役務提供が国内外にわたって行われる場合の消費税 課税について
著者 小島 俊朗
雑誌名 明治学院大学法科大学院ローレビュー = Meiji
Gakuin University Graduate Law School law review
号 13
ページ 51‑60
発行年 2010‑12
その他のタイトル Taxation of Consumption Tax on International Service Transactions in which Services are Provided Inside and Outside Japan
URL http://hdl.handle.net/10723/953
0123
456789 !"#$%&'(
8)#&'*$%+,-.+8/
01234568)#3456.+
8/07898:-;"#47
<=><?@ABCDEB$%+,FG
#3456.+HIJKLMNOPQ RS6TUVWXY8Z[\]^_`W abc87;WdeW8c2 3456fghi8jkl7 ,0m8)nop-L9qX8c2r _stuvwXYWa
xyz{|}~
34568)# !"#3456
\c82.+8/0-;L
\ (/8 8c2#3456\
c83456.+hl8H"P 8)#4567<><E@AB
B89#34_8^2H.+
8/0-;"7348)#
@B8/#3456t3456 8f4+(+,8/0-;"
#B
@ABB834AB
J 7¡ ¢N£¤¥N¦<§B¨©ªª«¨¬ª®
¯°±²³´µ¶·¸¹º»¼¸½¾¿ÀÁ ÂÃÄÅÄ·ÆÇ»
ȨɨʨË
ÌÉ6IÍÎ+Ï
ÐÑ
^Ò8
3456
© uÓfg
ÔÌÕÖÑ×
©£NOOØÙÚNÛ
§Ü¢ÝÞßàáâãä
§ åæçèjk é ê6ë
ì Líî6ïðñ
ò6óôõ 9c08
01234567898 453767 6 7!"6#$3%&'(89 )89*+,-./067003 45189*+01234"56 378*9:;89*+3%<3
=>?/@7A2'0B2C%6D3E
FGH3%/
I JKLJKMNO1P:Q=JK3R S3TU3VW1XQ1YZ/?3JK3 RS3TUMN5[\3[]
^ _`36abL_`36ab 1FQ3_`36abMN5[
\3[]
c defghijklXmn1opX qr7st7uv7wx7yz6{r M453D|}<3=~
a\%F/?3 a6lX
<3La\3 a6o pg3-(q$.[
=?
45([C%7$
>67327453(
[3 fg[1¡H¢£6
3[1%%7 fg[1¡H¢g%£
<3453MRS¤%
3453[(89'8' 1¥H¢¦§¨0'.%<3
¢673[1%F3%/37
3©7ª2¥HE£1745 MRS¤%3[(¨«.%
g%<33¬'7453(8983®
¤%¯°3<3±²³´µ3Q 7345453[(89 83¶·<33F¸737¹3 º(£Wf,-.%g%<33%/
»¼)7´µ3½¾¿'08F½¾3
½¾3893À1´ÁÂÃÄ<3
37¹3º(µÅ3*Æ;0%£
67ª2¥H1XÇ¢£X(=È?7ÉÊ 3ËÌÍ3EF73st7uv\3ÎÉ
3;3µ¯3ÏÀO1893
<7RSM453(ÐÑX0g
ÉÊ3ÎÉ[(8£67ÒÓ Ô¤7ÕÖ6רAÙØ1ÚÛ2E¥H37 8*+X.=Ü?/
ÝÞßàáâ
ã äåæçèéêëçìíî
ïðñòó*+3ô1%<õ6ö÷
ø*+£(/ùú67893×û
=½¾¿?'0üý1 Ã8×û½¾ þÿ01=2374567½¾7899 PNOQ\?½¾|1*DNOQ(7½
¾¿'03óº3µH£193!
