授業の様相－解釈的研究－歴史の授業を事例に－

全文

(1)½¾h¿Àh. ÁÂÃhbc. Ä ÅÆ. . Ä ÇÈ. ÉÇ rÅÊ. ÉssËj ÌÍ. .

(2) . . . . . ! "#! $ % $ $ ! ! &$ $ ' ( )' % * $ $ + &$ * ",! $ ' -* % .! /. 0! % .!-$ .! ' . .

(3) .

(4) . !. "#$$%&' ()*+,-./,01234 25 %678 69:;,<=2>()*, ?@ABCDE. F2GHIJKLMN, OP:. ; QR%STRUVWXYSZ[\] 6;^_2,`62

(5) =a$62!bcMNSde2fUghijklmnh ojkYSpqS rstuvwxySXYSzY 1,x;{ |TR 69RY}~

(6) b?@tu

(7) , 26,26RU >SXYShj tu,hj ZGH,QR ,26X mhj?@M NK,y2

(8) 26f6 926RUY¡¢2Z[\ ,£`QR¤h

(9) 2

(10) %¥126f6U¦§ >¨Llm©ª26R«¬®¯°±I²³´ 6; 9oSTRU µ¶·bT¸fSM¹) ¯º,»w¼R :y2.

(11). ¨. ©. .

(12) . !.

(13) "#$%&'()*+ ),- ./012+3456,$%,78 &' 9:;<=>?@AB- .CD9E@A,FGH H#IJ8K( ,=>?>LM@NOPQRST,UVWXY

(14) ZTB[\9$%]^ _àb,cdaefagS,hi j+ #ek(]

(15) )lm4 nB- op\ .. .

(16) . ek9$%,eqr,stuv+[ "#w!x+(k -y$%&' zS{|}~+ [ ,,2

(17) .ek9hiH

(18) ^ [ ,4 e,tu,ehiQaayW,- hiT e&W j+[ B4 .C B[, ek,¡L¢£¤¥¦>§¨©¨ªB,«¬® ¯ey°±40.¨©9²³´,ekµe¶j+· ,¸¹ºb»¼½¾ ¿·,ÀÁe¶k+eI, j+ Â,$%,ÃBÄÅÆÇÈÉ±ÊyËÌ Ê #ÍÎ(Ï ÐÑz

(19) . [[ek,Òd,ÍÓH

(20) ÔÀÕ3]".ek9Ö× eØÙÚÛÜehiÚÝÞ .ehiÚ9$%»ß,e ,àáâ,ã· »ä+ .×å9$%»ßQæç#X èW)( é½T,e»ß,êÑ&QÑëì íîïðT¿·,ã·,ÀÁ&

(21) .áÞ$%]

(22) ®

(23) Þ\0ñºòóô»¼½¾

(24) .k,eñº),12+34),9n·õ/0e e,9ö÷Wk0.ø,eÆÇ,Ú9,$%,ÆÇ f¯ùj+ñº op\ búû»½

(25). Q³<,üZ&,ýT.ek,³þ9Z¦BÈ,

(26) ..

(27) *+æR ð 6ñLòA. . ÂÊ.

(28).

(29) . !. "#$%&'()*+,-$. /0(*+,-

(30) 123456789:;<=>?@ABCDE F)*+GHI $JKLF*+$=>?MNOP= >?>QRSTUOBM$. 0VMNWFX YZ[ E\]^)0FX /3_à]^ =>?Fbc'()%& *+def*+de#OTg'() hijklVmno$pVqrU I OstuvLwlxyOwzI

(31) {|} /~3$U) %&*+F %&,- _?I / st8*+fVDo$

(32) / ~FF 456789OJ ¡]^( I /8¢£FIx¤¥F¦g'(H§'( ¤¨L H§F~ O$. /o)©ªE,~45«¬} 0OYZ~ Ox®LF¯(I 0?.°±²$~I/. .

(33) ³D´µ¶8·l¸ ÂÃÃÄl h ÂÅ h ÂÆ. ¹º¸H§. »¼½¾\¿À Á . ©ªÇ h iÈ/É*+de]^ =>?Ê hÃË. ÂÃÃjlfjkÌÍk iÌFbc'(I /ÎÏÐXÑ FX / ÒÓÐfÓÔÍhÕÖ× ØO3x89Ù5fÚÛÜ'o~¿$\¿À Ý'~V° )VÞßàáI /»¼½¾7o \°)âãäfåx ÜæOçè$Ý'(~I]^)éêëì]^) I°)MNOíI /éêëì]^)IQßFîï?í{.

