篠原初枝著『戦争の法から平和の法へ』東京大学出 版会、2003年
著者 孫 占坤, SUN Zhan Kun
雑誌名 明治学院大学国際学研究 = Meiji Gakuin review
International & regional studies
巻 27
ページ 45‑53
発行年 2005‑03‑30
その他のタイトル Hatsue SHINOHARA, Forgotten Crusade: The
American Scholars of International Law in the Interwar Period
URL http://hdl.handle.net/10723/1550
!"#$
%&'($)*+,-./01$23$45 6789:;<=>+?@ABC$DEFGA ,HI/JKL8MNOPQRS1TUP$
V&$WXY45Z$[\$]H2A=P
^$,/A_:$DEFG,`ab/8c MOP=>defTg*+h"ijP!+
:kl$Ymn2oFG'($p2qr stu(vwdT+d:$2xyz{2
|}~jP!
,
2o/h+~jP"+OP=>
A$+8OP,/(,s tu/8jA>($AP2o
'AH ¡r'Ui!¢£l A$¤8(¥¦$`a§¨#©
(¥Pª«¬8$2o®(,2 o¯°±²/+³{´µ¶·$¸¹$, º»/¼2o½¾¿% +~
jP!
`a§¨ÀÁÂl8(¥¦+O P2oÃÄÅÆÇÈd±²ÉÊAËj$p 22o®Ì(jAÍÎ$ÏÐ!
¾Ñ($¢ÒÓ'UP,#©ÔÕ2o
®/MO=>A$`aÖ×g`
ØHÙÚOP'#A$2oÛÜ Ý$ÞßÓ^8à¦$+AáOPz {ßÓ8¦âPp22o®#'ãk~
8,2o ä/åæç%è 'UP!w®(§'¾éêëìH2 oí',2o ä/$,2oîï/^8ðñ
~$¼ò$óôõHHìö÷øùú û',2oüë/^8ðñ~P2o äY ýãþ3'UP!
¾ÑþLj<$2oüë$2o ä$ýã^þ3A=P,´/T 'UP"+(j>'Tdj!$2o
®¾Ñæç'$
T§=>AYs+j>2oA+i
T¡d Ó'U:$´®DT{ ¡8 {T'UP!i$2o äý' UP"+8'¾Ñ8OP"+
'$í,o/ùúAOP+ A$
¾Ñ=:z{&AP"+TOPT 'UP!AP§A$¾Ñ8
""AË{!,Ü/$,×%
j2oÖ/$,× j2oA
ËlP/$,× /$
,× Rr ¨£l /$,×
Þ8¦âP/$,× d`Ø+2 o/$,/!
j2oÖ
×g`ØH$¹^`a§¨Ah
¼B8ñ:A$2oÛÜ
>'UP$2o=>A
~P+j>¾(#©p
HG$
!"#$
%&'()*+,-./012
"#$%3*456789:
;'<=>?@A BCDEFGH<IJ?KL, M%L+,-<NO?.
12P5QRRSTU<V ,-W:XYZ[\]^_<'`3EL+
: a<bc3defgTU
?hij9klm5:
no,pqr<s.ot uvw'xyzL-{|}~}*
j9- e `-kno|
bc3`-^
w'x<?.t xDx<
o?-) ¡'¢
k9-bc IQR,e£¤
¥ ¡'¢.L+¦§¨©
ª «¬®,+|
bc¯)-°A±²³ªQR´
¯,`-µY¶·|¸a TU¹º? ¢.
