仲裁人の忌避に関する諸問題利用統計を見る

(1)

ῌ῏ ῎῍

ῌ ῌ ῌ

!"#$%&'()ῌ * !+, -./01234567 )ῌ 8 9ῌ :;<ῌ !"=>?5@>A>B῍

=C1D6ῌ :;> !"=>B7*5($ 8 %&EAFG

#$HI1()ῌ J51 8KLBMNO'($^῎^῍^῏῍ P1Q R ῌ SRNOTU.V=6ῌ WR^῎^῎^῏"XYT;=ῌ QZQ[\]^R_

`a ῎UNCITRAL῏1῍῔ΐῑbcd=CQ[\ efgR ῎UNCIT-

RAL Model Law on International Commercial Arbitration῍ hi

ῐefgRῑ BM῏ "jk=ῌ J5lm=6nd῍ῑbRop῍῏ΐq=

6N,45C^῎^῏^῏῍

8KLr= Rῌ ῍ΐs7tu῍῔s'v,=6B$῍ #>P

wῌ xyῌ ῍ΐs7B6ῌ 8KLz=6ῌ {|t)

,A5C 8I}"~=>B6ῌ 8:;xC

"M)$><z1($"$ ῎῍῏῍ J5

=ῌ WRῌ 9"KL=M$z<z1($ῌ

"D6,=C'>B 81*"#$

ῌ 7tuῌ 81dbῌ db8ῌ 87tu:ῌ

xC'($ῌ 8"KL#$J1'$,

6BC ῎ῒ῔῎s῏῍ =C1D6ῌ 9"KL=M$z'($ ῐ :

¡R¢pῐ῎q ῎῎ῌῌ῔῕῍῎῕῏ +

ῌῌ ῌ

(2)

ῑ ῌ ῌ ^῎^ῐ^῏ῌ !"#$%&ῌ '()*+,

῎ῌ-῍.῎/01)2&3῍ 45ῌ 6789ῌ 78 :;<=>?@A9*BC2DE$%&ῌ FG῍$01

)*B ῐHIJKID1LMC2*+,

+N52ῑ ῎῍/῏ OPQR^῎^ῑ^῏῍ CR!95ST UVW*'()XYR&%+ZN5ῌ *!9 5[\ῌ ]^= U'()2+῍

45ῌ ῌ _`abc1defg&Dhi j`G29*Bkl9ῌ mn45

%ojQp_DRBKqrstu&%

῎῏.ῌ ῐ.῏῍ ZZst$%&ῌ VW*Fῌ !9 vwxyz5ῌ ZZ{YR2%G<0^῎^ῒ^῏BN5ῌ Cst|}*3&%῍

~%*῍ΐ-_%&ῌ '(vw$%&&%῍ +ῌ '(vw!9`C2* ῎῍ΐ-῍ .῏ῌ ZZ+%2ῌ '(!$%&

C2+ ῎῎.῏῍ Dῌ '(&!9ῌ

7QR5C2N545'()%RZBC2

N5%RZ"%ZY῍ῑ'(+gR+Y +% ῎῏.῏῍ !95'(45`

'()+%2QR5ῌ D'(5!

9ῌ Dfg5ZY῏ῌῌ ῌ !

'(&C2*ῌ ῌ !'(

B2{2ῌ '()B2+gR+Y +% ῎ῐ.῏῍ '(ῌ 45`'() B2QR5ῌ 1 ῎῎῍-῍.ῐ/῏ῌ

;11QRC2+ ῎῎῎-῏῍ 45ῌ '(

,

῍῍ ῌ

(3)

ῌ ῌ ῌ !"#$"ῌ

%&'( ῎῍ῑ)῎*῏῍

!+,-.ῌ /012'(3'45ῌ 1206 708903':+;<4 ῎ῐῌ῎)῏῍ =

>ῌ %&ῌ -.?#@(A+῍

4BCῌ /ῌ DE12FGH" IJ+4

!"KLMN#OPῌ ῌ !"

#$Q3' ῎῏ῑ῏)῏῍

!0%Rῌ .ῌ -."S4Tῌ UVW.XYῌ /01 2Zῌ 12["\]^ῌ _^"R`4[abῌ /%c /deE,\]_fgF0hijkl#' (mῌ ,12no:DE0Np12q 'rZ %12st^῎^῏^῏῍ uv#ῌ /012 Zῌ .wxUVW.0.;y0z{|ῌ }j~[

"7A+~0R^῎^ῐ^῏῍

ῌ /012F

῎῍῏ /0\]^ῌ _^

.῍ῐ)῍*ῌ 0\](ῌ /0

\]^ῌ _^120["'(῍ !0\]^ῌ _^"

R12[ῌ UVW.XY!"%P`ab#O ῌ ῌ !00p"4῍

!0Zῌ .DEῌ ῐῑ\]^_^RTD 4FOῒ "ῌ /DE"'0ZO(ῌ

\]4 #$4!"0mῌ 4 /0

/0\]^_^0N4J!"p

/012Z῎ ¡¢῏ -

῍῍ ῌ

(4)

῎ῑ῏

ῑ ῍ ῌ ῌ ῌ

ῌ !"ῌ #$%&'#

()*#+,ῌ -./

012#33ῌ 4056789*#ῌ :+ῌ ;<

=>?@AB^῎^῍ῌ^῏῍ :+ῌ CDEFGHIῌ J KFῌ ῐL ῎impartiality῏ MNOῌ ῒΐ MN0PQ#

Rῌ :+ῌ Lῌ!"3 ῒS0TUBV Wΐ Oῌ ῌ!"3 ῒSX YZ[ΐ 0\]Rῌ B^ῌ ῒ_`#+abΐ 0ῌ ῌ!"

S >cde#RYfRg]^^῎^῍῍^῏ῑ hi῍

:jῌ CDEFf3ῌ _`#+JKk=l ῌ!"=lmnodeBῌ pq) fr῍ sῌ JKFLO0=l#

e]hiBῌ "Ftῌ CDEFpq )ude0e]+>B^῎^῍῎^῏ῌ CDEFvwxy ,z{ ῌ JKFCDEFe]impartiality|M N0}~#+@B῍ :+ῌ F

B+JKF^῎^῍῏^῏JKFyI

ῌ impartialityyB^>eB῍

[#>ῌ CDEFde9 ῐS0TUBV W ῎circumstances exist that give to justifiable doubts῏ῑ

ῐSX YZ[ῑ fhiBῌ R

3>ῌ JKFyCDEFuvw0Q#I ῌ v wxy,z{ῌ 4pq)uU@B^῎^῍ῐ^῏῍ #+

ῌ "Ft#ῌ JKFCDEFuUMN

[0e] ῍

ῌ!"MN3ῌ "Ftῌ JKk lῌ ¡0z{#ῌ ;¡ JKkJK¢

.

῎ῌ

῍

(5)

ῐ ῑ ῌ ῌ !"ῌ# $

% &'()*+),-./0῍ ῌ 123 45 12 3 #) 6789:;<=>

- ῌ ?@ ῌ ῌ &'@AB() C+῍ ῌ D?E)-ῌ ῌ !"FGH IJῌ ῌ K LM- ῌ K #) ῌ NI ?@;0)῍

!" &'#)OPQRῌ STMU()ῌ ῌ῍VῌWE )ῌ ῎impartiality῏ῌ ῎independence῏ ῍#XY) ῌ 0 Z=> B#)ῌ OPQR[\ῌ !" =>

#)]^_ῌ ῌῑῐ῏` UNCITRAL12ab acK deῌ ac()E^῎^ῌ῎^῏ῌ OPQRf- MU => gh῍

ῌ &'#)c8(R, ^῎^ῌ῏^῏ῌ !"

&'#)ῌ %iῌ ῌ 123 jklmn 123o" pq7rsgh t(ῌ ῌ 12 3 o" %uvwq7xyzgh{;0)E^῎^ῌῐ^῏ῌ OPQR c|ῌ &'-ῌ %i{;0)=

>}C}7{~ +A0῍

( )ῌ jklmn,rs123ῌ 123

" o"ῌ oU() ῌ K 6)-ῌ 123 LJjAJῌ

ῌ |A06)-ῌ 123 j LJ(-C+῍ (B( Aῌ 3BA)123 o" rsBAj67 rs;06ῌ C0ῌ 6ῌ STo()ῌ o" 123

4BA|ῌ K0,)j ;0 123 STrgh῎῏ /

῍ῌ

῎

(6)

῍ ῌ ῌ ῌ !"#ῌ $%&'() *+ ῍ ,- .ῌ /0ῌ $%ῌ 123ῌ &451 678 9.:;1 (< =>?2 ῍

ῌ @ABCDE03ῌ @FG.HI+

῎ῌ῏῏

ῌ J,ῌ /0KL1 '>ῌ &KL.' &

M1() NOῌ @&PQ1 RS'TUV) ^῎^ῌῐ^῏῍ WN ῌ ῌ XFῌ !YZ[\&]^ῌ _:

NO&`a1 bc()ῌ /079=-.&W 51 d>῍ J,ῌ /0&e>f gZh) '

>ῌ $%&ij1 (<'DE) ῌ k'lm nῌ &e>f gZh) '>(V)ῌ

&/0Qo/079.pq 67'=>V?2 ῍ NOῌ D.ῌ rstu v() .Vῌ ,mnῌ /0&e>f gDE&wxy'ῌ NOz{&|}ῌ ~&$%1 =>

<ῌ NN "#&>&NOῌ

$%+ &1 67) ῍ =>ῌ /0e') DEx.Vῌ &e>f gZh ) ῌ 123ῌ h1 .ῌ &1

&51 67) ῍ ,-.ῌ &h.

