カウンツ教育理論の諸評価

椙山女学園大学

カウンツ教育理論の諸評価

著者

甲斐 進一

雑誌名

教育学部紀要

号

6

ページ

129-139

発行年

2013

URL

http://id.nii.ac.jp/1454/00001843/

129

àÕ&Article'

'&)(,*12#-/+

Evaluations of George S. Counts’ Theory of Education

‘Í ­v

Shinichi Kai,

.

0

­×¢†¡I½D"‰uHQT {}¶WáA?ºÏ¿®ÔD0S"}¶¢†¡i nkpe&Theodore Brameld'HO»7GwŠWÛ3?[ZqcI 1932 ÆI”yH ¹<C"1930 ƺ"40 ƺI­×¢†¡?@6FIQ2HÐz<?5W“—<?! "!$!#$Yqe]dog%_mq"›Â½«¢†"‰uHQT {}¶

Key Words$Indoctrination, Child-Centered Education, Social Reconstruction through

Edu-cation

$!%"

[Zqc&George S. Counts'I 1932 Æ 2 ŒI­×¢†‰uˆ{ƞ»{I”y(­ ×¢†‰uJ­×¿D0S2T5)-'

&ÁÆI¾¦*€J¬<1 {¼¨WB8S 2T5+.'

HO·I 2 ÖIàÕE‡H‹–;UC1T!'J"ÀI­×¢†‰u¡ H¹<C»7GwŠWÛ3?!f%`&Richard Niece'Eh%afb\&Karen J. Viech-nicki'J"žIQ2H”yIt†W^kqd<C1T!/' 1#[ZqcJ"­×¢†6">I£ßI½«W"OJP™FODJG8"Xko[ ±I´ÊsHV?T {ӚH48:EWݲ<?! 2#[ZqcJ"­×¢†I[o\lnj6"ÃĿك«WÇ©<"=KCIOI I?NHQSQ1°~W±M¤=E“3RUT {¢†¿|IYqe]dog% _mqW„ËH=T:EWݲ<?! 3#[ZqcI”yH¹=TÐzJ"Ñ¿D0TE12OI5R"Ο³¿DÉX ko[¿E12OILD¸ÜD0S"­×¢†¡I‚Hr•ÈÅ¿àµW±M¤< ?! ؒJ"[ZqcI‰uHQT {}¶à6 1930 ƺ5R 40 ƺH59CFIQ 2HÐz;U?5"ÌI‰uÞàW¥Tàµ6Žº‰uW“3TªDFIQ2Gt† WœAC1T5HB1C"ÚR5H<?1!

·Eë„&_]}i¤ƒ]bHàHŠ

* $!%"-+

c%e'Nellie M. Seeds(I"bN)ԍO”H?PG¤ƒ=V:D*+( '1932 <( C"ëP֞¤ƒ¡7³$HÆEQHV$RG[G_‚<"ñ—å¥H“46T• ג=Zû4B2V:DZHŠ<F7TQ"_]}iHº‡G*U<B"¡HëP ֞¤ƒ†7H)đ /F³ì֞/ìñ0•ZDA<B2V!c%eI"°åZ O”=VÖ[Fã7I"€–SUQO<XIR6TñMW"6A">Hã7Hï-@ 1I"IR»KH?PHñÄZŒ>G=Vè<2ԍ(áZUÊ=ԍ‰;W?0• Zõ.D=VD¸4B2V!=FY@"CI">HS3Fԍ0•7"ԍLÌ]b GA2BH_]}iH.ZöD=L8C1VDÖ+<B2V! §!/QÂD<B"c%eI"ÎÓH.ÒGI´+"dN7ÙR<B2V:DGš NB"1 °ÁH«¿/"ԍ/¦SHc$Gœ=V¤È"ê"bvynj[HþH w}q%DH6bØ&K•¶7Ë=V"2 ╶")5•¶¤È7«¿•"ԍ •"°ÁH#£µH¯…GA2B'V"3 ¤È7bvynj[Hg\mvhaF~ 2Iԍ/`D<B—7=V":DZÛÍ<B2V!)ÆEQH²I#JM¤ÈH ²C1V!*,(_{D23H7c%eH^äC1V!:HÍ2I"_]}iHº‡G"}

