ビッグデータのオーナーシップに関する国際比較分析
8
0
0
全文
(2) > $?2< / ƛʼnƒ† Ƴǘɪ†‡ ƙɽû†‡ ʌŇ\ V±Ƨ,¨;^X{yeHG,Ƒòș*="%e`ʥ¡Ù*:ě%ǟǶǷ*ěÝ% 6 dQkY,ʕä*=? ,= )Ġʥ,e` C<@nbRe`Dö?Ů '&@=. *)?ÔnjǬ2,ƘŔˈ6"%% @ƛȑ&- ,nbRe`*6#C@ƲÔɼ£#6?nbR e`,MhXbr*ʮ%ƍȟƸ,LjÕŊ;ɴɱ,àĂ,ƅǨDɌ" ȩƢnbRe`,MhXb r*ʮ%-ƎȆ)ǚğe`I d Xq)Ȉ¥DĮǧ@ 9*-nbRe`ÔnjǬ*ʮ%Åʑ ,MhXbr,ɩɳDʡŨ% Ŝɔ@'ÒƎ . The International Comparative Analysis of Ownership in Big Data TOMOYA HONJO† MAKOTO YOKOZAWA†‡ TAKAFUMI KINOSHITA†‡ In recent years, as the price of sensor devices decrease and social media widely spreads, the amount of data has been explosively increasing. Moreover, it becomes possible to handle such a large amount of data , so-called big data, by the evolution of technology. Thus, the expectation of utilizing big data is increasing. In this paper, we tried to organize and analyze legal systems and current discussions regarding ownership in big data. As a result, We found necessity to foster the common understanding of ownership in big data.. ʌŇ\ V±Ƨ,¨;^X{yeHG,Ƒ ò*="%e`ʥ¡Ù*:ě%ŵʇD %ěÝ %% @e`ʥ-ŇǦ 40%&ěÝȬ2009 Ň > 2020 Ň,ʭ* 4 ¸*)@'ŻɜA% @[1] A *Ý Apache Hadoop *ɏA@= )Mr ^ Z^pfJKG;þs a >Ž°A@ɒćV nZ,¿ĮQJgU o|dH R,Ƒò'':* ,= *ǟǶǷ*ě C<@”nbRe`”DƯ )Îʤ&njǬ= '@ànjǶ*)"% 2013 Ň 3 Ɩ,Ogh,ɯƤ*=@'42%, IT a nbRe`*&*ŰʁD ,ɜǰ@'Ț % @6 Ĭ¸ÈʯǶɏ ƍƛÊɁŪdz-JAPAN is BACK-,&:nbRe`,ÔnjǬ,ŻʕD# ,ɔȤ'%§ȴ$%
(3) ?ƘŔDij % @ Ɗ&õʷA nbRe`Įʶ* A,:,& @, (,= )ÔǬúȻ&(,= )ɼ£ @, ' MhXbr*# %Åʑ,ɩɳ) ¯ .ÀƍJR Ơƍƛ IC NgʇÖ Suica ÔǬȺ, ʺʇ,ʇĽƼDæāä &ƍȔ*Ž° ' Ġ)ɧ˃DĆE ƕȦǷ*ÔǬȺ >,Ġ)ôǶ* =? JR Ơƍƛ-Ž°DŊºƹ @D ))" ,= *ƬȺ'ɃǎʀȺ,ʭ,ɩɳ,ʙ >n bRe`ÔnjǬʰİA@¯&%% @6 nbRe`*-rIlX,ċ˃:# %6C@Ġ ʥ,·*ʮC@e`Dö?Ů = *)"%@ 9 ADöŮ ƬȺ,ɼ£:ʣĠ*)"%@'ȹ >A. @ đ 1 *ȇ= *ƍƛ*
(4) @ţęǕNj¢Ƅ -«Ň Ƴ. &?2012 ŇéƘ&ƌ* 954 ¢D Ƅ ţęǕNjƹ6>) . ţęǕNj¢Ƅ. 1. . 1800 1600 1400 1200 1000 800 600 400 200 0. đ 1 ƍƛ*
(5) @ţęǕNj¢Ƅ,Żȍ ÍūˍƍƛjbfQ\P|dHê¥ţę\P|dHI Xe f*ʮ@ɯƤęĄƔ2006 ŇŊǠ > 2012 ŇŊé ƘʒęǠ=?űȠ. † ʟĠīĠīʳţęīȅȓȋ Graduate School of Informatics, Kyoto University ‡ ƥŌ¥ȈʤƝȮÿȅȓū Nomura Research Institute. E)ĒʶǷ*:e`´ɶLjÕ,ɕǻđ>A % @2012 Ň 1 Ɩ*- EU ƌĪ,e`´ɶŸ Dɖ ×*Ƨ@Ƀe`´ɶɖ×ƨDǶɏ 6 ȟ Ē&:MlwƃƲ 2012 Ň 2 Ɩ*ǎʀȺrIlXƲ ÔȕÇDǶɏ@)(·e`*ʮ@ǎʀȺ,ƲÔ Dŏä@àʅ"% @ þĒ,ȹ Ɗ; ɖÕ*-ł?e`´ɶÕŊ-ɓʸ):,')"% @,= *nbRe`*6#C@ƲÔ;ɼ£# 6?nbRe`,MhXbr*-ƎȆ)ǚğ. ⓒ 2013 Information Processing Society of Japan. 1.
(6) Vol.2013-DPS-156 No.19 Vol.2013-GN-89 No.19 Vol.2013-EIP-61 No.19 2013/9/13. ţęÌǨī¥ȅȓęĄ IPSJ SIG Technical Report ,= )ǣLJ&-ƬȺɇȲnbRe` DnjǬ e`I d Xq)Ȉ¥DĮǧ@',Ħ *)? +) &ƛȑ&-LjÕŊ&ɖĭA@nbRe`, MhXbrDƎ> *@ 9*ĒʶǷ)ɗǚ > LjÕŊ;ɴɱ,àĂ*# %ƅǨ@. 2.2 2.2.1 &7 nbRe`*ƎȆ*ĭ6" ĭȷ-) ȾĠ)e `DŸȇ%nbRe`'% @:, >ůɍ; Ɯ6&Dă9%ňȷ,nbRe`'% @:,: @ ,= )&[4]&-ƌĪ,ɃǷ)ůɍ&-Ȝ. 2.
