日本経済における無償労働のマクロ・インパクト - 無償労働SAM/CGEモデルによる分析 -

(1)

!"#$%&'()*+,-./01234/56

7)*+,89:;<=>?@A%B(CD7

!

"#$%!

&'(! )*+,-./!

&0(! )*+,123456!

&7(! 89:;!

<=>%!

!

!"#$%

?@%<ABC)*+,D"EFGHIJK%JLEMNEOPQRSTUV$EWXY%ZL

TU[\QA]^

!"

_{[[_"EJ`I)*+,%a>bcdTefghQCJ`bijD}

_EikIl

m%<nU+,QoABbcdTE

#"

_{J`bij\pqrefghstuEvwMNExPyz{}

QClmbijD\A]^!

J`%<nUJLEMNEOP"EJ`bij\lmbijr|c}=~%aB>^

CuLD"E\%FGHr)*+,%a>=XE\%ikIRSTUtu%a>=X

U^!

r|c}=~"E_yA^ITXE)*+,roIEJ

`")*+,QYEuLQa>tu%~U_]^turI ¡yXEJ`

"WXQYE)*+,QoABJ`¢_uLQa>£U_]^!

[r|c}=~r¤¥"E)*+,r¦Q§#E+,S¨%©ªQ«¬T^Vlmbijr

bi®r¦Q§#E+,¯°%©ªQ«¬T^+,¯¨%±²lm_I³XEWX"

´µ)*+,roElmbijr%©ªQ¶EJ`bij\lmbijr|c}=~

Q¤¥~U^!

[ra]%JLEMNEOP%·TU)*+,EJ`bij\lmbijr|c}=~"¸¹

ºr»|cQ§#BE¼½¾%©ªQ«¬T^ ¿À%<nUJ`\ikr8ÁÂÀÃÄÅ

ÆE+,ÇÈÉÊË%<nUJL%·TUbiÌÍ\+,S¨®r·ÎH%AB89QÏ$

UV$%"E)*+,QÐ8¹º\BÑUÒn_y¡E!

Ó! ZÔbirÕÖt%×ØXBAV)*+,%aUJ`bijrbiEÙÚÛQeÜÝÞ

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

!

_{!"#$!%&'()*+,-./01%2345,678-99:;<=>?@AABC>DEFG!>DEFHI}

>DEJ

K23LMNOPQRSKTUV%W

*23XYOZ[23K\W

*]^_`O-a.b9-bbW>23,c>

defghijk

!"#lm+nC7opqr%)s-9tK-99u/0WV)vwxiyz{nF|}~F+>23M

8;=>P,evZ\qrJZeij!"gi8;=J#+,

-9/0)23 ¡¢8>£¤¥¦>¡¢23J

K §O¨©ª«¬®¯°±²

³®´µ¶³·¸¹)Wvwxi23,c>defghijk

!"g#-99./º»ei;=>¼½¾¿ÀÁÂ¯Ãei\ÄÅ´¼Æ*

ÇÈÉvÊËÌÍÎ>ÏVÐÑÒÓÔvÕÖ×ØÓÙÚÛqr>ÜÝÞg¾¿ijk

!">P,vwßà#%)á23)vwßà*â>§Bãäåæç>èéÐ²ê³ëßìßjíäå

wîïÀðñijÐw!">ò^ó*ôõö#÷N>øùväiÕ>ghijk

"#

_{;<=K;úûüýþkÿk<üÿk=ÿüûWvwßà8J#*´ZKs¨NZWväà}

i8ÓÙÐBC>DEJ>vhiÕ>>*

8ð>BC>DEJ>viQ>ßËj6*

ÌÍvÕß)K!³µ¶!"#$%4N*&'(öWÒhijk

$#

_{)**+É>,HIvwxi8Je-.ijk}

᪥ᮏ⤒῭䛻䛚䛡䜛 ↓ൾປാ䛾䝬䜽䝻䞉䜲䞁䝟䜽䝖

䠉↓ൾປാ

_{SAM䠋CGE䝰䝕䝹䛻䜘䜛 ศᯒ䠉}

∾

㔝

ዲ

ὒ

䛿䛨䜑䛻

➨䊠❶

↓ൾປാ

_SAM

➨䊡❶

↓ൾປാ

_CGE䝰䝕䝹

➨䊢❶

ศᯒ⤖ᯝ

䛚䜟䜚䛻

(2)

!"#$%&'()+,)-./012 ..-345/462 +057/89:;<=>%()?*@ABCDEFG

HIJKLDMN$EOP#

!"

₂

Q2 RSTUVDWHXYZ[\]Z[(^XYZ[\#_`Z[\]abc(def]ab#

UVgh]ij<kl$mYnop:qrst,u-vw350x1y2 zy4y7012 {|3/1/x7/3v}uz{9

~<(qrst]OHP#2

H2

IJ ¡¢STUV]£¤¥¦] ¡§

,¨©ª«

¬®¯°±²³´µ°¶·µ¸9¹$m¢STUV)*+§º»]¼½IJ<¾¿#$(

ÀkÁ<klOH½ÂºÃÄÅDÆ>%Ç)*+]È<OH2

ÉDÇ)*+<Ê±ËD(XÌ(ÍÎ(ÏÐDiOHSTUV<ÑDÒGmuz{~#$%

¢STUVuz{~§<(ÀkQ<ÓÔ½ÂºÃÕÅDÆ>%~]È<&ÖOH2

F×DÇ~<Ø=$(RÍÎÙÚÛ$m`(^XÌDiOHSTUVZ[cÀÜ$m

`(dÏÐ°±ÝËÞDßàá<hâ$m`(ãäåæç:;UVDâèOHéê<ëì$m

`:;]íµîïð<OH½ÂºÃñÅDÆ>%òóôõ<löH÷mHøíµðº

ùú]äûH2

ÃqD(ÍÎÙÚÛ$m`(ÍÎ°±ÝË]¦ü(ýþÿáº#DÀÜOHPGºÍÎ

Di$%_`Z[\ÆWUVÚÛOH##D(XY]STUVÙÚÛ(UVghÙ

]ÚÛDHmHÙºOHÍÎDi$%XYZ[\(_`Z[\]

º#DÚÛOH(¾¦ü]DWû(f×fDWûðOHXÌ(ÏÐDi

$%Ç]ð×GHýþz(zº#DÚÛ$mq((!

×HXY]!=º"ú$m2

Ã#D(X$%&]'()*+,-DWûXÌDiOHSTUVZ[cÀÜ$m`(XYZ

[\]¦ü"ú(XÌº_`Z[\×XYZ[\DðOHSTUVZ[cÀÜOHm

(STUVÙºOHÇD¾¦ü$(ÍÎ(ÏÐ_`Z[\×XYZ[\D

ðOHÙ!UVghÙºÚÛ(.]ôõ(ýþÿáº"úOH(z/±0±]

"úZ1(ÿáºÀÜOHýþz(zº#DÚÛOH2

ÃªD(ÏÐ°±ÝË]¦ü<ú2HWÔ34[ÞDßàá<hâ$m`(°±ÝË¦ü"

ú(ÏÐºXYZ[\×_`Z[\DðOHXÌ(ÍÎD5>%º¾¦üû

$:>m(

XYZ[\]67Ù(

_`Z[\]XYÙDº8#9;×G::m

ßàá];hDWûqr<]o=ò>º(.GD?>!$(@ABº$

mýþz(zº#D))$m2

ÃCD()DED]Ø=:;DWû(äåæç:;UVDâèOHéê<ëì$m`(UVgh

Ù(Ùº#DÚÛOHUVghÙ]ÚÛºýþÿá<FFH(z/±0±

"úOHm(ÿáºÀÜOHG=]"úD?>XÌ(ÍÎ(ÏÐº_`Z[\×X

YZ[\HðOHýþz(zº#DÚÛOH2

2 !!"# $%&'()*#

ÃÄÅº¢STUV)*+§]È<&ÖOH

#"

_{.Gº)+ÀD)?@ABCEOIJK}

L<kI(JKÀD.G#&LDSTUVMDiOH±0<&'OH

$"

_{¾¿º»]¼½}

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

!"

_{!"#$%&'()*+,-./012345#6789:6745;<=67>?@ABCCDE}

_FG3H>0

IJKLM#LNO'()*+,-./012345#PQARSSTEUV&WX

#"

_{YYZ['()*\]^+_`0abc&Wde[fghijklmnopqlrstquARSSCE0vw+YxWX}

$"

_{yz{ARSSTE+|}~mZ[F)0r)xm)*#OFH>0fAH}

+01FH$01FH$01E#O3WF;+

(3)

½¾_U^!

