「考古学」から社会学へ : enonceをめぐる横断的考察利用統計を見る

全文

(1)「考古学」から社会学へ : enonceをめぐる横断的考察著者名(日) 雑誌名巻号ページ発行年 URL. 小林修一東洋大学社会学部紀要 43 1 39-59 2005-12 http://id.nii.ac.jp/1060/00002993/. Creative Commons : 表示 - 非営利 - 改変禁止 http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/3.0/deed.ja.

(2) e ńonce ´

(3) ¼. e ńonce ´

(4) From archaeology to sociology. Syuuichi KOBAYASHI. +3 . ! "#$! "%&'!()

(5) *+,-./012"%.

(6) 345 67895 :;<=>?

(7) @ <AB:C7;- MD E0F0GH,-I ; ;!J5 KLMNO "O5 OP QARS-TUH+AVW7 XY-- 5 :ZJA7[\]

(8) U^_à]Y-bcJde]Y<f-I g h e ńonce ´ ij

(9) klmn./012op1qr0 7>

(10) s

(11) tK7G5 K u

(12) vwtI. A gh7

(13) xUy Aῌ+. E0F0z`ghij. E0F07,<"{|7 g 7 }5 t!~g7|!!SI ;5 :Y zS< <Bt{|GHA5 +-5 7a"h ;<{|GHI :Ygh e ńonce ´ ,<]Y5 ]Y{|7]YI J5 +K!ij

(14) uJtI E0F0 |

(15) gh 7_Ì KghK:J5 |GHA5 : ¡

(16) ¢t7XY<SI ;;!J5 : gh£¤¥]YC!5 }¦!. 5 §!

(17) ,-g¡7¨!+I. :KG5 E0F0 gh

(18) ,<5 ]+¢+!$J©ªY<f-I «gh5 _`5 ¬;5 ¡;5 ;5 }¦A5 y>>?

(19) ;®;5 ¯;5 g

(20) °±xtI ;;g 5 %j²³!´|>?_`YK7!S µ¶·¸¹º,I +-5 » 39.

(21) EFGuNOuH ? I .--+ ( ,**/ JK ).

(22) .

(23) . !"#$% &'"(") .

(24) # *+, -.% /. * -.01. 23 -.45 678 &3"

(25) * 9

(26) : %'";< = > -6-.?26@AB2 3") C-.45D -& E+, "("&FG CD

(27) H:I JI&K , "678L (G

(28) 678

(29) M 9 : 9 NO ;< -P* -QRS6@A7 * ("D TUVWXYVZT-Z) 3[\ -]Q 9 %'"

(30) ^2_. 78 `. [G(") aYbY c de f ^4gh *ij gh3" )

(31) k^ * de le & mn* n* opq' 3 " f -.78fr2, ") s. /tuv! wx"yz#. & !${2, %& >' |} f ~(#opM "678f d e 012, "T.Z)

(32) de ["9)-

(33) /-gh) .

(34) k^ *+*3"]^+* +3") aYbYM &* +3 tuE+3"6-. de f ^G2* le o p * ^ *n3"t'/|} v!/ T/Z. f 6Q` . " ) G -fE+, "-.". 9 78f . Ê+ 45 *[' c ) *

(35) , aYbYM 3" XY/YV C-.RD / `)MG , "

(36) ") 0 -. T-Z R "

(37) f4R,

(38) G -.R1 *"& (") aYbY c _RM2 3& 4, 5"3 ¡

(39) ¢-Mgh3" -(¢&£R "/ ¤¥-{6 ¦ \M-

(40) ¢ C-RD C-.RD (") §¦¨M©3" _ f _2\ G7ª 89 =9 «7 ¬7 2 z%4_, :(") -R §,-M(f k4& 0 ("T0Z) aYbY -

(41) -.R ®¯GM -.R-°; * +G* , ")

(42) <=m!aYbY

(43) ±[") G 9 C-RD 4_3 " *c*c9²³->? 3") 3[\ ¬ ´G «7 7ª /µ z ¶z· . &@?¸3") §³ . &-R A. -. M¹n, º¨-M »,[*·¼B& ·1 CD9 40.

(44) 4³´ # +®¯ µ¶e ńonce ´:O·¸I³¹¶º»J¼.

(45) . !"#$1% &

(46)

(47) '( '.

(48) )*+

(49) +"

(50) ,-.

(51) ! &

(52) /012& .. 3 &) . . 456'78# + 9 :

(53) '" ;< =>? 'DE .FC#. $2%.

(54) & ' .! 4@AB +

(55). C.

(56) .:

(57) 'G'**. <E< '+H+ I:JKL' 4M:. N O6P

(58) Q# $RSTU. V% WXYZA [\]X\[U ^!E _` A, Z, E, R, T a:"0. &. [\]X\[U" bcdeT $f#% A, Z, E, R, T eTWghij k l:Q0

(59) $3%

(60) & & 4WXYZA [\]X\[UE eTWg hij kl#

(61) ' A, Z, E, R, T

(62) f# +&$J A, Z, E, R, T

(63) ,-%m . _

(64) n&op &' qm[\]X\[U

(65) ! ' r()s ' (:*+' (:CtNu,: !

(66) n&

(67) - '+ . 4# /0v-/'2 4wx yz{ Tt(|A# $1%$+*% &. 4A

(68) # /23}

(69) '. 46

(70) # ~: & UZY +

(71) -! A 45 ;&L+'5:6! '+ 7 +8 4# : NA $&}39%

(72) w*2': ' '(|C;

(73) *.

