雑誌名 国際社会研究
巻 1
ページ 401‑422
発行年 2010‑10
URL http://id.nii.ac.jp/1092/00000546/
asKUIS 著作権ポリシーを参照のこと
!"#$!
%&'()*+,-./0123456789:-;<=>?@A B)*+,2CDEFGH IJK L-MN?OPQERST56EUG8
VWPXY:Z-[\]G8
^_`a)*+,
^bca b
^dea f g f h
^i4a
^ijka lmno+
^p qarstu
vX Ywxyz{Q7B !>#$!%&'H :|}~sB !"#$!%&
'H PU Q78 --2]G:iQU]G
:KQ4EU
! "#$ %&'
!"#$%&
'()*+,-./0123456478 4/09:.;5(<=>?@AB(456*
CDEFGHEIJ6KL5MN=O*
P !"#$% 5 QRSTUV5WXKY& Z[
!"##$$$% &!#%#$#! '()*+ (,,-,(\
]^_`abcdef
ghi jk6K kl
m nopqrs&'tKq,-&uv m
.5wx'j!"#$%yz{|
'
m }~'F!#
m +,-=/012346
(
m jkF'
-
m ' ¡¢£¤
,
m jk¥@¦§¨©9:ª«¬
/
m ®¯9:'5°±²³´¬
m &'µ/6¶z·¸
g¹i !"#$%5º»
m [bFyF¼5½#$½!¾¿ÀyÁ m ½#$½!¾¿'}~ÂÃÄ
m ÅÆyÇqÈÉÊË
'
m Ì6Í! 5ÎÏ9:ÐÑÒ
!"!#$%&'( )*+,- ./01 !"! 2345(
6789:;<=" >?@>
ABC ;DEFGHIJK
!"!LMHNJ8 OPQ
3R=STU$%&'( VWXY Z[\]^_`abc defg
hi78#jklmkno pqrfs t^uvw;xyz{|}78fN~
!
;x | xUHJbU
|Kyzx xa |
x | x78UK8 ¡¢
£78yz¤¥H¦?§¨©ª¨\«¬®H¯©78| °
±yzkx²³´¤µ¶U·W¸¹º»|¼Kx²
³´|½¾78¿ºHÀÁKÂÃU ÄÅÆÇ87\c;
ÈHÉ8t^1Ê¿ºËÌU78x²H³´t^|§vÍ8¼ Î|78bÏ1Ê¿ºÐÑÒHÓÔ78w;xÕÖ×HØÙ|bÀÁ HÚÛkÜÝ7ÞÍ|MK88U·; ¡¢£
\yz¤¥ß§8àáâãäåæçRèékêë\ì
!"#$"%&'()*+,-. !*/01 23'4567'89*:;<=>*?1@2AB;'CDE@F
GHIBEJKLM'NO" P.QR 'SJ
* P.*CTU2A'SVWLM P.XYZ"[\'7]- DFHI^LM_`a3H7'bcd"B *WLM_`a 3 P.XYZ'ef1g? Kh"2AiFUj"
k^lm^nok3pqrs"tuUvw"xyz{|*
}~FCD^AA"`AE E.'12AB
G^z'T|}E2AiFAzw WGZUWw%ZEJw"*0D
'¡¢-23'_£-DLMBw^¤¥¦¡A@5§¨
m^©ª«31@F25-Dv¬'23Cg|*®k-1@¯2A }°iF±"G"²lUGL³´!"DS"±
"µ¶·¸kEJ} P.XY"E¹iF25-DXY"º»
E¼½k*{`1«R*:;'¾S1@QE`3pERE@F