=Vx%d'Lucia Burton Morse(Rpm'Paul Hanna(HÑHbw}kGQ®TWV! )YWYWIO‰=VíCYWYWHÆEQ?@7ñ8VÜFZ=VC1X3 7"<6<"¾ÞG"ê"¤È"ÇTD<B"YWYWI:WTHO‰Z]Ž=V: D7C8F9WJFTF2!*-( )_]}i?ÅH,óGˆ4VÀH¾#HV$I"#•"ÈB•¶"¬ü/F°æ ½©aG59V¤È©aC1VS3GÉYWV!:WI¤È©aHè<20•D•¶ ¹ð˜"™]Õ"¶-HúHª@;W?Ê9îZG[D=V!*.( W±=WJ"c%eI"ëP֞¤ƒ7éGëP֞/C1V?PG")đ / ³ì֞"Ï:)ç֞6T%Ÿ<BԍùH^äZÛÍ=V_]}iH^äZD V:DD"ԍGA2BH¤ÈH]ŽHøëH?PH¤È¤ƒG3PV:DZ[ò< B2VD23:D7C8V!

, ('#!&)"-+

sh_%f}'J. Allen Hickerson(I"Ï:)當7"\}lak{o%cz} F2<t|r`}gGÚYF2^%t}#u\}lHÆEQHƒïZUÊ<"•¶D ÆEQ7é¨H)CýÁ=V6HS3G"Ý<B8?:DZDA<"_]}iHÑH ®ŽZËÐ<B2V!/( )ԍZZU76=#8Fb÷2Gœ<B)^C1V:DI"ÿM]b/GŒ>C 1V7"Óô/GIó2GœY=V¾¢H`GËÐZY4V:DD85C1V!*0( sh_%f}I"¼;H#8Fb÷27"ßX­"ì›H­\C1VDû4B2

îÅߘŒþ˜ª‰˜F¢\ Vol. 6 2013 5 V!ÞW±Zb0^åJ"§ù"]‹'¥. "Ì)ÎQÙ£Z#D6"ì›I± ]ZÜÍ;V^åJ¨/"ÁêIw~„p„a"ՔŽ8W>­ÀZ#D6V!Þ W±IËÏÖJ"%Ɩ¦…äIìKED.U"ì›I±]IËÏÖJ"z`hÙ £Ö"Ք٣Ö&ÎQÙ£2TՔ٣LIIa)K—%%,>I™[HSVK— %%ZՔ)ëŽEOG;ìKE'"°ODLã8W>b|„z„IÒXIGµZà 1VìKE"³ÂIՔ)Ÿ HB/CÐÿH4Ó;VS0HGAC/VáÛ"I® ݒ"ĒD.V!tl^$j„J·ÖI^åJN?©_DJG/E¼1C/V! (ª‰Ö>@JI>QHª‰;M42!YWYWJF@TIûH^AC/VI2! YWYWJÞW±IC‘éïÉøZE¤8<VM42"´ì)§ùZúë;M42" ´ì)ð¹I>QHª‰;M42"öVG´ìÙ£Z©Ž;M42!=WJYWYW 3‡9C4>7ED.V!YWYWJNºZK1C¨/"ՔÛ"LIô3"¿Q) G`ù*IŠ$)@I>QHª‰D4V2!YWYWJ´ì)ð¹c$IýYU HՔ)c$ZÇFREØÖHí4½P&imbue'7E3D4V2!)+*' tl^$j„J"ÇFRIŠ$3"[„o`n€q$f}„.V/Jwƒs_„k HË88WG/]$w„#z[„oHSACDJG5"ÇFRIó™;VՔHê Zº6"Ք)c$ZÇFRHí4½P7EHSACð&;VEè:C/V!í4 ½PEJ[„o`n€q$f}„E/£E¼1TWV[¸D.V!/ZH"rd[ e$&Allan Hulsizer'++'_{R"ª‰)Ê0Ö>@3ª‰I ”¬-Iug}„Z¯/C}

/V7EZU!Í9C"=IS0Gug}„I[„o`n€q$f}„I=\Z4Q C/V! tl^$j„"rd[e$I[„o`n€q$f}„Iü1NJ"^\„mI² •HA>RIE¼1TWV!929"¿Q)G`ù*HB/CIŠ$)ɼ_I‰ ð32(I^åI[„o`n€q$f}„G/9í4½OHSACR“>9C‘7D .X02!7I*H9Ctl^$j„TIõ1_I.VõT3PNWV!

