大自然の見えざる力 : 最新遺伝子研究で感じたサムシング・グレート

全文

(1)人間関係研究（南山大学人間関係研究センター紀要）, 2, 209-248.. . . ¶9Z<=·0¸¹º»¼oo½*¶. `Ù`¾¿'ÀÁÂÃÄÅÆ_`ÇÈÉÆ_`Ç ÊË.

(2). ÀÌÍ ÎsÏÂ.

(3) . !. "#$%& '()*+

(4) ,"-./0+121234"56#78"9: ;<= 2> ?@ @AB!"#$%&CD7 EF79GHIJKLM:?NOP%QR,50#$S& R

(5) +TUVWX2>RY>ZS" [ \7]^"S$S5CD$07_Ùa8bcdB!N$%& Refg0+

(6) ,"-hijk71Qlmnop q rst Iq4unvpY5RR7wx-7Ny$8 B!z{ |p}7Qstu4 ~S!N$%S:$ 0+

(7) `à" ?Y5Refg7 15>:?Y `,S!RD2>W1S!"R-2,"-+ 1-2,"-ZU?4!N$S& C-"-,stQ"+u4 ~,RD2>s t7/ p7Ny$"8,"-5¡¢ £0%& W-¤¥¦§S!"#15>CS!JK:?N¨7 ©S!">5",ªB!N$%& '+ «¬k¬l®¯°l±®:?7JK:?² ³´µ$%&. ―209―.

(8)

(9) 47Ny$"#EF7 5,-²Ð"$%& JK:?¥N"08"$S!5,-²Ð"$%& 0R-1450#QR,Ñ+Ò7ªB!"$%&1Ó 2,ÔS$%,ÕÖ× 9:;,ØsªÙRTÚ7B! +ÛÜD1"ÝÞßÚ40¨à"!áâ%QR,+ 7,B !ãäÛåS"æ@0+1"2,ª"$%& × ,ØsRDRC

(10) +¹ç,S0¥B, áâS!VS",ª"$%&Cç7 7¥ 5R-"-R, qB!"Q,"-R,¥èB!VS",ª"$%& x+éÐéÐR4ç7!"#$S!EF75,²Ð"$%& . 0+ RD2>êëJK:?7N¨-25"",ª"$%&. . U ` ¾ìí7'E vî®°ï®ðð,"- ñ%ò>S". óô)5õö÷0#$S&ø8!$""óô)51"ì0Ñ Y'E 7ùúûP!8D0+1"2,ª"$%& üýþ,ìãT ++1 K >D

(11) 1 K >D,"-0+0$%5C 0+ 70$%& üý:?+ ÎsÏ0UðB>S8éD! ¥ªá0+1","-¸¹0S& Æ+$. 7+. nB,B!$%5n+n0¥ 0$%2>CD+

(12) D!"é0%& S2Sìã+8°¯0>8ãä2D +E 0+1"2,ª"$%&ð4!$S!¥0>D $S!8ÙS!N>D12B,"-R,58Ç2$S& 8ÙS!1","15>ÙS!"Q:?¥N>D$%5R:? +>8DR,¥²¹012B2¥SD$. &'E2>+>. 85B!1",ª"$%&'E2>5B!">ZàI+¯ 0#$%2>°¯0S2¥¥dB!N>D1" º. n¯

(13) I5°ï®ðð,"-+RD+7¥$1" 0+1"2,ª"$%&. ―210―.

(14)

(15) . !"#$% &'()*+",-./) . 0) 1%23456%78(9:;*;<=>? 23@AB=C=DEFG$%HIJ=*; KL8(9:;=)45EFGJMNOEKL6! =P%7Q-RST! $UM= V)W0JRNOEKL6!P%7XYZ 0=[)D3=\=/E]!^_à=bc defg$\EhiEj"k1 "l 3#m)n 3op6 7qrs)tuEvw"$xyz()U!"k" {rs#|)}~$#m)%M01 7 bc)VE 7!"#$ 0%7 6M=NOE 6%!"#$ 7$NOE$6M0%7 =C0)+M "=C!"M 0)(E "#%7!"+ %7MR=%R!"MC# " $0 6!" R$0NOE VE 7 "0=aER F%. !"#$. 7F%7!"7R-aER R=%21R=1¡B)¢£%M1¤ R¥= ¦=§~¨©k+3"0Eª«¬)%M6 M7ª«¬)%M1¤ R 3"FF ®E¯F=AB6M+%7 °±RR60) ²760)²%³%´µ-¶ %=t·¸¹º"¹º". !"%7R-¹º"M+%. »ª«¬)%M1=¼½¾(¿ÀÁ $=Â1UR=06M+%7 0AB)Rz¼Ã¼Ä. !"#%7a. =>?¦ ÅÆ =AB%7 Ç¼=ÈÉ 6 "Ç¼=ÊÉEÅÆ )ËºAB6%7 )RÌ=aÍz¼Ã¼Ä. !"M+%7. "R!#R =ÎÌI=aÍyÏÐz¼Ã¼Ä =6M=%0ÎÌIE$²7 Rl 3!"CÑÒEÓÔÕ1"#|)} Ög$×Ø 1ER=ÙÚ"1%7aRÌÛ$MÜ6M+ %7)ÝNÞ0P!"%aÌÛ$M. ―211―.

(16) Þ++%7)Þ3áEâ)3 6M$%7%M0a=ãäåæEçR$º R =èé(êÞ0P!"%R=ëB ì=%g6íÞ0!" %=Þ+ 7 ÝNAB)Þ"~P%7%-> ?=CP!"Ma@a=¼î(ªïðª) P!" %7 ¥°kÎÌI a%$yÏÐz¼Ã¼Äm z¼Ã¼Ä)m P%7 q=a=ñò=%70ñòÚ 7 "z¼Ã¼ÄEóM¬ôx=%7¬ôx %$¤ Rõ~#E7öP÷Úp6! Á=Lø6!Ñ@6!D06M+%7 »HIùtJ=úû=1!+RÑ@6! EÞ"6 7Ñ@!"2üý)0þ"M= !=0= ï0%==1!+k!7R-Ñ@ k+8(9:;]º7 #R 0Ñ @6!0$!0%7 ¥$/\E]!R=a=^ k!=D3 !"# 7=

(17) 3= !"í ! =%7HIJ68((k!=%7 k$8(9:;¹p=%r0^k= k 0R+%7=C2)U!E =)ä=í0=%7HIJ= R6 =bÐ¼ENOEâ<# "$3Ð¼)8( 9:;E E@7 Ð¼=CNOEð =úûHIJ=¦. ) ". !=%7%M. í01%$^Ð¼=a<3" =<6MHIJE!+%7 k$KLEí0k+6!" 00R7°=I -T!? %AB? +%7Ea=AB 62) =%0k+ %$ KL= R8((k!=%7 0=053E=D3!"%7 $= E t !"8(9:;*;#ár%7J ) "JJE8(9:;%D . !$. !"m)!%70-T! . ―212―.

