OntheScholarlyUseofElectronicJournals:TrendsandIssuesfromtheMid1990s ῭Ῡ΅῔ῒ῕ΐῪ̯ 1990 ῟Ὶῡΐ̰ῠ̮̮῏̮̮ῳῲ ῎ ῌ῎῏῍

Re´sume´

In the past decade, electronic journals have received much attention from both researchers and practitioners in scholarly communication. A large amount of research has been conducted to explore how faculties and graduate students use electronic journals. In this article, the main literature on this topic is reviewed in terms of 1) overall trends of use and users, 2) factors that a#ect their usage, and 3) users’ perceptions from 1995 to early 2004.

Most faculty members, especially natural scientists, use electronic journals as a useful and convenient tool for reading articles. They usually visit library web sites to obtain an article as a PDF file and print it out for reading. Specific functions of electronic journals, such as links to references and early view, are highly valued by users, but motion picture, animation, and pay-per-view are not frequently used. Although some faculties visit the library less frequently, they valued the library as an institution that provides scholarly journals and as a repository.

Each users’ discipline, age, rank, work place are often recognized as factors that a#ect their usage of electronic journals. Those who major in natural science, are young, and belong to a large university or institution, tend to be heavy users and early adoptors of electronic journals.

In its early stage, the legitimacy and authenticity of electronic journals were doubted by most users. Such doubts, however disappeared by degrees as prestigious commercial publishers and learned societies have begun to provide their own scholarly electronic journals. Users value usefulness, timeliness, accessibility, and the ability to search electronic journals. Howev- er, at the same time, they feel that electronic journals are hard to read on display and their perpetual archiving is not guaranteed.

108῍8345 2῍15῍45 Shinji MINE: Graduate School of Library and Information Science, Keio University, 2῍15῍45 Mita, Minato-ku, Tokyo, Japan, 108῍8345

e-mail: [email protected]

!"# 2004$7%28# !&# 2004$12%10# '()!" 2004$11%24#

ῌ῎῏῍

*+,-./01234 1990 $56789+:;

On the Scholarly Use of Electronic Journals:

Trends and Issues from the Mid 1990s

Shinji MINE

ῌ17ῌ

I.

II.

III.

A.

B.

C.

IV.

I.

1990 !"#$%&' ()'*+, -./0 () 123456789:!;<

= >?@A !>?@B2C DEFGHICJ KLMN&OPQF ORSTUVWIXC YIZ[V& FV 'I\]^_[V`abcV adDCJ

eO456789:!VC_ f'

*+,g0h3;IX¹⁾J i=

jk=ORl!'*+,m)n"

0 FWo)DCp#I F 1 2CD'*+,qr_k s

$t3DCu%[V; ORl!

E&vwIxa'IXJ

!"#$% j ORl!() Ei=apB*YMk=VyJ + ikCORl!'*+,VkDz{z|!%}

~& [)<IORl!() 9€,-Y./(‚ƒ01„d=;

VkD=…=…y†() ‡ˆ2CD;‰2 .aFŠ‹3ŒFWo)DCJ V]

o3 OR456789:

!2CD"0ŽuŠ;‘„=

)DC'*+,IXJ

m)’‡ˆ“<I &O”*

kD •4o=–

56—FWo)Dg=J m)Š6—˜™{

š6[VrdD ‡›223 7–5& 58<

V[V eO456789:! œ3 Ia0OžŸIl!}š o kD;p9¡ V¢J

:£I 

;W <‘{š6W_[VI m

–5&+= F

¤DC2&'2aq>&J (Š

UF<‘IXd=›ORST V‡ˆ–5VI ¥Šu¦)2A?§

2FXu¨CD;©J II.

ª« '*+,IZ() STIXF²⁾ U„=aC;;X)

¬ UEk=œ3;<I "@a

­5FAˆ³⁾J ‡ˆ mBKLMN

&OPQrdDZ()U®W›¯&

°±:²„k=<<Ek=;IX F –5;W FWo)

=›¯rdD³adDCJ [–5?§

´V2] ˜™ &

CŠuaµ³;=ŠkDCJ rdD:£I C_ ª« V ª¥Šu" %

¶I ORZkDCST«

VC_/C·D;¸[Vk=CJ z{

z|!%}~kD nF¹aC=

;EFI;"Ce-Print archive<=

arXivVk=J

Gº1960<IH Vyo)DC⁴⁾J kuk I›

‡ˆ;VJ0³»;IX] m

›2<I;V[V:£·V³ aJ &z{z|!%}~F:

1990

!"#$ 90%&'()

*+, !-.*

/01,234 5 ,

6'( 7

1995892004:;<

,0+,4

'(),)'( ++

=>?@ABCDEF'(GH

IJK4 8 L M

!"NOP 5#$Q'(<R S;%86&6 <,6T 4 5U3 'V M!(),HHJ

<L*T"NOP1W,X +

"N,-YZ< 6 4

6X +.[\0"N'(T

< 1) "N/-OP0]11,^<

2) 2>34_5`a 6 b7 c,4

III.