' $!%#"(&

y${i&Henry W. Holmes'J"1932 5I`H(ªÈIñј)+,'

D"ëMÙ£ )Ì^˜»IËÏÖ>@3"B¾";Ã"A¡"CòIS0GՔI³ÔZÇFR> @H$T<S0E9G/"xv‚„&Thorstein Veblen'HSAC2çD6TW>Wœ –¦Iª‰šZÏAC/V"E<99>^\„mIËÏZ?T9C/V!929"y$ {iJ[„o`n€q$f}„H;V^\„mI²•HJˆ`Zà1C/V! y${iJ"[„o`n€q$f}„I†RZÐIS0Hü1C"^\„mI[„ o`n€q$f}„•×Z<99C/V! ([„o`n€q$f}„E/0[¸J"1 BIš*"š6"wƒa~{IJ². V"S:â)"S<9)ÚYZR>T=0E;V+_Z†R;V!=WJwƒs_„ k"æ."]¶)«R"J²LI÷1Zž†;V!)+-'

²Fâ‚$_^zhženHÔJ‰ <VBI"]zlakvm#dtzYG3U=PFˆ0E6VUM1/!o#qf I.R<ÃHR,FÑMA+U! ãKCH˜F"~¥"ܟ"‘ÜF@+AN¯+ó€0*U!Z†nò*B*U[ ÿI"[ÿHïôYF­PB*UM1¸þHjÞ*/kFR?A“±BÌT{XVG JESE+!7=0?A"“±I"¼DQH@!F+êE£Bnò-YÌT×4UI c0*U!“±IÖE2CQÝAƒBE3VJESE+!.<S2"¸îHSTI" úfÏ#HºiY­PF”b7"ž½Cè.FR?A6SVU÷HQHYMŠ7E0 S"[ÿY_v`suqFÌT9VU5CB*U!5HÀ-/S³-UC1"_^z hI"à¶Enò*[ÿLHúÒTY«?A+UR,F„U!ž½I"­*]ãB* T"DHè.=>LøäÊ0¤72H89U—;"§õYáeC7A…7M3U5C IB1E+!<HR,Fž-U5CI"š¦B*UHOES:"L­PBQ*U!Q >WZ"ž½I"F·Hý´ÊBIE+!·I"LQH£ü"ܟ"§õFR?A' ›6VUª'7=ÈùBIE+!ž½I¨F*U·F@+Až-UC5aÕdèæ9 U/Q7VE+·F@+AQž-U›WH†F*U!7=0?A"ž½FRUi\# gzbI=Ž*BQB4*BQ*?AIESE+5CYe;GJESE+!ž½I ÁÈC§eHhSH’0/S¨öH·H9MAYç1F³g;GJESE+! N="o#qfI"[rv_Hž½0žY©ãH@!FHOFZY®3A"Ɍ *’0/S³-UΖYÂ=E/?==PF"ž0ɌHDHR,EîY³-U M1/Y[,5CIß=E&íB*T"IcE5CCOE7A+U!7/7"o#q fI"ž½0Ɍ*[ÿ"l-J"¡ÍT"kH­*Ó^"™é"neczky#w" m3ðµðÚ"Ç R¦2H[rv_ɌH¨È*[ÿF@+AÅSHì\*¥ÆY @,6;U5CYû@5CE2"_^zhH¥Y]zlakvm#k9U5CF I"(°Y•8A+U! 5HR,F"o#qfI"_^zhH]zlakvm#dtzHfØY`¬7E+! 7/7"ÃHصF"o#qfI]zlakvm#dtzY`¬9U!&¨¹Hnò -I"¨¹Hj\xzpYe9U=PHUdHîH—-0E+ES"ÐcåYÂ> 6E+!Q7_^zh>»0"UdHîH¥YX?EVk*EÛBK2C}BHO “±0o]zlakvm#k9Up5CYcœ9UES"¿IDHfØY¾Â9U!'()% o#qfHË%YDHR,FJ9UM1/!UdHîF@+A"¢ù*Fn:V J"<H5CF@+AQ"n0O/VU‹<å0*U!7=0?A"UdnC+-D Q"]zlakvm#dtzFñ-U5CI"7'HfØY¼DQ=>FÙ-M3U V0*U!o#qfI"UdHîF@+AQ"]zlakvm#dtz|HST B"9EX>"ÖE2CQ"è./SHEAH_$Y:PU‡ë*EQHC7A)Ä 9M1B*UC³-SVU!

à¹Ó’‚𒤀’2™F Vol. 6 2013 (

0 "*-%&!1.