(74) 9 <. 39}

(75) w0

(76) & (|:=' C;H+ $++% ' WUU: 4A

(77) #

(78) ' A/2

(79) '&) 4A

(80) # :>' A

(81) !' + $% DE wx

(82) ' 4:# $+[\]X\[U bcdeT A, Z, E, R, T &% :. ?"0 WUU 4@AB +

(83). C'DE #

(84) . 12& ' ' q 0 @¡¢

(85) ' WUU Aa ]£¤ybU¥ <.B

(86). & WUU 4# ;¦C' - * <:§'). ῌ. 4

(87) #

(88) ' 4A

(89) #rï©Uª:/20<. ῍. . 4A

(90) #

(91) «D ¬®¯Y¥Zj $39}%

(92) w*2 E&®¯"F: °x

(93) 'G C0<. ῎. ῍ 4Hr«D# ]£©Z: ®¯Y¥Zj:± 41. ²®¯"F (|.

(94) >?@.,-.») A .--+ ¼ ( ,**/ & ).

(95)

(96) -

(97) . !

(98) "

(99) #$%& '(. )(*+,-..

(100) /01!23. Aῌ,. 4567(*+ 89. :(;<=>1

(101) 89 2? ,-.@

(102) 4567(A&B8C&D3 E

(103) /F 89

(104) G:(;<=>

(105) AHI.

(106)

(107) JKDH B

(108) L E

(109) M '()(AE

(110) NO

(111) P+QR

(112) B

(113) L3 S89

(114) AH 89

(115) TU

(116) V W4567( C XV P+TY Z[\

(117) XT]^2\_C à1 Wbc de fY ghij2kOS institution

(118) lmno L W+,Y3 :(;<=>pqT 89T]. 2\

(119) !r_

(120) ghi s[&T. ECE"

(121) #tT I. _CTn$L%\&uvL3 H

(122) B E

(123) W 89 wa xy / &z2 T{|VB}H\~ 'EC{['1hiT()LAHY !r_

(124) g hi INghi!1!1LW+-Y3 2} '()(

(125) 89

(126) 2"T1![&AH 89TE

(127) U

(128) ,-V{2\ A&*_CgjS +|hi

(129) DTno

(130) L3 45 67(ACaE

(131) !r_

(132) ghi

(133) #tET,-.#!13 :(;<=> T,2AH - +

(134) .[ 1!

(135) {2 +JK1 _1K L8982 /BAHTlm2+T ECT

(136) !wa IOT

(137) IO

(138) 0 porteur 2+

(139) IOT_CO ¡_C+!1

(140) L3 ¢1@

(141) T! C[&£ [¤5(¥A&2¦_C§34¨5[&* !CT

(142) ¤ 5(¥A&6u_C&7L!1

(143) L W+.Y3 H[& ghi

(144) H} no,-©O§34

(145) H8 :(;<=>

(146) 89

(147) {,.#

(148) §[&ª_C9_C3. Aῌ-. 89\«¬>:

(149). d. H[& '()(*+ 89

(150) ® 4567(*+S89 89

(151) ®&¯&D3 '()(

(152) ECp;T §[& _K°Kg ±]2²EC1

(153) ¨³;L´5µ(¶ W¨·;Y

(154) )¸2*& -B 89B. E

(155) [&

(156) +lm¹ºB

(157) j_C&3 T. EH[{m¹<21 '()(4567(B 89

(158) ,-±= WOX 42.

(159) 9±²³; W0³ké ńonce ´!µ¶·±¸´¹º3»¼.

(160)

(161) . . !"# $% & '( )*+, !- .. /

(162) . 0

(163) !12 3 )4

(164)

(165) .567 8 567 91: ;

(166) <= >?

(167) @ ABCBDEFGHB I

(168) =J+K!L 2 91: ; M 567 #N

(169) 9MOP QRST/

(170)

(171) NUT/V!U W=DX0+Y

(172)

(173) >?2 Z[

(174) RS T/

(175) NUT/V!UW!X0\57]B^H_à >?2 57]B^H1:)4

(176) bc )4NU QdT U

(177) NU T/U

(178) eU

(179)

(180) fa

(181) !Y

(182)

(183) + >?;$+/2 N 57]B^H/ 9gh; >?

(184) >?/ 567 91:;

(185) ijk $Spaltung .l!mn= >?2

(186) c. 9ij; >?/

(187) c 91:; .+opq-r 91:; sk

(188) tO2 u[ 91:; vw.

(189) x+ 9gh; y. W0.

(190) . 9ij; z 9gh;

(191) $+02 567N{ | ij>?P 1:0 57]B^HNU 57]B^H!}xb 57]B^H |! $~"# 1: >? = !tO2 1:

(192) T GjBFNU= >W+ >?2 gh $~ij

(193) 1:

(194) 9

(195) $%~i 7; $e ńonce ´

(196) 9

(197) )4 ~i 77; $e ńonciation

(198) Jo0

(199) +2 BF 56 7N!&'P. Bj7 9)4; n 9)4;

(200) ) 4)+ 9$)4;

(201) !Jo2 BFN{ 9

(202) $% 1:;

(203) 9

(204) )4 1:;

(205) 9(; /K

(206) +2 9)a;

(207) U ?

(208) $%!T#.N+z>?P 9; q1:

(209) q>W+2 9)a;

(210) U

(211) )4!}xb.GjBF ) 1:

(212) + n{+0+2 MOP 9g*> Q

(213) $% 1:Y

(214)

(215) $% 1:!

