冷戦体制解体とアジアの「奇跡」の終焉―アジア通 貨金融危機の本質―

冷戦体制解体とアジアの「奇跡」の終焉―アジア通 貨金融危機の本質―

著者 涌井 秀行

雑誌名 明治学院論叢. 国際学研究 = Meiji Gakuin

review. International & regional studies

巻 18

ページ 47‑85

発行年 1999‑03‑31

その他のタイトル Dismantling the Cold War System and the Asian Economic Crisis

URL http://hdl.handle.net/10723/1602

!"

#$%&'()*+,-.

/0123456789:;<=>72?@

ABCD)E FG H+

IJKLH4MNO>2PON 6QR;STUDHJGVWXY Z[\STCD;]^Z 7 _`.ab A>

cd eMefghiVjVW XYZklmnWW^oVj+pCD .qrG+IstuJG AFN2'(c dv\KGjwj'(xWyz{7

|}GK>_~;?j€m.‚Pƒ

„…HG?† ?‡ˆ1?'(cd‰Š‹

2?Œ87G6A

jwjŽ?‘7’“F”•G–

—˜G ™š›7 œ.

ž2ŸDG  \A>8G jwj¡\‹¢

£¤‡¥jwj‡¥.¦§

56…¨8?©;ª@ A£¤.«“5 6¬­…N£¤H NG ¡®¯2°±²³ .ab´µ?N¶78·¸¹•Gµ… ºA?»>£¤25?¼2½¾;P?

…7F$NF¿G A 7j€m

ÀÁÂÃG2¨@ÄÅÆ:.7ª¿

OÇ@6jwjaÈÉ56…HÊ

?ËÌ'(cd.Í¿ƒÎºMMºA Ïjwj7@ KÐ;ª6<HÑ [;?„GŒÒÓ?ÆÔ2Õ@6A

jwjËÌ'(cd<Ö

× Ø Ù &

ÄÚÛÜ7ÝÞßà á Û Ü

á ÝÞßàâãäåæ7?2…á ãäåæçè

ãäåæéå ãäåæéå"L

‡ˆ1êëìí7jwjËÌ'(cd á jwjËÌ'(cdîï

á jwjËÌ'(cd

¦åðñjwjŽ&PòM7GËÌ'(cd7Yóôãä ájwjŽ?22¨@H NF …

á +õZ7Gj€mö˜÷øùú 7ûüoýôþ›

á j€mðñ  £

á j€mðñ  ûüoýôþ›

á j€mäL â­á

M7$ <j€m7jwjŽ

!

"#$%&'(&)*'+, -./0123&4'5 67'8 39:;<='>=?@A2BCD EFGHIJKLM0NOPQA&R STUVWXYZ [\]^_`XYabcde8fAgh 3&4ijgklmnaMnop'39qr' 23&8stuRS'32A34

P92Dvwx

yzyl{c|}~)€3‚3ƒ„…

3&4

PQ†‡†ˆv32†‰Š‹

ŒŽ‘’“”}(•v–32 3&40—'2˜™š›œ

žŸ#$h  ¡Z¢£

¤¥¦§£¨h%&4†‰Š‹©ª

«¤¬­®0˜&¯°±²0³´² (&°Sµ¶·¸'39L¹º„»¼f/

Q†½¾¿À'ÁƒÂÜÄ'39ÅÆ8'

