21COE-GLOPE Working Paper Series

21COE-GLOPE Working Paper Series

If you have any comment or question on the working paper series, please contact each author.

When making a copy or reproduction of the content, please contact us in advance to request permission. The source should explicitly be credited.

GLOPE Web Site: http://www.waseda.jp/prj-GLOPE/en/index.html

Rosca

2007

2007

2

19

!

2007

2

28

!

2007

7

27

!

Rotating Savings Credit Association (Rosca)

!"#$%&'()*+, -./01234 !"56789:;<!=%&> Rosca

?@AB,*CAD(E*@72&FA?@AGH5IJ3KALM

$%;GHN"AD(E*OPQRS&T<HU<:"VWX%&>

Y1Z[ Rosca \S&]^_`Ha!b 1990 cdeMfg

#$%&hijklmHnS&>KAoT%$pq!;rk<so

AtuA;MAvwAxyz{Ha|>

Rosca ^*)

!"#$

#

%&'()*+ ,-

./0

#12

34-5

6

789

:;

Rotating Savings and Credit Association

^<=>?@ABCDEF

GH

’Rosca’

^{IJ KL.MN}

OL P QR

<

STL UVK

W

XY:

.

=

WZ#

[\*]^

;

$#_`a-

.

bcd-L

e-fghT9

:;

1) 1) 1) 1)

ⁱP Q RWL"#j .

klm n#op*qrTscd*m

.

tud-vhL

.

wxyz-{

h

|}9

:T

&%x~

#

€-5

.

‚ƒ„c…†‡j

#

ˆ‰Š ‹

<

Œg#‚ŠK#Ž;UV&%

.‘

’ 4 “

”

•x~#

–

—

*˜8

Ta#a™;

i

š2

‘

’ 4 “

”

x~

#

P Q RW›_`9

:;

œL

. 9ž

-LŒŸ-vha

 

¡ž

:v



. v5"

7

^{c¢-£T;% & m n¤¥#¦§a-.}

P Q RWLfg¨©

h;

2) 2) 2) 2)

ⁱ

Rosca

" #a##fgL .

ˆª#«'¬›*a

6

­®

h;

i

+N'7¯*

°±#a#

›ž

.

Rosca

^{LMN#s²³´O™;b´ µ´¶#·¸·³´*L¹}

¡

.

9ž-L·

Լ

»

.

b¼½

h

6

Tc…#¾-vha

.

"#¿ÀOÁ

Â#[\

a-ÃS:h;

3) 3) 3)

3)

^iST.Ä

ÅÆdz´ -ȞÉ

.

ÊË´#

–

Ì-vha

.

h£ Í;“

šÎ

º ÏЛ

ÑÒ ^

;

Ó% &

OL

Rosca

^{›Ô89:; Õa™;iÖ×'ØٛÅÚ}

h



h

m n%&-vhL

.

ÛÜÝO™:ØÙ-Ÿ£;Þß*àT^š2

‘

’ 4 “

”

x

~›áâ-ãS:;՛äå

.

Rosca

^{a"#æçO™;èrž:;}

^{4) 4) 4) 4)}

ⁱ

*)

^{éêëìíîïð}

21

^ñò

COE

^{óôõö÷ øùúûüýþÿ F}

1

^óô

ü

H

ëð

ìíîï ð

! " #$%&'

1)

^{( )*+,-./01üúë23ú4ë5,67î 8}

1918

^{9û:6;þ<= 8}

1275

⁹

ø

>?@ABC DEFFGHIF

ø JK

8

üL

9

FIM,NO%LPQ

R?

8

1920

^{9û:6Sú(* T(K TJ*TJ)*5ULVúûü}

2)

^{WXYZ[\+%]^ü_þ 8}

1989

^{9`?YZ()*+%]^üab}

8

1993

^{95Uë6cd( )*+efð'4N}

3)

^{ghXijklm6nAomTnpmTqm6ré6st÷6uvwxyA4}

Rosca

^{z{%]^ü}

Geertz

⁸

1962

^{9,6|ü6I }~ €6uuT}

uvw x

T

‚4

Rosca

^{%]^ü}

Ardener

⁸

1964

^95U,ƒ„3û

4)

^{†üÿ 4ë6‡ˆ‰Š‹Œ,vŽ 5$‘l’“”%•„O5ü}

–:

6

—˜$‘뙚

›œ

ü$ žŸ, û5U

6¡

|¢|5£¤

v



Ž 

 5

$‘,¥|

û€ü

|ü

6

¦

¤õö§¨

©ª4

“”üõö«¤

¦

¤ 5

UL

… ¬

4N­

6

®¯

°

†

‡ˆ‰Š‹Œ%±²

† J

4N

³

–O

,4€ 8{–:

6

Bardhan and Udry

⁸

1999

^9%´µ9

Rosca

^{OL. –0·# < XY:;K›}

234º

ž»¡ž

:

.

»¡ž

:T

¸k^ ¼

<

=W•Z

K›

.0

¡ž:T½¾-+¿

h æÀ

# 12

34-Árž

:;

i

Rosca

^{#»€ÂÃL1234#ÀÃ-Äå.^ ¼# 123 4}

›

–

~W•*Å©Æ; Õ-;

i

^£Ç

.

Rosca

^{#È'L.Õ#.1234ÝÉ-56»¡ž:T¸k*¾1234›}

ʄËÌ^;Õ-™

.

Ë Ì

T

¸kL

.

Íθ#Ï}¶

–Ð '

–

0

Ñ#ÒÓ#T¡

-Ôhž

:

;՛äå

.

STL±Õ#

Ö×ÒÓ-Ôhž

:

;Õa™;

i

»¡ž

:T

¸k*ËÌ^;1234ØO#½¾*Ù¡;Úw-5

6

.

":Û:#

Rosca

*

/

ÜÝ©;Õa

OÞ;

i

":

ž

L

†ß

.

