ルーブリックを活用したエンドオブライフケア実習評価と課題―学生評価と教員評価からの検討（活動と資料）

全文

(1).

(2). . ÏÐ. .

(3) . !"#$%&. ÑÒYÓjÔÕÖ. ×ØÔ\Ù. ÚÛÔ Ü. ÝÞÔßà. ÛÚÔáÙâãä. åæçèéÇê. u@ARS-TU2 (-TUFNct"ëìteuvw x"hRS-TUº¬"íîhQ ïÐðrñu@ARS-ò1"óô9 op-õö÷³ ôNLh ð ø ù-RSTU"RSTU-ct(TUú2 TU(TU-ûüý"íîhQ u@ARS-TU"RS|}þ( ( ÷ctDY7(TU hûüý"j7(®"h-± ð(<m D®(-. TU°

(4) -b,±-Ï ðDYghQûºûüý Fgh-®Rh-TU±øðD D®'Z-ëì±-ð®-è±-ððø DYghQ2-|} -=®Rh-TU± °-ÍTU(<®ctq±"23hé¥ ï" hQ 3$='- m m(RS- "½h D °

(5) KTU"C7teuvwxTU-H"CRS\ -ewx"C X Y7Q u@ARSTUteuvwx. . TU(<WXDY7 RSZ[-\D- ]^ -_"`[ab,cdef(ghi-jDTU6

(6) 7k(lmTU2n^Kop KL !"#$%&'()* 7 qPrPQs-\D<teuvwxyzTU{|} ~hTUP-hJ-8~DYRS +,-./01"23

(7) 4056789: <s- KL7 PPQD- ;"<=>?@A40"BCDE7FGF"HIJ OP u@ARS<! K3LMKNK QRS37TUV TU-4(teuvwx"7Q . . . . . teuvwxTUS67|(S . . . . . ct"6 ZKTU8~"¡fvwx¢i£D ct|¤"¥¦§3¨©!"6< . Ô. Ô Ô . Ô Ô. DY7 ªPQ teuvwxTU «¢f¬DlK ®¯°±a®5²°³´° !±®µ¶°·± . . Ô -TU¸7¹P(L«¢fDTUDEK ïÐðñïïÐOñ -RSTU-º¬(»¼DY7(NL ¾/ÑÒYÓj 7Q½hteuvwxTU® z

(8) 5 åæçèéÇê ¾67b,¿ÀL7k("Á67Â3(K7±( ðïï ÃLTUÄ?Kº¸Å"6((<ÆnK . TUÇ-ÈÉÅ"ÊË67(LOP( R SÌ[(

(9) TU-Íº"ÊË67-»ÎDY7(<.

(10) . Y.

(11)

(12)

(13) !"#$%&&'

(14) ()*+,-./0 12+34-5678

(15) &9:;<)(&'=>?&

(16) @ ABCDEFGH

(17) I7JK*LM3NOPQ ()*+,-RS8TUV#WXFY'

(18) P ZPQ[F()*+,-\]^._`C abcd;&@ef

(19) ag8hijklmI7 JK*LM3NOPQ &noH

(20) pq4 r(&st"uv

(21) ()*+,-"wxePQ "_`2%&F

(22) ()*+,-\]^s.

(23) abnyz{|}~"= &e. . . I7JK*LM3NOPQ

(24) &n oH pq4r("uv

(25) ()*+,-"wx ePQ"_`2. . .

(26) hij l I7JK*LM3N OPQ"]=

(27) C= e PQ\st

(28) pq4r(

(29) 7?&e . i PQ\pq4r(&s

(30) &no"_èT e

(31) 7 8

(32) &no stC ¡e¢£7H ¤"#9e

(33) ¥¦§¨©oª«¬b

(34) "#9eno& ¬"®e "¯°

(35) PQ\ ±x ²³&´µF"=e . . I7JK*LM3NOPQ8

(36) ¶·¸PQFY'