(34) Y. É. \. Ê. Ë. .

(35)

(36) . !"#$%. !"&'(#)*+,-. ./0*1"234*5#"(6. 7

(37) 89: ;<=>?@&%AB"C<*DE4. "$F. #"G. 89*HIJ#)*+,-*KL&M=>?@CN.OPQ R*ST=5U#"F. '(-J. V

(38) WXYZ !*[\ J. . . ]^_*àbc&deG"Gfa-. #;<#g*h![\.iF. #C<.mnjoi5F G#[\pq"2rs. *jkl.. *j=>?@&%AB<ji5F. #". '(J. t

(39) Y:uvw xyz[*{|&}~#=>?@"G jG! ".i *'( *'(7*j4"+,-*'( Zj# *'(.+,-*'(`d.*'(- j+,-*'(**}~'(&B-*j4xy-+,-j# * i¡¢£¤P¥+,-. ¦§F+,-. ¦,G*. ¨©ª«¬-

(40) jU+,-5U7'(®¯°* §

(41) & ". F7±² ³ :³.´µ¶°*·. '( 4 #¸'(Bi,#'(*¹º* +,-.

(42) »¼.xy'(#/0{|&½xy*)#¼' (¾¿Àj47¶°*·'(-¸4@#ÁÂ+,-,G* ¨©ª«¬U7'(uÃ#¸*'(&} ~

(43) #ÄÅ#ÄÅ*Æ@"@*ÇÈj4.

(44) 12Ø ÙÚÛ. #X.

(45) .

(46) !"#$ %&' !"()*+,-.. /01234 5' 67089#:;<=> /0?@99#ABCDE0FGHIJK ?

(47) LM

(48) +.

(49) NO#P Q-89

(50) +.. 0NOE0RSE TU4V( 99WX

(51) ; <=> !NWP+<= ( LM

(52) YW#Z <= (0SE[\ TU4V Y]$

(53) Y^. (_ Y^ `]Wa b. -.

(54) ,cU. 0de [ fg ;.

(55) 0hiJSE. [\Z<=j (kl`mn.a0d6op( ?. LM

(56) . qrs0b12tu

(57) vJwESE[\ xyz{/0 LM|}

(58) 0~gz['[0SE[\

(59) Q- zFG V(K0(yz0 ( [ SE[\0 `??

(60) 012 ¡¢£( Vq¤¥ ¦§JJ ¨ ©ª0«¬ ¨®¯[ ( F° avJwE(K [LM±K[

(61) 0+. . ²³cUSE

(62) 0;´q (µ¶)wc '[ Z. Q-0hi·¸`Da(K 0?

(63) b²¹º». `¼½e

(64) wcw¾/(·¸½'[a(¿ÀD /0 b12ÁÂ(Ã¾fgK `;. (Ä mÅ.a¼`½ea. Æ. Ç z0È89

(65) . Ç 9É;

(66) ÊË0 {Ì(KÍÎ(5Ï ÐNnÊË(Ç 9ÉÑÒ ½z0ÐÅJ9Y$ Ó

(67) µÔ(Ç 0ÊËÍÎzÕÖ 60!Y$ #×$ ]

(68) ÊË(Ç 089·Ï .

(69) $:. }. b. º. .

(70) .

(71) !"#$

(72) %&'()*+ ,()%-.

(73) /012345+. ()"6$7$ 89$:. $ ;<='>?@AB<CD'<1. E%&

(74). !F

(75) FGHI%JKL

(76) F* QRI%S,TD'<1 +. U V$W

(77) X<*. M?YZ%[\]5^_. à$ZbX<. M%Zb%cde=,2f'gh+ Zb45. M%NO'P. "aa

(78) 2

(79) 2. M%

(80) 2

(81) 2,Zb%ciNjk5Ê%. l!F* a mF%45X< nopq

(82) 2

(83) 2 3rs%5^ Zb[\3tuvwx+ "ay" aW,no<= 87 zpq3{|}~*+ p~%' ` 7a Zb ()3*2<5^tuB'

(84) M%45 Z%%3, c'!j*2()

(85) >? %?

