再生産表式における資本分布について(2) : 社会的平均資本を成立させる等差で並べられた諸部面資本を，特定の部面資本が，異なるc:v比を持つ2大部門に分割する場合

y Ā ā Ĵ ½ 4  C Ņ Þ { · 4 .  / Ţ  ţŨ

ē g ć ¹  Ņ Þ G É Ĝ " ' C Ġ ´ 0 \ : A D * Ŀ Ő ś

Ņ Þ G ť ü « 5 Ő ś Ņ Þ  ť ą 3 C  Ũ  î G Í .  ¤

Ő œ 4 { ƒ % C   ‘

ï²
£˜ă
Abstract

A theoretical consistency between the value structure of “average social capital” (illustrated in “Capital: Volume III”, “Chapter IX and Chapter X”) and that of two departments of reproduction (illustrated in “Capital: Volume II”, “Chapter XX. Simple Reproduction” and “Chapter XXI. Accumulation and Reproduction on an Extended Scale”) is examined.

For comparing these two value structure, the number of circulation of each capital in reproduction is assumed to be the same i.e. 1. Furthermore, a specific capital segments all capitals into two departments of reproduction, and the ratio of the first year of reproduction is used for this comparing.

The conclusion is that the Marx’s reproduction scheme is not always compatible with the spectrum of capitals including average social capital. This work does not show a general proof, but means that Marx’s numerical example contains the counter example in itself, and this conclusion is contradictory to his own description.

I. HN69

ÞĘ06ťŅÞľğ 3 µ 9 ĝ¹÷þ1Āānãť_{10 ĝ} Ğ_4@CVİć÷þ5Ġ…¶ nã1¶ nrņŏ÷ example contains the counter example in itself, and this conclusion is con- tradictory to his own description.

0ŋ:AD*ēgć¹ŅÞ©œ%CĀāŐśŅÞ5{·1ť ŅÞľğ2 µ 20 ĝˆĢyĀāť21 ĝıę1̤yĀā 0ŋ:AD*yĀāĴ½5¤Őœ5nræÉťľÿć3VŃÆG Í.“ťGĘ[ï²(2014)]4¾Ħäĸ%C
äĸ5*>4ťŅÞľw0mĒ"D*yĀāĴ½GŐœ5ŅÞ æÉ4Ä$/{ş#ťˆĢyĀāŧ̤yĀā
zĆĴ½ğ 2 mPLR1ť̤yĀā
zĆĴ½ğ 1 mPLR5 2 .5IR UM4‡{#*
ğVIRUM5ˆĢyĀāŧ̤yĀā
zĆĴ½ğ2 m PLR16ťĀāŏė0Ėň"D*Y¢ŅÞ1Œ¢ŅÞ5nrőŢĴ Ĺ6(D)D cťvţ6¤Őœ0ą3Cť¤Őœ5 c:v î6Ġ # ‘0C
Ę06!5IRUM5PLR4./ťs&¤Őœ4ēgć ¹ŅÞ”;DC ‘Gäĸ#*(#/(5 ‘46ťēgć ¹ŅÞG©œ"'CŅÞ{·1yĀāĴ½4/yĀāGŒĮ 4%CŅÞ{·15Ŕ4ĎČ6Ā$3ť1ĥľGÂ*
.4ť¤ŐœwŐ5ŐśŅÞ4/nrĖňŐ{Ţc+vţ u/Ġ#ť;*ťcŢÁ-/ vţŐ{Ġ´13C@4ŐśŅÞ G\:ť(5]5ü«5ŐśŅÞ4@-/uŐśŅÞ 2 .5¤Ő œ4{ƒ"DC ‘Gäĸ#*(#/(5 ‘46ťēgć¹ ŅÞG©œ"'CŅÞ{·1yĀāĴ½4/yĀāGŒĮ4% CŅÞ{·1[ĜŒĮ13C56ťŐśŅÞ5nrĴĒ4@C ŅÞæÉîĠ# ‘0Cť(5 ‘46ŚB‘ŐśŅÞ 5cŢÁ-/ vţŐ{Ġ´0\91NRHJ5Ðö*"D 33Cť1ĥľGÂ*
Û À 4 ť  Ő ś Ņ Þ 4 @ C Ā ā û 5 ń Ă n ã 4 Ĵ D C n r Ő { Ţc+vţĠ´0\8ť;*ťcŢÁ-/ vţŐ{?Ġ´13C@4 ŐśŅÞ\9 ‘ť(DA5ŐśŅÞ5]5ü«5ŐśŅÞ4@

-/uŐśŅÞ 2 .5¤Őœ4{ƒ"DC ‘Gäĸ#*(# /(5 ‘4ťēgć¹ŅÞG©œ"'CŅÞ{·1yĀāĴ½ 4/yĀāGŒĮ4%CŅÞ{·1[ĜŒĮ13C56ť ŐśŅÞ5æÉîĠ# ‘13Bť!5 ‘?;*ŐśŅÞ 5ŅÞæÉîą3C1NRHJ5Ðö*"D33Cť 1ĥľGÂ*
Á-/ť!5ğVIRUMŢˆĢyĀāŧ̤yĀā
zĆ Ĵ½ğ 2 mPLRţ4./6ťŐśŅÞQSKO4¤Ő œ4±%C ‘OHN PäĸĽŞ1#/ì"D/C
ğ`IRUMŢ̤yĀā
zĆĴ½ğ1 mPLRţ16ť ¤ŐœwŐ5c:v î¤ŐœŔ0ą3C ‘0Cť!5PLR4 ./?ťğVIRUM5 ‘1’çťü«5ŐśŅÞ4@BŐś ĿŅÞ  ¤ŐœŔ4{DC ‘OHN P1ŐśŅÞQSK O4¤Őœ4±%C ‘OHN PťäĸĽŞ1#/ì"D/ C
(!0ÞĘ06ť!DAì"D*3 .ĽŞ5,5OHN P4. /äĸ%CŐśŅÞQSKO4¤Őœ4±%C ‘GËOH N P1OHN P4./6ťéĘ0;1>/Ë!14#*
Öò6ťĘ1’ç4ťēgć¹ŅÞ5Ĵ%ħŅÞ5{·ýÈ 1yĀāĴ½4 CŅÞ{·GîʼnŒĮ3¿4¢Ñ%C*>4ť yĀā4 CŅÞ5™ňÓG  1%CÐGĩ*(#/(5 W0ťyĀāĴ½5|º»4 CÓr4čĉ#ť(5Órēg ć¹ŅÞG©œ"'CŅÞ{·5ßeGö*%2Gđļ% C!10[Ĭ5Ŕ5ĎČ5ÜùG}«#*?#ť|º»5Ór ēgć¹ŅÞG©œ"'CŅÞ{·5ßeGö*"33Ať| ºé5Ór5îþ4‘F'@1%C 2 ºédŖ5yĀā4/ ?ēgć¹ŅÞG©œ"'CŅÞ{·©œ#3!1GǕ% CA0C

