ロウントリーの都市貧困調査 : 食品化学実験からの出発 : 近代イギリスにおける「効率性」の探求

全文

(1)Jour. of Musashi Sociological Society, +., +ῌ-., ,*+,

(2) +., +ῌ-., ,*+,. +. ' % & : enop?W1 ¹b º/ :; »¹ The Poverty Research of B.S.Rowntree in the UK : The Original Idea Based on the Food Chemistry. < ¼ ½* Naoko TAKEDA* : B.S. +233 !"# $ % &'(ῌ)*+ ,-. /

(3) 0 123 4 5678 9. :; <=>/?3@AB3C .- :; @D<EFGH.-C IJKLMN / IJKL3OPQRST3/UV?W %ῌXYZ[ <)* ,* \]^_`PQRaM B.S. _ `PQRaSb-cdNC B.S. efgYhiRjk68 ,* l +* me. nopq7r sHt/euM fgvwxyih p<Ez{ |" 3 ?Whi:v 'YH}~!<k5t 5,-.</"#3 68.- 3MH8 $%3& BAJ"3Zc ' % &-.e()*+ ,<- &t/S,3 C.-C SW8/ : ' % : en ./ G/. + +ῌ+.

(4) . +3 \]0 123 45678 ¢1_£¤Y¥MN/. ¦§¨ῌ©S2ª. h«: 3¬S.@ 8/3C +233 ® 4¦¯°M 5±S.²³<6 3-R78´t/Sµ98 ¶·¸:;!3 ,6 * ¡.

(5)

(6) . ,. !"#$ %& "'(&)* + ,-./ 0 1234 5/567!

(7) . 23 8 9:;!"#/5#$. <=! >?@A4BCDEFῌ CG HIFJKL2M NO PQ!RSL2TUV&&WXY#$ .Z. D[ @ !RS T &\WB>?@A-B]"4^. $ T _!`*Zab. T c&Qde! fg./5#$&B Hhi>jkl,&mhnop4q UVNr-./ 23s&t uvjῌwFw xyxwῌ z{|G}$ +233 ! D[@ &~+F47NO$j zjῌF. FGῌ mj

(8) @F&0 + 1F' &F !B T ! 5q#$ B.S. mj

(9) @FB 0 , 1 0 - 1F ' / &L!R5/)*& 7.$ + & * & + T &\W4q T U V&0 'Za& 4 'Za" &L !& !"Z "&# B.S. mj

(10) @F&L *& + 4q#$ +3., !$NO$ @n %¡ 4¢ W. @n B B.S. mj

(11) @F&£&'/ L¤¥ &¦" L(§!&"&¨)©$ *ª4B D[@ &FF m«nῌDj C«¬F

(12) Borthwick Institute !® NO/5 mj

(13) @F ῌ u¯yj Records of Rowntree and Company +5/ +233 &0 + 1F. ' 4 B.S. mj

(14) @F L!" Y'° ±²,³²!q$#/ 7´µ&&. "¶·. &¸¹ῌº»&F !"#/5Z\ B.S. mj

(15) @F & T \W&-.!5/¼½.

(16)

(17) : . + B.S.

(18) . : . -.

(19) ..

(20) . +ῌ, + :

(21) . +

(22) !"

(23) #$% +3*+ &'()* +,-./ Poverty : A Study of Town Life 012 + ῌ. , #345 6' # 789 : #;<)%3= >?@A$ BC&,D=*E FGHI' J

(24) #$% KL M)%3=N O ῌPQ ῌRS T UVWTX O #PQ N YZ&[<=\J

(25) T]= FGHO ^&)% 3=2 B.S. _

(26) `NaῌObcd?ef$%3= U#T]= B.S. _

(27) `2 gh9iῌj _ k_ ?lm9&$*#;<)%3=N j &2a? n &$*J

(28) 2Vo p `q^?&r$*2 B.S. _

(29) `8mT]= stu B.S. _

(30) `` v`wx + s2 aῌObcd?n & WW yuyup `z{?|&^$ O Rq}#[~%3*&]= FGHO ^&]*% B.S. _

(31) `2 A. >T. O B. C. D.

(32) . J

(33) &s3% ! & $ _ " bN>T2*#&s3% $o%3=+ t* `pOb $V %? %#$%3% &p `^&'*%2 ( )? 3 &*% $ Xp `q ^TX X? Wo*% $%3=, U¡4& ¢ ^'&s3% |Vcd&£~3% ¤+ ¥¦V§¨?'©4# $*0ªN4WN«= 2 ¬ Rq T2 ®NO I'&:¯4¡4Va?,%. 3=W4W -_ # °_ ±3tT ².$VNM ?³E%3= O#´µ#/[¶ &s3%X; ·$%¸u a0T 2 ¹/ #[~% º<)%3*U #N<W= »¼¡4& + ¢?¦$% / R½&F1.

(34)

(35) : . /. ,+.2 !"#$%&#' (")* + ῌ , -.'!/0 !"#1234. , : ,ῌ+

(36). & 34*

(37) 5678. ("349-.#6 B.S. . :; < =# > ? 34* /@(0 AB4 + -C6DEFGA HIJH K*L1@ M:N 6O/@E" < =

(38) ῌPQ RSῌ TTHUVWXY +22*3* Z* X[@10 H.I. \](^_`[0 . abc d e . !" < = +21+ ῌ +3/. . PQ RS fg !" `g PQῌhiji=kel6m2 @ +22/ * +1 n

(39) oW*pq/0 rst*uvWw6[ +221 *xQTy ῌb =. zY6{|0 }= |. ~(' LTTH 63G TTHῌ *#t/0 !" fg < = +22, ++ n #( b*!/0bc d. 0{|0gkel =*[0 '( vU*k[ 0- +221 +, ¡*kel6¢[ £x¤¥¦ ¤ῌd y§P ¨ £x¤¥¦ ] *©GA ª iῌ« i. !" bc d 0*¬|0. `bc d. A/0 ¨* \'6, #%"®¯Y6°± [0#(. bc d. £x¤¥¦ ] ¤ῌd. y§P²Y ª iῌ« i²YA/0 ³e´!µ¶ · < =#¸¹%"º§bª » 0¨'¼^ ½/@1.

