Graduate School of Creative Science and Engineering, Waseda University
Doctor Thesis Screening Results Report
Thesis Theme
Study on Fatalities in 2011 Great East Japan Earthquake & Tsunami and Evacuation Preparedness against Future Earthquakes
2011 ¥Á¸À ÓD79LmÝø EàèC
ÑtD >Làè
Ù ñ (Applicant Name)
Nam Yi YUN
l
(Department of Civil and Environmental Engineering, Research on Structural Mechanics)
July, 2014
) = ' 1A38 1 7A51C51AC8@D1: 5 >33DAA54 1C>66C85 * 139693 3>1BC>6,>8>: D F 85A5 C85
* 139693 ? ;1C5 AD? CDA54 D=4 5A C85 ? ;1C5 25=51C8 C85 =>AC8F 5BC5A= * 139693 ) 351= , 85 51AC8@D1: 59=4 D354 4 5BCAD3C9E5 CBD=1< 931DB54 1 8D75 =D< 25A >6;>BB5B >6 8D< 1= ;9E5B 1=4 BD2B5@D5=C4 9B1BC5AB B1 A5BD;C>6C85 4 5BCAD3C9E5 6>A35B 9=3;D4 9=7CBD=1< 9 7A>D=4 < >C9>= 1=4 B>9;;9@D5613C9>= C85 =D< 25A>6;>BB >68D< 1= ;9E5B A513854 1=4 C85 < 9BB9=7 1B >6 ( >E5< 25A , 89B 4 9B1BC5A31DB54 D=? A5354 5=C54 4 1< 175 C>C85 ? 5>? ;5 1=4 C85 B>395CH >6
$ 1? 1= #CF 9;;C1: 5 1 ;>=7 C9< 5 6>AC85 A53>=BCAD3C9>= >6C85 4 1< 1754 1A51 1=4 A53>E5AH >6C85 ;965
>6C85 ? 5>? ;5 " >F 5E5A 9C=554 B C>69=4 6DCDA5 4 9A53C9>=B C>3A51C5 B165A1=4 < >A5 B53DA5 B>395CH 1719=BC6DCDA5 51AC8@D1: 5B1=4 CBD=1< 9B21B54 >=C85 ;5BB>=B6A>< C89B4 9B1BC5A
, 85 F 8>;5 3>=C5=C>685A4 9BB5AC1C9>= 9B 4 9E9454 9=C>CF >< 19= ? 1ACB C85 5E13D1C9>= 2581E9>A 4 DA9=7 ! A51C 1BC$ 1? 1= 9B1BC5A1=4 C85 4 9B1BC5A? A5? 1A54 =5BB 2581E9>A9= ,>: H>1A51 531DB5 >6C89B 85A4 9BB5AC1C9>=3>=B9BCB>66>DA 81? C5AB
81? C5A 9B 3>=35A=54 F 9C8 C85 >E5AE95F >6 C85 ! A51C 1BC$ 1? 1= 51AC8@D1: 5 1=4 CBD=1< 91=4 C859A 4 1< 175B 31DB54 2H C85 C8A55 6>;4 4 9B1BC5A 1 < 17=9CD4 5 51AC8@D1: 5 51AC8@D1: 59=4 D354 CBD=1< 9 1=4 =D3;51A? ;1=CB 13394 5=CB 9= F 8938 ? A5E9>DB A5B51A385B F 5A5 6DAC85A A5E95F 54 >= 5E13D1C9>= 2581E9>A 61C1;9C95B 1=4 9=6;D5=C91; 613C>AB 1=4 ? A5? 1A54 =5BB 256>A5 ? A54 93C54 4 9B1BC5AB ) = C85 21B9B >6C85 A5E95F B >6C85 5E13D1C9>= 2581E9>A B85 6>3DB54 >=
C85 6>;;>F 9=76>DAC>? 93B
F24E66LC492B24D6B:CD:4C :6 286 KC>F 81C5GC5=C4 >4 51C8B81E5 9=4 9E94 D1;31DB5B * A5? 1A54 =5BB256>A5 4 9B1BC5ABgF 81C9BC85 A5;1C9>=B89? 25CF 55=;5E5;B>6? A5? 1A54 =5BB
1=4 BDAE9E1;A1C5B