`s{cf%Milton C. Cummings&K"L4'’³K'†IÚ=1ƋöÔ[C8 V2W4(+,&<sub>%1932 (&E"`_{iJ)’³KÚ=1ƋöÔ[C8V2W4*</sub> %1932 (&JǾI¢?=H5US"`_{i5Ú=1ƋöÔ[îAHD2W78 L[>š=H4B@:FI}„JT2I1:[/>=D1W! `_{iK"d$z5^{mblyo$ew{ITBD¤3UX2WFÇø=D1 W!=4="»´›ÏJ”ëÊ&5`_{iJA¼>SJJóã[5Ø>WF¢I" ÜJƋ‘=[åPÎ>!ƋˆJj]$g{c›ÏF=DK"MBòJ>Hü "NBòIïÑ>Wí8Jqx{JüÅ"Oqx{J§;"PT1qx{J ÁÿÉE"QÚ=1Ø Iú@=Dqx{Jä+-&_{5´3UX":JŠþ[¨DÜ}

JƋ‘=5ÇøE6W!=@5BD"`_{iJ7ÃK`_{iJƋ–[ÌÐI ÉE>Wʕ[ÕK>WI>7H1SJE0V"©‰ÿI5ÈÿF1Z<W[&H 1! `s{cfK"°JHÙ5kv$^%John Dewey&4US½À;X2WF´3D 1W! kv$^K"-Jù1»¸J(ªJ·¶!I¿BD1W)ÅâJôž*%1929 (& Jñ 9 ×'78JC~(E"ZXZXJƒ1Gì5ů;XW@RJ›ÏF78Jé 3<WôžJÍFâ[£8Û=HDD1W4UE0W!+.& \uy`{#my$tK ¥RDðçI;XWN6E0W5"=4="%ÁI"?:M¿W*J[€DWN6E 0W! :JT2I"`s{cfK"`_{i5"5ÈǝF,$JJMJý²"TVT1 ƋöÔJqx{n{cJ9­[’³IFæ=@:FI¢?=H5US":X[^{ mblyo$ew{[û=Då#@AI7ÿID3W`_{iJ¬ŒIœ[61 D1W!>HZA"`s{cfK"`_{iJT2IôžJŠþ[ÖI=DºGS@ AI©‰JP["3W:F5"-UIÚ=1mcr[D3"?Jmcr5ŠŸJ±V [,3="?X5Ƌå“[ßÝ>W:F[«)=D"ºGS@AITW©‰I¿W 78J”ëÊ&[Fæ=D1W!

/ #,)(+'$!1.

azplyhbK"1932 (I)¤€FƋÿ—˜*+/&_{[÷="úè`_{iJ<}

[¡9DK1H15"`_{iJ¬ŒI}„JT2I®=10‡[µBD1W! ¦("Ú=1´37[ÀCÞLFK"ºGS5ÒDJËõIåOX"?:Eãù> W:F5?J᎖[.êÿI^{mblyo$l;XW:FE0V":XK|1: FEKH8"Q=YT1:FE0V":J^{mblyo$ew{JÄ+54…[À @H1ºGS[åPÎ>F´3D1W!=@5BD"Ú=1´3[ÀCÞLFK"G

¥5Ôz%`^vh•yPWIË9€ IU/G:~3]vkbjtm$j8YXN42HÒ[¤5C.X!;GZ@"Ÿ °I<ªH1.C"’½IG†GØ!T:~"&Hœ¯ýdeiq3]vkbjtm$ j8YC.XID"Ó9.SI[]vkbjtm$j;X7N3-XEÈNC.X! aunjtgbJ"7Iž„3"Ÿ°IЖ[¦R;XE4"-Xü!P„D4XE 3-X7ES)RC.X! 929"]vkbjtm$drvH9CJ"aunjtgbJ"¼IU/H2û ýž„[8D9C.X! Ÿ°IŒ”}D"ˆÑH"ðD4G.OF_$ov#p]vk[×.;X7EJ“ 8YG.7ED-X!929"]vkbjtm$drvL£À3"µ¦E§#IŽI A¾ýëQ[ãû9C.X7ESFïD-X!µ¦J§#Ià§ý"É6ýäEE9 Cæ0VYXN4D-W"SÀJ 1 BIVéý‚üIšH-W"ß0ŽG.˜B[ 0/§#3D4XՎ3"|ôýՎD-X!œ¯IFï[ÂWÎ6YK"z!¡W ƒ8Y>œ¯UWSosvlvcœ¯[®M;[email protected]./7EHG X!‹ ;YK"U.³CJ"*xEˆÑE./¶%Ù[»@G3VS"ß0<|ô ýP„HÿRXÕLED-X!9>3AC"*xEˆÑJµ¦T9€EëQ;XE¦ 0XN4DJG.!]vkbjtm$drvJ'-XSIIúÊH9C"¢OF> E0‘F¸;X©PýPH3Û:XE9CS"‘F¸D4G.U/H"-X.JÌO ‘F¸8YG.U/H-XSI[i\$f;X7EH÷Ã;X-XÄI•y(*,&_"'‰ ÆÀ[¦±øI¹;IUWU.'Qý1òÀH;XU/Hi\$f;XxÖ[»>G .-XÄI•y(+)&_{E¦0VYXSID-W"]vkbjtm$drvL£IQÏ}

