JAIST Repository: 知識生産・移転・交流・利用の四元モデルに基づく中間機関の類型化

(1)

JAIST Repository

https://dspace.jaist.ac.jp/

Title

知識生産・移転・交流・利用の四元モデルに基づく中

間機関の類型化

Author(s)

吉澤, 剛; 西村, 由希子; 田原, 敬一郎; 安藤, 二香

Citation

年次学術大会講演要旨集, 26: 724-727

Issue Date

2011-10-15

Type

Conference Paper

Text version

publisher

URL

http://hdl.handle.net/10119/10218

Rights

本著作物は研究・技術計画学会の許可のもとに掲載す

るものです。This material is posted here with

permission of the Japan Society for Science

Policy and Research Management.

(2)

"#!"

ƺȏƧƨǃȞƔÄƩ1ð¸wc}0û*ȳƅȴ1ɇùÐ

âƜÇǷųƫĞĆɌŶĂĈɍƪÖŚȬɌŰŵěĈƻǇłɍĉǰɉɌǁĈņǲŌǩƅƁɍ

1.

ǊɎůǁĈņǲûűǾƬɌĠŀ23 ġ 8 Ŭ 19 Ţȵ ȐƏĊɍ,2ǁĈņǲûűƒ0ȡ;?B%ǐƿ0 ǈ'Ȣ@ǁĈņǲŘǎƾ¡Ù4»¼1%;1 Ǹ/Řǎ1)-+#1ĭÈEɋ;))§êE Ÿ% -EŐ+@ǁĈņǲ-(%ƺƲ ïƞEȥ+ĳ?B%ƺȏEƾ¡Ʋ»¼Ʋ«³0 Ǘ4)AƓÍ1Ľǟı9 9 ɋ9A- ļBA%&ǁĈņǲ>4ƾ¡1ƱĔǖ ș1Ƽċĺ=ǶȻĺƷªćĺɋ9A0)B +%ƓÍ2Õ1¥Ǳ-Ƚ ȕȰȮÁƅȴƺȒshXvdƅȴƾ¡ȗžĎ NPO ŖŔó¥ǌ1ȳƅȴ0>AºůİB AB9,űƻǇɌâƜ? 2010ɍ,2Ơ0ƺ ȏ-ƾ¡Ʋ»¼Ʋ«³EǗ4)AƓÍEǱ ž¥EŖŔ AƅȴEȳƅȴ-Ċǟ#1 ƅǥ0)+ȍ+%Ÿ%Aƅǥ2Īȅ ƅȴ1Ǖǜ-.1>/ȴ¬E®(+ÅĥÐ B+A0ªć A-ǹ?BA#1%;űǅ ,2šįŝƣ=āƂ/ƅȴ51J^lx?ǯ ǆ%ƺǹE<-0ȳƅȴ1ÅĥƲ/ɇùÐE ȃ:A#+#BEĂ4 )1ƅǥƲÅĥƲ wc}0Ǯ-ȡF,ȳƅȴ1āĬ/īľEő

2.

ȳƅȴ2#1ä1ȥ@ȳ,A%; 1Ƕś1¥ȳ0÷ Aƅȴ,A /D' ȳƅȴ2ÕƢ,ǧ?E£ǝ*A-2Ƚ 1¥-1Ʒȴ0+Ċ£BA%(+ 9!2ȳƅȴEćǈ"AŴ-+1¥E ǡA-ƌ;?B>WYbuȍ0A CATWOE Áŷ,2HQ^=OY^s Nf/.1ƩȉƩ?BAɌCheckland 1981ɍ&OY^s2gZEǧ-<0 >ȇȏ+AǠĿƲ/ɈČɌÝȜƲ/ÝƳǢ ĐȑǢɍ-JvXĩƾ¡ƲíɅ1ǼƏ -gZ0+2ÝƳǢǧȜ#1gZ EƱȾ/B3Ǣ2#1gZEƦǼ A -ȽơƑā9%ƾ¡ƲȊɅ51Ü@ Ǖ:2Ķ!<ǠĿƲ/Ǳƞ,2/%;ǠĿǢ Ɍcustom-erɍ-éǂ1ăĪĺ¤;?BA D@0Q{JHdɌªɄɍ-Ʃȉ0>