L-$»¼½L+!/¾
"¿wA73*¦À»ÁÂÃÄÅÆÇÈ' Éʽ?Ë®EÌÍÎÏÐÑ ÒÓÔÕÖÎ,`-רZ{ÎÏÐ<Ùd ZÚÛÜÝÞ|¸ß|àáâÛãäå
!æçèé6<êë+®k ìí<îï? ðñÌ4í
° ±uot
rò-),3¢¡'3<óë¡'
ôë"#78®E:KL, õö2.L-r÷»ø½ ùr÷»øúûø½KL,
{|¶üýþø wA5:
5¾w Io
no <)`+<A aTUf<)`+bc ÒÙø|bcÙø<
pª?.2 {|}~}
ZÛÜÛÀ¢k72 u áâÛãäå||ZÚ}
?.|| Ò ìú
<ÙL¬¢ZÚ} Ò
?53*;<(L
56 ^G
kKL,l
£<`+,x.
A7ÑA?:
½o«dL+12 9ø®E
"6<NO?.t|f g2 "#569¢
½L+ýþ2"6 4569¢
. ë+12 ýþø [åZãÛ àIÔ<NO?.*x
<L+®k®E µY¶·|¸ïG< -*L- ,.H12 ýþø ò<
:,B CDE<»<?uG ë./¾"¿wA:
d@ÐÑÐ
< d{|¶<ë+òrA ÒL+<Hkv+,x.
KL,A²
¢k3-<)A7A
d33`-wA Òno --)ýþø»?
Ì4íòr<Ó.
«¬3*"¿ d ,Ì4íGL-*P
ü ,3¢¡'3.0/
0 5678Ò²
A<²L-*X Ô<)<=>L+,.1 2Pø *<
«$A3*bc
!"#$%&
'()*+,#-./012 3456789:;<=>
$?@A,-.'B#C@D 3E3FGH,$I2,JK'3$L A3$M A+G:;$I NOPQRSTUVWXYZ[Y\
]\^P'_`a`bcde,JKfg LEh:ijkH,lmn o pqr$sA/t uv#wx$yz{|$}~m+`
+lm'H,v~v/
t
3$
H,v/H,,H
n,n3Gp$Cb
:' :¡zv$I 2¢£¤'¥q3$¦G¤/
§¨fg©ª«¬no ,Hn®¯h°¤±
²,³H,#m´$µ¶e·JK ,fgL$¸¹kHºiH
»¼½i,$B#¾l#¿C®À Á9*+H,9Âà hH,TUÄÅÆno,#C³
ÇJÈÉÊhC/tHuv ËÌÍÎÏ6Â#hHÐÑÒÓ ÔÕÖרÙ'CGAHÚ Û,#ÜÝ/¦GÞt%&h
3ß$32H, àCáâ#/ã;3Gä¦
§¨:;'¥åAæt çèã;é,êëì/í.îH rï/ðñòYóïôã ä
H,v:õöé,÷øGùú ûüý$$hþ<Éy
ßH,v$I2:;¢
Æjkã;ãH, Eä¦G9$UV W0d' #/F/Cã;
,#¦G/tãH,¡z ,AG$`
æ~äG$ã;h
$ã;»¼nh,#³
Enh'w/(G
ÚCw/hÆ
³VW$H,~v /H,êë# +#¯$Ók H,$I2ã;:zG°¤
ãH,ä:H,$ãH ,'))w3+/GY YPðY]\^PH, ìâ'ã;3;Ö×#m´$
`G$YYQOV p£¤'#
nã;´C/tö '©H$ã;' `Gã H,w½ihF$Cã H,EY\'½Ge3ç~
ã3H,d
ÂAGXYZ[Y\33 2§¨#H,h$F +Á9$*ß$I28 :;<#$2
+£¤é3zGC /:;<=ã;$2H, ')F/ 3$`+
ã;$H,'+z(G
$ 2G$§¨ã;
'ô$ãH,®w G/
ã;$I2H,9ÏÚâ
$F·H ìâhH,
$Cõ/G($ /AGH;Ö×#l$3h
ïðñòYóïäC/
;Ö×#m´MË3 6ã;?#Ä +
ã;,3Ö×,
!"