(216) GjBF +b.1: ,< -/+a+0+2 ?

(217) q !

(218) $% 1:

(219) GjBF +c.1: N+! Q

(220) )4 1 :Y

(221) .`n2 MOP 1::

(222) +

(223) $% ¡b ¢£ ¤£>?

(224) >?;$+12 ¥567 91: NU¦/01:$) ¥;~gh

(225) 1:§.=

(226) 2 9

(227) $% 1:

(228)

(229) )4 1:

(230) NU ¨© 567/ ª0= «

(231) ª

(232) «

(233) ¬0¥k

(234) 1W; $® >?2 9RST/

(235)

(236) NUT/V!U W=DX0+;

(237) 2K g* Q0= Y

(238) Q

(239) Y ¥

(240) ¯°.

(241) +2 43.

(242) NOPD»¼D Q R .--+ ¶ ( ,**/ ST ).

(243) . ! " #$% & ! '. B. () * +

(244). Bῌ+ ,-./0* 1 2# * "34 56789/:;<= ">?3 3 @ AB CD EFGH I J$GK "LK(M' NODCPQRD"3S T*U 2 ,-./0 "VW XY"Z[ !F \:.;] ^_K>' K &` abcd" Ke. f!BI!"@gQhiG ' jk " g. K ,-./0 l #hiGm$ (K W%noa OD K> op[$Gq./r"&st $jSj!*'P"(Z )*u+2v w+$ G ' *'P\:.;], iG@*x u/;.y I!v (Z"z- @ F!' GOD" &st "@.I{h *'P $G ' GZ +m$ |QA "}J &"/~K %na"0 oJ 12 "+ %n3 "w+ ' G|Q"h 4 +! Gi5656.i}J$G 7 !i!' u%na! av G"h *'P* K}J$G 8&|Q" 4 ' 9K &8P, -./0&|QaK :12"+ &" I z) 0t * "; @!F ' #F &z-)iG P a" 4 *'P )C <J $GK>"].ῌR=ῌ$,-./0K ' jk +0 >jF]. (K P a"&st *'} ? $G ' & ? eM%n3 IjF@!M @ A ¡K 0¢£? !i!' G@@¤! a¥¦%n3F u+3v' =§By¨©7yABF ' jk y¨©7yª«o¬ Cn ! ' gF CnPD h EF K$G `6 ®G^H¯ F ' K &")) y¨©7yª«N<®?¯ ° !i!' &I ? °IP a"+ G"%n &! ' 1R=F*JK!?° ±²g>L+$G ' *³<M´ a8P¢76 "}J &µ¶8"/K·" & ! ' i { a7Kµ¶¸y¹; +

(245) )iG &Fµ¶ uP av µ¶2º 44.

(246) KcU- ?<«¬¶e ńonce ´J·¸0c¹¶º»G¼.

(247) . ! "#$ % &' ()* +,- .,*/ ".

(248) 012 34567+ %() 3 &8 9:; <1=>?% " @A+BC &"# DEFG "HBC F &DI< J"% K?L + M $ NOP?+Q R &S T U

(249) VWX YZ %X[\]^7_71àLbc1 &#d?<e ,+ f &gh ijk &"ilmn o$p -.,+/ "

(250) 0QOBC &. %qrE. FBCs3!"#t+ %# [\]^7_7 X$!. &3 &uvkE FGlQw. +M "% % lD&%"1'FGxE " y7z7 KQ %# Qw3q()*+d>?< ,{|- 0}1q(/ krBElD& '. & ../}~. &l ."}~ 23. / xElQw3q( " %D&Q F4rlmn E ?< Q ; KO< %- KO%- 5Q QO 789E. 6. H1lQw3q()E "a K. riQO-.,,/ E%. Bῌ,. 7cU. %# Qw3q(?<x[\]^7_7y7z7o X$!}bc 1E J5:mn3K,{- E% " ,{X $!. & "MM. &2E$!V;<= "% Qw>¡. %BElmn=E.,-/+ ¢M $!. &"# . kr " £?Q# J,{lmn%" K,{- >? <.,./ " %# Qw3q(?¤¥¦Q Kqd§mn- +M ";1@ ¨]^© Q krmnªE " KA. «¬!2$ RQ. #%S "& kBQ krp]^©-.,// + "¥¦Q krB§]^©+M CQ ®¨;+L Q kr DElD&®¤+ ?< Qw3q(D¯°±²7³ Q 1kB EuE J´µ;M "# ";Q F;?<®¤;17 >?<.,0/ 45.

(251) gh?¹ºi»" T .--+ ¼ ( ,**/ &> ).