'()YTdeA 8 0Tenopir⁵⁾ -NSF⁶⁾ fTg9

; 4 Tenopir 1995892003

:; 34_h:i

;-)YT200<% 8-"N=

j>kdeAX 'V Tenopir deA 8?l@T 4 8 A 8 -mnopB 34_h:qC D),'()i;

YTX9r s1E-tu1E6v Fc 4NSF 8 L6GH>IwJD pxy '()z %0]1{|1999:, }K*,- 6 4

'Vz) D)Xf~L),'(

)-d€F‚ƒ6v34_h:„

:6 …m†‡<ˆ

Tenopir‰NSF 8„: 6 ŠM1

,^ 8-"N=j<YT 4 'V

Tenopir 8‹ŒK691) '()

, >NO6v FcŽ 2) 34_h :%c…m†‡YT 3) f } 8„ˆ 4

!:'( 2Kl1WPH 170+,K⁵⁾4 GH ‘6'(

’/>k“2”Q6'(t•–

 <ZG RST—"N)

&1U-$QV˜W”

Q6'(4 ) ?6'(’/™T X /š6'(XP; 4 ) GH8PH'(’/“ V˜›

1UGHœ"NT

<1 Y< 6 4

2”Qt•–Z, žŸ€

p eLib f T SuperJournalb  ⁷⁾ Outsell ¡mn34_[¢ (Digital Library Federalation: DLF),34_\=h£¤

¥¦ (Council for Library and Information Resources: CLIR),§AT"N⁸⁾ pnF

¨©ª2>34_f Stanford E-Journal Users Study (eJUSt)^9)«12) ¬­ž¬34_\=

®¯°–fOhioLink±]34_

),"N¹³⁾ Tenopir,Kingf G["N⁴⁾ARL,x²‚pA&M2>§A fLibQUAL³L^,6TT"N¹⁴⁾

JSTOR"N6v¹⁵⁾4

2”Qt•– G_?6'(’/

“ 4 ,3$ SuperJournalb  tu1E `´"N ¨©µpu

‰žFneA eJUSt `´"N

web¶aŽžFneA‰tu1ET 4 +9"N G_?6bc891E X :V˜d{|T·e 5O >kf¸6<

4

W”Q'( IJ 1U-' (GHX f?ghˆ 4

Tenopirf$ W”Q'(ij '(

/ `´"N}<?l 6b ¹º‰i

» žFneA,e 4 '(

ῌ19ῌ

!"# $%&

'()*)+¹⁶⁾

,-./^{17), 18) 19)} 0)²⁰⁾ 1.2-345

67²¹⁾ 8-9:²²⁾ ;<9=>?²³⁾ </-@

:²⁴⁾ UAE²⁵⁾ ABCD

&EF *G HIJ 9=KLMHC#N%O 1) ' 2) P 3) Q R+STUVW X YZG X9[\;:']#^_

A.

1. !

`a" b#

'] $%X9[\;:#

c + FN c+c A d &%#'efg d h (i jkljck #) N&m j*k jnok j&+k jp pk Ehq,-r%#

N s&tu ABC#.vV]

AwS& r%c /x#

0F1N 21 34y y!#5zc N WW{c j!k e -o6F| jc k }~#

c dh €7ho6",+S jc k }~#‚#!c 2 1VWc q,-r%89c c :ƒ-#c

„%& jn(…+s&*;k <!

=†c

!",-‡ˆc 1) >?#‰

Š& !‹2) 34 yEhy!@‹

W2zŒS&

1995>+S1998>^ ",-!

5}AO s&` &+X9[\;:

D& 1995>BuddS)

Ž8BŠ# #

$ ",X9[\;:#c 13.7 Cc BC ²⁶⁾ ‘D’ E

“ 0²⁷⁾ # F 12.6³⁵⁾ ‰ ” 16.0³³⁾18.4²⁸⁾ dh

!2}*G c+c GF

• H–ƒ40—75*;X9[\

;:#c dh y34 yEhX˜34?c I™-šJ#c ›u+c&

1999>*œ X9[\;:",- 50#Ku!#VEFh L

Mc#’Ož_ N2000>*œ

!O 7}Ÿ‹

9}Ac NP-N 2003>QRS #

$ X9[\;:#c

",90.0`aV¡

D& ⁴⁶⁾ 50—70 c 4E“ 34y 3}Ac ",‡

ˆ+S’ ¢£EhD&

S'D&

X9[\;:2000>£

E D&˜34?c …T¤"#

¥Uc›u y!

‹DVEh¦WN BX

VEF§¨#YuPZ[N _ ©ªgX˜34?V

šJEBC›u!«F

2. \-

¬]­®¯#^°\- _ˆ±

`² ³´ a4µb¶fc ·¸

fc zŒS& X9[\;:

e-d  c+c X9[\

;:Nef¹ºX,g\-#

»c X9[\;:

1

1995 13.7²⁶⁾

1996῍1997 77.8 ²⁷⁾ 75 !"²⁷⁾ 1996῍1997 28.6 #$²⁷⁾ 38.5 % &²⁷⁾ 1996῍1997 20.0 '(²⁷⁾ 14.3 )*&²⁷⁾

