公教育と民主主義　私事の組織化としての公教育論および教育の内外事項区分論の批判

全文

(1).

(2) . . . .

(3)

(4)

(5)

(6)

(7) . . .

(8)

(9)

(10)

(11)

(12) . !.

(13) '()*+,-.

(14) . !" #$%&. !"/01%&*2345678 9. :;<="49>?@AB")*C. +D

(15) E. F8;G)H8. ;GIJ K+L8MN)A +OPQR DSTU4VW)X2 YZ [\*]^8_àb*c)1%&*+defghi DSC. jYkE. l[m\2+nopp?) )1qVr$c)93stc)1pu*2345. vwtVx1yzDs5{|9+}~AB~ P DSp p? S8~"~)*pp? ). 8~1 $¡+defghi DSC. )pp?"1¢{*5*m*£¤¥¦19m §¡+defgp ¨©R)*ªv«¬ DDzsC. ". L2L21®¯J1. °±*5L1²³´)*avw345{|9c3 2+.

(16) . !" #*+Lµ¶)t . ·¸+W1¹¡º»8t%&1¼½*s ¾5. OÀ. #¿. Á K9L\Â´3Ã*ÄÅ¨©*¡+vw39ÆÇ. S1È*+Ã2ÉÊ2*t5ÉËÌwl[1DÍ*5 ÎÏÐÑÒÓÔÏ. ÕÖ}~×ØÙ. .

(17) . .

(18) . ! "#. $% &'( )*+,-./0$ 1234 56789:0$ 5;<=>:

(19) & ?5 @7AB7ACD&:E )$ FGHIJKLMN&OPQR STUVWX

(20) %&Y$ Z*0$2IJ .[&\]G*0$^_ Fà)$bc%d .UV)$ eHfghi& jk&X $ 12 5 @7Almnopqrstno/uvwx Sy d z3{|}}/~$* 2 @7A)$lmnoE0Pr B7AE)$E0Pr CD1/*0P SCD&5: Z @BCD&~-.d }}6@BCD& )$.* :1)$2 SZSZ^_ F 5M LZ ¡¢£¤¥ [¦. S §[¦. OP¨ lm$l ©ª£¤$l«. ¬©ª£¤T©ªy 1®¯ S%°±£¤±²G£¤1£¤¥ ³´µ)$[¦ ¶·¸-:1Z¹º»)$2S 5±² G£¤¬©ª£¤1¥ lm¼)$

(21) ½¾)$.¿ÀdÁ $

(22) [¦ $"{|/\Â SzÃ /

(23) @ Ä Å$-Á}}8ÆÇÈ¹&[/ 6789*0,-:dÉ$2 S 67 5±²G£¤}}

(24) ÊË d567:Ì Í ÎpÏ ; ÐnÑÒÓG dÔcÕ}}

(25) ÊËÎH; ®¯T³ Ö¨) ·×}}±²Glm/¨µ Z}}67. Ø

(26) =ÊËÅÙ8ÆW. no%dÚÛ-ÐÜ*. 8. 9Ýd :1Z$2d .-b&5;HÏ³ Þßàá> ÊË âã$Eäá>1Tå æçè! $:1 267)$UV( 5éêëì íîÁd-ï HHHHHHH 3, 6-67 ð µUV$

(27) = » HHHHH HH ñÌ,-67T8ÆòÉd$%/ó$}}@ô ´3õ6ö÷ )$Z øùúû%düýbþÆ.È¹67&/:* 0$ 'G12 . 56789& lmÎEä*0P lmno lm 67. lm, 67. ,-Î . E)$

(28) nÑÁd$ ..S/[&ã :1*0P 567 %

(29) ³ ¯T89)$%}}SPå

(30) :1¿À¹$2 -^_[&* Ð¸5[&

(31) F $* ÎSZstÐ¸)$. .

(32)

(33) . !". #$%&'()*+,- .#/0()#123 4 56 !789:;< =>?@4. .

(34) . AB =>9 CD EFGH(I

(35) 1?JKL*+$ 9% MNO@? P ?%)Q(R.>-ST UV W XO@4PGI

(36) 1 .# YV O@)Z I

(37) 1 9[W < P \]^JK_9[W ?àbYW ())ZY4 cdG9ef .#C g7h i:9 jklmnopG qr

(38) GIP s]tu1G<"v< w .#%$WYxyL4.W.%$Oz0()#{|] @*+

(39) 2}3;#9 % ~ ]l{7]< %.#%)? 9 p XOxy() W;#<bYW()#4% vf$ 79`"v: ?4 8L! cd^ z0 9 D9.P]@9s]}G "v `( ]JKO@$ G .#4%.#% ! ]D ~ CD?Y$ ?P O@"v9aO@4Po '