(252) . !" #$%&$' () " *+, !-. ! ./0 1 )02

(253) " ! 3456

(254) 7" /8

(255) !9/

(256) 2$:; !< 9" . !$' % =%$>?. +!?@ . !. -!AB? !CD!EF/G2$H H 2$IJ %$>?. Bῌ-. KL M$,$?MN"O,1P'. Q

(257) R

(258) S

(259) . ? Q

(260) R

(261) !,

(262) !T+/H2$ +$!"%M$' +' !%c& +. !UVWXY6Z

(263) [*. #WV

(264) \ :]!#^!_$/`+$aba ! #^d( efg'+hi(/jg$k"O,2P. K)!lL *+!m?M$% aWV

(265) \ ! K,-n.oL /&+ $' #?/pq%0r! .?M% s!t+(%+% af' 1 u!2fe2a K3vL -!w45x#? !X y 67z' { !X y 8!9:%Me {%-!;e|x/}~?+$' ke<+= ]+@% G>+?x@$' 1 @A B>!Mf +#^!C b~>D5!#^%/Mf2"O,3P' WV

(266) \ /E S

(267) !$/Q

(268) R

(269). #xp%+$' Q

(270) R

(271) k$. +! z" /2$ ! F7 , G+H #%$,I9J!K!/L !hM! 3456

(272) 7

(273) /NxOe2$ !?M' % Q

(274) R

(275) !. !PQ>#a'. f%+a! !,I!FhRx !,I!S$ 2z/I@$k2C/a2$ +#^d!1!?2"O-*P' f f. 2$ Q

(276) R

(277) ! /Q+$Q. H?!Tm¢!£U/¤¥. !2 O¡N~ . +$V?x+%P k Q

(278) R

(279) <W!_. $!8v/¦§#+' f! .,?@l¨

(280) *#e !,I!IXY©!?2"O-+P . %ª«$¬J !#^d OZ®. [^d? [!\]^% ./8

(281) xP ¯ O,?@,I/ .2$+_?P °±/²`2$Fh . aaf³ <W/ #^d" <´H. +$_(2$!"%M$' Q

(282) R

(283) !$+!aµa S

(284) :]!#^`. !?M$' ;. ¶!kb#^!_$ S

(285) k$ 1F^" 2$cd/e#. !?Me. ?f! 0 1" !#^ <f!·]

(286) !f¸ 0 1" 46.

(287) 1´ e=µ¶´S·e ńonce ´2¸¹7º·»lm¼N.

(288) -, .

(289) !". #$% & ' (. )*+, -./0123456789

(290) :3; < =0 > ?@ 7892# 4A(BC$DE0 FG. H I*!J 1" #KL$. $ . %L$M&

(291) NO 'OC4 . ;DP= Q=Q=4R3 N(CST7UV N)"FG

(292) --. *WHX YZ+[\:]4 b,(Tc8B(4d(. $DE0 3^_`4a. $ (-S. $^ &.-e=/0 = S 2j. H. N. f g1hi

(293) e=2. k# 34l=m ( no 5pq 4 &. 0rS67 s2St8 4aE/&%u9:v2;w4q _`4Axb<B(4 b< =yz(l=m a;{4

(294) T |>}~ =y4D(? $&@$D <=0 (E0b<=y

(295) A4A(0Bῌ CD$D < b, E( ?@ =y

(296) B῍ e= =4. CDb,5FG. qwj b<' !" 9HI>9:v4aE50Tc8=y

(297) B῎ (E0 - : j % & J !" (E0 - :4dq$. fKL^. ww_è=Sb<B(N2. . 2M3#. f4g17. 4A(z OP-SC0=q $ 4. C. <E4wQRST. C῏+ c $ T|>UV$D V- _`(4:(#A0( W<S R. c2 P $ X )<+, e $ ¡¢K£¤>b,D;Y Z¥¦Y4:( b, <=0 qwj§.¨V ©[\]^_4. < qwjb, E^. _ b<ª`>+ax K«b$DE Cz5Sb21q¬cq

(298) -. b3$C^. )<=0 , )< , B4q 3$_`. ®U =d¯4°eCD4e=( ::b,B(4:( g( b,2 ²N(b,(mC. $ c_`2f h(-hi±-j4j#. k³-4A(b $D; sbqQ N( 47.

(299) àb:ef:c¶ d .--+ ¼ ( ,**/ ef ).

(300) .

(301) . !" #$%&. '("" )* +,-/-. / 0123456789 0:;<=$>" ,?+ @AB - ?" C+ 4D1EFG2HIJK /"L MN2BOP2Q2 " ?0:+ RSH T UU;/$" ?V0+ V< "/)* WXBYZ[. K .. % \)WXBYZ] 0! "#$^ ?_`%^+ K . ?& '() W75a* . bK+c d efg h&_`%î) "#. jk) l,m nefoL$d p . "K/ q-rU$ .. st / _`%^ ef/u d 0bK vw5x26 12d"K/ +,-0- )* . WXBYZ /$MvF2Y0:>m yzef:"{3 0|}~m4 d >. 5]6 ] 73894{3 :LK B12 "m`/( ;d& . ". 5 ?_. `%^+ /u< =K $ > &'+c)*m . ". ef?Ovw5x26 ?12+ )d* /B12 ?6V&$>+ c+O87 "m`. /$MvF2Y P2Q2 @ " #ef:)* . d O? AV&$t ,B῎ - % CDOMBW2]E = , ` ?0:+- )"L ,ef: ?F+ G& - O?GK vF7# O? efHRI ,B῍- J#K / K#)* . / ?F+ ," ?0+- " ,B῎ - % "# K FHK ,B῍ - ?GK )"L [ LL ?%^+ ,Bῌ $- H ( ¡ ,[¢- £+",¤ ,¥¢- ,M £¦#o ?£+§ t+ d$KLNO& - ?]GK /" . ¨ B῎ MBW2 ,£¦ ?%^+ H £+K GP$? G© (12ªK /" . / ?«$/+ %^*. bK. ?« /+ ?Ovw5x26LL ?12+ ¬Q >O_`%^<$ WXBYZ &R S]* . ?%^ * UU () /uT®&§UK. ()&$ d U# 7)K. U$-r ()&$UU /u %^ ef/u o . 0mbK )K. $<%^ * () ¯V)* -r. ef_W° *$"±u *$"XY *$"$ 0b)d*mUK+,-1-. P2Q2 0:b² Z[\³K ?´:+ K $ WXBYZ `b² µK ? ,]( +2 /¶Pw·7¸ >¹OVvwYº6- %^ ^ #FG& #J>K . _» ef()? 48.