Random Rosca

^{<à <á¸KP Q RWK}

Bidding Rosca

^{<âP QRWK-­ã9:;›.äåOL.ËÌ#½¾›á¸æސ¶#Úw}

Oç2è é-Ù

0 9

:

. jå

OL

¾d-

.

»¡ž

:T

¸kSTLW•*ËÌ5ê^;1

234›

ëì^

;

.

}íÑ#†

Þ 9-5

6

½¾›ÙS;

5) 5) 5) 5)

ⁱ

Rosca

^-çhL.%&îïÀãî™;hLðñ-vhL .

ºò亞­ó

9

:ÞT

i m nî

OL

Besley, Coate and Loury

^<

1993

^{K¶#­óºž«ô'v5õö÷}

'

øù›

úû-‹£:;5ê-

6 T›

.

"#

üýLþÿ'

h

i

N-vhL

.

•x~#üý'ÅÚ

O

ž

:;

Rosca

^-çh#.Õ:SO#

m nî'­ó*y«

.

j#*tžº-^;

i

N#7 8

L

. ò #

v



O™;

i

‚

æ

OL

.

Rosca

^{­ó#z'è .SɱÕ#Ö×å‹#­ó _O}

Rosca

#a

ç à›

9

:;

i

Õ ÕOL

.

!"#$%&'

()

$

* + ,-.

/0

1 2 3

4%&5 67

89:;'<$=5>?@A

B C

DEFG

HIJ5(

KLMNOPGQR STU'VT

W

X YZ

%&@

[

*C

\]

^_`

T

a

bcd5U

`

Rosca

^@eSTfghijkT

Besley, Coate and Loury

+

1993

^4lAm

van den Brink and Chavas

⁺

1997

^{4n1o p_`Taqr's@5t}

"\$DEF

uvGw

h 'J

Rosca

^{Gxy'JC*Tazr5,-./01'}

Random Rosca

⁵

Random Rosca

^'

Bidding Rosca

^5{|<$T}~@AT

Bidding Rosca

^@[

*C

\]J

s

k

=5r5t€‚%

!"#$%&

Rosca

^ƒ„

g…N`T

a

_N@5

Rosca

^{'*)†‡(sGˆ‰_ŠT‹ŒkT5}

Rosca

Ž„G:ij@‘’

*C

“”ST

a

b•d5–—˜d

™gGš›

)› 5

Rosca

@eSTœ

gGžŸ@ fST

a

5) Bidding Rosca

^{¡¢£¤¥¦§¨£¤©ª«©¬­¦§®¯°±¦²³¦´µ±¶¨·¸¹}

º»¼½¾¨¿ÀÁÂÃÄ©

Rosca

^{ºÅ½¾¶Æ¢}

Premium Bidding Rosca

^{ÇÈÉ¿ÀÁÂ Ê}

½

Discount Bidding Rosca

^{ÇÈË¿ÀÁ ʽÌƶ¨¬­Í Ψ·Ï¥Ð¡¢Ñ©£ ¤¥}

§Ò

ÓÔÕÖµ¸º

¢

× ØÙÚÐÛܼ¦

ÝÕÞßེáâã

£ ¤¥Í

¢ ä

©

ÙЩ¸

ºå¨à½ ÍÐæ

¨

· ç

¬

¢ 襩

Discount Bidding Rosca

^{С¢é¦Â¸ºåãê ëìí}

¡

¢

×î¦ïð±

¶ãÖµ¸©ñòºÝÕÞ ß

ç

¬

¢

£ ¤¥Í

¢

óô¸ºå¯ÕÃÕêë

ìíÍõÝ

öÖµ

¸¦÷¾¨

ÈËòºøùâ

¢

×

ÓÔÕÈËòºùâ ã¥Í

¢ ä

©ÙЩÂ

¸ºúå ¾¨

·

Bidding Rosca

^{С¢à©§öã ¤Í Ç× ØÙºûüÊýÙ¦þÕ¯ÿÒ}

°

¶

¢ ä

©

¢

¸ºå¾¨êëìíÍï

°

¶

¨

·

1. Rosca

Rosca

^{} ~89: ;@5A)$GSMGT U'@ABC5}

Rosca

S NM@$T

a

*

[ M

f gh\]5DE 89F

A)$

W

YZG

)5

lumpiness

^{+WX„489: ;@I_`/GJC*T5d5}

Rosca

^{6789: ;\]@A)@I_`TM5(`A)$ƒGs[}

MG“”JC A)

a

1.1

^!"‚%89:;

# $%><&'

89(

@e)J

C*

T5U U>@*+ST

,- .

1

:;

G/'\]'J

C–

A)@

01ST

a 5

,- .

1 S2

C3

4k=5

3

W

ƒ

Le5Gs

B C*

T'ST

a U

ƒLe55&'''s@61J$

*s

'ST

a b

t

/

} ~

i

89 7G

i

C t

'ST'5(

89MNvN`TƒL89

i

U t

5:

A)@;›N

`

T'ST

a

U t ^{i =} U C ( ) t ⁱ

^<J5

U C ^′ ( ) t ^{i > 0}

5

U ^′′ ( ) C t ^{i < 0} (1)

S$=>589

?@ƒL k=ABST

a

W

C5}~

i

b

t

/@vTDv5

i

y t

⁺

≥ 0

4kT'ST

a

U`N

Dv˜}~@'

B C

D;kT'ST5˜ } ~˜/@REFTDv5GJs3…$

*

a

!"

h

$H?‚%@l

*C

!"#$%&5} ~

89:;žŸ@^SU'VT

+ UU

5žŸ

1

‹@I%kT'ST4

a U

'V5bJ/MNb

N

/

K†

L5:

A)@$T

a

1 1

= =

∑ ^N _t ⁱ ≥ ∑ ^N _t ⁱ

t t

y c (2)