1996῍1997 11.1 +,²⁷⁾ 14.3 -.²⁷⁾

1996῍1997 0 /0²⁷⁾

1996῍1997 0 1234²⁷⁾

1997 18.4 5²⁸⁾

1997 8.5678/49.0698²⁹⁾

1998 46³⁰⁾

1998 36.4³¹⁾

1998 36.2³²⁾

1998 16 +:³³⁾ 606;<=8 >&³⁴⁾ 1998 12.6 ?"³⁵⁾ 57.2 !"³⁶⁾

1998 50@A B>C>D>!"³⁷⁾

1999 61³⁰⁾

1999 23.9678/68 +,>²²⁾ 80 ¹⁷⁾

1999 9.3 /0³⁸⁾

1999 53.9³²⁾

1999 34.7678³⁹⁾

2000 9.0 ⁴⁰⁾ 90.0 EF1!⁴⁰⁾

2000 18.0 /0⁴⁰⁾ 92.0 GH⁴⁰⁾

2001 98/70678⁴¹⁾

2001 69/50698⁴²⁾

2001 86.5/44.7678⁴³⁾

2001 74678⁴⁴⁾

2001 29.6 ²⁴⁾ 82678 1I⁹⁾

2001 54.2 J #$J J 34²⁴⁾

74.8 DJ !"J CJ KLJ 34J M²⁴⁾ 2001 69678 ⁴⁴⁾ 73.6 1IJ 5J N²⁴⁾ 2001 65.3 OPQJ &J RS²⁴⁾

2001 77678 ⁴⁴⁾

2001/2002 74.9⁴⁵⁾

2003 90/64.6678 C⁴⁶⁾

2003 84.5/55.5678 !"⁴⁷⁾

2003 89/68678 !"⁴⁸⁾

T1: UVWXYZ[WJ \ ]^_Z`a bcdef^_Z`g hijJ klA!"

\J mnopq\89J 7km@rXpq68est_Z`uhe^_Z`g T2: vwxXy_Z`b\pz{|`Z\}z{~ef^_Z`g

ῌ21ῌ

!

"#$% !&'( )

*)% *+,-( )^{35), 36)}. /0 1234564 !*$

)789: 7(

!"#;<5=

>9 )? 7(Lenares

" ;@'( )³⁰⁾:

A -

;): AB A/0C D )!E(<FG?#

G$'HI ): J /0 K!"

)#L<$%&'1MNO&

P'( )*)#L?# 78(Q) /07*):

3. R)

WWW*+S'( ) ,T*R)- U.* V

# /01/;0P19 ):

23/0 2<

WebW R4 ) :

SmithXY2 Z[

(n\129)74]^56_

`7a )⁴⁴⁾:

eJUSt "^9)b12)cdefd*

gh 89MN:ijdk +S )Weblfm nPubMed<Science

Direct*+o ghp;* V# q<

70]r(Weblfmgh

): =6 PubMeds;t$

>u'( V# r?@' AG<'

<' Bv4 ,-( ) :

SuperJournalwx yz g

h{|d}B?# 1) C~(enthused) 2) MN€D(journal-focused) 3) ‚€

D(topic-focused) 4) €D(article- focused) 5) Eƒ€D(binge) 6)Fh(ex- ploring) 7) „…d†„‡Xˆ‰dŠ(win- dow-shopping)&G2)8⁷⁾ nH2Io:

9‹ $%ŒJ?510N

YU.?(‹ C~

* r8*)YkŽKLM

: ‘Žˆ‡Xd ŒJMN’k‡Xd

?#L15b20&NL r8*

)#L8b10&NL“” ): •–—

˜/0 sO/0P™B) )$

r(J+!šHI )*) ›—˜/

0/0P™œQ 56!" ) HI ):

2RS9T U V# RAL€D E

ƒ€D&G'(: A Z[</0[

"#V;W ž 7Ÿ™ D )⁷⁾:

¡e„dŠ<gh¢X*56Fh/

? :+S )£

|¤Y#MN|fm¡e„dŠ

7“”'¥ ‚gh7Z¦

'¥ )⁴⁹⁾: Y§¡e„

dŠ7¢X0¨*) +S2©[*:£|¤

r\MN<‚ghª–;

F«( 2 ):

•–—˜/0¬#]­)/0®

^<‚C_žMN: A ›—˜/0 `a§¯b

°’dmY„±Y²<cdl³œQ 7 egh V# O)§

´µ'(¶iYkŽ

): « "#eƒ1MNœQ ) fX*: g· )¸

)*)⁷⁾:

¹* hŒEº0P 2 V# J­+/0YkŽi»

56jk*# &'Q L?(‹

:!"#;F­) /0

4.

Smith

29 !"67

#$%&'()*+,⁴⁴⁾ Tenopir -./012345), /67 89:;<

<54.545.5 !"

