Kymlicka's Theory of Minority Rights and the Situation of Korean Minority of Japan
著者 KIM Taemyeong, 金 泰明
journal or
publication title
明治学院大学国際学研究 = Meiji Gakuin review International & regional studies
volume 19
page range 35‑66
year 2000‑03‑31
その他のタイトル キムリッカのマイノリティの権利論と在日コリアン
URL http://hdl.handle.net/10723/1503
!"#!$%###
&' (!
&&$&&' ! $&)&
!$ !$)'*+! &,'
&- .$ '/!!!
&&
'0$!
!&',$!$
!$1 '
$2 $& $$$#####' !$
$ ' 2 ' &$3&
! "##
# "
# $%&'' (
"#)"*!+)"
"
, "#%-"
##! . %/.#%''0 +1"
*
2 3" #
""
" #
"## # 4
#"
! ) %'%5%'0-+6 6 # #
### $
7!8! # 7!8 # ! #
$ #! ##
1.
! "#"
!
$"
"%
&"
"
" & "
"' "
! " ! "
"( " "
)"
"*+"
,(+,(-./0123 124
"
-.55&( 6""! 124&667 #8
* &
9 9! "&
9! #*! &"
&
!
! "
"!!!"# $ % " # &!" "
% % !
' !
!( !"
!"
" ! % ) # %" % !!
! * # ! "
$+)'(% ,-,.!# -'
#! $!
$
%'/+0/
! !"#$"#%&'!
!()
! !
&
) !
"#%& *!
+++++ ,!
!! -
! !)
./"#&+
' ! ,
!
'
!!
//0!!
1!
) #%++++
' '(
-(*((% *!
2+ ! 2 '3 4! 34
!.) "##2
&++++
&%++++! 3 4034 3 3*!
3 3
' ! (!
(' ,5 ,
! "#$%
&' (
% ) * +
* ,"%
- .
/ #0/
/#""' #0000##1#""2
'000&000
% 3* #4
5/
6 )7 )%
*% 8 7
!"
#
$% &
& '
" &#
# () # &
' # &
""
# *
#
"
# # # * #+
+# # # # #
#&
# , ,
' #
&+ % - %
!
"
# ! $ ! %
!&
'! ( "
"
(
(
#! ! ) * + * ,-*.//012
*
!3///
0014444! 5 0 .36* ! 7 8( 9
! :.; %!.
! " #
$
%& ' (
#
$ # )& *( + , # - - ( # .
/0 .' ,
&1$
# #
2 , 3 3 3
$ 4
4& / /
* &5/''6(00 # 7( ' 8 9 %
&&
.$: ( :
!" #$$% &'( )&*
+,- .// /.0 . . '1
)$+,.%
- . . 1'
2. -2.'2.
.34!5565) ' 7!/36 +8
-2./ 9 .:9.% /
.1'&;
<2. / ) = 2. &*' )2.9 9$'>.% /?
+ /. .. &*
8 -2. .%
.= 2.
'1&7
)2... ) &*' . .3;
+)/ / ... 1'(2.
=89($ ,=$2.
! "#$"%
&' ! ! !
! !
!!()
*"##+ ,! - !- ' ! %
& , . ,! % !!/*. !!0 1
2 ($
- '%
&' 0!!
3!2!'.
! . !4(#
- '3'5+ )6"##7&
8!4(
&28.
(+9
* ! ! :!. +"
! 4!!
! " "
# $"%& ' &
!!& ( )*& ! !+
& (!
* , -* * !
! ! +(
)(. ! !
* !*('*!
! ! / !01
*' &
, 2"! *
!- 2"* 3 - ! 4" !2 *
"5 6 ! ! - ( , ! 2
" 2& "7 ( *!
!&! $ ( *
,1 *& 2 "*8* ! - *
& , !9*1
!) %:" ! !*1! ! ! *!