(86) <

(87) 1. F%45777:p. q{|}~X<3125^ {|}~

(88) 2

(89) 2p%[\k+. 7;,pq. rZ%gh.

(90) _I<5^*< %NO' <=+j >?5^3B'>?5^

(91) >?2 *2. ¡¢. , j>?2

(92) . E%lU%GHI'£+*¤¥_12. U0>X<. Zb

(93) 2

(94) 2no312¦§[\k5^

(95) Nj*2. . M%NO')%¨©y%ª«f%¬0>'Zb[\ y®¯312¦§B<°±%¬

(96) <?M3

(97) 3?2. . 2e=,%tA%_I)²³M3,2¡¢ rF

(98) GHI%J%mFP´_ I&%e=,'µ)%¶·

(99) ¸0123NO. 2 ¹.

(100) st5ï ð ñò>ó¿. e|.

(101)

(102) !"#$%&

(103) '()*+,-

(104) )."#/01!23 45. .5&6789:!;5<=>$?@ ABC0D"E. F,-:!GHI. !J. KLMN. OPQRSTU. effgT hhi hjk. VWUXY. lmn opq. Z[\]^_` abZc'd. rstuv]wx!678do foy. hzzpT{|}~pf}1!J5 " "!J ~ep 55k56A.IB. 4

(105) )!J k 59 ¡¢ k5£¤ ¥¦I§x!¨©Iª«¦!J.¬8# !5$ ®¯°±H²I!5³k¨©$´.5$®^_ÌµB!5³ ´.¶·I¦!J e |~jf¸ 5¹º

(106) »¼½

(107) 8# !5$®^_Ìµ4´.5³ I¾¿1!J¥¦)85IÀÁ).2Â$85´ÃÄ: Å.ÆÇIÈÉÉ$85

(108) Ê:Å.ÆÇ$75xËÌI8#

(109) Í ÎÏ).t¡ZÐIÑ@

(110). Ò0$³´. ´.ÓÔIª. «¦!J¢ÕÖ)$ 1×Ø$³´.¢I$³´.Ëk Ù©Ú´. ´.¹º8¦!J.Û¬Iª«Ä01! "#$´.5Ñ@I$®Ü$5³$®¬Ýª«^_Ìµ4´ .5³ #Þ¶8¦!J ßj h~zhàá âãIä56785¹º

(111) åæ)k8# ).5ç 5U èIé)³´.Ñ@IÜ$³´. #&

(112) Qê¶· )ëì) !J678.ÆÇZÐ½Ií)5Ìî. ¡Ë$³´.

(113) Ë. Ó. Ô. Õ. Á.

(114) !"#$$%& !'()*+,-./012' 341/0+5 6789:1;'1<=>? @#$#AB"#C$DE& FGHIJKL1MN>?HO.PQ1R STU V WX1

(115) +R S&YZ PQ.[S \]1^_àbcdef1ghijklm1H1? k kkn1olmap1q >? rsH.; tNRkuTU;vHIJ1wo

(116) ko' x4Ryz_{ |}~ HIJ.v|;1A'( #C#%"#C %& )*1+S

(117) kg1q' |&nR<=WXe+Z1 g1)*.zk

(118) + ?R+¡s¢£¤¥¤¦fz§ ¨¦fg©ª )*nRg«¬.®5 C ¯ |;)*.®°«& °±«&|.;y_k1 ?²³´µ|.¶q ·+.)*g1qnRgR¸g |°¹º²]g1 »«;¦f¼½|DE1¾«¿B1À «knÁ|Â¬«gÃR ®|.ÄÅ¥¤D®gÆ)*1À¹º]g Çy|dÈÉÊ0sdÈa;<= Æ#ËÌ nR1gÂ¬«g.D±«DE°«DA±« ;y_q .k ÍÎ+®«gÃ1qnR'(.¼½| C «g1;1 É±¹º²g1 #«q)*.%±²Ï ±«®¹ºgDE##CÐ#+ÑÒnR.

(119) ¨ " ®¯°. ,4.