hǤfAÈ¥¦'8

ÉÊËÌ'39Í6S08 ꐑÏÐw Ç¥¦'8Ñ 9•vÒ'Ó94ŒŽ‘’' Ô=ÕÖ'×£uØnÙÚ¥¦0Û>

rÜÝޕߣ;PQhžŸ´

à†‰Š‹•áâh£5'3 9ã’h%&4±s ä å 0æ猍è>rVÝ xä 0éê4

dž‰Š‹0ëZì(í•hîÝ 25&xyïT†‡†‚ðñZ0òó Çñ2†‰Š‹Ç"ô25

&'39äõÐö÷ρøùúûïú{

4üý'ýc¸8h34†‡

†þïHIJúû'ú{09

& 8'Â '3€

3402xyïï0

2†‰Š‹Q0å

¨ 02%ók

C;Z049€&' úû%&hj94 G'39¨ ¤0 «ª

/QœÄù†‰Š‹œ

žŸ¥¦#$ùxy Dvù2¢U*¸4P Qc¢}±œ0˜ó¸¤

á œð†‰Š‹

zyl{á 3œ¸ðñZ½Ðƒ

œÇùh%&4œ¸ï

*¸'½Ðƒœ˜T†‡†

ð'2Q†‡†þïHIJ 05ç&P'4PQ

h%&4

œ¸'áâüA&á

<0' u l{¸

'9&áâ¢Uì3

&h†‰Š‹0'(&zyl{á

·¸P'h%&4PPhœ'39

œzyl{á «ªl{¸' '39 ï°±uA2/Q

¬L¹32/Qh3P '0(h%&4á ~0

&¸'š«ªl{M' 05P'Pzyl{¸£

h%4ÎÐ ‚°

h¢25&'”“”

ZkA9 @&'39 Ò8Q34á s

¨h¸0çÄ0›

4P9œzyl{¸h :&A908234

ï°±uS

n0C}4áⵠʵ

¦á 'ùB

ï0ü'°±SnÊï

ÊïïSn0CÒ

œ¸*¸'†‡†ð

!"#$%&'(%)*"*

+,-./0,/1234"56 789:;<1"$=>

?@<ABCDEFG21H<

IF4"%JKLMNOP0QR STUVWXYZ<[\]^_`1 a<%0bc4deJKdfg h(i^jklmnopqrs_`

1a<UVWXtutvwxy^j tzde{|itz}~

€‚ƒ„'…g†‡%$$

%opqrsˆ_‰ŠUVWX‹Œ€

‚ƒ„Ž0LMg‘‹@$%’“0

”•€‚ƒ„4–—˜™`%

š‰Š›"$%A+,-.

œ,žŸD ,¡¢_`

£‚¤¥Q¦Q§¨RŽ©1a<

ª «vwxy^jt‹Œxy^j^

j¬tz‹Œj­/®¯<o‹Œt

°±²skŒ³´|µ#$%

+0‡¶·¸¹º¬»,xy4t`^

j¬³´xe³´t¯<¼½³´h(

kŒ³´¾%¿µÀUVWXLÁ

‹Œxy,–—Âo±²Ã+ÄsÅ Z1"šÆ,DZÂÈÉ«<Ê^j/Ë

*ÌÍÎÏ"šSTJKo_Ðs:Ñ

@<Òә԰ÕÖ×vwØÙÚÛ"

ÜÝÞÛßàQáâ¥Rã¾%

»,xy4t`"*äåæçoèésê u8ëì^íîã¥NUêïu8ð ñ+·¸òó«¾%‡¶

ôõST<tö|÷øtöSTùúû üýÅ$þ‡¶ªo#sû eh(% %š<,0¶ó

ª àOk¯<

^j1AAÕÔ 14"A:¾UVWXx å|TJK÷ø‘‹àOã

RR£ÛßSToQRâ 4VXsÌ«T%$T

@$%‹ŒxyçLÁJK_

Ð ¥§R[oÕs

¯<"<

Å6‹Œxy,œ

Ì«T%š@$%"³´_S TDT<T½

<@"6_$%

ª =BCDEAµ<åºA 6ST '"

de¯<o[4±²sk 1a$ ¾$%B¢

‹Œ1ãP1H"û1a*

UVWXT,-b1«"<"

$[4±²k¯<

2Ó0ÓSTTÀ"AÈ*

š !{$%UVWX1 1<"š'

