ジェンダーと暴力 : 宅間被告の公判から

全文

(1)人間関係研究（南山大学人間関係研究センター紀要）, 3, 227-246.. . .

(2) . ½¾¿À½ÁÀÂ Ã¯e0ÄÅ0¾Æ ÇÈ³´ÉÊ. . .

(3). Á

(4) Â.

(5) !"#$%&'()#*+,-./012)#3453 "678#9:;)."<=>?@A/9BCDE 9".F"GH9I"#$%J"#9KLMNOP,Q RST6UV2WX.7YM/Z9[,9U#$%HK\UV ,]H"678#$. ^_àUb""69#$%. . [Nc,S% cTdGe01f)#012N"$XTaghi/"Mc/,j" [N/kl,m"86"/nH"#$% opq rs9#96t\7"% upvw/hix/"My zjX#96% {"H6"aM"M|}~AHchic/V$ d%Kc/,UV99KTdG ,]6"/n"#$% { ,1"#91ag -,$.NhiA y?}~|oKM"H6 ¡¢£/¤¥¦§DE$.¨6S©ª«¬$.2®96% K¯°1>±@²³´µ¶/ag7XN\: ¨,$.¨·¸ ,aM¹9"\d/"Mc/³´º»6. ―227―.

(6) S,¦.ËqÌÍÎ«¬FÏÐÑ¦"\-F7/ d«Ò9BC9"#96%,ÓdGgÔÕLM,BÖ,ag -A y?}~|o-

(7) ~×q@Ø -¨· ,ÙÚH®9".¨6SÛ«¬-H"#$% Ô0, ,Ü6ÝdGÞß#"Y"YNhi àX6¨6 S@á

(8) â@á

(9) KáãÌÍÎ/" Mc/,ÙÚH8#96%µVäå,KM"M®2)./æç9 \7"% è1é/"Mêë2ì").aNV$.7YM/nHÓ GT6Fg".d/n"#$%{ccef,Ú6Híîï_9" #$%NðKN,ñòH".d/"Mc/N$% )®ó2ô86/8z õ?aNöM,÷ø96dù9n"ú 9\7"%ûW-yoü,ýþ ¡/hiýþ ¡//"M @26\#96%è12ýþú]9"6/"Mc/ g)H)¨ýþ ¡N7/nÚTKc/ õ?ýþ ¡cjc/jN6÷øf1,Ú6H9"#9 6% õ?6"Û,Y9"igH"./n"#96%)T/ gNc/96%ýþ ¡¨6Shi,9-$"¨6 S)#3%9-$"¨6Sg)#3%KM).,g ÚGKM÷øT6c/,LHB,6\ýþ H" .¨6S2³,9","-GTNd,GH6¨6 Sg".$%KTýþ ¡7XN\¨6S,/Hg )6dg$ýþ ¡).dLMN÷ø2T"6% ûW/"ML\/Nc/ì"N"$%9d9t ú92¨,aM"M.d%G,tú99d#N"¨g6\ "#$%[N7H 9"/8Ndtú99d#N"9 M% tú9,ýþ ¡/2ñ$.LMNc/ì""./{6Ss ,ýþ ¡HNdN"¨6SNdN/"MKM"Ms 2#T"8#$%ÔÕLMNc/)#$L%;¨//" Md6S÷øT"\/;¨H9-$"¨N7/ù 9#/g,mTKNN"/nMc/,á} T "H9#"#$%cTz×@2{6S,aLMNá}. $.d/"M/#H6\ÔÕc/$% è1éýþ ¡)#3%Kc/µgSYH8 ÚdH".c/$XTag)®ó2ô81gN\ÚdH6c/ $%,gddÚGKc/d2!6T66,ýþ ¡ u6"Û,Y9"¨6SN7x/t.t22#96%. ―228―.

(10)

(11) . !"#$% &'#($)%. *+.