(120) . !"#$ %&'()*++, -./. )01,2 31,45&)*1678.9:/#)*;<7, =7>? 1678=77.@ABCD*E)*;3F7G <+7-?HI 9: JKL JM/M/#NOP*;31>7/<>> Q<>R=>-=> 4 /<> G=>- SQRT/<R 8 <0R,/<R 7 Q<R >=R G/<R R=R- ? UO. <1R 2VWX. YZ . !"#$ %&'. ()*<1.SQR 4 =G85&)*3FG 2<1V@ABC )*Q[G7.<08 +3->VE)*\]^ _àb*_a cd9:_eV) fg!hVi j.)*k) l_]bm 9:.n* V oDpeb*HI q` rOp]stE)* uQv +3 31J9:J mJmb*wa` I Q<8 T 7./)xyD*;<18 TR 3F8 TG ++8 8G? 8,?. 5/;018TG z8 T- 3Q8,8 318,2? {|D*;<v8 E) %&.})*9:~]V)* q]pe l ab*<8,-sab* HP Vjm. !.$mD* ab*q9:. z 31J/#Ok.eVu])* _]aHPPpel ab* aprO )m 9:j EUP)H) .NOP*n. _à !" #$ %&'() rm})m UP )HI OP)%&) r r}n.NOP*M a9: jJ !.$*Jr}c 9:J ¡ JM/M/# r}n.¢£¤¥ H¦ ^§ ÜrrO 8 ©ª«¬) n.NOP*.

(121) . «. ¬. . `.

(122) )!. !"#$%$&'(. *+,-./0123%$&45. .;01</9. 6789:!. *+. ! =>?!@A:!. B+. %$&*CDEFG&HIJEKGL)MNOPQRGST UV9. !. B+WX<JG):!. %$&*C&YZ(9. ![:!. B+YZ23X. B+DE\\ST&HI. ]^QD\_&HISTMNOà[7bc 9. !. B+de\ f23ST&HIbg%$&G9. B+h*]^&bi9. (Z!. !. B+jk67l!&ST&HIF. i)!Smno6pqrsGt'B+./01dd\uGST L)):vwxy! L)ST&HI{|9. B+JE\ z]^. !{|G&HI!. B}:!. B+~. (7DQ h&HIGi{|GbiSTGiL)Gi) !L)&HI*. Hl{|G&HI*. 4DE_ &HI]^):! . H9. !:!. B+W. B+,-&<_ . B+ <EzPQ D z7&9. (Z! G&HI*'G~Z! !. H[G)!. !dD_ \'(de uh f i)! B+<E&/i[V):!. B+h*ST&9. (Z. B+dDu _UVV):! B+<u&V9. !:!. B+.01&HIGiSTGi{|Gi G/i G/i)!. B+YH7./014G)!. .b01dDG VST9 )!. . !. B+. B2. +.01Q<fGUVSTX7. ):!G>7*G ¡* B+YY'(G%$&79 *'$H'G~Z!. Hl):!. (Z!G>7. B¢£DEf_¤fDQfu<fz. DEf \_¥¦f \<f \ £<§f f\DQf \f£<Ef Df zddfJEf\z¨+JEf\zMNO9. !©ªv.

(123) RS ê ë ì7ík. JI.

(124)

(125) . !"#" $%&'()*+,-./0"#

(126) 12. 34 5678 +"9:&; &>. <=&>. $%&>. . ?#"@A,BCD&EF+"#

(127) GHIJK<=&?. #"LM NO%8?#, P"#

(128) QRS@A,BTU-V1WXYZ[Q\! ]D"*^ "#

(129) 8_àb cd,-&ef8g#hi8jk+"'(. &+"#,34@A!+, l8mn8op+qj#78?# "#,@A,B !+,`r s

(130) `&t(+"#, uv<=ww9:x *^&yz{|+,}(P,$%~&P,` (P,A P,, '(!"#, EFd

(131) +#P"q Ujkz #P,v`#2

(132) 8+#

(133) -#x,+". # ¡P,¢*'( £8!