!%"biØYÛE"#%$U½¾ßàQáâTU^%%"JLEMNEOP%·TUJ

`bij\lmbijr|c}=~E&J`%<nU+,'(®r)8s+,E)+,E+E

,-{HQáâTU^!

.oV)*+,-./Q/01E23'%45TU^23'67"89:3ãE23'6;"¤

<3ã_U^!

!

!"#$ %&'()$

-./?ä%"=>?ikE@kEABkECDkEefghkQEfh\TUFrbiGQ

DTU^!

&%ABkQHboIJKILM\WrNABk

$"

_{%O8TU^!"J`bi%oAYX}

U[\IP¡E)*+,123456%<ABWXrJ`Û®QJ`bijrbi®\QRS~

UV$_U^!

&T%efghkQJLefghkEMNefghkEOPefghk%O8TU^WXUXr

VW"&73r§>_U^!

!

!"*$ +,-./01234-./01256-./01$

ÐXY!

ikZ·3r±?8p!

JLefghk!

WrNr[\Èefghs]]JLefghkE^_efghk{!

¸`uaEbcaEdeKdfKgjk!

MNefghk!

MNshi{

EMNsjD{!

OPefghk!

Àkls¼mKnop{

s]]ÃOå{!

qrsOs¼mKt{

s]]uv^{!

K/W®¯0Ã7vwßà#po12ßà8)34JÖ5

8%67JÖ89:;

<=ÀjZ12>>?ð*@t#Â0¯ABC¯D»Àjk

K=W¨©ª«¬®¯°±²³®´µ¶³·K-99uWvZ<÷NP,jk

!

[XYikIbiTUlmbij"E)*+,IbiTUJ`bij\w[%±²æçQ

TU^!

biGxtrÐXryzEV89ryz"{|\B}~-è.%aU^KefghrK

idéB%·TU`"-è.ikZ·3%E2rbiK8)Kdyz%·TU`"

¢êë½¾Àì}íîå¼H½¾`ïÐsðññ{%±²¡^!

V123456réòQcE?@_"QefRe6ÜRsðññ}{%<AB

m3XBAU)*+,-./rÐQV^ä%"xËr_U^!

Ó! ok,\}åQ}V!

ó! iE%CB_áBU¼¢r 89E¡t\r 89QWXUX¢£

¤¥V!

¦! C¡t%[TU§r¤+Drá¨×QV!

©! ª°%yVC 89DÐXE

C¡t! 89DÐXQ«¬V!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

EF*Ge>HIö-JÀÐßjk

!">Å¯CKBëg#Z12>>?ðÓXLv2ÕÓXLv1ijÓã;<=>M

NvOßP>QqRFEFGe>HIöÕ-Jij;STS>ÐÑväåvUViE

WXÀIÒÌÍvÕÖ×Ø¾¿g<iäË*YZÎvwßà8EJ[\ijk

%#

_{;=wä]!"g#>^_½78_½7Je-.ijk}

(4)

!7#$ 89:;<'=>$

)*+,-./r]]E-./?äréB"xËr§>_U^

%"

_!

ikZ·3\®%EbiGK¯%éBQE°%idéBQãT^2"2G

K°%±n8YXE¯_&7²år)8G%8)XU^!

&7²år)8G"°_2<aµiåQ±n8>E¯_WXQiår³A

%=T^´>Q&7²åµÝRh\Bår&;²8)G%±n¶T^!

år&;²8)G"°_&·²åµÝRhEÀÁHQ±n8>E¯_WXQåK¸H

%¹XU½º»r³Ayz%BU^´>Qô¼8å\Bô¼8år.oG%±n¶

T^!

ô¼8år.oG"°_ô¼8åQ±n8>E¯_WXQ½¾Ûd\"#%=T^

!"[¿TU°E¯Q½ÀEbiG%dXU^%"?õÁG%±n8YXU^!

?õÁG"°_"#HQ±n8>E¯_WXQìÂ?ÃEÄÅÆ¦E¡t%[TU

§r¤+H%BU^!T"[¿TU°E¯Q½ÀEbiG%dXU^%"¡tÐ

Xr?89G%±n8YXU^!

¡tÐXr½º89GK°%"¡tÇrÈoöÉEiåEWrNr½º*ÊQE¯%"

ËÌdE¡tØYrÈoöÉEiåEWrNr½º*ÊE½º[tÍQáTU^?8

9GK°%"¡t%[TU§r¤+Â½º[tÍQE

¯%"¡tØYr?*ÊQáTU^!

xE-./?ä"-è.÷øäùIãT½¾ßàQáTU^!

!

!?#$ @*'=>$

Î3"-./?ä\ú}%)*+,H%·TU5fÏQúûTU^éB"xËr§>_U^!

&"J`IÃÐTUJL®EMN®EOP®\±ÑÒ%<nUWXUXr¼ÓÔÕ_U^O

PQ%\U^23'67©%aU\EJ`rOPÃÐ®"ðñÖñ}×Ø}_V^

&"

_J`"[r]]

·×Ö~ÙØ·Q)*+,%a>biVJ`bijQÙÚÛTU[\%a>E·Ö×ÚØÚQlmbijr

Û%a>¼ ÓTU^V ÙÛðØÚQ[J` HÜnopÝ äsèüýÞþÿüß! àýá!üýá! -"ÿâý#!

ãü!á"äü$åá%èæà-ã{%aUbijrÙÚÛ%a>EÚñðØñQ¸çë%aUbijrÙÚÛ

%a>¼ÓTU^

'"

_!

[r]]OP%·TUlmbijrJ`Û·Ö×ÚØÚ"E

-./?ä%<nUOPefghrJ`Û

·Ö×ÚØÚ\èTU^®%èæà-ã%aUbijrÙÚÛÙÛðØÚ"E-./?ä%<nUèæà-ã½

¾ÛdÙÛðØÚ\èTU^¸çë%aUbijrÙÚÛÚñðØñ"E-./?ä%<nU¸ç

ë½¾Ûd·ÖÚ·Ø}r]]çë\ÎÛÚñðØñ\èTU^!

&T"+,'(®\WXr+,E)+,E+E,-Çr)8_U^23'67©%aU\E

J`r+,'(®"ÙÖ·ð×Øð_>EWXQ+,%ðÙÖÚÙ·ØE)+,%`·ÙÖ}Ú}Ø·E+%`

ÛÛÖÛðØðE,-%Úñ·Öñ}Ø·éBU^!

OP%·TU)*+,®"·×Ö~ÙØ·_>E[X%êër+,biÌ7Qì#V·×Ö~ÙØ·I

OP%·TUJ`bijrbi®\yU^J`"WXQÙÚÛTU^!

&"bij%·TUJ`Ûr¢í_U^[X"-./?ä%ãXUJ`ÛQEJ`bi

r÷Ü\WrNÛ%O8BãT^ABk%[TUJ`ÛÛ}ÖÙñ·ØÚr]]JL%·

TUJ`bi%î]r"ðÖ·ñÛØÙE®%MN%î]r"×}ØEOP%î]r"×ØðEWr

N"ÚñÖÚð×Ø}_V^!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

&#

_{``g#abÒ-JiciHI>ÞdeÀjk}

'#

_{`>+f#gh>¦ijeÀkl+fghijk}

(#

_{`Ö#m<no;Tpq%4rpq%4ghå<no;TrÒBCst%4À2vué}

vwijk

(5)

)*+,123456%<ABEJ`bi%î]r"Wrbi®%±²Û®I³U^Wr

N"ïïÅðr\EñoQ½ò¥TUa]Û®I³U^!

!

!A#$ 8B9-CDEFG)'HI$

)*+,%·TU`Q-è.eÜÝÞG\BúûTUóô"2õæ\rö÷E¼øö÷EÒ

ù¯ö÷yz®ù_UIE[ra]%G°¯\Î3Qú.E½¾ßà\eÜÝÞ&öQQ

RS_Uû°_U^!

!

&!'% ()*+,-./01%

)*+,123456"biüý£SEJ`üý£SE¯¨¹ºüý£Syz·ñrüý£SØY

U^456I¹ºV%Eþr!Sý"#QïdTU^

!("

_!

xËE&üý£SréB\!Sý"#%ABâÿU^¤<QhQ/01E230%45TU^!

!

!"#$ JKLMNO$

biüý£S_"&ikI÷ÜE+,E?QoABbijQbiTU^!

&%$! ! ·Þ! Û~%&%<ABÂÎ<Q§#bi®ØY÷Ü®QE

$! ÛÚÞ! ×ð%&%<AB

®%2Q'$U^!

