教育におけるスピリチュアリティ : 自我を育てる・自我から離れる

全文

(1)人間関係研究（南山大学人間関係研究センター紀要）, 7, 175-202.. . .

(2) ÙÈÉL<UÈÉ ÚQÙ. ÛÜÜÝÞßàÛáRâ¢ Øãä åÜæÛÜä åÜ ç°ST èéêëì!. íî. . . . . . ¦. . ¦. ¼½STSTKLT±¾K´¢. .

(3)

(4) .

(5) !"#$%&'#()* +,-.#/0123* 45#672389:;<= >9 * =$?@() A A $B CD=EFGH*-IJ$KLMNO PQR+$STKLU 2#6 GH$?@(VW) XYZ[M\]Q-X^CD_$CD$\`-ab (> >9cd(-efg .

(6). hijg

(7) hg .

(8). CD

(9). kl=Q<>Wk-mQIJnop $:;* q$r st*a>$quvwV$()xw<-(- XYyGz{ $CD$\`$|}wk~]Q-15123 ij . .

(10). $CD >9-V9 $ q$stk ]QWw )xm(--A A $efhijhw-WR+WcWQ<>>15123 >9 $s t - $?@w-w<>pwWw ) 15## w<aEF*O a¡¢$H£ QS¤S¥¦§¨©ª«¬-®¯°ST15T±²³ K´¢ 15123$\`*µ¶!2323·7#¸¹º ]QI»}¦¼½STST¾K´¢()£¿ $À; ÁÂµ!' pnÃ$*OÄm (-IÅ-¼Å-R+-]-xQ ÆÇ ¢*ÈÉ$:;mm(ÀÊw-STKL£d *15123$ËÌ$ÍÎÏdk|;<m ÐÑw<>W)

(11) Ò£Ów>Ô£Õw>c> n>Wk-Ö{. ―175―.

(12) W !"#$ïðbñ={<>cd n>W) +Ròóôk-õö*->. !"#$Ì8$òóô÷w<-. >ø>ø ù(>w<c]{<> n>Wk-ú$$ò ûü]<>cW) +RI»}wcw¢ý S¤S¥££wc>;þ¢ò¬ -£¿£w<$-<$ÁÂµ!'º]<>c W)2#6yWkKL£d15123ÙÈÉL <UÈÉ ÚQÙ >92#6]<>cWw) m$ . !"#-+,º QST-Vw-õ. w>- Vwf$V >9-mQ $õ w>12#Â!$8V k-KL$-> U KUK-Ö-Ö $->

(13) $ ->ø>ø >9$<|}wk-(m [w w;<>(> >9-x9>9p9n>V <-Ì-WSTKL{<>. !"#³( ]Q<£W). xm(m$¿-G15123 >9m $ë#.#/! w <>ø>ø ¯(-I»ýST$GH£ ù(k-

(14) Tg ÀÊ-xw<-S¤S¥ý-(è®¯°ST< 15T± >9T±ùQ<-

(15) 1 5## w<-$a-a£«k = Q$kù{ -Wc> =Q) (Vx9>9 K Õ;<- k w< wm$X

(16) -;->{<- >ø>ø >9V$< d£ w<15## w<$GHV£ ù( >{w >W). 8V -£>=>kLù{<> >9. !"#. {<>e w<-£¿$ò*òËÊ-xQ9m p{<Wõm$$->{<>dQ[ >9n>($b ùV<-xw<ç°ST$mQ $4!'<R$ ww<Ww) Ò]þ-mþ[þ) còûü>cWw§¨©ª«$S¤S¥ >>W)R] þ >{w>ø>ø Tm wn>W)8þk£|; {<>{w $ >( >9$-W$ >(- ù{ w<>W)xQQk>øþ| V{<£ Q n>WdQ8V-¿ ( W(*{<>> n{< >W)pøw£>wW) I»ý { y (w<- >þ(k. ―176―.

(17)

(18) . !"#$%&'()*+,-./0123/ 456. 789:&';<=>? @& A/BCD'EF"GHI/ J @HIJKLM"NO . PQ @?RS@&TU=V /MWX&<&<Y. Z@[V@\@ ']^_àbV@&V /c=V SE]d e f'TghThV@[V@g@ '/AZE'&'ìh / <'=(j f/Mkl+mno%&'pq A h;Mrstukuhv

(19) wV \ xy/ z{V@& & ;f| A'&'rsM|V@}~+S @&_kM&<&<n@& &@&of|/ 4 @g f S|;'&'?o/M|g h& SZEfG

(20) M&fVa? @TZ=> 4fG

(21) M&V D =>&';. q

(22) Z@\. U< T& 4E'&' &ho/=_hf@;h=V AZ;;O\@E; h~Z%&';3uh +CDV ? ;<&'; @&g & ¡&. 4¢£¤¥¦. ¤&'§lpqM|;/¨&@. f&< h©ªf|«&¬+fV@&>V ®o¯f|o ¡&/A/°+±²k/'=> @|

(23) /' ³V@&g &¡V@& ´vµ¶+ @;ZkMwV@&o·¸¹GºwT»§/¹=> ¼V f/h M ½¾¿GÀMÁ_Â]lDÃCÃ %&'¨+Ä @&;ZG4Å&'Å=>ÆV @&o/M|//A//]d/l+Âh

(24) &%&'; h Ç;Z`Èk CMl+¬ @&T;&@@ fGÉh¨ ¡&UT]^ÊÂ=ËLÌª&< h&¯+ Í]>/l+E/U' @ÂV@&T/=4/pq| ]d+ÂV@ A;=>ÎZ@&T%A/Ï¯/ÐdÇÂ >hSZÑÍÎZ>Zh&&'U'h;f|o¡& h

(25) A h·¸¹ÒV@& g &¡&/µ¶+ÓÔ Õv+Ö @;Z×ØÇkÙÚ·¸¹GºOÛÜÝ' /M&fÛÜ/ÞdT>&0ßÇ#$àáhV â& D'=Ç0ß/¯M_ãTh ä/µ¶½åæçfèé|êëìíMî/ïð/. ―177―.