(302) 05·o1 o¸e ńonce ´ ¹ ºm5»¸¼nopS.

(303)

(304)

(305) . Cῌ,

(306) !"#$%&'

(307) ( )*!$ +, A. . -./ 0 +1 $

(308). 2$ 01 $

(309)

(310) 3 45

(311) 6$ 0*789:;1

(312) <$ 0 =>$?$@3ABCD EBF G$9!9H I/ J KCLMNOP @3Q R E$F

(313) 3 SCDTTU

(314) $@( 1V-2W L3

(315) X Y

(316) . Z[L/ 0#\]7^451 01 $(_!

(317) XY. $ 0#\]7^1

(318) `3F3"a$bc

(319) #$[L %de[L/-$ [L/ -$3"a$\fgh

(320) %i.L <$j&k*78# l'mnL/ /D A 3()"a$bc

(321) nL L3 0*+[L/,o p-Bqr./$st01$uQ231 J 4v$(w x#

(322) 56 / [L . $ 0*789:;1

(323) U 45t

(324) < @. 37y V8z9 /W :;_B{ F <|J$bc3=>&

(325) 5 [L 5}L/ XYD /#\]7^ <$~?

(326) `} ^Hk0@$ 1 $A [

(327) <$~?$!#* B /$

(328) 3*#. CDF$x# eT <$45$E2$ 0:[L/Ft1k. f^ / AkG$HI$lJ

(329) `` $4vBK L $Mp

(330) N$3

(331) 6$ 01 BO P>$(_!@( D 0 $L 4v$P$3 $$2$vK$Qj$-$@-O <L32D E # vK $$@( 1V-3W. $ 0 E#1 3 XY$ 0^H1 $SR -$@(_ /D 2$SC 4T7UB )¡Q

(332) V. U¢ eT 0W+. !£9 91 $X%

(333) 0 $~Y¤H¥93eM$¦B# £$- @[L CB EC

(334) Z -$@( <Lw} L$B#£$ )¡B7DJLJ§- <$ )¡B7$¨?

(335) 3[\ < ]

(336) ©^BªC D@ $B

(337) 3 C-M_- ò ao b« c¬B?-d 3NQ$@( D(®/e¤H¥9DL$~Y=f_ ¯°±gh² ³$3

(338) i=>

(339) ńL $¦

(340) i=>

(341) µj[L L$¤ H¥9BD ¶k [L @( 1V.*W. @A 0=f_ ¯°±gh²1 DXY$!#*

(342) Jl 3@( 49. $()$b 3 2$.

(343) IJKa]â9»F ? .--+ ¼ ( ,**/ L+ ).

(344) . !"#$. %& '. () * +%, -.%/0

(345) -1 2. 3 4* 567 /8 9:; /(<1 =>+ %& '. () ?@AB C 80%D 5E9FGHI: . 8 9:; ) J

(346) DK+LMNH1 +OPQEJ R

(347) ST +-.%5.+;& UAVWX (Y )Z$% /' 81 Y.

(348).

(349) [% , 1 '. \+%]^J/_"1 O`]â 9K!7: R

(350) 1 67 . b" Icde/8f#+%g -.%& h1 Q0i-g 1 Y AB(23 Q EJAB $+%g -.%&. Cῌ-. jk. 1 lXFUAVWX 9 : m(1 K!7 ABZ1 % K! 7

(351) b"+%) &Z1 ' b"+%J

(352) no/8p'q$. . %& Y08" AB((]âg -.%& ' (rjks & lXF' )*tuv8+wjk

(353) xy8%Y/,z8Z! "& +-{. "|01 jk(}HV~ 9 -/8 .Q: Q. aD

(354) /"]â 9K!7: -.%

(355)

(356) 81 Y Q .&E9Jb ": 0 1 2!

(357) 1 % .g"+ 9 : /' ]^S|0/+%& 95 -/8 ; 34/0g (1 ]^]^g5

(358) b6 +%Y/-1 Y b6

(359) % 8% -.1 ' . `. %h$1 iq$. `q$. gY 34 . %s1 ' +g %:5.,;. -.%& Y081 jk( 5E

(360) \8" ,7,88"

(361) ST+Y/%& Y. (UAVWX 9: 5( 9Y

(362). b+% $

(363) 9_ %

(364) :1 ' 5.-;. ?@ ;¡/<¢ :.

(365) . -._"; £¤8"

(366) ST+ =¥8" AB. -.%& '81 Y (> ]^4+% 5?¦§; 9:

(367) b +%& i1 @z C¨q"©1 ]^©

(368) g_1 Jb" J

(369) A0O$-.%& '. ¦§ ª«+J 1s& Y. =. 81 9]^¬a(1 Z|«+Y08" ®E ¯ °+% 5?B§±²#;

(370) g1 ]^ ³i´`:5..;& 5CµDE +¶ , §xy; jk 9·© ¸©: /_")*FG(1 5 E¦§

(371) ]^¬a = /8 9]^J: 0P³D1 ]^¬a('08"J4+%B§ b"

(372) ¹H +%/0g -._"& ]â._(1 Y E/]^/ 4ºZ 50.

