放射性物質による環境汚染に係る法制度と「汚染者負担の原則」――原発事故と「汚染者負担の原則」に関する予備的考察―― 利用統計を見る

ῌ῏ ῎῍

῍῍

῎ῌ῍῍῏῍῍ !"#$ῌ %&'()*+%,-./012 3.-4 ῎ 5 ῐῑ 6+῏ 7ῌ '89':;<=

>?@ABCDE$῍ FEGH2IAJ$KLMNOP QRSTῌ PUVWXYA"#Z6῍ #G#ῌ [

\]^ῌ VWXY_`;XY a6Zῌ 6bcde f#Z6;6AKg7;6ch+G῍

&i7ῌ [VWXY ῎^GjkX Y῏ _` lma6Zῌ noZp#6lm7q ῐ ῎r s6῏ ῑ tu#ῌ vwxyaz{|}

~#Z€}‚῍ ƒ„z{|Avw…#Z ῐ ῎r s6῏ ῑ }†‡{|#Zˆ‰#ῌ jkXY Š}‹Œ

7e+Gῌ ‹Ž}u῍

&i7ῌ bῌ Eb7Db‘b;’7“”DEZe$ ῐ ῎r s6῏ ῑ ῌ ῎aa6Z•–῍ —aῌ ῍῔ΐ῎

˜™DE$OECD ῐrs6ῑ 7qfῌ M+2aῌ ῍῔ῒῌ

š !›AœžŸ ;GGH¡›EZe$ῌ ›Aœ¢£ ῐ ῑ 7q῍ ¤a ῐῑ –”¥¦}῍῔ΐῌš

Š§¨©”ª}«•–῍ •–}¬b­ῌ vw#

®¯°z±1ῐῑ² ῎῎ῌ῍῎῕῍῎῕῏ ,+-

῍῎ ῌ

ῌ ῌ ῏ ΐ ῔ ῐῌ ῍ !"#$%&'($)*+, -./01234!15678/9:;<=>?@

ABC ῏ ΐ@B῔ ῐῌ ῎ DEFG ῏

ΐFG῔ ῐ HIJHῌ OECD ΐ;<KDL

M῔ ῌ NOP ΐ;<KQRM῔ STUVWX῍ YUVSTῌ

Y4TIJO ΐ;<K ῏DLῐ QRM῔ FZSW [\ !῍

ῌ

;<KQRM

]^S

ΐ;<KQRM῔ ]ῌ _`a]ῌ bcOECD/ ΐ;<

KDLM ῏PPP῎

Polluter Pays Principleῐ῔ /῍ _def

ΐ;<KDLM῔ g ΐ;<KQRM῔ ^hdi4ῌ 3T ΐ;

<KDLM῔ ]ῌ 3jkj^lmWfnopn^῏῍ῐ῍ Y ΐM῔ ]ῌ Y4jq῎HrA34s!῍ tu ῑ῎ῌ῍῎ῒ ῏῍ῐῑvῐ M ῌ jwH]ῌ ΐxyz{|W}y~-€‚ƒ῔ „

OECD ΐ;<KDLM῔ q…0ῌ fH] ΐ†‚ ^h-

b‡BC῔ W„NOP ΐ;<KQRM῔ q…῍ 3Tῌ

ˆ!^ ΐ;<KQRM῔ lm ‰Š ΐ‹ŒŽƒ?„ῌ

‘~€DL„ ῌ ’“”lm34῔ ῏tu ῑ῎ῌ῍῎ῒ

῍ῐῑvῐ ῌ •– ΐ;<KQRM῔ Htu ῑ῎ῌ῍῎ῒ ῏῍ῐῑ

vῐ ] ΐf]g„d’—˜ ^῍῔ ΐf ῌ PPP™š

W›q…4iῌ œc!῏Hlmh4Wž Sῌ῔

[Ÿ~ ¡6Wž¢ ῍

£¤q]ῌ £¤¥‡!¦ῌ OECD ΐ;<KDLM῔ N

OP ΐ;<KQRM῔ Hῌ ῍ῒῑῌ§OECD ΐ;<KQ

RM῔ O¨©34!Šª«¬­n®„W !῍

,+.

ῌ῎

῍

῏ῌῐ OECD ΐ ῏PPP῎

Polluter Pays Principle^῏῍ῐῐ῔

ῌ OECD ΐ ῔

῏ ΐOECDPPP῔ ῐ ῌ ῌῐ῏῍

OECD ῏ΐ !"#$ῌ%&#'%(

ῑ)*+,῔ῐ -./01234 56῍ 7ΐ ῑῌῐ῏῎ῒ ῏ῌ8ῐ - OECDPPP῎9ῌ :;<56῍

ΐ=>?@ABῑCῐ῍DEFGῌ HIJKLMN@O

P῕QDRS4TUVῌ WXYZ[\῍]^4T

῍_3`a bῌ PPPcH?_?῍ d ῌ ῏ bῐ eῌfg?hiDjI4Tῌ b@klmnDo

`a56dDpqG/O<ῌ G4b./dYZ῔5ῌ JKN@rG῕QDsaOd-?tukDv῍G/?_?

῍ ῏wxyz {῍ῐ῔

2_OECDPPPῌ |}ῌ z~`a€~\῍I/ῌ ΐU

\῍῔ ῏7ΐ ῑῌῐ῏῎ῒ ῌ8ῐ d56Gῌ ΐH?<‚ƒ„…†

῔ ῏7ΐ ῑῌῐ῏῎ῒ ῌ8ῐ 5ῌ ‡\῍D2ˆdb‰†

Š‹56ŒŽ4./4῍ Cῌ €~

‘[’*C\῍D“”•–—˜y˜™š›2ˆ/z~Gῌ

=>?@ADœῒC]^d6.4῍ d-ῌ OECD PPPῌ €~\῍z~ῑ56<ῌ b)C?

€~\῍Dd56./ῌ bžŸ ¡4€~\῍

Do¢dDpqG/5?^῏῎ῐ῍

7ΐ ῑῌῐ῏῎ῒ ῏῍8ῐ -ῌ OECDPPP£_:῎¤5

6G/῍

῍ ΐ¥¦D§¨©¥¦D§¨©ῌ =>“56DªdDpq

H_ῌ 3«P¬­I­dD®§G¬­I­dD®§Gῌ H­G/ῌ -?

¨©¯°4±\D῏œŸD†4ˆd῍῔

²³„´µ-¶·X¸ ΐo¢ ῔ ῏¹º»¼ῐ ,+/

ῌ῍

῎

῍ ῐ ῌ !"ῌ #$%&'() ῌ !"ῌ #$%&'()*

+,῍ ῎-. /0῏ῑ

῍ ῐ1#$2345678 '()*+,῍ῑ

*ῌ OECD2PPP 9ῌ :;<=>ῌ?@AB2CD2E FG9ῌ HI2JK=Lῌ ?@MNO'EPGQ +,RST^῎῍῏῍

ῌOECD2 ῐ:;0UVTEFῑ 2PW

IX2"ῌ OECD2PPP9ῌ YZ2[Z\EPGQῌ :;

0]?@:;2HI^YZUV"+,GQ῍ YZ,9ῌ _

`ῌ abcdGefgab2hiῌ abefj kl^U 9ῌ mhnUVogGQῌ +g]p^,q`g GQῌ abefrstuvf',wxy^2+,p^z{

,q|῍ ῌ abef,}~ῌ mhkT]€e Thiῌ +gYZ,qῌ efstuv‚',wxy^

€e'YZz{YZ,q|῍ OECD2PPP9ῌ +2z{Y Z[Z\'kƒ2PW„…†‡GQ῍ +2"ῌ k

ƒ2PW9 ῐˆ‰Šῑ ,q`gPWGQ῍

++Gῌ Q‹Œ2efTŽh2_Gῌ ˆ‰Š2PW

7CT ῎ῌ῏῍ Tῌ ‘’^mh“Tῌ Žh]‹Œ‹”T

῍ +2,wῌ nl2‹Œ‹”€e'Gxyῌ p^z {•. ῎PMC῏ ,qῌ nlῌ kƒG9ῌ +gmh“!–

—•. ῎S῏ ,q ῎ῌG9S῎῏ῌ ˜™]2•.,῍ s‡ῌ pC

š2‹Œ›'œž'•.9ῌ œ•. ῎D῏ ,q`gῌ ˜-]

2•.,῍ kƒG9ῌ –—•.,œ•.,2Ÿ  ῎ῌ2E῎῏

G9ῌ (¡^¢£¤¥]¦§T+,῍ ῌ ¨ῌ +2‹

,+0

ῌ῍

῎

῏ῌῐ

῍

ῌ !"# !"#"#$%&'ῌ ( )!"# ῏SMC῎

Sΐῐ *+,῍ --.ῌ !"#()

