JAIST Repository: 研究者と実務家との知識交流 : 理論と実践からの教訓
全文
(2) !. Ęġı'²³'+ėŇoþŪĉŅ'²Ŋ7+Üŀ . Ăŧìp¬® ÛĦ¬®şŨũčÝeŗŧè븮ĘġÌŨ. 1.. . ®ĶĘġÛĦ*Č&9' '*$ %m$+Î
(3) 9e$,«+Ęġ,>X adKQ@dW%Ĩ)ėŇ<Ċ2% 8Ĉ²+ţ<"='°¼% ) ' '4e$,®Ķďß ī kį*Š #%8ÛĦ+ 3+ėŇ5IJ684ÛĦ +ėŇ<Ō*$9' ĘġıijŌ+®Ķ ĔËï:9' ' gŁ*$ %, Ęġı+ėŇ,ÛĦ5²Ŋ+Ĉ §*ĝō:ÀĢ%7:9 ' ²łkįĔ) İà:1&ėŇČ+Ęġ&,×*
(4) # 'ĉĎ'%Õ7:9eà&ĘġÛĦ *h9¿š*, ĕÖĔ)4+-8,& ) 'â7*:% 9ŧNutley, Walter, & Davies, 2007Ũ &ǧ +ėŇoþ ' ôÅ&
(5) 8ěwĜ®+đ¶'ç)7Ęġı6. +Ëï+Čı&
(6) 9ÛĦ²³+ÁëĔ)À *Ļĕ<ő#% 9éĠ&,Ĝ®ÏĶÛĦ* Ş;9ėŇoþ*œ)9ĉŅĔ¶ŝ'ÿªņ¤+ ²Ê6.ĥı7áé&8Ī=& ėŇo þ+²Ŋ<ĩr9. 2.. . 2.1.
(7) ČĘġ&,ś 'm$+F\^RM?ĉŅ ÚřĔ&
(8) # m$+F\^RM?ĉŅ',Û ĦĘġ+Ċċı6.+É£9Čı*6#% Ð:% 9iďľ6.}Åzħ+ģ*Ş% Ęġ+ĕÖĔ)Č÷ŏĔy Ğ»*'(1#% 9 ' < Ń â 6 ' 9 4 + &
(9) 9 ŧ e.g. Caplan, 1979Ũ !m$+F\^RM?ĉŅ*, f$+Ā)öŠÔÙ:% 9Ĥe*+ ĉŅ,s+F\^RM?5m$+F\^RM?+ ~q*6#%Ð:% 9ĻĿ+ĸÞÇ<ŎĽ % 9ÉÆú°*9:7~q+Ç5 Ş|Ç<ĻŔ% 9ZLEHÎ96 *íı,. ėŇ+Ċċı ' ÉÆú°ı , ėŇČ+Ćü* %m$+âę)TdM?
(10) 9'Ĩ*u°% 96&ěwĔ)ėŇ+ Č*$ %mó]N_&Ęġ<V`d\bE9. ĉĔðÒ<h9',1) ŧBoggs, 1992: 31ŨÛûĔaU@HOċòď+ŕı¥¢z 5ŞÂ
(11) 9¹ø+6)s+ěwīāĔcÛûĔ> DJd*6#%ÉÆú°¬¿š:9', 6
(12) 9+&+',âē&
(13) 97* ė Ň+Ċċı 4ÉÆú°ı 4e+ĻĿ< å9eî·+z&,) ®ĶĘġı4ÛĦĢ ñı4::+F\^RM?&Į½8l
(14) 9 Ĥm*ŒŃĔ4:) s+ěwĜ® Ś*9eŘ+ČĘġ&Ě:% 6* +ĉŅ,m$+F\^RM?
