質問書方式による考える力をつける教育実践(2)

(1)

質問書方式による考える力をつける教育実践(2)

著者田中裕

雑誌名神戸山手短期大学紀要

号 51

ページ 15‑33

発行年 2008‑12‑20

URL http://id.nii.ac.jp/1084/00000841/

(2)

!"#$ %&'()*+,-./012 34+5 6789:'(

;<=

^>?@

+ABCDE &'(FGHI+J:(

KLMNONP+Q:'FRS2T89UVW#X+

Y(

?LZ[\:'(

L+]^4_`a"+AbNcd'(

eL[\fg[\,hi:'(

Ejk+lmnm/0opq&'qFErTsY2t

^>?@

()uv wxyz{Yqn2Xd+2'n|&'( }=~,,XE t'-sY2t'2tn,(`uc%<+

n$'qtYn!|E'(

34

^>K@

1A4-./012 EtYn/0

^>?@

,2'7q=&'(E/0NP+:',2|2Z%An ( n/0NP+:'qNPN+_q2t j

',q$|E'(q)uz{&'(F FE

+A'''-./0?

; <

'-./0

¡¢34^>K@+£¤¥¤NP¦2t§¨-./0op&'(NP

©,'',ª«,t'(GH

!"#$ %&'(34op,2'7NP v¬:' ®i¯ 7&'(E+AX®<q°:'AXt Ft ,#E'(

(3)

!

"#$ %&'()*+ ,-./&# ,-'0'&#1,- 23456789:; 9<=>4%)??@ABCDE"#

'-F'0GE7 9<= %BC6H ! E7I"#%J ! %/@KLE7M"#(6H NJ"#O(H 9

<='PQ H0GE7

8RSTUV)WX*+%Y !SZ[G 00GJ\%[]^

SZE_`ab[E7cdEe HfXE1'IcdEeXf gh-'I!ESiPjklHmnQ7Eo,Pp% qfX PpE) rstuvu !wQxy'z{(wQ|}~)6|}Q

GX-PpE7

Pp%SiQG"#H !B8R0G$

N4$Q ,-)E0GN,-

%

_89 ,-GX- % 4) "#)#$) ST) y4 4

E7

¡¢£¤E N¥X%"#H¦X N¥X§E7 ¨©N=ª'0'QG«

^¬

£¤ «£¤ %/e( §Q7

pE%8R®4"#$%S¯E7N)¬«° E"#±

#$N)²«°<zEH³46NESZE(«£¤E%Pp , '0'S´µ¶'*+ ,-%)X%0N&' E7,h"

#±#6 QEe·)¸D¹(]^ ST Q{(,E)¨n

cd4hº# »Y¼½'-)+%H³6NE¾e8RST !j¿'7eG0 pÀ§0GÁ zÂE7,Q)+cdÃÄ

¥X )PQ '-cdQ2T ÅÆ'

S´ÇÈÉ1·0GÁ7GÊ !ËÌQ7X%YZ

&'´E6ÍÃ6(N0H'-Shf)½ÎQ^ÏG0 ½ÎE7 Ð¯

^Ñ

%ÒÓM/+Ô*ÕE8RÍÃ6Shfcd%Y!0-Ö×ØÙÚ-

¬r+ÛÜEÝÞßàPpáâ «Si)cdãÃ¬«ä åæ'- X )ST«çQèH»Ycd¹éêë%è' «IE=QN- 0% «ìGIE(cdQEe0,Q) «íÉ-0GîcdQ2Z

"#´Pï H¹¡¢£¤²

ðð

(4)

!"#$%&'()'*+,-.#/0/123/4(

*+,-.51

567(89:,-;) <=4>?@(A/>51(B 5CD:E>*+, F#BGH

I-JKL4MNO14PQR(%S#TUVS(WXYZ [\]^#_4SJ`abc de`af%PgX2V\h"

H#ij(k/#2'#lm;4`dA414P51n o<5:#p>CDqr's`dEtEu,-4,,KL4MNO#`d Etlm,s>4ij#4=/vAwx-v2'lm;

CD:>51#yz{:|4}HGP:~(ij#!1#L 4oPH5=//.51(A/,ij:,15

#Pij1#L4oP

^$

1"# 0GP:`dlm(

:ijCD:E>[\(L"5[\#QR: ,

`dm](,",-5",4"} ¡

`d:¢(,-}Z£ 1"

5QRS¤¥(¦§>1¨GP:

$©ijCD:E,-K[\ªLOu«(¬[\(®>

¯©5}°±²³1ij´²³(µ¶V·¸:L¹ 4[\(9L

U©[º:)'*+,=;9L51(%PK »¼½:G¾\OK

[\ OK[\¿(.OK¯'ÀÁÂOK¢(,-.OKÃÄO KÅ3ÂÆ OK Æ"OKL¹4[\(9LOI:ÇÈv:

+É, [\ÊËÌÍÎ(.51Ï}-4;Ð/ ÀÁ*

+,-4 #K [\ OK¯'ÀÁÂOKÃÄO KL¹4[\(9LOKÇÈv:+É, [\ÊËÌÍÎ(.OÑ

Ò:Ó,4QRÔ(Õ>

$© (1QRÖ×1Ø:ÙI»¼½(Ú QR:Eu,51([

\,H($0ÒC:]4- Û>]4gXs Ü<gX#H.Ý]

4-P `<51Á/4Þ:ß-4(à51;

áá

(5)

!"