!"#+,/0123 ῏Tῐ $4-῍ -23

῏Tῐ *567389:῍ 43$-.ῌ $;<ῌ

=>?@.AB-*CD῍

Eῌ 567343Fῌ GH1IGH ῏Pῌῐ EJ43 KGH ῏Pΐῐ LMN῍ -OPQRS3TUT.V*ῌ WXUGHMNFY*Z[L\] ῏Pΐ῍Pῌῐ ^:ῌ Z [*WX-῍

OECDPPPῌ -_`abc&^῏῍ῐ-EJῌ \ ]$de-῍

Eῌ -ῌ @*fg!^῏῎ῐῌ Z[UPQhij klmno pqrs ῑ[WXtuῒ ῏vwxyῐ ,+1

ῌ῍

῎

ῌ ῎ ῏Dῐ ῌ ῏Dῐ ῍ ῌ !"#

$%&ῌ '()*+,#-.῍ /01ῌ 2

#(34567%891:;ῌ <=>?2#(3%

@AB/ῌ (3%CD*+,&Bῌ EF? ΐ(

3GHIJB/῔ ῏KL ῑ῎ῌ῍῎ῒ ῍῏ῐMῐ ῍ Nῌ ῏Dῐ /OPQRῌ ST'()GH^῏ῑῐB.UV

&W ῍

XYZῌ 4567[\]^1 ΐ45_%`ab cdef-ghij&B/῎ij&kῌ lm n!oOECDPPP45_%`abcdef-pqrs tuB/῎vwXYZῌ xy[QRῌ ῎def -pqr\]1z{8J῎|}?~€\]oῌ ‚)ƒ

Y[^1ῌ xy[„uJ1^῏ῒῐ῍῔ ῏KL ῑ῎ῌ῍῎ῒ ῍῏ῒMῐ ,+2

ῌ῎

῍

῏῍

῍ OECD ῑῒ ῍^῏῍ῌῐ

῍ῌ ῌ OECDPPP ῍ !῍

῍"#$%&#'῍()ῌ *+,-./0"

#$%(1ῌ *+,2345"

#$%67!89:0

῍&#'!;<"#$% ῑ+,=>?@$%ῒ

῍ABCDEFGH'

῏῎ῐ I*J ῑ67ῒ

ῌI*J ῑ67ῒ H῎KL

OECDPPPM:ῌ I*J ῑ67ῒ ῏NO ῑ

67ῒ ῐ ῌ -P/0QRSTURVWῌ+,XY$

%Z[%()ῌ "#$%&#'῍0\ῌ ]^_]

(῍ `)ῌ QRaR( ῏bcῌ AB(*

dῐ Zefghῌ0i/:5 ῑ῍ῒ (῍

67*j῎!ῌ ῑURkl-B*ῌ m3 :5URM:n/EF61o*p1*qῌ ῒ (῍ `)ῌ r*ms:5QRaR(

*G(qῌ*(῍

0 ῑ῍ῒ *I*Jtju<5KLῌ _Rvwx yz{*(῍ I*J῍῔ῑῌ|}῍῔ῒῌ|}ῌ ~€Tj

‚0_Rƒ„*…†':5῍ ‡0ˆ‰Šῌ I‹Œ_R

vw ῏Ž‘ῌ’“”•–-—˜™vw῎

’“š›œῐῐῒ|῔῎῔ž

Ÿ ῒῐ῎¡῔ῒ¢ῌ Œž£¤¥¦UR§W¨©-—῎

ªš›Œž£#œῐ ῐΐ|ΐ῎ῐž Ÿ ῒΐ῎¡῏ῌ¢ῌ «¬««¬«–-—῎

­®¯~›°±

²³´µ¶+,·n¸ ῑ67ῒ ῏¹º»¼ῐ ,+3

ῌ῍

῍

ῐΐ῔῕ ῒΐῐ῎ῑῌ ῏ ῐ῔῏῎ῌ ῒ῕ῒ῍ῑῑ ῌ

!"#῍ $%ῌ &'&&'& ()*)ῌ +(

,-./0123456ῌ 78 9-῍

ῒ:+45 ῐ./012345ῑ ;<=0>?@

ABῌ ῎ῑῑ῍C?@0>DEFGῌ H"IAJ KL0*(M0ῌ NM0OPQῌ R0ῌ SDT6-I(, -HA)UVWXYZῌ C0*[\]^_`-abc deῌ Mῌ NMOfghDij-ῌ O7kC^_

9lm!"#0[\noj-pCOKqrst;

ruvwxy7B῎ῌyz-{(|U}~W!"#A

!"ῌ €[\‚ƒῌ „7k[\‚ƒ…†‡

ˆ‰Š[\ῌ :+45KL0*9#abcdeA &

AW|U‹ŠŒŽ!"ῌ H"j-:+y

\)`"IYHA)‘’“9#AB(,-῍

”90 ῍ῌ῕•῍–*—7k˜™6);<

ACš˜(,-[\ῌ ῎:+45KL0*OD9#

T›0 ῍ῌ῕•῍–*— ῒœ9Z)ΐ ,#-HA

\[A8žŸ(,-῍

 6:+45)abcdeODi¡OD9#‰Šῌ &D !¢£¤D!\¢#I(,-[\ῌ 0 ῍ῌ῕•

῍–7B¤ U0>VA9"¥,-IA8žŸ(

,-¦Y\`ῌ §EFG῎ῑῑ῍¨p 9#¤

6Iῌ 0 ῍ῌ῕•῏–7B p0>VA#©9”¤D

"¥j-ª$D%8žŸ(,-῍ ῐa«¬­ ®&Vῑΐ

H78ῌ 7¯ῌ °±() ῒw²³´”

µ†7¯¶·D¸¹9ῌ ”"7¯¤D'$#º»)ῌ ” )¤"¥D%8A8 ¼(῎{78…Z)!"#ΐ ,,*

ῌ῎

῍

῏ ῑῌῐ῏῍ῒ ῎ῐ ῍ ῌ ΐ῔

῍ !ῌ "#$%&'()

*!ῌ +,-./0&/01ῌ 234,567,89 ()*!ῌ +,:;4,89<=>?῍

"#@῍῏ ABCῌ DEFCG )HIJ῍

ῌKL ΐ῔ M

ΐ῔ !ῌ NOIJPQR STIU*VW*

X῍ Y ΐ῔ M()*ῌ ῑῌῐ῏῍ῒῌ Z@

ῑῌῐ῏῍ῒῌ [\ ῑῌῐ῏῍ῒ ]^_`abcdef'Fῌ MF*g

)῍

hiῌ ῑῌῐ῏῍ῒ ῏῎ῐ !ῌ jIJkEF*)῍

ΐPPP()*ῌ +,=l&'D>m*nopYG IU*+,noCDq>G)JYG@rG>Pd sῌ tῌ uvw'xU*!ῌ y0z{D|}~y0z{D|}~

€Pc‚ƒF*„… !+,noz{o†‡ˆ‰Š‹ῌ

€Pc‚ƒF*„… !+,noz{o†‡ˆ‰Š‹ῌ

ŒŽ‘IJPYGP)IJ

ŒŽ‘IJPYGP)IJ῎’sPdP)“

J῍ ῏”• f'ῐ῔ GF*ῌ OECDPPPG–)Dk—F*)῍

!ῌ >PK˜ ΐ+,noz{I12™k—t+,noz{I12™k—t ῏”• f'ῐ῔

YGῌ Gš›F*)῍

jῌ Z@ ῑῌῐ῏῍ῒ ῏ῌῌῐ !ῌ ΐ῔ !56D ΐ

@῔ GFῌ / 56œCžGF*ῌ jIJMDE F῍

ΐKL!῎Ÿ )!¡^¢+,£¤4,|¥>dkdc Pῌ h¦/§4,z{)h)4,z{)h)ῌ 56¨©

PP)῔ GF*N ΐ56U*!ῌ56U*!ῌ 4,uªDh>YG4,uªDh>YG PkdcF*ῌ Ÿ cd«¬K­®DGdH῍ F*ῌ PkdcF*ῌ Ÿ cd«¬K­®DGdH῍ F*ῌ YY¯Pz{aIU*ῌ °,DpYG

YY¯Pz{aIU*ῌ °,DpYGῌ +,±²³

´µ¶·vI"#¸G ΐ῔ ῏¹º»¼ῐ ,,+

ῌ῍

῎

῍ ῎ ῏ΐ ῍ ῌ ῍ΐῑ῏ῐῌ

῎ῌ῍῍ !"#$%&'( ^῎῍῍῏῍

)ῌ *+ ῐ῍ΐῑ῏ῑ ῎῎ῒῌ῎ΐ,῏ -ῌ ./0123 ῍

ῒPPPPPPῌῌ 4567#89: ;<=5>?3 4567#89: ;<=5>?3 ΐ

@- ῒ89: ;-ῌ 67ABC DEFG

HI;ῌ /JKE#A!LM)KENOῌ PQ HI;ῌ 67#>?3 0R#45STU'(C(

V῍ ABC DEFGI;<ῌABC DEFGI;<ῌ WX@YZ[\ῌWX@YZ[\ῌ DD ]^_`ab^ῌ D]^_/ c deS/0Pf_]g ]^_`ab^ῌ D]^_/ c deS/0Pf_]g h-ijk#lf3 "ῌ "Rm3 ῍

h-ijk#lf3 "ῌ "Rm3 ῍ ῎ ῏ΐ

ῒn]DEop;ῌ qrs89tuH;ῌ vw]

