!
!
! !
!
1.
!
2.
!
3.
!
4.
!
•
!
– [2008]
— 31! 41'59! !
– [2007]
34 103'125 !
•
!
– [2012]
Moral!Agency
•
Moral!Agent
!
!
–!
• Moral!Agent !
• Moral!Pa>ency !
– [2009] !
•
Moral!Agent !
•
Moral!Pa>ency !
!
•
!
•
Gunkel![2012] !
• moral!judge
Moral!Agency
Moral!Agency
•
!
•
• !
–
!
–
!
–
!
!
•
!
– !
• ![2004]! !
!
•
!
– French,!Peter![1979]!“The!Corpora>on!as!a!Moral!
Person”,!American)Philosophical)Quarterly,!Vol.16,! No.3,!pp.207'215.!
– French,!Peter![1995]!Corporate)Ethics,!Harcourt!
1.
French![1979] !
2.
French!
[1995] !
3.
!
•
•
•
!
!
1.
!
2.
!
!
1.
!
2.
!
!
1.
!
!
1.
!
•
Moral!Agency !
– Davidsonian!Agency !
– Cf.!Davidson,!Donald!![1971]!!“Agency”,!reprinted!
!
•
!
1.
!
!
2.
!
–
!
1.
!
!
•
(Corpora>on’s!Inner!
Decision!Structure,!CIDS)
!
1.
!
• •
A Y
X Z
CIDS2.!
!
• •
• •
!
1.
!
2.
!
– !
!
1.
!
2.
!
– !
3.
!
1.
!
•
!
– Donaldson[1982] !
•
The!MIT!Press.
–
1.
!
•
!
– Donaldson[1982] !
– Werhane[1989] !
→
!
2.
!
•
Velasquez[1991]!
–
– (an!originator)!
!
– A
2.
!
•
Velasquez[1991]
!
–
–
a!larger'than'human!person !
2.
!
•
CIDS
!
– Gibson[1995]!CIDS
!
– Danley[1999]!CIDS
1.
French![1979] !
2.
French!
[1995] !
3.
•
!
•
→
!
1.
!
– Gauthier,!David![1986]!Morals)by)Agreement,!
Oxford!University!Press.!
2.
!
•
!
•
!
•
•
!
– !
– !
– !
– !
•
!
– !
– !
– !
•
!
!
– Machan![2002]
cf.!Shapiro![2006]!357 !
– !
–
•
!
•
!
––
1.
Shapiro![2006] !
2.
de!Waal![1996] !
3.
Rowlands!
•
!
– !
!
– Masserman,!Jules!H.,!Stanley!Wechkin,!and!William!
Terris![1964]!“”Altruis>c“!Behavior!in!Rhesus!
Monkeys”,!American)Journal)of)Psychiatry,!Vol.!121.! pp.584'585.!
• 3R
•
!
– !
– !
– Wilkinson!G.!S.![1984]!“Reciprocal!Food!Sharing!in!
•
tropism
!
–
!
–
!
•
Kin!Altruism
!
•
!
– !
– MacKinnon,!John![1974]!“The!Behaviour!and!
Ecology!of!Wild!Orang'utans”,!Animal)Behaviour,! Vol.22,!pp.51,!65–67!
→! Rachels![1990] !
•
!
– !
1.
!
2.
!
−
•
de!Waal,!Frans!![1996]!Good)Natured,!Harvard!
−
•
de!Waal,!Frans!![1996]!Good)Natured,!Harvard!
University!Press.!
−
•
de!Waal,!Frans!![1996]!
Good)Natured
,!Harvard!
University!Press.!
–
−
•
de!
Waal![1996]
!
– !
– !
– !
•
the!law!of!
parsimony !
–Bernstein! [2000]!33 !
•
•
Rowlands,!Mark![2012]!
Can)Animals)Be)Moral?
,!
Oxford!University!Press.!
1. a!moral!subject !
2. a!moral!subject
•
!
•
—
!
•
—
• Roboethics !
• First!Interna>onal!Symposium!of!Roboethics!Sanremo,!
Italy,!30th'31rd!January!2004.!
• ICRA!2009!Workshop!on!Roboethics,!Kobe,!Japan,!17!
May!2009.!
•
28
•
![2009]!2
!
1.
!
2.
!
3.
!
•
(2)!
•
![2009]!2
!
1.
!
2.
!
3.
!
•
(2)!
2.
!
–
!
– Ar>ficial!Moral!Agency,!
• !
•
!
•
!
•
•
1998
!
–
170 !
• Allen,!Varner!!&!Zinster!
[2000] !
• Dennep![1997] !
• Danielson!
!
•
!
!