(+ǥÍƲ0gZEƱȾ A¥EǴƥ A-ǖƗƲ«³1>/gZ¸Ʋ,ǧŤ/ ¨-ư/@Ơ0ƾ¡Ʋ»¼Ʋ«³Eń¨, 2ĽèA-ǡA,ƮĽ 6 -2Q{JHd-)1¥1:0å% ƓÍ2ƾ¡Ʋ»¼Ʋ«³-ǻƝ?´å +Q{JHdǧȜ1ǀƲȴĵÄƳ0ȈĒBA #BA-Ɲ,A#1%;ƶŎƲ/ ÝƳǢ%AQ{JHd-2Ã0ȳŎƲ/ÝƳǢ EHe~W-+ȂĊŤƽÐ A- ȯǸ0/(+A 9%Nf2ƺȏ-JoadEƾ¡ -HKdoad0ÿœ AWYbuEŀ@ǈ% "AA2ƈ;A-1,AWYbu1łŭ Ǣ,AȕȰŒ©¥ɌYrUɍ,<@ AƻǇǢņǲǢ-(%ċȚǢɌHQ^ɍ ,<@Aȳƅȴ0Ǩ(+2HQ^-< Nf-<OY^sɌQ{JHdɍ1!B 0<Áɇ0 B?Eț9ȳƅȴ1Ȑȍ,ƩAƩȉ1 ċƩƲĊǟE1>0ȃ:A ċŠǢ(P)ɏƓÍ1%AƺȏƧƨǢǁĈǢ ņǲǢĂĈƻǇƅȴNPO /. YrU_{(S)ɏċŠǢ1ƓÍ0Aū<ƶŎ} Ʋ/ȕȰŒ©Ǣ1-ŘĤ žȒóƒ /. Q{JHd(C)ɏċŠǢ1ƓÍ1ƶŎƲ/ɌɆ ÷Ʋ)ĽôƲ/ɍÝƳǢƺȏÄƩǢƨž ƭJWxó¥/.,ċŠǢÅĥƲò ǠƲ0ǸŮ0ķAȓÎAƷŃEŊ He~W(A)ɏȳŎƲ/Ɍƛ÷Ʋ/ɀĽô Ʋ/ɍÝƳǢƺȏÄƩǢǪĝƋ/. ȳƅȴ(I)ɏƾ¡Ʋ»¼Ʋ«³0ȕ Aƺȏ EƧƨǃȞƔÄƩ A%;0Yr U/Q{JHd-ċŠǢ/He~ WE)/Ǖǜ

3.

ȳƅȴ1ÅĥƲɇùEǱ0%@ȳƅȴ 02Ă3 )1ÅĥÐ@A-EƠȁ+ %9!Ƣǈ/ȳƅȴ,AƺȏƧ ƨ¥-<ƾ¡ƲĽĹƏĊ¥-<Ǖǜ-+Ƣǈ +@ȥğȳƅȴ-+ļĊBA@

(3)