II. HN "40&=>
'@F3A  $ !Q;1


KMJ7/CJ7  0KL().,R+=>


KM=>:CI?%8B.,O#EGP

̤yĀā
zĆĴ½ğ  m_{5üÃ6ť¤ŐœŔ5ŅÞîþ} ą3Bť;*(5ŅÞîþťĀāłĀāŐœ4/ôńłĀ āŐœ5(D4î:/¤ĺ«"D/Cø4C

Á-/s&!5 ‘46ťˆĢyĀāPLR0äĸ#*ť[¤ Őœ’Ù4ēgć¹ŅÞG”=ť1 ‘6BÂ3

!!0äĸ­ŀ1%C56ťŐśĀāû4 CħńĂnã Ġ#Ùťü«5ŐśŅÞG¡4ħŅÞ 2 ¤Őœ4{ƒ"DC  ‘0C(DG›Ē#*?5-  0C


-  5Ő{GdX5@4«Ī%C

_{a

ĀāŐś4 CťũY¢ŅÞ+Œ¢ŅÞū5ħnrĖňŐ}



{5nãĴĒސĀāŐś4/Ġ#ţ

b

¤Őœ II 530ŅÞæÉÛ?hĀāŐś4 CťY



¢ŅÞ5ħnrĖňŐ{5nãĴĒ


_{c

¤Őœ I 530ŅÞæÉÛ?hĀāŐś4 CťY¢}



ŅÞ5ħnrĖňŐ{5nãĴĒ


d

¤Őœ I 530ŅÞæÉÛ?ŠĀāŐś4 CťY¢



ŅÞ5ħnrĖňŐ{5nãĴĒ


_{x

ħŐśÓG 1 1#*15ť¤Őœ II GæÉ%CŐśÓ5ƒ}


‘
1 _{¤Őœ5ŅÞæÉ6ťI Őœ 4,000c+1,000v+1,000m=6,000ťII Őœ} 1,500c+750v+750m=3,000 13-/BťŅÞîþ6(D)D Ic:Iv=4:1ť IIc:IIv=2:1ťIc:IIc=(8/3):1≒2.67:1 13-/CŬD.K.II, S.505. ÕØÞúťğ 7 {x _{827 Ŝŭ6 ºĉÝ5îþ?ťIc:Iv≒4:1ťIIc:IIv≒2.00:1ťIc:IIc≒2.75:1 1ĺ} «"D/CŬ_{D.K.II, S.508. ÕØÞúťğ 7 {x 833 Ŝŭ}

 ࡲࡓ㸪_{0 < ܾ < ܿ < ݀ < ܽ}㸪_{0 < ݔ < 1}  ͐͐ _(2,1)  ࡇࡢ᫬㸪๓ᥦ࡟ࡼࡾ๫వ౯್⋡㸻_{100㸣࡛㸪◚⥺ MJ ࡣ♫఍ⓗᖹᆒ} ㈨ᮏ࡟࠾ࡅࡿ㈝⏝౯᱁㒊ศࢆ㸪◚⥺_{JE ࡣྠ㈨ᮏࡢಶู฼₶㒊ศࢆ♧} ࡍࠋ  ࠸ࡲ㸪኱㒊㛛_{I㸪኱㒊㛛 II ࡀ⏕⏘㒊㠃 SpȘ࡟ࡼࡗ࡚༊ศࡉࢀࡿ࡜㸪} ኱㒊㛛_{I ࡟ᒓࡍࡿ⏕⏘㒊㠃ࡢ㈨ᮏᵓᡂࡀࡍ࡭࡚኱㒊㛛 II ࡢࡑࢀࡼࡾ} ࡶ㧗ࡃ࡞ࡿࠋࡼࡗ࡚㸪᭦࡟௨ୗࡢࡼ࠺࡟ᐃࡵ㸪෌⏕⏘᮲௳࡜ࡢ㛵ಀ ࢆ୍⯡ⓗ࡟᳨ウࡍࡿࡇ࡜࡟ࡋࡼ࠺ࠋ 㒊㠃⏕⏘≀⥲౯᱁䠄⥲౯್䠅 㻿㼜㻌㼚㻗㻝䠖㻌㼚㻗㻝␒┠䛾⏕⏘㒊㠃 䠄䛯䛰䛧㼚䛿ṇ䛾ᩚᩘ䠅 ๫వ౯್⋡䠙㻾㼙䠙㻳㻵㻛㻵㻭䚷䠄㽢㻝㻜㻜䠙䠂㻕 䕕㻮㻞㻺㻞㻺㻝㻮㻝䠙㻵㼏 䕕㻭㻜㻺㻞㻮㻞䠙㻵㻵㼏 䕕㻯㻞㻮㻞㻮㻝㻯㻝䠙㻵㼢 䕕㻵㻭㻮㻞㻯㻞䠙㻵㻵㼢 䕕㻰㻞㻯㻞㻯㻝㻰㻝䠙㻵㼙 䕕㻳㻵㻯㻞㻰㻞䠙㻵㻵㼙 㻳 㻱 㻴㻝 㻵㻵㼙 㻴㻞 㻰㻝 㻵 㻶 㻵㼙 㻯㻝 㻽 㻯㻞 㻵㼢 㻵㻵㼢 㻮㻝 㻷 㻭 㻮㻞 㻵㻵㼏 㻵㼏 㼐 㼍 ኱㒊㛛㻌㻵㻵 㼏 㻌 ኱㒊㛛㻌㻵 㼎 㼤 㻹 㻺㻝 㻜 㻔㻿㼜㻌㻝㻕 㻺㻞 㻔㻿㼜㻌㼚㻗㻝㻕 㻔㻿㼜㻌㻞㼚㻗㻝㻕 㻔㻿㼜㻌䃐㻕 㻝 䚷䚷䚷䚷ᅗ㻝䚷≉ᐃ䛾⏕⏘㒊㠃䛷኱㒊㛛䛜ศ๭䛥䜜䜛ሙྜ䐟 㻰㻞 㒊㠃ᩘ 㻔㒊㠃ྡ㻕