E13D1C9>= C9< 5 g8>F 4 >BDAE9E>AB1=4 C85 4 514 1=4 < 9BB9=74 9665A9=C85 2581E9>A>6 9=4 9E94 D1;B9=A5B? >=B5 C>1 F 1A=9=7>AC85 7A>D=4 B81: 9=7
9665A5=35B9=2581E9>A25CF 55= 7A>D? B>6=>=BDAE9E>AB1=4 B9=7;5 BDAE9E>ABg56653C9E5=5BB
>6CBD=1< 95E13D1C9>=? A9=39? ;5B
81? C5A 9B 4 5E>C54 C> C85 9=E5BC971C9>= >6 C85 381A13C5A9BC93B 25CF 55= BDAE9E>AB 1=4
=>=BDAE9E>AB 2H DB9=7 F 9C=5BB 4 1C1 >6 C85 9=D=4 1C54 1A51B 9= C85 ! A51C 1BC$ 1? 1=
51AC8@D1: 5 1=4 CBD=1< 9 1=4 C85 4 9B3DBB9>= >6 613C>AB F 9C8 A5B? 53CC> 9=4 9E94 D1;5E13D1C9>=
2581E9>AB #C6>;;>F B6A>< C89BC81C 81? C5A 4 5B3A925BC85 4 9665A5=35B25CF 55= C85 BDAE9E>AB1=4 C85 =>=BDAE9E>AB 4 DA9=7 C85 ! A51C 1BC $ 1? 1= 51AC8@D1: 5 1=4 CBD=1< 9 1=4 C85 56653C9E5=5BB >65E13D1C9>= ? A9=39? ;5B 21B54 >= C85 4 5B3A9? C9E5 3>< < 5=CB 12>DCC85 BDAE9E>AB 1=4 C85 4 514 1=4 < 9BB9=7 B 1 A5BD;C B85 945=C96954 B>< 5 >6C85 4 9665A5=35B 25CF 55= C85 5E13D1C9>=
? A9=39?;5B1=4 C85 13CD1;2581E9>ABC1: 5=2H C85 A5B945=CBD=4 5AC85 4 9B1BC5A
#= ? 1AC93D;1A C> ? A>E945 ? A>? 5A 4 9A53C9>=B 6>A 5E13D1C9>= B85 A53>< < 5=4 54 C> C1: 5 C85 6>;;>F 9=7 BC5? B 1 B5;53CB97=96931=C1=4 ? A>? 5A1CCA92DC5B 1< >=7 71C85A54 297 4 1C1 2 4 5E5;>?
CA19=54 4 1C121B5 21B54 >= C85 3;1BB96954 4 1C1 1=4 ? 1CC5A=54 3 < 1C38 9=? DC4 1C1 6>A< 54 F 9C8 B5;53C54 1CCA92DC5BC>C85 CA19=54 1=4 4 ? A>E945 85;? 6D;13C9>= 7D94 5B C>C85 ED;=5A12;5
? 5AB>=B 16C5A < 1C389=7 C85 =>=BDAE9E>AB 3;1BB96931C9>= #= 14 4 9C9>= 3>=B945A9=7 ? 5AB>=1;
1CCA92DC5B BD38 1B 75=4 5A < 1;5 1=4 65< 1;5 175 C85 >;4 389;4 A5= 21295B C85 4 5? 5=4 5=CB 21295B 81=4 931? ? 54 ? 5>? ;5 B93: ? 5>? ;5 ? A57=1=C 1=4 >C85AB < >C85AB ;9E9=7 1;>=5 BCD4 5=CB 4 96693D;CC>A5CDA= 8>< 5 1=4 B>>= =554 B C>1=1;HI5 C85 381A13C5A9BC93B 1=4 4 9665A5=35B 1< >=7 C85 31C57>A9I54 7A>D? B
#C9B B8>F = 9= 81? C5A C81C< >=9C>A9=7 1=4 51A;H F 1A=9=7B 1A5 5BB5=C91;C>? A>C53C;9E5B 1=4
? A>? 5AC95B " >F 5E5A 9< ? A>E5< 5=CB >= C85 51A;H F 1A=9=7 BHBC5< 9B BC9;;=535BB1AH 6>A133DA13H 2531DB5 59C85AF A>=79=6>A< 1C9>= 1A5 1;1A< 54 >A=>5E5=CB16C5AC85 61;B5 F 1A=9=781? ? 5=
DAC85A< >A5 4 D5 C> C85 DCE>2= : 5 6D64D:?> 3E?ILC 72:<EB6C 5 EB:>8 D96 DCE>2= : :D:C