·6. !'¿hdÀÀ*Á@1}ÂÃGA"Ä ÅÆ«3D ÇÈÉÊ]U
!"Ë̬]*/01Í^
zÎÏÐ"ÀÑÒÓ"ÔÕ^Ö×*ØC01@F!"EJ"Ù Ä]'ÚÛ1º»*_`a3ÜÝEwÞUßÞ.à']S1á¯2 A^âã"EäåAE01@F
B
#æ"çèg?éêëìUé êëwììéêëíî:cpïðñðòóðô
õö!A|÷"øå*@1'ùú=ûhüý'þ01=DF"
Æ. !øåA¯*LM"wÐ"ßøå*@1é êëìER*ë"w^S1Ø@õ'cN%*"øå*@
1ûh¨m S1@2A^)=DF1éêëB
!"#$%&'()*+,- ./01234567)8-9:7;
<=6>?9@ABCD$EFGAHIJ,KL MN)OP9QR,S& !TU,VW9XYZ )[\9]^_,4567;
@)`abcdef9<H566ghi jklmnopq9LY6;
rs
!"#$
,t5u5 v)'(wx)yO z{|}#$~#$),) 9
) 9¡¢
,£7¤¥¦§¨)©ª«¬9LY6;
N® ¯° ¯±²³´µN¶· °
¸®z{|}#$¹º» ¼¹½¾¿
ÀÁÂû®rsÄ]EÅÆÇ
@ÈÉ$E"Ê$MËÌ)'()ÍÎ9Ï ÐÑ_£Òº¦ÓÔÕÖM6g,רÙÚÛÜ ÝÞß9àM HZ!á!)àÑâ¸_^ãä)å=Þ©
!"#$%&'()*"#+,-./0 123456789:;<=>?@./ABCDEF"#
0GHI9:;<JKLMN-OPFQR0S T9:;<UVWXYZ[F"#0GHI9\
]^_<U`abcdF"#0efg^_ h ijkl mnhopq<`rstuv-wx*yz{|-}~
0123456789:;<l -
^-^F
UV
!"
F^_<0ST9:; ¡¢£¤<¥¦
§¨©ª«¬¥¦efg^_ UVW X<0ST9:; !
®¯°±HI²8¦ ³²2´µ
-¶·Q¸zE¹¸zF-º»¼½¾¿ÀÁ-Â{
63ÃÄÅÆÇÈÉʺË-ÌÍ$α(ÏÐÑÒ
TÓÔÕÖÎÈרÙÚÛÜÝÞßàáutâ-ÓÔF
ÛÕÖãä ÆÇQåæçèéßàáÆÇÈ./AB CDEê-ëìíîï((Xðñòóôõö÷Î'
(!
"ßàáÓÔÈø]æâF'ùúÎ-ûü
ý1<þʹ-./»-ÛT
!"#$%&'()*+
,-./!0123456,-7.89:";<=>?@A 2$%&'>B:"CDEFG.HI.J:KLMNO
PQR?@2STQR?UVTWXYZ[\]-.^_K`a2 bcQR?defghijk.;<=>lmnopqr stuvwxyz{0|}:2 bcNj bc~?QR._
K2;<=WXY`0:" ]@iNO j.@2
!fllsd2de2:Kd.Hi
0NO~"sd. @_N .ANOiH.^_K|}¡¢£:"#¤¥z¦?@2§Q¨Nj©
_¤ªK2P!jª«.¬ ®jN.i¯"#
°±
(² ³ ´µ¶ (·µ¸ (
¹²º»¼r½p
.¾Q0¿À:K_CÁHÂWºG¾Ã.ÄÅ2ÆÇÈÉ ÊºÃ¡eºÃËÌÍÎ2Ϩ2ÐÑÒ0ÓÔ:2&rÕÖרÙÚ ÛÜÝ0¾Þ:"#CÁHÂWºGØ@ÁHÂßà\áâ¬0ãä:2º åPØæ: 0çèPØ?Iéiêëì0í¹?A#ºÐÑ Ò2+2îï2Ðð¨sϨ5ñ0òK2ÁHÂߥªs
¬ó.^_KôNõöMQ-0+¯"#ÈÉ÷ïøÔùúvû?