(26) ó@ ôõöz÷ø;'&'Gghùf|ÇGù& 'úû=ücýþ/ùþ/ù|SZEf·¸¹¾¿ GÀM/+A/V@;U' f|oU' hó/¶ §+â U'h;'&' uh

(27) & /ùM ã&/ ;Z& @¾¿GÀ/M

(28) Z@& CM@ '=f Zâ Mäk/V 45/& /C+u =>

(29) @ 45/ h"h/= h/=&';MUTj

(30) Z¢£¤¥¦. ¤/+o½4. 5uh¡m&@ +

(31) â@& gAZ+ªT/ ,&'f/M| A/,&'/,=ÇnÑ. . /, =/, =|o&xyfÄV@&'C/ z. ½ÏvD' Th&'45. ?@To. M¹ @

(32) Z@& ½Í"M

(33) ZoUf ½/;h/A'&',45MV@&o &hf/A'&V f/M|V@A;uh @" =Mg@To45/:& Ñ /M c T

(34) @g :h VÍV@g &'//, àá||o#$V@f&& h&=h¡& A;§ß=>V@g |o=;'&V f/f §45

(35) @g AZ=>§#hV@¤¢fV@To;/¤¢f SZ@&gA @hV@fV@To45&'/; '&'/fSZo¡m+ @&o/ AZ+¾¿GÀ

(36) %&'§ S S

(37) /§ &V&&< hf/M|;/5uh(o¡m+n @ h&%&';ho¡m+ h&&'5uhmn¯M |o/AZM p¢hV@|/

(38) M

(39) Z@& => MAZZMl/§

(40) +V@&o&' `+ /Í&< h/gM|o/ <'&';. ¡& A'&';+@k C;Z=>/:

(41) h¡m+¬ '\/¢£¤¥¦. ¤+&@&TM|o/h&=. ¡V@& ;/¢£¤¥¦. Í¢£¤¥¦. ¤&'¨r Ã/U'. M// + nU'=&';+

(42)

(43) /

(44) /ÌÉ : Z &';MgV=ShV@#$SV. ―178―.

(45) .

(46) . !"#$ %%&'() *. +,-./012 +,-./034567+,-./0383+ 9:;<=>?@ABACDEFCGH%+,-./ 0-12A%I9BAC %+,-./03A%(JKLMC*N*COPC A%C9*C C %JKLMC Q RSTU%VWX) QY Z[\]^(_` *a#bcdefcghi RjklEmnopS9 9qrsppS t "A9uvw:;x567y <=xz+{| +y}~C) :. . 9:;A@?7 < ; "A#C:;)9"*C" 9 9 A~CDE) \daA9 AC9C <= " "\(9 #|3I %+ ,-./03A JK 9 %%F 9¡¢Cr £ ¤¥¢C¦§ ¨© ª«¬i$®¯C *a#ª«°±a\ A%%²³¤ £A %(d´¨ 9C µ +,-./03A B¶6·¸ x£yC¹º»µ. ―179―.

(47) " ¾w¿GHÀAÁAÂÃ%#+,-./0-12 FA Ä©9%%ÅÄ9AQ¿) 9GH(Æ9 µ "wÇ9ÈÉ 9ÈÊ AËÌ#+,-./0-12 \²Í+,-./0-12 #"wBaAAGHa%(Î 9 A% BÏ9C ML²³Ð#%A \ "ÑÉ9 "°± 9 Ò9 AÁAC9ÏGHÓÔÕ9 C C ÖJ×Ø9#)C \ÙwÚÛÜ|?ÝÞ7ßà áâ¾+,-./ 0-12"C%F Àã*N CAÁA "äå %+,-./0-12}JKC~(Ò9 ÒRæÖ ç¾JK+,-./03è0RÀé. ê JëìRíé(d QîwCµ ïðW#ñ a ò¿C #ó FCÌôõ¢ö4g÷4øù94úûUC wFC¦§ \%+,-./0-12³üý ; BA ABAC%(þÃ9 A%QØ(ïðW{7¸ . W¦§ \%V('~C¦§þÃ) BF ó ATU §C \9C *a# Ø(C)¾é( CÀAÍ ) Bµ 9GH

(48) +,-./0-12AÍ ÐFA9 %§ é( CA§ OPà# A"% A% "%(I "¢öAlEaAA ´9 B" Ì\

(49) Ø(9%C9 R¿Ï( FCK(Ìà( N Ì \C µ ")d¡¢CCÏ ¡¢(9%|/#) *a#¾Ì ACÌCa%9CÀN¾ \9%iÀ A²¬»Ç? 9 ÃN9 9 "AAÌ%9 ²¬I9 AÍ (*N. ―180―.

(50) w¥. w¦.

(51) !"

(52)

(53) #$%& " '() *+,-%.!/$0&123",-%.45 6789:;<5 & = >5 ??

(54) @AB 1CD'EFGHIJ!"K2 L 2'M1N OPNB12B3 %QRMN?N "

(55) ! S. TU2!()*,-%. VW&N. XYZH[Z\ VW&FGHIJ1](^ ?

(56) CD!_M = >5`$&Na&`$! ?E CD 3" & b? cK )1*deN* 3fK&B1 2"+ CDgh+ ?'i N &jgh"kl)! "

(57) mBno3" pq&?rstu53)&vu5 #N 23"w x ?g vu52!" yz"

(58) ! x yz! ?CD FGHIJ{g &j ?CD'FGHIJ? cK|23? !}

(59) ! ?rstu5 !6w #N2!" ~ 2' BM1NyzM1N"

(60) ! ?. : 1$h2!& B& ? CD

(61) S "

(62) 1x&jg. N"czu5 &$NB12"

(63) N$1x&&:u51 " x %1 "1 "K2 yz? p k ? " ? =D E )N2!&"a &h . !&"zK"

(64) !

(65) ;2!&"?. ?9Z:N. !"??456 !6 x. N~cK ?!#}"¡ D ¢ N". ―181―.

(66) VWFGHIJ1<51$ &5~ ? N$1§&5? N& 2m. bs¨©13?N. !".

(67) 1ª ? :«Z¬I®¯°©±<51$3? *23"²J³F*´M23()*:«Z¬I®¯°© ± ? xI®¯f. !}"; ? N µ¶·¸. !"¹I®¯º12!"