(134) QRS ¤0,-#¥*¦&C§+"G¨J©vª« ¬ W'(àb $P,-xG®I ¯°v_± &"²à b cd

(135) ¥*&+,-x ³´8P,#D

(136) G®I ¯° 834op+"#

(137) vÏ ¯µ¶`&*Vª-P,

(138) -ª·x ¸¹º»8¼¥zP,jk d,-# ½¾¿ÀÁ. ÂÃÄ2. ÅÆÇÈ. ÉÊËAªÌzZÍÎ. IÏÐ Ï I[vÑÒÓÔRSÕÖ8×Õ0"##x ËCD

(139) @AÎJI¯Ø. Ï¯¯K. ÔRSÕÖ. Ï¯¯°vKÙÚÛ°°Úx8ÜÝ0"#

(140) Þ. ß^$¥àáâã8¥

(141) w1ävä¨ÛÏÙåHx 34 Qæº»vAªÌzç#&+,u,BèéB&CD

(142) x&!.

(143) W>. ·. ¸. ¹. º.

(144) . !"#$%!&'()* . +,-./ 012+" 314+5678 9:;<=>?@A?>BCD EF+7GH0. !I

(145) JKLM!" . +,-.!NO 0P QR,S 0 +TU78 9:V<=?WXBAYZC@D XB+ ,-.

(146) [\]^0LM!" + _`

(147)

(148) ,ab S +c3d BC+ ef ] ,S,-.!ghi jk!" 9:l<=Ym@Ano@D EF+ =pqrst

(149) D,-.+ef ] u !v wS,-.!xi yz.

(150) {|}~ {|!+(0 ! K ]^ efS ]^ efh . . JKLM!EF

(151) + S ux!(u !56 7 LM EF LM

(152) e > nS VLM

(153) V S LM+,S=;

(154) m D / ¡d:¢ <S

(155) £LM+¤¥¦" :e<S

(156) §ËF+;LM! d m m© +LM! ;LM!

(157) ª©SEF

(158) ¢LM + ¡«LM¬

(159) eS LMQ!56 . 12! I . +¦C®¢

(160) l£LMS®¯ C@

(161) V B° ±² C³ ;LM!+ ´µ¥eL M+¦:;< ¡«LM

(162) EFS«LM¶

(163) l©S. :.

(164) vw±² ³´$µ¶. 66.

(165)

(166)

(167) . !"#$%

(168)

(169) &' (. ! )*. (+,

(170) &'-. /0.123 456 78496.:;

(171) <=>'6 ?@46AB46 / CD3 &'6 E:;

(172) FG9H7I@61 (JKLM

(173) N

(174) @4HO9@H . 59H6%

(175) (

(176) P 5QH E 3. >'H 1@4? .:;

(177) RSTUVWXYZ=D[ \]Î@?6

(178) (FGJK_M ` a( bcd

(179) @4-AO0A/29-A.0AE2ef.

(180) 5QA645AHgVW3h

(181) ^! ij_ [kFGPl

(182) @m/ .9-/O0/628KK _Cn9@FG8KK( U=\ (\! VW (

(183) -/ A0/E0E72 9@4@E A:;

(184) P 45E 60E?0E1@4E E017g;opq

(185) @43 &'1 O 84Q1 .:;

(186) 4r1 6491HVWst

(187) ]nF G\u

(188) -1E2( vw(xy

(189) zLRS{vw b|}$%

(190) (~ VW (cd t vw(

(191) S ef8 ;_ _PK~ bt Ut

(192) U

(193) ]^ FG_~vw{$UFGt

(194)

(195) FG3$3et 0 b=U ~

(196) FGCnCD= (

(197)

(198)

(199) [ -

(200) 2@m=

(201) 9\ -

(202) 2(K_ M

(203) &'. 45 ¡-<¢2£( ¤8. ¥o¦§(¨

(204) 5Q© ªh-«2 -

(205) 2(

(206) ¬ªh-«2[\z

(207) =D® U¯°Ut

(208) CnI@. H -

(209) 2(

(210) [.

(211) /\. . . . .