ş,AƆ0ƺȏƧƨ¥0£ǝ*?BA ƾ¡ƲĽĹƏĊ¥-1ŹƄƅȴ-+ƅǥ+ A<1,AĂĈ0ȷǝB+AƨĈȦŕűȭ /.ǴƲ,AB-2Ȥ0ƾ¡ƲĽĹƏ Ċ¥0£ǝ*?BAƺȏƧƨ¥-1ŹƄ ƅȴ-+ƅǥ+A<1,AǱŘƅȴ¾1 »ƲȕȰȮÁƅȴ/.B0ƷĪ A 1ɇù2ƺȏƧƨ¥0ĕ A<1Ɍ1 2ɍ ƾ¡ƲĽĹƏĊ¥0ĕ A<1Ɍ3 4ɍƢǈƲ/ <1Ɍ_{5
10ɍ0ĂÃBA1ɇùÐ02àǄ} šįŝƣ17űƻǇ0ȴȦ+2011 ġ0ċŠ %ǬöɌ2 Ŭ 8 11 ŢɍǏöOf_Ɍ2 Ŭ 22 25 ŢɍɉƘɌ7 Ŭ 4 5 Ţɍ0Aàƅȴ51J ^lxȋŻ<ÚťB+AɌcf. âƜ? 2011ɍ &B2ǖɊƲƦǼ0û*ũĊƲ/<1, ı1ȋŻ=Ȇǔ/ƀĸÐ0>(+?/A°Ɖȣ ËŜƦůİBA (1) HaoYd|uù ƺȏƧƨEƔƺȏÄƩEƔ-Ɗî0² (+ƺȏƧƨ-ÄƩ0AƔƅȴ,Aƺ ȏƧƨ¥¾0ȳƅȴȂǝB+Aýá, AĂĈ¾1ƺȒƨȦȴȦȭǞ¨-+ŋ? Bƾ¡Ʋ ž=ǧƐ¥/.1ƾ¡ƲgZEƎ: /?ĂĈĈȭƻǇƅȴ1ŭ Aƺȏ1Ɠ ƩEƵŊ+AŢű0+2ƾĈȦŕEŐ AĂȶĂĈTtxgSWzcVJ[^ /.ƠĴƲ,A ¨H|]fĚǈĂĈƾ¡0AfibQ iX[^ɌCNS-ASUɍɉƘŝĂĈÉž ƻǇĵɉƘĂĈƺȏƔčɌKEOɍ (2) ocxUù ȳƅȴǧ¥Ş%/ƺȏEƧƨ AċŠǢ-+1ĭÈEŸ% ýá,AǁĈTtxgS Wz= TA -(%ŁƯƲƺĺEŭ Aƅȴ= NPO ŖŔƅȴ,2đȱĎȴ¬ǢĝƋ-(% āƂ/ƺȏƧƨ¥1ƺȏEŜƦÁŷ»Ʋ Ƌȳƅȴ0Ʊ¯+ĭÈEŇ(+A ¨ǏöKaeKI}\öȹĈǲ[ ^ǬöǁĈÔ¡ɌBAɍǬöƻǇĻühad QɌRINɍN{_{bfKƻǇłcs QņǲĄì¡ɌDBTɍɉƘƾ¡UlYOKW }Ɍ_HKCSSɍ (3) _KYd|uù ƺȏƧƨ-ÄƩ0AƔƅȴ,Aƾ¡Ʋ ĽĹƏĊ¥¾0ȳƅȴȂǝB+Aýá, AǏö,ǹ?BAƸĢãŽù=ƸĢ¥ ùɌŰŵěĈƻǇł_{2011ɍ1>0ŘĤƸĢ¾} 0ȕȰȮÁƅǥEŇƅȴ(+đȱĎ=ȴ¬ ǢĝƋ0oXLQdīħ,ȕȰEȮÁ A ¨ǏööǈǳƧȸɌNIHɍǏööǈƃƙņǲ ƻǇłɌNISTɍ (4) d{Ydù »ƳȒó1>0đȱĎ=ȴ¬ǢĝƋ0Đ+ ÌŀEȥ+ƾ¡Ʋ»¼Ʋ«³EÉÀ AƺȏE Ƥĳǧ?»¼Ʋ/UlYEĔȲ AƅȴEŊ YrU-ȳƅȴãŽ-/(+A ¨HWzOOf_d}eȒó (5) mIejaQù WQ^QTU}^d0ǴBA> 0đȱĎ=ȴ¬Ǣ1ƺȏEȺǒŜƦÁŷ A ƺȏƧƨ¥1¶ɁEŉ'/?»ƲƋȳƅȴ 51·Eȥ+ǧ?ƾ¡ƲĽĹƏĊ0ØƬ A¶Ɂ<¦"ŉ)ǟƲ/ȳƅȴ,A ¨bQir|YSRI J^fWzf} (6) WR}mGcIRù ŘĤƸĢ/.Õ1¥?1ȕȰŒ©EÝ đȱĎEĵ- AƺȏƧƨ¥5¿ȮÁ A½ù Ʋ/ȳƅȴ,AŢű1ǁĈņǲJip WzŘǎ0+2ŢűĈǲŌǩ¡ɌJSPSɍǁ ĈņǲŌǩƅƁɌJSTɍŞMh}Pƨžņǲǚ áȲƱƅƁɌNEDOɍ0ǴBA>0»Ʋȕ ȰȮÁ1īľ-+ǪƲ,A ¨ǬööǈǁĈņǲǫǲûȰɌ_NESTAɍ ɉƘĂĈřǣÌŀĄì¡ƻǇÌŀēɌRGC-UGCɍ (7) QYmGcIRù Ƕś1ŘĤƅȴ/.?ȕȰŒ©EÝđȱĎ Eĵ- AƺȏƧƨ¥5¿ȮÁ Aýá,A