(15) 9Ğ»+ĻĿ+ ŤxÇ< å% 9IJÇ<ĖŔ"&
(16) 9 $+GdY@ĬïŧBowman, 1978; Weiss & Weiss, 1981Ũ*6:-m$+F\^RM?,n +ĻĿćą&
(17) 9'9ĉŅ+×<ĺ9 Ĥf*gŁ+ă'Ş|%+>XadK, jĢĔ)Ęġı7eàĔ*h7:9Ŧʼn&ã ±*Ŗ# ÓĔ)ȦĄêv*ÛĦú°*Č :9'u°% 9ŧRich, 1979; Shapiro, 1984Ũ +Ļà, #%ėŇĊċı7Čı/+ Ş|+ª*Ģ# ²łkįḜ*Ęġı<Đ3 %4+&
(18) 9ŧKarapin, 1986Ũ 2.2. STS STS Ęġı+À*$ %,:ijz STS Ęġ +Md[&
(19) 8ĭ% 9G@BbHACdI< õ' 1990 ºtjĵ+eŘ STS Ęġı+Ûû Ĕō¡52000 ºt+ STS Ęġ+Ĥf+ý ' -:9µŜÇ'īťĘġŧSEEŨ ŧCollins & Evans, 2002Ũ {9ŧserviceableŨSTS +ňŅŧWebster, 2007Ũ* 91&STS Ęġ&,Ĝ®ı5 STS Ę ġıijŌ+À<ļ°0µŜ³'%ėŇ +Ċċı&
(20) 9'<¯9Č:9ėŇ<Ċ ċ9'<ù3%ÛûĔŢŚ'+¨ď*ŋ29 Ņlĭ7:% 9:*´%äŐ& ,ALPSAH7ŧWoodhouse et al., 2002Ũ STS Ęġ+Ñ Í'%ĘġıÄ'ÛĦĢñıÄ >DM?UHOÄ+fğŤ*+Ĥf+ŕ <¾ń% STS ĘġıĴ+ð`Y_&ěw©* Ø;9IJÇ'ÃĹÇ<¶æ% 9ŧķ 1Ũ . -202-.
(21) n 1 STS ach +> ach , zM vP RW x ?[ , il 5>_% 5>_ ") #'d9. FhN: STS F<. X7HN: STS k T
(22) b0B8. `_woO. QfeUhN: STS QK IyH-6ph ! QKL/ 34-}. Fh Fm_ Fm{qSg F0. QfeUh G2_ @;S Qf$)'. X7HJV tu &)) Fh(*j: Sg|ED1 ŖWoodhouse et al. 2002. é"}~ûÿijm!/)# STS ĀĈ ė#ÍøĽg" /ĀĈ+ÑĞ#Á ! ĀĈ5B9cG#Īª3´£/Ą¨Ñ Ğ?W[OJ6#¯Ø!|#ÅĢn?W[O J6#ʼn2.
(23) ÅĢ/i½*/ #àÃ#xþ.§3ĸ," STS ĀĈ ė
(24) 5>Fe#Ĭč!ĝĀĈ3ľ#5> Fe3üĤ)/ŔSTS =Cŕ+STS Ā Ĉė
(25) 5>Fe#ņ!5>Fe#ęý3y ÁŔSTS W]eŕ
(26) Ö-0/ŔBijker, 2003ŕ ^cH?e_#ĀĈ$STS ĀĈ ,& STS Ā Ĉė
(27) «Ō"ę-#Á
(28) ķ0ñí3ä /ŔLynch & Cole, 2005ŕ?e_
(29) ÕČ#Ą ¨û¤¿É" STS ĀĈėjĠ #º ĵ{#īmĉďœ3ĩ*#Ġ ĩŅ#®"ĥį/,"^cH