S$=>5

N

/'REFTDv

&M5

3

/'YZST89

&M@NJ

*

M5

(`G—OT

a (

J

C

589rU

†LŒ

5

N

/'@l

*C

QRSTƒL

&M5

S$=>5

( )

= 1

= ∑ ^N _t ⁱ

t

U U c (3)

GP Q1JA)'ST

+

UU&'{|G'J5R SJ$

* 4

a

U

'V5} ~

i

@'

B C

PT$89: ;MU5:

V W

V- XY

,-

GP Q1STU

'@A

B C

M`T

+

<

J5

λ ⁱ

^{†LŒ +}

2

^{4@xZJVWV-XY[5kT4a}

( ) ( )

1 1 1

λ

= = =

= ∑ ^N _t ⁱ + ⁱ ∑ ^N _t ⁱ − ∑ ^N _t ⁱ

t t t

L U c y c (4)

U

\ ]

W^

Œ'5N_ˆ‰ST†LŒ

+

2

^{4MN5PT$89 7@[*C5}

1 2

1 2

, ,

* * , , * * + + +

= = = = =

i i i

i i i i N

N

y y y

c c c c

N (5)

'$T

a

PT$89 MU589r} ~

i

5S2

C

/'@l

*C N7

89G:l

) '

a

a

1.2

^!"‚%

Rosca

zag…

!"

‚%

89r:;@

Rosca

^{I_`'V589:;A)$}

GRET kb)M

a UU

Rosca

^{c d5–A)$žŸ$/01_}

`T'ST

a

5J

[

>5

N

⁺

≥ 2

4~

,-.

1 MNˆ

B

Cl=5(`Nb

N

/

'5

U

>@D eJ5f/

b

⁺

≥ 0

4

gE?GYh)s

'ST

a J

B

C5˜/

gE?

&M

bN

'$=5U

i‹N`gE?5˜/5J~

,-.

1

@Yh=`T

a

Radom Rosca

^{5U>?GREFT/V-j k@(_`Ta<J5W‡>?}

bN

GREF

B

,-.

1

5lm>?GREFTU'V$

*

a

<

J5(

REF

B

,-.

1 5

+ m

,-.

1

S 2C>?GREFT4P n/gE?GYh

*

E5opqrST

r*$

*

a U

A)@JC5S 2C,-

.

1

>?GREF

B 'V

+

S$=>b

N

/

@l*C45>nsST'ST

a

Rosca

^{5gE?t'>?'uYGf/vw_Š5b}

N

/xST5–

™gžŸ1‹@5U

A)$>

cd‹@yN9LMMN$

*

a

5>

cd@l

*C

I z{Q1:;G:)

$

5|@uYvw<EG‹}Ss

'S

T

a

—~

A)$>@+ISTU'589r"\DvG–

A)@61_

Š T

a 89

r

i

b

τ

^/

@>?

bN

GRE

F

T'ST'5b

τ

^/

@

y τ ⁱ + b N ( − ¹ )

M

[

(`–€

/

@

i −

y t b

⁺

<

J

τ

≠ t

4589r

‹@IL"#'$T

a J

B

CK†L5

( ) ^{( )}

1

τ 1

τ

= ≠

≤ − + + −

∑ ^N _t ⁱ ∑ ^N _t ^{i i}

i t

c y b y b N

^a

(6)

‚

= 1

∑ ^N _t ⁱ

i

y

'$T‹5K†L

(6)

⁵

(2)

^{'3…@$TaABC5—~A)$}

Rosca

@+ISTU'589:;@

G_$

*

kT

a J

B

C589r@'

B C

!"

h$‚%IL"#kT$Nƒ5

Rosca

^{@+ISTU'@ABC89r„}

†TU'@$N$

*

a

1.3

^I%‡kT%&

Rosca

U`5H?‚%

I% ‡kT'J

C

™gJCV5I%‡kT

%

&@

Rosca

^{89: ;@GSkb)MaUU5I%‡}

r

⁺

> 0

4 !"#

kT'ST'5

Rosca

^{@*+J$*%&5}~@'BC}

N

/'G6J

C

K†L5

:

A

)

@;›N

` T

a

( ) ¹ ( ) ¹

1 1 ⁻ 1 1 ⁻

= =

∑ ≤ ∑

+ +

i i

N N

t t

t t

t t

c y

r r

(7)

S$=>5U`5

N

/'@=T89

Rˆ‰Š‹

&M5Dv

Rˆ‰Š‹

&

MG—OTU'$

* '

* )

U'kT

a U

'V5—ŒJ>†‡I

_

`T'5}~

kb)

a

> 

b

,- .

1

N

'ST

a U

'V5

N

/'G

6…

C

K†L5>?GREFT/'@A

B C

<$

B C

T

a

S$=>5

N

/'G

6…

C Dv

Rˆ‰Š ‹

&M5>?GREFT/@ŽxS

T

kT

a

S$ =>5>?Gb

τ

/@REFT'ST'5}~

K†L:

A

)

@$

T

a

( ) ¹ ( ) ¹ ( ) ¹

1 1 ⁻ 1 1 ⁻ 1 ^{τ −}

= =

≤ − +

∑ ∑

+ + +

i i

N N

t t

t t

t t

c y b bN

r r r

(8)

—0

‚5

( ) ¹ ( ) ¹ ( ) ¹ ( ) ¹ ( ) ¹ ( ) ¹

1 1 1 1

1 1 1

1 ⁻ 1 ^{τ −} 1 ⁻ 1 ⁻ 1 ^{τ −} 1 ⁻

= = = =

   

   

+ − = + −

∑  ∑  ∑ ∑  

+   + +   +   + +  

i i

N N N N

t t

t t t t

t t t t

y N y

b b

r r r r r r

'$T‹5>@+IJ$*%&'2

C

N

/'