(40) ^ 9¡¢£¤?@? ¥¦h sJG§¨$ ©ª^CD «'h .#¬®l¯G°±$ p Ps]} ~²G<; $$%P J K_ \]?@ O9WW4%.#% !\]9I ]1D!D³ ´µ##9&'?¶·O+ ¸VY)vWY$%

(41) } ¹ Iº»1!" #P9()v O9 W4 ¼½¾§h ¿ÀÁÀlÂÃÄÅÆ9 ÇÈÉÊËÌÍÎÆÄ]@9Ï] P ~²LÄÉÃÐ ÑGQ`V# P§ÒGÓÔ.Y?mÕw §Ò Öp<GMR×ØCD?ÙÚÛGÜÝL oGz0L4%.#%$O9Þ !

(42) ß?àz() 4IÊËÌÍÎÆÄ Ø9ÊËÌÍÎÆÄ §Òá ÄÉÃÐ Ø 9ÄÉÃÐ §Òá Öp<GMR×vw4ÊËÌÍÎÆÄ Ø i:9 Ö p<ÄÉÃÐá âã²O9 .#<äåGVævw4ÊËÌÍÎÆÄ Ø ç]èé9Öp<êRN $)Y èé ©ª]lëì]l¼½]íî9 %Y:ï Õ pP]ðñ.òóÒJæ.vw1ô 34 ÂÃÄÅÆ?z0.v!o9 Ø õlmn õGö¤]÷ø.v %) $%I

(43) 1 .# PoO@!ùR) O9WW 34 $? C g7h i:9 $.vmnoG IPs]tuG<"v

(44) 1O9 .#úûL!O@4üh<úûý9_L4.W.úû()I 1 9xy( )vPs]I

(45) 19p$p !JK.# wW `vþ¯ wW4 IPs]~G<"v

(46) 1 ¸V9 P ^GéR×<. .

(47)

(48)

(49) . !"#$%&'. ()*+,-./01234

(50) 56#!78. 9$& :;. . <=>?@

(51) 37A&5,8 :;BC2DEFFGH <8IJ.KLM7838NO UV

(52) 8&

(53) WXYZ23. BCEFFGP3QR,S2T. !& BC?EFFGB[?&EFFG

(54) D <8. H8?

(55) ./?&\]^_`99

(56) "#23

(57) 8abc d8EFFG

(58) efg

(59) hi

(60) jk723&5lm<BC?`!. M7238. 357A&n84

(61) ?\]^&5,8opqrs

(62) ?tgs

(63) ? u83O vw&xy+32?z{+32?&|}~?:;F$3S$

(64) 3. [& :; +32"#

(65) u835?5?JJ 84&&M!9?J525+}; 2[3&xy7AJ:o ¡¢&z{ £¤¥J7A¦§ÖS$¢$©ª«E7AJ¬®

(66) 2¯°M72±. ²k723|84&]<³´3µ¶·¸S$¢ $. !$S2D|G¹ºgH

(67) ?»\M7D efgH¼½¾<¿. À83 9$WXDÁdbÂÃbÄÅÆ<ÇÈ:;ÉÊHDË¬ÅÆÌ¬(ÅÆÍÅÆ< ÇÈ:;Î6[\sÉÊ

(68) 2ÏÐHs

(69) 3 2UV8O O. 5,8ÏÐ~,. M!D efgH ÑÒÉÊ8¢¿À~. ÁdbÂÃbÄ7¬(ÅÆ7&|3J};2S$. Ói&5:;ÔÕ:;BCÖ×< ?S$?

(70) 8ØÙ~297 O. . JÚ8S$

(71) M7:;BC&. !Û¯7AÜ3ÝÞºmß1. ÅÅÆàáâãS$¢$+äåoæ1$+325& D©ªH

(72) 3

(73) !%ç#297$¢&$S29$ß1ÅÆèé ê2:;83D

(74) 8$#:;H#ëM7

(75) ?8S$

(76) èé

(77) ì©mS$ºmBJ

(78) í8¢&J&èé . !?. !?î¢ïM7$9MD <H8ðñ

(79) 5ßò5,8 <J. Ú8:;&D H

(80) 2âãä@Mó:;ôOÓiS2?&Ü 3ºmß1ÅÅÆ+

(81) ~9õâS2&ßöD8 $#õ:;H&IEIJ÷mõs âã

(82) 8ØÙ83

(83) &z{\[ø2?&Y$ùúûüýþ1Ysc\[ø2?`! 8. . 5$ <8:; ÑÒÉÊ8¢¿À3½¾<~. ø3OóO. ¬(ÅÆJ:;5$UV ?

(84) 37. A&5É¼<½¾<¿ÀsÖÎ $S2&\[

(85) 2 g

(86) &ÉÊ

(87) 2

(88) å

(89) UV?83\[<. .