#$%& '()*+,-./"01#

2'( 3"4-56#7895:%;41 <"==>?341;6+@ABCDEF"

G,HIJKL '(MNO6+PQ

RS T&:"4-56+,H#UVT%;6+,- WX-"4-#YZ[/\]1"#^_3#`YZ$

a$bc-T1+de/-f&T+3#ghi jT93"k)l5:m#Qm"n Tdeop/

qr%& 3"

s,Htuvwxeyz{|R}~"xe#tu56 L '( 3"tu#/`<=T 0# 2 3"4-

256n"denn"R+Rj

2+g%&<<+9MNOXT&:"

R#+R

^s¡

!&%5:+%&¢}£¤

U(TR #+tu¥¦§(R+,-¨6©5:ª«

"c%&#¬%&g®¯41#~°+R±^_¥¦%&

²³5:ª«"´g®¯CDTG(&RS %&®¯5 :ª«"^_µ¶ <#+g41T3+^_¥¦

±-·¸µ¹µ¶ <41º +»®¯T%¼&

41º +¬#%&½¾¿ÀÁÂ/ 51ª«

"

ÃPÂRS T&:"4Rj2RÄ%jT&:"g

%&1TRj41# 2R#ÅÆÇ %5:"

#RCD+¬Mxe&- +%6ÈÉÊËÌ R41 <"

ÍÎÏ,HIJ !"4#e41 <M

#e"MNO3ÐÑÒÓÔ#"

K !Anxe Õ^_|R&Me"4Î Ö#MNO"4-#?× ØÙ3"cÚ(^

_5ÛÜTp/3"

ÝMNOÞß àá+â<&ã? <½#ã?T&

:"Me#^_1S9 +äåæ56ã?+çè5 6ã?T&:"

æ5deop/Îéêë

ìì

(6)

!" #

$%&'(%)'' +,- .$/01+, 2345/6)7 89:9;%<=>?/96)'@A/BCDCEFGH'*=/

I? J/K:LCFG%MNO'%PQR).$SHI? FG

%MNOHTU%VWRXYZ[&L)78 ?\]%^' _`%ab$cd9ef)

Eg+,hi!j kl mUn @oE)

p78ZqZq #$r%stuLvw45x%ry)stz{|{/6)}~

:LL %$o@oEE#$/E0Az{) }~:LH MuC'/ #$/6:L !"/6'/6)

zE#$ xr %) /I vw4 5xr%rySO/ hi!"00)

%ry)x uLH Hg@%O

H ¡%yuC)

"¢ @oE+, £¤]o/6:C0%¥¦§XE¨©(o1 LªE%)' +,+,0«¬®*@oE¯u°E±²³´µ

/E)78¶uLTU ·WSO%XL¸¹'Vº»' V0:C /HTU ¼½¾6H¿¿EÀÁ/XE>?%&(Â:0 OE+,%ÃÄuL @AÅÆC9 /6)-ÇE+,&È0«p8§É ÊËÌÃuLgL) 8 /ÍÎÏ?OL%g'E:

L)&Ð%1O'' +, ÃR/6ÑaÒÓ £¤ kÔÃÕ n {/6)

pÖ9Æ×.u ¡9ÀØ/Â'%ÙÚRF) zÛ$H#$%Ð%1O)

XE¨©%&'/Â)

¡%ÆÐHqiÜÝ%Þ»LA"°LÂCVy 9 /·³®*L SOHÊß 9 /6)u0uE«}69 %à·³áâã%»ÆH

¿¿E9 äå@A78 ¡%æçèAHæÐ9éêL)78 ¡%

=E Hë/9ÀØ/ÂE0«/6'VH''/ìíEîïSHÖ

9Æ× ¡%Æ×?0('%ÙÚ®ð'YZ ÃR/6)

Yñ ÃRÛ$ò#$%&Ð%1O'/6)óô7õ kÔÀö Z1I

÷÷

(7)

!