Rˆ‰Š‹+STM)M5P

‚b

2

^{a‘_@ŽxJC*TasJs5bJ/@>?GREFT}%&5S$=>

τ = 1

'V@5S 2C

1, ,

=

t N

@

[

*C5

( ) ¹ ( ) ¹ ( ) ¹

1 1 1

1 0

1 ^{τ −} − 1 ⁻ = − 1 ⁻ ≥

+ r + r ^t + r ^t

'$T‹5b

2

^a˜

{} ^⋅

^{'$TaREFT/’$T'5b}

²

^aB“

J5

τ = N

%&@5S 2C

1, ,

=

t N

@

[

*C5

( ) ¹ ( ) ¹

1 1

0

1 ⁻ − 1 ⁻ ≤

+ r ^N + r ^t

'$T‹5b

2

^a

{} ^⋅

^”'$Ta

J

B C

5•h@5

N

/'

Dv

Rˆ‰Š‹

&M5>?G

–

REFT

} ~@

[

*C

>@+IJ$*%&A=

s

QV$T5’

REFT} ~@

[

*C—_

$T

a

Random Rosca

%&@5•zh@˜ ,-

.

1

˜/'>?GREFT˜‡

vN kT' ›N`T

a

S$=>5b

τ

^{/ +}

τ = 1, , N

4

REF=˜‡

1/ N

kT

a

U

'V5>@+IST U'@A

B C

N

/'} ~vN`TDv

Rˆ‰Š‹

&M

/™‹5:

A)@;›N`T

a

S$=>5

( ) ¹ ( ) ¹ ( ) ¹ ( ) ¹

1 1 1 1

1 1 1

1 1 1 1

i i

N N N N

t t

t t t

t t t

y y

N r b r ^τ r r

τ = = ⁻ = ^{− −} = ⁻

   

 +  −   =

∑   ∑ + ∑   + +     ∑ +

(9)

'$=5>@+ISTU'@A

B

C5Dv

R

ˆ‰Š‹

&M

/™‹61J$

* U'

@$T

+

1, , τ = N

4

a

JMJU

U'5

Rosca

^{+I>,-.189: ;lAmš}

N

„…@G;›$

* '

*

)U'$

*

a

S$ =>5…›Dv

R

ˆ‰Š‹

>?

GREFT/@ŽxST‹5{œ_`T897s(`@Z…C61STU'@$T

a ()

J89

6;5?@ƒLAB

…›ƒLGTžVGST

kb)

6) 6) 6) 6)

a

˜/

897…›G

6…

C

W

@$T'J

'

V

5

Rosca

^{ƒL8 9@Sƒ}

:

A

)

@$T

a

Rosca

^{$*%&˜/89 75}

( ) ¹ ( ) ¹

1 1

ˆ 1

1 ⁻ 1 ⁻

= =

=

+ +

∑ ^N ∑ ^{N i}

i t

t t

t t

c y

r r

Ÿ 

¡

( )

1 1

1 1

1 1

ˆ 1

1 1

+ −

−

=

 

 +       

=       −   +   ^N          ∑ ^N + ⁱ   

i t

t t

r y

c r r r

'$T

@xJ

C 5

Rosca

^{@+IJ%&˜/897>?GREFT/}

τ

@ŽxJ5

( ) ( ) ( )

1 1

1 1 1

1 1

1 1 1 1

ˆ 1

1 1 1 1

τ

τ + −

− − −

= =

   

 +         

=       −   +   ^N          ∑ ^N + ⁱ + ∑ ^N   + − +     

i t

t t

t t

y

c r b

r r r r r

;›N

` T

a

<

J

(9)

⁺

7

^{4‚'NJ$T‹5}

Rosca

^{@+IJ'V89 7}

/™‹

Rosca

^{$*%&897@NJ$Ta}

S$=>5

1

1 ˆ ^τ ˆ

τ =

∑ ^{N c i} = ^{c i}

N

^¢

U

'V5?@ƒLAB

Jensen

^tN0MN5

( ) ( )

1

ˆ 1 ˆ ^τ

τ =

> ∑ ^N

i i

U c U c

N

'$T‹5

Rosca

^@+IJ%&89 MU…›/™ƒLG£_

Š

TU'@$T

a U

`5–

1.4

^{a™g'3…f¤kTa}

U

A)@

!"

h$‚%@l

*C H?

!¥¤@VT%&@5

Rosca

^I>

,- .

1

ƒLG†‹TU'$

*

a J

B C

H?‚%€kT%&@567

8

9<EG:

)

}~@xJ

C

Rosca

^{yN2 3hOPGsN_5(‹}

Rosca

^@+IJ

A

) '

* )

p-¦-§¨

©…

…

$

*

U'@$T

a

6)

^{ª« ¬­®¯°±²³´µ¡¶·¸¹º»µ¼ ½´µ¾¿¾À}

¢ ÁÂÁ

ÃÄÅƸÇÈ

¬­

ª« ¬

´É

Á

À

²

³´µ

¡

1.1

^{ʸË̲Íδ¡¹ºÏ е¼ ½´¾±}

¢

ÃÄÑÒÓ

Ô

¼½

»¸¹º

­ ÕÖ×

± ØÙ

´µ

¡ Ú

¸¹º»

µ

¡

ÃĹº¸ÇÈÛÜÝ Þ¸Ùß

­

ÃÄàá¸

ÇÈ

ÛÜÝÞ¸Ùß

´

ÉÁâ¾±Ÿã

´ ä

½å

×±

¢

1.4

^,-./01

za5}~态

!"

h$H?‚%D;

I%‡ J!=STU'æVT

%

&

89:;@xST

Rosca

^{ƒ@[*C JCVa a5 çèéêëìíî}

¯

¡

} ~æH?‚% J!=G

:

)

U'æV$*%&

89:;'5

Rosca

^I

æ89: ;@;›T @

[

*C

“”ST

a

1.4.1 N

/'

