反実在論的な真理概念の特徴づけをめぐる困難について

全文

(1)Shiga University. ¬®¯°±¯U²r ³´¯µ¶·´¯ No. ΐ῔, pp. ῏῕ ῌ ῐῑ, ῐ῎῎῔. ῌ῍.

(2) . On Difficulties Concerning the Characterization of Antiῌrealistic Concept of Truth Hirofumi SAITO. ῌῌ ! "#$"%&' ()*+,-(.

(3) /0 12#3 4! "56789:῏:῍ 1AR: ;<=7> ! ? ;<=2 1@: AB(.2#3CD. E"7F "GHI0"J7>K? "JL! ")M" NO7>Pῐ: M *+,-QR0 S2AB(.2#3CD E"7T ")UV ! W +,-"GXYZM"=7J[\)P ]^? UV. SEG2AB=_G. 2#3CD E"8I0`"/aT ";bc/0P MM7! 2ABG 2#3CD".È ! W+,- +,deUf0ghijGE 7>klmn! o_ 1pq: Nr P GIG! stuvwux(0a! 9I E."E/G4yE"9z(.! M A{ 1AR: I/! 2AB=2#3CD8I0")M"= SNOT pq M"=|I0Pῑ: MM7! EG! ]0]0=2#3CD8I0()M"=>K)! ?Go>.`"GE! ? ()CD8I0M" ! >9R7}OM"=/7 >[\)P NO2#3CD8I0! "A{~0AB ! 19"E#$ ")I/ : ST "5 ~]GE 7>P ]^! 7 0a/! ") =! M Qstuvwux q7>.`P m! ? zYZM"()Pῒ: R! 1AR:. Z 7! N. O! W+,-! S=F "GHI0T ") F B ! S2AB=_G2#3C¡ E"8I0T ") q. "M"(.! ' 1A῎: ()YZ~0῍ 1A῎:. ¢f11f1qBf::£11qBf:f::. 1A῎: f q "G¤Z! ") =! ¥< ¦§ ¨v©s7>P 1῎:. 11q1qBq::£11qBq:q::. 1 ῎ : I/NOª«G. NII-Electronic Library Service.

(4) Shiga University.

(5). ² ³ ´ n. . qqBqqBqq.

(6) . qqBq. q . q. !"#

(7) $% . qBq. &'()* !"#+

(8) $% . Bq. , -.#/0% . qBq. 123*456-7%0 . qBq. &'()* 89+ . qBq.

(9) :$% ;< -= . qBqq. !"

(10) $% . q. 123*456-7%0 . q. >?

(11) @0%1 238ABC

(12) D% S EFGH#I/07%0 JK '() * ABC

(13) D% LM4NOH#I/07%0PQ7ῌ a. fRfy. S. y. '()* !"#. b. fy. S. fy. '()* 89. 7H#

(14) D%TUV%@= a 1 '()*

(15) @0%W XY Z[ !"#I\] 4^_'()*

(16) `Q% abI\]7c dWJ K\] 0ef%0 71gh40ij b 1 '()* ? 238 ?Dk

(17) Wl=H#im inI23*i4c an

(18) op '()* W\] qrIs b

(19) D%1 ^7^7tu1 a7Iv wi0xy^7^7

(20) z{|}~4W140W740 a [O O

(21) W b I}

(22) ?7%@=

(23) '()*

(24) D/0 fy i1 ) 12W\] %040 f I\]%00!0%) 4W0

(25) @0% y I \]%0 0

(26) 4 W fy I\]%0i7c ) 4f% fy I\]%0 w3 f I\]%0a 1 y I\]%0I Q % >?

(27) /07KLGH#Is ^7^71 A q 0 O*423*K=40]

(28) $%1 ¡¢4£¤I-7. ¥¦40 A I')O*4§¨©ª«¬Wim ')O] q I®04c 71')O

(29) $%x

(30) ¯°4±®i. NII-Electronic Library Service.

