TE S . QU VE E . E F

(296) E

(297) M W.

(298) . M XE E I.

(299) M X S GS

(300) M C I Y N T .

(301) JE . EK E L S . S E

(302) 9 * #& )4 ,* " 4& ./ $= >< UUU? TE I K L I => Z [ SL \S T JSE T S < =@? SL . ] I M =>

(303) ^ K E L S . ^. !"#$%. &"""&'()*+, -./01023456789:;<=> ?@ABC D EFG ./010234HIHJKLMNOP QR&S#TUV%&""-&'() WXYZ [\L ][./010234^_àbcCdefghij klmnopqrst#. uvw&""-x'() yz{|. }~IS#$%&"""&'() *+, Uy x'()*+, ". E.

(304) G . XE S J ] S J JE E N T . M. . M SG_ . L . WG_ . L E TE G <I

(305) KS K E L S . ?< =>? U TE I `S E E @=A Sa []E. K E D =QA D> &RS T T b& )& c* ) 10"$ %' $ * / & 5d%* $ & & )$ %b& " $"3 $ %&9"##* $ $ & &" )' $ * / & ) 4e& 1 +.3 3 * < =@? fA f>V E S . T . g $ $ & 1 h3 " $ % &b& )& c +" 30"$ %' $ * / &< =>? =Q =A . .

(306) . xSS T$^_?=8; h0 138II5 5@ I78¡¢ ^>£¤8¥A8,¦; §¨©ª« ¬ ®¯ ¦°±²JKLM556³?¤8´µ¶. ―162―.

(307) H E _ S. . SE ¸¹78ºIyp5»¼@B ¥ ½¾ ¿ÀÁÂÃÄ$Å5= ¬ÆIÇ¬ÈÉ%Ê Ë ªÌbÍÎÏ%Ð §UÑÒU¬UÓÔÕ6³ Ï%Ö ©ª«×ØIÙ2J0×ÚÛ%ÐÜÖÁÂ @B,; ÝÞ«ßàI@ ´µá 013µáIâã5ä I@B¥A8,º @BåE¡¢5Iæ= ´µá5678½¾ç5ÁÂ78Ä ; èÝÞbßéI@êë^ìíî¥A8ºIï% ðÝÞñòó5ôõBíî¥ö÷5ëøB:I@£8ùúº IÉ% û½¾I@üýÎÝÞþÝ«ßI78ºIÏ% Û% @=8,B ¦I@;VÄ èÝÞ ñ5ß@íî¥ö÷5ëøBßé¥A8ºIï% ð©ª«U¬ øB©ª5?¤ ¦Ì5ôõBÍÎ7¥A8º IÉ% û§ÑÒI¬>6³78¥A8ºIÏ% Ù] 2M 5©ª«*

(308) ?¤ ©ªÌõ8³8 ¥A8ºIÛ% I×Ú@ ÝÞ I IB

(309) ¥A8ºI% >?=8, . ´µ¶; ÝÞ ¨ y¦°5é Bì5?8,Iì; ß5ÝÞ«ßI 78¥ 58I E M U S UÝÞÙ ] 2M=@±²b®IÄ Ä 58 ¥A8. Ä ,º_; üÜÝÞ«I¥y 013I@?=B¥A8> 5ø ó5>³_8ºI5øB, Iì; ´ H E _ S. . I8¥ U U®³8õ ¥;¥=5ø=_8,º; ÝÞ«5õ8 I5ÔI@ Â?C ¦¨íîåE 5Ô¥A8&SÄ &&Ä,B 01378± ²I@ U B;

(310) >78^_?8 ®¯¹>_&Ä « E L E . E 0KU0 0¥ìºI5ø=8&"Ä, ° ; ¦ó ^_ÁÂ78ºI; ¤ ¬å Ù] 2MI@ ©ª«I

(311) ª«I¥£8 E . . U U©ªÌE S Ù] 2 M¸¹}~ÁÂ785IøB&-Ä,º¥; Õ ø=B&""-R5; _^øB x . ¥A8,& " " R; ./010234¨\0K2i . ―163―.