(40)

(41) . 0. ῌ!"#$#%&'(#

(42) ῌ)*+,#-./0 # 1#23456789 : #1#2%;<=8 >9?@ =ABCD#'

(43) ῌE#'FGFH38 4FIJKL5= 89 M=8-. )*+,#NO !P $#F% Q#RF +

(44) S#T5U V = W=-

(45) 3X/ #1#2%3 / Y , Z[9\]= 4 #O^ _Fà5b c3 ,. dZ%4Fef3N=0 Fgh ij%k=XlC 4FYm5n= \34F o5pq1 ,ῌ,ῌ ΐ῔῎῏῍ῐῒῑ. #1#2% +223 +* r +2 s0Fth3uv #1#2C w x 3yu?z5{3 F |#})% H.I. +.

(46) S#. 3 ~X ef Laboratory 5 #1#2FFt% F ef 0 4B =89z -0.z F 4FB=8LqF0 H.I. +

(47) S#0% #ῌD 3. =8 ?03Q# F/5=8 l@F 5 =8- 3ef5z% |#})Cl8b =8-VF0 ¡=¢5e£=8-93% 4 o3¤ ¥-8 ¦§F¨! "#F©ª $«X¬F®%XK3&qz C'(F. z3¯)° , ± +221 2 r3%*C® ²R

(48) ῌ F*bª³%´+3µ¶8- 4FoC#1#23 :?·3m¸(¹,% ²R

(49) ῌ FlXqF 0 º* ῌE#» # F¼ º* ῌE#» # % /'xS+ ῌE, ½#.

(50)

(51) : . 1. !"#$%& , '()&*+,-./ &-01. 2 3 4 5/ 67!8 9:&*;<= >

(52) !? 9:@02 +223 +* A -* *;<= & B. CD-

(53) E!FG 3 4 5/ !H9:I>&J.1 K!>02 L* 3 4 5MN&J.1OP-QR!S&JT :I>!#U.V9 WWX MN Y!Z[.\V92 -+ &* ]67&^9: E_`,a 3 4 5>;< = bcd\2 3 4 5+ efῌ; gM / !Q: + '&-02 ῌ &h I>@02ij&* k l mnon5/ !H9:I>&-01.23 I CD& 3 4 5* H.I. p qr / !Q :st >\1 uvwx! yz{2 |} ++ A 3 4 5 *;<= >h~&_vi&!G " _v !Tz{2+* efῌ; gM !#.2 ῌWWX * +221 . $z(% $ U &r&-01.2 3 4 56v &02 +223 * CD-MU@a: '(M &C01 MN )&-01.2U@: -{U@: efῌ; gM s* n * ' ' Y,a I *>\1 CD& G¡a1.. 2 ¢+,a2'2£,U¤¥ s*!S¦&§yI#$ ¨'¨ '>©-Q¥a1.2 ;<= 3 4 5 s* Y* ¨'ª&ZT:©-Q «.!¬\1.: \\ Y,a2 3 4 5* ;<= CD- !w :u'>*® -01 /QR!S&JT2¯b$02 h0\ °/&1±9 :!Q01.2 s* n !²³Q>\11±9:9´!# $stb >\1 µi MN¶·!¸¥1.¹I> 3 4 5&º »a22¼$02>.¥:$½D.

(54)

(55) . 2. . -. -ῌ+ :

(56) ῌ H.I. !

(57) "#$%&%'()*+,-.. /0 1$2 3405 6789:340 5;< ,=>$?0@ABC D E!ῌ FGHGI J#

(58) K LMNOP2Q RS/0J#

(59) TU +220 V 2 W,N%XP20++. E!ῌ. FGHGI5 +22/ V,Y,Z[MNOP \]'2^_3. 40 `à bE`c#

(60) d"#I e fF#G gh!i#j k 'l,m2P no'(pqr5TU$?P20 st u#v# wῌx#

(61) yzzj{3 J#

(62) Km|NOQ}~ +223 V, 5=>$?P E!ῌ FGHGI##I. D53K ,'XQ , 3* VO, u5 +, [0 ,'XQ D2aῌ !

(63) "#5j,2P2Q]40 +23, V, J.B. xcG5. ,

(64) ῌ . : [Borthwick : HIR-1a-,] (Production in l22*ῌ3*s), Chocolate Grinding Machine.

(65)

(66) : . 3. !"#$% & '( ) *+,-./012% #3+ 456. 12789ῌ:;<;=>? @ = A BCD EF GHBI461J*+ KKLMN9KO PQ R( S ' T7 U VVWDXY07KKLZ [ - P \D]^ _7 EF H.I. `'./012%KKL N9KO . PQ (aa*bc *+,d #$% EF H.I. `'e

(67) 612%VVW fgh( i>6 1j VklhmY%( kn8;#$% opDqE_7d. '( rs t uOvs wxv Zyx VnV tzrV v= {pDqE_7d '(Z|L }n xnr~ b uL;g -e/012% P O?D e

(68) _7VVWB + Y%( 21 B $%B VVWrk >2+ VVW rkB__B >2+ n8~ DVV WrkB01__> ttGD,7 0B VV Wx >2+ VVWxD(S- //῍ XY0127 ῌ P '( VVWxBOD1 VVWx SB 6_ 0B ¡¢ ¢ >2+ ¢£0%S - KKLZ $%¤YB ¥2¦D6%d - KK Lῌ}s 'T7 N9KO B7§¨( VVWxB¢_7 '(, ©DK KLZ Bª«7 ¬ ®B6¯°>-±D, ²³´_7 VVWx KKLZ ®B!µD¨/¶ ¤·% d - EF N9KO ' 4¸ *+,,·,¹ N9 KO '(,2 EF$12% k; ῌ >2+N9KO º»¼,PQ D21 89ῌ:;<;=(c *+D½6127.