APØüýþòj!2N^¾º«®ý.i¯"#
!"#$%&'()*+,-./
01 2 34
56!"%78 9:;<6=1>?@A3B
+CDE./FGEDHIJKL M:NOPIJKQRST UVW=
&'()*+,-./0GXY%ZL &'[+\P]:^_6=1
=`abcIJKQRST=defghijkl 6=mnopghiqrjks63Vtu
v)(Bwxyz1 2 34 Bw{G|}~Z|>h QL]:^_1=
BwPG|}Z%QLPGL
3B
ghi3 ¡y0¢0./0£¤F¥F¦§¨
©ª«R¬®
¯°±
Z²1³´´Yµ¶G³·¸¹.[FºL
»¼½¾ Z¿·ÀÁÂÃÄÅ´YÆÇÈÉÊË zÌÍ%²^ÎÏÐÑÒÓ+Ô0½ÕÖFz¶¸¹5×ÀØ
!" !
#$% & '(
)*+,-./0123/456789 :;<=/$%>?@A%BCD)*
EFGHI%JKLMNOPQRS KTUK VWXYZ [\]X^_%JN`^aQbcdefghij
Kkljmn_$o,pKqrstuv[wWQxyz[[
{|_}#K~KTUKL{[V^Xb u8
%Js[K;oL{ bcch
ciHH jQ)*Kjs ¡¢£N s¤¥
¦§¨dHb©ª«
!" !
#$% & '(
)*¬®¯/E°±²89 ¦³´Aµ01 :;¶·¸¹/$%>?@A%B'º
EF»s$N¦§¨¼½[¾n¿Àuxyz[ÁÂQÃÄÅ
KÆÇÈÉÊQ¦³´AËÌ[$K¿ÀN2ÍPz[ÎϤ
¥X^_$o[Ð]s^ÑÒÓÔ[ÕÖ×KØÙKÚÛÜQ
¦§¨µuÝÞWßàáâãgä;ÞKåæçDK¿Às t[V^XèPé;u8%JK;oQL{
bcchciHH jQ)*
Kjs ¡¢£Ns¤¥
!" #$%&'()*+
', -.'-/0 , 12 , 1 34 5 67
89:;<=>?@(A BCDEF>4G(H6I
JK(@LAM'(NOPQRNM'()*STUOVWX YZ[\&#]^SN#_3`abcdefg#h ijOklmnopA#8`a"OqQres #t uOvZY(wOxyzmA#{|zm}p~es"
?#x6>)*
pX89&&#Mpu
es
¡¢£¤>¥¦£¤#§¨&'4#©ª«¬Z®O¯°
XeZ\&±+
', -
!'²/0 , 12 , 1 34 5 67
89³´?µ> ¡¢£¤>¥¦£¤¶·¸¹º»¼ A?@
£½¾A
BCDEF>4G(H6I
JK¿ÀNÁÂXYA&XY#ÿpÄÅuÆO'4#
¡¢£¤>¥¦£¤¶·#Ç^S8sÂ#ÈM ¡
¢£¤#É`aÊe > Ë#ÌÍÎ(ÏOÐmÑÒ xSÓÔmÕÖ× > Ë0##ØKOvZYÄ Ås # ¡¢£¤ÙÚOÊmÛÜÝÞß¹,#
à¶WápâãlmäåÂXY'4OæÓam©ª×OvZY
!"#$%&
'()*"+,$-./-01234566789:
;<%=>?@ABC4 DE&FGHIHJKHLMNONP"
QRST U% VW6XYZ[\]^_`01 ab
&F<cdeOfghijkWSlmnopqrstuvwxy 0Rz{;"|}01~z{;%/
^% Wtu/B6%
lmNiWS5666"%p?