67#)(<>?3xyΐ ῍

"/0e<z{u3 |X}~€ῌ ‚ ῐ῍ΐῑ῏ῑ ῎ῑ ,῏ -ῌ .ƒ„<2 ῍

ῌ)X}|]…†=#DEADEA‡ˆ3:‰Š|i

‹‡ˆ<vŒŽῌ n4-)‡ˆ<‘’3 "<“”

•0῍

ῌ)X}#DEKE–—˜™<š ῌ )(›iI X}/ X<œ)“”<ž ῍

ῌ)X}vwš€8967FG<Ÿ ¡ ῍ )(

)(<¢.]£¤4Sῌ KE)L¥%˜™

=¦§< ῍

"/0w¨ ῒ67>?Rΐ ῌ DEKEC KE~

PQ;<©ª67«¬~­30e-®S῍ "(w¯

-ῌ ῒ67>?Rΐ ῒeΐ <./04H "3 ^῎῍῎῏῍ ,,,

ῌ῍ ῌ

ῌ ῌ ῌ !"#$%&ῌ '(

#ῌ )*+,῍

ῌ'(#-./012234567῍

ῌ89:;<῍

ῌ-.89=>?@ABCD12EFGHIJ#

89KLMNOPQ7ῌ RSTUVWQ7X1 YZ#1[῍

\] ^_ῌ OECDPPPZ ῒ)*+ΐ `a[:

;<=bc῍ $de=^ZZfX1gX῍

OECDPPP#ῌ hi=di<ῌ 89:;< ῒ`ΐ j HklmjH[ ῒΐ nlῌ ῒ)*+ΐ #ῌ op )*+q, ῒ`ΐῌ 89:;<

ῒ`ΐ 23rkQ7H[ ῒΐ῍ st ῐ῎ῌ῍῎ῑ u2Zvwῌ \] x ῒOECD yzy<Q7PPPZop { 37PPP#|

#}1j`ΐ ῎st ῐ῎ῌ῍῎ῑ ῍῏ῐ~῏ Z[XYZ1^῎῍῏῏῍ €

‚GH[`#ῌ ƒ„…†=‡G-.89:;< n῍ Y 73=ˆ^‰ῌ f] #ῌ Y€ ῒΐ Š‹Œῌ q,

Ž€‘€[H’“=”X῍

ῌ

Z‘

῎῍῏ •(ῌ –—ῌ ˜r ’“

ῌOECDPPPZ ῒ™š›•(q,œ ῎ž ῒ•(ΐ Z[X῏ΐ

•(ῌ OECDPPPq6Ÿ  ngXῌ ¡ῐŸZ¡ῑ

¢£¤¥¦ƒ„§‘Z ῒ)*+ΐ ῎¨©ª«῏ ,,-

῍῎ ῌ

῍῍ ῍ ῌ !"#$%&'()*+,- ./0ῌ 1234+5./(῍

ῐῌῑ῍῍6708῍

ῐ 9:2ῌ + -;< ῎=> ῐ

;<ῑ /?῍῏ +@($ABῌ +C(D(῍

ῑ῍῍ ῎5῏῏

;<ῌ 6E,FGH8!"+IJῌ KL3MNOPQRNOSTUC VWX08ῌ Y;<ῌ Z[!UCVZ9:\Z[!UCVZ9:\

] UCVZ^] ῍,῎ῌῌ_`

] UCVZ^] ῍,῎ῌῌ_` ῎ab0,-

ῌ ῍,῎ῌῌ_`=c0ab0,-de

/῍ => ῐ;<eῑ /?῍῏ + f./H0Jg/Chijklmno+p$ g ,,.

ῌ῎

῍

῍ ῎ ! "#῏

$ῒ%῍$῍&ῌ '(ῒ)*#+ῌ '(῔,-./0%1 2ῌ '(ῒ3456789:;<;;:2 ῌ =3456῍,῎ῌῌ>? ῎56@$ΐ%ῌ $῍ῌ%῏ 2:῍

A0B῏ῌ CῒῑD-EF:῍ =ῌ CῒῑDG HIJ;ῌ KL'MNOP*B2GQF:R

῎Sῐ῏῍ P*BTGQBUῌ VWCX)*YZῌ[ῑDGH\] ῎^

_῍῍`῍῎a῏bcde*fΐ$῍ῌῑg῏ $῏% ῎P*BGH῏ hiῌ 34jkῑ2GQ+7:῍

OECDPPP'ῐῌ lmno῍pB῏)qrs2ῌ MtT-Eῌ uv;wxlmy῏B῏zM

;{2ῌ |*῍pT}wF~€€‚ƒ„…†‡~

ῌ ˆ2ῌ 34‰6ῌlmŠ‹7B῏-E7 '];:῍ ῌ 56@Œ20Ž0R῍ 56

@ῌ ')‘’56B῏ῌ “iῌ )’”B῏CῒῑDT- E2:Rῌ OECDPPP•–”:—;:Ž0῍

ῌOECDPPP ῐ^_˜™š`ša™Vb‘2›œNž^

῎Ÿ A0'(ῒC¡)hi¢£F¢¤¥¦§hl m¨©Tª«¬­®@ ῎¯ ῐ­@ῑ :0῏ῑ

­@°;U”ῌ ')hi ±'(ῒC¡R¢£F

¢¤¥¦§hlm¨© ῎¢¤¥¦§hi¨©F²³¦«ῐῌ

¢¤¥¦§hlm¨©´@µ¶ ῐ¨©#·¸']ῑ ῎¹º»¼῏ ,,/

ῌ῍

῎

῏ ῌ ῌ ῌ !"#$%&'()*+,-./012.῍ 3'45ῐ῏67ῌ 890:;<=>?.-ῌ 7@ABCD)*+0EF80'(<

#$./0G+*.῍ 5ῐ῏6H+#IJEF80'(+ῌ 5ῐῐ61ῌ K0CDLM7ῌ NO45῏6PQ !0 LM0RST?.G+ῌ !0U;CDLM0VWXG*YZ῍

"H+ῌ 3'47OECD0PPP0[12. ῐ\]^_`<a b?.CD<cd?.KG71&.ῑ G*ZKGG7ef;G7gYB*

12hZ῍

ῌOECD0PPPG ῐijNOklmn4 ῎oR ῐmn4ῑ G*

Z῏ῑ

mn40n>7ῌ 5῍pqJ5῕pGrsGqJ>H+*.῍ t0u1ῌ ijNOklmn ῎oR ῐmnῑ G*Z῏ 0 vwx?.y, 75ῑp2.῍ 3z{G0|17ῌ 5ῑp05῎}G5῏})*

+12ῌ t)*+~*῍ 5῎}7ῌ !"mn0 v€0-0LM‚ƒ„)*+0y,12.῍ LM‚G7ῌ …"0 !῍῎†"ῌ mn0 v‡ˆ0-ƒ„?.‰,Š0KG12.῍

5῏}7ῌ S‹Œ"ŒŽfῌ NO45ΐ65῍0y,?

.NO'(Š ῎῍,῎ῌῌ‘’῏ <“Y.ij"ŽIG&ῌ mn"ῌ ij0NO<”•q)–—BST<˜.-ῌ PQ !™š‚›

„<œZKG<,-+*.῍ K0<˜0"˜ῑ12.῍ J 5῏}7ῌ žŸ0š‚›„?.y, ῎mn45ῐ῍6qJ5ῐῐ6῏ 12 .5῍  ῎˜ῑ0῍¡P῏ Gῌ F¢qJ3£Bkl<@AG?.3£

¤¥¦§¨š‚›„ ῎mn45ῐῑ6qJ5ῑ῎6῏ ?.5῎ ῌ 5῏ ῌ5ῐ  ῎˜ῑ0῎¡P῏ G1n>+*.῍ 5῏}5῍  )*+7ῌ žŸ0š‚›„©Yῌ 5῔pªs1ῌ !qJ0LM

‚G7£ῌ F¢0a«¬*+mn™0š‚›„)*+0y, ῎5ῒ῔

,,0

ῌ῍

῎

῏ ῍ ῌ ῐ῍ ^῎ῌ῏῏῍ !ῌ "#$%&ῌ ' ( )*+,-./0-1- ῎*+2345 678῏῍ 9/:2;<=/῍

>῎ῒ ῎*+,῏

"#$%&ῌ '(%?8@ ῌ '( AB CD)!ῌ '(Eῌ *+,-./0-1-

῍

>῎ΐ ῎*+F῏

G>ῌ*+Fῌ H"#$%&Iῌ JK*+

?8LF*+MNOPF B῍

῍. JK*+?8LFῌ :QRASTB!UA - VW<!XYZ[<!1/-./0- 1-῍

\ H"#$%&]^_`a1ῌ bcd<ef9 g"#hijkl%mn-io^pqῌ r st%uD&v*+wxBy9/- z ῍

z/ῌ {q"|%}~^῎ῌῐ῏ῌ -y€ῌ "|%}‚

ƒ&„…ƒ†‡ˆ‰€Š‹!Œ῍ OECD

PPP ῐŽCD‘"’“ῌ ”•&–—˜”•%G™-

ŽCD^šz [ῌ ”•&–—˜”•›œOŽCD

*+Bz žŸ-῍ῑ ῐ‘B IŽCD

ῐ¡¢CDῑ ῎¡£CD῏ z ῍ῑ ῐ¤¥¦§‘ῑ "’X

¨I'(;*+^῎ῌῑ῏©ª῍ st*+ῌ H"#$%

&–ῌ {q%}–|«¬…ƒ†‡ ^š­/!

