バリアフリー新法に関する一考察
著者 中西 眞弓, 前角 和宏
雑誌名 神戸山手大学紀要
号 10
ページ 97‑109
発行年 2008‑12‑20
URL http://id.nii.ac.jp/1084/00000721/
!"#
$%&'()*+,-./0.1(*2&'3456789898:;<=
>?2@ABCD=EF78'G22HI3-./0.1(JKLM+,J KLM2&'3NO%9;PQG(4RS%TUVWXISYZ[\2 ]B-./0.1(4H^_U%`a78'bc4XIS%dR]CDHefI ]R'3(4gh%JKLMNOijklG2mlnoWp qrstuJKLMvghBNO]w;xYy%zl]{|}X'RB~
7 S; !
"#$%&'()*+,-./0.1(*2&'3BO783
%Bg(*O78\eBx~%}
]w;-./0.1(%dR]B2H'G24HR%Z'3K
WB[%CC2 RG2¡=¢%8'-./0.1(
%dR](£¤S(4G8S¥¦-1§¨©ªYyBS'W«'
¬%dR]®¯°±'G22&'3
²²
-./0.1(%&'[³´
} µ ¶ ·¸¹º»¼UC½
¾ ¿ À Á¸¹ÂÃÄŽÆC½ÇÈ
-./0.1(B%É1Ê˨(2-./0.1(ÌÍÎÏÐ7Ñ' ÒWO783-./0.1(4TUVH()2R98]R4YÓEF%6DÔo;
Z8]R}¥¦-1§¨ÕÖרÙÚÛ¢ÜH'-./0.1"%zl]ÝØ0¨
Þ2]ßUà78WBHRS2³8'3x]CÙÚCe -./0.1áI](43S-./0.1(%wR]âã78EFä åæçè-./0.1EF%2oHR>?Jéx%dR]çHçêë oo%HI]R'ìR3-./0.1(%wR]e-./0.1%dR]BícH`
îï278]R'%SS9ðñVHòN4óôõWX;ö÷¬2]øíêV%
:;ùoHl8HHR2³'3
!
"#$%&'()*+,-./0123.45678129:;
<$=>?@&ABCDEFGHIJKLMNOP#$%
&'Q)R@ST"OP#UVWX? !SUVJYZ&)
[\]^_OP#`a?b&)c*OP#Cd#'efghi
ijklmhnopiqnr ?s
?tuJvZwxyFz{?u?|&)R@
S?OP#}~?JT`a$ T**"O P#UV !UVJYZ&78?b&' )
R@STUV?'{@OP>]^
J]&R_&lUVSZ l¡gn¢l£¤hS¥ZJ¦§+UVp¨fpl#&b&)
RR©ª+UV«¬J®*Z¯°M_+±²?c³´'t]&
R@S)
! "
µ¶·¸¹º?©»¼½¾¿'À?ÁÂ_.Ãĸ¹º MÅyUVÆÇÈÉÊ,=®M+'Ë)?ÌÍ ÎJsÏ?ÐÑÒÓÔÕJx&ÍÎÖ׸¹ºM+)
±²ÖרÙx¨ÚÛlÜ@M*Ý*Tl Þ?ßZ&^àváâã仸åÍs²Á¶¸¹ºM+Ræ?ç_
Tè$bé+)êëìV?Jí
]&RJìVîãïðy±²ñ`«?¯°M&RTé+)
í??ò&±²à?./0óôõ ö÷ø' Jùú]&)
#$%&'()*+ !,-. "
ëû?ü]&}~ýþJïðê Fze Jûë4 +SZRýþJn qgnh²ºÖ×$Jx&@S+)RJò?
Qí$¶ûs²?ü]&þJ²º +')
p¨fpl ¸?ü]&,¥
!"
