• 検索結果がありません。

米国都市学区における相補的アカウンタビリティ・システム / 「学校風土」開発を鍵とする指導助言行政の新展開

N/A
N/A
Protected

Academic year: 2021

シェア "米国都市学区における相補的アカウンタビリティ・システム / 「学校風土」開発を鍵とする指導助言行政の新展開"

Copied!
12
0
0

読み込み中.... (全文を見る)

全文

(1)

!"#$%&'()*+,-./01234567895:;

!"#$%&'()*+,-./01234567(!8 8 9:8 ;<8 ! !"# 8 =>?@ABCDEFGHIJKLMNOPQR#S5"#$%&'()*+,-.TUV W*,XYZA"[\]^N_N`Ia'bcPd*efghijkl,#$,5"mnopH qRcr^FGs`bFt'*uv-.wx,yz{*|}fg~=>?€‚fgƒ„@A …†hijkl@A"#‡ˆ‰Še‹"#$%&'†Œ†'*#$5hiŽ‘*’“-.” Nd,f•–—-.˜,‚™XAš›œsž,Ÿ -.h¡k5¢£{()*0¤•¥XA ¦†#$,hijkl*^§¨R-."©ª`^FNcN'«A¬­5®¯*°±²«€o³² /012*3´²?Aµ†#$5¯²€¶hijkl·¸g#‡-.¹º,f•)»f•¤¼ 6f¤/012bcPd«uv½¾•¤.~˜¾€5¿‚A!"#$%&'()*+,-./0 123456789:0;<=>?@A@BCD0E2FGHI1JKL„Àfg~8 8 ÁNÂNÃÄ#$%&AmnopHqRcr^FGA[\]^N_N`IaAŸ A8 ÅÆhijkl8 8 $%&'()# BC?@A¦ÇDž È5ÉÊËÊhiÌT͊ÎÏ8ÐÑÒÓÔ8ÕÖר8ÙÖÑÒÚÔ8ÛÜØ8Ï×8¦ÇDžAÝÞ"ßà áâÌ',ã-†ÝäA#åFbJæ¿çè‚é¿êfgAëì²KpHqRcr^FGs` bFt5uv«í•±g~ï5²?@A,XðñAÅÆ#S‚¥ñ.òósôPõ^ F Gö÷ 5 < ø·* ù ¼ úû. # $ «AK ü ýF bJ æ ¿, Èþ ÿŠ ÛÔր‚ØÖ8 ƒÖ‚„Ó…8 †„χ„Öˆˆ†5»‰Š‹€"TŒ«Ž',5*‘ñA’“o²”•–—*‘ñ.V˜‚ ²™•±g~˜´fgFbJæ¿çèš5é¿ê,•›œ!@AVŽ!A#$¬­*FbJ" #‚$¤%¯A&hi'o(H^ÁM)t*+5,-êA.FbJ/'Ý05h/(12o² 34–5567A8<ø·*9îg#$5:u‰k5#$š5;<=5>ÞA?@A‚v¤• ±gpHqRcr^FGs`bFt,B—(C«DXE½¾.²ø5FG«²½¾•±g!"~8 ˜˜‚@AHI8§dJpŠHÒÜт„Ô8KI8LÓMτֆ«/N-.™´‚Aßàáâ̂™."bc R_NÂÿO¼TU'5>P«AQR5"dNbsHIa^RS'P>‚ÿO¼ÿ=oTU *DXE-,¤´•=uV!5WX«Y.~§dJp‚™¾YA"bcR_NÂÿO¼TU' ?@A&hZ–55"¢£[\oË]'š5^y_{,¤´"dNbsHIa^RS'P>5 ÿ=oTU*DXEfA"4#«#$5Z`5Ë]¸?ab‚c»'f•¤.~.dRAhZ– 55"¢£[\oË]'‚¥ñ.ef{(^³Ž{*A0g5|h(ij€š›-.gî‚ kkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkk 㧙㧙

(2)