[EX7EJD4G.!ˆ2H"Çñ:~3ÁÀI/ðH{—;X7EJ‘FIIõ IG.7ED-X3"7I{—3"å]vkbjtm$drvHGX7EHJ$xD 4G.!ÇñH15X+úÀ3:~ýŸÐI'òý·»ÀD-W"2B:~41[) RG.Ï©"•yE]vkbjtm$drvJ$z¸8YX-ÙJ-X!929" +úÀ3:~IêéI>RH41E­›Ú[7NE;XE¦0XGV"ÁÀJ]vk bjtm$j8YX-Ù3Í8.!9>3AC"Çñ:~IÁÀMIþð3]vk bjtm$drvHGX2F/2J":~Iه¼îD-W"Jºw¨I:~Iþ ð[=Y?5D]vkbjtm$drvEJQG;7EJD4G.! 7IU/H"aunjtgbJ]vkbjtm$drvL£W[419C.X!> ?9"JºI•yH9CJ"aunjtgbJ">?WýHJ"]vkbjtm$ drvE•yEI™=3«(D-XE¦0C.X!+*& 9>3AC"3J"7Ió… DISÀI™=["•´IxÖ2V§AC.X!=IPHJ"JºDJ•´3@P 9.E¦0XƊTì!IPH[ÞD;XâHi\$f;X7E37NHGX2VD -X!929G3V"-G¡WçT2H"²FS>@3P„D4X+UHGA>V" •0VY>ƊTì!HB.CÞD9"wâHÅK9>ƊTì![41ýH­ù¬ ;X7E[NÜ;X7E3íÝD-X!7Y3¿á8YG.E4"²FSJ"JöG ,HTè9CÛ4X7EHGX2VD-X!

óË囏+›®‹›X¥l Vol. 6 2013 J ˆèMmg4V"eƒxt‚pf5m#I=X®‹NÖMU2LKX! 'S;"Ñ5"àß\r_$o;G1XKV"PV5PVMãWMùœM²;I’ Lõ"AM²;\ø=^_IAM’Lõ\UWU7.ö=X^_LF1G"Ö,Lf ‰¦LŽULKXjK^ÙHPV5ö5=X9I\"P@L*=XÆÃM¦cI> XH0Z2!K@KV"ÑN"PV59MU2Lö5=XKV"PV5¸òI;G¿ YH0XIBÕL"UWp19IMBRL>r;G1X(ßIf½L«B=XIì< X4VH0X!(++& 9MéÄ"®ÎM™ìNJMU2LÍJSBDL<.:YXM4!®ÎM™ì"= K[D"®Î5ÔEG1XÆÿM0ÚN"ù=BDL/©MÈMälKÉoI;G8 ª:YX9ILKX!;4;"®ÎIB<´tLÒX9I\¢EGHNK7"ÍJS BD5ErHÏÂ;"³7=X9I\¢EGMSMH0X! eƒxt‚pfN"ca†qIBjL"+­À£M^}‚cޔ\"+qùÌ\’ LL;Brfw…j$LUEG"„pl#yb$ƒ±Ç4Vz†v†g±ÇOM\ š5TlLKEBޔI'3B!;4;"z†v†g±Ç\Ð3X÷×9báᦠM~sƒI;G"ca†qN…i^Mh{€vk|T`m‚^My]ik|L3e; B+,&<sub>5"eƒxt‚pfNA2HNK7"9M;HNeƒxt‚pfNs€$`</sub>+-&

Iné\B<7;G1B!

( $#%!"'&

m`$%Ralph W. Tyler&N"1944 JMtZ'^}‚cùœM—ÿMBRM›Á MûH(+.& H"ca†qM)›ÁNî;1ޔ1æ\F7W2X4*%1932 J&Lt §;G1X!m`$N"›ÁIh{€vr_IM¡°LF1G"^}‚cHNˆþ 4Vt<VYG1B5"=PGMSM5iI;2X7ّNQC8‡:YG1K1I Â3G1X!1932 JMca†qMá4LUEG"t$N&ñ:YB5"®‹\6; GMޔ—šNuoMÜýIBŒÓ:YXSMI;G")7M®‹ßBDN2nõM ˜KL¡í\ÔEB!AMº"ü$OM¡hLUEG"2nõM^ÊN:ž:YB! m`$N9MA¾L¡s;GˆMU2L»•M–R\¨RG1X! '›Á5^}‚cùœ\—ÿ=XûH\ÔFI129IN"9MtZMd-H0X! ;4;K5V"^}‚cùœ\—ÿ=X9IN"ޔ!ëI±Çô?MD7MúÝï MܶMBRMC¯I;G›Á\œk=X9IIÅB:YXP6HK1!(+/& m`$N"›ÁLUX^}‚cùœ—ÿMBRLÖM 2 FM^Ê\8ç;G1 X!,ŒM^ÊNÍJSM—ÿ"=K[DòC9Kê"QN9ÏÂr""%9œA r\ÔEBù=\‹ö=X9I\6;GH0X!,FM^ÊN"®‹9KޔŸ¬\ "%;"ŠÔ=X9I\6;GH0X!ÍJSM®‹\ô·;O7=XlI;GN" m`$N"z…xd†n"âa\Û[?ùœ\[`L=XSM²G"àßLع^ ¾V8M±µIAYLM2ûH\W2¤”\h3K1ðM“]¼"®Î5ò aM0