$! ! ·Þ!Û~%!

X

_ij

₌

a

_ij

XS

_j

!

s!(·ÖØØØÖÛÖ!}{

s"(·ÖØØØÖ}{!

$! ÛÚÞ!×ð%!

_{VA =}

_j

va

_j

XS

_j

!

s"(·ÖØØØÖ}{!

&T%xËr13-)bi·<<aµo½*¥+,%±²$! ×~Þ!·%&_+,®QE

$! ðÞ!

}ñ%&_?®Q'$U^

!!"

_{&ik%<AB+,"+,åQE?"?åQbcdT^}

!#"

$! }·Þ}}%&"+,E?ØYU2rè"Þæÿ'"_U^!

(ý!

4

3

4

2

1 j

j

VA

PN

j

R

KD

LD

W

_⋅

₊

_⋅

!

á!)-"'!ü!

( )(

)

(

)(

)

1

1 −

−













−

+

=

j

LD

KD

VA

σ

δ

!

$! ×~Þ!·%!

( )

j

_W

VA

PN

LD

j

σ

δ













=

! !

s"(·ÖØØØÖ}{!

$! ðÞ!}ñ%!

_j

j

(

j

)

VA

_j

R

PN

KD

j

σ

δ













−

=

1 !

s"(·ÖØØØÖ}{!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

!"#

_{!"#$%&&'()*+,-./012.3456789:;<)=>?@AB)@CDEF)12.3456}

7GHIDJKLMNO8DPQLRS8TUV@AWXDYZ)[U\]^_D`aG)bcdLeFVfgAh

ij)*+,-./0D%&&kl)minoLpqGV@rsJKtuv89:;<)=>wA.34567)x

yzDJK0WNO8DPQ<WNO8{|}~wDtu)8gDHl)minoYZ)[U\]

^_D`aG)bcD^dLeFwAh

!!#

_{80*,tLg@ADJKGi))L3 D¡¢}

3 f£¤G8¥fw82¦VDU§L¨©@C=>wAª0«¬))L®&¯°

GV@Ah

!$#

_{ij8±g®JKYZ0²³´µDiYZ0¶·¸]¹|YZ±º»¼¦i½¾=>wAh}

(6)

!" #$%"##&"

PN

[

( )

j

( )

W

j

(

)

j

( )

R

j

]

j

σ

δ

−

₊

₋

−

=

1

1 "

"

'!($)***)#+"

!$,#%$$-&./0123456789:;<=>?56@A;BCDE

!$,,%$,F&./056G

HIJ>?56@A;KLMNOPQRSTGH;BCDE"

UVWXYZ[\]4V^_`ab12c?" defghij0klfghi12mVnopqr

stuNvfghi12m/wxMNOPQRSTGH0yz{U^E|}/~|;

{M56GH;>?56@ADE"

!$$F%$&

M

!$-%$&./074tM

!"#

_;|<=M12R

4DM;BCDE

!$%$&./0124?;<=Mr T;B

CDE

!$#

_"

WXYZ[\]4V¡D12c?¢£¤Vno!" " $%$&.IJM|¥fghiO;K¦§

2O12¨©ª;HDE|J;!$%$&.4«EWXYZ¬®¯°±0|¥fghiO

12¨©ª;©ª²³´µ¶·¸¶µ{_VxM

!$&.4V^_|;$DE

!%#

_"

!$,,%$,F&"

OS

_j

₌

R

_⋅

KD

_j

₋

DEP

_j

"

'!($)***)-)"#+"

"

OS

₈

₌

0 "

!$,#%$$-&"

_{DEP =}

_j

dep

_j

XS

_j

""

"

'!($)***)-)"#+"

"

_DEP

₈

₌

_R

_⋅

_KD

₈

"

!$$F%$&"













+

=

_∑

=

j

i

ij

i

j

it

P

X

PN

VA

IT

9

1 "

'!($)***)#+"

!$-%$&"













+

=

_∑

=

j

i

ij

i

j

sb

P

X

PN

VA

SB

9

1 "

'!($)***)#+"

!$%$&"

_{SDP =}

_j

sdp

_j

P

_j

XS

_j

"

'!($)***)#+"

!$%$&"

(

)

_























+

−

+

−

=

_∑

=

j

i

ij

i

j

it

sb

P

a

PN

va

sdp

P

9

1

1 _"

"

'!($)***)F+"

!$&"

P

₉

=

₁

"

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

!"#

_{!"#$%&'()+,-./0123456789:;<2=>?5@A(BC-DEFGHI(BC8}

JK5;<2!"#$%&'LM-NOPQRST%U&V,WXY5ZC[-D*;<R[%&'LY\-]Q

5^_[-D`abcGHI(BC8d

efgh-ij5f7k)+,-lVm2nJ7oR[Bp+,-lVqr5s7kt]Quvwx*y

YJ<T!"#$%&'-zu;-{{|7T8d

!$#

_{}~XuGCT*PQ-5s7k)o-Z_euvT8d}

!%#

_{dfZ}~-U5s7k*(HC8d}

(7)

!"#$ %&'()*$

8)üý£S_"&%2.QWXUX/`EWXQ¼¢&ÅÆÐX%8)TU^W

XYQ$·ÙÚÞ·Û·%&%ãT^

!"#

_!

$·ÙÚ%!

_W

PY

_W

RV

j

ER

CE

LD

W

CE

₌

∑

₊

_⋅

₋

=

*

9

1 !

$·ÙÙ%!

∑

=

9

1 j

j

OS

!

$·ÙÛ%!

OS

_H

₌

os

_h

OS

!

$·Ù×%!

OS

_E

₌

os

_e

OS

!

$·Ù%!

OS

os

OS

f

F

=

!

$·Ù}%!

∑

=

9

1 j

j

DEP

!

$·Ûñ%!

∑

=

9

1 j

j

IT

!

$·Û·%!

∑

=

9

1 j

j

SB

!

&T%iår±n³AQ456¥TU^

$·Ûð%&%<AB¼¢&ÅÆÐX<aµ¡tI³

]iåQ/`E

$·Û~Þ·Û×%&_WXQö0_¼¢&ÅÆÐX%)8TU^¼¢&ÅÆÐ

X<aµ¡tÇriår³AQtb¤<\TU^¡triår³A"16CB_tb

¤<\EWX%2ç!fQì#3CB\TU^2ç!ftb¤<\TU^

!"#

_iår±

n³AQ§#E¼¢&ÅÆÐX"&7²åµÝRhQU^WXYQ$·ÛÞ·×ð%&%ãT^!

$·Ûð%!

W

PY

F

PY

E

PY

G

PY

H

PY

N

PY

PR

ER

PR

=

+

⋅

*

!

$·Û~Þ·Û×%!

PR

_i

RV

₌

pr

_i

rv

(

PR

PY

₋

PR

_W

RV

)

!

_{s!(èÖ!ãÖ!2Ö!3Ö!{!}

$·Û%!

_Y

_N

₌

_PR

_N

RV

₋

_PR

_N

PY

!

$·Û}%!

Y

_H

₌

CE

₊

OS

_H

₊

PR

_H

RV

₋

PR

_H

PY

!

$·×ñ%!

G

PY

RV

G

IT

SB

PR

Y

₌

₋

₊

₋

!

$·×·%!

Y

_E

₌

OS

_E

₊

PR

_E

RV

₋

PR

_E

PY

!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

!"#

!"#$%&'()*!"

!

+,-.$/0*!"

"

1234!"

"

56789:;-<%&'()*+!"56=>

?@;-<%&'()*234A

!$#

_{BC$DEF>GH<IJKLM$NO>POQ+RSTRUV8WX<4A}

(8)

$·×ð%!

Y

_F

₌

OS

_F

₊

PR

_F

RV

₋

PR

_F

PY

!

&%´8)K½º*Ê.r±n³AQ456¥TU^åK¸H%¹XU½º»r³A

:"$·×~Þ·×Ù%&%ãT§>E&7²åµÝRh%öTU\E

$·×Û%&_WXQ/`TU^

ÀÁE4jÀÊxtrÀ¨2EWrNr½ºÊr³A:"tb¤<_U\E

$·××Þ·×%&_WXYQ/`Eö0_¼¢&ÅÆÐX%)8TU^´8)K½º*Ê.r±

n³AQ§#E¼¢&ÅÆÐX"ô¼8åQU^WXYQ$·Þ·}ð%&%ãT^!

$·×~%!

DT

H

=

dt

h

Y

H

!

$·×Ú%!

_{DT =}

_E

dt

_e

Y

_E

!