<sub>IcŨIIc








Ţ*+#






ţ

Ic : Iv







Ţ*+#





ţ







IIc : IIv








Ţ*+#






ţ</sub>

‚knrþ
_



šŢ*+#



_ţ

-  4/ťyĀāĴ½ö*%ße6ťé5(1)A(4)0C
(1) Ic:Iv=


:1 @Bť































Ð(1,1)@B


+Ať!DGÔÿ%C1ť

















_
ť@-/














 (2,3)
(2) IIc:IIv=




:1 @Bť

























Ð(2,1)@B


+Ať!DGÔÿ%C1ť
















ť@-/















<sub>

</sub>  (2,4)
(3) Ic:IIc=



:1 @Bť
























Ð(2,1)@B






+Ať!DGÔÿ%C1ť
















<sub>

</sub>







Ð<sub>(2,1), (2,2)@B














</sub>

+Ať

























;*Ð(2,1)@B




+Ať



(i)


13C56ť
























!D6Ð(2,1),(2,2)5?10¸4ÉĜ%C (2,2)

(ii)


13C56ť






























!DGÔÿ#/ť








<sub>

</sub>





!D?Ð(2,1),(2,2)5?10¸4ÉĜ%C


@-/





















(2,5)
(4) IIc=Iv+Im @Bť





































Ð(2,1)@B






+Ať!DGÔÿ%C1ť











































_{5oÓG¢¿%C1ť}Ð(2,1),(2,2)@B,



























































Á-/ť




































Ð(2,1)@B




+Ať



(i)


13C56ť





































!5Ù{¨6ťÐ(2,1),(2,2)@B,







































;*×4ť{í

_0CAť







6Ð(2,1),(2,2)@B¸4ÉĜ%C (ii)


13C56ť





































!5Ùť×4ĵ*@4{¨1{í61?4êÓ0C




Ať

!DGÔÿ%C1




ť





Ð(2,1)5?10!D6¸4ÉBĜ.Ať







6¸4ÉĜ%C



@-/













































































(2,6)
;*-  4/ťēgć¹ŅÞ
_




ö*%ße6q~ ÷þŪ¹÷þ0CAťé5(5)13C

(5) ĐĨ
 5Œ" ĐĨ
 5Œ"



















(2,7)



_{(i) Ð@B‚knrþ=}



š+Ať




_q~÷þ
ĐĨ
 5Œ" ĐĨ
 5Œ"
ĐĨ
 5Œ"


ĐĨ
 5Œ"







































(2,8)



<sub>(ii) Ic+IIc G








GĂ/Ĵ%1ť




Ic+IIc</sub>


























































(2,9)



<sub>(iii) Iv+IIv G








GĂ/Ĵ%1ť




Iv+IIv</sub>






















































(2,10)



(iv) Ð@B‚knrþ=



š+Ať




Im+IIm= (Iv+IIv)
































(2,11)



(v) (2,7)=(2,8)4(2,9),(2,10),(2,11)Gct%C1ť

Ð(2,1),(2,2)@B







+A!DGÔÿ%C




1ť










































_@-/ť




















(2,12)






!5فÐ<sub>(2,1)@B










+Ať

















;*


13Cße6ť




+Ať















@-/



13BťÐ(2,1)@</sub>






B!D?¸4ÉĜ%C




<sub>@-/(2,12)13C
6Ð(2,1)5?10¸4









Gö*%</sub>
(6) ¯ó
Ð(2,1), (2,2)5?10





13Cŕo6ť



















 (2,3)






















 (2,4)


























(2,5)









































(2,6)














(2,12)



!!0






_{ëć4ÊZ0D7ť(2,12)A}



6į„ć4ñ«"Dťēgć¹ŅÞ©œ%CŅÞ{·5ß


eį„ć4®DC!143C



(!0é4ť!DA






_{ŢÁ-/
ţÊZ5 ‘}


4(2,3),(2,4),(2,5),(2,6)Gö*%
















5Ŕ4

25@3ŕoÉBĜ.Gäĸ%C!14#@



(2,3), (2,4),(2,5),(2,6)5ßeG’Ù4ö*%

<sub>













</sub>





fÇ5r0©œ0D7ťēgć¹ŅÞ©œ%CŅÞ


{·1yĀāĴ½4/yĀāGŒĮ4%CŅÞ{·¸4


’Ù4©œ%C!143CA0C
(7) (2,3), (2,4), (2,5), (2,6)’Ù4ÉĜ%Cße6ť



_{(i) (2,3)
(2,4)@Bť}





























































































(2,13)



(ii) (2,5)5ŽŊ4(2,3),(2,4)Gct#Ôÿ%C1ť





















































































































(2,14)



(iii)(2,6)5ŽŊ4(2,3),(2,13)Gct#Ôÿ%C1ť

































































<sub>









</sub>





















_

































































 (2,15)