³9ބ$`_~j ƒOSKÒ<‰ Xa^h~eJ)RI0“² ƒ"[ž8E0X!9YVKpak]sIØ©Kӝ J)RX9G4“²Kç2F/X! g^z#L"`_~jKˍðSJ½§[Ñ7I4VS"֚KU1J"ˍí Ú"¤»â*K0!KæÊÝ[ɬ=XÐûG;E“²[”M=X9G[“²JUX ˍðGQI=`_~jKP×[86;E0X!g^z#JGCE"`_~jKP ×L"^~nbm{p#dy~G+Kÿè$F$NK·ªG[3RXoiK“²t} czvGÇ>¹1JIXG01KF/X!

& #$!"'%

rx#%Jesse J. Pugh&L"1948 4KS='^~nbm{p#dy~Kl]|~u K’(*,& F"^~nbm{p#dy~J˜R;E"2 DKÍNIP×[ÎWÖ8ES <;E0X!„DL"'=OEKk]#i~cL^~nbm{p#dy~F/XG0 1«Ž(*-& F/W"`_~jK«ŽL9KP×J‚ý=X!ôK„DL"Sï$I GùJ˜;EþPKP×[GXG5"“²L@K¯HK™5[à¶;E0XG01« ŽF/X! rx#LëÌKGù'[‡KU1JÀ#;E0X! '9K’*3V ƒ[´2XßMGL"HK(-40>J\w{`$3[ä;6¨ !=XG01¹1I‹ùJÿE=X!I?IV"\w{`=DL¢REõºI…¡[ J2VYE0X3VF/X!(*.& ôA"°ÌK“²KþP$P×[Nœ=X«ŽJ˜;EL"ÄKU1J<;E0X! Tå”KSï$òE[Ӑ=X ƒ¥ŒJ%†=XCÛKq#fo{k][ÃCA  ¾[ˍ4–¦=XGL´2VYI0!U ¾4•ìJþPKP×[GCE0XG Ü<XG5"õ6K׸"Ƒ;I0PP¬ÙKARJ^~nbm{p#m;E0X! '“²@KSKK@Ï$BÈL"9K£±[ñÞ;4BF/X!®63V"„7JÑ K:YA ƒF$L"¬óK=ˆ$qg#~K„DKá÷3VÄá÷NK(úF/C A!(+)& ;A4CE"'=OEK ƒ4^~nbm{p#dy~F/X(G01«Ž4é/ Q[ÃCE0XU1J¿ZYX4"rx#L^~nbm{p#dy~[µ!=X9G LI0!rx#L‡KU1I0Û[H=Xø¼KP×["€;E0X! T ¾4õLI«A4/XGùTŽ,K„òEKQ["Å=X׸"^~nbm{ p#dy~GIX!;3;"Š“$JPÔ:YAÂÉ[k]#i=X9GL^~nb m{p#dy~FLI0! U^~nbm{p#dy~[ÁÃ=X9GL"êö͛K&“[ÁÃ=X9GJI X! ¾Lü$ÆI[@Õ=X“²—ŸKîðJ)RXO5F/X! V^~nbm{p#dy~L"?±ãK;¬TSï$IGù'K„EKQ[ÎWÖ 8X9GG:>;S.„F/XGL­VI0!^~nbm{p#dy~L˜JG.L

