唐初期仏性論争における一闡提成仏の考察　－霊潤の「一巻章」逸文資料を中心に－

全文

(1). . . . . !"#$%&'(#"$%&'). ! .

(2) . .

(3) . *+&',-./ 012&' 345678 9:;<,-.=>?@A401!. BCBDE&' FGHI

(4) ?JKLMN,<EOPQR@A4,@SN2TU. @V&' WXYV51Z[\]D ^_à0b\c,de?fg!1-.,

(5). hiECV012jklmnop5q&!rstuq!vwBx G. +&*8&yz{|<},!9~012,}S!+&' \cB.c V. 5 \]q&!Z[iE !Bq +*8X!,B@k. kl ^R*B.,

(6) iE 012WD}CVt q & ¡¢hB£¤ *¥¦R!§8iE.,¨©2. mª«5} MN@¬Z[] \c®¯°±©.G0+&' ²³´©b., -. ÄÅÆ ¿ 2&' ¬0µ¶?@·¸01-.¹º»¼(7½¾¿),NÀÁÂÃB.2. .

(7)

(8) . !"#$%&'(. )*+,-./0 12#34567%89:%2;< =>?@7. ABCD!EF;G

(9) HIJ" KLMNKLO

(10) PQRSTD!%2#UV. WXYZ[\@567%2]^J";< _=àbcd3%ef

(11) ghij%2k;DlmnoTD!%2#. \pq(rsT to%5673% &'

(12) 0lDuvwx(3j5S.

(13). . y?HI(zl;# . &'{ 34|}_"~ J"n# &' Rn. _;< $%<)*p, p( (< nz

(14) J"#. n%2V#T &'

(15) 5673%n%2n;<

(16). 73%VV( <;D s¡_V;¢?£¤w¥;#. 8U¦{n|}§ &'

(17) ¨©J"U ª«¬®¯°¯¯±²WL³|}Zń. Ñ ¹BWÌÍÎZ(ÏÐJ" _. !n#µ¶·¸¹º»¼½&'}¾¿ÀVÁ

(18) 2;< i

(19) ÂÃT #&'ÄÅÆÇ% 89ÈÉ/ÊË¼&. WÌÍÎZ(×Ø;! _q(ª«¶ÌÍÙÚÛÜ"ÝÀÞß (³ à. Ô ªÒD!W/ÓZ(ÏÐJ"# s;WL³|}Z% &'

(20) ÈÉº»¼ÕÖ. .

(21) . 234567.

(22) . $"%&'()*+,*-./0 1. !"#. 89:5;<=>?@$AB"C>?@DEFGHIJ>CKLMCKJN?OPQRST" VWX U. YZ[\ ];<^_]$AB"_]OP^_]QR^_]ABST"_U%56`/a. bc*de%fg23^" ];<^_]$AB"_hii j]$AB. `%. 1. jij/ t. klLmnop ]$AB"HI_>CK]$AB"LM_CK%qrstu. q. wYstj ]AAC`_. VX *op ;<%'*o j*o. nwjxyz{|}~ . "_ v Z 1$" j. ]`_* tv. ª«áµstv. ª^â*j«. çè%éêZ>GÊ. ãä%°H ±. Aã ë°HA. ôõZ jL ª. 2ê. ûü(^ýj t]`_]AA. *o. æ^" î4ïî%ðñZã»òóst\. ² ³´ nµåv* j ABÄB. ÛÜÝÞßà -^". rÏt ÐÑ>ÒÓ¹½ÔÕ»L ¹½ÖG×½½Ô» £¤ØÙ 8 §¨Ú. VÎX º»¸¼½¾¿À°HAÁÂGÃAÄB^"JÅGÆÇJ9:ÈÉJ>GÊ¢¥Ë§¨ÌÍ . NG J¡G¢£¤J¥¦G§¨J©:Gª«J¬®I9:¯°H±²³ńµU¶·¸¹. . * `j t80z´tiÓ. dö÷øùðZú 1. Áì¹«í «. C`_þ*-. . .

(23) !!"#$%&'()*. *+,

(24). <=> !%)5

(25) 6 %789*:5; :?@ABCD.

(26)

(27) +,%

(28) -./0 1234 !%YZ95;. E /F5G

(29) HI(

(30) JK L*B4:;MNO P(

(31) QRS E TUVW34X4. %B[\]^_`

(32) abF5%cdefg:hij(5;kGlmnop

(33) qr. ( /F5st )u4:!v3wxyz

(34) qr

(35)

(36) {q|M})95

(37). S5;MNOwx~

(38)

(39) 3X3*:!%uA;)

(40) .

