奈良教育大学学術リポジトリNEAR
明治末白川学園における「低能児」の処遇・教育実 践の歴史的検討 : 障害による学習困難のある収容 児童の事例をもとに
著者 玉村 公二彦
雑誌名 奈良教育大学紀要. 人文・社会科学
巻 53
号 1
ページ 115‑122
発行年 2004‑10‑31
その他のタイトル A Study on Educational Practice for Children with Mild/Moderate Learning Difficulties in Shirakawa Gakuen in the late Meiji Era
URL http://hdl.handle.net/10105/172
!"#$%& '(
)*+,-./012345 6789&:;<$= +> ?@ABC*
DEF&>G1,-#CHIJCKLE !"
MNEOPQ&)*ER?SE UV,-WXY ZT[\ Z]^_`a167bcdef T
ghiijklmlnopqjrshtjuvwijT[ukwjxyhizj{|wtj}u~
&,-&
b' =&&8'
+
UV,-W,-I_ ,-b _cdef ¡¢£¤¥b
¦ |zhs§worshtlzp woli¨mltzp t©ªwmy«p i sm©o¬p z«
p i s®ws©mlz©¯©lmop o°±p ªªp thi zp ©²p o|«p ml³l¬l´l³h©o p oz«©i lz©©p µ prml
¶hop «p ³w·¦¦n¸¦
_ b
_¸©t©pq©sl§eu~b
|«pml³l¬l ´l³h©oulo po²zpzhzpwo ªwm t«pism©o ¬pz« i©lmopo° spªªpthizp©² potihspo°
¹©ozlim©zlmslzpwou¬l²©²zlºip²«©spo»»º§z«©¶§wzw¦²²wtplzpwowªrshtlzpwox¶§wzw
¶§whp³h¶lp}j·«©©shtlzpwoli¼mltzpt©wªz«©po²zpzhzpwo«lsº©©otwoshtz©sº§¸§w³pt«p
½l³pzlu¬«w«lsº©©opot«lm°©wªz«©po²zpzhzpwoj
¾pm²zi§uz«p² ²zhs§ whzipo©² z«© ªhzhm© wª z«© po²zpzhzpwouz«© t«pism©o los z«©
©shtlzpwolil¼¼mwlt«©²ªwmz«©²©t«pism©oj
|©twosi§uz«p²²zhs§ lzz©¹¼z²zw loli§²©z«©tl²©²zhs§ wo z«©t«pism©o ¬«w ¬©m©
¼m©²©oz©sl²z§¼ptlitl²©²º§ ½l³pzlºl²©swo «p²¼mltzpt©²j¿p²z«©wm§ wª©shtlzpwo ªwm t«pism©o¬pz«i©lmopo°spªªpthizp©²©²zlºip²«©sz«©ªpq©z§¼©²wªt«pism©o¬pz«¹pis®¹ws©mlz©
i©lmopo°spªªpthizp©²tlh²©sº§¹©ozlim©zlmslzpwou¹©ozlipiio©²²ut«mwoptlipiio©²²u²©o²wm§
p¹¼lpm¹©ozuloss©ipoÀh©ot§j¿©tlii©sz«©²©t«pism©oÁ·§h³loµpÁlos©Âl¹po©sl¼¼mwlt«©² ªwmz«©ªwhmz§¼©²wªz«©tl²©²poz«©ªpq©z§¼©²j
½l³pzlò¼mltzpt©²losm©twms²wª©lt«t«pislm©qlihlºi©ªmw¹ l«p²zwmptliqp©¬¼wpoz² wª²¼©tpli©shtlzpwo los ²wtpli¬©iªlm©ªwmt«pism©o ¬pz« sp²lºpipz§uliz«wh°« z«©m©lm©