(7) . Ǩ@'ďʹ)e`ȶ' ĭȷÅʑɩɳ& @'% @6 ɃǷ)ůɍ&ȜǨ@'ďʹ. ƛȕ&-ȅȓ,Ķɷ&@nbRe`,MhX. )nbRe`,ǢŚ'%aRIi 2001 Ň*. br' ƭş*# %ʍ3@. Ƕɏ ęĄƔDʅǓ*OfhȈ¡*ȇIJʥ. 2.1
(8) 0 +. (Volume)Ȑ˅(Variety)ʒŊ(Velocity),ˌ#D%. Ƀ*MhXbr'-@ūƗ,Ķɷǡ*ʮ. @[4]. ,@ -Lj*Ķ%Ɍ® @ƲÔ'ɸ"% @ɼ£,ƞ(a bundle of rights and duties)&@[2]Mh. •. Xbr*# %Ǝ> *@' '-1) ,Ķɷ. ʥ(Volume) . ǡ-ɭ*ńĻ@, 2)(,= )ƲÔɼ£@, ' ˋǚ*# %Ǝ> *@'&@¯'. ȾĠ)e`ʥ,'ƄçdlIf >Ƅ t`lIf' ɕƊ:@[1]. •. %ɀıǬʇ,MhXbrDȹ @ɀıǬʇ,M. Ȑ˅(Variety) . ɻĜĽƼ)(,ƮʓäA e` >dP. hXbr,ńĻÀ#6?Mh-āȷ&@'. Zf)(,ʻƮʓäA e`6&Ȑ˅. ɃǷ&@ %,Mh*-ʇDʖʈ@. ğƯ&@'. ƲÔ,ʖʈ@'DĦ@ƲÔĜ@ƲÔɵ ǐ@ƲÔɿÍƲÔ)( >A@Ɗȏʦ. •. ʒŊ(Velocity) . ǶǪ˂Ŋ;ƓƉ˂Ŋˈ '. Dȣ9@ɼ£ʇDĬÂȜǨ@ɼ£ɿÍ Ěÿ, ɼ£)(Dɸ '*)@6 ĀĶɷǡ&"%:. ʥD'> %7%:(,ȎŊ,VI[&A.n. MhXbr,ő-ǵ)@':@¯ .ʇD. bRe`), -ĭ6"%
(9) >ůɍ,ǂǔ*="%. &Â˄Ɓŭ"%ʄÁ Ěÿ-ëǤ&ʇDūƗ@. ĝä@:,&@ƛȑ&-A¡nbRe`,ĭ. '*)?Mh-ʇ*ʮC@Ġé,ƲÔDɌ®&@. ȷ*Ȕ!Á>Ʒȝ*
(10) %,ˌ#,ǢŚ*:'$. ɼ£:&ɸ '*)@ƊʇDɓƄ&ʄ. nbRe`*
(11) @MhXbr,ȆĮŢDʍ3%. Á Ěÿ- ,ʇDÅĀūƗ@'*)? A . . A,Mh-âŬ*ʇDĜ" ?*ʖʈ ? @'-&) ĬÂȜǨ;y dh Z)(,ɸŴ. 2.2.2
(12) . DÎŴ@'&@,= *ëǤMhXbr. nbRe`,MhXbr,ċ˃,ūēDÀ4(,. ;ÅĀMhXbr' " ʙ *="%Ķɷǡ*Ķ. 3 #,ĻŢ*Ę$ɬƎ@. @ƲÔ;ɼ£ǵ)"%@. ǚǺ-e`,ʥ*# %&@nbRe`,Ǣ. A>-e`DūƗ@' " Ěÿ*
(13) %:ĀƯ. Ś'%/'#/'#,e`,±¹-ʻŅ*¨ :,. &@[3]&-¤ƬȧȳÈ&,e`wjYy f,Ɔ. &@ A>õʷA@'&Ġ)±¹Dŷ#=. ȼ
(14) %e`,MhXbr,ƲÔʼ'%GQ. *)@'>A@e`*ť@MhXb. \ZƲ;ØʴƲ¶ƺƲ' " :,D% @Ɗ&. r,ŏ- ,:,*Ķ@±¹&DŽ6@»ʼ@ 9. ɼ£,ʼ&-e`,ćʃȜǨɼ£;y`e`,ȜǨɼ. õʷAɉȒA@'&±¹Dŷ#= *)" Ŗ . £)(D% @6 e`*ʮC@þʮ³Ⱥe. ,±¹*Ķ%þʮ³ȺMhXbrDŎ@ú. `*Ķ%ť@MhXbr,ŏ-ƦƛǷ*-. ȻŢ@. ,e`,ÔǬ >Ǫ7ÍA@þʮ³Ⱥ*'"%,±. 2 ǚǺ-e`,Ȑ˅*# %&@nbRe`-. ¹,Ġ&DŽ6?Ư)ǗēǷ)ʮ³Ⱥe`*ʮ. Ư)e`^Z >e`DõʷGRTf%. C@njà2,þ,ɺǥ*Ę$e`,MhXb. ÔǬ@Ěÿ@,= )Ěÿ* ,nbRe. rDŎ @'% @. `*- A A,e`^Z,Ư)ʮ³ȺʮC@ '*)?nbRe`DÔnjǬ@Ⱥ- A A, ʮ³Ⱥ,þe`,MhXbr*ljŤ%ö?ŮC) A.)>) . ⓒ 2013 Information Processing Society of Japan. 2.