=535BB1AH C> 5=81=35 C85 >2B5AE1C9>= BHBC5< 1=4 C85 1=1;HB9B BHBC5< 1B54 >= C85 1=1;HB9B A5BD;CB 6A>< C85 ! A51C 1BC$ 1? 1= 51AC8@D1: 5 C89B BHBC5< 5BC9< 1C5B 1=4 6>A531BCB ED;=5A12;5 ? 5AB>=B F 85= 1= 51AC8@D1: 5 >33DAB F 1A=B C85< 1=4 ? A>E945B 9=6>A< 1C9>= 6>A BD335BB6D; 5E13D1C9>= B 1 6DAC85A A5B51A38 9C9B 14 E9B12;5 C> BCD4 H C85 1==>D=35< 5=C
< 5BB175B 1=4 9=6>A< 1C9>= 6>A C85 F 1A=9=7 9=3;D4 9=7 1 51BHC>D=4 5ABC1=4 3>=C5=C 1=4 5G? A5BB9>= 2 5G? A5BB9>= ;514 9=7 C>1= 13C9>= 3 3>=B945A9=7 C85 4 5;9E5A9=7 C9< 5 C>A5359E5A 1=4 4 945=C96H C85 D? 4 1C54 9=6>A< 1C9>=
81? C5A 4 51;B F 9C8 C85 56653CB >6E1A9>DB 9=6;D5=C91;613C>AB BD38 1B CBD=1< 9A5;1C54 613C>AB CBD=1< 99=D=4 1C9>= 85978C1=4 9CB 1AA9E1; C9< 5 1=4 5E13D1C9>= A5;1C54 613C>AB 5E13D1C9>=
4 9BC1=35 1=4 1754 ? >? D;1C9>= >= C85 61C1;9CH A1C5B F 8938 1A5 4 9B3DBB54 21B54 >= C85 4 1C1 6A><
C85 695;4 9=E5BC971C9>= 9= C85 B5E5A5;H 16653C54 1A51B +85 9=E5BC971C54 1=4 1=1;HI54 613C>AB 9=6;D5=39=7 C85 61C1;9CH A1C5 2H DB9=7 71C85A54 4 1C1 9= C85 9=D=4 1C54 1A51B 1=4 4 5E5;>? 54 1 6>A< D;1 6>A 5BC9< 1C9=7 C85 61C1;9CH A1C5 #= 81? C5A C85 < >4 5;6>A 5BC9< 1C9=7 61C1;9CH A1C5 5GC5=4 54 6A>< C85 ? A5E9>DB A5B51A385B F 1B 4 5E5;>? 54 " >F 5E5A 5BC9< 1C9=7 C85 61C1;9CH A1C5 B8>D;4 3>=B945A>C85A9=6;D5=C91;613C>AB D5 C>;13: >64 1C1 6>AC85 69ABCCBD=1< 9F 1E5 85978C 4 1C1 C85 < >4 5;9= 81? C5A DB54 C85 < 1G9< D< 85978CB 9= C85 B5E5A5;H 16653C54 1A51B =>C1B 1 F 8>;5 16653C54 1A51 ;B> C85 5E13D1C9>= 4 9BC1=35 4 94 =>C< 51BDA5 C85 13CD1;4 9BC1=35 C1: 5= 2H C85 5E13D55BC8A>D78 C85 5E13D1C9>= A>DC5B #C81B1 ;9< 9C1C9>= C>1=1;HI5 C85 3>AA5;1C9>= 25CF 55=
C85 6>DA613C>AB 1=4 C85 61C1;9CH A1C5 ;C8>D78 C85 >33DAA5=35 >61= 51AC8@D1: 5 1=4 CBD=1< 99B
=51A;H 9< ? >BB92;5 C>25 ? A5E5=C54 C85 ;>BB >68D< 1=B 1B 1 A5BD;C>6C85 4 9B1BC5AB 9B 1E>9412;5 #C 6>;;>F B 6A>< C89B C81C6DAC85A A5B51A38 =554 B C> 25 31AA954 >DCC> 4 5E5;>? < >4 5;B 9=3;D4 9=7 14 4 9C9>=1;? >C5=C91;613C>AB C81C3>D;4 16653CC85 61C1;9CH A1C5 F 8938 1A5 =>C4 9B3DBB54 9= C89B BCD4 H BD38 1B C85 69ABCCBD=1< 9F 1E5 613C>AB C8A>D78>DCC85 16653C54 39C95B C85 A>2DBC=5BB >A 85978C>65E13D1C9>= B85;C5AB 31? 