¹1Ɍ_{6ɍ1¨-ư/@Q{JHdɌYrU} ɍ1gZ1Úť2ȳŎƲ0/AD@0He ~W51ĽȏE>@ĩŉ(+ƾ¡Ʋ»¼Ʋ« ³1ÉÀEǧ?¥Ʋ0 ƬċȚ A-ȳ ƅȴ0ƌ;?BAȳƅȴƱȪ+AN{ _0>ǹ?BA9%NPO Ìŀƅȴ1>0ĝ Ƌ=Ƌȳ ž?1ÀȕEÝ_{NPO 0¿ȮÁ A} --<0NPO 1ƓÍǧ¥Eģƾ¡ɌHe~Wɍ 0ƺ?"AĭÈEŇ<1<æ9BA ¨N{_ǁĈƻǇƅƁɌNWOɍN{_ ņǲûȰɌSTWɍ (8) _JHRù ŘĤƅȴǌ?ÀȕEÝ#1ŘĤƅȴ-đȱ ĎĝƋ-1ĐȄ1ýEȂĊ A-/.0>@ ƺȏƧƨ¥-ƾ¡ƲĽĹƏĊ¥-1ȴ¬EƖÐ ">- A<1#1ĐȄ1ŀŸǧ¥<ģ ǪĝƋ0ƺ?BAǁĈTtxgSWz- +>@ȓAī0ĔȲ+(%<1,@ Ǭö,2%ƅȴǣ'))A ¨ǬöUJMYJZǬöǁĈņǲ ȒóɌFSTɍ

(4)

(9) sa`Rù

ǧƐ¥ ž/.?1ªɄ0>@ĂĈNPO

/.ƺȏEŭ AƻǇǢ=Ǖǜ-ņǲƲ/ċƥǥ ÊEŉ) ž-EǗ4)AąǢ-+1øúƨ Ĉ»Ȧŕűȭ/.1ƅȴEŊ Ţű,2(8

CjJNQ{Y^Bio-S µĦǁĈƨžQ{Y^

1ÉÀ--<0meUJMYO~aX-+ Ñƕȩ0żŲEȠÀ%oR{u<ĔȲ +A ¨Of_INO (10) kx|YbIaQù taWz=lXzEŉ'#B0ż%ƾ ¡ƲĽĹƏĊEŇA¥-#1ċƥ0ĶǸ/ƺ ȏEƧƨ A¥EãŦ0ōǓ AǕǜǧ?ÍƲ 0±=ó¥ȳE)/ƓÍE A-,ƱǹƒƲ 0ƾ¡ƲíɅ-#1ǼƏ51ȩǍEǹ)#B0 å+āƂ/¥ȴDA-1,AýEȂĊ AŢű0+2ÑƕȩƮǭĝ0AøúŌǩ -µĦþȧ0ȴ AƂ/žĔȲ>4ȴ¬Ǣ1 Ȧŕ1ý*@ŖŔEǱ(+A _{NPO ƺƲȒƨƻ} ǇŏȧƅƁɌPRIP Tokyoɍ=Ľó¥1)A )/A)oXLQdɌ)ȭɍ/. ŋ?BAƕĀ,2íɅǼƏ0å%No JipWz/ĝýEŒ©+A _InnoCentive ƾ/.ƷĪ A ¨Ǐö_{InnoCentive ƾ}

4.

