1 Pentaceneg¯W#Õï¸ïÂ5ÂcpicenemÅÌ (j¦æ¡ÜÅôÓV^m)fÅß´`±KvÛ
j©T^5)$L@´`±ÌgVenÅmTc 20 Kc$ÌïÅ\¢jcCenQl¶£6)QÆ$«
åÑÄ#¦æ¡ÜihÅôÓXg´`±ji
#Åßfn¦ç³¡ÜÅôÓV^«åÑÄfTc
12 KgibeC7)$
«åÑ¢ïm¨
}gåwåw@¨¿Èw¤È¨wêU
LÀO
åwåw@wn¤È¨wêU
ÂØGv
§1 2 ³»gVem«åÑ¢ï
«åÑ¢ï(graphene)K¨«¨wm׿Äi ÂôÚjôoeXfjvVC$«åÑ¢ïm¤
n#2005N m Geim «çôÓ#Ir Kim
«çôÓj¿¬g#ÁÙiÊq×ôçø Êm©
1,2)j¨¿ª¥ÑT^$RmN
«åÑ¢ïÖAmïcfb X@ïK½xJ Ab^K#\mxj#C}êåªìj¬·V^
Rm¯ÛáÇÂômMC´ W$condmat f»Äçj graphene Ü e_¶õ Xg#89Ò(2006N)#269Ò(2007N)# 504Ò (2008N)#563Ò(2009N)fAJ#RmN nú 1`2 Òn«åÑ¢ïÖAm_¶Ko»V eCPfA$R©e#«åÑ¢ïÖ Am¤n}TjIióµjARgK©e g$
«åÑ¢ïmèÏáônCNcJoÅTeI
1,3)#M¶fm«åÑ¢ïmðà
4)©óP
óµfnAK#{ðàfn#fL_Pe_
fiN«åÑ¢ïjÖAX¨»ÛmfÕ IiÊÐîXRgÚIgV^C$Áj«å Ñ¢ïmdqóÔnuÁÙvgÄoK#½K hmEjÁÙimJSj}ge~^$î {IiðàÚwV^K#©gm_
¤¬ÊKXDfC$Rmðàf#i [«åÑ¢ïK\zh»¡[CmJK`o KCfA$
«åÑ¢ïmdq\¢©Oj#»gVe m«åÑ¢ïm»wI#¨Ii\¢Jn
E$«åÑ¢ïnÕï¸ïÂK½ÊójciKb
^ 2 ³»fA#Yf´qK(sp
2m»w
j)ImiqiXÞ
1$Yfn#ÅC
¤L«c³fgVeâÇôªf#ÀÛ sp
1, sp
2, sp
3gCE½li¬¬gRg½fV e#\] 1 ³mÙæ·½èï#2 ³m
«åÑ¢ï#3 ³m¼àÞïÅgCE`ÔK
¶ÝX(üú¥\f¯°m³æ¯ïfn#«å Ñ¢ï\¢niNgVRjn¶ÝViCRg
zNT^C)$êÊjêcmO¹`Ce d ³m»iq\¬VEgXg#zÊ
(A´qJ~^gLm×Ú´qmÂ)nÅá f d{1 iCg³À d ³»\¬XRg KfLiC$R`Eh~^XmK 1 ³f zÊ 2 mÙæ·½èï#2 ³fzÊ 3 m
«åÑ¢ï#3 ³fzÊ 4 m¼àÞïÅf A$RmÓ ¡fn#Rmiqn d³P
§ûiq(VRjnA}¶ÝViC)î{
IgCG$»wIjn#Imiq¼
ÞïÅi q#C Bravais iq(»m PÊEj 1 ´q)fniN#PÊEj 2 ´qÜ
(^gGo#¼ÞïÅ\¢n#2 Âm fcc i qKüÄjibeC)
8)$
_IÏ_Jn#«åÑ¢ïK¬fL^m KÁLfAmn#´qPw#Jc\ªÚªéµ
¯Ð¿ª(»Ýfn#T^Ij\Ûªéï)i
æP}
µ¯¿½ÂôÓ@jKV^¿(¶)#
SiO2îÂ(E)j]ÊX$(Ê^n#ex´ê
#nÓI÷ñ)
æQ} «åÑ¢ïmripplemTO}$
¿ gVe¬ T_ jA(æ P} Q Æ)$
Peierls, Landau, Mermin K¦ V^Ej#á
³m »n·g·MjÎVesÀèfA
#_Ijni 1 ³ 2 ³m»nÀ
»fLiCglGeC^
9)$jÖY#
«åÑ¢ïnhE\ªjåLi±¶f 2
³»\¢gbeCglGeC$Úª éi«åÑ¢ïmOüm`ÔK#»\¢½f XÁè mûÊcRg(C faceting, 3
³»fnÁèmûÊc»\Ê)j\
eC$ÀÛm¿fn# SiO
2ihmî ãjIJ^#Ìçªm³æ¯ïE¦ôÌÅ m\Êjì^# Åßfn CDV fîÂmãj ìmf#2 ³nn 3 ³njxGe C$VJV# ãqX freestanding graphene(A
Cn suspended graphene)gÄomfn#
î{Ijn 2 ³³ÀnglGmKKØfA
glGeC$_Ijn¶ÝVenCPi CmK#ÀÛjfLeV}E$RmA^K#
©RÈw mÊCgRf#À±ÆmÊÚô@
gCEgRfAE$`Rmbjn±L KAbe#»Àm«åÑ¢ïjICen#Im
iqn®øi½ÊfniN# ÊbeCe(R
n ripple gCEæQ})#Rm·g·m
ElKdviðÊ^VeCglG
eC
10,11)$c}#«åÑ¢ïn 3 ³óÔj
¶ÝXPf#2 ³»gnCbe#3
³ûümElm©Rx`#Rm©RxK£
ïÄéÐôzûXRgfMjÎVeÀè i 2 ³\¢ìgCElGûfA$El
KA}åLNiXMg}YCK#\Ei
g sp
2¤LKc^jdqnn£Éç©ô
¹X^#ÇIjnÏ`¬TNVe£É ç©ô¹¸}Gcc#KiåLTmElK
¶ÝXRgj£ïÄéÐôðúXg CEÌåïµj#æ¿Óç\¢gib^
2 ³ÅÌK¶ÝV¾glGeC$
§2 ¿Ê^iCÃ忪±q gVem«åÑ¢ïmdq
2.1 ¸é©ß¿Ó¼±Ìg¿Ê^iC Ã忪±q
«åÑ¢ïn# À Û m ¬ R\SNÅ ß j Geim j¿K¾Ejib^óf AK# _Ijn1940NãJl GeI
#\mÁÙ idq\¢Åj wEV^mn Wallace
12)m1947Nm_¶fA#\mã#Q_
Il@#Lø¿Êßjl@K Lomer
13), McClure
14), SlonczewskiWeiss
15)jiT^$
êÊj»mdq\¢n#à®gâÌ(¼±Ì
Ü )jª P$à ®nÑ¢çÛÊ
`#\}^Odq³Eζ¬j©ß¿Ó èµmãNcêû#âÌn»müúj
ÊqÍwI±ÂøÊjNöXÌïÅE©ß¿
ÓfÁ¥tP$êû#¼à®gCE¦Â°
æôKA#RnÊn#¼±ÌjICe£É ç©ôE©ß¿ÓK¸égib^óµgVeè`
T$VJV#«åÑ¢ïmên#©ß¿Ó K¸égCEÓ¡fn¼à®fAK(ÀÛ#«
åÑ¢ïÏwTZ^«åÑÄn#¬Tid
æR} «åÑ¢ïmPÊEgî{ÀiÕªÄç$
2 Ên«åÑ¢ï(Pw«åÑÄ)fmÁÙiªU n#pdqjÎXtightbindingÍ^fc_T$V JV#Ã忪E¯ôïnImÎÌ«m^j¶W
mf#tightbindingÍ^ÈOmêÊIiÍ^fÃ
忪E¯ôïK¶W$^gGo#´qÙÂï³ßç
ImójuC^Í^fÃ忪E¯ôïK¶W
Rg¦Z16)$ÀÛ#RmÍ^j#tightbinding Í^jIP×ÚmòrÚϪml]¿XRg
IRieC17)$}^#¥êJP^gLmåï
¼¡Ê#Lø¿ÊߥêPeierlsÊjæ
üßjYRgKfL16)$
æS} «åÑ¢ïm£Éç©ôªU
qÙ¬¿Äg¬Ti³EÙ¬¿Äc¼à®f
A)#«åÑ¢ïKÁêimn#Ñ¢çÛE£
Éç©ô E
FmgRfÌïŪUn¸éfni CÑ¢çÛ¬xbeÑÊVeC$c}#
Ên E
FKÌïÅ[jgdqm¬xn¸é jimgnÎÆIi#ÊfniC¼à®fA
_jA$Rn#«åÑ¢ïKcImi qgCEÁÊiiq(æR})m^fA$Im
iq n#}jH `f`C^PÊEj 2 ´q
(}fnf\¦)Ü$iqn#Yfm sp
2¬¬O¹KÝCj120 Ùi 3 ûüüN¤L
jVeI#»wm¾tfCGo#R
K s iX$c 1 dqn#iq(x, y)Ê J¼ jòro^ p
zO¹(p O¹ )jü#R
K´q ÔòrÚ$R p gr#
RJ¬ÌïÅ p ÌïÅgu$
«åÑ¢ïmdqI«¿SEmn#p ÌïÅ fA#Ñ¢çÛE£Éç©ô E
FRm핁
¡Ø beC$R Ên tightbinding Í
^fµEÞ
2$Rm#ËÛçÄÇïn#x P ÊEmÊumåÕçgVe
t
x[c
õä(x)c
å(x ){c
õå(x{e
1)c
ä(x )
{c
õå(x{e
2)c
ä(x)]{h.c.