3+%½¾þÿ01½¾|37¹1F N»13%/*DNOQ6½¾¿3ïð 3º73ÕÖ61Â3%<337
¾¤%6õ(ö÷ø*+37 9-7XÕÖ6313%
=?/03*+67893½¾¿*DNOQ7
*DNOQ83½¾þÿ013ÛC3RS '0 ;7½¾¿36*DNOQ39 (-'0&7@77¹3º73ÕÖ 61Â.%0'07½¾¿6òó3 º1òó6º!Y3783%/*DNOQ 3 Ã*ÕÖ6"X#º3F¸9
-7X<3~3ÕÖ668$.
&7*DNOQ3%%&6='(-L
)¤Ã&63*+C%67©,A-./?
g/0737/3ö÷ø*+1
£=ùÝ?67&630162g%/
ÛC3RS1"3l¯Xµ¯3RS '7ÛC3453RS'U667g/
½¾|3*D8=?1FNOQ3ÕÖ639 6:;6ö÷ø-3(ÒÓ7<=
>ï\3 =Q=0??´@7ÕÖ6×
$>A>>È=<=>ï\Mö÷ø?3B7 ((7*D8Ô@0&C0'3O51 DX<3)7µ¯3*+3ö÷ø*
+X36gZ7E3ïðñòó*+3
È F¨GiHi×hiHI956J9KØ>Ü2
0123445673898228 82
!
"#$7%&'()0*+,-./-.
0.123405678.9.:;/<=0 .>?@A,&%BC47D8EFGHI,'
%BC48AJKLMN0),38&%BC
$7'%H8-./OPQRHI,*;
S7%&H8-./TUN0VWNXXYZ [8\0O]^AJ43+0),_5*`7V W:Habcd8efO%&4%'8)S+e _,8HI,9RN0)5)47ghij 67ab8cd$-./:8abcd2 k8Kbl:8ml7_5*`&%BC8lno HpX843+7\qO]^Z[4rj3+
,345,Ts7'%H8-./OPQRH I,34;7EF$D8PQROt]^AJH I6uvEF^qwxOHyS7VW:Hab cd8mlO9R3+0),mz4{|07}~
^8q8OPy7X7 [PQR8
abcdO%&'*Xp0*+,mz8}~^]^)0
012345678974 985 !"#$%
&'()*+&'()*,2- ./01 2345627819:; <=5>
5&'()*,5?@ABCDEF%E D4GH IJFKL1M*)*1M*
&NOP9QRST1>35>
234 M*&5>U9NOFVW4 3 X6YZ[8?@AB
\]^- VW_`a4U9bcFd eW5%-5L12fgWIJ8
\]1hi9&'()*+1jklM*
&mnopbcF>M*& 4 3 NOqrstuNOvCwhx9y cF2zk82-82Wb c5> 1{5|}2#$4~%
(*_m
~%o 14GH234GHF
\9 ¡ VW5>Sa¢
m£¤¥¦§¨_*©ª«¬®¯*_
°±*¨²*³*_´µ¶·wo ¸1
¹º»9<¼78½r+¾
¿ÀC Á1ÂÃFÄÅ2>%
3ÂÃE:U9 ¡2Sa¢
¸1KVWF zk8l- ¸ ÆÇ \]5ÂÈF5É:
ÊS1KVWF zk8lL 1IJ \]5ÂÈF%
ED34GH2Ë24<Ìw1ÍF\
ÎÏ Ð0234GH ÑÌ - <Ì ÒÓ5cÔ96782>
%½r+1L1IJ »Õzk\
K:012ÑÌ56789 5 Ö×ÂÃ4543E:55>
FzkØmÙÚoË24EDL1IJ ÛÜ1]2> 5Ö×ÂÃ45»Õ Ýu8FzkØmÙÞo45 L1IJßc àÀC28Fz
kØmÙáo2>58 zkØ1â¿
|}2#$4~%
ãä åæçèéêèGëêèé*Mì*íîïð×
0234567489
!"#$%&'()*+,-'./0 1234 !"'(#567587 )+,-9:;<7=>43-'.