!"#$%&'() ********* +,-./01234!"56789:;<=>;?@<ABCD>D=BE5./0F1 2G,H+()IJKLMNOPQR)S+TUV+5WXYZ[\]^_`aJbcd%e fG,HZgh367!"ijk5lmnQof)p+%qrstG,):uNvwmxE!"I? p-2Gyz5./%{M|0}HZ~3€‚K~_ƒL~„…),†€‡Lˆ[‰Š~ L‰Š‹]^~„+,-ŒŽYZnF‘’“,W2%”gtG,)Ip5N3•–3€— P 0 … ˜ G , ) U ™ a ‚ ‹ ‚ „ † 3€  ‚ K + _ ƒ L % š › Q œ p ) a ‚ ‹ ‚  ‰ Š :žŸ ¡;¢>DB<¡ž?;<<žB£¢Ÿ@¤¢?;B>¥BCž¤Ÿ¦E„§¨0©m2G,)p+%qrstG,)#"I? ? p5R-Z!"#$5ª’Z«¬­®0¯°()±3²§[%/œ()€³|0´µ)’ µ5[\]^_`aJb5¶·¸„:CB=Ÿ¦C<=Ÿ¢¹?<º?>==<¡D¢>»Ÿ;Ÿ¢¹?º<C?=>¦>=Ÿ¢¹E5¼9$" †½mZ¾¿0À2G,)I(ZÁÂ3!"#$ÃÄÅ+UVÆ!Åj+5cdQÇ,G3È 7É5ÊË/À†ZH3Ì7É5€Ǘ0ÎQ€³|:=>¦>=Ÿ¢¹E„0€ÏÐY„QÑÒ2 …-[\]^_`aJb5ÓÔ…)IsgQ²§[†3p5ÓÔ0ÕÖ()×3€ØÙÚ a‚‹‚‰Š:¥Ÿž¢CŸ»¡¢B¥?;B>¥BCž¤Ÿ¦E„§¨5½m¸0/œ2G,)%"Ip5€a‚‹ ‚‰Š5ØÙ„+,-[ƒ¨[†3ÕÖ5ÛÜ~g†€Ý½Úa‚‹‚‰Š:ž¤>CB¥? ;B>¥BCž¤Ÿ¦E„+,-mÞ+šßQm,gtG,)I’+àh3áâ?ãâ?ä‚å:᤟C;B¹?ãâ?æ<C¥E g†3€ÃÄÅ5UÍçèéêJb„ëì5Êí+2G3€îïYݽÚa‚‹‚‰Š :ž¡¦¦<C¢ŸAB?>D¥?ž¤>CB¥?;B>¥BCž¤Ÿ¦E„0ð˜3€ØÙÚa‚‹‚‰Š„9n0!ñQ2’ ò‚óô‰Šõ0/ö2G,)&"I' ? p-2’÷ø0ù‘àZ%g3úû†3üýçþJb\‰LSêé‚ÿƒ^U™:€B?æ>ABDE 5‚ƒ„õ0…†Ž‡+2G3!"ijk+UV+5€¶·Y[\]^_`aJbƝKJˆ„ 5ˆß+‰³¸0Šg~Q()p+0‹Y+()IŒŽ†35+Ǒ…)I’“Q3 S5[\]^_`aJb$”+5•–0—‘3,~Z)U™˜™5[\]^_`aJbƝK Jˆ%ëìstG,)5~IU™˜™Qëìst’€U͚›:á=¤<<;?œB>CDŸD@?!DAŸC<D BD¢E •!„:o"€UV#$:á=¤<<;?%;Ÿ >¢BE•!„3&'€UV#$•!„EQ(‹2G3)5Õ *+,0…†()I’-Q3úU™QÇ.)€a‚‹‚‰Š5ݽ:ؽE„†/5R-Q0 12stG,)5~3)5Õ3045()I’6Q3U™785€¶·Y„Z€U͚›„0 µ9(ª’Zq:;<#$5ˆß+‰³¸0=)IZÇ3…†ñ>+2G3Û?ŒQ@àG3 êé‚ÿƒ^U™cdxA5ƒ^_`邯¨‚_+/BC>:DEFF GHI3DEFD GJIK “L°•!EÇRMNO•!QR)’ȐC>0m,)p+Q()("I?

?

!"#$%&'()*+,-./0123456789: ;<=#$%&'()*+7>?@AB:

êé‚ÿƒ^U™PUV5eQR† FSTUVW X:DEEY GZE3X[Æ\]^Ó_†3`X aFâbc3dKeê‰óf Wbâbc3gX FDâac3[h[f)5i FâYc+jgX%Hk&×0l µG,)ImneQ:o£FY pE5qrs† Dbâbc+JXQ“X%qrt&'5euvwQÇ

(3)

!"#$%&'()*+,--./0123456789:;"%<=>?2@A$BCDEFGHIJ 8KLMNO#$%0PGQRSTU:AM#VWXYZG[\]^_`%aAbcX%0+ de8Vfg8h% ij klV123GDEmn]opS>qrS8st#XCGuVvwx yz+{|+}~x&€‚ƒ+„|+(…‚†V‡wxˆW2/G‰2Š‹ŒŽy&*‘’……“+”‚•‚“…–‚—˜+ „†…™†€Vš›‰}~x>ŽyœA`žœ!"cŸ%0}~xA‡wxˆW2G ¡uV ‰2Š¢£&*‘’……“+(“¤€˜‚/œG‹Œ]¥¦§¨JAM#2ŠGqr‹Œ8©@M#XC0+ + dªGU:uV«.¬j k!­‰}~x>Žyœ]®8V‡wxˆW2>23DE¯°±> ²³7´Gµ ¶·8¸%DEmnb¹‹;"#XC\8Ÿ%0U8V¥ºG ,- kl8»%¼ x½xDE³&¾‚™¤—€“¿+¾|+À€Á…Â+«..,Ã,-«Ä k/AÅÆÇÈÉÊ6³&…’—+”‚*˜‚Ë€—…+†|Â+ «..ÄÃ,-«Ä k/Gµ ¶·8¸%DEGHÌÍÎÏuVÐYÑÒ!­4ÓÔ;"#$%#"0+ d[GU:AM#VÕÖxׇØÙ23ÚÛ2Š8Ü$#uV‡wxˆW2b‹ŒMC‰2 Š¢£ÝÞ&*‘’……“+(“¤€˜‚+*߆•‚Á/œbVij kl8»àVá2ŠGâãäå^æAM#ç$ ­"#XC\8Ÿ%0‡wxˆW2‰2Š¢£ÝޜGåèS^æuV2ŠéêëGìíîí ]ï#TÜVéêëlGµðñòAM#V23ѶG‰¢£œ]óôM#XCïõbŸ%0+ !"#$%&'()*+,-./012345062789::;2<946=0 +,-.2 2 ¼x½xDE³AÅÆÇÈÉÊ6³Gµ ¶·8Ü$#V,--. kö!­V23DE¯°±uV ‰'‚÷+ø€•‚—+*‘’……“+(’€—™‚œAJMCùCT‡ÕúûüØ]‹ýMC0¼x½xDE³8¸" þV‰ÿG¥€¨JuV‚ƒ4GaA]de€8V`„#GÆÇx…†ˆ‡xbˆ‰àŠ ‹MVµ8IJŒMVµŽx‡xú‘&*’€†‚¿+ ’‚€¿‚†ƒ’¤–ž+ “ňc‹YaAcŸ %œA”„#$%&¼x½xDE³•ûÙV,-«« k–— «˜ g/0!"#"DE³G$‰ x‡xú‘]µŽ`%œqr8€O#VÅÆÇÈÉÊ6³uVùDE³‚AM#!!Æ &"€†˜’+ø€††¤‚ƒ/]ÕÖx½x…6¸à#$MVDE³‚ª%¶·]ÎtC0aM#ª% GDE³‚G‰µŽx‡xú‘œ¶·8¸àVZGª&GŽvw…'bÛ(F)­ "C0*!!ÆDE³‚b+,`%‰23Ѷ-x‡xú‘>üxy±.œG‹/AV ‰2Š¢£ÝޜGq0cŸ%01š2!­GDE³‚b+,`%V‡wxˆW2AGŠ‹ 8¸%DEqr345G67S89s:cŸ%023ÚÛ;<=ŠG(VU8<=>~‡Ê Ç>?@G‚ƒ4]ABC`% «- ŠbV‡wxˆW2Gkl]ðDCEÙFˆGÙ']H OTb­V‰}~x>Žyœ]IçMCqr8JàKLc$%0+ ;­8V4e%V¦§T%MNObT;"C0¼x½xDE³uV}~x­&‡wxˆW 2/AGŠP8¸àV‰23ÈÉúÇxGxœA$QR]ùSMV}~x­bTU`%VÇ ÙDWe%]XYMC0aG‰23ÈÉúÇxGxœbV2”MCª&GŽvw…'G qr]&TZ&[\S]^/VDR°G67_‹Œ]`a`%Qb]cB#$%0+ ! ! ! 㧙㧙