(18)

(19)

(20) . !"#!$%&'()*# $. +' ,-./0 '123 4/ $ 5623 4/78' 9:4;<=>-/ ?=@ AB1CD#!$E' FGH2<I2J K1LMN OPQ RS#!CD $&'TUH AB# (EVWV,-./0'X+YZ#!$ [\] * ^_` ,-./0abcd e#!$ Vfghi# *8jk# l0amno pb! %&qY!rs $tuvw&! x$ %& %_`'KyK12<I2ls*&# #z*{|V 1!Rr&a $ }~_`'%&'()#! ^2-* 16 <'ge"#!$Ky# x$ ' [\]I*!*1 %?= @23 4/6a*&!v'6g ^ 16 <'ge"#!$ %# ,-./0l0'^Ky! 1#!e}~ _`'"#!$!*5V,-./0V* ^Ky! 1#!eR! x$%&' +'*&!Z $_`' '! ¡1_`. ^¢ ¢e_`'1 $Y* '£ !Z a*&#! f¤v¥¦a§b 1! ¨©ª«¬1 '5'¨©ª« ®¯#1*Za*&!Y Z $ ,-./0°%'1rs $±²²³*´µ ¶· ³¸rs $¹º»¼½ V¾*& V¨©ª« v'1rs $Y* (Eg'() *&!Z . %#_` ¿('6*&1_`K 10°O!' t!5vV'KyÀga $ +' 5'ÁÂÃÁÄ¦Å ÆÇKC ¸#! È=9\ÆÇKC 'zY! ¸ \!É!'1Ê a#!$Ë&!'1'Zg#! 5vV !O!'KCYugvÌ1Ys'1 K CÍÎKyÏ! $Ð ÁÂÃÁÄ¦Å' Ñ . ÒÓEKC' Ô ^ÆÇKC'ÕÖ×ØÙKC {| Ú1v1eRÛÎ rs $5vV'1 %Z #!$. ―213―.

(21) %& KC' vÝÞ#Vp*1 ßà S áÑrs $KCßà'» âC` gãäV V78'åæ1{| $5vVç1Rè' ^ÆÇKC*,-./0é {|S%eRè#!$## &'R °O1 * vt R! ^ÆÇKCT UêKC #te5vVK1ë $()'¿( êVKy1 _ìR!t íCTU'¿(îV ugvïðfg* 8¿TU Ù KCñ 5vVòZ#!$ % g1ó¾! $%ßà}~_` ôõö! Z %÷ 1sVøO#!$ %s78' CùYsVTU Ù Cù ) ú È=9û üý a*&#!þgE29<! ##!$29< 5'r# ^þCùèV 7ú' $ %KC# ' KCv#!* v# !*TU KC 5vVZ '} ~_`l0 ôõö!5'øOa $ % 5vV'ó¾{|#!Z $. 5 î&{|'

(22) cd $5' ¦ ¿(', &! 6#!$È=9 û . û ^,

(23) e-2!r s $,' J ! 1 %

(24) Ö!#!$ ,

(25) '*

(26) î Ö $&' c $%& 7'¿(s $ 5vV' 7'vVs%Y¦³**6# #! Ky1rs $% #!rs $'» ,' Oz , Ö!7?<,rs $ <, < Ö!7?< $Y* 5v V' ag*7, ag*7,° %

(27). ―214―.

(28)

(29) . !"#$%&' ()* "+. , - . /012#3456 789789 +

(30) :;<" 45601=>?@ ( ABCDE9FGH>?@IJE9FGHK L+ 456* "+

(31) MI(=3E9FGHNOPQRSE9FGH T,RSA"UA"VWA"XYA,NO =PQE9FGHIJE9FGHKL+ Z[* " \]^_). 01, -` "% "0 1+ -T a!b cd e f)*. "+, -g2#<"f+, f` "%

(32) h<"ijklmno456Kpqrsa!<tu 456vwa<hKxxy xxz{|456}K~. b <rss(~C. P h<"noA

(33) , MI( kl( <h Tkl<h T < h M,f"TJTJe"A<j9 kk9T * "+9k+ k 9T C h<"+T f"PA+<(M I(tuT ijc, PA KB"%K ¡ <¢,Q£( B

(34) , << MI(h9kKQ¤ "\]^_I (ij ¥ " <<T¦¡, § ¨l©) lFlªt B" MI(1(«f"¬®¯f"°±K²

(35) h %³ A+ ´µ¨l©<"¨l©K¶·<"¸,)^ _(+

(36) <<¹f

(37) ( ¸ ¦,))¦cº -»" +

(38) < <Mijcºe+ " cº¼D, ". §,tuij½ "¾¿ÀÁT,MI(ÂÃ. ―215―.

(39) ÆÇÈÉ ,ÊLK<"A ij½ËCÌ ÍAÌ ´ÎBÏB ÐtÑ9ÒÓÒÓ ÔÕÖf×ØÙ " +

(40) MtuKÚ!",ÛCDÜÝÞßA Üà%³ %áC<"Üà tuK×ØÙ I (ij½T ,<. h<"h<!â' ãÆäåæK <"%<"çèéêK<" +

(41) hcd ë ¥ MÜì¼Jtu(í+ BÏKîA< Êí B MªïðlñAòÊóªïðlí h~ <ôõ öÊí MI(Â Ãtu(í+ ËC"A

(42) h + ijí ÷ø+tu456KÐùúûü9klý Ýþ+ + Kq , < Ðùúûü9klýÝ <")É ´ 456}2#KC" <(hT ¶h ÑlEKP9 lE2 <.