gP$RRf#c
õn(x)n x jAPÊEàm n
ä}^nåm´qm p O¹jdq¶¬X
Zq#t nÅ×Ú´qÔmòrÚϪfA$
»Àm«åÑ¢ïfn tq|3 eV gCElc$
ËÛçÄÇïg\¦X^j# c
åä(x)
ke
ik¥xc
åä(k )mEj Bloch \¦Xg#
(k )
kc
õ(k)H(k )c(k ),
H(k ) ( DÞ 0 (k ) D(k 0 ) )
gi$RRf c
õ(k )ß(c
õå(k ), c
õä(k )), D(k )t (1{e
|ik1{e
|ik2)fA$e k SgjÎp »X
o#iNûö®K e
2(k )|D(k )|
2giRgJ
XOJEj#£Éç©ôªUn e(k )
}|D(k )| gi$Rm£Éç©ôªU æS}
j¦XK#RJ#«åÑ¢ïmÌïŪU n#góÔ 2 _(ÒæçïEºôïm#K _ g K _go_)f£Éç©ôE©ß¿ÓK ü`jÂW(gCEJð·X)~(cone)
c#ÁÙinfARgK©eæ$©ß¿Ó KÂW_ßTfªUÖWK#¿Ê^iCÃ
忪±qg`®IjeCmf#«åÑ¢
ïmdqn Î_IfAg\»T$
D(k )0 K¸é©ß¿ÓmðA^Gg
mðfA#ïÌIjn e
|ik1v, e
|ik2v
2(R Rf v
31, v1 n 1 m 3 æª)gi$Rmã
Iiðn#e±ÄJf 3 {mæïªm
¯«jARgn SlonczewskyWeiss jÃ
NJmeC^
15)$ÌïÅEÍåÝô»gV
æT} ¼±Ì(a)g¸é©ß¿Ó¼±Ì(b)$
3 kÞ_#Xi`¸é©ß¿Ó_ßTf£Éç©ô´
_jg˶«^Zg#êÊjnÃ忪¯
ôïmXL(tilting)^G#ÀÛAímL@ÅÌfRm
EiRgK©oTeCK#«åÑ¢ïfn#nj ãqmåÇIi¦åçÎÌ«vXo#Rmtilting nNLiC$
en#Lø¿Ê mÞ q0.6 m
e#Ñ¢çÛ¬x [
Fq 10
5m/s(õ¬mñ 1/300)fA$
RmÁÙiÃ忪E¯ôïm¶ÝnôRi mfAEJG }^#ü`j£Éç©ôKÂW
_n 2 ÓAK#1 ÓgCERgêÊj nA¾mfAEJG RâèÓ¯g Ve#VêÊIjl@Ve~E$ÊímÅÌ
m£Éç©ôEÌïÅ\¢n#CLø¿
ÊßjðT$ÒæçïEºôï
m ÚX_(ÊnÌïÅmê#VNn¸_) mg k
0ßTf£Éç©ôªU e(k )# e(k )|
e(k
0)k}(
2(dk )
2)/(2m
eff)(RRf dkk|k
0)m
EjWJV#m
effLø¿Êg~iV#k \¦
JÀóÔ\¦jXè±L( dk ¨|i ; )j
#LøËÛçÄÇï H
eff|(
2/2m
eff);
2glG#¿Ê m
effm©R±q(ÊqÍwIjn½ Êg)g~iX(æT}(a))$RmLø¿Êßn ÌïÅ_mêcmîbgVeA}lNge CmfA$
VJVRmß n æ 5 }(b)mEj£Éç
©ôªU Kü`jð·XgLjn#ªUmÈ
¦mtgVemLø¿ÊnE}Nè`fLY#
L ø ¿ Ê ß K ¬ § V i C $ \ m ^ j # SlonczewskyWeiss n#K _#K _mü#C
k¥p Û®pCeµb^mfAb^
15)$ RRfn# ȺmEiÏ_J©e~E
18)$ êÊj#£Éç©ôIjÚßACnð·V^¿
dqÑ#`±ÑgCE 2 cm£Éç©ôEÌïÅ
©ß¿Ó(ACnð·)ßTfc_Xjn#
g k ÍåÝô»gX 2 ÊngVelG
oC$c}\m k óÔfmËÛçÄÇïn 2 s 2 ñgi$RmEjlGg#RmÝè n#ôRkÞ_mßTfg®ÖêÊjc_V
^ Berry ml@\mmg©iZ
19)$be#
£Éç©ô´_©ß¿Óm(ACnð_) jg Tr H0 gXoÞ
3#LøËÛçÄÇï n
H(k ) ( DÞ R
3(k) (k) |R D(k)
3(k) )
ß ( R
1{iR R
3 2R |R
1|iR
32) R¥s
mEjP$RRf s(s
1, s
2, s
3)nÍ¡æ sñ#D(¡f)g R
3(À)nÌïÅmÚ×
èXÍåÝô»fA#Ræ 3 jIC en Berry j]be 3 ÂmÀÍåÝô» R(k )
(R
1(k ), R
2(k ), R
3(k )), R
1(k )Re D(k ), R
2(k )
|Im D(k )fL¼V^$RmËÛçÄÇï
mÅL£Éç©ôn#iNûö®KE
2R
2(RR f Rß|R |)giRgJ#^_`j E
}}R
(k )gi#¡n{K`±Ñ#|K¿dqÑj
ÎV#E
g2R K£Éç©ôE©ß¿Ógi
RgKJ$
RRf#«åÑ¢ïn 2 ³n_Jg k n 2 ³óÔ®L#ËÛçÄÇïn 3 ³mÍ åÝô» R jwèTmf# ©Rxm
Ïm³mûKiCJ#êÊjn R(k ) n´_ÊßZY#c}#ËÛçÄÇïKã Lm 2~2 sñjPgLf#£Éç©ôE
©ß¿ÓnêÊjnÂWiC$c}#¸é©ß
¿Óji^jnðKKvfA#êÊjn
¨ÍåÝô»E}N²®(fine tune)V^gL m~À»XgmÓ¡fôRkÞ gCG$t j#ôRfÇCmfAo#2 {mÌïÅKð·
XRgnA¾$Rn#ÒæçïEºô
æU}
¸é©ß¿ÓEËÛçÄÇïm¦åçÎÌ«mô
½wI\¦$
ïàfÎÌ«mC_fIL¾V#êÊm_
fIL¾$\fn#«åÑ¢ïjIPÃ
忪E¯ôïn#hiðj¶V^
mfAEJ$
«åÑ¢ïjICen#Ã忪E¯ôïn ÒæçïEºôïàfÎÌ«mC_(K, K ) j¶V#Ên«åÑ¢ïKÃ忪E¯ô ïcRRJà¾X
12)$VJVÀ n#êÊIjn#¦åçÎÌ«go
AÎÌ«KdvfA#RßfÚVNà
¾Ve~E$
2.2 ¦åçÎÌ«g«åÑ¢ï
«åÑ¢ïnPÊEj 2 ´q(A, B gÄr#R
n¿#æ 3 }m#miq_)cJ
#eiq_j 1 O¹(¡mên p O¹)l Go 2 ÌïÅgi$V^Kbe#ÀiÎÌ«
TGAo(^gGo#»Àjn³fLiC
×ÚÈm·£×¿Ðï«KAEKA}C K)#g\¦jÚb^gL 2 s 2 ñmËÛçÄ
Çï H(k )fLqT$VJV«åÑ¢ïm
î{IiÁ¥gVe#Imiqãf A, B ª iqjªP^gL#æ 3 }mEj#åviòr ÚϪn A, B iqÔjm~¶ÝX$Rm«
¿#êÊj bipartite gÄu$Rm«¿j#
«åÑ¢ïmËÛçÄÇïn gs
3gVe#
{H, g}Hg{gH0 gCEÖW®^XRg K¦Z#«åÑ¢ïm¦åçÎÌ«gÄo
$ÀnRm¦åçÎÌ«n«åÑ¢ïmêc mdvi Á«fAÑ¢çÛ¥ïE¼Òæï«
(Fermion doubling)jICe{ ¿ Ii ð fA
$Rnêm_jIPpêfA#`i~
j#ì_jICeÎÌ«m©IjKlG
^gL#³Xn¦åçÎÌ«KOªjuJ
^$
Ⱥf¦XEj#¿ÊmiCÃ忪±q jÖXRm¦åçÎÌ«#êÊmÏ_
JlGgJXC
18)$}Y#êÊm¦
åç Zq g 3 ³mPÊ ÕªÄç n
g, (|n
g|
1)pCe#mEjè`VE$
gn
g¥s, g
2s
0RRf s
0n 2 ³mPÊsñfA$Rm#
ËÛçÄÇï H K¦åçÎÌfAo {H, g}0, gHg
|1|H
giJ#Äèôµgg Tr H 0 gi
$be¦åçÎÌiËÛçÄÇïn#ê Êj HR¥s gWJfL$RRf#Í¡æs ñjÖVe KâèihfIÚjJJÖW®
(A¥s )(B¥s)(A¥B){is¥(A~B )pCg#
¦åçÎÌ« mðn 0{H, g }{R¥s, n
g¥ s }2R¥n
ggiJ#R ÕªÄçK#´_
Ê n
gm@½ÊjíjmbeCRgjÎX
(æU})$
j#Rm¦åçÎ Ìi 2 ÌïÅn jIC e#¸é©ß¿Ómð(R(k
0)0)K½g
k
0f^TgVE(êÊm¸é©ß¿Ó¼
±Ì)$RmgL#\mgüf H WJX
g(k¥p Û®g¯lmlGûfA)#á£Éç©
ômLøËÛçÄÇïn k m 1 Jn}#
H(k )kH
0(X¥s)dk
x{(Y¥s)dk
y, X&R/&k
x, Y&R/&k