$·×Ù%!

F

f

F

dt

Y

DT

₌

!

$·×Û%!

F

E

H

DT

=

+

!

$·××Þ·ñ%!

SC

_i

RV

₌

sc

_i

rv

SC

_H

PY

!

_{s!(èÖ!2Ö!3Ö!{!}

$··%!

F

PY

E

PY

G

PY

N

RV

H

SB

₌

₊

!

$·ð%!

OT

PY

OT

_N

PY

OT

_H

PY

OT

_G

PY

OT

_E

PY

OT

_F

PY

ER

OT

_W

PY

*

⋅

+

=

!

$·~Þ·×%!

OT

_i

RV

₌

ot

_i

rv

(

OT

PY

₋

OT

_W

RV

)

!

_{s!(èÖ!ãÖ!2Ö!3Ö!{!}

$·%!

DI

_N

₌

Y

_N

₊

SC

_N

RV

₊

OT

_N

RV

₋

(

SB

_N

PY

₊

OT

_N

PY

)

!

$·}%!

DI

_H

₌

Y

_H

₊

SB

_H

RV

₊

OT

_H

RV

₋

(

DT

_H

₊

SC

_H

PY

₊

OT

_H

PY

)

!

$·}ñ%!

DI

_G

₌

Y

_G

₊

DT

₊

SC

_G

RV

₊

OT

_G

RV

₋

(

SB

_G

PY

₊

OT

_G

PY

)

!

$·}·%!

DI

_E

₌

Y

_E

₊

SC

_E

RV

₊

OT

_E

RV

₋

(

DT

_E

₊

SB

_E

PY

₊

OT

_E

PY

)

!

$·}ð%!

DI

_F

₌

Y

_F

₊

SC

_F

RV

₊

OT

_F

RV

₋

(

DT

_F

₊

SB

_F

PY

₊

OT

_F

PY

)

!

!"#$ %&'()*+,-./012$

[J`HÜnopÝär½¾ÛdE"#Q456¥TU^[[_"&bij%[TU½¾Û

dr"#Qtb¤<\TU^

$·}~%&_"WXUX%bijQì#E½¾ÛdQ'

$U^

$·}Ú%&_"ô¼8åØY½¾ÛdQ¬E"#QU^!

$·}~%!

CS

P

₈

N

₈

P

₉

N

₉

N

=

+

!

$·}Ú%!

SV

_N

₌

DI

_N

₋

CS

_N

!

(9)

!3#$ &'/012$

J`%<nUÛE"#E+,S¨E)*+,yzQ456¥TU^J`%"JLEMNEOP

I®(ÄTU^)*+,123456_"&J`IÃÐTUJL®EMN®EOP®Qtb¤<

\TU^!

&%J`"+,Q

_L

E?Q

os

_h

KS

ÃÐE

!"#

_{WXY'(®ØY$·}Ù%&r5fô¼8å}

QU^!

$·}Ù%!

(

)

(

)

CPR

OT

SC

OT

SB

PR

CE

ER

DEP

KS

R

os

L

W

dt

DI

PY

H

PY

H

RV

H

RV

H

PY

H

RV

H

RV

W

PY

W

h

EX

+

−

+













−

+

−

⋅

+

−

⋅

+

⋅

−

=

*

1 !

J`"5fô¼8åQJLEMNEOP%·TU)+,E+,K)+,K,-%2$TU

*+EÛE,-E"#H%BU^WXY°+rÅð&"xËr§>_U^!

(

)

(

)

4

3

4

2

1

4

3

4

2

1

4

3

4

2

1

4

3

4

2

1 FL

CC

NS

HW

DI

H

LZ

O

LZ

UW

PW

TT

HW

CC

NS

HW

CC

P

CC

NS

P

NS

HW

P

HW

EX

SV

LZ

OC

C

P

TT

OC

X

P

X

P

X

P

C

OC

C

P

C

OC

C

P

C

OC

C

P

DI

+

=

4

3

1

8

7

6

6 !

&76"J`r78éBQãT^J`"árÅð&r\E&76%VIAñoQ½ò¥T

Ua]EV&oQ½*¥TUa]°+TU^!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

!"#

_{! ""#$%&'()}

_KS

_{*+,-+./01234+/056789:;<=>=?4@ABCDEF}

j

os

#

GHIJKLMN!

(10)

!45$ &'678$

!"

#$%

&'

DI

EX

()*+,-./

()*+,01/

01 CES,σ

cc

/

P

CC

23,-4567/

L

HW

89:;

23,<=567/

C

7

>G

7

?i @23

C

i

AB

S

C

CD

ΣTT

k

EF

CES,σ

h

/

LZ

LS

23GABGEF

CES,σ

u

/

*+HIJ

L

23,<=567/

C

₆

-.

CES,σ

hw

/

P

HW

C

F

ΣΣP

i

X

k i

CD

OC

TT

_ΣTT

k

KL@

DI

FL

MN@

C

H

C

1

Cobb-Douglas

C

CC

! X

CC

_"

L

CC

23 89:;

-456GOPQR

56,-4567/

*+

! X

HW

_"

23,-4567/

C

HW

23,<=567/

C

O

56,-4567/

?S@23

TU

CES,σ

ns

/

P

NS

23,-4567/

C

₈

>N

8

>G

8

56,-4567/

()*+,TU/

C

NS

! X

NS

"

89:;

L

NS

㻔 ὀ㻕 ➹⪅సᡂ䡝

(11)

&T%J`"JLEMNEOPQJ`bij%aUØElmbij%aUØ%ABr78Q°

]^MNQ%8>E&;6%Wr78éBQãT^!

!

!95$ &':;<=>?:;<$

!

OPQRSTUN!

!

J`"J`bij\lmbijQ:}Eå¶rMNQ]^!

)+,123456_")+,%a>biXUJ`bijs)9ÂJ%aU ¿r:;

H{\ik%a>biXUlmbijs<kHIRSTUMNefghH{"#I=yUV$E

w[I¤¥B>?æçyA^VrÜ%"@Öæç0ArÕ|I,¡\

TU^!

[[_"J`bijrÙÚÛ®\J`E

çë%aUlmbijrÛ®Q13-·<%a>:}E

MN"Wr}%a>=XU\V^

!$#

_!

J`bijrÙÚÛ®ElmbijrJ`Û®"WXUXrETy=])*+,r

o_BYXV!r\%r%±²EoI½*%yUa]³U^lmbijrç

ë\ÎÛ®"tb¤<_U^!

JLEMNEOP%ABEJ`bij\lmbijr78éB"WXUXxËr§>_U^!

JL%ABExËra]%456¥TU^!

(ý!

4

3

4

2

1 HW

P

HW

C

OC

C

P

₊

6

6 !

á!)-"'!ü!

(

)( )

(

)

(

)

1

6

1 −

−













−

+

=

hw

HW

hw

C

HW

σ

δ

γ

!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

!$#

_{,-VWX+YZVWXB[\]$,^+_`+ab;cdefJKghi=JNjhklmnoB5pq}

r8s8tMZu+,^$vwxiyz{cd[\IJ8+ab$|}L~G`S;cJxib7B

;[\Lfx~L=fN#<=i]$#JM+&BD#$,^;J[\

B],-++K~;+_`;J[\B]+ab;J[\B]*;+

,^$ ¡¢£B¤¥;cd[\L¦I8+ab$[\L;§K¨LMN!

"#$!

%&'()*+!

,-./!

%01+!

23"#!

4567"#%0189:;<=>(?@+!

AB"#$!

%23()*+!

23()C@!

%2DE+!

23()*!

23()!

FGHIJ!