(43)

(44) / b P9 lEK" + ü9kl ýÝÝ456}2#kl ¡A+, h -þ+MI(e " ) ij- ËC< Ðùúû§J³. M³ T,T B. <j§j Ðùú û;p. r 9³K L" +

(45) ¸ijÅ. r 9 ijb(%³Kf¼JL" +

(46) h<"MÐùúû . %<ûú©Ð³ % <f" m, v JIK<" hÐùúû° ½ý <Ðùúû ¥ ()Çr 9%³KL+b B ijb( %³Í § Ðùúû½´Î³P¶<" l F½(h ÛCD³ÔÕ. ÀÁ³ Ñ9 9 ËC,u©l b ËC <"(³Ô Õ.

(47) ¸¬I KC"A ³b ã E9FGHb(

(48) ©G ã E9FGHÌ¬ ®¯ C"A

(49) ÁT K+ h ³E9FGH E9FGHK+ Ì¬®¯ << MI(³T KÀ+

(50) ³ PKÀ+³ P . ―216―.

(51)

(52) . !"#$%& ' # ()*+,-. .-)

(53) /0)1%23" 4

(54) 56! *!78-()8&)*+-

(55) )9%& 53!/56

(56) :1;</ =>!78-(56? @)8&)*+-

(57) ABC(!DE(FG HIJ$K@+L

(58) 3"(!MNDO PQ(RSHI%TU V=+L

(59) RSHI%TU 4WX) &YZ53"([\]^

(60) _à/bL !cd&ef gd3(hdLi!_ -DEIj,X 56.X (k@+5lm)

(61) 5-!n=op Ijqrs K@t4!au&eZ53BC([\]^)

(62) &e3(v L -)*78-w+xy ZbL+!zwt 6{`56z|6J}z ~"33")bL !i){`5 6&%)3 (5) !I w+[)&e%w+p3"=56(L

(63) 5 6!-DE+%w+ L

(64) A(!![! ¡¢£¤(¥¦§ ZbL

(65) 56!¨( $wt

(66) n3 !!%3"(!DE©)©& %3" ZbL+!cd(ª« ZbL

(67) n4%w+p3(

(68) It¬-n=®t

(69) ¯@>!7°SG± ²~wt4(!³´%&I)8µi8/bLi t

(70) 5!¶(!·4L !¸¹º»º(¼ SS½%¾@³´¿ºZ V=+L

(71) 8i))À²~w+-³´¿ºZbL

(72) 7(Á GÂÃÄÅ²~4Lt!ÄÅÀÆiP ÇÈÉ%&Ê 3w+Ë%Ìt6ÍÎ³´ZbL+!Ïwt6àI(7 t

(73) n33Ð Ñ3(ÒÓÔ Zb!I-»º¢ÕI -{65Ö1;&%&×Ø+ Ù5"=%Ú6n3?@+

(74) "Û)5)5Ú6)

(75) n4!¯@>³´Üº Ý5ÑÜºÝ53(!n33Ð Ö1;&%Ú6

(76) 5-!

(77) n33" !-»º¢Õ-!¶(PpL i>w+

(78) 5!7ÞGw+4tßà(ßà ()*+!I()9áâã )53ßà%Jww+4Lt

(79) 7(äå¦%æ+. ―217―.

(80) !äå¦7)9áâãßà%w+53!°°G± ²~wt56

(81) èå¦~wt

(82) èå¦3(/-Û*+!ÛÛ)å¦Id+L

(83) ""é

(84) n+!-¬Ûièê (ZbLi56ë êi%ì"( 4Li!íîßà(Ùå¦ -

(85) V=-(!ï /ðL !¥ 1ñò%ó!ñòôõ. Ö+

(86) öw+!å¦)8(Ùå¦ -

(87) 7(!à (ZLbÕLi t

(88) ÷ø÷[%æ+. !÷[3[å(¬ùw\wt"ÛZw+!ú÷[û%úüwt [åû ! úü[ûVw+IL ! $ ¯%ýþL

(89) 7(!_56G±÷ºÝ²~4Lt

(90) LJw*bt(! ÷ø[åÖ¦÷ºÝ%t3"

(91) ÷ø[å Õ ºÅ¦% ¬ þL+!ªw+à)bLt

(92) 7(ÖLt

(93) )95L !7å ÷[¦( à. ºÝ ZbLt

(94) _ - @+L !å & [4). Zw+!úà. ºÝ÷ø[åÕ ºÅ¦áºÝ. å[å%3û3º[s6=+Lt

(95) " 33º%[s3"Û÷[/5"Û ZbL !7-/55wt ~wt

(96) n3t6!÷[ (-)

(97) 7 I5+)5wt

(98) n+!( t- ZbL+!N « t

(99) [å ±Ö¦ !N S Gïåª¬`[ª¬!ªw+à)bLt

(100) ÷ [¦(.Íà!NSÍå h)bLt

(101) )9"i)""wt53! IüwtIæt

(102) #I æt3ð-ZbL !7w+( I5Li

(103) 3_ ZbL

(104) òI(!N « t6ni)"Û ª3)83(") !Ä5Ù5bLi! å N SÐ %® 6=t

(105) )wt5835b Li!åÙ5 ºÝ%Û3?@tI It.

(106) n3t6!i)úni)"(+/ !ni)""( J() ()5ûV=tVw+Lt

(107) ÷[(º ()

(108) öw+!Ïw+4tt$%@) => )

(109) ú83w+Zi)$%@t6åª+5û!i)¿ =tVw+Lt

(110) 8Ê3¿=t53!ú/L@à% I ai!78-à% I ZbL !/ L@ai tVw+-n=(l. ()

(111) a i

(112) /5*)wt6/L@ 4

(113) 5!÷[. ―218―.

(114)

(115)

(116) . !. " #$%& '()*+*, -./0./&. 1' 23456789:; <=>*:;? (1@AABCD!E*F067EGHIJHK

(117). !. L'((, ?KMNO P0QRK. ?ST&U&, V! 1LW

(118) X YZ0 [\T&]&^_à

(119) bc1WKU de) fgh0&W" Uî0X jS Tklmno

(120) ]p Wq Wrsrsde)fHtuv*w03x

(121) "&WYZ 0[\W]&^_à

(122) yzyz&{^1bEGHIJH

(123) K jKU |!} K )*+*, `V V!

