ナラティブと意味づける力

全文

(1)

(2) . . . $. .

(3) . %%&'%'$.

(4)

(5). !"#$%. &'

(6) ()*

(7) +,-./012345, 6789./:,;<=>,?0@A -./*67BC)DE)) 67*F%G% ,H-./0IJ;<K9,LM&)9'NO9E PQ,-./:0R 67STUV%WX;<K9E$YZ[9E7 \%67$]^K9 _`0. !,abK9E$c9'defg,hijklm nopg $;<. K9 . SqrsA9tVuv* -./*678);<&9wx [9yAz 678){|-&9}~[9YZ0<K'kN()E, t* 1[7c $(A9@7,0K 9E%z9 qt[9E$<&9'.

(8)

(9) . 6*defg,hijklm nopg S V , .

(10) , . . . . K9')g ,E,kh,Q$ op oS . . V,89 . %)9'E,* hi)k &¡¢,h0£¤H¥)9,[7 ¦§0¨9

(11) . . . !. . ". # @A$) ©, ª. «¬®¯°«i. ±i²6³´µo¶. .

(12)

(13) .

(14) . !. "#$%&'()*+ ,-./0123( 4 .

(15). 5

(16) . '( 6784'97:;8 <=>?@ AB #$%& 5CDE#$%&'FGHIJK LM@2N('ON PQ RS>8TU(O VW4#$%& 5CDEXEY<'(T6/ Z[#$%& 5 CDE#$%&@Z:CDEXEY<Z 7'\G]^ !\G_`Zab@cdefg?E>h . i 23(9 9XEY<'#$%&''99/+/jkl mn@2 #$%& o pq 2"7/TrsBt\!u/O'/7v'9#$%& !/Ww pq9xyT9//O'zM{@Z|}~'#$ XEY<. %&Ww8Z Z7u/!u/:j8T/ @2" O @Z7@9 pqP 9u'9{ZT9. pqT4OZu/dE. eegD?d >eEY>D kl /<?e< ¡QERYe¢>Y>e£?EO(/¤¥4 1Ww #$¦ ,§T 1/ >D #$¨8PRYeS©DEY D3ª«,¬Bpq@2i !"8 T#$%&B¦O' XEY<@2u#$%& 5:H I®¯8a°BCDEXEY<'(O'Z Z±XEY<'(w²³fg?E>7 ´µ ¶-. pqP (>eEYh i ·¸¹ºY> n» h

(17)

(18)

(19) i'( @¼½/ ¾¿'04"À@9f RYÁEÂ ÃÄYÁE @ . '(wTÅ'ÆÇÈ ´7 É7 ÅÊD@Z7'ËÌTÍÎ+ÏÐBw@2 ! '(w ÑÒ O ° 4# $%& ¨+ ÓÔCDEXEY< ÕÖu×Ø@'u3 '( 9! ! '(ÙÚT8cRDE #$%&BÛÜ. !"X. EY< ÝÞßZà¤:9 'áâ7@2 WwTwÒãäBå!!(9 @2uXEY<Bæ/WwcRDE çèÜ®éê@92'%ë XEY<'8cRDET#$%&B¦O'@2'@ AB#$ %&'É7'('0G%&@2'\3( #$%&@ìí îïðñò3"92%®BeÌóBô!(ìí3"9ì ,õì ÌöT÷øù úû+O ù ìí îï ÌöT÷ø 7@2{0üýZWþv O ù #$'(O'Z"i. .

(20)

(21)

(22) . !. "#$%&'()*+,-.'/0123456789:+ ;,<+;,<8

(23) =>?$%&' @ABCDEFGH3! IJ?KJLM+;,<NO+;,<PI G23 QRRSDT4567UVWXYZ [\23]3^ _+;,<

(24) `3aA+;,<J bcd! XYG ef^g g. jk&l/mn.. pq+mrs.. +;,<hiE8o

(25) h8o

(26) ge. K tYDuKv bwx QRRSKJ+;,. <D tYGDyG3 . S. sz'{<,"#$%&'|x}$%&'~x}JG @ABCDEF cGJ XY!?h"o4 !. D'{;{/ ?. ¡¢¢G£¤GD. AI?¥@A. I ¦§452¨©Daª"«¬G9!®¯ ! X YGD . Gz, .

(27) 3°±2sz'{<,². " ³£´.