²w¹©ip¹pzlzpwo²po«p²¼mltzpt©²losº©ip©ª²j Ä |«pml³l¬lÅ´l³h©ouy«pism©o¬pz«
¹pis®¹ws©mlz© i©lmpo° spªªpthizp©²u ilz©©pµprml
Ä
! " #$%&
'()"*+,-,./.0123456789,.:;0123.5 678<*#$=>?@ABCDEFG DHIFGJKLMNO)PQR+4-,.:S012T:5 6789,.:.012T4567#$DHIFGJ KUVWX)YZR[\]^*
_`abcdefdUVWXgh 198"*
5i5
jklm no"*#$%&DHIFGJKV W pq=>rJKsotu v*,.:.012T45 6wxyz #$%&DH IFGJK{|}~[
aMa
z [)"*
JKa8<)^ ¡J K¢X" )£¤
R12T46¥¦§R¨©) gh 198) ª«LM)
)t#$%&¬9JK®LM)
F¯ DHIFGD'°FGD±²FG)³"*^
8#$´_µ°¶·*^ DHI FG¨¸¹º»)"*JKLM'(
D'°FGJK ¼^ [[#$DJ K½¾ ¿ F¯ÀÁG)"*DÂÃFG D'°FGDÄFGi]ÅÀ" DÆFGDÇFG DÈF®ÉFGDÊ%FGËÌÍ^F¯dM
Î^F¯ DÄFGÏÐ" D'°FGDHI FG)ÑÒÓÔ¶Õ['DIÖר Ù'°FGDÚÛ±²Ù'°FGDÜÝÞßÙ'°
FGDàáâáËãÙ'°FGD(ÜÊ%Ù'°FGä ]Áå"*^ 0¼DàâËãÙ'°FG) æçèéË̾êëìF) í"¥
îï·#$¶·DàâG)D0æç5èéG ÓÔ5^]8Áåð"*#$
ñå)¾òó ô¼<õ ö ÷z*^ £¤ªøLM#$ùú"
òó )ûRagü]^*ý þ"¾))
R#$«) F
¯ËÌdM÷f["*IÖ ÕF¯
4T_°e q í )z ) q9#$¬Ü[í
8"*^ "8"^
*^8z DHIFGJKÀ {
8 òóõö #$Mùòóõö
)^q _` <*^
)q9òóõöja)
"*´*9)q9
" DG *¼5
´§DG¾D(ÜÊÀ ÇæçàáâáËÌJK ì F¯g
¥aG)9*^ (Ü ËÌF0a;89,T5 JKà âJKàâ)Ó'9
*^a ! C
)"*DZGDÂÃG¾z*X ¡JKàâ))"*D G*^©ËÌF
¬®JK ÷)^z
JKàâ®Ý]^*
#$q Ã"*[ghNO t
Ò)F¯]^*
¾gh8 ¾
DG¼^*ú D(Ü
À ÇæçàáâáËÌJ Kì F¯G)^IÖ¾z*
D'°FG ÅÀ"["*['ËÌgh¾ Áå"*#$)"*^)q9 )9Fgh)"*
í¾
#$ D'°FGäÁåz )89Õ 8¾[ª«ËÌÎÙ aËÌF8 ÞßFçËÌFçËÌ F÷fMF)^z ÎËÌF)"*
*^ )ä5["*[9F ËÌÎz*DJKì GÙ
ÃÙ F)
[ªø#$D'°FG))¾z
*ËÌÍ^F¯**ËÌF {aËÌ^F¯
"*^)#$ËÌÍ^F¯ð DÄFGÈÉÇæDÆJKG
"^)"*^5
"8" Y)"*"*^Õ<
^"DG½^
)"*["^¢´_
a*ÍaËÌF¯ )
ø
,,;
!"#$%&'()*
+,-.)/01,$234567$'
%89:;<=#$&>?%'(*
!@<AB)C%DE%F!5GH $IJ
KDE@LB)C5M !N$F!5OPQA BRST/!UVW@XM
'YZ%RST/![\]X"^_Q ALBF%`a@b&cdefgRShij*
kjl,mnQAB%5oU!@$F!p L$pqr,st%&u3)*RS%vwxy
%z{|}~;<&% %
p,R5#BNl%_5E$
p*!QABF!5T"MQ AJ'k,mnQA$F!"
B
F%:&u3)*RS/#W;%
¡¢kf£¤p9¥QABp '9¥¦§;<7A¨f£¤!©
¡¢9¥QA$%pª«"BM pstf£¤!M¬®¯,¬!
°N$%%±²,"B³Jst#´
&µB*5¶·%¸¹f£¤!