? '()!" '(@A-B@);<7 C43-#B>DE%&FG3+$-H B>< '.!" '()FI JK L#2M3NO+,PQJRS*+,- +$-7<FIJKL QTUVW#XY Z3@[\<>-HB>< 3]>
S^JCZ3'.+_` a#56@58 .Ubcd=>43Z3'.ef>-H
Kghi+jkl#mn opFq KrLstu)vw3jkxyz{@|}0 1A>~jkxyz{ _` vwPQ FI@C4Gf>-HC7Cm opZ
01Z%43-&jkl56FIhs tuvw di@58FIhjkxyz{ _
` vw di@cdA-B@)-B@
+$jkl a)Qa
_@A-B@Z-B@7<@C4 FqKrL234Q #XYjk l+$-KrL234FqKrL#C Z3Qa34SQaA-@3p
#XY-H&Kghi m0 op 01+.UbZcd)e%43Z3@
oKr d#58+ef>4 3-S77f<] ¡ aPQ=>- B@Z-B@7<¢.fZ3@Z-H
?B+m£ op01+.UbZcd) ep@C&'.¤¥ opZcd+$>~.U bZS @C4O<>- 7&¦01
+.UbZcd)C43Z§4S.UbcdC 4¨kA>~? ¨k#O<>- 7Z¥ ©
#XY-HB>< FIJKL Q TU ª.«@S¬A- +Q/®Z
Qa @¯°4±²A-H
q2³-´ !"L
!"µ-K(¶· ¸¹34º»/
¼<½C42<]KO¾¿43-
#KghÀi op85ºÁ Â@? 56K( ÃÄ+!"#ef>- B@S$- +B opZ'.¤l&- !"'(@A- 7¦56K(#$
-ÅÆ !"Ç-'.+SÆÈ5 6K(@A- 7ÉÂ@v ÃL)
!" '(@C4?>Ê> '(+!"=>&
Ë.oÌdA- 7Z¥ ©#XY -HÆÍ56K(#$-'.? K (o$-3? K()Y4!"#
Z=>-@Î=>-B@7<bJ^
56K()!" '(@OA-B@#Ï 3@Ðf>-#ÑÒ#$>~¶ 58+
$-@ÓA-B@S$-+$ÔpHQº ÕÖ!" '()Æ×Ø*A-ÙÚ
#$-@A>~¤ [\Ä op l
&-6Û#¥B+!"=>&7hg\~ÜÝÞ /ßà+? áâ×ãä+$>~? ãä '(io*A-B@#åJ+$-@[\
-HB Ø,âæ ç8èé G3
!" '( *J&%4êëìr op Zí&-r#ef>-'()[îCZ3B@@
C42ïZ§@S¦ [\Ä%43Z 3H&Qºð!"
¬A-ñ²+Z3S Qºòe»ó ôõóö÷høù Z3øú (û×i½ A-K( ¸¹,üý þÿ¶|}
¬A-Kr)epò0AZf01 1
üý IÿC23 45¶)epò0#B
>^JA-B@);<7C43-#B 6 Z[\Ä!"µ-K(¶34SJ 4-@7=>h8i9}bZr+Z§
l&-6Û#ò=>-K(¶@C4S
Z3opÐf>-HB Ø+Qºòe»
óôõó÷Z3CôS01 1/0 Z¥l&-#!"=>-$-3!"=
>-@[\<>-'(#!" '(@=>4 3-H
üý þÿ/+Æ üý#(+
!"#568f&%4ef>-'. QPQ34
0123456785960 125965
!"#$%&'%&()59
6*+,-'9./ 0"12
#$34556789:6+;<5=>
?45@,A4B7CD651EF 78G12<5=HI+4GJK@
2678GLMNO5-P4QRSTU IV;WXY'4Z4[\X]8^_`
a?56,296Lbcdefgh5 6ijLkl12-+B+mncop 5ocqrstmnSuv345 965Bwxyz{mnc|}5
~RS5=<oBQRS55<o
Bgh,6784^oc26