#$%&'()*+
,-./012345 6789:;<=>?@ABC DEFG>?89:;<=>?@ABC,HFG>?=%I/JKLJ MNOPQARNSTUVNOPQAWXY$ZA[\]^_`A3a=bc deDE$fBCg@hij=Ek2)* +lm=noCpqr s$DtBu\vw"A2x345 yDEz>z>
$%&'()+
l2xDEFG>?34{| 34|}~=
TQRNSTUVNOPQ= EijA2x[
DE$fBCg@hij=' $$FGBCAA2)+
34DE$fBCg@hijl2xlmTQ
RNSTUVNOPQ=bcdez>ij/9vk'(
EFG>?$Wx E5ij/k'(z>ij
h5$Wx $BCE4 $lijFGE=
$kn)+
!"#$%&'(&!)*%&'(&!+
}~E=2)/~$lpqEA2xJJN gAZWuc ¡a/¢£$¤¥~cC¦k§¨©§¨ªG
$fBC«¬KN®L¯ABC+°±JJN²$YWx
BC+
!
34³´k'()KN®L¯ ¡a/¢£$¤¥~cC
§¨©§¨ªG)nµ=¶·CA$¸§¨©¹º»=¼¸Z½x¾¿
ÀG$ÁBCÂÃA=A2)+A\$ĦkÅÆ/¤¥BCÇ ÈÉÊM¯a=¦k§¨©*A2xl§¨Ë$D2¦k§¨©§¨a$C zÌÍÎÏÐa$YWx ¡a/¢£$¤¥~cC$ÑÒ§¨©=¤¥
¢£szÌ$ÍÎ'ÓC)n$ÔÕµ=¶·CnCAA2)+5à ¡ a/¢£$¤¥~cC¦k§¨©§¨ªG$fBC«Ö×34³ Ø7ÙÚ×Û Ü¬KN®L¯×ABC+¤¥¢£sz̳Ã
$YWxÝaÃÞß{ÃÞß$àá¸â($ãäBCåæçØÃ èè
!"#$%&'()*+",*-. !"/
01234*+56
789:;<=>?@ABCD5EFGHI=JK5LM*NOPQR ST UVWXYZ[\L]^?56_`ab>c"defghiEFGHI=
jklmnopqrs2tu!"v>>cK56wK>wxy'zEFGHI=
'"-.{|9}|Fi~c $%24*
?{FIic cLJK56
v'c2PQSEFGHI=i,*-. K_
2i"5+,*"v>cqpL*CD"fgw_
¡2¢£56Cm,¤,*-.>?@,*pL¥i¦>?@§¨
4L!",*-.§¨4Le"'
!"v>L,©ª>CD"fg«¬®¯°±I2*+²T³´µ_-
¦ ?,¤,*-.-&"¶·#¸¹ @§¨4
Le"'xº-.2¶·#¸Cn"v>2»56
´
8¼=i½*-. !"¾¿À,)ÁÂÃMÄÅÆÇEFG HI K_2i"5+ÈÉÊË2*+"ÌK56
PQSEFGHI=ÍDcLmwÎ{|9}|F=i§¨4
LÏÐ?5VÑ^ÒÓ(ÔÕ^Ò2Ö×!"v>Le"'ØÙÎÚ ÛÜ hÓ(ÝÞßÓ(ÛÜh2àá>?58* â&"ãäå¢
_æh{|9}|F2+§¨4LØÙÎÚ 2?5ç èéÓ(êëéìíCmiØÙîï2Cn"v>2ðñ>?@M*
CD56T>qØÙÎòÛÜh-óJ" iÝÆÇ
`çè¶·ô#¸2»õCmiö÷øL¦Æ?çè¶
ùÞú2ûQ?äÛÜh>_üýãäå¢þ â² R³&"çè"òþñ¹84ñc2iK561@Î{
|9}|F=>?@iEFGHI=PQSZec215>
w !"v>Le'6
v'vDm=i_DD2K@e56??~=>?@_
DDL Ð?5=J"L1?5{|9}|FL+mDc á{|9 }|F L> K5=&"MÄJ"LÂ?@e56Cm
v'cMÄ1PQS'z->L
{|9}|F= !"8 !
""
!"