(69)

(70) . +*. Dqῌ>o+,.

(71) !" #$%&'() *+% ,-( ./0123 45-(1678 9:%;"< =>?@"AABCD ./ lbs E!6 F G )HIJK"I LM"I@H1NO PQRSTO

(72) UH)(V ./ QWXFY@Z[6 \]@(1"AABC D8 /^/^_` H-"< 01 lbs abE!6 abFc<de' ++*F >?D ,. fgWXE!( \] h(). AABCDab i + fg +/ QWX

(73) %J6 jd) k-"#C / oz E!( +/ Q./YJ

(74) l-)Imd@H 8< n"1opq%rrstIu@ Jv wx y@E!6 wx F

(75) z{ c<de'&'() rrs8L'(@5O wx8O5)|5H1 }~jd)JIJ"' wx= jd1 @@ ( , Y'wx O Y jd1 dM 7! / Y O rrs 8<d1OFI7J18 rrsF \]@ )H6% RS@H8<U@I wxM"< rrs E!(L5@ +,+2 fg1('6. !"#$%&'(' )*+,-.('/ 0 123. 4'5678782,9:;<=!

(76) >?/@AB $%: ;<=!

(77) CDEFG((0HI(12JKLM:J NO P;Q @'GRS,TUV: %WWX ! Y Z56,[\J(:] ^_àbVcd abefg (h]d: RSV: +213 i j klkmῌnPo,P;QpqrCst g - uvwx&NOa:yzC{|}g/ H.I. ~P

(78) n! +22/ iJ Pῌ!P Cg +221 iJst Jg/IbV?/IH +223 i.

(79)

(80) : . ++. !" #$ !%&'() *+*, -./0 1234 5678*8 -ῌ,. 6^_àb0. -./0 9ῌ,:;8< 3=>34 #$ ?@3 ABC !*DEF**8GH'I6J K + L' MN O8%I> P Q=>//RST U V9 :WXYZ>[\ //RST 1 2/]:^_YZ>[\ à*//RST 3bc>bdMN e *f g%hi'jk\YEJ L!B PQdMN UWX /] l_'mn*GH"6J PQdMN\o7p<qr* 4 //RST K < %I> o o sd=>ttuv w x0y=>z{ |{} v ]. ~ῌ367 MYEJ//RST V9348'> ' 3 :4+7 , t +23* + 3//RST 3=> *'cE78> \&'()*> BBCDE'FG+-] ῌ ῌ+23* +

(81) -+ ,

(82) - ῌῌ + : + !". # ῌ$%ῌ&'()*+,- , ./012 &'()*34. )!563#789 &'()*3:;<=>?@9 56AB BCDE'FGHI ῌJKῌ&'(34)LMNOP QGR*3SNBBCDE'3T. UVW- , ./FGPNXW9YZ>PN,[N. [ 3EF ] ~:>[\367 V9'n c"67;*>\8*[\4*6J%I> ttu] M367 3//RST \//R '1 YE> ¡34 ¢\o7//RST :£¤o78>\[.

(83)

(84) . +,. !"#$%&'() *+',"(-./0 1234567"8"9:;3 <=>5?@) 0 AB" !CDEF Z/0\=>+.[ XY ῌ ῌ+23* 0

(85) +1ῌ,* ῌ0 ! "#$%&. ! ''()ῌ*+,)-.$ /012 + 1! , 1! 3%'3' /012 + 1! , 1! ῌ45/012678 0 9:;< =>?. @ - A B,CD B,ῌEFGHGI J + K =>9LM ῌNO !P!QRS =>TU<RVW . G"9:"HIJ KLMN!O)03=>">PQ@)RF)0 3GS5TUV3HI'. H.I. WM

(86) X!SY)J Z"= >'Z[5\@3GS'.]- G"^ KLMN!"6_J` 4 "a'bc de"

(87) Lfg5hi3(-'.j Oklm' XY - /0. : [Borthwick : HIR-1b-+/] (Original experimental Note), J.W.Rowntree Private Mixing Book (chocolate).

(88)

(89) : . +-. !"#$%&'( H.I. )* +23. + . , +1 -./0 1 234567289:9;( +23* +<= H.I. )>&?!@"(AABCD *EFG. @HIJK L"M N;( !! OOIPQ RS.T;@8 U7AABCD V*W:9" X (G AABCD &?*L :Y"( AABCD &?AQ2Z[7\]*^_9à> AQ bc de2fgh7(G i Tj9%kFU( k//012',/( ++/l ῌ ῌ+23* -

(90) - ῌ + : + . !". # ῌ$%&'() +0* lbs *+,!-.//012',. 345 ,/(67 ῌ89&'(:;3< +/2 lbs =>[email protected] //0CD. E' Cocoa Essennce ,3F +*/ lbs //012',3F .3./ lbs =GHIJKLGM"N< , O. 6PQR < +. R . ASTU /* lib //012',/(< +,* VWX YQZ[\ ]^_`B abcbde fgI + lib //012',/(< ,, ,ῌ/ VWX. \U]lmh7(G. n.i %kFU( k//012',/( ,+0 ῌ +23* 0

(91) , ῌX"hEi ῌ$%&'() ,+/ lbs *+,!-.//012',. 345 ,/(67 ῌ89&'(:;3< ,++ lbs =>[email protected] //0CD. E',3F +.0 lbs //012',3F 0/ lbs =GHIJKLGM"N< + O. 6PQR < . R ./ j.

(92)

(93) . +.. 0/ lbs

(94)

(95)

(96) +0 + lib

(97)

(98)

(99) +ῌ. . !!"#$%&'!

(100) () *+,-*./012 3456 789:3;<= =0>7 8?3@ABC,-*DE1, FG HIJKL>M1N OP QR78ST*U+BV2 78HW 789:<XY 78Z[ \]Q,^_`L ^_9:ab3cN =0>&'?*@= & '!

(101) dX*efg, hi4j* ^_klmnoJp1 *q &'lmr3sN-*tufg2 !!"#$%&'!