#"$%&'()*+,-./01 23456789*+:;<=>
?@ABCDECFG<)H%
IJ(K-LM:NOPQRS TU>VW1X2YGZ[<\](
^_`CabcdeD )1fZg)hijklmnop:qrs 9tuvwxECyz{|}~
,-/abCz{
)>Co<
"H(Zg12Y:N
z{C78):
7~^@Fs9
¡¢£78¤¥¦J§J)¨©ª«¬
@®¯:7°P±L
²U³´µ¶·¸%&'1~
,-¹D:N^º]7<1Z[»¼·
½y@¾7¿~ÀÁ) 2\]"H(C¿~ÀÁà ÄyÅÆ<Ç]:NÈÉÊË²Ì Íάabcde¬f7®]
ÏÐ97:ÑCEÒÓDÔ^ÕCy Ä9Ö×$ØÙÚxÛaÜÝÖAÞGßà áâ)Kã"h"ä1åæ SçG èå)éx2½CêëÀÁ)~ìí<
Ä9èå$îCe2~ï¬f78 CZ[<)%&'ðiJI¦ñU ¬C<çG:N^º]ÀÁ
<ò]7f¿~ÀÁ)Ô^Õ CçG¿óôÞWDWEõ7DG ö÷X2ï¬ ÀÁø¬12ùF úÄ9^uûeG½CüýòC y]¿~ÀÁþÂÇ®/:
~^@C:N^º]b<
D \]<W
½Ô~^@ÕC :N^
º]^z{& o¦HCE ÀÁÂ:ѽyÔ@Õ ÔºÕÔRÕ]ÄyDÈ
)8EW7Qe2D )s2
::@e¿~ÀÁþ X®¶¬¾§<
î12:Ñ eÅCÀ Á<»¼e)}
Ѿ:/?:RC:NC y¾7?Rêe&k èå::×làUW1ÀÁ )¾:/é@D1DC y 7:Ñ(
Cy:N»¼:
ºP)<ÄyÔD Õ¿~ÀÁr<~´µ GÄyC ½C
¿~ÀÁø¬12aܼa W78ÀÁa¬C
:UfDGEG
ÂD
$½CD
ho*¾Ó~
Ã4~u9
¿òEÅÆ º¤b)éÅ
C C bz
{s:²¬Eûe2 G½CD\] 7X2 2ÔÕC:¾^- Ã4~u:N^º]à@
¯Qò/
½u¾
$):NOP/
)¿~ÀÁ)þÂe2~
,-)4D CDE:N^º]
f4}7)?
R7é@
~^W1 ^
!"#$%&'()
*+,-./)012345#$
6,7879:
8;<=>);?@A>BCDEFGHI :JKLMNOF PQPRSTUVWS BXYZ"[!"\)G]<=^
_/)`abc!defghi!jk l)mnSo3V3TpSqS)WrVs tGEFuv;bwxy%z>x{
|}!de~%z/)
5G!deB<=
?@A )
=)<=|!?@Ah!v
T?@h ¡hB!(
¢£fg!¢¤eF $¥!)WrV F¦9:§!de¨©Z)ª«Z¬
®¯j°!)!±b²³) N?@´µ¶·¸¹
¥!WrVF º»9±¼!½¾
¿\)À«<=±M5ª«)Á<=±M 5Â<=~C/)ÃÄÅÄ!d¢£)fG«
Æ<=K)=)ÇÈ<=)
<=¢#$ª«<=ÉÊkËÌÍÎ G;Á<=>«!±
B<=¥ÏFÐ)WrVF¦
9ÑÒ:§'ª«<=¨©ZÓÔ
®ÕÖ×/£~C;Â<=>ØÙ Úl/$)¢¼
,Û®Z !ÜÝ)Þ|ß ,àáÛi5âTE#$7 ã!),<=^_5$Fä å×
æ¬/¢¢¼æ¬·»fG!çè 6 )éêb²NëìZA%F
¢)¦Aí!_<=îï)ðñZ
ò!±<=îï¢#$º»
ì/)!;óô>WrVõK
½¾6¼/$ö÷øùú!~D ûKWrV"üý h¼) 665*+""/)WrV !þS 'Ù),!½¾ä
G)m23gy!欷»
<=N! ûe),àá à!Û/±¼6±¼!)`abx ,àá²à ÞM)!/¢)õ
£¢#$欷»§ Ãb 5]!Ìä ),g%z'(
/£/$¢e±¼!