(12) ,-./0*

(13) 012./3012 456789&: ;<=#> -$?+

(14) <./0$@* &+,<A %BCD-; -*+./EE;F84 ./<AB%*+B GH<IJKG>LMNOH>./PQR STU8VWXQ @Y Z[A>\T]^ 9_`QXa ./

(15) <b> &c456789de$ f<-%g+*;GA:h>

(16) <ij; -*+ ekeHAB%*+,lme-*+nmoBlm c <pqr./b>+010*+,%>-s Bt o u;<vHw,>)%*+ 01xxy<AB%*+- 01x z-;{lm c< ./b>@* eE&|}A%B~,;-*+ $>|}2%*H,;-*+ y <~, -;&)%*+ A>x- : x~ < -*H, -u;~;-lm c<./b>@* &E E;<'#:,>) -*H,$keH =G, :A; #%*&. A- c$. fe~O$ <AB%*+EE;<< & -*+ d,¡¢:&;o£#¡I¤ -*¥¦¦¦§ ¨© -01./012 ª«¬lm-*+§R ®X¯8°±® ./-nY 01²<³#%*+,-nY´µ ¶+R ® X¯8°±® 01² z ./01-e ·¦¬lYe*+ ./ ¸¹&:ºf$ )

(17) $°»X¼® ./ EE;½¾ k$¿À$Á -;&'#> -*+ Â >&:°»X¼®./`86Ã®T $

(18) Ä-*+2A ÅÆk ;Ç "#:,$% )%$ +ÅÆ<È ÉÊËÌÍ:, Î Ï$&;& GH-ÐÑÒÓ¡&B<ÔÕ&, . ―229―.

(19) -*< °»X¼®¸¹ØÄÙÚ<

(20) z-ÛBÜ$ ÝJ;./. !"# eE& <<x¡;H,. ¡H;R®Þ-A>Éß$%$ +$'#~g>k <AB%$ +kà#O:,>)%*H,A-á

(21) Y <â~, GH-*+ á

(22) Y ã

(23) %-n Y e -*+kA ÅÆÈ$ Éä &HØÄÙÚ åæÀ çâ$ & $&$âg;èé²<êëì z -c& í¨'# + ØÄÙÚ

(24) PQR STU8VWXQ îÓ2-*+ï

(25) ç <%$ + ðfi$./b>ñH

(26) -*+C åæÀ çi$òó<èô$ A&$â*& '#%$ +$&$õÅö ÷ø<ùú:,;+ûøü B ý;Oþü%*<,-dk&:;+z- ,-c& í¨-"#@E'# < ÅÆe GH-*+ tIEE;c& í¨'#%*+c<nmij $ â

(27) -*+£#¡ =- ~ Q ^Ã®Qk k kA>nx @-â*o;'# -*+ KA>- -A ÅÆ. fo;B%$ + eØÄÙÚ<

(28) - $ ÄG -*H,ÕËÌ<& B$%$ +<($f,; -*+, -Å%$ +c<u;~= o ;<

(29) Ä; & y $fe~O$%$ +$ : ÄÊ -< y$f, -*+

(30) y $nY¡&B & y -$ +,i$ØÄÙÚ $ &&G&:;< e eEo;=%$ +~:gA k:$?;n;> e&:$?ße $%$ + yñH$%$ +,t -*;fn m Xa f~$%$ +£#¡%%-kA A>ó$ nm ´<mr;ij-$&;& + $f,>

(31) Åf,>

(32) $& $'#:,;o;=ËÌ=- f~=. ―230―.

(33)

(34)

(35) !"# $%"&" '() *

(36) +,-. /0. . /1 234 5167-. 891:; < $%"+,-=)>

(37) *67-? @67AB!%" C<1!%" D. <E8. <FGHIJI<( 1!%"

(38) KLM

(39) N - O7 ?P-QRSGT %*< U)VW XYZ[\]^_àXbc-Fd6e?<f

(40) -. 67g < <%"Khijkg -lmno

(41) &"p"q1e Fdr stugvwT)??5G"&xu y y z{stewT) *e@|}~wT)

(42) o 5"z z5 -eG&"-1)8-1G " g" 8T G"#. a"Kg8 e a" 1. !x"# G<G"#. 11o 1&"a" "Ke9oN 1. ! u?a"&1. !"#