p?AW/6 ¡¢WB£¤¥1
`¦§ ¦¨ © Uª«40¥^¬n opqrs®¯°$S1¦0tu/BS±²j³o
_`S0R%´µ6 /vS¶·¸¹Wº»§
$¼½-01¥-0¼½/¾¿%6WSÀÁÂÃv w" Ä.`ÅW+,%Æ/9qrsÇu4ÈÉÊu4±² ËlÌÍ%tuÎÏÌÍ%ÐÑÒÓPÔÕÖH×%ØÙÚX .SÛÜÝ/ÞS¦WRW^$01
z{;Ù¦WR0ÌÍ/ßàS@-SØ%`¦áµâã4
n6WäË"QR U"å,S1æçz{;/ © U^2
3Sèé¨êëìíî ç© ç ·ï¦@-SØ%234
ð£/nopqrs"ñºSòó-S1z{;/Bô-0Ê
!"#$%& '()*+,-.'/
01 2
34567 89:;<=>?@A B CDEFGHI JKLMNO@PQ R
3STUV 89:;<=>?@AWX WCY ZC[\]^_L`abPQ R 3cdef MNO@AWX WC Cg9;hi
j_LMNO@abPQ R
3klm nopA B Cq@rsGIJKLt EuvEabPQ R
3wxyz nopA B CO@g{>[_LO
@g{>[abPQ R ,| }1 2
~#.$ }cdk lwx''.)2 }+))O@g {>[CO@g{>[_L\Eq@rsGIJKLg9;
hijCg9;hij_L!"TCg
!"#$%&'()*+
,-./012345"6789,+:;<=>?@A6 B,CDE?F"&GH@IJK"#LM#)2,NOP QR)2S,TUVWXYZ[8\]S^_`)abcdYef]gh S^_`ij&k!l!mn,opijqr'6s?F"tuv w0x8ZJKy#Lz{ |}~JA#{) ?
}s+?6L{&v*+./JH!6&
,"63)k! ?Bv%J)WR
#2S?H!6J"?#"L
,B%? 6¡Q,¢£}¤,@('6L ¥ ~¦~§B}
~¦~§B}) ¨ ~,
©ªJAe«¬®¯Z°3±¦~§B²,³´Yµ¶J·
"6)¸ ¹ º» ){» ,³´J¼½
"6L!M¾?¿ ¹BJ)*¦ §? |J
"6LB,À}ÁÂs,YÃÄ-E~~«
,Å®ÆC)Ç?ÈÉÊËYÌÍÎÏYÄ-ÀÎÏvÐJÑÒ
6L
Ó YÃÄ-YÔÕÖר,Ù-
} ÚÛJR)12JÖ×6ÔÕÜ Ý
ÞÔÕ,«ß/àá)ÔâY$ãYghvÐ,.,ä´YåæJ·")
M#¯ç,è/¦éêë,ì/íîJïð6&u£v'6L
ÃÄ-}ÃÄ- ÚÛJR)¦éêë,ñïðJòó?k
,+ô,¦éêë,ïð)¯ç/õQö,·).ä´)÷øùú)e
!"#$%&'()%*
+,-./0123456789:;<=>?@A:;
BCD+,-.:E>?FG@HIJ%*-.:
;>?(KLM !N05O9PQR"STUVWX YZ[9\]$^_`'0 a\bcdefgfhiejfk kcelmn*
BCo0pq rstuGFvOwBCxJ%yz0K {|fS}~@%*0 ()%*
EZZ
v "UVxJ%*
BCo`'0#@¡¢£¤")¥¦J%*
§¨©ª«¬®¯°±9²³J%´('µ¶(0·i}®¸lh
¹:º¬·i±9²³J%`'()%*
»¼½w¾¿ ÀÁ ÃĶ
»ÅGÆ`ÇÈÉÊ
»¼ Ë®nuÌͯi
ÎÏÐÑÒÓÔÏÑWÕÖרÃÙÚÛ \ÜÌÜÝ`
'@Þa%*
ß^_`'STàáUVâÃÕãLMÑ%*
äåæçèé
