責任能力判断と精神鑑定 : 最二小判平20・4・25判 タ1274・84(刑事)
著者 緒方 あゆみ
雑誌名 明治学院大学法科大学院ローレビュー = Meiji
Gakuin University Graduate Law School law review
号 11
ページ 111‑116
発行年 2009‑12
その他のタイトル Criminal Case Study, Assessment of Criminal Responsibility and Psychiatric Evidence URL http://hdl.handle.net/10723/936
0123456
789 !"#$%&'()*+,-.,/
0123425,6789:;<=>?
#()*+,@9ABC,D:EFGH:IJ KL(MNO*P#,QR1STU(V7 'WX#YZG[\]
X,R1*$^8_`KWaJbO%
,/cd%eP#*fghijYk l,mn/G#oXpqkPr,s*
fgtjY:sGuvcp,w9#
xyzp{d|}~G1*J
s*??P 0`K,:
#,`1k*<A
<I4A;<IJR1,`l
0?/PG:
P89(;<* ¡*¢£(¤
¥9:
¦t§*¨©ª«¨©ª¬®¯4®°4±²
«¬³X'´µ¶·¸¹'9º»¼*¶·,
½¾G<=¿µÀ*Á ,uJ÷G£ÄÅGÆÇÈ ÉÊ8:N9,QGËÌÍ(ÎG:ÏÐ
«¬³X'´µ¶·¸¹'9Ñ»¼?
¿µÀÁÂ,uJG(¦Ò§*¨
©Ó«¨©Ó¬®Ô4Õ4±Õ,Ö
×W¬Ø ¡ÙO1`K,xO1CÚ(u 1NJÛ3GN*NJAÜÛx=ÝI®J GbÞGWNJ,ßR1º¶·v`àѶ·
áPdW?*JGâãGkP 9,~G,G?s9, äå0¿µÀ*ÁÂ,uJÃ^'9æ _翵èé*ÁÂ,u?*JKêd Pu1JG¦t§¬ëìíGÈÉî8*
ïÇÄÅG:N9,QGðñÍ(kG ±:òÓ«Õó¬ëìíôõG
*`K,¬öG:
÷1øù
úût
Aüýþÿú0Pu1´µ1*¢£2à3Ð 4à,N9(¿5þÿú0,6O78*¢£2 à3Ð,9s*Ø(´µ»þ*
\Pu1NJ,X(9]1´µ»
þ"*x(¶·hJG¾JW1 ,¶·*Ö8$ ¡,(ü¹~
¶·*,(u~R1WaN9 GW5ÿWCÚ(Ã^'91*PW
~s*x\, ÛG÷Rêd?
*JKêdPu1:I
úûÒ
A9*2!"#*$78P<¥9
<,9ó¬ë*%öR1CÚ(u 1X'Js*NJ*,`s*<
=(Cý*5&'(ðÝR1 ¡ )N*ðÝ,*<+R1 ¡,0-
*PW0¿µèé,Ja7JÃ
^1NJ./Pu1J¥z1W:I
®®®
012þ34þ564þ3789:;8<¦®®=>±°°²8>®®®?®®¯@
A12þ34þ564þ3¬BCDEF
GHIJKLMNOPQ
RRòÜS¬±°4T4±U¬V®±WT4ÔTÇCRR
X Y>u Z
001 23456758975600
!"#$%&"'()*+,-./
0123456789":;<"=>1?@A
#$%&BCDE"?F0GHI?2"JKLF MNOBPD4QRS"T0U234VW"BX MSYS0Z[\]^_`abcdTJefYR .ghJK.Nij0VW"BX45kalmc dnJ4OBPaopq.N
r stuvwx
y8z{|02F}~7}~7"
0c34}~7,D467"0?
g"aq.%&)-DQ"
0V3Gq.%&)-2a4~7
,D467")2^"%&aq.
