第2次高度成長と景気変動過程:現代日本資本主義 の景気変動(3)
著者 村上 和光
雑誌名 金沢大学経済学部論集
巻 28
号 2
ページ 1‑71
発行年 2008‑03‑31
URL http://hdl.handle.net/2297/9865
!"#$%&'()*+,-./01*2345$6789:;<
%%=>?@%ABCD6EFGHIJK LM;N$O%"#6/0PQRSTUVRWXYZ[\R/0]^
_`*R/0ab$cde-/01*fghij`&9k;N$l m9N)*noN%Kp&q6% !r stu;N$N:L<v.p&q6%
wxycz{|%}(- !~*9k; N%6
9:;$My<
%cL:%N 6yc-N$cm
-<.-Nq_
;-"#6%cL:Ky 1$$c ;¡¢£¤¥c- L¦c $c§¨<%©ª¡¢«¬(®
¯ycK°±²
³ ³
´_
µ ¶·
¸¹ Wº»¼
½ ! /01*
¾ P ¿ À
!"#$%&'()$*+, -."/0#1234 !$"5 !/0$#678 93:;<=$,>?5
$89,"3@ABCDE5>FGHIJ ,K"LM LM *>NO P3 3Q#K"3" !R ST(*UV WX3$YZA[\]
*=^_`ab6cdYefgh#ij *kO<=$
$(D=5 !>T3$0OPlmn3 !$$
J#o6Ipqrb6st3uv=PwJ 3x+yyz{|}~?!qV !="
3 (=5
<=3 efgh731
3 !efgh<=03$6 789#T(!"5
$ "F?
T(= OP3<=3>N 3 b
Yb
h !$5$W3b
¡G¢b#£9=#>N[6h*+¤=
" ¥¦§¨©ª«¬#!®(=5<2¯°±²³´
µ¶³±²·¸µ¶¯±²¯¹µ¶°±²ººµ¶º±²³¸º h*+HI JY¶¯±»¼¥½¾¿ X,´¹±r3À=>Á¥à !ÄÅ
v!=5ÆÇ¶º±³¸ ºÈ¬,¶³±É3 ÊLM<=DF # !ËÌ¢b# HIJ¥½ÍlÎÏ J*+Ð !ÑÏ !ÒÓÅÔÕ Ö× !=0,>NØÙ5>T3$ÚÛ3$HIJ
ÜÝÅÞßàÞá/@ â ã ä
å ¸å
!"#$%&' ()*$(+,- ./012345&67!& (!89 :';<=
>?@7ABCDEFGHIJKL$ (!&M NOOP !'QRST@7UVWXYZ Z[\YZWX U] ^[(_`$(abcJdeCDZf g[\hZ ][(ij$
(klm(n9OoQRST@7pq!rCDEF, sot(k u<vwxCDEF,-yz{|n}
'~vnM(krQR ST@7YUWXUY Y[\YVWXUh Z[\YWXU^ U[(2J $
((CDEFrZU f[\ZV V[\h^ U[(
(y
]
G H
ZUV YZ YU YV Y UV YZ YU YV Y
[
Q R S T @ 7 g h^^ hZ^ UZV ]ZV fY ^hg fgV h]Z Y^g h YZ Z U] ^ UY Y Uh Z U^ U
¡¢£¤¥
¦ § ¨ © ª « Z Zhf g Z YYY Y ] ^]g V f f^V Y U ^V] Y U V f ] V f V Z
= ¬ ? F ® ] h] U V ^hf fZ^ g]Z Vh^ hVU ]hU h^ U hg f^ f ]h ]V f f^ h
>¯?F® h f^] f Y f^Z ] g U] YZU ]f gZ g^V g h^ f ]h h h] h h Z ]Z f d e C D Z g]f g f hhg f U ^Zh U ^] ]Zh VU^ f Zf g hZ ] ZU f ZV V h^ U
° ± j ² hYh f Z ]Uf U YV ^ h ^gh g h Uh^ Y h h Y V h Z ] f ^
?F® V^ h Z Yh] Z ] Z]V ] f ]U Y U U^^ g g U V h Y f V V
³ 7 ( ´ µ
¶ Z ]hY U Z ^f V ] YVh f U Vh ^ g ZgY V ZZ ] Y ZZ ] ZZ ^ ZZ f
= > ? @ 7 ZZ gVU ^Z VUh V]h YU^ fUh gV^ ]Yh gh^ YZ^^ ^ Z^^ ^ Z^^ ^ Z^^ ^ Z^^ ^
= > · ¸ ¹ YZY ZZU gUU ZhU UU Zfh Zf] ^f hV] YZ^^ ^ Z^^ ^ Z^^ ^ Z^^ ^ Z^^ ^
· E F h Zf] V U VUV U Y U]U Z] ]hY ]ZY gUf ] hh ] ]g h hU h ]Z Y ]f ^
` º » ¼ Z Zf g h ZYU f ZU Y U ^ V fUU h
7½ ¾d¿ÀÁÂÃ=>¶ÄÅÆZYWÇÈÁ ¾ÄÅÉÊÆZgZWÉËM
!"#$%&'()*+,- ./01!