y, dkk|k
0mEj£Éç©ôªUnÃ忪¥¯ôï
ì$
RRf X~Y }^Rm½Êm@üÕªÄçf ARgjÓV#RK n
gg½smêj#
Ã忪E¯ôïm¦åæÂô x {1#
½½ sm ê j¦åæÂô x |1 g è`
VE$c}#
X~Yx( c )
2n
g, c
2|X~Y|/
2gRE$(X, Y, n
g)KEènmÀWncN
o¦åæÂô{1#¶èni|1 fA$
RRf c nuõ¬v(¿ÊmiCÃ忪±q
æV} ¦åçÎÌigLmR(T2)$
(a)Ã忪¥¯ôïK¶Wê#(b)©ß¿ÓKJNê
m¬x [
F)fA$H 2 æXg H
2( c )
2(dk
x, dk
y)J ( dk dk
xy) ,
J 1
( c )
2( X¥X X¥Y X¥Y Y¥Y )
gimf#det J( c )
|4|X~Y |
21 giR gJ#³èl mÎÌsñ J Îp»X¼ð s ñ VgVe J V
õdiag (j
X, j
Y)V, (K
X, K
Y)
(dk
x, dk
y)V
õgXo#H m£Éç©ôªUK E} v
K,
v
Kc K,
K j
XK
X2{j
YK
Y2, j
Xj
Ydet J1
gCE(êÊIjnÙûIi)¯ôïjiRg
mJRgKfL$
RRfn#A, B ªiqm¯«jîdN¦
åçÎÌ«KAê#©RjÃ忪ªU K»Rgc_V^$ßfc_XEj Rm¦åçÎÌ«çÀ#n detune V e (^ g G o # I m i q ã m 1 O ¹ tight
binding Í^JÏXVe)#Ã忪ªUnÄ
Ùé´¦çjÀè(LÀmOjÎVeÀèIf
ÕI)fARgK¦Z$tj#PÊEàm 2 ±Äm¯«jo¦åçÎÌ«Kj
$ÎÌ«nj^½jTTRgnì
_mCEgRfAK#Rm¦åçÎÌ
«jêKA#Ìçªf¦åçÎÌ
«jiNg[tßfÇIj¦åçÎÌ
«nj(AB ±Äm¿«jµÐï
K§c)mK\máfA$RjcCen
uÌçªE£¿´ÎvgÖAVeãfc_X$
2.3 ¦åçÎÌ«gÃ忪E¯ôï mÄÙé´¦çÀè«
RmEj#ÀiÎÌJc AB ±ÄK¯f A«åÑ¢ïfn¦åçÎÌ«KíjÛ^
Rgà¾V^$Rm¦åçÎÌ«TGÛe o#êx¶¬V^¿ÊmiCÃ忪±qgV emªUÖWnOmÛ®jÎVeÀèj¶Ý XRgK±J$VJ#RmÛ®n³À¬
fARgnKvfiN#êÊjnAÍÍmL ÀmåLTmÛ®ºfAbe#¸é©ß¿Óm }}fA$RKÄÙé´¦ç À è« fA
20,21)#^gGo#iqÏ`KLÀj¶We#
«åÑ¢ïmiqKZp`JKjÏ`V^g Ve#\mÏ`KAÕEl´GTGViP
o#©ß¿Óèµm£Éç©ôªUnÀèj¶
ÝX$RmÀnCNcJmlI¤j
¦´TeC
22)$
}^#ÒæçïEºôïKüúIfA#«
E^iCRgjÎVe¸éE©ß¿Ómg
nêÊjnKYô¶ÝX$RK Ñ¢ç Û¥ïE¼Òæï« fAK#4 ³miq®ô
´_jICen#Nielsen_ ñ{è
23)gVe#
Nm^ÀfA$m 2 ³n («åÑ¢ï)jICe¯mc_KsG#¦
åçÎÌi©ß¿ÓèµmÃ忪ªUn¼Ò
æï«KYºE#Xi`Ã忪_nKY
ô¶ÝX$RmÓ¡f#¡mÃ忪
ªUn¦åçÎÌ«jÄÙé´¦çjÛì
æW}
¼Òæï«j¦åçÖm¦åæÂô$
æP\ «åÑ¢ïjIPíXmOK¦åçÎ Ì«jJÛJ¦V^\$
«åÑ¢ïjIPO ¦åçÎÌ«
s¨´q ~
òrÚϪm
åï¼Ü¥ê
æ¿Óç
½¥« ~
ØïÅ
TeC
18,24,25)$
¼Òæï«jcCeȺÈPjà¾VE$}
Y#ÒæçïEºôïnüúIfA#2 ³ fn T
2{(k
x, k
y)|k
x, k
y¸[|p, p]}gi$Xi
`#³û ` k
x}p \ Ze³æï
¼ôj#Tj k
y}p \ZeÄôåµ gi$RRf#OßfËÛçÄÇïmc_f pC^ÕæômÍåÝÄæ¸ô³ãïfAÊ
k¨R(k )gGo#3 ³óÔ R óÔãf 2 ³ Â È ÊfAÒæçïE ºôïm R(T
2) n#n 3 ³miJm 2 ³ÂÈÊgi$
RRfTj¦åçÎÌ«vXoRm ÈÊn´_Ê n
gj¼i½ÊãjcuT
e¶ÝXRggi$D÷mãjVcu XRglGe©oC(æV})$RmgL#
´_ãjn(jeCiCÀ)DnKYôñ dibeCRgn¾JfAE$^_V#S NdibeCiC}mEmEióµA¾
$}^#cuT^DmKôR´_gdi
RgnêÊjnlGiNeCmf#dib^
ñnDAöxLÀj®JVeÏ»Vi CRg¾JfAE$´_ãj R(k
0)Kd ib^gL#¸é©ß¿ÓA^GRgjÓ Xo#Èãml@JÑ¢çÛ¥ïE¼Òæï
«g\mÄÙé´¦çÀè«n©¾gi$
RmEjêsvZZYj#ÈãK±J
RgKÄÙé´¦çic_m_fA$¯lm c_n 4 ³fÀsÂ\f#RK Nielsen_ ñ
{mèg©iZ$RmEi±on
gƧj Creutz jiTeC
8,20,21,24)$
¦åæÂôjcCen#m 2 ³ mê#3 ³mmÂÈÊ R nêÊm_fnü LtPÂ\fARgJ#\ 2 ³½Êã jcuV^#¼ÒåôÔfn#æW} jA
Ej\g jA X~Y ntüLgi#¦
åæÂôx tgiRg¾Jgi
18)$ 2.4 ^«åÑ¢ïjIP
¦åçÎÌ«
«åÑ¢ïn#ÀÛj¶ÝX¿jnKY
K¶ÝV#«åÑ¢ïm¨jIPdviê
¤ÊcN$ðjUÔo#«åÑ¢ïm ü`ªUm ©nÀ±jÀ» nJj ÃCRgnùjà¾V^K#Ã忪±qjÎ XmøÊm_#«åÑ¢ïm©
JiÈOjTJm{$Oßfà¾V^¦å çÎÌ«n#LN#ÀiÎÌ«^iC
gib^«åÑ¢ïjICe#bipartite iiqãfè`T#\mÓ`nåï¼Ünm
Õ«mÏ_JCCgc_ KiTeC
26`28)$
«åÑ¢ïjIPgVen#íXm»
ÓKlGK#R æP\ j}ge
~E$Rm\fn#K¶ÝXgLnm¦
åçÎÌ«KÛ^JÛJ¦X$¦åç ÎÌ«ÛcjÖVen#¸éE£Éç©ô KÁÊiÓ¡`#ãfà¾X¥êm n
0 åAÊnåLie¿óP$\jA
Ej#s¨´qJmmøÊn¦å
çÎÌ«j K#RmðàmÅ jG^Ñ
æôµ»ïÃï«E«åÑ¢ïgÄoó
jJ_«åÑ¢ïlGg#Rmnfns
¨ÈOj 2 ³ÅÌmÀè«mvJK{f Aæ¿ÓçKàIvögVemgVe¶Ý X$À±IjÉÀIj¸Veæ¿Ó ç_PnæPiCmfA$Rmæ¿Óçm åiøÊn#´qÔm£ÏXV#p O¹Ôm dimpxÏGRgjñ^XglG
$RniqÍ^gVen·üúmóÔÖ
cåï¼Ü¥×¿Ðï«#åï¼ÜÊgVe nje¿A^G#}^#A±Í^gVen
C_®ô´ê^XRggi$
§3 ¥ê«åÑ¢ïm Êq×ôçøÊ
«åÑ¢ïmÅåmÁLn#\mÁÙiÊq×
ôçøÊjAb^
1,2)$À±I©ÈOj# À¡
jËǦÜiqmÊq×ôçøÊn_Ij² xeC^
32)$«åÑ¢ïjIP¸é©ß¿
ÓóÔ¿Ê^iCÃ忪±qgÄxo#
«åÑ¢ïmÊq×ôçø ÊnRm¿Ê^
iCÃ忪±qmÊq×ôçøÊgCEP fA$¨Ijn¥êøÊfåAÊK`
¬TK#«åÑ¢ïmên#Ã忪±
qmåAÊgi#ÊímåAÊg nÙimgi$Áj#Êq×ôçøÊj tX#CÄÙé´¦çÊqmlKÁ Ùji$\_PfiN#\mwigVe#ê Êj×ôçøÊnÑ¢çÛE£Éç©ôȺmó ÔKÖ^XK#Ã忪±qnfnRKÁ Ùiâègi$c}#Ã忪ûö®jÎ Ve#\m£Éç©ôóÔSeèLV^dq óÔÊíÃ忪mCgVe^óglGK#
«åÑ¢ïjgben#¿dqÑXxe^
«m¸é©ß¿Ó¼±ÌK\mÃ忪mC jÎX$åAÊq»n`£Éç
©ôóÔjyuJ#\mÓ¡f#¥ê«å Ñ¢ïfm¥êøÊnKRIj^ómÄ\¬º ERggi$Rmßfn}Yn#ÁÙi«åÑ
¢ïEåAÊ\¢jcCeà¾V^C$
3.1 åAÊg×ôç`±x
Åj#Êm x y ½Êàm 2 ³©Rdqm åAÊjcCeÈPjKVeIRE$Ë ÛçÄÇïH
F(1/(2m))( p|eA )
2, p|i ; gV# êl¥ê B(0, 0, B)rot A ^Gåï¼