(30) ?e_"7cFR[eĩŅ -IJÛ
(31) èÌ0 /µû!¡ŃèĿ#óÈ ,&Îî$ĥł ¨ûÚĊä/*ħ /?e_
(32) Ġ 3ľ Ò B`cV Ŕ1ŕSTS 3Ą¨ŎĄ ¨#÷āª"w# ÷væŔboundary workŕ#ĀĈńÏ# ŔSTS ĀĈė" ±*Ġ ©+YK65$Ą¨ûģĥ3Ă, "âÂ/ŕ Ŕ2ŕSTS ?W[OJ6$Ą¨?W[ OJ6#oğ×/Ě /# Ŕ3ŕ Ą¨ė $! ëĀĈė%0/² ŇÉ#ù
(33) tģ!0/Ŕ4ŕ³©$īħ #«ĹûÎđûĭijûŊ÷3Þ- "īm #ĘzőÉ3t)/
(34) Ö-0/ 2.3. `s.Y. Äã#ÿijö#Ė Ý$ĀĈė#ÿij
(35) ÚĊ +«Ĺ#ò"ąĻ0Áĉ-0/f Ý#ÿij#ð0.«īiĕû!Ë
(36) ¾ ĒÀ#ŁĆ3ğöĮ¸ÿ-0 /#$ÿijąĻŔknowledge transferŕ. Ĝ#^@eH<8cA_$rĐû"#öĮ3 ö/ÿij#æö3ÈŐ"Ĕ*# ¢¨#ÿij
(37) õæ÷"ąĻ0Á"ĉĖ. b0(^A<~. Ý/ÿijïöŔknowledge utilizationŕ öĮ*ÿijąĻ"sĀĈ
(38) ÚĊ"ïö 0/*#/Ë
(39) /
(40) «Ō$gļ#Ð "/,"¨ĞĀĈ $Å*ÚĊ+«Ĺ#Á"ĉ! ÚĊĉåė+«Ĺė#ØĦ3ľ¨ĞĀĈė *ę-#ÿij3ÚĊ+ăq"áö!*#" ,ý
(41) ģ-0¥)/#ð03 ¨ĞĀĈėÚĊĉåė«Ĺė
(42) k"Ô ÿ ij 3 l Ù d ~ á / ÿ ij l ð Ŕ knowledge exchangeŕÜ.Ď(
(43) úŔcf. Jacobson, 2007ŕ0$ĀĈėÚĊĉåė", /ÿij#~ôõŔco-production of knowledgeŕ 3çÈ .hė
(44) Ķp3ÔÀ/ÿ ijąĻ#,!¢¨"/ÿij3æö, QeM@7:cC3õæ+Ûûŏ"Áĉ, ùÊ -ŀ4ÿij3fě#}~ÚĊ" ö,*#/0ß" ÿijl ðöĮ",ĀĈėÚĊĉåė# Ýû!ÿij#ð0|û!ÿijôõu çÈûS`eXbe>3v.g/ġō! ñí3ĭij0"Çÿij#ôõö#. Ý3ì)/1"ĀĈė«
(45) |/ #ŃĢÉ
(46) /. 3.. ZC r= ` s. Y ] \. ĝÚ©ęĺ#aeJeA\c",/ÿijlð3Ė /ĝÚ©$Ó¿/ÚĊİŒ#®" Ĭ!/CUAZ^CL/' ¶¸Ú Ċ"óĥÚĊTaDC#²Ň/E P]^CL/' ĴIJ
(47) /ė 0%ý·ň#ı+G7NW>C
(48) !!. Ãė0%ÿij#R_M5IT
(49) !!/ B`cV3Ò /;]cG$ē.#CUAZ ^CLÆ
(50) *##ć#ýŌêʼn",. #»¬3.ŋ/Ĝ+S]cC $ĝÚ©$TaDCVPBYcL
(51) i}ûĀ Ĉêʼn+¦ĨĀĈ°Ĵqݼ",. ôû!ÿij 3"ÚĊĉå3ĝ/ċ$ĝÚ©$İ. -203-.