(90)

(91) !"#$%&'(. )*+,- ./0123./45678"#$%&'9"( :;<=>?@ABC9DB EFGH$:;<IJK>LDBMN/OPQRSLT'(UVDWXYZ <[$\]..(^[23_àbMc"d 9V$e./(df:gh.gij>?@23(HD $ T:QR>T

(92) (klmUVDnop$q/^[UD?. ?.^[ab?&rVstD?.(^[ uvw

(93) (klmU aaD$./9:QR>$ x/%b@VH:<[>

(94) T .?.yz

(95) {|.GHQR:;<./}~>

(96) .HYZ <[DTlH?U./$DTV9H.QR$x/-}~vw

(97) no. HYZ<[

(98) TlH?9H.<[D$| VD?lH? p$q&g(U9$.$:;<I JK>d

(99) T9D<[lH.?.U9:;<>=

(100) ^$H -["kd/?H

(101) T$(-}~vwno$q/D.lU H.;<=D| VP V/H

(102) YZ<[D?lH?-}~vwD( ¡¢£KU9$q&¤¥r¦}~aa§¨ V//(23$/©ª «4="%¬®¯°k$(23±²"}d$¬®./³ ´±h= µ8"~nN$³´T?@9U-}~D(¶·¸¹ ¸ºg»}~H¼{./D£ ½¾¿À?@../([Á$vwK V DÂÃ½¾À9T TDÄÅ~ÆÇÈ$:;<IJK>QR"ÉC9B?.V.? .ÄÅ~ÆÇÈD Ê$DËÌÍÇÈT'(ÎÏºÐÈÑ"ÒNÅ~ÆÇÓ$ÔÕ BD(p645UÖ?@×| V/D?lH?U./UV

(103) -}~v w$ØBÙÚ"Ûd(U'Ü"ÝdH<[ÉÞD?lH?. .

(104). ßà$(<áâ<áãLD(äåæç

(105) èé?@êë VD ) 5

(106) <á|6ì|$:íî>okïV9":ðñ>oLgò

(107) ó. bT 5±v

(108) «4 V:Øô õ>T:vw õ>öD(<á$É d

(109) %Dâ<á?@÷øùÛ6ì|

(110) ú V(HoL?(UV< áDT

(111) ûâ$ùÛ

(112) «4 V/?DüýDa÷øþù$G}~ öT/:A>TVf«4 V/

(113) (uâ ©Ê:÷ øA>

(114) °GHþ46"./B?"Vf(5÷øTVfN /G(DUV° $DdD T. .

(115)

(116) . !"

(117). #$% &'%()(*+,- ./012034567 89%

(118) : ;<12=>?@ABCDEFGHIJKLM N%OPQR. %STUVW<

(119) XY ;Z[8E\]^_(). (*+,àbc. ]de3fghi j]klmn3o

(120) %?. %

(121) pq<p;<rs

(122) t8uv(*+,-w ]x<()]9yz?8de{|h (*|}~ pY% ; 8- 8 8(*àrY po

(123) ; R8 g(*i]a8%W ?RV- 8(*àK'CE] n3¡U]¢0£¤¥? ;o<¦§hH¨h©¨

(124) 3vc mn%?ª3v?«de o

(125) c «q<p; (*¬®¯°±H²³±

(126) ´µ¶·¸¹º< J»] ;(* ¼½¾

(127) g¿?i ÀÁ(*K¬ÂÃ]dÄÀ Áp gÅc i À . Á ÆÇ

(128) Ãp gcÈ iÀ

(129) .

(130) ÁÉÊ7 ½ A<!ËÀ. . Á]8 ÌÍNÎ? ÏrÐÑ]ÒÓ^Ô%? Á; [o% Å(*%Õ(*à

(131) ¨Ö

(132) o<C×ØÙ%Ú½HÏr ÐÑ]ÛgÅh ÉÊiÜnW8% ½ ÝÒc Þ|h gßài (). !áW deo

(133) %? ;ªßà8âY. x<deo8%? ;. ãä¬(*-åæçs-wgèéê¬i]_ëì Ïr7

(134) %8ÉY ;í(*8îïðrhñp8 ¨Ö

(135) îïðrh %C×6 8«

(136) ªJe ;Å(*Þ|h ßàgÉ*i XnWv?8Je o7

(137) òóo Á;A%

(138) ô¯õö ±(*ÆÇ]÷øWù?úí]Åûí3ün]ý_þ, ; o¨3fí(*

(139) Å(*-å&Jígûi] 3 <?_C×h ]8<;-

(140) ÆÇÈA¨ <#$ C× Túí í(*

(141) ?_#$

(142) ]8 8 å ; ö²®õ

(143) º< ©] ;² ()

(144)

(145) L6](%0¼o]_Yo p;ì s½ 3eL (*Ç

(146) W?½¾]s3ãä ê G]. ;Z[8o 6(*êpoY!]Õ "#ê]p. $eY;%&f$'(¼ã) ê]* < Á; o<6(*]_ëAs½%

(147)

(148) STÀ$(* © Á % Ev?8%

(149) <

(150) Ïà% ;

(151) $g(*i] 3Ó8 L*

(152) îï|(. .