'(„,BCD“ῌ %GŒ [ῌ OECDPPP

"’Jῌ %}¡£B!CD ®-z €1ῌ

¯°±²³2—˜”•l;78 ῐ”•&*+"´ῑ ῎µ¶·¸῏ ,,1

ῌ῍

῎

OECDPPP ῍

ῌ ῌ !"#$% ῎&'῍῍(

῍῎)῏*+,-./0῍ῌῑ1῏ 23"# ῎0῏4῏ 567ῌ ῐ89 :;<=>?@ABῑ ῌ CD8E23 ῎Fῐ῏ G

"HIJKLM ^῎῍ΐ῏῍ NIOῌ PQῌ R89:S :!TUVM:WXS ῍ VL5ῌ ABY0῔ Z[%ῌ \]56 ABG^_`aJK ῎0ῒ῔4῏῍

0ῒ῔4$#ῌ ῐbcd$e89:;<fghi jῌ ABklmnopqr5rst NK5uva 6 ,,2

ῌ῎

῍

ῌ !"#$%&ῌ ' (&)*+,-. /001ῌ 2 34*52678.$%39:;<=0> ;?@

A1ῌ BC DEF:)Gῌ HIJ&ῌ K LM N,/0<COῑ 0&G)῍ PQ1 ῐ(&R.STU V3ῑ WXYῌ ,ZG21HI[MN,/0<

\]0)^/0_῍ &<`Gῌ S_ῌ ab<$c)ῌ d ef`G<Ygh ῎Q'.hi῏ , 0)^OECDPPP0'j@XC')kl^῍

῎῍῏ mnP)Gop

/^ῌ OECDPPP0qῌ rstῌ uvtῌ HIt

;w;mnxy῍ z{mnqῌ rstῌ uvtῌ HIt)9

;_ῌ V|}~J,hY€[f,t‚

C'Rῌ WXƒs„,t‚0)^/0<…†C=l^῍

//Cῌ ‡ˆ?<ῌ ‰Š‹ŒŽ=?@ῌ [/;hY<f;0‘^qP)G’῎C“&)῍

’῎'ῌ ”• ῎P῏ ῌ –•— ῎X῏ 0&’C=

῍ &Gῌ /ˆ?'ŒXˆ?Cῌ ˜ <de™š‹R›œ&

)ῌ PQ1˜ dež<Ÿ ?@¡&G)῍ /¢

˜ £¤ ῎D῏ '¥¦^῎ῌῐ῏῍ ’῏§¨XA©Y

῎SMC῏ 0'ῌ |ª† ῎T῏ «B&Y0,῍ /0 Oῌ †¬ῌ HIt^ῌ $c`ῌ g­

®BS¯‘^°±Oῌ

#Y[B²,/0<COC=;¬ῌ hY'ῌ QQ[f;/0῍ &<`Gῌ 'ῌ Q`R³9ῌ ,ZG<,/0

´µž¶·¸¹ab t‚0 ῐab¯ῑ ῎oº»¼῏ ,,3

ῌ῍

῎

῏ ῍

ῌ

῎ῌ῏ ῌ ῌ !"

ῌ ῐῑ

#ῌ $%&'()*$+,-#./01234 ,- 5 6789:;< ῌ =->?:@8ABC ῍ @8#ῌ D8EF:;<BC ῌ ῐ ῑ GH28 I ῍ Jῌ #ῌ K῍L3CB

$+MNOPQR:ῌ K῎L $+MSQR:Tῌ QRUV:;<BC ῎῍WX῏῍

K῍L $%&'(Yῌ$%&'(Yῌ Z[$%&'()*$+,-:Z[$%&'()*$+,-:

\]0^#ῌ Z[$%&'(_ $+M`

\]0^#ῌ Z[$%&'(_ $+M`

,-*

ῌ῍

῍

῍

῍ ῌ

!"#$%&'()*+,ῌ -./)0῍ ῎12 34῏

5῏6 7689:0%ῌ ;6<=#/

>,?@ABC4DE4ῌ '0῍

5῎6FGῌ HE<=*( ῒIJKΐ ῎LM ῐῌΐῑ῎ῑ ῌῌN῏ (O%ῌ ῒPQ4RS?Tΐ UV#W+(+XY) ,῍ ;Zῌ [῏6:0%ῌ \]#O%ῌ ^_`

+0W ῒPQ4RS?Tΐ (a9 )*+0b῍

Fῌ cdῌ [5ῑ6ῌ5ῌe#Wῌ $0%

fghijῌ kG[5ῌῐ6)ῌ lfg+%ῌ c=mn oW-+<=kp%0῍

5ῌῐ6 qrῌ ?@A&'89:0%ῌ ?@ABC4 ῎E l?@Ast?@ABC4uv῍῏ 5w6<=#

/ >,hfgh-bῌ F$ῌ -[xy z{ |}*+~ +,ῌ ?

@ABC4ῌ ?@ABC4 |}

mnoW(+῍

[5ῌῐ6ῌ ῒB€ ‚?T)ῌ PQƒ&„:j…†

‡ ˆ‰Šῌ :#‹Œ&'89ŒŽῌ  ˆ‰Šῌ PQ4RS῍ΐ +0W ῒPQ4RS?Tΐ  {?‘a9 )*+0b0)*’W^῎ῌΐ῏῍ -pῌ )“”

ῐῌΐῑ῎ῑ ῎῍ῒῌ῍ΐN῏ •– ῒƒ&„:j…†‡ˆ‰Šῌ —

˜™š›fgῌ … œžŸ œῌ … œ#¡;¢‘+0O

#Wn £¤)oqrmn-+ῌ - ῎PPP῏ ?T¥

῍ ῎¦§¨© ªŠ4῏ΐ -+’W῍ ῌ [y «ῌ

¬­®¯°#±²PQt[˜³+ ῒPQ4RS?Tΐ ῎´µ¶·῏ ,-+

ῌ῍

῎

῏ῌῐ ῒ ΐ !"#$%&^ῐ῎ῌῑ῍

''"()*"ῌ +,-.Q&A ῐ/0123ῑ 45.

6'῍

ῌ῏῎῍

Qῑ 789+,:;<+,=> ῐ?@ABCD,ῑ EF GHIJ"KLMN#&O PQῌ R#"S&῎

Aῑ TJ78UV TJWXY<+,SZ[

"ῌ KL\]^N'_`*ab῍ &ῌ cdῌ TJWX<9+,=><e!.*ῌ TJ789G HfJ"Y<+,"g#h7i9UV PQῌ jkjk lm`BCnaHN opqr"ῌ j9TJ78 lm`BCnaHN opqr"ῌ j9TJ78 s.ῌ tuv=>ῌ wx=>ῌ yzv=>h{' s.ῌ tuv=>ῌ wx=>ῌ yzv=>h{' 9)!HN*S῍

9)!HN*S῍ ῐ|} ~ῑ

€῏

/13HP`

ῌ‚= ῒΐ

‚=ƒ#„…ῌ †7‡`ˆ‰TJ†Š&H‹€^N

‹ŒŽ‘ ῐ‹ŒŽ`^N ’“Ž”ῌ

‹ŒŽ`^N •–hῑ sῌ jῌ —˜™š›ῌ œ

TJ78h9žŸ g=>-.¡¢£"_῍ '„…¤¥

S ¢ῌ TJ78+,¦§¨¦§¦/

9ῌ ‚=ῐῐ῍©ª῎©!῍

ῐῐ 7‡«¬‹ŒŽ‘s”S ¢'­

®¯gž°HN=>ῌ TJWX+,œS­TJWX+,œS­

῏῍©±¡`œTJ789+,S¢

῏῍©±¡`œTJ789+,S¢

,-,

ῌ῍ ῌ

ῌ

ῌ

῍

῍ ῎ ῏

῎ !ῌ "#$%&'()*+,-

!,./012!ῌ 34567898:;<=><?