(2,14)
(2,15)0ť;*Ð(2,2)@B








+Ať





























































!DGÔÿ%C1ť







<sub>




</sub>




















































<sub>





</sub>









(2,16)
_{(8) (2,5)
(2,6)@Bť}









































!D4(2,13),(2,14),(2,15)Gct%C1ť



³Ŋ













































ŽŊ















































³Ŋ
_ŽŊ+Ať






























































































!DGÔÿ%C1ť









































































!DGÚ4Ôÿ%C1

<sub>












</sub>

(2,17)
(9) Ð(2,1)@BÉBĜ.ŕo6ť




_




























































;*ť


Ð<sub>(2,1)@Bť








"A4









@B

















+Ať</sub>





































@-/ť


















































































(2,18)
<sub>(2,16),(2,17),(2,18)G›Ē#*?5- Ţ*+#




ţ</sub>_0C (!06ťÏĄ"D*ěŔw4/+ Gĵ/?ťēgć¹ŅÞ 2



5 ‘Gîʼn5*>4›4Ē#*

5r¤3D7





¹ś4­%CĶ»¯"3Cťċ¢FA&

<sub>











</sub> 5ģ<‘F' 6ŗ«"D*;;0C

ܴ௠ ൌͳ ࡢሙྜ ܴூூ௖ூூ௩ ܴூ௖ூ௩ ଶ ൅ ሺܴூூ௖ூூ௩ െ ʹܴூூ௖ூூ௩ ܴூ௖ூூ௖ ሻܴ ூ௖ூ௩  െʹܴ ூூ௖ூூ௩ ܴூ௖ூூ௖ ൌͲ ூ௖ ூ௩ ㍈ ூ௖ூூ௖ ㍈ ூூ௖ூூ௩ ㍈ ூ௖ ூ௩ ூூ௖ூூ௩ ܴ௠ ൌ͵ ࡢሙྜ ூ௖ ூ௩ ூூ௖ூூ௩ ூ௖ூூ௖ ᅗ  ࢆ ྠ ᫬ ࡟ ᡂ ❧ ࡉ ࡏ ࡿ ூ௖ ூ௩ ூூ௖ூூ௩ ூ௖ூூ௖  ࡢ ⤌ྜࡏ ூூ௖ூூ௩ ூ௖ ூ௩

5©œ%CŅÞ{·1yĀāĴ½4/yĀāGŒĮ4%CŅÞ{ ·’Ù4©œ%C

<sub>











 5ģ<‘F'6ť








</sub>














0š;DCěŔw4B



5 ‘1#/Ē "DC¹śW4ŗ«"D/C!1{C
@-/°31?