(4)

!"#$%&'()*+,-./0123456789:;<=

>?@AB/CDEF6GHIJKL456789:;<MNO-P&'=

!"#$%&'()*+,-./0123456789:;<=>?@ABC/DE0FGGH IJKL()MN6O(PQRSTUO(VWXYZ[\YS]^O(VWX[\YC_`Za bcd0?@6ABaefdghi[\/0O(VWX6jk6glE0(Vmn"!:o`p q6r's#6tuvwaxy`zglE{|%'}~qzYC}~0O()A€(V6`p q60*‚0*ƒ-0„…S†‡ˆF (IZYE0i[\‰6Š‹ŒŽ}~qz!"#

[\S‘’“”„…0•V„…00*‚0ƒ-6†–—Z/0O†˜6™š›YaœTš ›Cdq0~ž~6Ÿ ¡¢Œ£¤}~qzhO†˜6™š›Y/0O*+‰6¥¦YOmn "!§#¨©'YOª«YO¬­S®¯°±°²³²¯´ZYOµ¶C·¸Y¹ºzh

»¼0½6()*+,-.O(VWX[\Y/0¾¿dgO%À#ÁÂ(6(VWX[\Y aÃÄÅÆ#;CdqyÇdgÈÉÊËÌC}~zS%À#ÁÂ( ÍÎÏÎÐÑ'ÒSÍÎÏή³³Ó¯ÔZ ÕÖ×'Ø0FGˆF IÙچÛZhdgŒÜq0%À#ÁÂ(ÝC()*+,-.Ý6ޘ6O( VWX[\Y¹/0ßàC»zÃÄábâE¼qœT`zš›ŒãË}~qzh >Q@6GHIJKL56789:;<4RSTUMV-WX%YZ= Ÿ ¡¢E/0ä6åæ»çèŒéê~qzhëìE0íîïaélg`pq6;:#ð ñÁò#EåzOmn"!§#¨©'YOª«YO¬­YaTdgóôõÇC0O*+‰6¥¦Y ŒºzOµ¶C·¸YEö÷g(PQRøùuŒúû}~qzh½6ÃÄžüE/0:; <=>ýþ6wŒÿ#Á¹/»ù0€6(‚Sƒ„Å…†‡6+¤ZŒºzh ëÞE0O†˜6™š›YKL»zŸ ¡¢E/0()¶ˆ¹¢š`‰Š©'á‹ýŒC6 Žš›Œlê~qzh[\‰6Š‹aTdq0œT‘’6eÉET“qzh ë”E0(V6v•ÅeÉ6–vwŒ—ˆÅEŸ ¡¢E˜}~qzh6’™E/0í îï6š›Åɜal!`!K»(PQRøùuŒ"#dqzhCu$%†˜6š›6’¹ ï0Oª«SÍÓ&&±'Ó(±´)Ó¯ZY6š›Œ¸*}~0OœE«ù½CS+Ó(,)¯°´Ó°²´-²(ZYCæ ./Œ0[}~qz!!#h½ædq0`pq6;:#ðñÁò#S“”„…00*ƒ-ZŒ

¢Åaœ1dqœE«ùgl6(V6v•ç2Œü3}~qzh $

>!@6GHIJKL56789:;<4RSTUMV-674[\%]^4_`=

*‚‰6Ÿ S¶ 45 ¡¢Z¹/0†˜6™š›E6`zO¶7ÅWXYa89zŸ C0 (V6v•Å:2;ObâYŒ"#`zKa89zŸ ¹£¤}~qzh½6’¹0(V6 v•Å:2a˜dqz6Œ0Oª«YE6`zŸ SF< ¡¢Z¹ºzh6=>/0?O(V E¼%z×#ò#¨@AbâYSˆB ¡¢Z0COxyaD%qzKYS”¡¢Z0EOFGƒm n"!:oYSˆG ¡¢ZKL£¤}~qzh

]þ6HŸ ¡¢aIJdg?@!%#0i()¹l!}~z(V6v•Å:2aä6”>Eç

K¹Lzh?OVMaéNOÃP#QYSVM9šŒ0×#ò#¨@AaÉR`zÑ{Á¹ /»ZEåzOœ1S×#ò#¨@AYbâEåu0C*ƒ-6OFGƒ(Pmn"!:oY

(5)