0c3-2)4"%&"c ¡cd
a¢£q.¤7B¥¦01z¤§¨¨,2F_
`)BXn©ªc32.Nd^c4Q"~7
~7"9 DKJ8«n"l¬JK .Q,MS4®¯)~7!JK.M°c
D~7!JK.M,2F#$%&"'("B C°8«BCJK.Q,0-.d±46789"
²³°´Bµa¶·c-2¤¸¶·kN¹P¥
º»{0z¤º¨¨N#$%&"'("BC0Kd3 D467,2F¼5½¾¿)À±SRRI d^Á0~7~7,BCq."JD-
4g"Âaq.%&,"0 V3Gq.%&,2F~5½¾¿aÃÄ3 ÅÆq.ÇÈJK.¤É½Ê8¨,2F")4 BXËk"ª/JK.Ncd)34Ì"6 7Í0Îc323°4"gÏ"[J~7
~7,BCYR."JD-4ÐÑ67 Í0?4%&ÒÓ%&)-2M4dD
c ¡cd0KdMEFM)*+,- .N
!"#$%&BC0c3D4¹P
¥º{Ôz¤¦¨)®¯)ÕGÐÖ 0
Îc32dMS,234"Q,^×JØÁ 0®¯)~7"0Kd,YR.°"
JD-4"#$%&"'(D4®¯
"ÕGÐÖ"Í4ÕGÙ"¼Ú4ÕG"
ÛÜÝaÞc3B9qÇÈJK.,c34
¹ß´,c3à±3áâBCabcdNãP9i ä4 JK3°#$%&aå9q.j æçBX)èé31¤êëìB¥¦0¦§¤Ô¨4 íîßB¥¦0ï00¤»¨4ðñßBò0Ôó0»
¤{¨4ôõìBò0»ö0º¤0÷¨47øì´ò1÷
ºz÷¤00¨4êëì´ò1000¦¤01¨Ý¨4BX"
D4ùúûüÝ"ͽýþ0Øÿ01YR dÕGJK./"[)~7JK4Ri 2"/0D"3"4567¤Í,ÕG8
"94ÕGÛ"_%<4ÕG0.J
"g4ÕG"Ü4ÕG"4ÕGÐÖ0 U23"4ÍÙ"<,ÕG,"<ݨ
,"ÞBC0?3#$%&M9#$%
&MaBCq.0K.¤0z¨N
5kD47q.,4675½,06 789aÌc3#$%&aBCqÇÈJK., q.ª/¤0§¨,4 ½ª/MSBX¤Ù!¹ß
´¥"º{#P9¨"ÞBCa0$q.ª/¤0º¨
,0%×.Q,)JÈ.)4´BµD46789
"²³a&Ì0opcdnJÞ½-BCajc 32."J4Ï'0Q"öU"5k"(ª))*
+q.Q,D,-2¤0¦¨N
- u./0
123456789:;<=>
O?0123@éYRdöA"B0?.89
²³0U234¹ß´D4}O?GC) "ùúûü001YR4K.2D4R0 DYRd°"JK43ÊJEF-GH¼Úa I[J.%&aKH32d,c3°4RD2L ÌÐÝ,c3k3)%-MNJK34 O?GC0UÈ4®¯)g"a
q.%&O@Q"0V3Gq.%&aK H32dQ,aPc-2,2F_0123Q Rc32.NQ"?F-S89D42TR°UO
½0ß2:;<aKH32.,2FÇÈJK.
,c4#$%&BC"V,-.¼5½¾¿
JK.67"'(O@W@0QR)~
01234567894 70 !"#$%&'
()*+4,!"-./012344 5677!"89:;4<= >)77
?(@ABCDEFG(+H1(IJ K LMB$(N7OCPQ4RSF K"?TUV'F$>0
!"WXCRS?YZC[L\F7]A^
F_`a,b`a cd?WXe!"