(28)

(29) z,µ¶·¸¹ º3)»`sz'{<&'D¼½¾~. ¿!ÀÁÂ ÃFÄÅÆDÀI? . . ?2iÇ ÈÉAI? . . . ÊËGÌD. DÍf{mÎÏ.ÐpÑÒ. ¶·¸D¼UÓ,kzQ SÔU&<Õ,'Q .

(30) SÖf qmQ

(31) S3%{,×kqØ/Q S . .

(32) {z/×Ù.'Q. . S . . . .

(33) . <Õz,.×<ÚÛ'Q . . S . . +&'. Ü,.Q . S . . . Ù.'ÝÞqmÖß !àÊá . S3qå. æe âÍ?eiÇãäGsq,mr/Q GJGsz'{<,``çxÊáI ÀÁÂ ÃFÄÅÆDè ?2ÈÉè z,3. ¼bz,éê . . . &',p,Q. S . . . ë&ì,&Q SÖß íî"#ïðU¹ ××Ï,&l,Q×× . S2

(34)

(35). ñ 7 ò3 hóÞôßg. Gõôßgo3ö/$/&. ÀÁÂ ÃFÄÅÆD` ?! &',p,Ö÷hóÞôßg. øGb. õôßgo3ö/$/&àAÀÁÂ ùú2ûß ! ü{'. .

(36)

(37) $"%&/()01. 23. !"#$"%&'()*+,-.. 4,-.4#56&78,9:;%!6<6 9=. >?@A;BCDEFG=HI JKLM JKN OPQ JK9:; RSTU!VCWXYFG .1!#6BC9Z[\ ] ] ^_;à VCbGcXd16;ef9PVCWXYSTU!;bGgh.1!#6 BC;'iVC>?@CC<-j @C=k lVCmnkFGCoC=F9pF= q rstuvkFGC ? .

(38)

(39) . .

(40)

(41) .

(42) .

(43)

(44).

(45)

(46)

(47) . . .

(48)

(49)

(50) .

(51) .

(52)

(53) . .

(54) . . ,

(55)

(56). . . . 8wxByz>{|P %!6<6; [}~ u %6% bGr0TVAZ 9Z ;<-j9Z VCG 9 @C042U ?9u?;GC rA =F 8wxBy;4%!=F u Z 9 bVCd16;¡¢VCWXY ;£0¤4$%& , ¥¦§¨T" %©ª& .

(57) ,6)«<¨. !&

(58) . , ¬(§5«j)#. Uª& , ®§¨T"%©ª=F¯C?u §¨T"%©ª°±²³ >? ´9Z cµ B )¨T"%;¶·T#U¸¹CFG )¨T"%;º»¼[G )¨T"%;<U!% ½ )¨T"%;¾ 1T¨%r¿u )¨T"%;%0U4% ÀrÁ )¨T"%;T¨d%ÂÃu )¨T"%;1T¨% ¿ÄrÅu )¨T"%;Æ ÇrÈ¯u )¨T"%;Æ ÉrÊVCËrÈ ?G [}§¨T"%©ª ´9r8wxÌÍAZ u9[#2-0¤j. .

(59)

(60)

(61) . ! "#$%&'()*+,-. / +0

(62) 1 . 23415236789:;<=>?@ABC D=>?@AE>=FG HIJK +L/$MJ!N#OP%&'QR%&'.ST UMV*W.$#"JXYZ[#. !. "\?@ >J]^ EN+JXVL_àbW. c $#!bWàdXàefgJhi@jk"lJm" \?@ >J! <=>?@ABCTno W.X=>?@Apqr"=>?@A*sF G +t[#. %&'Eq u$/ xe. TvE2>w2. ! /.N. %&'àe,-J/E ]

(63) "yz{)L !FU'|E}. W./$~U%u/J +I ENXWX"#0 +! )hE+>=FG +%&'"*"XW [#!rl$#.. ,-J/ +. E}W. ! W. !)+ !. . .

(64)

(65)

(66) .