!"#$%&'()*+,-*./-#01234567#!"2389:;3<= = !"#$%#&'()*+,-./01 23456789:;<=>[email protected] >?@AB&CDEFG&4HIJKLM)NOPQRSGT&U45V)DWXYZ[\ ]^_@A`abcdeTf3!"#<g>?#hijT%klmnoIJpqrB&>?@AG sfT&CD&4Htu)*vwE-)xyz&U45){|6}~#€jTf3!$#<2 ‚ƒ„&…U45G†‡3*vwE-)xyGhˆ#‰%&Š>?0‹z@Abc)ŒŽo #&IJKLMz45ILz)vw‘’‚“”N•–—m˜™š›o˜œzjTždŸ  ¡zjTf3<'*¢£@A-)w¤¥¦u’‚§¨)©ªB&U45)*«¬­®œ-G 3m®¯®›°Œ0±G²³deTf3<´¡jT&µ¶’‚·™®¸¹°º#»¼jT f3½:&¾¿G&À˜oS0‹š@AbczB&Á)’zwÃaĂÅTf3<= ´)½&ƮǮIJpB&*_/zB&Èf45É#Êz¡´z:B‚f<ÁeBËÌ)4 5)Í}zÎ}GÏÐfT&Í}#ÑÒ2kÓG,ÔÕÖa;3<´e#×ÌB&Ø®S·Ù mښ“Œ®­zÛÜ-zjT&Á)ÝÞGB&*IL^ß)àáâã)ä»zåæaÏç :;3-´z#&IJpBÍ>jTf3[ƮǮIJpè“m•é&êëìì Díî ìï ð`<I JKLMB&À˜oS@Aã)ñòÖó#ô¶’Gõ2):B‚Ô&U45ö÷ø#n•ùú ®23´zGhˆ#‰%&4û’ö÷â#"üdŸ3ýþ#ÿfTf3½:ÂG€23<= 2K4#$LM9:;<NDOPQRST#UVWXYZC.[\1 ®–#€fk4Htu)‚#ƒ„23kÓG…4HIJKLMB&>?†DE êëë‡ DE ҈&W)hւ‰s)ú®Š•éšé‹®Œ#Œ„yk<= 34#&'(%)*]^_+.`a1 lmnoIJpqra67!23*>?KLM-B&4Htu҈)«¬"c&IL" c&("c:#‘deTf3<*>?KLM-G |&CD&>?)$%&'&0‹&@A)· ™®¸¹°º);|Òk#(ÓkWDEã)ñòa)*deTf3<g>?0‹š+€,-) ñò#Ó!3*>?KLM-G†‡3‚G†fT!>?@A®–#€fT&UKLaÁe "e)Œ#[«¬&IL&(`҈)"cøzjT$®%#KLM)‚ãz&'dŸT f3<Âde3½B&lmnoIJpqrz()KLz)ö÷âG†fT&*S°Œ¯N•[4 HIJKLM`z)Sœš“°Œ[U45`)*+,$-®›.•š_/š0±-!%#a¦1! jTf3´z:;3<IJpqr/ˆ!Á)012‹#0±j&UKLB*3k„)>?-zf¡Ú®4®›°Œ56#!ÅT{|67:f3[KLè“m•é&êëì8 D9î êë ð`<= K4%#$LMbcDdDeGfghDi+_j.[k1 45ã)(ö:B&;|*”<®šŒé=œ-)ùR°SšŒ>OºS?†[ì‡@A D` ҈&z|ƒ‡&BC*+,$˜™)45GzÅT)D»ÖEF:;Åk<GW)IJñHG †fTB&êëë‡ D ìë îG&ƮǮIJp&lmnoIJpqr&o˜·IJKp)9C 㧙㧙

(6)

!"#$%&'()*+,-$./01234056789:+;!"#<=>6?@(,ABC DEF9:,GHIJ$K"#LM-N2O2PQRST2UVWXYZ[\X]^_`ab^cY_d^a]^befXg_ h^ai,jkKlmnopqpEr$78(st:uv<=$Er(w,"#L xy zV{S|S}q $-~!€‚>,ƒ„…†>…‡ˆ ‰yy Š‹Œ!Ž(E9:uv<Ew,‘4’2 “2”•$–—˜™V"#š›œ0.2(vžŸq, ¡¢S•£¤0¡¢$ž¥¦—,•£ ¤0¡$§¨“2”•,©ª“2”•$«¬­„,®¯°S®±²6³´9,µ¶$·¸6¹ º»vž¼!½¾(­‚>:uv<=$Er6¿ÀSÁÂ9:uv$!,"#$-~ʐ Äł>vKÆÇÈ0OÉÊEpËvVÌy‰Ì ÍÎBÏÐEr,Ñ42ÒÓÔ2Õq<! Öw,KÆÇÈ0OÉÊEp(×ØÅ‚>;KlmnoEr$ÆÇÈ0OpVÙÚq6¨ )9;…$Ëv<ÆÇÈ0O$ÛÜ(w, Ý$Þ­1QPß0!à‚>:uv<_ Klmno$1QPß0w,-F"#᪠ÉÊEF$â2ã’2PQR(äu:-6å 0âæ29çè»v=F(×,ƒ„…Fé ê$ëì(íCî­ïð6ñòv=F»< "zF$×uó1ôõö2Pß0F÷ø 6ùÙ9,ëú$"ûS"ü$*ýFÅþ6 ÿ$€F9:u‚»<pVkƒ„…†‡q_ =Þ9;1QPß0$…F,Ö$Þ(, ˆÐ$Erw,E‰¥IJK7E$Š‹p, KŒ˜™pFŽES$†6,KÆÇÈ0 OÉÊEpÉÊ(vK‘’“N2O2PQRp ”7‚>:uv<•9:,Er$–w,K— ˜pIJ$K"#љPN32.2pVš›œ Vœq·!q!!"»v-$æ2#PßQR Ëv<‚$,32%Ò&F(·¸‡'$()*+69;ý,LM$—,(-v<—,$ w,áª./0…š():,"#љPN32.2FF…(,%"z$-N2O2IJ$( )61+2×,áªÉÊEF-„Þ9$3Qãæ2#4Œ×(569:uv<_ =Þ9:,áª.,áª./0ä7"#-~!,µ8S9ê²$:;6<ò:,=>3 2%Ґ‘4’26?9@­!JAŒ9,ƒ„…$"ûBC$DE(*F:,AG­KHI6 ‘’p»vK"#LM$JKp!D×)‚>:uvVÌy‰Ì ÍÎBÏÐEr,Ñ42ÒÓÔ2Õq<_ _ !"#$%&'()*+,-)./012344567389:; <=>?@A)*+,BC06