,àá)8iJä£dJ)`abx
!¢E¥Ï#$E
¹!± Ð)G?"[ñ¢
¼ÑÒZiJG! ûe£ /$!/
£)fgH rm,XY j !/$ Õ/$¥!,XY ÄSEFFÐ)fgàá·¸
Z!¢5¢)jkJ k 5#$/E/)6±¼X YÙ!çE#$7 ã8æ¬ä $oV3è
欷»¬/);fg`a!deA
¬((5)=)<=)ÇÈ<
=!¼fGÂ<= ±>¢¼;Â<=
>5#$²HI /£fgbhi÷E#$)
¦9:§!F $¨©ZÓÔ/)®
Õä $6¼/$ú!`abx
!#£;eí>)¢¼6
§¹±M:J;>
;>CDEFHI/£¢¿\)
`abx'ÙÑÐ!Öä $ Á<=HICä ((M)Ù¦9 :§!Â$!Öä $¨©ZÓÔ F ((¢¼)ÂÁ<=G J$bcÂ;éê
)8 B>);Ê^{>y!;>
!/£)fg;¥A>);?@A>B
/)Øb! ??F6/$hi
«ß!±¼O Ee$Eäº/E#$fg!£)6
|ßG;Â/¢>i¤
!de? !E/$M)`
%ÊEFñ-
!"
#$%&'()*+,-.
/012345678(93:;<
=><?@ABC4 !DEFGHIJ K(LJMNJO(PQO(MRSTUS(VW XS(YQZJ[\]^_*+`ab cdef(ghijk(lm_]noc pqrstu\Bvw/01xby z {B|z}~(WQ(JJ(R SX ([IS\(;!$
]^_(Fg
}(<?Bg}(
<?hi#BC
K ¡¢[]^<?K
J£J¤¥¦(§;¨©ª««B¬b Hv ®B¯°glm_
±²³´Bµ¶w·¸¹Bº»¼
½)¾¿
B<À<?xÁlbBC(§;
¨©ÂÃHVÄÅ[ÆÇÈ)BÉÊ}(
]^<?xÁËÌBÍάbHÏ Ð È)§;¨©ÑyHÒ´BÓ zHÔÕÂ&¥Ö±×BØC(Ù
;,ÚÛÜzÝB®gH]^<?
Â&:>Þß%(È)§;¨©Ñ yHàát5âã}äå}ÞÔæ çBØCè8géb}([ISo cÎØµ¶
êëìíg}~½îƾ) ï¬ðñ) BòÃó(ôbÏ Ð&èÂõö?÷øùª¶}
ú>B¿ûhüvý g st jkógþ}ÞH z}~(VÄÅ[È)BHlm_
¿ûvýocB
¦ (Hé }(«B :HªgÌèB
?~¶gHèg(<?@A
BC4¦(ºJf
ÐLJMNJOIJK&]^_
<?Bo|}(WQRSX
&lm_ìíxÎ?B}
<?$BC(*+,-./0BH
h BCªgXUS
&_<?BstHóg
Þlm_g_]^<?hiB¬bH H(¿93:;
v B }~8z}~(¿
93:;íE
g8stB }~8¿ÈbÛ ]^<?zHis¿
]^<?~*+xHªgB
C(¿~Ù;gBHª g;!Bo|Hª¶} !º BH(<?)