(37) l¹º »¼ H®

(38) >½()¾¿F¶¼ ½()¾ CÀ

(39) ¶¼ÁÂF@ÃP Q"#$ 8¶·¸PQ[FÄPQpq ÅÆ\>?qi"c9

(40) ]=& 8

(41) PQÇÈ ÉÊ&Çf1µ2&GH. ËÌÍÎ"#

(42) ÇDÏÐÑÒ

(43) ÏÐPÁÓ "ÔÕPQÖÈ¸F#$>·Å 8>È ×P. . . . !". PQpqÅÆ >?I7JK*LM3 YÉÊ&@

(44) : ;Ê?" ¦FG ¶?I7JK*LM3ÉÊ&@

(45) :; Ê?":e¸"Ñ FG ?I7JK*LM3 YÉÊ&@

(46) : ;Ê?þ eÓ ËÌ"¦Ó O 7

(47) ÛÜÏÐCÑÒFG ?®ÉÊ":C H F"ÅõeÛÜ"P ÁFG ú?PÁeÛÜ 1 FG ¿?I7JK*LM3 YÉÊ&@

(48) : ;Ê?"&NO) o&:;C¦FG) 7)&Ó c&

(49) # C& Ö?I7JK*LM3NO ÛÜã ÛÜ 2.¦"wx¦ ¤2 Ä?I7JK*LM3 YÉÊ&@

(50) : ;Ê?ÛÜ"&Ó ÛÜ?"\FG. j» j». j». º» º». º». ú ú. QÈ"Â®

(51) ËÌØ¦&ÙÚH ÛÜÝ{Þß &ÛÜÏÐÑÒ"#$¶·Å 8¶È¸ ×P QCY'

(52) >È8PÁGeI7JK*LM3NO à'á'&PQ"â ãT&f"#

(53) ¶ ÈÅ8z{4ä)åi&æçèÓ]^"#$ Te

(54) PQ[ 8µé"#

(55) êPQÅÆ. PQ ®ëì¢íî¬PQïðÀµé?&

(56) êPQpqÅÆpqm&¦ñî¬ ÔÕPQòób

(57) µé?"#9

(58) PQô#[ 8no&õRÊF Èö÷ø"î ¬C

(59) d;Àçèµé"PÁe

(60) ()*+,-"wxePQ\8

(61) ÄPQ pqÅÆ"ùÅÆúWXpq4r(Fûi \¶? |PQpqÅÆ&PQ\ ¯°8

(62) PQK+I7ü)567À PQ\ ìý&&c #9eno&PQõRÊ8

(63) PQ[ ¸Às>·ÅòóÀs?F pq4r(î¬ "#

(64) þ4r(¶ qÚ8PQ õR×"_èÔÕPQòóbµé8

(65) PQ\"x st¦ñ"î¬

(66) P QæòßÀæ×"c&

(67) noF /0"î¬C Ú"#9e.

(68) ¸G÷ø-ÐÑfg·Jß #TU. . . ·Jß%à¤áâ.]Û R Ëãäåá.æ» RËÚ§äá4çg6ß . v. èé#% %êëá-Ýìs6 ß ]Û#æ»Rí

(69) # -fgºîï-ð #.ñw2ÐÑ-fg% ÒÓzRv §µ ò#ó`ôÂ.õ=4öw"#f.

(70) . !"#$%&'() *+",-./01 2345 6 b%! "#$%&'()*+ ",%cd-e)fg hi10jkl-mn 45 6.

(71) .

(72) . !"#$% &' ()*+", %. 7189: -;<458=6 KLMN! "#$%&'%d =-opfgk qrR458=6. 7189: (> ?1@AB1@C D1@EFGHI J, -;<45 6 KLMN! "#$%&'%d =-ops Q #%)*tR;< 45 6. .

(73) .

(74) .