512.787.3=>,⁵⁰⁾

?@A#BC5DEFG HIJK LMDE),A5)

*+^{27), 51)N56)}HTMLOPAQ>

RC5S# DEFC5PDF

#HT*+

SuperJournalUVWX 2

YFZ[R),\]

DE)*+A#?+(44.8) ^

B,_5DEFA41.9`ab(

BA7.6 `ab(Mb a,cA3.8M=>,

;<dFeKAfg=

MhS*JK ijkl`a5 mn)*+AA+,# op=>,⁷⁾

qrst-'ue9hWX#-*+

eJUSt vwxyzF5

{|/678}~€t

PubMedt->*@+9‚#ƒ

A?+A=>, /678}~€

,^5 „…w†r),K

‡ˆFG#‰[*+ ŠC5z FC5 {|yM ‹ŒFG

=TKh+ PubMed‡ˆ)/678 }~zF\] yŽ‘

95#HTMLy’)*+ HTML

“2 2” !"•

2” "• 2"•

#–— ῌ$h ῌ?pz ῌyTR

˜%h” 78F™š›/œ0 12

78‘— ῌƒA$5F ῌ"ž785#‘

ῌyTR5Ÿ

"ž78ƒ ¡¢Ža£¤

‡ˆ&B›/2

¥¦‘— ῌ6$5%

ῌ'§3.58 ῌyTR

Y¨=¥¦5‚+*&B™š

›/œ012

‘— ῌ2©ª5%

ῌ%8M ῌ,T5yTR

£¤‡ˆF›/2

«¬‘— ῌ­®‘)*

ῌzF78p‘¯°

ῌyTR

ῌ™š›/œL/±²

ῌ³2eKA?@78„R

´#–—µ@¶

·ˆ— ῌ­®‘)*

ῌop78z y(/)²

†lj†Ž¸r—

ῌ$5)h+

´1ŽM¶

ῌ78¹Icz)h+

ῌyRh+

y(/)²

º»: Pullinger, David; Baldwin, Christine. Electronic Journals and User Behaviour: Learning for the future from the SuperJournal Project. deedot press, Cambridge, 2002, 145 p.⁷⁾

῍23῍

PDF !"# $%

&'PDF()*+&, -

. %/012Web

3456# 789:, ;1<'=>

&[email protected], FG12Web HIJK6LM'NO! # P=>&

'78Q!, -RS TUJ'VWDE78X' PDF HTMLY"Z[\]^6E_"#

HTML`PDF.

Z aQ [⁵⁷⁾,

Davisbc'# Y"ad12BIJe

?@DEZ'# -.f a d&ghiZCj6E, IPkl mgn38o bcpqr s3tuv _E1 2w-.D# 3o 100w xy.DE, ^# IPgn#

55.5o 1BIJez-.

DE # .f12o{

E|&d# 102xy.

DE'1.9o!, ?@}'# ~

4€e‚UJƒ„…j6†‡ˆY gz&DEh-‰ŠE⁵⁸⁾,

1999‹JSTOR ŒDŽbc

Y6‘# ~&k„’mY"“”•?@

–—DE_"# ‹OJSTOR˜™?@Z–—

DE⁵⁹⁾, JSTORj6-gn#

51.8o ()j6#29.9o j6, “- 'adš›>!":ŠE # š

YEœ&E, LFfF$ZžŸ

?@j6-'# -“j?@q ' ¡'& # ¢£F_E'# Y"

¤D-¥¦ j6 §¨Š6,

^# Yd?@j6-y©10w ™ {ª«Z^šœ&E_"# LF '22o#k4k¬­'1o!, $Z?

@j6-'®¯°&±²³[6“´&

-!Guthrie'µ¶E⁵⁹⁾,

;1< ~4€e´·&?@AB.

¸´¹ E-Journal User Study Report of Web Log Data Mining Dec. 02 [2004/10/26], ºhttp: //ejust.stanford.edu/logdata.pdf»⁵⁷⁾

¬­}~4€e?@

5.

!"

PDF!HTML #$%&'(

#)* +,)-./

--01&2/ *

a.

---3456 78--9:,/ ^{30), 32)}*;<=;

>-?% 5678-@

A9,BC 2000D%B E3-2-FGHIJ#

(%KL &5678 M2 !NO"K /O"PQ#, / ³²⁾*

R-5678&,/

$%&' )S&- T#$%U VD),'W/ * KingX-?%Q

#-4YZR-[\%V](

%&^%/ ⁶⁰⁾* :)% _Y-`*a b-5678&,/ V- - +,Ecd-5678](%

&e#//+fgVh/

30)*

eJUSt-?% CV&e

V-.-75i/,BC E-0(1 023(99i) 45(85i) jk6-78 (77i)lmX)* n &D#/0 (, o93(86i) '%p V-q X/ (74i) PDFDrs :;(62i) t#V-%K)* 5678- u/V-cd vw7xv <=

y/ o93,Ecd<=&>/

/#/⁹⁾*

- 01&

2 "z,?{@|"A}?~

5678-lmX/ ⁹⁾*

?{@|"A€%Bu/

;x‚=x-&D#/ƒ„KC …?†&C,&',/ * DE‡

7ˆ-&-F‰-V-CV-

&e* 1&-G-CV 5678&eƒ„K E1 GB/AŠ XHg‹

D%-I#dJŒK KL, / * =xŽ&R V-cd C5678&eƒ„V@WX ) u/‘%V ’w“”Mq …vw7xv-<N#d-0( X 5678&D#/V-V/ * }?~€% ~,!N4#/ /cd ; x‚=x&eƒ„K)* ~,4#/