#$%&$'( )*+,-./0)123-4 5067 89:;#<=>?@ABCDEFG HIJ KL9CDE 0MN 3OBPMNQR
#$%&$S8)CDOTU9VW0XYZ[O*+\]^_
\`aMN0ObcE3deP KL8#$%&$S0d
!"#$%&$]fgfhij f kOlmd!n
!"#$%&$8059opqr+stq[EO)uvq d-#$%&$S89opqstq[E0dopq850!istq Or+stqwPMN04xy\stqz{stq|}stqO~M)st q)uvOCd9[E^89 8 r+)) ewONqE0dOPdN#$%
&$#$%&$S 3
#$%&$S-uv0MNX8VW Y)
X" XO¡¢0d*P)£¤N¥¦§¨©ª!"¦
#$%&$ gfXO¡¢0d*P)£¤wf4¥¦¦
«¬ª®YZ-¯°f #$%&$S d fO#$%&
$P±NY²³q[´µ ¯°X¶·q#$%&$S
¸µ ¥¦·q¹µ ¦«¬ª·q[µ YZ·qµ - º )X[O¶·MN00dgf»P ¼
0x½bM78#$%&$uv«04RY0d )¾¿À²³qO#$%&$S8gf¯°0gN Áopq
stq[)ÂÃOb\0MNÄž¿À)ÆjÇd8#$%&$SIµP
±N [0dÆjÈÉ3)ÊOËÌÍ
!iopqstq[)ÎÏÐÑ)C^i ÒÓ)C-8]f N 004R)gN
ÔÔ
!"#$%&
'()*+,%-./0123456)789%:;<=>?)
@A"?BC#D%EF=GHIJEF789%:;<2K?LM%GHNO PDQN0RS2TU?VWXY=Z[U?)\#]^%H2P_
`%&'()*ab%cde$%fgEh2i_
d789:;<VWXY%Z[=jk#]
789:;<VWXY%Z[2l1mLn%op=qrU?st%Xu)Ov#]
wxyzst%<{789:;<VWXYZ[#|}~st
"?]
xyzstVWXY=Z[eU?456VWXY%Z[2 TU?xy VWXY%2K?I= =N456
nLM9=pnnn9n9456)@A
#n=X[_?]
P2789:;<VWXYZ[#|}~stn
z9%LMnn¡n9¢£T#¢£T¤=X[U?D
¥'%&'n9)45623VWXY%Z[¦|}=~U?)\
m§~=¨©#456ª%«¬=U?®¯)"?_d%"?]
!"#$%&'
°2±#i$ `%3²³-´ v%
n)ªµ%9=U?"v#2.´#]_¶
<=}2S_·¶n%2®¯=¸U_%¹%
º¶»d¼½¾2¿_?_¶nÀ9)xÁU?TK2ÂN|<
)Ãv?1]
ª789:;<%ÄS2TU?VW»ÅÆ[ Ç È !ÀÉ zʯËÀÌËÍÎÏ Ð+ÑVW»ÅU?]789:;<%ÄS
%#%¹2TU?VWN0Lª%Ò789:;<%ÄS2TU?VWL2i©?À
%Ó¯ ÔÕ\Önn9E»×ØQnª%Ò
%nxÙVW»Å 2VÚ·n%ÔÕ\Ö%Ûܪ%Ò%7 89:;<%ÄS%#%¹%ÛÜ2P_789:;<%SÝ%Þß9=àPP v%n%op=qr´á?#2@A0Ö=Ôâ#,ãä2OPãå0»2 `2TU?Dºæ
ç ç
!"#$
%&'() *+, -./0123 4-56789 :;<=>?