(43) & <T )Uo"# uKGa"K ¡ " ¢"£¤; ¥

(44) <? ¢"£¤ ¡e5G

(45) ¦[ \X"K " ¢"K ¡ ¦[\X "a"§? ¡e5GT¦[\X 1 ¢ag 1¢ u?a" &1 ¨©ª~«¨©¬"K""K «

(46) &©5) ®?¯ ¨©q°±²³´µ¡¨¶«1N G < 0. P·¸¹ºN. <;. »¼y½½y¾¿À". K&9-©5) Ádr¥ Â"ÃÄÅÆ<?g%"& ¦[\X g ÇdÈ-ÉÊ UNËUÌÍÎÏUÐÏRÑNe5 )

(47) Ò ÓÔ)"ÕÖR<?d%"& C$. &. ea&Çgea""&". ―231―.

(48) ³´µ¡Ù¶ " &91ÚÛ5G"ÜÝG ³´µ¡Ù¶-¬ ¬ 89-© GÞ Ádr¥ ß"ÃÄÅÆ<?%& ¦[\X <? ÇdÈ-ÉÊ¬ àá â ãä1nå<d N% & e¬"<!"æ- ¨©ÜÝ a"&&"¬"&<5G "& <5G"¨©ÜÝN G"&" u³ ´µ¡¨¶ ¢¨©<q«1"1 < 0 ©éê¨ëq«ê¨ë-1 Á. çè. ©5GÞ. dr¢? E«GÃÄ

(49) 1Gg%"&. ¦[\X 1¢ Ç. É¾E%"©5G!1! ì-. ì íUN" îïeð !" ñò-ó{|ô %"

(50) e ê¨ëGa ¬g8 1Þ Á. dr¢? 1g%õ|ö÷ø& ¦[\X. & ù8"#0. $. 5úûüê¨ëe ¬" dr. ¢? 1g"ÜÝG" 5)-<ý" :e¢" ¬"!1o

(51) rd¥<G T<¥x. þ8<

(52) &" ê¨ë©G. d¥<(G"# 8<¥1«- u'e G ê¨ë ¾À ½¾Èy½¾È<1

(53) & Áe

(54) dr¢? 1g"&" Ç U)É¾¬E%"©5G!£¤e1 ì. Óo )G18 ¬+¬E%"© . õ|ö÷ø& eN-a"&" ¨©-²"&ÜÝN G&"e©5G&" '¥e a!"&" qÙ-¡G"# íUNoð à%

(55) ÚÛ5G!1!x $ Óo ) àá â%"

(56) ¬+1!x $ ' ¬"5G"#0. xx1 }<.

(57) 11`1 e5)

(58) 1` <- a "&"e5Ga e<. nåû "&"<5G"#! ¨©eÜÝG9- "&<5G ¬"&<5G"æ-Ð1. ―232―.

(59)

(60) . !"!. #$%& '() !$*+)'( ,-(-./)0$12.)"3! 4506789':.! ; <= #:.! $.!. $ ..) 0>.!? $ $@A 0B4C&.!? 0D. E0!F.GHIJKLMN 0/)(:OPQ

(61) RST( U(3!G . )" 3!/)V. WX;?!YZ[0.%\] ^. !.0)V0_à4.. 0$bcdeKfgh.N<i jklmn opqrs t. !?u]v ). fP4 !?. X(w!qxyh. . 0$3z(0.F.{|.:}~N%.{|0 :0$"? }~s(.N>l("?(Pf 4 0.f 4 $h(n (l 3!Y2?N 0'("? sT( /f'(.0 u]PD opqr 4 !.w!(:O.!)0E M.N. opqr'dx /) qx ¡¢; !?.N £¤¥¦§ dx $¨©ª«¬:.)

(62) ®:.)

(63) $/)¯°(?.N 0± f.) :² '(`³Iw!$"X ´ . X"XUd. :µ´(/fN :¶·0¡¢B4 $/fN ¸¹º »Xº¨¬Td :N ¼½.f/¾.N ¸¹º:¶·: ¤:; f`³I(w$"X. XUu]¿ÀUu. ] ¶· ÁÂ Ã ÃÄ¶·À

(64) $¿u]('.Å? N 0ÆÂ ÃÇÄ ÃÈÈÉh.N 0.. ―233―.