<*῍

5ῌ @ABῌ C.DEFῌ G$DH῏ῐIB ῌ J$%ῌ 2'(KL<67*2;ῌ @M$%NO 8P QRS*῍

῎J$%῏

H῏ῐI J!ῌ HTIUMVWX<YZ[\ῌ ]A^_`ab /cd<ePDfghe$%NiP/Bῌ 5)ῌ

$%'(67/9dKLO

$%'(67/9dKLO j98ῌ k&<$%Ni ῍

j98ῌ k&<$%Ni ῍ ῎ ῏ 4!dG$DH῏ῐI91ῌ G$D ῐlmnῑ Nop qrsXB0!*t<*B0u8῍ 2vῌ G$DH῏῏I\

98ῌ Dqw! ῐlmnῑ NxaS982

*tB!<*vu85῍

ῌyoD ῐlmnῑ

yoD!ῌ C.DHῑIH῍#UMC.$%z ῎῍,῎ῌῌ{K῏ N

|t/}~2ῌ €‚ƒNO8PBῌ C.N„35)…†<N‡PNˆ<‰X*῍

?yoDB!ῌ yo6Š‹‡῏BŒ2

dῌ Ž6Š‹ῌ G‘gheG€Š’/0῍ G

€Š’!ῌ yoDH῏ῐI“*ῌ J”<•€Š’/k&<

_EB Bῌ –—˜™8G

‘ ῎῎ῌ῍῎šῐ›ῒœM῏ /P02῍

žŸ ¡¢9£¤lmD¥¦ ῐlmnῑ ῎§¨©ª῏ ,--

῍῎ ῌ

ῌ ΐ ῔ ῌ ῑ῍῔῔ΐῒ ῏῎ῌῒ ῐ῎῎ῒῐ ῍ ῑ῍῔῔ΐῒ ῌ !"#$##$

#%&'()* ΐ ῔ ῌ +,-./0῍

῍ ῑ῍῔῔ΐῒ 12340#$##$#%&'()* ΐ

῔

56789:;ῌ <=>?&'()*@ῌ '()* ΐABC DEFGHIJK LMῌ AN&HIOPQR0ῌ BS HI&T-UVWXY<=A?Z=&0[\]OB R0ῌ CSHI&T-^_YZ=R0῔ &- ΐ`

a bcdR0efg῔ &ῌ hefg&ijgῌ ῍῔ῒ῎kΐlm nK ῍

ῌ

ΐABC`a FGHIHIoMpjqrs 3t-῍ uῌ ttvwxK 1ryz{|}~~=€

}FGOB3TBxK0‚ƒ0῍ '()*

oM῏ῑ.῍῏ῌ„… †‡ˆ=FG7‰Š`a FGHIOB‹

ŒŠ ῏῍῔ῒ῔k῍῍l῏ῌŽῐ ῎ ΐC‘῔ ƒ0&R0’4ƒ0῍ ῎t ,-“”•4ῌ †‡–—˜™ ῏5῎+ῐ `a FGHI

‚'()*oMš›œ ῌ ]KT῏῔.῏῔ῌƒ0῍῔

ῌ

ΐˆ=€}HIOHI5ῐž5῍ ΐ]N&0&Ÿ…

K0 ¡¢£ ῔ &R0¤jῌ ΐC‘ῌ¥¦ ῔ ƒKῌ ΐ§

¨©HI῔ ƒKῌ ª«&H¬œ^QR0­®

0῍῔ ῏ ῑ῍῔῔ΐῒῐ

ῌ

ΐ'()*,0 ª«&¯O¬°±0&ῌ ῍#$##

$#%²³<=´µῌ ῎`aDE,῏¶·¸FG-¹ῌ ῎`aDE ,-.

ῌ῎

῍

ῌ ῌ

῍ ῌ ῍ !"# $

ῌ ῌ%&'()*+$,-./01ῌ%&'()*+$,-./01 /23ῌ 4%&567897:;:;<=

/23ῌ 4%&567897:;:;<=

>?@ABῌ @/0CDEῌ FGHIJKLC

>?@ABῌ @/0CDEῌ FGHIJKLC

@M18NOP@FCIQ@R

@M18NOP@FCIQ@R῎῍ ῐST U<ῑ῕ ῐVW ῒ῍ῒῒῑΐῑ

῍VW ῒ῍ῒῒῑΐ XEC)*;Y9Z[\ῌ )*]

^_:;` ῔56<ab῕

cdῌ efghi1Hj)*561HklC!/ῌ )*;

Y9Z[\ ῐmS ῔9Z[῕ I῏

῍ῒῒ῎noῑ ῍ῒῐ῏

pῌ qr)*;:;` ῐsr t῏

uvwxyz{|

}ῌ)*~€ῑ )*]^_:;`no‚R῍

9Z[ῌ ƒ„…<†‡ˆZ‰Š‹97:;G ῌ :;Œ@ŽEῌ ‚ῌ 97 ῐ‘/1ῑ )@ˆ‚’CJ ῐ“ῐ”ῑ῍ 9Z[J1ῌ )*

;Y97•)–—/0R῍ •)˜™13š–›

[\C ῐœšZ[\“῎ῌ”ῑ῍

ῌ )*;:;` ῐsr t῏

uvwxyz{|}ῌ)*

~€ῑ )*]^_:;`noῌ )*

]^_:;`n‚)*;:;` ῐmS ῔:;`῕ Iῑ 1 R῍ cῌ 9Z[QlCž/ῌ :;`:ῌ ῔)*;)*;

C97RŸ[\1~)  ῌ ¡¢ῌ 9 C97RŸ[\1~)  ῌ ¡¢ῌ 9 7 ) £ῌ ¤ ¥

7 ) £ῌ ¤ ¥ E ¦ M  R῍ ῐS T U<ῑ῕ ῐV W ῒ῍ῒῒῑΐῑ

)*Gῌ R§ lCῌ ῔¨!©k@Kª¨!©k@Kª

"«¬!­®vK1Eª1¯ῌ °#±²$³

"«¬!­®vK1Eª1¯ῌ °#±²$³

%´µ¶C·¸56¹C–— ῔56<ab῕ ῐº»¼ῑ ,-/

ῌ῍

῎

῍

῍῕ ῐ ῒ῍ῒῒῑΐῑ ῌ ῔

῔ !῕ "# ῐ῍ῒῑῌ$῏%ῑ &ῌ ῏ '()*῎ῐ+*῍, ῔-.'/01234 56῕ 478 9:;<0=>4ῌ ῔?@ABCDE.ABF GH ῕ I7&ῌ ;JH 0KLGMNOP4ῌ ῔QRSTUV WX'(YZFH KL0[\G]῕ WX^KL4ῌ

E ῔F0_84&`abcd Ie῕ Oῌ

fgJKLhijGMNk43῍ Gelmῌ nOnO ῔AB.KL῔AB.KL 9o῕ 3pῌ ῔?@ABῌ E.AB῕ &ῌ KLq438rOῌ ῔Q 9o῕ 3pῌ ῔?@ABῌ E.AB῕ &ῌ KLq438rOῌ ῔Q RSTUV῕ WX^KL4ῌ EOst.KL9o0uvῌ RSTUV῕ WX^KL4ῌ EOst.KL9o0uvῌ fgJKL0w<xy478z04p3OP῍

fgJKL0w<xy478z04p3OP῍ ῐ{| } .ῑ῕ ῐ ῒ῍ῒῒῑΐῑ 4~7῍

ῌ ῒ῍ῒῒῑΐ y€'/d'T‚ƒ„ῌ €'…

'†‡ˆ/g4 ῔AB.KL9o῕ ‰Š

῔‹Œ'('/.Ž€0>ῌ - tO‘ l3'

F/0_8478&ῌ n’ῌ ῔AB.KL9o῕n’ῌ ῔AB.KL9o῕ We8 We8ῌ

῏Œ“”€ῌ €'/d'Œ“”€ῌ Œ•”‚–—ῌ

˜™Qš[\d&ῌ €'/ G›œe€4e6ῌ ῔žv 3€῕ 4Ÿ 7῍ vX&ῌ €  0¡¢7 OECDPPP῏ £¤G῍ ῐ{| } .ῑ῕ ῐ ῒ῍ῒῒῑΐῑ 4ῌ ῔¥

€¦§AB G ῔AB.KL9o῕ ¨ 478WX©4ῌ

¦§ªv3¥€0«6¬N­®¯0_8­®ABTO&ῌ ῔AB.῔AB.