ƺȏƧƨ-ÄƩ1ȴ¬0)+2)1Ttx gbIƦȍɌwc}ɍ>ƺ?B+AB 2ŘǎƻǇ1ƧƨǢ-#BĽô AÄƩǢ-1 ƭǻ=¯ĸ¥Ǒư/(+A%;0ƻǇƶŎÄ Ʃ B A - 2 7 - F . / - A < 1 , A ɌCaplan, Morrison & Stambaugh 1975; Caplan 1979; Webber 1983, 1986ɍ1Ʀȍ0Đ

AŅÂ2Ă 3 )ŋ?BAɌcf. âƜƪÖ

2009ɍɌ1ɍ1TtxgbI=)1TtxgbI

¾1±1ǹǼ1āƂĺEȟǺ+AɌ_Boggs

1992; Sabatier & Jenkins-Smith 1988ɍɌ2ɍȤ0 )1TtxgbI¢%>/ǹǼE¼ŭ AÞǥ

ĺ0)+ǹȨ+AɌBowman 1978; Weiss &

Weiss 1981ɍɌ3ɍ1Ho`2ǈƲ/ƻǇǢ ?şƲ0?B%ɋëȖ,^Ju|Ïň Ʋ/ĻüƟŴ,ŘǎƏĊ0Ʃ?BA-EÆ Œ-+AɌRich 1979; Shapiro 1984ɍ

B0Đ+ƺȏƧƨǢ-ÄƩǢ3@,/ ȳƅȴE<Ĝȡ:#B$BƺȏE¼Ƨƨ Aī,ƺȏƔEǱý1wc}ƇǏ/.0 +ǹ?BAɌâƜƪÖ 2009ɍB9,2ƺ ȏǃȞ-ƺȏƔ1Ċǟ*#B7.2( @/B+/(%ɌMitton et al. 2007ɍŘ ƐƲſĺÐ1ȐȍɌContandriopoulos et al. 2010ɍ EŔƩűǅ,2ȳƅȴ1ĭÈ-ǻƝ? ǢEƆ1>/ċȚ/Åĥ-+ÒÃ A ƺȏǃȞɌKT: knowledge transferɍɏƧƨB %ƺȏEƾ¡ƲĽĹƏĊ0ȕ A%;0)% AƓÍ1-ƺȏ-ƾ¡WYbu-+2 ȿƲ,ƺȏŊåĩƺȏ?ƾ¡51ş åƲ/ƔBEőŘƐƲ0ſĺÐB+/ ȊɅ0ȫ A}}pY1ȺáƲƓÍ -/@Ƽõ%AǕǜ=ÅĥEûƴ-=

ƺȏƔɌKE: knowledge exchangeɍɏƾ¡ƲǸ

Ȍ0ķAī,ƺȏƧƨEƺȏƧƨǢ-ƺȏÄƩǢ1#B$B1ƺȏE)/AƓ Í1-ƺȏ_{-ƾ¡WYbu-+2ÍƲ,ƾ} ¡Ŋåĩƾ¡?ƺȏ#+ƾ¡51 mIejaQƲ/ƔBEőŘƐƲ0ſĺ Ð%ȊɅ0ȫ AtaWzpY1± ƲƓÍ-/@Ǖǜ=Åĥ2źȝ0ÿÐ AǦĨ0/@= 9%ãƂ0ƺȏƧƨ>4ƺȏÄƩ0)+< #B$B1ƥý,ȳƅȴEŇA-Ɲ? ŗ;+Ɔ1>0wc}Ð A ƺȏƧƨɌKP: knowledge productionɍɏƺȏE )AƓÍ1-ȳƅȴ-+2ƺȏ Ŋåĩƺȏ1ċȖƲÄƩEƵŊ %;0 ĽĹƏĊǢ1gZ?ȼB=