(65) ÌAÍÎ'(ÏÐdÑCÒ$ÓÔN Õ. Å

(66) ( Ö×$lm$ÒØ$ Ù? ('.ÚÛ..N P

(67) ÅmÜ 4 !.uu]mÜ$bÝd¨.)0ÞßI ÚÛ: .N ¶·RS:¼½ àá.) âãä$ åæ('f Nç È (è. X$¿Å?) M'u]. B4.)Üé$/$.N fÜ opqr dêëIx // Uìí dx `³Iw!

(68) î ;Àïð(u]v) ñÕòló.ô¶ò l(4..N w!

(69) Uðõ$ opqr'(#(ö.:u]v). #:÷P .)0 dx . øð IÍùgh.MN 0:bcdeKu](Õ. Uw!ú5.!)M opqr/û .)P4 øh5s$u]v)üýþý(u] v)²Ns² ²D.N Õ p$ü.$; Ã È ÈTN ó

(70) P.:hk !)Md? f f;. 5.. þ . f fNN:s$². 0 5( $}:( i$3 Tú 0 &.N /) /) À

(71) (ö./) Îf

(72) (ö.XIu] Õ (v)sT! MvfaE. . . $jkiv) .N dx $/) KdbÝK$.i( )u]v.)00 .N f>.) .:.)Y2N ´ fYZ IYZ:²P.N P

(73) f(. ―234―.

(74)

(75) !"#$%&'($ )%*+$%,*%-./012 . !"01&3$+"$45$. 678&3$+". $%"9:;<

(76) =$>!?@5$ ABCDEF!"GHIJ. KH7LMN8OPQRS7TUVW&. (%X&;Y$%"Z[\]-. *,YY^_&`>. ab6cdeHSfg!&h%. &;Y. iSfjdk!Vlmn<!&o;Yh&6cde !Y-&$*p@$%YXqr &%"\Y-!*% -X<stuv. &6cdeY. w;xyqr&%"%>. Y6789:

(77) &x()!wg" . . $SHSf ¡ ¢£¤¥¦§ 9:;<

(78) !Y-

(79) z{. |@g}$!~$!$!. !"\! Y- ! . . w;

(80). . )"$Y. !Y

(81) !. -;

(82) .

(83)

(84)

(85)

(86) ]$NdY

(87) .

(88) Y. !"

(89) w

(90) [$

(91) %,. ―235―.

(92) Y¨--4<

(93)

(94) %YY

(95) . . YY

(96) ©**%";-!. ª«$$%2¬Y$®>$% -YY

(97) ;-!". $¯Y!°*±². >!. ³´\!cµR8f&¶w·&¶w¸!!"9¹" !Y%º»¼²(%<½°*·& ¶w%"(h¾(¿¾À!"Á@ <!Â<5$!%Á@<! Äw(Å$&-. h,Ã *. <"(¿,YÆ*%$¯YY¨ YY

(98) . -ÇÈ$;-!. «*$Y. |@gÉ¿ÊËYÌ\*!"ÍÀ!"±Î&¶w*%Í ÀÏÀ&ÐÏÀ¾ÑÒ&Ó$*%% <°*±². X<,!"ÔÕh%-. Ö×&"!<-%¨ ;%,ØÙ$ÕYY°*±²&%\<$*%(. w . $ÚYº»

(99) &Û@$%-YY

(100) YÜ "wg"¸!Å$Ü$¶wÝ>"w g". . *Ô%X ( (stÞ°w"

(101) &¸!!"9¹"$% Y%-&±²$*%ŸY*

(102) & '¸!Ü- *(% $¯Y!%$%"¸ $¯Y 'YYßà&Ü-. *&$!¶wÝ>. (%Y(%<áNâd( .$-ã Ôä&åæ,\Ã%"<çèå"+ Â;Ô%Xéê(-YY

