日中歴史教科書に関する比較研究 −近現代史記述 を中心に−

日中歴史教科書に関する比較研究 −近現代史記述 を中心に−

著者 張 ?

学位名 博士（人間文化学）

学位授与機関 神戸学院大学

学位授与年度 2015年度

学位授与番号 34509甲第69号

URL http://doi.org/10.32129/00000031

Creative Commons : 表示 ‑ 非営利 ‑ 改変禁止 http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by‑nc‑nd/3.0/deed.ja

9

5

2 0

1

1

(

3 (

. . 7

3 (

. . (

. . (

3

. 6

. 4 0

38

2 5 6

5 6

, 29 4 (

, . 1 6 4

0

. . 1 6 4

3 (

5 6

. 9

06

8 3

8

2 (

2 (

3 (

1 1. 2

P k P

_P _

_ P k P P

P P P s P P

k a P k …ks .,

ks P i s P

P m g k s

wg k P P P

k P k k P kP s

s P ks

kP k n P

P kc ks

w _P P k

P i j lP P

k

P nP i s

k c _P i

m _

k P s w

i k P

_ g P k a

k

P P s P

— s ks s ks P

ac P a

_ ⁽ P ks m

P P

2

P ac__

_ g P a

k f P e as sk P

a mg a t _P nP _ k c

P P l Pi j P

as ac e P

P kP s k

m U c U c

m P ⁴

3 . 2

P io P P

P s P fs

a _e P wc U k

kP a t g

eP P _ s

P m g i P

i s

21 P

kP s P P

P i

P P P

m k P r

k P s P m

cP k m g i s

g • P s P P

ksU c

i s^, U c i ^-P

o P , P , . P ( P i s ^.

U c s P P _

i s P k c _P _

i P ks sP cP m

U c

4

P P

P P

_ P P P

k i P P

m i P

w P s

P P s f

P r i P _ c

a

h P e P h P

k k c

s P k P os

k s P P

P P

P g

i f

c

• P

k

5 e

k i s s

_ P h P P

P P c

P P P P

i s

P kP P e ksg g

a P w i

6

t k_kP P m g

P c P P

w kP

s k

c P

P P , P

P ) P

, P

U - . P

( ( P ( ((

P k

P s t_ m kP

k kP a P we _ k

ks mgk m P c i s m

P s w m P

P , ks s _ s P w

s ks )

ks m

i ks P i s _P _ i ks

( _ P i ks .

g P w P P a P _ P c

P k sP

f P kP

i s _ m a g c

s P l

U c m _ P l _P

P _

7

P k w

_ t k P

P ― ― s ks m

kP P g s _m _

s kP P P

s …wg m ag k

r k

― e P l

sg _ P m g ki k

U c e P

― w i s

P kc i s P _

m kP s ― m g i

o ks P a P P g

P ks_s

sP m P ― w P ks

― _ m g k ks

i P m a gk ks kP

r m s

g P ios s P m

g ks P

m w P

ks _ m kP

P mm k P P P P

m t ks⁽ g i s

PU c P lP

k gk ks aP m i s

8

s P m _ w P

_P _ f PU c P

asg nP P k a

ks kP kP U ks _PU

ks _ P m g ks

_ P P ― Pg

s . m ― s P

a ks

P m c

m g k P w ― s k

m P ― g

m

P g k P P P

c P sci s

P eP

ks P a s P

kP P k s g kP P

• _ e P _ P s P

_ m k

g kP P U(

P ksU m P m

k P a m P

io g P i s r s P

m g l g kP

a kc ks

_e ks P P i s

m _s ks

.) _ s P

9

i s P i s . P i P

ks ks

P k _ P

i s P sg i k

m ,

U c ( onP s

stP ( i _ s P i

s . P i s i P ()

( k g P

a ks P ( ks_s

fs sP ( s g w

_ ⁾

_P P l s

s k P U c g k_ s

P s p k s _

m g io m P P s

_ s _ P s

• P gks m

PU c P gk ks

m g kP

nk k P i m k P

ks P

g P c P s _

m m s P

s P n k k

ks P P

k k

k_kP p kP m _ s P

lP c P on

10 P nk

.

U c k P nP

m g am s P c P

P m g

s U c g

eP PU c a Pi

k m g ks

P _ s k m g kP

PU c U k ^, P

U m i P k as

U _ P

P U c e ks

k i P h

P P

e

U P P k

c P P s P

w PU c P a ks kPU

P ( s k

11

P P

P P

P P

― P P

P _c e kc k r P

k m ksg _

_e k m P

P s P k m e g

a _ s^-

s P P w_ k

s _ P P k P

_ P ks k g

_ P w_

jks _ g w P P

k

w_ ks _ w P _P

_P _ P _ as

P nk t s cP g t s

g k P ks

Pg s t s i

Pg P _ m

nk t s kP

m k g _ i

_ k

.(, P P

c s P g

12

k g s

P _ m ks

ios g _ s e

ksg _ ac s

k _ P gks P

P ac s kP nk

a P k

g m P _s P

U U _ P k

P P i as P

e … a gm s c

i gk kPi

mm P P k m s

P s

k_kP P c kP

sg P P e

a gi P … i

o ss P a gi s c ,

m P P k_kP

_ P s

sP k o w PU

U c l P P

ks k

P g s P

P― ks P k _

P i s P s

k i s .

kP i s i s

P ( k )

13

U c P a P (

o g a _ s P k g

sP PU c P U

m P U m U c

k s

U P P

P ks

i t ,

P c wes w P

e e g k m

m a_P t

w P m P

s

es k P … kP

m w s m cP

_ P k k

s

g k P P io s

t s

m P i k

… m P .

w kP P g m g

_ U P P

m c P

g as

g P c P s_

k_kP kP P

P_ _ a P ks P

14

P P w_ m

P P s ^.