(41) . *B

(42) hM:*¡3¢£3*¤!:;. O/F5L (X

(43) G 4:%9 5; . wx¥Oj!¦§¨©^_ª\]^_

(44) «¬¬® ¯§%

(45) °^S[;¯§±². !%u5;B

(46) hÊ¡3ËÌ3!:;Íu

(47) Î¨©Ï. *:5;¯§/F5´Á4Â BB ÃX¯§%%

(48). ³´ µ¶·

(49) #SO¸w¹ºt3!%95qr »·³¼q§½ F5

(50) ¤ ¾C¿ À*}{3*3N Ä§ÅÆ

(51) A4^Ç

(52) ÈÉS Ð

(53) A4stS5;. !^íÊºt3µâ. åß <ë> ¨®;èéåêÝÏ§ã; ÑÒÓÐÔÕÖw;×ÚØÙÛÜÝ \]Þ ß;àáÙµâ§ãäæç. ìí§ÛìîF5¯§%:ïð\]Þ%:. .

(54)

(55)

(56) . !"#. $%&' ()

(57) $ *+,-./0" '12345 1 678. )9:;<=">. ?A@BCDEFGHI-JKLMNOA@PQRN!-STAUVWNX-SYAZP[WN\-SA]^_N`-SabcA@ >d w x e!fg- ShijA]klQmNe-SnAo]pi=q-Srstuv. y&' ,->de!"fgz{| 9:;<="}~ . %~,-4QR[W! &W &klQmej. 9:;<="#,-4u'

(58) . '&,- Y&4 1 &2. )

(59) $ *+>de!"}~ 9:;<="*¡¢£ ¤¥ 48 . ®¯°±²³¯r´²³¯µQ²³¯¶QR·³ Y¸¹º»¼½¾¿&&' »À. Á+ÂÃ»Ä4ÅÆ&' ÇÈ2 4ÉÊËÌ,- ./ÍÎÏ Ð8 . &+,- >ÑÒ-¹Ó*+ÔÕÖ×&' Ø+ 9:;<="Ù *+»%~4 . ÚÛÜÝÞßàáiâãäAåJææ-SçãJMèéNQêÑÒQë«ìPíãîAïæe-Sð,Þñ. x. 4úÚÛ^ )àá^^f ×æ

(60) . òóôA@PõÎÚÎ-iköNf÷ø;N$ù¬ïúAv-û-iüãiýNþALf-Sw. . . . w x ¦,-§ 23 &¨©ª="«4 1 ¬#>,-. .

(61) CBHIJ!K' CL/FMN=O

(62) PQRSFT@-@. !"#$%&!. "O

(63) PQRSKUF. XYZ[)\]Z^_

(64) àbcd eZfg hlijk5[ZmnopqpZrZ)stuJg"vwdxi.y_Z. V?W. FG. '()*+,-./012 345(678

(65) 9:;<=>?!"@,AB CDE.

(66) . . ]g". !"OmnsS[(. z!{|F }~(F= EefbI Omn`sS lOmnsS. )s5(r(tu.y.y_]FsU=. #efE {|@$Az!, ¡EG,@. "=¢#£N,-. ¸"3 3s¹'5º]»²³/´µ¼A½¾¿>. . "¥@Ò¾ Ó°±Ó]». =. ã@sAz=¤>?!"3 #.y_] sU©!s' 4äåæçè. À-sÔÕÖ¥! ×@¸B .y_]U' ØÙÓYÚÛÜÝÞs¹ßàáâ. ]»efBÇFÈÉÊË Ì$ÍÎÏ,ÐIÑ@. ?="ÀB¼=ef¶°±ÁÂ ÃUÄ½=Az!"ÅÆ@E- °±. 5()sF·67. E.y_]¬U==F }~_l®¯Az=°±²³/´µEef¶. ¤¥!¦I r(§¨(o5(}~($%©ªsEz=«>?!". '. E./yAz!= #ef'3? 4Az=A!". . ¸Az!". ¼A½¾¿>? îïðñ$Fò¸óô>? éyê ëìíy. . . .

(67)

(68) '*+ ,-./012,3546978:1;<=1./ 9,-9>?@1A95B-;CDE,FGH5A5IJ, K,-HL=1MN1O9PJ>,Q-R9ST:U1/VW9XYZ1[V

(69) ,-K>1\=-]6^1_7`8aT&6_7H9b57c,/d @qr9aT:s1tuVH5r9dv/V. 1. e,-f1g<hi1jkl,697/m n,-op. w,-e-O,H5x9d:s=,yz-{]|}=1x_7 ~,- 9A ~0x5XB8VGGX ,- 9c91 ,-{*9aT61

(70) VH5*9;1

(71) V ,-9TJ>1$,s,394BVH59V>, 9,-89qc_7H9GW_I K,-K;=1-q97T:sVH59V|}V. !"#$%& $'( ). !"#

(72) ¡¢£¤¥¦§¨

(73) ¢'©ª«¬£®¯°. / ¸ ¹ºª»¼. !"#'½¾+ %¿:;<= ./£3. 1 1 ±²¦§§³´µ{¶¦±§§· ./012,354678 9 : ;<= .. .