%b ÅÑZÅUVWX u84:¯<å

–µÑZÀ"|"$

UVWXJKR%

® ¶o(sH

® “<"š"$%

$ 1a<%

JK^¬³´|Ì 1š"<

ªui¶4"$%T PU UYZ<

k¶%ŒµUVWX tvwxyU Ude"›([

¯<,`%Ö|TU UYZ

<i^j6a%;a|T0 LÁ¯<›([ÓQ

‚P‚ã;šô þ(ªUVWX <Ü

›([g"

L¢Ó"|tó

i^jì^U Uos

!"#$

%&'()*+,-./0)12 3456 78927:52 6'78;)<=>?@ABC?57

<278DCE?5FGFH8 IJKLMNOPAQR

; STUVWPXYZF[!\]^

_<`aM(5Fbc(d (8e<f5gUhijklmn8^9;<?o +QRpqM(rstufgUvwxyz {a|}~P€f‚XƒR d(lf{„.…<†!(

‡.ˆ‰B5mn8tŠ‹Œ

ŽneX[‘’“`a<”•.

–—v˜-™šPX›pqM (rsœ9žŸ;œ 

¡RM(LM¢£)<¤7

¥¦§¨©.ª„?pq«¬­®

¯°l±²pqr³´µ¶F·

¸¹º»¼F½'wx.*+¾B UV¿ÀÁÂP€<|ÃP|ÄÅ

f{aÆÇÆDŽ

ÈÉÆÊËqqÌ.ÍÎ`a¹ÆÊÏÐ

·ÑÒ.ÓԄ?¿ÀÆÊÐ ÕÐ<P„Ö×´ØÙ.ڃRl

‹ÛÜÝ:‹ÜÝÞßà?ÏзÑÒáà ÈÉÆÊËqâeãägU6 åàQæ çèlPwxžŸféhêë ìQæaP€pqM(íîï<?ðañ„

?4wxòó<e|Ãaã ägU D|.wxLMQæ

¿Àlô­õf{aö

¨R÷wxø?}.<„?

|apq«¬¾­ÔD?¿ùúûM (üúûâý.þ|

P|‹4q+`a÷f{a .ÓÔ¿ÀÆÊMáÃaíî ï{a|í -r^9;¿À|

æP|ƒƒÆÊoMwx<÷¡R

¾`aÆÇ)<

fö2v˜-ee

¢ZMP.P€B.{aÈ ÉÆÊËqâF.`P„

ÆÊ6 ‹<’“

›awxý<?ÆÊ

_<P¿ÀÆÊBR

·hi9; ^

<`a5†!8¾QR xP€

ÆÊ_.à?TXRÆÊ

¶f`aB<.P„

¿ÀM(›.‚

Xž4÷F.ƒ¾a¿ÀM(¾ BRSTËv`aB<RXf{a 2f|Âqq<P„?

RRXqhi¸<|

Cf¯lq{af5GLq 8f{P¾X¿ÀM(

¿ÀM(58<|C^¥¶<

M(÷qfe{„q

flP¾>QR

X­®.Cƒfü.

qؾQR2¼F<A .Fåý.|B

<|C XP|

ü.?|a

BCM(›.FØ

AR{¾„ ÓüFØ

.¦§á.›a

ƒÓf.ª”EA

^{9 ;}.Fbáf|Â

}~gUágUvwx ÓüfÓf .BRX Ó ŽÓŽ

pqM(LM<258­õ

!"#$%&'()*+,-&./

012345,6 -7 089:;'<=>?@ABCDE@!