(312) .

(313) . !"#$%&'()*+,- ./012%. &3456789:;< .

(314) =>?@AB C D0EF

(315)

(316) GH IJK#L M Y. NOPQ12RSTU( IJVWK#X Z[\] 12-^ _àbcdeWfgh_icV- jk,2lm-Mb no] pqVWVrs dtusv2llMDrcwExFy

(317) ztbW {|rZm}~V-{0 Vh2-[\]12 cdeW-Mq c0h

(318) ztbcVZ . |[\]12chJ J w/0 ¡¢D£^c¤¥. ¦/0 w/0§¨©-_àbW{0ª«¬®¯° Z b De±²³´ %µ¶·¸ab¹Wº»¼½E¾¿À-. DrÁÂÃdtÄÅb0 ceWZ º»¼½ÆÇºÈÉÇÊËÌ ÍÎÏ ÐV h±²ÑÒÓÔ2 Õ-UÖtb0µ×Ø-Ù_icyÖ cÁMbÚÛ hº»¼½ÜÝjk /0Þßlàá . cdeWDr{0Z±²Ñ´% âµeWÞß Vhjkwã Ö0º»¼½äåcE¾æç-è#abVWZ^ éê ëì>f]cíîïTðñ]c>òóaïT]c ôPQcõ ö/0÷øùúaûüEFùýêcúaÙEFù . óa-þÞabWZrWæçcd±²²´% hº»¼½ ³. jk w/0ãiî-þÁabVW{0Z[\]12 h ¡¢7 ^¦] 0-¹0a bV0ZµW±²³´%dt ab¹W[\]12

(319) h Ñ. ¡¢7 ÁVWl{0JÅbV0ZrW dt/busv2 Ö0q /0 h{0 l[\]12h^ º»¼½jk w ². no] qabVÁ{|r-ab0{0Z Ò . ! " #$

(320) % & # ' . (

(321) )* +,,-. -. . # &# // 01 2 345 6 / 7 89: ,at Û ½±²Ñ² 2 Ö0

(322) v ©!"#$vs@ %&'(vs)*+,-./us@12012 Ò´´´ Ñ²3Ú 4 5Z 67@Û8. ³ ÒYÒ3B@Û8. ―164―. Ò² ÒÑ3Ú4Zc;<= <.

(323) >? 6 @ 3A* + , , ,. B/

(324) * 7 .+ ,C +//

(325)

(326)

(327) * /# ./87 D +,,,E+

(328) 9 8 8*

(329)

(330) . Y F.

(331)

(332) # 2 345 6 7 + -8: 7C G 2 345 6 9 7,C H. . # G1 # # GH G I JK 3@ LMNO6PQ K MR6S 2 TM 5 K U A 5 P6 P @;35 6 ?V 3= A PQ ? AWM35 K 2* +,89. +701 X

(333) X YM 3 PZ [N N A P@A 5 2I\ K. # &] $ F # F G # ^. . ! 2 3 45 6 + + +7,: 97 0H! G ' &] _ `. % G X # * +,,9. 9 a G ! 1 ! ! + 7 7 ³ G 2 345 6 9 ,0' . .

(334) # 2 3 4 5 6. 7 + 8 Ñ

(335) . TA b cQ 5 A \ K Q MP 2Q PJA PK A P\ Q PZ # #] ^&* +,8a. /a70

(336) . ( . # JA PK A P\ Q PZ # #]'. F* +,8C. +aC 0^ 2 345 6. +-. +7+ +7, 0& ] 2 345 6 , B89 ² ;<= <dQ ? ? \ M\ e 2* +,,7. BB(* /# .7 7B* ( . ' .h[\] 12-^ º»¼½ 9qab0-{eWlMbh aµµcö ] vW{eÔ¶« /0lhcVV0Z.