º5»B%$F¼½B&µB*
pYZ%RST/![\]5¾B¬%"
B¿ $
YZ%RST/&OÀÁ*·Â&ÃÄÁ*X"
^_QAB&OÀÁ*!&)CÅÆÇÈÉ·
-.ÊËÌÍÎÏÃÄÁÊÐÑÒÇÓÀÊ}Ô*%
&ÃÄÁ*!&¢ÇÕÖרÙÚ4×ÛÜ ÏÝÒRSÊnÔ*%$ÞßJW´F%RST /¢%RSÕÖ5àÓFá$´
-.âã5¿äBËÌåÍÎ5æWWçèRé êëìíîïð5ñò!B¢%ÕÖórô õ#RSö÷ÞÞJ!¢%RSÕÖØHÚ£, RéøîpnQA$RSö÷ù£QA^_QA
$¿ $úA%Á%ûüýþP!Q AB´Béüß"BÞJ )C%RS-ª%¥5BQA$!
XM
&%´7;<V?5y*$
!ÞJ¥H <AB%p[\]$!
M¬ l$!@B;<$"
,=)[\]=7$F!pN<AB F%[\]% 9Fpf£¤%¬!P,
£QA$à%$F%[\]% 9)C
%Ä-å%&%*5«7$!
MÕ !/7$pBXM)C%RS 5Qä$F!5B$Õ !7$%$A
,,½5¬,-7$%
#åïåêÂüð!M ðp"B½¾%Ì,}ð5
«ñm!RS»% @´ä$F!5¸¹ 7$YZ%RST/![\]%¾X
¾,RST/!%f567$F!$!
XM
¾,RST/!%ªfÜ RSEfp°N<A$
st%&u3)*RSw&u3)*%RS%
!=1ð5ñò!B
ÆUE%ËÌïåã%ÍÎ&+%*
$ìí%îï5¥H BÞJFA<
&*E&OÀÁ*%ñòP<¿AB F%F!stpd ;<v,5
=XM!BF!5¸¹7$st
%m5´F%v,5RS%
¥H Réøî!RS5Wl;
WW%ñòx$%E
&)C%*5êë$!@
A<5&RS,7$!*pùÕ $!
7$ÞJF%XMRSEk $%p
%RSE%f!$;;$f5 WF!p23"B%@BRST/![\]
%¾!Mª%4567$"B;<"
B
stDE%XM5B$RS!
¥H &RS%ã"RéK
øî$*!P7$ÞJ5
&ã*!N<A$RS$%
M;
stRS% v5& 1Z*!f H BÞJFAËßýá"B 5ÂB%$%þ
%5'%m5^B!
$
;Ap-.å æ1567$)C5 mQA$!MF!p%$st
& 1*$5P&)Cª $
%35M*!WW&Æ$-p"
ð;%35Àó% 3
%ñjj$%5 1!*!
$ÞJFA-.)%RS2345B
'k $&u3)*%RSm%, ÞÞ
!"
#$%& '()*+,- )./01234 5&
6789:5$;<=>?:5@:5A B5: CDE& FG@H@I
<JK L5AMN@5$;8C '()*+,-OP@<Q RSTAMN 5#"#UVWXYZ2[\]
^5#0_`ab@c dedf gh5ij6*:$
[\kl<mnopAf5q r7[sh-tu $)kl@<v w69*x"5A5#y90@:5$
)*@<z{b@|}:@~mn
{b@:}:0_
A5#:*x:C:5MN@5
#W$7qI)@}H5#b
:$MNb:8C 9# 0 125qr734O$./YZ@
Xh5<L= B9I
9I@ ¡¢
£¤ ¥uAMN@5#UW$)*x8I
@:5./¦C§<
A¨© ª«6*$7qI./¦¬
®¯`G6*-:$
°2j/6*±²./+³b´µ)e¶
·f0134 6*$@)*
+,!./@¸v:¡¹ ºz6*5&8
»"#$
±²./ j/°¼½¾¿ÀÁqÂ/
@½C86*5ÃIUÄ$ÅÆ
@<±ÇAÀÄÈ#É<ÊK±ÇAËÄW<ÌÍ A
Ä<®Î AÄ<ÏÐÑÒ AUÄ6*5$
MN@)Ó8Cw ÔÕÖר Ä ÙIÚÛÜÝÞ1ßà#
5W$ Â/áqâãä.åæÝ ÞÂ/ç âP:è75édqê$
Øëì@< íîïÓð Añ5ØÔ Õ<Óð Adëì 7I)ª ò±²./¡¹óÕ59$
*C Â/fô:-»õ@[
sh-tu $
ö÷Ø @øùúb:àûü5$
)@ùúhýþ:è·
ýÌ!5y9C*$IÆDE ü ¦Á :&
ýÌ 6*./Â/á&5 y9C*$
ö*C @Â/ä.åæ ø$8.h5@~:
D :6*5:5x8I8.