(373) ³´µ :$µP¶e ńonce ´k·9³¸¶¹º:»¼.

(374)

(375)

(376) . ! "#$% &'()*+. ,

(377) -./0123456/&78+ (9 :8 3456/;#<9

(378) "

(379) " 93456/

(380) ! *$=9 >?@A8 . BC BD

(381) E)*+ FG&H)*+I &7J

(382) KL2MN. OP

(383) 8+$)*>./I QMRSNT!U@

(384) VW:$ <X YZ [8\;]P

(385) ^:*+MNO_9U

(386) & QMRSN! * `FG(

(387) U@?@a A Z[ ,! `FG(]A9 bc:$def *! g h&)*+i jakl m!n7+o#paq:A_)*re& &FG()*?9 st :$9*f *! ,

(388) -Du

(389). &dv&w#x*+*$Du ". y#z{$|9re& FG()*?9 >.0I }N~NdY %X28 F&)*O/ $:& @

(390) + @& QMRSN! ,2Y |28 F&)*O/ ' +

(391) ?e@ *! v$*+U

(392) dv

(393) vU

(394) d ? af

(395) >&:*BCA!. I

(396) (&7 e?8

(397) )*. j+\;]hg $:&9U

(398) A>.1I. D. dtz".

(399) UA U@ + v$*+U

(400) >2d)I

(401) vU

(402) >2dI

(403) E!9 ) * v:

(404) ?7+ t +,-)q }N~N8+.

(405) dE & +** t +,

(406) U* ? UUA! }N~N/ 09& 1j+? U

(407) &7 }N~N2OQ 0N37. :$A. 1 p8 9A&¡*+@& ¢N/0$dv/& + d)

(408) d E&£ ?+t/4^¤#$*? 5ef ¥!¦§&.

(409). ?7+¨$& d) 9@ p U@d) ©Je ¥ª 8 «! R/NMt 87

(410) ¬m&def t&7d86&®< )*+¯ AU

(411) & a!? °:$ ¬ ?B7A d)t¯

(412) d )t*

(413) R/NM6&®<9t±² U8E)*. . !$? d)t

(414) R/NM6&|(9tU@± 51.

(415) ?@A¥¹º¥9»0 : .--+ ¼ ( ,**/ BC ).

(416) .2 . !" ##. ! ) *+,-.. $%&' ( . ! ) ) *+. /0* 12 3453 )67 89:;#33% <= . ! 12&' >?@A B* C (. %5" D >?3%*EFG . NO0( P

(417) - .. R #Q. ! A HIJKL :4M+. #&' <# >? :Q. . !" :S%+ TUVWL %5X#YM+*. 3% XZ& T [\.L!]: &[. ^@:3%.3 . ! _ "" >. ? >? `G *+a.. !"&'. b! cde:fKL+ghO+%= E. ijkl&' bm no)pq %5ffrsV+O nje suis, j’ai, je fais, je marche, je regarde,tq uo ' ovw o( ox oy tz 453Q:S%+ {% !e"%!Q:S%+ |} #= Je uoz :f*+ #!z me (7 {%. ) . . +% Je {% u#$~. 7 !e {%#$ a(/*. ! ) :%*+% <= Je :"5. Rw=' Je %5:& (Q&'?(x(V Ga*+%. /+. . +%. &'. ) )673%*)* 5*! *!"&'= 7:S ~:S%+ . ! )k. *+O0* " ,&&$3>-"w :.>(/0=' & %K,$ =:1*JM+%#&'/, 5*+ :4 ] . ! *!. =M+ >?$3k /0:S >?$ 28 *!"&' <= 283$:.: ) %M!4-.. ! 5¡. x :3 ¢£ s¤¥ ¦§ *+% w%& ¢£¨J ] %K ©6*! ª A7##«¬. 89:Q®(Rcd8$ª0¯:(°&3% :R; ¥$<J: *3%#&' : :Rcd±b3% Rw . &"²D =*+%#&' ³: *+ DK Rw. ´bM!8$µ¶ . =Rcd"&'. cd"&' /-. Rw>·¸fr"!3%#&' bm 8& Rcd $:. =((+. . o 93 %5 & 52.

(418) t¶S ¡YS·6e ńonce ´(5¸¹Utº6»VW¼4.

(419)

(420)

(421). !"# $% . & '()*. *+, (- ./0

(422) 12 34 /0!.$5

(423) 678. 9:;<

(424) =>6?@ A4 BC2D 4)

(425) 1E*+3/.FF G>&@H@I ,,

(426) $, ,. G

(427) H$JKL M(N$OPQP RS " T$ OPQP UVWX

(428) )$ $ Y I. & Z[P:\ B]^$_(`5D a5 bI^$ &I . . Xc

(429) ,(! @TIAX . (c

(430) . % d

(431) efZJfeP g"#

(432) $h$i$ A, Z, E, R, T IX %jk$I$ , (?,

(433) `5lm . RSno. OPQP,@pl qN (rs C2&4A tNlmI u

(434) Av'

(435) A @I wu 4) x $yIpl$()k@, s* z7IA {|IA }+IA T$ ,- @~

(436) (.

(437) /(0N 1 n .23 I TTs 4

(438) 5 6

(439) .=@

(440) 4 7. 8I 7 )&4 I $ 6c$

(441) =u

(442) $@6+ ). I3//F c%*IX %jk 9:;E

(443) <*$5u=. 8 1}Z:A*+ . RS>*(. - .A I (

(444) 1.C2

(445) *4? W "^>($

(446) , . (. % ~@?