LMfNNO_WfacP^ ¤õPÆT%w,Q2R2áª.F‘•3љÔS.$ Ìy‰T ÍIUVW( vXIY…,ZNå•[áª.Vš,áª./0qF[S.M\(]^‚>,§_`Ía€( !"# DEFG$%&'()*+# !"#$%&'(')*+,-'./ !"#! ! $ " % #$ %&'"()*+ %&'((+ ,-./+01/223+ 0123(/ 45! 6789:/ )*+,-./0123456#2789:;+ )<=>=?@A/?@ABC2<DE=F;+ + ;5! <=>?8@A/ )*+,-./GHIJK=LM2NO;+ )*+,-./*%P2NO;+ )QRST?@AUV/WHXYZ[\]^_`a;+ + B5! CDE8%FGHIJKLMN!OP>QBR ST/ )bHXBC2c=def+ )HX2c=def/"ghig%Pg*2j=klmDn;+ )7o! ! 4$ pqrst!u2vwxgty2*z={2|}x~€‚ ƒq‚^g„…†`ƒ‡5ˆ‰ŠƒB+ 5$ *‹Œ2Ž‘’“”Œs„2•…–2ˆ—ƒB/h ig%Pgj=klmDn;+ + U5! MNVWJ8!EXYKZ[\]>^/ "GHIJK=2vw/ )pqr2HX^˜™ƒ*‹Œ2q‚2KšcK/ )›œ2%P6!"#! ! % " ' #+ ! HžŸ*R= =lDnz={KFJ¡ -.%<¡¢=£¤+ 㧙㧙

(7)

!"#$$%&'()*+,%-./0"123456789:;"<=>?@A"BA&7 CDEFGHIJ&KLMN&OP8QRS0"$S%T"#UVWX"YZ!3[H4\] ^_`VY"]B!ab23^_+,cdeSfgh^eihjVkl"<mnop!fqp rsMN&t?Yuvwox/yYZS;"zQS{|"#} !"#$%&'()*+,-./012'345)*06789:;<=>?@A2B "#$%&CDEFG>*+,-./012B } [H4\]^_`2~€‚ ƒf„…†‡ˆ3‰Š‹ŒŒ}Ž‹‘’ “”•7–—&/˜!"™š?A ›œR3˜<žŸ u¡7¢NV£?¤¥%{"#¦§pV23<^_`&¨©œRªœ«¬ ~‰­®’¯°±’²’±!"}³°‘‹±}´­±ˆNSµœB“¶E·?¸¹º&fg?»¼VœR3½¾¿%À ÁÂÃĜRŸB#[H4\^_`VY0Å3<fg–¢ÆS&ÇÈp!ÉÊ~°±’Ë°Ì’} ²°ËŠ­Ë˰ŒËˆN?+{3<¸fgVk{RÍ8ÎÏ!ÐBÑN<ÒÓ&BAVÍ8ÔÕÑN<fg &”¢ÖVYuYÏ×|"ØÙ2ÍÑNVÚ1?TRB“¶E·%T"SWXR{"!"##} H#*+,-./012>IJKLMNONPQR>STB [H4\]^_`23½¾¿&<žŸ u¡7¢N?ۜR3Ü^_`&žŸ u¡7¢ÝÞ ßàáfº&âãSäåæçVr;"èéê”IJј&ëJ¢ìíîï&ðñàò!$#?óô õ¢Æö¢÷xVøùœR{"#úÝÞß23ûžŸ uü¢F?3ýŸÏþÿ&I¢~<€ N<^‚N<fg&ƒ¢·ë„H…N<†‡pˆ¢G\N<fº¤‰NˆVðŠh‹Pœ3Œ<ž Ÿ ÐBŽNS0V;"<‘„’“”•~–¯—}˜Š±°Œ}‰±’®ˆN%™š/0R{"#B S|Å3<jSèéê”IJh›Eí¢&žŸ uVY0Å3^‚&œ!!™š83€&0 ?"#œR{!{#$B%23&œ^‚&'(S)*?ox/y"ÔÕ8T"NS;"#$& <‘„’“”•NSœR3<+,!œ!h-.M?/ÿ€B%V0×;"^‚&'(?1â; "BA&œ2…ëJ\&]3N?4AB'(56&ÒӔ•8¦§pV7189˜0R{"# /˜V3[H4\^_`23<èéê”:¢•;ESÉ<N&=µVÿ{R3U&YZVWXR {"#} <$83+Ï&>.јžŸ ÐB$S23¹?hfgh€hj&–¢Æ@¢ïAB? CMD/y"]B!nEVYÐR3fgF^_Gi»83>.H&YuY{èéê”:¢ •;ESˆ¢G\?9IœRJœ{S{Z”¢Ö%T"#$B%23KL/VrM;"æ NLZœ%3L&YZVvwOPpVH75F“Æ&QÝ?RS;"ÑS{ZnE?T| !ÏR2!˜!{#œR3$B%23jH&×UV‡?PB;›C”ÖÆ?vwWXV Y+œR{ÏÔÕ8T"#Z~È[ˆ$B%23¹?ј&“E\î·S7“ü7?Yu vwÃÑ0B/&VœR{Ñ!l0Å!˜!{#N~]^_`(aˆ} $&YZV]^_`23bpcd~BS|Å<fgefcdNˆgl%2hiðñ8jœ{† ’&fg†¼&ÈV3˜©oŸ3klVm;"n»?oÐR{"#&m?ۜRpq &”¢Ö?<žŸ uN~tpcdˆ3^_Gi»&,rstHSCяZSzQR{"#/˜ V3<žŸ uNü¢FVuv{B˜&ðñS,rwxÀy?k%V3fºz§&èéê”I 㧙㧙