(124) ~W_ `W~Kbs

(125) ( '(1

(126) U. , Tj^*w0 ( , T s

(127) b '(1

(128) U U^ ]1 U^_`WbEGHIJH

(129) ,W K( q ^T@ BCD! jbs

(130) ( 1

(131) U &U&"X^

(132) W . !X "uE0] U . #]1 lm1 ^ W K./ ?K " s det¡0&j

(133) ¢{ £T# ¤¥c¦ W§¨©ª«W K ?ST ¬_` ®¯*°L xU ^¬'V!x jS& ?K" _`det 'b ±. W T&²³ 'b ´µ

(134) ¶b{·b ±'b ¸¹ºUS¬

(135) »±

(136) U ¦ ^¬¼½c

(137) !ºW~

(138) ¼¼¼½"&W¾£W¾£W¾£T~K"¶b {·b¸¹0{W'b ¿j

(139) ackWq~ QÀx "

(140) !º_`b

(141) ]WK. !

(142) "&Wq1&. , V&^&£1V &OjT~K . !. U~ÁWÂ& #]1 ^ W K ?ST. ―219―.

(143)

(144) " # s Äu &

(145) U U^ÅA^ Æde)fgÇjT&"K #ÈÉÊ@AË

(146) ST& ÈÉ@ A Ë

(147) K (ÌÍÎÏÐÑ0Ò\Ks q T\ ÓÔV UÕfV U #de)fs @A ËÈÉ0Ö W~KÈÉ #]1'×Í?STVU^# de )f×Íc(Ì ×ÍcK &~

(148) WPØK &U&ÙÚmU^

(149) ÛL ÜST&Ý Þßà áK âã ägåÄ*æç*0&W~TTèé~S& Xäêë ì AAAí? # ¶îïÌÕð ñ1

(150) a

(151) ò T&óìbì AAAíä ò K "ôõäåºT&"K 8õö÷ 8øùúûü

(152) ä?ST&Wý þ Am^ SWS " K (ÌL `j~

(153) K"&W K "

(154) . ^

(155) # bÂ ]. ^

(156) VU^#?TSÄu &

(157) 1 ?

(158) VU^&U.

(159) U

(160) ? 1?ST 1'§¨`

(161) j0&W T] U jSS&W K. mU "aWÔ0T"K uE0JH&W uE0Jtº# ]1./Ë1

(162) K K Ë1

(163) K Ú^Ø&" ` æçH=

(164) ?STÅA Æ# ÁSTk&" Ç . #L§¨`j~

(165) W×Íc &èl 0&T& ÛÄ*æç*¡ST Ä*æç* ¡c

(166) !º !

(167) . !&U&0W KUcSmU^

(168) U^". VS. !SºUS&W T&. &U&#"#u$0%! âã0v å T&v ä &0¶'·()WT&Wâã j]j&¡&*!W K 1LÙÚ¡&*!W K. !. !K & mUWÇ. +K&U&# âã&0U¦j

(169) "#u $0%!T&#ÙÚ &,V

(170) ? -. /# 0670 1ÙÚ0T 1&&mUKÙÚ1mU^

(171) . "#u$0%!T&. ―220―.

(172)

(173) . ! "#$%&'(. ). *+,-./01% 23(#4567 *8/&'. 7#95:;%&'(/. <=>/#?(0@=5A5(0&'+#BCD% E"!F!7*!D7(0&'$88GH "# "("IJKL0%&'MND7*8/! "#%O PQRS(/TUV&'OPQRWMN781%/( X #15YZ[\]%/+. ^_\](. 0#"("OPQRà>b8%2à>bc. a. de/#"

(174) f8gh7]T#?(0ijklmn +klm9 !%S(/#o

(175) pS!1

(176) pS !7]T# %q (>/T/#1r&'8 st%q (uvwxy/st/#z{|kl%D! s]/T/#"("OPQRW5}(~= (s q (2W%/(/(q (/(0 MN7 mm/! #1r$1]0/]T# `]. ". . s. +7à7]T#ia"1%7 11 c. 7%/(s0$1%a&'. @=FD/(FD/(WT/s "#95. &'@=?8%# &. 'aOPQR¡b9¢£/]T(0$a . 7. ¢£7]T/#¤¥¦ "("$1&'@=81§¨©ª/! #% «". ! "OPQR¬`%«%K®#KL. 5¬`%¯°±²"/81©ª³7#&'@= ?X. ´µD/#1%D#5¶·¸%¹º. IJ»/(0OPQR%¼½*8/½?X "1%¾¿? /oÀÁ%X "# OPQR%klÂÃÄ aÈK>É ". . 5Å". ÆÇ%/#"("1. Ê0+´µË/+/! #´µËÌÍ. 1/T/#´µË/81%o/%´. µÎ¨/>81(0#81%9881(8 iÏ¬`%0/+/781# 1%Ð"/oX. %&'%9?Tb. 5OPQRWÑ. %(/"$A(RÒl7¨%´µ"/TÓÔ. ―221―.

(177) /#1r´µ8%×K×K1Ø7%Ù/# %©ª/!(T. ! "#"("%$D. "#Úl. {Ûa8aØÜ8]T#1D¶·/#A" r1a%Ü 95Þßàá. (0IJKÝklÂÃÄ0 "#1% + "#.