(15) Vol.2013-DPS-156 No.19 Vol.2013-GN-89 No.19 Vol.2013-EIP-61 No.19 2013/9/13. ţęÌǨī¥ȅȓęĄ IPSJ SIG Technical Report 3 ǚǺ-e`,ʒŊ*# %&@e`,ǶǪ˂. ɼ£,ʼ'%Ʒ,đ 2 *ȇ= ):,ȹ >A@. Ŋˈ ' '-þe`,Ž°ȺȫȬǷ*e. ƲÔʼ. `¬Ũõʷ*ʮC"% @' '*)@ ,=. ɼ£ʼ. )ĚÿĎĎ,ɺǥ-Ĺ)%:ȫȬǷ)ʮC?* ="%Ž°Ⱥť@nbRe`2,ɺǥˈ6"% ƷȘ*MhXbrDť@= *)@úȻŢ ȹ >A@ ,= *ğ,ʮ³Ⱥ A Aǵ)" Ȑ˅Ŋ ÿ ,ɺǥD@'*="%Ǫ7ÍA e`*=" %nbRe`ƮŨA% @ 9 A>þʮ³Ⱥ A A,ȹ Ɗ*="%MhXbrDŎ @ # ,nbRe`,SZDÎơǢĭA Ǘē ǷMhDɏ 1 *ȇ. e`ćʃ. ĝƓ. əơȩƢćʃ. Øʴ. rIlX´ɶ. ÔǬ. GQ\Z´ɤ. ɻĜ. ɬƎʏƎŢ. Ⱥ*ƲÔD @. lbQGbr¬Ũ. ,ƲÔDĦ@. )(. đ 2 nbRe`,MhXbr,ƲÔɼ£. ɬƎ¯)(. Mh ɐɘǑȺ. \P|dH. ɓɒ. )(. ɏ 1 nbRe`,ǗēǷMh ǗēǷ. GQ\Z. 3. / . e`äA@ţę,ª;Ěū,ūƗȺ. nbRe`*ă6A@e`*-·Ǫ7Íʄ. ¯)ǎʀȺ\ VɠȴĚū,ūƗȺ. ɾɞʧ;§ȴţęwIQqR,Űȑe`' " Ǫ7Íe`'ɀàɻĜƵ;ǪǫƵƩ)(*ȧ7. ¬ŨȺ. DŽĭȺ. e`DÁÜ@Ⱥ. ʋ6A \ VǪ7Í C<@ M2M(Machine to. ¯)SNS }We`ÁÜɌȺ. Machine)Ƿe`6&Ư)Ȑ˅,e`Īē@ . õʷ@e`; ,ÔǬƊLj,DŽĭȺ ¯)JKqVnZƬȺ. ,= )e`*ʮʔ@LjÕŊ'%*·ţę´ ɶÕŊ'ȄǷɹǫ´ɶÕŊ, 2 ǚ>A@>*ƍƛ &-A*Ý ʑµ,ȌĴ)(ÝC@ƛȑ&-Ē. ´ƗȺ. e`ƧȣA ZfY,´ƗȺ. ʶƿʉ,ǚ >, 2 ǚ*Ę$ nbRe`,M. ¯)VlŽ°Ⱥ. hXbrD*ÔnjǬ% ƬȺ,ɗǚ > Ǝ> *@'Dɦ7@. VnZ/. e`DöŮ ^pfJKG/VnZŽ°. ^pfJK. Ⱥ. GŽ°Ⱥ. ¯)SaaS ƬȺ. GR. ɓƄ,e`D6'9%ƗǬ)e`\b. ʕ8&rIlX,ìƵù.A@= *)" . T`. fD¬Ũ@Ⱥ. 1970 Ňʾ >ÕĭA% ·ţę´ɶÕŊ,ƿʉ. ¯)µǬ¥Ȉ. DɌ Ěÿ*-ǫƬÓ;ţęöŮȺ,ªÓ,ɖÕɌ. e`. e`ÎơȄɕDķÍVnZ,Ž°Ⱥ. ÎơȺ. ¯)e`ÎơɌƬȺ. e`. e`DʄÁ@Ⱥ/I\ Z@Ⱥ. 3.1 , % :. ). þĒ,·ţę´ɶÕŊ-U o|`]X~ . CA% @ ( *'(6>ɀɖÕ,ȞĐ\ XdHqŢ*=@´ɶ,ʙ ˉǺǷĞÔǬ;ǻȵɖĭ*ʮ @ɖĭ,Ɨǜ) ,ȎŊ)(ˉȁǺ3ǚ-ʻŅ *ğľ*C @[5] , 9îĴ&ãŶǷ)þĒƿʉ-ď. Ž°Ⱥ/. ʹ&@. ʄÁȺ. ƛȑ&-nbRe`,ÔnjǬDǺŸɃǷ)Ƭ Ⱥ*'"%,MhXbrDƿʉ@'D)ǺǷ'. ɏˊ&ȇ Mh-#,ªɓƄDŴ Ěÿ ?6 Â%,SZ*
(16) %Īē@ɢ&-) )( Ŝ:ƎȆ*,ő&ɩɳ&@C&-) ǚ*DzŤ Ŝɔ&@ 6 nbRe`,MhXbr*ă6A@ƲÔ;. ⓒ 2013 Information Processing Society of Japan. LjÕŊ,ĩȥ)ǚ*-Ȕ!Á>þĒ,ÕŊªȡ, ʙ *DzŤ)>ãŶǷ)LjDś*ƿʉ@ 3.2 6 5 ; 4 :. ). e`*ʮʔ@ȄǷɹǫ´ɶÕŊ'%-Ɉ¬Ʋ e`sZƲČƬȌĴĊưǢɡ)(nbRe. 3.