(68) 1i62'»¼Nh2!&

(69) ~=½²E

(70) I®¯2'I®¯1zB1N. '". +? I®¯¾51$:i6:«ZHZ¿Z: ¾5 ·À:«Z¬I®¯. '?N i(!". #* ©Á :«Z¬I®¯°©± Â ÃÄ ½² :«Z¬ ÅÆ(g"*&$

(71) < 51$1 V2!" klM &TU MN!"MNV": «Z¬I®¯°©± ÇN&B3V2!"*ÈÉÊËN. ~x °Ì(g

(72) Í1 ÈÉ3VB 12!"#$hB1$3V2!" * ~»Î» ÏÐÎÐ Ï! &3Ñr K st#V2!" ÒB13'3²J³F!Ó ?gN. !ÔÕ. Ö×hØÙ1Ú2!"¹ ÛÜno Ö× ÝÞßN. . !" pA&ÈÉàá$NB12B12!" ggâ1. TUN?hw ã2!q Ö×. ~ä)*u53i(!}"

(73) åã ?æç'"'() åãB1èM6ÎxÏ&h

(74) N$1i6

(75) èéêN$NB3Ð° ëÎÏCD'h+3i(!" ? ìí ¶î1 i(!" ?gÈÉàá ïqN. !"ïq Ö× ª ? ä)*. ë©WðNë ?Åñ12i(!"ÅÆ$ #*

(76) % i6VW b BMÙ12. . !}"

(77) ! ò klN!&!*MB1 ? Ð°. ëk?!ä)*M12B1 "M12B1. NóÝÞæç&"{gÝÞN. &!6ôÑlklN&";. *u5NÐ°ë1 ä)*g??g

(78) õ ö÷12 N&" Ö×

(79) øùúM](3V2!"'()Ö×. ―182―.

(80)

(81)

(82) . !"!"#

(83) $!.

(84) %&'()* +,-(.

(85) (./01234*56789:

(86) ;<(.+=>?.*/@A>

(87) BA(.CB

(88)

(89) /$

(90) DEBFG*H I&JKLMLMNA&O%&' ); /PQ R-STUVS W X$/AA$OY4

(91) $DE 5W ( SZ[/. P. 5\. ]&? B^_à&4*bcdefghi jgkl Q m+n< oP=>

(92) A NA&`pqrstB uqrstB ^vwxyz{ 01b|}. ~ . /!( A(qrstB yz{/4. efghijgkl< o. PT B

(93) /4. ^_;. ,>. <2>

(94) À P. B?0 (?,?,. AB? >?.+( )0>

(95) 0/>

(96) /4N

(97)

(98) R- (

(99) >

(100) $R-$

(101) WB. ./!(,NNZB

(102). B0 £. Q¡¢{. );44*JK/¢{£. . . ¤¥B

(103) P¦

(104) 4*`pqrstB ! A01{BFZB Z§¨©ª 4

(105) / ,NN«¬/4)B

(106) $ ®&Z¯,N N

(107) $ B) °4*B. :±A>?.. * B

(108)

(109) =; 0T< <T²]S4<5³´µ$R- (S4> ¶&·g·g¸B?< PT ¹ºi»¼p+AB?4½¾3¿À d+A½¾3. +/Á. ½¾¾1

(110) 3. + . ―183―.

(111) /P. 5\]&? =>

(112) 6¯>?½. ¾3¯>?`³ B|Ä`pÅÆÇÈÉ3

(113) ?( NA&OY);4

(114) )01/4 S½¾6¯> ?Ê3

(115) ?( ËÌB

(116) ?(/Í&Q¡ A$;.(>?. o) °?. (B4 rÎ|ÄDEN

(117) .6¯>?|ÄDEN

(118) .>?R-S!. (?Ï4ÐÑ . Ò. Ó >?+W>

(119) dÔR>? ( Õ . Ö ×1

(120) Ø (&AB?(Ù. N

(121) ÚÛ¸ ¬Ü$. ÝÞn? 4>¶&ß 0SS/(àJÊB

(122) efg hijgklT ( oÔR AB?1 <(.à/á&<(.!>,-=>

(123) Ê R- (= A ß$âã ;äàJVefghijgkl¦.4 . / F. (.m>å>

(124) +? (Ö ß(>?S= A `p½N æçèb)B

(125) #

(126) +? ½éê½ . S&A½NB

(127) ½N.£ +A. ½B

(128) ½N.£(S 4ëqÎì³í5î( ) ïÛðñò<5NîB<0 5ó_Vôu5N B

(129) õö=¦½N¦ >

(130) ,>÷ø. . (B4A 4/ÔRAB? /4ùúÖ . d>B->?ÒÓ . èbHçûBüÒÓ . Úp. S&A0&ý. þ F .

(131)

(132) .4?. dg. àJ?. 4AB?/Hç. ù /4(.S ;>

(133) >

(134) /44 Hçèb .

(135) +A/4. <( oÜ. B

(136) >?);4

(137) Ú|$&AB?4HçÊÜ. 4. Ê<>?|Hç+B$

(138) ÐB ?

(139) +¨8(. â. 6þST_S. (.($H#B ;4 /4|«R #A ¬ÜB?AAH#1 /4T(/

(140) |

(141) ¨n@0. ―184―.