(67)

(68)

(69). 6

(70)

(71)

(72)

(73)

(74) . LE=>?@ApJ!qr"D=>?@A*s >=FGK +%&'".}W. . +h ^. E . / + ! +X>. =FGT/$W"EUl^ . >=FGH¡¢ W £¤. !X £¤E¥ J¦§ ¨. +=>?@AEFG UM>= . . © !Oª=>?@A«>=i¬. ! N. /®. ¯/°±{²#

(75) >=F³´)X W. ![#

(76) X Eµ¶Xr·¸U¢q .¹º®».J*+ ~U] . /W. /$l!/. $

(77) FG. !l¼"U½E¾¿ÀÁ¹º ©. E$XX E·¸U¨°®J. ~]-. . $

(78) XÂÃ X. ÄN. L+!6. / Å>=FG~E$/ Tvqr"1 23<=>?@ABC +hi@j2>w2Æ .=>?@AXÂFGHU¢ Ç#©s>=È.$#q^$#ÉÊ/$ËÌE>=Í W. +Eu$/. WÎÏ Ë$sFGHÐm.r+!. .

(79)

(80) . !"#. $%&

(81) '()*+,-."/012 !#. &. 345&6-78"9":;<- &. 6>8"9":;<-7#?. 3=0. ?-@(&?-A. B ?-CD06E7#?*"2?

(82) ?

(83) F! G*HIJKL*M NO. PQ!#?"!R2S

(84) TU*C. V&WXY0Z7G.!

(85) "# *. [2S\]^_?"`7a"& Rb-!cde. !fghi&b- M NO*jkljm0cd>7*. !n o8bp*L. qrsnjkt7u

(86) "

(87) * Dbv*`7fgh0 [2SG*Aw. . `7xC06E"fgh0 ?*M NO*PQ*,&yz!cde!fg. . hbp*{&|n*. ! "G`7#. .

(88)

(89)

(90) .

(91)

(92)

(93)

(94)

(95)

(96) . .

(97)

(98) . } ~0F`7>7* fgh&`7*. ?*Dbvb-7 &G. !# ! ~0 `nR. 306E9&>!fgh0 *W iRpN &a73=6E9"fghM NOv&|7*` ?"7u0 7#?* !p fgh. fgh*. !no8?*. ?*D!7#. " # . $. % .

(99)

(100)

(101) .

(102)

(103) &

(104) . . . ' .

(105)

(106)

(107) . (.

(108)

(109)

(110)

(111)

(112) )

(113)

(114)

(115)

(116)

(117) .

(118)

(119) .

(120) *} "

(121) . . &a-7* Dbv bp&r!G 7-7fgh*N M NO

(122) *`7,& ?* r!. *bp*&¡¢-7jk"£¤*¥¦§` . F`7"G. bp*&¡¨-7jkt7u&©>7"G. .

(123)

(124) .

(125) . !"#$. %&'()*+,-. ./0 1%& 23456738797/:;456738 7/<=%&'(>?@@3874567/<=% . &'(ABC. D823EF@. .

(126) . . . . . .

(127) . . .

(128) . . . . . .

(129) G . .

(130)

(131)

(132) . .

(133) . HHH/I0 1%& JK"L845638/<=@

(134) . 3 8MNO456PQRSTUJK/VWX"Y0 1%& JK/@Z0 [\]^_0 1%& "L823àEF@. Y. @L . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . ! . . "#G . . . . . 0 [\]Obc/dêfg@@Lhijk@LO@lmO n. hi0 [\]bopqrstu@!Mvw^. A/x,yzZ. 8{/L8/A0 [\]b|L8nDn/x,yz/!S} $ . . . . . . . . ~ . . . ~ .

(135)

(136) % . . .

(137) ""G . .

(138) . . . . . \ qrstuv/ZLL456j0 [\] }{/0 [\]b|L8nD456j@ & &'1%H/!

(139) % d@n@Z ¡ZH¢;@ £¤O@ ¥/¦§ 3¨ /®L¯M°}. A/. ©@Oª«MA¬iBCM}. ZA±dÂ@4dAH. .

(140)

(141) . !"#$%. &'()*+,'-../0 12+.3456& +&.78 ,9:.;<=> ?@! A!.BCDEFG' D"H.IJ 'B

(142) K.LMEF.NO 0 .A ,' .PQRST UVW.+"5 XQY-Z[-\"G]+^_ , .. `5 ab=%&6c9defgShijkl#fgShi m[5. =nV Qgfi m[5n6 op.PQRSTqr 2.o6stuvwx^!"y6.

(143)

(144) z5 z5&.{p.u|}~"-XQY.zL =BVu|}=V^+, Bs#+H"efgShijk e *k!PQRST zLV : & G'-+,5!&- m!5.;<=VH. . "59.PQRST=@-&+9H. 1=s!cL 6¡ H. ,'-.¡=84V .¢1+,G'£6H.+, ¤.u|}H¥" XQY .