¡E®ô´jIPÕªÄçEÙÂï³ßç A
(0, Bx, 0)go#g®Ön CX
ky(x )e
|ikyyg P#g® Ö Ï ª £V^ X
ky(x )n x
x
0(k
y)l
B2k
y, (l
B /(eB))SgX(x ûü j Ç Ý V^ )p U ® v eB/ m m ² a U ® q m g ® Ö gi$ y û ü j · T L
ym ü ú I
«EðÛZo#g k
y(2p/L
y)n
yn#n
y¸Z mEjgKÊq»V#£Éç©ôÊn E
n
v(N{ 1/2), N0, 1, 2,c gCEåAÊ
\¢cN$Tjn K x û üLÀm³æï
¼ôãjAgVe 0x
0(k
y)l
B2k
yL
xgmS
© ð I P o # e Ê n D ( 1/ 2) ( L
xL
y/ (pl
B2))_PkÞXRggi(åAkÞ)$
RRf Laughlin jibe#³æï¼ôàj
ËéÊÑEØôÜ¥© F fMIj±üV#
nm×ôç`±xvZVE
29)(æX})$¥©
møÊn#A
y¨A
y{DA gè DA
yF/L
y_P y ûümÕªÄç¥ÙÂï³ßçÁXRgf À»fLK#p
y|eDA (2p/L
y)(n
y|F/F
0)g
PJ#DFF
0mÏ»nËÛçÄÇïj ÎX£U» T^g k
ym 1 c ªm³ÑÄg i#fMßmÍÍf#Xi`²aU®qm
SÀWmÏ»jºiEåAkÞV^g®Ö
m x ûüwm 1 cªmYjÎX$RRf F
0h/e n¥©ÊqfA$C} F Ôgg
jfMIjV^gVE$Xg#DFF
0gi#ËÛçÄÇï(Ir«Eð)n³ jß$c}#Rmßöf#£UIi k _m·
¿Änêlj³ÑÄV#³æï¼ôme[jdÉ KcCeCgXg#¿àmóµnÏ
Y#A®Â(M )mdqK#êûmdÉJ
¼ûmdÉjÚb^Rgji$be³æï¼ ôm¼[md³· V
xgVenjÁb^d
DE n DEMeV
xgi$RRfC Byers
Yang mö®J×ôç d¬ I
yn I
yDE/DF g
©Ïmf
æX} Laughlinmc_g×ôç`±x
I
y MeV
xF
0 e
2h MV
xgi$be#×ôç`±x s
yx(e
2/h )M g CEÊq»¾$RRfnmÑ¢çÛÊnÌ çªm N ÔÚg N{1 Ô ÚmÔ jAgXo (N1, 2, ...)#RmfMßöjICe³æï¼ô m¼[èLT^åAÊm N _Pê
±qÊ(Xi`dq)KÚ®V^glG
J#MN fA$
3.2 «åÑ¢ïmåAÊg
×ôç`±x
«åÑ¢ïfniqmøÊn {¿IfAJ
#êÊjniqãmÑ¢çÛ¥ïgVemdq
¼ÚæµERgKKvgiK#\mOjÑ
¢çÛÊ K©ß¿Óèµm E0 \ ªß TjA
#Jc¥êK\ªãCgLmá£Éç©ômL ø_gVemA±nm¿Ê^iCÃå¿
ª±qm¥êøÊjcCeà¾VE$
OßfcJb^êÊm¦åçÎÌi¸é©ß
¿Ó¼±ÌjÎXLøËÛçÄÇïn#k \
¦JÀóÔ\¦jsNè±L dk
x¨|i &
x, dk
y¨|i &
ygiK#RRfd¥êgm®
ô´sÏi`f|i &
x,y¨|i &
x,y|eA
x,ygVeæ
üE$RRfn¥ê Brot A nóÔ z û üjêlfAgX$be#LøËÛçÄÇ
ïn
H
|1[(X¥s)p
x{(Y¥s)p
y], p|i ; |eA
gi$RRf [p
x, p
y]i eB jÓXo H
2n H
2
|2[X
2p
x2{Y
2p
y2{X¥Y(p
xp
y{p
yp
x)
{i(X~Y )¥s[p
x, p
y]]
c
2(p
õJp)s
0|x(eB c
2)g
c
2(j
XP
X2{j
YP
Y2)|x(eB c
2)g gi$RRfOjpC^ J Îp»X¼ðs ñj PVp gV^$iI X~Y¥sx( c )
2g fA$H
2mæên#det Jj
Xj
Y1 jÓ Ve c
2¨1/(2m )gÇ~¼Zo#ÙûIiLø¿
Ê m/j
X, m/j
Yc 2 ³êl¥êm©Rd qmËÛçÄÇïgiJ#\m£Éç©ô
Ê\¢n vdet J(eB/m)2c
2eB ±ªéÄ éïüggX v(n{1/2), n0, 1, 2, cg CEåAÊì
18)$êûæñn eB c
2(1/2) v gPmf g mÅLl x jWe æêm¸é_£Éç©ôÅ`ÁX$Ç#¥
êÃ忪±qm£Éç©ôÊn#n ®
gVe
E
}n}c 2e B|n|
gi$Rn#ÊímåAÊjäx#
(i)n fniN n jäá(sÔu)fA#(ii) B fniN B jäá(±ªéÄéïE£Éç
©ôK B jäáViC)#gCEñ_fÙi$
Rm B|n| ˶«n McClure jÃTÊq
»j#1956NjeC
14)$Áj#n
0 måAÊnÁêf#RmóÔm~¦
åç Zq g mÅLl x gCEÁèm¦åæ ÂôcRgjÓVE$}^êÊm n
0 måAÊn H
2jÖVen 2 djkÞX
K#H jÖVenkÞViCmf#Ãå¿
ª±q 1 ÂA^#eåAÊnÊímåï
¼¡ÊgIiWkÞxc$
Èãn#LøÃ忪Í^fmbfAK#
«åÑ¢ïjICenÑ¢çÛ¥ïE¼Òæï«
j#Ã忪E¯ôïn 2 ¦ARgj
ÓXo#nmåAÊnÊím 2 {mk ÞxcRggi$Áj n0 måA
Ên\]mÃ忪E¯ôïj®X(K, K _jÎX)¦åçZq g mmÙi
ÅLóÔJ\¬TmfA$
eåA¡ÊjhmNCmóÔKkÞV eCJïÌIj©Ïjn#^gGoåï
¼¡E®ô´g#y ûüjüúI«Eð
ÛZo#óÔKÊm 2 ³dqng¯lfA
æA@} ϪT^«åÑ¢ïm×ôç`±x1)
RgKJ$RJ#Laughlin m c_jeåAÊn×ôç`±x 2(e
2/h )cRgÓ ¡ X$Ãå
¿ª^mª Und qE ³EÎ Ì(E¨ |E jÎVeÎÌ)fA#Rn³XmIm
i q fÅ × Ú ò r Ú m~m tight
binding Í ^ f n ¬ § V # R m ^ j u×ôç`±xnÑ¢çÛÊmÖgV e E0 jÎVe½ÎÌ(ïÖ)fAv gm¨Iv¿tÁXo#Ñ¢çÛ
ÊK nåAÊg n{1 åAÊ
mÔjAgLm×ôç`±xn s
xy| e
2h (2n{1)
f^G$c}#åÑæïmc_J
Ñ¢çÛÊKåAʡØx j e
2/h PÊjVe 2 _PÁXêû#ïÖ
fA^jn#E0 måAʡØ
Ûjn|1 J 1 jµuRgvX$
Ã忪E¯ôïK 2 ÂAJ#kÞx 2 fZVee¯ôïmñ^©Ïg
s
xy| e
2h ( n{ 1 2 )
gi#c}eÃ忪E¯ôïn¼ïm ñ^c$Rnïi»ÛfAK#êm
_fn¿Ê¸émÃ忪±qKcÙíi«
¿gVemeC
30)$^_V#Í^XRV HvV#¦åçÎÌ«uo#ÂXmÃ
忪ѢçÛ¥ïmñ^lIjE}NÇ~
oXRgfLRgK¦´TeC
30)$Rm ÁÙi×ôç`±xmÊq»¥n Novoselov j
æ A@ } mEjÀ±IjmFT
1,2)#}^
_IjnÈOj ZhengAndo jvZTe C^mfA
32,31)$}^RmÁÙiÃ忪 ªUn«åÑ¢ïm¥CõwøÊjÁ¥Iiø Ê^X
33)$
ßfà¾X#iqãmdqmµ§iæµ CjÄÙé´¦çi\®pCo#RRf pC^dqE³EÎÌ«m¼èiVjÑ¢çÛ
ÊK¸éE£Éç©ôßTjAêmRm«å Ñ¢ïm×ôç`±xm\®K±J$
3.3 «åÑ¢ïm×ôç`±xm ÄÙé´¦çi\®
3.3.1 ½±qnm×ôç`±xg½ßôï
êÊjãNj£Éç©ôE©ß¿Óc½±
qnm×ôç`±xn s
xy| e
2h C, C 1
2pi fT2 , d
mEj#½ßôï C gÄ oÄÙé´¦
çiÊj\»T
34`41)$\m±on´_
¶QÆVeC^_NRggVe#RRfn\m Ó`c_VE$RRfíϪÖj»#
÷ªô½f 1 `®gÄo n#¨m¾t fnÕæôÚ±gCE#d¥CwfmÕªÄçE ÙÂï³ßçêÊ»V^EiÊfA#
qG|dGrqG| &
&q
m|Gr dq