(31) Shiga University. CD῕(Mῐ·¸¹º»mG¤EF ¼21. ῌ῍. ῌῌ A῎

(32) !"# q $% &ῐ'()*ῐ'(+,-./ 0"123 2456 7$89: ;<= >?῕ @AAB CD῕EFGHIJ KL122῔

(33) ῏ ῐ'()*ῐ'(+,-.24/ MN4$"12OPQ RS(. A/BTUVWXῒ;"122 24JBT A῎ 021 q YBTZ [\1 O]J^ f 2/Bΐ ;". !4/ _$J 2 J" ῐ'()*ῐ'(+,-. T^<PQ^`ῑ. Kῑ24J Sa12 b c+[!4 A῎ 021 q TdABCe D(fghig1jk"10Z kDil;"12$mB 2n^ @ oZB 2np4 qQrstuvwB f q 1ΐ ;"12Jp B T^$ @JB ῐ'()*ῐ'(+,-.kD T^<P Q^bῑ\1il;"12J xyJp qQrsz{B B ῌ|῕i l;"12BT @"B w}u~} ^"?῕ CD῕ \1 } /2/ \1A4 D @4B 2 AR G A῎ 1 B d A 1 J !\1 gGB [\1 @" !\1 CD. ῕ῑEFHIBUVW;"12 q f 1AJGXῒ1 qf JB !4 X=^" ffqfBfqfBff. A. A ^1 ῏ B[ A῎ ^qQ῍qQB[fgGX=1. j!4 qQrstuvw 021 Z f G p Bΐ JGX= pqp BpqpBpp. qQtuvwbqQ῍ ¡[ p qp ¢£"#!2J ¤ $ $% p¥qp !4 p "#!2 ;^ D¦ /4§ JfgG¨JB D¦ bqQ©dª¡BqQGK1j!4 ῏. pqp Bp«qp Bpp. ῏ rs῔P¬ ®!4 ῐ. pqp Bp. JJB qp G¯ ῑ. qp. ῑ °=1 qpp Kῑ12"# p KῑB ῐ !Z ῒ. qp Bp. ῑ ῒ ^ &CeD(fgh±²³3 !\1 ΐ. Bp. ῑ ´ ΐ ^ fghµ¶³G῎21 ῔. qpBp. NII-Electronic Library Service.

(34) Shiga University. ῍ῌ. ² ³ ´ µ. ῒ

(35)

(36) ΐ. qpBp. ΐ

(37) ῔ ῏. qp Bp. !" #$% &'() * ῕. qp Bpp. ῔ ῕

(38) +, -" ῏῎. p. ῏῎

(39)

(40) ῏῏. p. ./ 01 ῐ

(41) ῑ 2 3456 7 qpp 89:;<=> p ? 0 @ ;

(42) A BC)D3456)E<> qpp 890? F89? qp p ?GH=F@ IJ1K 008 L q 8* p 890. MNOP>

(43) @ p . qpp ?QR=-STN 'U89: V 'U?890?WU;L 89@ p XYXZ [O \]^_ -\]àbc I8 V?QR=0?. 89 -STN 'US0 ? V -S'U?de fg " h i .jd*SkP8 IJ1K@ L<> p O U

(44) l89-S'U) 1S@ 0 m WU?no pQRO p ?V. qr=\]àb. c 7IQR=0?89 `s

(45) -SI 89t: p 89 S089@ l'U d V ?QR=Ls uY Gd)àbc 'vOddnoLI 89: V Nw8xwy z- {|}~011S@ p O -S'U) fg " hi- ?<0 -S. <ῌ *IGd 'U dV)l S )=Ls \]^_ -\] àbc?p QRO 008 qp ?QR=O-S@ =kJ p p ?l8 9 S )=Ls \]àbc?p QROO-S@ 0 m f -" p ?QR=0?U

(46) 89@ OL?" qpp VOqpp Q R=@ OL?" p =kJ

(47) 'U q= \]^_ -\]à bc QR?890?^8m0 @ 0 f?^;^_ : f89'kP>

(48) 1S@ΐ ῌῌ fgl\ )<-S=m 8 L \]à \ A I O>O>:

(49) I ?9@ O>O> à knowability \ > -S^89@ K. ¡ff¢Kf. 008 ¢£¤¥89: £¤¥ K ¦¦?a

(50) SNw a§£¤¥ 89@ OL?" K l'U=oa

(51) S ¨©0?8m@ A ª« 0 \ dI {|}~¬.?S0?^;L@ ®¯5°. K. ±<. NII-Electronic Library Service.

(52) Shiga University. H

(53) I$JKC?»¼'<. U. ffKf. ῍ῌ.

(54)

(55) . !" #$% &'( !)*+, $

(56) -./01 K '23456 c. Kfy. 7. KfKy. 89# : 8 d. Kf. 7. $ ῐ <;". f. 6 ;. != # > ; ?

(57) @ K U $ A. 8

(58) B

(59) C @

(60)

(61) '

(62) "ῑ ῌῌ B D$E> ; @ A K F G$H

(63) I$ JKC6 A L H'M NO PL$;Q R -S

(64) ". != JKC. 8 G$T6 H

(65) I'<. $- - $UV8

(66) QFDPWX YF'Z- $LD![8;" \8$ ]^_6

(67) àF8" A K $]bJ'c d # $ef

(68) -. fgXf (Yh /.

