͉̲͛ͅ
ȁΧȜϋ͈ޗ͈̥̥͂ͩͤͬࣉख़̳ͥષ́Ȅ൳শయ͈ୌ؎̤̫ͥͅဢڠࡄݪ͈ૺೃ͂Ȅࢩ ไ̈́උ৪ͅࡉͣͦͥޗ͈͒۾͈ࣞͤͬ͘ণͅਓ̤̩̭̦͛̀͂ශةͅਹါ̜̥́ͥͬ া̱̹ത́Ȅಅඤຳঙ͈ࡄݪ͉ࠨഎͅਹါ̜̹́̽1ȫȃ ȁ̺̦Ȅ൳শ̠֚̾͜ͅདྷ͉̞͈͉ͦ̀̈́ͣ̈́Ȅྶহ૧ոࣛȄޗ͈ঐ൵৪̦ু͈ͣջ̽̀ ၛ̾ၛݗതͬࡉ̾͛ೄ̱Ȅুࡨ٨ڟ̱̹ͬषͅȄୌ؎ςϋΗςΒθ͈ࡄݪ଼ض̷͈ͬܖ ๕͈̱̠̱̹̭֚̾͂͂͂͢Ȅ̷̷̱̦̭̥̀̀ͣ͞ݙͅȶུޗȷ͈ຽ༑ͬୟޭഎͅୌ ؎ଲٮͅอ̱̠̳̭͂ͥ͂͢ͅঢͥఱ̧̈́ഢ۟തͅΧȜϋ̦ݳ̵ࣣ̹̭͉̞̺̠ͩ͂́̈́ͧ ̥ȃ ȁ̳͂ͥ̈́ͣȄୌ؎͈௰̥͈ͣဢ͈ޗͅ۾̳ͥ۾͂Ȅུ͈ޗ̥͈ͣୌ؎̫̹͒࢜ࡤ ͍̥̫͈͂Ḙ͈̏ඵ͈༷̦॒̳̾࢜ͥ౷തḘ̷ུ̤̫̏ͥͅͅޗͅచ̳ͥΧȜϋ͈۾ ͬպ౾̫̿ͥຈါ̦̜̺̠ͥͧȃུა͉̭͈ণത̥ͣȄ̩͂ͅȜσΛΠ͈ȸޗޗၑ࿚ ൞ȹࣱ͂ന૯൸͈ȸఱޗఱփȹ̢͈̻̹փ݅ͅࣉख़ͬح̢̠̳͈̜͂ͥ́ͥ͢͜ȃలˍડȁȜσΛΠ͂ȸޗޗၑ࿚൞ȹ
ˍȅȸޗޗၑ࿚൞ȹ ȁ1890ාːȄρέΟͻȆΧȜϋ͉ͺις໐ͅইͥ͘ಿ̞ၫႹ͈ྎͅȄ൶ͦྪͅࡉ̹ ̷ུ͈ͅల֚༜ܱ̳ͬȃ൚শͺις͉̯̥́ͭͅͺΐͺ͈ౝངܱ͞ၫ࣐ܱ̦͈̯ͦ͜Ȅࢩ ไ̈́උ૽͈ಕ࿒ͬਬ̤͛̀ͤȄ̹͘ୌ؎ဢڠࡄݪ͈อജฺ̞ͅȄဢ͈ਕޗȄޗͅచ̳ ͥ۾͜എ̞̹ࣞ̽̀͘ͅ2ȫȃॠধͅࠇश̯̹ͦౝངܱ͞ྔ࣭ฎ။ུ̱͈ٛͬ̀ম ͦͥͅܥ̦̜̹ٛ̽ΧȜϋ͉̹͘ȄέρϋΑ͈υΣȜ͈ȸུͺϋΕυΐȜȹ3ȫ̱ͬ̀ ུ͈থ͈֚ͦ͜ͅȄ൳̲ಠ৪͈ȸུྶȹ4ȫུ͉̽̀͢ͅͅਊޗȄ૰ൽȄޗ̦̜ ̭ͥ͂͜ܡ̞̹̽̀ͅȃ ȁြࢃ͈ड͈ै̜́ͥȶဢల֚ȷ5ȫ͉́Ȅ̜̭̦̫̹ͦΈΖΞͻΛ·̈́ဢͅ ̠̩ͬ͢͞౾̞̹Ȅ̷͈૧̈́ޥ̧͂ۜ൲͂ͬȄ̜̹̥͜උ৪͂൳শ̥̻ࣣ̠̥͈̠͢ͅͅȄ̷͈֚֚ͬଠș̱̞ຊ౿́ຝ̧̱̞̀ͥȃ̭̭͉́Ȅ૽͈͜͜͜ة̥̦̯̩͜͜Ȅ ໓་ͩͤ̈́ȶမୈ͈࣭ȷȶσέ͈ଲٮȷ̜́ͤȄͤȄ૧֣̈́ય̦ষș̹̯ͣͦ͜ͅȄΧȜ ϋ͉ޝ͈ࣞྺͤͬဲ̢̞ͣͦ̈́ȃ ȁ̺̦࿒͈ஜ࡛ͦͥͅমͅ࿒ͬࡉಫِͤͬདྷ̞̹ͦ̀ΧȜϋ͉Ȅ̱̩̳͊ͣͥ͂၂̧̻ͬ ৾ͤ࿗̱Ȅ႖̹͈̺̠̥̈́̽ͧͅȃ؍ຩ͈ځ̥̈́ͬา̫Ȅུུ͈͈ͬࡉ͙̹̞̞̀͂ ̠এ̞̥͉ͣͦͥࣼͅͅȄȶ২̦ٛ་ا̳̜ͥͥশܢͅȄඏட̷̭ͅව̧ࣺ̹ͤͭ́ၫ࣐৪ȷȪ10ȫ ͂Ȅুͣͬજ͙ͥဒဉͬॿ̳̠ͩ̈́͢࡞ဩܱ̳̠̞ͬ̈́̽̀ͥ͢ͅȃ৬̧̥֨࢜̽̀ͅȶΞρ ࣐̫͒ȷ͂ྵ̲Ȅང͙̹͈ܱ͉ͦ̀ͅȄ൚͈ࣞလ͂൭ଜͅȄۜޟ͈̩͘͘ளೄͅຊͬ ڲ̵̹ͣ༭͉࣬͂։̈́ͥȃ̱̩͊ͣশ̧̤ͬၪͬਹ͇̀ष͈ఘࡑ̱ͬठࢹ଼̱ೄ̱̹ ͈̜̠́ͥ͜͢ͅএͩͦͥȃ ȁȶΞρ࣐̫͒ȷ͂ྵ̲ͥΧȜϋȃ̭ͦͅ؊̢Ȅএ̞̞̹֚̾͒͂८ͅ૽ႁ৬̵ͬͣͥ৬ຳȃ ൽș͈໓ࠊȄ५ུ̩̪ͬͤ൴͒͂ൢͥਔս͈အঊȃ̤ͅ४̱ͤͬȄܐڥ̫̳ͬͥளཀྵ̈́ ྦྷ̷͈͂ަȃ̴̞ͦ͜ΧȜϋ͈̻ͬȨ̫̞͈͉̞̏֨̾̈́̈́͜ȃ ȁ̺̦̭͈ࢃ̧̩֨ͅඵ͈̞̾ٛ͂చდ͉Ȅ̷͈ા́ष̜̹̞̠̽͂ͤ͢ͅȄশۼ̥ͬ ̫̀Ⴏ̜̬ͤͣͦȄࢹ଼̯̹͈͉̞̺̠̥ͦ́̈́ͧ͜ȃ̷͈͉̭͈͈֚̾ਯ̱̹͂ͩٛ დ̜́ͥȃచ࿂͈ਯ͚̥̽̀ͅΧȜϋ͉ޗၑͬდఴ̱ͅȄୌ؎̤̫ͥͅޗࡄݪ͈ड߃ ଼͈ض̜́ͥȸ༷ങȹ̞̾̀ͅࢊ̵͙̦̽̀ͥḘ̏ͦͅచ̱ਯ͉̹̺؋̱࿑̞̽̀ͥ͊ ̥̜̹̞̠ͤ́̽͂ȃ ȸ༷ങȹͅਓ̹͛ͣͦࠐങཱུ͈ȄΫȜσȄΫνσΤέȄέͿȄΟͼόͻΛΒȄ Ήσϋ̷͈ఈ͈Ⴛै̞̾̀ͅة̮̥͂ࢊ̵̥̠̽̀͂͢দ͙̹ȃী͉߹̫̩̀ͦͥ ̦̭̞ͦ͂̽̀ܨ̻̦൲̩အঊ͉̩̈́Ȅ͈࡞̦̱̩ͬ̀ͦ̀͜Ȅ֚̾ ̈́ͤ͂࡞ဩͬ༐̳̫̥̹ͩ́̈́̽͜ȃȪ22ȫ ȁ̠͉̭͈͌͂̾͜ͅܙ̱̞̀ͥȄނ́םࢊͬڠ̺̞̠ͭ͂৹̞͈͂ٛდ̜́ͥȃ ͏̞ͅང̹ͦٸ࣭૽̦ޗͅ۾ͬা̳͈͙ͬ̀Ȅ͉ಢͅΧȜϋ͈อ̳ͥৗ࿚ͅ൞̢̀ ̞̦ͥḘ̭̏́ࡉ൪̵̞̈́͂এ͈͉ͩͦͥȄਲြ͕͂ͭ̓જ͙̹̭͈̞ͣͦ͂̈́ոئ͈ؿਫ਼́ ͉̞̺̠̥̈́ͧȃ ȁ̦ΧȜϋͅ࿚̞̥̫ͥ ȶͼϋΈρϋΡ͞ͺις͜ͅޗര͉̞͈̱̠̥ͥ́͡ȷ ȶޗএேͅ۾̦̜̞̠ͥ͂ഽ́͘܄͛ͦ͊Ȅ൚ఉ̞̳́ȷ ͉͏ཱུ̞̱͈͂ͬ̀ۼ̥̠࢜͂ͅȄ֚ॗ͈߿ུͬ͂ͤͅḘ̻̏ͣͅओ̱
̱̹ȃࡉͥ͂Ȅ̷͉ͦȸޗޗၑ࿚൞ȹ͈םࢊๅ̜̹́̽ȃȪ20) ȁਯ͈͂చდ͉́Ȅȸ༷ങȹͅ࡞ݞ̱Ȅᱳș̹ͥୌ؎ޗࡄݪ৪͈ྴͬႥݷ̵̱͙̹̦̀Ȅ ༐̩͈͉̥̹̽̀ͥ̈́̽͜ȃ൚ட̜̠́ͧȄۧങ̻́֗Ȅਘ࣐ͬୟ͙Ȩ̱̹̏ͬ̀ ਯ͉ͅȄྴஜ̪̞͉ͣী̱̹̭̦̜̹̱͂̽̀͜ͅͅȄୌ؎͈ͺΟηΛ·̈́ޗࡄݪ଼͈ ض̷͈͜փ̩݅͜ڞ̹̹̽ଲٮ͈დ̱̥̩́̈́Ȅਯু̦ͬ౾̩ا۪ޏ͂୪̳ͥത͉ ̴̢̜̠͉̥̹ͤ̈́̽͂͢͜࡞̞̺̠̽̀ͧ͢ȃ ȁఈ༷Ȅםࢊ̢ٜ̳͉̞ͬͥ͂Ḙ̭̏́৹̞̦םࢊ̥̹́ͦޗවͬ͂ͥͅຈါ ͉̭̜͈̺̠̥̓ͥͧͅȃխ̞͉Ȅ̹̯̥͘ངͦͥٸ࣭૽۷ݖ͈୰ྶဥͅဥփ̱̤̞̀ ̹͈̜̠̥́́ͧ͜͜ȃ̷̱ͦ̀͜ͅ΅ςΑΠޗ͈ȶޗၑ࿚൞ȷȪޗါၑȫȪΧȜϋ͉ͺις শయ̳́ͅȄ΅ςΑΠޗޗ͂Ξ΅Βθ͈۾ͩͤͬა̲̞̀ͥȫ̥̩̈́ͣ͂ͅȄȶޗ͈ Ξ΅Βθȷ͉֚͂ఘة͈̥̈́ȃ̯̹ͣ͘ͅȄष̦ང̷ུ̹͈̠̦̜̹̱ͦ̈́̽͂̀͢ͅȄ ਹ࢚̈́ȸ༷ങȹ͈գുഎ̈́ͺΟηΛ·଼̈́ض͉͓̩̞͂͐̈́͜ȸޗޗၑ࿚൞ȹ͈ྴ ̢̭̭̜ͬ́̀ݷ̵̬͙̀ͥຈါ͉̭̓ͅݥ̧̭̦̺̠̥͛ͥ͂́ͥͧȃ
ȁ̭̭́࡞ݞ̯̞ͦ̀ͥȸޗޗၑ࿚൞ȹ6ȫ͉ȜσΛΠ (Henry Steel Olcott) ͈̈́ͥͅ ͈̜́ͥ͜ȃͺις໐༹̤̞̀ͅٮ́ڰ̱ȄΐλȜςΑΠ଼̱͂̀ͬਓ̹͉͛Ȅ ২ٮ́ل̥̈́͞șͬށ̳ͥಠྴ૽̱̞̹̦͂̀ͣͦ̀ȄήρόΜ΅Ȝຳ૽͈͂୪ത ͬං̹̭̥͂ͣޗࡄݪͬএ̞̹̾ͅঢͤȄ1879ාͼϋΡͅളͥȃȸޗޗၑ࿚൞ȹͬۏ࣐̱ ̹͈͉Ȅ̷͈ޱ̥ˎාࢃ͈1881ා͈̭̜̹͂́̽ȃ࡛౷̧̧̤̞̱̥͓̀ͥ̾ͅͅȄུڒഎ ̈́ޗਘ࣐̱ͬ̀ဢͅ௷̧̱̹͈̺̹̦ͬ͊̀̽Ȅൢࢃ΅ςΑΠޗືޗͥ͢ͅͼϋΡȄ Γͼυϋ̤̫ͥͅޗଚప͈࡛ેȄഥൡഎ̈́২ٛ͞ا͈࣏ͬ࿒͈̜̹̱ͤ̀ͅȄ̷͈ठޟ ͬޑ̩ܐ̠̠̈́ͤ͢ͅȄ༷࢜ͬഢ̵̯̹͈̺̹۟̽ȃ̷̭́৽̱͂̀ͼϋΡՏఱၘ̤̫ͥͅ ޗޗ͈݅ܖயഎ̈́ၑٜ͂ຽݞ̳͓̩ͥͅȄୌ؎ςϋΗςΑΠͥ͢ͅޗࡄݪ଼͈ض̥ͣ ఉ̩ͬං͈̯̹͈̦̀ͦ͜Ȅఈ̭͈̈́ͣ͆ȸޗޗၑ࿚൞ȹ̜̹́̽ȃ ȁȜσΛΠ͉Ȫ΅ςΑΠޗޗͥ͢ͅڠࢷ࠺୭̷̭͈͂́΅ςΑΠޗຽݞͅచࢯ̱̀ȫ ൝ޗ֗ঔ୭͈ਰ͜ͅႁ̩̱ͬḘ̠̱̹̏ঔ୭̤̞̭͈̀͜ͅȸ࿚൞ȹͬΞ·ΑΠ͈֚̾ ̱̹͂ȃ̴̭ͦ͂̓ͣ͘ͅḘུ͈͉̏ଲٮڎ౷́ޗ͈༜എ̈́েͬං̹͈ͥ͛ڒࢡ͈ව ̱͂̀އ̽̀උͦ͘Ȅඅͅͺις͉́ๅͬਹ͇̀Ρ;ͻϋȆͺȜΦσΡ͈ȸͺΐͺ͈ȹ7ȫ ͂ࡈ͓ͬͥαΑΠȆΓρȜͅତ̢̭̹ͣͦͥ͂͂̈́̽ȃཱུ͜ΡͼΜࢊȄέρϋΑࢊ͉̲ͬ ̳͛͂ͥୌ؎੨࡞ࢊ̥̥͊ͤͺΐͺ੨ࢊ͜ͅ֊̱་̢ͣͦȄ̷͈ޣུ͉̦̀́͘͞ͅݞ͐ ̭̺̠͂̈́ͥͧͅȃ ȁ̭͂ͧ́Ḙ̭̏́ΧȜῢ̢̦̜ȶםࢊๅȷ͂౯̞̭̽̀ͥ͂ͅಕփ̧̳͓͉̞̺̠́̈́ͧ