(74) ,-394B,{V697K:-5P6978

(75) :. . . .

(76)

(77) .

(78) . !"#$%

(79) &'()*+,-. "STUVWX(

(80). ./012%345

(81) 67-89-:;<

(82) -=>?@A7BCDEF !G!" . R. !_e

(83) fghijklmHb. P Q. !"YZ\cd. H

(84) A7I-JKL-MNO%D-89# YZ[<\]^_QàHb EF. !". 89zr. !)*+,-A67

(85) 7I-JKL-MNO%n#!D(

(86) [RQo#-p9qrHb. !"#$%&'() *+, |. .. A¼D´½¾u¿. . 7#(Astuv,v,D

(87) w#(AxI7y0I7yD

(88) oAULaLD. { | " }

(89) -A7BCD-~(

(90) Hr A DA7D qQ. !

(91) =>01- n !

(92) >- :!". !"

(93) GGX(YZ\-8$r

(94) o#-01HrP QI. "(. !". :

(95) ®¯-°>(GGX(±Q". . { ÀfhÁ®koÂBAÃÄÅÆLÇÈD´K-ÉÊ(ËÌXÍ!". .

(96) . . ²A³D´[µ¶·

(97) ¸¹Hbº»>. $5( ¡a¡-I¢£¤

(98) ¥}-¦]! §¨©ª«RX :!"¬. :. . .

(99) . !"#$%&' 67./0. !". . ()*(+,-./0. S(T . . . p3qrJQ. !. . #QLZ'y;(y( >QL. ./0. . . . . !"#$%&'. . .

(100)

(101) .

(102) 340'5(. ()*3F#G0%&>HIJKLMNG0OPQ. !"#$9:;<=(>?@AB#./0. 1

(103) 2! 8

(104) C

(105) DE. R

(106) S

(107) *(T'2! UV W7XDEY!0Z('. . >n0o.. ];]^_]à]bcde. \f ghDEijklm.

(108) (stuv./0.

(109) . \f ghDE. . . JlA'VJlA($'>de$>!". . >. . . . [\V W7XDE. . . wx yz{|}~./0!(T3^G0T(. . . . f

(110) ]T]]T((.

(111) <=( >. . . 1

(112) Vx!(~(2!. . OJQ. . . . W7X(#. . . 8V W7XDE2! CV< W7XDE. .

(113)

(114) 0 234 567#$%89/. 1. 1. 1. MNO. 1. 1. 1. 1. qr-s-. 0 TUVWR%XY/ 1. nPp. 0 >#$?@/. 1 1. 0 §¨%.!33h?@/. 1. 1. 1. 0 t(u/. 0 !"#$%&'(!)*+,-./. GH( I$JKL#MNO?!)PQ%RS. 0 Z[\ (]#^_`MNO%aO%XY/. 0 b$c( deAfg`4hijkl/. b$c( deAfgm\ nPl%m(lo. b$c3 (]nP?MNO#qrvM8wx&'.

(115) . 1. _. 0 b$c3 (]nP?MNO h#$m\ ¡$x'¢£%£_}T/. #$c ¤tm3~3#$x¥¦¤vM. . 1. . 0 :3; 56#$<=>?@%AB-.CADEF/. . 0 yz{3 b|MN$}nP_~x#$%&'EF/. . 0 N#$x'WVP/. 0 Z[( (]#^_#%&'(]nPV'-./. . . . . . . . . 0 GH( I$JKLMNOV.'VT%V/. . 3 56xW. . . . 0 3; 56%&'#$?@% R/. . . .

(116) . U. U U. U. . T V?àYD F HI ef~-3K6, T ?àYDFH ef. T ?àYDFHl4 ghO/M. . . . !"# $.

(117)

(118) % . 8

(119) 69()0:56;<=*>,7.

(120) &'()*+,- ./012-34056,7 . :5OS'MT. T U j7ghO/j k'-$l6m9. [\nop

(121) oqr T ?WXYCDZstuv]wx yzg6/Pg {|7^_à}~. U. !^_. ?@ABCDEFGHI0:5 JK7LMN6OPN: QRK5 QR,():5=,7. V . ?ABWXYCDZ[\?WXYCD] ^_àb6cdT U?àYD efghOi#,7. . T %?WXYCDZstuv]wx h lN6O^_6-. U. . . . . .