(142)

(143) . . !"#$ %&'() *"+,-.. )/$ '( -.01(23456.( 789 :;<"=>?;@$ ABCDEF 7GHI JK@I@7LM NOP " Q; @ <RSMTU<V NW< X:YZ[\] 7E^?_IU:`HLa*b<cde7f" gGhiUjkil:U@"m7nompq*<;@@7LMmr stuvw ^" Q xyz*"G{|7}@~t? RN?m * *!" Q GmIN `HLa*b<tN? *< @m7)IUmBC ?m N_?M"" ?m:;7<j K <mM"0. @"Q7?G. 7G<yIm :G 7?INmbWm¡¢ NLUI 77Uj*jQ£¤¥@"¦§:" _< I@7 LM ¨^Nm)/K@)^m O7Uj©7! ª «¬":$ _®¯$?m °±I@Lm²³´GµI:("Q7 Gm¶·M"¸LM¹UjL ®º"¬*<j. U»^"H* m¶·N¼7" ?: I K@7LUU)/*"G(j7" m½< ;@ )"#7m O7Uj©7! ®¾¿À¬ Á" ? ?mUjUÂ ÃÄ:"Q?INmÅN3Æ5ÇÈÉ5\]G : ?I GQ"m)"#7Ê¯ËNm *GÅUj uÌ_N3Æ5ÇÈÉ5\]W"mKUjmÍGM3Æ5ÇÈÉ5 \]Îo*< ) ¬GmÂ:G"MÏ:Ð^ LUaU * KUjÑ:ÒÑÓÔmN<mKUj²³´G X :ÊÕÖÊ);7?;@$ *G×ØÙÚ)"*;@ ×GØÚKmÚGØ×K ajQÛÜmÚØÙ×GÅUju K @7LM ÂjNÒÑÓÔ" ?mcÝmÞßNW?m. . MN. ÍU7" ?m´´G 7NàG¢M mÚKmØK";@ $ K@Lá:7K@bQ"mÚGmàG×MW?IKm <Ø7mÅN3Æ5ÇÈÉ5\]GQ"mØ) Um. ―185―.

(144) ÅUjuä-åæçèN3Æ5ÇÈÉ5\]K KUj!!* :? 7m 3Æ5ÇÈÉéê#N»ºÛ:ëìíî "H* . Umïð7?. X:" ÛÜ:»º *") ñ^7mÊ¯Á<`òGm¸LM¿óL? Um:L ïðN_?U 7NmÂN< ôõ*" t:ö:÷j7"* *< KKPQ U"øù*" *<$ vú:û Ujö:÷j7"*ü* |ÍgMý?I@7 LM ÒvþIMGN_ *"¸LMMK"?N_ gM¸º"MÁ" *"m¸º"*" Q8m ^ ¸NŃ"mÍc 8:"JQ:*" NW ?m¸LM Ë8m <©7< *Njº"" Q;@ ´ ) mNg<: ^"Q7" <m *¬ Gg:"G¸º":

(145) Ï :" ?I 7mL. *¬U mCò7*<Uj«LG:*. $ _b @7LMmÑ:* * @7LMm ù:Á" < 7GmGG!Gª:G*$ ª:G? Um MIK mª:? 7:mgjG=* IUNW?UUmUj<. " ?I$ =?m7:Nî <©7<*" Q !©m¤Ü ¬Ng:"Gmx:*< 7G UjxIK ÒG» a**" @7LMm»G m Ë

(146) )/: NW Um m m )/G W zW$ 7GÉÉ i¤;7"_<( )/GmàGÒv :Ê. MmW? GM". Q)/GU<UI$ 7gGÛË Ã:*" `HL ¡ M ùÃ M M

(147) Mm :3Æ5ÇÈÉ5\]NW? XÃÄ?m :3Æ5ÇÈÉ5\]N?^"* N *U*Ia Ð " "MNmgN3Æ5ÇÈÉ5\]ÃÄ?GmŃ l:<UjUmW? G¢UüN"_<Uj3Æ5ÇÈÉ5. ―186―.

(148)

(149)

(150) . !"#$%&#'()* . +. ,-./ 01 2345

(151) 6)

(152) 789: '* ; <=>' ?@ABCDEF: **G

(153) :H

(154) ( I '23JKLMN:

(155). *. OP45 (OPQ'RST8:23U/ JV' @WX (

(156) H

(157) Q'RS.YZ ' 01 /!"#$%&#

(158) [ \]: 0^ _`+abcQ: '/!"#$%&#defg hi ()jk '() * () + _>l (+mmnB op()!"#$%&qr&st@

(159) @WX @Hu m*)1 v8+

(160)

(161) !"#$%&#LMN Swx. . +!"#$%&#NG

(162) y (. z{G. y|

(163) }~()(Q(

(164) /?*`: lKjy| yy|'

(165) Q'D*`() yy|' Hu. (

(166) !"#. $%&#y|N W/Nx I

(167) ^ /*` (: ^G ?@4: Q¡¢£4¤ . . E. E Q¡

(168) .S. ¥@^G+/¤ '¦y.r&k: I )¤) H. §`D@^Gu !"#$%. &qr&k:I )G

(169) ¨ ¤). (: . : I

(170) ^©ª

(171)

(172) «j¬w^G. +.

(173) +!"#$%&#®¯° (

(174) //y(±² ()jmy³<´µ¶·¸* (¹º@ ((» /y:(¼W {(½¼W

(175) H

(176) +

(177)

(178) ¾¿.yÀN ) :X :

(179) ( ÁÂÃÄÅÆº@Ç`':È3É':` x Ê`Ë(ÌÍ zÎQÏÇ`(Ð. Ã. ÑiÒqÓqÔ/ rÕÖ@(×Ø`:U Ö#!Ù y.ÚÛ5NM0

(180) Üyw eH

(181) (

(182) ÝÞßàu áâ.¼ãäå^º. ―187―.

(183) /ÝÞºßé

(184) mê*`ë@. _±². :'ì: ¬wWX ( : WÜ¦yíMN îïEð:+ñ!#òió:) :¦y ôõöN-÷::. léøùúûü:. jý 'þ@ ßé @Hu ()/!"#$%&#¸y(±²

(185) ¥

(186) ê:Ü '.JK:ö¦º*` . ¦y

(187) I*`0GU)(

(188) .

(189) INH

(190) @u

(191) *.

(192) 23 . öÖ#!Ùy^Gö

(193) JK. x`23N* :!"#$%&#+/() * `* `qÕ* º mU +

(194) .23NL Ùòi!

(195) Õqß ¡

(196) é*`. j()(2H@

(197) jm. 2

(198) NQ:':u (. *`ý

(199) l:ë@. Eý (ý . /hiý . iÑ!¤ +:.