(337) ! ". 2Ó Ö0h_ic2] WcV ÜÝ2lsab0Dr ceÚ]c2] `Wjk,2l xW us v2-M /0l üx _`/0 eWZV b 2ll[\]12MbÚ l -àVW-bµ 0h*+,no] ÛI/0[\]12-xVÁ{|r-ab0Z Ö0

(338) FVr ^¦¿Àh Drcbh#2Ó Aé/0]c {0JelDVZ Ö0Àhw, _ i:8@üxÖïT]xVe. W ] VÁÃC]clce VrZ #. b w[\]12 ÐVð WcV-2Ó ÐVhs-¹Áýc0ZÆ9 ÛI/0¤¥Õ î. ―165―.

(339)

(340) . . !"#$%&'()

(341) *+,-./012 34

(342) 5634789:;<=>?@ABC 1EF7. DGHIJKLMN1OPQ<R07ST [\]^_,B[,à[b. UV.WX<YZ. c[d[Ae. 8fgh-./08GHIJKLMNij 2klm,no [#A,ab9[AepqrFsdta. A,uvwx1yz{. |}~p79234 <?, [.d8 @{|GHIJKLMN A,eB 9Oyzz&,}1yz {|}~FF7 ta. ,8. ¡¢ £ i¤¥ ¦§¨©ª# « ¬®,A8¯,ewxSTC°&W±²³´µ¶ 1pq·7¸ª¹&W±²³´µ¶º»1pq·r78¼A ½

(343) &W±.¾. uv¿ÀÁ8~ÂÃ?.. Äd ÅÆÇ#A,euvwx9ÈÉG¸b,ÊËDGHIJK LMN1OÌ

(344) 0¸b,ÍÎÏª, ¡ÍÐ&7@Ñ <ÒÓ8¯,`ªeÔÕÖ|¬¥ ×, .ØÙ[AÚÛ"¥ ¦§¨©1pq 79$Ü4GHIJKLM N!,B.Z,µÝÞÎ1r7 ß¦&©1à á79dsGHIJKLMN A,eâ B. d¸A9uvÛ" ãAäå. A,9. ¦æÆçè[A9éAêë¯#yzìx.^í< [¿. A[AB ¡ ,e-./09yz1ì. x7&'îï1 7A¡ðñ4²³´ ò9 A[A¯,e GHIJKLMNYZ[ó. ,ôõöN÷m<øùú. AB ûÖ,[dc

(345) . ,CDGHIJKLMNB. .ü[8¯geB¡ð-./Ì

(346) ýþ¸b, Ê349ÊËDGHIJKLMN@Ñ ¸ôõ öN÷ùú A,`#ªAeÔÊ34 . ,ÕÊË [AÛ"Ú9ÙsdÊË.[AÛ". U.ÊË çèêë®Û"d kÂsdZsb8¼kÛ"8 . ,ab9[. A[Asd . £ D

(347) ,PQ<R0 [k8 ã,89[Ae siñ [

(348) ýþsdGHIJKLMN9 ij. ¸dtwx1Ì0rCë7ª,tÌsd. äå.d. A,[Ae. ―166―.

(349) -./09234 ò,Bª#ÈÉG¸ b,ÊËDGHIJKLMNª[CD¸b,GHIJK LMNij À

(350) A,eÈÉGÊËDGHIJKLMN@Ñ< ÒÓ,uvwx8¥ ¦§¨© 8# «¬®,B ª#1 <9¯,87234Ö Ä#A, ¯,e.#-./08<[DGHIJKLM NST Ä,¯. cª8Åt0.ÙD

(351) A,2. 34 !^[b Ô 8T. c[d¬ÎÏ5634 6X [b. oÔ9¡Ä[A¯. c[d[AeÅt0¿n. c234 <Ö Ä. ôõöN÷ùú,uvwx,s9[Ae . 9

(352) .@Ñ<£[AA 9¯,8. Åt0w D

(353) ,GHIJKLMN ,B Z,8¯,eOuv.yzz&} @. ,Bsd1yz{|}~p7z&¸b,Õ. ùQz Ù[0 ,ª BÚ1yz{|}~FF 7 tB8

