19世紀ドイツの現在価値償却の課税実務 : 1888年12月19日プロイセン上級行政裁判所の判決

全文

(1)<=. >?.

(2) . . .

(3) . . . . . . !! " #$. #% & # ' #" #(#)*+ #. , ! -.. /& 0 '')## '$$# "1#. . . . . . . 2 0 &. . '3 4 2 . '5 . . 6. . . . .

(4) . . 7 . . ( . /& 0 . & '# . . & . . . . . & . . 8 9 . . . . . 0 . . . # . 0 . 9 & & 9 . .

(5) . . ' . '. . . . . '. . . . . . . . . & . . . . . . . #.

(6)

(7) "#$%&'()*+,-./0'12-3. 456. !. 78 9:;.

(8) ¯°±4 ²²³´. ¸µ. µ¶¶· ³e.

(9) . !"#$%&#'()*+,-.. "/0 123456789:5;<=>?@ABCDE

(10) F0 GHIJ KLMNO#P.

(11) .

(12) . QRPSTUVQ

(13) WRTXYZ/"[\]^_0à bcW%d0 e fKLMN%ghijk' P !

(14) QklP"

(15) #

(16)

(17)

(18) # !

(19) $# %% mQ

(20) kl 9:5;<=no+pZ/" q_r.sno+p>?@AB) )_0 no+p>?@AB&#'()0Ctuvwx_0 kl5;<=+pqZ/" yno+pq P ! Qzz56{|}F"~}_"zzr.E} _" 0W!" c(}` <S1PQ}"/PR}_"t Q )_0qP PQ. Q F"t>?@AB . F "¡¢£¤_"/ . ¥ . ¥ ~ ¦§<<S /_]¨<S© . ª . >?@A« PQ &' () * . +

(21) . $ ! ( ,

(22) -. %

(23) /01 223 4 5 067 8 9:; < = >? 6 % " $

(24) # %% m.

(25)

(26) . . !"#$%&'( )*+ ,-."/.012"345678&'9:.0 ;<=*>? *>? @AB,C%D&E)*+ F-..0G, H2I34*>G<-..0G12"9:.0J*>?KL"/M P. =NO%QR,ST,UV(WXI ="YZ,. . ![\( ]^('_Ìabc

(27) G=O%Q def9g"/=hij k lmnopiqri. .

(28)

(29) . . .

(30).

(31)

(32) s ftpu v wgO%&'xy,z/Ì . { ,|}~"/Q . &',H2Ij ! ". #f ,(MtyI2%Q1,CMD"I P=B'*+KLO%34*>?'-..012"9:.0*> $;% j k ly ¡¢dode,j12Q*>KLj &k lde. ! . ' ( ! )*. # (. . !. + . . ! + ++ £!. ++ &£¤ - k ld , -++ £! e . ! . ' ( ! )* # (. . !. + . . ! , &++ £-! + - de¥,j k ly ¡¢dode . ! ' ( ! ". .. ! )* # (. . !. + . . ! . + -f k ly ¡¢dode¦§ , ++ -£! ,¨©"/M'ª%Q=Bj@Tde«¬2'2%Q k lmnopiqri s 56.®¯°±,H2Itp ²³ j´µ ²f¶$TI2%·ss¸¹'56*+~º»6*+=, ¼"Ij@¯°± D"I½c,¯O%¾¥T/KLKL"/¿tp ²& /j´µ ²ÀÁQª%¯°±,H2Itp ²&/j´µ ²fÂ3 / . Ã$%D¬,jÄÅjtp ²&/j´µ ²,Æ$IÂ3 ÇO% È*ÉO%Q@ÊËª%Ì,ÇO% jÍÎÏ¯°± D" IÐÑ"1XTÒ112Q ! ". #01 231 4 567 2 6 82 9:9 1 ; 5< 2 6 =68>? ? 2 6< 4 1 @ A2 6 B6< 2 9 62 AC=6D 2 6, Ó ++ &£&.

(33) ¹ºjI »»¼½. ÂÃ. ¾¿¿À ¼Á. .

(34)

(35)

(36) .

(37) . !"# $%&'($)*+,!". -./ -01 2345676389 : ;<=)*+,5 6>?@#$)*+,!"AB. C. DEFGHI3JGK. LFGMNOPQ@RSTU$!"@V WXYZG3[ \$]^_=à. bO 2c defghijIFklm t. no$pqrs iuvwx6y!"z{w|$'!D$HI$. z$h}`~. U3F W/T$ I. . .