RS(<'mO ῍

῎῍῏ ῐ& <{ῑ DE

(ῌ $h() ῐ& <{ῑ VI+, ῎῎ῐ῍8ῌ ῏ῌ $hRS¡'.ῌ X¢=nῌ XF&£¤.ῌ $¥9DENO¦.ῌ

ῌ §$+ ~) &''ῌ ¨:

0

῎ῌ

῍

(7)

ῌ ῌ

῎῎ῌ῏

῍ !"#$%&'ῌ ()*+

ῌ ,-./01 ,-./23#45! + ^῎^῎῍^῏῍ 678#ῌ 9:01;<=>?@A&' ῎B CDῌ 97EFGHIJFK8LM?NOP*QRS T῏ ῌ 9:01K8UVWXYZ[@\]! +

&' ῎B CDῌ 97EFB^_K8;^_ M`abc defghB! T῏ #4! +ῌ i7ῌ 9:23K 8UVWXYZ[@\]! +&' ῎B CDῌ

"j97EFK8ck#lmno?@A Ap23῏

Ap ^῎^῎῎^῏῍

!qp#ῌ ῐ()*+ῑ ῌ "j01 rsῌ "jUVWXYZ[@\]! + tῌ !#ῌ "j ῐ23ῑ u8 ῌ ῐ01ῑ Zt v ῌ "waῌ 67 ῐxyYp#z9{|ῑ #ῌ i7 ῌ "j01 }S@ῌ ῐYp#z9{|ῑ

#;~z9?qp῍ Rῌ |w 0"w #

Aῌ "ws|t ῐ"jYR BxyYp#z9{|ῑ ῌ |%

ws ῐ"()*+ῑ t v^῎^῎῏^῏῍

῎῏῏ | 23

w#A@ῌ |ῌ ()WXYU A5?BZtῌ ;8 ῌ "(

)*+#9B C8@A^῎^῎ῐ^῏῍ ?K?8ῌ |ῌ

Bsῌ | -#ῌ !|GyN

9X#0K8! #῍ ?B[@ῌ

"jWXY ῐxyYp#z9{|ῑ #

"j#2 ¡῎¢£¤¥῏ 1

῍ῌ

῎

(8)

ῌ ῍ ῌ !"#$"%&'(ῌ ῌ!)*+,"- ./01234*5 ῌ 67 889:;^῏^῎ῑ^ῐῌ < =*>?

῏@AB῎῏C῍D῎Eῐῌ FG =* 8H^῏^῎ῒ^ῐ῍

*<IJ"KLῌ FG ="MN*Oῌ PQL P?RS TL UVWῌ X῎YZL [\8"]^"_`"'

* 8^῏^῎ΐ^ῐῌ a"R9 :;bc9 ῍ d(ῌ

< =e2"FG =*f 8῍

῏ῐῐ gh"FG ="ij"kl

FG ="N/gm(ῌ *nopRqrstu v ῌ gh"R9 wx"Iyῌ BPgh8(]^

ῌ]z/{|}~ ῌ ῌ !"/d W(8ῌ "FG =*ῌ gh":;RWH

'"H^῏^῎῔^ῐ῍ dῌ "FGIJ*ῌ !

(gm 8R9"'ῌ *ῌ !"

/"'Wῌ ῌ !*"!/

"'Wῌ ῌ !" 8!

* ῌ ῌ " ¡:;

*ῌ !¢£¤¥ ¡ῌ gh

":;*bc 8 !TP"/¦!

"'ῌ "§¨©s/ª«d 8R9FG =/ghRW¬

H'89H^῏^῎῕^ῐ^῏^῏ῌ^ῐ῍

"0/®¯῍ A°k Wῌ *IJnῌ ῌ nop*±²2ῌ Tp³'Wῌ *ῌ L ´῎/µ²TP

"¶῍·8gh*k Wῌ wx¸¹2º' 'ῌ !"/:;ῌ ῌ!)»³

1"M¼/NP' 8῍ d 2

῎ῌ

῍

(9)

ῌ

!"#$῍

%#%"ῌ ῌ &'( )*+,- . /0123 4(56 78/04(9:$;ῌ <=

>? ῌ 56ῌ @A BCDAῌ EFGH IJKL MBῌ NOP#"QR<=DAS TUVWXDA ῌ -Yῌ P@A$

BZ[\]#"^_`Yab>? 4DAῌ KLcdeῌ fY$g hij$^῎^῎ῌ^῏῍ kl;ῌ KLc `I#mn#ῌ opqrst uvwῌ * x3 (lijB$;ῌ KLcdeopqry .z { |`$ h῍

lIῌ -Y}~moῌ 56

;ῌ ;ῌ P`Yuv#"ῌ 56 iῌ *

ῌ ῌ #"V

y'$jῌ #" ῌ ##%KLcde

w%ῌ KLc `I;ῌ <=-H$j MBKLXJ R`$῍ lIῌ Ede

w%ῌ KLc `I" .PZ[\]#"^

_ij$B῍

%Iῌ 9:<=&> n#"KLc o S<=Vῌ lIEA>IJSVC wῌ lIῌ EA.;wBῌ <=9:&> $j

$#"ῌ P $KLcdehKL

`y-ij$ 4^῎^῎῍^῏῍

u%ῌ `YPῌ `Y)$

Pῌ lIῌ ¡¢YB%w£`Y .;D AIPP.;Bῌ KLcw4ij$

PKL u¤῎¥¦§¨῏ 3

῎ῌ

῍

(10)

^῎^῏῏^῏῍ ῌ ῌ ῌ !"#$%

&'(!ῌ )*+,-./0$ῌ ῌ 123456!%789:;<%=>?^῎^῏ῐ^῏ῌ

6!%ῌ +, @Aῌ BC:4D%!)EF !῍

G%ῌ 7=!%23HIJ9 K* !῍

῎ῑ῏ 23HLMῌNO

23HPQR/0 )S !TF*ῌ

UVWG%IJ:EX)$Y$Z[῍ 1\

1] W*^ῌ 1῍῔_῍`23Habc$K*

$^῎^῏ῑ^῏ῌ )W*^ῌ UVWG%)*9 23H:

def)$Y !) ῍ )gῌ h1i=!%2 3H:LM):jklmno^῎^῏ῒ^῏\pῌ 23HLM 6!%)*:qfῌ rsH$23tu-6!%ῌ )*:

v^῎^῏ΐ^῏῍ )1f23Hῌ wxy1῍῎_῎` z{c|}ῌ )*P~n$K*^῎^῏῔^῏ῌ wxy1c

:4῍

)gwxy1ῌ 19 ῌ wxy1\1:]

_ῌ ῐῌ \

6!%, !:oKW[ ῌ UV

: !Y^῍G^῍%^῍ ῎o^῍n^῍^῍ly^῍^῍i^῍f῏ 23K*[ῑ ῎g῏ fῌ 23H:%!^῎^῏῕^῏῍ )|

*ῌ ) ¡¢K*ῌ

£23H:¤¥)¦!^῎^ῐῌ^῏῍ G%ῌ )\1§

¨©>ῌ wxy1Rῌ ῌ 23H:LM):jK*

%! !K*ῌ )1%ª ῌ 2 3HLM1RjkK* !«¬῍

+*

῎ῌ

῍

(11)

ῌ ῌ ῌ !"#$%ῌ & '

!()$&* #+,-./0123453/

6789:;ῌ ῌ <)$=>?@

ABCDEF G;Cῌ HIJCKῌ LM8

D/NF2OK῍ ;@$ῌ

ῌ D P2O"Qῌ '01R ῌ S'01R9:ETUO"QVUῌ O9 :ῌ ῍῎ ῏῏ῐ WXY2O2῍

Z@ῌ W)[\]'^_`abc def,/&

'!()gh>2O01?3ῌ 59:%#῍ a i&')jῌ ^_`abc def,/@ῌΐk῎lῌ

῏lmn.m"#?^῏^῏ῌ^ῐῌ OoK!(01?KO Kῌ Op;& '/qr2@m"#"ῌ h>

!(01?5st^῏^῏῍^ῐ#῍ Odeῌ ῌ \]' #3453/uv2@wx/& 'yz2@

{|K}~"#gῌ D/q2@yKῌ

\]'f,"#t?ῌ & 'D/

;@ !^῏^῏῎^ῐ$ῌ 33& '!(%01?VU^῏^῏῏^ῐ῍ O def,;ῌ f,9:Kῌ W)[

\]'ῌ ^_`abc /de2@ῌ Z&* #

3453/2{|#gῌ !8KHI"O/2f,

#t?)5^῏^῏ῐ^ῐ῍ Z@ῌ ^_`abc def,ῌ

f,/$@ !ῌ ^῏^῏ῑ^ῐ,./5OK5 ῌ <Su;@33f,<ῌ ^_R/5 g

¡&KKῌ *&;K"#5^῏^῏ῒ^ῐ῍

2¢9:῏£¤¥¦ῐ ++

῍ῌ

῍

(12)

ῌ

῎῍῏ ῌ

ῌ ῌ ῌ ῌ

!"#$%&'(ῌ )*+ῌ ,-

%*'.!*/ῌ 0῎῍1῍2῏2'345ῌ

!'67 8*%&'(῍ 9ῌ .῍2'345ῌ :;%&+῍ %<'=ῌ ῌ 9 ῌ ῌ >(?@AB&8*C῍ 0Dῌ ῌ )*+ῌ ῐEF?@G8)'%&

H5%&IJ&^῎^ῐῒ^῏ῑῌ ῐ6K&ῌ LM

!NOPQ7ῌ RS)'TU8V%&WXH7ῌ 9ῌ YZP['LM8V%&+.\]C;

Hῑ &^_ῌ %` '6*/ῌ ῌ '?@AB (&K%&'(῍

a0b'Qῌ c^ῌ de%&'fghi0 Xg+H(%&C;^῎^ῐΐ^῏ῌ j!'67kl m%&H5ῌ '=ῌ >(?@ABH

&^῎^ῑῌ^῏῍ 9ῌ 0 n&+ῌ op&q(7!r st uHῌ devwdu&.xyzgop '{|Kst uH}~'ῌ >(?@(

%&ῌ ~&(&ῌ >?@

AB&` ^῎^ῑ῍^῏῍

%<'=00_Hw(ῌ 0'6*/ῌ Hῌ !'34st u H}~C;!'67U(

%&H5ῌ 9ῌ 'ῌ '

+,

῍ῌ ῌ

(13)

ῌ ῌ !ῌ "#$%&'()*

+,-./0*12^῎^ῐ῍^῏ῌ 3456789:;

<^῎^ῐ῎^῏῍ =.>ῌ ?@AB:;CDῌ EFG@

-ῌ "#$H&'(-<῍

Iῌ .JKL"=MNῌ JKOPQR2ῌ 2STῌ JKUVWX"=MNῌ $%YZ[\ ῍ ]=ῌ ^)ῌ $%Y._=.$%Y`abc . ῌ d$".1^῎^ῐ῏^῏ῌ e fῌ "#$H&'(g 1h+῍ i.jῌ

@.k*lm=EFG@ῌ "H&'(n!ῌ opqH

&Q'rst῍ =.>ῌ "H&Q' uv.?@Y1qῌ wxyzr +$%Y{|q}~^῎^ῐῐ^῏ῌ #$H&Q'rῌ '