?B °<?Ù;gB µ¶æB-./0xH]^<?B
#}(ÂÂ~Ù;\}Þ
&C(]^<?ÚÛÜuBb6Á }ªgt¦(&Âg8¶gX US&_q°ñ8gè~8 lm_%k_g]^_ ;¦
f }8<??H(
Ù;,-.ÚÛÜ/0ébB}
C(Ù;,ÛÜg*+,/0 BClm_BÏgè
WQ&lm_û«CèÂ(
ú>lm_ûg~à8´
ªgt93:;( &
é©§;¨©\먩BJ[}
}8B?~¶g}(Ù hi§ØocÊg"#
)\B~&o|sth iÂfg8¶<?BC4 !<(]^_glm_ðñg2à
rstóg}(¿FB st°z}~(¿Bî°~
stB~8¿ë !¦
f»¼stj
;!Â&,
!"#
$%&'()*+,-#./
01 2&!"#3456) 78-9:./ &;
1
<=>?@ABC?DEF&GHI;
78-JKLMN9&OPQR STUVRWXYZ[?D\O]&^_
`a\WXbcd*@AJKef:.
&g)hijk; Jl&mn ZoLFp;qrstuv)wg):x ycz{d&| &}y/
#<~;uw ~&`O
):W IJK
I
?Dn n R¡RL¢£
¤£¥¦§¨L&¤©;
:L&ª«¤¬(:L&®
¯ °fC <=>?
#±²³J´µ:c¶&ZoL 7.·¸¹º»¼½¾¿ÀJ#³ J/)·¸ÁÂ#ÃÄ Å c¶&ÆWJ4·¸ÇÈÉÊIËÌ ÃÄ&·¸ÍÎL#Ïo `O):
³J´µBÐÑÒ´Ó&Ô+,I;
Ò?JZoJ&Õ¨ËÌJb
¯Ö³J´µ×ØÙ
ÚÛÜÝÞ &>?ß³J JKLMN9&:+,-78-àáJ KLâ&Ôãä:(/#
cå&æçèÅné78-êë#
³J´µÑÒ´Ó&ìuw íîï_ðañ_ò_óOô_
)<õöz#M÷&øù78-&Ô
¯kúûüý g):L þ#;éB
;¤&é78-
û<=>?@AJKL#´
å&#&I JKL&mnÄçIR_T _&Ô N:
Iû:+,-îB;
ÄçIR_TL´
:78-<=>?û
î 78-:w(;L;:
´ & ?D·}bÐE
?;EF &L´
4§¨ î &<õöz:J K&mLIþ;ÔÃÄ;
_¤b[k é0çè ?D#(
c;78-:+,-<õöz û&uw0#g)ÝÞ
&:<=>?/)?#Y(
;&Âw!"ä#)w N:!")
cå&æ³JJKLM÷&mn+,- Ô78-ëD{N:~;
_&@ß
&ëî <&`Oa
\ña:î78-9:
kJK÷//JK
÷&LIEpFÃÄî Jl÷L&ÐE?
JbJå#JK÷®L
§¨ ÔO _R_T_\)+,-:
çJ#JKL&®;
J¨£ F&LIFáJ KL:ÀJåEp&' (?Db:JKL Ñ২ <=>?{/
)¨*78-¯JKLM#JK÷&
uw:)/; /N&
?DL/) L4
!"#$%!