KL9o῕ &° W±²ªv7e7῍

KL9o῕ &° W±²ªv7e7῍ ³´ῌ ῔?@AB῕ῌ

῔E.AB῕ d῎e0hpῌ AB.µ74KL Wl6

H ῐ^¶fgJ€ῑ KL_lv7῍ ῐ{| } .ῑ῕

ῐ ῒ῍ῒῒῑΐῑ Oῌ ῔AB.KL9o῕ 3p3AB.·0

\¸G3¹ ῔?@AB῕ º¶ ῔E.AB῕ º&ῌ ]»hˆ14n¼ ,-0

ῌ῎

῍

῍ ῒ ΐ ῌ ῒ ΐ ῌ !"#$%&ῌ ' ῒ ΐ ῌ !"#$%&ῌ ' ()*+,!%-ῌ .&/012$

()*+,!%-ῌ .&/012$

34

34%! 5 %!῍ ῎67 89 ῏ΐ ῎:; ῐ῍ΐΐῒῑ῏

ῌ<=> ?0@A (9

Bῌ <=> ?0@A ῒ ΐ CDE FGHI!῍ <=>"ῌ JK@LMN2OPAQC!?0

@A @R(9 ῎Sῐ῍OPTUVW῏ OPXYU ῌ Z[@LC!ῌ \]TUVW ῎Sῐ῎\]TUVW῏ %!῍

OPTUVWE"ῌ OECDPPP"^_` "ab 5 FGc2῍ "ῌ ῒ ΐ "d%e῍

OPTUVW"ῌ @R(9%&ῌ @f`ghD!(9ij

?0@A !"῍ 21ῌ OPTUVW"

ῒ ΐ "^_` N!῍ kE\]TUV W"d%e῍ .Eῌ BFGl῍

ῌ<=>\]mn ῒ ΐ

\]@Amn "ῌ ghopl cῌ <=qr\]TUV W34 cῌ <=ῌ TUVWls_ῌ .tu Uvwx y-ῌ TUVWD!TUXY4!(9z!2{

\]TUVW|!qrVW }~XYy!34%!s _d"ῌ ijTUVW€Il12?0@A ‚ƒῌ ij

?0@A !ghop„.…@A†‡ˆ‰ij?0@

A |!TUVWC!mn5 %&ῌ Š‹2\]@Amn

"ῌ ŒQŽxyy- ῎<=>῏ῐ‘῏῍ Z[

’@Lῌ ij?0@A "ῌ <= ‚ƒ\]mnŒQŽ“”

•ῌ ῎ῌ῍῍–῏—῎ῑ˜^῎῎῍῏ijŒQŽxy!῍

™š›œ!žŸD!> ¡ ῒ ΐ ῎¢£¤¥῏ ,-1

ῌ῍

῎

ῌ ῌ !"#$%&'ῌ ()*+, -.ῌ */()0+ ῎1῏ῑ2῏῍ 34 ῌ ,#()#5 !"

678ῌ 09: ῎;<῏ =>/?@ABCDE ῎1-

ῒ Eΐ FG῏ 0+ ῎1῏ῒ2῏ ῎H῏#῎῏῍

/I/ῌ ()*/?J"Kῌ()*/?J"Kῌ @ALMNOP@ALMNOP QRSῌ $%#ῌ ῌ TU- 6#VWX QRSῌ $%#ῌ ῌ TU- 6#VWX K'?ῌ Y/? !"-. ῎1Zῐ῍2῏ ,"

K'?ῌ Y/? !"-. ῎1Zῐ῍2῏ ,"

[?'῍

[?'῍ \ῌ ][?I\34BC DE ῎ E῏ ##^:_'?ῌ @ABCDE ῎ E῏ ῌ Y/?`abc'ῌ 0,#`

aJ[?ῌ ()#9:6d+e-(fg,"῍ / I/ῌ ,,ῌ `a_'?ῌ @ABCDE ῎ E῏

Y/?ῌ hi#j klm#n#BCo#pqr#st"p#st"p u#$%bvNO"'7wK'?

u#$%bvNO"'7wK'?ῌ -.x4y6#`a>-.x4y6#`a>

J#

J#/?ῌ z{4ῌ |6`a"[?'"'#-Q ῎1Z ῐ῎2Z῎}῏῍

,#]"1##ῌ ^:~wῌ € ῐ῍ῒῒῑῑ ῒ

‚E`a#Bƒΐ „'?'…†"'‡ˆ/?'ῌ ‰Š‰‰Š

‰‹#Œ9Y+ŽrŽY‘’1ῌ Ž“”Ž•–

—1#˜™š›œ/?'…†"žJ"'῍ /I/ῌ Ÿ 

ῐ῎ῌ῍῍ῑ ῎῏῏¡῏ ῌ ῒ‚E`aBƒ ῎B¢E`aBƒ῏ #£-ΐ ¤

ῌ ῒ¥¦§ῌ ¨hbc©ª«+,][?B¢E`a

„'?K8ῌ B¢E`aBƒ#„¬'­®I\¯°§±²-.]

῍ΐ ±²/?'^῎῎῎῏῍

῎῎῏ ³´_'?#µ¶

,-2

ῌ῎

῍

ῌῌ ῌ

ῒ ΐ ῌ ῌ ῒ

!"#$%&ΐ ῎'(῍῏ῒ)῏ ῌ ῒ*+,+,-ΐ . ῒ/

%ΐ 01ῌ ῒ-234.5678&99:;95῍ΐ <ῌ =

> ῒ ΐ ?@῍ =A:B5;ῌ ῌῌ :C5; ῒ ΐ .DE:C5;FGHIJ@῍ =F G:K?;ῌ LK6:ῌ ῌM.N; ῒ ΐ :O?@PQ&?@<ῌ R$&STUV ῒ ΐ HW5;559.<XY1@5῍ ῒ ΐ <9K6:ῒZ[[PQ.N;\]^$;1@9.:C5;ῌ

_:`῍ ῐ῍῔ΐ῏ῑ ῑ)ῌ ῍῔ΐ῏a: ῒbῑῐῌacdef^$;5%ΐ

PQῌ ῒPPP:C5;?1N@ῌῐgῌN:hJij $

;1@&?;ῌ kdῌ lmno2:@?;pqHrsBR$^

t5.ut5῍ ῎vw x2῏ΐ .yz{|N;5%^῎῎῏῏῍

῍ῌ :B}%~€. ῒ ΐ

9$[FGHIJ@ῌ .:ῌ &6C ῒ ΐ ‚῎_01Aƒ<%῍ R$<ῌ ~€%῍ ƒ ῎„῍…῏ :ῌ †‡T ῒ€ΐ Xˆ‰<%῍ ῌ R ῒ€ΐ :C5;ῌ Š]῎῏a῏‹῍῍Œ:ŽN@‘’“Š”•‘–:

—6˜:Kῌ y™š῏›œ ž^$@Ÿ ¡¢:K%

£¤ <Ž¥;5%9.:¦Jῌ ™š῏›œ ž^$@Ÿ

 ¡¢:K%£¤ n§¨:DN;ῌ ~€HX :_% ῎

„῍…῏ 9.<X©‰^$;5%῍ 9$H6};ῌ „῏…

ῒ~€ΐ :C5; ῒ~ῌ 9$[š῏ª«H¬­N;1@9.:

—6®¯°H?;5%ΐ ῒ±²³H´µ%ΐ .N;5%῍

:&ῌ ¶·:~€:D_%UV<ῌ R9&ῌ 9$[

~ῌ š῏ª«H¬­N;1@9.:—6®¯°H?;5%9 .<Xˆ:¸^$;5%῍ Lῌ R$H6};ῌ €:DN;&ῌ

Ÿ ¡¢:K%£¤ :E%PQ. ῒ ΐ ῎¹º»¼῏ ,-3

ῌ῎

῍

ῑ῍ ῎῍,῎ῌῌ῏

ῌ !"#$%&'()*ῌ +,-./

0123456789:;.<ῌ =>? @ A* ῎BC῎῏῍

DBC;EF@A*.<-ῌ = GHIJ@A :-K<LMN>OPQA*6RSῌ =H-.QAIJT, U!"-ῌ .<6 !"#$VWXῌVY>Oῌ >O

Z[*Q ῒ\]#P^_ΐ 4`:abc6de<2῍

fῌ gh ῐ῍ῒῑ῏ῑ ῎῍῍i῏ jk@A*ῌ ῒ\]#P^_ΐ -./

ῒlm-nQAaῌ o7pnf:6qrR2-@Aῌ +W

s2Rtu-vwxR῍ +@Aῌ ::;yz6>Oῌ-.Qyz6>Oῌ-.Q Aῌ {#P^T|:ῌ }~H€

Aῌ {#P^T|:ῌ }~H€ ῎‚ ƒ`#῏ΐ ; n/ῌ „…U!†;‡ ῒyz6>Oΐ rˆ-:U!†‰

Š€;n6Rῌ DBCa‹-ῌ +>Oῌ =- n2 !"#-n2῍Œ-6QA@f*ῌ ῒ\]#P^

_ΐ ‡fῌ ῍Œ-6QA@f<bcn῍ :.<6Ž2R 2ῌ „…U!†` ῒ\]#P^_ΐ ;‘r@.<

:-’@Aῌ ῒ !"#-WP^“”•–—a˜™ΐ

;n/ῌ ῒ Ušaῌ G›=H@AIJ@A‡;n:

2Rῌ +œῌžŸ ¡;nQ2¢<2G›£¤¥¦6T, 6§,S6R6*῍ +,6*ff;ῌ !"#¨©ª§-a +«¬>O­v,*<aῌ ®¯°±²³´<µ“;n*

.<῍ΐ ῎¶· ῐ῎ῌ῍῍ῑ ῐ῍i῏ *Q¸¹‡n῍

6ºῌ h»-º§:,f;¥¦f”¼῍;n῍

,.*

ῌ῎

῍

OEDCPPP !" #$%&' ( ) !" * +,-./ !0123 45*#67489: ;<=OECDPPP !" 67>?>?@A*BCDEF GHI ;< JKL*MNO'P:Q^῍῏

9 !4RST ()3U'VWVXYCZ [*V=\I=V !" ]C M !