fgh!"iEjCk"F7`l,Og^
(+H1(m&4nopq',KLMBrsK
$U('F7tuvw]
xyz{|}~
}~
- 5C)7A'1
M -4jC6() 7A', Ck"?H¡c'(
$>¢^]-,£+ ¤¥4g¦§¨
©ª«89¬$_;4®¯ Oc°
$_;±fgO8²ª³4´µ 4¶·Ff7_; ±¸$>A'qK
¹F±º»4¼½F¾OB(7
5C)f7¿ÀÁq>)7#/(
`l23CÂ6'^ ÃÄIJ ÅÆ pÇÈF7]FFABMIJM¯É
$,ÊË23`lCÌpF7',ÍÎ$>¢
^tuÏw]_`a4fqcÐ4,/(`l 23CÂ67A'C^ ÃÄIJ Æp
>M')OA'Ñ4g)£+
¤¥¦§¨©Ò89¬$ÃB7_;
4- $,(pÓÔ 4'@Õ)7'KLA',ÖÎ$>'
×S(YZC\F]FF_`a,b
`aCsK$U('?4'@Õ7
$>A'CØÙ14K"FÃÉ$,(
tuÚw]Õ7-_;'OÛÜÝ Þ2j?(Ãß±à8g7£+ ¤¥Cá )7-âãdä'OÛCÜ ÝÞ2V'Ý?A' $U4_
`a,-,忦ç# èé4êB
ë$Fqì/ íÞ2î,ÙLÖÎ(¨
©4ïBÛCðñF7'ÑMB$>
Mb`ag^4Ûðñ# ÜÝÞ2$
>'òó?,ôõ$,('^TU$>
V'`\F7tö÷wtöuw]
ø ù}úûü
_`aý'Fà¬þÿ >0MB]
12ÿ,!"iEj434`l 89'(550123fgAB H01 234567894,7 0!"CPQ4RS?TU$>'?67 C\F7A'$>]_`a,!"C@
RS?TU4891(Í,) (q!"'^%&%3òó 4c"67C567q'Fý >'ò ó$Ug^tööw]1ÿ,£+ ¤¥47áF 7ÊË23`l48 Úa"$\0B7IJ+`l'^
ÑCF7$ABC0M4F7ÿ$
>töw]Aÿ4F,+1(34`l 4õ7)!" @RS0B "
$(p34`l89'(I<=4 4g!"CRS?TU$>(M !"C!"?*+,qߢ®OBC n#'F734`l4fq$à
%IJ &'?'F7*+4,OH¡C+
H14($U(ÉB (M('?)` * 6MBtö+w],¬-.`a$,>
_`aà/401234526°!"$
$>'^78 \0B74qà Mr-ÊË23C9"F7I:q;
töw]7F4)`< 6=?g^4 +1(34`l4fÉ!">?oÉ,Ö Î(<=$,>]FFÊË23`
l,34`l$,>q`@,0 1$CF($>M!"
78CbA'FRS?TU$>'F7_`a 7<,Bõ$>¢^]1þÿ,12ÿ4C
?A'$> _`a - _;
±¸$>A'CK¹F77¶·C uu DE`Fö÷3G3öH`Iuöv+3Ï+HtJIw
01234562789712 64762 6234 !"#$%&'()*%+, 62-"(23'14 7./64%+01"262(
3,456789%+:;.89<=
>?6@ABCD"+:
EFGH"@ABC6CIJK%
LMNCI(7O%+:;
.89P6+046'"QRC623 EST62@ABUVB(W1 23XY%Z[-\]^!