(102) vXSTpwx%$*yzBV {| }~*pN12 =0= !!"#$%Yn1>f , 2 AQ,83!!"#$%fY1N 83I ST*BV2 aDEFG @A+1b cd . ῌ +23* ! ῌ"#$%&'(ῌ)(

(103) * H.I. +,- ./)(

(104) *. 3 01 23 4- 567ῌ89: ; <=>?>@A ῌ BC DEFG<HIJK)(

(105) * 3 01 LM NO - P &(QR &(ῌ,S:T:U V + W XM YZ / [\ ῌ]^Guerin Bontron - 567ῌ89:X_`. H.I.

(106) %/ [Y!G%

(107) AQ. ,J83w2 !!8 %81 * J8-=¡¢=w2 £¤ H.I.

(108) %¥fY +23* ¦8§¨ 3©ªn2 VY H.I.

(109) %«¬k* 8 lmnoJ3Q,®¯f°¤=2-3±=w, ²³ ῌ ´%µ¶T ·Y 8 ¸¹ A f, ²³ῌ´% µ¶T !!"#$%78*DE1q !!"#$%.

(110)

(111) : . +/. .

(112). : [Borthwick : HIR-1 b-+/] (Original experimental Note , J.W. Rowntree Private Mixing Book (chocolate). "#$%&'() *+,- ./#$%&'()0123 45ῌ 6 789! :;< ,-! #=>?@AB CD#EFGHI J K' H.I. LM +22/ N0 45ῌ6 789! #:;O 21. N0 45ῌ6 789! P0QROI 23 N0S T U< VW CD#XMYZ 3* N0M ,- ?@! AB[\]0^;O_ àI CD b<cdef_àIgh<iXK<a_j' k! lm0na_ ,-! =`#[\]0$%O /oCD#pZ " p`8#qr&s<ef_àI tu]vwx Ojy#z {&'|}0 k! n>0 ~G`v< ! CD! Q #> <KaIBMWJK' 0M JK' /a_` I I k! #O_`' M hIJKaI <CD0 # ¡0¢£#¤O ¥¦]#§¨.

(113)

(114) . +0. !"# +3 $%&'()*+, -./* H.I. 01

(115) 234 56789:;<=> ?@ ABCDE/FG*HIJ KAL#H+#M*ANH+ / OP QC8>R/STU 78V WXY 'Z84 [\&V?@ ]Â_`M*4aJ ]^bc4Y de# 0 1

(116) 23Z9[\ ?@ f+]ÂN#M*4 567g.9?@ Ah"/M* ieH ()Aj [\&AklDEH+e#M *ANH+/. . ῌ .ῌ+ : ῌ

(117) +23* m n

(118) o pqAr+ o$s. t uv#. w m x3yz4{?@|} ~>+e# ῌ WX3A #>R/ M4 o $s-. A ,$s ?@9l#M*A/ pqp4 , 9reH+#9 x1 ῌ 0X4 x3

(119) ῌ237AH+#> pq 7433de# 0 P-. 0 P>pq /M*_i Re# x3yz4 339 ¡¢£ p¤ A¥/M*9¦*§¨# +23+ m ῌ WX3A #M*A© 339. ῌ WX37A/M* Je# ª x 3

(120) pq4 x1ῌ0X9r+ 334«*H ῌ WX3pqA¬O/M* Je# ῌ WX3«[4 WX3 >R/ ® ¯ °n±> «F ²3 A+H³/´µR/¶> · ¸ ¹º9»HR/ ²3 ¼- º ¹º ½3 .

(121)

(122) : . +1. !"#$%& ''()* (+$,-. /01 234 5678#9:; <=>?@ ABC@ DE 6 6F"GH% IJK; /01 23

(123) LD 9

(124) MN"OP; H.I. Q8R%& S&S. 3 4 ῌT DEUVWXYZ"[%.UV4 Y9:; \

(125) "OP;.K$ S-. 8] ^_` 29:; /01 2R] "ab%. c "de% "fg; Y"eh 2 i "de%.N jk%& lm" no; pqrst9e% uv$wxy"P& z{no&|}"~.o;R ]"jk %.(+$D; /01 2MY3$P$ $DMgS 5ῌ 5 5" O )-$%& ] ^_` 2 35 9:; ab8+jjDSR 3g;58:; 2i "deg;R3 5 R5 ab" no; "T.g OjN 2> _ $'S&3 5 R5. "R8 9 q3 !R%& 8K$D. 2i 3 4 ῌ w / `0 ` w ?¡ =iC. !DE 8#9 ¢y""$%. . 9:; ¢y3 £ e$(& ¤¥8¦_m$D &§% 8¨g 2> _ lm"©h no;" T.g ¢y$3^_` 28ªj-&S; ^_` 23«¬ ® 9 ¯#$°±n-;R²³_ $´µg; (+$ 2> _ 3 ¶· OjN ^_` 2 ²³_ $OS&¸¹Rº%D;»¼½..

(126)

(127) . +2. .ῌ,¡ ¤¥¦& : §¨X"#©. +23+ + ῌ . !"#$%&'(). *

(128) +,-./01 23 ()4567891:; +221 . < +2. =>$ ?@ῌA!"B"5 !"$CDEF=G0/ %&= ,-.3*

(129) 5H1+3 I9$*

(130) CDJK$LM5NO8 9/0PQR+3ST/U1IV=.WX +221 $ ?@ῌA!"B"$*

(131) = CD./01 -* YZ$. !"=G0/ [\]V^_à5,b89/01 c$'d e fgC\=G0/hi=%&=CDQR5,89/01 + j+Hk 9l m$WXdH1 ¢ῌ ª« &¬ ,*£ ῌῌ

(132) . !