21345#$%&678(9:;&<=>?@AB CDDEFDDGHIJKL/M1NOPL/QRS1!2TU 5VWXY:Z[\ 9:]^_`]2abcdef
;gh@HiCR./jklm4FinDopi pqRrstuvwx01yzqA{ L/qiC|o}iFq
R~R1z!2 qDn q@R L
/C }b2(]w].
.5]./2d] .M
=( ¡ ¢ £¢ ¤ ¥
¦ n¦
abcdef
§¨ G© ªP= «¬&=
®U ¯°=± 9:
² ³ ´µ=±
² ³ ¶& · · 1
¸¹º»
h@ ¼ ¼ ¼ ¼ ¼ ¼ ¼ ¼ ¼ G
}pq q½ C| DD¾ D D¾ F n¾ n n¾ FF¾ F C¾ } nD¾ | nF¾ F C|¾ C q}}
p| q½ DnF DD¾ D F¾ | |¾ C n¾ F F¾ D q¾ p nC¾ | Fp¾ C C|¾ | ½ Dqq p} |½ qCD DD¾ D n¾ } C¾ D F¾ q Cn¾ p F¾ C F¾ n n¾ FC¾ n ½ DqD D C½ qqC DD¾ D n¾ F CD¾ } C¾ F Cp¾ p C¾ C}¾ } Fn¾ } C|¾ ½ C}
½ CCF DD¾ D CF¾ p |¾ | C¾ n C¾ n F¾ D C¾ | nD¾ } FD¾ q ½ nD C n½ ppF DD¾ D |¾ F ¾ F n¾ F Cn¾ D n¾ } FF¾ C nC¾ C F¾ C ½ D F n½ DF| DD¾ D C¾ |¾ F F¾ Cn¾ F F¾ q F¾ n|¾ D n¾ F ½ nq n p½ D| DD¾ D C¾ } q¾ F F¾ CD¾ p F¾ F Cq¾ n pC¾ n nn¾ n ½ |}
p p½ pC DD¾ D q¾ D ¾ C F¾ CD¾ F ¿C¾ F C¾ D¾ C pD¾ ½ Cnp p½ |q DD¾ D ¾ q |¾ F¾ D n¾ C ¿C¾ n n¾ | q}¾ } ¾ p ½ C|
q C½ qp DD¾ D n¾ | ¾ F C¾ } |¾ C ¾ D CC¾ ¾ | pD¾ n ½ CC
| C}½ qD DD¾ D ¾ n q¾ q C¾ q Cn¾ n¾ F¾ } pn¾ D nC¾ n ½ FFn } Fq½ Dq} DD¾ D ¾ F ¾ q C¾ n C}¾ } ¾ q Fn¾ D pF¾ D nD¾ } À qD n½ |}C DD¾ D p¾ F q¾ n¾ Fn¾ } ¾ p nD¾ p nq¾ Fq¾ F À
;ÁÂH ÃÄÅÆÇÃ:#$%&·ÈÉ}p}EqDÊ0!
}qDËÌ2`Í`ÎÏÐQ·È4Ñ!
! "#$%&'()*+,-.