(178) 5â "0â 7(5"/#95´µ5ãä% å/#5

(179) rbå?T%ÓÔ#"("¬D/æçè/´µ Î7D%åãäé0o7]T#

(180) 5å0â " 0â 7#êëìi>bíÄ%$88%2Wuv îïá "# $1aØÜ. (0´µ%ðñ. D "#/ò(. 8%1aØÜ (óôõö÷ø85ØÜ8 #9:;5÷ø85 0. ùú¬` 07(98(. %û! b(+÷ø857# /ò95÷ø8o?üýT(8xþ%i³=@>/ #Ù7]T#=@ %/#Ýr. 7#=@ÃÛ1÷ø. 77]T#1Ûs8. q£/ lÛ[þ? ¤¥¦ (+1÷øA(C895 JK Þ"# $%%`è/ ($8855o! þ (1> =,ý(7(0#"("÷ø(0/( /( 0/]T#"(51%23(+#9é0( +(8IJþ#I Jþé0õö ~!/"/7#

(181) +8%

(182) "(/]T# (0$88%uvC+# "("%Úl{ÛaØÜ (ó1÷ø 8¨=71D "#$" "#2. "0+". 2p. D. (01÷øÛ8ë. 5o78GC "#1% 5"r+//X "# ëôõö÷ø7#!Ø$8 Î%!÷ø (0/(/(Ø. 1/#. $D98"(8D¨/TT/91 7(#ªÛ Û£1/! "¤¥¦#¨Î0 Î. 5 0/#91o7(8¬%/+. @8%C/. @. $o781þ. (! "# ¬`. D. ib%1@(Æ+. ―222―.

(183)

(184) . !"#$%&''()*! +#'()*,+-. !./0

(185) 1 2'()* +3-.!24#56" 4714893:)*!; <:2=94>?@A4 !4#B, CDEF

(186) GH:!"# I=93:J!94K;L MN" 1OP ,Q+RST 4 8 U V 1W ,+X!YF

(187) #Z)[\(]^_P(`.aL"bcde9 "CX!24fgEF(V,1E h ,i

(188) jX!, CDEF+ 8 kl-.!"#, CDEF MN

(189) 1:9m#,9 42no i+1 -.!2

(190) #pqrFststuL Z)[\(vL"X!w Z)[\+xy zA4 -.!2

(191) #{ |c } V 1}(~L" !2} V 1}(~L" "#= }(1:9m :1 }XUL" 2

(192) #4}X( ! 4 ("4 !4F1}( " ! #4+P41 & }( 1:9m :1 )22 =,# + lKJ!IK;L6X"f" 691 K;L6X4

(193) X 34hU !

(194) # fU ,9+-.!2 U #X 91 X1 91 2

(195) #=F1,(UL" 4¡ ¢L"69!YF4IXh +U `.! ,9

(196) £¤¥¦¤§¨2OP ©¤ª©OP «¬OP ®( ¯D 234# +°±+² ³

(197) 3U !2

(198) #²(³ 1:9m#,F1,(¢L"X91 #X1 91 UL" "+#!´X1 4#IXh

(199) ²(µ"#X ,Q!¢.¶X!2 µ²(2<:2 +#°±+·¸¹+ 16"X3UL"C.!"º» ¼#°±·¸¹+½¾1 -.!2

(200) #, i(2¿À.!2 ¿j3:Á(Â*!2 +IÃ ÄÅÆh ,# Q Q1zgÇÈ(!= É ¿l zgÊËÌÍzg zg

(201) C49!2ÊËÌÍzg. +#Î41 lÏ Å !2

(202) #ÐÑÒÓÔ ÕfÖ(a4 9zg2, zg ÇÈ

(203) Í×CQL +#, zg

(204) -X#Øg

(205) fÙÚ6 ÛÜ#Ý+Þ. ÍßUL". !

(206) #Þ ÍßÛÜ(¢L"<:2àá+ 2â6X # Õf(¢L4$ãä(a9!YF, zg+lnå-.!24# Iæç

(207) è 43h+é4Íê+X1Lhé ! +# ,9+ ,(ë ÅL"ì(í "# lK@!. ―223―.

(208) I,9+8. ,3C!7K

(209) Xæç(ÊËzg

(210) X1 . ,+#°±·¸¹+½¾

(211) 1 3hKQF#·¸¹-!.è ð.!2

(212) # 8 feL"69mI·¸¹ Ø&+16"# X#ñò#óX3hUL"!2 +X#ñò#óX3zg4ë "C.! #,9(°± ôõ¢.! ö÷

(213) #}X+ Í×ø61.!=9ù#ö÷+'

(214) ø

(215) .!YFúø

(216) 4 1 ,Q

(217) 6EF- 2

(218) º» ¼#1CÍûø

(219) 4161.! ü ï ý ? ? ?' }(¿j¿j "#,9(uþ"¤¨¥ V "#,,4.P:" 6<:2=9+1 2

(220) # 8+¢+.j "C.!Z É

(221) -. µ³

(222) (L<:2,. X+U71 9E2 Ý 8 f+ "1 f1 f# 1 °±4## 8 PÍ×E9" , µ³

(223) (L<:2qø

(224) .!,.

(225) -4# 8+

(226) 56"#Ý

(227) 16"16!ó6 #=.

(228) <7t¨

(229) -42 #, °±+2AX1j.!8F1 # ü ï ý ? ? ?' Z)[\(" L 64

(230) a9 #? ï a91 ? ï(aü ïý ???' }(6 V 1s1 ,+!¡¢.!YF34# 8

(231) +K;Ls -L ,2ÉEFl3U<9" 4 24# - j+K;LC 1 ,Q

(232) 1 X1°±+X1 . ,Q-.!2? ï + 8 -.!2 #? ï+ñ\

(233) X1 <:2fgEF

(234) I89A4 ¢L4ñ\

(235) X!2hëX!

(236) #I&ï? 3h ï ? +>? ? -.!2 I= 2#zg#À}m.6 2h ,F1,+f+¢91 ¿jðL +# 8+w (!7 2

(237) #w ¥ +K;L 234#è ,(U l+I,F1

(238) Fm.!

(239) # 8 °±+w Ø + Y"¥ Ø + Y1 h

(240) f+¥( 2,

(241) `2#¥ (. ,+ÇX1 X1j.! !j "C.!2â ¨

(242) qFX 2¥ ¥ (

(243) 9 ¨2I77L#ÑÝ 2hf :-.!2 +ò ¥ ( Q ÅL"#, PeL" X!=9! + , +F8Î.!YF3 # fg+=. +. ―224―.

(244)

(245)

(246) . . !" #$"%#"&'(.

(247) )$"*+, $-!"./0&1 $ 23 4

(248) 56

(249) 78$#"9$:&2$ 0;12#"9

(250) <"*2=$;>,? @# $

(251) <#"&A!$BCDEFGHI;J<%K"?. .