"#$%&'()*+,-./0121(345 63 75809:'.;<805=>'(

?58@5ABCD2E1FG0E7(HI 90J0:'KL8M#7NOP QE7 (RS TU70CVWXY(3Z[N\]^> _`ab cJd^ea1f!7(gUTCV7(637hij

kalm8no2epqrfstuY2fqvwxyE2 z{&2)*|+CV[2}~r2c'E7(1206:' E72'E7(12&c'E7(12

x582ea1f_>(1CVm80S

ea1fs0>'Jx ¡¢T637

£E¤:Y¥¦7Y: §9"¨0¥¦ "©x2xª

ea1fU1y: ea1fsCV[« z{¬:Y Q

0fUT3¬:Y (3> ®¯7:'1y:

®° ±²°/ ± 7¯³´2µ!RJ¶·¸¹

J0f!ºJ0:'Y7O_>(1 gUTJ'1_

>Y:¥¦'( »¼>®J²°/½±¾a 9637_>

(1bcJ2ea1fCV0¿À>'c N

2Áea1fs'1z{Â¬(!> Q0Ã>'fsÂ ÄcCV7c'1 ea1fU(c06OCV![

2OÅ£ÆYy7(1 Ç È5YyCV'' É5YyC VUÂ7Ê:¬(!> +ËÌc1 ÍÎCV7(1O

![ 1(:>Ï7UÂ¬(!>

2ÐÑª_>(noÂ:fUÂÂCV!ºU> >Y>Èg Tfs23(3Â:YY Òc7c1((ÓÂ7T¬(

CV6307:'(!>

2ÁAfsÔÕ Ö&(Ö ×(AY AØ0fsÙ7T>7Y:

qÚ06.ÛÜQÝÇ

ÞÞ

(8)

!"#$% & '()*+, -.

/0123)4567,$%,839:;<=>? @,31A, BC;DE,F,& $%C;GHIJF,-.

+KL)MN>KLOP&$% MN>QFF;RS F;-

/TU1&VW)1XY,;1Z1F JF,[,3$%,3F<Q>F\]^_1`3 abcd)efghigh)j)<=kC;7 lm n >$% ,-j) )op)>J Fq,/<=>& ;.FE1g;JF,-.

/& rst,uv$% ;DE,w, x3sw,x39:[,FJFsPyzC;

DE ,-.

!

VW1&$% KL{ |0$% ;DE}

|F~;RSF;-23)RS$%C;&3~F;- / )0F3$%,F3)3,-.

/1Qs>C;tC-j))6|

F;euvD3C;C-,,)KLm 8F<=>&XY, DE 1i3,$

% ,-.

/C,g0F<=& E"m;DEC- j0D<=>$%C;}3;JFC-mF C U;)13&fg;DEC;mFm;DE

;,0F) UFHIJFC-.

3~;- /<=> )3-.

/<=1U n),F)m,-.

(9)

!"#

$%&"'()(*+,-./"0123456789 '#$:;./"0<=>?@(4A?#>

$./"./"BCDEF0G,6789H'I"JAK#>

$'A"LM)N?O?KC./"0P- QRSTOUV4A#>

$:;).&" =W+XYKWZ<=4-./

"Q[\)"XYZC]^AK#>

$%&_`PC"a&_4'4bcC=de=J"f g'#%&_hiKJ)a&_h@-a&_hiKJ )j&_H=#>

$k)l0""m'K4-:;0no)KpqU K#---#./"BCD0P-(']'Wr?

(ZAK#>

$.&"EFs(tubvw4]^AK#>

$"?x/yzZ*QKrKpq=KA?4-BCD0 )]^-{|A#>

!

XYH=d(}~)=dUP}'K#

$:;./"04]^W)"'K#-g$H=d(}~

)f(Q*>?"-"pqK#H=d(}~4

./"-<45K4XY44pqK#>

$Ku-H=d(Z"-KW0PC4+

'#>

" #$%&'

.=4 !./"XYH=d((}#

$./"'4 hu(("ZAK#>

$$:;./"0<=>}H+K')-,,XY<=d(

(q(=(AK#>

$:;./"0)]^AK,-%&<=

bPu@* ¡L¢a

££

(10)

!"#$%%&!'

()*+,-!%./012(&345%(6 78+97 %:;+<=>$?%@A

BCDE%(FGHIJ(KLMN&%-+O

%(FG78PQRST(UVW+X8Y Z2[\(&%-'

B]^FG(_78T(+>-T((2(

F[\%>%T'

BA`ab]^F(+c%de 2fG78

%>]^Fg%!h%T'

GC2]^+78>3J%%Zij>01+

G(2klm2ijklFno2+G(Fpq%

2%

BG([\T+r078T#sFH;Gt (uv&%-T'

BG3p]^?'

Bwx2yz{GG3%' BDE+%2]^F%|"-T'

B78?ZTUVW}U?([\(&%-' B~G3%'

!

]^FF"jJ!