̥ȃ̞̠͈͂͜Ȅ̷ཱུ͉͈͉̩́̈́Ȅם͈ȸޗޗၑ࿚൞ȹȪ1882ාๅȫཱུུ͈̦࣫ ̯̞̥̜́̈́ͦ̀ͥͣ́ͥȃ૧ུ̹ͅ௰́੬Ȫםȫ̫ͬ̾Ȅཱུ࣫ๅ૽̱͂̀କၭட ͈ྴܱ̱ͬḘཱུ͈̦̏࣫ނ͈ᄵങފ̥ٛͣۏ࣐̯̹͈͉ͦ1886Ȫྶহ19ȫා͈̭̜̹͂́̽ȃ ੬͈̱̹͈͉ͬ͜؎ਗͅളͤȄಿ̩ޗࡄݪ̻ࣺ͙ͅȄఱ଼̧̈́ضͬݷ̬̀ஞ̩ஜාͅܦ ࣭ͬض̹̱̹ධᕢဎͅఈ̥̹̈́ͣ̈́̽ȃ ȁਔ͈̠͢ͅ΅ςΑΠޗ͈Ξ΅Βθ͉Ȅඅ̭̥ͦͣ͞ͅަ͈ൽͅව̠̳ͧ͂ͥ৪ͅȄ ޗၑ͈ܖུഎ̈́ါത̵̫̯͓̩ͬ̾ͥͅȄ࿚൞ࠁͬৰͤ̀۰ͅॽၛ̹͈̜̦̀́ͥ͜Ȅ ධᕢཱུ͉̭͈࣫ͅܙ̵̹੬̤̞̀ͅষ͈̠͢ͅ࡞̞̽̀ͥȃȶ̥̾̀υϋΡϋ͈̜ͥزೳͅ ͬܙ̵̞̹̀শ͈̭̺̦͂Ȅ൳ز্͉ͅपͬ൮ͅࡼपȄ२प͈२૽͈ဘ̞ঊރ̹̻̦̞̹ȃ ൚শಿ੫͉ڠࢷ́Ξ΅Βθͬਠ̞̭̜̹͈̽̀ͥ͂ͧ́̽́Ȅ࿚̞̥̫ͣͦͥ͂ۼอ̴̞ͦ ͅ൞̵̢̢͙̹̱ͬ̀Ȅਠ̧̹̽̀ޗၑཽ̹̻̫̠ͬ̀ͧ͂͜͞ͅদ͙̞̹̀͜ȃ̭ͭ̈́ ࠊͬ࿒͈൚̹̳ͤͥ͂ͅȄِ̦࣭͈ঊރ̦႕̢͊ȸక͉૰̜̹͈̥́̽ȹ̞̠̠͂̈́͢ౙ ̈́ৗ࿚̠͜͢ͅ༐൞̢̱̞̞̈́́ͥအঊ̦ອͤͅෞၔ̨͈ͬͥͬ͢؋̢̯ඳ̞ȃ̷̭̭̠́ ུ̱̹̦̞͈̥̞̠̈́͂͜এ̞ͬݛ̱̩̳̠̹͈̜ͥ̈́̽́ͥ͢ͅȷ8ȫȃ ȁධᕢဎ̢̞͂͊ྶহশయߠঐ͈ȶࣞȷȪ௩ȶྶহࣞഥȷȫ9ȫ̱͂̀ྴ̩ࣞȄา̯ͦ ̀ڦࡔࡄዎ͂ඵ૽Ȅם࣭̹ͩ̽̀ͅζ·ΑȆηνρȜͅম̱̹৹̧ș͈ࡄᲣ̷̭̥͂ͣ ͙̯̹࣭ͦषഎ̈́ުୡ̩̞̦̽̀ͣͦ̀ͥ͢͜͢ͅȄ̷͈ධᕢ̦̭͈̠͢ͅള؎ࢃ͈ڛ എ்̞ٴ̥ͣܡͅȄ࣭̤̫ͥͅྦྷਤτόͿσ͈ޗ͈૧̹̈́ຽݞȄ࿎͈༷ഷͬ͜ͅय ̧̞̞̹̭͉͕̞̞̞̠͓̺̠̀͂͂ͭ̓ͣͦ̀̈́͂ͧȃ̺̦ࢃාȸུޗඵਕঃȹ ཱུͬ༎ॴུ̱̤̫̀ͥͅޗ੨ਕͬജབ̳͈ͥ༎ਬ̜̹ͤͅȄ̯ͣͅȸޗങȹͬ ۏ࣐̱̀ޗ͈ଲٮഎ̈́ႤঃഎȆ౷ၑഎജབ͂এேഎȆਕޗഎ̈́ࢩ̦ͤͬ͂͛͘Ȅࢩไ̈́උ৪ ͅ૧̱̩ࢹಃ̯̹ͦޗ௨ͬা̳ͥͅঢͥड͈֚༜̦̭̭̜̞ͥ͂̽̀͜ͅࠨ̱̀࡞̞ ً̨͉̜̹̞͈͉̞̥ͣ̈́́̈́͂ͅএͩͦͥȃ ˎȅධᕢȄڦࡔȄઐ ȁྶহ૧̢ͬࠞͥ͂ޗٮ๋͉ྃఘଷئ̤̫࢚̞ͥͅ༗ࢌ͞ࡀף̹̥̥ͬ̽͊ͤȄȶ૰ ၗȄኲ৷ȷ͈ଽॐ̽̀͢ͅࠨഎ͂͜࡞̞̠ͥࠢͬ࿎̭̹ͥ͂͂̈́̽ȃ̺̦ু͈ͣ ठ࠺͂٨ڟ͈͒փဳ̦ޥ்̩͕̞̓ٴ̥ͣນ࿂ا̱̞̭̀ͥ͂͜དྷ͉̞ͦ̀̈́ͣ̈́ȃুࡨ٨ ڟ͂ޗ͈߃యا̫̜̹͈̦͂ͤͩ́̽ͅȪാȫ૯ਕ̜́ͤȄྶহˑා͉ͅਕ৽ఄ͈ ྵ̫ͬ̀ୌུܐ̥ͣോ౷࿑ဿȪ̦ྶহଽຸ͈ਕޗଽॐ̱̩̳༷֚ͬࠣͥȄ؎ਗ̤ͅ ̫ͥ২ٛଷഽȪ̫͂ͤͩਕޗଷഽȫِ̦࣭ͬͅત̳ٚͥષ́ಠ̱̞࣓ࡃ̦̜̹̭͉̩̽͂͢ ̞ͣͦ̀ͥȫȄઐႲઽȄષాဏ̦؎ༀমૂ͈ণख़̧ͅȄུ༷֚ܐ͜ྶহˑා̥ͣံ ˒ා̥̫࡛̀ͅශȪఱȫȄੌరȄઐུฒلȄ଼ോཤȄ۾२̦ͼϋΡͅ୦ͬང͇Ȅ
̯ͣͅ௷̱ͬ͊̀؎ਗমૂ͈ণख़࣐̤̽̀ͤ͜Ȅ؎ਗ͈ڎ܁ͬ̽̀ϋΑ·ςΛΠ͈ ങͬר။̱̞̀ͥȃ࡛ශ͉ȶ౷ඵΞ௨֚ߏȄٵఉ္ࠐ֚ےϊංΞܦಱ౿ΏΗΠΐλ ΄ȄଵπςةȄ֣ഽΦڠϊޟΏࠐےϊཱུΏȄࢁ૯ਕϊ૦ΪܳΑΣັΞΧȄ֚षႁϊှ θȷ10ȫ͓̤͂̀ͤȄ૯ਕठޟ͉ͅͼϋΡ͈ޗࠐങͬࣽࢃ͈ಎഎ̈́ಔ̧͈̳͓̺֚̾͂ͅ ̞̠సࡉͬা̱̞̀ͥȃ ȁݰြ͈ۧങ͈͙ͬှ͙̳͈͉̩͂ͥ́̈́Ȫ̻ͧͭ͜႕ٸ̜ͤ͜Ȅ̷ͦոஜ͜ͅϋΑ· ςΛΠ̦ࡄݪ̯̹̭͉̜̦ͦ͂ͥȫȄͼϋΡͅޗ͈ࡔതͬང͇ȄϋΑ·ςΛΠ͞ΩȜςͅ ͥ͢ࠐങͬਓਬ̳ͥȃ̷̺̦͈༷֚́ޗ͈ၑٜ͞ࡄݪ͂̈́ͥ͂Ȅ߃ා̤̫ͥͅୌ؎͈ဢڠ ͬํ̱͂Ȅ̷଼͈ض͞ࡄݪ༹༷͈ݟਓ̧͓̜̞̠༷̾͂͛ͥ́ͥ͂ͅૻ̦ྶږ̞̩̈́̽̀ͅȃ ̥̩̱̀ୌ؎ςϋΠڠͥ͢ͅޗ͈ڠ࿚എࡄݪͬړ̱͂Ḙ̷̥̏ͣޗ͈ޗၑ͞এே͈ࡄ ݪͬ૬͛ͥ͂͂͜ͅȄఈ༷̤̞͉̀ͅږ̥̈́ڠ࿚എܖ๕ͅၛݗ̱̹ષ́Ȅྦྷਤ͈͒૧̹̈́ຽݞ ࿎͈༷ഷͬ࿅̱̞̭̠̳༷̫̦̯॑̀͂ͥ࢜̿̈́ͦȄஜ৪͈࿒എͬో଼̳͓̩ခෝȄခབ̈́ ৹̞ڠͬา̱̀؎ਗͅ෩ࡍ̱Ȅड૧͈ୌ؎ςϋΠࡄݪ଼͈ضͬڠ̵͊Ȅޗങ͈ࡕྟ̈́ ͺΟηΛ·̈́ࡄݪ͈ܖயࢹಃ̦ܢఞ̯̹͈̺̹ͦ̽ȃ ȁ1876Ȫྶহ˕ȫා˒Ȅา̯̹ͦඵ૽͈৹৪Ȅධᕢဎ͂ڦࡔࡄዎ͉ಎ͈૽֚͂̈́ͤႹ ؎ਗ̥̠͒͂࢜ȃဎুͦ͊͢ͅȶ࡛ශષ૽̦ဢ࣐̯̹ͦশȄ൳࣐͈ੌర̦߯ઁ̱̥͊ ͤᕨࢊ̹͈͙ͬ̾́͞Ȅྚ̺ਰͬͅਘ̴͛Ȅࣽࢃ̠̱̭͈༷̓̀͜࿂͈ٳఽ̳͓̥ͬ֝ͣ ̴̞͂͏͈́Ȅଛͅজో͈٬ٸၣڠ̹͈̜͂̈́̾́ͥȷ͂ ̞ ̠ ̭ ͂ ́ ̜ ̽ ̹11ȫȃ̴͘םࢊ͈ ਠ഼͛ͅȄ̷͈ࢃȄ̠̩͢͞·ΑέȜΡͅζ·ΑȆηνρȜͬང͇ͥܥٛͬං̹͈͉ 1879Ȫྶহ12ȫා͈̭͂́Ȅոြζ·ΑȆηνρȜȄ̷̱̀ζ·ΡΥσ͈͂́͜ϋΑ·ςΛ Π͈ڠਠ͂ᕨങ͈ࡄݪ̳̭̹ͥ͂̈́̽ͅͅȃ ȁ1880Ȫྶহ13ȫාո͉ࣛζ·ΑȆηνρȜ͂͂͜ͅȄγΐΕϋ̽̀͢ͅઉြ̯̹ͦྫၾࠐ ͈ᕨৢུȪȸޭڢࡕࠐȹȫȄུ̥ͣັ̵̯̹ȸᕨۧՒకࠐȹȄȸෝ౯߄๊࣠৹෨္ྠఉࠐȹ Ȫȸ߄๊࣠৹ࠐȹȫȄ܊ாߓণ̥ͣζ·ΑȆηνρȜͅ௭೮̯̹ͦȸ๊৹෨္ྠఉࠐȹ͈ࡄݪͅ ྶ̫༥̹̦ͦȄ̷͈ࡄݪ଼͈ض͉ȸ༷ങȷ͈ల49ےȶఱᄵޗࠐങȹ͈ړͬࠁ̩̭̿ͥ ̹͂͂̈́̽Ȫ153Ƚ154ȫȃȪΧȜϋ͉ਫ਼௬̳ͥȸ༷ങȷ͈ಎ́͜අ̭ͦͬͅਹণ̱̹̭͉͂ ȶΣσόȜȷ̤̫ͥ֨ͅဥ̥ͣ͜ၔັ̫ͣͦͥȫȃ ȁ୨᠂ీཹ̱̜̠༸̜̹́̽ڦࡔࡄዎ͉ॼැ̭̈́͂ۛͬͅංȄྫැͬޝಎͅૈͭ́Ȅ1882 Ȫྶহ15ȫාڠ̱͊̀ͅܦ࣭͈ഷ̧̾ͅȄံ1883Ȫྶহ16ȫා͉ͅཌ̩̱̠̈́̽̀͘ȃ̭͈ ܦ࣭͈ၫ͈ഷષȄڦࡔ͉ພ̤̱ͬ̀Γͼυϋͅతह̱̞̀ͥȃȶ൳͉߯ܦႹΓͼυϋോͅၛ ܙͤȄၣ̭ͥ͂͘ඵȄ֚ܦಱ̱Ȅ٬ͅူ̳ͥম̹͂̈́̽ȃȷȪ175ȫ͂ධᕢ͉۰ྶͅ ܱ̱̞̀ͥȃධᕢ͜࡞̞̠̽̀ͥ͢ͅȄඵ૽͉อশ̥ͣͼϋΡང࿚͂୦ႛͬැܐ̱̞̀ ̹͈͈͜Ȅྫැ͜ͅ؉Ⴙ͉́ض̹̳ܥٛͬං̴̞̹͈́ͅȄȶࣽষ͈ܦಱ͉ͅຈ̴֣ഽͅၛ̻
ܙ̽̀Ȅక͈Ⴀ̠͉࠘́͂͢ͅȄজోඵ૽͈͈̜̹ͤͤ́̽͢͢ȷȪ163Ƚ164ȫ͈̺̦Ȅ ڦࡔ͉ܦႹȄ̴̢͚֚ͬ͞૽̷͈̩̭̹̫̜ͬ̾ͣ͆͂̈́̽ͩ́ͥͅȃ ȁȸޗޗၑ࿚൞ȹͅܙ̵̹ධᕢ͈੬͉ͅȄȶ̱͙̀ဒ̜ͤͥ൳ڠ͈༸Ȅڦࡔࡄዎ͉ܦ࣭ ͈ഷષȄΓͼυϋͬང̹ͦȃ̷͈୬ུͤȸޗޗၑ࿚൞ȹ֚໐Ȅ̷͈ఈ૰౺ڠފ͈ٛๅ ତതͬ௭೮̯̹͈̜̹ͦ́̽ȃͅզ̹̀ڦࡔ͈۰ͦ͊͢ͅȄΑζϋ΄ρఄ৪̵͈̥ͭ͊ ͬෲ̧̹̱ͭ́Ȅ൳ފ͈ٛΓͼυϋ໐͈ਬ̱̹͈̭̜ٛͬ͂͂́ͥͅȷȪPreface, Iȫ͂ ܱ̯̞ͦ̀ͥȃ ȁڦࡔুͥ͂͢ͅḘ͉̏ͦ൚ْ̥͈͈۪͉̩֚ͣࠗ́̈́Ȅ୦ͬང͇͓̩ͥΓͼυϋͅత ह̱̹୬ͤḘ̥̏͌ͭ̈́͂ͣ͡ܥٛͬං̹͈̜́ͤ͜Ȅ૰౺ڠފ̭͈ٛ͞ފٛ͂൳౷̤̫ͥͅ ޗ͈͂۾߸͉̥̹̠̺̈́̓ͣ̈́̽͢ȃȶޗരΦࣻ૽ϊဥΑσΠྫၾςȄ΄ᄜΞ ఀྴϊρΎςΏϊ٢ηΗςȷ͂Ȅ൚౷̤̫ͥͅȜσΛΠ͈ྴͅޥ̵̧̞̞ͬ֯̈́́ͥȃ ȸڦࡔ֒ਬȹ͉ͅȄȶࣻ Ȫຊ৪ಕȃ૰౺ڠފ͈̭ٛ͂ȫΣΞ᳦ধΦᗁσκΦϊ發ᆈΓςȄ ΣșΦκΦϊΣ௭ܙΓςȄఀಎΣσΜΠΦ࣒݅൝ΦκΦȄ Φܰ௱൝ͺςȷܱ̯͂ ̤ͦ̀ͤḘ̭̏́࡞̠ȶσΜΠΦ࣒݅ȷ̷̭Ȅ͈ȸޗޗၑ࿚൞ȹͅఈ̞̈́ͥ͘ȃ ȁ̭͈۰̫̹ͬ৾̽শത́Ȅධᕢ̦ȜσΛΠ̞̹͈̥ͬ̽̀Ȅ̷̹͈͘ȸޗޗၑ ࿚൞ȹͬ࿒̱̹̭̦̜̹͈̥͂̽ͅḘ͈̏ത͉ၳ̦̩̈́ة͂͜࡞̢̞̈́ȃ̧͉̱̞̽ͤ̀ͥ ͈͉ȄͼΆςΑతह͈ڛഎ்̞ٴ́Ȅ̳́ͅධᕢུ͉̤̫ͥͅྦྷਤ͈͒ޗ͈૧̹̈́ ຽݞ̷͈༷͂ॐͬ͜ͅय̞̞̹̭̜̀͂́ͤȄܦ࣭̳ͥոஜུ̭͈̞̾̀ͅͅة̦̱̥͈ ে̞̹̞̠̭̜ͬ̽̀͂͂́ͥȃ ȁධᕢ͉࡞̞̽̀ͥȃڦࡔ̦ཌ̩̹̈́̽ȶ̷͈ံාȄ͉ͼϋΈρϋΡ̥ͣͺιςࠐဇ́ ܦ࣭ͬض̹̱̹ȃ̹̺̻ͅڠཅ̥̈́༸ȄઐႲઽͬངͦՕग़̱̹̭͂ͧȄઐུ͉͈ྴ ͬݷ̬Ȅ͕͖̱ਞ̢̹࢛̱̹͈̺̹͂́̽͘ͅȃ̷̠̭̠̳̠̻ͥȄڦࡔ͈͈֒ାၑ̜ͅ ̹̹͉̽Ȅ௭೮̯ͦ̀ڦࡔ̦Γͼυϋ̥̻ͣܦུ̹̽ͬࡉ̱Ȅِ̦࣭ͅࢩ̩̱ͣ ̹̞͛এ̞͈ဲ̢̧̦̹ͬژ̢̹͈̺̹̽ȷ13ȫȃධᕢ͉̹͂͘༆͈ࠐႹͬࠐ̀ઐ͉ܡͅȜ σΛΠུ͈ͬඋ͚ܥٛͬං̤̀ͤȄ̷͈ઐུ̦̭͈͈̭͂ͬდఴ̳ͥ͞ͅȄ̹̺̻ͅධᕢ ͈ෞၔ̷͈͂ͅڦࡔ̧̦̩͂ͬࠫ͐̽ͤ͂ຝ̧̯̩͈̺̹ͦ̀ͥ̽ȃȶِ̦࣭ͅࢩ̩ ̱̹̞ͣ͛ȷ͂࡞̞̭̥̱̽̀ͥ͂ͣ̀Ȅ̷͈ඤယ̦ޗ͈ྦྷਤ͈͒ຽݞ͂۾Ⴒ̳̭ͥ͂ ̢͉̩̞̹̞͈͉̞̺̠̥ͬ̽̀͂ͥ́̈́ͧ͢ȃ ȁઐႲઽ͈ȶᄵޗ͈ୌஞȷ͉Ȅྶহܢ͈ई၄͂൲ဝͬา̫̱Ȅུ͈ޗ̦૧̹̞̈́ ͈͂͜ͅஞ̩૧̹֚̈́༜ͬ൩̷͙̠̳͂ͥশయ̢֣̳͈̜̞ͬ࣫ͥ́ͥ͂ͥ͜ȃઐ͉ਲြ ͈ਕ෩಼̢͈֑̹̭̻ͬ͂ͧͅၛ̧͓̀ͣͦͥȶུޗȷ̢ͬͥȃ̷̷̱͉̯̀ͦͣ ࣭ͅඤ̭̩͂̓ͥ͂̈́͘ͅȄୌ؎ଲٮͅ૧̹̈́ιΛΓȜΐͬൎ̬̥̫Ȅఱ̞̈́ͥ۾ͬࡤ͍ܳ