V-;x‚=x•-’w“”& D,/V -€ /+C&' )S O"#

V-€ ,/ -, /V-;x‚=

x%R-&–—,O"#&P &

˜Q#,/ ⁹⁾*

j’5678E+%#/%

-™š›#C 70ij’5678 R)&S,/ -, !j’

5678,-%T/,/

fgVh/ ⁴²⁾*

œ%VKX GB/O"#$

%U%KC'WBC⁶¹⁾ žI#-•-

ƒŸ@WX#/ -$%U•

- ¡¢A£/ * b. PDFHTML

eJUSt-?fg ¹⁰⁾ ¤¥¦’

§U,^P&e¨-VW%

56i.&©Xª%^%BC E-+«

42iPDF% 14iHTML%^%

s )* :©Xª%^% X ¬­®p V--¯ /W&¡/ * :Y&

°,)‘% 68i&e)S:

¬­&,/)-±%K ⁹⁾* 41² X50² ¬­ CV©Xª%e&

³Veƒ„K)* -6- CR-Z&C, ¯ /W&¡/

+%K ¹⁰⁾*

DavisjŽ8BW E´µ¶·¡

-5678&° š[%p)1,283- IP’¸¹” Xº»\&¡/ * .IP- ῌ25ῌ

HTML 10

HTML

PDF⁵⁸⁾ 6.

!"

#$%&'()

"*+, -&./%0-+

eJUSt1-2

%34 5677&

&#7+89:;

7+, <=>+ &?-

@A6*+0-+ B3C DE FGHI&87%J0-%%

&K(98)%L0-+ . MNOPQRSH-<T0-+"

& 3"UV"

(27) !WX@A6 "#Y

@A6 Z[

&\*]⁹⁾

"^$%&7+_'`a&\

6 WorlockEbGcde6%f

gde6hi252(7+1j*]%$

k 563)2&*l7+m1?n5 +%&o,7+%pq\*] 7

?7 3)256 -.&r

%&9sKt%uv+⁶²⁾

OIwc;Fcxy/z{]OIw c01"⁶³⁾ 62Fcx y| $%"7}3"OIwc4

7. %56~7~

$% ) %7 +56~7~7e(€$%8/

"‚$%%/"&& $7]ƒ9

‚/?1„0-+

1997-…†&‡e):j*]1 5626.1&*

+56~ˆ[‚5&‰;7]%57+

²⁸⁾

1999-JSTOR1 5648

&ƒŠ56~‹<7+& Œ5-"

%38‰; 56~=‹<>{]

):*+Ž" e):52&

?&e):22&56~‹<&@

$%A`7+⁵⁹⁾

. @A656~B‘%7+@A

’“”•EN– CD—˜EF,VG

™“G CD—˜o,&=Gš/\%

›"7+JSTOR15648&5 6~!œHž>Ÿ\%  + , ?&e¡@A663&A`„

7+ . "OWE¢&£:7

¤) 7+-2 56~&!I¥

$%{7?%JK7+ 5 656&A`„0¦ ):›%e 35 ?&e75\*] ?&e¡

@A656~‹<>&K‚ {]56~

K‚L97+$%&§ {]

eK):KU¦@A6"H<7+

¨MN+, 56~Nˆf&B‘

q]>Ÿ©%  +⁵⁹⁾

2002-Oª QG«HyPe¬­!

Q®mR¯

3 °H«EH %

°H«EH

()

() Av€S±%&GHI 87 98

Ž"€TU±GHI 76 99

²³´cGHI 63 94 µjV%&OIwc 63 86

W6e-mailGHI 61 85

"¶·X· 60 95 W6Web¸E“GHI 52 81

°H«EH1Y 49 96

¹²°NOPQRSH5 45 67

%&R¯o, 36 33

ˆZ: E-Journal User Study Report of the Second Survey: The Feature User Survey Novem- ber 2002. [2004/10/26],ºhttp: //ejust.stan- ford.edu/findings2/report῍survey2.pdf»¹⁰⁾

@A6

⁴²⁾

19982001 !"#$#

%&'()* +,- .-

/01 12

345678³²⁾

SuperJournal9:167 .-0

1;<=171.1> ?4-0%44.8>

@ABCDEF)5F

5G @ABCD

E2HIJKLM FN O MP1QRS1;<=T FUVWFX3YZ ⁷⁾

@ABCDE[1;<=G

\ 2]^

_[` a;<=

FNT1`N

' %N % ;

<=513FZ @ABCDE21HIJKFX bcFd efgh%

Oi

8. a11jklH

mn ;<=@ABCDEo %N[

p@ SqSr#$sCt ;<3Y;<=

1WebsR$ e-mailNMN !uF

4), 49), 64)

a. SqSr#$sCt

SqSr#$sCt U !"#"Kvw 1@xFyz{$%&|

!jklH%O5 SqSr#$sCt.