B]^F"(?"2"WF(+>' B]^FG"%+"ZT'

B!A(+>-'

Bf%!jJiEZ&ZjJ

%>%%&%-T]^F([\(&%-T' B(2?Z!"H@A"T( ¡2¢£¤[\2

¥¥

(11)

!"#$%&'()*

+,#-. /#0123 /456789:%&

'6;<(=>?@ABC:'D. #EFG6H(IJKL(MNOA PQ RE789:OA=>SNT/#D2 (9:UV. R V3

WX(YZ/[\'W]$64^#'_2T#`D /3(abcdT6ef#ghijC#E4^Nijklmn o /6EYZ/#pq rC:(Estm(. u>

/IJv wxR6yAE@ABrx:/'D/r6DQ z'69:{'Db|26/3'E}~ (yA@Au>6x

' #.sTN3) 6Nd

(23sT(@AyAr6x =>#$ C@AB /6EF'(tm /?AC. sTC`$#.

*

6(G@Ad2. #E@Ar6x T@A G='D

@AB/6`AC. sTC$#6. '_.

*#C('__ sTC

6E@ANTQzl#V2'@Au>'_6#

. #EGIJ'/@ABT/#W]u>no23/'D D

E(G@Au>EhEC

T 6N¡ef. ¢£¤d¥#$E@AN3

¦' :E§:¡(E¨yA(T/#'_ET T (©/d'_sT(`

=>#.@Au>6N¡¥¤3o' 'dbcdYZR¨(yA(T/#'_E©¤3/#'_

ª«(3#T3. ETT¬n2E@ANr#x N F'd6E.®`@Au>/#/'¥]'N#E'd¥]

@Ai¯(su>rx:°±²³©

´´

(12)

!"#$%!& !"'()*+,"!

-./0.12-3456",

&789:.;<=->?@ABC !"!,

DEFG- H().6%$IJ.KLIJMN OPQ RS R-*

&T UVWX->? UV15-!-.PQY RZ-[[\ ]^% _`a%

%bc!"[MdeZ-/f]" !g[hi aj[-k! ,

&.DEl$]C RZmjC*nopq-<"

"L]-0.TUV%%j[ -.rs!",

&? St.^$]-PQu !"%#]!

L]vw xy.*%[.#]!L]%$34 zz{|%$c-}! J]~78 -<j [-" ,

&ES' !$%q$ ._~ !"Y"

!u>? Z-~\ ]^

\Vy*rS <M

! -<j[~!& ,34-.4%$

,

u[S"X6j[ ![(c*~

! - 9S!"%$ .UV"

^$IJ"%~ !--%$L~

&/ [!%! !

!"XV"pq!".$[15 u'¡L j[0.%V". !,

&34 "¢Bnouc"L**

&£+,&u[!"+,[*!".L][S"¤¥

no!"Y-<"%$343.[k! <u

¦¦

(13)

! "#$%

&'()*+,-(./0 11 #!23 45(67 89:1 !;) - #6(6<=>(1$(?@6 AB( C(@+-,D<E<1$%

F6G<HI9J6KL6MN(OP<(,Q #RS$+

6Q +<?,T(+U-VW$

&XFFY#?Z 6Q:Y; ,> )F #1 6([7'(? \1]^(1$(?7_6`aSb17

"$]^9J6KLcd(?Q F1$eG6f

(6f

g,hi-jkl11$mn(?opqr11$%

& CZ- ,67/0U!2 st1:(67

\1#($11@6AB(KLcd(?D<u1$[7vwx y6(<- +'(7?z{@611$(?' 6vwx(7- +|}~gu+Q#iE<u 1$%

&(<DPD<#Q"$6cd6

(?6+<E ;)1P<h:<F +

Q F1$UU!( ,@;uD?

_$%

&mn(7D7"#$ -6(?U#-&

i- ,?2(? %"#+<'(7& ++7+6Q UT%"Q #-($%

&+(KL6(?P"#FQ F1$%

&D7QF?"$+6HI1- +;7+

UT#(u$ef1u(f1u

?P<U- Q F1¡@11P<!-

<b1¢, #_<1$+Q#P<!@;('(3

#45<36U "1$%

&£¤¥6¦c1-& D<§ %;6(mn(

7FD< "#6(<D<6 "#$%

&¨©o6ª«¬ 23?®gu¯1+ (UT$ (

°±²QD!³´µ¶·

¸¸

(14)

!"#$ %&! '()*+,-./01

"23456

2678)019:;<=">7)[email protected] 3DE/F GHI).CJ- K 7DEL")MNJ-' O/6

P8)Q$ 3R "STUVWX"YZY[\ )6 3" - -]^/>_8@_5- \ = ]^

\ `"/ab KcL26 26J 8dZF3 \ 6

26Jef")*01 2-/5 /"2Q$

?@AB).C/"26J3 '!")016J- \ 6g`< `<26 3"01 2-/5 \

hi.C3"j k`R /6hilm `n< 2Q$8"

ophi. /5 `<"]q/-rste`<")*

.CJ"26J3u8 \ 6

23`L^"Yv/5w@-Nx

te NyQ$ 3zN"2N 6_; N</-F {35>_8Q$J3 `< \ 6|}2Q$

8j>\ 3"~6\ N \

rs/2E M`_ 33/8 `-_

~.C 3d @3k N$ 6)*9

=YZ/M`_ Q$ "~ - XI3@

_5

26J35/8g`< x3M 53"r s`x:_"336`/5C=` 5N- e W"- (`8 N-F \

+b-rsteM Ny_5`"2 Me +`YZ/ 8 -~F \

16-2Q$35ww`<2

(15)

!"#

$%&'&()*%!+!,)-&./012 34

5#6#7&#89:".;<=>?