P c k l P

cP k PU l U _ g t

k g P P

m s P c m lj

15

as P P c m

m g P g P s

m g f s i s P

s

k s k m P P

fs P

r kP ks

s c P

m k i s

P r m kP P

P P w

r P w ⁽

P P m P

m w l P

m g P g k

P k P

i ⁾ P

s P P

i P P ) P U

U m i s

U w i P

r _ w P

.( _ .) aP P P w

P r _ . P _

P _ k h P P

kP ks P

m ^,

P e m

16 s

c

_

m

h P k o k_kP

kP ks_ i s

-Pgg P ks_ w k cg

ks

nP m cw_

w P -.) _ .

Pg P k c

P kww P

s k k_kP s P

i j i P k -

P ks k

P P ^._ P P

ks t eP

k k s ⁽ P P

l

e P w k

ks_ w

r P i

k P P ksU k P

17

i P _ kP s

m w ⁽

P ― c ― lP

w s g P m s ⁽

g P P ―

k aP i s

kP P k gks

P g s ⁽⁽ k

m a g _

k P P s ―

P k P P g ―

k m g l P

P k at s k

()

P P — e k P

fP s g a

s P

s g P g — n …sn P(, P

gg k s gk s g w

k ⁽

e w P P

__ k ⁽ P P

P _ es g k

P P i s P P

k fP s

s m ^(,

i P _ ^(- m w P

P m k

i P a gks t m

18

cPi j _ g

k ^(. P k P U

ks k P U

ks P m ks ⁾ k

w P _ _ s

U P i s ⁾

g w P m P

w_ k m P s w

t i ⁾ k_kP _ P g s

s _ P ⁾⁽

ks k g ks P w s

sP P m o kP p

as_ k P as• w m g ks⁾⁾

P s g ks P P w

_ s ( P

ks kP k ⁾

PU P

k l

P e

P .), ( i P

k P P k P P

i U ( ,

PU P m P P

m k k

g k ks P

— P

P es k

19

P c P P

k P

g P P e s

a g P e

k i ⁾

m s P

m P k P •

_P ks g m w P

te c ks i P nk

ks e g

P P ks c s

kP

m s k m

P kP kc f

l P g ksg

P m g _

g _ P P

e k a ^),

g w_ c P P

a c s P g k P

_ w_ P a g

g P s

20

P a t _

P c P wc

s

P m s ..

i sU P P P

14 a i s k_kP l

s P i P

k s^)- l P

t

P P k

s P .- a _e k ^).

fs Pg P

s c i j a k_kP

w ks s

.

k P k P i

s n P m

k s a m _

k s i

g g U c P

P P P

w _ P r

w P . . P s o

k ks k m

n sP i g ks P

nP

w P . . P

m P

m P o ks P

21

m P s ks

m g

P k k c .

i ks U e P

wc ks P

n m

g P r m g n

U c P cg s P

P ks w P

i s _ kP c

m P r P P

w s k P

ks _ _ s g g

a w k f

P s ks P

g _

P as _P s

m _ k cg t

k .

P P P m

c k P m g

k P r a te

m s P k os k s

U c P w P ks

a s P r sP

P w P _ m _s

s P nk P s

w PU c P P (

22

s k ( m g g P

nP P

g _

sP i P m

g anP w_ m m g k

U P w_ w P

P k

P k P P

P k_kP

P m g _ s P m g

P m m a k

P P _ m g o

nP kP m

a g P k __ nP

wg g m g as

lcP P m g

m g a ⁽ P k P

a ks

P e

w P P as

m kP P k

g P m k f ⁾

i P k P P

“ Pi j _ i P k c

P k m g P

s k

. . .

P P w e

23

s_ ks_ w

U c PU k P k

ks s P

P P P P

k k U w P ks

i

k_kP P p kP P

s_ s w ―

P P P

i j l P io g

s P P s

P P U

w kP P P a s k

as k P g_

w P g s P P

P m g P

s ks r m g

g P P k P

a g m

P k P

cP P P a

k k m g c

P k_ _ sg ks t

P cP

m P g

P i _ c

U c U k

24

n k P c e

g

P P m g

k P

k m P

25 .

as P P

cP c P

i s _ g n m a

g ks P e m

k te cP ^, _

k _P g _w t

p ks _P m g

s P i as _ kP

t

g P P i s

_ m

w_ k m cP m

_ we m _o

eP “ ksP P l

m ^- P n .. P

e kP

. P f P

kP k c s

wes P e i

sP ks P

P k e P P

a k i P

P s

g P P e P

w P e _ kP

e m g m

s … P i k

m kPk k

k P .- g

26 k

nP p P ks

_ nP kP s

P e

_ P k c P m

k k r P

m _P a _ k

c

ac ios _ P c t

P P l m

m P c s

P c _ c

m P c k g

_ kP r k

P w k as_ P

c

p tks _P _ m

_ P ―100 s i es

s aP k

P i k w P

k as _ P k e

as “ P g_ _ s e m

g m

P r P

i _ P i

P f

P e k

P k c

27 m

c c e

U .). .., ..- ) - ) .

U w g s _

U s

( U w

” ,

4 _ P i

io stc

k P .- ks U

.- U .. U

.. U U i

P U

U _

P U _

P

U _ ,

5 c U

c _ - P

i

6 P P

28 _

P P

_ ,

P _

7 U c

P U

k _ P

k g

8 P

9 P U c

_ -

10 P U c

_ -

11 U 0 U c

_ U

-

12 P U c

_ )

13 ks c

e __ U - - (

14 P U c

_

15 P U c

_ -

16 U k P U

l

17 U k

18 ) c U

29

• k _ ss P k

s

19 P U c

_

20 P

21 U

)

22 P i • w P

U , U

U ) i

23 kc P

/ 96 : = 96= 6 86 7 6 =75 8 E 5 E .