@ABCDEF :;<=>?GD-5HIJKL@MNO
;<:;<=>?PQD@RSTUVWXT)3 9Y
9 Z[\9*]]^J_<`3ab%cbd?ef@*+WXg hg6i'jk QlmTgnoTpqrs9tuvY
wxab%cbd?yU@9z*]]^J_{T|}~D
` *]]^J_C_JKwUU
p9@$f_*]]ATr @D
_ ¡j&¢£¤¥¦§`K¨wy©`@Y
ª «.¬y ZI®¯`\ab%cbd?yU@°}9 4±²_ _<³´9@Oµ¶·¸O¹Dº»VJK L3 _ ¡j&¢¼¤¥ ½2_¤¾ ¿d ¼¤¾<
±²_ _<*]À<ÁÂÃx Äű²_
_<:;µ¶*]ÀÆÇfD<EF ±²_ _<=>:
;µ¶*]À¹DÈÉTÊËD)ÌYy zM NO;x ZI`±²_ _<O¶·¸OÍÎ2ÏD<
ÐÑÐpO;9ÒÓw4ab%cbdÔÕ)Ö×ÔØf2ÏÖÙÀ9
@ ÚÔØO;Û9ÜÝS`ÝwtuvY
Þtvßàáâãä妧æç¸èÓéêëìíî4âãäåÛïðäå Ûï0ñ9ð)ªy òó¸ô4äåab%cbdñ9)GD õö÷`iÚ@YZøäåùRSú+ûäå¨ü_iú~ýÕþy!b
®9 äåab%cbd{9@tuvY äåab%cbd{y ]ù ù ³ù R}ù 90{ª Z ú2ªÃª@Y iú`¦§w@[ª ù`
à 96£3`,`y,wª
©xY9 4 )ªÚx DÚ4r)`¹
?w`,ªY
!"#$%
&'()*+,-./012$% 3456789:;
34<=>?=@/ABCDE7BFGHIB<=>?=@JKLMN7 8;OPQRSTLUVWXY$WZ[\]^_`a=bc=
def8ghij*,g9klIBmnopmn8gqr stmnuvwxyxz+{|IBDE}9gF~/8g,;78L
RgUVNyg ,y99gFg,;/78L*
+Ug:
<=>?=$ (F KLMN$.g-/~78
/Q 78;$Rg:#B
!"#012*78L$-LIBL/Lg
Y<=>?=¡6/78¢£78:
<=>?=/DE¤U;$¥L !"#¦§y¨Y©Lª«
¬+U:®¯qrdef°c±²³Q´µ¶.·!#$9+-
s¸#¹º.¹Y »¨s¸7¼½s¾¥¿®À/Á´;
ÂÃI78ª«g:WÄÅjÆÇÈÉ!Ê$¾g+®ËÌÍ ÎUÏÐ-wZ6g:
¤$ÑÒÓÔÕ½¡6defÖרQ$¥UV <=>?= Ù*
+$g¤¤Úg Ù$ÛUgC$ÜÝÞß/8+·!#à áhâÇ@C©Fª«g:
$¥UVãäåæçèéêÏC7012 34äåëæì í$.gîå 012X012æ/ 34äïN8gðñä ëgòógåôæ:õö$ 34äïN012012$
L÷øI$äëõ/ÏÃù012/ 012äëB g012012B9g:äë/Bgúû012X$¤üB
!ý7ä /¯9gBg012õ)7BFþ<=>?=ÂB 7$
mXB ¦+{Ug;y;çé<=>?=m}$¥L g9*,ä56},;/¤Ug:®À$% 34äåëæ
$}U012 34äñ¼/; èçä
¿7g:
-ÑÒÑÁQCgåôæ: 0
/7I§gìí/8;:9L0 /DE¤U
<=>?=$¨-
!
"#$%&'()*+,-./0 1#23%&
'()-456789:;<2=>?@AB C DEFG23 HI: !J=>KLMNOPQ RCDST:U2%&'()*:+,/V0WX/Y5 Z/[ CDEF\]^-G23$_`-a3/3Y5;bc-/
d efgh-+,/ijOklmn*0$ofgh+, p#qrstu/vwxyz{0# ijO:2|a}V ~+,:9[ |aJ=>0#gh
p#3$+,:C
\m+,p#3:/J3/
gh r gh<gh¡¢:£ gK¤¥¦§¨ © ª«¬¦l ®m¯<«¢°±²vwxyz-³´=>0#3$
$#0µ¶ ·:9+,"#\¸:¹/
º2;-»:¼½/8¾#
¿ÀÁ0 · ÂsÃu··ÄÅÆ ǾÈV 9[ÉÊËÌ:ÍÎz-Ï6Ð¥Ñ/
ÁÒÓÔ«¢°Õ:Ö×-£3·ØÙ:92 Ú<$*z- 6Û; *3<#ÜÛÔijOÝ×Õ:Þ23Øßp#V;:
½à*ÜáâJ×?
/;/ ·9áâp#3×ÐãäÛåæç·ØÙK¾#3 /; èé-êë/ +,C§-ìJíîç:2£[ z-9[
216VRïð-ñ/3×áâp#+, -K2 efgh+,V qrstu/«¢°ÖòóQ?