@A.;B&.ACAC<=+">? !!D.E F+&!D<GH&!.I#J@!

.KC F+&!"LMNC!&OP DDQ"4

5<=.R S T!U .V@

Q&!W ACACX YDD. 0!D4

5Z[&!K\Y%!.]^^_)H +&!4

5`a bc!3d&,)%+&!4

5.eC!&`afB.,)gh]&#4 5ij&\89k9.,)l ..3d

&mn#C3o! 4

5#pq!+!rs. *!D"$

rst!Cua!!4

5vw! *x1.vyz{?K%|.}()~

,).!4

5.ij<=dCAK!J2!

,)!@! ,)$B& & &dT) D J2!*2z{{&JJ@J%&D 1C!B upK 4

[ #nJ .I[#!

() #!()[&"I$T * p !"#D.BB)T+!

{

5 # \Y%*."#!+! .AC!

K!¡¢J+&!".,) 0

N£¤&+,)#@_¥¦§

¨¨

(16)

!"#$%

&'(()+,-&)./

0/12

34&56!7, &89:;&<7,=>[email protected] DEF& @AGHIJKFJLM@ANO

PQ0/(R & QS

BTUVWX&YZJ[DEN F [N 'D\[&] (

^_2`a&bNbN&cI de&f\ghB iiDj 20/JKR(V WXJFBRkl&WXd

&2mKmnopR (opR=,q( J

%NRr%s tu topRvwxyb&YZB

z{(RF /((RFJ{[R%@A(

BdeBR| {F}\ 2 (RV= { R2DE R

z~{FNR N{(R{i N (R9NB+,NF&WX{FJ[,@ b

./J FJ zR(RFN {[

K ()* = R,Ui =

K

9&F= NRp+V= N R9JF( bF(./!

FB(N ,N9p+&\

{&`aJ{[R

2`a&YZCFB@A{F {F 2m opN&J {F{RF

FJ{RF {FJ7R[&[ {R7 K R&U

(17)

!"

#$%&'()#$*"#+,- .$/01 2 345678- #9:;:- #<=$.'#>?

@#+".

ABC,DE&$/F%#+5C1.,B5GH%I& !"

J%#+5C1.K

ADLMH,'(N$5O/#+%5#.K

APH*#J#+".DQR$/5GH%I&( !"

%.'$&*#S$6%/.K

ATBC,UVR$/1W69:X,$.)YZ- [#\

]^]_`1 abc$6%5[#)V9:X,$.d /efghijkl&mfg%no5/'cp"F- #5"

#+"!"%"q$r5st,UVF !"$!"#+#G,1.

Tabuv7#+/5C$5G5G%u- #5"#1W6c

$G5##+5C1.K

ABC,v7#R$/wx$/F1y/5#+5C1.(&v7

#R$/5GH%Iz&FmY{F$*"#5"F IJC$.K

A|}~lo,&( %nPHv$1y%5#+"!"%.K ATI1y/75/5%n%#656C,F /5 "57C%5a15C(%$C$.

#,H%sE&UF( !"%#p%#+

5C1.K

A /5"!"/C$.K

A)1 $/5-(5- #+"!"%C$.T5

5n&$F/%n)1 $/5-(5#G- .

#5F, !"%C$.K

F #!"%#5"Y%,/5 . Av7v7MH,u'"#3%/F/5C1.K AJ.6F !"%.K

Av7#6F/55%#+5C1.BC," ¡%¢£,UV

««

(18)

!"##$%

&'

()+,-./0123) 4 5+&367 8%+9$:%+&'

(8%;<7=%%>?@AB,"CD D 7E% &'

($:E% &FG,H%I = -.)* 4 %J 3 8)* 4 KL %+&'

!M,NO5)*+ PQ-&R:D S&

(TU,HV7WA+9!"##$:%+&=X 7Y+#+&8%XZ[1,0/7+\7],

% 8(^X= M,+S_ `';<,D 7E%

&'

(abEcE+V%0- d8"ef0gD 7E% &'

(V8hf"S7 ij"kl+mn%

J3 &Sd"op,qr "kl7mnij,sD 7E% &'

(t<hu7D 7E% &= =t<B:v7w

=!7: 7+&(' S=

!7()*+' D 7E% &'