ƺȏÄƩɌKU: knowledge useɍɏƺȏEƾ¡Ʋ

ĽĹƏĊ0)ƓÍ1-ȳƅȴ-+2ƾ¡ŘƐŊåĩƺȏ1ȑĴƲÄ Ʃ/B= ƺȏƧƨǢ1Ľô?ȼB = 1>0ƺȏÅĥEð¸wc}- A-¹0ɇ ùÐ%ȳƅȴ2ƺȏƧƨɌ_{1, 2ɍƺȏÄƩɌ3, 4ɍ} ƺȏǃȞɌ6, 7ɍƺȏƔɌ8, 9, 10ɍ#B$B1Ƀ ú0Û;?BAmIejaQùɌ5ɍ2ƺȏƧƨ -ƺȏÄƩ1ş1Ƀú09%A<1-ǹ?BA

5.

¹0ƺȏǃȞ-ƺȏƔEƅǥ>4Åĥ1Ɂ ?ÒÃ%wc}EŒƽ%Q{JHd >4He~W-(%¥-1ȴ¬,ǹA-ƺ ȏǃȞ,2He~WȯǸ0/@ƺȏƔ,2 Q{JHdȯǸ0/A-ā-ǽAƺ ȏǃȞ0+2ƾ¡Ʋ»¼Ʋ«³1ċƥ0å +ļĊ%Q{JHd1Ê&,2ÓÁ/ -āċŠǢ1ƓÍ+AƥýEȘ+«³ ȇ;?Bƾ¡0ċǵBA%;0He~W ȯǸ-/AşƺȏƔ0+2ƠĊ1ƾ

(5)

¡ƲíɅEǼƏAQ{JHdEǹÀ+ċŠ Ǣ-Ǘ4)A-0ÊƝǝBA%;He~ W>@<Q{JHdȯǸ0/A#1_Jf tQY?±pY1ƓÍā/A-< Q{JHdȗƝ1Ǥŧ-+ŋ?BA ,2ƺȏǃȞ-ƺȏƔ1.'?Ů9 -ȐȍEǱ(+A1,2/)A -)%A-)-ƺȏǃȞ1:QZH aoBAŢű1ŘǎƻǇċȚ0ĐN}^f bIn-+)A_-)/A-)-ƺ ȏƔ1Ho`A--#1ĽǟEƠǋ +%

6.

űǅ,2ȳƅȴ1ȐȍEƱĔ"ƅȴÅ ĥ-1ȴ¬ĺ0+ȳƅȴĊ£BA- ȇȏ10ċŠǢYrUQ{JHd He~W-(%ȴ¬¥1ċƩƲĊǟEǱ(% B0Ĳ(+#B?1ȴ¬¥-ȳƅȴ1ȴ¬ ĺɀğ0āƂ,A-Ešįŝƣ=J^lx ȋŻ?Ť?0ũĊƲ/ɇùÐEȃ:% ,ȯǸ/-2àɇù1×ď,2/ȳ ƅȴ2ƺȏƧƨ¥=ƺȏÄƩ¥0+<ć÷ A-Ʊǹ,A?0B9,ł-+%ƺȏƧƨ-ƺȏÄƩEŹƄ Aą¥-+ 1ȳƅȴ<ƺȏǃȞƺȏƔ1ƀĸ1Ę Ã0>(+#B$Bwc}ÐA-Eƽ% B0>(+ƺȏƧƨǃȞƔÄƩ1ð¸ wc}ŀ@ǈ'qduHaoƲ0ɇùÐB% ȳƅȴ1wc}10¿ƀĸÐBA-EĒ% ı1ȊɅ-+2>@ģƍ/ȋŻEț9+ ȳƅȴ1ɇùÐEǐǛ0 A-Ȥ0Ǚď/ ¨ƻǇ0>@ȳƅȴ0AǕǜƲƓÍ-±Ʋ ƓÍ-1)/@EŤ?0 A-B?Eț 9+ȳƅȴ-+1ƾ¡Ʋ¯Ʉ1Ƽ®1ş Ųǣŀ1@şEĔŮ A-/.A9% Q{JHd/He~W102ƺȏƧƨ ?ÄƩ9,1Ǖ:EÿANfɌv^yV ɍ<A-ǡ?BAĮ?1ȴ1@ş< B?ǹ+/B3/?/bs,A

űƻǇ2ǁƻȔûƴ_{Cƺȏ-ƾ¡Ʋ»¼Ʋ«} ³E)/ȳƅȴ1ƅǥɌ22530395ɍ-+ċŠ B+A<1,A

Boggs, J.P. (1992) ‘Implicit models of social knowledge use’, Knowledge: Creation, Diffusion, Utilization 14(1): 29-62.