(122) " !. #. $%& '()*+,-./ 0123/'(45678)*9:;<=>/.

(123) . . " ?@ABC:D!. EFGHIJKLMNO >PQR ACS. ^ _% V-.?

(124) `Xabc. #. " T/ ?@!. " m][ACn!. #. # #. " m!? ACR AK>C!. #. . !¢. >S! H£_¤¥¦§¨©ªM>« ¬;. >Q][!. !g:D;. / _o pqrstPuvwxyz:D{ |}A~}>oO}T. . !/>>o}. de:fgAhgDi/RjkZ[;Tl. " UFG V/WXY>)*Z[;V-.\;][!. . . . !3_Q R >WC[;[. gr>R/ >-.A?SRS!. !. g>O7T? A. g>O7.?¡Q. . . g>O7A|{?>>S [email protected]. . . . . .

(125)

(126) . >?@. !" #$%&'()*. +,-./012 3#4 /56789 -!" #$/:;< =. ABC D3>EFGHI JK4LMNLOMPQHIAC -R,ST/ 2. UVWXYZ[]\â_`XObMXUV #$

(127) c

(128) d>EeFG fgNhi . 8o/'plP. jklmnopqr

(129) stu )*/v+wxyz+w { N | }~ . " (4" P9 p)*E ObM . 5a!ZPXZLâ_`XObMXUVa !¡¢!£¤!¥!. ¶ · O¦!§M"bM"¨©ª"«X¬®CXgf¯°±²]³a´¦µ±. gÇ>ÈÉÊ F. ¸¹ !"'(º' »¼G ¯½¾¿56789 -Àp Á±`>?ÂÃ)* ÄÅÆPEo( !" »¦. no/q)*Ó EÔq89ÕÖ. G>?bË!"ÇÌ!"¨©ª" -ÍÎÏ`/ >E¸'n op(4o( FG!"EÐÑGÒ® FG!"Jä ¦$¼G. î. åæÃp/()* Pçè "é. ×>?Ø FG

(130) Ù -ÚÛÜq"P/pnop ÝMÞßP à áâ ã. ·. ". >?e ð/ñòó. FG Ý -ê2a ëìÝE)*/^íÂl4 ÂíÂl4 ïFG!" JK4ObMP "ð9. ¶ /. p' bË!" EMß/P'oÃn( EUV -. '½ôõ+/ö÷1øùúûEbË!" üýþ>? Ep4ô. . . .

(131)

(132) . !"#$% . A B !"#6789:;<=:>?@ . k|. _`. A B "gUkdg, kog,tou,. "ab>cdefghkijbl]jm,nopqrstu,vwdxy,z\{k|}"gUP~dIg,`. XJYZ'[[\]^MNOPK'. L ,. C&DEFGHIJ$% KL2MNOPK'QRSTU)VW. &'()*+,-./012345'. . 4 ,]^'*J""#. !"#9¤¥6@¦K§W¨©4,. !"#¬%}"#K®¯ °±,²³´. )¡6}"#9¢£6@v6 Lª«]^'. µ("m'¡6J}"#¶}"#·¸¹Hº»&¼½!#¾ T J,. H¿ÀKÁÂÃLÄÅÆÇÈÉÊ!"#Ë&MÌÍÎ¼½ÏKÐÑ. "JX ,ÉÊ!"#'ÒÓÔÕÖÓ×ØÙÚ9:ÀÀ@K67¤¥ÛÜ{Ý¡6. ä è PJU)ITé)ÉÊ!"#"&¼½!#!&ê ëìJíîï. , ÉÊ!"#J4MÌÍÎ¼½Ï 98ðK'MÌÍÎ¼½}á4@

(133) '. ("ÁÂ -J)µ("mK'ëìñ ãÈW¨©4,ò ó. ±45ÉÊ!"#K'z(Ãôõö4÷øù'úûK-¼. . . A B H4Þµ(&"m'ßKàá ,'Mâãäåæçã J,. .

(134)

(135) . !"#$%&"'. EIGJ/K33. 'V7WX:"YZ[\]M"^T/_:àb. LMNOPQ ()*+,89FR SP"T. ()*+,-./0"1234567 89:;<= >?@ABCDEFGH U:.

(136)

(137) . c3def5aghijk=l . '7"z{. "#$q. 5"Y+V%M" . mn

(138) opq r/"Y+=stu/vwxya /M#$=+|/}95~WVr. r3 /89" p:'=l. M"/NO\=V5'" q*,

(139) 7=/3". ±²"NOY³3. " ¡¢V5Y+ £¤¥f,

(140) ¦§=¨©Mª a"-.1A«/p:¬/®45¯° . '7 Â*6»"Y³ÃYÄÅ. ´µ/r" £¤¥f,¶

(141) M·¸/¹º»"¼q

(142) 1q

(143) 4 5q½ £¤¾¿Àº=ÁV5. ÆÇ5È"Y+ÉÊËÌ,ÍÎ"N53,ÃÏÐ5Ñr. 'ÁMTUà×Øu3ÖeÙÚÛ"#$=. "'Ò&/gÓ57M"ÔÕ Öe6:()*+,

(144) Y+.