(8)

!"#$%&'()!&*%+,-./0123-456789:;<=0>?@ABCDE FGH5IJKLMN$OPQR!SATUVWXYZ02(:[-./\31] !"#$%&'()*+,+-./01+23456789: ^_A\3K`Qabc>[email protected]& o&p+qSV\05IJKrsJtu9Vvwxh./01(CyzGHr{|}~Q&o& p+q"&€‚ƒ„…†S‡G~"ˆ‰Š‹V\0HŒ$q+(LŒŽLSA‘’“ &p”$"•$–—:˜lGr{|}A™š›œœ›žŸ †:¡¢0£¤šVK¥./01] ] c>?@}¦Y‡GH‚ƒ„…§¨©ª«SFc¬khG­®A~¯°±&€²&³F˜¬k h./0 !"#1‚ƒ„…A±&€²&³Y‡G‚ƒ„…´µ«A¶·"¸¹:‡º¢G»A¼G r{|}A~F½¾Yl0«¿ÀÁÂÃÄA¯°FGOŒ€Q&VÅckh./01] ÆÇÈÉ ÊËAH‚ƒ„…§¨©ª«S#$%&‡GÆÇÈÆ ÊÌ·HL³Í$o©ª«SA©ªÎ Ï(c#$%&YTÐkh./01g4GÑÒ=Ólc-/χGH‚ƒ„…§¨©ª«SA ÔÏFG>?©ª«>?©ªV¾y¥./02(YZ012AÏÂFGH‚ƒ„…§¨©ª«S 'AÕ֩ר\Ù»AQ&o&p+qA®Ú9:ÛÜ=0ÝDE:ÞCß-./\31] kxVGH‚ƒ„…§¨©ª«SFàÐ-4GH’‘&áŒâ$r{ãäråA~Q&o&æ zA~tçDèS(é-4êëì"b²Œ$ëìA¯°ÆÇÈÉ Ê É ´ Æí ¶àІFãîkh ./0$%#122Y‡GH‚ƒ„…§¨©ª«S:ïðVGñòA~tçDèAóîôõö(L* ÷bFøùVK¥./01úH‚ƒ„…ûüýqþÿ€Ø\Ù¼A€©ª«SG‚Hƒ„… A†‡SGˆH~‰&Š&p+q©ª«SG‹HOŒ—Ôr{|}A~Œ©ª«SGŽH’ ‘&áŒâ$~rS~&,p”+q†G‘Hr{|}å@’A&“$ÿ"ÿ—&qSG” Hr啖A–—˜©ª«(&“$ÿ"ÿ—&qSYZ01] 2A\3VGH‚ƒ„…§¨©ª«S:™$O&V-.Gr{|}A~tçVt=0všDè F–+&“$ÿkhG›œV7º4L,™b!F![kh./01(CyzG~Q&o& 'AL,™b!Aã˜V\CG"#K$%(-.AH&FEw0Stu:ÞCß»3(-./ 012A¯°'+q»AfAfG~tç:()=0r{A*+,-C:.¤-./01] ] ;<=>: /µ:0º.Ew.l4c-/1234Á—AZC5‡G6ó78>?9%Š$b:;A <=J>?YZ0m@AB=ÀCDnQ&o&p+q=V>,-WXKEFJGH:I[-. /01J¥.G¶/Ac>?©ª«¦ËKVØz0>?©ª«"L@MN"ÜOô"Š‹"> ’ªV\0Hm@ABS=Vt-.fEP9AZ0EQRŽ—:I[-./01^KG/S< Y!xTV-4GH:UVVW<-.g(¢4/1] XÔVY›KV‡G>?@AP³”$(Q&o&p+qA5æ9VZ01»h‡GZ‚„[ \KVØz0G]AøRb^V_`V>,-:abc›d:ø5æVråVK=HÐ`e< RŽ—STxAfg:hi-./01=KyjGƒk‚lmŒ,—A|Án:GråTЪA 㧙㧙

(9)

!"#$%&'()*+,-./01234567!"#89:;<=>?@A$%BCDE?F

GHI8JKLMH&'NOP+QR?SHTUHVWX9YTZHTUHVW+[%\9\ %]^_`Hab+cRJ/deefHghHi:D7!!#.?TUjklHmnofpE?Fq