89:;

U U5

}~ˆ‰

DvGïð@59LGñSTU'$

Ž>òSU'æVT'S

T

a Jæ

B

C5kT/@lET89æ5(

/

DvGOT'V@5ó=æôõ' J

C:/–ö@Ž>òSU'æVT

a U

'V5} ~

i

N

/'

89 MU

+

2

^4†L

M ==@5˜/@l*C:

A)$†Læ÷_`$E`ƒ$N$

*

a

1 1

γ γ

= =

∑ _t ⁱ ≥ ∑ _t ⁱ

t t

y c

^ø

γ = 1, 2, , N

^ù

(10)

—tN0

γ = 1

'V@5bJ/@l

*C

1 ⁱ ≥ 1 ⁱ

y c

'$=589æDvG

—O N$

* U

'5 5

γ = 2

'VbJ/'bc/G6…

C

1 ⁱ + 2 ⁱ ≥ 1 ⁱ + 2 ⁱ

y y c c

'$=5Pú

c/'@=

B C

89

& MæDv

&MG—OT U'æV$

*

U'GûüJ

C*

T

a (

J

C 5

γ = N

'

V

†L

+

2

^{4'3…@$Ta˜89r5U†LŒ +}

10

^{4 5+}

3

^4ƒL

&MGPQ1JA)'ST

a U

P Q1

\ ]

V W

V-

XY,-5

1 ( ) 1 1 1

γ γ

γ γ

λ

= = = =

 

= ∑ + ∑  ∑ − ∑ 

 

N N

i i i i

t t t

t t t

L U c y c (11)

'$T

a

<

J5

λ γ ⁱ

^{†LŒ +}

10

^4b

γ

^{0@xSTVWV-XY[5 kTaU'V5}

W^

Œ

:

A)

@M`T

a

( )

/ 0

γ λ

=

′

∂ ∂ _t ⁱ = _t ⁱ − ∑ ^N _t ⁱ =

t

L c U c

^ý

t = 1, 2, , N

^þ

(12)

—

W^

Œ@l

*C 5

1 , , 1 0

λ ⁱ = = λ N ⁱ ₋ =

'$=5bJ/MNb

− 1 N

/

/'

†L

Œ

+

10

^{4æ5ÿ $ûütN_ˆ‰ST%&5}

( ) ¹ ( ) ^{2 , ,} ( ) ^λ

′ ⁱ = ′ ⁱ = = ′ ⁱ N = N ⁱ

U c U c U c

'$=5

1.2

^{ag'3…@$T +˜/}Dvæ&'''s@B“ST%&@5U

1

'$T4

a

{$

1

'JC5S 2C/'†L0æN_ˆ‰ST%&@5

˜/

89æ(

/

Dv@NJ

$T

a

S$=>5

i = i

t t

c y

^a

⁺

t = 1, 2, , N

4

5}~ævTDvæ5ïð@$T†

$T'V@5U

æM`T

a

U

A)$,-.

/0

1

23@5—ŒJA)$>æI_`T'589r

A)

$GRETkb)M

a

S$ =>5˜,-

.

1

5f/

b

<E

gE?GYh

* 5

*

`M

/@>?GREFTæ5REFT&/V-jk@(

_`T

a

˜/@lET89r

)

a

sJ} ~æb

m

/@l

*C

>?GREFT'ST$Nƒ5b

1

^/MNb

m − 1

/@

[

*

C5U)J

> 

+I@A

B C

gE?

Yh*<E˜/

89@ETU'

VTH

æ“$

$T‹5}~

i

b

γ

/

†LŒ

( )

1 1

γ γ

= =

− ≥

∑ _t ⁱ ∑ _t ⁱ

t t

y b c

⁺

γ = 1, , m − 1

⁴

(13.1)

'$=5

bN

<E

>?GREF

B b

m

/–ö@

[

*C5

( )

1 1

γ γ

= =

− + ≥

∑ _t ⁱ ∑ _t ⁱ

t t

y b bN c γ = m , , N

(13.2)

†LŒæ÷

_

`$E`ƒ$N$

*

a

S$=>5>@+IST'5>?GRE

F T

/'

˜/

PT$89æDv†L@

GRET"#„æQV

$T

@xJ

C 5>?

GRE

F

B

@5()J

†Læ89@

G;›TU'æ“$

$T

a

– 5™gGžŸ1ST‹@5c/'@=Tc~

} ~MN$T>5S$=>

= 2 N

1

@

[

*C

5(G“”ST U'@ST

a

} ~Jæc/'@vTDvæ

( y y 1 , 2 )

k

=5}~cæc/'@vTDvæ

( y y 1 ′ ′ , 2 )

k

=5(``c/'Dv@

[

*C5

1 = 2 ′ > 2 = 1 ′

y y y y

e戉J

C*

T'ST

a

S$=>5} ~J@

[

*C bJ/

Dvæbc/

(`

A

=QV

+ .p

J45} ~c@

[

*C

@$

B C

l=

+ .p

c45qr

c/'G

6 J

C

Dv&MNJ

$

B C*

T'ST

a

(``

c/'Dv5} ~J@

[

*C

J

Y

^5}~c@[*Cc

Y’

^{ ^_`C*Ta}

}~J@

[

*C5bJ/

Dvæbc/

DvA=

s

QV$

B C

l=5('

V c/

'

ƒL

( ) 1 + ( ) 2

U c U c

GP Q1ST895

J

C

^{ ;›N`TaS$=>5bJ/89}

c *

5

( /

Dv

y 1

A=s

—_ 5

1 − * y c

<Eæbc/@Ž>ò

_

`TkT

a W

C5}~c

Dv

c

Y’

^{;›N`Tæ5bJ/Dvæbc/DvA=s“$*‹5bJ/@l}

*C

1 = 1 ′ c y

'$=5} ~J'3…A)@

C

^{89GˆSTU'æV$*a}

UU5>

gE?

b

æ

− * y c

@NJ

*

'ST

7) 7) 7) 7)

a

( '

V

} ~J5>@+ISTU'@A

B C

f/5gE?

b

GYh

)

U'@$Tæ5gE?Yh

*



c/'Dv

•

Z

^

;›N

` T

a

7)

b

y − c *

^!