mqG|&
mGr dq
mß ¥d q
mEjè`T(JÔT^Y mx, y j cCenagRggKñX)$RRf¬¿
Ä |Gr n#2 ³ x, y ûü wmql«E ð
(|G(x{ L
x, y )re
iqx|G(x, y )r , |G(x, y {L
y)r
e
iqy|G(x, y)r )mgfm½±qnmîêóÔmg
®ÖfA$Rm«EðnËÛçÄÇïm sñvfgVeæJ#R
H(q)|G(q)rE(q)|G(q)r
mEjRE$
RmÅLûö® nÄûö® _J#Ki»
qG|Gr1 vVe#\mÊ e
iujcC ensèfA$c}îêóÔgVe |Gr m ãj |G
r |Gr pCeC$êÊjR mÊ u n#ql«E ð q SgjÙibe
ÇCRgjÓVE$^_V# ÎVe
qG
|dG
r {
|1d {idu
{idq¥= u
mEjÏXóP$RmÏ·¥nÕæôj
mfA#\j`ifÕæôÚ±go
19)$Ú±gCEmn#êÊjÕªÄç©mó Ô(RRfnÎçÕçÄóÔ)f#÷ªlG^g Lj»Êf#¡mên#Ê÷¬Ï»T Z^gLjhEÏ»XJ\X$d¥Cwf CGoÕªÄçEÙÂï³ßçjÎX®ô´Ï
·g¯^fA#d¥Cwg¯^mÊ(Ç U (1))m®ô´\¢KRmâèj¶ÝXRg
Ó¡X$
RmEj ©gn®ô´#Xi`½±q nmg®ÖmÊm©Rxj˶XK# d #Àrj\mϪf^G½ßôïg Äo C ©gn#
qdG|dG r
[ q&
xG|&
yGr|q&
yG |&
xGr ]dq
xdq
y[rot
]
zdq
xdq
yß
gi^j#®ô´jn˶ViCsÏÊfA
$½ßôïK¨IϪÊfA×ôç`±
xjÎXJ#\K®ô´j˶Veni
iCRgg®X$
iI#nmËÛçÄÇï H K˶XÍå Ýô»fAÀµÄ«Eð(x ûüj e
iqx, y û üj e
iqy)jICen#q
x,ygj[0, 2p]®N K#ÀµÄ«EðgVen#0 g 2p n¿
fAJ#Ϫ Ìæn«E ^iC 2 ³ Äôåµ T
2g~iZRgjÓVE$Oj à¾V^ÒæçïEºôïg¯lfA$
3.3.2 ñ· ÕæôÚ±\ÄÙé´¦çÊq
ÌïÅtßfhEvZXJ RRfn#dqÔmÝìpK³fLêÌ
âèlGg#nmg®Ön#ê±qg®Ö
c
lJCµèô»ôsñ®gVe\¬
T$l nRmê±qóÔwèXYGf A$Rmê±qóÔÑ¢çÛÊ}f j Âm dqulvRgf½±qnmîêóÔ |Gr K¾êlGE$c} j ÔÚg j{1 Ô Ú mê ± q £Éç©ômÔ j L À m£Éç
©ôE©ß¿ÓKA#\RjÑ¢çÛÊKA
êlG$Rmê#×ôç`±x#Xi
`½±qnmÕæôÚ±Kè`X½ßôï
n#ê±qóÔjÖX½ßôïmÑ¢çÛ
Ê}fmafA^G$RK TKNN ö
®fA
34)$ãLmê#½±qnm½ßôï
n
C
l1jC
l,
C
l 1 2pi fT2dA
l,
A
jc
õjdc
jmEjP$«åÑ¢ïm×ôç`±xn#
ãfÓV^Ej#l}b^ uÃ忪mCv
lGKvKA#R^jRm\
®¼ÚKp XRg´IjnÂ\fA
K#ÀÛmvZ#Áj»ÀIi¥êfmvZ#
åï¼Üɵm¶ÝXêmvZVEgX
g#Xxem£Éç©ôE©ß¿ÓKcuY jcgnÀY#RmEie½ßôï ÊjvZXû@nzghÀpjiiC
20)$ RRfn TKNN ö® £ eC Niu
ThoulessWu ¬jãqm½±qnm½ßôï
¼Ú]¿XRglGE$Rm#Ñ¢ç ÛE£Éç©ôȺmê±qO¹ c
lXxe}
geìb^½dgVe C(c
1, c, c
j)è
`Xo#½±qnmîêóÔn
|Gr _
l1j(c
õc
l)|0r ß|Cr
mEjP$Rm½±qóÔJè}½±
qnmÕæôÚ±vZXo#½d C p C^
Tr A
gCEÖW®K¾
39`41)$RRf#A nè
LT^½dJìb^ñ·(s ñlm)Õ
æAA}
ò Ã忪ªUgÃ忪mC(Ô)$
ò ¿Ê^iCÃ忪±qmåAÊ$
ò «åÑ¢ïj¥êJP^Ûm£Éç©ôÊ$¡²KËǦÜiqA^m¥©¥©§x fªb^mf#c²nê±q£Éç©ô$ã¥êmÉÀf¿Ê^iCÃ忪±qmåï
¼¡ÊÄ»X$
æôÚ±fA
39`42)# AC
õdC
] ^
_
c
õ1&
mc
1P
c
õj&
mc
1c S c
c
õ1&
mc
jP c
õj&
mc
j` a
b dq
mmEjè`T$½d C nêÊjê±q óÔmÊmæûm©RxcK#Tjè LóÔÔmü`mæ¼Vm©RxjÎX
j ³mâÇ»æÏ· Ve#½±qn móÔn ¿fA$¨ IjnRnÑ¢ç ÛE£Éç©ôȺmèLTeCê±qóÔ
K#U( j )gCEâÇ»æÏ·f¬URg
XRgjÎX$^_V#Ñ¢çÛÊÈãm ñèLóÔgm¬¬nÖ~X
18,40)$C g#\
Jìb^C Slater sñ® móÔ |Cr j ÎVe
|C
r|Cr det , det ¸U(1) C
C , ¸U( j )
pCe#½±qnm½ßôïn TrA j
ÓVe C 1
2pi fT2Tr dA
mEjL¼Z
20)$RnL¼VjXMi CK#«åÑ¢ïmê E0 ßTjÑ¢çÛ
ÊKAêK»¡mSf#iIJcÌïÅm êJ E0 ßT}fjnÑï×ôÒÁÙ«j ÎX§WV^£Éç©ôÌïÅKÁjã¥
êmóµfn½¶ÝXmf#ÂXm½ßôï
vZXû@fnæµERgK¢ïji
K#RRfmè®»gERgfevZÂ\
gi
20)(æ AA })$WêIjn# uÃ忪m Cvm½mê±qO¹³mjæµE^j nñÂ·ÕæôÚ±jè®»Kdvgim fA$c}#U( j )m®ô´Ï·eX
è®»j#½±qnm½ßôïn#Ñ¢ç ÛE£Éç©ôK®X£Éç©ôE©ß¿ÓT G«EqljÎVeÀèj¶ÝXo#Ñ¢ç ÛÊJ£^ÌïÅKÊð·kÞV
Eg#lIjÀèjvZfLmfA$
RRf#½±qnmg®Ö©gn#½dm
®ô´Ï·f U(1)mÊÏ·EPm~fA
K#ãLmñÂ·ÕæôÚ± A n A
|1A {
|1d
gCE U( j )®ô´Ï·óPRgjÓV
E$}^ÎX®ô´êmx FdA{A
2(&
1A
2|&
2A
1{[A
1, A
2])dq
1dq
2gè`Xo#
Rn®ô´Ï·jÎVe F
|1F ,
Tr dATr FTr F
mEjÏ·V#ñÂ·ÕæôÚ±j½ßô ï
C 1
2pi fT2 2pi 1 fT2Tr F
Tr F
æAB}
½ßôïmvZj^«åÑ¢ïm×ô ç`±x$Ôün½ßôïK2µrmÌæ#Âün 1µr$JXC^j#¥êmTn¥©PÊ fvbePÊiqA^1/31gCEåLiljgb eC$ãjYG^mn#¡²£Éç©ôjgb^
ÌïŪU$
n®ô´sÏi`f½±qnm×ôç`±x^
GmfA
40)$
ïÌIivZjICen#®ô´ÅèVeR m½ßôï¼ÚvZXRgÂ\fA
K
36,39)#Tj#iq®ô´_f®ô´êmÄ
Ùé´¦çizuvZX^jJT^è
@ T
2ãfm£UϪjKpV^è@KLøf A
43)$Tªn#}Y 2 ³qlmÍåÝô»
óÔ T
2£U»V#
q
m 2p
M (m
1, m
2), Dk
1 2p
M (1, 0), Dk
2 2p M (0, 1) gV#
C
M 1 2p
mF
m,
F
mArg [u
1(q
m)u
2(q{Dk
1)
~u
1Þ (q
m{Dk
2)u
2Þ (q
m)], u
m(k )[C(q
m{Dk
m)]
õC(q
m)
è`X$REXg C
MnLÀm£U»jI Ceí j ® fA#Tj M ¨ jIC e#® C jû©X$Rm^#Aöxå Li M go#¸xmâèiN½±qnm½ ßôïK¾Rggi$qhNªǦ
çibgCEóÛJViCK#Ànæê´
vZfßNÇNgªÉjÖX#C
KingSmithVanderbilt ö ®#½ßôï jg
£V^gðXRgfL
44)$
RïÌIj#«åÑ¢ï(Åî{IiP O¹ImiqÍ^)jKpV^Ê æ AB } j
¦X$R©eJEj¸éE£Éç©ô ßTfn#c, |5, |3, |1, 1, 3, 5, cmEj#