(12)

!"#$%&'()&'*+,-./0123

%&'(+3

(

)

HW

P

C

hw

HW

hw

σ

δ

γ

_











=

−

6

1

6

3 %&'4+3

(

)

HW

OC

P

C

hw

HW

hw

HW

hw

HW

σ

δ

γ

_











−

=

−

1

1 ₃

%&'*+3

(

) ( )

(

)

(

)

hw

HW

hw

HW

OC

P

σ

δ

γ

−













−

+

=

1

6

1

1 ₃

56789:-;<=5>?@ABCDEFGHI%&''+,C;$?JK12

_µ

hw

L5>?9

01DEFG78M-NO0PQRSTUV123

%&''+3

L

HW

_hw

C

HW

µ

1 =

3 3

3 (

)

HW

hw

HW

L

X

C

₌

_µ

3 56CWX,Y#Z56789:[\=5678]C^_I%`aa+,C;$?JK123

%`aa+3

OC

HW

(

dt

_hw

h

)

W

µ

−

=

1

3 5>?@AB5678]CbcdeHIJK1f=gC78HIJK$=

%`a&)`ah+,C;$?

gi?jkdelCmnHIopq:-;<JK12

!"#

₃

%`a&+3

X

HW

a

hw

C

HW

1

1 =

3 %`a`+3

X

₃

HW

₌

a

₃

hw

C

HW

3 %`ah+3

X

HW

a

hw

C

HW

4

4 =

3 rs?@AB=tuC#k?vwxy0123

z{|3

4

3

4

2

1 NS

P

NS

C

OC

C

P

₊

7

3 }~33

( )

(

)

(

)

(

)

1

7

1 −

−













−

+

=

ns

NS

ns

C

G

C

NS

σ

δ

γ

3 !"#$%`a)`a(+,-./0123

%`a+3

(

)

( )

7

1

7 NS

G

P

NS

G

P

C

ns

NS

ns



−











+

=

−

σ

δ

γ

3 !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

!"#

_{!"#$%&'()*+,-./0123456#$789+:;/!"#$76<=#$7+>?%@A}

BCDEF2GHIJ

(13)

$ðñÙ%!

(

)

(

)

NS

OC

NS

G

P

C

ns

NS

ns

NS

ns

NS

σ

δ

γ

_











+

−

=

−

1

7

1 !

$ðñÛ%!

[

( ) ( )

(

)

(

)

]

NS

G

P

OC

P

ns

NS

ns

NS

7

1

7

1

1 −

−

+

=

σ

−

σ

−

σ

−

σ

δ

γ

!

J`bi·<Q§#EMN%ABr)*+,®I$ðñ×%&r§>%³U^

ns

µ

"MN%·

TU)*+,biÌQ3=T%ÝCÏf_U^!

$ðñ×%!

L

NS

_ns

C

NS

µ

1 =

!

(

)

NS

ns

NS

L

X

C

₌

_µ

!

J`rÅð&<aµJ`bi·<ØYEJ`bijrI$ðñ%&r§>%³U^!

$ðñ%!

OC

NS

(

dt

_ns

h

)

W

µ

−

=

1 !

MN%ABJ`bijrÙÚÛ®I³U\EWrbi®I³>E

$ðñ}%&r§>%WX

%î]ÛrD®IÂÎ<Q§#³U^!

$ðñ}%!

X

₃

NS

₌

a

₃

ns

C

NS

!

OP%ABExËra]%456¥TU^!

(ý!

4

3

4

2

1 CC

P

CC

C

OC

C

P

₈

₊

!

á!)-"'!ü!

( )

(

)

(

)

(

)

1

8

1 −

−













−

+

=

cc

CC

cc

I

cc

C

N

G

C

CC

σ

δ

γ

!

áa>$ð·ñÞð·ð%&QEdTU^!

$ð·ñ%!

(

)

( )

cc

(

I

)

I

CC

cc

CC

N

G

P

CC

G

N

P

C

cc

8

1

8 



−

+











₊

=

−

σ

δ

γ

!

$ð··%!

(

)

(

)

CC

OC

CC

G

N

P

C

cc

CC

cc

I

CC

cc

CC

σ

δ

γ

_













₊

₋

=

−

1

8

1 !

(14)

$ð·ð%!

[

( ) ( )

(

)

(

)

]

(

N

G

)

CC

P

OC

P

I

CC

cc

CC

cc

8

1

8

1

1 +

−

+

=

σ

−

σ

−

σ

−

σ

δ

γ

!

J`bi·<Q§#EMN%ABr)*+,®I$ð·~%&r§>%³U^

cc

µ

"OP%·

TU)*+,biÌQ3=T%ÝCÏf_U^!

$ð·~%!

L

CC

_cc

C

CC

µ

1 =

!

(

)

CC

cc

CC

L

X

C

₌

_µ

!

J`rÅð&<aµJ`bi·<ØYEJ`bijrI$ð·Ú%&r§>%³U^!

$ð·Ú%!

OC

CC

(

dt

_cc

h

)

W

µ

−

=

1 !

OP%ABJ`bijrÙÚÛ®I³U\EWrbi®I³>E

$ð·Ù%&r§>%WX

%î]ÛrD®IÂÎ<Q§#³U^!

$ð·Ù%!

X

₃

CC

₌

a

₃

cc

C

CC

!

&%J`"5fô¼8åØYJLEMNEOP%·TUoE*+roQ¬AV$ð·Û%

&r

DI

FL

QÅð%ÛE,-E"#%ABr78Q°]^

$ð·×Þð·}%&r§>E*+"WXU

X+,®E)*+,®E,-®%öTU^

!"#

_{J`rÅð&ØYE*+·F¨V>roQ}

$ððñ%&r§>%ôTU^!

$ð·Û%!

(

)

(

)













+

−

=

LZ

UW

PW

TT

HW

CC

NS

HW

CC

NS

HW

EX

FL

TT

OC

X

P

X

P

X

P

CC

P

NS

P

HW

P

DI

₁

₃

₄

!

$ð·×%!

TT

PW

₌

tt

pw

LS

!

$ð·%!

TT

UW

₌

tt

uw

(

L

HW

₊

L

NS

₊

L

CC

)

!

$ð·}%!

TT

LZ

₌

tt

lz

LZ

!

$ððñ%!

OC

TT

_{= 1}

(

₋

dt

_h

)

W

!

4Ä\GÔQ78TU^!"ÛE,-ØY>E%""#%BYXU^J`"

xËr§>EÅð+,r\ñor½ò¥QÁTUa]4ÄEGÔQ78TU^[[_"

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

!"#

_{!"#$%&'()*!"+,$-./01+,234567$89:;<=>+,/0?@#ABCD)}

EFGHI:JKLM<NOPQ$RS/01TQ234567$89:;<?@#ABCU%EFGHI:JKV

WW8A!"<XY!"<Z[\:]:3^_J`abc$TQ'%&d<\:3ef?@#7%&_JFG

H<

ghijkhilmn$Bo3pqr&dsKV

(15)

ræçrHÇÌQ·Ø·\V^

!!#

_!

(*+!

( )

(

)

( )

4

3

4

2

1 U

F

u

H

u

C

1

1 −

−













−

+

σ

δ

!

á!)-"'!ü!

DI

FL

₌

P

H

C

H

₊

P

F

C

F

!

áa>$ðð·Þððð%&QEdTU^GÔ"$ðð~%&r§>_U^

$ððÚ%&Q§#EG

ÔØY"#I³U^!

$ðð·%!

( )

[

( )

(

)

( )

]

FL

F

u

H

u

H

u

H

DI

P

C

u

σ

δ

−

+

=

₁

1 !

$ððð%!

(

)

( )

[

( )

(

)

( )

]

FL

F

u

H

u

F

u

F

DI

P

C

u

σ

δ

−

+

−

=

₁

1

1 _!

$ðð~%!

R

P

O

F

=

!

$ððÚ%!

F

H

P

C

SV

₌

!

²%4ÄQÛ\,-%)8TU^J`rÅð&ØYE,-roQ$ððÙ%&r§>%

ôTU^!

$ððÙ%!

OC

LZ

_{= 1}

(

₋

dt

_h

)

W

!

4Ä"13-·<%aUÛ\,-r}_U\,E

oQ½*¥TUa]&®Q³$U^

æçrHÇÌ"ñØ×\V^!

(ý!

4

3

4

2

1 H

H

C

P

LZ

O

LZ

OC

C

P

₊

!

á!)-"'!ü!

( )

(

)(

)

1

1 −

−













−

+

=

h

LZ

C

H

_h

O

_h

σ

δ

!

áa>$ððÛÞðð%&QEdTU^!

$ððÛ%!

( )

_O

h

H

O

C

P

C

h

σ

δ













=

!

$ðð×%!

(

_LZ

h

)

H

C

OC

P

LZ

h

σ

δ













−

=

1 !

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

!!"

_{!"#$%&'()*+,-./01,234567489:;<=>[email protected]}

I/JKLM5NOGHI/LM,018PQR8,STUVWXYZ[\]^_QR8,`abUcdeST

UVWEf

g@A+,!"#$8h>-.GHIUi>jEkl[mnUopqFklrs/Otru>5-.