24 U

/ 96 : = 96= 6 86 7 6 8 E 5

25 P 23 _ m g a

i oP ). )

26 P U P

U s

P k

27 P U

28 nP

U s P

U , P U

U ks

29 U m P

k

30 P U p.123

30

31 U p.91

32 U p.86

33 U p.133

34 U pp.95 96

35 U pp.136 139

36 U pp.104 105

37 U p.142

38 k

m s P k P k

g ks g w kc

39 U U (, )

40 U ,,

41 U (

42 P

P k P g f

k

43 U (

44 P

45 .

46 P U

47 P U

48 e w P U

e ..- k

49 w m

50 U (

51 a _ U c

k U ( (,

52 P U

53 ks U

31

54 P a _ U c

k (-

55 P U s .

56 U s g

. ( )-

57 P P e P

_P P P

g

l e

P P P

P kP sP

o P _ m P

m

- U _ s .. U

_ .. e

H _ — ,

e _

15( ) 2000. U _ _

_ 2004

. U _ ,

U k

P U c

_ P U

sP P

APARC P i s

i P P P P P kP

PGi-Wook Shin and Daniel C. Sneider, eds, History Textbooks and the Wars in Asia: Divided Memories (New York: Routledge, 2011)U m

e

32

o , o

o

o o

% , o Q

% , I I Q

N

% ,%

o a I I o

I Q o

oQ I I

I o I

I I o Q p

I o a o

a I a I

a o o ^%

o I

I a o a %

I I

po a o

I I o p

o Q A

B I I Q o

o o

o N I

o o

% , I NQ

a N % , po

33

o I o

I I

a o

o a o N

I o

o o o I

o % %

N % , a o

a

p N a

o Q o

I I a o

N a

34

― o % () % I

% % I

% ( … a

% % 014 I

o a

” N % ( 014

o % ⁾

N

% ( o

I ― o

―

% ( I I I % )% I

― % )) I ―

―

o

% ), ― o a

oo ― a o

o

% ) o

014 ―

p o % )%

N ^, o

35

― I o I

o N I ―

N o

N I o

I Q oa o

I b a

I ― b

o N o a I o

I a o N

I o I o

Q o o

a

I o o

I o N

― p

% ( ― I o N

% )) ―

o

o

o p p

o p

a % ( I ― I o I

36

I o p

o % I

I o I“ I

p a o

N ^% o I o I

Q aa a o

o I o ―

a ― o

o I

I o a o

― o Q

% )

p % ) o ^%%

o o

oa o o

a

% , % ) ^%

o I o

I I o a

o o

p a o )

a I I o

o

37

I o o

N % ) ^% I

o

o o o % ^%(

I I

Q o o I I o

% I

I a ^%)

I o ,

o p

I o o

p … 8 (,

%

% , No I

I o oa

o a % ,

I o I I …

8 (, ^% % ,

I I o

Q % , ^%, I o % ,%

% o I I a

o o % ,% I

o o

I o % , I o % ,%

% , o

I a a I o

a o

38

N o Q

― % o % o

o a o

% ―

o

o o a o

o o

o p

o a

N

% ―

o

o o N o

a

H o o

o oo

H o

I H o

o I

N o o

H Q o %

― % , % ,%

a o o Q

― % ,%

o

N

39

― % ,%

a …

― N

o o

― o

% ,

o % ,(

a o I I

I I o

o

% ,% ^%

N

% ,(

p

% a

o

I o a I o

% , o

% ,% ― a I

I I Q

b Q I

I o

N

40 ,

% ) o N

% ) oo ⁽

% ) % (

) % )

o Q I

o

a % )% ―

N % )% % ― 2

o % ) ―

222 5 6 %

― 22 … …

% ( ―

% )% ―

… p N N

p p p

9 2 2 /

o o p

o o N o

I o ―

I ― p

41

) I o

oQ

% )% I I o N

% )% ^,I %

% ) I

% )( I %%

I I o

a I o o

a o

p

A % )%

o

a o o N

Ho N

B % )

o

o o a oo

% )

a o o

o

A B

I o N

I oa ao

) o I

42 a

o I o Q

B I o

p o % ) o

a o

Q 8 (

) % , o

p I I I

o I o

a Q o

I N o

I o o

N Q

a N a o

o a I N o

I o o N

a

a I o Q o

% ,

o % ,

o a o

N % , % ,)

% ,) I I o

% ,( % , I o

43 o

p o % ,

(

I o o I o % ,) ⁾

I % , I % ,)

I a

% , I a

% ,)

I o I

I o o

o a o

% , I

― o

% ,)

b I ― o

o o

Q I o p

a o o

44

I o N o I o o

oa

N p

Q o Q a

I o o

N

―

o p I I I po I

I I o o

% ― % ,%

a I I I Q

o

, Q b

I I o

N ―

o % ,

I o I o

a o

o o N

o

N ^, o

45

%) I % o

8 )

I Ho N

o % ( I

a

I I o

% ,

% ( o p

o % , I o I

―o a o

o

46

o N I o

― I o

a o

% ,

o o Q

I I I Q

― %

N o

% ,

I o I I o

% b oI

, I oI

oo Q Q

o

o

% ,

o o

I o Q

I a

o I o

p a N Q

o o

a

47 a

p a N o

o a ⁽ I p

H H N

a a o

a o o Q

48

% )

% )

% ),

% )

%

%

%

%

%

% )