Êq»lKë}^Cf 2 µrmïjÊq»X
$c}#Lø_fA¿ÊmiCÃå¿
ª±qmc×ôç`±xgêvX(iqgL ø_ÔmRmêvn#Ve©¾fniC)$
Rm}fn#Ñ¢çÛE£Éç©ôKÌïÅmS æj^be®C^ê\¦VeCK#Im
iqm³Xm(¸é¥êfm)ÌïÅm[ßTf n#ÊmÊq×ôçøÊ#c}ÌïÅmêß Tfn|1, |2, |3, cgCEdqIiÊq×ô çøÊ#ÌïÅã[ßTfn 1, 2, 3, cgCE
Êm³EIiÊq×ôçøÊK¾$R
mÙiU Cn#XjÏ» Xmfni N#Ñï×ôÒÁÙ_m£Éç©ô«gVe sA±jØÖ$Rn×ôç`±xnÄÙ é´¦çfA#ÁÙ«jbem~\mÊq»
¥ÏXfLgðfL$}^#ãLmè@
pCRgj#Åßfn½O¹Í^mæ ê´IdqóÔvZg×ôç`±xmvZg
~ZRgÂ\giccA
45)$ 3.4 n0 åAÊg¦åçÎÌ«
êÊjêl¥êm 2 ³dqnjK¶Ý Xg#eåAÊn®SkÞZY#
cRggi#g®ÖnÌïÅmSÈOfn ÇÝV(ï¼ô¹ïÇÝ)#RmÇÝ}^Ϫ TÊq×ôçøÊjICendviÓ¡
cmfAb^$«åÑ¢ïICeêÊm^må ï¼ÜɵjÎVenÃ忪¥Ñ¢çÛ¥ï meåAÊnÊímdqmåAÊg
¯l®SkÞnðÁVLÀmcRgji$
æAC}
åï¼ÜEØïÅc«åÑ¢ïjIPåA
ÊmóÔ§x47)$s²n#åï¼ÜɵmóÔ
Ö·f#·CzhK_gK_mÔmUK}§T
$
gRK#«åÑ¢ïjICeÁÙiRggV e#æ¿Óçm~KglGEi«å Ñ¢ïfn# n0 måAÊnÊím 2 ³ dqnjIPåA Êg¯ljc K#n0 måAÊn#kÞKÛ^^}
}gi$ïÌIiiqÍ^jïÌIil I¤jÀÛjmFT#æ AC } j\ml q¦ X
47)$¸éÞôÅmkÞx jcCen#
AharonovCasher jc_jîdNg#êl¥
êfiNóÔIjÏ®X¥êcnjÎVe
n0 m~n®SiåAÊKÛ^#\
mkÞxnnSÌÑNS¥©m~fèTe C
46)$Rn#êÊjuwèvgo
ÄÙé´¦çièK«åÑ¢ïf»^g lGRgfL$
§4 «åÑ¢ïmÁÙi£¿´óÔ
«åÑ¢ïjIPÁÙidqóÔjcCec _VeL^K#«åÑ¢ïn[ßTm¨jÉ
eÁ¥Ii¤ÊKARgKmeC$\
\#ÄÙé´¦çi(Êq×ôçóÔnT
^á)fn#ÌçªmóÔg£¿´óÔn§Új ÖAVeCRgKmeC$«åÑ¢ïf
n#Rm«¿KÁ¥Ij»mfA$Rmß fnRVêÊIiÏ_JÕIjð XRg~E$
MÍwIÊc_XÛ#«Eðj«
Eme¿nÊ ín³fLgl G$`
#«EnÌçªinjäVe³Kqgci CPfA#nm±¶³ÀåjòoXMÍ wIÉÀjICen³fLRgn³VC$^
_V#«Em¨KÌçªmóÔ½fV^#
tj«Em¨KÌçªmóÔÁ¥IjLqV eCêiNiC$^gGo 1 ³Êqn jICe#ÌçªjIP¤`sÏ«K#«Eß Tm¨ÊmÕEIUCÁèXRgn
NmeC$RnãNj©ß¿Ó^i CnfmáfAK#ßNãNj LÀm£Éç
©ôE©ß¿ÓcnjICe# uÄÙé´¦
çvjñ©¾iâÌfn#ÌçªjnÁ¥
^iCK#nK«Eb^gLÁ¥IÇÝó ÔK¶ÝXRgK#½NmájICe¦Te C$\mT^áKÊq×ôçøÊjIP£¿
´óÔm¶ÝfAK
37,48,49)#¯lmán®µ Ð ïJ ¬ Ê q µÐ ï ½
50,51)# â p ´ q m n
52)#ѤÄÇ¿ª»
53,54)#ÊqµÐï×ôç
55,56)#ÕIfARgK¾Jgicc
A$«Em¨nRÄÙé´¦çâÌg Äo¨¿ jICen# Iðfni N#nmå^Á¥gimfA$âjA
Ìçª^óg~^gL#\m©ß¿Ój¶
ÝXÇÝV^£¿´óÔnAím±qg~i Z$^óK\m±qKèV#±qK\mwã jA^óKèVAEmfA$RêÊj uÌçªE£¿´ÎvgÄuRgKA$Êq
×ôçE£¿´óÔÜe#«Ec«åÑ
¢ïjIPÁ¥IiÇÝóÔn# uÌçªE£
¿´Îvm§êJ#^óXi`Ìçªm¿
Ê^iCÃ忪±qmî{IÁ«gVe
ðo
25,37)$
4.1 ôܽ¢[#´«²«[g ÇݸéÞôÅ
«åÑ¢ï#c}ImiqJ[Øo
XgL#T^Ii«Em`gVen æ AD }(a)j
æAD}
ò «åÑ¢ïmT^I«EfA´«²«[gô ܽ¢ô[$
ò ´«²«[c«åÑ¢ïjüúI«EÛV
^n$(³æï¼ôóm«åÑ¢ï)
æAE}
¸é¥êjIP#´«²«[gôܽ¢[
c«åÑ¢ïæØïmê±q£Éç©ô57)$
æAF}
¸é¥êjÎX#´«²«[fmÁ¥IiÇÝóÔ mæê´dq\¢vZÊ58)(ã)g#«åÑ¢ïm
«EßTmSTM(º)$´«²«[jm~ÇÝV^
óÔKϪT59)$
¦ X # ´ « ² « (zigzag) « E g ô Ü ½ ¢ (armchair)«Em 2 ÊKA$Rm«E
c«åÑ¢ïm#¸é¥êjIPê±q£É ç©ô¦V^mK æ AE } fA
57)$R
©g#«åÑ¢ïmÃ忪E¯ôïªUm
¼j#£Éç©ôK¸émgRj#´«²«[
cnjICenÁ¥Ii½RÌïÅK¶ÝX
RgK©eæ$RK¡cjbe©C _T^«åÑ¢ïjÁ¥ Ii[ÇÝóÔfA
57)$ÀÛ#Rm¸éÞôÅÇÝóÔnÌçªm
«åÑ¢ïm¦åçÎÌ«jNöXmfA
$\mÓ¡fOqmuÌçªE£¿´Îvj xzT^ÕIiÇÝóÔglGRgKfL
$RjcCeßfVÚVNà¾VE$
iIRm´«²«[mÁ¥IiUCn#»
Ýfn#æê´Idq\¢vZ
58)ÀrjÀÛm
STM Ϫ
59)jϪTeC(æ AF })$
4.2 £¿´óÔg Z
2ÕæôÊ#
¦åçÎÌ«m©Ij
Oßfc_V^¡cóÔ(¸éÞôÅÇÝóÔ) n#ôRj´«²«[j¶ÝXmimfA
EJG i[ôܽ¢[jn\K¶ÝVi CmfAEJG Rm^âjG#Jc¯
lm»ÛK¼m¿Ê^iCÃ忪ªU
cnj¶ÝV#\RjnÃ忪±qm uÌçªE£¿´ÎvgVemÕIÁ«KA
Rgà¾VE
60)$\Rfn#ô½wIÊ
gVemÕæôÊK{¿IðÊ^V#ÇÝ óÔm¶ÝnôRfniN#ÌçªmÃ忪 ªUmcÄÙé´¦çi«¿g~iZ$
}Y#«åÑ¢ï³æï¼ôójªC^«E ðflG#[n³æï¼ôm[j»gV
E$\Rf#³æï¼ôm~üûü(y ûü)jq gcmî{ÀiÕªÄçg#RgƧiû üjEêcmÀiÕªÄçg$beËÛ çÄÇïn
H
2D
kx,ky
H
Z(k
x, k
y) or
kx,ky
H
A(k
x, k
y)
mEjJP$RRf H
Z, A(k
x, k
y)n\]
´«²«[#ôܽ¢ô[jÎXPÊE
gb^êmüúnmËÛçÄÇïfA#³ æï¼ômûüj©R[m«EðflGR gj´«²«[#ôܽ¢ô[c³ æï¼ôóm«åÑ¢ïmËÛçÄÇïK¾
PfA$«åÑ¢ïngóÔ 2 _f©
ß¿ÓèµgiÈOnLÀm©ß¿ÓcJ
#2 ³nn¦åçÎÌ«c({H, g}
0)gX$RmgL#k
ySgj k
x 1 ³mÍ
åÝô»glGRgf#£Éç©ômÅLóÔ
|k
x, k
yr
Z, A, (H
Z, A(k
x, k
y)|k
x, k
yr
Z, AE (k
x, k
y)|k
x, k
yr
Z, A)J#
g
1DZ, A(k
y)
f2p0 dk
xZ, Aqk
x, k
y| &k &
x|k
x, k
yr
Z, A|
kyFfixed
gVeè`TÕæôÊ(²¿ªÊ)lG
g#k
yÅèVek
xÏ»TZ^gLjíj©
ß¿ÓKACeCo#g
Z, A(k
y)n#\m¦å çÎÌ«m^j 0, p j mod 2p fÊq»T#
2 cmlVJæ¾iC Z
2ÕæôÊgi
41)$ Tj#Rm 1 ³n©R[m«EðflG
^gL#¸éÞôÅÇÝóÔK¶ÝX^mð
K g
1DZ, A
i
kj
kl p 0
¸éÞôÅÇÝóÔK¶ÝX
¸éÞôÅÇÝóÔK
¶ÝXgnKYVCGiC mEj^GRgK¦åçÎÌ«mÇ
«gfMÏ``CRgf#¦T