ñ5@6*.5C*5$
%&ùúh5.h5ýH ½ Ì:&°¼./Â/5
$)*@ü ñ5DE H ä.8C½ &88ÆC tu:&5u:àû ½ ./¡¹"& #*
ªò$
±²./ÙI34@rB#:C
÷|rI eDEHàû¢)=
Æ]^b[\¢5¦6
#&$DEH= ÷|rIÑ :&5°2¡¹@÷|rI&5@
I÷|rIFG×½C86*
ø!#$)*C Û h#$
/ ñ5 @ Â5$
./h5@q ö÷ý¦
9 6*$¦*H_
K:ë 7 û6*$ Û@
§SñV8CUq
XU8CU8CqX8
CËqhH7ð IË8CÀq Þ
HðÀ8CÂ)ÛÂ
6*@ä5#&$Û@
÷b: @:5$)*@./
DE K ![
&8C# ÛÒ¦6 6*`a59"#$
÷|rIeÛÒ¦´Åb:[\
h5DEH= ¸v6*8 àû:
$
Ø e[\34"#$
<®ÎïÓð AéC* @ 5#àû¢7 &$ &
eÙIoC5@h8*
5$
Xh5@MN@ =X
¢#28C»5$
UU
!"#
$% &'()*+,-./
012345&6789:;<=>
?@AB%CDEFG%HIJ K(+LMNOG
=PQR!ST!UV&WXIYZ[\
]OUV%^_`[\IOabcGQR!UV&d OIeIfghi&jIkl mnopqOr OstuEUV ] HavcGw&QRxyz{|}~E ST&83WH&IOEFG
T J\ T!O
^& K
¡&¢£KT¤EFGT&
¥¦§J I!]¨©ª&}~«¬"w FX Gr®¯E!]¨V°q[±!
q ²e\³<´YZµ¶V°q·]
¨V°}~F¸E¹º[\IO a»cG
¼½&r¾}Ip ¡¿[À¢£
ÁÂ& Ãx+q¥¦§Jº\ G^&
QR!xµ¶l!ÄÅOÆU¶
ÇIÈ=É£ aÊcG^\&WXI
TËÌÍÎÏÆÐÑÒ\ ÓDYZ WH IOGK¯¦xÔÒÕ[«1 Ö}~À×µ}~&ØÙ[«% ¹º[\ OÚ WHG
ÛÜSTTÝT& ¥¦§J!
À¢£ÁÂ& Þr(ßwqÉ£
EFX G^\& IÈàÀáâ&F J
\ T¤& Þr(!³ãqEFX ä HrG
àåæçTèé J\ êTE FX GQR!êTëàTìzí JIO GêT!îïÀð=ñòqóqOq·ôõ ö÷Ò\yøxùqóqOúÈ
ûü1Ö&d(ëàTýþAP+
!"#$%&'()
*+,-*./-*+0- 1234*5678- 29!:;3
<=>)?@ AB CDEFGHIJ3
+,EKL ,./ FGHMNO P3QRHS" TU3V() HU3 WXYZ[\3]^
H_`U3abcdHefN9g,h Ti 3jklmHnopqlmHrs ,ECDtuHefN39
vwP3xy*+z{|H}!NU-!U3
~CG$CrEG T./ .
/{| 39
* - TH*
G-!3*t-!3
hce*t
5-!)3 @
4!xO2941
!X3 ¡xS23 9¢h!"£¤xaL23@ ¥¦sJ
§¨39q\3x*©
ª«-¬\s3 <>®¯{Er°
±g²8³E´¢U THµ`U9*Fw-
¶·EZ[*ª«-!U3¸wfEs¹X#{
|rºE»¼½+ ¾ T}9 ¿À O29Á49*+,- T ÂÃ3 O
ÄÁ4Å@ Æ Ç!"È@ x./,H
`3./ {| 39O
9ÉÊËÌEQÍSgHÎUU 9Ç!"HxPLJ !) 9ehÏÐÑUjk!ÒÓO 5 123ÔÕÖ×UØ ÙÚO29!L
" ÛJ ÅYs 4E
\3x*ÜÝ-ÞßOVÝO29!