1.ῌ ῌ ?@qiῌ -

H.1C+S^῎^ῐῑ^῏῍

῎῍῏ ?T=Cbc

@ῌΐoῌCDῌ $%Y.JKN=MNῌ N=JKC῍ ῌ 9ῌ $%YN

sst.<72ῌ M Nῌ sstC῍ =Dῌ %6

%s῍ΐoῐῌ ῐ6ῌ $%Y7C,

=Iῌ :4562ῌ $ῌ tῑ st ῌ 9.$tt῍ $%Y

JKN.MNῌ @ῌΐo῍stC2ῌ .t+῍ t9ῌ <

=.t Si¡+iῌ ]=ῌ .@῎ῒo῎

9¢῎L£¤¥῏ +-

῎῍ ῌ

(14)

῍ ῌ ῌ !ῌ "#$%&'(&)*

+ῌ ,-./01&23ῌ "#$%&45678 9:;<-=>!1῍

-?@'(&ῌ %A+ῌ ῐB7CDE(

ῌ "#$%&4F?)*7GHG3ῌ IJ4K- E(291Lῌ MG7"#01NOPQ RS-E(TUOV-ῌ ῌ WXY+)Z )*4[\]^3ῌ )*_`+Aa01-4=bL8 ^῎^ῐῒ^῏ῑ (῍ ῌ cde8ῌ %fg2(&ῌ "#$%&4 567"#:;<hE('(&Fi 01^῎^ῐΐ^῏ῌ IJY+"#$%&45678"#:;<

L^῎^ῐ῔^῏῍ -jCLῌ 7MGNO2(&ῌ "#$%&ῌ Tklm8nῌ (+ῌ .!?@(8+(NOῌ ,)*o3)Z"#+Tp3ῌ -1oq&rs tu4vw-E^῎^ῑῌ^῏ῌ x.01&(῍ 8q8ῌ 7 ῍7NO+ῌ 7yzLE+ῌ "#@)*L -+!(^῎^ῑ῍^῏ῌ {7yzL(E+ῌ "#@(

)*L-|}-Eῌ -1oq&"#$%&

4L+ῌ )ZRL"#$%&4-E~01

῎ῑ῎῏

῍ cde8ῌ -NOῌ +)ZRL"#$%&4- E^῎^ῑ῏^῏῍

῎῏῏ "#:῏ῒ῏ C

ῌ "#'(&:῏ῒ῏

(῍ 8L-1ῌ

῏ῒ῏o3ῌ O+h&7

zNOῌ ,7"#'(&:

+.

῎ῌ

῍

(15)

῍ ῌ ῌ ῌ !" # $%

ῌ &'()*+,^῎^ῑ῏^῏῍ ῌ

!" #-./ 01234- 5ῌ ῐ 67ῑ 89:;<ῌ ='ῌ 6>8 ?@='A +B ( )*CDE+FGῌ HCIJK-0L MNOP ῌ &'($+ QR;^῎^ῑῐ^῏῍

-ῌ STK'UVW XCQDE;

ῌ UVW YZCK'YZ[\ῌ !" $%ῌ

῎ῒ]῎7STK'UVW῍ΐ]῍^%_3+$%

'G,QR`aK^῎^ῑῑ^῏ῌ b c)d\e fghH῍ K'iῌ UVW ῌ !" $

%C $%j_Fi'- GHῌ UVW k%C0 lmnoK'^῎^ῑῒ^῏ RpK-ῌ UVW Rpq,B

;r,῍

῎῏῏ !"s tuῌ6vwx

ῌΐ]῎7 k%yHzῌ !" #CKy,+6ῌ hH'C{i'|='!"6};C{i'|

~HF|FGῌῐ|5ῌ !" CK'#C

KHzG῍ !" #CKFi'6 ῌ b cῌ K $% e!

"6}C+ F,F῍ , ῌ

῍ῒ]eῌ eῌ ῐ6ῌ k

%6 ?@y<%_GH' S ῎~H-

3K- ῍῏ hHC{<Gῌ

῎gC BB %_;X?;iῌ ¡

=῏ gC Bῌ 6¢£ ?@<ῌ ( !"3+¤῎¥¦§¨῏ +/

῍ῌ

῎

(16)

ῑ ῌ ῌ !"ῌ #$%&'()*+,- .ῌ /-012!"3456!78$9:;'!<

'=>!"^῎^ῑΐ^῏῍

'? ῌ @ABCDE!78FGHCIJ,KLM NOP=>ῌ Qῌ @A1RSTUVWX4 78=YM=Z[#$%\]'^ῌ _#!"'

`978abc(d012&ῌ 78a4&e,-C CMXf"^῎^ῑ῔^῏῍ Qῌ N῍ΐg῎h&ῌ ῐijῌ k&#

lijmC4no/p'-q \#$%&ῌ # lij2r3$978stuv)^ῌ #l78 '!<ῑ ῌ 78$9"'r^>"]4/

%ijuvῌ #l$9L^#l78a 4'&!<C!ῌ /M!">wῌ 78$9"'r^

>78a4=3#$%&ῌ #l78$9L^#l 78'!<C'CM^῎^ῒῌ^῏῍ 'xymC4z{|N N1R}C4~|&ῌ #$%78a()78 a4=3uvῌ /2@A>.ῌ TU

@Aῌ b@A}C4#l78$9:;'!<CP

!<!"Xf^῎^ῒ῍^῏ῌ &ῌ 'XfmC4

'ῌ Q''=3^῎^ῒ῎^῏῍

'xy &ῌ N}C4ῌ #$%&ῌ 78

'@Ab,Kuv&ῌ T78uv^῎^ῒ῏^῏ῌ 78 CM¡¢Xf!"LM£¤-^῎^ῒῐ^῏῍ '-¥

ῌ ¦§:;#¨¦§TULMuvῌ ]wῌ T©ª$9«#$¬#$%!"uv ῎®N῎῏

g῍h῍¯῏ῌ '-&ῌ °±²F4³´$9!"^ῌ µῌ ==@A_¶N&·¸,-'&>.ῌ #$

+0

῎ῌ

῍

(17)

῎ῒῐ῏

ῌ ῌ

ῌ !"#$%&'(")*ῌ ' "῍

+,-./0"123῍ 4567ῌ 89:

;<=>?@῍ (Aῌ 8)*ῌ BC)*

Dῌ 9:E'FGHIJ3KL9?@"K῍

M(ῌ NODῌ BCPKGHQ"R;<7S ῍ T UVῌ BC8Dῌ 'WX!"YQZ [ῌ '>\]^_`abEAcM"3KZ"

?@"^῎^ῒῑ^῏῍ )*ῌ R;<ῌ 8deXfg hQ(ῌ Pi"Bj ()*ῌ 8deX j"Z2"Zῌ NOE;< kQ"lm^῎^ῒῒ^῏῍

@n ῌ 9: ῎oN4῎῏p῏ ῌ Bqr"sFtu

vwxy (7Z^῎^ῒΐ^῏ῌ 9:")*ῌ BC'FGH IJ3KL9?@"ῌ 'zBCNOJ{NO4|]}

"῍ )*ῌ 9:;<ῌ NO)*~ῌ B

!"($ῌ !"#$%&")*ῌ (0ῌ BC9:7z'!""ῌ 8' Z")*Kῌ 8a`'Z")*

῎oN4῎῏p῍῍῏ῌ 8'FGHIJ3KL9?@"12

Z"?@"^῎^ῒ῔^῏῍

b^ ῌ NO)*ῌ BhQ"'

Kῌ oBn!"g!"($ῌ 9:ῌ 6E

R;<kQK@(?@"^῎^ΐῌ^῏ῌ )*ῌ T='X

>WE"3Kῌ ;<Z"NOdgDῌ Tlmt<*NO1u[^῎^ΐ῍^῏῍ 3 Kῌ '

Kῌ on !"NOY"c;<

og!"lmt"Z2^῎^ΐ῎^῏῍ ( 8^!"+,῎ ῏ +1

῍ῌ

῎

(18)

ῌ ῌ ῌ !"#$ῌ %ῌ &' ()*+

,-./012345ῌ ,,67$ῌ 89:1234;<

῎ΐ῎῏

῍

=> :ῌ ?@AB$ῌ CDEFG >ῌ &AHIJKLM= ABῌ N3 AB῍OPQ= ῌ R3$ῌ ST%ῌ UHVWX?

@ABῌ YHZWX?@ABN0[0\]=^῎^ΐ῏^῏῍ =ῌ

^῍ῒ_`aIJKbcdefg῍ hiῌ

# ?@ABja-0ῌ &k#$()*+,-./0ῌ lm dn<ohp34,-ῌ ?@ABPQ$ῌ ῍ῒ_

ῐlmqrs/0=ῑ &t:/0῍ N

ῌ ZWX?@AB O$ῌ lmCDEFAB34 5ῌ &k#lmdn$ῌ ^%uv!wxῌ &AH$IJ KLM= $-:/0῍ yzῌ VWX?@AB O

$ῌ u d{3$oῌ &AH$ῌ ?@KLM=

:/0῍ |tῌ ^ῌΐ_῍}~` >0ῌ ?@AB4=

5-4<NH# 67tῌ &kAB >5&

k#?@=$32=,-ῌ ?@AB4=

5-?@,t&AH$ῌ &k?@AB >5&

k#?@={|t32= :/0^῎^ΐῐ^῏ῌ ῌΐ_῍ }/0{|tῌ ?@AB$u dVWX?@AB -0>῍

|tῌ ^$ῌ K dIJ^῎^ΐῑ^῏$I5ῌ

)X~``a3ῌ &AH$ ?@

)$ῌ ?@ $ῌ = =

5ῌ NY$ῌ ?@KLM= ῍ , -ῌ &AH$?@AB oIJ15ῌ IJKLMῌ +2

῎ῌ

῍

(19)