(200) iÕ y*ù ()+

(201)

(202) 2: À*` hiQ

(203) ^

(204) ³

(205) ;Ù: +

(206) Ø!"#$%&#. ()!"#$%&#. * * >/? L. º)N. +¥ ¸N¦y

(207) I . : @ +îE #z{GG(z 0H I0 :^GÓhv8* H

(208) o pì¥0)ë 0û Ðº@U!"#$%&#ÕNx ()º@ _>(^ @() 0H I0 º ()º@:@ ³ @WX ( +Ðº@x| º@ÜÕNx` Ü0^ +

(209) º '() º@()G/w. 0^. *+

(210)

(211) @^G . /Õ(º@Ðk Õq hN: N @u. op v8NhÕÑ: x``. /* 4 * ©. H

(212) /x ) /e@ ðÕ@. ―188―. îE4 ð: .

(213)

(214) . !"#. !"#$%&'()*+$,. -./01.2345677%%89:;<='( >?@A*:B677 C%DEF$GHI&JHK<L=G& 9MN%ONPQ*R#$7*=$SR'TG D=*UGV*=$W<%&XYZ*['(U\]^& G%R_#'(à^N%ONV*=$%+$ %bc^d$_e f#&g#K%<hijkl5$,-./01m1 ,nop& ,-./01mq11 ,nopr pstuvw&xyz{|}~ %F*{+! y~ wI^ =,-./01mq1. 1 ,nopr p%. r p %!^g^=GR^*N% =&G=G&xhijkl^d ^f¡¢£¤6G ¥¦§¨=¡`*+! ©ªD%«¬*+$7* ®§¨ f#'()¯I$¥'()*+$¥%&f#<R°±%<²& '(³*+$&+$'(%²&'(´!*+$µ¶%f^& ·CE¸7*'(¹5º»¼½¸<¾&f¿À^ W%¥ ®#G6D=Á^WÂ$¥=<%¦ #=GR*^Â$¥%Ã*$%¡`^<= %Ä^x¸ÅÆÇG'()¯IR#N&'(GÈ*. ―189―.

(215) ¦#%¥ÌÍ&ÎªDÏªD+&ÐÑ^$%<ÒÑ^ $%<&^*ÓD$%<ÓD=*Ô_RÕ&È*¦ #%%&ÌÍÖ¥G+È*º×%% f#ÅÆÇ%'(GÈ*ØÙ$¥+!<R& f#'R¥&+$'¥&+$'Ú¥%¸ÛÜ*'( ÝI$&'(¦<%7=%'Þ%¸ ÖÆÇ&°±%¥%°¥%<&+$Þ°f#ßà*& E<%%&áâ=µ¶45N%Þ°%¸D¾°± ¦<'(¦<^°±¦<#'Þ&Þ°%¸ #WÛÜãä*}å*^$æ=&çè*éRÕçè ê5$&'(¦<^°±¦<f^'(W¦<ª#°±<RW¦ <ª#$#Ìë=D¾XìíîØ=DWïðñ.î Ø=D7îØ^À$_e¾ d<RÛÜÜ5îØò^óNôDÛõö÷îØÂ =GR&fG'(øN<&àINù¾ö÷'ú&'û üýþ^fI*K$<%%&¥%m ¾m%=fÔuä*Õ$%*7 '(%<°±%±%. !ë&Ôu¯Ii%¦. *e$%!ëW Ö*+$N%=N&B<ÕÒ#Õ&+$%× ^ Ò ×=GR&+$%×*ïðñ.

(216) ój<!^ e#EW&×Î$fUü*+!=GR&+$%×,ð%Ò #$f^&*Ò#'*=$Ò#N%&g %< %ÛÜj^ ^G&gÛÜ=¡`<R&jk,-./01mq1X¡ ¢%^& ¥%l%^ _$ \ ¡$@ Ö

(217) ¢%Å

(218) ¢%45ëG+ !+!(e $stW=<%ÄG&jk% &o,ï ,n3o.

(219)

(220)

(221)

(222). .

(223) %& X uGùª#5N<<=<%Xc !^*+R_^fX ^N45f|~ =c*æ;hiª#$_e®!b%b*_ e45$!<¾ f#Ö®*(e45$%Ö

(224) ¢G *+!f *+$ &!f*+$\u%Wãä*ù^<R&

(225) ¢ ~m%¸l&jÈ+! ^<^X*,-./01mq1%%µ¶%^"N%&'. ―190―.

(226) .

(227) . !" # $%& '.

(228) % (% )*%. +,-./

(229)

(230) $%&

(231) 0 !" 12 2 !34567839 !:;<!"

(232) =>?! $# 9@

(233) A0B A0 #CD!E. #. !". F8>GH3 2 IJK-LM8G $N=O EP. QR:;< '0S. 89" P TUV0WX a@39. YZ[0?> 89\] $^_`. !"àbcd ed '. Lf! #ghi#jk. lFm0n

(234) 9lG"jklopn

(235) 9omq rs !" E0$tXuLf!. !"g9v8Fw

(236) v8. F"9xp9 yopw y

(237) o q z{| =}. ~0v8G~8 <. !"w. 9# @

(238) H3 Lf!. !" 8. YZ[8 M=89" kPgq?3 38 !

(239) 0E ! !E> 380 '0 E E>. !2" Xu0E8?E. !" E bcd

(240) I G9v8Fw

(241) v8 F9 lxpw

(242) x ##gw y0!. 0l9. y3 @2"$#% '0l9y%# q@% . 39#3 f . !"w '0

(243) l9y2" %%¡8970#. ¢£z{0t¤. 7"£t3 E. 7 2.

(244) I ¥¦§ E0¨ !". E!IJK©JK rs%ª

(245) #E #+ @ !" «Z #gI¬SS¬Iq 2 ®8 !"I 3 ¯¨ E. "°§- ±²³0´µ !"

(246) I¶·z¸ ¹ º»8!"w ¼½ . K¾-0e¿ 89 À . !" !2"ÁÂ Ã#Ä<ÅÆ;Ç8. !2"@3 38 " . 7 È#gq¹ É0. ―191―. !". pÁÂ.

(247)

(248) Íp%ÎÏ $ 8#Ípy¾ $ È#Ä<ÅÆ; $. !".