ã¾Õ“†ø“£‚“B›U Vol. 6 2013 3 GÁERI÷:~X¤QVאI[Ü1TR·½8WHKFTF-¼C,V! dZ{k_jym%bw{X=;V>QG"£ÂJ"ê(I÷:~X¤Q"1 A̋ne%{I`ò%FŽïXê(GØ_9F-¨³2,V;NBI„¥1T“Ñ 0RXG±;VS.G"“Ñ0RGÝG<8%C,V>U2,V! e“µJ]y^vxu0RI/º%ª$ÍDFVN3CF-!(JVIä÷Iö) DÞ4Gõ;Vì1J";NBIX‘˜§XÉA̋ÒüI¢.%ì1C,V!)+*' ۜIS.G"pv%J][{h%FZ{k_jym%bw{–0SL“µI"[ aX<8;VD¢G"Z{k_jym%bw{X|-€IG¯$9BT-B-V!F 0"pv%IcI(Š“%G[Ú8W>ÈËXiY%f;V7DJZ{k_jym% bw{CJF-)D-.íLJè’8X©-B-V!’1G"Š“%G[Ú8W>È ËJ"®Ê'C"¹RÞWGñV­Œ&‡í'C,V7DJ;$C3F-!919" Š“%G[Ú8W>RID-/ER"=WXîõÇ9BiY%f;V7DJ"ÙV" ÐèF-9;$8WV‰5æ2,V7DXR29F-Z{k_jym%bw{DFV D·/TWV1TC,V!

!"

H¶J"ÎG][{hI 1932 3I£‚GSV̋ŽïaGõ;V 1930 3÷1T 40 3÷G06V@ˆI-³X·½9>! b%cJ"][{hI̋ŽïaG¢M9"áDΞ£‚2àGáD%C,V>Q G"¿¡%°âΞ&“1TIû D"£ÂI̋YŒXðá;V£Â£‚IÓU æXb@B-V!og]%d{J"ÁERI\%q{#sZ{kI÷XÓÇ9BÌ ‹IOùGA-B"[%[ÜG\OV7DJ"*ÊIÅ7%å^C,V"¿¡}Û Iâ$Iˆý–XS²;V7DGFU"ÔQ¬SURâ—I¬XXÓÇ;V̋% a%zXÁER>?GZ{k_jym%j;V7D2ÓUC,VDÎ#9B"][{ hI[ÜXÅÉ9B-V!919"og]%d{Iܸ"ÁERI…þ%÷^I‚ çXéG;V7DF5Z{k_jym%bw{IS²2EIS.G9B‰51Ia Ÿ2©6B-V!r%ucJ"][{h2̋I®ËXÁER>?GèÇ8<"AS UR,6DPšGÓ3Xÿ5KÎΞXNÄ;¯U"][{hGÀ.;V2"][{ hIZ{k_jym%bw{–GJŸX?L9B-V!]t{`cJ"][{h2 CÏΞD9-Iå^Gõ´;V̋!ÖIqx{l{`XUë9>7DX@ˆ9F 2TR"][{h2=I[ÜGê(>?2ÆVEFSUR=I[ÜXZ{k_jy m%j;V7DG˜ßXÉ@B-V7DX<89B-V!^znjyg_J"ÁER 2çâ1T™H%Fê”Ñ•X“M7DXƒZGZ{k_jym%bw{DPF9B £‚DZ{k_jym%bw{XƒôÇ;V][{h%[ÜX<89B-V!^zn jyg_GD@B"£ÂIÞ4RóI­ŒDDRGê(>?2¦I;V»]IƒAG ;4F-RIC,U"ê(2£ÂD.:«aG+ú9".:Þ4XÉA7DGFV1

ŸøÌ}%ZYzf•|06EÄû€ õ/F+@1C+5A;/P@*R!î4@­ 8R͌E|Ó59\xlhwe ]0(®8ME@*Q"9EO,C͌0¥¿çDF"\xlhwe]盅D°Q ,RA+,E0"öE{'EÉóA -PSR!bXv#F"ZYzfE¹„‡Ù6 D©™U¾3C0PM"íåE¹„ØÈ"˜¦ÑêEÕ¸ËU·œ8R½àA7?‰ žUŠ.8RZYzf繄‡Ù6Uoyl[zcAJC7?",ñ7C+!bXv# F"ÍE|ÓA•|狔ÔúDéLR‰ž0ËE¹„‡ÙU‚:7,RA»ä7 ?+R!nt#F"Ü-C›#E*R)ÞE}Ú&EJU•¬0æµ8RÇ¢"Xz i]hwj#_uzAJC7"‰çD3Å6S:²·UgW#d8RÇ¢FXzi ]hwj#_uzAFJC6C+!8CT<"öF"Xzi]hwj#_uzA•| Uð,DŽ>+?—"7?+R!7/7"‰çD3Å6S:ME@M"‰Àº0× Ý±8RO,DgW#d6SSG"Xzi]hwj#h6S:A -PS"ð,DŽ >2—ÿ;3@FýÁÿ@*RA -PSR!I:öF"Xzi]hwj#_uz0 ×Ý»’è‰DŽ>+:MEAJC7"5SU†ù8R:LD"áç¶*E‰ž‹” UÔú8R5AU±7"ZYzfEO,D¡åçDXzi]hwj#_uzUÛ-R5AFC+! ƑE6ºE,<"p#ra"Zqz^a"\xlhwe]"bXv#"nt#F Xzi]hwj#_uzD÷ôçªÒUA=?.Q"ZYzfEXzi]hwj# _uz6E¯´ºFÜ2C+!7/7"•|0¹„E)ÞD֖çD¼QØKªÒF ˆ7?,ñ6S?.Q"³ìãÊ»’E%E~D‰žA¹„Eÿ1U¯´8R›…F ›PSC+!