/ 01#223,+4 56#1789:
2;<=>?@AB CDEF#7GH=
= CDEF#IJKLMBANOP:2"
QR%&'(#ST QRUV'(#2 WX(YZ[#2)
\]^P:?_` a] WX(YZ[#b7cdef QR%&'(# 56#IghP:ZijklmIn
>o<K?p[qrstuv rwxyztus {wxyrtu| ywxystu
| }wxy|tus sw2~AB/:BA
P:= ! "#$[ E#IP:
2Pf QR%&'(# 56#I_1M,B AOP:2a7~=
a a] QRUV'(#b7?I2 { {wxy swx{ zwx |wx} w2^7<:f7~ !
"#$I~f ¡$#¢£¤aa ! "#
$¥~+¦§¨*B?©ª«¬2>
7JB:?K®I¯a2@°
±²f %&'(# 56#2³_~´'(7µ !
"#$2q¶ #· ¸<]#~f®¹7Afºg»
1:22 a ¼½¾¿ÀP:Á>
¡$#IÂÃ2 UVÄÅÆÇÈ#7ÉÊËÅF1aa
:M,7ÌÍÎ>:2~=
S/I_<" ϼ#Ð]I*Ñ:2Ò2 SÓ=mÉ7ÔÕ:PJ6Öר6¥~;Ùf=
! "Ú°[#$~%&'(nÛÜÝÞßàIá~
fâã@=ä å)ÞæçèFéæêë#2~fJK ìÏ æìíîïÏ#âã3AB~f_1= ìÏâã#
¢Ñ:%&'(ðñ7 '(7'(Iòó#2Zôõö
'(÷ïÏ÷¾ø÷ùú#ð ûüýþ#Iïf2~
! "Ú°[2E) µ/·
r
!"#$%&'()*+,-./ 0123456' (789:;<=:;>?9:"@"ABCDE FG;FH BG;FH I GJAKCDE EG;FB LG;FM FGJAMCDN HG;L NG;FH MGJAACDE B G;N FG;FK AGJAECDE EG;FB HG;FA LG OPQR S TUVW)*+,XY Z[\
"T ]:^UVR_ `abcdd;efdgh ijkl">?9:mmnop qrsTtuvw7xy z${|}~$$#%"T: )*+
,5 X] R `abcddmefd;
ghi &$01j )*+,Yq
+,XY!4s! $u
7Q#
Q)*+,rsW0134u ¡!": ¢£¤ %¥¦7!$
#"§l¨©ª«¬ ®¯
)*+,j n ¢£01°± j ²ª7 +,V;)*+,$°2³´u$ lWjµ#
¶j)*+,·¸X] ¹ºj °27}~$$#
»¼]8O½80¾¿ À Á Â
à AÃ
ÄÅHICÆ HA HL HE HN MB MF MK MH MM MI
Ç È KBÉ HMA KAÉ FLE KMÉ HFL KIÉ BLN KNÉ LIB KLÉ MNA KNÉ EFH MKÉ HNL IHÉ IEB AAÉ KKK EFÉ HAM ÊFBBË BÌÊFBBË BÌ ÊFBBË BÌ ÊFBBË BÌ ÊFBBË BÌ ÊFBBË BÌ ÊFBBË BÌ ÊFBBË BÌ ÊFBBË BÌ ÊFBBË BÌ ÊFBBË BÌ
Í : FFÉ AHF FIÉ MKI FHÉ IHF FHÉ KLI FIÉ NFL FHÉ ENA FIÉ BBM KMÉ FEK HFÉ HLF HEÉ HLK MLÉ INH ÊILË KÌ ÊIEË NÌÊIIË AÌÊIKË NÌÊIHË IÌÊIBË IÌÊIBË HÌÊILË BÌÊIEË IÌÊILË NÌÊIEË IÌ
Î789: FÉ AMN KÉ MLB KÉ FMA KÉ KMI KÉ LLK KÉ HKI KÉ HEN HÉ KAA MÉ LMF IÉ EEA LÉ FEL ÊEË FÌ ÊNË MÌ ÊEË EÌ ÊNË BÌ ÊNË HÌ ÊEË IÌ ÊEË BÌ ÊLË LÌ ÊEË EÌ ÊEË NÌ ÊEË EÌ