% ,

% ,%

% ,(

% ,

%

%

%

%

… % ,% % , % %

% , %

― N

I N o I o

I a N I

a I o I o

N I I I I

I I I I

49 8

… . a .

a o

…

― N

50

IG o a

% )

Ho N

%

% )

aa

G

% , G G

% % G G

% (

% , G G

% , G G

% ,% G

% , G G

% ,) G G

% ,, Q G

% % G G

% G G

% ( G

% , G G

o N

o

%% G G

%)

o

51

% I

Q I I

o I o

30

…

(

( % )

) % ( % %

I I

N % )%

, % )%

a o

% % %, 8 %

%% o % )

% o % )

% % )

%( %

%) % o N I

o

% % )) I ―

a

52

% …

%, % ,

% % ,%

% % ,

% o % ,%

o % ,(

% ( oo

( % ) ( % )% % % )

% ,) 8

) % ( % ) 8 %

― 5 6

% )% %

% )%

, % )%

% )

% )(

% Q I o o

% (

% )

% )

( % ,

) % ,)

% ,

% ,)

, I ―o 9 N 9

o

37 ), %)

( a I

% % %%

53

% I

o

% I

% o

o %)

a o N

54 2 0

t x

c v p x v h p v

v

.). p

v p . % v t p

h p h p .%

p p

... h p x x

x p

%% x v

h x ,

h p

x w

v %% h

% h p w

w v

x v w

xn o t v v

.), xx

h p x w p n

. . % x v

xx t x

n % gx

%% % %%. h n o

% ( % ) % (

h v ⁽

55

x x

x w w x

v x v

xc v v c

56

x … h w

h p h x p

v x

v

x x

v p v w p

w %% h p

c h v

p v x

p

p w

x

, h

p x v w h x

p gx

p

h h x

w v x

p x jv

x h

v h p jv ^.

v w p

w ^%

w w p x v

w v

v w

57

p %% v

w p x h p v

%%( ) x

h p x v

x p gx t v

x

j w

v v

v x

w p w

x x

c x p h x

p B t v

t v

58

x

v x

v x x

w v v p c

p v x v

v

p (

(x ⁾ v

x

t v w

w x

B

x

B x

B x

%%)

w x v h v w x

h v

w p

n

x v n p p v w

x v

x v

v ( v

v p

x w w e

x p v

59

p h v . ( x

x v p

v v p

v ^, w p

60 v p

v h v p n o

w t w x

x v . w h

v

w x w

tx v

w x

x v x

. % x v h

w p

v v x

w tx v

w w

. ( w h p w ..

h p w

p

x x

v

) w h v

v t v

v

61

w 8 x

8 x 8 x x t

vn o v

c gx

v

t w

v

t v ( h v

H x t v

xx

x t v v

x

x t v p x

x x

pv

x p x

( x t v c v

x x x v ev

v x w

x jv

x h n x x

v cx w t v

jv v c

v gx

h v n o

h v p vc v

6 3

3 3 5

62

x x t

w

x t x

p x h v

x

w t x

v H

N x

P

t h w x v

t )% .).

.). x v

p x w v p

x

x

x

63 x

j w jp

x v

w p x hmv t

v t v

v v x

gx x v

x p j

.x h tt w h v v

v v

p x

v v

1 2 ( ) 3

3

1 2 3 3

3 4444

)% .%% hm

hm

hm

p hm

hm

hm n

64

tc v

v

v c x w

e v ev

t e

v

n ^% t ev

w

w

v p v c

w t v w c v c

65 1

v x

x

x x x

v h

v h w

x w p

x p

v

x p

x v w

w h n xx

v

jv

h

v v % , h

(

( n

h v

x v t

w x h p . .

v h v x

w c vw ⁾

66

x v t w

x v

v x

x v x v

w x w x

x v %

v p xc 0 , . w

(

0 ( w w

v

0 w mv ) )

w (

w w

p v p

H x (

(

) (

x

pn x h

%%. p w % ( h

67

gx

( p x

h v

x v w

x t v x

w x

v x

t v x hm x

x w v

t t v v

c x w hm p t v x

x t hm x v x

v x x n jv

w x v w x p

hm x x x w

p v p x

v x

v t v n o

v c t v v

hm x t v hm

, x v w v

c

t v

v v hm x x p

% x v x p x h

v

v w H

x t v v

H x v

68

hm x t v hm x v

x v x

x v x x

h 0 v x

v x x w

w x

x w

t v

x

x t v x v

hm

x

x t v x v hm

x

x t v x v hm

x

x t v x v hm

x

x t v x v hm

x

t v x v hm

t v hm e v

v

c

69

x v v c

x h v gx x v hm

x w v w

vw v

x

% x

( x

v x h v

w w vv v cx

x x t

v p x

xn x

v x v t v hm

v

x v p x

v j

v p x x h

m hm

p p v xx

p t v hm x

70 p x m

t v hm x

p wx x x …

v xc

p p x v

x x t

v v

x

x x v

x x x t

v hm xn

x

v n x t

v v hm ^. x n

x

v c h

t v n x v

x v cx hm m

x v

p v t v v

p v H t v

c xx …

p v w H t c

c … x

v

71 H x

v c

x h v p … x … v x

x x

v w

t v v

v w

t c h v c x

72

x v w

v x

c

v h p v x

w

v

v x

v x vw v

n w w

x v

h p h

n v

w w w

v v

h p t xc 8

x h v t

x

x v x v h

v

w x v x

x xh v t w x

x w n p p v

x v v x h v

w

73 1

m x v

h h v

hm x w w c

x v

t v c

x w x v n

c x x v h w x h v

0

w m

p hm x v

v c w

p x h v

w … ep t

hm x x v t

x h … …

p x h v x c

v

v x

v ep v c

w c v c

74

%%

7 / 9 5 6 4: % %

w xh c x

p x

n v v

w v x

x w w v

x x

..,

( t v

) %

) t v v

%% ,

13 % %

v h

v h

,

v x

v

. w h

% .. ..