VôÌÓ3$õ+,5ÖòY50#«¢°-Y5 *3Ëö :÷0/3+,]^-G$-øùz/3×§ú6/3Y50#
3Ü «¢°×:£ ghgK¤¥¦§¨ ©ª«¬¦l
®m¯<:ûЫ¢°±²: WX/Øßp#3ü5ýþª
<$*µ-/ o©ª-/KÛ; *3o©ª<Ð#n PQ-J;:Òp#
*3 ·-[2 µ¶p#3 :èÐ67à- ë :ØßÐ3*Ü+29:ÌÓ0#ÂsÃu·§ªz
!"#
$%& '()*+,-./"0./"+,12./"345 63#789:- ;<=>?@ABCD#E&FG#E@
H?IJ-K LMNOPQIJ RSTU$6VWFG.XY$VZ[\']^_A
`.Zabcd@FGbXd@A[d ef&#g@hij$ '!$Vk lH3B
[email protected]\uvw$xyz{@ |}
.v[~@ V#g@@Y[mnopq z
#6356@A.' V."$U$Z@ '!$VB
'! b"A^@BVCD
#;rsb'$'!$u
bZ[@ b$.W '!3b;O
ub [~¡¢.£&@]#¤¥W3BCD#E&¦§¨
©ª«VW TU!¬#¥W3@[BV® FG#E
@!O!^;H3@$ !¯#H3°±.(b¤[BY[F GbXd²³ ´CDIJ-Oµ¶·¸¹#E@6 ]# bXd ºV »·w$*©.¼½#$Z@$.3b¾X' ¿ÀÁÂ#$Z
@ '!$VB
'!FGºÃÄ.Å.^Æ@[dÇÈÉÊ!ÉÊ#7
@PË!PË#7@ ÌÍÎÏÍy.H3'3Ð3 9:-.\$Z@
FGb9$Z[BÑÒ abÓ6 ]#^ Z@A V"$U )g'(B@FGÔ.ÕTUÖ×#7c7bQØ ']#Ùd@AgY^FGÚ·#E& Y[ÛÜ?]
oÝpB
HW#CDÞ#ÌÍÎÏÍyb'FGb Xd@@ '(VW #7@ßàÌÍÎÏÍybFGá
\âã' äåÜæ ç^èéOµ¶·' ^êé* ¼ë$6bìd[íîw$ïð bñÜ.( '!$VB
8.ò'óô3@ . '(¤¥W3B b^
õV$ö^÷Î ]^)ø FG!ùú#$Z@A '!$Vû?W3 Y[_A ` äü]#÷Î FG.FZ@$Eº@ `.ý@þW
'A^#!@V$û?W3B
#7)û
!
"#$ %&'()*+,-+#$ %&'./012345 67898:;<=>?@A/BC 0DEF6GHCIJK
?EL(MN:;COP?QRBST>?ULVW7*+,-+X#YZ [*+,-+>\]8LV6^_Q`abGcCdefeabg>hVi>
\]8LV6GcCig>hULVWjkBDl$m'7 !"#9M*+,- +X#nopVLCqrstBCPu86i\]GcBSTCX#v w()xyz{|}~#>W[ M6gBDW7j:
C#YDLeLV5VkBDl7
#C.?>>[ULW} ¡
¢@£¤5?5K¥¦>§¨W©ª«>C¬ 86p9®P>¯ULV W°ELVW$m'7898±.²©ª«>³´8*+,-+0«
MW6 C.µ¤¶·¸>¹W12DWº¬MW7»¼*
+,-+½V°¾C8¿8¿ÀVMW#W¼*+,-+Á«CÂà D !"#()*+,-+#2Ä>ÅÆ¤869W
*+,-+X#[j:CÇÈÉÊ>Ë8LVW°7
Ì ÍÎÏ»ÍÎÏ*+,-+ÐÑ<=ÒÓÔÕÖ×½$'
Ø ÙÚÛ»ÜÝ0(ÞWßàán³´âÝãLäåæ> çULâ½èãé0êëì írîïéðñòÕßàáóî$'ô7
í {õöë÷Yøùúûüýþñ$ 'ô7
0øCûü0>L9MWB%2ø>V7 {õö í'þ ô7