"_32-"(2'1462 Z`abVBcd64e.fgh(iO
%(3j^"k06'6l.mn(
op67qr89"st64 n%uv-2wx"+2(I2y Hzt-"{|}~:3^6
623W%(e.f "3 2(Z[-\]3:
("12F:,6 2yHst6233890LM.3 2qrv%(t"}
~:&'CIJELM6+
Y'3^*"_32(l.l .614"}~Y&%+
^8¡¢0
e.f(£.£%(+7LM ."2:¤¥¦l.£ §¨6 __©`ª«B#$"_323ª
¬®:&,3^./641"3 2®\U¯6CIJj^0°Z`abH
±²³´µA¶·FG"¸O:¹"2:
l.=l.l."LM."_32 7º&»¼½%+ ^8¡¾0°.£
¿ÀÁ!430
e.f#Â62ÃÄ76+0
§ÅÆÇÈÉÊË̾¡<Í89¢¢Pξ¾ÏÐà ÄÑÒÓÔÇA[ÕÖרÏÏÍ89¢¢Pξ¡
ÐÙÚÛÇÜÝ.£XÞßàáâ¡89¢¢Pξ<Ð
ÃÄnÅãäÇ.£ÕåæÌ9¢¢P89¢¢Î¡¢
ÐçèéÇnêA[¿ë9ìíÍ89¢¢Î9<
ÐÃÄîÅïéÇðAÈñØ×ò¾ÏÍ89¢¢
ΡÐÃÄ0 óô
õö°e.f÷øùúû8üý¦.þ9¾Ç ÿÇ9ë012345678Í9ëÏë¾ë¾¡"940 .fj}~(tö%F3430
8bH6h3O,8h
j6623 ´-zé-v!" "2J 23#$O%
"7123&0'(ã8)*+,-.©`
/012Ì3458667¾<Î<ÏÐ9¾Ï Ð0
88e¹n9û:é;<=Ì62>?@A 3BI2¥¦l,R+5&5LM.
*^,CDð:ë<Í89¢¢Î9ëÐà Ä0
8ELM.§¨©`FGNH
I"6Z[-\]"½4»¼ NH"_32©`²[HªU
±6JK123&"l.L .5M8b"jNO#$
P3»¼Ä%FW4FG"_32ãQ .234^'6WRS6+
'J312{k"j12T9é 6Z`UV"1234CI(WX Y4£0e¹(ð¿9ìÿ;ëëÐà Ä.£%Ý9¢¾¡Í¾ëÐÃÄ"7YZY2 30
8í𿾢ìP9Ð0
8ÿ.£%ݾ¾¢¢Í¾ëÐ04ª²(A[
.62T9é(Z`ab\Z`UV\]
^LM%+3^ /:(_Y pl.`6©`ªaI4+JbJK 'J¥c-"LM.F^01"2 62îÅïé3LMA-.,ðA ÈñØ×ò¾ÏÍ89¢¢ÎëdÐefg ,ð©`ªh58-i²[j.k9¢¢Ï
Î9<d9Ð04l6LM6*
l.l."32(l."¶:»¼6 º&34Iªé(Z`ab±A[.
628/:(m&%+
6Z[-\]"262(FG"_
32nH:(o\%+0Ùopq3L M6*l.l.rstH û5M,u㯢ìEÍ89¢¢Î
¾¾Ï ,8v[wº[A/º[wxØåyÉØ5z¾¾Í
001 234567899715079
1
7 5 !8!"7
#$%5&%5'()!00!
*+,-./012370817 08+,-./01237001077 00+,-./01237017 07+,-./012371881
0456789:;<=5>?@ABCDEFG H0"788I!"
0JKLMNOP=QRSTUVW=MXYZ 8[\]^_`JKabcd=efYZg
_OhijTkl9:m;<OnUATo pklqrstluvwZ[\]^_d=9:
;<SxyzU%5wOU{|}~l
YZ8[\]^_=Q}{Z9:;<}
nUSvh=OnZP=
SzPTwO ~u9:m;<Tz
ATu|wopstU{|}~vP
=}klZ8JKabcd=9:
;<AM10""I0"
01Z ¡¢£¤¥¦§¨©ª«¬
®¯°M±«²Z788!I!³ 0!P=}klZ456789:;<A¥=
´788I7³
0vµkZ¶5·wi5·=¸¹Sº»O
~uTzU¼½¾~¿ÀYZ¶ÁÂÃ=Ä}
?ÅÆh=OnZÇȾJKcOnU[\]
^_}zU5>OnUPT}ÉÊSËz U ¡Ì¶Á^ÍÎX9DEFGH 0!788I00
0ÏÐÑ9'(5XÒÓÔÕ788I0!"³08
0" ¡Ì9 Ö000P=}kl YZi×=9:;<5>=Ø¥wnÙ}hÚ ÛzÜUPTOZÝÞß=JKÄSàá}â ãO lu~uPTSäåTklZJKæyS çèk~u\¿¾~Äw»étU=O~
uZê=ÊSëa}ìíkl»yz
h=Tu| OnUT5îzU}ïv=O Y~uT=wîstluUÏ9 Ö 00!"