FG=5, HIJK!LM*>

NOPQRSTM UVWX!* &' >Y-

&Z[\]^E_`aZbc,RU- defghijklmnodep@

==> &'UVqH$%

70Z,&derstu*vw dep@xy,czl!{|}

~CB€]‚^]Bƒu „…†

‡ZˆZ‰}uŠ~^]‚‹]Œ]ƒ &

+[Ž‘’“-”•–b c,—]^˜™]vw* šZ,HI

›œUžŸ ¡u+[¢< &' 6£¤¥*+,—]^˜™]

6¦§6¨©ª 6¦ §£^~ƒZ,

«,¬­-®UV§^~ƒ&¯°=>

[n šZ[±Z²”'ŸU³´c[

µ¶Z[n

·¸$%‚-®Ž  šZ, µ¶œ¹º&Z[¹,»¼

*½¾R>&|¿=>, RšZ,œ!¥PQ‡Zˆ=>

,u6NÀÁÂÃēÅZ,

* ÆÇÆÈp ɞ'¥Ê˳ÌUžÊÍHÎO=>[n

=PQHÃÏ}Ð

>ē*ÑÒzlÁÂÃ

‡ˆÄ“Ó&6Ô&<6NÀ

‡ˆÄ“ÕÖÓ[× &!

=ØZ<H‚PQLjē

Ù* &ÚÛ'Ü¡Ó[

& &!!·Ý$%-®Ž n4 FÞP'+,ßÆ6NÀÕà'Ä

“á¾RZ[6ē}6 âēã±Ó &! >

6n&ÑÒzlU-ßÆu äåæ!ç«+[n, &ÅZ[n«, èé'Ž ên+[nëHÆBìC ÏÐēÕÖ,nZ[íîïð'ñò ÏÐóô=!õö+[n÷

®UøùØZ<úûZ[ü&÷ýþ!

©>[<«Ï}Ð>†­!…†*

6„¨þÏÐē

£*! šê6…† Ï}Ð>ē! £c[n PQ!*&Z […†U- !“n!R …†Ï}Ð>!“n&nŠš >

„¸O…†U-Ï0‰} &

+[†HøU-0Z, &ÅZ [n >U-!¥@ß]

‡Z>,uÓ&zl'¥-® 

'n¬­@ß]‡Zˆ=>[n&

<-®Cp!S =>[n'nßÆ

ÆBìC]C

«,ñòëH¦S!

šZ,.-®¬­2~@ß]ƒ‡Zˆ=>

[nH šZ,œUž!

üÖ¡'<-®Ÿ U- Z[n+,‡ZHÃÓ&

ɞzl!cFÞ P&'+,ßÆ ÆBìC

&“<'+[n]C! z*&<½z‡ˆó!

Án.2&nš›

'’÷š' !*+,R>

6 „ŒÉžHø

J,cz!²”'‡ZˆZ³O

´c,u*&<ýHŠß Æ~6 ƒ^~ƒÆ B ì C

~6ƒ^~ƒ“-”Ž*

>¥›'ŸU³*+, >ýH‚P QOuŸUä,cqH$

%Œ]Ç!&g.‚

j&.2

! ! ! !

!"#$%&'()*+,-.'/0 123456789:.;

<3 =>?'@*+,-A-'/-B+C" #$

% & $ 'D*+4E'9:F/G@ E"H+!IJKLM34C ;

NN9OPQRS*+,-.QT"/UVWX/Y&Z[>/\&%]&/%&^/_`VaAbaQcdeI*3/fVa/$UV g/h$i/jk/almAb noOPQ"pq*+,-.;

decrstuv w K OPQ x y z{|cfVa }z& f~W^  x `Va  Q € Q  ‚ # $ $|h

ƒW`„V …| †‡>

W $|h ˆ‰Š‹

ˆ Œ ˆ Œ ˆ Œ ˆ Œ ˆ Œ ˆ Œ

ˆ‰Š‹

ZˆŽ

‘’“u

ˆ‰Š‹

ZˆŽ

‘’“u

` z | g h $ i

j k

$ U V g f V a

ˆ‰Š‹

ZˆŽ

‘’“u

` z | g h $ i

j k

$ U V g f V a

ˆ‰Š‹

ZˆŽ

‘’“u

` z | g h $ i

j k

$ U V g f V a

ˆ‰Š‹

ZˆŽ

‘’“u

` z | g h $ i

j k

$ U V g f V a

ˆ”Š‹

ZˆŽ

‘’“u

` z | g h $ i

j k

$ U V g f V a

ˆ‰Š‹

ZˆŽ

‘’“u

` z | g h $ i

j k

$ U V g f V a

•–—˜h&

!"#

$ %

%"&'