(133) ῌ"#$ : %& '()*+,-./0123-4&5 6789:;<. =>8?@'AB C' +*2 lbs &D8173EFGH I&J'KC8LM 23 NO5KC8PQ4 KC' +-. lbs & +-.ῌcwt 817 R"& ST8CU'VW2X/T YZ[2<\]<:^_à4 b<^_`c2 de3f-gX- 6&hB'^_àig3 C' /f:j-3 kl 'X]m: noj<6p8qr. /d]^:sg3 tu/h<X]mT K&v2w<5 xyz<{ -p: K"&|48}23 ~&'d 'J&=>8A - ~8^H4 & 0 'f '-/3-4&5 678Kv2w<5{-9 : K&|4'}23 phB' NO5PQmKC'174 I6S ,30 lbs &

(134) M&ῌ , 817 / NO5PQ. 3 s^d `m ,.* lbs &

(135) 8s^23=]m 8 ^' g3xr /5_X-hB'O8jg4 '

(136) /d]^:sgmT NO8pQ.

(137)

(138) : . +3.

(139) +

(140) !"#$ %&'()* ./0 lbs !+,-./01 -* 234$ '(567 238. 9 20 lbs !:;<=01 :;<=>?7@9AB

(141) CD EFG HI :;<=J6 K6

(142) - JLDM

(143) CD - NK6?5

(144) OPQ

(145) HR

(146) SL6TU:;<. =V WXYD Z![\8 :;<=]^_DM à6 85_ :;<=0167 bcDda '(5efg7 ++* lbs !hi I hijkjL

(147) AB

(148) CD #l7mI6j!n6o$ à

(149) pqQr]7sD tZu +-/ lbs !nvwx 23$n6/ y.z ++*F $ WX{ | /y.z7}~6 nv] IL6

(150) W3{ ]IL6w e N =ῌ=/01 à , N! )* ῌ/.<ῌ,. : !! /.<L

(151) . /.<!I>w\ ]? ]`@L

(152) 8 (]/,Q ]$>= =ῌ-.= 8\j~Z

(153) !¡¢L

(154) /.<>?7@9/y.zI

(155) pqQr

(156) CD £$j +, ¤¥!/.<$?¦ - §>/y.zI

(157) CD ¨ pq6/.< ©!yI , ª¢ : ,*+-./+ =< ,*+,.1/+ =< Z

(158) L

(159) ©y!«W/ .<¬¦

(160) ®9 /.<! ¯°!±®5

(161) ²M 23

(162) ³d976 w´ L6f? 5

(163) /.<y!Z y>/y.zI7 /y.z!µ> 23¶·]L

(164)

(165) ¸¹>º»L

(166) ++* +,*F ! ++/F ¼½$? /.

(167)

(168) . ,*.

(169) 1 2 ++*F ! ++/+,*F "#$%&' ()*+, -. /0 1ῌ 23 / 456 789 23:;+<= >?@ABCῌD E:F ῌGHIJK : LMELaing & Co., London NOῌTate & Co., Liverpool P. DQ /ῌFrankenstein & Co., London RS1TῌDuche Co. , London UQ U/ῌTeergus & Foster , London 2VTWXῌSeager Co., London. !" #$ %&'()*+,-./0 1234 5672

(170) 89:;#$<=>4?@ABC@DE 1234 FG<HIJ@K2LM2CNOPQ R-/ST4?@U VW<.<X14 Y#Z[&\]^<_7234?@<à [&6bZcdK> .7N e3fgh \]îjQk"ATa3@72lmKN [& noQpqK rsQtuK2 23v3wxyT4>z $<. .7N {|}~Z F. 01234<C.7N . ῌ8

(171) Z{|}32 88{|} 8{|} >z FQK2/K234 FJh. T4<C.7N?@<.<M4 R->5/ S{Z ¡LME12CNFGHIJQ¢£+BC¤K ¥¦§K@KN¨1@3M4©ª 8«88

(172) A ¬R->/SQBC®D234 vY/0 1ῌD E,+w +23, xy Y 0 Z: "#%&/3 [6 /

(173) \']^()* _/ 3 [` + abc de"f` -':g"hi j PSTkU 2 lCUQB 23 9_. /

(174) mn: 3 4 23"J%, o p No. , Crystpal q/rs D6()*+& /

(175) \' 236()*+ &tu:/.

(176)

(177) : . ,+. ῌ

(178) . + ῌ ῌ!" #!$%& '()*+ . ῌ ,-., -/0 1234$ 5)1 2$67 58+9: ,/12;<=7>?@ 126/ 0 A$BC& D$ E 58F: ,&,D; 5 GH)+BC& >, D$ E D$I-/0 +/JKLM. ! " # $ % &'()*+,-./0123- &'45*6 7-839 : ;<*=>0?&@A3BCD@;E*.0?F@ ;< ./ 01B GHI J $ KLMNOPQ?F@ R; ST UV *ῌW01X YM2L &'Z[ ST*\]0 1A3B^B_@ à K^- +,b.῍% cde30?f_Q?D1gh ij -klmnM C2L o-pqrb&'() st STPQ1u vwx yz-mbB@M C2{1 | }~ῌ rbuv \*Mm&'{13_K^ .ῌ-y |}~ : `ῌ . $ -% AQ8CBcdeCr-0?D1 * GC0 0K^3w*1A3BQ@ zAῌ T U"V_àbNO,,{ ῌNOP : +23, Q + R ,0 P ῌNO8S : T U"VWX Y Z[\]^ Y_àbcd ῌNOefῌgh?ij : --/.+ῌ, lbs, klm/D : / +ῌ, lbs, nop q. rs` : 0/.,, 12tU" u qvo : 0-., lbs, wxj ; -,2 lbs. ] / % R;-mF? ¡3V ¢£V*.01M C2@,- ¤¥V ¦§¨©V ª«uvV ¬ ®G 2n¯°Vb± B.PQ?F? ² +,*³´0K^30?F@ V ¢£%µ¶ 30?.῍PQ?F@ · %¤¸-¹jPQ@º»¼B½n º»¼¯.

(179) ,,.

(180) . /

(181) . : [Borthwick : HIR-1b-2] (Original experimental Note), BSR, +23,ῌ3.

(182) !"# $% !"# &'()#.