Bowman, J.S. (1978) ‘Managerial theory and practice: the

transfer of knowledge in public administration’, Public

Administration Review 38(6): 563-570.

Caplan, N. (1979) ‘The two-communities theory and knowledge utilization’, American Behavioral Scientist

22(3): 459-470.

Caplan, N., Morrison, A. & Stambaugh, R.J. (1975) The

Use of Social Science Knowledge in Policy Decisions at the National Level: A Report to Respondents. Ann Arbor, MI:

Center for Research on Utilization of Scientific Knowledge.

Checkland, P.B. (1981) Systems Thinking, Systems Practice. Wiley, Chichester.

Contandriopoulos, D. et al. (2010) ‘Knowledge exchange processes in organizations and policy arenas: a narrative systematic review of the literature’, Milbank

Quarterly 88(4): 444-483.

Mitton, C. et al. (2007) ‘Knowledge transfer and exchange: review and synthesis of the literature’,

Milbank Quarterly 85(4): 729-768.

Rich, R.F. (1979) ‘Editor’s introduction’, American

Behavioral Scientist 22(3): 327-338.

Sabatier, P.A. & Jenkins-Smith, H.C. (1988) ‘Symposium editors’ introduction’, Policy Sciences 21(2-3): 123-127. Shapiro, J.Z. (1984) ‘Conceptualizing evaluation use:

implications of alternative models of organizational decision making’, pp. 633-645 in R.F. Conner, D.G. Altman & C. Jackson, eds., Evaluation Studies Review

Annual, vol. 9. Beverly Hills, CA: Sage.

Webber, D.J. (1983) ‘Obstacles to the utilization of systematic policy analysis: conflicting world views and competing disciplinary matrices’, Knowledge: Creation,

Diffusion, Utilization 4(4): 534-560.

Webber, D.J. (1986) ‘Explaining policymakers’ use of policy information: the relative importance of the two-community theory versus decision-maker orientation’, Knowledge: Creation, Diffusion, Utilization

7(3): 249-290.

Weiss, J.A. & Weiss, C.H. (1981) ‘Social scientists and decision makers look at the usefulness of mental health research’, American Psychologist 36(8): 837-847.

ŰŵěĈƻǇłɌ2011ɍ ƕĀŘĤǑƻǇȲƱƅȴ0 AƻǇȲƱWYbu0ȴ AȋŻÁŷȋŻüçŪ Ġŀ22 ġĥŝȭǁĈƸĄȀȋŻ âƜÇƪÖŚȬɌ_{2009ɍƻǇǢ-ċÎĎ-1ƺȏ} ƔɏƦȍ-ċȚ?1řǿ ƻǇņǲǾƬĈ¡Ǌ24 ñġƆĈǲĂ¡ȎƚǸţȺ_{202-205 ɂłÛ} âƜÇǷųƫĞĆƪÖŚȬĉǰɉɌ2010ɍǉ ƲȕȰÅĥ0Aȳƅȴ1ƅǥ ƻǇņǲǾ ƬĈ¡Ǌ25 ñġƆĈǲĂ¡ȎƚǸţȺ476-477 ɂł Û âƜÇĖ¾®½ŶėęŨǘɌ2011ɍǁĈ-ƾ ¡E)/Ǖǜ1ƾ¡ƲĊƹ0å+ɏǬö?1ř ǿ ǁĈņǲTtxgSWz9 ß93-106 ɂ

JAIST Repository: 知識生産・移転・交流・利用の四元モデルに基づく中間機関の類型化