($: &ff Sd0 dhf&'

0,xy+vz7{|},~ &=!wXkl+

7mD -&

(8%hu7-!Xd %J3 &7 XX D & FG,H=D

# :E% &X3S

(19)

!"#$%& '()*+, -.-/012345"67

89)6:

;<1"=6>?@ABC5DEF8GHIIJKBC5 L"5MNOPNMBQRS5T

@AUVB)5 !WBXYZ=+6 G["\6T6N]^_`abc dN=6>?B C5 e6M

=6>?B7"f,g#$$B7hM

@ABij,g4"7&6>?kk8l,g"mnBo +(pq&Br]s<ts>?B=),g=>?"

ua*u>?,g"#$+&"vwBx5>?

Byz,gB a

>{BU65+|56

[}

^~

"BV!BZ=V"@A xH=&+):"Z6;<6

:6&L}"6;<6*b"

" 9" 6L}[}6"L}"8B:&j ]k@A6 B¡8+%{V[}

+6

[};<1UB=M$6b"ª«:;<

1¬3/8®¯U°)±²8³6MI

¬3"´µ¶·M&k¸$:+|<t¹º6!"»¼U¹º"6 :d½¾¿$+aÀÁ{&ÂÃ8M5:+ÄpÂ Å!B»¼++|ÆÇ"ÈaWÉÊËL}ÌÍZ6Î=

ÏÐ&U"UÑºÒ¿&++6 ÓÔ6;<6Õ6:\Öb"g&6M

×ØUVB)5ÙÚ±Û

ÜÜ

(20)

!"#$%&'()*+,-./01234566 7 8 9:&;<=>? "#$%&@AB)*CDEFGHI3JK$

LM@

N

OPQRST UV

W !!X$YZ?[<\-]^_-./01234566

``

質問書方式による考える力をつける教育実践(2)

!"#$ %&'()*+,-./012 34+5 6789:'(

;<=

+ABCDE &'(FGHI+J:(

KLMNONP+Q:'FRS2T89UVW#X+

Y(

?LZ[\:'(

L+]^4_`a"+AbNcd'(

eL[\fg[\,hi:'(

Ejk+lmnm/0opq&'qFErTsY2t

()uv wxyz{Yqn2Xd+2'n|&'( }=~,,XE t'-sY2t'2tn,(` uc%<+

n$'qtYn!|E'(

34

1A4-./012 EtYn/0

,2'7q=&'(E/0NP+:',2|2Z%An ( n/0NP+:'qNPN+_q2t j

',q$|E'(q)uz{&'(F FE

+A'''-./0?

; <

!

"#$ %&'()*+ ,-./&# ,-'0'&#1,- 23456789:; 9<=>4%)??@ABCDE"#

'-F'0GE7 9<= %BC6H ! E7I"#%J ! %/@KLE7M"#(6H NJ"#O(H 9

<='PQ H0GE7

8RSTUV)WX*+%Y !SZ[G 00GJ\%[]^

SZE_`ab[E7cdEe HfXE1'IcdEeXf gh-'I!ESiPjklHmnQ7Eo,Pp% qfX PpE) rstuvu !wQxy'z{(wQ|}~)6|}Q

GX-PpE7

Pp%SiQG "#H !B8R0G$

N4$Q ,-)E0GN,-

_89 ,-GX- % 4) "#)#$) ST) y4  4

E7

¡¢£¤E N¥X% "#H¦X N¥X§E7 ¨©N=ª'0'QG«

£¤ «£¤ %/e( §Q7

­ pE%8R®4"#$%S¯E7N)¬«° E"#±

#$N)²«°<zEH³46NESZE(«£¤E%Pp , '0'S´µ¶'*+ ,-%)X%0N&' E7,h"

#±#6 QEe·)¸D¹(]^ ST Q{(,E)¨n

cd4hº# »Y¼½'-)*+%H³6NE¾e8RST !j¿'7eG0 pÀ§0GÁ zÂE7,Q)*+cdÃÄ

¥X )PQ '-cdQ2T ÅÆ'

S´ÇÈÉ1·0GÁ7GÊ !ËÌQ7X% YZ

&'´E6ÍÃ6(N0H'-Shf)½ÎQ^ÏG0 ½ÎE7 Ð¯

%ÒÓM/+Ô*ÕE8RÍÃ6Shfcd%Y!0-Ö×ØÙÚ-

¬r+ÛÜEÝÞßà Ppáâ «Si)cdãÃ¬«ä åæ'- X )ST«çQèH»Ycd¹éêë%è' «IE=QN- 0% «ìGIE(cdQEe0,Q) «íÉ-0GîcdQ2Z

!"#$%&'()'*+,-.#/0/123/4(

*+,-.51

567(89:,-;) <=4>?@(A/>51(B 5CD:E>*+, F#BGH

I-JKL4MNO14PQR(%S#TUVS(WXYZ [\]^#_4SJ`abc de`af%PgX2V\h"