(17) Vol.2013-DPS-156 No.19 Vol.2013-GN-89 No.19 Vol.2013-EIP-61 No.19 2013/9/13. ţęÌǨī¥ȅȓęĄ IPSJ SIG Technical Report `,MhXbr*ʮʔ@:,'%>A% @. ōĨĈ¥(FTC: Federal Trade Commission)Dś'% ,. [6]. œÚDŴ"% @Ɗ&ƍƛ&-ǤȔ ȘȺƵʮ-. ƛȑ&-nbRe`*ʮʔŏĒʶǷ*ʣɔ)ʙ. Īē áĠȿþÎʤ*
(18) @ǹȂª')"%. ,@Ɉ¬Ʋ;e`sZƲ*# %ƿʉ@. @ . 2013 Ň 5 Ɩ*ŨȔ C<@ĒǁǴüLj. ƨ&ɠȴA@Ǣĭ·ţę´ɶĨĈ¥-LjŕƋɌŖˊ. 4. " $. ŇDǺÌ*Ǣĭ·ţę¡Ğ,·ţę*: ,ǹȂŸ. )2< /. ķȞĐDň@'ƫɝA@ĭ&?ǤȔ Ș. À4( pxQ*Ę$ƍƛ'ȟĒEU. ȺƵʮ'%,œÚDƘŔA% @. ,ÕŊ*# %ÎơDɌ ũĒ&@ƍƛ*Ý ȟ Ē' EU Dƿʉ@,-óƊ':ȨǏǷ*ʣɔ)Ĕė&. (2) ZUr. ?ȟĒ-rIlXƲ,Ƕȉ&@EU -þĒ,. ˈŊ*jbfQäA Ȉ¥,*
(19) %·e. e`´ɶLjÕ*Ġ)ŒʽD % ' " ǨǮ. `'%´ɶA@e`,ȞĐ:ĝä%% @. >&@ɏ 2 *ƛȑ*
(20) @)ÎơĶɷDʊ @. EU e`´ɶŸ (¡ʱe`´ɶŸ )&-´ɶA @3e`DǢĭA ɀǝ6 -ȜǨȺ@. ɏ 2 ÎơĶɷ. - A¡Ğ,ɀǝ*ʮ@Â%,ţę·e`' %
(21) ?>*Ƀe`´ɶɖ×ƨ(¡ʱɖ×ƨ)&-. ·ţę´ɶ. ȄǷɹǫ´ɶ. ·ţę´ɶLj. Ɉ¬ƲLj. ĩșDÝ % @ȟĒ&-ǎʀȺrIlXƲÔ. ȨǫǾOIgI . LjɌǛLj. ȕÇ(¡ƲÔʂÇ)*
(22) %·e`-Ǣĭ,·. ,¯ȇ,&ɳÓǴü§ȴe`M I ɳÓ ƍƛ. ȟĒ. ȮáǾm^h. *ȩ0#(linkable)><@e`&?Ǣĭ,U . e`,ÔǬǍʑ*. o|`; ,,elIZ*ȩ0#:,:ă8'. ʮ@ȅȓ¥ęĄƔ. %
(23) ? ,¯'%ZwfpL ;U o|`,. ȟĒǎʀȺrIl. Ɉ¬ƲLj. XƲÔʂÇ. ȗLj)(. @·*ʮ@ţę&"%Őɨţę*ă6A@ǀā ǪŇƖƍ ,,ɞʍș*=?Ǣĭ,·DɳÓ@'. FTC Protecting. &@:,& ,ţę'IJƏ*Ǟÿ@'&. Consumer Privacy in an. A*=?Ǣĭ,·DɳÓ@'&@'')@. Era of Rapid Change. EU. ɳÓĩD% @ƍƛ,·ţę´ɶLj&- ǪĪ. :,Dă8'?ZwfpL ș,ɳÓǴü6&ʑ. e`´ɶŸ . ƸĿɈ¬ƲUg. Ņă6A% ) 'ȹ >A@ȮáǾ 2013 Ň 6 Ɩ*. e`´ɶɖ×ƨ. e`sZŸ . Ƕɏ m^he`,ÔǬǍʑ*ʮ@ȅȓ¥. ĒʶǷ. OECD rIlX. WIPO Ɉ¬ƲƟȢ. ƣȧ7. OIgI )(. )(. ęĄƔ(¡m^he`ȅȓ¥ęĄƔ)&-Į ʃǷ·ɳÓŢ' ƭş,:'·,U o|`; ZwfpL ș,ɳÓţę:´ɶA @3'% @. 4.1 , % :. ). (1) ÕŊªȡ þĔė-·ţę´ɶÕŊ,ªȡǵ)"% @ƍƛ -ǁʭʞʪ'ÃǷƵʮD A AÓ,Ljŕ&ɖÕ%
(24) ?>*Îʤ'*ĭ9>A OIgI *="%Ȫ DžA% @EU -ÃǷƵʮ'ǁʭʞʪD#,Ljŕ* ="%ɖÕ% @ĶǞǷ*ȟĒ&-ãŶǷ)LjŕĪē A A,Îʤ&·ÓLjDÕĭɖÕDɌ"%
(25) ?6 ƬDZ,ɀɖÕDʣE% @ ȘȺǹȂƵʮÕŊ*# %:ʙ @EU -þĒ *ǤȔ ȘȺƵʮDɠȴ·e`ʚƺ*ö? ŮCA% @ DǹȂ@ƲʲD % @ȟĒ&-. ÕŊ&ɖÕĶɷ')@·e`,öŮƬȺ*:Ʌ ņ,ʙ @EU ,ɖ×ƨ&-ƬȺ,ɖƱ;öŮe `ʥ,ʙ *=@ʚǬʴĞ-)Ư*ƬȺ;· *ʚǬA@Ɗƍƛ,·ţę´ɶLj-ö?Ů. ·ţę,Ƅ,ÿɜʗïÄƖ¡È, A,ƍ*
(26) % :èDʆ ) Ⱥ-ʴĞ@'%
(27) ?ȟĒ&-Ljŕ &,ɖĭ&-) :,,FTC 2012 Ň 3 Ɩ*Í vf Protecting Consumer Privacy in an Era of Rapid Change ,pxQ,Ķɷ-ö?Ů e`Ňʭ 5000 Ρ&\ XdHq&-)ȘȺ*Ž°% ) ƬȺ-ăE&
(28) >ĸɖƱƬȺ2,ʗŊ)ɸŴ) = *ʠŦ)A% @. EU ,= )e`´ɶ*ʮ@ȘȺƵʮĪē@ɢ &-) ǎʀȺ´ɶD ,œÚ,#'@ȟʔʝö. ⓒ 2013 Information Processing Society of Japan. (3) öŮȺ,ƲÔǷ»ʼ. 4.