Y$'[nT11 ;<=]^

M;<}(~) F(

T1 €NLMN[ [\1(

&'o %O

SqSr#$sCt1*+‚

ƒ„N ALPSP_,N-./0

&5(%1=1'2% …3=178>

SqSr#$sCtF4†+

‡ 5=1|ˆ%67>SqSr#$sCt

..1‰67Š%‹%N 88>

SqSr#$sCt$'F8ŒN …3⁶⁵⁾

9:./% ‚;⁶⁶⁾Manuel⁶⁷⁾(F

&5 ‚;1998<1‚‚Ž

EC9:1;<=F0‘’-“(F&

e-PrintHC”R•1 !jklH

1~) F( e-PrintHC”

R•F&=–%&5;<=6—˜™ š

›1œ%8—˜™T1;<=G ;<KQRE)5a1>

žN :$;<=)5G ]Ÿ17Š%&=š› 3—?%N 8—1:$;<=¡¢1;<@7£A1|

e-PrintHC”R•FB¤% 9—

CUVW8Œ e-PrintHC”R

•21&=;<@71£A\¥DE4N T1O–¦„N ‚ŽE

C9:./T :$]Ÿ17Š%

;<KQRE;<=§1¨©ª«¬C"­#

1OhN®O ae-PrintHC

”R•1~) ¯°FF„

x./% Brown⁶⁸⁾)5(&'

Brownx./1SqSr#$

sCt%O Chemistry Preprint Server ±˜

² CPS³ F0‘CPS&=GS qSr#$1GH+NUVW21´1?

&=GSqSr#$1UVW21&|IN MF(CPS&=;<=0

&5’-“(% ;<=J1.7 µ1$'F&= 78>UVW8

Œ(n¶60) CPSFKLT 18>55>·M~32>¸M~%

(¹N%CPSSqSr#$

217µ1œ&=GCPS&=G$

'UVW$'´GT1O[N5 CPS%¡T‚ZFºP 1– {$

GSqSr#$1P32>67

UVWm Brownx./

SqSr#$sCt»+N€QR FF„

m¹N%x./ 9:

ῌ27ῌ

!"

# $%&%'(

b. )*+,-WWW

)*+,.%//

!( 012%19973 4 5606 7895786 :;95 826!)*+,<= >²⁹⁾%

? 20013%:;95@A946 47895@A88.16!B

= ⁶⁹⁾ C012D% E 886!F*GH%IJKLM<N

%"O( P# OPACQR!ST 32!)*+,PUWeb JK!N%"V P# ?

! WebJK( &>SWXY

< E= ²⁹⁾ P

? 836!)*+,JKZ[<

54.16!01)X\]^_Q`

<"ab%= ⁶⁹⁾ 01)`KRF*GH?&>

!cd= )e)fQ

[FMEDLINE<ab%= P#

gh]^<MEDLINEijklm = i= Sn`KRoHQ$F*

GHpL Q!h( ⁷⁰⁾

!:Webq[<rs-tuL M?Qv"%"! S#w$=

>%<&x= ?P# 'y Ytu-(zC= ){<?|>=

?

!Webq[%}*+%<tu&

>(z=>M!"il hli D!~

Tenopirj,<p€

D<~( ! -Webq[ij%

<(z= ?200120023%

0.86L‚ƒ %(zC= „…} †|!‡ ⁴⁹⁾

v%GaddjDˆ20023%

E57.86!WebX./%%<tu

=>M!"# 886!WebX%./%(z%

‰%<=>M!"= j XŠWebX./%%<tu=>M

!"?‹956 S=>Œ0%

<= (zC= WebX%./

%(z%‰%<=>M!"E

816!-Webq[ 666!Ž

LWebq[ 446!I‘’)“

ij%<(z= ^{71), 72)}

%20033P WebX”

%<tu=>•–"? E#

446%"(> S‹%tuC=

74.06! 30.86!:

Webq[ 17.86!8—%"(>

:Webq[X%<tu= ? E676% S‹$!40.96 F*GH”˜!42.86™^š›œ

!35.26{%tu >

%1žgh!WebX%<tu

= M!2œŸ⁴⁸⁾

B.

C~( 3 [¡¢£g4

¤¥!5ji(>! S6¦4§

¨!©ª<7 M!‡ W

«% ©ª<7¨= ¬ M!g?­8< P ¨

# %#%5®¯9 ??"

ˆ ¬ !©ª<7 °±%‰??" MM% ²

<©ª<7¨= kLM

=>

1. :

:;9 ³ f PU•´Qµ 3 [¡¢£Qn3 Y¶<

· ¸ i j = P # ; < =

27), 29), 31), 32), 42), 73), 74) =¹1988

e-mail < u º =⁷⁵⁾ 1999 906!3 [¡¢£<= P# » 3 [¡¢£

5

!"#$ ³⁰⁾

%&

' &()* +,

# -.&

./01

# ⁶⁹⁾ 23245678 &' 309 :;509' 209<:;309< # #' %

=( &*>? @)

^{65), 76)} &

arXivAstrophysics Data System (ADS)' ABC ! B DEFG/0HI

# "#:;' $%J

# ⁴⁹⁾ . &KLM /N # M &' O&P !DEFG'Q>

# /0(1

)*# R+ ' ' ,S ' TU' VC&

W-.) ^{27), 38)}

X//Y0Z 1[&' E\

](HI2^

_ >34@)

2. 5`6

56 abc d7 ef8N:;!g@) Speier;Hahn;&' ARL"9:

h; M.&5i*' )*# # !jk

>l# ^{33), 77)} 1996, 97<m' 40nX oTp= #

#' 40nX/&189q$ _r ²⁷⁾ ()>&>' 5j*s % a t u _ k > !g @ )