_5 ‘ťfÇ ŦŦ 5 Ŧ













 5r0 ēgć¹ŅÞ5©œ%CŅÞ{·1yĀāĴ½4/yĀāGŒ Į4%CŅÞ{·[Ĝ%C!163

III. HN "40&=>
'@F3A  $ !Q;1


KMJ7/CJ7  0KL().,R+=>


KM=>:CI?%8B2.,O#EGP

!!0lĂ%C56ťĘ0?Ă*-  5ŅÞ{·0C

-  6ť-  0Ē"D*PLRAŐśĀāû4 CńĂ nãĠ#1ßeGŘ*PLR0C
-  5Ő{GdX5@4«Ī%C

_{a

ŅÞæÉÛ?hĀāŐś4 CťũY¢ŅÞŤŒ¢Ņ}



Þū5nrĖňŐ{5nãĴĒ


_{b

ŅÞæÉÛ?hĀāŐś4 CťY¢ŅÞŐ{5nr}



ĖňŐ{5nãĴĒ


_{c

ŅÞæÉÛ?ŠĀāŐś4 CťũY¢ŅÞŤŒ¢Ņ}



Þū5nrĖňŐ{5nãĴĒ


_{d

ŅÞæÉÛ?ŠĀāŐś4 CťY¢ŅÞŐ{5nr}



ĖňŐ{5nãĴĒ





ħŐśÓG1 1#*15ť¤Őœ II GæÉ%CŐśÓ5ƒ


‘
;*

௕ ௔< ௗ ௖, ܿ െ ܽ < ݀ െ ܾ, 0 < ݔ < 1͐͐ (3,1)  ࡇࡢ᫬㸪◚⥺_{MJ ࡣ♫఍ⓗᖹᆒ㈨ᮏ࡟࠾ࡅࡿ㈝⏝౯᱁㒊ศࢆ㸪◚⥺} JE ࡣྠ㈨ᮏࡢಶู฼₶㒊ศࢆ♧ࡍࠋ  ࠸ࡲ㸪኱㒊㛛_{I㸪኱㒊㛛 II ࡀ⏕⏘㒊㠃 SpȘ࡟ࡼࡗ࡚༊ศࡉࢀࡿ࡜㸪} ኱㒊㛛_{I ࡟ᒓࡍࡿ⏕⏘㒊㠃ࡢ㈨ᮏᵓᡂࡀࡍ࡭࡚኱㒊㛛 II ࡢࡑࢀࡼࡾ} ࡶ㧗ࡃ࡞ࡿࠋࡼࡗ࡚㸪᭦࡟௨ୗࡢࡼ࠺࡟ᐃࡵ㸪෌⏕⏘᮲௳࡜ࡢ㛵ಀ ࢆ୍⯡ⓗ࡟᳨ウࡍࡿࡇ࡜࡟ࡋࡼ࠺ࠋ   _{Ic : Iv= ܴூ௖ூ௩: 1 㸦ࡓࡔࡋܴூ௖ூ௩> 0㸧     }   _{IIc : IIv = ܴூூ௖ூூ௩: 1 㸦ࡓࡔࡋ ܴூூ௖ூூ௩> 0㸧}   _{Ic㸸IIc= ܴூ௖ூூ௖: 1 㸦ࡓࡔࡋܴூ௖ூூ௖> 0㸧}   ๫వ౯್⋡_{= 100ܴ௠}㸣㸦ࡓࡔࡋ _{ܴ௠> 0㸧} (3,2) 㒊㠃⏕⏘≀⥲౯᱁䠄⥲౯್䠅 㒊㠃⏕⏘≀⥲౯᱁䠄⥲౯್䠅 㒊㠃⏕⏘≀⥲౯᱁䠄⥲౯್䠅 㻽 㻽 㻽 㻴㻝 㻴㻝 㻴㻝 㻰㻝 㻿 㻗㻝 㻗㻝␒┠䛾⏕⏘㒊㠃 㻰㻝 㻿㼜 㼚㻗㻝㻦 㼚㻗㻝␒┠䛾⏕⏘㒊㠃 㻰㻝 㻿㼜㻌㼚㻗㻝㻦㻌㼚㻗㻝␒┠䛾⏕⏘㒊㠃 㻔䛯䛰䛧㼚䛿ṇ䛾ᩚᩘ䠅 㻔䛯䛰䛧㼚䛿ṇ䛾ᩚᩘ䠅 㻔䛯䛰䛧 䛿ṇ䛾ᩚᩘ䠅 㻯㻝 ๫వ౯್⋡ 㻾 㻳㻵㻛㻵㻭 䠄 㻝㻜㻜 䠂䠅 㻯㻝 ๫వ౯್⋡䠙㻾㼙䠙㻳㻵㻛㻵㻭 䠄㽢㻝㻜㻜䠙䠂䠅 㻯㻝 ๫వ౯್⋡䠙㻾㼙䠙㻳㻵㻛㻵㻭㻌䠄㽢㻝㻜㻜䠙䠂䠅 㻱 㻮㻝 ᖹᆒ฼₶⋡䠄 ⯡ⓗ฼₶⋡䠅䠙㻴㻝㻯㻝㻛㻯㻝㻺 㻱 㻮㻝 ᖹᆒ฼₶⋡䠄୍⯡ⓗ฼₶⋡䠅䠙㻴㻝㻯㻝㻛㻯㻝㻺 㻱 㻮㻝 ᖹᆒ฼₶⋡䠄 ⯡ⓗ฼₶⋡䠅 㻴㻝㻯㻝㻛㻯㻝㻺 㻰㻞 㻰㻞 㻵㼙 䕕㻮㻞㻺㻞㻺㻮㻝䠙㻵㼏 㻰㻞 㻵㼙 䕕㻮㻞㻺㻞㻺㻮㻝䠙㻵㼏 㻵 䕕㻯㻞㻮㻞㻮㻝㻯㻝 㻵 㻵㼢 䕕㻯㻞㻮㻞㻮㻝㻯㻝䠙㻵㼢 㻵㼢 䕕㻯㻞㻮㻞㻮㻝㻯㻝䠙㻵㼢 㻴㻞 㻶 䕕㻰㻞㻯㻞㻯㻝㻰㻝䠙㻵㼙 㻴㻞 㻶 䕕㻰㻞㻯㻞㻯㻝㻰㻝䠙㻵㼙 㻴㻞 㻶 䕕㻰㻞㻯㻞㻯㻝㻰㻝 㻵㼙 㻳 䕕㻭㻜㻺㻞㻮㻞䠙㻵㻵㼏 㻳 䕕㻭㻜㻺㻞㻮㻞䠙㻵㻵㼏 㻵㻵 㻯㻞 㻷 䕕㻵㻭㻮㻞㻯㻞 㻵㻵 㻵㻵㼙 㻯㻞 㻷 䕕㻵㻭㻮㻞㻯㻞䠙㻵㻵㼢 㻵㻵㼙 㻯㻞 㻷 䕕㻵㻭㻮㻞㻯㻞䠙㻵㻵㼢 㼐 㼏 䕕㻳㻵㻯㻞㻰㻞䠙㻵㻵㼙 㼐 㼏 䕕㻳㻵㻯㻞㻰㻞䠙㻵㻵㼙 㼐 㼏 䕕㻳㻵㻯㻞㻰㻞 㻵㻵㼙 㻵㻵㼢 㻮㻞 㻵㻵㼢 㻮㻞 㻵 㻵 㻵 㻵㼏 㻵 㻵㼏 㼍 㻵㻵㼏 㼍 㻵㻵㼏 㻭 㼤 㻝 㻭 㼤 㻝㻙㼤 㻭 㼤 㻝 㼤 㼎㼎 㻺㻞 㻹 㻺 㒊㠃ᩘ 㻺㻞 㻹 㻺 㒊㠃ᩘ 㻺㻞 㻹 㻺 㒊㠃ᩘ 㻔㒊㠃ྡ㻕 㻾 㻜 㻔㻿㼜 㻝㻕 㻿㼜䃐 㻔㻿㼜 㼚㻗㻝㻕 㻔㻿㼜 㻞㼚㻗㻝㻕 㻔㒊㠃ྡ㻕 㻾 㻜 㻔㻿㼜㻌㻝㻕 㻿㼜䃐 㻔㻿㼜㻌㼚㻗㻝㻕 㻔㻿㼜㻌㻞㼚㻗㻝㻕 㻔㒊㠃ྡ㻕 㻾 㻜 㻔㻿㼜㻌㻝㻕 㻿㼜䃐 㻔㻿㼜㻌㼚 㻝㻕 㻔㻿㼜㻌㻞㼚 㻝㻕 ኱㒊㛛 㻵㻵 ኱㒊㛛 㻵 ኱㒊㛛 㻵㻵 ኱㒊㛛 㻵 ኱㒊㛛㻌㻵㻵 ኱㒊㛛㻌㻵 㻝㻝 ᅗ㻟 ≉ᐃ䛾⏕⏘㒊㠃䛷኱㒊㛛䛜ศ๭䛥䜜䜛ሙྜ䐠 ᅗ㻟 ≉ᐃ䛾⏕⏘㒊㠃䛷኱㒊㛛䛜ศ๭䛥䜜䜛ሙྜ䐠 ᅗ㻟䚷≉ᐃ䛾⏕⏘㒊㠃䛷኱㒊㛛䛜ศ๭䛥䜜䜛ሙྜ䐠

-  4/ťyĀāĴ½ö*%ße6ťé5(1)A(4)0C

(1) IcŨIvŪB2N2NB1 5śęŨC2B2B1C1 5śęŪ




@


Bť


Ĩ{ B2N2 5Œ"Ū








Ĩ{ C2B2 5Œ"ŪĨ{ C2N2 5Œ"– Ĩ{ B2N2 5Œ"









Ū













+Ať





























_

























(2,1)@B


+Ať!DGÔÿ%C1ť











<sub>














</sub>









































(3,3)