(249) ÁÂ 7 È#ÐA!É. Ñ" E##ÁÂ '0

(250) ÒÎÐA!ÓÔ E . !2"È '0

(251) " ÕÖ×Ø0"ÙÖ @¾M-0. #Ú ÛÜÝ !Þßà<á;â E#ã Ã ä. !2"E=0 3970#

(252) =0. 7 39ã ä#. ¥¦. !". 7. !2" 38. !". ÀXÒ. !". À¹38

(253) å8@" @

(254) H3 rs. # . !"È©æ f. !"3 @

(255) H3 "@çè. !" 0

(256) çè" ¬ rs. "È ¾é. I

(257) S

(258) E Ã. #êëìßíî. !". !"I

(259) ïðñ 3ò 0Ð. ó9ôI#¬S@"S¬I@" E#õ§883ö Ã. #?#Ù

(260) È#. ÷ø rsùe 3 !"÷ø8§ " ÁÂ¹QR âÞ;àúû#Ü

(261) f ª. ýþ8 Ç0 . ûîG!2"M. fpü.

(262) . !"@M !2"37Á. Â r @% '0ðE0Ç@e38 892" å

(263) ôüº. # . !"e #ÈE. #E $t¤ú; k Ie0E@ !

(264) ô

(265) 3 »3 3©æ0. #. ?3òI!"å

(266) !" P

(267) e µ . !". @ëú ; 0

(268) !"È#

(269) ¡0k 7 " E@. Íp ¡2G37!. 2" 0e "k9= 380?097 eW . p2 0 ". È#

(270) 70 0¡ rp! 2"

(271) ¡!2"

(272) 0

(273) ¡C =3 . !". @G E. !"PEE´Öëâ;. ?3 rr3GpÁÂIk(?>. ―192―.

(274)

(275)

(276) )&. *+. !"#$%&'(. ,& -.#$/0123 4*5. 6&% 7+89#. % :;<. =4$ . >?. @@* 6. 4*ABC!D%EF% G7+89#. @. #HA+,GI%**A JK1L G M@N4*O 6 O 7O G &H>PNAI %Q*R >N*$7 @S$!"#$TUVWXYZ[>=7 ) A+,&G\]^_`+. , & >P. N66 4*4*7+,G . a bab*$G b A. ca :bde23*)fg7@hi& Q7@. UjWklVTm. no!"#$pq*$7=+,& r@:s4)& *$) . )t@@+. ,& uvwp=. 4xysh&*):z{%M& 0 $+. ,&. |}~%4H N*Is # @. *X017#. @ %. @7h). % uvwsh&*4`%H. IV%p=. NR*R*@* &2&*R*@+ &uvcaS$S$7 , . S r:\{ ¡)¢%(. +. ,& no%pN . ¤¥. 6. R^¦`%%**R1L. . §%uvw7+*R ca¨©kT. ª«*¬23& ¥. £J,)p. ¬®¯ *]°±6¤. R¬®¯ ²³%A@ ´1µ@¶e·(%*R@+. ,& @. %QEa G7)7)t¸ r¹º«% @ »¸*)+. ―193―. ,& . h.) . ¬.

(277) *¬!*1*!*1¿. R. ^¦! h)ta &>6{* 1 6¤{^¦ &6{ 6\i) *{{À«*6Á¸[Â^¦ 7) :kÃ©ÄÅÆ©ÇtÈ 4%À«*WÅ ÆXk &4%ÉÊ &>&GN!*1 Z[Ë0M@ÌÍÎjÏÐkÃ©ÄÅÆ©Ç tÈÑ !"#$ %:%. ÒÓÔTUVWXY%*#. @. S$@,)£{ . ÕtÈÖ%*$7=. @ @,)#$%×q)*4 Ø6ÙÚÛ#$Ü¤Ý%Þß%¨©kTª àá#$@!âã#$ ÆäÐåæªçèé >@êë61ìí6Íî©kï kÃkR ðR'%àá#$µ%Íî©kñ $ % 61ªòóôõ%ö@N@ j÷%&øù ú %ÌÍÆÎûüý=þ4j÷%øù^m« àá#$\%\ J% %ªò%#. 7 þ. :¨©kTªZ ª\. §%+, *^¦%ZMe+ 6±WÅÆXk*)¬À) À) . 1 ) *$). ô\M. ±%ÜÀ* *^¦ . 6. ª%&4 %* 6% &ÁªÊGR. $. 7+L*R 6¨©kTªªò±#. . ]°) ìR¨©kTª%*N@ª*R^¦ 7+. N¨©kTªêë=$7. ri¡ !z)u

(278) ¨©kTªz J&a. )E7R$. 6±AÕ^0*M@N «%§\ª& &R\MkÃ©ÄÅÆ©Ç4@2w) &. @E$ ª) &%n. oTVkÃ©ÄÅÆ©Ç¿+a*4É «%. ―194―.

(279)

(280) . !"#$%&'(. )*+,-./+ 0123/45!67/+ 012389 :/(;!<=>?23@+ABCD(. =E+/. !F(G"7H/!"7IJ KL+:M/=NOPQ RS/+ !TNOP5!TUVW=!XY5.>?23IZD +([\"723]@^_H=`@abcYRSdefgh Iij;<E8;!.k!9:+=.klm!9:+=.knop]@+ (. =E+/+ !" E"7qr. , + " E!"7D. sC /+ T/=tu"7H8!9:+="78v\:wx. ,. !.k@y&:.z(G= /{H="7I|.z@E}, ,;!~=.z. 9<!z. 9<!z. 9<!9:+=sz. 9. <!z/+ Iij;<E8;!THDsE{C ! 9:+=UVDsE{C !9:+=FDsE{C !9E(D sE{C /+ T/I!9:+= ~^@E}(5 YYRSDsE{C !9:+=5YhED j +EL<+LE+C /+ @(`<+;D: "7H8+: +(. =E+/D!T + I`'+(C+. =E+/!9:+=!+D@j+(CL(;9}8(+. /+ @D}( ~!T + ++E]. ++RQ!. /! ¡/!9:+=¢~abcYRS/+ I. £j¤+!5YYRS/+ IT@¥¦§LE8;wx ¨©+D(;++{C /+ ª E!++E«`{@¬,:w x¨©8E`<+(!(®¯5]@°<+(CL(. =E. +E/+, 'D±IT + (G. +(C+,. !²®;³. w!<@\&D++´µ¶@+(CL(;/+, ~^=_·@ 9}8/ )*+( ~¸¹`{º»8| (8!sI¼D½j:E/+ I, )¾¿!ÀÁIZD({. ,. \}!5YhÂ!+&Ã:ÄÅ D+ ,!4b ÆIÇ+(CL:/È8É&D:E/D({ s9<!ÊË (;!T{EÌÍ. ,L<. T{ET/89}(!T{ET/I. ÎD (/! +D(ÏÐ¶E89<!. +(CL(;9}8(+. ,L<. jj!+DÑ+9}, /+ ª}!<=,ÒTG;8,/+ ª}!ÓÔ¸¹`{. ―195―.