(69) 6#$i $] '( 6 f ;!?$jk (Yh /

(70) 6 ljk Xf m no " K '( Xf 6 f p ;;Q A '( Xf 6 f #$ f 'qr D stu' Y= s vw'( x 8 ;" Xf $'( A 6 B K 6 K F L' y z'2-/01{|. # : '(C#$!}68

(71) Q~

(72) = " A '2&88

(73) YF' x/01 B 6 $E'( |!}/

(74) " O$a

(75) $6 qf $" L.a| y'2-= Hjk#

(76) $;" 'q. . K '( 6 p/01' X y/01 K $

(77) !}/ ". 6 $ 'H

(78) '= $d%*

(79) $6

(80) P p F

(81) y $&')B #%*`no" L.a| 6$'6%*$$WX()X`C$' A p$T_ CQ'( H'= $%*L ;Q<K C-C` ¡

(82) PL#$%*$¢£HV*8¤F6

(83) P

(84) '

(85) " 6 $%*"+,-¥$¦.p'2§/

(86) %*$§G WX p$T$¨ ©) YF"ῒ 0 ' s $T'< L H1 YQ§/

(87) %* WXU 2ª;" # 6 $T Hjk# F*'c" \8$I Hjk# « F$63¬«$; «®

(88) -. $j k#$¯k 4«®5;8

(89) °. @ @#$«6R" . I «® '2$«'< L 4«®'± stu²s vw I6A L56 ³

(90) p´6B $;"῏῎ +µ$YF

(91) ¶($T'< $ §/

(92) V*8$·¸6 ¹7º L$;Q D!. NII-Electronic Library Service.

(93) Shiga University. . E ¼ \.

(94) ! "# $%

(95) &# '()*(+ ῍ + ,-./0" 10 234 56378 129 :7 ;<=+ >?9@ A'&'B CD#EFA#G-HD#C)*( + IJ IK ; C+J LM- AANO ;ARP+ Q G-MR IK CJ S C # ')A IC!CJ S CP !Q-TM "(DG IC!CJ SQDG-# " ICAJ S C - CP H "#U VQWC(D#)*( X* C Y# Z$G #US %&#-(-"Q C IKAJ -TM GQD# I J [C IK CJ -- IJ --\]^_A >?9. C'`(%

(96) $ab ;)MR Wright ;+c pp. ῌ .+ d* + Plantinga ;+e + f>ghigj+" ,`kl-m.Qn/A#GQ 0o" p 01-TM qr+" stj3u-v>3w ;Brogaard and Salerno ;+c pp. ῌ .+ CD#xy2AG ,`k z3+"4{5G + %

(97) 6|}7 C~ .#HMR %&%

(98) . ; + Q8Gl / Ro 09 : CD# ; + YC ;+ Q8Gl " - -Q01 'G - ;b+ .# QR-G!. + Brogaard and Salerno ;+c pp. ῌ . + stj3u-v>3w ;Brogaard and Salerno ;+c pp. ῌ .+ ;Rea ;++ d* ;A+ 0.+"xy2 -D#;<FA -(=# -Q Q ;"#>+ ?} @ÂC(-# l"( --! " AAB# " Y# l+"g4C -G + Fitch ; +e Y i+"D # E ;+ d* "A }7 IF%

(99) 0J I`(0J -GHM#EF -. CD# "8¡¢Q3-%

(100) Q-£GQ ;AP+ -.A[ I¤¥¦§g9¨M- J . / .#©ª«K + LMMN # Kvanvig ; +c p. d* >O¬ # Kvanvig ; +c Chap. + Brogaard and Salerno ;+c pp. ῌ . O¬PK FSQQ@C(. Q-.D#Q ^"-( "Gl "N. CD#R®( ;"# 0 ;A+ ®(+ -(N¯ ^ [ + "%

(101) S- °±² T&Q "U T³V'M- ,S´Hµ,WX¶·¸Y¹ FC( ºOXWX Q¢G Y¹ x»Z - -[A ῎. ῌ. Brogaard, B. and Salerno, J. ;+ “Antiῌrealism, Theism and the Conditional Fallacy,” Noûs : , ῌ . Fitch, F. ; + “A Logical Analysis of Some Value Concepts,” The Journal of Symbolic Logic , ῌ . Kvanvig, J. ; + The Knowability Paradox, Oxford. Plantinga, A. ;+ “How to Be an Antiῌrealist,” Proceedings and Addresses of the American Philosophical Association, : , ῌ . Rea, M. ;+ “Theism and Epistemic TruthῌEquivalences,” Noûs : , ῌ .. NII-Electronic Library Service.

(102) Shiga University. '()*+,-./0123456789:. Wright, C. Realism, Meaning and Truth, Blackwell. ῌῌ

(103) ! ῌ" # $ ῍ %&. NII-Electronic Library Service.

(104)