(i)
5oÓ4./




Ð(3,1),(3,2)@B












+Ať






<sub>5oÓ


















































ū0</sub>





@-/ť














































(3,4)



(ii)


13Cße6ť






_
























³ŊG¢¿%C1ť










<sub>




















































</sub>








@-/




















(3,5)



(iii)


13Cße6ť






<sub>








































</sub>

!DGÔÿ%C1ť










<sub>








+A</sub>


























(3,6)



@-/_{(3,5) (3,6)5 ‘(3,4)6}




13C


_{(2) IIc}

IIvŪ






@Bť












































(3,1)@B


+Ať!DGÔÿ%C1ť











<sub>







































</sub>






























(3,7)


(i)
5oÓ4./





Ð(3,1),(3,2)@B














+Ať







<sub>5oÓ



















































</sub>







@-/ť



























































(3,8)




(a)


13Cße6ť











<sub>












</sub>











@-/





















(3,9)




(b)


13Cße6ť











<sub>


















































</sub>













!DGÔÿ%C1ť




































 (3,10)



@-/_{(3,9) (3,10)5 ‘(3,8)6}




13C

(3) IcŨIIcŪB2N2NB 5śęŨA0N2B2 5śęŪ









@Bť




































(3,1)@B






+Ať!DGÔÿ%C1ť













<sub>

































5}~½6ť





























</sub>

















Ð(3,1),(3,2)@B


















@-/
6é5 2 .5¬ÓķGÍ.








































































##Ð<sub>(3,1),(3,2)@Bť{í

+Ať











13C56ť</sub>


















































































































 (3,11)





5 ‘4ŗADC




!5Ùť


<sub>(i)


13Cße6ť</sub>











+Ať










<sub>



















</sub>









[Ŋ6êÓ+A(D)D2 ^#/Ôÿ%C1ť



















!D6Ð(3,1),(3,2)@B¸4ÉBĜ.


<sub>(ii)


13Cße6ť











+Ať































</sub>

<sub>

</sub>








!DGÔÿ%C1ť









<sub>





















</sub>










[Ŋ6êÓ+A(D)D2 ^#/Ôÿ%C1ť











<sub>

</sub>













Ð_{(3,1),(3,2)@B}













+Ať





!D6¸4ÉBĜ.




@-/ťÐ<sub>(3,1),(3,2)5X0ť(3,11)Ē%
6ť








13C</sub>


(4) IIcŪIv+Im @Bť+



IIc = A0N2B2 5śę












(3,12)



;*ťIv+Im = Iv





=C2B2B1C1 5śę










Ţ

_{ĀāŐś5‚knrþŪ}



š+Ať
<sub>

</sub>

ţ



@-/ť




_{Iv +Im =}


































(3,13)



(3,12) = (3,13)+Ať





























































(2,14)@B






+A!DGÔÿ%C1ť

































































 (3,14)


(i)

_5oÓ4./






Ð<sub>(3,1),(3,2)@B













+</sub>





Ať




























































(ii)

_5oÓ



















5 ‘ť

!DG¢¿%C1



















(3,15)





!5Ù(3,14)@Bť







































@-/ť








































(3,16)






Ð(3,1),(3,2)@B{í

+Ať




(a)


13C56ť







_(3,16)5{¨






















!D6Ð(3,1),(3,2)@B¸4ÉĜ%C




(b)


13C56ť
































@-/




















(3,17)







(3,15)G(3,17)4ct%C1ť
















































!DGÔÿ%C1ť






























Ð<sub>(3,1),(3,2)@B











+Ať</sub>







!D6¸4ÉĜ%C





@-/ťÐ_{(3,1),(3,2)5?10ť(3,16)6¸4}









Gö*%


(iii)

<sub>5oÓ

5 ‘ť</sub>





b

1ĩ1ť








































































_!5ÙťÐ(3,1),(3,2)@Bť






























_(3,18)





























































































(3,19)





























_(3,20)























































































































 (3,21)













<sub>13C56ť



































































@-/ť</sub>ŕÓ



_{5ŝø5
¼è6ť}













































(3,22)




_{(a) (3,14)5}

5oÓê5 ‘ť




















+Ať







































@-/!D6ť





















<sub>5 ‘ť
















































5 ‘</sub>ť


























(3,23)

           ࡜ሙྜศࡅࡉࢀࡿࠋ        _ ๓ᥦ_{(3,1),(3,2)ࡼࡾ െܽ < 0 < ܴ௠(ܽ െ ܾ) ࡔ࠿ࡽ㸪}          㛵ᩘ_{݂(ݔ)ࡢ㡬Ⅼࡢ ݔ ᗙᶆ=} െܽെܴ݉(ܽെܾ) (െܽ+ܿ)+ܴ݉(െܽ+ܾ+ܿെ݀)< 0        _{ࡇࢀ࡜(3,18),(3,19),(3,20),(3,21)ࡼࡾ㸪㛵ᩘ݂(ݔ)}ࡣᅗ         ࡟♧ࡉࢀࡿࠋ         ࡇࡢ᫬_{݂(ݔ) ࡣ 0 < ݔ < 1 ࡟ゎࢆ 1 ࡘᣢࡘࠋࡲࡓ㸪}        _{ݔ =}         ିଶ{௔ାோ೘(௔ି௕)}ାට൛ଶ{௔ାோ೘(௔ି௕)}ൟ మ_{ିସ{(ି௔ା௖)(ଵାோ} ೘)ା(௕ିௗ)ோ೘}{ି(ଵାோ೘)(௔ି௕ା௖ିௗ)} ଶ{(ି௔ା௖)(ଵାோ೘)ା(௕ିௗ)ோ೘}                             ͐͐ _(3,24)      _{(b) (3,14)ࡢ ݔ}ଶ _{ࡢಀᩘࡀ㈇ࡢሙྜ㸪}  (െܽ + ܿ)(1 + ܴ௠) + (ܾ െ ݀)ܴ௠< 0 ࡔ࠿ࡽ㸪           _{െܽ + ܿ + ܴ௠(െܽ + ܾ + ܿ െ ݀) < 0} 㡬Ⅼ䛾 ᗙᶆ 㻜 㻝 㻜 㻝 㡬Ⅼ䛾 ᗙᶆ ᅗ㻠 䛾ಀᩘ䛜ṇ䛾ሙྜ ᅗ㻡 䛾ಀᩘ䛜㈇䛾ሙྜ

@-/!D6ť





















<sub>5 ‘ť
















































5 ‘</sub>ť





































1 ‘{ "DC







Ð<sub>(3,1),(3,2)@B











+Ať</sub>








ŕÓ



5ŝø5
_¼è








































Ú4ť




























13C56ť





















_{5 ‘0Bť!D6Ð}









(3,1),(3,2)5?10¸4ÉBĜ.