(145) /_:Öe. .

(146) !"#$%&'()*+,- ..

(147) =6=DE<FE=. <6GH<IJ5=. K61<LMNJO= . B6JO. /012345671*89:;<<)==6>?2345<6@A1345>?234 5 6;<B)C= . . `. a. b_c d=efghbij kl&m =no FE D. pqJbr5fsHh. LMNUbJO1. JOfQv . o -&234&m5t. . @A1345. ub. 234&m5tSubN _ . |"&')*f}) ~h.cbh&1*8f 1*8=e&'.>. 1*8t12345u. . SwxyzU{1. >?2345. P<QR=@A1345 6S1TUVW1<234*=9XYZ<[\=PT]<34=C^_<1*=. . . &. !"#()*+,- '.@A(12345,t1234*u_c «.=n. f.'( .¡¢£¤¥¡¢ ¦ ,-&§¨f©v ¡'ª. &w.o1*t1234ub _mc . .c34f]*f =n.6(@A1345, '{1U. &.6(>?2345,b'.=> 34t1*uf .. . . .

(148) *)!+,*-./. 789::. !"#$!%&'. 0123456.

(149) (). 0; <= .> 456? @= .AB$#CD E.F= 6HGD ABI .JHK LM? HN .?D OHP QRS ? .. ` d T;UHVABI.JMKW.X?YHP;Z[?.\?]MVÎ.RHP;._aDM RHG .bMcH AB. $#C.ePRHP; .ZfSg=hI.cd;iHVAB$#C.. jk? 456? @=.AB$#CDE.$Mlmgk?.3M$HP.noHp;qrI.bMhSsHDIWtKC.. uH?DOMPv?.T;6HVABI.LWwx?yMRHVC I.TH;Sz thIk?.{D|H;wx?.};~H=ID. I.bMcHdAB$#C.JMK;W ?P;.v?P;.bMhIMDqMVhC I.cd;i?VAB$ #C.k?bM%DHP_I.P;$MlI#.cd;iVCABC.. ¡¢)£¦*¢§9 ¨. b*-. ), *.k) ¡¢)4. £¤x)*-.¥. !.* 56. £¬-!.>. !®¯ !q( -!°±.®¯. !©-9ª456*¨«AB:H: *uAB:QR. *-.. R²!-+©q( R³)´ªAB$#*)!µ¶q( R³. g$)AB$#!¹!*¡¢!¢©. ÙÚÛÜÝ. Þ. ÃÄ:ÅÆÇÈÉ«ÊËÌ. ¾¢!¿. )ª·¸Zf. HÂ. º»¼1©q( ¸$E½¤x ®¯ !q(. . ,À¡¢Á1.. 6×!Ø. . . . ÃÄ .â1ªNß. /Ö ÔÕÁ. Nß àTNßá/. ÍÎÏÐÑÐÒÓ6/. .

(150)

(151)

(152) . ! "#$%&. '()!*+ ,-./012345 67896://. ,^_`Kabcdêf`K. TghN®¯E°HQUgh±. ^§¨nIJ. ±YEJ¯². . . 7 9lÞnQUÊËÂ·¸YNUÊËY^mJIUyz

(153) YEU{|

(154) Y^dßnI. ½KNGØ¥HsRQTghN·¸¹ÙÚNÛG¥ÜÝlxIQ·¸¹N

(155) ¿. ÎÏÐ^ÑKEQÄÅ¹E·¸¹ÒqÇÓJQUÊËÂ·¸YEJulÔNÕu^Ö×. ¹qÆÇ°HIJÈG¯ QfÉUÊËÂ·¸YEJuTMÌ|ÈJERÍqQN. IJK QRNÁlqUÂ·¸YEnInEÃ½KG¥Kghd^TÄÅ. t^ghq·¸¹ZFNU

(156) ¿À Y^_`KabNÛyz

(157) YEU{|

(158) YlFJ. ^nIJRET¾d£¤¥HK. ³EnI´¤KREqG¥KsN Qqghµ²N¶µQ·¸¹º»l¼½. Q©ªiN«Hl¬qQsN. lxIJKT I¡J¢NE£¤¥HKt^T¦I. NiFlnIUyz

(159) YEU{|

(160) YNlnIJKGKqQqghN. IQU

(161) N

(162) Y^mJIUyzYEU{|YNml}~InIJKghq[ . ghTiFjklmN EnIopnIJKqQrnPsNtÛ

(163) YEJuvlwx. EFGHIJKLMNOPQRRNSTUVWXYZFN[\]. C D ;<$=>?@AB. . nEàá°HKsH=^QTâãQ{|

(164) l äÈxHåQæç{Tè½KE£¤ NÍu. . .