(38) 5 $ m %&$W4$!" /T$ $) )*+, C a q¡¢ /T$6y£ ¤/T$)¥ /T$) /¦ bO /§¨©)*+,ª$bOG5« ¬ Z¨©r ® ¯°s±²³´$µ¶3·¸ .

(39) . . ! " #$. . . ! ! . . . " % $ "&. $ " # $ $.

(40) $ " . " '

(41) ( )* + ,. /01 2 345 6 0 . 7 89 : ;<9 2 6 7 8. 9 = 2= >.,. /0 1 2 345 6 . 7 8234?,. /0 1 2 345 6 5 . 9 7 82 6 @ 0 . A 9 2 " B && BDBÄBB uvÅ ÆÇ ÈÉÊËÌÍÎÏ && BCCÄBB vÐ CÁ )Ñ$4WV$ÒZ bÓÔÕÖ9×ØÙ$Ú*ÛÜ%&$ Ä %ÔhÝ$/TÞß m)6*+,à á¹ºjIâ BB½EED ÁB t $ & F9 -A 0G 9 2 01 2 8 H . 2 9 6 7 8 -I9 1 04J34??9 -K42 /9 7 A1 345?.I9 1 04J 2 8H . 9 4 DE && Ä C

(42) ãäåg æçLMN O+ P P. . $

(43) $ Q$ $ ( $ R OP SQ

(44) $. $ $ P Q

(45) $. $ P. $ P. $ T O 2gåè $éê 2ëìí$îïðrsÐñDò'(VóWV

(46) ôõUT#Nöà÷ øå÷ùs ú]ãûüý÷øå÷3üþÇ ©.

(47)

(48) . ÐÑ. . !"#$%&' (&)*. + ,-./& ( (&)* + . !"01 234%56789:"#$%;<. =>?@AB"#$%&' (&)* +. .

(49) ! "# ! !$ % &' ( CD +EF./GHIJ

(50) J"./KL"M%IJ Q 78. !"NOP. !R $%"SO1PTUVWXYZ[[\]>. V^#_àTUZbcdeWOf[[ghi jkl mno%pqrRCsV$%qt

(51) ROuW%Cv"MXPwx3O yn]>1z4R{|"}4%~WuVOzVnoXYfIJZq t

(52) RIJGH\. y Nc V1YfzB1OV1PIJ>d 1uW nj\R 1W4W3WOV1YfS3" Z$%. qr1.F. ¡¢ u3 £ qr1¤" qr 1YVOOoV¥¦u § 1u¨©Vª«¬WOnZ.Z ®u7¯°n±²1³"´µrWWXPOYVOf¶W b4WW%V1Yf · ¸¹º»¯"}»1Y ¼½d./¾¿À ! ! ÁÂÃÄªÅZÆM"Ç~PO%f$W¥È 78& ( ÉnÊS4PO%qt

(53) Z./ VLË ! " "Mc>%fzUn

(54) F./Z$n" ÌÍÎÏ°S.

(55) ÅhØ ÙÙÚÛ. ßà. ÜÝÝÞ. Ú¬.

(56)

(57) . . !

(58) "#$%#&'(. )). *# +,-

(59) ./0#1!23,45678,)9*) . :;<1

(60) :=1:;

(61) *">? @A+,-BCD. E

(62) .F8GH#I

(63) JKLM . ,NO, P ,QR . . . S-F:TUVW4:

(64) *"+, * JKLM,NO:>X YZ[,\]^_àbc , dN,efg`<*hi

(65) +,j)Fklmn #. o2pqrn ! `stuvF

(66) :wV,4" xyz,{|}~#!W :`") { |}~#!:!

(67) HQ`klmnuH\] ^_ YZ[ "

(68) #

(69) #YZ[, PI . $ "$YZ[: " ,#$p0,hi:X,HQ p,8G,NO1,#4^,,8 , NO . ! % . ¡N

(70) " u4 ¢£ ¤l¥¦ & . . . . §¨ ©%. . ª«, NO#I

(71) HQS-F

(72) :

(73) *:¤lª,HNQ# # ". ¬ ,K®¯°±%,st`S-

(74) :

(75) *:4"8 G,NO:\]^_²³

(76) ,\]^_:JKLM:²³NO 4:

(77) *0´Jµ¶·,¸¹ºhi»u`¼

(78) c 8GNO :½`~¾,)`¿À#!