ῌ !" !῍ #$ῌ %&ῌ '()*

&ῌ +!,-./῍῔0῏123456789:;ῌ

<*ῌ =>.?@AB.CD&ῌ ῎ῒ0E-ῌ F?@ABGHIJ4.^῎^ΐῒ^῏῍

EKLMNO</PQ4RS4&ῌ T UVO WX/!EKYZ!῍ 4.Z[ῌ LH\']^ῌ TU_`ab ῎IBA῏ cdT_ῌ ῍ῌ VOef῎ῌῌῐgῑhij# ῐTUkH\']^4 IBAlmnomp ῎IBA Guidelines on Conflicts of Interest in Inter- national Arbitration^῎^ΐΐ^῏῏ῑ &ῌ qrst#&u9s*'v wx :yῌ %z{4|F.}~. ῌ

|&}~t|&.%z{4|F

῎*ῌ %CD&ῌ %z{4E-<<y

$ L4|F4῍

%&ῌ &.-. ῎no person can be his or

her own judge῏ῌ K-ῌ L4|F

.yῌ ῌL%|-ῌ t#&ῌ L

%|_L%|CDῌ ῍L%Lῌ

t#&^j|CDt#&!ῌ 4%

)¡¢£¤4CDῌ ῎L%t#&¥¦§

.¨©)Hª¤4CDῌ ῏LL«#%

t#&+^¬%35)ῌ t#&Lt#&+O®

%t#&+^¬%</.¨©)¯°CD±²

῍

GIJ&³ῌ %Gz{4&

!|´K<῍ µ()^&ῌ q¶^Z-ῌ %

!z{4& !." !῍ !('() L^4c·¸῎¹º»¼῏ +3

῎ῌ

῍

(20)

ῌ

῍ !"#ῌ $%&'(#ῌ )*

+,- ῌ %./01234+5ῌ % 6789:;<=>2?2

@A^῎^ῑῒ^῏῍ 4Bῌ CD%EFῌ CDGHIJGKL)M NOPQREῌ STUVW.XYZ[

\]ῌ ^- CD_`9a^-bc6de 5ῌ 4Bῌ ῍ῒf῏gDGhUVijkJ#J-%

bcFlm#2?^-2no^῎^ῒῌ^῏῍

##2+ῌ pqa"# ῌ rqa sῌ CD_`tu"e ! 2vῌ wxyz21{|

##4}+ῌ ~,

9: e2῍ 4Bῌ DGhUVJ-CD%

῍ῒf῏g ῌ l#BKJX"4B CD?

2KJ#BAlῌ 6KJ DGhUVck Jῌ 6

"#2+῍ #Bῌ pqa ῌ o# 2῍

῎ῐ῏ DGh@|

CD%῍ῒf῏g{ῌ l#BUVῌ 4B ῌ l2Alῌ CDUVῌ CD2 KJB ῌ 6#B ῌ 6KJ

01B+῎ῌῌ DGhq#ῌ CD@

2῍ kJ"# ῌ ῌ

@5ῌ CDGHῌ 6CDGH ¡

#¢-3 !2῍

£"#ῌ '( ῌ DGhq@¤¥¦§ῌ F ,*

῎ῌ

῍

(21)

῎῔῍῏

῍ ῌ

ῌ ῐ !ῌ "#$% &'()*+, -.

/012ῌ 345678349:;< .=ῌ >=

' ?ῌ 34@ ABC 49D 56EFGHI*/01ῑ J K^῎^῔῎^῏῍ .'ῌ LMῌ ῐ349:NOP56QRSTU VWAXYZῌ 34@[\V]^_`

^a bcdefg*ῌ hgῌ 34567i 349:;< j*klmH 0

῎/῔῏῏

ῑ n[ o-ῌ ῐVp( gWA'qrῌ /Y=

3456stu v;<^῎^῔ῐ^῏ῑ JK῍

.wῌ 34x῍῏y῏zῌ {-|'Vῌ ῏ῌ}~49 D-tg ῐ{-|* ῎may re-

quest῏ῑ tAE2ῌ g !ῌ ῏ῌ}"#7iNῌ

{| 49D*12ῌ

Yῌ ῏ῌ}~w{| - !0

()*1H ῍ gῌ 34*34S%

9: 349:|tg=='qrEῌ

tV*49D-34S%9:

A{| *ῌ tA34x῎῏yῐzt

ru/0dtH g῍ ,lῌ 34x῎῏yῐzῌ x

῍ῒy῏zt12^῎^῔ῑ^῏ῌ x῍ῒy῏zῌ 34@

56tA'x῍῏y῏ztῌ 34g34 S% t-49D {| WAt tA '*^῎^῔ῒ^῏ῌ x῍ῒy῏zt-dῌ 49D-{|

/-/ῌ VQR¡¢0 E2ῌ {| Iwῌ V*34S%£¤ 349:OP-{|

¥¦0 H ^῎^῔ΐ^῏῍ gy/0ῌ -' 34@§¨[\῎©ª«¬῏ ,+

῍ῌ

῍

(22)

ῌ ῌ !" #$%῍

&'ῌ ()*++,-./0 ῌ 12 3 4564789:;'ῌ <=>?@A#

B;Cῌ DEῌ FGHI1>?FG9:ῌ J

#B>?&"GK;Cῌ EL῎MNO0#

!0P%'!^῎^ῒῑ^῏ῌ QRSTῌ U; ῌ >

?VW;ῌ ELX ῌ >?&"

YZW$[Eῌ ELX῎M\]X^῎^ῒῒ^῏ME./'^_ῌ

`>??a;bcde; 1fῌ >?V

;bghif^῎^῍ῌῌ^῏ῌ Jjῌ klTmEnῌ X

!op$%'^῎^῍ῌ῍^῏῍

1Lῌ ()*++,-./1%Kῌ +῍ῒ\ῐq r;()*+῍῏\῏qstuῌ !>?v '>?V ; Ww;x CyLC!/zV{ [fῌ klT|}O%Ww; B t' ~P%῍ '!ῌ CC+QR ^῎^῍ῌ῎^῏ῌ

!'Btu&'`1![E ; Bt ῌ ! [%K[

P[E #$%[E῍

1L[# ῌ !;1Lῌ U ' ῌ ^_0'"ῌ Y Z; W; [fῌ >?!t [!D [

E!ῌ stῌ ; ῌ >

?&"YZ; !"[E'n"D fῌ U'!st1ba[C'h

"Dnῌ J'NU"D fῌ &'ῌ %1>?FG$% ["ῌ >

,,

῎ῌ

῍

(23)

ῌ !"#$%῍ &'ῌ ()*

+,-./012'3$ῌ 456 789:(;<=0!>?ῌ ()@A?BCD C% EFG%HI0!@J9῍ 4@3ῌ ( K῍῕LῐM<Nῌ 0$ῌ OPJ

$%Qῌ RSGT4UGJV<4ῌ <NWXYQ ZJ$[%῍ \]^ῌ +_`(2a2J bcd)ῌ !efgh<i0 'Kjk lm0!$noV?p@ῌ <Nq$rs@V> t uC῍

%vῌ wxyz$ῌ ῐ0$56>3 {|m}~0!@J9 ῎(K῍῕L῍M4῏ῌ

GT4UG ῎LῐM῏ $"UGC!

D ῎῎ῒL῍M4^῎^῍ῌ῏^῏῏ῑῌ $(K῎ΐL>3R

ῌ ῐR$h%!%3ῌ J,-J9

!%?{ JV^῎^῍ῌῐ^῏ῑ <ῌ {'Jῌ (K῍῔L῎M

ῌ +3%@{(;=45ῌ : +>?:(;!@J9%JVD

ῌ +@V!?%@%D34$ῌ :+>?:(;0!$J9%JVD^῎^῍ῌῑ^῏ῌ ῐ$ῌ {CZJ~2Js+%

4iG@C4*C!%!]ῌ {CJ$

%D34JVDῌ >?!ῌ {>

CZ^῎^῍ῌῒ^῏ῑ ^῎^῍ῌΐ^῏῍

D!s+$e@V῍ $ῌ (K῍῕LῐM@GT 0$"UGJV?ῌ @!C%5 60!C%!$DJV@ῌ 0 (; 0¡ef῎a¢£¤῏ ,-

῍ῌ ῌ

(24)

ῌ ῎ῑ !"#$%$&'(ῌ %()*%

ῌ +,-῎ῑῌ ./01234$%+,56789:

%$%;&**ῌ <=><=?@$%Aῌ <=

BC4DE$Fῌ %(ῌ 4./0 ,GHI4JKῌ '5678L3$4Dῌ 5678L3M4./0NO<=BCF&PKῌ <

=BCF$Q5R./0ῌ ,GHI4

S4$4Dῌ ῎ῑT

UF$$%῍

*>&ῌ ῎ῑῌ ./0ῌ +,O/V%(ῌ +,56 783F/W;&**ῌ <=?@$Aῌ <=

BC4DE$%(ῌ ,GHIF S4$XYῌ Z'[\4 FA$%%(῍

%(]^ῌ ,GHIFBCFY]_ῌ

`aFY]b$%%(cd^῎^῍ῌῒ^῏῍ >ῌ ./0,GHIFefg4%!

&ῌ <=TUF$%$%h῍

῎ῐ῏ +,i566

+,-῍ΐ῏jῌ k/l,GHkm4%

n%Dῌ +,iῌ +,56op4ῌ >64ῌ *ῌ +,G qFA4ῌ +,i566%῍

rs*%ῌ -t.0ῌ ῐ+,56uvwx4ῌ y%

+,56z{4|}~$xF^῎^῍ῌΐ^῏ῑ

4%῍ 566F@A(ῌ +,i,

%h^῎^῍῍ῌ^῏ῌ 'XYῌ +,iῌ ($XYῌ ,.

ῌ῍

῍

(25)

῍

ῌ !"#$%&'(ῌ )*

+,-./01%ῌ 2&+,3-45ῌ 678 59%ῌ :&ῌ +;4&'(/ῌ +;<5=4>?