(52) Əƃ+NaLeiNV& 9øĐy})(= đ*½¿5LnGQnG)(øÏ»+Öœ*ĺ# 89 3LNTd'%+R@XcGN :% 9 ½¿+ĶĽő=Ş9'ƁŏŸõ'%ŚøÏ& '
(53) ' 8
(54) 9NJSVhnW+w &,ūƏŢ˵+ĶĽ=Ś
(55) Ĺ¿ő*'#%Ś øÏ&+ĵŮ5ʼnƑĶĽ*Öľ# '
(56) ! ĶĽő'ŚøÀ&,Ąƈãşĭ)9'5
(57) ę+ųįŧĶĽő'%+čŎ*¢ ă9|ň2=ú 9'ūƏ& 9 rþ+øłľČő,rŗį*Ĺ¿ëś*Å9 ƉÚ, '®Ə& 9+ 3ƉÚ=ï # z+JcfYIqQq5÷ïő*Ǝ96
(58) ) Âä')#% 9'4Ő 7:9ChnR5NJ SVhnW+6
(59) *øÏÒ*¸=ŦÁ9+&. :-¼Ý)øłľČő*Ɓå _lHhd' 68ŠÄ)zƈƉŃ96
(60) )ƌÒį)¸+ ŦÁ)( 9ĻÐ+ōĕ37:9 NJSVhnW+6
(61) )Dz&4 9 ,ń² +6
(62) )½²& #%4ĶĽő'øłľČő=$ ) 3*Ƅ')9JcfYIqQq+¾³Ƃŝ & 9'Ă7*:% 9ń²& :- Űī)(&ب)zģŅį*\^iSG@`n V+Ñƅ=3Ćů'½¿z5čʼn¯ő= í %×7+JcfYIqLgn+ž=±#% 9NJSVhnW&,ب)zģ'
(63) <&, )Śø5½¿)(::+đƉ&ĵŮyĚ* ƉÚ=ï# őŽöHjq_'%ę=Ś #% 9)<"ĵŮyĚ+¸=ŦŤſĨ 9+,¨)¾³&4)ĶĽő 9 ,øł ľČőŖŷ&4)ĵŮyĚ*ƉÚ=ï": *rÁ+A]BqV=9-ÆƆÃ+6
(64) )ő & 9ŦŤ9¸+½*Þ%ĕ37:9Ř ¨Ð,º<8
(65) 9 :*6Ū74ƐŞ 9¾³& 9'Ûŝ!'ß<:9§Ê zį)Ƃŝà'%ĵŮĨ5ĵŮyĚ*ĦŢ= ķĢÚ)÷ïőƒchampionsƓ+¾³ð7: 9×7,Ĥ*øłľČő* 9'¼ø łĶĽ/+ĦŢ 8:=ļĎį*ęĨ6
(66) '9²ů& # 8sË+ŚøÀ& # 89 ' -ChnR&,ùŔûĹ¿ij+ ĵŮU?kGQq]hnN&,KjJM½ŊƍŖ ŷ:*IJÔ9. 4.. . 4.1. STS
(67) ŀő7,STS ĶĽő'øłĶĽőøłÂő +ZSVmqGÕæ'Åũ+¸=ďŃSTS ĶĽ 'øłĶĽ+ó¦ƍ¶&ħ1:9ý )ĶĽ+¥ŕ à=ì'=ıį*Ĺ¿ëśĸŬƒSTSƓ¿ ÍĒĶĽ½* %3 oÍ*< #%STS Ķ Ľ'øłĶĽ 'Ə9mqGLgS_=ĪÂ. ÿ% STS ¿*9mqGLgS_ ,ƌ¿+Į¹ő*$ %,ű=ğü*9 )(ÎƇ: |ň2')#% 9 2006 Í*Ƈ Ŀ 1 °&,:1& STS ¿ &, 18ţ :9'+)# øÏņLn GQnGŁ*9øłĶĽ+£ň2*$ %Ň{ STS ĶĽ'øłĶĽ+¡þ*9uÚį)Ķ ĽūƏ+ 1 $& 9 =EqmqW*ÌŚ %CqDX@OWpPSLgnƒOSƓç²* 9ġåµøłĊ+ÂŶ'ÉƇ =Âÿ Ŀ 2 °&,ůŬ+Tqb'% =Óŋ STS ĶĽ'øłĶĽ+óĞ=¿®įÜ©à5þ ĘŬįšĞ7ò;
(68) 'Ũ2 3 Íı,øłĶ ĽőSTS ĶĽő+::ÆƆà '%+ :1&+ľ"ŏ=êį*ñ8ź8:: +ĦŬ5ĥėŁ=IJx*Ġ9'*6#%Ā Ĉ* %::ÆƆà '%ĸ ' (+6
(69) *Ɖ<#% 0*$ %ôŴt ő+§+¥ŕà'+į)ÉƇ*$ %ť ů 2006 ÍÐ*Âÿ OS =ª3Ĉ WS ,Ĺ ¿ëśŚø*Ɖ<9ÂÃ'øÏņ+øłĶĽđ Ɖ5Ĕƈƌ¯LnGQnG' # øłĶĽ ++vőSTS ĶĽő*Å%¬. 9ÕÒ&Âÿ% Ŀ 2 °7,Ĉ WS +ŵ ā*Ųâ=ķ%: STS ĶĽő*Į¹ő' %®ƏôŴ= Ǝ9Õ='# :7+£8ň 2,ØŻ+¿§ WS *$)9)(rÁ+æ ċ=ð ' 9)7Ŗşį) STS ĶĽőŒř+u*¼ ', STS Ķ Ľ'øłĶĽ+ó¦ƍ¶&ħ1:9ý )ĶĽ+¥ ŕà=ì '
(70) 44+ıį=*ċ ',ţ Ƌ 1 Ùĉ7% Śø À~»+ÂÃ+,)+Ŝƃ=î7: )# '
(71) â«&STS ĶĽő'øłĶĽő øłÂő+ZSVmqGÕæ'Åũ+¸=ďŃ 9 '
(72) ıį4*ċ )# 4.2.