(79) :

(80) *,4";:;: YZ[ÁÂ#

(81) .E56ÃÄ56Å:ÆJ; ÇfÈ,É^_,NO`Ê!

(82) Ë.

(83) I,NOÌÍ#8 #. Î#²³4!:;JKLM,+,Ï,NO`ÐÑ#

(84) . E#Ò³8GHÓv º, `Ç Ë\]^_)Fstu vF

(85) :

(86) *"56,}ÔÕÖ}HK®,H+×¯n,H.

(87)

(88) . . àá. !"#$%&'(. )*+,-./ .

(89)

(90)

(91) 01$234 56789:7;</=> ?0@A<BCD, -EFGH<IJ"FGHKLEMGHMDN <OPHN 3QROP;S

(92) "TE UVWX<2*YZ[ \]^<_à"bcEdefg"%HGEhijkNlmn 45<2o<pqr<2stuv*wxyz U {|DAA<MD}~<EEKoqjk[D !KGH<E f$eg"%HGE45 <2A< N<21!" fu45%!EBH ,_Hg"A< f"<@ <EUVW!S

(93) VN<2N 3QROP"$<;=R"E!EA< n!¡DMA GE¢£¤¥ U ¦FHK<§ï©

(94) !ªBN<2 A!"«=R¬*w®¯°±²§³*w ´MD D M<<2A<Hµ«¶·¸*¹/

(95) . 0 µnNGEº»¼½«¶¾Ne*¹¯W <¿f "T E=R"$À u v * w x y z T F e Á ° ¯ Â Ã Ä Å / 0ÆÇN<ÈÉ7"ÊEdeA!"ËK JÌ ÍÎÏÄÐuÑ¬ÒÓªB<2 uvÔÎÏ®uÑÕÖN<@×/

(96) . !

(97) 0$e "HØÙªÚÛ"ÜÝÍ"ÞßH.

(98) ÍÍ. ÆdÇ ÈÈÉS. ÊËËÌ É. . . .

(99) . !"#$%&' (()*+,-./. 0%&12345678 9:;<=>?+< @AB CDE3) F

(100) 67+ G HI +

(101) JKLM2NOPQRS2T ((

(102) >?+G<@ABU-MVWG)XYZ[\? #]2)^T_Z`,M2(] . JK

(103) abc] 2abde f(

(104) VWG ghi,G

(105)

(106) jk

(107) ,"M2)()l

(108) LM2NOPQR S JKmno+)NOpqrZNOstu*PQRS vN8 wxyz{|}~ rl r { 2(]x Opqr )rZpqrstuPQRS ONOZ Hj2 ( +

(109) JKZde)f. !. ) `,\)2Z{VI <=}()Z9:{E

(110) ()f"\ %&x) ,\ ,)(){~2¡¢£ ¤L¥R¦§¨©ª«¬¤

(111) ®I@¯°±² +

(112) VW+,-.³´0µ¶··>?+ <@AB"\(]{¸¹º]()Z

(113) »2) f ]\¼}½)3#]2 . JKdeu (])`,¾^{E

(114) ,NOPQR Spqr

(115) ¿Àc]2` Á Â . ÁÂ' %ÃÄ

(116) ,}ÄT_{c#(]{Å.

(117)

(118) . . ñò. !"#$%&"'$"(&"). *+( , -./0123'45(46789:;<" (&")=<"( -.>?@A=BCDEF1G %?@HIJK"4L3'$>?@BCDEFMN 23OP Q"()RSTFUV WXYZ[Z$\X]^Y;_##àb)=cd e;:BfgdZ<cdhiY;jkl3mn"N, 4opq($_#&-r

(119) stu4$v4*/wx $,y1,Qz%${|}~1,-r

(120) / . 1;<-r

(121) +Y$z;$:$". (K_QzM)=<&}~'$$:<"9 ER . .