< = : KÉ AHA HÉ KKN KÉ INM KÉ KEB KÉ HML KÉ MKE KÉ ANN MÉ MMF IÉ IKA LÉ HBK NÉ BHM ÊFHË BÌ ÊFKË HÌÊFBË LÌ ÊNË FÌ ÊLË NÌ ÊEË EÌ ÊNË FÌÊFBË IÌÊFBË HÌÊFFË BÌÊFFË FÌ
>?9: KÉ LMB MÉ FBA HÉ MKK HÉ FBA HÉ NLN HÉ FHK HÉ LMI AÉ EFK EÉ NKA FBÉ LLB FKÉ NIB ÊFHË IÌ ÊFIË LÌÊFMË FÌÊFKË MÌÊFHË MÌÊFFË MÌÊFKË AÌÊFAË FÌÊFAË LÌÊFAË HÌÊFIË NÌ Ê¡ÏÌ O½ÐÑÒÓÔÕÐ:+,-.ÖÈyרÙÚ#
,Û»FÉ BBBÜÝRS ÔÕ#
! "#$ %&'()*+,- ./ 012345 $627859:%& ;<'(
)=>?@ABCDEFGHIJ=KL,85MN%&,8 53ONH5P!Q=RSTONUVHWXY6$
7Z[[,\]5^!Q=_` abcdefDgC3hi H=? jk lKmG3nVopI P/- q STr[W5 stuv)wxyz{B|}H5
~/78I3\!V3 S<r F\H5]H5^\9+^ ["Z $ 62W5e e \4=!
$ 6\ c
cS<r S<r
¡¢%& N%& ¡¢%& N%&
£¤ ¥ ¤ ¦¥ § ¦¥ § ¨¥
£¥ ¦ ¥ ¨ ¨¥ ¥ £
£¥ ¤ ¥ ¥ ¥
§ £¥ ¦¥ ¨¥ ¨¥
¤ £¥ ¥ ¨¥ ¥
¦¥ ¥ ¤ ¥ ¥
£ ¦¥ ¥ ¥ ¥ ¨
¦ ¦¥ ¥ ¦ ¥ § ¨¥ ¦
¦¥ ¥ ¨¥ £ ¥ ¤
¨ £¥ ¤ ¥ £ ¥ ¤ ¥
£¥ ¤ ¦¥ ¥ ¥
¦¥ ¥ ¥ ¥ §
¦¥ ¦ ¥ § ¨¥ ¨¥ ¨
§ £¥ ¨ ¦¥ ¦¥ ¦¥
¤ ¦¥ § ¥ ¤ ¥ ¨¥
¦¥ ¥ ¨¥ ¤ ¨¥ ¦
£ ¦¥ £ ¦¥ ¨¥ ¥
¦ ¦¥ ¥ £ ¨¥ ¥ ¨
©ª«¡¢%&¬®¯°§±¨§±¨¤±
!"#$% & &' ( () ' *+,!-
!./"0*1 ,23456789:
;<=>?@ABCDE1
E2FG,HIJKLMNOPQRS:T UVBWXY0,Z1[\]^2 3_`ab%*
cde9:;<fghZijklmnoTpqSrT stTsuTqvwxyz,<{T|o}~KL VBkmB03 E Ym1*H
b_`boqBmmpq
bBVJ%jBj Y0¡J
¢**+m10j£¤,¥¦§¨©ª«¬®¯°±r
²³*B"´µpq¶·¸¹º»¼Ym!"yzpq
;<½¾de¿ÀMjÁÂjÃ!1Yj ÄÃÅÆ!", KLÇÂUVjDÈm 23j?É;<?ÊEEËÌ
ͪ½¾mj9:;<ÎÏYJ ÐÃÑVJ1
jFG2 ÒÓ¹ºÅUVj¥*"*1ÔÕ
%Ö×mZj23jhØJ9:;<ÎÏÙÚ*rÛB9 :;<½Ï|o@./¦Ü¨ ÒÓ¹ºÅUVݽ¾jÞ+
mßàáâB23ãzjZ+, ÒÓ¹ºÅUVBÞ Jäf Y0må.ÒÓMݹºæVjçY0m9:;<½Ï jÀ,Z*¿ÀM»¼Bè,¸éÞ+m1
mB+, }êëìÞµ1E^23ÔwMíî ,ïm 2 3jE!bðÃB mÞ
^Yj0jñY0, 9:;<ò£=óô>?@A
@°B m â1
E 9:;<Ôwõö.klm÷|oTã øðÃk%1 ùj|o!"J
úðÃû!1ü¤-ýþq|oW
¤-oqs ( ) && &
¾ÆÆ } 2 2
&
!"#$%&'()*+,-.'(/01234567859 :;<=> ?(@ABCD%DEFGHIJKLIMN(OP Q6RGST=G:;UV=R;,-.'(;WX)Y Z[\']7,-.'(;W^)_`aM(b7c d67e8U9:R=fghi_jkfghi_j,-_('lm 7:;no)pUqr sr rs ( t s sut (qtu su su t( v9G67 :;wx/yz{|=}67fghi_(;~G'=},-_(