(73) 2009 Í 3 ąĶĽpëśŤĪ¿' STS ¿*6 9§mqGLgS_²+Ĺ¿ëśp@[`qL gnèĬ'¿+ÖƔĀĈµĶĽpøłJcf YT?+Õæ*©% Âÿ: ¿§mqGLgS_&,Ĺ¿ëśp@[`q LgnèĬ*9ĀĈ+ūƏ'%z¤ěÈĸ ²ƊAZjFqá´¶@[`qLgnĶĽő +Eei>\N½¿' # øłūƏ*Ĵı ŭĜ5Cq_n@[`qLgnK@AnNJc fYIqLgnĶĽpøłJcfYT?²Ɗē Ź)(+šĞ=ż%øłƀĻ .ĵŮĨ=é# ŭĜ): GlqMnHpPSLgn&, Ō¦Ĺ¿ëśů+IJĝİĩů68Ŀ 4 ćĹ¿ ëś·ĈŤĪ*©%·ĈŤĪ&,é :). -204-.
(74) aï#ä" £µ0
(75) ù¼ĒÇþ 8MQ^@W\Çþ#SGF\<4 0
(76) å Ĉù¼ĒmĢĢğ10# Ăh 14ôû]¼Ēęîm# Ýì®mĭ 8MQ^@W\ 25 Á.1Ì þ4yn*8MQ^@W\Ñęî 4Çþ#Ö"0+"úBH^;RZE^ "%
(77) 8MQ^@W\O:^XU4Ì #ynò!Â× õ1Óe#¦ĐÏ ÈÀ$÷m#K^C"38MQ^@W\, #*#iă)4ċ 0"$ĆĶc$ã (!ĵ /6JRG;8\O:^SZ! Ģğ#4 ,o0
(78) +Ğĵ 0 ¾Å IJ#ª§ø«{ÈÀ $YB;4 ĊO7^JNG;0 ?8;Z4ç0- !~Ĝę]Ĥ]Èč# Īē¶4¿0+"ôû]¼Ēęîm, STS m è¨ÿ#!m#ĦÄ4/6 A64ĕī"u1fÉ÷mùÿ#x+Úā &$!
(79) ĝ vnĚğ$Í©ò"8\D^LGI`#> TVK=^@W\# 0$Çþ#8MQ^ @W\?8;Z4Î
(80) !0#$!
(81) ù¼ĒÇþ#b"8MQ^@W\Çþ4 /ĥ5
(82) ËĢğ Üù ¼Ē/ ĕå!÷m@BHU ,psĖ! $/Ĕ !ēĀ+* Çþþ4đ &Ğĵėß#Ėå
(83) .0ù ¼Ē"ʶ$´+ÐĪē$!8MQ ^@W\#/Ë4 0
(84) 310 Ģğ ¥Į1. 5..