)3 às)4U*áâãä x5@Y¡k@ 塿 s ;U-!:;3 91"<ç>5ä§HèéUêëìí {|
q!1232"×îHïðUØ x!ñ¨39!)
ÄÁ3¦9CWs)<òójkHôX õö )xEQÍSgÈU1"!@
÷ø"sLùúóû+z!U3üý! 2 39!þX) ss +zehs )J)+zÔ!() U
sUeh+zQÍ s29LJ B
! 29 ¡/ O?HJ
!(3 !Uy94
2"éìí {| ?H {U39xssL)Û+0 ähU3923+zÔ#¿
3¦9QÍxÔU39!þX) HU1"
ehÃhÄÇH!U3+
zHS239+zÔ#õ QÍ ÔU323 q!' " 23 s HØ ?Heh+09¯2 331"
*e¿HU3Þß -!¿
HJ9HÒÓU9 H39>+039eh
TxO29 ehH1"U3 >
*! !
ùhO !Y6 jkà3 eh!5àñ
Å !\3O !1 x "U3,s;
3°2ss 8!xÁ
H 9Ysà-
ehùóÒEH./@
õO E ßehÒ O!}? ãc¦
OH_`U391"O
!3 jk
!ef!õÚ®U3§) 9 HN3_`N HØ Us x¿s)@ §
!23 x!
jk£¤E5£¤HϨU39q!þX) UÅ?! !@ ! q§ÆO
ehJH31"<>
eh}/ò<òòä5 O29l HòäH!231"
òäehH !U 3ß5ð!91) H Ø 23 /<>ðU 3òçh! 23 ùóàJä
<=!39s)hc 2
´
<
!"#$%&'()*+,- .'(/01234$%5678&9 (::;
<=>?@AB&CD*EFGB&HIJ KGLMNOABPQRMSLT.UVWGMXB
&YZ[\RM]&(^8_`&Xabc 5defE5de(ghig.j
)kl$%.mno,'ph(
qrsZt)*K, u/0<vwNxyz&{|}B1~
5o. K&
o.'(j*5&__g
:;!)K,g_-_+
2&(*Uxyo,<Q7
*o(7iB& o¡¢£j*_:;
/0Be5 ¤_¥G2&¦8§¨(
)*&i©
ªA5*ig.K«¬
&*®h,¯(5¢°i±!²³&´
µ()*K_¢*8¶·¸¹!ºK'ig )*K»¼^78_-_)./0
B!½¾.¿À_¢ÁÂKÃÄ^
g.'ig
ÅÆÁÂÇÈ&7(É#ÊN*_<vwNj 5 Ë*o(xyÌ*_Ín_gÎÏÐ nZÑ-,ÒÓxyÔÕ*Öר5ÙV_g Ú%.'ig)*8o()*&7iNOÛÜw ÝÞ5ßµÝÞoà&h.xy!áâ5ãµ 78*_g).z(äå*æç^
Ú%ªIèéêeëìK¼,(_- ZíÜÐ&<îïNjxy·ð.ñò _ógôõäö÷«äøçåÚ%*ùú!
&Xû5ü_g))&ýþþKm o(*1Ü&IèéêÌ_©
5ÚÍo(*µ(
+h.xyq*Õ.*
&<vwNj*8 ˬ K^(/0ù o(*)ÅÆNO5goÅÆ N&xy5éÅo(*8q*87 _&ÅÆNO5 Ë-,ào^µ, g78o(&ÅÆ&7iÉ#Ê5ó _ZÜxy&Ä_KgK_
-_<j*igÅÆNO Ë*(NO*8.xy
&7iÍKÐ^(NO.'ig)ù.