G: ()7-,-
(G,-&)J K(?;/ m()
vG RR=0D/ 759
R;8Uv']()¡¢££-(¤0Uy¥¦§
)¨e©J K(?=0J K(?ª«¬®(;
.'G¯°v;/}Z75U[=0v595U;0±²®(³ u t´µ¶·®³q ´v¸;¹®Gº»)'¼½67 5;¾¿7ÀÁ(³t qrq ´ Âî(³ u qu ´®(³u rtu u t´v¸
;&ÄÅÆG°5Çv\R ;EÈÉ/3{56 785 9
ÊR;J K(?}670,-.Ë;Ì/R¬
®(ÍZÎÏ/v:;ÐÑ=¬®;
ÒÓ/Ô|;R=}1U9
ÎÕ)Ö×7J K(?Ø×R;"#$%&'j,-.'(
Ù)MNÚ(5UÛ<ÜÝ7ØRU9:R=ÞMNÚ(
)ßz(Xà(;áâãäå75[\> ?()æ 7ßz uç³Xàu uç´tr tç³ ç´¤è 0;;/ét uç³r qç´½ê)e:;B/
ç³ qç´ ç³q ç´ r ç³r uç´
5UëìvLMN) 9[JK(?í5î J KLIMNïðÙ ³ñÕ´
s s
!"
#$% &' ( )*
&+ , - ./( 0,-
./( 1(
232 456 5 376 846 8 436 3 46 9 :56 5 456 7 386 3 356 3 :36 4 36 3 46 356 8 456 2 5 386 56 7 276 5 396 346 2 36 4 336 9 526 326 8 426 5:6 3 3:6 4 56 2 326 5 526 7 96 7 226 586 3 526 3 536 5:6 3 946 3 546 5 5:6 9 9:6 596 7 596 5 96 57 946 9 936 26 : 946 : 526 7 9:6 : 976 8 986 5 526 2 96 4 956 2 956 2 946 2 9:6 8 5: 8:6 7 8:6 6 3 876 2 986 : 86 9 86 3 846 4 856 5 956 8:6 8 26 : 896 5 876 9 54 256 : 2:6 56 4 256 : 296 : 286 3 26 7 2:6 4 246 236 : 296 9 46 7 246 9 236 8 53 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 55 :6 26 836 8:6 436 556 :6 6 26 3 6 5:6 4 76 9 6 46 59 :46 8746 946 ::56 426 536 :76 :76 36 446 ::6 5 396 8 96 9 :36 9 58 386 ::86 736 :56 4586 42:6 3:6 :796 7 776 3 926 8356 9 756 5 756 : 356 4 52 846 9336 846 5896 8776 27:96 4926 3:26 3 726 746 38:6 4 73:6 2 :56 8 8:6 3
;<=> ?@A?BCDEFGHIJKL
GM NOP QR*S
T&UV GWXP
YZ[\ ]Z^_`Qa<
b c d e `Q[\ b c d e
f f f f gh gh