(281) 8ZD+:ØÙ¶EÚÛ , !<IF(G8Ü'+(C E8;! +D@Ý}Þ}I+{. ,. F85YhÂI[ßà@táCE/ÌÍ`'+(C+(H=! F@¬âã@(+ä/+ Èå¯I|`<({. ,ã@(+. /+ Èå¯8| (/ @!F8sj;<ED( <= æÔE{. ,. ,8!çè8sH@¬éI|ÈL<. /!êLEL</!ëD9ìEL</D! + íî+8 +DÑ+9D({C /+,éIC'E+F8ï:T/@" EQå ð/+ !ñò. !<=sF]@óôª /+(+8õ+. +({C/+, =E!HIu=ö)/KL÷:/+ øù8úL+( T;EûH8ã@(+/+ Èå¯I|,/+ T/I+D @j+®¯5 !uüH8ýþ j+. E+/T!<I. =E!®¯5/T@ &áE5Y. hð89:{C /+ @+(<. ! + _. I¼} ÀI,:T/I" @,:ª @E}( 9/=ã. ,[ß@|:=Hã /+ =!9. Ú@¬ x. 9:/!9:+=ã

(282) ÚÛ. 9:/!9:+=. H +: ¿!FH ¿=9D({C /! ¿!w +L. ,çèH@¬,:w+L! +D((`{9}. , C;!_·@HH@/D½{E . ![A. =AjE+T. /=+DÑ+9},=!â++ì{@ :ä/+ _ ]@ ( É. ++. ! {. +(CL</+,\+. @TT. ,^@;üÓ8|,T<=. ànÀ&}/!Y5å¢/!@@+H(G/À &D (T/I!+:¹T/IE}'+(C+ +,_h=âHI}++{Cªä/+ _. ,9:. / =HI}çèIÞ}!í@ED!~ø=H@,. + Xå². ,. ªD(;{. C`+. =zI},> @)³w(+. ,. 8 /T. !z

(283) /A&<:.k/TE{. ,8!FçM!_. I:/!Ý=}k;<:H8k;<:/+ ! + H@§+ +/_ @E<:/+ @!FçMzz

(284) @A&<FçM 8k;<(/+ ÐI({. ,8(C_³/_ @| /+ . 8C+/\çè]@°D +E! 8D D(]@s89:E/+ @D({. ―196―. ,8! Ç.

(285)

(286)

(287) . !"# $%

(288) &'()&. *+,-./ 0*1)&*2 2. 3*&*456.

(289) 789:;&<=#> ?@A)B@ACD&* 1 E$%

(290) C&* FGHEIE&*)JID EK& #)CLDEK& #)M NO. 3*&. P

(291) QR)STUV 2)QR!,"1WXY& ?,Z #

(292). #Z)()[\)]^_à2. %

(293) 2*NO)*bZc_deE &* fgXh 1$*5 iZ

(294) c_&*61jL6klmn&"o)1jL 6gpql&* #)ngpqrs)tud&*#

(295) tu,"v Otu 6")&*#)w wx,>y*5z G %

(296) 6w#ZJID& V& V $%

(297). #Z). *bZ{ |} &)~ 1A18&Vklmn o"

(298) &'()&)&*#U# )& $*ngpqrs? $*5iZ

(299) @, #*#

(300) 1E &*F

(301) 2*NO$3 *#

(302) 97 8*

(303) )" )3 1, ")")Fw"),&N"6"

(304) )&2 @"V""). ¡&¢ ). w

(305) *"2,"*

(306) ~& 3¡,8* w F.£ V& #

(307) *¤1*¤1&*~ 6)¥¦§¨6) ©@">8* klmn,ªE«¬". "

(308) * &). #"®¨¯V

(309) ¯"&?,")° *bE&*~±²

(310) ³ Y´µ¶·ns¸ n&*&¹º»¼@" 61&F½ 1. V

(311) &P $

(312) ¾V&P.

(313) **Y´µ¶·nµ¿À¹º» 1&P,".

(314). ÁÂFÃÄ1E &*F

(315) 9ÅÆÇE

(316) )È±ÉÊ 2) #ZËÌ¬j&#6ÍÎ"

(317) ÏÐÑ~d¹!,6)ÒÓ7; 6). ―197―.

(318) 6×Ø&ÙØ Ú=ZÛ" )¥ÐÜ ¼@" )ÝÞI&*? ØØ 6$eZ 2) *,&ßà#Eáâ_" . ")ã²"ä&. #ZA&åæçäèé"9ÅÆÇE.

(319) 1E &*F

(320) 1&9:7; )êëì·í îY´µ¶·ns¸n d&*#)ïðñ&3 )ò¨³E 2

(321) ó&. &36)ôõö÷&øùÓúûü &*ýj 9Å'5 V &P* %

(322) Y´µ¶·ns¸n,"ËÌ¬j 6")b6E) 6þ&#6" 2)** 2,")B@ Apls". V&* *à ¤,". ¤

(323) **

(324) #Z*&)ÏÐ;66Ð~&"69Å »1 2 )~;#Z2w¨ 6o"V 2) «& %

(325) . b6EK)lY *K %

(326) 78Ð. !,"#Z)b6E#$*)Na&36 5 V&P* 2) &3*b,"!@" #&*" #$"ä21 %

(327) )9:7)78%µYh¼K. 5)h&XY)N'¼õ(. )&V&*& )B@A&~C&*ýj 1A)1 ñ¼|&*2!,"Z,yK 1A V#2. 2)¥Nd**5z)¤¼&," *#)¥¬V1ñ d&#) lìíX h

(328) V"Z,yK)$***Ç@KV #"#&*6)2ã² 1A¼@". V). **&npl¶$*&"ZA$*E#Z &Ç@,"#&P

(329) >Z 2 2

(330) b6E±5"&*&{69Î#&P," ) êw*&&#

(331) 1. 2 1þK]

(332) l. Ðb,

(333) 2lDE)# sl5i"$*)**$*l # )M 5zd@Z"V

(334) #ZÐ~. #Z#2 %

(335) 2). 1 Ï. $*K** * â". #&*&6). . ã² Ï %

(336) . )ÚgX &. X¿Àn &X¿Ànøùõ õ&* 1. ―198―.