del5 P4mncc 012[\b345cE
gh6+,6,2io
5bc65coc 12,?5c65-"6 +;+;,596B4^b cf#$%&[\X],
6E596L@M6,296O, 6?45-
¡=d¢#$£¤5
#$%&6¥+;,5125 912¥7¦§;P565
¨g5- ¡=d¢©,;#
$34556%&3456#$%&£
¤l596Bw,A4ª«L _`a?w,mncof#$%&6
¬qTU®345¯°±.²³´µ¶
·¸¹º»¼½2¾B¿>ÀÁÂà ÄÅÆÇÈÉ%&ÊË&ÌÍ'ÎÏÐ ÑÒÓÔ%&ÕP4596Bw#$£
¤56345#$%&7Ö5 6×w,-/8^./ 0"WY ØÙÚÛÜ£Ý3Þ5Ý`ß1+s tàÔáXY>,¬q:$£¤5âÒ ÔL5-¬qTUã.£Ýä659 6Bw#$%&å5.$2#$%
&£¤5ã.£Ý3Þ5 65JK@Ö+;,56?45-7G /8^¶æç·M2:$QRTU127 èy<5=Ï#$%&5@
4^%&5èyé3#$%&å5
n5,êy)9:±)ëìíî+
ïð,ñkl,12596bc de5,ïßpòóôõDBwö P+,6785-L÷6LøS@#
$%&<56<=ùIO596ú ,6?45TU[\X]<5ç<
=ùI+;¨ûkl,12596ü ý2-©#$%&~V5þ©,;
#$%&å5n5,êy)9:
±)ÿE'4wª«íîO ,6,201LE5TUz{@M 234'2ª3,;<5ç<=
ùI@i34;,4^J$fL94¥45 965E5L6785-
mncoªW6789!9w¶
·54457 44TU_5×5S'Î94
«A5Så5.$2mnco>
5.$ÕP,6+;
,594w'4Z4oc,269ý Ç>2.$ !"#M.
$,2L6?4ococo
© V 5 $ % & '() '*+, -.*./
(0/-12304,*./"í 5"?6.:
bc+5.$2B7Bª«6Le8@?
Þ;,5-mnco©V5#$%&9 ,;LÇ>2.$2:í
©V5.$2;§+,6+;ð2
<§56?45-
=>?@ABC
WD,2Ec6stmn©,;bc3 4mnSqr59665mnc7F
<G|}34AH6z{xy.:SI E65JK,2-L<mncïß 8M NÿOPQRPoSRPQÙÒTÓUÒV0
01234567895 125 !"#
$%&895'(#)5&8 95*+,-./081232)5
*45647893*:;<89/=!
>?678@A2B'7CDEF&8*
GCH1&IJ45647/KL67M N/OPI795&845647 89*Q!;<893*9545RS 8TU;<V)W/')/.
895D678XY2HI Z8[5D\]8^_D081
[5`a*b7c3de45fghijk jl9mnopqnrstuvwxyz{/.8$
5|}~hijkl9mnqt/
67UDy ht=/)5 yz{#8DXY 2'R&895E/$%2 H/B\]81cy ht/ HB
y{D/h
5}/ H* ¡¢/=!
R£¤¥¦/§27¨5*©ª
«VD¬C33H2®¯°/=!
±)5RS&8²t[5D\
]³81
y ht3*´yz{Dµ/#¢¶
308b·µ/¬C3/2HG!
[5¸9*¹2HºI78Dy ht3
*©ª«V/»Hy{D5}¼
/½H¾8D¿À 0B[5`a*¸9&812D
©ª«/95+ÁDH/*
y{ÂÃ085}¼DÄÅ3UHb 3CÆDÇBÈE¤¦¯°8=©
ª¤É3HG!/ H
µÊ&8b*Ë67H¾81E8
©ª«3EÃ08D3U'7/
WÌ:95D¬K67H8Í
y{DÂÃ085}¼ÎC78 U/*[5DÏ\2Hb3CXÐ*
Ñ123ÆD$%&83`a!