78), 79)5i&v5wx\ yz

{5| aR+ ' 5j

&s% }Yk>a? ⁸⁰⁾ Tenner>

Yang&~TJ

tu_0' ()T' €TN>?

ef,# ³¹⁾ eJUSt? &' ‚&

mZ@A:;B/0ƒC #„DE F…0' G&(†‡`H

)/0

tu_ >@) ⁹⁾

#:#' 5> ˆI+;):r ef&N‰:_0^{32), 49)}'5 abcd7 >&JŠ#

‹Š' @; ?JK _ Œ;

L&MŽ1N bcd K _ k>‘;)' !’OP ‰)“”&•@NrNk>QR

@)

3. ST`h;–ˆ

ST–ˆ—U/r ˜\5

&”r Davis/)™' AVW Xš›v5œDG…$ IDEALž|

Y}r>kŸ' ‚.–ˆ & 

¡¢\]6 #' :

£Z:•£Z¤3¥ &8[¡¢\

]6:;¦{5ž§# k>¨

)@) ⁸¹⁾

:£ZXš›\]©^ ˜\5 cd7 ⁵¹⁾ Xš›s%/0 ª« +_>)™' &

#¬0⁵¹⁾' Xš›

­`›&Xš›®ra¯;) ^{32), 82)} :£Zw¥°8|:>hb C¡¢

%c? §3±²: &' •£Z F³D:/0C¡¢ $%

dª# $%$% _ !&' w¥°8|:' §3±²:

()´)519, 439 _ #' F³ D: &209< _r

24mZ µe _ k>

&' ¶K _ >Y?ef_

⁸¹⁾' :=&fgST:·h

# ^{83), 84)} 3¸'

4¸'11¸¸i:;ji¹k=™:;¹^.

Nº w± ' Oi¹^:l»

ῌ29ῌ

⁸⁵⁾ 4.

!"

#$ %!&'()*+

,-./ 01234 5678 ()*

1234569:;< 0

/ =$^{31), 33)}

Walsh> ?@AB4CD?EB

FG4HI@ JKe-mailL M8

1 %N

OOO P-OQe-mail

R⁷⁵⁾ ST e-mail

%U/V> W58.5X W0R OYO7>

$Z$69.4X 64.8X%![R \]2

^_!e-mail`abcd

e-mail"# $%&efWe-mail g'hiST 1$j( 0R

Boyce>)OQ

R $M$k %1 l*+,mWe-Print4nop

%-q.r/st 0!

0!1uW78 vhwx y"z 2/> p{|2@}

y"z78 e-Print4nop~z9 :;< 0 !%/>

€=$3Re-Print9:

[1 ,=$⁸⁶⁾

‚ƒ> OQ„4… R %†5>

23456Y‡a‡ˆ@‰Š4‹ŒŽm6 78W 2†5 69>::[8[ST ⁴⁸⁾

$>‘& eJUStW> 9 ;<[0>=’&[M 82345667[;< y€

z$ %> >%“?

”@•z$ 1:W

‡a‡ˆ@‰–W1uW—R W>[AB¹⁰⁾

Ehikhamenor CD5o2˜ˆ

QRW> o@C4™š‰ % :" ŽE89.3X

! ›#[ŽE o@C4™š‰

&FG&[œQRST ž GŸ^_!>o@C4™š‰

>j [! HIJ jS•z²³⁾

/$ %>

%!-q 67/ ¡r W0 K¢ 0£L¤

MN¥¦O§>¨©W>P QW0

C.

1M23456

~zW>[! ª 1M[

Y4Ryž—

S:W0 «W> ª 4R323456 y!/:

1. ª

1995 T¬U­®ŸW> 23456

>¯O°±²M8VW X³r$

Y©> Z[ ž\Y 23456´µ&[W0¶[

8 „ 2·¸^{87), 88)}/Y©

23456>¯[*W ]9 u1[W0R

¹M 1998 08—W>

2345669>2R /©Ÿ

7> 23456:ª Yj^J&2W0R 234 56_)ºY º$%1M[

23456 0[>[

![R 234569/ 0

> 2»3Xu1[L`W0R ^{26), 28)}

23456

Harter⁸⁹⁾Zhang^{90), 91)}

19961998

! "

# $% & ' ()"*+ , -./01

*&23 !

33 456789:

;<6='1>?*+

@+ A3;BC ;! 1990 ARLDEFGHII

JKL M

N!O3 B3 P;>

"PM6='>?Q#RS BT3 ;³³⁾! Tomney $:U $ :%&P;VWXI'6KL70YZ (>[\*+ )* M U<B3 >

+,RPA]3 - UP^&_A`a ²⁷⁾!King $:U& M.

/0b1;UcdP3 ⁵¹⁾! 33 e2UNf 13b3 $:$%&<g 4h5P

>6C@+4&6D3;i7 3 ⁹²⁾!