8(**2"+55) !*
*- * 1
&*(", *) *%/& ) *
!! "#$ ! !
! %
& % ! $ ! ! #
$ ! ! &! ! '
!! ! () () ( )*
+ , &! ( ) '
-
! - ! "!#(!% ( . ! /
! !)&*
01
! , !! //
23 4! 5!
!! !!$
+067
% %!
#$!28 - ! 2!,
!"
# $ % # "%"
&
""
"
'(
(&"
&#) *
##&
##%(
+(+"
(
%"
"
%
%( ,-
!"!
# #
$ % &' ( ) ' *
+( ) ('
%& ,-.
' / ) ' 0 1 '10 1 * #
#% % %
%$ % 2%
3 1 *0 1041 0 1 !".5
1$ '6 &'%
! !
"#$$%&'
"#$$%#'()
*
"#$$%#+#
, -. /"
"#$$%0
1
2 3 /#$0$+##
4 ! /
"
#$$%'
"#$$%$
.
5. 657
!!"#$%&' (' ) %&' '&* &' %&'(
&
&&&&
+ & &,-' .' &&
&
&/' & &&&
/ ,
/& &0
&&
&&1 &
*.- !!2 22 2#
. &
&
&
33.'. & /
4 & / &&*3.'3 !55 2"2+ 3.' (
&
3.'
%&'67 8%6-
!
"# !! $
%$&#! ! &#! &#!
' ( )(! )*++,*+
"# "
-
! . ! / 00! /00 ! ! !
0"
&
#! 1 0 ! ! ! 2 ! ! .00 !1
!" #$ #
% &
" '
&"(()* +
!
' +
,&"(()""%
- + +
& .
/ 0%1 /%2
& +
$3 !'
,&"(()
1
.
. ' 4 5
/ 6 7 /
! "
"
# $% $ "
" &$''
$ () *(+*
, "
- $ , $"
, # ,"
#
$ "$, . , $ /
0%
" &$'
&
"
1 *$
+
$
$ "
% " "
&$'2
& $ * $ ,
+ , ,
*# + 3- + ,
! "##
$ %#
&# "' (#( "
) "* "* # !
"*'
+# ##
,#
#-.#$/01
" # 22 3# #* "* 45 .#$/00
,6 +#-
"*,&78"&
!
!""#
$#%&'"
( ##""
")*
+","#"
"#"#"
""( &' #""("
"",)-.
/"'""
#""
#)+"-.-
+##$
## ##"
#$#( 0' #"
#)-0 '!
)+"-11+#
+( # #+ ""## #2&#
#"
% "
""# $$3+( #""3 #&$' ##"#(
"#)+"- 1$43'# #3"
#567#5#
! "
#
$
% ! !
" &
" "'
(! %)
* "
"*+
! &
" * ! , * - ! . ! / *
0
(-
$$/ ! 1
$ - '
$/ , 23 , *
!"##$"%$"%&'
( )
)
"##$"$$
) '
* +
,
- "##$#&
( ./ ' - . '
. '0. ' . '.
'"##$$"
* ' . '.
( * ((
' 1 02 1 (
! " #
$
# # #%#
"
& # ## % #
#
' (
# ')'
! " ! # $ %
& ! '
('
& )
*'
&" !' ')+,
*--./' ' 0 )
! &
*
&'
&* &
''
' ' * ' ' '
!1/ 1'
!
"
# !
$ "
"
%
& ' (&)*& &*+
&,* ! -'. /&)*0+123 ( &0)%
,0&,*4, -23 25&))67&&))* 8 ' &*0
7 5(.98% / :'
; <-=2 = 2>6'7&))4
+ ( < </9 -(
< =5< 9 -
6 ?@(A<% -&))+
7,
0 ( - ("
< 8 5
&),1 3 -&))0&6
, &))) ,+**7* &&0&)))
#
611111&))071071*
)61111
4 &))7 +14*47 60 B '&47+*) 70
<5 .