rs8J/&tuvwx7pJ&y<=kHzo{=+|?.QH}~%€6i%‚ƒ?F „wx…†J&y‡ˆDQ‰>Š‹Œ$ŽJ+‘’“>?”•–—˜H™•CJš›œ $žŸ ¡€HŽ+¢£Dƒ?FG`HŽ+¢¤&t‡ˆH›œ¥¦§+J¨©5 ª«¬€­D®‹¯°±>?iƒ\TUjklH²:•C†J&³$%´µ*pE?Fq q r¶8JTU·¸¹º»V`M/0}¼½€¾€¿À¥7456+›Á¯JÂ&tH/0} ¼½€¾€¿À¥7i/¹º»H&'ÃÄÅÆ Ç7—˜+Èɯ‚ƒ?FG\¯‚JTUj klpÊÉ>?/0}¼½€¾€¿À¥7ËÌ689:JÍÎ%ÏÐDJ01½€¾€ˆÑ H›œpҗӐ‚ƒ?FTUjklM1Î8&t()Ô_`HÕÖ8ר?&'+ÙÚÛÜJ ¸ÝÞßMà.&'>?•–i¯‚˜á¯Jâã$%äǀ­åÀæ+ç›Ó肃?Fq q %XJ„éD†ê믂ƒ%ƒpJ/ìíîï7lzDð./&yäñ¿½ €Ë€7†J Â&tHTU›œòó+ôõ>?Ìö€6÷&H²:•C8Møù(ú¯‚ƒ?F+,¯ ‚JTUjkli&t+û%R¹ºü³$ôõ+ç›Ó肃?FGHIJ¨64ýHƒ\J &tiTUÑþ8XÜ?/ÿ€H‚ƒ+„.>…†‡_%ˆ‰%Š‹7!$#H€iƒØ9 \FG\¯./ÿ€H‚ƒ7+„.>/01½€¾€7H²:•C+¯‚J&yTUj kl89? €æ‚6¾€ƒHׄ*iⅆ‡+ˆQ?Gi8,-‚ƒ?HDE?F/‰ Š7/‹Œ7/ÃÄÅÆ€¿Žª7H›œ$˜ÒpC`JhHҗpà>à>ÕÖӐ?Fq q !!"#„$†J%&'& ()* +,+-./01/2"TU·¸•–34i5012368(>?7é i›œH8z$)97:)9;°Ô«<=W›>89?)9=„H?^DE?Fq q !"#$% @>ABCDEFGqHBIBEqFJKqLBDEMBqNDDKqBKOPqQ+RRSTUq!"#$%&'()*+,#%-,./%0,'(#*1%234%/',%53% &'()*%-,./%0,'(#*%67/%89%:";"<(#<%=>+%&'()*+,#%"#*%=>+%?7'33)9VqWBFXDJq'EBOOPq s>YIXGFEKqZPq[\]DEBqQ+RRSTUq?7'33)%@,.3+;%.+3;%/',%8#9(*,%=>/1%A3)(7$B%A+"7/(7,B% "#*%A,+.3+;"#7,Vq^FE_FEKq[K`XFaIDJF\q'EBOOVq.Rb.cPqq ¶>YIXGFEKqA`ZD`EVqYBCBXXFqA`ZD`EVqFJKqYDCBEaq[FdBEqQ+RR-TUq@,C(9(/(#<%A+3.,99(3#")% -,"+#(#<%&3;;>#(/(,9%"/%D3+E1%5,4%8#9(<'/9%.3+%8;F+3C(#<%?7'33)9Vq&D\`aIDJqeEBBVqqq cS/bcS+Pq f>[\]DEBqQ+RRSTUq3FG7(/PV1cPq g>8H(*Pq,,b11Pq%F]BOq'Pq&hI\\FJBqQ+RR,TUq:(9/+(H>/,*%-,"*,+9'(FVq%DOOBibWFOOPjk lmqQ+RR0TnTZHâã$/›œ78op¯.&t3q7é8(>??rstu«v 㧙㧙

(10)