@-/ť!D1(3,18),(3,19),(3,20),(3,21)@Bťŕ







Ó



6-  4Ē"Dť



<sub>6




4ķG 1</sub>







.Í.!5Ùť




































































































13Bť

5oÓê5 ‘5â1’ž43C


(5) ēgć¹ŅÞ5q~÷þŪ¹÷þ@B




ēgć¹ŅÞ5q~÷þ
ĐĨ
 5Œ" ĐĨ
 5Œ"















































 (3,26)




¹÷þ







































(3,25)


(3,27)




_{Ic+IIc
B2N2NB1+A0N2B2 5śę5śę}


























































Iv+IIv
IAB2C2 5śę+C2B2B1C1 5śę








































































































@-/Ð<sub>(3,1),(3,2)@B









+Ať</sub>



(3,26)=(3,27)6¸4ÉBĜ.@-/ťÐ (3,1),(3,2)4



/ēgć¹ŅÞ5q~÷þ
<sub>¹÷þ6




















</sub>


16ùŕo4ÉBĜ.


(6) ¯ó




!D;05ĥáG;1>C1ťÐ(3,1),(3,2)5?10









_13C56ť




(1)@Bť











_5ße6ť






























(3,5)







.




























(3,6)






!5 ‘4ť

















































(3,4)

(2)@Bť











_5ße6ť






























(3,9)







.
































(3,10)






!5 ‘4ť
























































(3,8)




(3)@Bť



















































(3,11)









Ţ!5Ù
<sub>6¸4




ţ</sub>




(4)@Bť








<sub>5oÓ

5 ‘6ť</sub>



























(3,15)






!5 ‘4ť



































(3,16)





C6ť








_5oÓ



















5 ‘6ť










































































































(3,24)




(5)@BťÐ(3,1),(3,2)5X0








<sub>6




5u/5rG1BC</sub>

(7) ;Ð(3,1)Gö*%Ór1#/ťÚ4































(3,28)



1%C




ēgć¹ŅÞ1yĀāĴ½4 CyĀāGŒĮ4



%CŅÞ{·¸4[Ĝ%C3Aťēgć46ÊZ0



C!DA5r5X0?ťWĹ5ĿŕoGö*%ŅÞ{·6



¸4ÉBĜ*3 D73A36&0C




(!0!D;0ÂAD*Ŀŕo4!DAGct%C1ť


<sub>(i) (4)5

5oÓ

5 ‘6ť</sub>




(a) (3,15)@Bť




























+A










(b) (3,16)@Bť









































































<sub>(c) (3,28),(3,29)Gť



</sub> 4€ġße53(3,11)4c







t%C1ť
































































!DGÔÿ%C1ť








<sub>
































 4./}~½5rGð>C1ť

























</sub>










@-/

<sub>

 6¬ÓķGÍ.ť













</sub>











































C6




 













13BťÐ<sub>(3.1)5





4‰%C</sub> (3,29)

@-/

5oÓ

5 ‘ť

<sub>











</sub>









5ģ‘'6©œ#3


<sub>(ii) (4)5

5oÓ

5 ‘ť




(a)


5oÓ

5 ‘






















@-/
















1!E(3,28)@B



+Ať!5 ‘ť</sub>






ÐGö*%

<sub>











</sub>


5ģ‘'6©œ






#3




<sub>(b)


5oÓ

5 ‘






















@-/</sub>
















;*ť


































+Ať_(3,23)@Bť




































@-/<sub>(3,25)@B



6ÉĜ%C!10</sub>






C







!5Ùť






























































































































































(3,30)






13BťÐ<sub>(3,1)5




?ö*"DC</sub>




@-/<sub>(3,28)6ť(4)5

5oÓ

5 ‘4­Ä#*Ó</sub>



rm0C!1FC




(!0ť

<sub>5oÓ

5 ‘4­Ä#*Órm0C



(3,28)5 ‘4













 5Ŕ425@3ŕo</sub>



ÉĜ%C5Gé4đļ%C!14#@


<sub>(8)








</sub> 5ŕo

<sub>











































































</sub>






























































@-/ť













































































































(3,31)




(3,31)4(3,28),;*(3,30)@B


_
1#/ct%C1ť
























































@-/ť


<sub>








(3,32)</sub>


(9) (3,28), (3,32)5?10ť(1),(2)0Ē"D* ‘5ßeÚ



4Š Cŗ«


(i) (1)5(3,5)1(3,6)4/ť


























































































!DGÔÿ%C1






















































3 _+Ať




































3










































































>0
<sub>(3,32)@B








</sub>

@-/_{(1)1(2)6°31?é5 ‘4ÉBĜ.}


























(3,33)


(ii) (2)5(3,9)1(3,10)4/ť

































































































!DGÔÿ%C1























































+Ať’ç4ť










































@-/_{(1)1(2)6°31?é5 ‘4ÉBĜ.}





















(3,34)


(10) !DA(3,33),(3,34)5X0ÉBĜ.ŕoG;1>ť(D4



<sub>(3,28)5ÓrGct#/













</sub> 5Ŕ5ŕoGð



>C


_{(i) (3,4)
(3,8)@Bť}





























































































(3,28)5ÓrGct#/ť























































(3,35)


_{(ii) (3,8)
(3,11)@Bť}




































































































(3,28)5ÓrGct#/ť


































































 (3,36)


_{(iii) (3,8)
(3,24)@Bť}












































































































































(3,28)5ÓrGct#/ť



























































(3,37)