(29) Vol.2013-DPS-156 No.19 Vol.2013-GN-89 No.19 Vol.2013-EIP-61 No.19 2013/9/13. ţęÌǨī¥ȅȓęĄ IPSJ SIG Technical Report ğ,Ē&·ţę´ɶLjÕ-OECD 1980 Ň*ǶɌ. OECD rIlXOIgI *@= *·. C<@ OECD rIlXOIgI DðǞ. e`,öŮȺ-ɼ£Dɸ 3&@'% @ . %țĭA% @ , 9 ,,í×,#&. "%þĒ,´ɶÕŊ*
(30) %-öŮȺ*Ķ%. @ǺǷƎȆä,í×:þĒLjÕŊ*ö?ÁA>A% @. Ư)ȷáɮA% @&-nbRe`,. ƍƛ,·ţę´ɶLj&-ȘçƟ&·ţęDö?. IpVIQ,Ǎ >Ǎ*Ă%ɼ£Dȹ @. Ů *Ő "%- ,ÔǬ,ǺǷD&@ʲ?Ǣĭ) A.)>) 'ĭ9%
(31) ?>*ȘçÄƟ*
(32) %. (a) õʷƐ,ȷá. ǢĭA ÔǬǺǷ,ʘŨ*Ŝɔ)ȞĐDʆ %·. ƍƛ,·ţę´ɶLj; EU ɖ×ƨ A A*
(33) %. ţęDö?Ů"%-)>) '% @6 ,ÔǬ. À4(ʍ3 = *õʷƐ,ǺǷƎȆä' ,ʑȄȷá. ǺǷDĝƓ@'@ -> 9ȘȺŽ°D. $>A% @. ǺǷ'% ) Ěÿ*ȘȺŽ°@'*-ƛĀ. EU ɖ×ƨ&->*ÔǬǺǷș*ʮe`ª. ŤŜɔ&@EU ɖ×ƨ*
(34) %-·e`,Ì. >ƎȇǷ*ĀŤDö@Ŝɔȷá$>A% @ƍƛ&. ǨƺŐ&@ 9*-> 9ƪǷ&ƎȇǷ)Ĺ. :m^he`ȅȓ¥ęĄƔ&-e`,ƵřŢ. )':#¡,ÔǬǺǷ*Ķ%ƛ,ĀŤŜɔ&. ;õʷƐ,U dPZf',ʚÿŢ*="%-ƎȇǷ)Ā. ? ,ÔǬǺǷ*ȃǽ) ȞĐ& ÌǨ%-). Ť,ŜɔŢDƫɝ% @. >) '% @ƊȟĒ,ƲÔȕÇ&-e`. ÔǬǺǷ öŗ@e`*ʮ%-ȟĒ; EU &-. ª-·e`DU dPZf*dž" ÔǬDƘŔ&@. *ĶÿǨǷ)ȞĐ*Õʲ3'%õʷÕʲDɮ. '%
(35) ?ȘȺŽ°*ʮ%:U dPZf*dž"%. % @ƍƛ,·ţę´ɶLj&-õʷ&@e`D. A.úȻ&@'əʢ&@. ÔǬǺǷ*Ŝɔ)ÿǨǷ)ȞĐ*Õʲ@ɖĭ-) 6. ·e`DnbRe`'%ÔǬ@Ěÿ><. (E)e`Dõʷ(,= )ÔǬD% @ *. @Ěÿ&·DǢĭ% @Ŝɔ-) ¯ .zlI. # %C ?;GQ\Z; ʏƎŢ,@ƊLj. Ȗƚ,§ȴe`ș >Ĕėƾ,øǍÍÁDÎơ. &ɬƎ@ɼ£*# %-EU ɖ×ƨ'ȟĒƲÔȕÇ*. @' " ȪɜǷÔǬ&@ ,= )Ěÿ-·,.
(36) %ɖĭ-@,'Bƍƛ,·ţę´ɶLj*. rIlXD²İ@úȻŢ-¨ 'ȹ >A@ . -) )>m^he`ȅȓ¥ęĄƔ,. " ǚ*ʮ EU ɖ×ƨ&-æā&Ž°AɳÓú. &-ʏƎŢ,Ȇ´*# %ɚòA% @. *)" e`-ZUrĞ'3'%
(37) ?>*. A>*Ý EU &-ɖ×ƨ&·e`,Ţʃ*=. e`´ɶŸ Ș 29 Ɵ*Ę$ɠȴA% @ 29 Ɵ¬Ƭ. @ZQ*Ş%·e`*ɌCA@ÌǨ,ŒʽDɥ. ʞ¥&-nbRe`,ÔǬSZD1)ţę,,¼. ±@ȷá(e`´ɶŒʽɥ±)ĭ9>A% @. Ă;ǼʮDȄ@ 9 9,ÌǨ2)·,čģ;Ź@ɂ )(DȄ@ 9,ÌǨ,#*åÓÙȺ,ÔǬ,Ě. (b) ÔǬȜǨƐ,ɼ£ȷá. ÿ-æāäÌǨ)(DƋ &ÔǬ@'&ȃ. řĥ)łǵ-@Åʑ% @ǚ'%-e`. ǽ) ȞĐ'%ÔǬ @''Žɚ% @ƍ. ª,ƲÔ'%@ -öŮȺ,ȷá'%·e. ƛ&-·ɳÓŢ,) ţę-rIlX*- >. `,GQ\ZɛƺDúȻ*% @ǚ&@EU ;ȟ. ) '% @Ò¯?æāäA e`*ʮ%. Ē*
(38) %-A>-e`ª,ƲÔ'%ĭ9>A. -ʑŅ·ţę´ɶLj-ʚǬA) 'ɕ>A@. % @Ɗ&ƍƛ*
(39) %-6&:öŮƬȺ,. )>nbRe`*
(40) %-æāäA%:,. ȷá'%ɖĭA%
(41) ?ÿǨǷ)ǨǮA.Ş). ţę'#C @'&·DɳÓúȻ*)@' " . ':úȻ')"%
(42) ?[7]ǎʀȺ,ƲÔ'%ŏɩ9. ¯:?Ŝ:æāäA >' "%·. >A% @'6&-ɚ ) 6 EU &-e`Øʴ. ǢĭúȻ*)@C&-) 'ɚ @ &m^. ' ǚ& ŝAï>A@ƲÔDĭ9%
(43) ?·-e. he`ȅȓ¥ęĄƔ&- FTC *
(44) @ȹ ƊDðȹ. `öŮ,ĀŤDö?@'&öŮȺ´Ɨ. *%1)ʚÏ)æāäżȴDƋ% @'2)æāä. @·e`DØʴöŮȺȘȺŽ°% Ěÿ. e`DÊɳÓä) 'DȢƞÃɏ@'. - ,e`6&*:Øʴɔɰ,ßÜò1ǚ&·,. 3)æāä e`DȘȺ*Ž°@Ěÿ-Ž°À. ƲÔŏäA% @. ÊɳÓä@'DĢȢ&Ȋƹ@',ɔ¢Dǒ . ,,Ǽʙǚ'%-EU ɖ×ƨ&-e`´ɶ. '*="%·ɳÓŢǜ :,'ÒƈÔnjǬúȻ. ǹȂȺ,ɠȴȷá;e`v`ndHƲ)(ɖĭ. 'ȹ >A@'% @. A%
(45) ?ƍƛ;ȟĒ*
(46) %-ɕ>A) ǢŚ')"% @. (4) öŮȺ,ɼ£Ƿ»ʼ. ⓒ 2013 Information Processing Society of Japan. 5.