13 % % x p

%%( )

) x v h

p

75

. % h t

w

( ( x w p w

) B

x % x

w

% )

B % )

B % )

B % )

· 0

) w

v n

( w x ev 0

9 8

w x ev

, 5 4 9 4: % . )

v

. %% (

% n

p e v

x p

tw

x v x

x x

t

e v

76

13 7 / 95 6 8 % % (

w v

w c v

w x v

%%

( , v p

13 % % )

) %

2 %

( . %

%%. % )

, %.

.. w p

h p n ... w x

p x c px

p t v

. %%,

. )

( %

p

77

p p

p p

.,. /

. / /

- p p p

p

p p

p

p

p p

p p

/.- ⁽

/.- .

p ④

( ⑤

p

p Ⅰ

p

78

/

p p

p

Ⅰ

p

p p p

p

./ ./

./

./

.// / / /

/ /

/ /(.

/) /)) /)(

/)( ) /)

“

79 /)- - -

/)- (

/)- . )

/)- /

% ( “

3 4 p

3 (4 p

3 (4 p p

p

80 p

p p

p p

p p

81

) ]

p p

―

), ( . (

) p

. p

.

( p

) ⑤

⑤

, -

]p (

p

(- - ,

. p

(- )( ( . , )- (/ -, ,

(( )) (- , , )) (- - ,

,. ), ( -, , ) /. .

(, () / ) )/ ( ,. ,

82

3 (4

p

. p

27%

46%

25% 27%

46%

29%

23%

43%

34%

21%

45%

34%

83

p ,

“

p (

]p p

]p

p

p

p p

84

5 -

85 p

― ⁾

― p

p

p ( p ―

.

5 ,

―

p

p ―

86

Ⅱ p

p ⑤

p

.

5 ,,

p

p p

p

87

, p

,

.

5 -,

p ④ p

p p

[

③ p

p

88

p p

p p

( p

. .

5 ,

=

p

p

p

―

p p

[ ^-

p

. /

p p

89 p

p p

p

pⅡ ^.p

③

]p

“ p

90 p

p p

/ p

( p

p

p ⑤ p

p p

p p

p p

3 4 5。 5 5

91

6 5 5 5 5

5 “ . 5 .3 4

..-

p ③

p

p p

5 . 5

. 5 5 5

.

5 5 . 5 .

8 5 5 .3 4

./

p

p ./ -

. p

p

p

p

( p

p

p

=

p [

92 p

B [ p

pp p

[

pp [ p

5 .

93

③ p

p

p p

p

p [

5 . 6

、 7 7

7 5 — .3 4

./ p

( p

p

p

3 /

3 - (,

(

p p

p p

p p

p

7 8

5 .

94

5 .

p p p ⁾

《 8 . 》 5

. 5 .

5 5 .

5 5 .

.3 4

p

p p

p

=

=

p

A

p

p

p / /

95

p p

p

p p

p

― p

p

p

5 )(

p p

96

( p p

/ p p

p p

⑤ p p

,

5

5 , p ^-

p p

p ^.

p

5 5 . 5 ,

p 8 5 . 5 /

p

5 , p p

p

p

97 p

p [

⑤

p ^/ Ⅰ

p [

p

p p

p p p ⁽

p [ p p

p

p p

p “

p p p

(

p ⁽⁽

7 8

5 ,,

p

p p p ⁽⁾

98

p p p p p

p p

⑤ ⑤

⑤ ⁽ p

p p

p [ p

p

99

/) 」

7 8 Ⅱ

5 )-

/)

p Ⅱ

p

p ^(,

8p 99 5 ” . 5 -

99

5 8p 5 . 5 .)

/)

5 8p 99 5 ” .5 ),

/) 99

Ⅱ p

p p

p ④ p

p

p

(-

(.

p p

100 p

p p

p

,

⑤

( ⑤ p

p ⑤

⑤ p

p

5 . .

p

101 p

③ p

p

5 5 8 5

5 . 。 5

. 5 .35 4

/)-

p p

p ④

p

p p

p

p ⁾

p

p [

)

[

= )

9 p

9

( A

④

[ ⁾⁽

102

13 p

“

7 4

7

5 - ( 5 )-

p

p

④ ④

/)-

④ 55 - -

④ ④

/)-

④

p

“

5 5 .3 4

9 p

103

5 .3

5 5

.3

5 5 .3

p

p p

p

))

= 6 4 . 5

. .

p p ) 99

6 8

8 .

99 (

9 8 6 5

.

p 99

) p p

)

p

p

104

0 1 4 7 4

) 5 - 5 .

p

5 8

5 -, 5 p

5 .

5 p

. 5 -, p

. 5 .,

《 5 )/

p

p p

105 p

=

④

[

p p

p

106

p

p ⁾

p

[ p

p

④ ③

p p

p / /

p

p

107

. 6 4

Ⅱ

)

p

p

% p

p

p

5

108

p p (

,- .

( p

p

. p

1 / -. / - - / () -

2 (, , ( ). , ( - )- (

1 )( , / / . . ,. ( ( )(

2 ),) , - , ,, . ( -. ( (/ (

2 (,/ ). , - ( )/

2 ( , . / , . . . )/ )

3 4 “

3 (4 “ p

p

/

-

() (/ )

109

p

p p

p p

p

p

p 2 p

p p 55

p

③

p 55 (

p p

p p

p p 55 /, /-

p

p ④

④ p

p p

p

110

p [

p p p

p p

p ]p p

[ p

p

p 2

p p

p - p

p p

p

.