"#$%&'(

)

^*+,

^*+-

B

C

Y

y 1 ¹

c c 2

y 2

c * c *

Y ′ C

y′ 1 c ¹

c 2

y 2 ′

c * c *

B

^*+.

(U5bJ/@>?Gv/0123

45 67

8

9:;<=>?3

X

^@8ABCDEFGH

IJ

4K

LMN

H O P3

4

2b

^QRH

>?ST

5

62UVW X

G I

2Y

Z [

4

\]=^_ `a

C

^{SbcXEGId8JEFef4T562ghSiRjE0123456789:;<=}

>?3

C

^{@8ABCD4\]=^_ `aSbcXEGId8JEFf/dZ[4KLMNH}

O P2

I

Z [

g2kl

f

=m

Z /01

In o2

4

\]=^_ `a3

C

^@8ABCDEF

^pqr

Z X

Y B

C c 2

y 1 + b

1 *

y − = b c y 1 c ¹

b b

y 2

Z’

X’

Y’

y 2 ′

c 1

y 1 ′ b

b

c 1

b b

B

1 *

y ′ + b = c y 1 ′ − b

C’

s

y

z

~€

z

‰ y



€

’“ˆ”• –—‰˜™šu›

œ‰



€

žŸ ¡˜™



€¢

ˆ

£

Š‹Œ}‚ƒ„…†‡ˆ

¤

¥}

 u

y

Œ¦}§œ



€

¨©

z

”•„ª«

¬­

‰®¯u°±™”• –—‰ ‘’

“

ˆ

£

›

›u‚ƒ„Š

y

Œ}…†‡ˆ¤¥}



u”•–—‰²³´

z

X’

^{µ®¶·¸“u‚‰¹º›}

™



¤¥

z

”•¸

z

žŸ Žš¡»



 ž

}™ˆ

£

››¼½¾}



uŠ‹Œ®‚ƒ„…†‡ˆ¿À¡uŠ

y

Œ®…†‡ˆ¿À¡¨›

¢

1/ 2

®

Áˆ

z

®u‚}Âà Ĉ

¬­

z

ŒÅ ž

 u

( ) ( )

{ 1 2 } { ( 1 ) ( 2 ) }

1 1

2 ′ ′ 2 ′ ′

= + + − + − + +

Rosca

EU U y b U y b U y b U y b

­

™ˆ

£

Ɯu‚}Âۙ



­

¯

z v

wxy

z { |

z

ž

 u

( ) 1 ′ ( ) 2 ′

= +

U U y U y

®¶·¸

“

ˆœÇu‚}Âà Ĉ

¬­

}ŽˆŒÅ ž

z ÈÉÊ

 u

( ) ( )

{ } { ( ) ( ) }

( ) ( )

{ } { ^{( ) ( )} }

1 1 1 1

2 2 2 2

1 2 1 2

 ′ ′ ′ ′ 

− =  + − − − − 

 ′ ′ ′ ′ 

+  + − − − − 

Rosca

EU U U y b U y U y U y b

U y b U y U y U y b

­

˯ÌÄ

¬­

‰ ®¯ˆ

£

¬¬®



u žÍÎ}

~€

u

′′ < 0 U

ę§ÏÐѝ ž‰ÒÓ Ä

ˆ

­ Ô՛

€

ˆœÇuÖ×

z y

~

z

[ ]

^{z؁u­¡}ÙwÚÛ}™ˆ}

^{8) 8) 8) 8)}

^£Ž€u

− < 0

Rosca

EU U

­

™šu‚}ÂÃĈ

¬­

}Ž



€

 ž‰»ÜĈ

¬­

}™ˆ

£

ę§Ïu

¬

«›

œ

Random Rosca

^{uÝzÂÃÞzŒÅ ž¡ßLj¬­™z®Áˆ£¬“uvwxyz{ |}}

Ž



€

u‚}Âà Ĉ

¬­

}Ž



€ y

Œ¦

z àá

z

Èâ‰ã¯

¢

™šu俐å‰æãÄ

ˆœÇ® Áˆ

£

¬

“Æ®

z

‚

z 熃

 uv

wx

‹

z { |}

~ €

uÏè«ÝyŒ¦}é

€

*

c

‰”•

®¯ˆŸ  }ê Ւ

“

€

œ‰u¡›uë

z 熃

b

‰

1 − * y c

Žš¡ã¯

¢

™ˆ™¸ìuvwx‹

z {|}

­

€

¡‚}Âà Ĉ

¬­



uŒÅ ž„Üí

ˆ

¬­

}™ˆ

£

Öî›

€

¯œŽ«}u

Random Rosca

^{uïð›¡ÂÃÞzž„ßLj¬­™¢uñ}

›òà០‰»

¢

™ˆ

­

¯}‚ƒ„…†‡ˆ

¬­

‰®¯ˆ

Bidding Rosca

^zt‰u¹ºó

ô‰Áˆ

­



·ˆ

£

ę§Ïuàቻ



Œ¦}‚ƒ„áˆ

¬­

}Ž

€

u”•

z

Èâ„õ

’

¢ Ĉ

¬­

‰®¯ˆ

z

®Áˆ

£

8)

^ö÷øùú

U y ( 1 ′ + b ) − U y ( ) 1 ′ < U y ( ) 1 ′ − U y ( 1 ′ − b )

^ûü

U y ( 2 ′ + b ) − U y ( ) 2 ′ < U y ( ) 2 ′ − U y ( 2 ′ − b )