@Aῌ +B/ῌ CDῌ EF GH4IJ KL '(M Nῌ 677O P^῎^ῌῌῌ^῏῍

῎ῑ῏ QR

+,/ῌ )ST(U%&GHVWD%X/+B:&/

Y5EFGH4&'(ῌ -./01

῎῍ῌZῌ[῏\῏῍ ]^ῌ GHVW:&/+BEF GH%&_ῌ )ST`%%ῌ EFGH%&'(ῌ GH`%ab/

῎ῑZ῏ῌ ῎ῐ῏ c&Yῌ defghi%&+gῌ +

;<=67jkῌ +67l67YN mGnoApq&rs@Aῌ 67YN D0tumG4m P῍ %

&Nῌ YGHYNῌ SFvwK H^῎^ῌῌ῍^῏῍ '(ῌ EFGH4&'(ῌ GHYNῌ +,Wx%&+67/yg5ῌ zQ ῌ /ῌ +,{.|}~Q/N%ῌ ῌ

%῍

W%ῌ /`%῍ /ῌ ῐ+B67

ῌ7ῌ 4J/+;: D#&g ῎ῌῒZῐ [῏ rs4^῎^ῌῌ῎^῏ῑ EFῌ ῐEF5 GH/`%AQR%ῌ 4&+, : N

&{./ῌ QA P^῎^ῌῌ῏^῏ῑ `%ῌ /ῌ +,W῎l῏ ,/

ῌ῍

῎

(26)

ῌ

^῎^῍῍῏^῏ῌ ῐῌ !"#$%&&'(

)*+,ῌ - ./012$34῍ 567 ῌ !ῌ 89:2";<=,">?ῌ @;<

AB: CD2"%&EF$ G7 -,H+^῎^῍῍ῐ^῏ῑ ῌ I"59:Jῌ ῐK

=,"L!89:7 ;<=,$ῌ 5;<MN OPM2Qῌ K8EF$26ῌ

;<RSTQU,2I6V6+ ^῎^῍῍ῑ^῏ῑ 6῍

I1ῌ ῌ WFXῌ =,^῎^῍῍ῒ^῏ῌ @ YGFX$Z[=,A6ῌ \]^2"A6ῌ _`a' +bcde=, fg8hi7 j*klmnB:

op7 ῌ bqCD2"%&rMῌ ῌ set3uῌ B:op7 @8 vw7 w) G=, ῍ ῌ 89:

7 w<7 ῌ =,"s_`a'd eMxOPy!z{2ῌ ῌ|M7 }~^῎^῍῍ΐ^῏ῌ

+2ῌ s69:

Qῌ $ῌ mnB:8e#ῌ nB:J ῌ ῌ|M{4G7#V6῍

?ῌ|M8<7 YGῌ E%&&'()*+, 87 ῌ %&&'(ῌ n7

ῌ )*+, $ ^῎^῍῎ῌ^῏ῌ @(D=, @ῌ ῌ %&&'(8'2ῌ K82"ῌ w<2"CD2"%&rM ῌ KI'!

"%&r!2I6ῌ ῌ|M8<7 yQ2$ῌ

@,8<7 y ῍ I"ῌ KL89 :7 ;<=,"ῌ 5;<OPM2)*ῌ ,0

ῌ῍

῎

(27)

ῌ ῌ ῌῌ ῎῏῏ !ῌ "#

$%ῌ "#&'() !*+

ῌ ῌ,*- ῌ ./01234%56

78῍

῎῏῏ "# 9:;<

"#=!;<<>1? ,?ῌ #@!A"#B 9:;<C!"# DE ῌ 9:;<%"#

!*FGHIDJ ,῍ KLῌ "#B9:%ῌ MN"

#O3-ῌ PMN"#B"#;<,?QRSTD ,?ῌ "#-U%ῌ "#BVW%XYZEῌ "#B QR[\%ῌ 9:()%P] J ^῎^ῌ῍ῌ^῏῍ * ῌ 9:

#!Zῌ ^A_9:/`a?bc!%ῌ .d"#B

>*->e%fgDEῌ ,,/Oh./02i%

?ῌ "#BjW,?QRSTkl!mn ῌ bc D*ῌ 9:()%P] ῌ ,,9:/op./0

%ῌ ῎ῌῌ῏ qf !ῌ "#῎῎rῌs῏tMuv!"#

&'wfD x῍

y!ῌ #@!A9:()z!ῌ "#=;<<

>1>{-|}"#-bc%~ ,῍ bc!%ῌ #

@;<>C!"#BVWXY !Eῌ %"#B jW>,?QR %Lῌ 9:/`OhI

῍ bcῌ 9:/ῌ E6Iῌ ^A_9:/`

Oh./02i%?ῌ 9:;<%ῌ "#- !

*FGHI x.%,J ,^῎^ῌ῍῍^῏῍

Zῌ "#U9:hh!ῌ

%ῌ ῐ!D*ῌ #9:()?-!

"#B9:!῎C῏ ,1

ῌ῍

῎

(28)

ῌ ῌ ! "#$%& %'$ῌ %()

*+,ῌ -./01234%56 ,7ῌ 89:;%<=>?ῌ & %'$ῌ

@A>,^῎^ῌ῍῎^῏ῐ B'ῌ ῌ CD./E῍ῐFG%

./01>,+ῌ "#+>,ῌ H

>,7ῌ Iῌ "#,7ῌ JK 6$

L$ME>,N4%$ῌ L$MEO P

% & %56,AQ@^῎^ῌ῍῏^῏RS%+>,

@ῌ T&UVῌ T&WXY Y0%ZE>,

7ῌ ῍ῐFJK 6%01[L$UV\=

&56O]ST&UV^$()῍

_`7ῌ XY\abD#N4$UVῌ cT

&def$XYg*ῌ hbD#N4$UV ῌ T&Pi:XYῌ j0XY\ῌ kl mnT&P 2P>ῌ T&P-\+ῌ D#

ko N4%pq,7ῌ XY r 56,@

῍

῎ῒ῏ s [UVXYt7u$

XYvwῌ T&dD#s [UVῌ T&dxy z{$ῌ |}T&d~x῍ UVῌ T&XY t7u%>,A῍ ῌ xy z{$

T&def$0<T&XYME>,UVῌ XY 7ῌ t7u%56,῍ ῌ ῎ῑ῏ >Q&2

e$ῌ D#hbD#>,UVῌ &2 ῌῌ @>ῌ cT&def$

T&XYH>,7ῌ E`ῌ T&Wῌ XY t7u%56 ,2

ῌ῍

῎

(29)

῍ ῌ ῌ ῌ !"#"#$%&

'( )*ῌ +&, -'.῍ /01ῌ + )*'. 2ῌ 3456789:;ῌ +<=0>?

@Aῌ ῌ BC5Dῌ EFGῌ H=0IIJKLMNO P<=,.QR^῎^῍῎ῐ^῏῍ STῌ UTV3W.)

*,ῌ +XYZ[,\-'.Eῌ ,ῌ ]^_`ῌ Z[

aEb0G010A῍

῎῍ῌ῏ cdef -g

X2ῌ \;hijk dlV&S'm/nR/ῌ AFocdef -g6pqrῌ //ijk dlV&S 'm/nR/AR6p.῍ s]t@A2ῌ //34

*u -gvA,wx. ^῎^῍῎ῑ^῏ῌ Fyz{,ῌ | },ῌ 3W~ 3V;1Eῌ 3|}Acdef,;1ῌ ]^;

dlV|}S,'m0A2.^῎^῍῎ῒ^῏῍ ]_ῌ

;hijT*u -gvA,ῌ ῌ +

T, ῐ3_ijῑ '0G010Aῌ

6p,ῌ S^῎^῍῎ΐ^῏῍

ῌ g /῍ 0Fῌ 34S 'mij'./nR/ ῎῍῏e῍f῏῍ SgvA,ῌ 34*ukg6p0῍ kRῌ TV3W vA,ῌ 340wL0AEῌ w

'ῌ ,34*uk S'm'.

^῎^῍῎῔^῏ῌ ῌ UTV3WX,ῌ cdef)

*qrῌ 34*uk S'm0A FEῌ X¡6p῎¢£¤¥῏ ,3

ῌ῍

῎

(30)

ῌ !"^῎^῍῏ῌ^῏῍ #$%&ῌ '()*+,ῌ - ./0123῍ 4$ῌ '()*5()*ῌ 67 89:2;<=>?@A Bῌ %CD3 !"῍

4$ῌ -Eῌ F)*GHIJ2#$῍ΐKῐL+ῌ M7%NOPQIRN%STJ2 2U

῎῍ΐK῍L῏῍ #$%&ῌ ῎ῐ῏ VBWX$)*YZ[\]0

^_ῌ NSTJ2`>%@Aab%ῌ )*YZ[

cPd$ebῌ NJ2ῌ M7%PQ#$)*f2g`4$

-he)*Ii%Rf2(#ῌ F)*GH IM7%PQe&jkῌ lmRN%bQn &

ῌ o;o;M7%)*IUpqrsfItuv"- PQ )*w2KL\]0@Axy`>#s3 ^῎^῍῏῍^῏῍

zWeBῌ -{)*IUpqrῌ 5()*`Rc PIkῌ -e&sfRN%!"῍

῎῍῍῏ -{)*-V|#`>

῎ῑ῏ d$}Bῌ -~M7%)*GHI#ῌ

%NIf2RcPῌ of2eB-{)*@A sf3N῍ N(#ῌ M7%)*O

ICD#-ῌ NI#-IVB|Rῌ 4$ῌ NI-##Tf2IRN%

ab῍ 4$ῌ -{%<HI&$c P)*%-#$cP;N^_@A%῍

-EWῌ )*V|#X%ῌ 5()*

%UcPῌ ~<=Ii ῎ῐῐK῍Lῒ^῎^῍῏῎^῏῏ V -*

ῌ῍

῎

(31)

῍ ῌ ῌ ῎῎ῌῐ !"#$%

&'(&)* ῍ + ,-ῌ ῌ ῑ./012 34ῌ 56/7῎῎89+:/;<"=ῒ > ?@

ῌ AῐBC#ῌ $Dῌ <Eῌ

$%> +;EFGῌ <ῌ HI$

%> JK C#BIῌ $D/L!"#

$%ῌ M ῍

="#ῌ /LN>OP+QR)* ῌ /STῌ UVWX!Kῌ ῑY/ZFῌ [W+\]+

;:ῌ Y^_; `ῌ $%a=bc>de+:/;

Cfg!( ῌ $%> +!hij k>lm#ῌ $DL $%>+>no+<^῏^ῌ῍῍^ῐῒ ῌ ῑY/$%W="#ῌ /^_pῌ 6m/q o/rsTtufvwx fg^῏^ῌ῍῎^ῐῒ ῍

y=ῌ z{/|};<ῌ ~]+ῌ 3 4;<&ῌ Y//]ῌ $%

/ῌ C#ῌ ῑ/p

&ῌ =J;Iῌ /\

JK Iῌ Y;:I$%/qo

=/Hw;<(῍ + ,-ῌ Y/] &"= K

$%/qo "=:/;<"=I;</Hw;<

῏ῌ῍῏(ῐ

ῒ /<῍ y=ῌ ῑ/E,#;<C

;<(ῒ ῌ ῑ1U=$%Y//SBC#W;<

BY/>+=e/!( J; Cfg^῏^ῌ῍ῐ^ῐῒ :C(῍

(ῌ /ῌ pῌ Up>(W

<ῌ > ¡¢O&£¤ῌ Y!"# $%

/T+¥)*῏¦§¨©ῐ -+

ῌ῍

῎

(32)

ῌ !"#$%ῌ &'^῎^ῌ῍ῐ^῏῍ ()ῌ

*+,--./0ῌ !ῌ 12345678 9:;!<=ῌ >?9:@A'Bῌ78 CD;EFGH;Eῌ 3456/)IJK'L M'(NOPQRS TU

;!'VW0V῍ X(ῌ YJKZ[\]56^_`abῌ U 5cdO3456e)(QR!ῌ fg;hi'W0ῌ Y^_`ajklm!ῌ noῌ JKpq0<1U'r6!'P=ῌ ῎῎sῌt῏u 56/) !'P'vwx^῎^ῌ῍ῑ^῏῍

y

z{;!ῌ Y34|Ma*@D}y~ *ῌ

[)(῍ ῌ

(῍

X=ῌ 3456|!ῌ ῌYJKp!ῌ YU5c

v'vrEvvῌ Z[p!ῌ YJK'

|U5cῌ 5 ¡v'vv0ῌ ῍

ῐJKpX(!Z[pq0<1U'r6ῑ !¢3456;E

ῐJK£GH5¤ῑ ¥`;Eῌ ῎¦§Y§3456

¨©!¥;Eῌ ῏U5cª«Y0;'vY

¬v§3456¨©jv!'vῌ ῐ3456i!