5

111

p p

. .

. 5 (/ / 5 (/

p

p [

p (

p (

112

. 8

( 5 ( , ( 5 .

p

②

p

113 p

) p

p

p

p

p p

[

p p

p [ p p

),

p

5 (/

p 5 .-

p 5 ()(

pp 9p Ⅰ

pp 99 5 -/

p 5 -

p ^)-

114

p p

p

⑤ 5 (/

⑤ p

5 .-

⑤ 99 5 ()(

⑤ 99 p p

5 (

⑤ p

5 -/

⑤ p

p p

p p

p

).

p

p p

p p

115 p

p p

p

p

p

99 55 (/ (/

③

p p

)/

p p p

p p

[

( )

)

p p 5 .-

/ p

2

Ⅰ

116 [

p p

117

p

5 ( - p p p

p

(

5 (/

5 . p p

(

p 5 (/

p

p

5 (/

[ p

p p

118 p

/

p

p -

p

③ [

[

③ p

5 (/

③

] p

5 (/

5 ./

5 (),

5 ( .

119

p ⑥ p [

⑥ ⑥

p

/ ).

)

5 (/

[

99 p [ p

)

p

p p

p

p 5 (/ p [

p

[

⑥ ④ (

p )

p p p

5 (/,

p

120

p p

p p

⑤ p

5 /

p p

p

p p

p p

p

p

]p p p

” p

⑥ “

p p

p

p pp

p p

121 6

p

/ ⑥

p

“ p

p p

/ “

p

p

” / 5 (

”

p

” 5 (

5 (-. p

”

p p

p Ⅱ

p 5 (

p %

p p

p p

122

p ③

p

p 5 )(

-p p

p p

p

123

“

p p

p

p p p

p

p

p p

“ p

.( p

.)

. “

.

p③

p 5 )

p p p

124

99 5 )

5 ( ) 5 (-/

5 ( -

p p

p p

/) .

p “ “

p 5 (((

p

p 5 )

p 5 )

p 5 (-/

p 5 ( )

p 5 (((

p 5 ( -

99p p 99p

③ p

p

p ^. p

p

125

p p

p p

Ⅰ /))

/ p p

p “

=

Ⅰ

Ⅰ

A B

p

/)(

p p

p

p p

p

p p

p

126

p p ④

“

p p

p

p p ” p

p p

Ⅰ

p

p Ⅰ

p Ⅰ p

“

“ p p

p

“

p “

“ p

p p p

p

127 p p

p p

p

p

5 ) ) 9 5 ( ,

9 5 (.,

p ⁽ p

“ p p

④

p p ④

[ Ⅲ

p p “

5 ) ) p [ “

5 ( , p

9 p

p

p ⁾ [

128 p

③ 5 ( ,

p )

p

p

p

p

p ③

-) 5 ( ,

② Ⅰ

p

④

② p

129

p p

p

99

99 99

5 ),.

p

p . p

p

130

p

p

③

p p

p

p

2 p

Ⅰ

p p

p

131 5

p

Ⅰ

. .

p p p

p

p ⑤

p p

p p

p p p

p p

99 p

p

p /) .

p

p

132 p

― p

p

p

p p

99 p

p p

p p

Ⅰ % Ⅰ

Ⅰ

p

Ⅰ p

p p

p

p p

84 . 7 .

② p

133

p

99 99 99

99

)

99

99

p p

p

p

99

5 5

p p

134

④

/ p

“ p

p

④

p

p p p

Ⅱ

p

p

% %

( % ( p % (

p p

p p

(

135

) p

p p

) p

p p

99 p

-)

④ p

p

7 . 7 .

p

99 99 99 p

p

p p

136

99 p

p p

p

p

[ [ p

(

③ p

p p

p

p

. .

p p p

137 p

p

p

p

p p

p

p p p

p p

p p

[ p

“ ⑤

[

⑤ ⑤ p

p

p

138 p

p

, p

p p

p p

0 4 1

(

pⅡ ^-

//- ^. p

p ④

p p

⑥

( ( /

pⅡ

p p

p …

p

p

p 5 (/ p

139 p

p p

./ p

99 p

p p

= p

p

[ p

④

p

p p

p p

99 p

p

140

p

p p

p p ④

99 p

99

99 - 99

p p p

p p

99

p

p

141 p p

= p

p p

p A

p

p

p

p

p

/

p / /

p p

142 p

p [

p ③

[ p p

p p

p p

p

p ④ p

p p

p

Ⅰ

p p

143

③ p

p

p

p

144 2 3

) ( (

( . /.-

)

p p

p

, p

- p p

p p p

. (

5 ,/

/

Ⅱ

- ⑤ p p

145

p 5 - p

( p

p

) 5 ,/

5 ,/

p p

,

6 ( (

- p p

p p

p

. p

/ p

( ( . 5 .,

( (

5 ,)

(( p

p

[

()

p 5 , p

( 5 ( ) p

( . / /

⑤ p / /

⑤ ⑤ p ⑤

146

p ⑤

⑤ p

⑤ p (

///

(, p

p

p p

(- ( ,

(.

(

(/ p p

( .

p

) p

p

) p p

)( [

)) = -)

= =

p [

)

p p

p

) ( ) ),,

). ) (-

), p p p

p

147

p p

2 )-

⑤ 5 ( p

). //- p

)/

5 .- p

5 (

99

p 5 -/

p

” 5 (/)

5 .

p 5 --

( p p

p [

p p

p p

)

5 -.

5 / 5 .)

Ⅰ ( (

148 //

Ⅱ %

% % %

, Ⅱ /, 5 ).