GHI/JKLM[01/Dv8wZeh>xyYz{r|}Y]~+uFg

(16)

!""#$%

[

( )

h

( )

h

(

)

h

(

LZ

)

h

]

h

O

h

H

OC

P

σ

δ

−

+

=

1

1 %

&'()+,-.'/0123+,-.4()567889:7;<=>?@ABCDEF)GHIJ

'K2LMFNOPO4()5*QR23%

STU%

4

3

4

2

1 O

O

_C

P

H

C

P

C

P

C

P

C

P

₁

₊

₃

₊

₄

₊

₉

%

?;8VWXY%Y7%

C

O

₌

( ) ( ) ( ) ( )

C

₁

H

κ

1 C

₃

H

κ

3 C

₄

H

κ

4 C

₉

H

κ

9 %

Z[L\!""]9"^^$_*`a123%

!""]9"^"$%

O

i

O

i

H

i

C

P

C

₌

_κ

% %

%

_{b!cde%^e%fe%]g%}

!"^^$%

9

4

3

1

9

4

3

1

1 κ

κ

















































=

_P

P

O

%

hi'jk4lmno5*QR23hpq4LM'FrrsB4tuBlmvw5xyzlmF

{|F}~'/0O\Flmno5x!"^f$_'L\Qs23%

%

!"#$ %&'()*+,$

%

!"#$%&'()

%

!"^f$%

LS

₌

L

₋

(

L

HW

₊

L

NS

₊

L

CC

₊

TT

PW

₊

TT

UW

₊

TT

LZ

₊

LZ

)

%

!-.$ /0123456$

4I()aF*123rrBx+,-.'12I()a4

*NOPO,A123

!"^$_Bx'@12()5FD()

5*kF

!"^$_BxNOPO',-. ¡¢£FI()a¤R23

!"^¥$_Bx¦§

!"^$%

G

₈

₌

G

₈

I

₊

G

₈

C

%

!"^$%

CS

P

₃

G

₃

P

₇

G

₇

P

₈

G

₈

P

₉

G

₉

G

=

+

%

LZ

UW

PW

TT

!

LZ

L

CC

NS

HW

L

!

LS

(17)

$ð~×%!

SV

_G

₌

DI

_G

₋

CS

_G

!

!"#$ %&'()*+,-./$

$ð~%&Q§#En ÕÈ<k"ô¼8åØY"#QU^!

$ð~%!

E

DI

SV

₌

!

!0#$ &'12,-./$

·"ô¼8årÐQ-±-Ñûr¤+\BJ`%³AE

$ð~}%&_"´

>Q"#\TU^-±-Ñûr¤+Qtb¤<\TU^!

$ð~}%!

SV

DI

CPR

F

=

−

!

!3#$ 45678,-./$

"#Küý£S_"E

$ðÚñ%&%<AB"#HQ/`EW[ØYÄÅÆ¦E¡t%[TU

§r¤+yzQ¬EìÂ?ÃQ'$U^&bijrÄÅÆ¦®Qtb¤<\E

$ðÚ·%

&_"WXYrYQ/`TU^

$ðÚðÞðÚ%&_"ìÂ?Ã%I$Ur"#J¤

Q\KE"#:Q&bij%)8TU^V$ðÚ}%&_`rªL}Q/`TU^

!

$ðÚñ%!

(

DEP

IVT

CCW

)

SDP

CT

SV

GFC

F

E

G

H

N

+

−

+

=

!

$ðÚ·%!

IVT

₌

P

₁

Z

₁

₊

P

₂

Z

₂

₊

P

₃

Z

₃

₊

P

₄

Z

₄

₊

P

₉

Z

₉

!

$ðÚð%!

GFC

i

P

i

P

i

P

i

P

i

P

i

P

I

r

9

5

4

3

2

1

1 +

+

=

!

$ðÚ~ÞðÚ%!

I

i

r

I

i

=

! !

!

s!(·ÖØØØÖÙÖ!}{!

$ðÚ}%!

∑

=

9

1 j

j

SDP

!

!9#$ :;,-./$

¡tüý£S_"E

!"#

_{$ðÙñ%&%<ABËÌdE¡tØYrÈoöÉsË{}

_EiåsË{

_E

WrNr½º*ÊsË{ØY½º[tÍQ'$U^[[_"2ç!fQtb¤<\E½º[

tÍI¤+TU[\\V^"#ËÌdQtb¤<\E16CBr¡tØYrÈoöÉE

iåE

WrNr½º*ÊQtb¤<\V^

WXY%"2ç!fQì#3CBr89:\TU^

$ðÙ·%&_"¼¢Çr?*ÊsË{QE

$ðÙð%&_"¡t%[TU§r¤+Q'$U^!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

!"#

_{!"#$%&'()*+,-./0#123456789:;<=>?@;<=#AB5C8DEFGH>I}

DJ+,-#KLM5NOD8PQRSTU.VWXY5Z[M\]^DJ_`a#()*+,->bcdQ/

0e>fge#ABQ;<=#/0hi>fjk#lEQmBnop#0;M_q5+,-drstuv>wx

yU^DJz

(18)

$ðÙñ%!

(

)













+

−

+

=

PY

W

PY

W

PY

W

RV

W

RV

W

RV

W

OT

PR

CE

ER

E

P

E

P

E

P

E

P

E

P

E

P

OT

PR

CE

CEB

*

9

6

4

3

2

1

1 !

$ðÙ·%!

CT

₌

ER

_⋅

CT

_W

PY

₋

CT

_W

RV

*

!

$ðÙð%!

CCW

₌

ER

_⋅

CT

_W

PY

₋

(

CT

_W

RV

₊

CEB

)

*

!

!<=#$ >?@A,-./$

¯¨¹ºüý£S_"E&%$ðñ·Þðñ~%

E

$ðñ}%E

$ð·Ù%&a>UJ`biK÷Ü®\

$ðð}Þð~ð%&a>UJ`Û®Q/`TU^WXYQ$ðÙ~ÞðÙÛ%&%ãT^!

$ðÙ~%!

C

X

HW

C

H

1

1 =

+

!

$ðÙÚ%!

C

₃

₌

X

₃

HW

₊

X

₃

NS

₊

X

₃

CC

₊

C

₃

H

!

$ðÙÙ%!

C

X

HW

C

H

4

4 =

+

!

$ðÙÛ%!

C

₉

₌

C

₉

H

!

&T%$ðÙ×ÞðÛÙ%&%<AB&bijr¯°®Q'$U^!

$ðÙ×%!

₁

9

1

1 X

C

I

Z

E

XD

j

+

=

∑

=

!

$ðÙ%!

₂

9

1

2

2 X

I

Z

E

XD

j

+

=

∑

=

!

$ðÙ}%!

₃

9

1

3

3 X

C

G

I

Z

E

XD

j

+

=

∑

=

!

$ðÛñ%!

₄

9

1

4

4 X

C

I

Z

E

XD

j

+

=

∑

=

!

$ðÛ·%!

₅

9

1

5

5 X

I

XD

j

+

=

∑

=

!

$ðÛð%!

₆

9

1

6

6 X

C

E

XD

j

+

=

∑

=

!

$ðÛ~%!

XD

₇

₌

C

₇

₊

G

₇

!

$ðÛÚ%!

XD

₈

₌

N

₈

₊

C

₈

₊

G

₈

!

(19)

$ðÛÙ%!

₉

9

1

9

9 X

N

C

G

I

Z

E

XD

j

+

=

∑

=

!

&%$ðÛÛÞð×~%&%<ABE&bijr¯¨Q¹º~U^VÒ%âTUM$ÿá!N*O%a

>WrNefghkrbij%·TU¯¨¹º&QtT^!

$ðÛÛÞð×~%!

_{XD =}

_i

XS

_i

!

_{s!(·ÖØØØÖ{!}

&&%$ð×ÚÞð×Ù%&%<ABbi°PlmQWXUX¯¨¹º~EYE?r!RÏ6

QÝÞhQ³$U^!

$ð×Ú%!

LD

LS

j

=

∑

=

9

1 !

$ð×Ù%!

KD

KS

j

=

∑

=

9

1 !

½%%M$ÿá! NO%ABúÓTU^)+,123456%"Frbijlm\+,lmE

?lmEt¼2çlmI(ÄEWrÜ%"xËrM$ÿá! N*OI>^VIB·ð\r

lmr]]··\I¹ºTX´>7rlm"Ù+%¹ºTU^!

(

)

(

)

(

)

0 *

*

9

6

4

3

2

1

9

1

9

1

9

1 =













+

−

+













−

+













−

+

−

∑

=

PY

W

PY

W

PY

W

RV

W

RV

W

RV

W

j

OT

PR

CE

ER

E

P

E

P

E

P

E

P

E

P

E

P

OT

PR

CE

CEB

ER

KS

KD

R

LS

LD

W

XS

XD

P

!