&'()*+,-./0123 456789:;,*<5=>?@9 ABC*D,E5FGHIJ9KLMN OP9>QRST;)UE-V W5XYZ[O\]^_`ab,cde fg*AG5Fhi5jkl0mnop5=
Aqrst*+,()uN,) 9Ib,vwxy)ztA{|}A
*+,-~S*
b,/5=5=
,5=>?@st$%{
()9
6()*+, )UE-(;UN5=
U¡9¢N£E¤¥¦§b,¡;¨
©ª«¬¤¤¥®)¯°*¯±
5=78²³b¤¤¥®´µ9
¶D,-·¸95= 9¹º,2¸) SR)»¼ 9½¾b,-¿À5=
78¸lb,5=>?@|}JÁ
¡/Ãlb,ÄÅ)'Æ ÇÈt9É¡Ê/ËAÌÍUU-
ÎÏrÐ9ÑU{¡ÒÓ*+,-Ô 9Õ;9*Ö×E9Ø9¹º ,ÙmnÚÛ*ÜÝÞ,5
=ß5=¤*àDAáâ
)¢NU,-(EãäAåæ&
çè9éU<,A*Aº5 ê*ëìí/,A*A<î9P78 ïØðñ9òå·ó)ôTõ')u N,×D*+,-E"*rÐö55=
ß÷ø)%ºùúû9òå5=
ßüýþ%<¿9v N<U,-°%U *
2b,;rÐ{
,×D*+,)uN,-(9ß
9Îx)û¸Ö×ÒÓ
U-
{rÐ9ÑU-ß?*³ b,d Þ*+%;¨, I5=r)U
9Ib,³A*+,-' vwüW)UE¢NW9d
<AU-)UE5=¯±
2mnh3mn
"mn"mn°ÜÝb, E9Ø8L*ÎÏ mn Þ"9nÏ ùC^mnA {
U- 0mn)A
,(mn0
0 ¼ö50 *د±8L*QA*
+,-?mnÚn5Æ5)V5j*
b, 9ÑUùC U()3l¹%)UE 9/{y9, ÃU°m'5=9¹ º,mn)AUU ,-寱8LvwÈ b,'º*<
jÀ9b,
')UE()A*D,*U'æE¡-
90L£E
º,¡-({*ÒÓE9rÐj Àö55=ß9,
A'5=9¹º, º;¨
,LrÐq)U,-L;, ß)ö55=ß
9ÑÑgr°ßL9
AU,-E"*
0LÞUU
¡-9IjÀgr5
=ß'9I
5=q9{*Þ¡
%)UEϦoÑ5
¡/¯±#
!"#$#%&'(
)*+,-./)-012)34 -5678/)9:0;<8=>?@) A<B?@CD)EFG)HI-J8KLM /
N80OPQR*ST8UVWXY0?
Z[)\@-L8]^_V`a)Lb2 :HIWcd0ef8gh*0ij;klm
;Zno:pq;<)r*stuvD/0
;)wxy5z{*|}~%
L0 3)0;
<0;%-(;
)0;j<)u0
<<;< ¡y5z{¢T8=
>;£¤¥¦)0§Y:¨©(|}
ª«§Y)¬ %XY0;®¯)°
±p²:L³´hµ-¶·¸q /?Q¹º8»;<)¼;
)½<CD¾%ST8UVWXY0½;J¿¾
?@)A<B%ÀÁ(ÂÃÄ)½ÅÆ)Ǿ -*h]^_V`a9È
NÉʥ˯ÌLMÍ8OPÎϳ
*Ð;;<ѯ*ÒÓÔÕº%Ö
/)0רÙ*ÚD)ÛMÜ%ÆÝLhW
$#:*OPÞß);<Ñ0dà>
Ð;;<ѯÐ;)áâ)ãäåæ%ç
XY0hW×èé% ³)L%éê Wë?Q0dà>Îì);
®¯8=>Ð;)íÀîï:·Óð0ñòj) 3óô)õö÷0øuùU 0;<Ñ2
)ú*ûü;ký-;kË¥þ8í Àîï%d(Ì\:Æ>MVµ Wr)%XY0t:Ð;);
<Ñ2%0)8 Vµ%
t;<)EFÚ0 º0
m ;< N 0 º00t;
<?@)A<B !í"\#wÚ$®0 º00%&"½'Á(Àï)
*+¹0,?+¹¾t'Á +¹wN-.0º0 /01½ !;<Ñ)2<¾34
;<?@)A<B !í"\#w
Þ?@)<LM)<G