( )*+'

, - .'/

!"#

012345 6789:

0; <5 67=>?@:

!"#$%&

'()*+,-*./(0(1 2345 6-7879:

;<=>-?@AB<CDEFG4 HI787<J,)KL<=>- M+NOPQ787RSTJ*

UVWXYZQ[\]^_Y`

Q[\]^_abcQ[\

]^_*deIf^^]_ g,>-hijklmnopq0

>rstuvwQ[\xyz 9{(,>-rstu|}><=~(78 74hijk€.7$‚

ƒ„+t…5 †DS‡

ˆ,>-?‰*Š‹<*ŒEhŽ

< ^hi ^+f^

‹‘’“7*h^”•

S–—+a@ac˜l*h ^™hi?@š@^ +›‰^œ>S^]_ža@- 787Ÿ *hiQŸ <{=>-

.¡¢£¤¥12¦!5 6})0§2lm¨|,

>)©@-ªŸ *d« *?(

¦!¥lQ¬ ­e)®

+ 787¯lQ6°¥±g<

+b+)²³,>-<*+´¬

*de®,wµJ¶·¸¹º

»e"#¼½¾¿{ÀcÁ Âà ,>ÄÅÆÇÆ&Á ÆÈ ÉÊaË­e®c;-ÌÍοÏÐÑ=>7 87Òl*)Î@Ó®+¾±ÔÕ Öc@-y«×Ø*Ùa®ÚMœ

@+b+-)(ÛÜiÉÊ­«

-ÄÅÆÇÆ&Á Ýg*"#¾¿Þ ß·¸,>}z+,-®

?àÑ*áâã°ä787åæçN4

™èéê¨!ëÞ{* ì 4}%&$Ƒ<{=-

?{?{äíîïðñ«<,ò@78 7óôçõö²÷)™èøùú û½*Eïüý)<=>-?

þçõö²÷*CD0(+787 )²÷ ÇÆ

=>}>äÇÆaw

@-)(787²÷*çõ ]‹ ä7f_7

$‚õô çõ787

ˆ)^]_­« <=>-?õô Ö¸â çõ õôac¿õô«<787a@

-)çõÌ¢<*‹&&Ä

&% çõ¸0!Ï |a@?@078 7}>rö ä

¸a@-{(Ûyä<=

>-h®c  Ö +ç õPBM)«@787<óÚ 4}>Æn+çõçN 4a@-)@*]h_7873 éêlmçõ}>é ê<= ž+‡Ï{,>- )±,be* ò4

±,®ˆµ+c+,-40>¥

¥¦ @±+@

µ+c+,-{+@µçõPB

<×çõ*M«MQ«>-)

*?787Õ{9N787çõ ã°+ ™*ä787™

3w>¡Ã„-Ã

<=>-

) |N0(- !

*ú“‘Æ ˜l

ââ787äåæ

" #$%%&'()*+, )-

!"#$%&'( ))*+,-./

0123456#78&'9:/0123

;<6=>?@ABCD"AEF C G*(/0=HIJ&@AK LMNOB(PQ*RSTUVC EWX&'JYZ@AE)[

R\]^_`Ca23bJYc(

A>d!"(e\fg#h6*K ij!"(kilmnoAp7AQ )"q*(&'#rs6tu/0#vwx6 23y#6z{/0BqC0|}~

*PBQP()"q*b€

C‚()/0UV>?Cƒ"

„lm…o*†(‡"ˆ‰O;KŠ‹

PŒ)PCE)=Ž*(

!"/0>?M NAE)*[‘=(=‡"q /0KLMNOB(PQ*R STUVCEWX&'JYZ@AE)

’%AE;A(*

/0“0RSTBC)’

%AEe\fg#h6=Kij!