(252) %LMNOP? T9

(253) 2UVW;X. $QR& S)9 456.

(254) % YZ[\P]^). 256;_,! 4&#Sàb;2!"%cd . Se 49fgh @W9iPj!k ! );V(%K569V)$lm56;n56"2!# "9A$56O. 2)oW9p/!"?2& W. 9$$pA

(255) % ((]q,). S"APrstu&v #wxyz{|;}%"EFG HI9~s

(256) )2("4

(257) 9 ,L

(258) EFGHI; <%"*8 P L;!,P !2# $P&P !L L& S)&~s

(259) )%$!2P8A &2UW&/!

(260) )$S%$ iVW;WS%S) N OP9rF;%4

(261) "#<&o!NO9 =$P$!,Pv! ;/,Pv! 9 A9 ¡rF;%¢A2&. $. £0¤;¥@=$P ¦P 2$K"S%$)o ¦

(262) !@( wxyz;_<%K"?2& 2P #"9 "

(263) $"#<P0;1 "%#" EF§¨;BCDJ!,P9 EF§¨wxy;#$" $S)&© 2EF9© ª«¬® (%"% #"P$ ª«¬GHIwxy;!56PA wxy9¯°?(%P EF±²9³´µ !2 ª" ¶$"%#"2 EF±²9Lm·¸

(264) ¹ ¸

(265) _2 "P/´µ 2S ª«¬

(266) ´ µ2 SLµwxy;º/2$$ © 2B»NO&&o !"A @ª«¬2&GH Iwxy&)K"? 4

(267) ¼½A 56T&¾¿À. ―225―.

(268) "A wxy&)"%#"9 Â¿&Ã. 2@(. K"%#"=$0; ÄÅ;Æ=1 S% ÇÈ"A ÉÊ&om`P4nË PÌÍ&A @¯N ÎÇÏÐÑÒÓP Ô¿ ÕÀÖ~¿×&4

(269) "/Ø-ÙÚª«¬GHI;1. ÄÅÛÆP

(270) ÜÝ "%HÞ¿ß&à Káâãä 24

(271) 9áâ(/Î!2& Î 4

(272) 569 å&LÊÐáPÃp å&LÊÐáPÛÆ " %#"PB¶æçè& éÊ0 ´Ê09@9 UêëìU í %îK"%#"ï. !2ðñò

(273) i. ñò

(274) $/ Wñò2 "9óÀôõSlBöSlBö P$ =$9÷h&$/$ 4

(275) ø 9÷h&$ /$2& 4&÷h;$/ ¼&ù)2 £÷h;1. =$;>,? @úPÎ û09ÖüÖßý¿ 56þ"%r !Ößý¿9 &$9$ ÇøBPÎ&M)

(276) Ößý¿9 &$

(277) &#"P 3ª«¬GHI ª«¬ $;

(278) B #"9$EF;2,P9 EFGH I&!3 56;ª«¬EFP¥. !K. EF±²9 ª«¬(

(279) P© )3_

(280) 0 /$É&S$P P0P$ è " A è "

(281) ìy;Ã/!"?Ö üA Öüû0P"94

(282) sr Î 33; /" /$A !°0; $&&A!(%P$ 49Öü@. O"#<9EFGHI;_!. K"? @_!K"?%29ÜÝ. EFP/ #)&øÊ249. ; b@ . O"#<9#! è "?. !

(283) ?/. )$K"? &HÀü @9 ¯EFGHIw xy;K"HH !2@ "9ÄÅÛÆ3!K " 4P@#!K"?% @_ ª«¬Î øEF (%"*! %&o

(284) wxy&)$ 3K"?@ "#<9 $ßóÀ_!K ") 490;P 2!" 9hS% $; @#9. "#<9ª«¬Î EF

(285) Î!. $ ·ä2!$ # éÎ è&). ―226―.

(286)

(287)

(288) . !"#$%&'()*+&,-./'(&01. 234/'(01 54 /36 789:; <=> ?'(&@A4./789:;4/B

(289) CD9'( EF"GHI J%K 78%4% 6 ?LMNOPQ 4B

(290) %?4RSTU4B6 VWXYWE8Z8[4\]U ^

(291) %_àF!b %cdefg9YFhFV4 ijk

(292) cYFhFVijljm'(nò)*+p6 4àF!q6 ^

(293) %r@&s;k.B

(294) YWE8Z8[ij%?5?tkuvwx% ;A%cNy45 U6 ^YWE8Z8[ij&z{|}}~.6 ;A%cij%|}} ij&}?6 &^ ^.A%&r B

(295) /546 ij94/x .A'()*+p4B6 x6 9

(296) ' (&@A /789:;44&39 B

(297) 44^&& F8x%t4B6 dF 8%F8

(298) %B6 ;A%c6 i jiPq6 ^ %c6 %

(299) Ny6b .I¡!XF8YFhFV9¢£¤9¥ ¦A 54§ ??4¨©&,-%c4&ª«¬

(300) 4 4%c/®%c¯/CD/° .I 34%R±²³&°

(301) c&.x.x´µ:;6 ^

(302) ¶

(303) .r@&01 &A

(304) ·xt'()*+¸¹º»&¼½¼¾»1 ? CJR¾%¿ t /

(305) %¶6 78x/9 :;6 54c%c/<=>lj&'(%ct &¾/6

(306) cÀÁYFhFV¡!XF8¶ &Â /%5?96 t/6 &F8Ny45Ã ^ 4%ÄÅ9YW9k

(307) ÆÇx/9@A

(308) /4 96 %c &

(309) B34;A%ct/6 È¾OÉ ¤9J9©6 ÊËc/?4R©.AÌÍ%¶434 %c &BÎÏ6 ;A%ciÐVWX\ ÑÒÓ%P9Ô44ÕÖ&ÄÅ9×ÌÍ%?dØWo(eo( 9Ô6 5 ?4RÏ&ÙA ¶44;A% c5?¾Ú&i:ÛÜ7WÝÞo[%ßà9á6 . ―227―.