2000JSTOR8jf KkEF9

:Q;* 58l6 mn6<%

&$:o ! -$:$%9+p

=60YZ(>f13b3 ;! >?q%3 @A3 g - B0>CDU<rC EPstu Ib1v ! wxyVxF G=*stuIP"EPzGI {&43 g |}9gHIE4Q 2]J~ ⁶¹⁾!

eJUSt$:9 >;

€KLC./U i760Y>

€K<M0./

LC i73 ! -6‚ ƒ EP./3 „…DQNO(98Y) 9g1†‡>?Pˆ(86Y) QRZ‰)

*Š6D(71Y) S)*‹Œ

(71Y)%3 TQ& )*5 (52Y);ŽVU>?TU?

(42Y)F3 3 , NO 9g1>?PˆP"5>?T U?V,3&FW P! jX4>A + cd./LC g Y8‘

M0>’(3;“”, •MZ 6>?TU?>’(3;J~ + ⁹⁾!

2. 4

>?q4QA%3 – 4—˜ ! 4[0 \0 „… E5]^Q{&CDP_`

3 `a ! ™-+("CDU P“ E5 šaŽ›œžx U<;³⁰⁾! bDstyša Kš

Ÿc;P U“”+

E5%QCD0-+("Uf 1P ’><⁶⁵⁾! 6=')*¡dP„…

)*e„… BP¢u>?XxJ fgCDPE53 `a + ⁹³⁾!

1> £DP4

¤x¥¦t 24@U&)*§Ž

J¨IU©4[0U<Aª3

31), 65), 79), 82), 94)99)! 4m‡

>h «Fi3;g„…3;g QAj¬* VDP*k‘­x®¯

^°>h5PA >?l3* ŽJ¨Im Sn±opU©AP"²)U

50), 54), 79), 95), 98)! )*Eqr3 }U^

°3 O#³´U©A&µ;s 4“”+ ⁷⁹⁾! 4[0ŽJ¨Im

¶gt3·¸*+ g j¬PŽJ¨I =

*„… ¹u ŽJ¨I Dº>

4vwQ—˜

⁶³⁾!

1990xyzk»M

%3 —>EP@P>gO ;>¹⁰⁰⁾ m >[4P-3;@

ῌ31ῌ

!"#$%&'()*+&

, $- ./ (012 3#$%&()45$

3.

6'7869 :#$&- ;7< +

*=&%>?@$- *A6

$17<(+ $

&B- CDEFG' :- HI !'"#J$- K%'DE' LM L'&.NOPF'5H (Q'J$8$%&()45

$55), 79), 95), 97), 101)R*+STU5@

$%&,-VW5@- CDE !"#$%&()0?'5X- ./230 5@$%&()45$⁷⁹⁾

1#$ !"1+ ?

<( $ ALPSP'2Y5- Z3'75[4.\](5^+1 _6+ !"5`$- 69[7a*

+&8%1+ b.(cd $⁶⁵⁾ e9'J$Af5Qg?'?*:;

(8 $ hijkl<CL mn '93['op&87['<Cq=- r;*

>?5@s'A'J$(+ $&Z3 + $⁹⁶⁾

(Q'5tB+ C(Du

$'- " i'5 (0/'X&

vw'EX5@$50), 65), 79), 92), 95), 102) H?x(FyGH&+ - zI-{J- KG|L- :;}&+ ~

€ $³⁰⁾ M?- xW7#TU5@

- vw?N€ - zI7 !"+7#

N&}‚OX€ $ LPƒ

' !"*A5@$&cd $

?'?$¹⁷⁾ „…†<C5.‡X€2Y5 - 9QˆC‰'op'22[ !"#$/

'R6`HŠƒSTUV‹€$%&

()45$¹⁰¹⁾

4.\@$ŒW#$6Ž

%&?&+ ~€$ OFO XY<C5‹€2Y5- op7<Cq=

cd $1 ‘%’(Z“ ”€•

€24[&33[A[5-1–?

&, $?'?”€•€8[- 6[—˜

³²⁾™iPš<C'2Y5-2001@\r

 31['op(+

%&Q- ”'GH' !"[]›€5@$%&- œ^](+

$_;5@$&X€ $⁴²⁾ ˆC 61#$Zž`a1- ”€

(+H=&+¹⁷⁾

%€*5Ÿ `H=- 6(+-  ¡?”'¢S6QH=5

@$ ++- >- R'b;N CacAf5Q- 'd- e- £ fH ;5@$ H gh#

$¤¥i $1?@$- '¦

7j)§¨(k$' ‘Cac“-

‘@l“- ‘ma“- ‘n“- ‘od}Œ“ &;

©5@$

<Cop65"F(

ª«#$B- ”€(#$ ++-

‹—

+6f$ <Cq=e?(

#$H=5@$ 9QˆCHŠpC‰'

- 'qa¬5(r

­®"7(+ ( 45$ "KGC7sCac'

¯m¯iG°L(+±+ $ ^

²³ˆC‰'Rt0u['J

$(+ - M'ac'H?./

´%#$¢S@$ <C'7<Cq=

(e?(QW- (µ

79v+ $ ++- wx}Œ7¶

·'?*R¸´%

+ $ ¹C‰'4.\5- y1<C7h mMH?z{'DEFG(+

$ @l'º6H´%

+- |}» - ”€1#$~Z '