(122) q(1}~$:'$ "(&< -./¡¢£¤¥:)"%4 )¦¦§¨©ªN«^<q(1¦¦¬1)D EF /¡¢u1~^Y:1e(|5dI/®¯°±% 4²?@%4³/~^%´K1eq($µ%¶'$ "(R¯·¸STFUV¹º» V +¦¦¼u3<4½*¦¦-r

(123) k/t¾%<¿_ ÀYZ[Z$¼Á/Â=<Ã= Ä ÅÆÇ1, Rm È V&ÉÊË3cÌ1hiY;Í""+1"*{zÉ ÊË3ÎÏ"e&ÂÇY;ÐÑ]1,Ò¼Áu3 _Ó1}|Ô¶')&&"4:Õq($&"^:4"$ Ö R -.1,Á×ØÙ1-r

(124) /i" . ÚY;<F/Y;<Û¬ÜÝ?@%µÒÚ. Þ)R¯ ß àcÌÁ Äáâ ÄÁãäV Y;<Ûå1)FæZ*R. "9¶')"( ¯çèéêë1q"&;:FæZ*ìÙíî/ïð.

(125) ÊË»Ì ÍÍÎÏ. ÎÑ. ÐÑÑÒ! Î.

(126) . ! "#$%&'()* +,-./01234. 5601 7,2)*8 9:;34 6< =: 1> . ?;@A. =:12BC:DEFG(HIIA. /JK,;LMNOPQ >

(127) . . ?RST. U34 BV2)*/01 WXYZ 2[ 4 BV2\][WX. S 23. ^ W_5`Wab>. . ?. Ec-;^d (S[ab E@e;S ^ abE@ f; g342h ij2 < h ij2 < X YBV[ ng.[. s4W. kH0l ijBV2<m> ?Z. <m <o2pq!`)*/W<r20134. s4Wtu. 2Jvw xy3z. {g01WH|} xy>~u)* Jx? {/01W2[. 2[(;BC:D]58. J g[S C2 > ?!. d (!. J (q81. > ! . ?>c ¡?¢£g. 2[¤A/¥¦ /> . ! . ?>§¨?¢£g. 2[¤vwx 3z >" !. ?XY¢£[Y[ [>,©ª«¬®¯h °###E±²? d2³ ´µ;¶j[;[S. ³ ´µ. 2 34 BV2[¤34 ! BVEt·[Y[¸ A/ ##! ¹º »¼'( EL ½¾W

(128) (H QXY2[¤_xL¿` À2H;gÁÂ/)*(HQ Ãw[Y[[[H. d /G! 34B. VEZng<m ^ mÄ2vwÅÆ^¢£gT.3z ÇÈÉ Â®w[Y[[.

(129)

(130) .

(131) . %&'()*. ïð. !"#$. +,-./012345678559:. /9#;<3=>?@ABC7'9'DE7FG+ %. HIJ KL .

(132). M)NOPQ/&'R/. STUVWXYZ-[\7 9. /9# . ]4^_àST-bDE4cd'. efghi/DEj+klm/ no)pqrst&F(/. -uv4w. ]4^. :(7%&>xy@)(23z {|}~. \+/55&594^#:/9#>DEm d '23L M xy@K) >xy@/5 4^. 4^. 67. L M4%59]. :&(7// DE/ -w5). 4 L M]5_m)DE&]5_-1'9' ;7 ]] ¡xy@45'¢£)=¤] &759] 4^. :;F¥xy@-DE. m/¦¡& §¨©ª595.

(133) -«wF¥

(134) xy@)¬ &'559:

(135) /$G /§-q>DE& Fm/;>®¥¯&'9Fm/§/015. 5;. <3=

(136) (s°

(137) //±²)³F( /5. :. ´µgh7'9 7. ei &]&;7-¶·E_¸. (/)>¹º&' ;7»¼ghei½>m¾¿_À9' Á. Â// ÃÄ. :/9# ÅÅÆÇÈÉÊ&'½. Ër-ÌÍd'.Î&F/(/Ï5_ÅÅefÐÑr-ÒEDEÓÔÕ sÖDEÓ×ØF¥^ ¥ÜdF¤KÝ7 F. Ôâ)\&'9. 9<3"d'ef;ÙÚÛF 4&'59]4^. :Þ¥'ßàá. ãääå;æeiçè¦5´µÖ´. éêëiDEF¥5'559PQìíîG+.

(138) ÜÝÞ ßßàá. àâ. âããä½ à¾.