(447) X. . 5 >* (.

(448) > %[P

(449) =+ ,I C2 IX ?, ,@$ @,

(450) .A 3/0F OPQP ¡Y Rsu - A B¢£T$4 C D(EF CD

(451) > 9:

(452) "^-G

(453) CH.A

(454) ¤ $ (us.I¥ ;E " I OPQP ( 3¦F ! $ I *J4?I> b§ b §I

(455) > b§( 4K ¨¢)) (L¢©N$ %ju! }Mw

(456) {.

(457) ¤ qN OPQP

(458) ªN«¬ O P~sm$ V@ ®¯

(459) Q°m, RS±§ A@²) ³R

(460) ;E

(461) A ´S A

(462) µ@=@A 5 C

(463) s @ 5²)²) KI (T5 v'(8$.,I 53.

(464) _`Gighia» b .--+ ¼ ( ,**/ cd ).

(465)

(466) . ! "#$ %& ' () *.

(467) + ,

(468) -

(469) ./1! /01234 56 . 789"

(470) :2;<=0>? @6A@B CDEFG HI ? @J@K 5H9. LM9 5N. O

(471) "

(472) ? P>QR DD Q6 * STU V W$XY . 5Z. [-\]L

(473) . ^=_=` Labc. !d e0:f=ghi9G. 9*

(474) gh j"$#k E $ /=;12l" 5%&mn. 9 o'j" (pI 5)*mn. [

(475) !

(476) HqQ6r+L[

(477) s,. t . [ *Pi -./p 4. "%&. D) 5umn. vmw 'xy[

(478) *9AHEz9 9

(479) {

(480) *pI P>* 0"9| P>*0 u}1\w ~

(481) \\

(482) W]P>*09R >2R HE

(483) "

(484) 3p" 56s>mnK. q7E9 "87 p. 7E9 :;R. *0}1\>4K9P[. z4K%*9 9. 30=[. ? W<=) 930=[>R ?\. "

(485) ./2! ^=_=9` ?q* TU[r@R. L A B 5". r@. h j" ? W<BCD. C e0:f= *g. Mgh ">" pouvoir $#. . e0:f=. . "D > ? W. < . ;1O

(486) "

(487) EFDD ;19Gj"%. . H*sK>%&KI"$#9[ 5J. me ćonna-. fl ıtre! R K94 [ ^=_="lL e0:f=* M ì N¡i ghi . i¢ -£. \¤7¥ 7¥ ! mn

(488) O7. ¥ ! 6P ` ?Q;

(489) 5r+. . gh mnR" 57¦§. ¨B©. ª«gh ¬F 0=! S®R9H" ^=_= MR * ?W >6P! P". U¯. * DGV ` ?. ! 5*mn. XSE 5O7¥ 6P.

(490) Hq*

(491). 7YIZH 5*IZ. . ±²=³R§. 9T. -

(492) oD` °+. ´ Reµ=:0 `LC.

(493) 9" ¶·`

(494) @¸:0X¹ ghi ¸:09 cr[R . \] 54. HIoºi¢

(495) ºXâb .

(496) .° _m±²ke ńonce ´R³$´«./kµ¶·¸~.

(497) . !"#$%. &'( )*+,-./0( 12 34,*5 p +23 678 9:;<=> ?@$+,- ABCD

(498) EFG# HIJK( L9:;<MNOPQ R ( )S T; AU 6.

(499) EV WX V%. T; AU. ῌ῎῍ 3 + 8 YZ[\0]IJ^ _à b ]cd$ e;IJ^ _`#afa& ghijklm mnmEV$b XoREpq .nmEV$Jmr$s<_mlmtXuvwNxy z J${| b h}b ~Ib &Vb m_ s&Vyz J$ hik l IJ$ 3 4+5k)S No IiQk p +,*8 3 , 8 4/5 p -3. 3 - 8 405 p ++2. 3 . 8 M$ h}~0 gj Vy[\@ b J$V0Vy~ HVEV$I0&V $~|! b [\ $0b XIJy vaKb $[\0b ¡¢b £¤b ¥¦§¨b ©ª«¬$[\IJKb ®¯. 55.

(500) ()_,-»* ¼ .--+ P ( ,**/ + ). /# 0# 1# 2# 3# +*# ++# +,# +-# +.# +/# +0#. +1# +2# +3#. ,*# ,+# ,,# ,-# ,.# ,/# ,0#. ,1# ,2# ,3# -*# -+# -,# --# -.#. -/# -0# -1# -2# -3# .*# .+#.

(501) .

(502) !+" p /-.# !/" p ./. !+" p +,/. p +,0. p +,1. p +-*. !+2" p +3. p ,*. !3" p 2,. $%

(503) &'()&*+ ,-ῌ * .*/01234 %567 8+019 p 2..# p +,+. !+0" p ++*. $:;+ /<9 =(+.>+?.(+@ AB.C?

(504) @ / :;D2CE9 F GHIJ/.