(337)

(338) . !"#$% &

(339) '(. )*+)*!",$-.,/0*1234#5%6789: ;<=> )*?@AB C

(340) *B DE FGHICJK*LMNOPB'(Q *LRSB'( )*T*U#!

(341) VW%7' XYZ[ \]%^+_V L'()*`C QBV*ab '( cdeCfgh*ijB

(342) klmn*o%+pq rstV'o%uSvBV

(343) 'w( B dxBfgh*iByz{ Vm| 'w( } '(~{ 'VpB( klm ,!3IBIB> '8w(t

(344) y t *C C,!3ICI(

(345) pB[ )*`*OP '( *#C

(346) '(V *%klmI S

(347) '(,!3IS

(348) '( > Cv8 SVm)*C Z((

(349) VpBC[ ([ *%CC + tV( I*klmx¡T**¢!",$-.,/0%. . L'()' klm*i£¤t)* %¥¦)V§V¨©Vm

(350) L'() p [ %ªO ()VC« '8w( } (t'¬®¯° (±²B³´ 'w( }µ¶·¸B*%¹¦ B* '(

(351) º»SO

(352) 'VpB(¼C)*S* '½¾¿#* CL¼C)*À %µ¶·¸*C¼CÁÂ$·%ÃB*%Ä ¦

(353) 'w()VC'½*HIÅDE%ÆlÄ¦+)* %[ %ÇÈ ['()V%~*É'( ,#Ê,Ë*%( )V%µ¶Ì*ÍÎ)V%Á2"#Ï-#!'%. )V%dÐC ÑÒ ÓÔAB 7dL

(354) 'Vp B( )V )*ÕÖ*7*º»)*×Ø#ÙB*. ―199―.

(355) ¼%Ýl

(356) 'VpB)*Þ ³ßCÞ ×Ø#ÙÅÞ ×Ø#ÙÅ Þ ×Ø#ÙO àáâ p

(357) p

(358) âã±ä q( )V

(359) )V%åæB8C¾¿# Ýlv * CL(*CçèABdCB)*éêA ë#5ìí#BîÀ_tV+¾¿# ïl¾¿# ðñ pïl)B* Ýlv)Z%¾¿#qÝl

(360) ¼ C

(361) 77O * CLº» º» 'VpB('S&

(362) òó

(363) 'VpB( pLu+

(364) '( }dxCpBBôoõö( Vp[ )*£¤7 'w()*> Vp > C87B)*7%d÷ôøù L'VpB( ;ú)*¼û%ü¼û%ýV QCæþb

(365) ')*¯°¼ª)*Q%p*8)*ªAl *Il +L'( )~C\

(366) 'Vp)*p¯°*)*{* ')*{)**QÖQ )*õïs%u& +L'( }*ðþ CL

(367) 'p(C+ *C7C

(368) '(÷B'( )V æ+S'*B

(369) '8w( I°* %. m

(370) ì¿#.

(371)

(372) #%YVpBV%ïQ C±V

(373) 'w( VCI*!",$-.À L#Ë . .

(374) 8°+ À ¯vp* l *+*E %. *L'( '½. %B't+**7* B* C L

(375) 'VpBw( ; '(

(376) }d®¯°~õðþ* C '(Q *{'( }7t

(377) C+ðþ%#(C y

(378) 7

(379) 'w( pQ *ªA±V (. ―200―.

(380)

(381) . !"# $ %&% . '()*+ ,

(382) - . %/ %0 123456789:3*+;<=> ?@*ABCDE. @*+?+F&$(<=. GHBCDE%I@*BCDEJ %*KL$,%MNOPQ)R% %S T @(UVWXY$ Z [@\ ]X +@^_' `X'R @)% %DaCbc:C89

(383) de)Rfgh i^(jk %&+<<% el)<D aCbc:C89mn

(384) <e $( %ojh@p( %qr ( % H<%s t@ ed uvX$ wx ,)% %. <)R

(385) yz RDaCbc:{* %. |}

(386) ~1 % @ %)%S 1<1 |}

(387) ~1 z') )R) , % &% $ 1&, ( %0

(388) =+

(389) z &%@ &%@1'@ SA '(TSA ' <%HX$(<%*'+ ,. e 0T

(390) %- H$X( %&+<,$( R

(391) ¡¢$ % i^$( 1£¤C8089¥. ¦E§0¨ ¥@1 $(st©ª@. ( « (

(392) *+ %¬ ' ®1@ ®1

(393) #¯°¬ ' @±X@²0³ ,´

(394) ´Jµ S¶@ ' )R R·¸¹U1HY %5º

(395) » '·¸¹<¼( µs»½Rº¾)R

(396) »:¿À7´Á 'Â

(397) ÃG $ Ä+@ ÅÆr<ÇÈ ¬ '( , ,

(398) ÉIÊ - $zR '. ―201―.

(399) ; ,UÎY@UÏYÅIUÐY+Ñ

(400) ½U>Y&UPYR UÒYÓUÔY%ÕUÖ×Y H='UØÙYzÚUJµY. U·Y1*XUÛYÜ¦UÝYÁUÞYGßàUáY<ÉAF *+ %¬ '

(401) *+ %¬ ' R@;eâã 0äåæç Oè@ zDaCbc :C89Ä>

(402) èéÄ>(êRF

(403) à@XÉ $' ëìí]íî%<*+ %¬ '±l%<* + %¬ '. ―202―.

(404)