重層的な通商政策と日米関係 : ポスト冷戦期における日米通商政策の検討

全文

(1)

(2) ７

(3) ７２００３pp.２７５５２００３. ISSN １３４３０６３７.

(4)

(5) Japans Multi-layered Trade Policy and Japan-US relations. Takeyasu FUJIKI Abstract In ２０００, the principal of Japan s trade policy has shifted toward multi-layered trade policy, which is designed to mesh with multilateralism, regionalism and bilateralism. Till then, Japan has advocated multilateralism due to constrain of the US aggressive trade policy. The question addressed in this paper is Does Japan s multi-layered trade policy affect the character of Japan-US relations? This paper examines the Japan-US relations in post-cold war era, focusing on the following trade policy issues: １ Japan s trade policy in １９９０s, ２Bush administration s trade policy, ３ Japans trade policy change in recent years, ４ several issues on Japans multi-layered trade policy. ２０００

(6) WTO

(7)

(8) .

(9) ２００２１

(10) Free Trade AgreementFTA

(11) Japan-Singapore Economic Partnership AgreementJSEPA . ASEAN

(12)

(13) FTA

(14) FTA

(15)

(16) WTO

(17) ２１

(18) WTO

(19) APEC

(20) ２０００２０００５８ URL ２ ASEAN

(21) <http://www.mofa.go.jp/mofaj/press/enzetsu/１４/ekoi_０１１４.html>. − 27 −.

(22)

(23) .

(24) . !"#$%.

(25) １９９０

(26)

(27) WTO APEC

(28) .

(29)

(30)

(31)

(32) . !.

(33) .

(34) . !.

(35) . .

(36) !"

(37) ２００２１０２６

(38) ASEAN FTA ASEAN Enterprise for ASEAN InitiativeEAI .

(39) . .

(40) FTA

(41)

(42)

(43) . .

(44) . !".

(45) . !.

(46)

(47) １１９９０

(48) ２

(49)

(50) . !. ３

(51) ４FTA

(52)

(53) １９８０

(54)

(55) . !"#. !"#$%. ３ WTO

(56)

(57) １９９９１４

(58) . !"#$%&'.

(59) . !"#$% &.

(60) . !"#$%&'.

(61) !"#$%&'

(62)

(63) ２００２２７４５ URL EAI

(64) <http://www.whitehouse.gov/news/releases/２００２/１０/２００２１０２６-７.html>. − 28 −.

(65)

(66) ７２００３.

(67) １９８６

(68)

(69) . !" #$%&. ２

(70)

(71) .

(72) .

(73)

(74) １９９３ ! "#. １９９５

(75) . . １９９３７

(76) .

(77) . !"#$.

(78)

(79) . !". !"#$%&'.

(80) . !".

(81)

(82) ３

(83) . !"#.

(84) . !"# $%.

(85) . !"#.

(86) . !"#$.

(87) within government reach

(88)

(89) . !.

(90) . !".

(91) １９９４２１１

(92) ４

(93) ６

(94) . !"#$. !"#$%&'()*+.

(95) OECD WTO . APEC

(96) ２

(97)

(98) ２００１１

(99) ７. !"#$%&'()*+. １９９６

(100)

(101) No.４１９１９９５２

(102) ８１９９７３２７３３２. − 29 −. !"#$%&.

(103)

(104) .

(105) ９１０

(106) ３

(107)

(108)

(109) . !. .

(110)

(111)

(112) . !. １９９５５１０３０１ WTO １６３０１

(113) １７ WTO １ WTO

(114)

(115) ２９WTO

(116)

(117)

(118)

(119)

(120)

(121) ６２８

(122)

(123) ３

(124)

(125)

(126) . !"#. !.

(127)

(128) . !"#$.

(129) . !.

(130)

(131) .

(132)

(133)

(134) WTO

(135) ２ .

(136)

(137)

(138) . !"#$%.

(139)

(140)

(141). !".