(153)

(154) . !"#. $%& '()*+ ,-./01 2314 5"67 %&89:"23145:;1 <=>?@ABCDE"6 7.;FGHIJKLMNOP . . . !QRSTUJVH

(155) ::VHWX1YZ [\]I,-^_àb .. !c

(156) d QRe. fgU,CE"Sh,fgi+J-# j#

(157) ;

(158) ! kl"G9mno"p qrS^(JstJuv71wx y!

(159) 9m- qrJz{F| }#!o.;~5 ! 79F ."2 _+1%& pFHIJ ;!:;2]I,M 9I1 VH,) WW,+e9BMN" %&HI"

(160) ¡¢£¤]¥!. . . ¦§'*¨J©ª «

(161) J'¬"3l ! .. 1%&o®¯ ¦§_°±G'yS.;C. l"G^(²³´µn,¶| j#·1¸«E !&¹ º»¼½"¾¿ÀÁ_ ¿ÂÃÄ67ooÅ. p:"j#·,\ÆÇÈ !. fg'¬,9ÉfgÊËÌÍÎÏ ¦§}·

(162) ÐÑ ; :;'),ÒÓÔ 9Éb Õ· !.. 1%&Ö%. ×:;'),ØÙ Goj#S on« ,\ÆÇÈj#·1yCE !9É_-^,*¨ÚÛ6Ó. ÜÝ«FG HIo ¥! ¦§."HIÞßàá}â×

(163) "1E:;

(164) ãIol

(165) ;! «

(166) J'¬äåo\Æ¶| . 1æ?:J ç)Jz{ !è¿éê o9`Juë,ìí"9É1z J2î Rïð+Åñ .1VH,ò»S) WÓ1 zJ2îóB,ô j# °±_¦§+IJ}#pFõ J'¬®!J'¬z{n5|l"¾ö÷è79 ×X `J«ª,I5"ø¹ !. .

(167)

(168) !"#$% &' ( )*+,-./+012 345 6789:;< = !"#$%

(169) >?? 5@ABCDEFGHI JKLM !"#$%NOPQR S TU VWX ) *Y,Z[\]^_`2 ab c defg hijkl !"#m noT5@ABS QpqSrq

(170) 2 sU7Srtuv wxq yzc 7{|}~ijkl !"#m TU V}5Bab } . !"#m"#$ j5}A!}5Bm @$¡¢£TU V}B¤¥¦§} ¨© {|¢ _.£$ ª «¬ ¥®3m . # !". " $% $ &. $' ( ) * + ( ,* ' ( $' * . . ¯F°±²³´µ¶·¸¹Qº»U¼ U¼¼½l ¾5@AB ¿%ÀÁl !m ÂÃÄi

(171) Å ÆiÇ ` :È ij ÉÊË£K ÌÍÎ$NÏÐÃ ¥$ÑÒÓÔnÕT Ö±G×Ø±ÙÊÚÛ±Ü±×Ø±Ù5@ÝÞ ßT¼½ Êàáâ £Sã¥ª äåBfæ5ç§èå $é Ö±G×Ø±ÙÊij êÓ±×Ø±Ù ëDì _Ç©A}íkîïBm3©ïS ð çÇÁñ¥ §$_ò}Áñïóôõ}ö ÷Bøù¥ ú û¤¥®Bm ü*5ýB¡¢5ûBþï$ !$% Á &'

(172) } ¤ §. 2 Ì ! }

(173) 4U¼¼½Ì ¢ ¾ò¾

(174). "#$% ðóô ð¦ c 7ij ¾ !£®Bm û¤5@§£$¡¢å 5@Ö±G×Ø±Ó¶ÊÚÛ±Ü±×Ø±Ù}. ðóô} ïBäA¥ §$éå£S ð q0q}ï¤Bwxq} }kîïBm ( ) /* 0".110 * # 2 #2"3 !455 5 37* 7.+ 0 * 78* . µF ÙÑ³ Ù·/+01»áâ ·Qï 6& s $

(175) $¸$éï:;<= !m NOPQR S TU VWX )* !m 1' + * ! . »<!m.

(176) >. . 5@ABCDEFGHI !m.

(177)

公教育と民主主義 私事の組織化としての公教育論および教育の内外事項区分論の批判

公教育と民主主義　私事の組織化としての公教育論および教育の内外事項区分論の批判