^4_` aUbcV$aUde# fS%ghQ iVT M\4jk*W'Ql]mnTV# V o]:BTD *#* p ῌῑῐ῎ ῌῌq Trs*:fF M\>Ttuvwx+y 'zT j{D

|}~tumnu€$0$#TVW >:‚WƒTM ῌῌ

„U…u†

OECD^PPP !"

‡ˆ‰Š‹Œ‹ŠŽ *

:‘’“”•‡–—“˜™F

„U ašf›œ\

:›žŸ ¡f¢£v +¤¥¦

OECD^PPP

!"

„U…u(§

¨©(§

OECD^PPP !"

¥^e§ª

OECD^PPP !"

œš «¬ˆ

›žŸ ¡f¢£­ !" ®¯°± ,.+

ῌ῍

῍

ῌ ΐ ῌ

ῌ !῍ "#$

%&ῌ ' ()ῌ ῒ*+,-./ΐ 0 .123456'789! :῍ ῌ OECD PPP;&<=>ῌ ? '@A B(C> &ῌ D EFGHI;CJKL;Mῌ ? NOPJ ,QRSC;ῌ .T,5UBV;;:

῍ OECDPPPMῌ @? 'A B8C./;ῌ WJ KLXY5KL;C%ῌ ? 'RSJZ'J ,M[\8C"&;!C῍ ]^_ῌ JKL` &ab'cd

>eeῌ 2PfC5g'h8ijkjlmno_p C"Cῌ HIqr;Mῌ "ijkjlmnMst;!

῍ %ῌ " ;7 ".123uv*+'?

> wx>ῌ yzJZQRS8Cῌ J,M {zJZ'-8C"|῍ };~>€‚

o_Mῌ ]&]&uvƒ„P? …Mῌ †‚'8C";? …

'1p( C‡ˆ‰ῌ ] ;Š5‹Œ;M7 ῎? ῏ '78Cijkjlmn'fC"ῌ KLŽ(C"; ῒ*+,-./ΐ o

_Mῌ  ῐ῍ῒῑ῏ῑ ῎῍῍῏ ;‘’“ ῒC”•–—˜b

™š'`"›ῌ œF8C™”•&"žŸ; 1

> ῌ –6' ¡> ῌ '¢ΐ ῌ ῒ‡

5> ῌ ™š£ ῎῏ ¤¥'f ῎¦§¨A ©,῏ΐ C"

C῍ ^ªῌ «¬.12­> ῌ };<='®¯š° ῎ f›ῌ ±²-ZP῏ ;Mῌ .³•,HI?

NOPabQRSῌ ´µ.³•,M ῒ¶·5-%

¸C";!Cΐ ῎¹º ῐ῎ῌ῍῎ ῍῏ῐῑ "C;C῍ "

q»'¬>ῌ gijkjlmno_'p¼Mῌ ,.,

ῌ῍ ῌ

^ῐ῎ῐῑ῍

ῌ OECDPPP!"#ῌ ῔$%

῕ !"#ῌ ῔&'"( )ῌ *+", -./

01 ῌ 23410567.08῍ 2 ῌ --!

9:( ῌ ;*%<=-.#ῌ >*῍῕

ῐ? ῒ῍῔ῒ῏ΐ ῍῍ῑ !"@ῌ ῔..ῌ ῔$%

῕ )ῌ OECDPPPA <BCῌ !D". #:

"5=( E$<B῍ ῏ ῐ1ῑ F GH.I%J!ῌF GH.I%J!ῌ

$%K&LMNO5B P!"῍

$%K&LMNO5B P!"῍ ῏'Q῎

(RS#T@U<Bῌ ῏ ῔VW%῕ )X >*

Y+Z ,[#-XU<B ῐ\]^.D_`/ a%%ῑ῕ ῐb0 ῒ῍῔῔ΐΐ῎῎ῑῌ῎῎ῒῑ -.Lῌ 5B5B1c #"^ῐ῎ῑῑ῍

d)ῌ efghij"ῌ

kL OECDPPP. ῔$%῕ lmno ῔23"

pq῕ rL῍ b0 ῒ῍῔῔ΐΐ st0ῒ῎ῌ῍῎ΐ #u4 L.v@ῌ OECDPPP. ῔$%῕ )ῌ <,w,GH<B22 +#x#0B L῍ yῌ c510OECDPPP.

῔$%῕ 6z{ῌ 7%. |8 9}P!"῍

*d)ῌ ῎ῌ῍῎:῍~῎῍;€<=‚ƒ„!>…†‡L! ῍

;€‚ƒ„!)ῌ ?ˆ0@‰‰AŠ‹@B CDE)Œῌ F?

GŽDEῌHIDE10‘’“R”JK,῍,ῌ d•L

"@ῌMN–—@‰–‰A€˜™jš›‰œŠ‹OžŸDE.

 .-#P/ῌ @‰¡'‰AŠ‹¢Q£RDE10)ῌ €

¡'‰10῔$%῕ kL P/“Š¤JK,῍ <

0ῌ ¥¦§@‰‰AŠ‹¨©ªDE10)ῌ d!lmo.

῔$%῕ kL ῌ « S10¬­®h¯J/-.#!

P,῍°T ±²U³´, ῍ Xµῌd,B¶ῌ)ῌ V·#W¸€$¹. ῔$%῕ ῐ¨º»¼ῑ ,.-

῍῎ ῌ

῍ ῎ῌ῍῎ ῍῏ῐ ῎ῌ῍῍ ῐῐ ! "#$%%%&'()* +%,- ./01 2345ῌ567 89 :;<=567

%> ?7/@! !AB CD*!

῎ PPP ! ῍῕ΐ῎E^OECDFGHIJE KL ῍῕ΐ῏

BM+%N ./0OPQR<= %S !T*UV WI!

῏ ῎ῌ῍῎ ῍῏ῐῌ῍῏ΐ ῐ ῎ῌ῍῎ ῍῏ῐῌ῍῏ΐ

ῑ 234:;,X%B,:;Y( Z23 [9 \]

^_%( Z23N` ! ῒ ῎ῌ῍῎ ῍῏῔

ΐ +IaZ b/cde*fg*,!h6 %B ,h6234b/cde*i7/jH! Jb/c de* ki5 [l

῔ ῎ῌ῍῎ ῍ῐ῎ῌ῍ῐῑ

῕ \]^_e* mῌ ῎ῌῌ῏ ΐ῍ no pW%:;qr

%sRt u*!_(vwWIJw Q7S%

Polluter PayPay Principle JHI^. \]^_ xyz <

B{_(<=|} *!~€(‚*B Q5,ƒ

x „… † *! ‡ ˆ^‰^ \Š‹ Œ#Ž

  ῎ῌῌ῍῍ΐΐ \]^_noeQ7%>

‘! /Jw <=’/\]^_(“”*,!

*!

῍ῌ • Ia–1,—/,!˜ I( OECD%^PPP [ l

῍῍ ™š›῎ῌ῍῍E῔œ῎ΐ žŸ ¡¢£U…%¤¥¦§

e* ¤¥ !/ +I/! ,%- ¨*© ¤¥ ! BMª£«m`¬­®Y/¯-HI!,!- CD*

!

῍῎ Ia– I(• % [l ῍῏ °± ῎ῌῌῐ ῒ῏ OECD%^PPP( ²³^%e= !´%

µ¶"·e= %¸ ./0% % ( ²³^%

e= ‹¹ºe= »¼HIJ%e= ¸(°AJ%

,..