-

(

p p

p /)

9

(

. “ “ 9

5 )

5 ( )

55 (-/ (.

“ “ 9 “ p

5 )

“ p 5 (((

“ “

5 ( -

/ p

p

p p

6 ( ,

p 6 6

//-

149

5 ) - 5 ((,

5 ( /

( p p

) p

p 55 ) ) )

[ 5 ) -

5 ( / pp

5 ((-

⑦ 5 ((,

5 (/.

( ,

-

. //

[ //-

/

2 3 ( (

150 I

./ ./ i / /

/ / . /) i / / h

u

- f u e i q s f

q o e fi

mi ¹ o ei i ef

e e q u s

v ² u

d ³ u

e a b 2005c06

m u

e u o e q f ho

m e

vm m w f u

d fi f u e fi

d i f e i

ue e f u u

i efq w u u emq

d

e

w q i w q

d

u v

u

m u

e s e ^, q ho

u d v

s ^- u e

151

uiu q u e 56

ho s

/

f o i u e

u ^. e

e o w

i u i u m d q u

i f w i q f o i

u e e i d

/ 56 u

e u em i u em

e w w d

s u em i

e u s

w o

i u e u q s i

a b u em

u / i ( ) io m

1 ^/ u u

s em¹⁰

q f w

o ei s w i ef

u e e

152

.-( s u u

o u

.., / s e

s e o

.// qwq u

s s de q

/ s

/

u i w q

e

/ ( u

w q u w q

fq w f v

.., u

s / ) e q s

u s q f

u em io e f p e

i f

, , 9

./ i / ) -)

u

./ ef e s a b

f e e fi¹²

w d u

ui u

153

u q u i q ou

ui u

u

v o

s u i u u w

s e

s u e /

a b ) u

u u /(,

a b he

u u e

q f p u u e

13 q e d fi

./ q q f

o m u ④

w u

w q u ⑤ w

w

ef w ef u ¹⁴

u u d

m w

q ui e d f ef¹⁵

uiu m w q q

s ¹⁶ u e

w ⒈ w i

m u i s u

m w u u s

s u m

w w

ef f w q w q

154

u u

u u u

w u

u u m i u q s

s q w

q s em a

b

ou ef e

q u m a

b ef u i h

s

a b,, / ) s

m

, 9C

u m

( / - s a b (.

u n

w u u n

u u

w t f

m s

u w v

u e q fq

u e ^. q f u e fi

19 u e

/ he u

155

u u

s u w

w u s

t e e

u w s

u e

u u u u

w m i

w u

e u

u e

w e −u

o e i w

iu w

u ef d

d d w

s

u

s e ⁽

f e e

w q e u e

u e

, C

/) io he u

m ⁽

e e ef ef u

u d

f e e i /)) a

b f

156

u w q

iu u d

u u e q

e q iu

w e q f

d ( ef f o

e q i

/)/ a b ,/

o u w q um

④ u u ef f

iu e w q

u e w q e d q

f u e fi

/) / . e ⁽⁽ o (

w ²³ ef s

u u

w ②

u ⑤ ①w

s

w w u w ①

w

(, ²⁴ s m

d t

e

q f u e

w ef −w

, C

e e v u

157

e u

m u e /)-

i u dp e

/)- Ⅱ q io e

q f o e i /)/

a b ,. p e

u u

w d ui

u e i i v

p Ⅱ

he u w

q

uio d u

u q wq w u e

ef e e

d ef d

ef f

f p

④ u e iu e ,

−u

u u ④ u -(

o e e m o

Ⅱ o m

u m q

u u d

w m d

e

q f v f u u

w

Ⅱ w s

158

o u ①w q

w

q f v f e

u q w

s q i

e e

s e e

e d w u i i

u e

q f w o

s em d

, C

/ ( u

u u

w e

25 i e e

u u u u

m u

u u w m u

i w m u

w

u e

m i / a b -

e

w

w mu w u w

159

u f u im

w m w i i

s w d d

q f m w w

f e v f u

i o u ef d

f u

u e

e s

e e

i e

o l em q m

o e e i e

ef f u s h

o u i e

d dm

o d ef u e

160

161

162

163

C 8 ( I

/ o u

(, 5AGAK E 6A N K AK NIKA A

2H G AK BHK CA 0EEDA HPAK 56 % 20

u u 56 u

2D DE 7GBHK DHG G 4 N DHG A DHG 274 u

w s ^(- q 56

u w q

em

/ ((

i ( )

u

56 u

u o v f

w ²⁸

( )

164

d ue

d e

q f 56 u

u

u fq ^(/

d em ef

e

q l ( ho

e u

w w p f

e ① u ³⁰ m u

① u e ³¹

e

m ①u e

① s ³² ①

e

ef q f u i

uiu q f d

w q s e eq e fo 274

v

(( i ( ) io u

s

i s u w q

I

56 tw u

e ³³ s u

ue s

uiu s a b³⁴ w

165

35 n 274 s q

i s q s

i

a b u ( (, s i

36 s i d

a b i m

e s s

s 4

274 f f

d / , am d b

a b / - a b( )

s

u a b a b w m ue

37 ( c )

c c

c e

u ) d

ue u 274 274

ef

o ①w q e w

d

e ef w

u w d ef

h d ef

ue u w q

166 q

d ef w

f ⒈ e

i q s d w

s d

( 56

e u s d

/ - i

o s / - ,

e he

u

s ue / /

q m a b ui

i ^). / i a b u v / (

a b³⁹ u u e e

u i f

I

(

) ④

, - . /

167 (

)