(183)

(184) : . ,-. "#$%&'()*(+ ,-./0 1234567 89: ;< 5=> ?@34&AB-CDEF%&7G# HIJ KLMNOP7 QRSP& TU3VWOP7X + YZ [\ '( ]^5_3`& a' bOPcd7efgh3 iLefjkQd:lQLmnocd& 89: TUDpoc qr stu vDwx yz{5./|0. o}~LwOPcd67QdS: .ῌ.

(185) : ῌ . 3+ gῌbh#dcX x3#OPcd &,. V 0 b Dt%&# ogD : V 1 c ῌ ,xDo7 ¡¢£L og+4Pd#oc¤}:# ¥¦§d#¨: Q L©& ª«53X ¬ D8G#%&! Q®cd 0 . : [Borthwick : HIR-1b-+,] (Original experimental Note), JWR Note, +220ῌ21, Gum Mixing, Crystallising, Marriner’s Department.

(186) ,..

(187) . 1

(188) . : [Borthwick : HIR-1b-+,] (Original experimental Note), JWR Note, +220ῌ 21, Gum Mixing, Crystallising, Marriner’s Department. !"#$,/ %&'(%)*$+,-./ 012'3$456 7&8 9:;<=> "#$ 3? @ABC +* D EF<"#$ GH IH J" GK BLῌM'N" BOῌM 'N" PQRSῌMTU'N" VWXYZῌM'N" ['\ ]B ^B _àb%cde fghQij%B kl7 mg ^mg nopqr$TU <= st uvwx> !"#$ T yg gzS.{$|=>}~ cS0/0"# 7 ' )>"#$,0 dhUC ^";U NU n$>(.l;> #%&.( ¡ 7ῌ%&C¢£¤¥¦$ ¡§¨©ªlo«¬C ®¯°.±²l ³´µl¶¦$%&.·¸¦$>¹º4 .

(189)

(190) : . ,/. ῌ !"# $ %&'(

(191) )*+ ,ῌ-,.. /01%234 56789:; .ῌ/% ()*+,. < => ?@4A+B8 CD0:6B EF %<2G3:;0%6 H I J2K 0LMNO5 2 PQRS T UV *WX3 Y Zῌ[),\ ]^ _` )+ PQRS T7 ab)RQ+ U Z_ c de04!"W "f Qghi# fjSHkTῌ l 0mno^p qῌfrT c. stῌfrT u. P vῌfrT wxgῌfrT$ yM%z4X3,1 +23/ & 23 { X3| q }'7~T Q);7 &(2. %6B+8 ! 42)+%878;gT2&+ g)^3%)2 4* gT 2&+ J Q +, 0#-); )- 0+ :;%.4^B83 &-./0ῌ1,2' ῌ : +23/ ++ +3 +, 2 ῌ : ,*

(192) !". #$. 018B4 )6B83 Qr ¡ ¢o / }'2£ 0 / 1018B ¤+ . ¥22¦ o^B83,3 H I J § ¨©0# +23+30 & ª06 Jῌ PQRS T0!3 /-3 « 2¬o^B83 3 2 ®^#¨4 0¯°± § 04² 2¬5o^B83 ® ª0 H.I. #³ ´µF ¶·´Q¸ 0Y¹º)*8 +23- &6 » JῌPQRS T472¶·´Q¸ 0¼8+ ½ 4Y¹º.

(193) ,0.

(194) . 2 ῌ

(195) +23+30.

(196)

(197) : . ,1. +23- ++ !"#$%&'() !*+, -./01 "#. 12 34567 89

(198) : ; < = > ?@ 0 A BC DE F% 7 "*G H<IJDE%K7L+M-* ,. +230 N()-+ O<PQ. RST< , U* , N 0V.W <X Y Z [. , ). .ῌ0ῌ ῏ῒῐῑ῍῎ΐ. \ ]M +223 +230 4$ 1 ^ Y Z [. ,* !. " _`#PQab $c$ RS%`#&<'dP\L ef Y Z [ghL*G i ]Mjk(l+Gm<n= Q\L%$9L+J]M o0pq 2)* = +,-.`/ 0r 0V ?efQk <s+ t.u

(199) v w1u

(200) v<xG wL. yz%{2PQ |3<4 }5 6w

(201) Vo/v 7 /~*jl+G O<8J

(202) x+)

(203) v 9 2 : 2 ;<$ 2 = [l+G*j

(204) 9 (;>l+G%n4QL+J] M 4 H.I. b ?LG ,. @. `# [ <'dP%7LJ)Q . >< (¡Q= ¢AT £B 5CDET¤F ¥$9Q¦§¨L O 8GHI<s(¡Q\L%©J K*¤ ª« RSLM ¬N !®j¯O PQj ) * °Ru%±%G+ ² 0jQRS<³F* ´!j)< 'dP\LSTPQ*d mµ>%¶4Q ·¸H<U¹ ºVP»9¼½.

(205)

(206) . ,2. !"#$% &'()*+ ,! -./010 2(34# -/5" 6789 : ;<= > ?

(207) @ AB;=CDE?

(208) @- FG ῌHI 2JK#" L?MN=*+?O(P"*"=!Q10 RSRT: 6789 (UV*W- >X ῌYZ%?[ \V [ ]H [?^_ `"5+ H. [ -a$#. *b.=:!W#c?(d* e?%/# [f. g. h=\8(iL#jk(lm*+!"=!Q#no0. /. . /ῌ+

(209) +23* p RSRT? ,* p?: ?7q r!+cs(. iL"tu%/# ? vRwx:RSRT?yz-7 c{K#|=- =}Q +23+ ~Tῌ R? /+ " RSRT:~Tῌ R?" = (L# r!+ (b10 W t ,*-* -*" +23, ,+ ?= RSRT:e%QL" e. : ?RR-F%"!U? + r%/# ?. vRwxc ,+ ?="M e?( ¡+" e #5+$#?:%/# ¢R?e:$J £¤?¥¦§?$M /5" ¨©n¡%:Wb e%Q# |= 15+ &7??Cª7q(;#10 W5+!5" e??«%(&* /?$$?Cª ¬K" |=. - ' yz(iL#5¡%/5"= RSRT:®¯5+! #-, e%Q#° RSRT:±RR(e*+()*" ²³´ µ*(¶5+!#|=(+·*+ ¸K?±RR : ¹º ,-. r!+?»¼-/5" [ . ¹º ,- ½#"L .