W[_WrNefghkrbij%·TU¯¨¹º&Q456ØYtT^WXr¯°®Q$ðÛÙ%

&a>¯°ØYEbi®Q$ð×Û%&a>ØYïdTU^¹ºR%SÁ%EWrNefgh

krbijr¯¨¹ºQJ£SEM$ÿá!N*OrQTUTU^!

$ð×Û%!

XS

₉

P

X

₉

W

LD

₉

OS

₉

DEP

₉

IT

₉

SB

₉

SDP

₉

i

+

⋅

+

−

+

=

∑

!

VrV\Q³$U[\I_yA^

[[_"WrNefghkrbijQè!("ÿ*ÿ"

\E

!"#

_{$·Ù~%&\V^&"WX\rw[_ãXU^!}

!

!""#$ %&'()$

)+,123456"á·ñüý£SØYU^y<¹ºR%SÁ%EM$ÿá! NOrQT

UExËr!Sý"#QïdTU^!

&"2õæ_U^dØYYE"#Q'$U^!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

!"#

_{!"#$%#&'()+,-./0,1()+2345#6789:;<=9>?}

(20)

(

)

(

)

(

)

(

)

(

)

(

)

(

)

(

9

9 )

9

8

7

6

5

4

3

2

1

1 E

Z

I

G

C

N

P

G

C

N

P

G

C

P

E

C

P

I

P

E

Z

I

C

P

E

Z

I

G

C

P

E

Z

I

P

E

Z

I

C

P

GDP

N

+

=

!

"#$%&'(!

9

8

7

6

5

4

3

2

1

1 E

Z

I

G

C

N

G

C

N

G

C

E

C

I

E

Z

I

C

E

Z

I

G

C

E

Z

I

E

Z

I

C

GDP

R

+

=

! !

")*%&'(!

+,-%&'./0121345)6789:;%&'./0121-#$%&'<)%&'8=

>?@A4BC)*67-#$67<%&'./01218=>?@A4BDE:;!

R

N

GDP

P

₌

!

"%&'./0121(!

GDP

R

P

W

₌

!

")*67(!

+F-GHIJKLMNOP@QRS89:;

TU-VWXYZ[A\E:]^MN_`JabC

cU-VWXYZ[A\E:QRdJab@ef;!

(

DI

CPR

)

C

P

APC

_H

₌

O

_H

₊

!

"HIJKLMNOP(!

(

DI

CPR

)

SV

SVR

H

=

+

! !

!

"HIJQRS(!

+g-HIJhi89:;HIJhi-jkl345mnlopq:rstuhivwAxyz;!

(21)

( )

1 (

1 )

( )

1 −

−













−

+

=

u

F

u

H

u

C

U

σ

δ

!

sJ`rño{!

&W")+,r._U^J`I°])+,QoÕ_.TU^æçoÕhX

YQh¤Qýf")*+,ÒÜ%CJLEMNEOPWXUXQZX%TU[\rDQì

#.:QïdTUIE)*+,123456"ikÎÂ[\Îr]Q,'yAV$E^_

"WXQïdyØV^®%CJL.oÈrDQì#.:QïdTUæçoÕ`J¢

ÝQh¤Qýf%±²¡.:E456%JL.oÈrI(ÄyAV$ïdyA^!

(

)

(

HW

NS

CC

)

h

OC

L

W

dt

UPW

_{= 1}

₋

₊

!

s)*+,r.EoÕ{!

!

!!"# $%&'#

)å+,123456%a>EMN®I¦Vm}EJL%·TU)*+,biÌIVm

}EOPefghk%()Q¨2Vm}E+,%2$TU+Q¡Vm}\A]&r

ab!fcR89Q°V^!

dQü!fcR:;E&ab!fcR:;Q/01E237%45TU^3"e%-./

%ãXU±ÑQ"<_EËe%dQü!fcR:;E&ab!fcR:;Q±ÑØY

r¤¥0_ãT^

!"#

_!

C1$)ÿüýDf"WXUXI±Ñ\èBAynXyYE¤¥0"g_U^!

Cè-hi·Ø~D

f" ¿¥rÏ°H%a>E

J`%<nUMN®

NS

I·Ø~j%¦Vm}_U^!

C(!äO'i·Ø~Df"JIAÆr+«Â,-Ï.%a>EJL%·TU)*+,biÌ

µ

hw

IJ`

%<AB·Ø~jVm}_U^!

Cá)'! k! ñØññÙDf"OPefghk%WrbijQ/Ë~Ua]E°PorñØÙl8E

()Q¨2Vm}_U^y<)*+,-./%aU\E()0"OPefghkEJLef

ghk%<ABgE

!$#

_{MNefghk%<ABñØÛl_>E4°rMNefghk\mÆr(}

)0QnBAU^!

CþO'ÞñØñÙDf"-0ã0r1oyz%a>E§2ÒÜyz+,%2$TU+Q¡Vm}

_U^!

xËEWXUXrab!fcR:;Q,/TU^!

!

!"#$ %&'()*+,-.$

MN®

NS

_{I·Ø~j%¦Vm}EMNefghr!}

_!

_{"ñØñ~ÛlEY""ñØñÛðl}

TU^WrV$lmbijra>)*+,roIw[%EMN"J`bijØY

lmbij%a>TU^MN%·TU)*+,®#

"#

_{"ð}Ø}ñlr¦EMNefghrJ`}

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

!"#

_{!"#$%&'($)*+,-./0123456789:;<=+>?@0ABCDEF}

!$#

_{GHIJKLM6NOPQRS,9KTLUVW9XYZ[0\]D^6_`6aCbcd"9efg(hi;}

jk0lmnoPp;+qPE:;D^KLM+,9rsg(hi3tuvawxyz{|}g(hi3tu~

]g(hi`;XYS,QRS+,9rs#;XYUn"PEF

CC6N:;]0CD9:",;; 6¡~¢9QRS0

&'($)*0®¯DEF

日本経済における無償労働のマクロ・インパクト - 無償労働SAM/CGEモデルによる分析 -

!"#$%&'()*+,-./01234/56

7)*+,89:;<=>?@A%B(CD7

!

!

!

!

"#$%!

&'(! )*+,-./!

&0(! )*+,123456!

&7(! 89:;!

<=>%!

!

!"#$%

?@%<ABC)*+,D"EFGHIJK%JLEMNEOPQRSTUV$EWXY%ZL

TU[\QA]^

!"

[[_"EJ`I)*+,%a>bcdTefghQCJ`bijD

EikIl

m%<nU+,QoABbcdTE

#"

J`bij\pqrefghstuEvwMNExPyz{

QClmbijD\A]^!

J`%<nUJLEMNEOP"EJ`bij\lmbijr|c}=~%aB>^

 CuLD"E\%FGHr)*+,%a>=XE\%ikIRSTUtu%a>=X

U^!

r|c}=~"E_yA^ITX E)*+,roIEJ

`")*+,QYEuLQa>tu%~U_]^turI ¡yX EJ`

"WXQYE)*+,QoABJ`¢_uLQa>£U_]^!

[r|c}=~r¤¥"E)*+,r¦Q§#E+,S¨%©ªQ«¬T^­Vlmbijr

bi®r¦Q§#E+,¯°%©ªQ«¬T^+,¯¨%±²lm_I³­X EWX"

´µ)*+,roElmbijr%©ªQ¶EJ`bij\lmbijr|c}=~

Q¤¥~U^!

[ra]%JLEMNEOP%·TU)*+,EJ`bij\lmbijr|c}=~"¸¹

ºr»|cQ§#BE¼½¾%©ªQ«¬T^ ¿À%<nUJ`\ikr8ÁÂÀÃÄÅ

ÆE+,ÇÈÉÊË%<nUJL%·TUbiÌÍ\+,S¨®r·ÎH%AB89QÏ$

UV$%"E)*+,QÐ8¹º\BÑUÒn_y¡E!

Ó! ZÔbirÕÖt%×ØXBAV)*+,%aUJ`bijrbiEÙÚÛQeÜÝÞ

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

!