(165)

(166) . !"#$%&'(. ) *%+ $%&,-./01 23456789:;. <=%+ >

(167) ?@AB1 CDEFG.&89.H. IJKLMNO P2345QRS@ TUVW .=%+&. 234567X. YZ) [\,]C5&2^ 9_X. .` JKLMNO J34MOab) TU JcdMOefghi Jj5NO JC5NOkl. m^nSkopq^_rs& tuv9kw&Y. x{yz |Nkz eJj5NOiMz ^}~ z { 34kz

(168) + { k z {. . ^k kz~ y { y k ¡ F¢ E z {z~ £ y ¤{ k. ¡ ¤{kzz~aklmA{F¥kz¦{2§]k¨ FEz {z|k. lmÒ!LsÓÔ CDEF(:Ë1 C 34 2345 ±. R) hÌÍklm ÎsC5¬X)Ï99TU °ÐÑXk. 1 349 345&2 HIklm_< t ^8R. ABYÂÃXX9?Ä Å .RÆsÇ MÈ ÉFÊ:Ë. aR»¼½ X ¾ ¤19 ¿ 2§]À F¥Á. ^;_Xt ¹klm tv9¸&Y°ºR TU. SGJj5NOµ;¶ MêJ34MOiuklm 34 2345 {R·¸. ..¯ °rYJj5NO±^²8 TU& klm R³)´°. ® {^k2{ ©ª345kaklm«z¬{yC5kz. .

(169)

(170)

(171) . !"# $ %&'. ()*+,-./ 012345()*/ 6789%:;<

(172) =>?@A B. . CD

(173) . E"FGH2IJ KLMNOP%Q5RST @A2U

(174) VWXYZ[. \]^2_`

(175) abc"#d,-!# !"2VWefghijA$ klmno. . pqrsltTu$vwxvy5z!" {|}~ VW2e. L 2%%hGF h5

(176) 2&u~ 2 s l

(177) . 2[B%.u@lV%huTA !"# ¡¢£5. qÌh

(178) `Í2e²³ÎÏ ". Dh¤¥l

(179) (=¦§/ ¨2( © q«ªª7¬°®¯+.±²³=´µ¶·¸º¹.A»°¼½=¾¿ Ë. !"# (). !Lëì

(180) í."#A."# î;<(= +A./@%h"v . *+,-./ul

(181) $2çèéuCê

(182) ,-!# =>?s. á

(183) uâ%hÔãs äåæ %01. B%(+.¸Û/ 01uÜ%h`ÚÝ" Þ. ßà%A. ¸+2. 2ÐÑ^Òrh 2ÓÔ@ÕÖ"#u×ØlÙÚ[. Ê »º°À¾¿ÁÂ=±Ã¶ÄÅºÆ¬!·xÇ±ÈÉ¾¹/. .

(184)

(185) ()*'+,-./(0123'456. lPmnYo. !"#$ %!&'. =>?@ABCDEFGHI@JKLMNOAP. STUV WK ?XYZ[\Q]^[\^. 789:9;< 7QR<. _àb=>-c4?@ABd [\ef42()ghijJHIk [\. mxyz{|pst$#*s)V. pqrstuvKwJ?@ [\Pmxyz{|p}}st~Jx?@5dP~ ?X . ?@A OA J?X Pqm?X5 |rrst [\e f$. _ ab2'¡¢)£¤$=>$¥¦ §s!¨©234ª«('=> ¬®!&'. ()J¯°±ªPmK²³q´9q}µt-¶·*s=> ¸¹s!&'( [\. ef42()º»+¼½¾ ¸¿45ÀÁÂÃJÄÅÆÇÈPÉmÊr}}ËÌr}pÍt. .