̭̱Ȅఉఱ̈́גޣͬݞ̴͖̱̠͉̜ͥ́ͥȃ̭͈̠̈́͢ജབͬຝ̵̞͙̀ͥઐ̦Ȅষ͈̠͢ ͅ࡞̞̭̽̀ͥ͂ͅಕ࿒̱̹̞ȃȶဒȄݖාߧུඵဋήȃକြΞȄༀ૽σΛΠঙΦ۰Ȅ ݞΫఀಠΑσਫ਼Φȸޗ࿚൞ȹΠͼΰσϊাΑȃဒȄ৾Ξϊඋθȃ۰ೊΒσਫ਼ȄఱΣِ ޗΦࢬϊཝσ৪ΦශΏȷ14ȫȃ1884Ȫྶহ17ȫාͅȸܗ૧༭ȹͅࠇश̯̹̭͈ͦȶᄵޗ͈ୌ ஞȷ̤̞̀ͅȄઐ͉ޗ͉̥̾̀ͼϋΡུ̥ͣͅȶஞȷ̧̱̹̫̺̦̀ͩȄࣽഽ͉̭͈ ུͬܳതͅୌ؎ଲٮͅࢩ̦̞̩̽̀ޗȶୌஞȷ͈শ̦ൢြ̱̹͈͉̞̥́̈́Ȫȶඊς٢θȄ ِޗةϊոΞ؎ਗΣୌஞΓΎσȷȪ൳ȫ͂࿚̞̥̫̞̀ͥȃ̷̱̀Ȅ̷͉̥͈ͦ̾̀ȶஞȷ ͉͂։̈́ͤȄ༷֚എ̈́൱̧̥̫͂גޣ͈͉̩͂͂̓ͥ́̈́͘ͅȪͼϋΡ̦൱̷ུ̧̥̫͉ͦ ̫ͬগ͛ͥȫȄୌ̷̸ͦͦͅ૽ͬං̀Ȅࡽͅ൱̧̥̫̜̠̭̭͈̺͂ͧܳͥ͂ͅ࡞̠Ȫ ུ͈൱̧̥̫ͅచ̱̀Ḙ̏ͦͅ؊̢ͥୌ؎௰͈൲̧̦ຈါ̜́ͥȫȃ̭͈ࢃ৪͈ത́Ȅୌ؎௰ ̥͈ͣ൱̧̥̫͈ߓఘ႕̱͂̀ઐ͉ȜσΛΠ͈ಠैͅಕ࿒̳̭̹ͥ͂̈́̽͂ͅ࡞̢̺ͥ ̠ͧȃ ȁ̭͈ȶޗ͈ୌஞȷ͉ͅȄ̵ࣣͩ̀କզ͈ȜσΛΠ͈۰Ȅݞ͍υϋΡΰอ࣐̯ͦ ̹ȶεȜσκȜσȆ΄ΔΛΠȷ͈ܱম͜ત̯̞̦ٚͦ̀ͥȄକͅզ̹̀1883ාˍ14ັ̫ ͈ȜσΛΠ͈۰͉ͅȄ̷͈ஜා1882ා11ˍັ̫͈ȜσΛΠզ͈କ͈۰ͬ၂ ̱̹̭͂Ḙ̏ͦͅ൞̢̀ȶ୩৪ಠΦȸޗ࿚൞ȹΦड߃ๅ֚໐ओΏષΊȷȪ72ȫ̱͂Ȅ ̯ͣͅକͅచ̱ȶڂ଼ཱུȄଲΣခףΠࢄ଼ං৪ȄఀཱུΦඅࡀΧܲ߯Σࢄો ςخ૭ȷȪ൳ȫ͂͜ັ̫ح̢̞̀ͥȃ̭̭̞̠́ȶड૧ๅȷ͉͂1882ාๅͅఈ̴̈́ͣȄ̳͂ ͥ̈́ͣڦࡔ̦̫̹͈৾̽͂͜൳̜֚́ͤȄ̳̻̈́ͩධᕢཱུ̯̹͈̽̀࣫ͦ͂͢͜ͅ൳̲Ȫխ ̞͉डࡠ͈։൳͈͂̓ͥ͘͜ͅȫ͂ଔ௶̯ͦͥȃ ȁઐ͉କ͈ࡓ̜̹̽ͅȸޗޗၑ࿚൞ȹͅ࿒̱ͬȄ̷͈փ݅ͬບثཱུ̱̦̫̀͜ ͙̹͈͈͜ȄȜσΛΠ̦ශة̈́ͥ૽̜́ͤḘ̶͈̠̏̈́̈́͢ಠैͬদ͙̹͈̥֚ࣽ̾ᦅ ͅ၂̻͈̦̜̹̱̞͆̽ͣ͜ȃȶடτΡκȄ൳ঙΧةΦ֦ΣဇΞࣻΣਲমΑσμȄఀΦȶΓ ΕέͻσȄΕΙȜȷȪ૰౺ڠٛ২ȫΧةΦ࿒എϊոΞ୭ၛΓσμϊમρΣΓΒȷȪ൳ 71ȫ͂࡞̤̽̀ͤȄ̷ͦ́ȶΣϊ·ΠᪧκȄစγྚΘ۠ΞϊଲΣ࿚ΧΒȷȪ൳ȫ͂ ̞̠̭̹͂̈́̽ͅȪȶᄵޗΦୌஞȷ̷͈ͥ͂͢ͅࢃ1884Ȫྶহ17ȫාͅέͿΦυ̦ઐͬང ࿚̱̹୬ͤȄ̹̹͘͘ȜσΛΠ͈̭̦͂დఴ͈͖̹̦̽ͅȄ൳̱̞̹̀ΫΊυ;̦Ȅ؍ ຩ̞̹́̀ȶιȜσȷঞͬা̱̀ȄȶεȜσκȜσȆ΄ΔΛΠȷ̥ͣഢश̯̹ͦȶ૰౺ڠΦ ٛ൮υΥσȆσΛΠঙȷ̞̠ܱ͂মͬޗ̢̩̹͈̺̀ͦ͂࡞̠ȃ̭̠̩ͦ̽̀͢͢͞ͅ ઐ̷͈͜૽͂ڰ൲͈͂૯ᒱ̴͈̜̭̈́́ͥ͂ͬͥ͜ͅঢ̹̽͂࡞̞̽̀ͥȫȃ ȁ̺̦ධᕢ͈͂ٛࡉ͈শത͉́Ȅུ̥̩͂ͅࢊཱུ̱ͅๅ̳̭͉͈ͥ͂ܰম̺̹̽ͣ ̱̩Ȅ̷̺̥̭ͣධᕢུ͉ࢊๅͬএ̞͂̓ͤ͘Ȅ̷̤̩ͣষ͈ॐ̱͂̀Ȅ൳শࣣͩͅ ̵̀ڦࡔ͈ުୡܱͬැ̳͓̩Ȅםࢊๅ໘࣫ͬۏ࣐̳̭̱̹ͥ͂͂ͅࣉ̢̺̠ͣͦͥͧȃडਞഎ
ུͅࢊ͉ނസ́ಎڠࢷ͈ޗ̱̞̹ͬ̀ࣽၛഫଜ̦ॽષ̬Ḙ̏ͦͅઐႲઽ̦ܙ̵̹੬ Ȫ͕͖ܡͅݷ̬̹ȶᄵޗ͈ୌஞȷ͈ஜ໐̜̹ͥͅȫͬັ̱̀ۏ࣐̯̹ͦ15ȫȃ؎ਗণख़ࢃȄࡉ ̱̹ڠࢷޗ༹֗ͬ४ࣉͅȄਕ͈ޗ֗ଷഽ٨ڟͅႁ̧̩̱̹ͬ̀ઐ̦ྦྷਤͅచ̳ͥޗ ޗၑ͈࿎Ȅຽݞͅ۾̠͈͉ͬ൚ட̜̹́̽͂࡞̢ͥȃ̺̦Ȅ̷̱֚ͦ̀͜ͅ૽͈؎ༀ૽ ̈́ͥͅͅȸޗޗၑ࿚൞ȷ̦̭͕ͦ̓ಕ࿒ͬဵ̶͍̹͈͉̺̠̥̈́ͧȃ ˏȅȜσΛΠ͈ြ ȁ̭͂ͧ́ȄΧȜϋ͈ြͅ୶ၛ̽̀ȜσΛΠུ͉ͬང̞ͦ̀ͥȃ̷͉ͦ1889ාˎ͈ ̭͂́Ȅːῴ̹̭͈ͩͥతह͈ࢃȄ1891ා̠֚͜ͅഽུͬང̤ͦ̀ͤȄ̷͈ष͉ͅέͿ ΦυȄΫΊυ;͂࿂͈ٛܥٛ͜ං̹ȃޘള̱͈̹͈͉࢛ͬ̽অȪ໘൴ȫ̜́ͤȄ ͉ζΡρᾼ߃̞ͺΟͻͺȜͅȜσΛΠͬང͇Ȅြͬઉ̱̹͈̺̹̽ȃȜσΛ Π͉අͅΓͼυϋ̤̫ͥͅ΅ςΑΠޗޗȄືޗڰ൲ͅచၛ̱Ȅ൳౷͈ޗ໘ޟ൲ͅࡈවͦ ̳̠̦ͥ̈́ͥ͢ͅḘ̷̥̯̏ͣͣͅࢩ̩ޗଲٮ͈Ⴒࠈ͂ႲఝͬͥȶξͼΞΛΡȆήΛΟͻ ΑΠȆχȜσΡȷ͈ࢹேͬຝ̩̠̞̹̈́̽̀͢ͅȃ̭̭ͅٳ࣭ոြȄୌ؎͈ଽহഎȄਕޗഎȄ اഎ̈́ૺ̽̀͢ͅܓܥ̯̯̞ͣͦ̀ͥͅȪ̜̠́ͧȫུ̤̫ͥͅޗͅ۾̫ͬ࢜Ȅ̷ ͈ၛ̀ೄ̱͂ڰا̹̞ͬࠗͤ͂ܐ̠ၑဇ̦̲̭ͥ͂̈́ͥͅḁ̩̱͉࢛͈̑̀ݥ͛ͅ؊ ̲Ȅ૯ൃ͈૰͈ࢽ̷͈ͅউ࡛̱̹͈̺̹ͬ̽ȃ ȁːῴུ̹ͩͥతहಎȄȜσΛΠ͉ނസȄఱिȄຍႹȄྴࡣؚȄނȄؖ५Ȅ५ ࢛͂ୟޭഎͅڎ౷̪ͬ͛ͤȄ๊̫͈࣒֚࢜ٛͬट̱Ȅ̹͘ڎਕͬయນ̳ͥၩ͈͂ٛࡉ͞ފ ݈͜ͅ؊̲̞̀ͥȃͼϋΡՏఱၘ̤̫ͥͅޗ໘ޟ͈ୡ͈ບུ͈͉֚͜ͅඑ̞̤̀ͤȄ ུ̤̫ͥͅޗ̷̦͈૧̹̈́อജ͈ൽͬࡉ̧̞̺̳͓াऐ̭͈ͬ૽ͅܢఞ̳ͥ৪͉ઁ̩̈́̈́ ̥̹̽ȃ ȁ̷͈࣒͜ڎਅۏ࣐̯̞̦ͦ̀ͥȄ̷͈֚ॗ̜́ͥȪΰϋςȜȄωΑȄσΛΠঙȫȸఱ ୰ཌྷಶຊܱȹ16ȫ̤̞̀ͅȄȜσΛΠ͉ȸޗޗၑ࿚൞ȹͅ۾Ⴒ̱̀ষ͈̠͢ͅ࡞̞̽̀ ͥȃΓͼυΰ͉ޗ̸̦̯̈́ަͬਬ̞̺̠̞̠͛̀ͥͧ͂এ̞ͬ༴̞̀Ȅ1880ා൳౷ ̞̹ͅȜσΛΠ̜̹̦́̽Ȅ̜͉̥ͣͭ͞ͅȄ̵͉࣏̥֭͘ͅȄდ̱̥̫̹֚૽ ̱͂̀ޗ͈ة̴̹̥ͥͬͣȄήΛΘ͈ශة̈́ͥ૽̥ͬ൞̢ͣͦ͆ఘ̹̩̜̹ͣ́̽ȃ̷ͦ ͉ୌ؎੨࣭ͥ͢ͅྦྷ౷ଽॐ͂΅ςΑΠޗޗȄືޗ͈̹̱̹ͣࠫ͜ضͅఈ̞̈́ͣ̈́Ȫඅͅ ൝ޗ͈֗ঔ୭ͅාઁ৪ͬਬ͛ȄȸΞ΅Αθȹͬڰဥ̱̹ਕޗޗ͉̭̯֗͂ͣ࢘ضഎ́Ȅ̷͈ ࠫضݰ̞ഥൡ͞ا͉ڛഎౣশۼ͈̠̻ͅ౯୲͈ܓܥͅธ̯ͦͥͅൢ̞̹̽̀ȫȃ̭̦ͦȜ σΛΠ͉ু̦Γͼυϋ̤̫ͥͅޗ͈ຽݞ͂ठޟ͈හ̜̹̠̳ͧ͂ͅͅঢ̹̽ၑဇ̜́ ͥȃޗ͈ठޟ͉ͬͥͅඅͅාઁ৪̫࢜ͅޗͬޗ̢ͥഐ൚̈́ව৪ဥ͈Ξ·ΑΠ͂̈́ͥ͜ ͈̦ຈါ̜̦́ͥȄ̷͈̠͈͉̭̞̈́̓̈́͢͜͜ͅȃ̷̭͉́ুͣຊͬ̽̀ȸᄵޗޗၑ࿚
൞ȹ͈̳̭̹̞̠ͬ͂̈́̽͂͜ͅȃȶΦவޗരΧ૽ΣκٜΏօ·ڶΜಶ΅օ΅အΣ σ࿚൞ఘΣ΅ΏΞືޗഥൽΣΑσΣΣΞκෝ·ϊٜΏິ૽ΣΞκෝ·ϊႀ ΏංσΣջΞဒΧۖྫσࣻΦޗࣻΦൽၑϊິ૽ΣঢσζΞκෝ·ႀٜΏංσအΣ ΅ϋΠᄵޗϊ२ྔཿκ৾ς͓Ξօσ࿚൞ఘΣΞಠΧΓΏ΄௲Ιᄵޗ࿚൞ςȷ Ȫ൳26ȫ͉͂ࢊ̞̽̀ͥȃ ȁϋΑ·ςΛΠ͜ΩȜςٜ̯̦͆͜ȶ৾ςαȷ̹ޗࠐങ͉Ȅܡ͈͓̹̠͢ͅͅୌ؎ ςϋΠڠࡄݪ৪͈ಠ̜́ͤȄཱུ̜̹ͣͥ́̽͢ͅȃ̷̷̱̯̭̀ͣͅͅȄૺاაͬ৾ ͤවͦȪ̷̭͉ͅ߃యشڠএே͂ޗ̦ಂ̱̞͈̜̭̈́́ͥ͂ͬ͜া̱̹̞̞̠͂ၪ̦ ̜̹̽ȫȄ൳শ̹͘ͅ૰౺ڠ͈এேȪઁ̷̩͈֚̈́͂͜໐ȫȪ̭͉ͦȜσΛΠ̦ಿ̩۾ͬ ̻̫̹͈̜́ͤ͜Ȅ͈ෞಎ̜͉̽̀ͅޗ͂૰౺ڠ͉გ̴̱̠͉̜̹ͥ́̽ȫͬ৾͜ ࣺ̺͈̜̹ͤͭ́̽͜ȃ̷͈ષ̥̩́͂͜ȶධ༷ޗ͈Φϋȷͅ௲̱̹͈̞̠̤͂͜ཧັ̧ ͬΑζϋ΄ρ̧̥̱ͣ֨̀ۏ̨࣐̭̫̹̾ͅȃ̭̠̱̜̀ͥത͉́ȶΧͼήςΛΡȷ̈́ඤယ ̜̹̦́̽Ȅ̷ུ̱̥̱͈̭̦̭͈͈̫͂͂ͤͩୌ؎଼̤̫͈͈֚ͥ̾ͅࡔ֦̱̹͈ͬ̈́́ ͉̞̥̈́͂এͩͦͥȃ ȁြͅ୶ၛ̾ΣνȜȜςϋΒশయȄΧȜϋ͉ܡͅȜσΛΠུ͈ͅ࿒̱̞ͬ̀ͥȃͺȜ ΦσΡ͈ȸͺΐͺ͈ȹȪ1879ාȫͅయນ̯̭͈ͦͥশܢ͈ͺις̤̫ͥͅͺΐͺ͞ޗͅ చ̳ͥ۾͈͈ࣞͤ͘־ಎͅΧȜϋ͜պ౾̱̞̹̀ȃ̷͈۾͉ޗ୰დȄޗ͈ޗၑȄ̯ͣ ͉ͅర൮̳ͥȶΥȆήΛΟͻΒθȷ͈൲࢜́͘ͅݞ̤ͭ́ͤȄΐλȜςΑΠ̱͈͂̀נ̞ ۜͬส༷ͅװ̱͊ȄͺΟηΛ·̈́ޗࡃ̥ͣȄήρόΜ΅Ȝຳ૽͈൲ȄͼϋΡࡣ ങڠཱུ͈́͘დఴ̱̞̀ͥͅȃȜσΛΠུ͈͉षͅু֚́ॗࣔව̳͕̜ͥ̓́̽ ̹̦Ȅ̷͈ບث͂̈́ͥ͂Ȅ૯ୃ͈ޗ͉̦̹̞̞̠͂͛͂๛എ͈̈́͜ͅਞ̞̹̽̀17ȫȃ ȁ̷̺̫ͦͅȶဢల֚ȷ́ȸޗޗၑ࿚൞ȹ̦ഴા̵̯̞͈͉ͣͦ̀ͥḘ͈̏ۼȄ͂ͤͩ ̫ြࢃ்͈̞শܢͅȄུ̤̫ͥͅޗͅచ̳ͥΧȜϋ͈ࡉ༷ͅة̥͈ͣ་ا̦̜̹̭̽͂ ͬࢊ͈̜ͥ́ͥ͂͜ࣉ̢̧̭̦͈͉̞̥ͥ͂́ͥ́̈́͂এͩͦͥȃ ȁͼϋΡ͞ಎ࣭̤̞̳̥̹̀̽ͤͦͅޗ̦Ȅུ͉́ၦେͬࡶͤȨ̧̏͂ڰ൲̱̞̀ ͥȃಿ̞ഥൡ͂Ȅଚ̢̭̞ͥ͂ͬͣ̈́ସႁḘ̷ུ̤̫̏ͥͅͅޗͅచ̳ͥΧȜϋ͈ܢఞ ̦̜̹̽ȃ̺̦ष̧͙̽̀̀ͥ͂͞ͅȄྶহ૧ոࣛȄޗ͉ض۠̈́ুࡨ་ڟ͒͂൩͙̳ ̭͂́Ȅ૧̹̈́௳ͅ༫̞͈̺̹ͦ̀ͥ̽͘ȃ̧̭͙̹̠ͦ́̀͘͢ͅȄུ̤̫ͥͅޗ͉ ༷֚́ಎ࣭͈༃ͬͤק̢̀Ȅ̷͈̭̠࢜ͅޗ͈อത̳ͬ̈́ͼϋΡ͈Ȫठȫอࡉͬ࿒ঐ̳ ̭̹͂̈́̽ͅȃ̷͉ͦਲြུ͈̤̫ͥͅȶޗȷ͈იழ͙ͬȄ̷̜̞͉͈ͥ౷֚ͬ૧̳ͥ ̭͂ͅఈ̞̈́ͣ̈́ȃ̷͈༷̤̞֚̀ͅ߃య̤̫ͥͅୌ؎ဢڠ͈ޗࡄݪͅၛݗ̱̀ࠐങͬඋ ͙Ȅ̜̞͉ͥඋ͙ೄ̱Ȅ̷ͦͬࣽࢃ͈ޗ̧͈͓ͥঐૻ͈ಎͅନ̢ೄ̷̠̳͂ͥȃ̭͈࿂