(75) . KLMN!"#$ KLMN!"#$ KLMN!"#$ %&'()*+", %&'()*+", %&'()*+", %9:-OP Q %9:-. ST %9:-. \]1 #R45 6 U@ VW-XY ^_`#a=[ Z[;<45 6 ;<45 6 KLMN! KLMN! KLMN! "#$%&'%d "#$%&'%c "#$%&'u =-opfgk d-e)fgkq f[. hi10j qrR45 6 rR45 6 kl-mns Q #R45 6. v KLMN!"#$ KLMN!"#$ KLMN!"#$ KLMN!"#$ KLMN!"#$ !"#$%&'() %&'()*+", %&'()*+", %&'()*+", %&'()*+", %&'()*+", *+",%wxyz uf[ 718 uf[ 718 u f [ 1 uf[ 18 uf[(, k{fg|W1@}W Rn4 Rn4 (g,8 R\]1 -fg 1~-.21@\ 58=6 5 6 Rn4 ^_`#a=[ R\]1^_ ]1JEf. 5 6 n45 6 `#a=[n4 18Rn 5 6 45 6 KLMN!"%cd- nfg nfg nfg $%¢%£¤ e)f8R.xy =[. 71 =[. 71 =[. !"% q¥. nfg -fg- 8/@-¡ 8/@-¡ cd-e)f[ -¦f8R /84 Z[ 458=6 Z[ 45 6 /@ 4 /@ 45 6 5 6 45 6 § fguf[. fg¨ fg¨ fg¨ fg }W1 45 6 !"©%ª« !"©%ª« !"©%ª« =[® -¯ =[;<458 =[;<45 6 =[¬O45 6 =. %TU =6 °r±²Q#R4 5 6 µ ®%¾¿@ÀÁ ®%¾¿@ÀÁ ®%¾¿@ÀÁ H¸¹/?% !"#$%&'() =[;<45 `#aÂ¯Ã `#aÂ¯ÃR -¡Åf[. ® *+",%hi-#¶ 8=6 %¾¿@ÀÁ` =[;<45 6 #Ä 6 f[.·JH¸¹ #aÂ¯ÃR#Ä %º»#f[.{¼% 6 )*tR2345.H¸ ¹½¸#f[% ®%¾¿@ÀÁ`# aÂ¯ÃR#Ä 6. $%¢%£¤ q¥. \]1^_ -`#/@ 8hiR 4 5 6 fg%³ ´=[. \] 1^_-`#} W1 45 6. Ë·J Ôfg Ôfg =[.¶¨Ì =[ÕrÖ Q# =[. ÕrÖ Q k{s ÍÎÏ R45[=8=6 #R45 6 2-ÐÑf.21 ÒÓs 6. ¶¨Ì k{s ÍÎÏ2 -ÐÑf[ fg-ÕrÖ Q#R45 6. ¶¨Ì k{s ÍÎÏ2 -ÐÑf[ fg-ÕrÖ r. -ÙZ ! "#$%&'% =[ÒÓs 6. Ú !"#$%&'() *+",%-#¶ f[.®%ÛW@ W(Ü,-ÝÞ4 5 6. !"#$% !"#$% !"#$% &' ()*+", &' ()*+", &' ()*+", %-#¶f[. %-#¶f[. %-#¶f[. ®%©%d ®%©%d ®%W(Ü, =-OP Q#R =-¬O45 6 -;<45 6 45 6. fg-# ¶f[. ®% ©%d=ÏÛ W=[OP Q#R458=6. fg-# ¶f[. ®% ©%d=ÏÛ W=[OP Q#R45 6. ¶¨Ì k{s ÍÎÏ2 -ÐÑf[ fg%ÕrÖ r. ×g8Øa5 -;<45 6. ÆÇÈ#ÉÊf[. ®%¾¿@ÀÁ `#aÂ¯ÃR #Ä 6.

(76) . ÝÞßq.

(77) !"# CD EF à ° CDS $%&'() * +,±²ªS ±²ªS !".$/012345 * á&¯ ±dT*âãUä±dT â6ä T å ª ª !"6$()789: + æ&¯ ±dT*âãUä±dT â6ä T å çUª ççª ;<=> è&¯ ±dT âOä6ä ã Tå çTçª ç Uçª ?@!"AB!"#$%&'() CDEFGHI$JK LMNO P@QRSTUPVW ! "#$% &'()*+ X!"=$()%& H!"Y - îéééï j$Z[\]P'()^_ à- LMN CDà-bcLMN=Xcd éO é. ê ë. ëO eH'-fCDghì'EF ;> bcLMN=`c'-fgh !". ê ãã ã ê * j;k.> !"O ê ã T+ ã* . +T CDHEFà-bcLM !"6 ê ã ì ê + Nj!"YH?CD !"= O TU ã # . T Zl;mnop>PqfH $rstZ[Pu'()PvwxfyH !"# O ãU ã = O * + e $z{|}eP~fyH !"í O ã ã ãU . T e $`Z[`@- !"Y = ã+ Tã ã ê * e $<`~e {{XCD !"? O ã Tç ã ê HEFbcLMNO CD -I .