(210)

(211) : . ,3. !"#$!!%&'()%*-- + , -. /

(212) 012 %)%34&.44056. * 789

(213) . 0!: ;<=./> 0?@!%AB.CD3

(214) E ?@!%FGH*IJK&L!.D)%D3

(215) M &N) + , -.OP#3 .QR S TῌU V W?C* U V9 +220 0X? YZN +223 0 X ;& Life and Labour of the People in London. + [\]N3 +1 [^?\].!@ _ VῌX. 7à ;Bb'N - c.

(216) "de ;?C*4& 0N3 f0g"*

(217) #h9 $ %0ij& 3 kP#3+ , -9 +23/ 0lm ῌnRoVS Vp-'# 3 Vp-?(q;)N)@3*+&rs0tD3 lm ῌnRoV S uv09 ,-N3w..x/0y:0z)%3. uv) {|1}#32304*& 56N37~.8% 9:;N@r. 3N)%3 ?P 5<=?Vp-04*4&9>"* ?5 r@?A@t*4&9N!%& B *+9CN3-- + , -.| 9oV 0DN30-. +RS ῌ E&F660!D3-/ +R. Sῌ 9 GH*0HN) ῌ;IJ K L. ¡# +23+ 0M"#35 ?C* +RSῌ &FNN)%*¢£9 7 ;¤OP0L%) + , - QM¥¦*5 ?CD3&§¨#* +231 0 9R©vª0!D3 « S09¬TP. # UV ®7.WXN + , - YZ9¯|!D)%3 R©v ª0!*0&5!% [v.,°0M\P#3 ±² ³´ ]µ¶ 9·I&50Z6@¸&N) [0X^P# ¹_&N)·I/

(218) º¦*`XY64&0!D3 ,3 » + , -9EZa[0!D 3-0 7 W/

(219) <= 3¦0¼.L&P#)%*½ .

(220)

(221) . -*. !"#$%& '()*+,#./ 01023 +233 4 5%63 70890:;<ῌ8 = > ?@A708

(222) B > > C, +3*+ 4

(223) BD EF Poverty : A Study of Town Life G%&HIJ. 6 /ῌ, . 0102, >KL4MN-&

(224) BOGPQ4R-& ?@A

(225) BPQG?A

(226) BPQST&UV%6 ?@A

(227) BO, W X#PQ, , R + R, WYZ 6[4 \ W] S^G ^J,_4à bcῌ d0 ef0; 4#^G4gh& ij4k%6 l/ + R, WS/6[4 mn PQSop^G ^J, q;

(228) r0s3t %6. d0uvῌ q;

(229) r0w(

(230) =

(231) JRSST 3 xy4 z#{#m|}S[~%&. f t4 ^. G4gh& mn!"ST6 ?A

(232) BO,;e ##$# 4gl ^J, % 4gh& !" &'#3(IJ6 ^J , 8 #) ¡ !" ¢£' ¤¥ ' ¦§' 4 l i¨'©0ª4MN-& i)

(233) BPQS«¬%6G®g/. 0 : 0ῌ+

(234) . ^g/#01024¯J*+S q°e,± )² G -³%&UV%&¯g/ q°e,±´µ, )² *+4R& ¶(·Q ῌ ¸ ·¹'#º.»¼ 0½%63*+.

(235)

(236) : . -+. "# $%&' ( )*+,-./#

(237) !. "#$%

(238) &'(& )* & +,-./,0123

(239) & 45 ) +67 8 9% :;<=>,?@A,8B,CDE FG

(240) &'(HI Fabian Society +3*-a. ,0. 012 3456%7. 89:8;ῌ<=>?56@AB#C%@ DE7$ 1$ +231 F+GA7$ HIDJ +K/.L HIMN. O@PQ#+R ST; ;@UV7 WXI@YZ7 HIMN. [A@\B# ST; ; ]^@ HI34MN+_à 7 bc+89:8;ῌ<=>?@ dB#W C%@,-./# efghijklB# 89:8;ῌ<=>?! R . 0 89:8;< =>? mn! op!

(241) q%rs! tu! @ + 7$56Nv+w x7$L y bῌHI56z{l+|}~+j"# efghiR D c e34D c +*

(242) + @. +3*, F - F O4! %/*12@ Vz+ 7$ zO +B# 56! j zO @B#C%@kl7.. z! a party of National E$-. ciency j$ C )*+ efghi R O!. @Q . ST; ; 89:8;ῌ<=>? zO! j¡¢ >£z¤+¥7. bc p¦§¨@kl7$C%j %/&)* 0ῌ,J KLMNOP, $%Q RSTUVW,XY. efghi%©ªB#% 9 « ? R ¬ p¦! @® ¤7 <£{¯ °z±+L²27./#+"#%³ &)* ´,7$)*+ µ´+ {+¶· .¸$¹jº» O "# p¦¼½! 6 kl+0{j . / $%¡&#.