^ýþÿû

y

®

z

Rosca

^{z z ž ¬­  ­}

«

 u

z

®



Rosca

^{} ÂĈ¬­}Ž€áˆ‚ƒ‰uz”•zœÇ}

}ž



¸“ˆ

­

›

œ

¤¥}“œ

£

‚ƒ‰

z

à u

s

¾}

ï

­

’“ˆ•

z

œÇ}ž



¸

“

ˆ¤¥‰ Áˆ‰uë“}

~ €z

}

~ € 

uخ Ĉ

£

1.5

^í

Rosca

½Ø®

 v

}醈

Rosca

^{Ãz}~  €›œ‰u}

Rosca

^}Ž

€

¡œ¸’“œ‚ƒ‰u”•

z

Ž«}

s

¾}

z

•‰!«‰u"Œ}§œ

€

#ž®¯ˆ

z Ã

z

œÇ}ž



¸“ˆ

¬­

‰



­



«

¬­



uÄ®}$%›

€

¯œ

£

Ø®



uv

}é

€

뫛œÃ„ª«

­

¯u

Rosca

^zÉÝzŽ

«™ ¾™

ó&„¡

~

„'(™

„ž

 €

›

€

)Ž«

£

½ØÆ®

z

­

˜™šu{ |



N

Œ¦„*

€

z

”•„ª«

­­

¡}u ”•

„Ûu듍¸¡ ž„áˆ

¬­

‰®¯ˆ

­ Ĉ

£

”•



‹(+,†Ã›u

ۜ



Š

N

ŒÆ®-ž./®Áˆ

­ Ĉ

£

¬z­

¯0Œ}{|

i

‰1…Ĉž

Ÿ 

 u

z

Ž«}”•

i

X t

^­

z

”•

i

c t

^z

ÍÎ

­

›

€ ̒

“

ˆ

£

( ^{t i , t i} )

V = v X c t = 1, , N

œ,›u

i

X t

^

‹Æœ

 23

z 4„

­

šuý}



X _t ⁱ = 0

®Ášuà 5}

~ €

i 1 X t =

^­

™ˆ

£

z

”•¡”•¡

­

¡} ž„ßLj„¡

~

­ Ĉ

£

ę§Ïu

( ^{t i , t i} ) ^{/ t i 0}

v X c c

∂ ∂ >

⁶⁷

^v ( ^{1, c t i} ) ( ^{> v 0, c t i} ) (14)

‰89›

€

ˆ

£

z

Ã:;



B

®Ášuë“



N

Œ¦„*

€

<Œ

b

,†

z

=ƒ

„

>?Ĉ

­

¯uÏè«Ý„: ;uę§Ï

B = bN

®Áˆ

­ Ĉ

£ v

®



Ã

z

ς}

=ƒ

„@šÃ“ˆ

¬­

‰®¯™



œÇuÃ

z

ς}



<

Œu=ƒ„>?›™†“외™



£ { |

i

‰Š

t

Œ}

i

y t

,†

z

àá„á

€ é

šu<Œ

b

,†

„Ã

z

œÇ}>?Ĉ™¸ìuŠ

N

Œ} ”•¸¡ ž„áˆ

¬­

‰®¯ˆ

£

¬z­

¯uA

z

N

Œ¦®1… Ĉž

z

¥ –

 u

z

Ž«}¶·¸“ˆ

£

( ) ( )

1 1

0, 1,

N i i

t N

t

U ⁻ v y b v y b

=

= ∑ − + − (15)

ę§ÏuŠ‹Œ¸Š

N − 1

ŒÆ®



”•„#ž®¯ðu¸

z

BC„1…®

¯ˆ

z



Š

N

Œ,†®Áˆ

£

¬

«›œ }é

€

u½ØÆ®}D›

€

¯œ

Random Rosca

^{„Ã Ĉ­u‚}ÂÃ}

›œEF

G

z

 žŸ 

 Ý

z

Ž«}™ˆ

z

®Áò«

£

¬z

‚}é

€  u

N

|

z EF

G

‰<Œ

b

^z

熃„H I



uJǸ“œç†ƒ



‚ƒ

­

›

€K

FLM}EF

G

z

‹|}

HI§“ˆ

£

‚ƒ„…†‡



œEF

G

 uë

z

Œ}„à Ĉ

¬­

‰ ®¯ˆ

£

›œ

‰

€

uŠ

τ

^N

≤ N − ¹

^O

Œ}é

 €

‚ƒ„…†‡



œ{|

i

^z

N

Œ¦

z

 ž

z

¥–

 u

( ) ( )

1 1

0, _t ^{i N} 1, _t ⁱ

t t

U ^{τ τ} v y b v y b

τ

−

= =

= ∑ − + ∑ − (16)

£

¬ z­¯

z

­

z z ë“

­ ­

z

R



(15)

^­

(16)

^¸u

( ) ( )

{ }

1

1, 0,

N i i

t t

t

U ^τ U v y b v y b

τ

−

=

− = ∑ − − − (17)