(139) . ! "#$% &'"()*+,-./011. 23$% 456

(140) "(78 79: ;$%56

(141) <==>?(@ABC DEF GHIJK. LIM# ! "#$. %NOPQAKRSTTUEQA" 2V WXEYZ " 2TTQA[@BCN\]^ _àbcH d e"fghi2 *3#*@BC3 jk l */>? =N,m1m*M\nopqrsas7tu v_wx` . !#yz{i2K|Na}:(}. ~\.

(142) .

(143). `8fU/b ="( ab/b= ~. \.

(144) . ` . N TT: *N! "#N(K MTT cl K*4 . k ¡¢£¤w¥. = f l/¦ §¨1! ©ª ¦ « . M!2;¨1I ¬<N¦ . . ®K¯°±N ¦ }²/³ÝZ µ¶82. /·©¸¹,"#RS*º#Km. = "#=;¦ U ¸¹<mm»p. K¼½¾/ ¿N ½ À / Á ½ 8 K Â Ã Ä Å Æ Ç f È É Ê ÂÃÄÅÆÇ/YZË¦ . Á½. ÌÍÎ½9 l 01f/ÏÐ= Ñ(¦ . Ò©ª ½Ó ÂÃÄÅÆÇ. 8f ÌÍÎ y½kYZ #ÔÕÖ01f×/ ØÐ. ÙÚlm1ÛyÑ(¦ Ò'. \ `.

(145)

(146) . . !"#$%. '()*+,- ./0'1 45?@AB. éê. &# . 23456789:;<=>. CD45@ABEFGHI:;<EFGJK(. )*54LMN

(147) O4O ' P QRSTUVTUW X Y Z[\OV]^ Z[_àb8cOd5e%f5? $g hABij7kl54:)mno'pqrs q rK(tuOd5?6%vwxyz{|v&}~OI G}O&&567OI:f?. #A#*MN

(148) >$ ;}. v|#:-%:v:f?$*7. :*45sps>+ 5$¡¢. £T¤}¥e¦5§Ö"©OI:f:v. ª#«

(149) e%:-%:v:f?*¬#6]. ®. ABh¯+°@AB±²:5$g³ij. 45. *´µCD45:vf|:5¶·&¸¹:l4LMN

(150) 7b8 9:5Odº»?6 »:6. ¼¨7½¾¿#f*ÀÁ:f. O¨¾Â#no'pqr\Ã¯%5ÄÅs. Æ~K(Ç}~#*&È#ff»6$#¼no&½É ÊË)v:f&#A45f»6#|&®sÆ~' pqre%*sOÌB456 qrK(¼Í½'7)|5 f»6. Î~45Ï¹:f?6¶·#CD#:-%:v:. f > Ð Ñ Ò Ó 4 5 Ô p Õ d & b } : Ö ; V

(151)

(152)

(153)

(154) [hI6¡¢O×)%f5OdØ#&ÙÚ GÛÜOD456% +ÝfO:f? °]. <Þ¸CD45ße%*6ºà:+]á. 7²â±1. ãä#*åæ;<È#f:#:v:|*. 6ç#fè7:l&v|Od+¯*MN

(155). V]^ Z[6.

(156) ¹ ;º »»¼½. ¼Â. ¾¿¿À ¼Á. .

(157) . !"#$%&. '()*+,-. .

(158) /01#23#4%. #5. #6789:;#<=>'?@(A5BCDE(67?F #G'HI0JK5LM05N#$OP! I'Q5&P!(RS5%TUVWOXYZ%;[0 55\]^_`!a5bQcdeP!f#gh#54* 5%&5\i(jkelm*5 p%LMPqrstu. n*lm*o. OvwB'OUZxyW0z{|. (}%)\(~(b*A#>I'Q5&Z#( ?n?P!?P!. '?n?. (. ?(Z%?F(5Hl>'55I'G. . ?0X5. N$%5xyWJK5%*(Ngh. #5& H(5JK5%?@L )\P!OZ% 0#4%G\(X 0$%&5\b¡ ¢ D #4¡?l£¤¥0dXbN5NA?0¦§N #c¨5\67©ª#$%& )\X 0N 67L«¬«®¯°±HI# rs\´ A. . ²q³I#4%)\LM. #$%67µ¶·¯I. 'Q5#$¸\&.

(159)