3083Ò3¯Ó*08ÔgÕÖ/
B=H3*H3ºI781
y{Ñ3ÂÃ085}¼Dר677
ÙH&8¾8*ÚÛ9{Ñ3*Ü!
ÝHDÚÛ9{D¤Ñyz{u¦
mÞ¤Oß²àA/¤¦/I8á}
âãäå8b*¾/:H3'=
0¾æ&8@ç*H¾8hèt1
éêëìíîïðñòó
95*Ñô530!5õöDÚÛ9{
÷p á}âãD¤¦/II789545/½H
01 234567589756
!"#$%&
'()*+,-.7/01#234$%&
5678!9:;<7=>?@A=
B$01$CDE7FGH#2IJ$01
#234'KL/;MN$01#234 2AOP$QRSTU/AV7W=>?
@AOX$QRSTU'34Y !<!' .7/01#234Z$+=[\]/012
;OX$^_TU`ab9cdeAfg#
hi7jkYHlJ2<7WZ$+=m6 nAU+!>?@+,-o=pqrsa tAuv/ Y=w=rs7$>?7W Yxab9cdrs$>?yz{|}
$~L/'Y +'A7W
!YHe=.7/01#234Yu AW!H=fg#hi$l J017WZo#$%&7A/ !p n=fgd+,Zo=fg#hi7eH x++,V#2Aab9cd$lJ$pT7 WeHZx78=7W$x
~L!
>?@)TU fg#2IsAj k/ Y/ 8A=
>?@$012 =>?@$l
A$ ¡¢~+,=£8
#2YHYxfgd$¤¥¦§¨
A©,/ !H=>?@/
+eHfg#2ªS01#2342'
o=>?@$r«$FG2¦2¬6®/
¯/ ;°±²³<!´n=µr7A¶·
n¸'H¹=ab9cd#lJY /ºx>?@#01Y01#23 4' xW»¼!B7=>?@l
x#012x½6/ =>?@
"#/;°±²¾<!$"#T Ufgd}$¿ÀÁÂ$+Al
$t8Ã$¿À~!
"#$ÄA=ÅÆ/fg#$'
#ÇÈÉ8Ê$ËÌÍY=MN$#$Î
»nÏ/ x$7W=fg#Al
$pTй,x$7WH¹=
ÑÒJAÓYx=fg#2'l3Ô ÕU A7W»=¶·n¸'I J=®];CDE34$ËÌÍ L Ö×7$<.7/01#234'KL/
$AØÙ'¼/ !
ÚÛÜÝÞßàáâ
9:;<ã =sr8ä7W>?yz {|åæçèéê$ëìíîïð H>?'ñò óA=ôõö$}$÷+, 7xøù78+,=úûüý;>?<$
÷þ ÿ0!úûüý$÷A=
>?'|é12YH3æ4ç$56
÷=ëìíî'78 8ä$÷Î9=ë ìíî$'KL÷/}$m6 n'78=#J=úûüý$
÷'X÷Y»=M7|é1
012345678974 484 !"#
$7%&'()*+,-./01 2343456#4#789:;<
=>?#@ABC5=D EFGHEI;J/0K)L M NKO !GHP!QRST !#P!