•
Dennep![1997]!353 !
•
354 !
•
2010
HAL
1.
!
– Gauthier,!David![1986]!Morals)by)Agreement,!
Oxford!University!Press.!
– Danielson,!Peter![1992]!Ar6ficial)Morality:)
Virtuous)Robots)for)Virtual)Games,!Routledge.!
2.
!
•
!
–
![2012] !
– ![2010] !!
•
!
–
•
!
•
!
•
•
!
•
!
– !
– !
– !
– !
• !
1. !
2. !
3. !
• !
1. !
2. !
3. !
• !
1. !
2. !
•
!
– !
•
!
– !
–
•
•
!
•
!
•
•
!
•
!
• Mar>n!CF!,!Bhui!R,!Bossaer!P,!Matsuzawa!T,!Camerer!C [2014]!“Chimpanzee!Choice!Rates!in!Compe>>ve!Games! Match!Equilibrium!Game!Theory!Predic>ons”,!Scien6fic)
•
!
•
!
•
!
•
• !
– Danley,!John![1999]!“Corporate!Moral!Agency”!in!A)Companion))
to)Bubsiness)Ethics,!Blackwell,!pp.243'256.!
– Donaldson,!T![1982]!Corpora6on)and)Morality,!Pren>ce'Hall.!
– Gibson,!Kevin[1995]!“Fic>>ous!Personal!and!Real!
Responsibili>es,”)Journal)of)Business)Ethics,!Vol.14,!No.9,!pp.
761'767.!
– French,!Peter![1979]!“The!Corpora>on!as!a!Moral!Person”,!
American)Philosophical)Quarterly,!Vol.16,!No.3,!pp.207'215.!
– French,!Peter![1995]!Corporate)Ethics,!Harcourt!Brace!College!
Publishers.!
– Smyth,!Thomas![1985]!“Problem!about!Corporate!Moral!
– Velasquez,!Manuel![1991]!“Why!Corpora>on!Are!Not!Morally!
Responsible!for!Anything!They!Do”!in!L.!May!and!S.!Hoffman!
(eds.))Collec6ve)Responsibility,!Rowman!&!Liplefield,!pp.11'131.!
– Weaver,!William![1998]!“Corpora>on!as!Inten>onal!Systems”)
Journal)of)Business)Ethics,!Vol.17,!No.1,!pp.87'97.!
– Werhane,!Patricia![1989]!“Corporate!and!Individual!Moral!
Responsibility:!A!Reply!to!Jan!Garrep”!Journal)of)Business)Ethics,!
Vol.8,!No.10,!pp.821'822.!
– [2008] ―!
―! !
31 41'59 !
– [1975]! !
– ![2002]!
• !
– Bernstein,!I.!S.![2000]!„The!law!of!parsimony!prevails“,!in!L.!D.!Katz!
(Ed.),!Evolu6onary)Origins)of)Morality,!pp.!31–38.!
– Clement![2013]!Animal!and!Moral!Agency:!The!Recent!Debate!and!Its!
Implica>on,!Journal)of)Animal)Ethics,!Vol.3,!No.1,!pp.1'14.!
– de!Waal,!Frans!![1996]!Good)Natured,!Harvard!University!Press.
1998 !
– Machan,!Tibor!R.![2002]!„Why!Human!Beings!May!Use!Animals“,!
Journal)of)Value)Inquiry,!Vol.36,!pp.!9'14.!
– Rowlands,!Mark![2012]!Can)Animals)Be)Moral?,!Oxford!University!
Press.!
– Shapiro,!Paul![2006]!“Moral!Agency!in!Other!Animals”,!Theore6cal)
Medicine)and)Bioethics,!Vol.27,!pp.357'373.!
• !
– Colin!Allen,!Gary!Varner,!and!Jason!Zinser![2000]!“Prolegomena!to!Any!Future!Ar>ficial!Moral!
Agent”,!Journal)of)Experimental)and)Theore6cal)Ar6ficial)Intelligence,!Vol.!12,!pp.251'61.!
– Dennep,!Daniel![1997]!”!When!HAL!Kills,!Who‘s!to!Blame?”!in!D.!Stork!(ed.)!Hal’s)Legacy:)
2001‘s)Computer)as)Dream)and)Reality,!MIT)Press,!Ch.16,!pp.351'365. !C.!
HAL G.!
HAL( ) ―2001 1997
!
– Gunkel,!David!J.![2012]!The)Machine)Ques6on,!The!MIT!Press.!
– ![2013]!
45 389'418 !
–
28 2013 1−79 !
– [2009]! Prospectus 11 1'10 !
– ![1998]! !
– ![2013]! 28
67'79 !
– ![2010]! —