!"#$%&'()"*"+,-./012304526/7869/631:0;<=>?$@ABCDEFGH IJKLMNOCPQ R STUVV WXYZ[77

\<]:0386^7_`7ab3/c7d9e617f`7gb5110hc79h/7i08809e7j`7]bee6317kTlmlno7!"#$#%&' ()*+,--#*%./'0,.)%#%&'1*22"%#3#,-4'5%-6#).3#*%7'18.//,%&,7'9")6)#-,7'.%$' :,.%#%&c7pb3q0hc7TlUTmc7SSUQT`77 r<stuv7kTlmwnxyz{|K}~€%K‚ƒ„=$…†‡GHˆ$)"*"+,-B‰6q7a9Š6h7]‹:bb87p:9hŒ67~€KŽ‘’“$”•BCDEFGH–—KL˜ ™OCwQ RCmwwUmPQ[stuv7kTlmVnxyz{|K}~€%K‚ƒ„=…†Xš‡ ›œžŸ ¡¢–—BGH£¤L‡K‚‡$¥¦§¨©ª#«¬)’“­+®’¯ BCEFGH–—KLCD”° Sl ±˜²³´7 GH–—Kµ¶‡GH–—·¸$¹º‡» ¼OCm½lUm½V.F¾¿CÀÁ$ÂÇÄE»…$ÅÆ§ÇÈXÉ>ʝ<[7 Ë<Ì9867p:08/7]25/^7p6h263c7pbe637]‹:bb87Í6Š68b;e6h27Î3bŒ39ec77 :22;oÏÏe6/0‹0h6`^986`6/5ϋ:08/125/^ϋbe63Ï7.891279‹‹6116/7TlmVÏlQÏTÐ<[7 Ñ<d9e617Î`7pbe637kTllQno7;8.3'5'0,.)%,$'#%'9<8**/4'=,+/,<3#*%-'*%'=.<,7'18#/$' >,?,/*62,%37'.%$'9<8**/'=,+*)2c7db116^UÒ911`7 ml<‰6q7a9Š6h7Î5480‹7]‹:bb817kTlmmno79<8**/'0,.)%#%&'@%?#)*%2,%3'9")?,A'!"#$,`7 mm<‰6q7a9Š6h7Î5480‹7]‹:bb81c79<8**/'18.%&,'5%#3#.3#?,4'9<8**/'9")?,A-`7 mT<stuvkTlmwn7ÓÔ[7 mw<‰6q7a9Š6h7Î5480‹7]‹:bb81c7BC(9'9<8**/'0,.)%#%&'@%?#)*%2,%3'9")?,A`7 7 mP<‰6q7a9Š6h7Î5480‹7]‹:bb817kTlmTno79<8**/'1/#2.3,'1*%3#%",'3*'526)*?,'#%'D8#)$' E%%"./'0,.)%#%&'@%?#)*%2,%3'9")?,A'*+'BC(9'9<8**/-`7 mS<d9e617Î`7pbe637kmQ½SnoÕÍ6e9h/7Öb37ר‹6886h‹679h/72:67‰66/7Öb37×Ù502^o7Ú:67 Í^h9e0‹17bÖ7pb8894b3920bhcÛ0h7_`Í`7Ü9h20h0762798`c7B99@'F,.)G**H7'@$"<.3#*%'#%' 9<8**/'.%$'B*%-<8**/'9,33#%&-c7Ýh0Š63102^7bÖ7_9119‹:516221c7TPSUTVw`7 mV<Þߜà B,I'C.?,%'5%$,6,%$,%3c7á‹2b4637Qc7TllQc7Õi:92794b5272:67Î936h21âÛ`7 mÐ<‰6q7a9Š6h7Î5480‹7]‹:bb81c7]5;630h26h/6h2ã17pb3h63c7Õ_^7h6q7ä/69179h/7‰6Ø27]26;17 Öb37]‹:bb87p:9hŒ6cÛ:22;oÏÏqqq`h:;1`h62Ï10261Ï/6Ö9582ÏÖ0861ÏTlmPUlwU mlå]‹:bb8åp:9hŒ6åg6Ö86‹20bh1`;/Ö7k891279‹‹6116/7TlmVÏlQÏwln`7 m½<‰6q7a9Š6h7Î5480‹7]‹:bb817kTlmPno79"6,)#%3,%$,%3J-'0#-3,%#%&'D*")'=,6*)34'E%./A-#-' *+' 1*22"%#3A' K,,$G.<H' *%' 38,' ()*&),--' .%$' ()#*)#3#,-' *+' L")' 9<8**/' >#-3)#<3c7 :22;oÏÏqqq`h:;1`h62Ï10261Ï/6Ö9582ÏÖ0861Ï]5;630h26h/6h21åf0126h0hŒåÚb53å36;b32ål` ;/Ö7k891279‹‹6116/7TlmVÏlQÏwln`77 mQ<p02^q0/67Î936h27f69/631:0;7Ú69e7q641026c7:22;oÏÏh:;1;936h21`h62Ï7k891279‹‹6116/7 TlmPÏmlÏlwn7 TlmVÏlQÏwl ¨æç®x%Fèéê#¿ëìCíîïð=‡ñò[7 Tln7‰6q7a9Š6h7Î5480‹7]‹:bb817p02^q0/67Î936h27f69/631:0;7Ú69e7]26630hŒ7pbee022667 㧙㧙

(11)

!"#$%&'(!"#$%"&'()**+,#-."#"'/(0+,(1'%(234'.(5-67"8(98:++7/(53,'.#(;'3&',/)(( "$*+,-.!"#$/&0123456789:;<=1>?@A12BCDEDFGH3456

78BCDEDFGHAI+,-.JKLMNOPQ;45RSTBUV345WXYZ [A45678\]B^_;3`abcdeAfIg1hiI//jk#l(

""*mnopq$rsr*0P45RS1tuqvwi*fxyzl( "{*|}~€(!"##%&'(+*<(8"#)‚(${$)(

(

!"#$%&'()*+

!"#$%&'()&'*+ ,-./0123456'7+ + 89:;<#=>?;@A:BCD>E>A:F?GH:GH?I+ (

Alternative Supervisory Administration Form for Developing

‘School Climate’ in an American Urban School District

Reciprocal Accountability System between School and School Board

Yasuko Fujioka

Abstract(

The purpose of this article is to examine the significance and possibility of urban district leadership under the No Child Left Behind Act of 2001, focusing on the reciprocal accountability system between a school and school board, the New Haven Public Schools in Connecticut. The New Haven Public Schools has developed their educational accountability system to create a district-wide learning environment (also referred to as the climate). Their current efforts show the alternative supervisory administration form through their Shared Leadership model. Three major conclusions are drawn: 1) The district-wide focus on human development and collaborative approaches has affected students’ motivation to learn. As a result, they have developed many co-leaders among all the stakeholders. 2) The district’s annual Learning Environment Survey gives a voice to all the stakeholders—teachers, staff, parents, and students— and provides them an opportunity to share their concerns about their needs and the quality of the learning environment at each school. 3) District leadership affects each school's implementation indirectly, through the mediated role of the District Facilitator who affects implementation directly with reciprocity.

Key Words: school climate, reciprocal accountability, shared leadership, collaboration, urban district

(12)

参照

関連したドキュメント

「総合健康相談」 対象者の心身の健康に関する一般的事項について、総合的な指導・助言を行うことを主たる目的 とする相談をいう。

In the tall and smooth surface algae in open wavy rocky beach, the prominent living phytal fauna was Brunneostoma sp.. 2, and

主として、自己の居住の用に供する住宅の建築の用に供する目的で行う開発行為以外の開

J-STAGEの運営はJSTと発行機関である学協会等

また、学内の専門スタッフである SC や養護教諭が外部の専門機関に援助を求める際、依頼後もその支援にか かわる対象校が

第2 この指導指針が対象とする開発行為は、東京における自然の保護と回復に関する条例(平成12年東 京都条例第 216 号。以下「条例」という。)第 47

8 地域巡り(地域探検) 実施 学校 ・公共交通機関を使用する場合は、混雑する ラッシュ時間を避ける。. 9 社会科見学・遠足等校外学習

小学校学習指導要領総則第1の3において、「学校における体育・健康に関する指導は、児