­

™ˆ

£ Ö×

z ST

z

{ }

^

⁽¹⁴⁾

^{ŽšU­™ˆœÇu}

^{U τ > U}

^­™ˆ

^{9) 9) 9) 9)}

^£

Ɯu°5}‚ƒ„…†‡ˆEF

G

 u

τ = N

^­

™ˆœÇu

ëz­¯z

 ž¥–



v

z

¤¥

­ V*

}™ˆ

£

ę§Ïu

Random Rosca

^{}Âà Ĉ¬­}Ž€uEFG}



¼5¾}



žŸ „ßLj

¬­

‰®¯ uW

¢€

¡Âۙ



¤¥

­ V*

}™ˆ

£ Ý

z

Œ

}‚ƒ„…†‡ˆ‰

K

FLM}êՒ“ˆ

­ Ĉ

­

u‚}ÂÃĈ½}XY’“ˆ¿À



s

Z®Ášu

1/ N

®Áˆ

£

ëz­¯z

¼½¾™ŒÅž

 u

1

1 ^N N U

τ τ =

∑

®¶·¸“ˆ‰u

¬

“

 [

\u

v

z¤¥Žš¡ß

¢

™



€

ˆ

£

ę§Ïu

”•„ÃĈœÇz=ƒ„]^Ĉ_¤‰¹º›™



v

}é

€

u

Rosca

^{ë«›œä`a å„bʾ}c`Ĉ¬­}™ˆ£dÖzŽ«}uÃzœ}

Çz

Ž«™

z

H„!«äef™Hz¤¥}



u½ØÆ®zD

­

˜™šu

Rosca

^

¾}góô™¡

z }™ˆ

£

}é

€

u

Rosca

^{z ¾óô„ÊhĈœÇzXa¾i j„ª€¯œ£¬“Æ}

®z

”•ÞªâéŽ

k

Rosca

^{zlmu'(™®­¸·¸“œnо™¡z®Áœ£}

o}



uŽš¥ p¾™ ªâ‰½q

­

’

“

ˆ

r¯®Á

šu

¬

“Æ®zst®



uŽšu

v™

®

Rosca

^{‰’“€¯œ£®u¬“Æ®ª§“€¯œë«›œÊh„w}

xwĈ

£

2. Rosca

^zp¾stzyz

®



u½zXa¾i j„¡

­ }›

€ u

¬

“Æ®z

Rosca

^{}͛€ª§“€¯œp}

¾

stz

¢~

„yz›u

Rosca

^{z¡~ ¾~{ |¾ó&¥„ijĈ£}

2.1

^vu­}~¾™

Rosca

^Œ¦

Öî

z­é

š u

Besley, Coate and Loury

^N

1993

^ONdÜu

’Besley et al

^N

1993

^OO

Rosca

}Í

Ĉ

p ¾

Êh

z

€

­



·ˆst®Áš u

¬

“}

f

¢

pst}¶·

œ‚

 ã

¯



£

9

^{ƒ „„…†‡ˆ‰Š‹ŒŽ‘’“”†•–—˜‰…™š›œžŸŒ} 

Besley et al

^¡

1993

^{ƒ¢£¤… †‡¥¦ž§¨Š©ª«’}¬ ­˜™š®¯°¥±

žŸ²³˜…

´µ

‡

—

„

…˜

Rosca

^†

1.5

^{¶·²¸¹Šº»¼˜½¾¿ÀÁÂÃÄÅÆÇ ÈÉÊËÄÌ}

ÍÎ

Ç ÏÐÑ

Ò

É

Rosca

^{ÆÓÔÕÖ×ØÙÁÚÛÜÑÒÉÂÃÝÞßÌàáÇÆÌÍÒâã}

äÆ

åæçèÕÖÚé

Ã

ê ÂÃ

Ý

ëÙÁÚìíî

ÒÄï ð

ñ òßÅ

Ì ó

ôÁõÅÆÂõ ö

Ý

êÉ

Ê

þ

û

øü !

y

^"

> 0

^#$

!ý

N

^%

ø&

%

'ø()

"

T

^#

*ý

+ ,

$

- ./012ûý

&

%

^{v X c} ( ^, )

^{ø+ ,34$5)6789:}

^c

^{$;<ý "* =0}

^{c ≥ 0}

^#

>*

X

89:?ø@A

$ B0

X = 1

^øûC

&

%

89: D?@A

$ EF

ý

G

X = 0

øûC

89:?ø@A

$

FHü6

ø+ ,34

789 ;<:ø;<

I 6

JKLM?

IN

O

PQRST ýû06ý

>*

89:

I 6

"

14

^#ûUV

( ) ^{1, −} ( ^0, ) ^{≡ ∆} ( ) ^{> 0}

v c v c v c

ûü

789:;<GUW

ý?X

89:

$

D0*YZø+ ,

÷2ü6Y

Z1

5

JKü[\.C]ü ^6ý

_

7 89:G

5

*`Mü+ ,

I 6

5 89:

$

Dý

û1^ab0ü6 ü

( ) ⁰

v c ′

∆ ≥

^{ûüý ü89}

:û789:

c d

ýû06ý >*

efg

hih

α

^j

⁰ ≤ α ≤ ¹

^k$

89:

$

Dýlmûýû

89: D3ý)n+,

( ^, ) ( ) ( ^{1, 1} ) ( ^0, )

v α c ≡ α v c + − α v c

û

o

_

ý ÷

α = 1

øûC

^v ( ) ^{1, c}

^{α = 0}

^øûC

^v ( ^{0, c} )

^ûüý

2.1.1

^{pqi rhstø89:uv}

pq i

r

h

6

&

% G

y − c

=Høwx

$ y6

÷ø

wxøz{G

t

B

ø

|}ø89:uv~Rüüýû

ýû

(+,

( ^0, ) ( ) ( ^1, )

W = ⋅ t v c + T − t ⋅ v y

'€ý 0*G^

ø(+ ,

$ - ./

012ûý

&

%

ø12

ü- ./

‚

$

ƒ

]

û

üý

ü

( ) ( ) ( )

( )

,

0, 1,

max

. . , 0

c t

t v c T t v y s t t y c B c y

 ⋅ + − ⋅ 

 

− = ≤ ≤

(18.1)

ø„

3

4

…†‡

$

ˆvýû

( ) ( ^1, ) ( ^0, )

1, v y v c

T v y B

y c

 − 

⋅ −  

 −  (18.2)

ûüý

‰Š

‹G

4ûüý*Œ

(+ ,

$

- ./

ý

û

‰

‹øŽ





‘

$ - ’

/ý12

;<“

c

^$

”

ý

ûý øûCø

• ø–—

˜ø12

'€