(505) ..(+ AB:;>4 ( IKL=(CMN :;+ .:;(OD/I PQRS EITU+ EKVWFFK<9 /IX

(506) !+3" p -/1.# !+0" p +-*. !+" p ,3*. $YZB[\]O^\_2>`4K+a

(507) @ EK bc2def g9 /g9h2i /82 ? jklmn(KFa

(508) !+-" p .,.# !+," p 2/. p 30. !+2" p +3. !-" p ,+ῌ,. !+" p 1*. p +,3. $opq+ *r5Nstu *2vM /iw(xy2z{L# (IG E|E}BY~2 @ ;} (I? + * +vM

(509) +M

(510) I# .8?}BY~

(511) p +32#@ !+-" p -20. !+" p 3. p 3ῌ+*. !." p ..2. p ..-. !1" p --. p -.. $*r7(/2`4 Y K(9 }BY~ J+ / O/ Y I F+@ *r 7+/¡ 2¢

(512) / +£nl/..¤I(K!¥¦ § ¨(+ /©ª«"¬? .(F_

(513) I L !+1" p +33ῌ,**.#@ p ,**. p +3,. !+/" p +/1ῌ2. !+." p +*. p ,+. p ,-. $C#!$ῌ®$«¯ + pq°p;±(U²³8´4µL%&2 pqN¶·'¸¹§Bº p ,/.#@. 56.

(514) wxy[ ]H./y¶e ńonce ´9·¸3¹Hwº»¼I4. ., .- .. ./. .0 .1 .2 .3 /* /+ /, /- /. // /0. /1 /2. 3 p +++. +. p ,-. 3 p ++,῍-.

(515)

(516)

(517) !"#$%&'()" *+,-'

(518) ./01 23456 789 : ;3

(519) <"#=>" *+,-' ;? *+,-' @A !"#$%&'()BCD ;? E EFGHIJC *+,-'

(520) KL *+,-'=MN./9O ;? EP *+,-'QR;3@A" " STUC VWXYZMNC"U3B;[ p ,*0῍1? p ,*3῍+*. p ,+1. +0 p +-*. p +-+. ++ p ,,*. p ,,*. p ,,*῍+. + p +-3῍.*. p +.*. p +... \]H^-_àNb cKUDHd3 D34eU fgh iUjUFBUk lEc]Hm k32BU? ENFcn] cK cE lENo]H m;3CB cW]H cKU D3 fpqh D3 fh D3 f] ONh iU;rs lt f;h f];h MN3c"U3\[ 2 p +2.? , p 02. 3 p +,+.. ῌῐ῏ῑ῎῍ + M. Foucault, Archeologie du savoir, +303. M. u`v` !"#$ wxy[ zR{%|. +32+. , M. Foucault, “Quest-ce Quun Auteur?”, +303. M. u`v` }~ & '4 "][ (y{% +33*. - M. Foucault, Histoire de la follie a lage classique, +31,. M. u`v` )! * +[ |, . +31/ . M. Foucault, Dits et Ecrits, Tomes ῌ, +33.. M. u`v` -@. /0 &_ῌu` v`w ῌ[ 12{% +333 / A.K. Marietti, Michel Foucault. Archeologie et Genealogie, +32/. A.K. ( 3 &_ῌu`v`wxy"4y[ |5 +33,? 0 J.G. Merqior, Foucault, +32/. J.G. _`_ 6 7 u`v` "89[ zR{%| . +33/. 1 C.C. Lemert and G. Gillan, Michel Foucault, Social theory and Transgression, +32,. C.C. ¡`, & G. ¢£¤ :;¥p3 &_ῌu`v`./75"¦<§¨[ =;©ª`'«`_R>? +33+. 2 G. Deleuze, Foucault, +320. ¬_ῌ^-_à @A4 u`v`[ zR{%|. +333. 3 P. Bourdieu, Ce Que Parler veut Pire, +32,. P. ®_©¯` °±BC ;"Kc"[ D²{E +33-. +* J.L. Austin, How to Do Thing with Words, +30,. J.L. `'(¤ ³;FG l´"

(521) [ Gµ. 57.

(522) * .--+ ( ,**/ ). +312. ++ E. Ortigues, La Discours et le Symbole, +30+. E.

(523) +31*. +, ! "#$ ῌ%&'& ()* +33*. +- M. Foucault, Les mots et les Choses,+300. M. %&'& +,-. /012 34 56* +31.. +. A.Y. Gurevich, Categories of the Medieval Culture, +32.. A.Y.

(524) 7&8 9: ;<=>? @AB C DEFGHI JK& L +33,. +/ R. #M :N OPQR SHFGT 5U* +33,. +0 J. Dor, Introduction a la lecture de Lacan, +32/. J. V& WXYZ [I\S]^_ L +323. +1 R. Chartier, Le monde comme representation, +323. R. #M :N àbZ cdHEe fgTῌFGῌh L +33,i jk +2 l %&'&Hmn oIp#qXr ,**+. +3 J. Lacan, Ecrits, +300. J. [I\ astu vwxy NzKῌ {F| +32+ ,* W}~- ῌ*H\&%$& Xr ,**/.. 58.

(525)

(526) e ńonce ´ . Abstract. From archaeology to sociology. Syuuichi KOBAYASHI The aim of this paper is to develop the methodology on social sciences through the re-examination of the concept “enonce”. This concept has been extended in three overlapping theories : Foucault’s history, Bourdieu’s sociology and Lacan’s psychoanalysis. This comparative study of “enonce” clarifies the phase of three points ; its meaning, its action and its materiality. This attempt also shows the overview of social scientific method including such interdisciplinary methods as those of Foucault, Bourdieu and Lacan.. 59.

(527)

「考古学」から社会学へ : enonceをめぐる横断的考察 利用統計を見る

「考古学」から社会学へ : enonceをめぐる横断的考察利用統計を見る