H#ij(k/#2'#lm;4`dA414P51n o<5:#p>CDqr's`dEtEu,-4,,KL4MNO#`d Etlm,s>4ij#4=/vAwx-v2'lm;

CD:>51#yz{:|4}HGP:~(ij#!1#L 4oPH5=// .51(A/,ij:,15

#Pij1#L4oP



1"# 0GP:`dlm(

:ijCD:E>[\(L"5[\#QR: ,

`dm](,",-5",4"} ¡

`d:¢(,-}Z£ 1"

5QRS¤¥(¦§>1¨GP:

$©ijCD:E,-K[\ªLOu«(¬[\(­®>

¯©5}°±²³1ij´²³(µ¶V·¸:L¹ 4[\(9L

U©[º:)'*+,=;9L51(%PK »¼½:G¾\OK

[\ OK[\¿(.OK¯'ÀÁÂOK¢(,-.OKÃÄO KÅ3ÂÆ OK Æ"OKL¹4[\(9LOI:ÇÈv:

+É, [\ÊËÌÍÎ(.51Ï}-4;Ð/ ÀÁ*

+,-4 #K [\ OK¯'ÀÁÂOKÃÄO KL¹4[\(9LOKÇÈv:+É, [\ÊËÌÍÎ(.OÑ

Ò:Ó,4QRÔ(Õ>

$© (1QRÖ×1Ø:ÙI»¼½(Ú QR:Eu,51([

\,H($0ÒC:]4- Û>]4gXs Ü<gX#H.Ý]

4-P `<51Á/4Þ:ß-4(à51;

!"

#$%& '()*+,-./"01#

2'( 3"4-56#7895:%;41 <"==>?341;6+@ABCDEF"

G,HIJKL '(MNO6+PQ

RS T&:"4-56+,H#UVT%;6+,- WX-"4-#YZ[/\]1"#^_3#`YZ$

a$bc-T1+de/-f&T+3#ghi jT93"k)l5:m#Qm"n Tdeop/

qr%& 3"

s,Htuvwxeyz{|R}~"xe#tu56 L '( 3"tu#/`<=T 0# 2 3"4-

 256n"denn"R+Rj

2+g%&<<+9MNOXT&:"

R#+R

!&%5:+%&¢}£¤

U(TR #+tu¥¦§(R+,-¨6©5:ª«

"c%&#¬­%&g®¯41#~°+R±^_¥¦%&

²³5:ª«"´g®¯CDTG(&RS %&®¯5 :ª«"^_µ¶ <#+g41T3+^_¥¦

±-·¸µ¹µ¶ <41º +»®¯T%¼&

41º +¬­#%&½¾¿ÀÁÂ/ 51ª«

()uv wxyz{Yqn2Xd+2'n|&'( }=~,,XE t'-sY2t'2tn,(`uc%<+

n$'qtYn!|E'(

1A4-./012 EtYn/0

,2'7q=&'(E/0NP+:',2|2Z%An ( n/0NP+:'qNPN+_q2t j

',q$|E'(q)uz{&'(F FE

+A'''-./0?

SZE_`ab[E7cdEe HfXE1'IcdEeXf gh-'I!ESiPjklHmnQ7Eo,Pp% qfX PpE) rstuvu !wQxy'z{(wQ|}~)6|}Q

Pp%SiQG"#H !B8R0G$

N4$Q ,-)E0GN,-

_89 ,-GX- % 4) "#)#$) ST) y4 4

E7

¡¢£¤E N¥X%"#H¦X N¥X§E7 ¨©N=ª'0'QG«

£¤ «£¤ %/e( §Q7

pE%8R®4"#$%S¯E7N)¬«° E"#±

#$N)²«°<zEH³46NESZE(«£¤E%Pp , '0'S´µ¶'*+ ,-%)X%0N&' E7,h"

#±#6 QEe·)¸D¹(]^ ST Q{(,E)¨n

cd4hº# »Y¼½'-)+%H³6NE¾e8RST !j¿'7eG0 pÀ§0GÁ zÂE7,Q)+cdÃÄ

¥X )PQ '-cdQ2T ÅÆ'

S´ÇÈÉ1·0GÁ7GÊ !ËÌQ7X%YZ

&'´E6ÍÃ6(N0H'-Shf)½ÎQ^ÏG0 ½ÎE7 Ð¯

¬r+ÛÜEÝÞßàPpáâ «Si)cdãÃ¬«ä åæ'- X )ST«çQèH»Ycd¹éêë%è' «IE=QN- 0% «ìGIE(cdQEe0,Q) «íÉ-0GîcdQ2Z

CD:>51#yz{:|4}HGP:~(ij#!1#L 4oPH5=//.51(A/,ij:,15

#Pij1#L4oP

1"# 0GP:`dlm(

:ijCD:E>[\(L"5[\#QR: ,

`dm](,",-5",4"} ¡

`d:¢(,-}Z£ 1"