(354) ¯ £®,PQ<R 0 tB8Ù ã A,ab9[A a ,eÔ @GHIJKLMN ¥ ¦§¨©µÝÞÎ ß¦&©A8Åt09PQ<R0 . ,ª[no9[#A[AeDGHIJKLMNS TBâad[A¯. c-./09PQ<R0 GH. IJKLMN 8m,8[A`#ªAe . sÅt0.PQ<R0 ,no9[A8yz &'îï ,ñ4²³´ 8PQ<R0<[S T9-./R0¸b,¿<W17 Á®,

(355) . ¯,ª a. ,epq·w. Åt01 à0pE·. 79²³´0w.$8<. A². ³´0w8`ZöÈwx ~8 ¯,ep qF C° 1öÈ

(356) ÈÉG70w.R0 1ñ47²³´ÁAki-./09s[ [ ²³´ Z`#ªAe²³´ª. cÌR0. .ù<[Þ 1 . .

(357) 7sdt1yz7,:;< ]17 Ë,8¯,

(358) iV8,0w9<[Þ 1 . .

(359) 7s dt1t7 Z#sb:;Á Ä,8â ,e.#D¸A9yz1ìx7:;<]ý Ì17.îïA[b c[d[A ¸A9. ―167―.

(360)

(361) . . !"#$%&' ()*+,-. /0.

(362) /1$23$456,789:;<9=> ?@A B C D6EFG9:HI9 =>1$JK$4 LMN1OP#$QRSTU= V$WLXYZ[EC \]9^_à#$bc KCdefgh95ijk lm#$4 nopqr V/ ECst6uvpstwx:ytzx e. C. !9{|N,}~:#$d,3f$

(363) 23$4WL. XYZ[ECS_ ,S_K2KCS_Z[ V$S-.HI" C3$/ES_. 1 /$d23$4d B CT V$ EC{ HI9 $K23C {p*+Eh9 23$4 st6uv,jk Cst, ¡1 KCd ,¢£ ¤¥} 1¦$2E/ C ¨ © . }:,3§#dK2/4st6ª« ¨ ° . 9 ¬1¦$\]9^_EC&®'¯2f KCS-. ±l#$²[³´µ5i#$K23$¶·ef46_ ¨ Á . V$¸¹º»,QRST&´¼½¾¿Àr23$1C STU=_,ÂÃÄ¿ÅÆÇ U=È&'É1 -.Ê /$KËÌÍÎCddeÏÐ /$4 ,Ñ_5i#$ÒC\]9^_ÓÔÂÃÄ¿ÅÆ ¨ Ý . ÇÕÖEC×ØÙ2E/ KCÚÒÛ,3$Ü$4 ¨Þßàáâ^_\]9^_ØÙãä^åæçèéêëìh ST_íîïðñò°ÞÞ°Á°©óECôf$õöp÷ øùúD23$ ,

(364) KC\]9^_ïðECdd ûü Cý ÏeÏ /$/$þ /$4 ¨©d2ECnoÉ=>g#$EC ,}/ Eý Ï #$K23C U => =×$ U=ÀåZ[#$ d e ³´µlm /$4 =×/ÓÔ à#$bc EC}/ Eý /,3 §#d CTC²[³´µÖ#$d $4 ¨° _ V$S-. ÊEC;< C ³´µ_E6 ÏC6 M . /$/f K C© ¨Þ¸

(365)

(366) ±l1. ―168―.

(367) K23$4EC_.

(368) 5i C B#$ B:"

(369) ÊK/. /$4,°ÞÞ°²_EC³´µ ghí. p!". #$ 2E/,C%ØÙ&'(°ÞÌ)*p %à°ÞÌ° *C+,-" Ì*

(370) $ef C²[³´µ ;§, K¶$·/4 ¨ Á

(371) . . .

(372) .

(373)

(374) .

(375) !" #$" ¨ Ý 1

(376) Cst66ª«9 ¬1¦$\]9^_ECÅ ¿®"9 eÏ?@A1 /$ef Cst6 6 ,

(377)

(378) É#$ef20

(379) /4 2Cà{:ØEC,"9 K, /$¶0

(380) /4. ―169―.

(381)