(103) ë&ìwY-&$ éê. $éê-YY

(104) (Üwp. @*$%wíî-YYï

(105) (Ãí" $p@"*$% -YY-ð}$ð~$ ð<,Y-&µeñµeñÃ'! "íî<Ã. !ò. ó»$!ôÃõ. óö%YÃ÷ à$Y,!"ø÷ %,!"àyú. $!$YY

(106) . $¯Y%"Y«ùØ©*$. X<óîÅ$<ûü. -&¸!Ã¶wÝ>"Y(%\<w. . . %,ýÂ;Ã%Yíî%Xóî%X$þw"eSd *¨íî$í%X-YY

(107) &X. ―236―.

(108)

(109) !"!

(110) #$%&'. ()*+, , -./0. 1234. 526-.3 #$%&'67 893:;<=4,>28= !. ?@ ;:A. 5 !;BCD

(111) 3:A. EF53G=HI 3* :AJKLM6 N, OJPN4! !QR. STUT1V 3

(112) W,H

(113) XX. 1P Y Y

(114) Z [ 3:A. 5;

(115)

(116) . BCD

(117) 63(A;;2S\6],^_6` /,5

(118) C X

(119)

(120) a;N25WP !J 52. b@ , . cd6e*1fgh i ! !-.. jk. 46-.l!, I

(121) =

(122) N,!63mno pqrstuvw%o6xyz6OJK{|}*S~*, cd "26 O)lK114! !OJ , *

(123) WK

(124)

(125) 6PC lKcd6e N, , 6-.6l. jk 63X. 1WN,. N *

(126) N*

(127) 6ZN3cd6e*S , -Pc6

(128) P4 ;gW

(129) C , *3. jk 3IC3. *E;jkO*+,=;cd*c 6PY!*.

(130) 6Pl!. X 3J6. ;F* ! , WZ¡*3 o¢£K

(131) 4!3*¤N526¥¦§4. ¨©ª«,¬, 3 ;®}¯=6OJ;cd¨©3°*cdCOK. ±!²£³'£´µ¶·´µKcdCª¸c¹ ,!OK ±!cdCºa*»z COJK IC36»zC !6526-.; ¼*½¾¿À ½¾³%ÁÂ'£ !Ã?. xIN. 4 ;Ä !J*

(132) N, 3 ¨©A

(133) =, =@*ÅÆ,Ã ;4! !¨©ª«6Ç È*16"!

(134) Y Y

(135) -.3. w#Én6ÈÊ*Ë%ÌÍn%ÁOÎ !. Ï ,12. 3Ë%ÌÍn%Á !; K! !Ð!*Ñ'ÁÏ. ―237―.

(136) ,Ô3ÕÔ6Ñ'Á6Ë%ÌÍn%Á 36l!Ö. Ö. N,. 6×Ø, ,=P Ù. w#ÉnØ,=P Ë%ÌÍn%Á !ÚI2[Ï , 346Û*Ñ'Á6Ü. Ï ,123Ë%ÌÍn%Á !ÚI2[. !Y*O;

(137). *ÝÞ

(138) ÌÍ'KµßPÏ. Ë%ÌÍn%Á !Z¡. Cà , . l163. . 6Z¡;4! !áâ;12 WC. !;

(139) =ãYO !6;

(140). *,= W6. Y Y

(141) KN, ,=4! !ä[åæ*, 3

(142). *,31JçWèé,g X IC36. X261JçW¾6ê*ë ,ìWíîW! K

(143) ï|* µß3 61JçW6e*;= W6 Y Y

(144) ä6. ðN, . Ë%ÌÍn%Á !ä[6¬ñ3. ;òó;

(145) =ï|*ô}

(146) ä[3l6"!

(147) OõÚö*÷ ,KË%ÌÍn%Á !ÚI2[ !6;46ä[øN, *"N,ô}*ùN, =

(148) ;

(149) 31

(150) . 3[

(151) l !úû}. üÔ346Ô[6SZSZ*Ký. þ, 3 Õ1JçW*;= W6. N, Z ;l. 6"!