(47) Vol.2013-DPS-156 No.19 Vol.2013-GN-89 No.19 Vol.2013-EIP-61 No.19 2013/9/13. ţęÌǨī¥ȅȓęĄ IPSJ SIG Technical Report (c) ŋƪƐȭšƐ,ȷáɼ£. ɒȸɢȸƨȽɄ ,,ĝƓÃɋ*Ķ@ʠŃ. e`,ŋƪ' ʼ*ȁǺ@'ȟĒƲÔȕÇ&-. ʎµĺȇ:-Ãɋ,ʼÙ&,ĮǖDĮƋ@. ¤Ƭ-:-;Ŝɔ&-))" 'ĬÂ*ŋƪ. '' A>Dɡɲ@',źǷƲÔDƗ@'. @ -ʻɳÓä)A.)>) '%
(48) ?EU ɖ. %
(49) ?Ŋ EU ėÈ&ɻĜ e`sZ*ʮ%-. ×ƨ&-ƼûǷȪɜǷñ-ȋīǷȅȓǺǷDʴ %Ô. ,ÊɻĜDU f@ƲÔDġ '% @. ǬǺǷDʘŨ Ŗ*´ŷ@'-ȊƹA% @ ƺʙôƐ,ȵ×ɖĭ*ʮ%-ƍƛ-·ţę´. (3) ƲÔÕʲ. ɶLj& 6 Ɩ¡,ŧœ30 É¡,ȵʦEU &-ʙ. ȟĒ&-ãŶǷ)ƲÔÕʲɖĭ'%pKG}Zɖ. ô,SZ'*ÂDZ,Ĝˈ, 0.5%1%2%Dʲ. ĭĪē@pKG}Z'-ÔǬ,Ţʃ;ǺǷ). 6&'@ȵʦDɮ%
(50) ?ȟĒ&- FTC LjȘ 5 Ɵ*Ę. (Dʩ7Ãƺ)ÔǬ&A.Ɉ¬Ʋ,²İ*Ő >) '. $FTC ,ɑʥ&ȵʦ;ŸķD@'@. @ɃƟʿ&@EU *
(51) %-þĒ&ɖĭ,Ɨǜ. ɞ¡Ğ*- EU ɖ×ƨ&ʙôƐ,ęĄȷá'% 24. @ɆĒ-pKG}Z'ƿ3;;ȞĐʲĭǷ. Ɛʭ¡È*ǹȂƵʮ*ʑȄ ,ŖĶɷ,·*ęĄ. )Ɵʿ'%pKGeH RɖĭDĭ9%
(52) ?. @')(,ȷáɮ >A% @. ʻĊǬǺǷ,ȅȓ,e`Îơ:²İ*Ő >) Ǭʐ' @')(ƫɝA% @ƍƛ-þ·ÓSZ. 4.2 6 5 ; 4 : (9 1 1 ). '*ƲÔÕʲ,Ɵ¢Dɖĭ%
(53) ?pKG}Z,=. Ɉ¬ƲÕŊ-Ɉ¬ǡ*Ɉ¬Ⱥș,ƲÔ,´ɶD- ?. )ɃƟʿ-ȴ % ) 2010 Ň,Ɉ¬ƲLjƂƺ*. :"%Ɔä,Ƕĺ*ij@'DǺǷ'% @Ɉ¬. ="%Îơ, 9,Ɉ¬ǡ,ɓɒ-úȻ'A% @ . Ʋ-ǯɰDŜɔ' ¬Ũ Ɛǚ&Ɉ¬Ⱥ*ƲÔ. 9e` ,:,Ɉ¬ǡ&@Ěÿ&-nbRe. Ǫ@:,&@. `'%Îơ@ÔnjǬ-ĘƛǷ*ċ˃) 'ȹ >A. (1) ´ɶ,Ķɷ. @ . e`*# %,Ɉ¬ƲDȹ @'e` ,:,. A e`sZ,Ɉ¬ǡ*# %-,ʲ?&) . Ɉ¬ǡ&@Ěÿ'·,e`,ʷÿª'%,e. '?e`Îơ, 9*¬ŨA e`sZ-Ô. `sZɈ¬ǡ&@Ěÿ'Dȹ @Ŝɔ@. Ǭ&) . ţęəơDɌ Ⱥ,Ǭ*°@ 9*¬Ũ. ·,e`,Ɉ¬Ʋ*ʮ%þĒÕŊ,Ɉ¬ƲLj& ´ɶA@Ɉ¬ǡ*Ɵ¢'%Åʑ%Û¬ŢDɔǃ. (4) Û¬Ţ,) e`,´ɶ. % @Û¬Ţ,@e`'%-¯ .ɃǷ*. nbRe`&- A>DƮŨ@e`*Û¬Ţ. Web tY;qR,Űȑ;¤ƬÈ&¬ŨA@gP|. @SZ-Ĺ) C<@ë)@Į&@pFQf. y f)(ǼŐ@'ȹ >A@. e`&ƮŨA% @'ğ ,= )pFQf. e`sZ,Ɉ¬ƲDȹ @'ƍƛ,Ɉ¬ƲLj&-. &ƮŨA e`sZ,´ɶ*ʮ%-EU &-e. e`sZ& ,ţę,ʛŲñ-ªȡǷ)ƮŨ*=". `sZŸ *
(54) %Ǥɀ,ƲÔ(sui generis)D@. %Û¬ŢDƗ@:,-Ɉ¬ǡ'%´ɶ@'%. ő&´ɶ% @,ƲÔ*="%e`sZ,¬. @ȟĒ&-ȰʷɈ¬ǡ'%ƌĪ,ȤƜñ-e`. ŨȺ- ,e`sZ,U d c,ÁŬƫɤñ-. DõʷȰŨ%¬ŨA@Ɉ¬ǡ&ȩƢ'%Ǫ@. Ž°, A *
(55) %ʃǷñ-ʥǷ*ǼŐ,ŰʁDɌ". ŐɨɈ¬ǡª'%Ɉ¬Ⱥ,¬Ũ*³@Û¬Ƿ)Ɉ¬. e`sZ,ʣɔ)ʞÎ,ųÍÊÔǬDĦ@Ʋ. ǡ*)@= )ƊLj& ,ƌĪ,ȤƜñ-e`ʛŲ. ÔDƗ@ . AɯƅAñ-ʠȴA% @:,Dɖĭ%
(56) ?. Ŋ EU ėÈ&ɻĜ e`sZ*ʮ%- ,Ê. EU e`sZŸ &- ,ʛŲ6 -ʠÐ*="%ˉ. ɻĜDU f@ƲÔDġ '% @Ɗƍ. ɈȺ,ȄǷÛ¬DƮŨ@e`sZ-ˉɈ¬Ʋ*=@. ƛ;ȟĒ&-,= )e`sZ*Ķ%ƲÔ. ´ɶD÷@'@= *ţę,ʛŲ'ƮŨ*Û¬Ţ. %
(57) >ƺɌǛLj;ȗLjș&ýLjÒƈD%. Dɩ9>A@:,-(,Ĕė*
(58) %:Ư*´ɶA. @6 ƍƛ&-(1)e`sZ¬Ũ2,çÎ)Űʁ. @. (2)íĄʭ,ȗÿʮ³(3)ɓɒ,ɖƱĠɖƱ&@'. Û¬Ţ,@e`sZ'ĀƯ*. " ǚÒ¯LjɌǛɩĭ,ɔ¢'%ŸžA%
(59) (2) Ɉ¬Ⱥ,ƲÔ. ?[8]łƹ9ɰǃƲ,'Bɩ9>A% ) '. e`;e`sZ,Ɉ¬ǡ*ʮ%:ɃǷ*Ɉ. ǢŚ,#&@. ¬ǡ*ɩ9>A@ɓɒƲ;ˁŃƲș' " :,,źǷ ƲÔɩ9>A@ . EU ,e`sZŸ *
(60). %e`sZɈ¬ǡ,Ɉ¬Ⱥ* >A@ƲÔ-ɓ. ⓒ 2013 Information Processing Society of Japan. 4.3 " $ = 2 < 8 ' ƭɘ% = *nbRe`,MhXbr-. 6.