(212)

(213) !"#$% &'()

(214) *+,- ./0 1/#$234567+% 89:;<=67 +'=> / ?:#$% 89:'@ABCDE FAGH/I1/67+

(215) 95JK;LM ANO@> P/ 2345

(216) *+,- /QRST% QRST1U'VL WU*LXY= Z[ *AQRST\?.\/\\9:% F AG.\ 11

(217) 89:'@1195JK;1U '] ^_4+ 11H\ "1I :% I?à

(218) 95JK;à=L()]7bc d eTfYghI/ i,jk

(219) I\:i ,jk% -l .I PmII" P0 ./ . \:2345% I:2345% ln FAoPmI p W% I :p W%FAG ?qRi,jk% rs:i,jk% tu, 47, vw=i,jk% 5xy:i,jU A,95JK;<z{WA=Lv w

(220) |}, vwi,jk% bcwu= ~ dTf*Avwbc m 2 345 à

(221) 2345Aà,U'=> / n 2345à

(222) 95JK23Aà,U'A = 47, 02345p W

(223) 95JK;=234589: L,2 345 p WU =LN,=U'A()] 7BC

(224) rs:. ! "% FAG. 95JKAoA:A=A] tu,K\.I"0 oA:A% oA:Avw% oA:A=U '7:U= U'=vw

(225) " 0i,jk.

(226) FGOÜ Ý Þßbàd. á.

(227) . . !"#$ %. &'(&)*+,-. .

(228) /0/012 3456789:

(229) ;<=>?@ABCD&EF GHI DJKLMN

(230) OP;QRESTUVWXYZ +[$\

(231) M]Â6W_àbcdS B$efg(&hij

(232) LMVTUklmAn D&5o=(pV/0ij

(233) cdq rDRM]Â6stuv&(w$Wx 5yz{|g}~58p(D&A>?cd ;(;

(234) ?T$;MDR Dg7(D&5X@|p/0?AFG$/0 '(D& V. . . $

(235) "BFG@ABC$

(236) {p

(237) ;<g]A{;=(=&K0rLMN

(238) {p&&KQR};MQR=4bcd( HbN5$ ¡p$¢ijTJ£l

(239) ¤;=(5LMNcd5¥¦b;QR&§¨SJK©ª;«¬ ($

(240) LMN

(241) ®¯>°±²³´ µ¶bT{´

(242) ·V5¸hK:;<¹º 5» =&(0r¼½cdij

(243) LMVT U¾¿£l,ÀÁÂ;ÃÄ$¹5&|;Å;(=& KÆ}~@(D&¹ºÇÈ;MÉÊ$ Ë Ì5ÍÅÎÏb;yz5Ð=(D&5qr&'7|5+¯Ñ$Òe ;/0VAÆÓÔÕÖ×{8FG$(Ø$

(244) ³}#$M]Â6(ÙÚÛNLMN

(245) µ¶b.

(246) . ². ³. ´. µ.

(247)

(248)

(249). !"#$% !&'()*+,-.(/. 0123 (

(250) 4567(89

(251) :(

(252) %;# <= >?@ABC

(253) !CDEFGHIJK.LM(NOPQ RSTPUVWXY;<=Z(#. [\(]^*_ "

(254) `. . !&'aZbcde #fghij klm Jn

(255) op(>?"fgHIPNq"rst#&'(BC % "

(256) 'u#\v*_. !"#d% w xrsy:z{.hi{|. y:}~(;Z

(257) !Cbc*_ x bc*x&'(V#'(BC

(258) %"

(259) V(N qZ

(260) -n!"#*8

(261) *(%'% 0;\hideK. . ;-J(`Z

(262) -BC

(263) ) ¡-¢n. hide. ¨C£©{ª«¬= ®¯ hide = ¿¯. £¶·¸¹º&. £hi¤:. ¥¦r§. °±²³´µ-¢n. hi»¼½¾<=£©{ª«¬. °²ÀÁhiÂÃ¬=rn. µÄu. £ÅÆÇ. -¢ -<=£©{ª«¬= ¯ xÈ a;x&'(`n"ÉPÊPËÌÍÎ· ÓÔÑÕ·Ö·×Ø-ÙÚF Û; ÜÝÞß. ÏPÐPÑÒ. (#_. . àá×"«â.ã²ä³åhi¬="àá×. æçè«©éêG. ® ëë. ìí;. ±î °ëï. ß;FGðñòZóôGõöö÷FGø`. Æùúûüý. x þ«âª"FGð*^?«â\Ä

(264) «è«Æùð«©«ð.

(265)

(266). .

(267) . . . . .

(268)

(269). .

(270) . . . . .

(271)

(272). .

(273) . . . . .

(274)

(275). .

(276) . . . . .

(277)

(278). .

(279)

授業の様相－解釈的研究 －歴史の授業を事例に－

授業の様相－解釈的研究－歴史の授業を事例に－