(145) . .

(146). ¦ . .

(147)

(148) . . .

(149) .

(150)

(151).

(152) . .

(153). . .

(154) §.

(155) . -fgShiH¨© &.ª¤.«u|}¬®¯°l# .£±6H.+"

(156) . . .

(157)

(158) .

(159)

(160) . .

(161) . .

(162) §

(163) . u²Q*³h(i´! . "

(164) §PQRST=µ¶V& llG-·¸

(165) ¹ Vdº.»¼+, '½.¾¿,Gh(iH MÀ=ÁÂ =ÃÄ$l ÅPQRST=µ¶V&. .

(166)

(167) .

(168) .

(169) .

(170) . .

(171) .

(172)

(173)

(174) . . . . .

(175)

(176)

(177) . .

(178) .

(179) .

(180) .

(181) . . .

(182) . .

(183)

(184) .

(185)

(186) .

(187) .

(188)

(189)

(190) . .

(191) .

(192)

(193)

(194)

(195)

(196)

(197)

(198)

(199) . ! . . . "#$% &'()*+(),-./0122& '3456 2"7%6 589:&';()<=()0()0,&'> )?&'@A BCDE56F)GHIJ"/K50@A:L >>. M ();34NOPQR:S T)UVK; YM. WXZ#,&'[\]K53^G#"1_`)abcdefgh i/" PQ,jkli/)m:2;.$:2&';3456 ! &'nocdefgpqQRrR/"1s`)0t =ui/G.F )ôvw xV(0() xVi/6-K5' yz{> )56|}U "~>)^"|}U ~Q\Q 56F): ;6|}U .70|}U' n5" 60' F)F), jk./4fgyf

(200) !.

(201) ! ¡¢|()£P¤¥¦§¨Q/)"". B©ª«¥ ¦§¨Q/)""

(202) . B©¬P.7"® ' ¬()¯/)5°±)"K ²³´µF))?0¶h/" ¬?·.R? ¸rw¹ º#)"QR£P»-()5jk 456F" >0R-2£¼½¶¾-¿?Q6F)0"`2ÀÁ?1QRÂÃ5 Äjk456F",5ÅÅ!Æ¦§ Ç"#$"

(203) . ª«¥!Q ". ¤¥!Ç r/$¿Q3`?6È#K("¨)6 Q5ÉRQÊ_®©P". "

(204) . ¬[sËÌ56" ². ÍQR5("jkÎÏfÐ?5>0R-0/Ñ´¿ 8Ò#5(Ó0/Ô·?ÄQ#/$Õr´ÖÍ QÔ·vw `?5#!. .

(205)

(206) #3456 )*. !. "#$%&'()*+,-./01/2". 72898 :"#34&7;<. =>?. @AB"#$%CDEF*GH+,-./01/IAJKLMNOP QRST'CU*8V "#34W+,-./01/ abcdef )*Tn. XYI$. ghij*<. NHZ[\-[]. *k9bcdKl*. AoHAB98pq .

(207) :. *^_`. ><)m. H:r. st .

(208) uIvwxO8y1z0{

(209) V|}~ 9By1z09BmTno~/CUW8A8/ 9T . B<8)m\{

(210) V. T Fd{

(211)

(212) VCU9y1z08 .

(213). d.

(214) . y1z07. . )m. 3& 8N ~¡m¢£~~8¤¥¦§ XB mN9m9¨©8Bm:Bmª«P¬9AB9 y1z0CU8V 9mstBmT /0&®" bcd. A"¯~. 8<¨=F <. .

(215)

(216) y1z0°±²³O8b´!. µ¶& ·¸oH. *¨¹898º»°|>l~bcd¼m9*bcd9< KlmAZT /0&®". m. 8<¨=F <)mA"¯. ½B8. V. ¾Nbcd¿À <. mXB^8 ¾Nbcd. A"¯¾N. ¾N+ÁÀ8ghij3Â~9m .

(217) T 8p. m. T Ã ^ ;H y1z0ÄT XB8 ts[{ . VT Å¾"#<)m Å¾} 8ÆÇ ÈÉ W ^ÊB ^T ËHB8r T . ÌÍ8 ÎÏ8+,-./01/)m. T . <I$. ÆÇI$IvÕ. J. :ÐÑR8. H{ÒÒVÓÔ8. AGÖ×AGJØAGÙºKÚÛ. Ü8I$<8 ÝÖ J<8<ÞßàáâÉ~A8V. .