(61) Vol.2013-DPS-156 No.19 Vol.2013-GN-89 No.19 Vol.2013-EIP-61 No.19 2013/9/13. ţęÌǨī¥ȅȓęĄ IPSJ SIG Technical Report ·ţę´ɶÕŊ&·,rIlX'%,±¹D. ǚ:ğ , 9Åʑ,ɩɳƶĤ%
(62) ?¯ .ɏ. ·*-ƲÔ'%öŮƬȺ*-ÕʲA ƲÔ'ɼ. 3 *ȇ= )U pQfʅ% @. £'% % @6 ȄǷɹǫ´ɶÕŊ&Űʁ;Þ ɏ 3 U pQf¯. ÜD e`*Ķ ,¬ŨȺ*ƲÔD% @ )>·e`*ʮ%ɕ%7@' ,. ¯. ċ˃,ūē. 2010 Ň : Amazon vs Blippy. Gw_ '}W,ˋȺ,. Blippy -ʄÁ ĊćVn. f WQX~ *="%Ƕ. ZDÅƗ@VnZ&@. Ǫ@e`*ʮ@U p. ʚÏ)ʻɳÓäÌǨDɌ '&·e`&-) :. Blippy -}W,ɡú,:'. Qf&@,Ěÿ. ,'%ö?Ů 'ŽĉA% @JR Ơƍƛ,. Amazon ,ʄɾĽƼ*GQ\Z. Amazon ,VIf*´ȜA%. % A*ĶAmazon -. @ʄɾĽƼ*GQ\ZDɡ. GQ\Z,ºƹ'ʄɾĽƼ,Ø. ú@ƲÔD}WëǤ. ʴDɔɰDɌ" . &Ɍ®&@ ' ÔǬɡ. MhXbrLjÕŊ&ɖĭA@ -·ɳÓŢ ɔ¢')"% @(,= )e`·e`& @ *ʮ%--"?%
(63) >ǍàǷ&@6 . Suica ,¯*@= * ,= )ÔǬDúȻ'@ 'ɃǎʀȺ',ʭ&ÿŤD'A% @'-ɚ ) . ɲƲċ˃*)" . 6 ğ,Ěÿ·ţę´ɶLjÕŊ*
(64) %Ǣĭ ÔǬǺǷ%ƺŐäA ·e`*ʮ%ʻɳ. 2012 Ň : Instagram Ȉ. }W,Űȑ ËȀe. Óä &,ÔǬ-ɡɲDö"% ) ,&-) 'ȹ. Instagram -ǜƇ,ǰ½ÅƗV. `*ʮC@MhXbr,. nZ&@Instagram Ȉ-. U pQf&@. >A@ǎʀȺ*=@ôǶǿʗ&) rIlX. Facebook ',e`ÅƗDʬħ. InstagramFaceboook '}W. ZQDɩȄ%,:, ·ɳÓŢ) e`*. @,*¦ ÔǬɖȢDĝƓ. ,ʭ&,ÔǬƲDŀ@ċ˃. Ķ%:rIlX¡Ğ,)E> ,ƲÔŤɳ@ . ĝƓÈIJ-}Wā. &@Web VnZ¤Ƭ&. QËȀDňĄ*®Ǭ&@=. 6}WDʷ9@'D. *Ƃɛ@:,. " ,ĝ. Ș*ȴwj`I[- ,. e`Dö?Ů ƬȺ,ɼ£ʼ&:ƍƛ;ȟĒ*ƿʉ. Ɠ*Ķ}W-ɀÎ,e. Ŗ >' ȹ Ɗ,ze. %EU -Ư*ʻŅ*ʣ ɼ£Dɮ%
(65) ?(,=. `ňĄș*ÔǬA@'Š. &-«&wj`I[@ '. GNJ fʫʨ ?ɣɟD. ƽʵ&}W',ʭ&. Ɍ Ǚˇ')" . ċ˃ʅ; . 2012 Ňˍp F Z f V l Ȉ. QJg*nbRe`D. pFZfVlȈ-uZd. ˀ@Ěÿ,ÇĕǷ)ċ˃&. bRe`*ʮ%-ğ-ĢȢ*="%þʮ³Ⱥ,M. H RVnZDŽ°% @. @ȫȬǷ)GQ\ZD´ɤ. hXbrɖĭA@'ȹ >A@çÎ)ǚ:. ¤Ƭ&@2012 Ň*ȜǨ@. @ɼ£;lbQGbrD¬. Vlȶ*Ķɫ" ƀ¬D. Ũ%
(66) ɼ£)(,ūē. 9 ' " 'DƎ> *@Ŝɔ@6 ·. )e`*ʮ%(,ȎŊ,ɼ£DƬȺɸ 3 &@, ' ǚ&:Ġ)ʙ @ ƎȆ*LjÕŊ*="%MhXbrɖĭA) n. @¯ .nbRe`-ɉȒA% >@ -. Ɍ ˆį,e`ǎġ%6". ƎȆ&" ?ƺɩɳ. ůɍ,ʕƻ*=?Ɖ )ÔǬ±¹ɕ# @Ěÿ?. A*Ý ĞʞZfY. A% ) ¯&@. õʷŐÑ-ĭ) Ǭʐ&,ÔǬʬ A@Ěÿ@. *lbQGbr% ) )(. ,Ěÿ ,ÔǬ*=@ȨǏǷÔǸ,ƲÔDŐÑ,ĢȢ. ,ʖǬ,ċ˃?Ř¾-ďʹ &" ȩƢ'%ˆį,nY. &ɖĭ%
(67) '-ʹ :A) 6 ĢȢ-. jZ*ğĠ)ŒʽDò56. ȯȩŐȺʭDȱ@:,&@ , 9e`wS. " . bfrIZ,= )ƬDĺʬ@Ěÿ¯ .ɻĜÀ. 2013 Ň ˍ R l e ` Ȉ. ·ţęDö?Ů Ⱥ,ɼ£. &ǕNj%6" Ěÿș*ȘȺe`DÔǬ@. Rle`Ȉ-zlI. ,?ƊƎȆ&@'. `, `VnZD. &ʅ ċ˃&@Ǣ*ĬÂ. Ž°% @2013 Ň*DŽǏÌ. ȜǨȷá;ęĄȷá*ʮ@. `ɻĜA% @SZ&-ČƬȌĴ,ɔ¢,#&. Ǩ, 9*ˀ "% 10 ¢. ċ˃'ȹ >A@. @ȌĴȜǨŢǒ A) 'ȹ >A@ 9ČƬȌ. ¡:,ˆį,QYbfN. 'Dłƹ9@'-&) ,= *nbRe. Ĵ*=@´ɶ:ƘŔ* 6 EU &-e`s. g,e`ǍÍ6" * : C>Ƕɏ6&,ˊƖ. ZŸ *
(68) %ėÈ&ɻĜ e`sZ,ÊɻĜ. ¡, "%6 ĶŞ,6. -U f&) 9e`,ʄÁȺ,ÊɻĜD. ċ˃')" . ƹ9@'-&>)@Ǎ*
(69) @nbRe` ,±¹DŐÑ,Mh*ʜ¾@'-&) ''. ¡ɏ&ȇ = *Åʑ,ɩɳ) 9*ċ˃Ǫ. )@,= *ǧɌ,ÕŊ&-nbRe`,ɻĜ. % @ƛȅȓ&- " ċ˃DəDŽ@ 9. ¾,ƲÔ'%-çÎ):,&@ :A) . MhXbr,ÅʑɩɳDʡŨ@ 9,ȹ ƊDȇ. 5.