!"#$!%&'()*+,-./01%2345,678-99:;<=>?@AABC>DEFG!>DEFHI

>DEJ

K23LMNOPQRSKTUV%W

*23XYOZ[23K\W

*]^_`O-a.b9-bbW>23,c>

defghijk

!"#lm+nC7opqr%)s-9tK-99u/0WV)vwxiyz{nF|}~F+>23M

8 ;=>P,evZ\qrJZeij!"gi8 ;=J#+,

-9/0)23 ¡¢8 >£¤¥¦>¡¢23J

K §O¨©ª«¬­®¯°±²

³®´µ¶³·¸¹)Wvwxi23,c>defghijk

!"g#*-99./º»ei ;=>¼½¾¿ÀÁ*Â¯Ãei\ÄÅ´¼Æ*

ÇÈÉvÊËÌÍÎ>ÏVÐÑÒÓÔvÕÖ×ØÓÙÚÛqr>ÜÝÞg¾¿ijk

!">P,vwßà#%)á23)vwßà*â>§Bãäåæç>èéÐ²ê³ëßìßjíäå

wîïÀðñijÐw!">ò^ó*ôõö#÷N>øùväiÕ>ghijk

"#

;<=K;úûüýþkÿk<üÿk=ÿ üûWvwßà8 J#*´ZKs¨NZWväà

i8ÓÙÐBC>DEJ>vhiÕ>>*

8ð>BC>DEJ>viQ>ßËj6*

ÌÍ*vÕ*ß*)K!³µ¶!*"#*$*%4N*&'(öWÒhijk

$#

)**+É>,HIvwxi8Je-.ijk

᪥ᮏ⤒῭䛻䛚䛡䜛 ↓ൾປാ䛾䝬䜽 䝻 䞉 䜲 䞁 䝟䜽 䝖

䠉↓ൾປാ

SAM䠋CGE䝰䝕䝹䛻䜘 䜛 ศᯒ䠉

∾

㔝

ዲ

ὒ

䛿䛨 䜑䛻

➨䊠❶

↓ൾປാ

SAM

➨䊡❶

↓ൾປാ

CGE䝰䝕䝹

➨䊢❶

ศᯒ⤖ᯝ

䛚䜟䜚 䛻

!"#$%&'()*+,)-./012 *..-345/462 +057/89:;<=>%()?*@ABCDEFG

_{[[_"EJ`I)*+,%a>bcdTefghQCJ`bijD}

_EikIl

_{J`bij\pqrefghstuEvwMNExPyz{}

J`%<nUJLEMNEOP"EJ`bij\lmbijr|c}=~%aB>^

CuLD"E\%FGHr)*+,%a>=XE\%ikIRSTUtu%a>=X

r|c}=~"E_yA^ITXE)*+,roIEJ

`")*+,QYEuLQa>tu%~U_]^turI ¡yXEJ`

"WXQYE)*+,QoABJ`¢_uLQa>£U_]^!

[r|c}=~r¤¥"E)*+,r¦Q§#E+,S¨%©ªQ«¬T^Vlmbijr

bi®r¦Q§#E+,¯°%©ªQ«¬T^+,¯¨%±²lm_I³XEWX"

´µ)*+,roElmbijr%©ªQ¶EJ`bij\lmbijr|c}=~

Q¤¥~U^!

[ra]%JLEMNEOP%·TU)*+,EJ`bij\lmbijr|c}=~"¸¹

ºr»|cQ§#BE¼½¾%©ªQ«¬T^ ¿À%<nUJ`\ikr8ÁÂÀÃÄÅ

ÆE+,ÇÈÉÊË%<nUJL%·TUbiÌÍ\+,S¨®r·ÎH%AB89QÏ$

UV$%"E)*+,QÐ8¹º\BÑUÒn_y¡E!

Ó! ZÔbirÕÖt%×ØXBAV)*+,%aUJ`bijrbiEÙÚÛQeÜÝÞ

_{!"#$!%&'()*+,-./01%2345,678-99:;<=>?@AABC>DEFG!>DEFHI}

!"#lm+nC7opqr%)s-9tK-99u/0WV)vwxiyz{nF|}~F+>23M

8;=>P,evZ\qrJZeij!"gi8;=J#+,

-9/0)23 ¡¢8>£¤¥¦>¡¢23J

K §O¨©ª«¬®¯°±²

³®´µ¶³·¸¹)Wvwxi23,c>defghijk

!"g#-99./º»ei;=>¼½¾¿ÀÁÂ¯Ãei\ÄÅ´¼Æ*

ÇÈÉvÊËÌÍÎ>ÏVÐÑÒÓÔvÕÖ×ØÓÙÚÛqr>ÜÝÞg¾¿ijk

!">P,vwßà#%)á23)vwßà*â>§Bãäåæç>èéÐ²ê³ëßìßjíäå

_{;<=K;úûüýþkÿk<üÿk=ÿüûWvwßà8J#*´ZKs¨NZWväà}

i8ÓÙÐBC>DEJ>vhiÕ>>*

8ð>BC>DEJ>viQ>ßËj6*

ÌÍvÕß)K!³µ¶!"#$%4N*&'(öWÒhijk

_{)**+É>,HIvwxi8Je-.ijk}

᪥ᮏ⤒῭䛻䛚䛡䜛 ↓ൾປാ䛾䝬䜽䝻䞉䜲䞁䝟䜽䝖

_{SAM䠋CGE䝰䝕䝹䛻䜘䜛 ศᯒ䠉}

䛿䛨䜑䛻

_SAM

_CGE䝰䝕䝹

䛚䜟䜚䛻

!"#$%&'()+,)-./012 ..-345/462 +057/89:;<=>%()?*@ABCDEFG

₂

~<(qrst]OHP#2

H2

IJ ¡¢STUV]£¤¥¦] ¡§

,¨©ª«

¬®¯°±²³´µ°¶·µ¸9¹$m¢STUV)*+§º»]¼½IJ<¾¿#$(

ÀkÁ<klOH½ÂºÃÄÅDÆ>%Ç)*+]È<OH2

ÉDÇ)*+<Ê±ËD(XÌ(ÍÎ(ÏÐDiOHSTUV<ÑDÒGmuz{~#$%

¢STUVuz{~§<(ÀkQ<ÓÔ½ÂºÃÕÅDÆ>%~]È<&ÖOH2

F×DÇ~<Ø=$(RÍÎÙÚÛ$m`(^XÌDiOHSTUVZ[cÀÜ$m

`(dÏÐ°±ÝËÞDßàá<hâ$m`(ãäåæç:;UVDâèOHéê<ëì$m

`:;]íµîïð<OH½ÂºÃñÅDÆ>%òóôõ<löH÷mHøíµðº

ùú]äûH2

ÃqD(ÍÎÙÚÛ$m`(ÍÎ°±ÝË]¦ü(ýþÿáº#DÀÜOHPGºÍÎ

Di$%_`Z[\ÆWUVÚÛOH##D(XY]STUVÙÚÛ(UVghÙ

]ÚÛDHmHÙºOHÍÎDi$%XYZ[\(_`Z[\]

º#DÚÛOH(¾¦ü]DWû(f×fDWûðOHXÌ(ÏÐDi

$%Ç]ð×GHýþz(zº#DÚÛ$mq((!

×HXY]!=º"ú$m2

Ã#D(X$%&]'()*+,-DWûXÌDiOHSTUVZ[cÀÜ$m`(XYZ

[\]¦ü"ú(XÌº_`Z[\×XYZ[\DðOHSTUVZ[cÀÜOHm

(STUVÙºOHÇD¾¦ü$(ÍÎ(ÏÐ_`Z[\×XYZ[\D

ðOHÙ!UVghÙºÚÛ(.]ôõ(ýþÿáº"úOH(z/±0±]

"úZ1(ÿáºÀÜOHýþz(zº#DÚÛOH2

ÃªD(ÏÐ°±ÝË]¦ü<ú2HWÔ34[ÞDßàá<hâ$m`(°±ÝË¦ü"

ú(ÏÐºXYZ[\×_`Z[\DðOHXÌ(ÍÎD5>%º¾¦üû

$:>m(

XYZ[\]67Ù(

_`Z[\]XYÙDº8#9;×G::m

ßàá];hDWûqr<]o=ò>º(.GD?>!$(@ABº$

mýþz(zº#D))$m2

ÃCD()DED]Ø=:;DWû(äåæç:;UVDâèOHéê<ëì$m`(UVgh

Ù(Ùº#DÚÛOHUVghÙ]ÚÛºýþÿá<FFH(z/±0±

"úOHm(ÿáºÀÜOHG=]"úD?>XÌ(ÍÎ(ÏÐº_`Z[\×X

YZ[\HðOHýþz(zº#DÚÛOH2

ÃÄÅº¢STUV)*+§]È<&ÖOH

_{.Gº)+ÀD)?@ABCEOIJK}

L<kI(JKÀD.G#&LDSTUVMDiOH±0<&'OH

_{¾¿º»]¼½}

_{!"#$%&'()*+,-./012345#6789:6745;<=67>?@ABCCDE}

_FG3H>0

_{YYZ['()*\]^+_`0abc&Wde[fghijklmnopqlrstquARSSCE0vw+YxWX}