(310) ßäåætk?ç%?9p6 èF8]U4xB6

(311) c ./i^é%3%cäåêë6ì6 ¶44å &íî%cäåæÙA ¶44å&ïð9 %&B

(312) &r %&/B

(313) /

(314) ñW(7WÛo!9q6 ;A%còr %&/B6 /4óô2¦ § /%có ô24õöj%&//÷ø%^

(315) ·xùöj%&c ³¾/ <=>4&ú ;A%c ò/4ûü&ýþð ü/6 ?%c/ &jU?UA/6 %c;kÏ/U4B6 6

(316) /&9& ?q

(317) ¾&Omó9 34;A%có94& . b ü?/6 %c 9&?6ü ? üü? 44å N 194ó34.å 1 1 æ 194.{°%c/¾&54b ó9 /U9&ÎÏ34%cUU U& ?U& ó -.3

(318) %c ¾¾/6 ¾¾/t4°%c 9k

(319) ¾&544

(320) ¾&? ó&

(321) C?^9^Nx ¦A .I ó -.3

(322) k

(323) & - %&;A%c & %c/&44 %6 % ¾/k

(324) ó6j±/¶6

(325) /6ók ^ ú

(326) <=> %&: %c

(327) %&¡!XF8YFhFV9& ? /;B6

(328) / & °.óô2¦ AYFhFVx.¡!XF8x.: øÌO mÜo8 9k

(329) t Â?4R©r@ t4 %ó°&

(330) ·x% //¾/6 ?/ %c/ij9OÉ¤9J9©6 h#d# c ?6 ./?4R©.A¶4 ;A%c B Ï/k

(331) 5?&YWE8Z8%Ô6 / S J9'(nò)*+ pk O)*+¸¹º»9 %CD9

(332) ú

(333) áFo%c±û Õ9

(334) cYFhFV. ―228―.

(335)

(336) . !"#!$%&'() !*+,-./(0+12342 .. 51678/9 516:23);<=> ?.@ABC BDEFG6H8@I./JK LMN. OP QRSH8/ >T" #T $ U ABC BDE V W8/XY LMNZI/ LMNZI/);9 ;[8\]^/);9 ?;3V_`51>. ab cde6f8@)3?I6g)h/i6jk_`S l3mn65@>)?I3o>p_`'() qr s )/) t6u(>)v)wxSy8@\@z{|6}~ 6w@./7 OPSRo ../A eDI. /AB BD6W8@)3)r78@<^>) ?I JK ./ w>) H8@X )./`6w@)/ .;2I)6p_` ?9 8/ BDE?;);63w@)/LMN. ¡8@¢_`w>2IW£,q¤);¥p_` qr );9¦9342 9ILMN ¡§¨6>8/ 9>89; ))W >@12/9 ©ª) 12/9_` «¬ ®)/. ?.@¯° LMNS±^/);9(z{²³@)42 ?9(X.´)/EV3 9I®)/.. "*µ ¥DS¶_`· ) ¸.¹Sº^>»);¼E©68@½¾¿AB 58@AB58@?>9; )) 9I(L MN S.99(eSÀÁ6Â)@)/s\/)Ã Ä ÅÆI@(8@)) s)/)ÇÈÉ); ¶rÊrs2Ë6 ÌIW))42 VÄÅÆI@(8@)) JÍ()\>»¯° ÎÏ¨¯° ÐÑSAÒÓ ;>ÔÓÕI3 Ö× ©Ã ØÙÚ6Ù8@X(I ;XÛ NE)E) ÜÝ);¯° ÎÏ¨ÐÑS¯°m n ÔÞ \3 ÃH¯° ¨ß¨);àáâ ãV 9IAÒÓ Õ8@äåEI@) >»9>9 \3 );Ã(¤;$*µ'()6LM N Aæ]V./LMN Fç./èéê);ë @\9ILMN FçSìíB î >4¤LM Nèéê);ïðs8/42 ïðs8/(9I>ñ òò( \@>óS.@)3);98/(ôBõ9. z{Söi./. ―229―.

(337) ?.@9 $ *µ ø)ùúV.@¤;¶µ'()6¯° ûüýÄÅQREI/);þ\./9Iø)9 ¥`¥` LMN OPSQR3S]h2@QR./ \\ QR./LMNOPSi>(¡ý H8/Ù) ../ 3V3\Rø)88ø)9V8/ );96<h\./;);9);R6)@V8 /);9 )@V8/(Ri3 )/¥Rs¥ ¤());?I)/¥ ©s)/))42 )/); >) 623>(;¸ ..>NHS2/.I>))X)EXWVE >))/(>) ?I)/ ;.@9>OPS)/ ¶û üý); Aç* V34I@)s(X E(* LMNS)XE( * LMNS(;. * I342 * ); s)/)AÝôÜ 9I¶ûüý 6)@V342 9 ¶ûüý ES .@i@³8../¶ûüý6 * I()E )9´6I@)3 );¶ >) ¶ T ***. ¶ 6)/ T *** ¶); (I¨ ß¾ ¶ T *** ¶);9´6 ïS\~ .\~ V3s2 >@9I`)>)@)39I S6./Ü ); 9> OPS 2342>) OP); FAÝô> ( F62>) FS9;^@Si@ Ë.>) \.@¥` SÜ Ù)>Ü >23?9 Ü);9S^ ../ ?;3]@)3); ÖÅ.&6]^3 .]@)>) >)? 6&6]^>)); V3. >)íB öi./¸>9IS6 .@)3 ¥` >) ¥`¥` LMNOPS2>)? .@Ã ç ÖÖ o>6)@)39I S6.@)3 ¥` >)674I@)3 9I ø) ¥` >)9SÜ;); ) ?9 Íi@HX(I@ØÙÚ >)>);9S íB ./..ôBõV;V) rVI 4s);96>; 6 bS@. ―230―.

(338)

(339)

(340) !" #

(341) $%&'()* +,"

(342) +,!./0123

(343) #!2#45678

(344) 89 :;< =>?@"8!A8 ;BC !

(345) 8DEF8F

(346) GAHI!JK LK=>?KEMN 2#K;

(347) !7E" 56

(348) 56O=>?@L

(349) P#OQR :;OST UP

(350) @E9

(351) 7.