êëìí:;\%î9ïðñò`¡óïôXMõö÷øùá
!" #$%&'%()%*+
,-. / 01 / 23.45 / 6789 /
:;<=>?@ABA ?!" , CD
,-.EF23.EF
,-.EFGHIJKL = %23.EFG EFM= N OPQ
RSTUVWOPQXYZ[\G]A^_Z_T?`_
^Ga b [c b def?=g^%hiG dRS jeTP_kA^_Qlm%nopqGr-s,CD?t%
&uv?wu%xyz.{|}~g^gm-h23
? ]A%%J@
O ]AOPT%i,[cO qGS
g^Zg^ A¡¢ Z£^_Q¤£^¥s%-¦
g^¡iu}§}¨k©ª«?G¬®¯°±j²
³´g^µm_Q
¶·
¸.?¹º»¼½¾¿g^%ÀÁZ¸.ÂÃÄ%ÅÆÇÈ
ÃÄÉÊË?%º»Ì5ÍÌÎÏ¡ÐÑÒÓÌ
!"#$%&'()*+,-. / 0123456789$:;<=>?)@AB C)DE F )GHIJI,)KL>?M. N O P)56Q RSTU89$VW>?M. N O)XYZU[\]^_=
`abc>?M. N!Qd !"#$%efg 0hi C)@AB C!Qd>?)jLk!l`m=]nop qrstuv]),0=wx)>?)yTU-]z{|<}D UC~! $h, !89$%g0 j~$7XUM]Q! j7&Q%
P O P T
& ¡s¢¡
£¤¥1¦§¨©ª«¬®
"8¯°±²³´¯°µs&¥1¦¶·¸¹ºs»¶·
¦µ¼½¾ks»¶·§¨©ª«¬® µ
¿ÀÁs»Â¶·ÃÄÅÆs»ÇÈÉÊ
¯°¸¹º¯°µËÌÍks&¥1¦ÇÈÉÊÃÄÅ Æs»ÇÈÉÊ4ή¡sÏ s&
!"#ÇÈÉÊ
&Q)ÐÑ
Ò Ó½Ô¥1¦ XYZU[\]^_)Õ~abc>?
Ò Ö½×Ø¥1¦ JIKL>?
Ò ¿ÙÚª«¬® ¦ »h
UÛ\ÃÄÅÆÉÊ7ÜÝ)Þß!àá$%x))Þâ=
BdU")ã äåT)æDUC~0çi)è.,-]%
!"#$%
&'()*+,-.'/0123456789 ):;<=>?(-@#3456789
AB67CDEF
$GHIJKL
M NOP QRS
TU V HIJKL
WXYZ[<'\. 3]/^_`^ V a=bc^/(
@7d0+e V +3f=;(gh=HIJK L3ic7
V HIJKL
Tj=k/^0lmnoHpEqic7@G
#rst=u=v167 wl3xyz{o|
)}~3$_(-)Z/'^q0/ ~h-@
#=43;0X=EF=wl3xy/3z{o
|60EFO=gh=<3:/^0KH7 M NP QRSAB67CDEF=g( !"#$%
$GIz3c7KL
Z_(q.'/qq0) ¡¢£¤6¥3¦§_(-
#/h@#¨©x+(
ªa«¬
®h6^qZ¯;°'/±q/77d0Iz²
!"#$%&'()*+,-./01 234516789:;<=>?@ABC;DEFG H<I2':7JHK23;-LM?@<IA@:
NFOPF>5Q@:4RSTU@V&34 W"XYZT[\
]UB;^_;`abc';defae&34 g ][h ijklm;no4pqrstUB;uv
Wwxy67z{|}
~F;wxy2'lm=-?@:@:'z
?I234)@)He&34r3 y 2'T*:3?Y2:
;Ua;3;) @H¡2':3:34 Wn¢;£¤
¥¦=§¨©l2¦ª@n«1¬;®¯?