®=ῌ ¯°v!34±5²³´¥%;Hῌ ῐ Y/µY¶·cJKZ[\]56^_`a¸R¹

!ῌ 34±5²³´²ºῌ ῑJKZ[\]56»¼à Yῌ Y¶·cEῌ ^_àῌ »¼àjklm!ῌ noῌ -,

ῌ῍ ῌ

(33)

῍

ῌ ῌ

ῌ !"#$%&'()*ῌ +, -./ ῌ ῌ 01234"567 89:ῌ ;< :=>?7@9:῎ AB$C1Dῌ E0FGῌ 234"5671ῌ H0FG ῌ IJKLῌ 234"56 ῌ 4E MNῌ 89:A OPQRῌ 'ST !4 UVῌ WXY234"56QZ ῌ [ U4ῌ 'S\ &"1 7+,1QRC1]

^;R"_`7C1DFGabUV7cDῌ 'Kdῌ @9:A OῌeK1fgῌ 'S T !ῌ '(HPQR 1ῌ ; !Hῌ '(1 QR&ῌ ;Rhbij"#$ ῌ 'S1klR%F Gῌ @9:hDῌ JKLῌ "mLn 7o1Lῌ 89:hDῌ pK1ῌ 0qrst4"uv7%lowx"mLn7o1 ῌ yz,{.ῌ 89:A OpKῌ '(ῌ @9:1klRFGῌ :=>|?hL}

L~QR1ῌ 89:1klRFGῌ ;R1'(

ij%FGaLῌ [|?hL}L~QRῌ %ῌ

ῌ |?;Rhb}L~QR ῍

-11ῌ }L-%

7rA ῌ ῌ 'Yῌ "7C

<e ῌ ¡¢£"¤<&ῌ ¥DD"¦§ D

% ῍

῎῍῏ ¨©ª«ῒ¬ΐ ῍῏ῐ ῎®¯°±ῌ ῎ῌῌῌ῏ ῎² ῐ¨©ῌ¬ῑ ³ 7r῎´µ¶·῏ --

῍῎ ῌ

(34)

῍῏῍ῌ῍῏῎ ῍῕῔῏ ῌ ῎ ῍῍ ῐῒῑῌῐῒῒ ! ῍῕῕ῒ ῌ "#

$%&'() ῌ*+,-,./0^VI ῒῒῑ 123 ῍῕῕ΐ 456 4ῌ*+- 78

῎ 9:;<= >?@ABCDEBC:FG0 H(῎῏I

῎῕J῔K ῍῔ΐΐI:LMNO<PQR῍ῌ B

C STUV:WXYZ9῔YZM[\O<]^_`=a LMb_῍ῌῌI':c<defVghKNOgi<

῏ ^jk:lmZK <no 456 ^LMSpd qiZ ^JCArs/t0ῑῌu῍ῌJ ῎ῌῌ῏ ῎78

ῐ vwxyz{ |} ῍῍῍ ~ 4

῎ῌῌΐ | 78

ῑ {+,-,./0 ΐῑῌΐῒ ῎ῌῌ῏

ῌ+-

ῒ vῌ῍῕῍ ^ 456

^} ῎῍῎ ῍῕῕῔

ΐ V:K ,G GQG_K ;aMFSY<

^^MK V_`d O:_`iZ];K

* :¡Y^¢ZS=£a_¤¥ BC¦ *§^

a_¤=NO= YVESDERAINS ANDROSABELE. GOODMANῌEVERARD, INTERNATIONAL HANDBOOK ON COMMERCIAL ARBITRATION SUPPL. ῎ῒ ῎῏

Kluwer Law International῍῕῕῔; WOLFGANGPETER ANDCAROLINEFRE- YMOND, in STEPHENV. BERTIet al.eds., INTERNATIONALARBITRATION IN

SWITZERLANDANINTRODUCTION TO AND ACOMMENTARY ONARTICLES῍ΐῒῌ

῍῕ῐ ^{OF THE} ^S^WISS ^P^RIVATE ^INTERNATIONAL LAW STATUTE ῏῔ῒ Kluwer Law International῎ῌῌῌ b< ®¯_K °' ;K

^^¢ZS* :=£a_¤¥ BC¦ H±g²

COMMERCIALARBITRATIONVOL.῍ ῍ῐῒῒKluwer Law International῎ῌῌ῕

hereinafter referred to as “BORN, INTERNATIONALCOMMERCIALARBITRA- TION”

῔ ^_^^:F=¸YZ¹º»{ ^

' ῌ ^JCArs/t0ῑ῏u῕J ῎ῌῌῒ ῎ ¼῍ῌJ ῎ῌῌῒ -.

ῌ῎

῍

(35)

῍ῌ ῎ ῒῌ ῎῏ῌ῎῏ΐ ῏ῌ ῒ ΐ ῍῍῏῕ῌ῍ῌ ῎῎ῌῌΐ῏ ῍῔ ῎ ῒῌΐ ῏ῌ ῒ !"#$%&'(#)*+,ΐ ^ADR-./

01῍2 ῎῎ῌῌΐ῏ ῑ῏ ῎ ῒῌ*+,ΐ ῏34)῍

῎῕῏ 5678ῌ9:ΐῒῌΐΐ῍

῎῍ῌ῏ ;<῍῍῍ ῐ=ῑ >?῍

῎῍῍῏ ῌ ῎῏ ῐ῍

῎῍῎῏ 5678ῌ9:ΐῐ῍

῎῍῏῏ http: / / www. kantei. go. jp / foreign / policy / sihou / lawῌ῏῎ῌῌῐ^{_ e. html}

῎῎ῌῌ῕@῕A῍῏῍ BCῌ MASAAKI KONDO ET AL, ARBITRATION LAW OF

JAPAN῎Shojihomu῎ῌῌῐ῏(DEFGHI)῍

῎῍ῐ῏ J῍

῎῍ῑ῏ UN Doc. A/CN.῕^/῎ῒῐ, Analytical commentary on draft text of a model law on international commercial arbitration, Article῍῎^{, para.}ῐ^. HOWARDM.HOLTZMANN ANDJOSEPHE. NEUHAUS, A GUIDE TOTHEUNCIT- RAL MODELLAWONINTERNATIONALCOMMERCIALARBITRATION: LEGISLA- TIVEHISTORY ANDCOMMENTARYῐ῏ῒ῎Kluwer Law and Taxation Publish- ers῍῕῔῕῏ ῎hereinafter referred to as “HOLTZMANN ANDNEUHAUS, MODEL

LAWGUIDE”῏.

῎῍ῒ῏ SeeJULIAND M LEW, LOUKASA MISTELIS ANDSTEFANM KRO»LL, COMPAR- ATIVE INTERNATIONAL COMMERCIAL ARBITRATION, para. ῍῏ῌ῕ ῎Kluwer Law International῎ῌῌ῏῏ ῎hereinafter referred to as “LEWMISTELIS AND

KRO»LL, COMARAITVE ARBITRATION”῏.

῎῍ΐ῏ See LEW, MISTELIS AND KRO»LL, COMPARATIVEARBITRATION, paras. ῍῍ῌ

῍῍^,῍῕^{; B}^ORN^{, I}NTERNATIONALCOMMERCIAL ARBITRATION῍ῐΐ῏ῌ῍ῐΐῑ^{; A}^LAN REDFERN ANDMARTINHUNTER WITH NIGEL BLACKABY ANDCONSTANTINE

PARTASIDES, LAW ANDPRACTICE OFINTERNATIONALCOMMERCIALARBITRA- TION, para. ῐῌῑῑ῎Sweet & Maxwell ῐ^th^ed.῎ῌῌῐ῏; FOUCHARD, GAILLARD, GOLDMANON INTERNATIONAL COMMERCIAL ARBITRATION paras.῍ῌ῎῔ῌ῍ῌ῏῔

῎Kluwer Law International῍῕῕῕῏; KLAUSPETERBERGER, INTERNATIONAL

ECONOMIC ARBITRATION ῎ῐ῏ ῎Kluwer Law and Taxation Publishers

῍῕῕῏῏. KL Kῌ MNO(Pῌ QRSPῌ TUVWXYZ [H

\]H^_ ῎῍῕῕ῒ@῎ῐ`῍a ῎a῏῏ῌ bcῌ dedSPῌ fgVW XYZ [H\]HI)3῎Rhi῍῔ῌ`῍a῏ῌjj(IkfgV Pῌ fg[Clmnoῌ pB_TUVqrXst)uvS4) wFG ) ῎SeePETER ANDFREYMOND,supranoteΐ^{, at}῏῔῎῏῍ BCῌ xyz ῒ (#)*+,῎{|}~῏ -/

ῌ῍

῍

(36)

ῑΐ῕

῍῕῕῍ !"

#$%&'()*+,-./012"34/""

"5 675 &'8",7 ,+92:;

/<2"=/"9 >?, = $< @Aῌ῍῔῍ῌ῍῔῏

BCDE, FG HIJ 2KLMN IO PQ7 , =9<'2KL/6'7?6<

RSTU IVW X+Y Z[\]2^

_`/a,bcdE,= _IVW ea7 , < f I ghi2j2klm:;/:86no FGpq<rsDc2k2,"9=2"D Igh(tu/6v6wx,yDE, ""

ghzx"2"

῍῔ REDFERN ANDHUNTER,supranote῍ΐ^{, para.} ῐῌῑῐ^. ῍῕ BORN, INTERNATIONALCOMMERCIALARBITRATION, at῍ῐΐῑ^.