͉́ဢ͈ਕޗ̦ة̥͈ͣփྙ́ୌ؎͈اȄএே͈͂୪ത̴̢̹̰ͬͥͬȄ̷͈גޣ͂ྫ ۾߸͉̞̞̭́ͣͦ̈́͂ͬা̳̭̺̠͂̈́ͥͧͅȃ ȁ̳͂ͥ̈́ͣȄ։ৗ̈́ါளࣺ̺ͬ৾ͤͭȜσΛΠ͈ȸޗޗၑ࿚൞ȹͅచ̱Ȅ̴̞̹ͣͅ ̷͈ȶΧͼήςΛΡȷͬঐഊ̱Ȅޗ̢͈૯ୃ̯݃ͅැ̧̞̺ͬȄ͈ͬဵ̵͍̱̀͂͢ ̳͈͉̩ͥ́̈́, ບث̞̳ͥͅୟޭഎ̈́௰࿂̧͓͉̞̥͛ͥ́̈́͂͜ࣉ̢ͣͦͥȃ̷̭ͅ ΧȜϋ̦̭͈ैͬȶဢల֚ȷͅഴા̵̯̹ၑဇ̦̜̺̠ͥͧȃ ȁ֣ય૬̞؍ຩͬࢃͅΧȜϋ͉ઐࢺͅၫ̺̻, ߧུͬࠐ̀, 1894ාठ͍؍ຩͬང͇̤̀ͤ, ̭ ͈শ͈తह̥̥͈֭ͣ̾̀ང࿚ͬठ͍ࢊ̤̱̹ͤ̈́ȶ؍ຩ̀ͅȷ̞̠͂ξΣȜ·̈́ै̦ ̭ͦͥ͂̈́ͥ͘ͅȃ̷̭͉ͅාͬਹ͇̹ਯ̦ഴા̱̀ΧȜῧޗ̪ͬ͛ͥٛდ̱ͬͩ, ̱̹ͬ৹̞͉ͬஜ̜̭̦̳̦ͦͦ͛ͬͥͅȄȜσΛΠུ͈͉ഴા̱̈́ ̞ȃ̷̺̦͈ࢃȄࣴͬ၂̻̫̹૰̥ͣΙͿϋΨτϋզ̹̽ͅ1895ා͈۰͈ಎ͉́ΧȜ ϋ͉ষ͈̠͢ͅ࡞̞̽̀ͥȃȶΞ΅Βθ̢̞͂͊Ȅ̞̯̯̥ඏฏঊ̞̈́͜დ̳̦́Ȅޗ Ξ΅Βθ͂́͜࡞̠̠͈̈́ͬ͢͜ै͙̹̞̽̀͂এ̹̭̦̜̱̹̽͂ͤ͘ȷ18ȫȃ̭̭͉ͅȸ ޗޗၑ࿚൞ȹ̦ැ൮ͅ౾̥̞͈͉ͦ̀ͥྶ̥ͣ́ȄȜσΛΠ͈ಠ৪͈ܱ؛͉փٸͅಿ̩ ͈ෞၔ̞̹̭̦̥࣫ͦ̀͂ͩͥ͘ͅȃ ȁΧȜϋ͈؍ຩठངͅ୶ၛ̾1893ා͉ͅȶྔ࣭ਕޗఱٛȷ̦ͺις̤̞̀ͅٳट̯ͦͥȃ̷ ͉ͦুࡨ٨ڟ଼͈ضͬݷ̬Ȅޗ͈ຽ༑എփ͈݅ౝݥ̷଼͈͂ضͅুͬ૬ུ̹̤̫͛ͥͅ ޗ̷̦͈ণതͬٸ̫͒࢜̀ૺ͙̳ࢡܥ̢̹ٛ͂͂ͣͣͦȃ̷̤̩̭̭ͣͅΧȜϋ̤̫ͥͅ ޗࣉख़͈̠͈֚̾͜࿂Ȅ̳̻̈́ͩୌ؎̷͈͈͈͜૧̹̈́་اͅ۾ͩͥޗ̞̠͂هఴ̦͘ ̩ͦ̀ͥȃ̭͈هఴͅచ̳͈ͥٝ൞Ȅ̷̦ͦΛΓͼȶΣσόȜȷ͉̞̺̠̥́̈́ͧȃ
లˎડȁȶΣσόȜȷ
ˍȅȸ༷ങȹ ȁུশయ͈లঅ๔࿒͈ಠै̜́ͥȸ࣭ാਚ֒ȹ19ȫͅਓ̹͛ͣͦȶΣσόȜȪַ૩ ଼ͥ͂͢ͅȶȸ࣭ാਚ֒ȹͅਓ̹͛ͣͦȶΣσόȜȷ̧ͬၭ̢͈ͥͅ२ාոષͬါ̱ ̹ȷ20ȫ̞̠͂ȫ͉ȄρέΟͻȆΧȜϋ͈ޗၑٜ͈ൢోതͬা̳ै̯͂ͦȄΧȜῧ ޗ͈͂۾߸ͬა̲ͥष͉ͅຈ̴৾ͤષ̧̬̹ͣͦ̀ȃږ̥ͅḘ̭͉̏ͅޗࠐങ̥͈ͣତఉ ̩͈֨ဥ̦८ͤ͊͛ͣͦȄٴ̤ͬ̽̀ΣσόȜͅঢ͈ͥ́͘ޗ୰̦ત̯ٚͦȄ൳শ͘ͅ ̹ȶΣσόȜȷ͈ޗၑ̪ͬ͛ͥୌ؎௰͈ၑٜ͂ࢋٜ͂ͅ൦͈̦ح̢̞ͣͦ̀̀Ȅಠ৪ ͈ޗͅచ̳ͥఉා̹ͩͥͅ૯ᒱ̈́۾͈̜̠̦ͤ͢ࡉ̀৾ͦͥ͂࡞̞̺̠̽̀ͧ͢ȃ ȁ̷̺̦͈༷֚́Ḙ͈̏ΛΓͼͅޗ̷͈͈͈͜ໝॠ̈́Ⴄঃഎࠊͬ൩̢͘Ȅผఱ̈́ࠐങ͈උ෫͂ޗၑͅ۾̳ͥڂฎ̈́ে̱̹ͬ͂͜ͅȄᣰྟ́ఘࠏഎ̈́აͥ͢ͅΣσόȜ͈ٜྶ ͬܢఞ̳ͥ͂ࡈ൫̥̱͈֣ય͜྾̞ͦ̈́͂͜ঐഊ̧̯̹ͦ̀ȃږ̥ͅḘ͈̏ΛΓͼ͉́ȶΣ σόȜȷ̷͈͈ͬ͜૬̩ݪྶ̱̞̩̞̠̀͂ͤ͢Ȅ̷̦ͦ߃యୌ؎شڠএே̭͂̓́୪ത ̻ͬȄ͈̠̓̈́͢փ̻̠͈̥̞̠݅ͬͥ͂തͅ۾̦ਬಎ̱̞̠̀ͥ͢͜ͅএ̢ͥȃ̺̦ ޗၑٜ̪ͬ͛ͥͺΟηΛ·̈́ளူ߱͞Ⴏ̦ࠨ̢̱͉̞̞̭͉̀͂̈́͂ΧȜϋু̦͢ ̩ઇ̱̞̹̭̜̀͂́ͤȄ̳̭͈͂ͦ͊19ଲܮྎ͈শయ̜̽̀ͅȄ̦͈̓౷ത̤̞̀ͅΣ σόȜͅ۾ͬܙ̵̞̹͈̥̀ͬ٨͛̀࿚̞ࡉޭ͛ͥຈါ̦̜̺̠ͥͧȃ ȁܡ͙̹̠͢ͅͅȄြոஜུ̥̤̫ͣͥͅޗͅ۾̞̹ͬ̽̀ΧȜϋ͉ȄུൢࢃȄ ୬̩̹ͤٛ̽͢ͺ΅ρȪ૯ණࢴȫ͈ఱ̧̈́੩ႁ̜ͤ͜Ȅ؍ຩ͞ہா͈ͬང࿚̳̭̦ͥ͂́ ̧̹̱Ȅ̷͈ࢃ͜୬ͅ͏ུ͈ͦ̀ુڰ͞ྦྷਤͅ૫൫̱̹ޗاͬ͜ͅܙ̵̤̀ͤȄ ̷ͦͣͬե̠͓̩ຊͬͥष͉ͅୌന୷ఊ͞ఱୃ̧̦ͣ͢ފႁ৪̹̩̹͂̈́̽ͦȃ ȁ̺̦ޗ͈ޗၑུ̤̫ͥ͞ͅޗ̦౾̥̹ͦેޙͅ۾̳ͥ૯ᒱ̈́۾͉Ȫ̽͋ͣ͜૰ൽอ ࡉ̥̦͊ͤޑ̯ͦͥઐࢺతहশ͜ͅܡͅධᕢဎ͈ྴ̜̬ͬ̀൚শུ͈̤̫ͥͅޗ͈ षͅ۾̳ͥૂ༭ͬݥ͉̞͈͈͛̀ͥ͜ȫ21ȫȄ1894ා͈ඵഽ࿒͈؍ຩང࿚ུ̥ͣڒഎ̞̈́̽̀ͅ ̩͂࡞̧̠͓͉̞̺̠̥́̈́ͧȃ ȁȶΣσόȜȷ͉̭͈ˎഽ࿒͈؍ຩང࿚͈װಿષͅպ౾̳ͥȃ̭͈̠̈́͢ΛΓͼͬ ̭̠̳͂ͥष͉ͅȄ൚ட̦̈́ͣޗ̞̾̀ͅȄུ̜̞͉̤̫ͥͥͅޗͅ۾̱̀Ȅ̷͈ఘ ௨̥̩ͬ͂͜՜̱̞̞̠̀ͥ͂ু͂ু̦ະخ̜͈͉ࠧ́ͥ࡞̠̞̺̠́̈́ͧ͘͜ȃ̭͈ ത́ΧȜϋ͉Ȅ͂ஜࢃུ̱̀ͅతह̱Ȅޗͅܙ̵̹έͿΦυ͞ΫΊυ;͂ఱ̧̩ ֑̞̽̀ͥ͂࡞̩͉̞ͩ̈́̀̈́ͣ̈́ȃ ȁ1884Ȫྶহ17ȫා11ȄઐႲઽ̱̹͂ͩచდ̦ࠀܥ͂̈́ͤȄέͿΦῦΫΊυ;͉ݢ ௸ͅޗͅ୪߃̱̞̩̀22ȫȃံ1885Ȫྶহ18ȫා˕Ȅඵ૽͉ષނ̱̹ઽ༹ྶ͈֭॓֔ࠉ ඃՒၐͅ٦̫ͬͥ23ȫȃനݛ̷଼͉͈ȶࠉඃఱგષၞഥȹ̤̞̀ͅȶༀ࣭૽έͿΦυ ȄΫΊυ;൝̹̠̀͘ͅ٦̫ͬȄ༹̱̱͊͊݅ͬ࿚͏ȃ༹̩ͬͥͅΫΊυ;ͬ ̞͂͌ȄέͿΦυͬം̞͂͏ȃ̹͘ඵআ͈̹͛ͅᕨ࿌༨य़٦ࠐ̴࣒ͬȷ24ȫ͂࡞̞̽̀ͥȃ ̭ͦոࣛ͜ඵ૽͉Ȅ̫͂ͤͩΫΊυ;͉Ȅܜഽ॓֔͜ࠉඃ͈͂ͬ͜ངͦȄ̷̱̩͈ޗ̢ͅဓ ͤਘ࣐ͅ႗̺ͭȃέͿΦυ͕͖͜൳အ̜̹̭͉́̽͂Ȅ॓֔ࠉඃͬࠑ̞̺ೄႅࠉͅզ̹̀ ۰́ȶ൳ාสสඵঢς༹ྶ֭ඵΞࢵඵఈΦ٦ϊςစࢵඵࣞ൝σਘުΦ༹༷ࢄޗ াඵဖςଵκఀΦࢃ֨΅Ⴏ࣐౿Ώȷ25ȫ͓̞̭͂̀ͥ͂̽̀͢͜ͅၔັ̫̱ͣͦͥȄࢃ Ȫ1890Ȫྶহ23ȫාȫ̷͉͈֒ͅ࡞̦̽̀֒ࣸ͢ͅઽ༹ྶ֭ͅ֊̯̹͈͉̩ͦͣͦ͢ ̞̜̀ͥͤ́ͥ26ȫȃ̭͈ඵ૽͂ڛ̳ͥ͂ΧȜϋ͉̞ࣞ̾̀ͅޗ͈ޗ̢̥̠̱ͬͧ͂ ̹̭͂͜Ȅၩ̱͈͂̀ਘ࣐ͬୟ̺̭̞ͭ͂̈́͜ȃޗͅࠉփ̞ͬȄͅങͬຏٜ̞̹ ͈͉ږ̥̺̦Ȅਕޗഎ̈́૬̞ࠐࡑ̱ͬ̀Ȅ࡞ဩ̱ͅඳ̞؈૬̩ྥ̈́ة͈̥ͬ͜ೕ͚ܥٛ
͉ͅࠃ̥̹ͦ̈́̽͂͘࡞̧̠͓̺̠ͧȃ̺̦Ȅ̷̳̺̫͂ͦ͊ͦͅޗͅ۾̳ͥে̫ͬ̀ ̩ͦͥ૽Ȅ̷̱̹͈̀ͦంह̦ਹါ̴̞͉͉̥̹́̈́̈́̽ȃ ȁषȄȶΣσόȜȷ͉ͅȶޗ৪͈̜ͥ૽ȷȪ168ȫ̞̠֚͂୯̦̜͈̦ͥࡉ൪̵̞̈́ȃ ̹͘ȶΣσόȜ̞ٜ̱̩̹̾̀̀ͦͅȸུ̜͈ͥ૽ȹȷȪ191ȫȪ̭͈ඵ૽̦൳֚૽ ̜̥̠̥͉́ͥ̓ະྶȫ̦̞̹̭̞͂ͦͣͦ̀̀͜Ȅུ͕͂ͭ̓ࢊ͈උ̧̧͙̦̥́̈́̽ ̹ΧȜῧ̽̀ͅȄࠐങྴུ͈ࢊ͈́උ͙༷̞̹͂̽༜എ͈̥̈́ͣ͜Ȅඅ͈ࠐങ͈̥̈́ ͈ਹါؿਫ਼͈ঐഊ֨͞ဥȄ̷ཱུ͈̈́̓Ḙ̠̱̹̏૽ͥ͢ͅޗা͞ͺΡόͼΑ̦̜͉̽̀ ̲͛̀خෝ̹̭̦̈́̽͂ͅઁ̩̞̥̥̈́̈́͊ͤȄ̯͉̭̠̱̹ͣͅފႁ͞੩ႁ͈ષ͉̲͛̀ͅ ȶུ̤̫࡛͈ͥࣽͅޗ͈ఘഎএேȷȪ186ȫͬೕ͙Ȅȶޗంहა͈ႊڜȷȪ184ȫͬຝ̧̠ ̞̠ͥ͂ജབ͂ু̦͂ΧȜϋ̴̹̯̹͉̜ͣͦ́ͥ͜ͅȃΧȜϋ͉ষ͈̠͢ͅ࡞̞̽̀ͥȃ ȶȸ؍ຩ̀ͅȹ͉ޗͅ۾̳ͥડ́ȁȽȁ̜ͥჇ͈͂చდ̜̳̦́ͤ͘Ȅַ૩ঙ̦ȁȽఉ̩ ͈ৗ࿚ͅͅࡉমͅ൞̢̀ȁȽȁഥ̩̹͈̱̹̽̀ͦ́ȷ27ȫȃ ȁȶΣσόȜȷ͉ͅྴ̺̫͈͈̥ͣ͜Ȅಿ̞֨ဥ̞̹ͥ́͘ͅȄઁ̥̈́ͣ͆ޗࠐങȄ ޗ۾߸̦ഴા̳ͥȃةͤ͢͜ల֚ͅȸ༷ങȹȪݞ̷͍̭ͅਓ̯̹ͦࠐങȫͬݷ̬̈́ ̫̞ͦ͊̈́ͣ̈́ȃषΛΓͼȶΣσόȜȷ͈ಎ͉́ȶȸ༷ങȹͅਓ̹͛ͣͦޗࠐ ങཱུ͈ȷȪ164ȫȶȸ༷ࠐങȹͅਓ̯̹ͦȪȆȆȆȫȸఱ๊ᙌᖧࠐȹȷȪ165ȫ͂Ȅඵഽͩͅ ̹̽̀࡞ݞ̯̞ͦ̀ͥȃΧȜϋ͈ल͈ط͉ͅͺιςশయȄͅਬ̹͛࠸Ⴤ́ၛ෩̈́൳ ͈ܜॗ̥ͅح̢̀Ȅ̷̤̩ͣ؍ຩ́ࣔව̯̹ͦ͂এͩͦͥల49ے͈ȶఱޗȷ̦́͘ ̞̹ͭ́Ȫ1894ාۏུ࣐͈̭͈͉ζΛ·ΑȆηνρȜͅచ̳ͥධᕢဎ͈ފႁ̦̜͉̲̽̀͛ ଼̀ၛ̢̱̹͈̜́ͥ͜ȫȪȸΗυΈȹ͉͕̥͜ͅͅఉତ͈ࠐങȄ̷͈ఈޗ۾߸͈ྴ̦Ⴅ ݷ̯̞̭͉ͦ̀ͥ͂٨͛̀౯̞̺̠ͥ́̈́ͧ͘͜ȫȃ̴̭̭͉̭̠̱̹́͘ޗࠐങ͞ޗ۾ ߸ͬȄ̷͈֚୯̵͢ͅȄ̴̜̞͉̥ͥͩ̈́ࢊ߉̵̺̫͢ͅȄ̥̩͂֨ͅဥເͬဥ̞Ȅ̜̞ͥ ͉ͼΗς·Άນা̯̹͈ͦͬ͜ոئ͈̠͢ͅȄˍȫȸဢങȹͅਓ̯̹ͦޗࠐങȄˎȫ ̷ͦոٸ͈ޗࠐങȄˏȫ̷͈ఈޗ۾߸͈ˏ̫̾̀ͅାၑ̱͙̹̞̀ȪȶΣσόȜȷ ͅഴા̳ͥਜ਼͓ͥͅȃΛඤ͉ȸ༷ങȷ͈ےତ̜́ͥȫȃ ˍȫȸ༷ങȹͅਓ̯̹ͦޗࠐങ
“ The Diamond- Cutter ” (“ The Sacred Books of the East ” (以下においてはSBEと略記する), vol. 49)