23: 76 5 36 9 36 9 26 86 4 786 34 6 56 46 : 26 8 826 :46 33 6 26 i:6 7 96 2 256 2 446 3 35 76 8 86 :26 86 9 86 7 346 3 39 :6 2 86 736 76 776 7 536 : 38 46 36 4 i46 9 6 3 736 2 976 9 32 76 7 26 7 56 2 6 5 :26 2 856 8 5 26 2 46 46 2 46 4 556 : 76 4 5 7:6 4 36 5 :56 8 46 4 7:6 4 7476 57 6 8 56 4 :6 4 :6 : 77:6 4 7336 : 5: 36 4 6 5 36 : 76 7336 7 7926 4 54 96 2 :6 : 76 76 : 7286 9 :46 3 53 6 3 46 5 i56 4 6 5 :756 : :736 3 55 36 : 6 7 6 4 6 7 :976 5 :336 3 59 86 : :6 3 796 76 8 4:56 5 :226 3 58 86 5 46 7 796 7 46 4 36 8 436 7 52 56 9 76 76 2 46 5 326 7 4226 8 9 96 8 6 : 36 4 36 3 5896 3436 9 6 9 56 8 :6 7 46 9386 7 3936 4 97 46 4 86 2 36 8 :6 836 3 536 9: 746 6 3 26 : 6 j :26 4 5586 9
;<=> klmAno4Gpqrs`Q[\BC;no75Gtuno47Gt>DEA`Q[\
BCGvD;no42GH>wIJKL
!"#$%&'()*+&,-./#012 3456789:;<=>?@$AB3#CDEF GHI)JKLM4NO/#)21HP-8<Q, RS#TU&VWHP5RSX#)YZHP4@:
Q-[,- !"#)S \. -]^.]_#'
`4a-bc85:Q,*d Q-$\ef#gh:
iMjklmnopqr4slt#$u]^-2vCw5xyz x{|}slt~# { l~#{
y yZ#y yy y"
^slt~#h C5l#
-"slt)x{|l~#- CM5
Z#-2y CK]^45 )¡HP5:H
¢£¤<-]^3#¥¦4@),-§¨S©ªl#$
u«4K¬JB6J:[®j©ªlmn|¯p°4
¦±²b³-xyzx|-}©~#y{ ´ ´ x
l~#{y µ¶ #x xy{ x
{·#y x !"s2)
¸¹¦ºP5:Q4Q-[\»y¼#"ªl½Cb 45¸Q-~)xy|´hJx|x´¾¿ÀÀhK
©~- x,-ªlÁ)l#-µ¶ # -x·#-CQPÂPM45 1§)Ã4 5hJQ-]^ÄX-H)DE89:
Q-Å,-@]^-ÆÇ#)ȳ ªl-²É.²#-
`Ê85Kbca4@:Q,¸Q-ËCÌ
§¨#hJÍÎP®R S#ThJÏÐT#h74ÑÒÓ´
ÔÕa4Ì ªl~x|Ö¿×<ÑÒÓ´CØ
5Ù<x|RÚÛTÑÒÓy´ÜCÝÞ:
HR S#T-ßàáâ³KÌ -85:À,- Ì )²É#CFGHI-ãD8a4²Éäåæ~#
R SXßàBeÄ ç
z yyz
!"#$%&'()"*+,-./01234567+89: +
; < =( >0?@ABCDE5+FGHI)JKLMNOP./
01256*QRS6"> T012A1U56VWTXYZ[\=
]H+^I!0#$_125/`ab()^c" 0dPeP5fg6 hh> =hi;"]0dPePjk5/lm "c/no/
p"% 01qrdPeP5%
%%%
% stuT= ].>iTvwx6yz{ih6"
|}"c/~0 ng5+k)> )(
9 ^.)"^^ !".0vw5()/
RW6.Wi>+""cI("0#
V ¡¢£¤ ¥ ¦ §
¨ ¨ p
© ª © ª
, «
¬
¬
¬
¬
¬
¬
® 12¯°~/±=
²³´8µ¶·¸n¹º»
+:9=
¼½¾vw d P e P
¿/
1 q r
¿/