œ§"VswZE‰ž•|F"2001 òDÑå6S: NCLB $&No Child Left Behind Act"BE«Mâ1“QD7C+$'E~D*R!5E$2F"˜¦çý!ë"ü¤ CBE£þ¨A7?"8H?E«BMßEï…AωEÃßE:LE•|UÎÌ7? +R!5E#$6A7?"*IQDMkX`gX]`g`hEš‚NVZYzbmw gWU±8R5AF)Þ±6SR0"ZYzf0¼QÆ4:•|A¹„E5E) ÞF")(АD.+?MC.Â/CƒÞ@*R5AU"NCLB $Fµ7?+R! !"

1'G. S. Counts, “Dare Progressive Education Be Progressive? ” Progressive Education, Vol.9, No.4, April 1932.

2'G. S. Counts, Dare the School Build a New Social Order? The John Day Company, 1932.

3'R. Niece and K. J. Viechnicki, “Recounting Counts: A Review of George S. Counts’ Challenge and the Reactions to ‘Dare Progressive Education Be Progressive? ’ ” The Journal of Educational Thought,Vol.21, No.3, December 1987, pp. 149$150.

4'N. M. Seeds, “ Educating for Social Change,” Progressive Education, Vol.9, No.4, April 1932. 5'Ibid ., p. 269.

6'L. B. Morse, “For a Wider Vision,” Progressive Education, Vol.9, No.4, April 1932, p. 272.

7'P. R. Hanna, “The Need for Teacher Training,” Progressive Education, Vol.9, No.4, April 1932, p. 274. 8'J. A. Hickerson, “Right, Left, or Neutral,” Progressive Education, Vol.9, No.4, April 1932.

SOQHEUHKDH]J_ Vol. 6 2013 Y

9'Op.cit., “Dare Progressive Education Be Progressive? ” p. 263. 10'Op.cit., “Right, Left, or Neutral,” p. 278.

11'A#Hulsizer, “The Rural Problem,” Progressive Education, Vol.9, No.4, April 1932, p. 276. 12'H. W. Holmes, “The Teacher in Politics,” Progressive Education, Vol.9, No.6, October 1932. 13'Ibid., p. 415.

14'Ibid., p. 416.

15'M. C. Cummings, “How Can the Schools Build a New Social Order,” School and Society, Vol.36, No.937, December 1932.

16'Ibid., p. 757.

17'J. Dewey, The Quest for Certainty, Minton, Balch and Company, 1929, Chapter 9.

18'W. H. Kilpatrick, Education and the Social Crisis: A Proposed Program, Liveright Publishing Corpora-tion, 1932.

19'Ibid., p. 69. 20'Ibid., p. 69.

21'W. H. Kilpatrick, Philosophy of Education, The Macmillan Company, 1951, pp. 123%124. 22'Op. cit., Education and the Social Crisis, p. 76.

23'G. S. Counts, “Freedom, in Relation to Culture, Social Planning, and Leadership,”&1932' in J. Dewey,

The Later Works, Vol#6, pp#445%449.

24'J. Dewey, “Discussion of ‘ Freedom, in Relation to Culture, Social Planning, and Leadership,’”&1932',

The Later Works, Vol#6, pp#142%145. <@$603587C;16C>9=B?$:ACI[Z0

-*.2"T`(87C;16C>9=B?$:AC`1\F1WM)X^<@$6HGJ_V 43 N"2002 Y 6 L/P4R+,!

25'R. W. Tyler, “The Responsibility of the School for the Improvement of American Life,” The School

Re-view, Vol.52, No.7, September 1944.

26'Ibid., p. 401.

27'J. J. Pugh, “The Horns of Indoctrination,” The Clearing House, Vol.22, No.7, March 1948. 28'Ibid., p. 398.

29'Ibid., p. 398. 30'Ibid., p. 400. 31'Ibid., p. 401.