(352) 8DEF

(353) 8!EV. N

(354) 2WO

(355) 2

(356) A8XY

(357) 2

(358) O Z[

(359) \@O. ]^_àbcbdefg

(360) 8DEF

(361) #. ]hijk l mn opgOqrsUO

(362) Atuvtwx" 78W26yx

(363)

(364) ]^_àbcbde fg

(365) 8DEFP

(366) !ze{|}2UP O8

(367) 8 >

(368) " S~!2]^_àbcbdefgP

(369) ! S~! !2" !@>P

(370) . EVN VN

(371)

(372) 8!;A. A. !! ]^_àbcbdefg !x

(373) WO

(374) wx " HU!EVNW

(375)

(376) 88

(377) !O^_àbcbdef

(378) 8!2!@XYO OHU!$@VN

(379) 2@ 7!P# O :;#

(380) 88^_àbcbde f

(381) Z[

(382) \2!XY 7A!2!wx! "

(383) 8

(384) 8yx

(385)

(386) 8XY

(387) L

(388) wx! "

(389) 8 0" :;O26E

(390) 8 à yxEP YWt ¡¢K;£t ¡¤O

(391) >P O A¥¦ ]t ¡g8

(392) 8 ]g E§

(393) Z[

(394) \t ¡Ë© w

(395)

(396) ªe«¬

(397) 7 7!t ¡EFP 12!®¯y

(398) 12°e±²¬#!2#4t ¡³E´ µ

(399) ¤O

(400) ¶9P

(401) . q¶·!/0¸¹P ¶·!ºE¸¹» ¼¡ ½¾t ¡½¾¿OÀ

(402) ÁÂeOÁÂeA@ x¿OÀ

(403)

(404)

(405) t ¡yx O

(406) 8!Ã~ÄÅÆÇ¾

(407) @yÈ./É³¬

(408) !. ―231―.

(409) " 8. A!ÍÎ4 ;;. WP

(410) !t ¡ÏW

(411)

(412) 8!. A!ÐÑÒEÓ§. !Z[

(413) \561!QRE

(414)

(415) 8t ¡!UP

(416) @EQR 12!®¯y#

(417) 8!8ÔÕE½2!Ö× OØ1ÙÚ6QRE QRx

(418) 8ÛÜ!ÝÞP

(419) 7¸ß¾

(420) !}eà!ÛÜ}e àE

(421) O¹» yx#¼áy

(422) yÈ./â ³

(423) ! ¼á½ãyx

(424)

(425) 8

(426) L

(427)

(428) 8 26yx

(429)

(430) 8#@ä

(431) 26åæçè!¼ áOéP

(432) êëìæçí îï

(433) ½í# ½èã!ðñòËÌçèã"

(434) ó!ôõö ÷¼á¼áøù O ìú :; æ ç èã

(435) 8û4üPýþ¾x:;4ü8A

(436)

(437) 2æ ç2!1U 2!½!È A!! ¹P

(438) ¼áÈ" 2!½ !È ¹ O:SSyx

(439)

(440) 8! Ä! 7!½U!½!E @K

(441) E »#

(442) {E

(443) N» E ³EP

(444) Çõ87!½! Èäw

(445)

(446) !¼áHUEy O Ey. HU!wxE OãE

(447) 7!

(448) ã ¼á UEY ä

(449) õ

(450) O yx

(451) ;E#O»

(452) {bÐ_

(453) 7!{bÐ_

(454) 7 U #7!UO

(455) !!E

(456) #!10 7E6

(457) w:

(458) !107UO

(459) UO

(460) Ayx

(461) @Oyx

(462)

(463) 8 #@ä WO

(464) " #

(465) " . Ayx

(466)

(467) 8E7;" #

(468) @>P

(469)

(470) yx

(471) !# @>P

(472) # A$Õ E

(473) Oyx

(474) . A¼áE

(475) 0O. yx

(476)

(477) 8WO

(478) " #

(479) !tHU! yx

(480) 2A½2

(481) :; W

(482) W ¨WW

(483) W Wy

(484) yx

(485)

(486) #@. ―232―. Aqy.

(487)

(488)

(489) . !" #$%&'. ()*+,-!./ (01 +234 567&89.:; )$:;<=*+, - +- >? @AB!.. CD. $ $$ EF!GH9 IJKJL; MN O9$ 7&@AB9PQRSQR*+, -TUVWX!YZ:;[-$ IMNOMN\] ^_W`!ab$ 9:cdefg hf. iZ$[-ijk . c :;lmc I7O;7\]^ _W`!ab$Zn. :;o[-(. )pqrstuT!$ =9 ( *+,-

(490) Z7vwvc xy

(491) ^zJn\v!{$c=/ . MN\]|xy. }X~VVs!)b$Z9[- #c :;! ? ^

(492) $ " ()!-)' )!./ $ )! . !G . ! . . G (^!W!G Z+ L:i ¡:!7: ¢$$$ N£ ¤¤¤¥:H91!$Z N £ ¤¤¤¥:n ¦¤§¨©¡ª«¬®¯ °[ ±² ³ =9 $$ *+,-´$³=[- ³¶ g9$·¸s $$ . (µ. ! . H9G . 0 ¹ºr»¼½¾¾¸!$ . ¿ÀÁ. Â}»V "]ÃK ÄÅU:;ÆÇÈÉÊËr ÌÍÎ$Z =c9 #c :fÅU:;!. ÏÐ!ÑÒ&&. ;Ó[-( ÅU:;. !.ÔÕ Ö9c×. $$ Ø?G . !G . Ù³¶. GGÚ. () ³Û Ú ÜÝÚÞ? ³. ßà!.ZZ á!G. ―233―. !G. (.

(493) äÕåÚ=

(494) ) !%Þ?gæç=ÅU :;. c[- ÅUèéêë- P:. ¹º!ìí$Zë- B!ìí$Zë- îï ðï[- ñ. òó ë- P:. . )¿Àôõ =Z :f ö ñ ¾r÷r)!.!÷r=)!. !G. . "µµøùjÓ. ³) ú$ üý 9× þ% ). . !. =û $$. !G . =c[- ÅU:;!.ÏÐ!$. Z ÅUè_ PS]

(495) Z9 . . c )G.Z ÆÇ$Z÷rè9 !c ) ° () ¤Q/ ©