“ Fo-Sho-Hing-Tsan-King ” (SBE, vol.19)
“ The Questions of King Milinda ” (SBE, vols.35 and 36) “ Sutra of the Great Decease ” (SBE, vol.11)
“ Sutra of the Great King of Glory ” (SBE, vol.11) “ Mahavagga ” (SBE, vol.17)
“ Sutra of the Lotus of the Good Law ” (SBE, vol.21) “ Kullavagga ” (SBE, vol.20)28ȫ
ˎȫȸ༷ങȹոٸ͈ޗࠐങ ´&KƈLQN\żµ ´+L]żKR\DNXµ ´&KLVKżKLVKżµ ´6RNXVKLQ-żEXWVXJLµ ´(QJDNX6Kżµ ´.HJRQ.\żµ$YDWDPVDND6XWUD ´'DLERQ.\żLµ ´'DL1LFKL.\ż6żµ ´'DL]żKżVƈµ ˏȫ̷ͦոٸ͈ޗ۾߸
Kuroda, “ Outlines of the Mahayana ” 29ȫ
ˍȫȸ༷ങȷ̤̫ͥͅޗࠐങ
ȁȸີ५ࣞ൝ڠࢷΰσϋࡩ࿒ȹ(“ Catalogue of the Lafcadio Hearn LiErary in the Toyama High School ”)Ȫີ५Ȅ1927ාȫ30ȫͥ͂͢ͅȄζΛ·ΑȆηνρȜ͈ȸ༷ങȹ͉ΗυΈ ๔͈890๔̥ͣ910๔͈́͘21ॗȪȸηςϋΘ͈ؐ࿚̞ȹ͉2ॗ̥̞̥ͦ̀ͥͣͅȄതତ͉́ 20തȫ̤ͬ͛̀ͤȄ̷͈̠̻ޗࠐങ͉˕തȪ10ॗȫȪȸ༷ങȹల10Ȅ11Ȅ13Ȅ17Ȅ19Ȅ 20Ȅ21Ȅ35Ȅ36Ȅ49ےȫͬତ̢ͥȪ̭͈̠̻ల19ے“ The Fo-Sho-Hing-Tsan-King ”Ȫȸਫ਼࣐ॶࠐȹȫ ͉ϋΑ·ςΛΠ̥̯̹͈͈ͣۧͦ͜ם̜́ͥȫȃఱങ͉ల49ے͈͙̞͂̓̽̀͘ͅ ̦ͥḘ͉̏ͦ൚শ͈ୌ؎̤̫ͥͅޗࡄݪ̤̞͉̀ͅܢޗ̷̭ୃൡུ̈́ြ͈ޗ͈ޗ̢́ ̜̯ͥ͂ͦȄ̷͈༷֚ఱޗ͉೩̞ບث̲̹̹۫ͭ͛ͅȄཱུ̦ಁ̞̹̥̺ͦ̀ͣ͂࡞̢ͥ ̺̠ͧȃ ȁષ́ࡉ̹̠͢ͅḘ͈̠̻̥̱̹̏ۧͣల13ےոٸ͈˔തȪ˕ॗȫ̥̥͈ͣ̈́ͭͣ֨ဥȪల 11ے̥͉ͣਓ̯̹ͦ։̈́ͥˎ͈̾ࠐങ̥͈ͣ֨ဥ̦̜ͥȫ̦̯̤̈́ͦ̀ͤȄ̞̠̭͉͂͂ਫ਼ ခ̱̞̹̀ޗ۾߸͈͕͖̳͓͈̀ȸ༷ങȹ̥ͣ֨ဥ̱̞̞̠̭̜̀ͥ͂͂ͥͅȃ֚૽͈ Քز̱͂̀ਫ਼ခ̳̳͓͈ͥ̀ࡃ̥ͣ֨ဥ̱̀ু͈ͣડͅ८̷̹̞̞̠̥ͤ͊͛͂͌̈́ ൲̥̹ͣͦ͂ͅே௨̳͈͉ͥڢ̱̞̦Ȅ͉̭͉ͤͦ͞ޗ͈ޗ̢ͬ༊഼̢̩̠ͤ̈́͂ͣ͂͛͢Ȅ ̷͈ఉအ̈́ڐ̦ͤͬা̱̹̞̞̠͂এ̞̦ד̯̹ͦࠫض̜́ͥ͂ࣉ̢̧͓̺̠ͥͧȃ̷̱̀
̭̠̱̹এ̷̞̭̦ȄΧȜϋ̦ু͈̞̽̀ͥȸ༷ങȹ͈͙ͅջݶ̱̀ડ͈ͬͥ́ ͉̩̈́Ȅ̯̱ͣۧͬ̀ͅȄུ̜̞͉͈̯̹ͥ́ͦ͜ޗങͬ͜ࢩ̩৾ͤවͦȄ֨ဥ̳ ̭̹͈͉̞̺̠̥ͥ͂̈́̽́̈́ͧ͜ͅȃ ˎȫȸ༷ങȷոٸ͈ޗࠐങ ȁ̭͈ΈσȜί͉́ྴུ̦̳͓̀ࢊ͈ࡤઠ͈υȜζলນܱ̽̀͢ͅা̯̤ͦ̀ͤȪ̹̺̱Ȅ ܱ؛֑̞̥֣क़শ͈ηᾼ̥̽̀͢ȄυȜζল̦ͤྶ̥ͣͅഐ୨̞́̈́͂౯̯͈̦ͦͥ͜ ֚໐̜ͥȫȄ̷̹͈͘ࡔങ͈̦͂̈́ͥ͜ȸ࿒ȹ͉́ږ̧̥̹̭̥́̈́̽͂ͣḘ͉̞̏ͦͣ ̴ͦ͜୶ུ͓̹̠͢ͅͅ௰͈ފႁ৪Ȅૂ༭ރ৪͈ͬ๏̵̹͈ͩ͂͜ࣉ̢̧͓̺̠ͥͧȃ ̭ͦͣͬ৾ͤව̹ͦၑဇ͉ఱޗ۾߸͈ࠐങͬࢩ̩৾ͤව̭ͦͥ͂́Ȅୌ؎͈ܢޗ͈͒ ༊ͤͬୃ̱Ȅޗ̷͈̱̀ޗࠐങ͈ఘ௨ͬা̱̹̞̞̠͂փ̦࢜ΧȜϋ̜̹̥̺̽ͣ͂ͅ ࣉ̢ͣͦͥȃ ȁུ̤̫ͥͅޗ͈ߓఘഎ̈́௰࿂ͅ۾̱͉̀ȶΣσόȜȷలː୯̤̞̀ͅȄޗ͈ͬ ત̱ٚȄུ͈ྦྷਤ͉ȶᙌᖧȷͅ۾͉̩̈́Ȅ̽͋ͣ͜ȶޭڢȷͬܐ̞̽̀ͥ͂࡞̞Ȅխ̞͉ ̹͘૯ਕ̦ȶ࡛͈ࣽਕȪ෩ȫ͉́डఱ̥̾ड͜ີဉ̜́ͥȷȪ184ȫܱ̱̤͂̀ͤ͜Ḙ͉̏ͦ ̦൚শུ͈̤̫ͥͅޗͅ൚̈́۾̷̞ͬͦ̈́ͤͅૂ༭ͬਬ̞̹̭͛̀͂ͬȄ̷̱̭̀ ͈ΛΓͼ̤̞̀͜ͅޗ๊̞̠֚͂ͤ͢Ȅུ̤̫ͥͅޗ̥ͣං̹͈ͬ͜ఱ̧̩̞͂ͤͦ ̹̭͂ͬা̧̱̞̞̠͓̺̠̀ͥ͂ͧȃུ̭̠̱̹̤̫ͥͅޗ͈षͅ۾̱͉̀ઐࢺশయ ͈۰̴ֺ̧̥̦̠̭̦ͩ̈́ͣ͂́͜ͅȄȶͺͼΞσ͈ΧϋΡήΛ·ಎུ͈༎͉ଃ̺ະြ ̜́ͥȆȆȆධᕢ͈̠̈́͢૽ུ̦̭̠̱̹̞̩̞͈̥ͬ̀ͦ̈́͜ȷ31ȫ͓̞̭͂̀ͥ͂͜ͅ ಕ࿒̧̱̤̹̞̀ȃ̯̹ͣ͘ͅȶ̭͈̯̯̥̈́͞ࡄݪ̤̞͉̀ͅྦྷਤ͈ަ͉ե̞ͩ̈́ȷȪ185ȫ ̱͂̀Ȅͣࣞഽ̈́ޗၑ͈൦ͅઙത̱͖̞̦ͬ̽̀ͥḘ͈̠̏̈́͢൚শུ͈̤̫ͥͅޗ ͈എ̈́ޗၑ̪ͬ͛ͥࡎ͈̦͂̈́ͥȪˏȫࣱ͈ന૯൸͈ಠै̜́ͥȃ
ˏȫS. Kuroda,ȨOutlines of the Mahâyâna. As taught Ey Buddhaȩ, Tokyo, Bukkyo Gakkuwai,1893. ȁ̭͉ͦാਕ͈ന眞൸͈̈́ͥͅȸఱޗఱփȹȪނȄᄵἕ學ٛȄ1893Ȫྶহ26ȫාȫ ͬם̱̹͈̜́ͤ͜Ȅཱུ͈ຈါ̦̜̹͈͉̭͈̽ॗঊͬͺις̤̞̀ͅື̱Ȅུ ̤̫ͥͅޗ͈ၑٜ௯ૺͬͥ࿎എփ̦̜̹̥̽ͣͅఈ̞̈́ͣ̈́ȃ̳̻̭͉̈́ͩͦ1893ාȄ ΏΌ́ٳट̯̹ͦȶྔ࣭ਕޗఱٛȷ̵̜ͩ̀ͅۏ࣐̯̹͈̺̹͈̜ͦ̽́ͥ͜ȃ ˎȅࣱന૯൸͂ȶྔ࣭ޗఱٛȷ ȁ1893ා˕ȄυϋΫͺྔ࣭ฎ။͈ٛٳट̵ࣣ͂ͩ̀Ȅྔ࣭ਕޗఱ̦ٛΏΌ̤̞̀ͅٳट ̯ͦͥ32ȫȃΠςΛ·ȄίυΞΑΗϋΠȄξΘμޗȄΪϋΡͽȜޗȄޗȄͼΑρθޗȄ૰ൽȄ ̷͈ఈଲٮಎ͈ਕޗ͈యນ৪֚ͬ൴ͅਬ͛Ȅ̤͈̤͈͈৽ಫ͞ැ͓ࣣ̞ͬȄ݇ͬ૬͛ၑ
ٜͬ௯ૺ̳ͥܥ̷̳̞̠͈̦͈ٛ͂ͥ͂ਇক̜̹́̽͂࡞̢̺̠ͥͧȃ ḁུ̏ͣ͜΅ςΑΠޗȪॄࢬൽȫȄ૰ൽȪড়നႛ֚ȫȄ̷̱̀ޗ͈ڎయນ৪̦٬ͬള̽̀ ४ح̱Ȅڬͤ൚̹̀ͣͦশۼ࣒࣐̞ͬͅȄৗ݃ͅ൞̢Ȅၠ͈ܥ̹ٛͬ̽ȃޗ۾߸͉́ ႉफਕ͈৷ਕȄȪാȫ૯ਕ͈สໟ᪰ၨȄ૯࡞ਕ͈ാ༹ܽၨȄഛరਕ͈ೋ̦ഴ౭̱̹ Ȫ̭͈͕̥ͅहز৪͈֔߄२͜४ح̱Ȅ̷͈ࡉম̈́םࢊͬߐঀ̱̹́Ȅ։दͬ༶̽̀ ̞ͥȫȪΉͼρΑ͉̭͈ྔ࣭ਕޗ݈ٛͅ௷ͬͭ́ۜྐྵͬݛ̱̩̱Ȅံ1894ා͉ͅȸήΛΘ͈ إȹͬๅ̳ͥȃ̭ͦͅޑ̩อ̯̹͈̦ͦȄఱ̤̫ٛͥͅ৷ਕ͈࣒ࡔࣂཱུ͈̜̹̽ͅ ̹ႝ࿐೭ఊȪఱ୩ȫ̜́ͤȄ̷͉͈ˏාࢃͼςΦͼ͈ρȆȜσͅΉͼρΑͬང͇Ȅಿ̞ తह͈ࢃȄ͈ಠུͬࢊཱུ̳̭ͥ͂̈́ͥͅͅȫȃ ȁփဳ֜ͦͅȄփܨࡌࢳ̈́ޗ͈యນ৪ోȪȶޗ͈Ιλϋάϋȷ͂ࡤ̹͊ͦȫ͉Ȅఱٛ ਞၭࢃ̯ͣ͜ͅ༆ഷ࣒͈ܥٛͬ୭̫Ȅུ̤̫ͥͅޗ͈ત഼ٚ͛ͅȄ̷͈ຽݞ͂࿎ͅ ཱི̳̦ͥḘ͈̏ڰ൲͈֚੩̳͓̩͂Ȅତത͈ॗঊͬထུ͛́ဥփ̱Ȅ४̧̱̞̀̀ ̹͈̺̹̽ȃ̷ࣱ͈̦֚̾ന͈ȸఱփȹͅఈ̞̈́ͣ̈́Ȫ͕̥ͅষ͈̠͈̦̜̹̈́̽͢͜ȃȨA
Brief Account of Shinshu Catechism.ȩȪสໟ᪰ၨȸ૯ਕࣇါȹȫȨ Tendai Religion.ȩȨBasic Principles of Nichiren.ȩȨ The Essentials of BuddhismȩȪୄాྖȸਕޗഓڠڄࣸȹȫȃ
ȁ̭͂ͧ́Ȅȸఱᄵޗఱփȹ͈࡞͉ͅոئ͈̠̜̦ͥ͢ͅḘུ̏ͦͬࢊๅ͂ם͂ͬచ ચ̱̀ࡉ͙̠̀͢ȃ ⧶ාኈฎᬍᅠཤༀࣣਤኈͅٳ̥ͥȕͅष̱̀Ȅ ଲٮਕἕఱᅠ͈擧̜ͤȄِཆఱ ᄙᄵἕͬᎢ̩ᗳༀڎཆ͈ۼͅᅯ͉͒ͭͅȄ艮一ͅ୷श͈ࢡܥ̈́ͤȃఉාᄵἕ͈ޗၑ學說 ͬࢬ̳ͥͬո͈֚̀࿒എِ̳̦͂ͥȶᄵἕ學會ȷ͉Ȅࣻܥͅᄙ̱̀Ȅఱᄙᄵἕ͈ ఱփͬ੪ ̱Ȅவἕኈ̀ͅ ၑͬݥ͚͈ͥ͜ͅ對̱Ȅِ̥̜ܵͥ佛క͈ἕ݅ ͬ傳̱̀Ȅἕز͈݅ྩͬض̱ȄՔ͈ ̵̠݇ͬͭȁܑ͂ͬ̀Ȅဒͅఀ ैͬ ̵ͤȃ33ȫ
The Parliament of Religions toEe held this year in connection with the World s ColumEian Fair, is a very good opportunity to make known among the Christian countries the doctrine of Mahâyâna.