(142) ３

(143) . １９９０

(144)

(145) . !１９９０. ９

(146)

(147) １９９５９

(148) １９９７１９９５１０１

(149) １０

(150)

(151) １９９５８１

(152) ５４５７

(153) １１

(154) ４５４７ E

(155) ５８６４１２. − 30 −.

(156)

(157) ７２００３.

(158) . !.

(159)

(160) . !"#$. . .

(161)

(162)

(163) １９９７２２８

(164) ２

(165)

(166) ３ .

(167)

(168) . !"#$.

(169) . !. ２

(170)

(171) .

(172)

(173) . !"１. １９９４. ９５９６

(174) ９４９９

(175) ９０

(176)

(177)

(178) １９９６１９ . ００３

(179) ２０

(180) ９７２５１ .

(181) . １９９３. ８２６ . ２０００５２８ .

(182) １９９０

(183)

(184)

(185)

(186). １３

(187) １９９０

(188) ８２０００

(189) １９９９

(190) １４３０１

(191) ３０１

(192) １９９９３９１５ URL <http://usembassy.state.gov/tokyo/wwwt２２７５.txt> １９９７６１９

(193) １６

(194) . !". ! "#$%&'. <http://www.mofa.go.jp/mofaj/area/usa/keizai/kanwa/kyoso.html> １１２０２

(195) １７

(196) １９９７. − 31 −.

(197)

(198) .

(199) 1993 . . . 1994. 100 1995. 1996. 1997. 1998. 1999. 2000. 134673 176934 187521 194869 211080 264238 357746 466209. . 62468. 68989. 62897. 50427. 58593. 67203. 76276. 84982. . 46.4. 39.0. 33.5. 25.9. 27.8. 25.4. 21.3. 18.2. . 22416. 32075. 36772. 42431. 53027. 60851. 73537. 90251. . 16.6. 18.1. 19.6. 21.8. 25.1. 23.0. 20.6. 19.4. . 48784. 66356. 68463. 73569. . 36.2. 37.5. 36.5. 37.8. 85275 118880 138000 161265 40.4. 45.0. 38.6. 34.6. ASEAN5

(200) IMF, . .

(201). .

(202) .

(203) .

(204) . !"#$. ２WTO

(205) .

(206) . . WTO １９８８８１９９５１３０１５

(207) WTO １９９５１１９９８６２ WTO

(208) . . . . . . . 1955 1979. 1. 0. 2. 2. 1980 1986. 0. 1. 6. 3. 1987 1994. 1. 2. 1. 3. 1995 2000. 5. 3. 5. 7.

(209) 252.

(210) WTO

(211) WTO

(212)

(213)

(214) . !"#$% !"#$. ３０１ WTO

(215) . １８

(216) . !"#$%&'()*+.

(217) No.４１０１９９４５

(218)

(219) １９９５. A

(220) ３０１

(221) １９ J

(222) . − 32 −. !"#$%２００１.

(223)

(224) ７２００３.

(225) . !"#. .

(226)

(227) . !"１９８０. !"#$%. GATT

(228)

(229) . !"#. .

(230) ３ WTO

(231)

(232) . !"３０１.

(233) . ! . .

(234)

(235) . . . . 20. 5. 3. 23. 18. 69. EU. 23. . 6. 4. 24. 4. 61. . 6. 0. . 1. 3. 0. 10. . 6. 5. 1. . 3. 2. 17. . 22. 19. 0. 3. 35. 3. 82. . 9. 1. 0. 1. 5. 8. 24. 66. 45. 12. 12. 93. 35. 263. . 2002 587. １９８０

(236)

(237) multi-track approach

(238) .

(239)

(240)

(241)

(242)

(243)

(244)

(245) .

(246)

(247) ２０ WTO

(248) . !"WTO . １９９６１２. ２１

(249) EU

(250) No.４１０１９９４５５１２２ WTO

(251) ２３

(252)

(253) . !"#$%&'("). １９９４２４２０００２５ WTO

(254) ２３ ITA

(255) ２０００１２１２. − 33 −. !"#$%WTO .

(256)

(257) .

(258) ２００２ WTO

(259)

(260) .