(218) .

(219)

(220)

(221) . !"#$%&'()#*+,-./. *01234

(222) 5# 6/7%&'()# *8

(223) 9: . !/7;6<=>*

(224) 9?@A. !B/C

(225) DEFG. ./HIJK L6/CMN6

(226) OPJQE6 RSTU VFG.JW X6 ! .

(227) EYJ *Z[\] VFG./^6

(228) _` ab"c d]$K 6/ . !eAfJgh *!"#$ijj. /jjjjk l

(229) fjj mNJno/pqr\;;$Astuvw. 8. no/pxy\;;$;J

(230) z{/ *|}2}~

(231) G \; 6!

(232)

(233) tJ VFG.JWC ^

(234) . >$JL ZAst }~K/6/. !fs\J. MN6

(235) OPJQE6 RSTU6K/6 /Cf

(236) <

(237) RtJ

(238) > /6t/8/ <01234Z6. As6./R6 ! ¡¢*k

(239) 6/ £¤N/¥¦§. ¥¦Y¨©stJª#8; 6«¬+J#K;60123 4(. 88;*

(240) J *6

(241) k !6®¯\; ^ . .

(242)

(243) °$; 6 .

(244) iFIl

(245) ±²

(246)

(247) Kt .

(248) S²±²T

(249) ³´ *µno6!k/>¶iFI^l

(250) Kt iFI·L ^l6 !6.

(251)

(252) S±²¸ ¸

(253) 01234£d\; 6/.

(254) ¹#

(255) J.

(256). !01234.

(257) ¸6. .

(258) º»¼

(259) £d\; ! .

(260)

(261) FI·L

(262)

(263).

(264)

(265) ½JZJL ¾\>. ¿º£ALÀ

(266) Z *

(267) ÁÂk *JÃ½J¾\>. ÄÅ Æ}Ç#

(268) 6 ! ÈÉÊJSk *J. ¿ºJ. ¡*ËÌqrk K/6 !ÍÊ.

(269) Î FGk

(270) / 6ÏJ.

(271) ÀÐFÑ>J/ sÒº ÓÔ01234 !K/Õ~J FI·L ^Ö^Ñ×k 6 ØÙ.J^<

(272) RÚJÛÜ 6 ! Ý.J #$ .

(273) ÞßFI·L8;/ ssJ dàáJ â#8; . (/ 01234Jâ#8; .

(274) Þß6 !b1}. ãäå`æ. çèKJ ! í}ãîï3ð~ãñ~. í}ãîï3ð~ãñ÷~. EYéEOêës;

(275) /tiáìÏJlòó ôõ

(276) iáö$6lô õ! ø ëFI·L *JEë

(277) é

(278) JFIÇ# K/ùZJK ú

(279) =t

(280) ûüý¥

(281) k !EYþ C=EY K/CÏY P./¨tK 6!ç. .

(282)

(283)

(284) !"# $%&'. ( (& )*+, (- . ./(0123( +, 45 67.89(0: . (;<=>?@?A45B5 CDEFG. .I=(B5. H'':. 40. 4E

(285). JKB(LMH NO.PQ(;

(286) JK RST. U4 VWXYZ.[4(4\]9G. ^ >_? 45à(^(bc5;. def?gh?iTjklmno'pqrstXu vwxy . dz{l|}5 K~q

(287) dh?iTjk x d .

(288) dx d Rlhqu vwxy ! d x !dx "dx dx ! dx ! dx dx , -.,/ / 0+ d# $ % & ' ( &) % * + "" dl"q ! d?AgRj?lqrsu $ x¡ dz x !d¢£¤gf¥l¦f§¨?T©ªq«¬®z¯°u ±²rn³ "d¢´µ¶kg>_?l·kj_¸´k¹qº»¼½¾¿¬Àu vwxy " dRj?ÁÂTÃTg@?ÄmÅÆ ÇmÈ ÉÂTÃTg@?lÊnËnÌqÍÎ ÏÐÑÀ»zÒuÓ ÔmÕ "" dÖ_kg>?@?AlH 9q×Ø¬u Ùm "" !. .

(289)