(152) . N, 6±!1JçW*;"!3. }

(153) . 123. ,. ,

(154) ". !33K!S1JçW*;OÖ. Y!3. 12. 3OÖ Y!3

(155) 63C lK X261JçW; 4 lW

(156) Ð!*,N, V 3 4!=63 Oõ6JçW6«·61JçW; õ61JçW;c36* aõ. 7! !O. 236«·;

(157). 2 a*cd·,,cd,, =Y Oõ61JçW;4 3*LKIC32Oõ !6;ü*÷Ô,KI

(158) 6Lõ;

(159)

(160) ¼

(161) «·3Oõ; IX ,, !63 ,@*6Lõ;1JçW;ü *N2P 46-46g * * PN

(162) C X

(163)

(164) "N,6Lõ;,1Jç WBCD ,PP*PZ¡C }

(165) -O)lK6õ !;46È6*N,

(166) 6 3 ü*÷Ô,KI

(167)

(168) Ì2*Oõ61Jç. ―238―.

(169)

(170) . !"#$%&'! ()*!+!,. *-.(/()/()0*-.&'! 1 2 345 67%8# 9%8#

(171) !5. 5 . :-(;5 5<0.=5>? $,( @AB !4,C%,!DEF0@5 . . \ Ki ¡¢£¤¤¤¥¦§¨ 5:-(;%G%!!0G H0IJ ! . 5IJ:KL%. 5:-(; M5:. -(;NOPQR0ST05U5VW5XYZ [B0! ST-' 0-,. -.5U5VW5X%YZ [B. 0!!ST 0.C !55\5 !]^ 0IJ_5\* -`5\* -:!a. 5b* -c. !c* -d d5@%, -:!eL5\EZ0 fg ! 5fg5\hij,k !M'5I J:i5\505lmQ05. !5n @. o% IJ5p 0

(172) q,C%rstF05 uv. 55wx y#z 4 !!. {|!}i5 -.eL5\%EZ0fg:, wx y# z !{|J:, %5EZ5fgE~40i IJ !%0i *!% Q%0, !:,) 4 !!,<0.!5,. ―239―.

(173) 0.% ©ª©0!!EZ0fg , «¬M#0!5-5©ª©0! !. 45M'5IJ05 55®¯°,5- 2 G5E~* -±"0!5EZ5fg«¬5lmQ % ,55 ! :5²*.4 %¯5* ±! ,*%³´%uv:i,©ª©0! ! µC wx. 5y#z 4 !!¶·05. ST©ª©0!. 5M'5¸.: 'i. 54 !ST !. y#¹C 4,º!, !. 5º!{|J5}i%!,(%F» !,¼5½* -¾*(%¿ 4*! 4. 5\. 5y#z. 51%À,uv%Á,. -.«¬5!IJÂ0% 4. . ,5 Ã$,(MMn !³´ 45 <0!!0IJ !Ä 4:0_ 0-%(;,*(5º`Å-, 2!!{ |J-Ä 0! ,.55_: !IJlmQ%0 .0!)E~%0 50«¬`05% %aÆ!5* Ç*0: `5aÆ! ! *C* - !. 0. !#0! -. ½È5ÉÊËÌQ5675ÍLÎ«. ¬5ÏÐÑ ± 59-.5ÒÓk"#` aÔ4 (i !ÈÕ! !10Ö× QÉ 9-.45«¬±"k. 55a5ÔØ ' !55%-0!IJ5EF0MÙ:%{".= 5IJ«¬ C 1 lmQ%0.=E~%0 !!. $,(¿ÚÛ !4 ±!. !. 9-.5{"iÎÜ®%1 $,(5X%:!!0x4 Ý'#. ,i:!Þ%Â0%0,i !. :"# 2,1%0L005 -0:, `05 - _%0-,51 - 0% aÆ!5 - 2",i: y#,ißày#,i !9-.5!!0Ý'$,(5X%á < 09-.Ý'#.5 !. :5- !. ,.«¬:-«¬*-.*C05* -± . oâ 25# «¬5ã. ―240―.

(174)

(175)

(176) . !"#$%&'()*+)*. --.. &' ,. &' ,!/01234. 56789:-;

(177) ()*<2, -=156>?