"kilmnoA”7AP(’%

RST=9•(&'–—=˜Cƒ"„(9

•/0*(K&ˆ‰OBCQ(

/0*;KŠ‹C)’%PR™

šA›‚(R™šL’%O"

„(e\fg#h6/0L‘ƒ=lm noAœKij!"O(žŸ C lm…o=¡TAEQ)CPc¢£

e\fg¤‡"qˆ@A‚

>d¥/¦k`O)=˜"„(lm

§¨©ª«©¬­¬®¯°±²³

^

´ (µ¶·¸¹(º»

œK

#;KŠ‹6

¼?

´

>?

œK½Ž

¾¿^ÀÁ

>d

KÂ

œK

>?

>d

Rij

HIJ&

KÂ

HIJ&

Ã Ä Å

hÆhh h

>d ÇAijx

R È lmno

´* ^ lm…ox;KŠ‹

x $%&'+,-./0#ÉÊx®2345±6

x¾Á78&'9:/0#ËÌÍ(/x®23;<±6 xz{

xÎÏfg

!"

#$ %

&'( )

*#+(,,-.+/01 2

3456$

! "#

$%&'

! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! !

! ! ! ! !

! ! !

! ! ()*+,- ./ (01- 23456789:;<=>?@6AB 456C@DE =FGH IJ4./=KLMNO 56666 HPQM6RST5UVDEO 566W5XYZ[ C\69T]6T\^_T`6a:6bc6da 6]:6Ta66:e6]f6STgRT H=>h6 Wij5klmnoc6d:g6a6:pqCPrsNH=>?O WijWV= RSTtuv I+451w@DENx6 RSTtu IJ4PI+4MNOyz{6;< Nx|}6~*@r€Ql{E?O VNW 456W  =>?OVNW RSTv I+45W  O

!"#$

%&'()* +,- ./0 1213456789 : ;<=>>8?@A./06BC D=>EF:GH912I<JKL MNOP'QR=STUVLMW X6B')Y/A./0Z[6B'(M) O:=YL\]^_`abcdefg '(</0hi;KMjhi9kl=m9 no7DNOM)Opqrs=

V123tuv:wjY/A.

/0Z[6B rs=WXtuvo:\M xL'(M)*yz{|L1 23}~uv:\ MO'€M)QR

=S‚ƒ„A…†‡ˆAWX‰Š‹:

LŒ WXtuv'O xL'(M)H]jŽWXoj

‘’zoyzy“'”H•–hn /0uv—˜ •–WXtuv —^{™ š}›œ)O

w”M;<yzžŸ ¡¢¡rs=

y“ ™£ yš uv

—^™š˜ 12t¤-L¤ - —Š¥¦§¨13t¤- L¤- —^™šŠ¥ M)©

ª«¦¬“­®=WXuv:

w¯]12t—13t —^™š'(

M)”LWX°±²:(³]NNO )y;KMWX°±²´=— µ¶—y'f·¸- —

¹º—´=—µ¶—»e

—'(M)O˜ WXD=¼‚'”H

—^™š½œ)WX=¾:GH0n

¿À./0s4567ÁÂ<^_

6BÃ-ÄÅe M)

ÆÇÈÉNj¡¢¡ÊËoj7ÌoY /A./0Z[6B6ÍÎÏÐÑÀÒ(

MOP¡¢¡ÓÔÕÖ×'w ÉNhi9kl=m9nØVÙPO ÚۛM)jÜżš¢¡0n¿À

•–WXÝÄcÞßoLàה

jÜżš¢¡0n¿À •–WXÝÄcÞ ßo:\Mj¡¢¡ÊËo¡¢¡á=

âãÑäåÑ¡¢¡jÊËoæç

™š

™š

™š

™š

èé2êë

™ š èì íë

é2ê:îPPï)