῎ῌ {|}{ ~ @ ῍ ῎῎῕ ῎ῌῌ῎

῎῍ @ ghv" ῏ o ῍῕ΐ῏ C @ῌgh ?

῎῎

῎῏ ῌ῍῍῍ u<+ 9 "9

= $< { ῍ῑΐ

῎ῌῌῒ C ¡

? F¢£¤ghDE, _`/a,bcd $<

ῐΐ῍®

῎ῑ oCῌ¯°ῑΐDea7 ' ῎ῒ oCῌ¯°ῑΐ®

῎ΐ @ῌghῒ®

῎῔ @A ± ²³´ ῍῍ῌῌ῍῍῍ ! ῍῕῔῔

C ? ῍ῌ῕ῌ῍῍῍ @Aῌ

῍῔ῒ¬ῌῐΐ῎ ¡῍ῑΐ ῌFª

«ῒῒῑ Nµ¶·h¸¹2k ghF¢£¤+jº"

""£¤ F¢Nµ',9»gh<

¼Q,=2,6E,= 7 "ghF¢£¤

-0

ῌ῎

῍

(37)

῍ ῌ ῌ῍῔῍ῌ῍῔῏

ῌ !"#$%&ῌ "#'()*+,- ῌ $%&./ῌ 0῎123456)7389:ῌ ;<=

>? @Aῌ B%CDEFG῍C H$

C!Aῌ 0+IJK)L#MN" OPQ "@

ῌ RST>$%&./#;UM- VW@

῍

῏῎῕ῐ XYῌC'(῏Zῐ ΐῌBORN, INTERNATIONALCOMMERCIALARBI- TRATION, at῍ῐ῔῎ῌ῍ῐ῔῏^.

῏῏ῌῐ [Kῌ \]ῌ ^_`abῌ CRScdefW '( Q ῏LEW, MISTELIS ANDKRO»LL, COMPARATIVEARBITRA- TION, para. ῍῍ῌ῕^{; B}^ORN^{, I}NTERNATIONAL COMMERCIAL ARBITRATION, at

῍ῐ῔ῐ^{; D}^{ERAINS AND}^G^OODMANῌEVERARD, supranoteΐ^{, at}῎῎ῐ῍ "g h]Wῌ ῎iZῌ Commonwealth Coatings Corp.v. Continental Casualty Co.,῏῕῏^U.S.῍ῐῑ ῏U.S. S. Ct.῍῕ῒ῔ῐ jkῌ Clm&

efRSn<oW@ Q ῏LEW, MISTELIS AND

KRO»LL, COMPARATIVEARBITRATION, para.῍῍ῌ῕^{; B}^ORN^{, I}NTERNATIONALCOM- MERCIAL ARBITRATION, at ῍ῐ῔῏ῐῌ cRpcqqr#stuvwR Srjkῌ RSn;Ux yz{R῍@ | } @ ῏BORN, INTERNATIONAL COMMERCIAL ARBITRATION, at ῍ῐῒ῔ῌῒ῕^,

῍ῐ῔῎ῌ῔῏ῐ῍

῏῏῍ῐ "gῌ ~D῍ῑΐ ῑῒ ῌ RST>'()

*ῌCT>;῏Q ῌ*ῌ ]

o#dKῌ=K RSῌ!

!Cῌ &K!?#|}x ῍

῏῏῎ῐ Aῌ RST>ῌ )* Qbnῌ ῏῏ῐ Wr ῌ Rlm# V)L!)*)*

bnῌῌ RST>ῌ Q ¡U! ῍ ῌ '()*4ῌ )*#¢£r ῌῌ RST>ῌ '()* ¡ῌ CT>n¤U! ῏"¥4¦῏῎῔ῐ #

§¨ῐ῍ ῌ BORN, INTERNATIONALCOMMERCIALARBITRATION, at῍ῐ῔ῒῌ῔῔

ῌ#¬)q®¯°W! ῌ R±

´K!?!Uῌ '()* ¡ῌ´Wµ!!Q

῍

C'(4x ¶·¸῏¹º»¼ῐ -1

ῌ῍

῎

(38)

῏῏ ῍ῌ῕ ῍῎ῌῌ῍῎῎ ῌ῍῔ῒ ῌ ῍ῌ ῍῍ ῍῎῎ ῌ ! "#$%

&'()!*)+, -./01 *2

῏ῐ SeeBORN, INTERNATIONALCOMMERCIALARBITRATION, at῍ῐ῕῎ῌ῍ῐ῕῏^. ῏ῑ 3456ῌ78῍῏῎

῏ῒ ῌ῍῔῍

῏ΐ 9:;ῌ<=ῑ῔

῏῔ 3456ῌ78ΐῐ

῏῕ UN Doc. A/CN.῕^/῎ῒῐ^,^supra^note῍ῑ^{, Article}῍῎^{, para.}ῐ^.

ῐῌ UN Doc. A/ῐῌ^/῍ΐ, Report of the United Nations Commission on Inter- national Trade Law on the work of its eighteenth session, paras.῍῍ῒῌ

῍῍῕^.

ῐ῍ 3456ῌ78῍῏῎

ῐ῎ >?@ABC῍ῒῐ DEFGH

ῐ῏ IJKLMN*! ῎ ῐ OP-1

ῐῐ QM9:;ῌ<=ῑ῕ RSTUVWL0X Y1 YMZ [0\ US]^_Y1./*`6X a bcd[_Y1./**2

ῐῑ >?@ABC῍ῒῐ DGHI)Me 9:;ῌ<=ῑ῕

fghM[ijkMlmcVn2Iopnq1 Y 661lmcfgrVst uvwxyMRST& z {|M }~-1 * *2

ῐῒ RST&JKM/VDT01M-1

V** FRST&g-1 VYgMX-.!MN*! # RST-1()1 ῌ῍ΐῐ ῌ ῐῐΐ

|῎῎῕ ¡¢ ῍῕῕῔ £e ῌ῍῎῍

῕ῑ ¤¥¦§cD

S,\[¬*SabcV !*1®¯V°6- YM±

ªj²£³´SM1&µ¶* 6*2·¯

῍῍῏ 9:;ῌ<=ῒῌ kM ¸abS&

SM¹R !*1`J º»³´&_YX)1./ SM

¹R !*6¼ `J º»³´_YX)1./*

-2

ῌ῎

῍

(39)

! "#$%&'( ) *+!,-./)01234567!8 ῐ῔ 9:;ῌ <=῕ῐ>

ῐ῕ ?@ῌ A῍῎ῒ>

ῑῌ ?Bῌ A῍ΐ῔> ?@ῌ A῍῎ῒ> C@ῌDE<=ῒῒ῕> 3Fῌ GHI ῐῒ ῎῏ῐ> IJ A῕ΐ> KLMN OFῌIJPQῐῑῌ>

ῑ῍ RSTUVW῍ΐῑ> ?BXYZ[

ῑ῎ UN Doc.A/CN.῕^/῎ῐῒ, Report of the Working Group on International Contract Practices on the work of its seventh session, paras.ῐ῏ῌῐῐ^. ῑ῏ UN Doc. A/ῐῌ^/῍ΐ^,^supra^noteῐῌ^{, para,}῍῎῔^.

ῑῐ ) \ ]^_`ab0 c ICC defgWhi ]^῍῎

j῍k0 lm$0 ICCde Ei nopqb' rstlm!uv$wx!y/z See YVESDER- AINS ANDERICA. SCWARUTZ, A GUIDE TO THEICC RULES OFARBITRATION

῍῕῏Kluwer Law International ῎^nd^ed.῎ῌῌῑ ῑῑ RSTUVW῍ΐῒ> @{Z[

ῑῒ |} A;~^Q&A ῍῏ῐ> ῎ῌῌῐ b0 lmqz {b0(6 A

Ao! J!

ῑΐ 9:;ῌ <=῔ῑ>

ῑ῔ UN Doc. A/CN.῕^/῎ῐῒ^,^supra ^noteῑ῎^{, para.}῏῔; UN Doc. A/ῐῌ^/῍ΐ^,^supra noteῐῌ^{, para,}῍῎῔^.

ῑ῕ UN Doc. A/CN.῕^/SR.῏῍ῐ, Summary Record reproduced in HOLTZ- MANN ANDNEUHAUS, MODELLAWGUIDE, atῐ῏ῒ^.

ῒῌ UN Doc. A/CN.῕^/῎ῒῐ^,^supra^note῍ῑ^{, Article}῍῏^{, para.}ῐ^.

ῒ῍ A῎῍j῎k0 lm

' 0]$

ῒῐ 9:;ῌ <=῎ῌΐ>

ῒῑ ª«¬ῌ*+ῒῌ>

ῒῒ A/CN.῕^/῎ῐῒ^,^supra^noteῑ῎^{, para.}῏῔^. ῒΐ 9:;ῌ <=῎ῌῐ>

ῒ῔ SeeHOLTZMANN ANDNEUHAUS, MODELLAWGUIDE, atῐῌ῕ῌῐ῍ῌ^.

®$*+¯°± -3

ῌ῎

῍

(40)

ῒ῕ ῌ῍ῒ ῌῒ῍

ΐῌ ῌ῍ῒ

ΐ῍ UN Doc.A/CN.῕^/῎ῒ῏, Analytical complication of comments by Govern- ments and international organizations on the draft text of a model law on international commercial arbitration: report of the Secretaryῌ General, Article῍῏^{, para.}ῐ^.

ΐ῎ HOLTZMANN ANDNEUHAUS, MODELLAWGUIDE, atῐῌ῔^.

ΐ῏ ῎ῐ῎ ῏ΐ῎ !

"#$%&#$'( !")*%+,-./0 12,34-5! +6% 783912,/:;5<=+,- &

783.>?@+,- 2AB45!,CD01 ΐῐ EFῌG῍῕῎ HIῌJKLῒῒ῔ MNOP GQRSTU

V'WXYHIZ[\ ]^G$_ ῎῎ῒ `ab ῍῕῕῔ c dG῍῍῎ e f+ ghidj,%"klmn/op 01,!qrs,%" LEW, MISTELIS ANDKRO»LL, COMPARATIVEARBITRA- TION, para.῍῏ῌῐῐ391

ΐῑ EIῌGQῒῌ῕ k=,k EIῌG῍῏῏ ῏ῑ ]῎῏ 3Dt1uvw Gxyz{|/}t1w 49BGQ~z{|,491,+4 GQ 301491<; uvw0149="k 2;

w/:B53; 2/GQ012,; 2/w 012,5!, 2d+, ῎῏

῍῍ GQ3491s 49="k n/op%q1,d13 .q4915;d/t"!1q

1

ΐῒ <ῌGKLΐΐ HIῌJKLῒῒῑῌῒῒῒ ΐΐ ῌcdῐΐ῍

ΐ῔ <ῌGKLΐΐ ΐ῕ EIῌGQῑ ῔ῌ cjG῍ῌ῕ e ῔῍ EIῌGQ῔

῔῎ ῌ ῏

῔῏ EIῌGQ῕ 2%HIῌJKLῒῒῒ uvw+1w3912,/:=+4GQ0149

.*

ῌ῎

῍

(41)

ῌ ῏῍ῌῒ

῍῍ῌ

῔ῐ ῌῒῌ῕

!"#$%& '( ) * +,-.#+

/!)0123 0%#45&$%& '( 61 2 789: .;<=>?@ABC>

D0 6EFG"#H5&$%& '( I?