(178) 2@AB

(179) . 9. CDE ,. 2

(180) FGHB. !,EIJ-9K. L-LLMN. -OPQR. -!,9S. TC99SUVW XUV= YZ [\]

(181) 7^-9S_`W âb;2 c-`TCdeZfF<

(182) gGc_. 49S_. hi9SjU. -hi9. SjUF49Skl

(183) -1,m

(184) 3 n!1< *9Sc< 7 op;1 9Sopc 7 411c< qLr sFt;H. 9Sopc 7 . uv5c3w cG

(185) _. !

(186) xyxz{|}~2. t!|}~!xcp!?2 9S 32c 7 uv5c3w cG

(187) _.

(188) 3 F 7 sF& G~c. 9S G~)rc9S;*2

(189) F& 7 nF&9

(190) F-1

(191) 7 ^1,49S1*2

(192) ` uv5F-3w F-1

(193)

(194) _.

(195) . xn G~^9S`c G~)rc56 F9F1:!:2=11 @P1- *_ _ ut3w r2_. ―241―. J1W.

(196) *_.

(197) u~. . 3w. ;GU 7 b

(198) ^ G~r5¡. -32Ft G~)r¢¢

(199) . Ft ` r2_.

(200) . G~r. £¤2OE¥¦2c. !,4@A1< *F G~)s< *§ OE¥¦pc,

(201) 7Y¨:

(202) 3!*2OE¥¦pc1©

(203) ª

(204) g_ _. . r2. u~. -O9 . 3w.

(205) u«¬®

(206) 3w G~)rcr. ¯. -. r!. °G

(207) G~)rp~.

(208) ,B,;!,¯ 2 _. -32=!=9±. --!9

(209) 3n. xT2²-³T=°

(210) G2! ´µ¶·°

(211) 7 !

(212) G~c9S G~) rc9S F¸

(213) G~cpr -92Fp G~)r- F

(214) ,

(215)

(216) ;- 56. cp;¹. º°

(217) »¯¹. s§ ¼2

(218) ¸

(219) = 9S*7X1½

(220) 1a¾

(221) Z[2¿ À-1!=. !ÁÂ

(222) 9S2P. < *LL1>,= !,x! G~c9S!-p2Ã= 7 -Ä 2-ÁÂÅÆÇ9S1!

(223) xyOP9S Èts!,É9S!, G~)rc

(224) 2)2)

(225) ,. B1¯. *72µ¶= 7 . ―242―. -=!p2Ã.

(226)

(227) !"#$%& '()*+,-./0123

(228) 456789:;<11 =12>?( @ABCD4. ! CDEF#2>GH 3.

(229) I4 JKL . !MN. !O04PQ. !1 JK(R%S 5T4U VWX. !>JK"Y8Z(R%[,\823] #G2ABCD4. ! CD^_48(8. U VWX !`1aaa8Hbc-F> >de8fg (2O0 G2K 8 6hi K . !H ` Fj (K kl0. o>8(n. 846hi K 4. 4m:(n !`:8p. 0 (5

(230) 2-7 q#9789:>- >3(3r sK . !-0Ft. deuv w. xyL1G4z{>. >|}~G191G26hi K 4789:. !#K . !5T. 20u(. 8(r

(231) 4F#1a # `K ,23G0-Fq#9- 7u sK . !-0Ftv w. yL. 1-01p8:((>( z{>>p#0 6hi K . !4

(232) 41Gw`1( . !. 2Y0q3p0

(233) 4OK 1M38 `> 4K 4 !1 F@ Eg0 r

(234) 4w(3. !4:81"Y8#@. ]0E. -3HbH01HL o>S#G88 # >:8 148K . I>*+:38(¡ 2. 0F8¢2£:¤#8 !. . ]0 18::812H+0. (¥¦§H0:"Y8 ¨©ª«¬4®¯°]0 ±H> ²³4'8 (´µ3(. ―243―.