GHUVWOX64Y34P !,Z
$[747Y\]8 34#7^4R !"7Z_`a b7cT8dabGHX64UVWeO fg34;cThiOjk7^
4lZ7<mnopqr sstuvwxMyz{|};DUVW eO~-',Myq^T34
#7^4#zZ O44 87Z7:Ohi
TZO34#7^
Z&v{T8:
vEGHEQR{;D
24#4;J/
0)YQR;cTOjk 7^43< ]¡¢#J6 ZG#£T8¤ hi x¥#456Z¦,§¨7©#ª«
34G¡¢v¬®¬¯°±D[²6³Z
e4{74´µ8¶·;J
¸¹º»
@ABC¼4hiZ@ABC5=#$
9:½¾4GH@ABC#$
cT456Z]¡¢#
¶·)3
hiZ¿7DÀ9:ZÁÂÃÄ
@ABCÅ9Æ344S#c T=ÇO¿È34=Ç)ZÉ D$ÊË=ÇÌÍ=Dz64 οÈOϲ34J;JÐÑZÒÓ
ÔÕ&;J7@ABC#
$';DD%#456$7@
ABC5=#/07ÖoT56
×'A#$cT²ØST45 6Z$9:OÙcTÚ#¶·4Ì#
4
PÛZ789:64@ABC¼4&A
="´ÜÝÞLMe6ß2Ö²àáâ
|}"£^ÔÕOcT4ÌSThi
#¿STyO£)ãähi(
åØ|x¥Oæ:34874G HÌHàáâ|}"T8Ìnç
OÐè3é^74ÐHÌêë ìí&A="Z4@A#BC45=3 4#îì744@ABC#ïV 5=745678ðHGñò2½¾
;D@ABC5=Oóô=STõDö4
÷ø
@ABC#$cT456hi£T
01 234567589756 !"#$%&
'()*+,-./0123*4 56)78-9:;<=> !?@!
456.ABC-/0)D8EFGH ,"#$.3I123CJKLGHMN) OP,QRSTUV.WTXY3Z) [J!\]56)^TD._`!a_
[)bc=I@ d^Ce
\]56.f3!gG)hi!KLGHM N)9j!kGlm)nop._3qrst
`uv,QCe86)EFGH,wxEFy.
ZTz{12C)^2|!gG,QRST!
}~y),sC[)uv^T!?@!
Gz{) Wy)n0
^C)!2)uvEFG88
)D^T>Ce[!.
3!)y)G)9j,u2 C .T,)!"#;W)
.ZY3.Gf,Cs2|!
G )~¡¢,QRC ,£¤12C d^T!%&'()\]56._3!
ZT3¥G¦¦,¥§12C¨,^C
©2Ce
ª
«¬®EFG8)D¯°±D²G&³´µ 7¶·¸!¹º»¼½¾¿À
«Á®EFG8ÂÃÄÅÆÇÈɲ«Ê7ËÊ&
´µ¿ÀÌÌÍÌÌÎ
«Ï®EFGÐ&ÑÒÓÒÔ¦²ÕÖ׿E FGÐ&ØÙµ¿À0Ú
«Û )*)ÜÝÞ!ßàá[)ÜÝÞâ ])ßàÓãäå[)ÜÝÞ,æçsC
2!ÃèéêÒ)ëâ])ßàÓã äå[)ÜÝÞì0._3!íîïyð )%&'()ñ3òG«EóôÇÁ õ4.Cnop,^Ce
«öW÷Õ!øù)úû.A3üý)þÿ.
ZT8012=sC =`3BC12=
e®øù)úû.A3²!W)³4 -56,øù.78sC =9!®üý) þÿ.ZT²!ü8012)y 3ÿ&)áC =eA!
«)®W÷Õ²):,:1 2C ,^C,!!."#)§)
@.sC.sÕ!"#)yC e®W÷Õ²=1y2=
@y)f!«80Ç^
CÈ12!®W÷Õ²=1 !801 2=sC =@y)f±2|!
)y.ñsC%&)'(.sCe
« !¬¿ÀÌÌÌ
«4EFG8"1óǬõ!#$)%&' )*+._3(6=)3C,!*|
¾+%&y^C,y)ï+i!- )%&%&.C&+Y3CJ!
ï+iáÿ&+áÿ,æç3Ce
«./0®12G)3@45f6sC7uv² 34567589756.
ÀÌ0ÍÌÚ89e
«: );!<i«íG#$=>«G#
$)O?%&)Z.!y.ZCwxE Fyð)#$)%&@,A612C*) -/0)uvX=B.3Z
Ce