139CH >6B85;C5AB 5C3 >< ? 1A54 C>5BC9< 1C9=7 65F 4 1< 175B 2H C85 CBD=1< 94 D5 C> C85 ( >AC85A=,>: H> 1H 51AC8@D1: 5 ,>=1=: 19( 1=: 1951AC8@D1: 5B 3>D;4 31DB5 8D75 61C1;9C95B 2H C85 51AC8@D1: 59=4 D354 CBD=1< 9 , 85A56>A5 C85 ? A>? >B54 < >4 5;1? ? ;95B C>C85 61C1;9CH A1C5 9= B? 539693 1A51B 95 % >389* A5653CDA5 1=4 9C9B ? >BB92;5 C>< 1=175 C85 A9B: B 3>=B945A9=7C85 5E13D1C9>=4 9BC1=35 1=4 C85 3>< < D=9CH 175 4 9BCA92DC9>=
81? C5A 9B 3>=35A=54 F 9C8 C85 9=E5BC971C9>= >6C85 ? A5? 1A54 =5BB >6A5B94 5=CB 9= C85 ,>: H>
1A51B 256>A5 C85 ? A54 93C54 51AC8@D1: 5 #C19< 54 C>5< ? 9A931;;H 5G1< 9=5 1 A5;1C9>=B89? 25CF 55=
C85 5G? 5A95=35 F 9C8 C85 ! A51C 1BC$ 1? 1= 1AC8@D1: 5 BCA>=7 B81: 9=7 B>< 5 ;>BB >6C859A
? >BB5BB9>=B 1=4 ? A54 9B1BC5A? A5? 1A54 =5BB #= 81? C5A B85 5G1< 9=54 4 9B1BC5A? A5? 1A54 =5BB 13C9>=B 1719=BC? A54 93C54 51AC8@D1: 5B 9= C85 ,>: H>1A51 DB9=7 ;9< 9C54 4 1C1 #= >A4 5AC>1=1;HI5 C85 ? A5? 1A54 =5BB 1719=BC4 9B1BC5A 9C9B =535BB1AH C>DB5 BDAE5H54 4 1C1 >=>66;9=5 1=4 C>>2C19=
9=6>A< 1C9>= >= C85 4 9B1BC5A? A5? 1A54 =5BB13C9>=B 256>A5 C85 4 9B1BC5AB>33DA9= 1= 9=4 9E94D1;;5E5;
>< ? 1A9=7 C85 ;5E5; >6 ? A5? 1A54 =5BB 256>A5 1=4 16C5A C85 4 9B1BC5A 1 CA5=4 >6 4 9B1BC5A
? A5? 1A54 =5BB >A 1F 1A5=5BB 1=4 B>< 5 381=75B 9= C85 ? A5? 1A54 =5BB 6>A C85 4 9B1BC5A 16C5A C85 ! A51C 1BC$ 1? 1=51AC8@D1: 5 F 1B4 5B3A9254
9=1;;H 9= 81? C5A BD< < 1AH 1=4 3>=3;DB9>=B1A5 < 14 5 9= F 8938 B>< 5 69=4 9=7B9= 85ABCD4 H 1A5 BD< < 1A9I54
, 85A5 F 1B 1 4 9665A5=35 9= 38>935 1< >=7 C85 CBD=1< 9 5E13D1C9>= ? A9=39? ;5B 25CF 55= C85 BDAE9E>AB1=4 C85 4 514 1=4 < 9BB9=7
, 85 A5BD;CB >6C85 9=6;D5=C91;613C>AB >= C85 61C1;9CH A1C5 1=1;HB9B BD775BC54 C81CC85 CBD=1< 9 85978C1=4 9CB 1AA9E1;C9< 5 5E13D1C9>= 4 9BC1=35 1=4 ? A>? >AC9>= >65;4 5A;H 3>D;4 25 5< ? ;>H54 9=
5BC9< 1C9=7;965 ;>BB9=6DCDA5 CBD=1< 9B
, 85 ? A>? >B1; < >4 5; F 1B 12;5 C> 5G? ;19= C85 61C1;9CH A1C5 1B 259=7 1;< >BC4 >D2;54 F 85=
3>< ? 1A54 F 9C8 >=;H DB9=7CBD=1< 985978C1BC85 9=4 5? 5=4 5=CE1A912;5
, 85 A5BD;CB 9=4 931C54 C81C ? A54 9B1BC5A ? A5? 1A54 =5BB 4 9665A54 6A>< C85 ? 1AC939?1=CB 1=4
=>=? 1AC939?1=CB 9= C85 CA19=9=7 1=4 9C F 1B B8>F = < >A5 9= C85 ? 1AC939? 1=CB E5AB5B C85