(iv) (3,33)@Bť




















(3,28)5ÓrGct#/









(3,38)


_{(v) (3,34)@Bť}

















(3,28)5ÓrGct#/








(3,39)


(11) !DA(3,32),(3,35),(3,36),(3,37),(3,38),(3,39)@8Ð



(3,2)5ŕoG›Ē%C




!DA5ŕoGĴ#*?5-  0C




-  A6ť

<sub>











</sub> ¸4©œ%C56ť]¦



5 3 ś’Ù4a´%C 1 ø4ŗADC!1{C




1!E0ť!5-  5]¦53 ś’Ù4a´%C 1 ø



4C

<sub>











 A®DC
6




0</sub>

C!1×4đļ"D/C




@-/ťÐ(3,1)Gö*%(3,28)5 ‘46ťÐ(3,2)G



ö*%

<sub>











</sub> ©œ#ť(DA5Ór5X0








<sub>13Cvō5
©œ%C!143Cť



















</sub> ©œ#ÂC56å>/ŗAD* ‘0C



!1ť!5›0Ē"DC!143C 

 

dWÞĘ06ť̤yĀā
zĆĴ½ğ1 mPLRť%3F,ť ¤ŐœwŐ5c:v î¤ŐœŔ0ą3C ‘4./ťü«5Őś ŅÞ4@BŐśĿŅÞ  ¤ŐœŔ4{DC ‘5äĸGij-*

äĸ4ř#/6ťēgć¹ŅÞ5Ĵ%ħŅÞ5{·ýÈ1yĀ āĴ½4 CŅÞ{·GîʼnŒĮ3¿4¢Ñ%C*>4ťyĀā 4 CŅÞ5™ňÓG  1%CÐGĩ*
äĸ5ĥᝐĀāŐś5ħĀāû4 Cc+v 5nrťÁ-/ ħńĂnãťĠ´G3% ‘ťēgć¹ŅÞG©œ"'CŅÞ {·1yĀāĴ½5yĀāGŒĮ4%CŅÞ{·16ťå>/ŗA D* ‘4#[Ĝ'&ť
ޖŞţ(1)A(5)5ŕoťÐ(3,1)Gö*%fÇ5ŦŦŦ






5

?10ťÐ(3,1)Gö*%fÇ5ŦŦŦ
















4/

ÉĜ%C 6ÉBĜ*3!1ĥľ1#/ÂAD*
ÞĘyĀā4 CŅÞ5™ňÓG  1%CÐGÍ.!1 AťÞĘ5ĥľGĊ,4Vİ…%C!1603##ťÞĘ 5ĥľ6ťNRHJ5Órmįj4NRHJįŇ5‹ŋ1ĎČ%C ‰m”;DC!1GĒ#/C

éĘ06ťì"D*ĽŞOHN P"OHN P5äĸ4Ŏ=!14# @



 



























































































































 














 












































































 




































 





        
     
















   








































































































                    ூ௖ூூ௖ ㍈      ோ಺಺೎಺಺ೡ ିଵ ଵǤହା଴Ǥସோ ಺಺೎಺಺ೡ ൌ ି଴Ǥହሺோ ಺೎಺಺೎ ାଵሻା ඥ ሺோ಺೎಺಺೎ ାଵሻሺ଴Ǥଶହோ ಺೎಺಺೎ ାସሻ ଵǤହሺோ ಺೎಺಺೎ ାଵ ሻ                                                   ஺Ⅼ           ூ௖ ூ௩ ㍈                                                                 ூூ௖ூூ௩ ㍈   ூ௖ ூ௩  ூ௖ ூ௩ ூூ௖ூூ௩   ᅗ  ௠ ࡢሙྜ㸪      ࠿ࡽ    ࢆྠ᫬࡟ᡂ❧ࡉࡏࡿ ூ௖ ூ௩ ǡ ூூ௖ூூ௩ ூ௖ூூ௖ ࡢ⤌ྜࡏ ூ௖ ூ௩ ூூ௖ூூ௩ ூ௖ூூ௖ ܴூூ௖ூூ௩ െͳ ͳǤͷ ൅ ͲǤͶܴ ூூ௖ூூ௩ ൌ െ͵ ξͳʹǤ͵͸ ͳǤͶ ͲǤ͸ܴ ூ௖ூ௩ െ ʹǤͷ ͳǤͷ ൅ ͲǤͶܴ ூ௖ூ௩ ൌ ܴூூ௖ூூ௩ െͳ ͲǤͷ ൅ ͲǤͶܴ ூூ௖ூூ௩ ூூ௖ூூ௩

*D5<

NRHJťK.(1885/1985)ŅÞľ ğ 2 µ ğ 3 {xēgĕªďĚ


ÊĈpTŅÞľīĻ§—gĻťğ 7 {xťÕØÞzúē ŬMarx, Karl. Das Kapital: Kritik der politischen Ökonomie. Zweiter Band, Buch II: Der Cirkulationsprocess des Kapitals. Herausgegëben von Friedrich Engels. Hamburg: Verlag von Otto Meissner, 1885. Herausgegeben von Institut für

Marxismus-Leninismus beim ZK der SED. Band 24 der Werke von Marx und Engels. Berlin : Diez Verlag, 1969.ŭ

(1894/1987)ŅÞľ ğ 3 µēgĕªďĚÊĈpT

ŅÞľīĻ§—gĻťğ9 {xťÕØÞzúē

ŬMarx, Karl. Das Kapital: Kritik der politischen Ökonomie.





_{Dritter Band, Hamburg: Verlag von Otto Meissner,}





1894.Herausgegeben von Institut für

Marxismus-Leninismus beim ZK der SED. Band 25





der Werke von Marx und Engels. Berlin : Diez Verlag, 1976.ŭ

ï² £˜ă(2014)yĀāĴ½4 CŅÞ{·4./ŢţŨē

gć¹ŅÞ15ŕoAďĚºŸ
ĤõªiIJ











Ĕ¥ÒÎŌĭĹŏťà†¤ªĤõªgť µ  ť












 Ŝ