/0µ¡ÅÆ*87E®ï¾
¾ÇÈ& 5Z(.'ù.x y!5&o*8.øK'(§
ª.'igÇȬ.'i gBx.'igo(.'(Kxy¡
ª^g*87$.'()
*
&( ÇÁÂ ÇÈ5igNO*!ÅÆ'(NO5 Ë*
o(.'igK¥Ð-,Ð&g(
q&`!&µ\ !rÅ Æ&5Vq5s_g*µ,(
'ÅÆr*qV5®78&
Çig-K'(qù .`!ùÓ5i(*µ,(
1Ü&&^g*,(ÅÆ !&*µ,(<NjJ_g )K xy-,<xyïj
*_^&^ógÅÆN ÁÂÇÈN5*éê*xy5 'K, éÅ_78*_g)*¸¹!&
5gÅÆN*<7
*&e®xy6&B*(
'(5Ó*_= &j*
8ÅÆN5[&5-(
*ig!& !&ÅÆ E®IèéêÌ*i²5 .qKs^()*&(
¥Ðq5NO&5 '!&_)-,`!rÅÆN xy¡5o(Â`5Ð_g
&(<îïNjxyq! Û
;<îïNjH¬ &<j Kñò_g+>-,<Nj®**&x yò&g*7`&
),¨*_*i (ÅÆN!ÅÆNrÅÆN®`!
5o()*ï.'(K .<îïNjK ZÜ!.'!5Çig)*5 _Â&)5_(hg/
0<îïNj5_[[^5 _<vwNj(5_()*' ZÜ/0K Ë*_gÅÆÉÝ Þª#Ê5[E®5µ\rÅÆN®*`
!&®78&o()*Kï-*8&[
çH .'(
A;0X<U&(ÅÆNxyÍ n;+:2&(<øxyj
*5v&j Uxyxyq2
W2Û
!"#$%&'()*+,-./01 2!3245667#5889!7::;
< =>?@AB+CDEFGH12"I456"6#5 8976;
J KLMN5OPQRSTUVWX.YZ[\.YL].
^N_`abK5-cQ*RdTUefghijk lR5mnopqr.stuvwxy*z{e_|}
TUg;~t`5mnoN5)5L*
_'~g=-
mno+P1"456I# 5qr.sN5
qr.sx+qr.s -c6##12356# 'vwe 5¡¢
U£¤_vw'hijk*¥{e¦yi*xy{e¡V;
§.s£¤¨©*5ªbu~«e*V¬e
jkp®¯ °'vw~g_Nt±¬V;
² +³´i>?1µ¶·56#5889 7!;
¸ +§.s1¹º»F56I#5889:¼½ ¾
¿;t5-cQ*Vg§.sÀs*Á~gÂÃN Ĺ'Q{V¡;
Å ÆÇ+§.s1589½;
È N5VÉÊd{VlRËÌtÍUÎ5 L].^NPÏ{eÐ0ÑgÒÓÔ«g*
uÕ¬e¡VÖ¨ ×Vg=ØÙ +=>?1232I45897 ;
" ÆÇÚ< ;
-c#Ûd§.s-c#ÜÝÞß©`
àáââã{eÑäåUe_5æçè5 éê5ëìíîïѬV;
ð.sñòó#¦ôõö÷øùúûü|yýþ èóPô7"Pº:Pý+BóÝÞ ß1-c#Ü¹Ý *AÀTUe¡V;
7 §.s+CDEFGH1245 6"6#;
! ÆÇ+\.Y*Íg1ò.·56"6#5 889!II;
: ÆÇ+³´i>?15889:6;
I OÖ589:
OÖ5889"
½ OÖ589 6 OÖ589:6!
" OÖ589 OÖ589I7 OÖ5889"!½ 7 OÖ589"
! OÖ589 : OÖ589!"6 I OÖ589!I
OÖ589:½
½ OÖ589:I 6 OÖ589:!
7" Rá* ¡eN.Y'{e]fgB
Ñg;T©{e*~g\s_ÑUÎp'¬
e*'g\ _Ñ pÕ'*{
e¡'t~\_ÑUÎ ptu_R{
gÍÐ0Ñg;Ypp·pp
!@"*@ï#N$%*&¡Rá'0~gOÖ 589:½
7 '(+¹A !7#156"6#;
7 !7#§.s+CD127645 6#:;
77 OÖ
7! ÆÇ+³´i>?158977;
7: F+CD127I456#589I;