(261) １９９０

(262) １９８８６ .

(263)

(264)

(265)

(266)

(267)

(268) . !"#$.

(269) . !.

(270) . ! ".

(271) . !"#$%.

(272) APEC

(273) .

(274) APEC APEC .

(275)

(276)

(277) EAEC .

(278) ASEAN

(279) . !" .

(280) １９９３７

(281)

(282) .

(283)

(284) APEC

(285) ３２５ WTO

(286) ２００１１１ WTO ４

(287) WTO

(288) AD

(289)

(290)

(291) !"#$%WTO

(292) ２００２２

(293)

(294) WTO

(295) WTO <http://www.mofa.go.jp/mofaj/gaiko/wto/new_r_soron.html# １ >

(296) !"#$% ２６ .

(297) １９８８ .

(298) !"#"$

(299) １９９５

(300) APEC

(301) １９９５１４３２７１９９３１９９６

(302) ２８ . − 34 −.

(303)

(304) ７２００３.

(305) . !"#$#%&. . . １ APEC

(306) １

(307)

(308) . !"#"$.

(309) . !. . １

(310) APEC １

(311) ５

(312)

(313)

(314) ASEAN

(315)

(316) １９９４６１５

(317)

(318) . !"#.

(319) .

(320)

(321) .

(322) １９９５７ APEC

(323) . APEC

(324) １１ APEC ASEAN

(325)

(326) １９９６

(327) . ASEAN APEC

(328)

(329) . !"#$%.

(330) !"#$%. &'( .

(331) EAEC

(332) EAEC

(333) . . () ２９

(334) !"#$%&' １９９３８１７２４APEC

(335)

(336)

(337) ４９２００２３０ APEC . ARF

(338) １９９５１０

(339) APEC

(340) ３１１９９５１２３１２７

(341) ３２

(342) APEC１９９４６

(343) １９９４７１２３３３４

(344) １９９５１

(345) １９９４３

(346) ３５

(347) . ! " #.

(348) APEC

(349) １９９５１１

(350) １９９６７２３３６. − 35 −.

(351)

(352) . １９９３７ ASEAN EAEC APEC . . ９９４６

(353) １ . EAEC

(354) ASEAN １９９５１２

(355) １９９７ ASEAN+３ ASEAN

(356) １９９７１２ASEAN+ ３

(357) ASEAN+ ３

(358)

(359) ASEAN+３

(360) . !. .

(361)

(362) ２０００７ ASEAN .

(363) ASEAN+３

(364)

(365) １１

(366) ASEAN+３

(367)

(368)

(369) . !"#$. .

(370) . !"#$. !"#$Early. Voluntary Sectoral LiberalizationEVSL

(371)

(372) . １０ EVSL

(373) ２０２０２０１５

(374)

(375) １９９８１１. ３７EAEC

(376) EAEC ７８１９９９EAEC

(377) No.５１９９５８

(378) ASEAN

(379) １９９３８３１３８２００１７３９

(380)

(381) URL ４０ <http://www.mofa.go.jp/mofaj/kaidan/kiroku/s_obuchi/arc_９９/asean９９/kyodo.html> １９９５１２１９APEC ４１APEC

(382)

(383) APEC .

(384) １９９６１ ASEAN

(385)

(386) Tatsushi Ogita, The APEC Policy-Making Process in Japan, IDE-APEC STUDY CENTER, .

(387)

(388)

(389) ９５/９６ No.７, March １９９６ <http://www.ide.go.jp/Japanese/Apec/Publish/pdf/９５wp_０７.pdf>

(390) APEC

(391) . !"#$%&'().

(392) ４２EVSL

(393) APEC . ２００１. − 36 −.

(394)

(395) ７２００３.

(396) APEC APEC

(397)

(398) . !".

(399)

(400) . !"#$%.

(401)

(402)

(403) . #$ !"#$. !"#$.

(404) APEC

(405) .

(406) . !"#$.

(407) ４

(408)

(409) １９９０

(410)

(411) . ! !

(412) . １９９０

(413)

(414) . ２０

(415) . ! .

(416) APEC

(417)

(418) ９０

(419)

(420) . . . . . . . . . . 1985. . 24.1. 37.6. . 25.5. 20.0. 1990 1995. . 29.6 42.1. 31.7 27.5. . 26.6 34.4. 22.5 22.6. 2000. . 39.8. 30.1. . 39.6. 19.1. 1985. 17.0. 25.6. 27.3. 25.9. 22.7. 15.7. 1990. 14.5. 31.7. 22.5. 22.1. 29.9. 15.8. 1995. 12.8. 37.8. 19.7. 22.6. 33.2. 14.5. 2000. 12.2. 37.0. 21.3. 18.9. 38.2. 13.0. ASEAN5

(421) IMF, . .

(422). .

(423) .

(424)

(425) ４３

(426)

(427) １９９８. − 37 −. !" ##$%&.

(428)

(429) . ASEAN+３

(430)

(431) APEC

(432) . !"#$.

(433) . .

(434)

(435) ２０００２００１

(436) . ２８

(437)

(438)

(439)

(440)

(441). !".

(442) ２

(443)

(444)

(445)

(446)

(447) . !"#$%. !"#$%&'.

(448) . !"#$%&'.

(449)

(450) ２０１０

(451) open marketplace

(452)

(453) . !"#$".

(454) . ４４

(455)

(456)

(457) . !"#$%&'(. ! "#$$%.

(458) ２００１

(459) .

(460) ２００２

(461)

(462) ２００２ APEC

(463) ２０００７８４５４６４

(464) Council on Foreign Relations, A New Beginning: Recasting the US-Japan Economic Relationship, July ２０００ <http://６３２ . ３６１ . ２ . ４０/public/pubs/Stokes_NewBeginning _Paper.pdf>

(465) ２０００１１; Institute for National Strategic Studies, The United States and Japan: Advancing Toward a Mature Partnership, October ２０００ <http://www.ndu.edu/ndu/SR_JAPAN.HTM>

(466) A

(467) ２００２; Council on Foreign Relations, Future Directions for US Economic Policy Toward Japan, October ２０００ <http://www.cfr.org/public/pubs/Japan_TaskForce.html>

(468) ２００１１; David Asher, Could Japan Become the England of the Far East?, June ２００１ <http://www.aei.org/ps/psasher.htm>

(469)

(470) ２００１５. − 38 −.

(471)

(472) ７２００３.

(473) １０

(474)

(475) FTA

(476)

(477)

(478) . !"#$

(479).

(480) . !".

(481) WTO G８

(482) . !".

(483)

(484)

(485)

(486)

(487) . !"#$%.

(488) .

(489)

(490)

(491) . !".

(492)

(493) . ! ".

(494) . !". .

(495) . !"#.

(496)

(497)

(498) . !"#$.

(499) ２

(500) .

(501)

(502)

(503) . !"#$%&.

(504) . !"#.

(505) . !.

(506) .

(507)

(508) ４７

(509) . !"#$%&'().

(510) ２００１１０

(511)

(512) NPO

(513) ４８

(514) . !"#!$%&'()). ２０００１２ <http://www.mofa.go.jp/mofaj/area/usa/keizai/kenkyu/００１２.pdf> Condoleeza Rice, Promoting the National Interest, .

(515) , January/ February ２０００４９

(516) ２０００３４. − 39 −.

(517)

(518) .

(519)

(520) . !.

(521) . !

(522) "#$ !"#. ASEAN+３

(523) APEC ASEAN+３

(524)

(525) . !"#$%.

(526)

(527) . !".

(528)

(529)

(530)

(531)

(532) . . !". #

(533) $.

(534) . !"#$.

(535) FTA

(536)

(537) . !!". FTA

(538)

(539) . !".

(540)

(541) WTO

(542) . !"#.

(543)

(544) . !".

(545) ２００１６３０

(546)

(547)

(548) . .