ῌῌ

῍

῍

῎῍ῐ῏ ῑ῎ ῌ ῐῑῌ

!ῌ "#$ %

&' ῎῎ῌ῍῎ῑ(῕῏ )*+,῍ "#$

%&'-./ῌ 01234567869:

;<=*,῍ =>/-.?@ ῐ῎ῌ῍῎ῑ :;<)῍

῎῍ῑ῏ AB ῐ῎ῌ῍῍ῑ ῎῏῍ CDAB ῐ῎ῌ῍῎ῑ ΐ῎ῌΐῒ;<῍

῎῍ῒ῏ ) ῌ E$F,GHIJ KFH%῍LMNO ῐ῍῕῕῔ῑ ῍῍ῌ῍῎ῌ ῒ+DP!QRSJ T:UV,WXΐ YZῒPPPZ*[

\ !: Jΐ ῒ]^"_`D[\_ ΐ ab:c

# ῍)*ῌ dG !+P ef%O῍

῎῍ΐ῏ $% ῐ῎ῌ῍῍ῑ ῐῐῌ ) / ῒ&ῌgHh

῔34Hh:i'jkg:lm !+

ΐ ῍

῎῍῔῏ .( ῐ῎ῌ῍῎ῑ ῍ῐ῎ῌ῍ῐῑ;<῍

῎῍῕῏ no ῐ῍῕ΐ῏ῑ ῎ΐ῏ p) ῒqr"ΐ :s*t u/

c+v/+ ῒwJxyzgR,{gR,{^

- |}.~^-:_€Fῌ O/‚ƒPw^-:/„ ) :lmO%O῍ΐ %'/!…†+Fe f%O῍

῎῎ῌ῏ SJῌ ῍῕ῒ῍+‡ῌ )kˆ0‰Šῌ gR12H‡‹

Œ123=*ῌ ‹ŒŽ4 %‘’612“”,iῌ , 56ῌ•–—˜=*H%,kˆ!+῍)H%™:

–d,7šῌ ῒ,–8 ›9.œ:Zῌ ,—˜:žŸ

= ΐ ῎AB ῐ῎ῌ῍῍ῑ ῎ῐ῏ ,i!|*῍ =>ῌ "ƒῌ "

#,$:¡dῌ S/ῌ ,$¢:£¤ῌ ;Ž῎῏

$¥RS‰Šῌ ‹Œ <¦§::=PFῌ RS¥Jd^-¨‡>ῌ,©

${C,ª†dw«?:¥¬@„­^-¨‡>:/

ῌ)*:A® ¯'O>£B:°F!ῌRS

¥CD:±EO/F²“” ,iy³…/£B:°Fῌ )*>WX_`Zῌ S´µ:G&BH:

῎ ῎£B῏ ῒ῎¶῏῍ IAB ῐ῎ῌ῍῎ῑ ΐΐῌΐ῕;<῍

῎῎῍῏ 0^HP;<῍

J·bK¸H[\qr¥J ῒqr"ΐ ῎¹º»¼῏ ,./

ῌῌ

῍

῏῎῎ῐ ῑ῎ῌ῍῍ῒ ῐῐ῍

῏῎῏ῐ ῌ ΐ ῔

ῌ ῌ ῑ῍῕῕῔ῒ p.῎ῌΐῌ

῎ῌ῕ῌ ῐ ῏!ῐ ῍" ΐ#$

%& '()&*+,&-./'()&*+,&-./!῔ ῎"0!123&῍ ΐ ΐῐ ῎"410 567!189&:;2&*+,&῔7<81ῐ

῍"! ΐ=./!1>?῔ &῍ @+ῌ ΐ:A1 7BCD/EA89&:*+,/῍῔ ΐ

ῒῐFGHI/῎ ῌJ K1

LMN!OPQRST "1*/#UV 2Wῌ XY Z[$\LMLMN!O&]^149&_[`

ab[2P/῍ c+ῌ ῎@7Z/ORῌ ῎ ΐLM (d῔[e%fg"h&1i/῍῔ ῏ ῑ῍῕῕῔ῒ 'jῐ

῏῎ῐῐ (k(E )l*mnoH ῑ῎ῌ῍῍ῒ ῌ (k(pE +q,rst 1u&῍

῏῎ῑῐ vwῌ -4./x ῏yz ΐPPS῔ RῐO&0/*

+,&ῌ ῌ ῎ῌῌ῕1{^@,/|}/(203~*&

PPS€ῌ ῎^.῔ῌ9῍ :OR‚ƒ1„…9&/*4†

ῌ/x„‡14u/ῌ 56ˆ7῎ῌ῍῍1῔‰ῐ6 ΐNTT"Š1‹῔ Œ8῍

῏῎ῒῐ ῌŽ9:()2&‘’“ŠH”ῌ῎ῌ῍῍1ῐ‰῍6ῌ H”Ž9:; •<lῌ –=>—=-^/-˜}

‘’%”^/῍ :ORῌ ™F(?pš[ῌ $(

k(?›/%@O&/(œ˜A2&ῌ?›/%@ž

%”^R:Wῌ Ÿ ‘’OR%”^OPῌ ΐLM (d῔ (2& ΐ?¡¢BC£^῔ D,&¤E¥[¦F@

,&῍LM(d1f§2,ῌ (k(B”DD¨©@

ªῌ j«G῎῍ῐ ORῌ /(|}1iHῌ ˆ41¬9&:/

(œ1­I^ῌ ®¯J%°^1Ks9672±R῍ @+ῌ ™F (?pšῌ G”H ¢B2&R2,ῌ ΐ²³¢

BA῔ ῏´L ῑ῍῕ΐ῏ῒ ῍῍ῐ 1[Pµ-9&¢=2&῍ DcG M+ORῌ G¢B1C£^9&:ND,& ῏ῌ ¶ GO–=·}€ῌ M¸^6LGPO&¹8º῏yz ΐGO

¹8º῔ Rῐ •»@,/¶GOQV–=R¼ῌRI῍ῌ1῍ῌ‰

S@,/GO¹8º–=·š9&TOPῌ ¶GOQ ,.0

ῌῌ

῍

῎῔^.῏ ῎ῐ^.ῐ ῎ῌῌΐ !"

#$

῎ῌ῍῍ %&'()*+,,-./0῍1 23456 789:; ^NO.῍ῐ῏῏ ῏῕ῌῐῐ

< ῎ῌῌῐ ῒ =>?ῌ @A! =>

῏" ῒ῎ῌῒῐ

%B#+,$%CD ῎ῌ῍῍ &E'#FGH I%B#

'J&'()*%B#+(K)*+(LM*,NOP

QR S ῍῕ΐ῏ ^PPP-./0 ῍&T+,U1L2(V"

W῍ X+YZ VOL.῏^NO.῍ ῍῕ΐ῏ ῑῌ῍ῌ

[\ ῎ῌ῍῎ ]3 %B#+,-./0 ^&

_4`ῌ56a ῎ῌῌ῏ ῏b =>cd* ef3 g67h i 6jk! =>lmn8 ῒΐῌ῕ῑ o9p:

;<qr ῍῕ΐ῏ ^PPPs6"=> X+YZ VOL.῏^NO.῍ ῍῕ΐ῏ ῍ῌ ῑ

tuvῌwῌx?@y ῍῕῕῔ =>=>=>nz῍{ ABC,nzD|,}(῍Discussion Paper Series No.῍῕῕῔ῌῌῒ^{, Gradu-} ate School of Economics Hitotsubashi University,῍῕῕῔

r~ @ ῎ῌ῍῍ %B#'J&'+, 3€‚ ῒ῔῏

ƒ ῎ῌῌ῎ῑ

r~ @ ῎ῌ῍῎ %B#'J&'+, E„3€‚

…ῌF†G‡ˆ9‚‰ ῒ῔ῌ῔῍

Š6‹Œ ῎ῌ῍῎ Ž‰Ž‰ef3 ῎" &Hef…IH

‘ ’ ῍῕ΐ῏ ^OECDPPP“@J.K” X+YZ VOL.῏ ^NO.῍

῍῕ΐ῏ ῎ῌῌ῎῕

l• ῎ῌῌΐ L(–—,˜ M()—

™@*GE+Nš ef›9‰œ^No.ῐ῔ ῎ῌῌΐ^.῍῍ ῍῏ῌ῏῎

?ž ῍῕ΐ῏ X+Om^PPP῍Ÿf P@J¡{,}(῍ X+

YZ VOL.῏^NO.῍ ῍῕ΐ῏ ῍῍ῌ῎ῌ

i6 b ῎ῌ῍῍ lQ.¢£'#H¤¥: 789:;

NO.῍ῐ῏῏ῐῑῌῑ῍

¦67 ῍῕῕῔ ῔p qzR§S §S¨%T U©V§S lªef3 ῎ῌΐῌ῎῎ΐ

R.K.«‚‚^{, D.}¬­:^{, I.}®¯;°¥ ±²³´W ῎ῌῌ῍ =>ef3X Yµ¶V·()*=>§S(¸* P §S¨%T ¹º»¼ ,.1

ῌῌ

῍

῎ῌR. Kerry Turner, David Pearce, Ian Bateman῍ῒῒ῏^Env- ironmental Economics : An Elementary Introduction, First Edition῍

῎ῌ῍῍ῑ῎ῐ

῎ῌ῍῍ῑ῏ !"

,.2

ῌῌ

῍