H.!"#JKL& 'MH5&$%&

JKL& N0: .;=O#P!)3:

QRSTC&0U#I?V>!)#W! X ) #YZ>[[ J QR<\]^_Q`>

<.abcdefgE #45& '( 6) I^_0< QR0#hi. jk#l!?].

j<m3n#bcdef> #H5&

'M)! )12 45&$%& !o45&

0gE< H5&$%& [ .;dpef QR#qras#"ntu!)<v0w" .;=Ox 0!< ῍ ῏ y?3 6"6"#b cdef!ov0:z0"<:H5&$%&

!o<6E+C=O"n 0gE0 ῔ῑ {|ῌ@A῍ῒ ῎ῐῌ῎ῑY}

῔ῒ ῎῏K῎L @A ~<#>0 ,- 60 <@Ad?12n 6e 612n[,-

[,-#!

#I >0iE0f0 $]

῔ΐ ῌ ῑῒ ῍῏῍ gEQRs s

d $: N¡¢£¤V . j<D

«y#§o?< X )y#¬]

῔῔ IBA®¯°±² http://www.ibanet.org/ ῎ῌῌ῕³῕´῍µ

¶·gE

῔῕ ῌ῎ ῕ῌ µῌ¸¹ῑ῔

῕῍ º῍῍ῒ {|ῌ@A῎῏ µῌ¸¹ῒ῎ I?

=!¸¹ »¼ .+

ῌ῎

῍

(42)

῎

῍ῌ῏ῌ !"#$%&'()*+,-./"01 234356/ ῎Patricia Nacimiento and Amelie Abt, in KarlῌHeinz Bo¨ckstiegelet al.῎eds.῏, ARBITRATION INGERMANYTHEMODELLAW IN PRA- CTICE῎῏ῌ ῎Kluwer Law International῎ῌῌΐ῏῍

῎῕῎῏ 78ῌ)*9:῎῏;῍

῎῕῏῏ <=ῌ)* ῎>῏ ῍ῒ;῍

῎῕ῐ῏ ?῍

῎῕ῑ῏ @ABCῌDE῍ῌ῎;῍

῎῕ῒ῏ UN Doc.A/ῐῌ^/῍ΐ^,^supra^noteῐῌ^{, para.}῍ῒ῍^.

῎῕ΐ῏ "F(G32HIJKLC623/ῌ "6M ./N2ῌ TAN POH LENG STANLEY V TANG BOON JEK JEFFREY, [῎ῌῌ῍^] ῍ ^SLRῒ῎ῐ^,῏ῌ^NOVEMBER῎ῌῌῌ^HCO/PQRῌ "

6S./N2ῌ Bundesgerichtshof, III ZB ῔῏^/ῌ῎^{, March} ῎ΐ^,

῎ῌῌ῏, German Arbitration Journal, SchiedsVZ῎ῌῌ῏^,῍῏῏O/῍ T!ῌ UV ῐWX2/"RY/ ῎may request῏ῑ 3ZV[V\K]

(ῌ '!ῌ X!^_`6a6bc./῍ "HI deῌ fg ῐHIChJ/ῑ JCAijklῑ῏m῔n ῎῎ῌῌῒ῏ ῒ῎;op῍

῎῕῔῏ HOLTZMANN ANDNEUHAUS, MODELLAWGUIDE, atῐῌΐῌῐῌ῔^.

῎῕῕῏ qrstu῏v(ῌ w(xyzu !{^u)

*9:(xy)*|}h64C~u{ῌ )*./ !ῌ H

WX2(32H(,-./"RY/ῌ O/3

ῌ ῍ῑ(H()*}/"RY/ῌ 3Z῎G

v5623u῎U.N.Doc. A.CN.῕^/WG.II/WP/ῐῑ, Article X῎῏῏reproduced in HOLTZMANN ANDNEUHAUS, MODELLAWGUIDE, atῐ῍῕῏῍

῎῍ῌῌ῏ UN Doc. A/CN.῕^/῎ῐῑ, Sixth session of the Working Group on Interna- tional Contract Practices ῎Vienna, ῎῕ ^Augustῌ῕ ^September ῍῕῔῏^: Report of the Working Group on the work of its sixth session῏, para.

῎῍῎^.

῎῍ῌ῍῏ UN Doc. A/ῐῌ^/῍ΐ^,^supra^noteῐῌ^{, para.}῍῎ῐ^.

῎῍ῌ῎῏ UN Doc. A/CN.῕^/῎ῒῐ^,^supra^note῍ῑ^{, Article}῍῏^{, para.}ῑ^.

῎῍ῌ῏῏ 78ῌ)*9:῎῏;῍

῎῍ῌῐ῏ ?῍

῎῍ῌῑ῏ 78ῌ)*9:῎ῐῌ῎ῑ;῍

῎῍ῌῒ῏ 78ῌ)*9:῎ῑ;῍ .,

ῌ῍ ῌ

(43)

῍ῌΐ BERGER,supranote῍ΐ^{, at}῎ΐῌ ῍ῌ῔ ῌ ῍ῒ ῏ῌ

!"#$%&'()*+,-./+0- $1 23%4 45 67 ,%89':; ῍ῌ῏ΐ<῏= .!"#-&'()*+,'>?.@A+

῍ῌ῕ BCDEῌ67FG῔ῒ

῍῍ῌ H IJῌ67῍ῐ῏ 67KLM4)NOP Q*R/.S+0 ITῌ67῍῕ῒ

῍῍῍ UVῌWX῏῏YZ

῍῍῎ UVῌWX῏ῒῌ῏῔[ῌ\]^ῒ῎YZ _` ῌ

῍῕,Qabcd'@A+

῍῍῏ ῌ῍ῒ

῍῍ῐ e_` f67῍῍ΐ g h ]^67K-ij ` kl$__md'no*+ 0

῍῍ῑ UVῌWX῏ῒ ῍῍ῒ e

῍῍ΐ e

῍῍῔ ITῌ67῍῕ῐ IJῌ67῍ῐ῎ pqῌfrsῐΐῐ tJῌ ucFGῒῒ῕

῍῍῕ vwDEῌxyf ῎ῌ ῎ῐ῕ zq ῍῎ῌ f67῍῍ῒ g YZ

῍῎῍ eYZ See alsoLEW, MISTELIS ANDKRO»LL, COMPARATIVEARBITRA- TION, para.῍῏ῌ῏ῒ^.

῍῎῎ f67῍῍ῒ g {% |"}~]^4+".

S+E7c'X3+- sE450 0 _

` UVῌWX῏ῒῌ῏ΐ ῌ ῍῕YZ '

-67a' ,%N

|-S+Nacimiento and Abt,supranote῕῍^{, at}῎῏῍

῍῎῏ UVῌWX῏ΐ

῍῎ῐ u IT fr"s ῍ ῏ῒ῏ῌ῏ῒῑ ῏ῒ῕ ve

῍῕῕῍

῍῎ῑ LEW, MISTELIS ANDKRO»LL, COMPARATIVEARBITRATION, para.῍῏ῌῒῌ^. ῍῎ῒ f67῍῍῏ g YZ

῍῎ΐ f67῍῍῏ g IJῌ67῍ῐ῎ |P| IJῌ67K

῎῏. ~"M 7c

7c' ¡ |P¢7c£¤+#_`¥¦,%'c§3+

῍῎ ῌ

(44)

ῌ ΐ ῌ ῒ !"#$%&'(ῌ )

*+,-.ΐ ῌ /01!"#ῌ 23,45678#"9:;<῍

῎῍῎῔῏ =>ῌ?@ῐῑABC῍

῎῍῎῕῏ D῍

῎῍῏ῌ῏ EFῌG,H῎῏A῍

῎῍῏῍῏ IJ=>ῌ?@῎ῑAῌ ῒG,Hῌ KL#

MNOῌ#ῌ 9PQ"RS,-T&JUVWMNO#

X YZ&ῌ [\#]^_"`ῌ a+&

b cde_"9:_fg_"h'(ῌ,-T0 ijk&lmn4hopῌ 9:_#q8#"

"_'r:'ΐ ":῍

῎῍῏῎῏ G,ῐῐ5῍6῔sX"#ῌ ῒG,-tuv&ῌwxXyz {|}~ῌ_ ΐ M&ῌ ja+9

ῌῌ 1z|_(?@1z|[

῎'ῌG,῎ῑ῏A῏῍ 0ῌ W῏ῐ῍ῌ῏ῐ῎A ῐ*ῑῌ ῒG,-tuvΐ ":Mῌ?@1z|M[

_"8e":&ῌ n4&g1DuvM4 ¡¢£῏ῐ5῎6 ῎b῏ ῎ii῏ ῌ j¤¥¦§9ῌ ?@1z|

M¨#XP ῎UN Doc. A/ῐῌ^/῍ΐ^,^supra^noteῐῌ^{, para.}῎῕ΐ῏ῌ G, j+;#8er:῍

῎῍῏῏῏ 'ῌG,῎ῐ῕A῍

῎῍῏ῐ῏ D῍

"#«v¬4-9®G,H&_G,-t¯°9PP

e_""ῌ ±G,-t&P

8#"9:;<&ῌ :_(ῌ²8M³ #"_῍ [ῌ wª´ῌµ¶·ῒῌAῌG,ῌ &

¸ῌG,-t« (e":῍

῎῍῏ῒ῏ EFῌG,H῍῔A῍

῎῍῏ΐ῏ ¹ºῌ»8¼¯ῐῒῒABC῍

῎῍῏῔῏ » ῎ῐΐ῏BC῍ ..

ῌ῎

῍

仲裁人の忌避に関する諸問題 利用統計を見る

ῌ /012F

ῌ

y

仲裁人の忌避に関する諸問題利用統計を見る