60)$ Rm»èðn#Ìçªm Z
2ÕæôÊj
¸éÞôÅ[óÔm¶Ý¦Xmf#Ìç ªE£¿´Îmêcmági$Rmðn\
ªðfA#wIjn#ÕæôÊK 0 fA
JgCbe¸éÞôÅÇÝóÔK¶ÝViC gnÀiCK#£¿´óÔKRiN¸éE£
Éç©ôjARgnlGjNN#ïÌIi½N mê#RmÕæôÊK 0 fAo¸éÞôÅ ÇÝóÔn¶ÝViC$Rm»è@³æï¼ô û ü mg k
ySgm´«²«[ #ôܽ¢
ô[fm 1 ³nmÌçªmËÛçÄÇïj KpXo#ÀÛj¾^gSgm¸éÞô ÅÇÝóÔm¶ÝmL³RmðfmèXR gKfL
60)$
RmEj¸éÞôÅÇÝóÔnÃ忪±
qm«¿fAK#êÊj#Rm«åÑ¢ï gÞV^óµKÊmnfNL¾(Î\(æ Q\)QÆ)$T^án#·´`±ÌfNm
^ 2 ³ d g´`±Ìj»$2 ³ d g´
`±Ìfn#´`±ÌjIPãN(Bogoliubov) ÞôÅK#góÔ 4 ÓjICeü`j©ß¿
Óèµgi#Ã忪ªUK 4 ÂA
g~iZ(æ AG })$Rm´`±ÌjICe#
«åÑ¢ïgÞjæ17}(b)mEiÙi`
óm«EjWe#ïÅèô£ÑÇÝóÔg
oêím£¿´óÔK¶ÝV^ViJb^
XRgK_Ij
61,62)#˱Ijm
eC
63)$RmïÅèô£ÑÇÝóÔmL³#
RRfmÕæôÊj»è@j#_I
j\¾fL
60)$iI#«åÑ¢ïfmªiq
m¯«Knm¦åçÎÌ«jÎV^mjÎ
Ve#Rm´`±Ìfn´`±mÔ½]ÎÌ
æQ\ Ã忪ªUgVe~^«åÑ¢ïgdg´`±ÌmÎ\60,64,65)
¨Ê «åÑ¢ï 2³dg´`±Ì
Massless DiracªU
¦åçÎÌ«
¸éÞôÅ£¿´óÔ
¦åçÎÌ«mÇIi©I j
¸é©ß¿Ó¼±ÌmÌïÅ\¢
ªiqm¯«
´«²«[fm¡cóÔ
´ª²ª[fmÇÝ¥»
BogoliubovÞôÅmªU
Ô½]ÎÌ«
(110)EÊfmïÅèôÑÇÝóÔ (110)EÊ#s¨ßTfmÇ¥©m©
I¶¬
æAG} ò 2³dg´`±Ìm±qªU$
ò
2³dg´`±Ì(CuO2)fmÙi2cm«EgÁ¥I£¿´óÔ$
«K¦åçÎÌ«gi$
RmEjÃ忪±qgVem 2 ³mü
`ªUgÎX«EmAnfmÇÝóÔjn
ÕI«¿KA#\mwãjnuÌçªE£¿
´ÎvgVemÄÙé´¦çiÓ`KA$À nÕ«nRjgh}iC$¦åçÎÌ«
N¹m¸éÞôÅÇÝóÔnÄÙé´¦çfA
JVe#©ß¿ÓKÂWiCÀÁ¸ZY#ê xE}^¸éÞôÅÇÝóÔn 1 ³mgó
Ô(k
y)fLÀmæÔ¶ÝXRgji$Rn
2 ³m¨gVen#«EjÇÝV^ 1 ³I Ñå¿ÄÌïÅm¶ÝÓ¡X$»Àjn#Í
£çµsÀè« }fl¶Xg#nns Àè
»V#Û®j¦åçÎÌ«n©Ijj
RgKúÒT$}^#¦åçÎÌ«m½ ÌøÊj©Ijmêcm\n#«å Ñ¢ïfm«Ejm~¶Ý XÇÝ¥»gCG
58,64,65)$d g´`±ÌjICen#ÇIJc
©IiÑ忪µ¶¬jÎX
66,67)(æ 2 \)$
4.3 «åÑ¢ïÊq×ôçnm£¿´óÔ Èãn#¸é¥êfmbfAb^K#¥êm
Êq×ôçøÊfnhE_EJ$Êq×ôçø ÊmåÑæïmêÊ_JXg#Ñ¢çÛÊ K¶ÝXÌïũ߿Óà(ºJ j ÔÚgX
)m£¿´óÔm¶EmÊug\mÂJ#
×ôç`±xKè}$R£¿´óÔj
×ôç`±x s
edgexygXg#Rn£¿´óÔ
jÖX winding gÄoÄÙé´¦çi
I
jg
s
edgexy| e
2h I
jmEjo
20,37,49)$³mjn#Ìçªmå AÊmg®ÖA^GÒé¿×Ö
¡f£Éç©ôjg£XRgf#«EmAn m£¿´óÔmg®Ö´«²«[mên\
¬fL$RmgL#\m¡f£Éç©ôÊn©
ß¿Óm_PmícæôÚïÊgi#
ãLm£¿´óÔm winding I
jn#©ß¿Ój ÎXæôÚïÊmümñ]gi$T
jRm winding nÌïÅSgm½ßôïg
C
jI
j|I
j|1gmÖWKARgK¦Z$RJÌçªm
×ôç`±x
æAH}
´«²«[c«åÑ¢ïmÊq×ôçE£¿´óÔg×ôç`±x$E[jÇÝX£¿´óÔn Âf#¶[jÇÝX£¿´óÔnÔf#åAÊ( ½ü)mÔm©ß¿ÓjVV^$Ìçª m×ôç`±xn«åÑmOjÎmÌôje¦X$
ò PÊiqA^m¥©(1/21)F0mmS£Éç©ôÌæ$
ò PÊiqA^m¥©(1/51)F0mmÃ忪¥Ñ¢çÛ¥ïIÌæ(E0ßT)$
s
bulkxy| e
2h
jlC
lcJGo#
s
bulkxys
edgexyiÖWK±P$Rn#Êq×ôçøÊmÊ q»nÌçªJ£¿´J±PRg
¦V#Ìçªg£¿´gKNS©TAbeC
gCEuÌçªE£¿´Îvmµ§iáfA
37,49)$
{èm«åÑ¢ïfnhE_EJ$ uÌçªE
£¿´Îvn«åÑ¢ïjICeR¬§
`#ïÌIivZjICe#£¿´EÞôÅm
gÌçªmÊq×ôçE½ßôïKêvX
RgjmFfL(æ AH })
20)$ 4.4 åAÊg¸éÞôÅ
ÊímÊq×ôçnjIP£¿´fn#ãq m©ß¿ÓÔj¶ÝXÁ¥I£¿´óÔm¶¬
jºbe#[jICeåAÊ\¬Xd q§xK¸X
48)$RmEiÊímÊq×ô çng¯lmUCn#n0 måï¼¡Ê jÖVen«åÑ¢ïf¯ljNR
68)$VJ V#E0 j¶ÝX n0 måAÊjÖV
enåCjóµKÙi$æY#¥êiVmê
jc_V^¡cm¤Èm´«²«[fmÇ ÝóÔK#Àn¥êf´«²«[jICen
¶ÝXRgK¦Z$VJ#E0 måï¼
¡ÊmÇ d×§xn´«²«[fn¸Z Y#tjÁX
68,69)(æ AI })$RmEiÙí nôܽ¢ô[fnSN¶ÝZY(æ B@ })#
´«²«[mÁ¥IUCfA$
´«²«[jIPÇÝóÔnÄÙé´¦çj
¶ÝKÛØTK#\mú~(¿àûüj ÎX¸·)n¥C·m¥ô¼ô`#Àn Ìçªmdq óÔiJY¬ ¬VeCR gKlvZf¦T#CouÄÙé´¦çâ
(topological compensation)vgÄx
68)$Åß RjÖXÂ\«¦´XÀ ±mñA
70)#ÖAmÀ±I¤KÒ^$
§5 Ij
Èã«åÑ¢ïmdq_IÏ_JmÁÙi¤
Ê#ÕIiÏ_J#ÁjÄÙé´¦çi«
¿²ViKðàV^$ã¼fnuÌçªE
£¿´Îv¨ôëôÅgVe#[óÔJ¿
æAI} ´«²««Etßmn0åAÊmÀóÔ(a)g#d×m#[Jm£Ë¶«(b)68,69)$
æB@} ôܽ¢ô«Etßmn0åAÊmÀóÔ(a)g#d×m#[Jm£Ë¶«(b)68,69)$
Ê^iCÃ忪±qmÁ¥¨G^$«
åÑ¢ïncåiªìj¬·VeCJ#{e fGiJb^bèøpfLiJb^_¶
`cåfA$¨¿ngVe#Ãå
¿ªE¯ôïcmn#«åÑ¢ïÈOj
L@ÅÌihjICeWVeC$Áj½Ìâ 軡[N#ÁjªÊq×ôçøÊKϪT
#ihÖngVeÚTK#{e fnêÌâèmÍÍjOVeðàV^$ÇÒmF Tj#«åÑ¢ïmÊT#Õ«¨I Ó`K½imJK`oKCfA${en#
ÂØ#LK\]#«åÑ¢ïjcCeÛ ïc(Graphene Week, Graphene Tokyo, YKIS i h)mµÒu#ujîdCe~¥V^
mfA$
}^#«åÑ¢ïm¤fn#Èw¤ïîÕ
¤ BuÎÌ«mjºiCÊqtÌFô
½wIÊj_g\mpvmóP eC$Åãj#«åÑ¢ïÖWm¤f
g¤¯¤sbeL^ä²T#} ^
¶#X{T#Í´Ñ O#LìWO#
Vä³jj´ÓV#}^ Andre Geim, Kostya
Novoselov mejLvic_´ÓVe#Rm
ðàI^C$
(Z³mÇL){N(2010)xmÊôÕç¨w ÜK«åÑ¢ïmÆÑjÎVe#Andre Geim g Konstantin Novoselov j^G^Rgìr^
C$
kQl¶£l
1) K. S. Novoselov et al.: Nature438(2005)197; A. K. Geim and K. S. Novoselov: Nature Materials6(2007)183; A. H.