The Bukkyô-Gakkwai, a society whose sole aim is the propagation of Buddhism, resolved to take advantage of this opportunity to impart to those Christians who are willing to receive truth the light of Buddhism, and thus to discharge their duty towards them as Buddhists and as fellow-men. For this purpose they
entrusted the author with the preparation of a short treatise on Buddhism.34ȫ ȁडࢃ͈ؿਫ਼̜̠ͥ͢ͅͅḘ͈̏ॗঊ͉ȶᄵἕ學會ȷ͈տుࣱ̫ͬ̀ന૯൸̦͈̱͜Ȅ̥ ̹̭͈̾͘ȶᄵἕ學會ȷ͈ࢷר͂ઇͬࠐ̀ۏ࣐ͅঢ̞̽̀ͥȃུࢊๅ͈ນঞ͉ͅষ͈̠͢ ͅࢷר৪̷͈͂ਕ෩̦ྶܱ̯̞ͦ̀ͥȃȶഛరȁᗣ࿐߰ȁ૯࡞ȁ৷ચȁႉफȁ৷ਕȁ ൸ȁࣞനൽࡉȁ૯ਕȁఆષୈȁڎࢷרȁാȁࣱന૯൸ȁಠȷ̜͂ͥȃ ȁ̭͈ȶᄵἕ學會ȷ͉̞ͩͥ͠ͺΟηΛ·̈́ࡄݪܥ۾̞̱̈́౬ఘ͉̩́̈́Ȅޗڎਕ̷̦͈ ֑Ȅ։൳಼̢ͬ̀Ȅފ̱̠ͥޗၑͬࡉ̱Ȅ̷̠̳̭ͥ͂́ޗȶࢬȷ͈௯ૺͬͤȄ ̷͈ഥȄຽݞ̳͓̩ͥͅ୭̫̹͈̜̹ͣͦ́̽ȃ̷ࣱ̭́ന͈ȸఱփȹ͜අ͈ਕ෩̷͈ ̴ͦ͂̓ͣ͘ͅȄ̷಼̢͈֑ͬ̀ވခ̯̠ͦͥޗ͈ޗ̢ͬা̷̠̳͈̜̹̞͂ͥ́̽͂͜ ̠̭͂̈́ͥͅȃ̷ͦͬםࢊๅ͉́ȶζΧȜμȜ͈Ρ·Πςϋȷ̞̞̦͂̽̀ͥȄུࢊๅ́ ͉ȶِཆఱᄵޗȷ̞̭͂̈́̽̀ͥ͂ͅಕփ̱̹̞ȃུࢊๅͅਲ̠̈́ͣȄȶଲٮਕޗఱٛȷ ͅ४حུ̳ͥ௰͈࿒എ͉ఱޗ̷๊͈͉̩֚ͦ́̈́Ȅུ̜̩͈́͘͜ఱޗ͈તٚഥ ̷̭̜̹̞̠̭̽͂͂̈́ͥͅͅȃ ȁਔ͈ͤȄఱޗ͉ಎ࣭̥ͣಱോͬࠐུ̀ͅഥȄഥြ̱̹̺̦Ȅȸఱޗ ఱփȹͥ̈́ͣ͢ͅȄ̷͈ࢃ͈ಿ̞শۼ͈ࠐً͂͂͜ͅȶඣȄಱ൝ఱ乘͈ἕ̴̧༹̜̈́ͣͅ ͂ᪧ͜Ȅ֎̱͂̀૦͉ȷȪ4Ƚ5ȫ̞̈́ခအͅۿ̤̽̀ͤ35ȫȄ࡛শത̤̞̀ͅఱޗ̦ၦେ ͬࡶͤȄڰอ̈́ڰ൲̦࣐̞̞̠ͩͦ̀ͥ͂ത́Ḙ̷ུ̦̏ఱޗ͈యນ৪̹ͥͅ͏̯̱ͩ ̞̞̠͂आݶ̷̭ͬͅࡉ̷̠̱̞͂̀ͥȃ ȁ̭͉̯ͦͣͅȄಎ࣭Ȅಱോͬࠐུ̀ͅঢͥఱޗ͈ഥ͉Ȅ౷ၑഎȄশۼഎ̈́ଔ֊ ̴͂̓ͣ͘ͅȄ൳শͅఱޗ̷͈͈̦ͤࣞ͜͢ഽ̈́ٴͅঢͥൽ̜́ͤ͜Ȅ̱̹̦̽̀ड ଼̯̹ۖͦ͜ఱޗ̷ུ͉̭ͅݥ̧͓̺̞̠͛ͥ͂৽ಫ͍̫̞̩̭͂ࠫ̾ͣͦ̀͂̈́̽ͅ ̹ȃ ȁ̭͈തࣱ́നུ͈͉൚শུ͈̤̞̀ͅޗ͈ঐ൵৪̦Ȅྶহ૧ո͈ࣛুࡨ་ڟͬࠐ̀Ȅ ̠̩͢͞ྶږ̈́௨ͬࠫ͐ͅঢ̹̽ȶུ̧̜͓͈ͥޗȷͬஜ࿂ͅ؋̷̱̠̳͂ͥփ̦࢜ޑ ̩ד̯̹͈̜̹ͦ́̽͂͜࡞̢͈͉̞̺̠̥ͥ́̈́ͧȃ ȁུ͈ޗ͈අ͈͉֚̾ఱޗ͂ޗ͈༷̦ވం̱̞̭̀ͥ͂ͧͅݥ̞͛ͣͦ̀ ͥȃȶఱ͈ޗ݅ዜட̱͂̀ͤȄ،ட̱͂̀େ͈̈́ͥ͜Ȅ獨ِͤཆͬո̀டͤ͂爲̳ȷȪˑȫȃ ̢͉̞͂ȶఱ͈ἕ͉݅徧̩乘͈ἕ༹ͬ༫௬̱̀ဒ̳ਫ਼̈́ȷȪˏȫ̩Ȅ̷ͦઁ̩̈́͂͜ޗ ͈݅࿂͈́ఱ͈ࣣ̦ޑ̯̭ͦͥ͂̈́ͥͅȃ̷͈̹͛ᙌᖧ͈࿚ఴ͈̠͢ͅȄ͈ࡉٜ ͉́ຈ̴̱ٜ̈́͜ྶ̦̯̞͈̦̜̯̈́ͦ̈́ͥ͂ͦͥ͜ȃȶ乘͈փ͉ͬߎේ͈आུ͂ ̱̈́Ȅଵͬת̱̀ൽً̱ͬȄז͈ਫ਼ٜͬᙌᖧ̳͂̈́ȷȪ27ȫ̦Ȅఱ͈ޗ̢ͅ ͥ͂͢ȶ̳̥ͥͅࡐ࡛̱̀Ȅྫၾ͈ඃͬߓ͒ඳএ͈ުͬা࡛̳Ȅͅᙌᖧ͉
ࠨ̱̀ߗ̴͈̭̜͂ͧͣͅȷȪ26Ƚ27ȫȃ̭̠̱̀ఱȄȄ༷̦ވం̱̦̈́ͣȄࢃ৪ͬ ༫܄̳ࣣͥഎ̈́ఱޗ̦ȶུ͈ޗȷ͈අ̱ͬ̈́Ȅ̷͉̹֚ͦ͘ڎ༷࢜͒ഥ̱̹ ޗུ̦ࣣ́ၠ̱ఱع̳̞̠ͬ̈́͂৽ಫͬआݶ̫̞̩̭̿̀͂̈́ͥͅȃܡ͓̹͈̠͢ͅͅȄ ̢̜̭̠̱̹̀৽ಫ̵̢̰̞ͬͥͬ̈́ࠊ͉ͅȄୌ؎ဢڠͥ͢ͅȶܢޗȷ͈ਹণ͂Ȅఱ ޗͅచ̳ͥࠚণ̦̜ͤḘ͉̏ͦͅႝ࿐ఱ୩͜ȶఱޗͅచ̳ͥഽਹ̈́ͥȄଃ̺̱̩ະ൚ ̈́ඳȷ36ȫ͂ະྖ͈ͬဲ̢̞̞̹ͣͦ̈́́ȃ̷͈༷֚́Ȅ1890ාయ̈́ͥ͂ͅ৷ਕȄ৷ޟட ̦ΓͼυϋͅളͤΩȜςͥ͢ͅങ͈ࡄݪ̻ࣺ̺̭ͭ͂͜ͅདྷ͉̞̺̠ͦ̀̈́ͣ̈́ͧ37ȫȃ ȁࣱ͉́നུ͈̦ΧȜϋ̢̻̹ͅփ݅ͬࣉ̢͙̠̀͢ȃˍȫୌ؎͈ޗࡄݪ଼͈ضͅ۾̳ͥ ࡉͬࠈ̢̀ြ̱̹ΧȜῧ̷͉̽̀ͦͅȄু͈ͣြশത̤̫ͥͅޗ͈ൢోതͬͥͅ ͉ȄͼϋΡ͞ಎ࣭̥̩̈́̀͜ͅȄུ͈ޗ͂୪̳̭̺ͥ͂́͂౯̱̠ͥआݶ͂ু ͬဓ̢̩̹̀ͦȃ̷̢ͦ͠Ȅȸ༷ങȷͅح̷̢͈̀ۧఈུ͈̜ͥͅޗࠐങͬح̢ͥ ̭͂́ޗޗၑ͈ఘഎႊڜ̷ͬͦ̈́ͤͅা̱̹̭̺̠͂̈́ͥͧ͂ͅࣉ̢̠̹ͥ̈́̽͢ͅȃ ˎȫུ͈ޗ̦ୌ؎̥࢜̽̀ͅփ͈̜݅ͥιΛΓȜΐͬอ̳̭̦ͥ͂خෝ̜́ͤȄष̷̠ ̱̠̱̞̭̹͂̀ͥ͂̽͢ȃ̭͉ͦȶΣσόȜȷ̤̫ͥͅ൚শ͈ୌ؎ଲٮ̤̫ͥͅا എȄএேഎ̈́࿚ఴ͈̥̥̤̞͂ͩͤ̀ͅޗ̢̞̩̞̠ͬ͂ͣ̀͂࿚ఴփে̹̱̹ͬͣ͜ȃ ijȅȶΣσόȜȷ ȁոષͬ൩̢̀͘٨͛̀ΧȜϋ͈ȶΣσόȜȷͬࡉ͙̹̞̀ȃୌ؎̤̫ͥͅޗࡄݪ̦ಠ ̱̞ૺೃ͙̹ͬ19ଲܮ̷͈͊͜ͅঢͥ͂Ȅ͈ςϋΗςΑΠ͈ۼ́͜Ȅ̹͘এேز͞ ا૽͈ۼ̤̞̀͜ͅΣσόȜၑٜͅఱ̧̈́۾̦ਬͤ͘Ȅ̯̰̈́͘͘ა݈̦̯ͩͦͥ ̭̹͂̈́̽ͅȃ̫͂ͤͩΣσόȜ͉͂ȶݫޭ͈ݹྫȷȶ֚୨͈કȷͬঐ̱Ȅ̱̹̦̽̀ ޗ͉͂ȶ୲చ͈કͅঢͥȷȶݹྫ͈ਕޗȷͅఈ̴̈́ͣȄ̷̳͉͂ͥ̈́ͣͦβΏηΒθȄΣ ΪςΒθͅঢͥ૽ۼഎ̈́ޗ̢͉̞͈̥̞̠́̈́͂݃࿚̦Ȅ̫͂ͤͩܡం͈ਕޗͬသࢌ̱Ȅ̜ ̷̞͉̭̲̭̠̳ͥͧ͂ͥ͜ͅସႁ̢̥̠̹͈̺̹ͣࣞͣͦͥ̈́̽̽͢ͅͅ38ȫȃ ȁΧȜϋ͜ΛΓͼȶΣσόȜȷ͈లˍ୯̴̭͈́͘തͦͅḘ̏ͦͬΣσόȜͅచ ̳ͥࢋ̹̽ࡉ༷̺̱̞̦͂̀ͥȄ࿚ఴ̷͉̦ͦΣσόȜၑٜ͈ະ̯͞ࡄݪະ௷ͥ͢ͅ ࢋٜ͈͉̞̞̠̭̜͂̓ͥ́̈́͂͂ͧͤ͘͜ͅͅȄ̷͉ͦୌ؎̤̫ͥͅȶুِȷ͂ဢ̤̫ͅ ̷͈ͥͦ͂आུഎ֑֦̳̈́ܳͥͅआ͈૬̞͈̜̭́ͥ͂ͬ͜ঐഊ̱̩͉̞̈́̀̈́ͣ̈́͂ΧȜ ϋ͉ࣉ̢̞̀ͥȪ̷̹ͦ͘Ḙ̭͉̏́ΧȜϋ͉૬̈́ޗޗၑ̷͈͈ͬ͜૬̩ౝݥ̳̞ͥ͂ ̠༷͉࢜ͅຈ̴̱̥̞࢜ͩ̈́͜ȃ̷͈ࠫض̭͈ΛΓͼ̜ͥͅփྙ͈́௷̯ͤ̈́ͬژ̢ͥ͂ ঐഊ̳ͥ૽̦̞͈ͥ͜ྫၑ͈̞̭͉̞̥̈́͂́̈́͂এͩͦͥȫȃ ȁȶ૰ȄऌȆȆȆ̞̹͂̽ୌ؎͈۷ැ͉ޗএே͉̩̈́ͅȨ̷͈͓̏ͦͣ͛ͥાਫ਼͉ͅȄୌ
؎ਕޗএே̷ུ͈͉ͦ͂൚͈փྙ͉́చ؊̱̞͉̀ͥ͂࡞̞ඳ̞ϋΓίΠ̦౾̥̞ͦ̀ͥȷ Ȫ167ȫȃ̷̠̜̦́ͥͅȄȶୌ؎͈ంहა͈͙ͬஜ̱͂̀ȆȆȆȸ༷ങȹͅਓ̹͛ͣͦ ޗࠐങͬຏٜ̞͙̀̀͜Ȅ̴̞͈ͦ༁͜ඨ̹͘ඨ͈Ⴒ͈͕̭̱̠̩́̓̈́͢͜ȷȪ164ȫȄ ߗ̱̩ഛͬަ̞̹́͛௳̩̥ͬ̾͊ͤ́ਞ̭̱̠ͩͥ͂̈́̽̀͘ͅȃ ȁ̭͈࡞ဩ͉֚ࡉ̱̹̭͉͂ͧ́հօ̈́ୌڛა݈ͅచ̱̀࠙ͬྺ̳͈̩ͣ͂͂ͦ̈́͜͜ ͉̞̈́ȃ̺̦ΧȜϋ̦࡞̳͈͉ͩͭ͂ͥȄږུ̥ͅৗഎ֑̦̜͈͈̈́ͥ͜Ȅ̥̥ͩͣ͜ͅ ̴Ȅհօ̈́൳֚ণ͞ౙ̈́ͥڛ̴༷͂̓ͣͬ͘ͅͅచ؊̵̯̠̳̭͉͂ͥ͂̈́͢փ݅ͬ ̻̠̱ͥȨ̷࡛̠̳͓̏ͅমఠ̦ܡ̲̞̞̠̀ͥ͂ͅঐഊ̷̭̜ͥ͂ͅ࡞̧̠͓͉̞́̈́ ̺̠̥ͧȃ̦ಕ࿒̳͈͉ͥୌ؎ଲٮ̤̫ͥͅ૧̱̞شڠএே͈ర൮͂Ȅ̷̦ͦୌ؎̤̫ͥͅ ݰြ͈ഥൡഎ̈́এே͞ྶ۷ͅဓ̢̞̀ͥޞրȪ༆͈࡞̞༷̳ͬͦ͊ਲြ͈ॽ༷͉́ၑ̧ٜ́ ̞̈́૧̱̞࿚ఴ͈ষࡓ͈ঐഊܳȫ̜́ͥȃ͞͞എͅ࡞̢͊Ȅ૧̱̞شڠএே͈ఱ෨ͬஜ ͅȄݰြ͈এே̦̈́ͅু͈ͣြ̱༷̱ͅȄ̷͈౷༜ͬࡥ̱̠̳͂ͥ͢ࡠͤȄୌ؎̦Σ σόȜͬୃ̱̩ၑٜ̳̠͉̞̭̞̺̠ͥ̈́ͥ̾̈́ͧ͢ͅͅȄ̷̠ΧȜϋ͉ࣉ̢̞̀ͥ͂ ࡞̢̺̠ͥͧȃ ȁ̯̀Ȅুِ͈࿚ఴͅ࿗̠ͧȃΧȜϋͥ͂͢ͅȄୌ؎͈ࣉ̢͉́ȶুِȷ͉֚́Ȅ་ا̳ͥ ̭̦̞̯̞͂̈́͂ͦ̀ͥȃ̭ͦͅచ̱̀ޗ̤̞͉̀ͅȄߓఘഎ̈́ࠁͬ͂ͤȄ଼͂કͬ߫ ͤ༐̳ȶσζȆΌȷ̦̜ͤȄ̷͈༷֚́൳শͅȶ̭̓́͘͜૬̩ஆ͙ȷȄইͤ͘͜ਞͩͤ ̞̹ͣ̈́֯ͦ͜ςͺςΞͻ̦̜̽̀Ḙ̏ͦͬȶσζ͈̠̻ͅథ௬̯̹ͦకȷȶྫِ͈ఱِȷ ͂ࡤ͐ȃ̷͉ͦȶ̯̞֯ͦ̀̀Ȅۜژ͉́༛̴̢ͣͣͦḘ͉̞̦̏ͣͦͥ͂̈́Ȅ̞͉̾ͅژ ̳͓̩̞͛ͣͦ̀ͥȷȪ170ȫ̞̠͂ȃ̭͈തͅୌ؎̦ΣσόȜͬȄ̷̱̹̯̀ͣ͘ͅ ͉ޗͬஜ̱̀ͅࢋٜ͂ྫၑٜ͂ͬ߫ͤ༐̧̱̹̀ၑဇ̦̜ͥȃ ȁ͉̭͈́ࢋٜ̦ٜ̥̭͉̞͈̺̠̥ͦͥ͂̈́ͧȃୌ؎̤̞̀ͅ૧̹ͅర൮̱̜̾̾ͥشڠএ ே̷̷̭̦͈ࡎͬ՜̞̽̀ͥȃ̳̻̭͈̈́ͩ૧̹̈́এே̤̞͉̀ͅȄଲٮ͉Ȫ̷̱̀ুِ̹͘͜ȫ ଼͂કȄอജ͂ଚపͬ߫ͤ༐̳̯͈̺̦͂ͦͥḘ͈̏߫ͤ༐̱͉ౙ̈́ͥ໘̤͈ͩͥ́ͅ ͉̩̈́Ȅ̷͈ഽ̮͂ͅ૧଼̹̦̈́ইͥ͘ȃষșͅ૧̹̈́་ا̦̲͚̭̦̞̀͂̈́͞ȃ̺̦ ̷̺̫͉̩ͦ́̈́Ḙ̠̱̹̏ض̱̞̀̈́་ا̱ͬ̀Ȅ̷̜̞͉͈̭̠ͥ࢜ͅȄ߫ͤ༐಼̱ͬ ̢ͥఱ̞̈́ͥȶςͺςΞͻȷ̦ۭ̯͈̜৾ͦͥ́ͤȄޗএே̷͉͈ޢ̠͂̈́ͤͥȃݙ̹͘ͅ ̷̠̈́ͥশ̷̭ͅȄݰြ͈ഥൡഎ̈́এே͈̠͢ͅޗএே̤̫ͥͅȶুِȷ̴̞̹ͬͣͅ๛ എ̢̧̭̥ٜ͂ͣͥ͂ͣͅ༶̹ͦȄޗ͈͂୪തͬࡉ̷̠̳̭̦͂ͥ͂خෝ̱̈́ͥͅȄ̷ͦ ̦ఱ̧̈́փ̻̠͈̜݅ͬͥ́ͥȃ ȁ̭͈ത̥̥͈̦ͩͥͅలː୯̜́ͤḘ̷͉̏́ٴ̤ͬ̽̀Ⴀഎ̈́ٴͬ൩͙ȄडਞഎͅΣ σόȜͅঢ̞̠ͥ͂ޗ͈ޗ୰̦ત̯̞ٚͦ̀ͥȃȶဳഛȷȄȶٮȷȄȶྫٮȷ͈ڎٴ ̦ڛഎમ̱̩તٚȄ୰ྶ̯̞ͦ̀ͥȃ̭̭̭́ͦͬ͜19ଲܮ͈شڠএே͂చ؊̵̯̭̦ͥ͂
দ͙̤ͣͦ̀ͤȄ଼͂ક̦͂߫ͤ༐̯ͦȄ̷͈ഽ̮֚͂ࣞͅഽ̈́ٴ͒͂ਜ਼ষૺജ̱̀ ̧̞Ȅ̷͈ൢోത͉ΣσόȜͅచ؊̵̢̯̠̞ͥ͂͂ͣͣͦ̀ͥȃ ȁ̭̠̱̀ୌ؎̤̫ͥͅ૧̹̈́شڠএே͈ర൮͉༷̤̞֚̀ͅਲြ͈ഥൡഎ̈́এேͅచ̳ͥఱ ̧̈́ޞր̞̦̈́̽̀ͥͅȄ͉ഥൡഎ̈́এே͈ۿ̞̽̀ͥ೪త͂Ȅুͣ͂։̈́ͥا͞ଲٮͅ చ̳ͥݵ୲͞ྫၑٜ̻ͬ෫ͥఱ̞̈́ͥخෝ̹͈̜̞̠̭ͬ͛́ͥ͂͂̈́ͥ͜͜ͅȃ̷̱ ̫̀͂ͤͩȄΣσόȜ̞̠͂ޗၑͅచ̳ͥୌ؎͈௰͈ࢋٜ͈༃̳ͬ࣪ͥࠨഎ̈́ࡎ͂ ̞̈́̽̀ͥ͂࡞̢ͥȃ̷̷̠̜̭́ͦ͊ΧȜϋ͉ȶୌ؎̦ဢ͈এே͂ϋΗ·Π̠ͬ͂ͥ͢ ̭̈́ͥ͂́ͅȄୌ؎͈ഥൡഎ̈́এே͈ଚపͬ௯ૺ̳̞̠͈֚ͥ͂̾ࢨ̞̈́ͥࠫض̦̲̭ͥ͂ ̠̺̠̈́ͤͥͧͅȷȪ174Ƚ175ȫ͂࡞̞̽̀ͥȃ̷͉̺̦ͦȄဢ͈Ȅ̜̞͉ͥޗഎ̈́ȶুِȷ ͬෳ̱̀ୌ؎͈ȶুِȷ̦ু̵଼̯̭͉̩ͣͬۖͥ͂́̈́Ȅෳੰ̳̭̩ͥ͂̈́ވͅȶ̜ͥȷ͂ ̞̠̜ͥষࡓͬঐ̱̞͈̜̀ͥ́ͥȃ
̢̤̥ͩͤ̀ͅ
ȁȸޗޗၑ࿚൞ȹ̦Ȅ֚૽͈ͺις૽ͥ͢ͅͼϋΡՏఱၘ̤̫ͥͅޗ͈໘ޟ̞̠͂ྪ͈ ਫ਼ॲ̜̹̳́̽͂ͥ̈́ͣȄ̷͉ͦͺις͉̲ͬ͛ࢩ̩ୌ؎ͅޣͬࡤ͍̭̳༷֚ܳȄୌ؎ͅ ෩ࡍ̯̹ͦၣڠུ͈̻̽̀͢ͅͅܦ̭̹ͣͦͥ͂̈́̽͜ͅȃ̭͈ඵ͈̠̭̾ٛ͂ͧ ͅΧȜϋͬպ౾̧̫̭̦̿ͥ͂́ͥȃུ͉̤̫ͥͅޗ̦ুࡨ٨ڟͬทͣͦȄ૧̱̞֚༜ ͬ൩̷͙̠̱̞̭͂̀ͥ͂ͬͤȄ̷͉ͦু͈ޗͅచ̳ͥ૧̹̈́۾ͬࡤ͍̭̳̭ܳ ̹͂̈́̽ͅȃ ȁࣱന૯൸͈ȸఱޗఱփȹ͉ȶུޗȷ̦ୌ؎ͅచ̱̀Ȅু͈ͣຽ༑എ̈́փ݅ͬୟޭഎ ͅা̢̱̠̳͈̜̞̦͂ͥ́ͥ͂ͥ͢͜Ḙ͈̠̏̈́͢ୌ؎ͅచ̳ͥޗ͈Ȫ̜̞͉ͥဢ͈ȫ ൱̷̧̥̫̫̠̳̭̭ͬ͂͛͂ͥ͂ͧ͢ͅȄୌ؎ু̦ুͣͬ૧̹̈́ষࡓ̵̯͒͂ͥܥ ̦ٛࡉ̯͈͉̞̥ͦͥ́̈́͂ΧȜῧ̢͉̹͈͉̞̺̠̥ͣ́̈́ͧȃ ȁུతह̽̀͢ͅρέΟͻȆΧȜῧུུ͉૽͈͂ഥൡͬอࡉ̱Ȅ̷͈ۜ൲͂อ ࡉ͂ͬଲٮͅഥ̢̭̹ͥ͂̈́̽ͅȃ̷̺̦͈༷֚́൳শͅȄ୲̴̢ୌၰଲٮ͈ޛۼ̜̽̀ͅȄ ̥ͣୌ̥̠༷͒࢜࢜͂Ȅୌ̥͈ͣ͒൲͈॒̳࢜͂ͥાͬͅ౾̧Ȅ̷͈୪തͬݥ̫͛Ȅ ༷͍̫͓̩ͬࠫ̾ͥႁ̩̱̹̭ͬ͂͜དྷ͉̞ͦ̀̈́ͣ̈́ȃಕ
ˍȫಅඤຳȶ։ا͈͒܉ओ̱ȷȪȶڛڠࡄݪȷల60ȄఱڛڠٛȄ1990ාȫ൳ȶΧȜϋȸΣσόȜ ȹ̞̾̀ͅȷȪȶ࣭ڠȁٜ৷͂ۻરȷల726Ȅ1991ාȃȫਲြ͈ࡄݪ̱͂̀Ȅఱୌဎȶஂส͂ ޗȷȪȶ͒ͥͭȷల˕Ȅ1970ාȫ֔೮֚ȶส͂ޗএேȷȪஂสȸ͈ศ͈၂༠ȁఈȹȄࢭ২Ȅ 1975ාȫਫ਼ਓȫȃ̹͘Ȅ ࢬȸ෫̹ͣͦૂȹȪ૧ಲ২Ȅ1987ාȫ̧͉ͩ͛̀ͅਹါ̈́࿚ఴ̦եͩͦ ̞̀ͥȃஜന學ȶρέΟͻȆΧȜϋུ͈ၑུٜ͂ޗȷȪȶ༷ȷల˕Ȅ1993ාȫ͜߃ා͈ াऐͅີ଼̺ͭض̜́ͥȃˎȫcf. Thomas A. Tweed, The American Encounter with Buddhism, Chapel Hill & London : The University of North Carolina Press,1993.
ˏȫLéon de Rosny, Anthologie japonaise, Paris:Maisonneuve, 1871. ːȫLéon de Rosny, La Civilisation japonaise, Paris:Leroux, 1883.
ˑȫLafcadio Hearn, My First Day in Orient, in The Writings of Lafcadio Hearn, vol.V:Boston and New York, Houghton MifÁin Company, 1922, p.10.
˒ȫHenry S. Olcott, A Buddhist Catechism, ColomEo (The Ilangakoon Catechism Fund) and London (TrüEner), 1881.
˓ȫEdwin Arnold, The Light of Asia, 1879. ˔ȫNanjio Bunyiu, Preface, I.
˕ȫ௩ဎȸྶহࣞഥȹȪུບა২Ȅ1935ාȫ 10ȫȸ૯ਕঃၳਬ଼ల֚ےȹȪ൳༸ৡȄ1975ාȄ381βȜΐȫ 11ȫධᕢဎȸ٥ݰȹȪఱဎڝȄ1927ාȄ141βȜΐȫ
12ȫȸڦࡔࡄዎ֒ਬȹȪฎ൴Ȅ1899Ȫྶহ32ȫාȄ148βȜΐȫ 13ȫBunyiu Nanjio, Preface, i.
14ȫȸઐႲઽၳȁષےȹȪུܐๅޫȄ1982ාȄ71βȜΐȫ 15ȫΛΙȄΑȄϊσΛΠȸᄵޗ࿚൞ȹȪۏ࣐ٛȄ1886ාȫ
16ȫȶΰϋςȜȄΑȄσΛΠঙఱ୰ཌྷඃຊܱȷȪ૩ࢺๅȃ1889Ȫྶহ22ȫාȫ
17ȫ႕̢͊ȶ૰౺ڠȷȪȸρέΟͻȆΧȜϋಠैਬȹలːےȄࢭ২Ȅ1987ාȄ371Ƚ375βȜΐȫȄȶ૰ ౺ڠഎߘ௨෫ٟȷȪȸρέΟͻȆΧȜϋಠैਬȹలˏےȄࢭ২Ȅ1981ාȄ44Ƚ46βȜΐȄ̈́̓ȃ 18ȫLafcadio Hearn, Letter to Chamberlain, KoEe, August 1895, in The Writings of Lafcadio Hearn,
vol.14, Boston and New York:Houghton MifÁin Company, p.384.
19ȫLafcadio Hearn, Gleanings in Buddha Fields, Boston and New York : Houghton Mifflin and Company,1897. 20ȫ ࢬȸ෫̹ͣͦૂȹȪ૧ಲ২Ȅ1987ාȄ202βȜΐȫȃ 21ȫสٛȪ༎ȫȸஂสࣂȆྚۏ۰ਚ֒ਬȁలඵےȹȪဎઐ൴Ȅ1992ාȄ35βȜΐȫ 22ȫ५࢛֚ȸέͿΦυȹȪષےȫȪ२જ൴Ȅ1982ාȄ431Ƚ433βȜΐȫȃ 23ȫΫΊυ;͈ޗၑٜͅ۾̱͉̀ոئͬ४ચ̱̹ȃ౻നםੇȸྶহ͈ޗȹȪບა২Ȅ1976ාȄ155βȜΐȫȃ 24ȫ५࢛ȄஜࠇȄ442βȜΐȃນܱ͜൳ͅਲ̹̽ȃ 25ȫ५࢛ȄஜࠇȪئےȫȄ54βȜΐȃ 26ȫΫΊυ;̞͉̾̀ͅఆࠁྶঊȶΫΊυȜၞഥȷȪȶࡣȷల35Ȅ२द২Ȅ1971ාȫͬ४ચ̱̹ȃ 27ȫΧȜϋ͈ΙͿϋΨτϋզ۰ȃ ࢬȄஜࠇȄ169βȜΐȃ ࢬͥ͂͢ͅȄ؍ຩहਯַ͈૩ ଼͈͂ͬΧȜϋͅۑ̹͈͉͛ༀ࣭٬߳৽̜̹ࠗۗ́̽ηΛΙͿσȆζ·ΡσΡ̜̹̞̠́̽͂ Ȫ൳Ȅ170βȜΐȫȃ 28ȫȶΣσόȜȷ̤̫ͥͅȸ༷ങȷ̥͈ͣޗࠐങ͈֨ဥ͉ոئ͈̜ͤ́ͥȃ ȁȪȶΣσόȜȷ͉ոئͬΞ·ΑΠ̱͂Ȅນܱ̯̞ͦ̀ͥβȜΐତ͉൳͈͈̜́ͥ͜ȃLafcadio Hearn, Nirvana, in The Writings of Lafcadio Hearn, vol.8, Boston and New York : Houghton MifÁin
and Company,1922, pp.162-203.