(549) . !"#$%&. ５０J. Robert Kerrey & Robert A. Manning, The United States and Southeast Asia: A Policy Agenda for the New Administration, July ２００１, New York: Council on Foreign Relations <http://www.cfr.org/pdf/SEAsiaTF.pdf>JA

(550) ２００１９

(551) URL ５１ <http://www.mofa.go.jp/mofaj/area/usa/keizai/partner３.html>. − 40 −.

(552)

(553) ７２００３.

(554) . !"#.

(555) １

(556) １９９７

(557)

(558)

(559) . !"#$%&. FTA .

(560) FTA

(561)

(562)

(563) . ! !"#$. .

(564) FTA

(565)

(566) !"#$ .

(567)

(568)

(569) . !"#!. .

(570) . . Free Trade Area of the AmericasFTAA

(571) .

(572)

(573)

(574) . !". .

(575) . !. . ２００２

(576)

(577)

(578) ２００１１２５

(579) .

(580) !.

(581)

(582) ７

(583) ２００２８

(584) . ８

(585)

(586) FTAA

(587) FTA . FTAA ２００１４３

(588) ２００５１１２ FTAA

(589) ５２ FTA

(590) FTA ２００２５３ FTA ２００２１０<http://www.mofa.go.jp/mofaj/gaiko/fta/senryaku.html> USTR, ２００１ .

(591) ２０００ .

(592) .

(593)

(594) .

(595) . . .

(596) . ５４ . .

(597) , March ２００１ <http://www.ustr.gov/reports/２００１.html> , .

(598) , November/ December ２００２５５C. Fred Bergsten,A Renaissance for U.S. Trade Policy ? ５６

(599) <http://www.mofa.go.jp/mofaj/area/usa/keizai/eco_tusho/tpa.html >. − 41 −. !".

(600)

(601) . ２００２１１

(602) FTA

(603) ２００３１５

(604) ２００２１０ EAI

(605) FTA

(606) FTA

(607) FTA

(608)

(609) . !"#$"%&. WTO FTAA FTA

(610) .

(611)

(612) １９９５

(613) WTO

(614)

(615) １９９８

(616)

(617) . !. . １９９８

(618) . !""#$.

(619) . !. .

(620)

(621)

(622)

(623) WTO

(624) .

(625) １９９８ . WTO WTO

(626) . !"#. ５７

(627) WTOFTAA

(628) FTA FTAA

(629) USTR, "U.S. Advances Bold Proposals in FTAA Negotiations to Create World' s Largest Free Market in ２００５", February １１, ２００３ <http://www.ustr.gov/releases/２００３/０２/０３-０８.htm > Bergsten competitive liberalization Bergsten, . p.９４. ５８

(630) . !"Tatsushi Ogita,An. Approach towards Japan' s FTA Policy , IDE-APEC STUDY CENTER, . . .

(631) ０１/０２No.４, March ０. <http://www.ide.go.jp/Japanese/Apec/Publish/pdf/apec１３_wp４.pdf> ２００２, pp.２１５９１０１９９８３２８１９９８８８６０６１WTO .

(632) １９９８<http://www.keidanren.or.jp/japanese/policy/pol１６６.html>. − 42 −.

(633)

(634) ７２００３.

(635) WTO

(636) １９９８

(637) FTA

(638)

(639) ６

(640) １１

(641) . !"#. １０

(642) ２１

(643)

(644) ６ .

(645)

(646) １９９９１

(647) ４ .

(648) .

(649) FTA

(650) . WTO

(651) WTO

(652)

(653) WTO

(654)

(655) １９９９

(656) .

(657) FTA

(658)

(659) WTO .

(660)

(661) １２

(662) FTA

(663)

(664) ３. . ９

(665) FTA

(666) ２０００７ FTA

(667) ６２

(668) １９９９８

(669)

(670) ２１

(671)

(672) ６３.

(673) !. <http://www.keidanren.or.jp/japanese/policy/pol２２６/index.html> WTO

(674) ６４ <http://www.keidanren.or.jp/japanese/policy/pol２２７/index.html> １１２９４２９６６５７６６１９９９８６７

(675)

(676) ２０００９ <http://www.mofa.go.jp/mofaj/area/singapore/kyotei/kyotei.pdf>. − 43 −. !"#.