C astro Neto et al.: Rev. Mod. Phys.81(2009)109.
2) Y. Zhang, Y.W. Tan, H. L. Stormer, and P. Kim: Nature 438(2005)197.
3) D. S. L. Abergel, V. Apalkov, J. Berashevich, K. Ziegler, and T. C hakraborty: Adv. Phys.59(2010)261.
4) ÄØKêN#¿{mu(Ò)F«åÑ¢ïm@\gpW ](CMCoÅ#2009)$
5) R. Mitsuhashi et al.: Nature464(2010)76.
6) T. Kosugi et al.: J. Phys. Soc. Jpn78(2009)113704.
7) T. E. Weller et al.: Nature Phys.1(2005)39; N. Emery et al.: Phys. Rev. Lett.95(2005)087003.
8) RmTO#4³óÔjg£X~K#iq®ô´
_fmM. Creutz: JHEP17(2008)0804#js
eC$
9) N. D. Mermin: Phys. Rev.176(1968)250.
10) J. C . Meyer, A. K. Geim, M. I. Katsnelson, K. S.
Novoselov, T. J. Booth, and S. Roth: Nature446(2007)60.
11) A. Fasolino, J. H. Los, and M. I. Katsnelson: Nature Materials6,(2007)858.
12) P. R. Wallace: Phys. Rev.71(1947)622.
13) W. H. Lomer: Roc. Roy. Soc.(London),330(1955)A227.
14) J. W. McClure: Phys. Rev.104(1956)666.
15) J. C . Slonczewsky and P. R. Weiss: Phys. Rev.109(1958) 272.
16) T. Nakajima and H. Aoki: Physica E40(2008)1354.
17) H. Hsu and L. E. Reichl: Phys. Rev. B72(2005)155413.
18) Y. Hatsugai: Proc. HMF_19, to be published arXiv:
1008.4653.
19) M. V. Berry: Proc. R. Soc. A392(1984)45.
20) Y. Hatsugai, T. Fukui, and H. Aoki: Phys. Rev. B74(2006) 205414.
21) Y. Hatsugai, T. Fukui, and H. Aoki: Euro. Phys. J. Spec.
Top.148(2007)133.
22) A. H. C astro Neto et al.: Rev. Mod. Phys.81(2009)109.
23) H. B. Nielsen and M. Ninomiya: Nucl. Phys. B185,(1981) 20.
24) Y. Hatsugai: New J. Physics12(2010)055014.
25) Y. Hatsugai: Solid State Comm.149(2009)1016.
26) A. Altland and M. R. Zirnbauer: Phys. Rev. B55(1997) 1142.
27) A. Ludwig, M. Fisher, R. Shankar, and G. Grinstein: Phys.
Rev. B50(1994)7526.
28) Y. Hatsugai, M. Kohomoto, and XG. Wen: Phys. Rev. B 56(1997)1061.
29) R. B. Laughlin: Phys. Rev. B25(1985)2185.
30) H. Watanabe, Y. Hatsugai, and H. Aoki: arXiv: 1008.0130.
31) V. P. Gusynin and S. G. Sharapov: Phys. Rev. Lett.95 (2005)146801.
32) Y. Zheng and T. Ando: Phys. Rev. B65(2002)245420.
33) T. Morimoto, Y. Hatsugai, and H. Aoki: Phys. Rev. Lett.
103(2009)116803.
34) D. J. Thouless, M. Kohmoto, P. Nightingale, and M. den
Nijs: Phys. Rev. Lett.49(1982)405.
35) Q. Niu, D. J. Thouless, and Y. S. Wu: Phys. Rev. B31 (1985)3372.
36) M. Kohmoto: Ann. Phys.(N.Y.)160(1985)355.
37) Y. Hatsugai: Phys. Rev. Lett.71(1993)3697.
38) Y. Hatsugai: J. Phys. C , C ondens. Matter9(1997)2507.
39) Y. Hatsugai: J. Phys. Soc. Jpn.73(2004)2604.
40) Y. Hatsugai: J. Phys. Soc. Jpn.74(2005)1374.
41) Y. Hatsugai: J. Phys. Soc. Jpn.75(2006)123601.
42) F. Wilczek and A. Zee: Phys. Rev. Lett.52(1984)2111.
43) T. Fukui, Y. Hatsugai, and H. Suzuki: J. Phys. Soc. Jpn.74 (2005)1674.
44) R. D. KingSmith and D. Vanderbilt: Phys. Rev. B47 (1993)1651.
45) M. Arai and Y. Hatsugai: Phys. Rev. B79(2009)075429.
46) Y. Aharonov and A. C asher: Phys. Rev. A19(1979)2461.
47) T. Kawarabayashi, Y. Hatsugai, and H. Aoki: Phys. Rev.
Lett.103(2009)156804.
48) B. I. Halperin: Phys. Rev. B25(1982)2185.
49) Y. Hatsugai: Phys. Rev. B48(1993)11851.
50) T. Kennedy: J. Phys. Condens. Matter2(1990)5737.
51) M. Arikawa, S. Tanaya, I. Maruyama, and Y. Hatsugai:
Phys. Rev.79(2009)205107.
52) V. W. Scarola and S. Das Sarma: Phys. Rev. Lett.98(2007) 210403.
53) Z. Wang, Y. D. C hong, J. D. Joannopoulos, and M. Soljacic:
Phys. Rev. Lett.100(2008)013905.
54) Z. Wang, Y. D. C hong, J. D. Joannopoulos, and M. Soljacic:
Nature461(2009)772.
55) C . L. Kane and E. J. Mele: Phys. Rev. Lett.95(2005) 146802.
56) B. A. Bernevig, T. L. Hughes, and S.C . Zhang: Science314 (2006)1757.
57) M. Fujita, K. Wakabayashi, K. Nakada, and K. Kusakabe:
J. Phys. Soc. Jpn.65(1996)1920.
58) S. Okada and A. Oshiyama: Phys. Rev. Lett.87(2001) 146803.
59) Y. Kobayashi et al.: Phys. Rev. B71(2005)193406.
60) S. Ryu and Y. Hatsugai: Phys. Rev. Lett.89(2002)077002.
61) C . Hu: Phys. Rev. Lett.72(1994)1526.
62) Y. Tanaka and S. Kashiwaya: Phys. Rev. Lett.74(1995) 3451.
63) M. Aprili, E. Badica and L. H. Greene: Phys. Rev. Lett.83 (1999)4630.
64) S. Ryu and Y. Hatsugai: Physica C388_389(2003)90.
65) S. Ryu and Y. Hatsugai: Physica E22(2003)779.
66) M. Matsumoto and H. Shiba: J. Phys. Soc. Jpn.64(1995) 3384.
67) M. Sigrist, B. Bailey, and R. B. Laughlin: Phys. Rev. Lett.
74(1995)3249.
68) M. Arikawa, Y. Hatsugai, and H. Aoki: Phys. Rev. B78 (2008)205401.
69) M. Arikawa, Y. Hatsugai, and H. Aoki: J. Phys. Conf. Series 150(2009)022003.
70) D. L. Miller and et al.: Science324(2009)924.