ȁȁ֨ဥࡃ͉൳ैಎ̩́̀ͥͅਜ਼ͤ͢ͅȄ൳̲ಠै̥ͣໝତٝ֨ဥ̯̞ͦ̀ͥાࣣ͉Ȅड֨ͅဥ̯ ̹̭̹ͦ͂ͧ͂͛͘ͅȃΧȜϋͥ͢ͅȶΣσόȜȷಎ͈֨ဥ͉Ȅຈါ̹͂͛শͅࡠͤࠇश̳ͥȃ 1. The Diamond-Cutter.
in F. Max Muller (ed.), The Sacred Books of the East, vol.49, Buddhist Mahâyâna texts, Oxford : Clarendon Press,1894.
֨ဥ͉ˏؿਫ਼̜ͥȪ(1) p.162 ; (2) p.167 ; (3) p.174) Ȫˍȫ
Because it is not possiEle, O SuEhûti, that this treatise of the Law should Ee heard Ey Eeings of little faith,Ey those who Eelieve in self, in Eeings, in living Eeings, and in persons. (Section XV, p.130) ͕͖ࡔͤȃ
Ȫˎȫ
... O SuEhûti, there does ot exist in those noEle-minded Bodhisattvas the idea of self, there does not exist the idea of aEeing, the idea of a living Eeing, the idea of a person. Nor does there exist, O SuEhûti, for these noEle-minded Bodhisattvas the idea of quality (dhama), nor of no-quality. Neither does there exist, O SuEhûti, any idea (samgñâ) or no-idea. (Section VI, p.117)
ΧȜϋ̴͉͘ષܱؿਫ਼ͬഐ൚ͅೄ̱̤̀ͤȄ̷͈ષ́ષܱ֨ဥ͈ࡔˏ࣐࿒ Nor does there exist ... ո ئ̦જၞ̯ͦȄ̥̾ Neither does there ոئ̦Ȅষ͈ؿਫ਼͂ഐܽழ̵͙ࣣ̞ͩͣͦ̀ͥȃ
Because, O SuEhûti, no one is to Ee called a Bodhisattva, for whom there should exist the idea of a Eeing, the idea of a living Eeings, or the idea of a person. (Section III, p.114ȫ
Ȫˏȫ
̭̭͉ոئ͈ˎؿਫ਼ࣣͬఘ̱̹͈͂͜এͩͦͥȃ Ȫˍȫ
Because, O SuEhûti, no one is to Ee called a Bodhisattva, for whom there should exist the idea of a Eeing, the idea of a living Eeing, or the idea of a person. (Section III, p.114)
Ȫˎȫ
And again, O SuEhûti, a gift should not Ee given Ey a Bodhisattva, while he Eelieves in oEjects ; a gift should notEe given Ey him, while he Eelieves in anything ; a gift should not Ee given Ey him, while heEelieves in form ; a gift should not Ee given Ey him, while he Eelieves in the special qualities of soud, smell, taste, and touch. (Section IV, p.114)
2. The Fo-Sho-Hing-Tsang-King
in F. Max Müller (ed.), The Sacred Books of the East, vol.19, The Fo-Sho-Hing-Tsan-King, Oxford : Clarendon Press,1883.
֨ဥ͉ˍؿਫ਼Ȫp.163ȫ
The mind, the thoughts, and all the senses are suEject to the law of life and death. This fault of Eirth and death, once understood, then there is clear and plain perception ;
OEtaining this clear perception, then there is Eorn knowledge of self, knowing oneself and with this knowledge laws ofEirth and death, then there is no grasping and no sense-perception.
Knowing oneself, and understanding how the senses act, then there is no room for I, or ground for framing it ; then all the accumulated mass of sorrow, sorrowsEorn from life and death,
Being recognised as attriEutes of Eody, and as this Eody is not I, nor offers ground for I, then comes the great superlative (discovery), the source of peace unending ;
This thought (view) of self gives rise to all these sorrows,Einding as with cords the world, Eut having found there is no I , that canEe Eound, then all these Eonds are severed.
(p.190)
ષུܱ͈̠͢ͅြ୯̮͂ͅߊ୨̞͈ͣͦ̀ͥͬ͜ȄΧȜῧ͉̱̞֚͛̀ͥ͘ͅȃ 3. The Questions of King Milinda
in F. Max Müller (ed.), The Sacred Books of the East, vols.35 and 36, Oxford : Clarendon Press, 1890 (vol.35) (Books I-IV-4), 1894 (vol.36) (Books IV-5-VII).
̞̩̥͈̾֨ဥ̦Ⴅݷ̯̤ͦ̀ͤȄ༒ܽષ˒̾ͅߊ୨ͥȃ(̴̞ͦ͜p.164) (1)
The King said : Nâgasena, is there any one who after death is not reindividualized ? Some are so, and some not.
Who are they ?
A sinfulEeing is reindividualized, a sinless one is not. (Book II, ch.1-6, p.50.)
ΧȜϋ͈֨ဥ͉́ड͈͈ؐ࿚̞ͅచ̳ͥȜ΄ΓȜ͈൞̢Ȅ̷̱̭̫̯͈̀ͦͬ̀̈́ͣͦͥؐˎ ̾࿒͈࿚̞̦જၞ̯̞ͦ̀ͥȃ
(2)
The king said, Is there, Nâgasena, such a thing as the soulȪVedaguȫ? (Book II, ch.3-6, p.86.) ...
And so herein there is no such thing as soul. (Book II, Ch.3-7, p.89)
ΧȜϋ͉֨ဥ͉(pp.86-89)ܱ̱̞̦͂̀ͥȄष͉ͅ࿚̞͈໐͉86βȜΐ̥ͣȄȜ΄ΓȜ͈൞̢ ͈໐͉89βȜΐ̥ͣ֨ဥ̱̞̀ͥȃ
̭͈ؿਫ਼͉́ΧȜϋ͉ಕ̫ͬ̾̀Ȅ൳̲ΑΞȜΠιϋΠ̦111βȜΐ́߫ͤ͜༐̯̞̦ͦ̀ͥḘ̷̏́ ͉ոئ͈̠̈́͢·ςέͻΉȜΏοϋ̞͓̞̈́̽̀ͥ͂̀ͥͅȃ
(2-A)
In the highest sense, O king, there is no such thing. (Book III, ch.5-6, p.111) (3)
The king said : Is there anyEeing, Nâgasena, who transmigrates from this Eody to another ? No, there is not. (Book III, ch.5-7, p.112.)
͕͖ࡔͤȃ (4)
The king said : Where there is no transmigration, Nâgasena, can thereEe reEirth ? Yes, there can. (Book III, ch.5-6, p.111)
͕͖ࡔͤȃ̹̺̱̭̭͉֨ͅဥβȜΐତ͈ນܱ̦̩̈́Ȅ̷͈̹͛ষ͈֨ဥ̧̞֚͂̈́̽̀ͥ͢ͅ ̠ͅএ̱̠̦ͩͦ̀͘Ȅ̷͉ͦࢋ̜ͤ́ͥȃ
(5) The king said : Does he, Nâgasena, who is aEout to Ee reEorn know that he will Ee Eorn ? Yes, he knows it, O king. (Book III, ch.5-9, p.113)
͕͖ࡔͤȃ (6)
ΧȜϋ͉189βȜΐ͈ಕȪˍȫ̤̞̀ͅȄȶ̭͉ͦȸηςϋΘ͈ؐ࿚̞ȹ̤̞͉̀ͅΣσόȜ͂൳݅́ȸͼ
ϋέͻΣΛΠȆήςΑȹ̞̠͂࡞̞༷̦̩̀ͥȷ̱̞͂̀ͥȃ̺̦͓̹ࡠ͉ͤ́ȶͼϋέͻΣΛΠȆ ήςΑȷ̞̠͂ࢊᏃ͉ࡉ൚̹̞ͣ̈́ȃ̷̤̩ͣոئ̷͈̥̦̜̹͈͉̞̥̓ͦͦͥ́̈́͂ͅএͩͦͥȃ (A) allEliss
Nirvâna is allEliss, O king. (Book IV,ch.8-58, vol.36, p.182) Just so, O king, is Nirvâna allEliss ... (Book IV, ch.8-59. p.184)
Just so, O king, is Nirvâna allEliss, and there is no pain mingled with it. (Book IV, ch.8-60, 185) (B) supremeEliss
the supremeEliss of Nirvâna...(Book IV, ch.8-79, p.197)
... heEy his careful thinking will realise the supreme Eliss of Nirvâna, from which the stains and mud of evil dispositions haveEeen removed.(Book IV, ch.8-80, p.198)
4. The Book of the Great Decease.
in F. Max Müller (ed.), The Sacred Books of the East, vol.11, Buddhist Suttas, Oxford:Clarendon Press,1881.
֨ဥ͉ˏؿਫ਼̜ͥ((1) pp.165-166 ; (2) p.190 ; (3) p.199) (1)
̭̭͉́ડ߉͈ࠁ̩́̈́Ȅ౯༌എ̈́ࢊ߉̦֨ဥເͬঔ̯͓̞ͦ̀ͣͦ̀ͥȃ༒ܽષ(i - vii)̳͂ͥȃ (i) It is all iniÀnite reason (ch.3-38, p.52)
(ii) nothing at all exists (ch.3-39, p.52)
(iii) that state of mind to wchich the InÀnity of Space alone is present (ch.6-11, p.115) (iv) the state of mind to which the inÀnity of thought alone is present (ch.6-11, p.115) (v) that state of mind to which nothing at all is specially present. (ch.6-11, p.115) (vi) the stateEetween consciousness and unconsciousness (ch.6-11, p.115)
(vii) a state in which the consciousnessEoth of sensations and of ideas had wholly passed away. (ch.6-11, p.115)
̴̞ͦ͜ۍত͈༆Ȅఱলল͈ঀ̞̫ͬੰ̧ఱ̧֑͉̞̈́̈́ȃ (2)
The sister named Nandâ, Ânanda, has,Ey the complete destruction of the five Eonds that Eind people to this world,Eecome an inheritor of the highest heavens, there to pass away, thence never to return. (ch.2 - 7, p.25)
ঀဥ̳ͥࢊ߉͈৹͈֑̦ۙࡉͣͦͥȃ (3)
They all, allEeings that have life, shall lay Aside their complex form - that aggregation Of mental and material qualities,
That gives them, or in heaven or on earth, TheirÁeeting individuality !
(ch.6-15, p.116)
ఉઁ͈ࢊ߉͈։൳̦̜̦ͥఱ̧֑͉̞̈́̈́ȃ 5. Atthakavagga
in F. Max Müller (ed.), The Sacred Books of the East, vol.10, Part I : The Dammapada ; Part II : The
Sutta-Nipâta, Oxford : Clarendon Press,1881. ֨ဥ͉ˍ̾(p.179)ȃ
Pleasures and displeasure have their origin from phassa (touch), when there is no touch they do no arise. (11-9, p.166)
displeasure̦ΧȜϋ͈Ξ·ΑΠ͉́ pains ͅȄ̹͘ when ̦ where ̞̈́̽̀ͥͅȃ
6. Legend of the Great King of Glory.
in F. Max Müller (ed.), The Sacred Books of the East, vol.11, Buddhist Suttas, Oxford : Clarendon Press,1881.
TheEeauty of the gods (ch.1-36, p.257)
7. Mahavagga.
in F. Max Müller (ed.), The Sacred Books of the East, vol.17, Vinaya Texts (Part I), Oxford : Clarendon Press,1881.
֨ဥ͉ˍؿਫ਼(p.183)ȃ.
And in which way is it, Siha, that one speaking truly could say of me : The Samana Gotama maintains annihilation ; he teaches the doctrine of annihilation;and in this doctrine hc trains his disciples? I proclaim, Siha, the annihilation of lust, of ill-will, of delusion ; I proclaim the annihilation of the manifold conditions (of heart) which are evil and not good.(VI,31 : 7, p.112) ఉઁ͈ࢊ߉͈։൳͂̓ͥ͘ͅȃ
8. Kullavagga
in F. Max Müller (ed.), The Sacred Books of the East, vol.20, Vinaya Texts (Part III), Oxford : Clarendon Press,1885.
֨ဥ͉ˍؿਫ਼(p.195)ȃ̹̺̱ ୃ̱̩͉̭͉ͦ֨ဥ͉̩́̈́Ȅུಎ͈ඤယͅ௲̱̹̜ͥഥ୰ུ̦̭͈ ͅਓ̞̱̤͛ͣͦ̀ͥ͂̀ͤȄ̷͈ڂ൚ؿਫ਼͉ոئ̜́ͥȃ
Id, V,8,2, pp.80-81.
9. Sutra of the Lotus of the Good Law
in F. Max Müller (ed.), The Sacred Books of the East, vol.21, The Saddharma-Pundarîka : or The
Lotus of the True Law, Oxford : Clarendon Press,1881. ֨ဥ͉ˎؿਫ਼((1)p.195 ; (2)p.196)ȃ
(1)
ΧȜϋͥ͂͢ͅոئ͈ͤȃ
perfectly extinct upon his throne (p.195) ̭͈ؿਫ਼͉ոئͬ൩̢̹͈͂͘͜এͩͦͥȃ
Now the four classes of the assemEly, on perceiving the Lord PraEhûtaratna, the Tathâgata, &c., who hadEeen extinct for many hundred thousand myriads of kotis of aeons, speaking in this way ..(p.237) (2)
ΧȜϋ͈Ξ·ΑΠ́ոئ͈̠̞̈́̽̀ͥ͢ͅؿਫ਼
the great Seer who, although perfectly extinct for many kôtis of aeons, now comes to hear the Law. (p.196)
̭͈ؿਫ਼͉͉ոئ͈ˎؿਫ਼̹͈̜֚ͬ̾͂͛́ͥ͘͜ͅȃ
(A) Here you see, monks, the great Seer, the extinct Chief, within the Stûpa of jewels, who now has come to hear the law.(p.238)
(B) AlEeit completely extinct for many kotis of Aeons, he yet comes to hear the law ...(p.238) 29ȫ̷͈ఈȄఴྴ͈͙ݷ̬̞͈̱ͣͦ̀ͥ͂̀͜ȸΐλȜΗȹ̦̜ͥȃ̹֨͘ဥ͂ࡔ͈చ؊̦ࡉ
̵̥̹͈̈́̽͜Ȅ֨ဥࡃ̦අ̷̸̧̥̹͈̦́̈́̽ͦͦ͜ˍ̴̜̾̾ͥȃ 30ȫոئ͉́CLHLȄ̜̞͉ͥȸΗυΈȹ͂ၞ̳ȃ
31ȫสٛȄஜࠇȄ35βȜΐȃ
32ȫոئͬ४ચ̱̹ȃ৷ਕȸྔ࣭ਕޗఱٛȹȃJames Edward Ketelaar, Of Heretics and Martyrs in
Meiji Japan, Princeton University Press,1990.
33ȫࣱന૯൸ȸఱޗఱփȹȪޗڠٛȄ1893Ȫྶহ26ȫාȄ7βȜΐȫ 34ȫS. Kuroda, Outlines of the Mahâyâna, Tokyo:Bukkyo Gakkuwai, 1893, iii-iv.
35ȫུࢊๅ͉́ಎ࣭Ȅಱ͉́ఱޗ͉ଚ̱̹͂ྶ࡞̱̞̦̀ͥȄםࢊๅ͉̞̯̯̥́̈́ͤ͂͜ఱ ޗ̦࣐̞ͩͦ̀ͥ͂͂ͦͥȃ
36ȫcf. Ketelaar, Op.cit., p.264.
37ȫςΙλȜΡȆΐλέͻȜȶ৷ఄͬౝ̱̀ȷȪȸএேȹల943Ȅ2002ා11ȫͬ४ચ̱̹ȃ 38ȫcf. Henri de LuEac, La Rencontre du Bouddhisme et de l Occident, Paris : AuEier, 1952. ȁRoger-Pol Droit, Le Culte du néant, Paris : Seuil, 1997.
ȁGuy Richard WelEon, The Buddhist Nirvana and its Western Interpreters, Chicago and London : The University of Chicago Press,1968.
ັܱ
ུა͉ܡอນ͈ոئ͈აͬܖͅȄ̷͈ࢃ͈ࡉͬح̢ఱ໙̧ͅ٨̹͈̜͛́ͥ͜ȃ ఆ֔ຳȶρέΟͻȆΧȜῧޗȷȪȸڛڠࡄݪȹల85ȄఱڛڠٛȄ2005ාȄ ਫ਼ਓȫ