ä¤59MDWVC©[p9M»æ½Vj> Þ»æDW
½»æ>¯p½}»æ½»æV½j>ÀVWDWÕ(VLC
#(VLÀLVW»æ½Vj.8LVW7
ðë ñR#ú$'ô7
»÷¤Â½$ð 'þ ô'
ð 'þ ô7
.»*+,-+9M*"nâ*+,-+#8â½ë ìñZþ )Z#sH$'Ìô7Ú$'ø ÏVÀ W©5U67${
õö»*+,-+*"Á«~`aW ½$'ô' {õö
$,·¸÷Y$ 'øò'
!"#$%&'()*
!"#$%&'()*
+,-./0123145167819:;<=>?@ABCDEFG,HD-./I0J KLMNO1PQ1RS<TUV;WXYZ[\]^_`a,HbcdTUV;W XYZ[X]
efg%hij kjUlWamnopqrstuvwxyz1{|1}~?t
]]
h?1?<<CDWij kjUlW c bjTVj:U¡¢£ X]*¤?jTVj:U¡¢£¥
¦§¨©
!"#$%&'()* efg% ª«
ij kjUlW¦§¨©¬E®¯E®°¨±²?³E°´µi j kjUlWt?1?<<CDW¶·t¸¹º»c
ij kjUlW01h¼½¾B¿ÀÁÂÃÄ}~?@¿ÀÃÅ^³ºdHJ}~BÆC DÁÂ^h?1?<@dHÂcCJÇBÈ^ÉBÊdoo¾sË
`ua@ÌÍÎÏXYÐ]aÊ1hÑÒ@ÓÔCDuaÕs?1?<@Â
¾sË`uah?1?<<CDWֳר%&
')*©F]ÙQ1hij kjUlWØaCDZY@ÌÍGÎÚvÛ ÎxÎcar1ÂÜÝÞßÕàáâ cb01h<dHãäοÀÖá I0ÂÜ<ÝÞåàáâCDæç^,HD©F%&')*©F] Yßcb,HxvbcD
Z*èdsABÀ>^¤2éêÖáGëìÊbßuºh Óíîïð %&
'ñòíîÕvÛ1¤2óôGèDõ*¤ö÷ôG01ø%&
'ñGès1øùñaÎDa1úûô øü@èýxvDuv^þvÛ1Ç ô0ÏaÕs1ô@vJaÎsºDw0ÁGèº
íîh Óíîïð %&'ñò
!"! #"
!"#$%&'()*
¦01¤ñ ^ëCDdH1JaÎD}[^æ¤aÊb,HdY Öáá?a¦<a¥Ý.ä^CDÏ1æçCD Ø^ij kjUlWGÊbcD¨ij kjUWßcbæç1 }~W}~Fæq1~FI0}~Ì s±Ê^³ºua@Gd@1 }~W Øc@ès1¨G} ßcb@bcdu ÕºÎ^CDdH Ø@0wxvdGèDij kjUlW
ij kjUlW
ij kjUlWCD¼
!"#$%&' ()*+,-./01 23456789:;<=>?
@ABCDE FGHIGJKLMNOPQ./RSFTU'OVN O4WX./VN O4XYZ[
\ ]O^_`abcVNO 4dXY AefAeghf ij klmnoghpijqrstf uvwHI
xf y0z{|}~YJ?fO
nghQFU'qGJKLQ&i jFU'q (FTU' ¡¢£¤¥¦§¨©
sªkl*¨«¬zij|}®¯°±²³FTU'q´µx¶·¸¹º»¼ x½¥¾¿À¶#ÁUÂâÄŦF¶||¤}ÆqÇ´µÈÉÊËDÌÍD8x Î&ÏUÐO&|&º»¼x½¥Ñ¾¿#ÒÓ&'xqÔªÕÂÖ#z×&'U ØÙU¢¦UOVNO4XYVNO 4ºX Y ÚÛÜ ÝÞ#ßIàáâãuäFTU'å#ÛÜF&'æçFTU'5
èéê#.ë¦Ðìqíîïéêîïéê#ð¨ñFòxóÅ'UØôõ¨ö
÷ø}¥ÆqîïFTU'qùúûúFGHIéê#óUqíîï FU'üý#£Å'UØ¢UIT|}¥¦þ»mmk mmmU¦vmmm mÀøÄØ
õ0f½?NÉO