=>=? 1AC939?1=CB ;B> 65< 1;5BF 5A5 < >A5 ;9: 5;H C>81E5 C1: 5=< >A5 ? A5? 1A1C9>=BC81=< 1;5B , 85 5G? 5A95=35 >6 4 1< 175 9= C85 4 9B1BC5A 814 1= 9=B97=96931=C56653C>= C85 4 9B1BC5A
? A5? 1A54 =5BB 2581E9>A ) =5 ? >BB92;5 A51B>= 6>A1= 9=B97=96931=CA5BD;C9= 85ABCD4 H F 1B C81CC85 ! A51C 1BC$ 1? 1= 51AC8@D1: 5 814 A5;1C9E5;H < 9=>A51AC8@D1: 5 4 1< 175B F 9C89= C85 ,>: H>
1A51 2>DC >6C85 ? 5>? ;5 4 94 =>C6>;;>F F 81CC85H ;51A=C6A>< C85 CA19=9=7 2531DB5 C85 B9CD1C9>= F 1B =>C4 1=75A>DB 5=>D78 C> ? A13C935 F 81CC85H 814 ;51A=54 9= C85 CA19=9=7 ,85B5 A5BD;CB 3>=C19=54 9=B978CB 6>A 4 9B1BC5A ? A5? 1A54 =5BB 2581E9>A 381=75B C> A54 D35 C85 8D< 1=
4 1< 175B9=6DCDA5 4 9B1BC5AB
DA9=7 C85 ! A51C 1BC$ 1? 1= 1AC8@D1: 5 1=4 ,BD=1< 9 5E13D1C9>= F 1B 1 < 1BB
< >E5< 5=C1=4 D96 CEBF:F?BCL6F24E2D:?> 6H@ 6B:6>46C @ B?F:5 64 E1;D12;5 9=B978CB 9=C>C85 613C>AB >< ? 1A1C9E5 1=1;HB9B 25CF 55= C85 BDAE9E>AB 1=4 =>=BDAE9E>AB ? A>E9454 E1;D12;5 9=B978CB 9=C>
C85 613C>AB C81C 85;? 54 C> D=4 5ABC1=4 1=4 5G1< 9=5 B>< 5 E5AH 9< ? >AC1=C? A13C931; 9BBD5B A571A4 9=7 CBD=1< 91=4 5E13D1C9>= " 5A4 9BB5AC1C9>= 79E5B C85 DB56D;BD775BC9>=B >= 5E13D1C9>=
? A5? 1A54 =5BB1719=BC6DCDA5 51AC8@D1: 5B
4 5C19;54 < >4 5; 6>A ? A54 93C9>= >6 C85 4 51C8 9B 4 5E5;>? 54 21B54 >= C85 1=1;HB9B >6 5138 5E13D1C9>= 2581E9>A 613C>AB >= C85 61C1;9C95B 1=4 9=C57A1C54 BCA1C5795B 1A5 ? A>? >B54 1=4 4 9B3DBB54 6>AC85 A54 D3C9>= >631BD1;C95B9= 6DCDA5 ;1A75B31;5 =1CDA1;4 9B1BC5AB & 1BC2DC=>C;51BC 85AA5B51A38 A5BD;CB < 1H 4 5E>C5 C>C85 3;51A9=B978CB 6>A4 9B1BC5A? A5? 1A54 =5BB 2581E9>A381=75B C>A54 D35 8D< 1=4 1< 175B9=6DCDA5 4 9B1BC5AB
, 85 A565A55B A53>7=9I5 C81C85AC85B9B 4 5E>C5B C85 4 5E5;>? < 5=C>6C85 51AC8@D1: 5 5=79=55A9=7 1=4 C85 4 9B1BC5AA54 D3C9>= 1=4 < 55CB79E5=A5@D9A5< 5=CB>61 4 >3C>A1C5 >3C>A>6 =79=55A9=7
$ D;H
Principal Referee:
Prof. of Waseda Univ. Dr. of Eng. (Waseda University) Teruhiko Yoda Sub Referees
Prof. of Waseda Univ. Dr. of Eng. (Tokyo University) Tomoya Shibayama Prof. of Waseda Univ. Dr. of Eng. (Waseda University) Hirokazu Akagi Emeritus Prof. of Waseda Univ. Dr. of Eng. (Tokyo University) Masanori Hamada