(78) . ┠ᶆ8. ┠ᶆ7. ┠ᶆ6. ┠ᶆ5. ┠ᶆ4. ┠ᶆ3. ┠ᶆ2. ┠ᶆ1. 0%. 20%. 40%. 60%. 80%. 100%. ᩍဨ. . Ꮫ⏕ ᩍဨ Ꮫ⏕ ᩍဨ Ꮫ⏕ ᩍဨ Ꮫ⏕ ᩍဨ Ꮫ⏕ ᩍဨ Ꮫ⏕ ᩍဨ Ꮫ⏕ ᩍဨ Ꮫ⏕ 䝺䝧䝹䠍䠖୙ྍ. ,-. 䝺䝧䝹䠎䠖ྍ. 䝺䝧䝹䠏䠖Ⰻ. 䝺䝧䝹䠐䠖ඃ. ./0123456789:;<. =>. 䝺䝧䝹䠑䠖⚽. . o%%à-% bc!"HbcLMN **+`H XawCDHEF`fHW fo`f/0 ¡ ¢£ ¤{¥CD¦§¨`f©ªP«`¥¥ `@{ {-HWfCD HEFbcLMNO@CD mnop ZlH'~¬- fH-A®q¬`6 &¯° CDHEF±²ªSÌ³ N´µ¶·P¸¹'I%&¯H º»fEFt¼½0`¾P¿AÀÁ`ÂÃ {ªfJÄÅfo%` aQfN´µ¶·<\] XÆ¿ÇÈw. CDHEFÉÊ¼½0%<PË uZÌ'%bcLMNP§¨`ÍQf¾A %<<ÎtÏÐÑÒÓÔfH Wf¬`%ÕtP¿AÖ`CD¦ ¾A`'-fP×Ø¸¹'©ª` {-APÙeÚØCD`Û´Ü¶·.

(79) ;O*6LMNOPQRS/0.

(80)

(81) !"#$%&'()* +,-./0%1.23$4. 56

(82) 78/09:;<=>?@A6 BCD*6EF/0G9:;H IJK% A6 LMNOPQRSTU VWX.YZ[\]^_`*6EF

(83) a" bcde-%fg*I 56h/0*i YZjkl%'ImRS*iIifIn4o 4p qD*6EF/0rs% @g*IItu h6v

(84) D*i w6EF/0*iYZ%Aix@A6@y@A 6@/0wnCD*6EF/0G 9:;H'.A6z{| D*6EF/0 *irs.}~%c4xI@YZ sq -%Xws!@$@ @q

(85) h4*6EFD/0 ws78Zc . 56;O%Iifb*6EF/ 0*iwiI4xI@%* -;O%*iI' . ;O*6LMNOPQRS /0%Ii

(86) /078/0<=>) c%sq/0 ¡¢A6 LMN OPQRS[\]^YZTUy'£¤ -¥¦§¨R©ªM«q%'I6vYZjk ¬3%'I hs.t|536®; O¯°±*Isq -. ;O²³. 56

(87) a´/ 0+,-%3s!%

(88) . á. 9:;µI*iI' . . . ¶·¸¹ º»¼½¾¿¹ À À ¹ »ÁÂÃÄÅÆ¹ Ç È É¾ÊºÀ Â Ç ¼ ºÆ ËÌ·Ã ÍÎÏÐÃÑÒÓÐÃÔÕÖ×ÐËØÙ·ÚEF 7Ûc Ü 786vÝQO ÞÌ ßàÃáâãäáãåÃâæçáÃèéêëàÃìí î·ïðNLÚEF %\/0%ñcòó ¡¢¾ôõö÷øùúûüEFÜ ý þþÃÃçä Ãâææ ·ÑÐÃÐÚEF /0% c

(89) °)s

(90) |%ñc¡¢

(91) *i ¾EF7Ãá Ë·ÃáãäáÃâ æ æ ß·õ<ÓÃÖÃÐÃÚ

(92) EF %\

(93) ;O/ 0 f% ¾

(94) ° Ü Ãã á Ããç äã Ã âæçã B·ÐÃÖÚEF 7/0% ;O/0*i¾

(95) ° Ü Ã ãáÃçäâæÃâæçã ·òð !7Ü 7ðËâæçç çâ ô· · ÚÜ %\;O/0ü +,-@1.³/0*i ¾ æÃâæçá ?7ÃçáÃå çä · Ú7/0%\;O²³6 vI'1@ M

(96) M/0 N/0%*i ¾Ü 7 ð ò ÃâÃçåäçÃâæçã ·?Ú /0;O(üÃ âææáÃ Ã .

(97)