°5±²67³-.´4µ´-¶·;¸[-89:;N¹ºF
»¼~>?>?½6@&':75£¤A$34 Wn¢;±²
n«1¬;±²=¾¿ª&3;-À;_?Á¼ÂÃ6 701ÄÅ234ÆÇTÈ;_?c&3=RS=¾¿ª&3
;-ÉÊË&'ÀJ675ÌQ34U@;ÍÎ=ÏB Ð34
WÑÒÓFÔ;£¤
p55-TÕÖT×=Ø:3U&3Utp(Ø-:QÙ×=Ú Q3:;Ut:1 ÛÜ65Ý2'ÚQ7Þ?ÑÒÓF Ô£¤234
!"#$%&'()*+,&-()*
+ ./012+,#34567*89:;<=>?#
@A8*B%CDE"5FGHIJJKLMNO5>PQ%
"RS5TP?UVP?#WX8YZ[>25L&'()
*+,#\]0?5^#_`PZ[Wa$*8 bcdef
gKh;ijPjQk5U%bcd5ef#0PZ[5Wa$*8 lmno:#pq5ef;r;)*8
s t uvwx2y5z{P?|}
~gK
no:;% ; 5CD8PL%" ( G~;V)*+Q8($*;%(5
;;)*Q kQ$*8
y
"¡ L¢ z£#¤¥P?UVP;%VjY
G5¦;§2¨©P%CDZUYG5ª«¬;®2¯7G
`P?#WX8°±²>³´#o{PJµ5¶$%V·jQ
&I,Qz£0PZ[5Wa$*8
¸j¹(Gº»#¼@A
gKh5½¾>;¿À5Á$*Jµ5¶$%&bÂ>
5|²BÃ[?#ÄÅ¥%Y`#I(¥Z[0PZ[58 ÆÇ!Èj)*·ÉÊIË50P?YU5ÌÍÎÏ #Ð 0©>Z[5,Wa8
<hhO#Ð)*gK
ÑÒÉÊÓÔQÕÕCD67%&x2y5z{P,[
!"#$%&'()*+,-./0-12
3456
789:;<!=>?
@ABC5DE589!FG-.H1IJKJLM'N OP1289QRGSTUV? %$!AWXY 5Z [5
\]Z-^#H2 7_`!abQcd
aeQfg/0#hijkb!cH'1lm89!nopq 1b QZUr^stuvQ w_`!cH1H2x54yw$z{
Q |}sQZ_`c~^s S5_`(x5Z5Q SQ Y 1bF( 2
75
895ZNgQHIZJP12
!-19$Hdd$(HK[5)*+
,!cHx^ZyU55X;Q? #h5 ¡
¢£Z-^#H2 7¤¥¦$§¨\]Q[H.
©NJK5I:;Ur ©dQ? 1b w5ª
¦Q«¬®¡¯°±(²³? %$Z´µ-.hd¶&d2' 1I§¨·¸w5©d#Z5!¹Y.TºQ»¼+»$- .:;pq.hd¶&d2
_`½
7 ¾2¿ÀÁ5«ðÄÅQM_-.ÆÅ»(345Ç
G!ÈÉ23¦fg89$g!ÊQ? 2ɦ5ËÌ589
!"#$%&' ()*+,-./01234563
7 89:;<=<>5?@ABCDE7F7GH+IJ<:
"KLMNOPQRSRTUV C5/WX C5+QRYZ[\]\^_.&'`abcde&+fgh<
iRjkQR(lcPmH+no12OPpq+r st2gh<i+uvbwxcyqz<{jk2
7 8|} <~<{/iM{"c$%&+f ZGH++>
5?@&+fpq+gh<iuvTUU
%
[?@fD'%c+5k%$
+(Pdejkn+"#/["/
R+c o12&+f¡+¢<£"AU¡
+¤¥P¦k§'Pc¨©ªc(Rjk&+«
gh<iCk¬5 !"#
L^Ck®¯P+gh<i°k ±P² ³P²
!"#jk2 ³P²D´kµ¶·bc¸¬¹(5§2+
.º»./012.¼½l2H@5c¾' 2g¿"N+8D ±P²Àt%ÁÂt2Ã/pqDp qpÄ/ZÅÆÇÈcjYÉÊ(l2 <ic+.g¿"
N&'(l2D5Ë\&+8DCpq+̲ /¥§)Z(_2%ÍCt
jRjkP/Ã}t2dÎÏÐ 8n_
c5¨3
7 8?@ÑA ÒÓcZ <¿g<ÔÕ"KZ
!"#$%%&'()*+,#-./012324 5&678)9:;<=>?@A&BC=DE4FC)>G>
H2IJ=KLM NOPQ%<RSTU
VWXY N%<Z[>3>3 \$*+,#-./G;]^_
`6abLcd$ef0ghL>ijVkl.m9n>9$;oJ \]^;pqKNr) N st<>4=KL>uv$wx 0ybz{4|}Z[01KL~JJ&uv`6abL]J };29>32)|}$Z[01>=;<0guq hL )KL>