78ð×OJKæySñòkvóLôYZõö;
÷YZ½øáTeù=úûüwý þÿ÷OY~ÆZá}ul=0¿12 wõö;~=3|}nUTkluU4 59 Ö77¶5·SqrkZ¶Á=
eù1OnU6789d}zUY ƾ?Shv~uZc¾Oõýö
;~h=TU=wþÿOnZc¾~
9STzU9=2µS
lZêP=à S!"zUPT}YÊ
#w~ÆZ9:;<5>S$UPT}~wU
TzUTklZ%¡9 Ö1"
70¶5·wõö; =&'}ul5>Sîk vPTYZê=JKLM(=ò÷YBTklZ íË~ÊSÃzUTkhZ8õö; A Tu|&'þ½}êt)3=íË Y~uTz UTklZ4*ß89:;<=+A(,
¥M§17788"I8³0
77P=}klYZJKLM=-ßOnU%5 Î=NS»év(OZ.ʾ9/0M¾~5
>S1éluUTh23PTwO Zê=Ê#
OYþÀ0w.Ê}4UPTS56zUh=
Tklh¸¹O UTzUhnU789 :89:;<=5>TæyA¥M;<=>!
788I0!
7¶·ySZ2#%)?1"I·y{ð@ABC DOZJKLM¾}EF=XG<SHluU æyOntZê=¦\¾5>=Ia}ul h{ìízUJK SLM±kvh=TU NOwnUTzUTklZ¡PQR9¶S
8TUV%5W%5S3|X|Y%5W 2ZT½¥©[B=\]¬9:;<A^
_`a1!788I1
7789 Ö770!ÙvZ5wîz¦
\¸¹Tu|!b}{lZæy}cUJK LM=d<YE¾}eÙluUT=!"
hnUfgh38JKæy=ijT+
k´TlåAmàn¦o¤p¥JKLM
ÁTJKæyfqr8Z788!I
*
71®¯O%6s78I67t5·5uvwZ xyfZuz{U|g;}~ßÁ¶
Á}klZ[ð8ß=æyßw9:
;<~kTæykluUR\}Z%5&w
9:;<nT5·zUPTY stUA5 071788"I0!³0YZ9:
;<S÷yzUæySZ=~u%5Î wQz=Y-ß5>=º»}~UTkl
5kluU
7!æy}{UTZÝÞßYZ8ß}kl<
SUuwsvZkvzUPTY
uPTAT=»SÃkluv
74*9 Ö707³1YZ¶ÁY~
uk=»Ynvh==Zê=²
¾Ê#Sëa}¿zU)3=`Yklu~
vT¿ztZê=`}lþ=
eùS2zU¾~nUZ=;<
ShlYu~vTkl¶5·T§
}zUTzU
7%¡9 Ö1"vµkZ»;<=
¡}¥9¢¥=`Bc{£ê=5>}{Ue f=JKÅÙO¤ÙtluU=µTzt¿
ö;OnUTzU
7" ¡Ì9 Ö000³00
8¶5·wZ`;<}ulZ}Y]zt
001 23456758975600 !"
#$%&#$'#$()*+
,-#$./01234/50167869:;
/601<234/0=10>?:@ABC@DEF G+H!IJK$LBMNOPQR$
STJUBV*+W#NXY+W##Z[
\]LB^K$_`abcdeBVf
%+H!IJK*+gRahYiajkal mnUBo$+Gpq+#rs +;Zta,-#$uvwxyLBz G+bcdeaBV#H!{5|aIJ},~
B5??=/5??16?:;