(243)

(244) . -,. .D.EFG:HIJ> +3., K(LMNOP QRS T LMNOP UVWXHY.)Z[\] ^_`VACG:Ha bcdêfg hijk^lmnCoAp7CF)Hqr)stG : .D.E$u vwXxy z{)9:F)^|}B ~ ^gr ) WX H^nCF)>C > HC X VH9 vwXxy gr E .+P

(245) ^g ¡ ) ¢ £¤^¥_nC¦§)H>qB9qr)¨tVAC. ῌ + A. !"#$ %&'() *+,-./. 0 12$ 12%&'() *+,-./0 345$ 126 78 *+,-./0 )9:;<=>?@AB9C , W.O. Atwater Foods, Nutritive Value and Cost U.S.Department of Agriculture, Bulletin No. ,-. Investigation on the Chemistry and Economy of Food U.S.Department of Agriculture, Bulletin No. ,+. Dietary Studies in New York City in +23/ and +230 - [Briggs +30+ : 3ῌ+*] . [Borthwick : BSR3-ῌxῌ1] / [Borthwick : BSR3-ῌxῌ1] 0 [Briggs +30+ : +*] 1 [Borthwick : JR3-ῌVIῌ-] 2 [Borthwick : RῌDTῌCCῌ0] 3 [Borthwick : HIRῌ,ῌ+,ῌa] [Borthwick : HIRῌ,ῌ+,ῌc] +* [Borthwick : HIRῌ,ῌ+,ῌa] [Borthwick : HIRῌ,ῌ+,ῌc] ++ [Borthwick : HIRῌ1bῌ+,] +, [Borthwick : HIRῌ1bῌ+-] +- [Borthwick : HIRῌ1bῌ+/] +. [Borthwick : HIRῌ1bῌ+/] +/ [Borthwick : HIRῌ1bῌ+/] +0 [Borthwick : HIRῌ1bῌ+/] +1 [Borthwick : HIRῌ1bῌ+/].

(246)

(247) : . --. +2 [Borthwick : HIRῌ1bῌ1] +3 [Borthwick : HIRῌ1bῌ+,] ,* [Borthwick : HIRῌ1bῌ+,] ,+ [Borthwick : HIRῌ1bῌ1] ,, [Borthwick : HIRῌ1bῌ.] ,- [Borthwick : HIRῌ1bῌ2] ,. [Borthwick : HIRῌ1bῌ1] ,/ [Borthwick : HIRῌ1bῌ2] ,0 [Borthwick : HIRῌ1bῌ2] ,1 [Borthwick : HIRῌ1bῌ3] ,2 [Borthwick : HIRῌ1bῌ3] ,3 [Borthwick : HIRῌ1bῌ+*] -* [Borthwick : RῌDTῌCCῌ0] -+ [Borthwick : RῌDTῌCCῌ0][Borthwick : R&Co.3-ῌXῌ+*ῌa][Briggs +30+ : +1] -, [Briggs +30+ : +-] -- [Briggs +30+ : +-] -. [Briggs +30+ : +/] -/ [Borthwick : RῌDTῌCCῌ0] -0 [Borthwick : R&Co.3-ῌXῌ2]. ῎῍῏ῌ Briggs, Asa, +30+, A Study of the Work of Seebohm Rowntree : +21+ῌ+3/., Longmans. Cole, M., Beatrice Webb, Longmans, Green & Co., +3./. " #$%ῌ& ' (. )*+,- ./01 23 456789 +32, :! Emy, H.V., +31-, Liberals, radicals, and social politics, +23,ῌ+3+., Cambridge University Press. French, David, +33/, The Strategy of the Loyd George, +3+0ῌ+3+2, Oxford : Claredon Press Hampson, Martin, ,**+, Bournville and Weoley Castle, Tempus Publishing Limited. Hardy, D., +33*, “The Garden City Tradition Re-examined, Report of the Fourth International Planning History Conference, Bournville, the UK”, Area, ,, + . Hardy, D., +33+, From Garden Cities to New Towns : Compaigning for Town and Country Planning, +233ῌ+3.0, E. & F. N. Spon. Hare, William Loftus, +3-/, New Earswick : The work of the Joseph Rowntree Village.

(248)

(249) . -.. Trust, Town & Country Planning, vol. -, No. +* : .0ῌ//. Harris, Jose, +311, William Beveridge : a biography, Clarendon Press. !"#$%ῌ&'(#) *+,- . / 0 . +33/ 1 / +331 1. 0 +333 1 2345678 Harrison, Royden, ,***, The Life and Times of Sidney and Beatrice Webb : +2/2ῌ+3*/ 9:. !;<=>+,-?@A BCD'(EF ,**/ 1 .. Hay, J.R., +31/, The origins of the liberal welfare reforms, +3*0ῌ+3+., Macmillan. Hills, John, +33., Beveridge and Social Security : an International Retrospective, Oxford University Press. Hobhouse, L.T., +3++. Liberalism, London : Oxford University Press. G<H! . IJKLMNO PQRST. JKLMUVWXY+Z[I\]. Ê_ ,*+* 1 Howard, Ebenezer, +232, Toῌmorrow : A peaceful path to Real Reform, London : Swann Sonnenschein & Co. Ltd. Howard, Ebenezer, +3*,, Garden Cities of Toῌmorrow, London : Swann Sonnenschein & Co.Ltd. `&CabῌHcbd efg h3+ijkl mn78 +302 1 Morgan, Kenneth, +31+, The Age of Loyd George, London : Allen and Unwin. Morgan, Kenneth O., +31., Lloyd George, London : Weidenfeld and Nicolson. Pugh, Martin, +322, Loyd George, London : Longman Rowntree, B.S., +3*+, Poverty : A Study of Town Life, Macmillan. Rowntree, B.S., +3,+, The Human Factor in Business, Longmans. Rowntree, B.S., +3.+, Poverty and Progress : A Second Social Survey of York, Longmans. Rowntree, B.S., +3/+. Poverty and the Welfare State : A third Social Survey of York dealing only with economic questions, Longmans. Thane, Patricia, +330, Foundation of the Welfare State ,nd Edition , London and New York : Longman. o)

(250) ῌpqr stuvῌstwT qx# U. VWX+y BCD'(EF ,*** 1 Vaughan, A., & Jordan, P., ,**., George Cadbury and Bournville.The Freinds of Bournville Carillon. Vernon, Anne, +3/2, A Quaker Business Man, The Life of Joseph Rowntree +2-0ῌ+3,/, George Allen & Unwin Ltd. '(bzr {|}= ~ b. ῌ!r

(251) #b+,- ,**0 1 Wren, Daniel A., +33., The Evolution of Management Thought, New York : Wiley. Wrigley, Chris, +33,, Loyd George, Oxford : Blackwell.

(252)