(235) 4Om:]0±:¸i0 2"Y'2 ]0 ²³8 (q#¹µ8 4. !]0`18:a1. 8: !~º»X]08 (G*+04 !48:¼- 1¯%*+8Y8=#½(-*+,4. !. Hb!JHb789:;<\0O0 4!JO04. !>¾¿H1G4. ) `) (H3. ! 4!J À ÁÂÃÄ. 8> ^_ÃÄ8

(236) 4O0ÅÆ Ç«È] ÉÊ@. !`^_nE. 3È] Ë Ì`KÍÎ@G28 ]0 Ï0> EHÁÂÐ3 gÒ. !>a>a !J2)ÓÔÕ4. ! hÑ. ! 4G2. 8]3G8> 789:4Ö×Ø0!J( aa8!J>0uÙ0. Ù8. 22

(237) >. Ö×Ø0!JÙ0 de3G#8 >1G4. !"Y8. 8Ú83G28#>

(238) 4]3G0 > !4n Û+Ð ! ÛH3o>2# 2ÜÝÞ ßàáu1G4 !8(3]3G8(3ÜÝÞâ"Y8 1G8(3]3G8 (3. !8 . >; !!J2)1a !4 2ãä9Ù 0 (31 å æ1ç GÐ( O( IY:. ! ä9è Åé. ! ä94S"8 1G2. !2!J)1a!J 4. 2ã#Ù8. Ö×Ø0!J42Ù8uÌ`>8:(ÙI #Ù8> 12. !4. 2ãä9Ù01 . ! hÑG28]3G8. 2Ù0G@. 2]0EH+0:"Y8 . aa8>01 3G031. 2]01 ÀU ê. 4]012Ï80u1. !. ]02ê3G0`(n Û+Ðëu Û+Ð"%OÛ+Ðì3Gí23mO î a a811. 4ï01 ]0. ð#ê3G PQ VWX4. !. !ñòóH½.

(239) 2]F0O82]F0%;ôäõ8 ð#ê3G01(3öm8 (3>G. ―244―.

(240)

(241)

(242) . !". #$%&'. ()$%*+,-. /012304. )567.

(243) 89: *8))567. :$;<= #;>? @A #

(244) #): C*$% MN.:. #;99. * .)* B#:$. ). D$. #$ HI. . E. DFG . );J# KL. OP QRST$T$UVWX. Y

(245) Z Q. RS))QRC*[LJ#KL\".: [L* ]^_à b . . 8:8. :UcZ b #)3defg88h Y

(246) i9_Ùcj:)k #l)m*: . TnS9[L[Lob: QRS. OP. QR*p6

(247) ))QRp6. #B#qM rsp6tuvwp6$x\"p6 ):. # .. yz9p6

(248) )b #): b.

(249) ##[L[C[L*. [La:. # . {|h}~6*b 8.

(250) .. B #. 9h. T

(251) l). B#9. B [L[J#h[ ./012304*))7:. #B. .6. # $ # #)*k #

(252) #Sl). . )7.*$* # . (8 B .)* B#$[C[L #

(253) . . S CBPS i) # i). ):. .¡¢£¤9¥b#¦89§$%. ¨©P [LDª«P $¬G8)):. . #B ®¯D°~) .j±²# ) :g³0´fµ¶·uQR*U ¸¹º6# ¼m*¡¢½fu¾ #c¿S }/012304Á:}g³0´f. ».. :À.mH$¾. ÂÃ¡¢ÄÅ. )ÆÇ. ÈÉC. ¼Ê*ËÌS. )XÍ . UcÎÏ*. bÐ.

(254) 89Ê*Ñ. ―245―.

(255) P~56Õa: Ö× #

(256) ». 9)TzØÙPÚ'~Û . 8)9S. )XÍ . ÜÝÞßàáâ.ãä }/012304. $%ÃåÑ 9. +æØÙçã. èéê. Ó Ô Ô ë ìí }¦89. ÂÃ¦89. îbæØÙçã. }H$¾Ã/012304ÁæÓòóôÓ õó ø ò ò õôò ù ìí úû û üý þþù õ üþ û û þ. ―246―. ïðäñ. ÓÔÔÔìí. /012304öe0÷f.

(257)