$©ijCD:E,-K[\ªLOu«(¬[\(®>

¯©5}°±²³1ij´²³(µ¶V·¸:L¹ 4[\(9L

U©[º:)'*+,=;9L51(%PK »¼½:G¾\OK

[\ OK[\¿(.OK¯'ÀÁÂOK¢(,-.OKÃÄO KÅ3ÂÆ OK Æ"OKL¹4[\(9LOI:ÇÈv:

+É, [\ÊËÌÍÎ(.51Ï}-4;Ð/ ÀÁ*

+,-4 #K [\ OK¯'ÀÁÂOKÃÄO KL¹4[\(9LOKÇÈv:+É, [\ÊËÌÍÎ(.OÑ

Ò:Ó,4QRÔ(Õ>

$© (1QRÖ×1Ø:ÙI»¼½(Ú QR:Eu,51([

\,H($0ÒC:]4- Û>]4gXs Ü<gX#H.Ý]

4-P `<51Á/4Þ:ß-4(à51;

s,Htuvwxeyz{|R}~"xe#tu56 L '( 3"tu#/`<=T 0# 2 3"4-

256n"denn"R+Rj

2+g%&<<+9MNOXT&:"

R#+R

!&%5:+%&¢}£¤

U(TR #+tu¥¦§(R+,-¨6©5:ª«

"c%&#¬%&g®¯41#~°+R±^_¥¦%&

²³5:ª«"´g®¯CDTG(&RS %&®¯5 :ª«"^_µ¶ <#+g41T3+^_¥¦

±-·¸µ¹µ¶ <41º +»®¯T%¼&

41º +¬#%&½¾¿ÀÁÂ/ 51ª«

ÃPÂRS T&:"4Rj2RÄ%jT&:"g

%&1TRj41# 2R#ÅÆÇ %5:"

#RCD+¬Mxe&- +%6ÈÉÊËÌ R41 <"

ÍÎÏ,HIJ !"4#e41 <M

#e"MNO3ÐÑÒÓÔ#"

K !Anxe Õ^_|R&Me"4Î Ö#MNO"4-#?× ØÙ3"cÚ(^

_5ÛÜTp/3"

ÝMNOÞß àá+â<&ã? <½#ã?T&

:"Me#^_1S9 +äåæ56ã?+çè5 6ã?T&:"

$%&'(%)'' +,- .$/01+, 2345/6)7 89:9;%<=>?/96)'@A/BCDCEFGH'*=/

:LL %$o@oEE#$/E0Az{) }~:LH MuC'/ #$/6:L !"/6'/6)

zE#$ xr %) /I vw4 5xr%rySO/ hi!"00)

%ry)x uLH Hg@%O

H ¡%yuC)

"¢ @oE+, £¤]o/6:C0%¥¦§XE¨©(o1 LªE%)' +,+,0«¬®*@oE¯u°E±²³´µ

/E)78¶uLTU ·WSO%XL¸¹'Vº»' V0:C /HTU ¼½¾6H¿¿EÀÁ/XE>?%&(Â:0 OE+,%ÃÄuL @AÅÆC9 /6)-ÇE+,&È0«p8§É ÊËÌÃuLgL) 8 /ÍÎÏ?OL%g'E:

L)&Ð%1O'' +, ÃR/6ÑaÒÓ £¤ kÔÃÕ n {/6)

pÖ9Æ×.u ¡9ÀØ/Â'%ÙÚRF) zÛ$H#$%Ð%1O)

XE¨©%&'/Â)

¡%ÆÐHqiÜÝ%Þ»LA"°LÂCVy 9 /·³®*L SOHÊß 9 /6)u0uE«}69 %à·³áâã%»ÆH

¿¿E9 äå@A78 ¡%æçèAHæÐ9éêL)78 ¡%

=E Hë/9ÀØ/ÂE0«/6'VH''/ìíEîïSHÖ

9Æ× ¡%Æ×?0('%ÙÚ®ð'YZ ÃR/6)

kalm8no2epqrfstuY2fqvwxyE2 z{&2)*|+CV[2}~r2c'E7(1206:' E72'E7(12&c'E7(12

x582ea1f_>(1CVm80S

ea1fs0>'Jx ¡¢T637

£E¤:Y¥¦7Y: §9"¨0¥¦ "©x2xª

ea1fU1y: ea1fsCV[« z{¬:Y Q

0fUT3¬:Y (3> ®¯7:'1y:

®° ±²°/ ± 7¯³´2µ!RJ¶·¸¹

J0f!ºJ0:'Y7O_>(1 gUTJ'1_

>Y:¥¦'( »¼>®J²°/½±¾a 9637_>

(1bcJ2ea1fCV0¿À>'c N