9 5
!!"#$ %&' ($')*&"+", &"+++, -"($' !!"#$ .+ ##'%
!!"#$ + /%+ ($' +0""+" /%($' + /%++ +.+1 +"2 &,- "1 3(
4--/ 2/"'%
5 6 2+,"
",+- "", ++")2" "# ""55 "
7(' "7"%
2+,' +,"# "# ,5555*+ + 8 +"",# 8'+'
4--/75
7 5"' ' 5577 $ #
& 75(
"&",+,"
' 2"%$ #
&+5 +, "' ,",5555(-$ 2# +- "#'%
,
+,+", ' 77 +", ' '#'+"+, +", ' 7 '#'+" 5
4--/+"8'&#
6 &
8#4--/ 2#
/"'%
2' ,, !"#% +9":*'0
'+-.20"'
!"#
"$ %"
&'()* """
"$
$
""$""%
( + $+",#
-"+ ./ 0 1((&2
&2 '((345 $67867/6 7 7 $9" 9"
:"
& 779 ;7;, <&=2(=3
&& + ./ 0 1((
""$>" 7
&< 779 ;7;, <&=2(=)
&= 779 ;7;, <((
&) 779 ;7;32;+<21((&&<&
& 779 ;7;, <&=2(==3=
&3 +00$"# 779
779 (' 9?
! "@"1'1 ((&>$A0 7>","#75, "B7(=(1'()# 779 +66+,((3(
& ./ 0 1((
&( 779 ;7;3(;+&)((<)
<2 .7&<C 779 ;&; ;+)
< ,4""#"# "
"6 "
4"$""
%90 (((>7",!
!"
<& 8"((&
<< 1 D(())
<= +$&=,((
<) ; "./ 0
601 ," 1
! " #$% & !%!
%'& ("
)% !& %! % ! )%
*+ ,-%
. && +, &/ $%
%% !0
&& / 1$% !!!
%% ! ' &2
/ % &&% 3 & & &, %4
54 6'%% ' '!
& &&&& % 7
"889.%
5 !& ' 7'% 7 7 4:.
,88,2. !#
;7#7<
:52% ! 66/=6=2/:540'!
66/=6=2/0'!
66/=6=.4=,4:
66/=6=.=,:0'!
>$(+ / *6 ? !#;7,!
"889("#$%$ #*68 8;682
.(&#*,2,
:, , . 6
", 6 '@ A B C#<<<2%<? >+&? 7 2 &#
+ ,-(63%-D ;& *$ B:0!50'!
+6 :10 66/=:=/'=,
+/'( )* +*?8
#
+30(<'/ +% *, +**
8& / 2 & &$%
!""#$ $%
&'()!" # $ % &'
"%
%(%)$*+(,%
!
%*++! +$%-
%#+, +#-#-"./%%0-,1 2 3#, . #3-
,+#-#-"..%%0-,12 3#
, . #3-
%(-4!,"%%56$
1%%%.$( 56$
)%%%/.$,"%)56$
!056$
7 - 78+9'-#-( (' ' ' 1 %!0-:#(3 &#
;.-"8&)- -$< (%(-4
%56$56$
;--& + 5" ' = ( ,"$ 1 56$56$
:23 $++4 +4 %+%4
-=!) >=#'9=-3-6(4 %5#%0)?@"-".@
A-- B@
5% - ;; @@>(.9 4 /6
:@= # " $#
3#<( + 1,4 1% ,)0-#(3 ,&#
:
(%))&#
!" :;
% )*!1 1 4 ) '- 9%
0< 0:#(". ".$=#'$%
%%! ! $@
:: #- ?+((# --
0%%.$2%(%% )0-CCC53
%(-9 $;". #$% ;$&'
!
"# $%&'$%&
( ' !"# $%&'$%&
)* +, -.&&' /&+&0 (!, *'1&0
*
"#21&3*4&"&