(677)

(678) .

(679) FTA

(680)

(681) ６ .

(682) WTO

(683) ２

(684) FTA

(685) . !"#. FTA

(686)

(687)

(688) ２０００.

(689)

(690) . !". FTA

(691)

(692) FTA

(693) .

(694) ５

(695) ２０００ WTO

(696) .

(697)

(698)

(699) . !"#.

(700) . ! $. !"#$. . ２００１

(701) ６

(702) FTA

(703)

(704) ９２００２ . ７ FTA .

(705) ２００２１

(706) JSEPA

(707) JSEPA ASEAN ASEAN

(708) ASEAN

(709) . ０２

(710)

(711) ２０. ６８

(712) . !". <http://www.keidanren.or.jp/japanese/policy/２０００/０３３/index.html>

(713)

(714) ６９. !"#$%. <http://www.keidanren.or.jp/japanese/policy/２００１/０２９.html> ２００１１７２１７５７０２７１２０００９７２２００１９０２０００１０

(715)

(716) FTA

(717)

(718)

(719) FTA WTO FTA

(720) FTA

(721)

(722) <http://www.mofa.go.jp/mofaj/gaiko/fta/hokoku.pdf> <http://www.mofa.go.jp/mofaj/area/mexico/nm_kyodo/ > ７３. − 44 −.

(723)

(724) ７２００３ .

(725) FTA

(726) ２００２１０ FTA FTA

(727) .

(728) ５ FTA

(729)

(730)

(731) .

(732)

(733). A S E A N. 10 . ASEAN

(734). . .

(735)

(736)

(737). . . 7 .

(738) . . 5

(739)

(740) . . . 5

(741) . . . 6

(742). . . 5

(743) . .

(744)

(745) 2003 1 21 .

(746) . !"#$%.

(747) FTA .

(748)

(749) . . !". .

(750) ７４ ASEAN ５

(751) ２００２６４ <http://www.mofa.go.jp/mofaj/area/asean/ ５_koso.html> ２００２１２５７５７６ FTA

(752) FTA . <http://www.mofa.go.jp/mofaj/gaiko/fta/policy.html> ７７２０００１１４ ASEAN+３

(753)

(754)

(755) . − 45 −. !"#$%&'().

(756)

(757) .

(758)

(759) FTA GATT FTA

(760) FTA

(761)

(762) . .

(763) FTA FTA FTA

(764) . FTA

(765) ６

(766) . !"#$%&.

(767) FTA

(768)

(769)

(770) Economic Partnership AgreementEPA . . ７８

(771) . !"#$ %. &'(２０００. ５ FTA

(772) FTA

(773) ７９ FTA

(774) FTA

(775) ２００２ . − 46 −.

(776)

(777) ７２００３. . . . . NAFTA. AFTA. . JSEPA. . . . . . . . . . . A. D. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . EU. . .

(778) FTA .

(779) . !" #.

(780)

(781) . !. !"#$%&. .

(782) FTA

(783) GATT ２４ GATS ５GATT２４ FTA

(784) substantially all trade

(785)

(786)

(787) . !"#.

(788) ９０

(789) ８０

(790) . !"#$%&'(. ２００１ <http://www.mof.go.jp/singikai/kanzegaita/tosin/kana１３１２０３b２.pdf>. − 47 −.

(791)

(792) .

(793) GATT

(794)

(795) FTA

(796)

(797) FTA .

(798)

(799) ３

(800) FTA

(801)

(802) . !"#$%&.

(803)

(804)

(805) WTO . . FTA

(806) JSEPA

(807) FTA

(808)

(809) . !". .

(810) ２００２７

(811)

(812) . !"#$%& . .

(813)

(814) . !"#. FTA

(815)

(816)

(817) FTA .

(818) ASEAN ASEAN

(819) . . !. FTA

(820)

(821) ８１ WTO