(186)

(187) . !"#$%&#'()*(. 3^_$3àbc$d3U e,U. +,-./0123456789:1;'<=7>?+@7ABCDE)+'FBCGGH+I JK

(188) 9VL C'WXYZ[\7 9]<. L23M

(189) NC)*OPQ3 RSTU<. -*·¸7#¹7º»9¼¢2$Cg23 R½TUWXYZ*D\"oD)pDG¾,3 R¿TU<=7#À9VL 'ÁÂ;ÃÄÅÆ67ij7. RÖTU"×"ØÙy¥¦ZG\"oD)p(D¾,3. |(|OPQs1tL3. . ËCh0ÌÍÎÏ

(190) 'ÐÑÒ7Ó9C'ij7#Ôt Õ

(191) L23M

(192) NC. ÇÈÉ%Ê'*|(+,9C'. ¬¬C'-0p[hph®p¯°p±²#³ ´s1 L23-'µ¶. ,7 L$ ¡¢2*£9'¤_y¥¦ L§¨-©ª«0123. RTU9VL 7MCg23t

(193) 'NWXYZ**\"oD)pD*(. '*|E*+,)(PQ3. 7>. . ?+CD|+0G*E+ , JKs123M

(194) NC5 . D|(,7cF

(195) [hlijl9}~

(196) t$t Js123~8C<. fg[hij3klmnU"oD)pD)Gq, rs1 L2tu'v0Nwxyz`D({. . RÚTUM

(197) NC5 ÛG\Ü×7F, "#Ý'*|||+,*H EOPQ3. . .

(198)

(199)

(200)

(201) .

(202) . [0\]H^_à'bCD+cC9defg8CD+hi

(203) jk

(204) lmneo,0FG8p. !"# RS. !"# $%&

(205) '()*+,-./0123

(206) '4567 8. . 9:;<=>?@8ABCD9EFGHI=9JKL0MNA2>E=+OPQH0 TUC+VWCD9@X84YM2>E . 1Z . [ 0f'J9D+OcLdefg8CD4+Ak. [0 'bE. Iqrstuvwxdeyz {|}uvwx+

(207) |~H

(208)

(209) %

(210) Z

(211) =)EC DH+. qdetmwde {%}wmw+&

(212) H

(213) ='E !"# 1

(214) Z. ,

(215) && &~~

(216) . . 0p¡, '4k¢£. ¤¥¦§¨©ª,«¬ª,

(217) ®¯°

(218) ±Z²³´. . ¤·¸¢£

(219) t%¹8ºM)D9E. »¼0

(220) lz½ § '4+°Umnº¾¿,¾E

(221) À2k

(222) ÁÂÃÄÅÆÇÃ ÈÉ. µ¶ . ÊÁË

(223) ÌÅÍ°nÌÎÏmn

(224) Ð5ÉUmn

(225) ÌÑÒÓÔÕmnÁÖ

(226) Ì×ØÇÃ ÙÚÛÜÁË

(227) ÌUmnÌÝ. ÎÏmn

(228) Ð5ÉÞ°mn

(229) ÌÑÒÓ

(230) ßinÁÖ

(231) Ì¢£ ÃAàáÒâÏÅÆ

(232) ÒÓãäÔÕmn

(233) Ìµ¶ Ã. åÝ ×Ø

(234) Ò ÓÞãä

(235) ßinÁ Ö

(236) Ì æÒ ¯çÃ ¸ÏÝ µ¶Á ¯

(237) Ì èé ¢£Á ¯

(238) Ì êëÁ ì² í

(239) Ã ¸ÏÝ ¯çÁ ¯

(240) ÌGîÞãäµ¶Á¯

(241) ÌÂÂtï

(242) %

(243) 8º9D9E. . . . . .

(244) . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . ? @A0 .

(245) 1MNOP78QR1ST45UVW5;XNYZ[\]^_.

(246) L. ? @A0 -

(247) 1JKHI789+LB:. ? @A0 -

(248) 1JKHI789+)(D. ? @A0 +

(249) 1EFGHI789+(C. ? @A0 +)

(250) 1EFGHI789++:. ? @A0 )

(251) 145789+B)D. ? @A0 )

(252) 145789+B:. ? @A0 )

(253) 145789+BC. ? @A0 )

(254) 145789+BC. ? @A0 )

(255) 145789+B:. ;<=0 <

(256) 145>789--(:. -./0

(257) 123456789(-+:.

(258) . .

(259) . @A0àMb0]cde;defghFiO]Tjcdej;de 89++C k]lmlnopq'rs]Qtuvnwx[yzn . ? @A0 -

(260) 145789+BD. . ! "#$%&'())*++,-. . . .

(261) . . . . . . . . . . . . . . ( )*$%

(262) Z[\]^_`[âbcd. ,VOW ( BXY',. NOPQ R ST(,U. BC ( 5JKLM(++. BC DEFGH(+. BC DEFGH(+&I+. 34 5678, 9:;<=>?@A. -. /012. (, )*$%

(263) . (

(264) )*$%+. ' !"#$%('. ' !"#$%('.

(265) !"#$%&.

(266)

(267) .

(268) . ef(, ghi. . . . . . -. /012. 34 5678,+

(269) &. ( )*$%

(270) &. . .