, - . /

( ho

( ho

((

a b i u w w

u ⒈ w u

u q ⁴⁰wq u s e

q f s e u

ef i

ef u h u

w o e /) i

u o a b m

s e q i

a b

f e

o s

f f f f u

e

e w f u

em i em

e e a b f u e

168

− qq

u u

d

o e a b u

u o w

e

o q q

uo ), e

a b u

e u uiu w w u

m e

u u e u m q

f e e

a b he d u i

w f u e

i ef o m e

u e

u ef

m u e q i ⁴¹

m e e w f o w

①s emq q 56 u

u e o d e

e a b f e e fi

i e

m u o e

e u t d u e

a b f e e i u hm

i u u hq

u w e h

169

qs w ho

i w u

u u u

a b u

v ef f d

w u e⁴²

u u m

e ef f s i

de e d

qq u e e a b

u o

u u efq w f ho

e m

w f a bi

w o ef ef

d i i f i

f i u e

e e u f

e o ⁴³

d /- i

v uiu a b w u

e hr

d u ho w e

Ⅱ

ho u e hqu q q

u w e d

i o u e

e

u e Ⅱ

170

a b s m

e d i m

u e hr d u w

e u e m

e u u w

e e

u f d

f q q 274

① ef q f a b

he w f s

s e a b d e

a b f s i em

u f

u u

u f u im w m

w i i s w

i o u f u e

a b ⁴⁴ ef u

u 9

EC u 9 u

s m

u u 4 4 e

u

u qq e v u s 9

he u

a b f r

e

i ef

171

s h mq

w q i s e e

d u e

u e a b u e q d

e f a b e w

u u e u

o h w e w d q

274 d

ue a b i u m

w ef f q f

f f q 274

m s e

e he

u um s …

45 o h d i

o e f

f s s d

q o ue o u 274

u e f m u q

( ) u e f ef s f

ef m e ⁴⁶ o s u

q f o

s q i 274 e h

274 w ue u d

i u / ( f

u em i u em

172

/ , e

o / - e w

m i u ^-

. / / i / /

. ( f

u / q d s

/ ) q ef^/

/ - l ue u u

e s

s S

s

S he

he

um f w

d e o f

u q d q e s m e

m

u e s e q f s

w m s e

u

/ / he d q u

e u e o e w s o

u fq u e d

he e q s e

/ ⁽ he s

u ho f

q w ⁾

e s o s

/ ( i / s

173 (

) i io

u q f

d a b

/ ( i i

f e i p e e

, , 9

u i a b

u u

ef o u d

u w

u ie

a b u m p e

/ ( q w

/ - q w

/, q w

/. u u

// o u u u

c( )

i u u ef

m e o q i

q f e m

u u u s d uiu

//- ^, f ho

s s d u e e q f

s e e

e / ( u d

s d n

o e d u i m

174

v d ⁵⁷

e o h a b i e

o l e ef u i d

/,) ue , i ,

io s u q u

/ ( i . io

i u

, e q

u uiu i i u /,

d e

n

d w q i q f s

s em

u e

/ ( n o e d

/ - n

/- ho n u

/.)c( n

n

−u e

n

o ii i v

d o u d u

- s m ee

e e ef

, , , 9

e w

175

t (. u

o q q 36 e

mq u e

a b e o ①u

o s u u

i i e u

q f ui s m

u u em q

w

/ ( ④

e u u u

e / ( u e i i i u

u e ef f he

v q m

w

s f

u em fi e / ( i

dp e

/ ( E

8C C imu q u i

/, he

q i fi e e

/ u

/- he

q i

fi e / u

/.)

o i // c(

o i

176

q e

i f i fi e ef .)

e o .) i o i s

q m s e u u

s e u

// ( ) e

e q f u

a b d

u d q d

56 ui u e fi

i u

u w w u h ⁵⁸

ef… i u f

w uiu s

ef s e e

vt e

, 9,

o e e

e f e e fi

/) . io e e u

qu

q e

59 s .( d /.

s ^,

i w d s o

u .(

e /.)

177 d

he u

ef i q d

uiu / , ③ u e

i / , (

u qfu s u u ⁶¹ q

d w s i s q

u / ( ^,( u ef f

ui e h s i fi

he /- u q

u t u hqu u d q

d q w f q f

u qs u e

e w

u o u w q um

,/ w f u e

a b

u ho w

w e ef f p m f

e q u / (

e u w

e h u

iwq ef −u e ^,)

e i u a b

u v d u u

d ef i f m u q

q f d i

u u

178 p hm

④ Ⅰ qf w u d

u q u s

u qfu

I C

④ u i

e

/ ) ③ e /)

u / i

e w ③ d d

u e

u em

/ ( u e

/, ④ u e ww e

/, ④ ww w

/- ④ o i

hqf

( )c( hqf

uiu i s

ho q o w f

( e

so e

ho s s

i w

e e ef −u e

q q i

q e

179 q f

s u

u uiu ef o

f e e

d u e i i ⒈ e

wq

, 9, 4

e i u

u ef e e

/.) w f

u

o d eq d /.

w

f f um

i u

u w o

e Ⅱ e e

Ⅱ he

u w ,. Ⅱ

o e a bi

ef Ⅱ ho

u hqu e m f

q f s / (

he Ⅱ hq

he Ⅱ u

( ) ef e e uiu

u e i w q d

e u e

④ u e iu e

180

e hr

d u ho w e

f w q o e d

/ ( d / (

w u ④ e e u /

w w u

qq e u e

u e q

w u

u e / ( o

s q i / ) hs

q u e / ef f

w

q f s w ④ ho

e em e

u w q e

e h s e

u u u m

w w

i e de e s

he q d

/ ( u d w ⁶⁴ m

o ef u ^, / (

o eq u e

q m u e d q f

s e m e

w n e m e

/.( u f d