(85) . ÍÑ" 0óġdâ#æ³$ù¼Ē Çþôû, STS ôû! ù¼Ē¹ðþ"}ë 1 0Ēôû@\;D\;ôû! 43 óġ#éêĬ ą£ò"¤!İĦ óġdâ# '5 ! Ę 0¢Ģm $Ù!ôûČ _"mw¯!óġdâ 4rħ0iă)!0 ±¯ò!ď² °ÍÑ$Ġ"Þ&>TVKH7į#ñ ģ¶$!*Ĵw¯!$jk`" ć¡!óġdâ .10 æ³ 0w¯ !Ĵw¯!4Ĩă)3@BHU4Ĝ ę0´ē 0 g#2#*#| !·ġ,Ď4½fÒ ôûČt"+Çþü× Čt"+!ýČ.$6JRG;! óġdâ4ÆÃ0P[A9;I4¥Į0 P[A9;I$lØ,NGOǬÿÛİ! Ù!ăĉ" ÷mò!ĵ#ėß" á4đ0($đċ 0 ôûČ, 4µÃ+/0. Ñôû$zı¬Ąã÷mĈôûºěcØ8 MQ^@W\ijxôû" 0Çþ%Ç þ|Ô»àôû#¸Õ#_ĩ/İqČ" öí`(. Bijker, W. E. (2003). The need for public intellectuals: a space for STS. Science, Technology, & Human Values, 28(4), 443-450. Boggs, J. P. (1992). Implicit models of social knowledge use. Knowledge: Creation, Diffusion, Utilization, 14(1), 29-62. Bowman, J. S. (1978). Managerial theory and practice: the transfer of knowledge in public administration. Public Administration Review, 38(6), 563-570. Caplan, N. (1979). The two-communities theory and knowledge utilization. American Behavioral Scientist, 22(3), 459-470. Collins, H. M., & Evans, R. (2002). The third wave of science studies: studies of expertise and experience. Social Studies of Science, 32(2), 235-296. Jacobson, N. (2007). Social epistemology: theory for the “fourth wave” of knowledge transfer and exchange research. Science Communication, 29(1), 116-127. Karapin, R. S. (1986). What's the use of social science?: a review of the literature. In F. Heller (Ed.), The Use and Abuse of Social Science (pp. 236-265). London: Sage. Lynch, M., & Cole, S. (2005). Science and technology studies on trial: dilemmas of expertise. Social Studies of Science, 35(2), 269-311. Nutley, S. M., Walter, I., & Davies, H. T. O. (2007). Using Evidence: How Research Can Inform Public Services. Policy Press. Rich, R. F. (1979). Editor's introduction. American Behavioral Scientist, 22(3), 327-338. Shapiro, J. Z. (1984). Conceptualizing evaluation use: implications of alternative models of organizational decision making. In R. F. Conner, D. G. Altman & C. Jackson (Eds.), Evaluation Studies Review Annual (Vol. 9, pp. 633-645). Beverly Hills, CA: Sage. Webster, A. (2007). Crossing boundaries: social science in the policy room. Science, Technology, & Human Values, 32(4), 458-478. Weiss, J. A., & Weiss, C. H. (1981). Social scientists and decision makers look at the usefulness of mental health research. American Psychologist, 36(8), 837-847. Woodhouse, E., Hess, D., Breyman, S., & Martin, B. (2002). Science studies and activism: possibilities and problems for reconstructivist agendas. Social Studies of Science, 32(2), 297-319.. -205-.
(86)
関連したドキュメント
Standard domino tableaux have already been considered by many authors [33], [6], [34], [8], [1], but, to the best of our knowledge, the expression of the
We then compute the cyclic spectrum of any finitely generated Boolean flow. We define when a sheaf of Boolean flows can be regarded as cyclic and find necessary conditions
It is suggested by our method that most of the quadratic algebras for all St¨ ackel equivalence classes of 3D second order quantum superintegrable systems on conformally flat
In recent years, several methods have been developed to obtain traveling wave solutions for many NLEEs, such as the theta function method 1, the Jacobi elliptic function
7, Fan subequation method 8, projective Riccati equation method 9, differential transform method 10, direct algebraic method 11, first integral method 12, Hirota’s bilinear method
A new method is suggested for obtaining the exact and numerical solutions of the initial-boundary value problem for a nonlinear parabolic type equation in the domain with the
II Midisuperspace models in loop quantum gravity 29 5 Hybrid quantization of the polarized Gowdy T 3 model 31 5.1 Classical description of the Gowdy T 3
We study the classical invariant theory of the B´ ezoutiant R(A, B) of a pair of binary forms A, B.. We also describe a ‘generic reduc- tion formula’ which recovers B from R(A, B)