(271) . . . . . . IJK

(272) ?@LMNOPQRSTUVWX@YLK?@A Z[\L

(273) ]^_O

(274) . C.DEA F

(275) GH. 7?@A

(276) B =(=. 34567 8

(277) 9:;<%< =>. *+,- % ./0 1'2. .

(278) . ). =>.

(279) !"#$ % & '(). . % M G_`_. ' Z%L. `_ZabcdKeUfgTXhijklKmVWXnopSOqr[sWXtuhv[wLxyR B . SVzZ{|}~jkWn A 8

(280) $ . & ¡¢DE*£¤¥¦§¨©ª«¬ ¡¢DE*ªj. ®¯d¢ ¡°ª±_¦²³]^_= 1ÓµST. UVn¶X·eNO¸z¹#Lpºn»]*WmgnO¼dRSV¢XIJZ½i¾¿WÀÁ. XÂZ[\Ã{|WÄÅÆsTUnÇ«¸ÈÉÊSVUËSLÌÍXÎÏZÐÑX

(281) ¢D. EZ

(282) ÃPÒV[%l

(283) `_O

(284) ]^_ÃÅUVKXpSÊZ[wZÓµÔÕ lÖeU. pp¸×Ø. OqÙLXtuhv[wlmV{|Z A 8 Z[\. M G_`_ & ¡¢DE*£¤¥¦§¨©ª«. O ÚÒVÛWÜU½iLK

(285) ¢DE*¢&ÝÞ¢DEß²àáªâDE. . . . . .

(286)

(287)

(288) . !. "#$%&'()*"+,-. /01"23456789. :+;1<=>?2@ABCDEFGHIJKLMNMOKPQRSTUVWXYSZ[. \45]^_IàbcLS ^_dèH8PfgcLhi`5jcRkHlmLMN. RknoSp^qrY

(289) stuNvwmPxy2z{YWX^|}ÈEA}~}HK LMNc YZi_^] ? SD}GEB . Z 4]D%>^; (7:D ¡¢£¤¥¦

(290) §¨(©. ª«¥¬¡®¯°:±²(7³)°´Dµ¶Dµ¶9

(291) *·¸¹º

(292) »¼

(293) ½$. ¾¿¬

(294) ÀÁ

(295) Âi¦I_Ã(7:Dµ¶>?2@DÄCÅG^;ÆPÇÈÉ. NÊncSZ 4]^;PYDµ¶`ËÌ>HÍÉNIÎYwM^tS ZÏ5]Ð. DÑ¸(Ò>^_I?2@ÐDCAÄÓGàbcLMNHÔKN. . . . ZØÙ4]?GPYS>HMkÚÛosÜPIJKLMwMÝcJÉNHSZÞØ. Z 4]ÐE©ÕÖ×>?2@DÄCBFG. Z 4]B(>?2@DÄCÐÐFG. Z 4]ÐB©ÕÖ×>?2@DÄCBDÅG. Z 4]ÐE©ÕÖ×>?2@DÄCBBFG. . Ù4]?ßG^à>PÇÈÉN;JÝcKwMoSDá>;âã^äoZØÙ4]. ?GPåæcLMNÊçSTUYZÞØÙ4]?ßGÎ`èéêLMwMRkPëkMO KPQRSììt^;YíHcwM. . . .

(296) . . . . . 9:;!<=> ?@ABCDEF))GH8I<JDKLMNOPQ. 2345 .

(297) 67# 8. 2345 .

(298) 67#)8. !" )

(299) *+,- ./0 #11. .

(300)

(301) !" #

(302) $%&'( ##. . R,7,STUVWXYZ[\D]^_à" Sb;c\Tdecfg.?. -

(303) ?@ABCDEFEG8pq. rstu

(304) vgrwx)y#F Ez{|)}~ .a". h !ijk KLMNOlmno . lu

(305) v"y#

(306) yG

(307) _`stuwx F #1. 2345 .

(308) 67#EG8.

(309) yEr F G1z{. GG)E H)EGSW\Td . |^" F¡ ##¢£¤¥¦§¥¨©ª« GGGG# SW\Td. . . . . . 2345 .

(310) 67#1H8. ·¸¹W

(311) #. ®¯®°±" E

(312) ²³´µ¶ )#. 2345 .

(313) 67#E8. "

(314) ¬! #GEG. . . . . .

(315) !"#$%&'. ()*+,-./0123456789:;<=;8*+>?.

(316) . @AB>?CDEF>?GB@HIF. . .

(317) .

(318)

唐初期仏性論争における一闡提成仏の考察 －霊潤の「一巻章」逸文資料を中心に－

唐初期仏性論争における一闡提成仏の考察　－霊潤の「一巻章」逸文資料を中心に－