(70) # @. 'ǺŸ. Îơ% = *nbRe`,MhXbr*. 6. * ( .. ʮ%-LjÕŊ:ğļǷ&ɓʸ&?Ǝ> &). ŖƷ,ƽʵ'%·e`,MhXbr*ʮ. ⓒ 2013 Information Processing Society of Japan. 7.
(71) ţęÌǨī¥ȅȓęĄ IPSJ SIG Technical Report. Vol.2013-DPS-156 No.19 Vol.2013-GN-89 No.19 Vol.2013-EIP-61 No.19 2013/9/13. ɃǎʀȺ*G SfɯƤDɌ MhXbr* ʮ@ŤɳDƎ> *Åʑ,ɩɳDʡŨ&@ȹ Ɗ Dȇ% %ȅȓ,ƕȦǺǷ'%ǧē» ʼ > ɥ±A% ) e`,±¹DƎ> *M hXbr*Ę$nbRe`,ƺą,ʁǫ±¹D ɥ±@ze,ʬǶD% 'DǺŸ% . !8-3 1) McKinsey Global Institute: Big data : The next frontier for innovation, competition, and productivity , 2011 2) Bergström Lars: The concept of ownership. Who Owns Our Genes? Proceedings of an International Conference, October 1999, Tallin, Estonia. The Nordic Committee on Bioethics, 2000 3) Loshin, D: Knowledge Integrity: Data Ownership, 2002 http://www.datawarehouse.com/article/?articleid=3052( 4) ĖǭȀǩ : nbRe`,Ɏſ—ŁĠ)e`ŪdzDDŽ9 @, ƠNJȨǏÍǠ, 2012 5) ˈƴǮÔĩ: Ɖ LjÕŊªȡ,ē? Ɗ*ʮ@¯ȅȓ, ţęÌǨī¥ȅȓęĄ, vol.2010-EIP-47, No.9, pp.1-5, 2010/2/19 6) Kemp Little LLP : Big Data- Legal Rights and Obligations, 2013 7) ʺĩţęůɍǫƬê¥: EU e`´ɶŸ Ƃĭ*ʮ@ɯ ƤÎơęĄƔ, 2012 8) ©Ɋʝ: e`sZ,´ɶ'ȗƃț-Û¬ŢDɔ¢' ) e`sZ,´ɶ'ȗƃțǷȹĵ-, ȄǷɹǫȅȓū, 2006. ⓒ 2013 Information Processing Society of Japan. 8.
(72)
関連したドキュメント
The following proposition gives strong bounds on the probability of finding particles which are, at given times, close to the level of the maximum, but not localized....
We will give a different proof of a slightly weaker result, and then prove Theorem 7.3 below, which sharpens both results considerably; in both cases f denotes the canonical
Furthermore, we obtain improved estimates on the upper bounds for the Hausdorff and fractal dimensions of the global attractor of the TYC system, via the use of weighted Sobolev
(Recent result: Yes, but consistent quantum gravity is delicate.) Early universe cosmology: Observations of cosmic microwave background, maybe even earlier stages with
Amount of Remuneration, etc. The Company does not pay to Directors who concurrently serve as Executive Officer the remuneration paid to Directors. Therefore, “Number of Persons”
ISSJは、戦後、駐留軍兵士と日本人女性の間に生まれた混血の子ども達の救済のために、国際養子
を体現する世界市民の育成」の下、国連・国際機関職員、外交官、国際 NGO 職員等、
析の視角について付言しておくことが必要であろう︒各国の状況に対する比較法的視点からの分析は︑直ちに国際法
